
       Science-Based Medicine Guide to Acupuncture and ‘Eastern’ Medicine

           A Critical Guide for the Health Practitioner and Consumer 

                                  2025 Edition

                                        

                       Executive Editor Steven Novella MD

                      Managing Editor David Gorski MD PhD

                         Series Editor Mark Crislip MD

                                  Introduction

                                 Steven Novella

The world of health care is becoming an increasingly complex and challenging
place. The internet is changing the way we generate and access information, and 
health information is one of the most popular uses of the internet. It
represents an unprecedented democratization of information and opinion. 

While there are many advantages and benefits to such information access, there
are also many challenges to health professionals, regulators, academics, and
consumers. There is a proliferation of health related products and services,
with many provocative health claims. Regulations are generally not keeping up,
and often have been watered down, in the face of this onslaught of claims and
products. 

The consumer is left with an overwhelming array of health claims, many of which 
challenge and even directly oppose the traditional experts and institutions. 

The mission of Science-Based Medicine (SBM) is to be a source of reliable
information and analysis to help navigate the wild west of health information on
the internet and elsewhere. The authors who contribute to this series of
e-books are all physicians and other health care professionals who have a great 
deal of experience educating the public about complex medical issues.  We
especially take on controversial issues and try to expose pseudoscience and
fraud wherever possible.

The Philosophy of Science-Based Medicine

The philosophy of SBM, at its core, is simple: Safe and effective health care is
critical to everyone’s quality of life; so much so that it is generally
considered a basic human right. Therefore, health care products and services
that work and are safe are better than those that do not work or are unsafe. 

The best method for determining which interventions and health products are safe
and effective is, without question, good science. Therefore it is in everyone’s
best interest for health care to be systematically evaluated by the best
science available.

Too often the nature of science itself is misunderstood or misrepresented to the
public. Science is not an arcane and privileged discipline. By its very nature 
it is meant to be transparent and public. Science is nothing more than a
systematic and careful use of evidence and logic to evaluate factual claims. And
good science possesses certain virtues that are not unique to science but
generic to all intellectual endeavors: fairly accounting for all available
evidence, using valid and internally consistent logic, using unambiguous
concepts and language, proper use of statistics, being quantitatively precise
and accurate, and above all being honest.

And yet there are numerous and powerful influences in society that strongly
appose the scientific basis of medicine. Driven by some combination of ideology 
or the desire for profit they wish to eliminate standards of science in health
care, or (often under the guise of “health care freedom”) create a double
standard in which unscientific methods and products can thrive unchecked. Others
simply lack the training or knowledge to achieve minimal standards of quality
for scientific medicine. And even the best traditions of scientific medicine can
benefit from more critical analysis.

Recognition of the need for careful scientific analysis in medicine partly stems
from a recognition that it is very difficult (almost impossible) to reliably
assess treatments anecdotally. Human perception, memory, and cognition are prone
to a host of flaws, weaknesses, and biases that will tend to mislead us,
especially towards conclusions that we wish to be true. Placebo effects,
confirmation bias, and simple statistics can make any intervention seem
effective, even when they are worthless or harmful. 

Science-Based Medicine vs Evidence-Based Medicine

Within the practice of medicine there is already a recognition of the need to
raise the standards of evidence and the availability of the best evidence to the
practitioner and the consumer – formalized in the movement known as
evidence-based medicine (EBM). 

EBM is a vital and positive influence on the practice of medicine, but it has
its limitations. EBM tends to focus on clinical trial results to the exclusion
of scientific plausibility. The focus on trial results (which, in the EBM
lexicon, is what is meant by “evidence”) has its utility, but fails to properly 
deal with medical modalities that are highly implausible, or seem to defy
well-established findings in science.

All of science describes the same reality, and therefore it must (if it is
functioning properly) all be mutually compatible. Collectively, science builds
one cumulative model of the natural world. This means we can make rational
judgments about what is likely to be true based upon what is already well
established. This does not necessarily equate to rejecting new ideas
out-of-hand, but rather to adjusting the threshold of evidence required to
establish a new claim based upon the prior scientific plausibility of the new
claim. Failure to do so leads to conclusions and recommendations that are not
reliable, and therefore medical practices that are probably not safe and
effective.

The SBM Series

This is why the authors of this series strongly advocate for science based
medicine – the use of the best scientific evidence available, in the light of
our cumulative scientific knowledge from all relevant disciplines, in evaluating
health claims, practices, and products. 

Some of the articles here will analyze individual studies, and explore the
strengths and weaknesses of their methods, separating what the study really
tells us from how it may be represented in the media. Other articles will
summarize what many studies tell us about a specific medical question. 

We will also explore health information on the internet, separating out which
information is reliable from that which is misleading, erroneous, or possibly
even fraudulent. Likewise we will critique mainstream media coverage of health
topics, giving the reader specific tools for to critically analyze health
information for themselves.

Other articles will explore topics related to health regulation and academia.
Regulations have struggled to keep up with the rapidly changing health care
market place, with critical gaps that leave the health care consumer responsible
for their own protection. Academic institutions themselves, long the defenders 
of high standards of scholarship in all fields, including medicine, have been
infiltrated by promoters of pseudoscientific belief systems. The result is that 
there is no longer any single reliable guarantee of scientific integrity. 

The SBM series of e-books is organized by topic, such as acupuncture,
chiropractic, homeopathy, and many others.  The books are collections of essays,
not intended to be a systematic reference, but rather to explore the various
scientific issues related to each topic. The goal is to give the reader critical
thinking skills and a deeper understanding of, not just the current findings of
science, but the process of science, specifically how it relates to health care
and the topic of each book. 

Science-based medicine can serve as your pocket guide through the wilderness of 
health information.

As of 2026, there are over 5000 essays on the Science Based Medicine website. I 
do no know about you, but I find it difficult to find any post I wrote, much
less one written by another contributor. 
So I have updated the books  and include almost all the articles through 2025.
The volumes are
CAM Concepts
Chiropractic
COVID 
Critical Thinking
Diet and Nutrition
Ethics and CAM
Herbs, Supplements, and Diet
Homeopathy
Infections and Immunity
Law and CAM
Media and Internet
Medicine, Public Health, Dentistry and Pediatrics
Miscellaneous CAM
Naturopathy
Neurology and Psychiatry
Placebo
Quackademic Medicine
Regulation. FDA and FTC
SBM or EBM
Stem Cells, Genetics, AI and Gender
Supplements, Vitamins and Herbs
Vaccine & Anivax
Vaccines and Autism
Vaccines and Preventable Infections
The articles are roughly organized by publication date and topic. Many articles 
will be in multiple volumes as an essay of, for example, chiropractic and law
will be found in both the chiropractic volume and the law volume.
You may find the organization a bit odd. I do. But 4700 plus articles are
difficult to organize and I have more to do in my retirement than work of these 
volumes.
Still, if you find I have missed a nentry or some glaring error, drop me a note 
and I will fix it for the next edition.
About the authors

Steven P. Novella, MD – Founder and Executive Editor Science Based Medicine.

Founder and currently Executive Editor of Science-Based Medicine Steven Novella,
MD.

David H. Gorski, MD, PhD – Managing Editor. Science Based Medicine.

Mark A. Crislip, MD. Editor, Science Based Medicine Guides. 

He did he editing of all the volumes so is to blame for any mistakes.

As to all the other contributors, if you are interested click on the ‘Link’ at
top of each essay to go the SBM site, where further information about each
author can be found.

A Note On References
The chapters in this book were originally blog entries at
ScienceBasedMedicine.org.

Blog and web pages lend themselves to hyperlinks to sources and references that 
are tedious to translate into footnotes for this ebook.

Under the title of each essay is a hyperlink, cleverly titled ‘Link’, to the
original blog entry with all the hyperlinks and references, as well as the
comments to the blogs, which often have interesting and thoughtful insights by
our readers, as well as some curious comments by the not so thoughtful.

Graphs, tables and links to videos are not in included these essays due to
issues of copyright and permission.  However, thanks to the ‘Link’, the graphics
are a click away.

Thanks for reading the site.

Mark Crislip  



                            An Acupuncture Overview

                                 Steven Novella

Acupuncture is the practice of placing very thin needles through the skin in
specific locations of the body for the purpose of healing and relief of
symptoms. The earliest references to some form of acupuncture date back several 
thousand years, and in modern times is considered a central part of Traditional 
Chinese Medicine. As practiced today it is often combined with other
interventions, such as sending a small current of electricity through the
needles (electroacupuncture) or burning herbs on the acupuncture points (a
practice called moxibustion).

Acupuncture has over the last few decades been transplanted to the West, riding 
a wave of favorable media coverage and increasing tolerance for unscientific
treatment practices marketed as “complementary and alternative medicine.” While 
advocates have been successful at pushing acupuncture into the culture, its
overall use remains quite low (6.5% of Americans have ever used acupuncture in a
recent survey - CDC 2007). While interest and research into acupuncture has
also been increasing, the scientific medical community has still not accepted
the practice as a legitimate scientific practice. 

There are many good reasons for continued skepticism towards the practice of
acupuncture. 

1) Acupuncture is a pre-scientific superstition

Proponents often cite acupuncture’s ancient heritage as a virtue, often referred
to as the argument from antiquity. Acupuncture was developed in a
pre-scientific culture, before anything significant was understand about
biology, the normal functioning of the human body, or disease pathology. The
healing practices of the time were part of what is called philosophy-based
medicine, to be distinguished from modern science-based medicine.
Philosophy-based systems began with a set of ideas about health and illness and 
based their treatments on those ideas. The underlying assumptions and the
practices derived from them were never subjected to controlled observation or
anything that can reasonably be called a scientific process.

An example from Western culture of philosophy-based medicine was the humoral
theory – the notion that health was the result of the four bodily humors being
in proper balance while illness reflected one or more humors being out of
balance (also known as Galenic medicine). Treatments therefore sought to
increase or decrease one or more of the humors (such as the practice of
blood-letting) to re-establish balance. The humoral theory survived for several 
thousand years in Western societies, perpetuated by culture and the power of
deception inherent in anecdotal evidence.

Acupuncture is based upon the Eastern philosophy of chi (also spelled qi), which
is their name for the supposed life force or vital energy that animates living 
things. In Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) chi flows through pathways in the 
body known as meridians. Illness results from the flow of chi through the
meridians being blocked, or by the two types of chi (yin and yang) being out of 
balance. Acupuncture is the practice of placing thin needles at acupuncture
points, which are said to coincide with the flow of chi, in order to improve the
flow and restore the balance of chi.

Further, there is evidence that the Western Galenic concept of bloodletting was 
in fact connected to the concepts of chi and acupuncture. Chi and blood were
considered to be connected, and acupuncture may have been just an Eastern
version of bloodletting. There are also astrological concepts tied up in the
number and location of ancient acupuncture points. 

There is no more reason to believe in the reality of chi than there is in the
four humors, or in the effectiveness of acupuncture than the effectiveness of
blood letting. The fact that each philosophy survived for thousands of years in 
their respective culture does not indicate that either method is effective
medicine.

2) Acupuncture lacks a plausible mechanism

Centuries of advancement in our understanding of biology has made the notion of 
life energy unnecessary. Further, no one has been able to detect life energy or 
formulate a scientifically coherent theory as to what life energy is, where it
comes from, and how it interacts with matter or other forms of energy. Within
science, the vitalists lost the debate over a century ago. Without chi, there is
no underlying basis for acupuncture as a medical intervention.

Recent attention given to acupuncture has attempted to bring it into the
scientific fold by hypothesizing physical mechanisms for its alleged effects.
For example, some proponents argue that the needles may stimulate the release of
pain-killing natural chemicals, relax tense muscles, inhibit the conduction of 
pain through counter-irritation, or bring anti-inflammatory chemicals to the
cite of pain or injury.

These potential mechanisms, while more plausible than the non-existent chi,
remain highly speculative. Further, they would only explain a very non-specific 
effect of acupuncture (no better than rubbing your elbow after accidentally
banging it against something hard). They might account for a temporary mild
reduction in pain. Such mechanisms could not account for any of the medical
claims made for acupuncture, or the alleged existence of acupuncture points.

Research into putative biological mechanisms generally show only that there is
some local physiological response to non-specific trauma. They do not, however, 
connect such responses to acupuncture points or to any specific clinical effect.


From both an anatomic and clinical perspective, the best evidence very strongly 
shows that acupuncture points do not exist. Some forms of acupuncture, such as
auricular acupuncture, hypothesize that there is a tiny homunculus of the human 
body represented in the external ear. There is also a complete absence of
evidence, anatomical or clinical to suggest that this homunculus has any basis
in reality. 

Acupuncture is therefore not based upon any basic science body of knowledge.
There is no chi and there are no acupuncture points. Any local physiological
effects of needle penetration appear to be incidental at best. 

3) Claims for efficacy are often based upon a bait-and-switch deception.

The most common example of the “bait-and-switch” for acupuncture are studies
that examined the effects on pain of electrical stimulation through acupuncture 
needles. This is not acupuncture – it is transcutaneous electrical nerve
stimulation (TENS), which is an accepted treatment for chronic pain,
masquerading as acupuncture.

This is not a quibble. Science requires unambiguous definition of terms and
concepts. If acupuncture is said to be something scientifically then it must
have some specific and unique characteristics. In medicine that means it should 
have a specific mechanism of action – and it is that mechanism that we would
call acupuncture. Electrical stimulation is no more acupuncture than if I
injected morphine through a hollow acupuncture needle and then claimed that any 
resulting pain relief was due to “pharmacoacupuncture.”

Further, during a typical acupuncture treatment there are many other incidental 
effects that may occur. The atmosphere is often relaxing, and practitioners
typically will palpate the “acupuncture points” prior to inserting the needles, 
for example. Practitioners also provide their kind attention, which has a
positive psychological therapeutic value. There are therefore many nonspecific
subjective effects that could lead to clients feeling better, making the actual 
insertion of needles an unnecessary component.

Reports of acupuncture anaesthesia are also misleading. Independent
investigation shows that patients having surgery under anaesthesia (dramatic
reports of which are largely credited with acupuncture’s popularity in the West)
reveal that patients were receiving morphine in the IV fluid. Other reports
indicate that patients were experiencing great pain, but were simply instructed 
to remain quiet by the surgeon (a product of Eastern culture). There are no
verified reports of acupuncture serving as effective anesthesia during surgery.

4) Clinical trials show that acupuncture does not work

The previous points are all reasons to be highly skeptical of the claims made
for acupuncture, but they are all also trumped by the ultimate consideration –
the direct scientific evidence. It is possible that acupuncture might work,
despite its origin and lack of an established mechanism. There is a surprisingly
large published literature on the clinical effects of acupuncture. Most people 
are equally surprised to learn that the literature is essentially negative –
probably because the press and proponents cherry pick apparently positive
studies and misinterpret or dismiss negative studies. 

It is important to evaluate the literature as a whole to see what pattern
emerges. The pattern that does emerge is most consistent with a null effect –
that acupuncture does not work.

Controlled clinical trials of actual acupuncture (uncontrolled trials should
only be considered preliminary and are never definitive) typically have three
arms: a control group with no intervention or standard treatment, a
sham-acupuncture group (needles are placed but in the “wrong” locations or not
deep enough), and a real acupuncture group. 

Most of such trials, for any intervention including pain, nausea, addiction, and
others, show no difference between the sham-acupuncture group and the
acupuncture group. They typically do show improved outcome in both acupuncture
groups over the no-intervention group, but this is typical of all clinical
trials and is clearly due to placebo-type effects. Such comparisons should be
considered unblinded because patients know if they were getting acupuncture
(sham or real).

The lack of any advantage of real over sham acupuncture means that it does not
matter where the needles are placed. This is completely consistent with the
hypothesis that any perceived benefits from acupuncture are non-specific effects
from the process of getting the treatment, and not due to any alleged specific 
effects of acupuncture. In other words, there is no evidence that acupuncture is
manipulating chi or anything else, that the meridians have any basis in
reality, or that the specific process of acupuncture makes any difference.

More recent trials have attempted to improve the blinded control of such trials 
by using acupuncture needles that are contained in an opaque sheath. The
acupuncturist depresses a plunger, and neither they nor the patient knows if the
needle is actually inserted. The pressure from the sheath itself would conceal 
any sensation from the needle going in. So far, such studies show no difference 
between those who received needle insertion and those who did not – supporting
the conclusion that acupuncture has no detectable specific health effect.

Other studies comparing standard "cookbook" style acupuncture to individualized 
acupuncture also show no difference. Some studies have specifically controlled
for the amount of positive attention given by the acupuncturist - and this
correlates strongly with the reported benefit of the treatment. 

The process of good science involves carefully controlling for and isolating
variables to see what effect each variable has. When we look at the totality of 
the acupuncture research, specifically at those clinical studies that controlled
for one or more variable, an overwhelming pattern emerges, which indicates
that:

- it does not matter where you stick the needles

- the training and technique used by the acupuncturist has no effect on efficacy

- it does not matter if you even stick a needle through the skin

- the only variable that correlates with outcome is the attention from the
acupuncturist

Taken as a whole, these outcomes add up to one unavoidable conclusion -
acupuncture does not work and its underlying concepts are false. Acupuncture is 
nothing more than a ritual surrounding a non-specific therapeutic interaction
between a kind practitioner and their client. The acupuncture ritual itself has 
no effect on any clinical outcome. In other words, acupuncture is nothing more
than an elaborate placebo. 

Reference

Center for Disease Control (CDC), 2007 National Health Interview Survey (NHIS), 
ftp://ftp.cdc.gov/pub/Health_Statistics/NCHS/Dataset_Documentation/NHIS/2007/alt
healt_freq.pdf

                              Acupuncture: History

 Acupuncture and history: The “ancient” therapy that’s been around for several
                                    decades

                                  David Ramey

                                      Link

   Make the lie big, make it simple, keep saying it, and eventually they
   will believe it

   – A. Hitler

It seems that just about every article about acupuncture makes some reference to
it having been used in China for thousands of years. The obvious reason for
such a statement is to make the implication that since it’s been around for so
long, it must therefore also be effective. Of course, longevity doesn’t argue
for efficacy, otherwise everyone would likely agree that astrology is the way to
chart one’s life; astrology has been practiced for many more years than
acupuncture.

What’s maddening about the acupuncture longevity myth is that it isn’t true, and
demonstrably so. In human medicine, “needling” was illustrated in the 17th
century by western observers: no points, no “meridians,” just a big awl-like
“needle,” driven in with an ivory-handled circular hammer. In addition, the
rationale for hammering these little spikes into various spots (of the
practitioner’s choosing) was said to be “exactly the same” as Greek humoral
medicine (see, Carruba, RW, Bowers, JZ. The Western World’s First Detailed
Treatise on Acupuncture: Willem ten Rhijne’s De Acupunctura. J Hist Med Allied
Sci (1974) XXIX (4): 371-398).

The same fallacious assertion is repeated (repeatedly) in veterinary medicine.
Acupuncture proponents may assert, for example, that acupuncture is “4,000 years
old.” While the assertion isn’t true, it’s also ridiculous, since the Chinese
hadn’t invented writing 4,000 years ago. Even if the assertion were true, there 
would be no way to possibly know about it, since no one could have written
anything down about the practice.

Regardless, recently, we published the first detailed research paper on the
history of veterinary medicine in China. The paper was published in July, in the
historical journal Sudhoffs Archiv (Buell, P, May, T, Ramey, D. Greek and
Chinese Horse Medicine: Déja Vu All Over Again. Sudhoffs Archiv. 2010: 94:
31-60). It is one of the first papers published that looks at the actual
historical source material, and the only one that compares the veterinary
medicine of ancient China to contemporary practices in the ancient world.

Based on the historical source material, it can be stated that Chinese
veterinary medicine isn’t unique, and it isn’t even particularly Chinese. That
is, what is presented to the eager public as the essence of Chinese thought and 
practice is, in fact, just an adaptation of contemporaneous practices in Greece 
and the Middle East. In fact, most Chinese practices, such as bleeding, and
burning at points, appear in Greek, Egyptian, and Arabic sources long before
they were ever mentioned in China. Such practices first appear in China during a
period of maximal western influence on China, corresponding with regular
traffic on the Silk Road (during Han times, approx. 200 BCE – 200 AD), as well
as with the coming of Buddhism, which brought in influences from Indian
traditions.

It’s remarkable – and particularly so in the face of all of the modern crowing
about the antiquity of acupuncture in animals – that there is no reference to
what can even be remotely considered as modern acupuncture in any of the
pre-modern Chinese veterinary works (which deal mostly with horses, camels, and 
water buffalo). This may be due to incorrect translation of the Chinese word
zhen, which means “incision” or “penetration,” and also used to describe
cauterization and bleeding, but which has been apparently somehow morphed into
“acupuncture” anytime that the word appears in Chinese sources. It’s absolutely 
clear that zhen has nothing to do with modern acupuncture, even as it’s equally 
clear that acupuncture proponents will insist on misinterpreting the Chinese
language to suit their preconceived notions.

The Chinese, as with every other ancient culture, didn’t have much of an idea of
horse physiology, and their treatments were based on anecdote and tradition.
The fact is that the Chinese didn’t have any better idea about what caused
conditions such as colic (abdominal distress) or foot pain than did other
cultures, and they really didn’t treat them much differently. Until scientific
investigations came along, people didn’t really know what they were doing when
it came to practicing medicine. There’s no reason to try to go back to such
traditions; there’s especially no reason to do so when they didn’t exist in the 
first place. 

                     The Acupuncture and Fasciae Fallacy.  

                                  Ben Kavoussi

                                      Link

   Let us be certain of a fact before being concerned with its cause. It is 
   true that this method is too lengthy for most people who naturally run to the
   cause and overlook the certitude about facts; but at last we will avoid the 
   ridicule of finding the cause of what does not exist.1

   Bernard le Bovier de Fontenelle (1657-1757)

Amidst the plethora of flawed, implausible, and wasteful research on acupuncture
and Chinese medicine, a 2002 study on the “Relationship of Acupuncture Points
and Meridians to Connective Tissue Planes” stands out as the height of factual
neglect. In it, Helene Langevin and Jason Yandow of the University of Vermont’s 
College of Medicine claim to have matched real anatomical structures with the
elusive acupuncture “meridians.” It should be noted that the widely accepted
term “meridian” is a metaphor coined by George Soulié de Morant (1878 – 1955), a
French delegate to China, and has no semantic relationship with the original
Chinese word.2 The original designation is the composite word jing luo (經絡),
which literally means “channel-network.” The term has been translated to English
as chinglo channels, channels, vessels or more commonly, meridians. Debunking
this study is of particular relevance because it is often used by acupuncturists
and a wide range of other CAM providers to legitimize the meridian lore. The
principle author, Helene Langevin, is a CAM celebrity and a member of the
“Scientific Committee” of the International Fascia Research Congress, an
organization dedicated to the “emerging field of Fascia Studies.” She is an
Associate Professor of Neurology and the Director of the Program in Integrative 
Health at the University of Vermont; and has conducted multiple NCCAM-funded
studies on the role of connective tissue in chronic pain, acupuncture and manual
therapies.

This is what Langevin and Yandow wrote in their 2002 paper’s abstract:

   Acupuncture meridians traditionally are believed to constitute channels
   connecting the surface of the body to internal organs. We hypothesize that
   the network of acupuncture points and meridians can be viewed as a
   representation of the network formed by interstitial connective tissue. This 
   hypothesis is supported by ultrasound images showing connective tissue
   cleavage planes at acupuncture points in normal human subjects. To test this 
   hypothesis, we mapped acupuncture points in serial gross anatomical sections 
   through the human arm. We found an 80% correspondence between the sites of
   acupuncture points and the location of intermuscular or intramuscular
   connective tissue planes in postmortem tissue sections.3

What makes this study fundamentally flawed, despite its scientific appearance,
is the fact that it is the embodiment of what I have elsewhere called “medical
Orientalism.” By this term I mean a depiction of Eastern healing arts by Western
authors, academics and researchers that is not generated from historical facts 
or reality, but from stereotypes that envision approaches to health and disease 
in the East as fundamentally dissimilar to the West. The historical facts do not
support the fascial-planes hypothesis, and rather indicate that the Chinese
concept of jing luo is quasi identical to the Greek notions of phlebes (blood
vessels in general) and neura (ligaments, nerves, etc.). Indeed, as the classics
scholar Elizabeth Craik has convincingly argued:

   Chinese medicine resembles Hippocratic theory in that anatomical
   structures and orifices (perhaps better described as systems and processes)
   are seen in terms of the channels which link them to one another and to other
   areas of the body. Greek phlebes and Chinese mo are significant in
   physiology (normal–carrying blood and pneuma or qi) and pathology
   (abnormal–carrying noxious matter, inducing disease). Their supposed paths do
   not exactly coincide, but several are broadly similar (and more similar to
   each other than either is to the observed paths of arteries and veins). In
   particular, the route of the Chinese du channel (“governor vessel”) from
   spine to back of head carrying life force is similar to that of the Greek
   vessel carrying vital myelos. And the vessel centrally placed in the forehead
   in some Greek accounts is similar to the anterior continuation of the
   Chinese du channel. Furthermore, the parallel pairs of vessels symmetrically 
   placed on either side of the du channel correspond with the parallel pairs of
   vessels postulated in many Greek accounts… Originally in China there was no 
   elaborate system of acupuncture points (for example, twenty-eight points on
   the du channel) with measurements, any more than in Hippocratic practice. In 
   sum, we see similar channels, with similar paths and similar contents, the
   focus of similar treatment for similar medical conditions.4

The elusive and mysterious meridian system seems therefore to be nothing more
than a rudimentary and prescientific model of blood vessels and nerves. Langevin
and Yandow’s conceptual model can thus be seen as historically unfounded. It is
also implausible because postulating an anatomically precise “medical gaze” for
ancient and medieval physicians is anachronistic. As one reader (Dr. Le
Petomaneon) pertinently commented on my previous post, The Cargo Cult of
Acupuncture, this postulation “begs the question of how preindustrial Chinese
researchers could have created an accurate map of meridians without the advanced
technology it has taken for anyone to have a remotely credible claim to have
detected them.” In fact, as Michel Foucault (1926-1984) has pointed out, it is
only in 18th-century Europe that the body became something that could be mapped 
with precision.5 For millennia prior to that, anatomical structures that lay
below the threshold of the visible were conceptualized according to mythology,
astrology, and other figments of the imagination. Consider, for instance, the
17th-century medical manuscript by Yang Jizhou (杨继洲) called the Zhenjiu Dacheng 
(针灸大成), where the medical and astrological narratives are inseparable. This
work, which is incorrectly translated as the Great Compendium of Acupuncture and
Moxibustion, describes a medical gaze that is not directed towards the body and
its anatomy, but towards the Heavens and astrology.6 The Zhenjiu Dacheng and
other prescientific manuals of medicine in China are not exploratory guides
about the fascial planes or other anatomical structures; they are manuals of
medical astrology. This is why the original designations of the principal
meridians (e.g., tae yang, jue yin) represent the angular position (hour angle) 
of the Sun (Table 1), and not the “physiological functions thought to be
speciﬁcally related to each,” as Langevin and Yandow inacuretly state. The
historian Paul Buell has argued that even the Yellow Emperor’s Inner Canon
(黄帝内经, Huangdi Neijing, 400-200 BC), the formative book of Chinese medicine, is 
as much an astrological compendium as a medical text.

Image 1. The Chinese zodiac system called Stem-Branch (干支 gānzhī). The closed
loop formed by the meridian network mimics the circular nature of the zodiac
system. Image source: Facts and Details about China and Japan.

Table 1. Chart depicting an astrological relationship between the 12 main
meridians, the 12 main organs, and the constellations of the Chinese zodiac
system.7 Each meridians is named after a solar hour-angle (meaning the position 
of the Sun on the Ecliptic), and corresponds to a 2-hour time division of the
Celestial Equator.

Also, historical facts do not supports Langevin and Yandow’s assertion that
“during acupuncture treatments, fine needles traditionally are inserted at
specific locations of the body known as acupuncture points.” The instruments
described in the Inner Canon are mostly pins, lancets, fleams and bodkins; not
fine needles. Besides, the ideogram zhēn (针), which has been mistranslated as
“needle,” actually means any instrument of puncture, incision or penetration,
such as a pin, lancet, needle or any other sharp device. In the Inner Canon, the
term mostly refers to lancing and bloodletting, not acupuncture (as we define
it today), particularly in a section called Simple Questions (素問, Su wen).8 Of
the nine sharp instruments described in the the Inner Canon (Images 2-4), only
three resemble coarse needles and pins.9 Some of these instruments significantly
resemble the instruments of bloodletting and surgery found in medieval Europe
(Image 5). In fact, most of the traditional reference material that is currently
associated with acupuncture and meridians is actually about a variety of
methods and instruments to incise structures that share their paths, contents,
and focus of treatment with the Greek notion of phlebes (blood vessels in
general). If the current map of acupuncture points and meridians is distinct
from the vasculature, it is because in the early 1930s the pediatrician Cheng
Dan’an (承淡安, 1899-1957) resurrected and rehabilitated the vanishing street trade
of therapeutic piercing by moving the treatment loci away from the blood
vessels. He illustrated his revisions by painting the new pathways onto the skin
of individuals and then photographing them. He also replaced the coarse
medieval tools with the fine needles we associate with acupuncture today.10 It
is the reproduction of these new pathways in modern acupuncture textbooks, and
the new use of fine needles that Langevin and Yandow have unknowingly taken for 
historical facts.

Image 2. The nine tools described in the Inner Cannon are fund in medical
manuscripts throughout the history of China. Image source unknown.

Image 3. Dimensions of the nine tool: the measurement unit is the cun (寸,
pronounced “ts’un”), which is roughly equal to 3.3 cm (1.3 inches). Image
source: Essentials of Chinese Acupuncture.11

Image 4. Reproduction of the nine tools. They do not look like “fine needles” to
penetrate the fascial planes. Image source unknown.

Image 5. Reproduction of European medieval bloodletting and cautery tools based 
on archaeological finds at the abbey of Saint Eutizio, Italy. Legend: A. Cautery
irons, 35 cm; B. Fleam & bowl, 28 cm; C. Medical spoon, 14 cm; D. Bodkin to
remove arrows, 20 cm. Image source: Medieval Design.

In my previous posts I have argued that since the Chinese classics, such as the 
Zhenjiu Dacheng, base their meridian and point selection on astrology, and not
on experimentation, it is not surprising that needling “nonacupuncture” (sham)
control points is just as effective as “true” acupuncture.12 In a recent article
in The New England Journal of Medicine, Helene Langevin, Brian Berman, and
their colleagues finally acknowledge that:

   The simplest explanation of such findings is that the specific
   therapeutic effects of acupuncture, if present, are small, whereas its
   clinically relevant benefits are mostly attributable to contextual and
   psychosocial factors, such as patients’ beliefs and expectations, attention
   from the acupuncturist, and highly focused, spatially directed attention on
   the part of the patient.13

In view of this admission, it seems that the further use of public funding to
explore a hypothetical link between acupuncture and the fascial planes (or other
structures) would amount to waste and misuse. The editors and contributors of
Science-Based Medicine have consistently expressed their objection to the public
funding of CAM research in general, especially for acupuncture. The Center for 
Inquiry’s Office of Public Policy has also voiced its opposition through their
Position Paper on Acupuncture:

The Center for Inquiry is deeply concerned that the new found prominence of
unproven and unscientific therapies like acupuncture diminishes the primacy of
science in our health policy discourse and degrades our healthcare system. We
believe the uncritical adoption of acupuncture will ultimately add incalculable 
costs to our already overburdened healthcare system and will lower standards of 
medical training and treatment. More fundamentally, the expansion of alternative
medical institutions–increasingly funded by the federal government–lends
dangerous and undue authority to pseudoscience, degrading respect for science in
the public realm.14

According to the Center for Inquiry, the 2010 budget fo the National Center for 
Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) is $128.8 million – more than 60 
times greater than its $2 million budget in 1992.  The budget of the Office of
Cancer Complementary and Alternative Medicine (OCCAM) was $121 million in 2008, 
and is presumably higher in 2010. Together, these funds amount to $240 million
of taxpayer dollars, without counting the money these institutions have received
from the government’s stimulus packages. Yet, not a single publicly funded
research project has shown that a CAM modality is significantly beneficial for
anything. Some of these projects are scientifically flawed, others (like the one
discussed here) are based on inaccurate assumptions and factual neglect.

The laissez-faire attitude at NCCAM and OCCAM, and their leadership’s ignorance 
of historical and epistemological facts about the projects they fund, are
certainly responsible for this deplorable situation. As a result, not only
millions of taxpayer dollars are being spent on seemingly ridiculous research
projects, but also the very fact that they are supporting these projects is
often used to lend an appearance of legitimacy to treatments and ideas that are 
not legitimate. Furthermore, as Kimball Atwood has argued, this research grant
money has resulted in the establishment of a cadre of academics who have come to
rely on the federal government with little regard for the scientific issues
associated with CAM research.15 Helene Langevin is certainly one of these
academics.

With special thanks to Kristin Koster, PhD, Paul Buell, PhD, and Paul Ingraham
for their valuable comments.

REFERENCES:

1. Fontenelle BB (Author), Bergier J (Editor). Fontenelle: Entretiens sur la
Pluralité des Mondes suivi de Histoire des Oracles. Marabout Université. 1973.

2. Kendall DE. Dao of Chinese Medicine: Understanding an Ancient Healing Art.
Oxford University Press, USA; 1 edition. 2002.

3. Langevin HM, Yandow JA. Relationship of Acupuncture Points and Meridians to
Connective Tissue Planes. Anat Rec. 2002 Dec 15;269(6):257-65.

4. Craik EM. Hippocratic Bodily “Channels” and Oriental Parallels. Med Hist.
2009 January; 53(1): 105–116.

5. Foucault M. The Birth of the Clinic: An Archaeology of Medical Perception.
Vintage. 1994.

6. Wilcox L (Translator). The Great Compendium of Acupuncture and Moxibustion.
vol. V. The Chinese Medicine Database. 2010.

7. Maciocia G. The Foundations of Chinese Medicine: A Comprehensive Text for
Acupuncturists and Herbalists. Second Edition. Churchill Livingstone. 2005.

8. Unschuld PU. Huang Di Nei Jing Su Wen: Nature, Knowledge, Imagery in an
Ancient Chinese Medical Text. University of California Press. 2003.

9. Dharmananda S. Bleeding Peripheral Points: An Acupuncture Technique.
[Accessed 24 August 2010].

10. Andrews BJ. History of Pain: Acupuncture and the Reinvention of Chinese
Medicine. APS Bulletin. May/June 1999;9(3).

11. Anonymous. Essentials of Chinese Acupuncture. Foreign Language Press,
Beijing, China.1979.

12. Moffet HH. Sham acupuncture may be as efficacious as true acupuncture: a
systematic review of clinical trials. J Altern Complement Med. 2009
Mar;15(3):213-6.

13. Berman BM, Langevin HM, Witt CM, Dubner R. Acupuncture for chronic low back 
pain. N Engl J Med 2010 Jul 29; 363(5):454-61.

14. Slack R, Mielczarek EV. Acupuncture: A Science-Based Assessment. Special
Report. A Position Paper from the Center for Inquiry’s Office of Public Policy. 
10 June 2010. [Accessed 05 October 2010].

15. Atwood K. The Ongoing Problem with the National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine. Skeptical Inquirer. 2003, 27(5). [Accessed 8 October
2010].

                             Astrology with needles

                                  Ben Kavoussi

                                      Link

The following is an excerpt of an upcoming article called “The Untold Story of
Acupuncture.” It is scheduled to be published in December 2009 in Focus in
Alternative and Complementary Therapies (FACT), a review journal that presents
the evidence on alternative medicine in an analytical and impartial manner. It
argues that if the effects of “real” and “sham” acupuncture do not significantly
differ in well-conducted trials, it is because traditional theories for
selecting points and means of stimulation are not based on an empirical
rationale, but on ancient cosmology, astrology and mythology. These theories
significantly resemble those that underlined European and Islamic astrological
medicine and bloodletting in the Middle-Ages. In addition, the alleged
predominance of acupuncture amongst the scholarly medical traditions of China is
not supported by evidence, given that for most of China’s long medical history,
needling, bloodletting and cautery were largely practiced by itinerant and
illiterate folk-healers, and frowned upon by the learned physicians who favored 
the use of pharmacopoeia.

   Heaven is covered with constellations, Earth with waterways, and man with
   channels.

   Yellow Emperor’s Canon of Medicine (黄帝内经, huang di nei jing)1

Acupuncture is presumed to have its origins in blood ritual, magic tattooing and
body piercing associated with Neolithic healing practices.2,3 The Neolithic
origin hypothesis is supported by the presence of nonfigurative tattoos on the
Tyrolean Ice Man–an inhabitant of the Oetztal Alps in Europe–whose naturally
preserved 5,200-year-old body displays a set of small cross-shaped tattoos that 
are located significantly proximal to classical acupuncture points. Medical
imaging shows that the middle-aged man suffered from lumbar arthrosis and the
cross-shaped tattoos are located at points traditionally indicated for this
condition.4,5 Similar nonfigurative tattoos and evidence of therapeutic
tattooing, lancing and blood ritual have been found throughout the Ancient
world, including the Americas.6,7,8 Health-related tattoos are still prevalent
in Tibet, where specific points on the body are needled with a blend of
medicinal herbs in the dyes. These practices appear to be largely intended to
maintain balance with the natural and spiritual worlds, and also to protect
against demonic infestation and malevolence. Seemingly, this Neolithic and
Bronze Age lancing heritage, which was intertwined with magic and animism has
evolved in various cultures into codified systems of lancing and venesection for
assuring good health and longevity. In addition to treating the impurity or
superabundance of blood, in various cultures lancing was also believed to affect
the flow of a numinous life-force that is, for instance, called qi (or chi, 氣, 
pronounced “chee”) in Chinese, prāna (प्राण) in Sanskrit, pneuma (πνεύμα) in
Greek, etc.9 In many instances, elements of metaphysics, mythology, mysticism,
magic, shamanism, exorcism, astrology and empirical medicine intimately
intertwined, making it difficult for modern scholars to interpret them as
mutually exclusive categories.

In China, for instance, the numinous force was believed to mirror the Sun’s
annual journey through the Ecliptic–meaning its apparent path on the celestial
sphere–and to circulate in a network of 12 primary jing luo (經络) known in
English as the chinglo channels or simply channels or meridians (a term coined
in 1939 by George Soulié de Morant, a French diplomat). These imaginary pathways
run from head to toes and interconnect around 360 primary points on the skin.10
There is a strong possibility that the web of these channels was a rudimentary 
model of the vascular system that was conceptualized according to an
episteme­–meaning a set of fundamental beliefs–that was based on astrological
principles and mythology. This episteme­ also indicated that a person’s health
and destiny are determined by the position of the Sun, the Moon, the 5 Planets
and the apparition of comets, along with the person’s time of birth.11 In this
worldview, each body segment corresponds to one of the 12 Houses of the Chinese 
zodiac system di zhi (地支) known in English as the Earthly Branches, and which
consists of 12 two-hour (30°) divisions of the Ecliptic. The channels are
therefore named according to their degree of yin (阴) and yang (阳), from tai yang
(太阳) to jue yin (厥阴), which are terms that describe the phases and the
positions of the Sun and the Moon.12 Each has five special points designated by 
the characters 水 (Water), 木 (Wood), 火 (Fire), 土 (Earth) and 金 (Metal) which are 
also the Chinese terms for Mercury, Jupiter, Mars, Saturn and Venus,13 and seem 
to correspond to the transit positions of these Planets in the matching House.
Each point is also associated with a color, which comes from the visual
appearance of the matching Planet in the night sky. Venus is white, Jupiter
blue-green, Saturn golden-yellow, Mars red, and Mercury “black,” for it appears 
to be the dimmest of the five. Each of these points has also an occult
connection with a direction, a segment of time, a season, a number set, a taste,
a musical note, an internal organ, a body region, etc, in an ancient Chinese
metaphysical cosmology often referred to as “correlative cosmology”14 and
reminiscent of the esoteric and mystical beliefs held by Pythagoras of Samos (c.
580-c. 490 BC) and his followers, the Pythagoreans.15 In his occult and
magico-mystical worldview, the nature of the life-force qi is often described in
such terms:16

   The major premise of Chinese medical theory is that all the forms of life in 
   the universe are animated by an essential life-force or vital energy called
   qi. Qi also means “breath” and air and is similar to the Hindu concept of
   prāna. Invisible, tasteless, odorless, and formless, qi nevertheless
   permeates the entire cosmos. Qi is transferable and transmutable; digestion
   extracts qi from food and drink and transfers it to the body, breathing
   extracts qi from air and transfers it to the lungs. When these two forms of
   qi meet in the blood-stream, they transmute to form human-qi, which then
   circulates throughout the body as vital energy. It is the quality and balance
   of your qi that determines your state of health and span of life.

Other texts refer to qi as a “cosmic spirit that pervades and enlivens all
things”17 and “from which the world was created.”18 For instance, the alchemist 
Ko Hung (葛洪, 2nd – 3rd Century AD) writes that “Man is in qi and qi is in each
human being. Heaven and Earth and the ten thousand things all require qi to stay
alive. A person that knows how to allow qi to circulate will preserve himself
and banish illness that might cause him harm.”19, 20 The belief in a
“cosmological correlation” between its pathways in the body and the Houses of
the Chinese zodiac seems to be based on health and safety beliefs in geocentric 
cosmology and the related doctrine of “as above, so below” which stipulated that
everything in the Heavens has its counterpart on Earth and also in man.

The episteme of “as above, so below” and correlative cosmology were prevalent
throughout the ancient world, from the Eastern Mediterranean cultures to
Northern Europe. It is notably found in the relics of a collection of occult
writings called the Corpus Hermetica which are believed to be compiled in
Hellenistic Egypt during the 1st or 3rd century AD and are attributed to Hermes 
Trismegistus (“Thrice-great Hermes”), the Greek equivalent of the Egyptian god
of wisdom, Thoth. The original text was presumably lost or destroyed during the 
systematic annihilation of non-Christian literature between the 4th and 6th
centuries AD. Nonetheless, a section of it known as the Emerald Tablet survived 
and was translated into Arabic by the Muslim conquerors and later into Latin by 
John of Seville c. 1140 AD and by Philip of Tripoli c. 1243 AD. An Arabic
version of the Tablet by the Muslim polymath and alchemist Abu Musa Jābir ibn
Hayyān (أبو موسى جابر بن حيان , c. 721-c. 815 AD) states “That which is above is
from that which is below, and that which is below is from that which is above, 
working the miracles of One.”21 Given the prevalence of this set of fundamental 
beliefs throughout the ancient world, it seems that the natural philosophy that 
has given rise to the underlying theories of acupuncture in China stems from the
same set of beliefs in that were also prevalent along the Silk Road in Persia, 
Mesopotamia, Egypt and in Greece and that have influenced the health and safety 
beliefs of pre-Christian Europe, such as the Eastern Mediterranean mystery
cults,22 such as Mithraic Mysteries.23 This hypothesis is supported by a
statement by Gregor (Gregorius) Reisch (c. 1467-1525) in Margarita Philosophica 
(Pearl of Wisdom), first published in 1503:24

   The pagans believed that the zodiac formed the body of the Grand Man of the
   Universe. This body, which they called the Macrocosm (the Great World), was
   divided into twelve major parts, one of which was under the control of the
   celestial powers reposing in each of the zodiacal constellations. Believing
   that the entire universal system was epitomized in man’s body, which they
   called the Microcosm (the Little World), they evolved that now familiar
   figure of “the cut-up man in the almanac” by allotting a sign of the zodiac
   to each of twelve major parts of the human body.

Figure 1: Link European medieval Zodiac Man form John de Foxton’s Liber
Cosmographiae, published in 1408. It indicated the repartition of astrological
influences on the body which physicians used to determine the auspicious time to
let blood. Images courtesy of The Master and Fellows of Trinity College,
Cambridge, UK.

Given this fundamental belief, European physicians until the 17th Century based 
the practice of medicine on celestial computations, also known as
Iatromathematics, astrological medicine or astromedicine. They therefore
utilized planetary transition tables called ephemerides or Alfonsine tables to
cast a prognostication–meaning a disease outcome prediction based on
astrological conjunctions, alignments and the angle between Planets
(Aspects)–prior to perform venesection, cupping, cautery, surgery or to
prescribe medicines with specific astral powers.25 Disease was then believed to 
result from interruptions to the flow of the numinous life-force pneuma and an
imbalance in the four humors--blood, yellow bile, black bile and phlegm–which
were each associated to an Element, a Planet, a color, etc, according to
European correlative cosmology. Therapy consisted of purging the offending humor
and its noxious pressures during favorable Aspects. Most bloodletters would
open a vein in the arm, leg or neck with a fine knife called a “lancet.” They
would tie off the area with a tourniquet and hold the lancet delicately between 
thumb and forefinger and strike diagonally or lengthwise into the vein to avoid 
severing it. They would then collect the blood in a measuring bowl.26 Initially,
according to the classical Greek procedure, blood was let from a site near the 
location of the illness but later physicians drew a smaller amount of blood from
a distant site. This procedure not only required the knowledge of the distal
cutting points and the precise amount of blood to draw, but also the knowledge
of ephemerides to establish the suitable Aspects and timing. Medieval medical
manuscripts therefore contained ephemeris charts (volvelles) and the schematic
of a body covered with astrological signs, generally known as “Zodiac Man,”
which illustrated the specific influences of astrological signs on body parts
and organs (Figure 1) and the location of the associated bloodletting points
(Figure 2).

Figure 2:  Link European Bloodletting Man from Hans von Gersdorff’s Feldtbüch
der Wundartzney, published in 1528. Bloodletting was done by venesection or the 
application of leeches. Most of these points correspond to key acupuncture
points, such as LV3, UB40, SI3, LI4, LI11, SJ3, LU5, etc. Image courtesy of the 
National Library of Medicine, US.

The allotment of the zodiacs to each of the major parts of the body started at
the head with Ares and ran down to the feet, which belonged to Pisces. Cancer
was believed to be responsible for diseases of the lungs and the eyes and
Scorpio the genital afflictions, for instance.27 The practice of lancing,
bloodletting and cupping (الحجامة, hijama) to affect specific organs or to
mitigate specific diseases based on a postulated relationship between the
internal organs and points on the surface of the skin is still prevalent amongst
the Muslims worldwide and nowadays video instructions for it are available,
even on YouTube. It is plausible that the same principle is at the origin of
acupuncture channels in China28 because the distribution of the regions of
astrological influences and the related venesection points portrayed in medieval
Islamic and European manuscripts significantly resembles the allocation of
master, command, influential, and other key points (Table 1). It is important to
note that Greco-Arabic bloodletting was known in China and fragments of
Avicenna’s (c. 980 – 1037) Cannon of Medicine (الطب في القانون) were translated 
during the time of the Yuan dynasty (1271-1368) and published along with other
Persian and Arabic texts in the Hui Hui Yao Fang (回回藥方)–meaning the
Prescriptions of the Hui Nation–with much of the text in Arabic.29 The
correlation between Chinese acupuncture and bloodletting is further supported by
the fact that the Chinese character zhēn (針) etymologically refers to lancing
with coarse needles or any sharp object used for scarification, bloodletting and
minor surgery.30 In addition, As Paul Unschuld points out, the opening of
superficial or deep-lying vessels for bloodletting seems to predate the
manipulation of qi with needles.31 However, Linda Barnes, in her fascinating
book on how China, the Chinese, and their healing practices were imagined in the
West from the late Middle Ages through to the mid-19th Century, also argues
that there were “sufficient apparent similarities that an early observer might
have been excused for imagining that the Chinese and European practices grew
from the same conceptual framework.”32 Although she seems to agree with Paul
Unschuld’s assessment that acupuncture emerged as an offshoot of bloodletting,
she also notes that the early European observers seem to have misunderstood the 
ways in which the body itself was conceptualized by the Chinese, and assumed
that they were simply using a version inferior of the Greek humoral system, and 
routinely failed to recognize or value an alternate conceptual universe which,
in the long run, made it easier for them to dismiss Chinese understandings of
the human body.

Western Zodiacs

Degrees

Regions – Organs

Chinese Zodiacs

Hours

Meridians - Organs

  Aries0°-30°Head Tiger3AM-5AMLung

  Taurus30°-60°Neck , throat Rabbit5AM-7AMLarge Intestine

  Gemini60°-90°Lungs, arms, shoulders Dragon7AM-9 AMStomach

  Cancer90°-120°Chest, breasts, stomach Snake9AM-11AMSpleen

  Leo120°-150°Heart, upper back Horse11AM-1PMHeart

  Virgo150°-180°Abdomen, digestive system Sheep1PM-3PMSmall Intestine

  Libra180°-210°Kidneys, lumbar region Monkey3PM-5PMBladder

  Scorpio210°-240°Genitals Rooster5PM-7PMKidney

  Sagittarius240°-270°Hips, thighs Dog7PM-9PMPericardium

  Capricorn270°-300°Knees, bones Pig9PM-11PMSan Jiao

  Aquarius300°-330°Calves, shins, ankles Rat11PM-1AMGallbladder

  Pisces330°-360°Feet Ox1AM-3AMLiver

Table 1: Similarities between Muslim and medieval astromedicine and traditional 
acupuncture theory. For instance, LU7, a point on the Lung meridian is the
command point of the head and the neck; LI4, an important point on the Large
Intestine meridian controls the face and the throat; SP4 on the Spleen meridian 
is used for the diseases of the chest, breast and the stomach. The Kidney
meridian controls the genitals; an important point related to San Jiao (UB39) is
found on the knee; one related to Gallbladder (GB40) on the ankle; and the most
important points of the Liver meridian, LV2-3 are on the feet, etc.33 Be noted 
that a two-hour segment is the same time measure than 30°, for the celestial
sphere moves by 15° every hour.

Paradoxically, for most of China’s long medical history, lancing, bloodletting, 
acupuncture and surgery were practiced by itinerant folk-healers and considered 
a lower class of therapy compared to the use of pharmacopoeia. As the historian 
Bridie Andrews Minehan describes:34

   The lowly acupuncturists engaged in a great deal of minor surgery, and the
   two specialties of acupuncture (zhenjiu) and external medicine or surgery
   (waike) overlapped considerably. Illustrations of the nine needles of
   acupuncture, featured in many handbooks from the late imperial period,
   depicted scalpel-like knives, cautery irons, and three-edged bodkins for
   bloodletting and lancing boils, as well as the fine needles we currently
   associate with acupuncture.

Andrews Minehan also notes that although needling is often cited in the Yellow
Emperor’s Canon of Medicine, throughout the history of China relatively little
has been written on it elsewhere. Reportedly, by the middle of the second
millennium its practice was mostly abandoned, and eventually the Chinese and
other Eastern societies took steps to eliminate it altogether.34, 35 In 1822 an 
edict banned its teaching and practice from the Imperial Medical Academy, the
institution that provided physicians to the Court. The Japanese government
equally prohibited the practice in 1876.36 The final step in China took place in
1929 when it was literally outlawed.37 However, in the early 1930s a Chinese
pediatrician by the name of Cheng Dan’an (承淡安, 1899-1957) proposed that needling
therapy should be resurrected because its actions could potentially be
explained by neurology. He therefore repositioned the points towards nerve
pathways and away from blood vessels-where they were previously used for
bloodletting. His reform also included replacing coarse needles with the
filiform ones in use today.38 Reformed acupuncture gained further interest
through the revolutionary committees in the People’s Republic of China in the
1950s and 1960s along with a careful selection of other traditional, folkloric
and empirical modalities that were added to scientific medicine to create a
makeshift medical system that could meet the dire public health and political
needs of Maoist China while fitting the principles of Marxist dialectics. In
deconstructing the events of that period, Kim Taylor in her remarkable book on
Chinese medicine in early communist China, explains that this makeshift system
has achieved the scale of promotion it did because it fitted in, sometimes in an
almost accidental fashion, with the ideals of the Communist Revolution. As a
result, by the 1960s acupuncture had passed from a marginal practice to an
essential and high-profile part of the national health-care system under the
Chinese Communist Party, who, as Kim Taylor argues, had laid the foundation for 
the institutionalized and standardized format of modern Chinese medicine and
acupuncture found in China and abroad today.39 This modern construct was also a 
part of the training of the “barefoot doctors,” meaning peasants with an
intensive three- to six-month medical and paramedical training, who worked in
rural areas during the nationwide healthcare disarray of the Cultural Revolution
era.40 They provided basic health care, immunizations, birth control and health
education, and organized sanitation campaigns. Chairman Mao believed, however, 
that ancient natural philosophies that underlined these therapies represented a 
spontaneous and naive dialectical worldview based on social and historical
conditions of their time and should be replaced by modern science.41 It is also 
reported that he did not use acupuncture and Chinese medicine for his own
ailments.42

It is the reformed and “sanitized” acupuncture and the makeshift theoretical
framework of Maoist China that have flourished in the West as “Traditional,”
“Chinese,” “Oriental,” and most recently as “Asian” medicine. Nowadays, in every
major metropolitan area in the US and in Europe, one can find acupuncture
boutiques where practitioners inaccurately claim that gently puncturing the skin
with silicon-coated stainless-steel filiform needles is a scholarly medical
tradition of ancient China that has been used for over 2,000 years to relieve
pain and to treat a variety of diseases. Meanwhile and despite what is reported 
by the advocates, this gentle insertion of fine needles at specific points on
the skin has consistently failed in well-conducted trials to show compelling
evidence of efficacy for conditions that are amenable to specific treatments.43,
44 And whatever the clinical efficacy of any type of needling therapy, there is
still no convincing evidence that meridians exist as discrete entities distinct
from blood vessels.45

ADDENDUM:

My sincerest apologies to Linda Barnes for citing her work as simply arguing
that there are sufficient similarities between needling in China and
bloodletting in Europe to warrant the belief that both practices grew from the
same conceptual framework. Indeed, the full citation is substantially more
nuanced and complex, and corrections were made to reflect her full argument. I
appreciate her bringing this to my attention.

REFERENCES:

Veith I (Translator). The Yellow Emperor’s Classic of Internal Medicine.
University of California Press, 1st edition. 2002.

Ernst E. Acupuncture – a critical analysis. J Intern Med. 2006; 259(2):125-137.

Ramey D, Buell PD. A true history of acupuncture. Focus Altern Complement Ther. 
2004;9:269-273.

Dorfer L, Moser M, Spindler K, Bahr F, Egarter-Vigl E, Dohr G. 5200-year-old
acupuncture in central Europe? Science. 1998;282(5387):242-243.

Dorfer L, Moser M, Bahr F, et al. A medical report from the Stone Age? Lancet.
1999;354:1023-1025.

Smith, GS, Zimmerman R. Tattooing Found on a 1600 Year Old Frozen, Mummified
Body from St. Lawrence Island, Alaska. American Antiquity 40(4): 433-437. 1975.

Garcia, Hernan and Antonio, Sierra. Wind in the Blood – Mayan Healing & Chinese 
Medicine. Redwing Books, 1999.

Villoldo A. Shaman, Healer, Sage. Hamony Books, 2000.

Lao Tzu (Author), Mair VH (Translator). Tao Te Ching: The Classic Book of
Integrity and the Way. New York. Bantam Books. 1990.

Whorton JC. Nature Cures: The History of Alternative Medicine in America. Oxford
University Press, 2004.

Wu AS. Chinese Astrology. The Career Press, Inc. 2005.

Lo V. The territory between life and death. Essay review. Med Hist. 2003
Apr;47(2):250-8.

Walters D. Chinese Astrology. Aquarian Press. 1987.

Pregadio F. Great Clarity: Daoism and Alchemy in Early Medieval China. Stanford 
University Press, 1st edition. 2006.

Burkert W. Lore and Science in Ancient Pythagoreanism. Harvard University Press,
Cambridge, MA. 1972.

Reid D. Chinese Herbal Medicine. Shambhala. 1987.

Pas JF. Historical Dictionary of Taoism. The Scarecrow Press, Inc. 1998.

Religion of Tao. Center of Traditional Taoist Studies. www.tao.org. Accessed
September 2008.

Fischer-Schreiber I. The Shambhala Dictionary of Taoism. Shambhala. 1st edition.
1996.

Ware J. Alchemy, Medicine and Religion in the China of A.D. 320. The Nei P’ien
of Ko Hung (Pao-p’u tzu). Cambridge (Mass.): M.I.T. Press, 1966. Reprint. New
York: Dover Publications, 1981.

Holmyard EJ (editor) The Arabic Works of Jabir ibn Hayyan. New York, E. P.
Dutton. 1928.

Kingsley P. Ancient Philosophy, Mystery, and Magic: Empedocles and Pythagorean
Tradition. Oxford University Press. 1997.

Copenhaver, BP (Editor). Hermetica: The Greek Corpus Hermeticum and the Latin
Asclepius in a New English Translation, with Notes and Introduction. Cambridge. 
1992.

Reisch G. Margarita Philosophica, Hoc Est Habituum Sev Disciplinarum Omnium.
Basileæ 1583.

Jackson WA. A Short Guide to Humoral Medicine. Trends Pharmacol Sci. 2001
Sep;22(9):487-9.

Starr D. Blood: An Epic History of Medicine and Commerce. Knopf. 1st edition.
1998.

Manilius M (author), Goold GP (Translator). Manilius: Astronomica. Harvard
University Press. 1977.

Epler DC Jr. Bloodletting in early Chinese medicine and its relation to the
origin of acupuncture. Bull Hist Med. 1980 Fall;54(3):337-67.

Alpher JV (Editor) Oriental Medicine: An Illustrated Guide to the Asian Arts of 
Healing. Serindia. United Kingdom, 1st Edition 1995.

Hall H. Puncturing the Acupuncture Myth. Science-Based Medicine. Posted on
October 21, 2008. Accessed November 2008.
http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=252.

Unschuld PU. Medicine in China: A History of Ideas. University of California
Press. 1988.

Barnes LL. Needles, Herbs, Gods, and Ghosts: China, Healing, and the West to
1848. Harvard University Press. 2005.

Kim HB. Handbook of Oriental Medicine. Harmony & Balance Press; 3rd Edition.
2007.

Andrews BJ. History of Pain: Acupuncture and the Reinvention of Chinese
Medicine. APS Bulletin. May/June 1999;9(3). 5.

Unschuld PU: The past 1000 years of Chinese medicine. Lancet Suppl SIV9:354,
1999.

Skrbanek P: Acupuncture: Past, present and future, in Stalker D, Glymour C
(editors): Examining Holistic Medicine. Buffalo, NY, Prometheus Books. 1985.

Ma KW. The roots and development of Chinese acupuncture: from prehistory to
early 20th century. Acupunct Med 1992;10(Suppl):92-9.

Andrews B. Tailoring Tradition: The Impact of Modern Medicine on Traditional
Chinese Medicine, 1887-1937. In Alleton V and Volkov A (editors). Notions et
Percpetions du Changement et Chine. Paris: Collège de France, Institut des
Hautes Études Chinoises. 1994

Taylor K. Chinese Medicine in Early Communist China, 1945-63; A Medicine of
Revolution, RoutledgeCurzon, 2005.

Scheid V. Chinese Medicine in Contemporary China: Plurality and Synthesis. Duke 
University Press, 2002.

Schram SR. The Political Thought of Mao Tse-Tung. New York: Praeger Publishers. 
1969.

Basser S. Acupuncture: a history. Sci Rev Altern Med 1999;3:34-41.

Ernst E, White A, eds. Acupuncture: A Scientific Appraisal. Oxford, UK:
Butterworth-Heinemann. 1999.

Ernst E. The recent history of acupuncture. Am J Med. 2008 Dec;121(12):1027-8.

Ernst E. Complementary medicine: the facts. Phys Ther Rev 1997;2:49-57.

                         James Reston’s Tooth of Gold 

                                 Ben Kavoussi 

                                      Link

One of the fathers of critical thinking and skeptical inquiry, the French
philosopher Bernard le Bovier de Fontenelle (1657–1757) recounts in 1687 in his 
Histoire des oracles–a debunking book on popular beliefs, myths and
superstitions that caused tremendous stir in theological and philosophical
circles of his time–a colorful story that could very well illustrate the flurry 
of interest and research in acupuncture that followed a 1971 anecdotal account
of its use in China, and the plethora of verbiage and publications that ensued. 
If the story of the Tooth of Gold is comical, colorful and amusing, its
applicability to acupuncture is not.

   In 1593, the rumor ran that a seven year old in Silesia grew a tooth of gold 
   in place of one of the cheek tooth he lost. Horatius, professor of medicine
   at the University of Helmstad, wrote a history of this tooth in 1595 and
   alleged that it was partially natural, partially miraculous, and that it was 
   sent by God to this child to console the Christians that were oppressed by
   the Turks. Just imagine what consolation and what concern this tooth might
   bring to the Christians or to the Turks. For this tooth not to lack
   historians, Rullandus rewrote its history in the same year. Two years later, 
   Ingolsteterus, another learned man, wrote against the views of Rullandus on
   the tooth of gold; to which Rullandus immediately wrote a fine and wise
   reply. Another great man named Libavius gathered all that had been written on
   this tooth and added his own views. Nothing lacked to these many fine books,
   other than the tooth were truly of gold. When the goldsmith examined it, he 
   found that it was made of a leaf of gold skillfully applied to the tooth; but
   they began by writing books and then they consulted the goldsmith.1

   Translated from French by the author

Besides the glut of popular publications on Chinese acupuncture and medicine by 
wishful authors without any training in biomedical sciences and healthcare, the 
NIH, the NCCAM, and some of our most prodigious medical universities also have
official and academic publications on the subject that too well resemble the
fine and wise publications of Horatius and his contemporaries. They also began
by writing books and articles on the theories that could explain the purported
indications of acupuncture, and then they assessed the veracity these
indications in clinical trials and according to the principles of evidence-based
medicine.

The rumor ran this time in 1971, when James Reston, a journalist in President
Nixon’s press corps, reported in an article in The New York Times to have
experienced relief by acupuncture for his postoperative abdominal distension.
Within the following months, journalists, scientists and physicians made
pilgrimages to China, most reporting in the popular press, and a few in
scientific journals, that thousands of successful operations were being carried 
out in PRC using acupuncture anesthesia; some described its use for a host of
conditions; other went as far as claiming its miraculous efficacy for treating
paralysis and deafness!2

For acupuncture not to lack authors and historians, many holistic health gurus
who did not have any knowledge of the history of medicine in China or in the
West; who lacked familiarity with the Chinese language and cultural linguistics;
and who have never–or, at best, for short periods–been to China,3 also turned
their Countercultural fantasies about the “Mythical Orient” into a series of
introductory books on the “Foundation of Chinese Medicine,” or on “Understanding
Chinese Medicine” and portrayed a set of astrology-based beliefs that
throughout the history of China have been associated with astral magic, amulets 
and talismans, and frowned upon by the leaned physicians,4 as gentle, humane,
natural, organic, holistic and patient-centered therapies that are free from the
constraints of the so-called repressive rationality of industrialized medicine.
Certain went as far as associating the health and safety mythologie of
Bronze-Age China with emergentism and naturalism, and metaphorically described
them as a “Web That Has No Weaver.”

Meanwhile, numerous clinical trials were also initiated, often poorly-conducted 
and biased, and their results too often suggested that acupuncture is effective 
for a surprisingly wide range of conditions.5 Finally in 1997, the NIH resorted 
to a panel of scientists and experts, “to provide health care providers,
patients, and the general public with a responsible assessment of the use and
effectiveness of acupuncture for a variety of conditions.” In the published
Consensus Statement that gathered their views, the NIH claimed that there is
“clear evidence” that needle acupuncture is effective for a long list of
conditions and perhaps beneficial for many others.6

In the sobering decade that followed, systematic reviews of literature, notably 
one by Howard H. Moffet of Kaiser Permanente Division of Research, indicated
that although acupuncture can affect outcomes and is distinguishable from a
placebo, trials that compare distinct needling regimens often do not indicate
statistically significant differences in outcomes. Indeed, the dominant
scientific rationale for acupuncture involves the release of neurochemicals
(such as endorphins) by the irritation and injury it causes, but there is little
evidence that this release depends on any specific points or means of
stimulation. Therefore, traditional theories for selecting points and
stimulation methods appear to be unreliable for creating distinct regimens in
clinical trials. Furthermore, since the difference between “real’’ and “sham”
(control) treatments has not been clearly demonstrated, Moffet’s review
concluded that most acupuncture clinical trials lack any scientific rationale to
justify any specific regimens, and  that the theoretical basis and logic for
acupuncture practice and research need to be re-evaluated.7

A most recent, as-yet-unpublished NIH-sponsored three-arm trial on chronic back 
pain also seems to confirm these conclusions. The subjects received either an
individualized regimen according to the traditional acupuncture theories, or a
standardized regimen, or sham (control) needling. Results demonstrate that
acupuncture added to usual care was superior to usual care alone, but different 
regimens were not more effective than control needling.8 These results indicate 
that the observed actions of acupuncture are either due to the placebo effect,
or to the irritation and injury caused by the insertion of a needle, and they in
fact are independant of the traditional theories for selecting points and
stimulation methods.

Deplorably, these results also indicate that in an era when pharmacogenomics and
therapeutic cloning appear to be not-too-distant possibilities, medical inquiry
and publication can still be based on rumor and hearsay in the press and in the
popular culture, and lead to much illusory verbiage before scientific rigor and
skeptical inquiry could assess their veracity, just as it happened about 500
years go, in 1593!

REFERENCES:

Fontenelle BLB (Author), Bergier J (Editor). Fontenelle: Entretiens sur la
Pluralité des Mondes suivi de Histoire des Oracles. Marabout Université. 1973. 

Reisser PC, Reisser TK, Weldon J. New Age Medicine: A Christian Perspective on
Holistic Health. Intervarsity Press. 1988.

Bauer M. An Interview With Dr. Paul Unschuld, Acupuncture Today. July, 2004,
Vol. 05, Issue 07.

Barnes LL. Needles, Herbs, Gods, and Ghosts: China, Healing, and the West to
1848. Harvard University Press. 2005

Ernst E. The recent history of acupuncture. Am J Med. 2008 Dec;121(12):1027-8.

National Institutes of Health. Acupuncture. NIH Consensus Statement.
1997;15(5):1-34.

Moffet HH. Traditional acupuncture theories yield null outcomes: a systematic
review of clinical trials. J Clin Epidemiol. 2008 Aug;61(8):741-7. Epub 2008 Jun
6.

Low-back pain: NACCAM Symposium features two researchers. Focus Complement Alt
Ther. 2007;XIV(4):4-6.

                      Acupuncture and Modern Bloodletting

                                 Steven Novella

                                      Link

Last year Ben Kavoussi published an interesting article on SBM called Astrology 
with Needles in which he purported a historical connection between acupuncture
and bloodletting. I had previously thought that bloodletting was a uniquely
Western cultural invention – part of Galenic medicine involving the balancing of
the four humors, one of which being blood. (In the West bloodletting faded away
with the advent of science-based medicine in the 19th century.) I was intrigued
by this connection and have since been doing my own reading on the topic. It
turns out that bloodletting was common throughout ancient cultures and not
unique to the west.

In fact acupuncture was originally a form of bloodletting – the “needles” were
really lances and the acupuncture points locations over veins to be opened. Chi,
or the Chinese concept of the life force, was believed to be partly in the
blood, and blood letting could be used to free the flow of chi. This was closely
related to the Galenic concept of using bloodletting to free the flow of static
blood in the tissue.

For example, in the ancient medical text of Suwen, we find:

   When heaven is warm and when the sun is bright,

   then the blood in man is rich in liquid

   and the protective qi is at the surface

   Hence the blood can be drained easily, and the qi can be made to move on 
   easily…

We also see in the text the connection of the functions of the body to celestial
events. The concepts of blood, life force, and astrology all came together in
acupuncture, but also in the ancient medical traditions of the West, just with
different names and specific variations. The main concepts were balance and flow
– lancing or needling were used to restore balance and flow to the natural
rhythms dictated by the heavens.

You may be surprised to learn that these concepts have a continuous cultural
connection to the present. In general the concept of bloodletting has fallen out
of popularity because it seems barbaric and because the real physiological
function of blood is now understood, and so are the dangers of bloodletting. But
the techniques that were originally developed for bloodletting have been
“rebranded” to be more acceptable to modern sensibilities (at least to a
degree). And so acupuncture is now purely about chi and no longer about blood,
and even more scientific explanations for how it might work are being sought. In
my opinion, this is all a fool’s errand – chasing the bloodletter’s craft.

Cupping was also developed as a method of drawing out the blood. But now it is
used to draw out imaginary toxins.

I had thought this “rebranding” was complete and all traces of bloodletting
removed from the modern variants of these practices. But the cultural roots go
deep, and even modern practitioners, relying on ancient texts, still adhere to
some of the bloodletting concepts. They talk about treating blood “stasis”,
which is a very Galenic concept.

The Japanese version of acupuncture, Shiraku, which survives today also closely 
ties together bloodletting and acupuncture (Shiraku means bloodletting). They
combine cupping with lancing within an “acupuncture framework.”

The Institute for Tradition Medicine online has this gem, which extols the
therapeutic benefits of “bleeding points.”

   Peripheral blood-letting today is mainly carried out at the fingers and
   toes. At the tips of the toes, for example, are the qiduan points, located
   0.1 cun behind the nails. These are said to be useful for emergency treatment
   for stroke or for numbness of the toes, also for redness, swelling, and pain
   of the instep of the foot.

I will have to remember that the next time a patient comes in with a stroke. It 
seems that the amount of blood drawn has been significantly reduced, which is
good, but the ancient bloodletting concepts are all there unchanged.

Further, Acupuncture Today contains an article describing the use of
bloodletting in modern acupuncture. The author, Skya Abbate, DOM, writes:

   However, bleeding is a specialized technique for specific conditions that
   can produce effective and dramatic results when the patient’s condition is
   diagnosed properly and the bleeding method expertly executed.

As an example of the use of bloodletting, Abbate writes:

   It can invigorate the smooth flow of qi and blood, thereby picking up and
   facilitating its flow when the qi and blood need invigoration. An example of
   this scenario occurs when a patient presents with a wiry pulse and mild
   feelings of stagnation that indicate qi stagnation.

The concepts of the flow of qi and blood are alive and well. I could have told
you that was a quote from a medieval text and you probably would not have
questioned it.

Conclusion:

When the actual history of acupuncture, bloodletting, cupping, and similar
techniques are investigated we find that there are many modern myths about these
practices. One myth is that there were completely different traditions in the
various cultures, especially East and West. In reality, these were only cultural
variations on the same themes – restoring balance and flow to blood and life
energy in accordance to some astrological principles.

There is also evidence of direct cultural contact – not just reinventing the
same concepts. For example, the iceman is the frozen remains of a 5200 year old 
man found in the Alps. He was covered with tattoos of points and lines over
traditional acupuncture points. This was probably an example of therapeutic
tattooing – the tattoos themselves were meant to be therapeutic. There are also 
needle punctures as some of these points. Think about the implications of a
person living near the Alps (what is now Europe) 5200 years ago being tattooed
over what later were known as acupuncture points.

It is further a myth that what we know today as acupuncture or cupping were
developed in line with their modern incarnations. In reality, these techniques
were just variations of bloodletting and were very deliberately and fairly
recently distanced from their bloodletting roots to make them more acceptable.

And finally it is a myth that bloodletting itself has been eliminated from
traditional practice. It survives in muted form in various traditions.

                  Oriental Medicine or Medical Orientalism?  

                                 Ben Kavoussi 

                                      Link

The following is the second adapted excerpt of an upcoming article called “The
Untold Story of Acupuncture.” It is scheduled to be published in December 2009
in Focus in Alternative and Complementary Therapies (FACT), a review journal
that presents the evidence on alternative medicine in an analytical and
impartial manner. This section argues that the current flurry of interest in
acupuncture and Oriental Medicine stems predominantly out of postmodern
opposition to Enlightenment rationalism, and bears witness to Orientalism and
consumerism in contemporary medicine.

   In five years, from 1971 to 1975, l directly experienced Est [Erhard Seminars
   Training], gestalt therapy, bioenergetics, rolfing, massage, jogging, health
   foods, tai chi, Esalen, hypnotism, modern dance, meditation, Silva Mind
   Control, Arica, acupuncture, sex therapy, Reichian therapy and More House — a
   smorgasbord course in New Consciousness.1

   Jerry Rubin (1938 – 1994)

Although acupuncture has been known in the US since the 19th Century, its
therapeutic claims were dismissed or judged to be “much overrated” by the
medical community.2,3 Nonetheless, the publication of a report in the New York
Times by James Reston, a reporter in President Nixon’s press corps who had
received acupuncture for postoperative cramps in Beijing in 1971 changed this
perception, and triggered a flurry of interest amongst the American public and
some in the medical community.4 Within the following months, journalists,
scientists and physicians rushed to China to withness this peculiar phenomenon, 
which the popular press and a few scientific journals sensationalized by
reporting that thousands of successful operations of all sorts were being
carried out in PRC using acupuncture anesthesia; some elaborated on its
widespread use for a myriad of conditions, to include paralysis and deafness!5

These unconfirmed claims in the heady social and intellectual climate of the
1970s–meaning the American Counterculture; the rejection of mainstream values,
beliefs and ideals; the youth movement, nonconformism and the hippie subculture,
the belief in a “New” and  “Cosmic” consciousness and the cult phenomenon;
revolutionary ideas mixed with environmentalism; organic farming and the
avoidance of pollution, agrochemicals and pharmaceuticals; nonconformism and
alternative lifestyles; a syncretistic mix of psychedelic drugs, Eastern
religions and Native American spiritualities; the resurgence of the taste for
mystic, occult, and magical phenomena;6,7 and the belief in the existence of a
separate and non-ordinary reality, as upheld by one of the fathers of the New
Age movement, Carlos Castaneda8–gave the justification to view acupuncture as a 
“heal all” therapy based on alternate perceptions of health and disease.  This
amalgamation happened precisely when a whole generation of disenchanted
Westerners were eager to find novel solutions for their existential
predicaments; one that would be free from the constraints of the so-called
“repressive rationality” of modern science in “overdeveloped” societies.9,10.
Most Western publications on acupuncture therefore fostered the belief that
Eastern healing arts have crucial characteristics directly and unequivocally
opposite to the repressive rationalism of the West.

This unfounded belief seems to stem out of our collective amnesia about lancing 
and bloodletting, and the belief in the existence of pneuma, or other vitalist
notions that have been part of European natural philosophy and medicine since
the Greek Antiquity. Indeed, as a result of successive epistemological
ruptures11 during the last five centuries, medicine in the West has gradually
evolved from late medieval astromedicine and humoral pathology to the molecular 
medicine and cellular pathology of today. Therefore, fundamental notions that
once underlined European medicine have gradually become so foreign to us that
their Eastern counterparts now seem to be based on worldviews fundamentally
different than ours. But in the eyes of many historians and epistemologists,
they have always appeared as similar to ideas that prevailed in
Pre-Enlightenment Europe, and based on which the Fasciculus Medicinae12 and
other late medieval medical treatises were written.

These ideas continue to find an audience in todays’s post-Counterculture era due
to the continued postmodern opposition to Enlightenment rationalism and the
claim that modern science does not provide more access to the truth than any
other fields of knowledge–that scientific discourse is mainly just another
coherent “narrative” or “language-game” governed by a set of protocols and a
special terminology.13,14 In this climate of incredulity toward “metanarratives”
and universal knowledge, many nonscientific forms of knowledge have gained
legitimacy and popularity as a result of the prevalence of postmodern culture,
politics and economics. Many ancient, folkloric and traditional systems of
medicine have thus appeared as compelling narratives, perceived by patients as
legitimate and equivalent but opposite to the logical empiricism of modern
science.

The persistence of such ideas is also due to what the late Edward Saïd
(1935–2003) has called Orientalism. In a 1978 publication by the same name, Saïd
convincingly argued that the idea that Eastern cultures have crucial
characteristics directly and unequivocally opposite to the West is a Western
construct that “exotices” the East while neglecting considerations of power.
Saïd argued that the alleged distinction between Oriental and Occidental thought
primarily derives from a set of scholarly and popular fantasies about Eastern
civilizations, Classical Eras, Golden Ages, scriptures, works of art,
philosophies and religions where mysticism is set against the rationalism and
detachment of the West.15 Saïd also argued that this mythical Orient is a mere
fiction that serves to represent the hidden desires of Western cultures, a
mysterious “Other” onto which we project our fantasies.16 The pervasiveness of
such projected fantasies about Eastern reactions to health and disease onto
acupuncture and Chinese medicine, certainly confirms Saïd’s argument. The
fictional character of this “Other” medicine can be further perceived in the
indecisiveness of the professional associations and the regulatory agencies to
refer to acupuncture and related modalities as “Chinese,” “Oriental,” “Asian” or
“Eastern,” for these utterly broad “umbrella” categorizations are based on
political correctness, and do not correspond to any geopolitical and historical 
reality other than a geographical and philosophical “orient”-ation.

Paradoxically, while the theme of “evidence of effectiveness” was gradually
becoming a central part of international, national, and regional public health
dialogue in the 1980s and 1990s,17 medical Orientalism became an important
commercial phenomenon by becoming synonymous with the fashionable and eclectic
New Age notions of “natural,” “alternative,” “holistic” or “integrative,” and
has since catered to health-consumers who aspire towards traditionalism and
spirituality,18 and who believe in a vast spectrum of ideas and practices
sourced by Eastern religions, paganism, alternative science, astrology, and a
range of other beliefs emanating out of a general interest in the
paranormal.19,20 In a fascinating article on cults in American, Camille Paglia
explains how the New Age movement gradually became an international commercial
success in the 1990 with specialty shops and mail-order catalogs supplying the
“ritual paraphernalia of amulets and talismans, healing crystals, angel icons,
incense, candles, aromatherapy bath salts, massage rollers, table fountains,
wind chimes, and recordings of trance music in Asian or Celtic moods.”21 To
this, she could have added herbal products, various types of yoga, chakra and
energy healing, tai chi, qi gong, reflexology, reiki, shiatsu and also
acupuncture, where, as Robert Frank and Gunnar Stollberg have argued,
“physicians tailor their practice to the individual patient’s (perceived)
demands.”22 This international commercial success has undeniably benefited
China’s export of medicinal herbs and acupuncture related products, especially
when their domestic use is in sharp decline due to the broader availability of
modern medicine in a country that strives to reach the top in science and
technology. 

At last, considering how the popular press in the 1970s created an enormous
interest for acupuncture in the West; how many books by authors who often did
not have any familiarity with Chinese history, culture and language popularized 
a set of unexamined assumptions about the mythical Oriental and its medicine;
and how they persists merely due to a set of social, intellectual and economical
factors; it is pertinent to evoke Bernard le Bovier de Fontenelle’s (1657–1757)
words of wisdom, who in 1687 in Histoire des oracles wrote what should be the
“mantra” of all serious endeavor and publication in alternative medicine: “if
the truth of a fact were always ascertained before its cause inquired into, or
its nature disputed, much ridicule might be avoided by the learned.”23

REFERENCES:

Cross G. An All-Consuming Century: Why Commercialism Won in Modern America.
Columbia University Press. 2000.

Cassedy J. Early uses of acupuncture in the United States, with an addendum
(1826) by Bache F, MD. Bull N Y Acad Med 1974; 50: 892–906.

Gross S. A System of Surgery. Philadelphia: Blanchard & Lea, 1: 1859.

Reston J. Now, about my operation in Peking; Now, let me tell you about my
appendectomy in Peking. New York Times. July 26, 1971:1.

Reisser PC, Reisser TK, Weldon J. New Age Medicine: A Christian Perspective on
Holistic Health. Intervarsity Press. 1988.

Turner F. From Counterculture to Cyberculture: Stewart Brand, the Whole Earth
Network, and the Rise of Digital Utopianism, University of Chicago Press. 2006.

Roszak T. The Making of a Counter Culture: Reflections on the Technocratic
Society and Its Youthful Opposition. University of California Press; New Ed
edition. 1995.

Castaneda C. The Teachings of Don Juan: A Yaqui Way of Knowledge. University of 
California Pres. 1968.

Unschuld PU The reception of Oriental medicine in the West. Lecture given in
Kobe, Japan, May 1995.
www.paradigm-pubs.com/sites/www.paradigm-pubs.com/files/u1/reorme.pdf. Accessed 
March 2009.

Marcuse H. One-Dimensional Man: Studies in the Ideology of Advanced Industrial
Society. Beacon Press. Boston. 1964.

Bachelard G. Formation of the Scientific Mind. Clinamen Press, Manchester. 2002.

Ketham, J de. The Fasciculus Medicinae of Johannes de Ketham, Alemanus :
facsimile of the first edition of 1491. With English translation by Luke
Demaitre ; commentary by Karl Sudhoff ; trans. and adapted by Charles Singer.
Birmingham: Classics of Medicine Library, 1988.

Lyotard JF, Thébaud JL, Godzich W (translator). Just Gaming. University of
Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, 1985.

Powell J. Postmodernism For Beginners. New York: Writers and Readers. 1998.

Powell J. Easter Philosophy For Beginners. New York: Writers and Readers. 2000.

Sim S. Introducing Critical Theory. Totem Books. 2002.

Anderson LM, Brownson RC, Fullilove MT, Teutsch SM, Novick LF, Fielding J, Land 
GH. Evidence-based public health policy and practice: promises and limits. Am J 
Prev Med. 2005 Jun;28(5 Suppl):226-30.

Sedgwick M. Against the Modern World: Traditionalism and the Secret Intellectual
History of the Twentieth Century. Oxford University Press, 2004.

Siapush M. Post-modern values, dissatisfaction with conventional medicine and
popularity of alternative therapies. J Sociol 1998; 34: 58-70.

Partridge CH. The Re-enchantment Of The West: Alternative Spiritualities,
Sacralization, Popular Culture, and Occulture. T. & T. Clark Publishers. 2005.

Paglia C. Cults and Cosmic Consciousness: Religious Vision in the American
1960s, Arion, Winter 2003.

Frank R, Stollberg G. Medical acupuncture in Germany: patterns of consumerism
among physicians and patients. Sociol Health Illn. 2004 Apr;26(3):351-72.

Fontenelle BLB (Author), Bergier J (Editor). Fontenelle: Entretiens sur la
Pluralité des Mondes suivi de Histoire des Oracles. Marabout Université. 1973. 

Oriental Medicine: a Tall Tale of Outdated Lore

Ben Kavoussi on August 13, 2012

Link

Editor’s Note: Dr. Gorski was on a rare vacation last week, recharging his
batteries. As a result, there is no new material by him this week. Fortunately, 
Ben Kavoussi was ready with another in his series of posts on traditional
Chinese medicine. Dr. Gorski will return next week; that is, if he doesn’t
return even sooner because he can’t stand to be away from SBM for two whole
weeks.

   The established laws of nature do not support Oriental Medicine’s claim of
   Yin and Yang and Five-Phases Theory. Oriental Medicine’s main theory was
   constructed when our civilization had limited methods to understand our
   surroundings, and as such, it is only an ancient illusion.1

   — Yong-Sang Yoo, MD, PhD, Chairman of the Committee for Medical Unification, 
   Korean Medical Association, 2010

Yong-Sang Yoo is one of the strong and growing voices in Korea that is calling
for an end to the national insurance coverage for Oriental Medicine.

Similarly, Professor Zhang Gongyao of the Central South China University
petitioned the central government of China in 2006 to abolish support for
Oriental Medicine because it has “no clear understanding of the human body, of
the functions of medicines and their links to disease. It is more like a boat
without a compass: it may reach the shore finally but it’s all up to luck.”2
Zhang Gongyao and fellow critics have consequently blasted China’s traditional
medicine as an often ineffective, even dangerous derivative of witchcraft that
relies on untested concoctions and obscure ingredients to trick patients, and
employs a host of excuses if the treatments do not work.3

Bloodletting is used in Oriental Medicine to relieve excess “heat,” meaning
fever, sore throat, joint pain, muscle sprain, as well as inflammation. It is
often practiced in unsanitary conditions.

A Product of Archaic Thinking

The arguments of Yong-Sang Yoo and Zhang Gongyao are reminiscent of those of
William R. Morse, Dean of Medical School at West China Union University, who
wrote in 1934 that China’s traditional medicine was a “weird medley of
philosophy, religion, superstition, magic, alchemy, astrology, feng shui,
divination, sorcery, demonology and quackery.” Morse added that Chinese
diagnostic methods “border on the ridiculous and possibly cross the line into
absurdity.” Harvey J. Howard — a Dean at the Peking Union Medical College — also
wrote in 1934 that “the great majority of these Chinese medicines reminds one
of the list of remedies suggested by the third witch in Shakespeare’s Hamlet.”4


Despite its antiquated underpinnings, Oriental Medicine has survived in East
Asia due to an unfortunate interplay of socioeconomic and political forces. For 
instance, after being outlawed during the Japanese occupation (1910-1945), the
profession was resurrected in South Korea and was able to join the National
Medical Insurance program in 1987. This revival is due to the Korean
government’s laissez-faire policy, combined with the unified efforts and the
activism of the advocates.5 In China, Oriental Medicine has a protected status
that — at least in theory — guarantees it equal footing with scientific
medicine.

But since the 1970s, Oriental Medicine has almost experienced some popularity in
the West, although for different reasons. Once considered archaic and obsolete,
Oriental Medicine has greatly benefited from the postmodern attitudes towards
science and knowledge. This is because postmodernists consider the “truth” as
being relative to one’s viewpoint or stance. They do not see science as a
superior process of acquiring knowledge, but as a “belief system,” a “language
game,” which does not give more access to truth than other conceptual
constructs.6

This attitude towards science has even achieved the status of academic orthodoxy
in Liberal Arts and Humanities in the last decades.7 Many proponents of
“alternative” medicine use this academic attitude to reject science as a method 
of determining the truth about health and treatments.8 Anti-science advocates
believe that these notions offer a viewpoint that is “placed in stark contrast
to the naive materialism that informs some scientific points of view.”9

The proponents of unscientific medicines, however, do not realize that prior to 
the scientific revolution, medicine was some kind of “mass professional
delusion,” as David Wootton has pointed out. Prescientific remedies, in general,
did more harm than good. Wootton argues that patients sought help from
physicians, not because of the efficacy of the ancient remedies, but out of
desperation; because doing something was perceived as better than doing
nothing.10

They also tend to forget that, as Paul Unschuld has argued, a sharp contrast
between “Western” (meaning scientific) medicine and Oriental Medicine is
entirely fictitious. The concepts and practices of scientific medicine have
their roots not only in traditional European medicine but also in Chinese
medicine, writes Unschuld. This is because modern medicine has emerged from a
set of conceptual roots that once existed in Europe and continue to exist today 
in the Far-East. Unschuld therefore argues that by looking at Eastern medicine, 
modern medicine is actually looking at its own past.11

Prevalent Along the Silk Road

The conceptual similarities mentioned by Unschuld are not coincidental.
Historical evidence clearly indicates that the medicine of medieval China and
Europe were once intimately linked through the contribution of
Middle-Easterners. Due to the importance of this rich cross-pollination along
the Silk Road, the historian Paul Buell also disputes the validity of “any
claims of isolation between east and west, west and east, with the individual
worlds turned in on themselves.” Rather, he recognizes an ongoing “medical and
other globalization of the cultures of Eurasia in the 13th and 14th
centuries.”12

Indeed, the spice trade by Middle-Easterners along the Silk Road brought many
herbal, animal and mineral products to Europe from the Far-East. These products 
were used for seasoning food, dying fabrics, making perfumes, love potions and
tonics, and also for treating diseases. Often spice traders would create a sense
of mystery by withholding the origins of their wares, and would ensure high
prices by spinning fantastic tales about how they obtained them.13 This trade
was so vital to Europeans that when it was curtailed by wars in the Near East
and the conquest of Constantinople by Ottoman Turks in 1453, they decided to
explore a maritime route to the spice sources westwards. In 1492, Christopher
Columbus set out sail to find this route.14

As a result of the commerce between Europe and the Far-East during the
Middle-Ages, it would be accurate to state that although the medieval medicine
of Europe owes its origin to Greeks and Romans, a significant portion of it
actually came from concepts that were commonly shared along the Silk Road. These
concepts are commonly known as humorism or humoralism. It is a belief that the 
body is made up of several fluids (humors), and an excess or deficiency of any
of them directly influences health and disposition. Diseases were not seen as
forces or entities separate from the body, but as states of humoral
imbalances.15

In humorism, each body fluid (humor) was associated with an organ, a quality, a 
temperament, etc. (Table 1). The prevalent belief was that if humors became
imbalanced (dyscrasia) or unhealthy (cacochymia) illness resulted. Deficiencies 
and excesses or humors were diagnosed by examining the pulse, body discharges
and complexion. Bloodletting, purging, enemas, nutrition, and herbal remedies
were routinely used as ways to bring the humors back into balance.16

Blood was thought to be made in the liver and distributed throughout the body in
the veins. Air and “vital spirits” went from lungs to the heart, where they
were distributed to the tissue via arteries. The fact that a cut artery squirted
blood rather than air was explained by unseen links between arteries and veins 
that opened upon injury. The belief was that the tissues consumed all blood
delivered to them, and the liver had to make new blood continuously.17

The four humors in Greco-Arabic medicine. The Chinese have a five humor system, 
with different but comparable relationships. Source: Jackson WA, 2001
It is important to realize that humorism was a first step towards scientific
thinking and materialism. Prior to that, disease was believed to be caused by
malignant supernatural forces, such as angry divinities, demons, spirits, or by 
witchcraft and malediction. It was the punishment for impiety and sin, or for
the failure to observe religious rites and precepts. Paul Unschuld also views
the advent of humorism as a shift from the “ontological” (single-factorial) view
to a “functional-individualistic” (multi-factorial) view of disease.

A late medieval publication, the Fasciculus Medicinae (first printed in 1491)
illustrates the most important figures of the humoral theory in medieval
times.18. If you look at the books on the top shelf in this woodcut from the
Fasciculus, next to Aristotle, Hippocrates, and Galen, stand Avicenna, Haly
Abbas, Rhazes, Mesue, and Averroes. Pliny the Elder’s Historia Naturalis, and
the books of Isaac Judaeus and Avenzoar are either open on the stand or on the
table.

In this first printed medical text to contain illustrations, the author outlines
the breadth of medical lore in 15th century Italy. This woodcut represents a
scholar at the University of Padua surrounded by medical classics. Image Source:
Title page from Johannes de Ketham’s Fasciculus Medicinae. Venice: J. and G. de
Gregoriis, de Forlivio (Venice, 1495). Library of Congress, US.

The birthplace of the majority of these authors traces the Silk Road. Avicenna
was a Central Asian, born near Bukhara in present-day Uzbekistan. Haly Abbas was
from Ahvaz, in contemporary Iran. Rhazes was born in Ray, and Mesue in
Gundeshapur — both in Iran. Isaac Judaeus Israeli was born in Egypt, and
Averroes and Avenzoar were from Andalusia, in present-day Spain. The period of
this remarkable Judeo-Islamic contribution to European medicine is from 8th to
12th century.

The most important figure during this period was Avicenna (ابن سينا, Ibn Sīnā,
980–1037), the author of the Canon of Medicine (القانون في الطب, Al-Qanun fi
al-Tibb). Originally written in Arabic, the Canon was a summary of all the
medical knowledge of its time. The complete compendium, or portions of it, were 
eventually translated into Persian, Latin, Chinese, Hebrew, German, French, and 
English.19

The illustrated opening page of the second book of the Canon of Medicine.
Undated; probably from Iran at the beginning of 15th century. Source: The
National Library of Medicine, US.

The earliest and most enduring translation of the Canon into Latin is attributed
to Gerard of Cremona (c.1114–1187), who completed it in Toledo, Spain.20 Soon
afterward, the influence of the Canon was permeating the writings of 13th
century physicians in Europe.21 In the 14th century, medical universities made
extensive use of it for teaching.22 It remained a standard reference for every
medical practitioner throughout the rest of the Middle Ages.23 An improved
translation was published in Venice in 1527 and was reprinted several times. In 
total, some sixty partial or complete editions of the Canon were published in
Europe between 1500 and 1674.

A Latin copy of the Canon of Medicine, dated 1484, at the P.I. Nixon Medical
Historical Library. Image source: The University of Texas Health Science Center 
at San Antonio, TX, US.

Zhu Ming of Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, and Felix Klein-Franke of
the Hebrew University of Jerusalem have argued that on reading the Canon, they
were struck by the similarity of some of Avicenna’s writings to Chinese medical 
theories. Among them, is Avicenna’s theory of humors, his pathology, his remarks
about how to distinguish the primary disease from the secondary, and his pulse 
diagnosis (sphygmology). Avicenna distinguishes 19 types of pulse, each with a
quality that indicate a specific functional disorder. According to Klein-Franke 
and Ming, Avicenna’s sphygmology does not have much in common with Galen’s;
instead, it significantly resembles Chinese pulse theory.24

In addition, the Canon makes several references to medicines of Chinese origin. 
Klein-Franke and Ming name 17 plants on which Avicenna wrote “imported from
China” or “the Chinese type is preferable,” etc. It is therefore indisputable
that Avicenna had access to, and made great use of, the medical lore of China.

Other scholars have looked at the ways in which Greco-Arabic medicine has
influenced Chinese medicine. The Canon was translated into Chinese during the
Yuan dynasty (1271–1368), and published along with other Persian and Arabic
texts in the hui hui yao fang (回回藥方), with much of the text in Arabic.25

A late 15th century version of hui hui yao fang exhibited in the Chinese Hui
Cultural Relics Museum. Image source: SINA Corporation, China.

The hui hui yao fang was probably the official formulary of the Mongolian
administration during the Yuan dynasty. Paul Buell sees this document as a
“smoking gun” of cultural influences, most of which are now untraceable, because
nearly all the other relevant works have been lost. This is why the impact of
Chinese medicine on Greco-Arabic medicine, and vice-versa, is widely unknown.

Avicenna is not the only medieval figure whose work shows the exchange of
medical ideas and manuscripts between Middle-Easterners and the Chinese. The
bibliographer Ibn al-Nadim (ابن النديم, dec. 995 or 998) writes that while a
Chinese scholar was visiting Rhazes (رازی, Rāzī) in Baghdad, he translated the
so-called “Sixteen Books of Galen,” i.e. the Arabic summary of the most
influential books written by Galen. The fate of this translation remains
unknown.26

Cultural exchanges along the Silk Road are the reason why Y. C. Kong and D. S.
Chen of the Chinese University of Hong Kong write that there is an “inherent
affinity between Islamic and Chinese medicines.”27 Paul Buell adds that the
medical syncretism that came out of this exchange became in the Middle Ages the 
base of most European and Middle-Eastern practices, with influences felt as far 
afield as India and Africa. As seen earlier, this syncretism is apparent in the 
illustrations of the Fasciculus Medicinae.

Discarded After the Renaissance

Beginning in the 16th century, humorism became increasingly criticized by
Renaissance scholars. Andreas Vesalius (1514–1564) was the first to publish a
treatise that challenged the anatomy of Galen and Avicenna (the same year that
Copernicus published, 1543 — a remarkable year). Others followed suit, including
William Harvey (1578–1657), who refuted many humoral assumptions about blood in
his treatise on cardiovascular circulation. Harvey measured the amount of blood
pumped by the heart in one hour, and showed that it exceeds the weight of the
entire body. He also showed that the valves in the heart and the veins allowed
the blood to flow in one-way only, and that veins carried blood towards the
heart, not towards the limbs.

In the 17th century, humorism was already synonymous with obscurantism and
ignorance. The French playwright Molière (1622–1673) made great use of humoral
language in writing comedies:

   Now, when the vapors of which I speak pass from the left side, where the
   liver is located, to the right side where the heart is, it happens that the
   lung… having communication with the brain… by means of the vena cava… meets
   on its way the vapors which fill the ventricles of the scapula… and because
   the aforementioned vapors have a certain malignity… which is caused by the
   acridity of the humors engendered in the concavity of the diaphragm…28

Now compare this laughable anatomy and physiology with a paragraph on “Internal 
Diseases” in a prevalent textbook of acupuncture and Oriental Medicine,
published in 1999.

   Wind stirred up by upsurge of liver yang sends qi and blood upwards , which
   together with the accumulated phlegm Fire disturb the mind , leading to
   sudden loss of consciousness…29

The inventions and discoveries of the 18th century allowed medicine to undergo a
paradigm shift. Disease became subject to new rules of classification and
medical knowledge took on an unprecedented precision. Physicians began to
describe phenomena that for centuries had remained below the threshold of the
visible and expressible.30

Medieval notions such as Humoral pathology, vitalism and spontaneous generation 
were entirely discredited in the 19th century, when Louis Pasteur, Robert Koch, 
and others bacteriologists were able to establish indisputable links between
germs and disease trough observation and experimentation. The discovery of the
cellular basis of disease, and the role of microorganisms in pathogenesis made
modern and scientific medicine possible.

Interestingly, as Paul Unschuld points out, when in 19th century Ferdinand von
Hebra identified the mite as causing scabies, or when Agostino Bassi identified 
a fungus as causing silkworm disease, their ideas were initially rejected, not
because they were new and revolutionary, but because they were based on a
single-factorial view of disease, which then was considered to be old and
outdated!

The 20th century witnessed the advent of the molecular basis of disease which
addresses the chemistry of disease and recovery processes. Science has
identified specific molecules that are involved in disease susceptibility,
progression and prognosis, and has allowed the development diagnostic and
therapeutic methods based on biochemistry. This has led to an exponential
success in disease prevention and treatment, increasing the life expectancy and 
the quality of life of modern humans.

However, the postmodern fallacy that the science behind these spectacular
achievements is merely a “language game” and a “belief system” has allowed the
return of mass professional delusions under the label of Chinese, Oriental or
Asian Medicine. As an unfortunate byproduct, dangerous and outdated therapies
have been legitimized, and quacks and charlatans can overtly defraud those who
cannot distinguish scientific medicine from lore and fantasy.

Modern purveyors of obscurantism and ignorance have also created alternative
training programs, have funded biased research and publications, have accused
the scientific community of corruption and conspiracy, and have spurred
legislative efforts to subvert evidence-based medicine and peer-reviewed
science.31

This is why responsible physicians, scientists, and public health officials in
the West should follow the momentum created by Yong Sang Yoo and Zhang Gongyao
in Asia, and call for an end to the licensing of Oriental Medicine
practitioners. The modalities and the rationale used by these practitioners are 
almost identical to the ones we abandoned centuries ago. As George Ulett, MD,
PhD, wrote in 2003, it is a “travesty that in this time of scientific
evidence-based medicine,” treatments based on archaic thinking are given to
unsuspecting patients.32

With many thanks to Daniel Bederian-Gardner, Ui-Won Hwang, Paul Ingraham,
Hyunwoo Kim, Chul Koo and Robert Slack for their valuable comments or
contributions. The opinions expressed here are those of the author.

References

  1. Yoo YS. Traditional Oriental Medicine and Integrative Medicine. Hanyang
    Medical Reviews 2010, Vol. 30, No. 2. Return to text

  2. Zhou SF. The Future of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Aust J Acupunct Chin Med 
    2009;4(1):23–24. Return to text

  3. Magnier M. Scalpel vs. Herb in China. Los Angeles Times. January 08, 2007.
    Return to text

  4. Morse WR. Clio Medica—Chinese Medicine. Paul B. Hoeber, Inc. 1934. Return to
    text

  5. Lee HJ, Jun W; Hong SP. Alternative Modernity: The Revival of Korean Oriental 
    Medicine in Modern South Korea. American Acupuncturist; Winter2008, Vol. 46,
    p18. Return to text

  6. Lyotard JF. The Postmodern Condition: A Report On Knowledge. University of
    Minnesota Press. 1984. Return to text

  7. Boghossian P. Fear of Knowledge: Against Relativism and Constructivism. Oxford
    University Press. 2006. Return to text

  8. Stenger VJ. “Postmodern” Attacks on Science and Reality. Quackwatch. Posted 30
    May 98. [Accessed 15 April 2012] Return to text

  9. Morris W. Medical Epistemology: A Bias of Culture?. Acupuncture Today. March,
    2011, Vol. 12, Issue 03 Return to text

  10. Wootton D. Bad Medicine: Doctors Doing Harm since Hippocrates. Oxford
    University Press, USA; 1st edition. 2006. Return to text

  11. Unschuld PU. Traditional Chinese medicine: Some historical and epistemological
    reflections. Social Science & Medicine, 1987, vol. 24, issue 12, pages
    1023-1029. Return to text

  12. Buell PD. Medical Globalization in the Mongol Era’, in T.S. Ishdorj (ed.),
    Mongol Sudlalyn Ogulluud, Essays on Mongol Studies, Ulaanbaatar: ‘Bembi San’
    Khevleliyn Gazar (Mongolian Academy of Sciences, International Congress of 
    Mongolists), 138–47. 2007. Return to text

  13. Dalby A. Dangerous Tastes: The Story of Spices. University of California
    Press; 1st edition. 2002. Return to text

  14. Turn J. Spice: The History of a Temptation. Alfred A. Knopf. New York. 2004
    Return to text

  15. Siraisi NG. Medieval and Early Renaissance Medicine: An Introduction to
    Knowledge and Practice. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1990. Return
    to text

  16. Jackson WA. A Short Guide to Humoral Medicine. TRENDS in Pharmacological
    Sciences. Vol.22 No.9 September 2001 Return to text

  17. Unglaub Silverthorn D. Human Physiology: An Integrated Approach. Benjamin
    Cummings; 4 edition. 2006. Return to text

  18. de Ketham, J. The Fasciculus Medicinae of Johannes de Ketham, Alemanus :
    facsimile of the first (Venetian) edition of 1491. With English translation 
    by Luke Demaitre ; commentary by Karl Sudhoff ; trans. and adapted by
    Charles Singer. (Birmingham, Ala.: The Classics of Medicine Library, 1988). 
    Return to text

  19. Elgood C. A Medical History of Persia and the Eastern Caliphate. Cambridge.
    Cambridge University Press, 1951. Return to text

  20. Savage-Smith E. Europe and Islam. In: Western Medicine: An Illustrated
    History. London I (ed). Oxford University Press: New York. 1997. Return to
    text

  21. Siraisi NG. The Canon in the Medieval Universities. In: Avicenna in
    Renaissance Italy: The Canon and Medical Teaching in Italian Universities
    after 1500. Princeton University Press: Princeton. 1987; 44-46. Return to
    text

  22. Khan KJ. The Canon: Essential Artillery of the Medieval Medical Student.
    University of Toronto Medical Journal, Volume 89, Number 1, December 2011.
    Return to text

  23. McVaugh MR. Europe and Islam. In: Medicine in the Latin Middle Ages. In:
    Western Medicine: An Illustrated History. London I. (ed). Oxford University 
    Press: New York. 1997; 58-59. Return to text

  24. Klein-Franke F, Ming Z. Avicenna’s Links with Chinese Medicine. A Chapter of
    the History of Sino-Arabic Relation During the Middle Ages. Asian Medicine. 
    December 1998. Return to text

  25. Alpher JV, Aris A. Oriental Medicine: An Illustrated Guide to the Asian Arts
    of Healing. Serindia. United Kingdom, 1st Edition 1995. Return to text

  26. Klein-Franke F, Ming Z, Qi D. The passage of Chinese medicine to the west. Am 
    J Chin Med. 2001;29(3-4):559-65. Return to text

  27. Kong YC, Chen DS. Elucidation of Islamic drugs in Hui Hui Yao Fang: a
    linguistic and pharmaceutical approach. J Ethnopharmacol. 1996
    Nov;54(2-3):85-102. Return to text

  28. Poquelin JP (dit Molière). Le Médecin Malgré Lui. Editions Larousse (FR).
    2007. Return to text

  29. Xinnong C (Editor). Chinese Acupuncture and Moxibustion. Foreign Languages
    Press; Revised edition. 1999. Return to text

  30. Foucault M.The Birth of the Clinic: An Archaeology of Medical Perception.
    Vintage. 1994. Return to text

  31. Auwaerter PG, Bakken JS, Dattwyler RJ, Dumler JS, Halperin JJ, McSweegan E,
    Nadelman RB, O’Connell S, Shapiro ED, Sood SK, Steere AC, Weinstein A,
    Wormser GP. Antiscience and ethical concerns associated with advocacy of
    Lyme disease. Lancet Infect Dis. 2011 Sep;11(9):713-9. Return to text

  32. Ulett GA. Acupuncture: archaic or biologic? Am J Public Health. 2003;93:1037. 
    author reply 1037-8. Return to text

             The Forefather of Acupuncture Energetics, a Charlatan?

                                 Ben Kavoussi 

                                      Link

   Not only his name and his titles of nobility were forged, but parts of
   the teachings of the man who introduced acupuncture to Europe were also
   invented. Even today, treatments are provided based on his fantasies.

   – Hanjo Lehmann1

Decades before President Nixon’s visit to communist China, and before the
articles in the Western popular press on the use of acupuncture in surgery, a
Frenchman by the name of George Soulié de Morant (1878-1955), published a series
of colorful accounts of the use of acupuncture in early 20th-century China. His
work led to the creation of a school of thought known as “French energetics,”
which has become the theoretical foundation for many proponents of acupuncture
in the West, including Joseph Helms, MD, the founder and former director of the 
American Academy of Medical Acupuncture (AAMA), and the founder of the
acupuncture certification course for physicians.

But just as the medical community gradually learned that the reports of the use 
of acupuncture in surgery in communist China were inaccurate, exaggerated, or
even fraudulent, we are now learning that the reports on the use and efficacy of
acupuncture by Soulié de Morant were also fabricated.

According to a 2010 article published in Germany by Hanjo Lehmann in the
Deutsches Ärzteblatt (a short version was published in Süddeutsche Zeitung),
there is no real evidence that the Frenchman who is considered the father of
Western acupuncture ever stuck a needle in anyone in China, and he probably
never witnessed a needling.

A century prior to Soulié de Moran’s publications, the therapeutic use of
needles enjoyed immense (though short-lived) popularity in Western Europe —
mainly in France, Germany, Austria. This use of needles consisted mostly of the 
so-called locus dolendi treatment, where needles are placed solely in the
vicinity of the affected area(s).2 But due to its lack of significant efficacy, 
this treatment vanished just as rapidly and completely as it had appeared.

During that time, paradoxically, acupuncture was excluded from the Imperial
Medical Institute of China by decree of the Emperor in 1822. The knowledge and
skills were retained, however, either as an interest among academics or through 
everyday use by rural folk healers. With China’s increasing acceptance of
scientific medicine at the start of the 20th-century, final ignominy for
acupuncture arrived, when in 1929, it was outlawed, along with other forms of
traditional medicine.3

The practice of acupuncture, however, reappeared in France a few years after it 
was outlawed in China, and from there it gradually spread to Western Europe and 
the US. This time, its theories were based on the laws of meridians (where
points distant from the affected areas are needled according to intricate
algorithms). This renaissance was largely due to Soulie de Morant’s legacy.

Soulié de Morant was born in Paris in 1878, and attended a Jesuit school. The
prevailing story is that he was a child prodigy, and in addition to speaking
fluent English and Spanish, he also learned Mandarin from a Chinese man who
lived in Paris, and who (according to family friend Judith Gautier, a French
writer) spent an afternoon with the young George writing Chinese characters (or 
ideograms) in the sand.

Soulié de Morant went to China at the turn of the 20th-century at the age of 21 
to work for a French bank. The legend goes that he was fluent in Mandarin before
going to China, and that once there, he also learned Mongolian. Reportedly, his
language skills and his knowledge of Chinese culture brought him to the
attention of the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs, who appointed him judge of 
the Joint French Court of Shanghai, and later the Vice-Consul of Foreign Affairs
in Yunnan. Presumably, he then became the French Consul in several Chinese
cities.

The legend also includes the story of how, while in office, Soulié de Morant
witnessed a Chinese physician help the victims of a “terrible cholera epidemic
that raged in Beijing at that time,” without recourse to modern medicine. His
curiosity aroused, he began to read ancient medical texts, and studied
acupuncture under several renowned physicians. Purportedly, he later practiced
acupuncture himself, and it is reported that his knowledge and skills were such 
that he became respected by the Chinese — an incredible accomplishment for a
foreigner, then or now.4

He returned to France in 1910, was married in Paris in 1911, and had two
children. He then tried to return to China, but only succeeded to go back for a 
few months in 1917. After this final trip to China, he wrote several books on
Chinese art and literature. Curiously, he didn’t mention acupuncture in any of
his writings until 1929 — the same year it was outlawed in China.

Initially confronted with skepticism and derision, Soulié de Morant’s writings
on acupuncture eventually managed to attract the support of several French
physicians. His major work, L’acuponcture chinoise, outlines his “theory of
energy” and its therapeutic manipulation by acupuncture. He is also known for
coining the widespread term “meridian,” as a translation for the Chinese
expression jingluo (經絡), which literally means “channel-network.” He translated 
the term qi (氣), the Chinese equivalent of the Greek notion of pneuma (πνεύμα), 
into the modern term “energy.”

Chinese Acupuncture

The 1994 translation of L’Acuponcture Chinoise. Image source: Paradigm
Publications

One of the main people who challenge the authenticity of Soulié de Morant’s
understanding of acupuncture and his interpretations of the Chinese classics is 
the American scholar, Donald (Deke) Kendall, PhD, who writes in the Dao of
Chinese Medicine that by jingluo, the Chinese were simply referring to blood
vessels. Kendall argues that Soulié de Morant’s theories are actually the result
of profound misunderstandings and misinterpretations of the classics, which
have resulted in the portrayal in the West of the rudimentary description of the
vascular system by the Chinese as an elusive network of intangible “energy”
channels.5

There is ample evidence in support of Kendall’s claims, including the work of
the classics scholar Elizabeth Craik, who has convincingly argued that the
Chinese notion of jingluo is quasi-identical to the Greek notions of phlebes
(blood vessels in general) and neura (ligaments, nerves, etc.).6

But Hanjo Lehmann, the author of the recent article in Deutsches Ärzteblatt,
goes a step further. Lehmann lists a set of contradictions and inconsistencies
in Soulié de Morant’s account of his journey in the Far-East, which shed doubt
on his overall character, the integrity of his narrative, and the credibility of
his exposure to, and practice of, acupuncture in China. Lehmann calls him a
scharlatan.

Lehmann first points out that it would be unlikely for a 21-year-old without any
formal education in Chinese (and who had never lived in China) to master a
complex language with several thousands of characters, even if he took courses
regularly for several years. We recall that the only testimony of Soulié de
Morant’s formal “studies” in Paris came from Judith Gautier (1845-1917), who
affirmed that on one occasion, a Chinese friend of the family in Paris drew
characters in the sand with him.

According to Lehmann, Soulié de Morant likely started his foreign service in
1903, as a low-level interpreter at the Shanghai Consulate, and not as a “judge”
in Shanghai. The belief that he was actually nominated as a judge might come
from the fact that in his book Exterritorialité et intérêts étrangers en chine, 
Soulié de Morant states that the French delegate in the Joint Court was “usually
the first interpreter” of the consulate.

As for his consular nominations when he was only in his mid-twenties, Lehmann
argues that they are certainly false. It is only after he left the French
Foreign Office, (probably in 1924), that he received the title of “honorary
consul.” In fact, it is only in his writings after 1925, that he calls himself
Consul de France.

Lehmann also believes that his aristocratic name “Soulié de Morant” was a
forgery, and that he was born simply Georges Soulié.

As for acupuncture, Soulié de Morant claims that he first saw and practiced the 
technique himself during a cholera outbreak in Bejing in 1908 — but no records
of such an outbreak at that time exist. According to the History of Chinese
Medicine by Wong and Wu, an epidemic of plague and typhus occurred roughly
around that time, but in Hong Kong and Fuzhou in Jiangxi.7 There is no record of
a cholera epidemic in Beijing or anywhere else.

Moreover, although Soulie de Morant recounts his studies with two renowned
acupuncturists of academic rank, other Western writers remind us that during
that time, only street practitioners and rural folk healers, worked with needles
therapeutically; the use of needles was actually often associated with amulets 
and talismans, and thus frowned upon by the Chinese academia.8

These and dozens more inconsistencies that discredit Soulié de Morant, suggest
that the his claims about acupuncture, and the lore of energy meridians and qi, 
are founded on sloppy translations, misconceptions, or even pure forgery. But
the accuracy of these notions are never disputed by the Chinese, because — as
Lehmann points out — the public image of acupuncture in China today is based
mainly on its reputation in the West. The Chinese consider that any criticism or
fundamental discussion would jeopardize that reputation.

Over the last half-century since his death, Soulié de Morant’s interpretation of
the traditional tenets of acupuncture, known as “French energetics,” have
inspired the creation of over a dozen methods, organizations, and schools
abroad,9 each with different levels of orthodoxy, critical thinking, or even
rationality.

Consider, for instance, a theoretical construct known as the “Energetics of
Living Systems” that was developed by the French physician Maurice Mussat. He is
one of the leaders of the French school of medical acupuncture, and has taught 
in the US under the auspices of Joseph Helms, MD. Mussast takes the fabulations 
of Soulié de Morant to the next level of absurdity by projecting cybernetics,
complexity theory, and quantum mechanics onto meridian-based acupuncture.

Mussat indeed believes there is a parallelism between the energetics of the
meridians and the “mathematical order inherent in the trigrams and hexagrams” of
the I-Ching, a Chinese classic of geomancy (a type of divination based on
patterns formed by tossed rocks, sticks, sand, etc.). Mussat, who believes he
has connected the symbolism of the I-Ching with modern quantum physics, has
devised “algebraic derivations” to measure meridian energetics, and has created 
a diagram that “incorporates nearly all of the fundamental energy relationships 
of acupuncture.”10 Mussat’s forced conflation of acupuncture and quantum physics
is outlined in his 3-volume Energetics of the Living Systems Applied to
Acupuncture, as well as in other creations of his overinclusive thinking.

A German book on Mussat’s “quantum-medicine” (1983). Image source: VGM Verlag
GmbH for Integrative Medicine.

The cognitive derailments of Maurice Mussat have, in turn, greatly influenced
Joseph Helms, the founder and former Director of the AAMA.11 Helms, who combines
family medicine, acupuncture, and homeopathy, served on the advisory panel of
the Office of Alternative Medicine, NIH, and presented to the White House
Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medicine Policy. In his book,
Acupuncture Energetics, Helms writes:

   Mussat inspired me with the strength of his conviction and his creative
   merging of two disparate traditions of thought and medicine. He guided me to 
   perfect my clinical skills and to start teaching. My early clinical time with
   him, combined with the years we lectured together, created an indelible
   matrix of clear expression that I hope is manifested throughout this work.12

Since the 1980s, the AAMA has taught the fantasies of Soulié de Morant and
Mussat on meridians and energy under the label of “medical acupuncture” to
thousands of physicians in the US , many of whom were members of the military.
In fact, in 2009, the office of the Surgeon General of the Air Force instituted 
a pilot program for active duty physicians to be trained by Helms Medical
Institute, and gave out 32 scholarships on a competitive basis. According to
Stars and Stripes, the US military’s independent news source, the program is now
expanded to all service branches, and will certify 60 active duty physicians in
2011 as “medical acupuncturists.”

Meanwhile, well-conducted clinical trials have indicated over and over that
needling location has little differential effect on outcomes, and that
acupuncture is largely devoid of speciﬁc therapeutic effects.13 The support for 
this argument comes from a series of 8 large randomized controlled trials (RCTs)
initiated by German health insurers. These RCTs were related to chronic back
pain, migraine, tension headache, and knee osteoarthritis (2 trials for each
indication). Their total sample size was in excess of 5000. Even though not
entirely uniform, the results of these studies tend to demonstrate no or only
small differences in terms of analgesic effects between real and placebo
needling.14

This evidence indicates that the use of specific meridians, points, and
particular types of stimulation are not critical factors independent of
conditioning, expectancy or other neuropsychological factors. Needling seems to 
have a broad anti-inflammatory and antihyperalgesic effect, which could be
attributed to the pain and tissue injury, or the neurostimualtion caused by the 
needle, regardless of the insertion point. In view of this, the meridian and
point lore, and the premisses of “Acupuncture Energetics,” are all devoid of any
scientific rationality.

Considering that acupuncture was reintroduced to the West based on a narrative
that was apparently fraudulent; that its cultural assimilation has conflated it 
with New Age crackpottery; and that reliable RCTs contradict its medical claims,
it’s time once-and-for-all to cease wasting taxpayer dollars on its
dissemination.

NOTE: The opinions expressed here are those of the author, and do not reflect
the positions of Hanjo Lehmann and Donald (Deke) Kendall.

REFERENCES

  1. Lehmann H. Akupunktur im Westen: Am Anfang war ein Scharlatan. Dtsch
    Arztebl. 2010; 107(30): A-1454 / B-1288 / C-1268. Return to text

  2. Feucht G. Streifzug Durch die Geschichte der Akupunktur in Deutschland,
    Deutsche Zeitschrift fur Akupunktur, 10. 1961. Return to text

  3. Ma KW. The roots and development of Chinese acupuncture: from prehistory
    to early 20th century. Acupunct Med 1992;10(Suppl):92–9. Return to text

  4. Soulié de Morant G. L’acuponcture chinoise. 2 vols. Paris: Mercure de
    France, 1939-1941. Published in English as Chinese Acupuncture, edited by
    Paul Zmiewski. Brookline, MA: Paradigm Publications. 1994. Return to text

  5. Kendall DE. Dao of Chinese Medicine: Understanding an Ancient Healing Art.
    Oxford University Press, USA; 1 edition. 2002. Return to text

  6. Craik EM. Hippocratic Bodily “Channels” and Oriental Parallels. Med Hist. 
    2009 January; 53(1): 105–116. Return to text

  7. Wong KC, Wu TH. History of Chinese Medicine. Oriental Book Store. 1977.
    Return to text

  8. Hillier SM, Jewell T. Health Care and Traditional Medicine in China
    1800-1982. Routledge; 1 edition. 2005. Return to text

  9. Hsu E. Outline of the History of Acupuncture in Europe, The Journal of
    Chinese Medicine, 29. 1989. Return to text

  10. Mussat M. Energetique Physioloque de l’Acupuncture. Paris, France:
    Librairie le Francois. 1979. Return to text

  11. Birch SJ, Felt RL. Understanding Acupuncture. Churchill Livingstone; 1
    edition. 1999. Return to text

  12. Helms JM. Acupuncture Energetics: A Clinical Approach for Physicians.
    Medical Acupuncture Publishers; 1st edition. 1995. Return to text

  13. Ernst E. The American journal of medicine, Vol. 121, No. 12. December
    2008. Return to text

  14. Baecker M, Tao I, Dobos GJ. Acupuncture Quo Vadis? On the current
    discussion around its effectiveness and “point speciﬁcity.” In: McCarthy M, 
    Birch S, Cohen I, et al, eds. Thieme Almanac 2007: Acupuncture and Chinese
    Medicine. Stuttgart, Germany: Thieme; 2007:29-36. Return to text

                         The Cargo Cult of Acupuncture

                                 Ben Kavoussi 

                                      Link

   Bloodletting, of course, was a major aim of early vessel therapy and is
   frequently described in the Su wen.1

   Paul U Unschuld

“Cargo cult” is a metaphor that describes the act of imitating an activity or a 
practice without any insight into the underlying principles. In the literal
sense, it refers to a magico-religious practice observed in tribal societies,
where the members ritually imitate the activities of a technologically-advanced 
society they had contact with, so that they can magically draw their material
wealth. For instance, after WWII, indigenous tribes in New Guinea who had come
in close contact with cargo planes, started to build landing strips and
populated them with plane-like effigies that were made of straw, bamboo, and
coconuts, so that they can magically lure the passing planes.2 The term “cargo
cult science” was introduced by Richard Feynman in a speech at Caltech in 1974
to describe pseudoscientific studies in which all the superficial aspects of a
scientific inquiry are adhered to, but the underlying principles are not
scientific. He classified many educational and psychological studies as such,
for having the appearance of academic research but lacking the principles of a
scientific inquiry.3

Another example of cargo cult science is the plethora of two-arm acupuncture
studies that compare a needling regimen using the traditional concepts, and
compare it with a non-interventional placebo. These studies might have the
appearance of clinical research, but they are inherently flawed and
inconclusive, because they do not rule out the possibility that the observed
results are mainly due to the painful stimulus and injury caused by a needle,
which can occur regardless of the insertion point. Indeed, an acute noxious
stimulus from a prickle, heat, or any other painful stimulus – almost anywhere
on the skin – can attenuate the perception of pain in another area of the body
through a reflex called “counter-irritation,” also called the
“pain-inhibiting-pain effect” or “diffuse noxious inhibitory control” (DNIC).4
DNIC was extensively studied by Fauve et al. in the 1980s, who showed in mice
that it has an effect equivalent or superior to that of glucocorticoids.5,6

Counter-irritation has been known since antiquity, and is at the base of many
noxious folk remedies, such as the application of cautery, blistering and
moxibustion (the burning of dried Artemisia annua on the skin) to name but a
few, whereby “one pain masks another.”7 These modalities were once widely used, 
generally in an attempt to reduce inflammation.9 It is therefore plausible that 
the nonspecific effects observed in some types of acupuncture are also linked to
DNIC, since some authors have reported that acupuncture is only effective in
producing analgesia when the stimulation itself is of a sufficient intensity to 
cause an unpleasant sensation. The DNIC induced by needles is believed to be
mediated by the release of endogenous opioid neuropeptides and/or monoaminergic 
neurotransmitters, mainly because naloxone, a central and peripheral opioid
receptor antagonist, is reported to reverse its effects.10,11 A true
interpretation of this finding invalidates the traditional lore of the
meridian-and-points system, and indicates that any needling regimen can lead to 
outcomes associated with DNIC. This finding echoes the position of Felix Mann,
MD, the founder of the British Medical Acupuncture Society, who after decades of
practice reached the conclusion that putting needles in “wrong” places was as
effective as a “correct” treatment. He therefore wrote that “traditional
acupuncture points are no more real than the black spots a drunkard sees in
front of his eyes.”12

There is also credible evidence that the stimulation of a myofascial trigger
point (TrP), meaning a localized, hyperirritable nodule nested within a palpable
taut band of skeletal muscle or fascia,13 can evoke short-term anti-nociceptive
effects on the same segmental dermatome.14 This local hypoalgesic effect is
reported to be greater than stimulation at remote dermatomes.15 It is based on
this finding, that Janet Travell, MD, (1901-1997) began needling hyperirritable 
points with syringes in in the 1940s, injecting them first with procaine.16
Procaine was later replaced by saline solution,17 which was later replaced by
“dry needling” (TrP-DN ) — without any fluid in the syringe.18,19 Although the
dermatomal distributiosn of anti-nociceptive effects do not correspond to the
distribution of the Chinese meridians, they do affect the outcome of two-arm
studies because any needling regimen in the same dermatome should lead to
similar results. Therefore, two-arm studies cannot rule out the possibility that
the observed results are due to anti-nociceptive effects on the same segmental 
dermatome, which can occur regardless of the classical theories for point
selection and means of stimulation.20

In addition, both laboratory and clinical evidence have recently shown the
existence of two-way interactions between the nervous system and the innate
immunity. There is experimental evidence showing that percutaneous and
transcutaneous neurostimulation can inhibit macrophage activation and the
production of pro-inflammatory cytokines.21 Kevin J Tracey, MD and his collogues
at Feinstein Institute for Medical Research have shown that an increase in the 
production of Acetylcholine (ACh) can inhibit the synthesis of TNF and other
pro-inflammatory cytokines in organs rich in cells of the monocyte-macrophage
system.22 Tracey argues that Ach interacts with members of the nicotinic ACh
receptor (nAchr) family, in particular with the alpha-7 subunit (α7nAchr), which
is expressed not only by neurons, but also macrophages and other cells involved
in the inflammatory response.23 It is therefore conceivable that the
anti-inflammatory actions that have been associated with needling – and have
been used to justify the traditional concepts of acupuncture – are directly or
indirectly mediated by neurostimulation and inflammatory macrophage
deactivation, and can occur with transcutaneous or percutaneous neuromodulation 
anywhere proximal to nerves.24 This is consistent with the hypothesis of George 
A. Ulett and Songping Han, who argued that certain effects of needling,
especially in the ear, might be explained by a “broad parasympathetic effects”
due to the stimulation of vagus nerve, which also innervates the ear.25 Again,
two-arm studies cannot rule out the possibility that the observed results are
due to the broad neurostimulatory effects of needling, and regardless of the
needling regimen.

In sum, for the reasons stated above, two-arm acupuncture studies that compare a
traditional regimen with a non-interventional placebo are inherently
inconclusive. I would further argue that the regimen used in these studies is
not even reflective of the traditional methods, because the loci of cautery,
blistering, cupping, moxibustion and acupuncture might have been selected simply
because they were particularly sensitive and painful, and the alleged analgesic
and anti-inflammatory effects of traditional regimens are not achievable by the
“soft needling” technique used in clinical studies today. These studies
unequivocally use quasi-unperceivable, painless, filiform, silicon-coated
needles for ethical reasons and to prevent dropouts. This type of “acupuncture
without tears” amounts to what Arthur Taub has suitably called “nonsense with
needles.”26

Finally, the most compelling argument to qualify acupuncture of a cargo cult, is
the fact that its apostles remain obstinately faithful that someday, someone
will prove that “astrology with needles” is a panacea that can naturally restore
health and longevity. This is despite the fact that well-conducted three-arm
clinical trials that used sham controls with needle insertion at “wrong” points 
(points not indicated for the condition) or non-points (locations that are not
known acupuncture points) along with a non-interventional control group, have
failed to demonstrate that there is a reliable difference between sham and
“true” needling. Three well-designed three-armed randomized controlled clinical 
trials with 302, 270, and 1007 patients, respectively, have demonstrated that
acupuncture and sham acupuncture treatments were more effective than no
treatment at all, but there was no statistically significant difference between 
true and sham acupuncture,27,28,29 suggesting that it does not have unique
effects on the central nervous system, or on pain and pain modulation.30 These
studies indicate that the “meridional theory” is of low importance, and does not
lead to specific therapeutic effects.31,32 The most recent challenge came from 
a review article in the New England Journal of Medicine which concluded that
acupuncture’s specific therapeutic effects – if any – are small, and its
benefits are mostly attributable to “contextual and psychosocial factors, such
as patients’ beliefs and expectations, attention from the acupuncturist, and
highly focused, spatially directed attention on the part of the patient.”33

I see the pointless studies that aim to validate notions that date of Galen’s
era, and hear the irrational narrative of the apostles of this cargo cult at the
twilight of a dying hope, and I think of Baudelaire’s morose elegy to “The
Swan:”

   A swan which from its cage had made escape

   Patting the torrid blocks with webby feet,

   Trailing great plumes of snow, while beak agape

   Tumbled for water in the parching street;

   Wildly it plunged its wings in dust again,

   Mourning its native lake, and seemed to shrill:

   “Lightning, when comest thou? and when, the rain?”

   Strange symbol! wretched bird, I see it still.34

   Charles Baudelaire (1821 – 1867), Flowers of Evil

References

1. Unschuld PU. Huang Di Nei Jing Su Wen: Nature, Knowledge, Imagery in an
Ancient Chinese Medical Text. University of California Press. 2003

2. Lawrence P. Road belong cargo: a study of the Cargo Movement in the Southern 
Madang District, New Guinea. Manchester University Press, 1964.

3. Feynman RP. Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman! (Adventures of a Curious
Character). W. W. Norton & Company. 1997.

4. Follett K. Neurosurgical Pain Management. Elsevier Health Sciences. 2004

5. Fauve RM, Fontan E, Hevin MB, Saklani H, Parker F. Remote effects of
inflammation on non-specific immunity. Immunol Lett. 1987;16(3-4):199-203.

6. Fauve RM. Endogenous counterinflammation and immunostimulation [in French].
Pathol Biol (Paris). 1987;35(2):190-194.

7. Wand-Tetley JI. Historical methods of counter-irritation. Ann Phys Med
1956;3:90–8

8. Le Bars D, Dickenson AH, Besson J-M, Villaueva L. Aspects of sensory
processing through convergent neurons. In: Yaksh TL, ed. Spinal afferent
processing. New York: Plenum, 1986: 467–504.

9. Holden AV, Winlow W. The Neurobiology of Pain: Symposium of the Northern
Neurobiology Group, Held at Leeds on 18 April 1983. Manchester University Press.
1984.

10. Pomeranz B, Chiu D. Naloxone blockade of acupuncture analgesia: endorphin
implicated. Life Sci. 1976;19:1757-1762.

11. Zhou ZF, Du MY, Wu WY, Jiang Y, Han JS. Effect of intracerebral
microinjection of naloxone on acupuncture- and morphineanalgesia in the rabbit. 
Sci Sin. 1981;24:1166-1178.

12. Mann F. Reinventing Acupuncture: A New Concept of Ancient Medicine.
Butterworth-Heinemann; 2 edition. 2000.

13. Simons DG. Review of enigmatic MTrPs as a common cause of enigmatic
musculoskeletal pain and dysfunction. J Electromyogr Kinesiol 2004; 14: 95–107.

14. Srbely JZ, Dickey JP, Lee D, Lowerison M. Dry needle stimulation of
myofascial trigger points evokes segmental anti-nociceptive effects. J Rehabil
Med. 2010 May;42(5):463-8.

15. White PF, Craig WF, Vakharia AS, Ghoname E, Ahmed HE, Hamza MA. Percutaneous
neuromodulation therapy: does the location of electrical stimulation effect the
acute analgesic response? Anesth Analg. 2000 Oct;91(4):949-54.

16. Travell J, Rinzler S, Herman M. Pain and disability of the shoulder and arm:
treatment by intramuscular infiltration with procaine hydrochloride. JAMA.
1942;120:417-422.

17. Sola AE, Kuitert JH. Myofascial trigger point pain in the neck and shoulder 
girdle. Northwest Med. 1955;54:980-984.

18. Kraus H. Clinical Treatment of Back and Neck Pain. New York, NY:McGraw-Hill;
1970.

19. Dommerholt J, Huijbregts P. Myofascial Trigger Points: Pathophysiology and
Evidence-Informed Diagnosis and Management. Jones & Barlett Learning. 2009.

20. Baldry PE. Acupuncture, Trigger Points and Musculoskeletal Pain. Edinburgh, 
UK: Churchill Livingstone, 2005.

21. Wang H, Yu M, Ochani M, et al.Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor alpha7
subunit is an essential regulator of inflammation. Nature. 2003;421:384-8.

22. Tracey KJ. The inflammatory reflex. Nature. 2002;420:853-859.

23. van Maanen MA, Vervoordeldonk MJ, Tak PP. The cholinergic anti-inflammatory 
pathway: towards innovative treatment of rheumatoid arthritis. Nat Rev
Rheumatol. 2009 Apr;5(4):229-32.

24. Tracey KJ. Physiology and immunology of the cholinergic antiinflammatory
pathway. J Clin Invest. 2007;117(2):289-296.

25. Ulett GA, Han S. The Biology of Acupuncture. St Louis, MO:Warren H. Green;
2002.

26. Taub A. Nonsense with Needles. In Barrett S and Jarvis W. The Health
Robbers: A Close Look at Quackery in America. Prometheus Books, Amherst, NY.
1993. Article available online at http://www.acuwatch.org/general/taub.shtml

27. Linde K, Streng A, Jurgens S, Hoppe A, Brinkhaus B, Witt C, Wagenpfeil S,
Pfaffenrath V, Hammes MG, Weidenhammer W, Willich SN, Melchart D. Acupuncture
for patients with migraine: A randomized controlled trial. JAMA
2005;293:2118-2125.

28. Melchart D, Streng A, Hoppe A, Brinkhaus B, Witt C, Wagenpfeil S,
Pfaffenrath V, Hammes M, Hummelsberger J, Irnich D, Weidenhammer W, Willich SN, 
Linde K. Acupuncture in patients with tension-type headache: Randomised
controlled trial. BMJ 2005;331(7513):376-382.

29. Scharf HP, Mansmann U, Streitberger K, Witte S, Kramer J, Maier C, Trampisch
HJ, Victor N. Acupuncture and knee osteoarthritis: A three-armed randomized
trial. Ann Intern Med 2006;145:12-20.

30. Campbell A. Point specificity of acupuncture in the light of recent clinical
and imaging studies. Acupunct Med 2006;24(3):118-122.

31. Moffet HH. Sham acupuncture may be as efficacious as true acupuncture: a
systematic review of clinical trials. J Altern Complement Med. 2009
Mar;15(3):213-6.

32. Moffet HH. Acupuncture trial lacks a priori rationale to refute null.
hypothesis. Arch Intern Med. 2008 Mar 10;168(5):550-1.

33. Berman BM, Langevin HH, Witt CM, et al. Acupuncture for chronic low back
pain. N Engl J Med 2010 Jul 29; 363(5):454-61.

34. Shanks LP. Flowers of Evil. Ives Washburn. New York, 1931.

                   Exorcism and Sorcery as Health Benefits?!

                                 Ben Kavoussi 

                                      Link

   Luis Fernando Verissimo, a Brazilian writer, once proposed
   “voodoopuncture”. Instead of going to the acupuncturist, you would be treated
   without leaving home. The voodoopuncturist would stick acupuncture needles
   in the voodoo dolls of you! I add that voodoopuncture could be outsourced to 
   Haiti and/or China. It is a win-win-win situation!

   – Leonardo Monasteri, Brazilian economist

As unbelievable as this might sound, “voodoopuncture” is no fiction at all.

The practice is called “Tong Ren healing,” and involves needling or hammering an
acupuncture mannequin, as if it were a voodoo doll. The main Tong Ren “Master” 
in the US is an acupuncturist in the Boston area by the name of Tom Tam. He
treats groups of terminally ill and debilitated patients in a deliverance
ceremony that is noting but a revamped Taoist exorcism — only the clay or straw 
doll is replaced by a plastic mannequin:

Unfortunately, Tom Tam is not the only licensed healthcare provider who is
treating patients with hocus pocus and crackpottery. There are over 30,000 other
adepts of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) in the US who practice medicine
based on notions of health and disease that are rooted in paranormal and magical
beliefs. Some of these practitioners take their delusions to the outer limits
of absurdity: consider, for instance, “acutonics” and “colorpuncture” as
described in these videos:

In anthropology of religion, the principles that underline the above practices
are called “imitation” (e.g. using a doll to affect a person), and
“correspondence” (e.g. using a sound to affect an object). They are the
hallmarks of what is called “sympathetic magic,” meaning the belief that a
person, or a thing, can be affected through something that represents it, or
that has similar attributes.1 The principle of magical correspondence in TCM is 
called wu xing (五行) in Chinese, and is known as the Five Phases/Elements Theory 
in English. It can be summarized as follows:

1. Everything (including our organs) is ruled by one of 5 entities: Water (水),
Wood (木), Fire (火), Earth (土), and Metal (金) — which are also the Chinese names 
for the planets Mercury, Jupiter, Mars, Saturn, and Venus.2 For instance, the
heart is ruled by Fire (Mars), the liver by Wood (Jupiter), etc

2. There is a sympathetic connection (or resonance) between things that are
ruled by the same entity (or planet). For example, the heart is connected with
the color red, the direction south, the summer season, a bitter taste, and the
feeling of joy — because all of these are ruled by Fire (Mars).

3. All 5 entities are interconnected and act on each other. Disease is
understood as a result of either the over-, or under-influence of one entity on 
another. For example, digestive disruptions can be attributed to “Wood
overacting on Earth.”

The concept map (pictogram) of wu xing is often drawn by placing the 5 entities 
in a circle, and then connecting them according to the lines of influence. The
connecting lines create a “pentacle,” or a pentagram within a circle (Image 1).

Image 1. The pictogram of wu xing. Image Source: acupuncture.co

This pictogram, unbeknownst to most TCM practitioners, is nearly identical to a 
sigil (magical or religious symbol) found in the Old Religion of Northern
Europe, also known as “Wicca” (from the Old English word wicca, meaning a male
sorcerer). The only difference between the Chinese and the Wiccan pictograms is 
that Wicca uses Air instead of Wood, and Spirit instead of Metal. The assignment
of attributes (color, sound, taste, etc.) to each entity also varies slightly
(Image 2)

Image 2. The Five Elements of Wicca.

According to the historian Cornelia J. de Vogel, this sigil was commonly used by
the druids in the context of spell casting, and protection against evil and
malevolence.4 It was likewise used in ancient Greece among Pythagoreans in the
context of the cult of Hygieia (Ὑγεία, Salus in Latin), the Greek patron of
well-being, sanitation, and the prevention of disease (Image 3). Notably, their 
brotherhood (an esoteric cult based on numerology) also believed in resonance
between numbers, tastes, colors, sounds, and the classical elements.

Pythagora

Iage 3. Pythagorean pentagram in Three Books of Occult Philosophy (Libri Tres de
Occulta Philosophia) by Heinrich Cornelius Agrippa (1486 – 1535). The word
Ὑγεία (Hygieia) is inscribed on the outer circle

In Christian Europe, some of these pagan beliefs and symbols were culturally
assimilated. For instance, the pentacle became the symbol of the five wounds of 
Jesus Christ.6 But with the advent of science and modernity, magical thinking,
its symbolism, and all the rituals that accompanied it were discredited as
superstition and ignorance.

Paganism and magic, however, weren’t so easily done away with — and they
experienced a renaissance with the American Counterculture of the 1960s.
Vietnam-era demonstrations with large hippie contingents famously mixed politics
with occultism, magic, and witchcraft. For example, at the mammoth antiwar
protest near Washington DC, in October 1967, demonstrators performed a
mock-exorcism to levitate the Pentagon and cast out its demons.7

The magical notions of occult resonance and interconnectedness now find their
zealots in the growing Neo-pagan and New Age movements. These revamped notions
provide the conceptual basis for energy or vibrational medicine, which includes 
not only colorpuncture and acutonics, but also herbalism, reiki, reflexology,
crystal therapy, magnet therapy, aromatherapy, acupuncture, and many other
methods to channel putative “energy fields.”

A 2006 publication reported that in 2004, the annual spending on various
channeling methods and alternative healthcare in the US was about $10 to $14
billion. It also estimated the number of Americans involved with New Age
activities to be around 12 million.8

The popularity of these unscientific ideas and practices in the last decades has
had a terrible impact on the public health policy in the US. One consequence is
the licensing of non-physician acupuncturists in over 40 states. As George
Ulett wrote in 2003, “is a travesty that in this time of scientific
evidence-based medicine, acupuncture treatments are given to unsuspecting US
patients by some 20,000 acupuncturists, posing as primary care doctors.”9 Be
noted that their number has now increased to over 30,000.

Another consequence is the attempt to mainstream TCM and energy medicine by
means of lobbying and political pressure. This leads to national and regional
healthcare policies that are not based on science and evidence, but on
consumerism and financial interest. As Steven Novella writes in Politics and
Science at the HHS, this tends to “contaminate” science, and change the rules so
that a popular modality can get a free pass. Novella adds that “modalities that
require political pressure to force them into our health care system are those 
that are not backed by good science.”

An example of politically-motivated healthcare policy is the Federal Acupuncture
Coverage Act of 2011 (H.R.1328), which is sponsored by House Representatives
Maurice Hinchey (D-NY), Judy Chu (D-CA). It intends to “… provide for coverage
of qualified acupuncturist services under part B of the Medicare Program, and to
amend title 5, United States Code, to provide for coverage of such services
under the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program.”

Yet another example is the current pressure put on the US Department of Health
and Human Services by Judy Chu (a Representative for a district with a heavy
concentration of acupuncturists and apothecaries) to make TCM and acupuncture
part of the “Essential Health Benefits.” These benefits are a set of
federally-mandated services under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
(PPACA).

This comes at a time when California State Senator Leeland Yee is trying to
expand the scope of acupuncturists’ practice in his state to include the
performance of “Chinese traumatology” — whatever that means.

If Maurice Hinchey, Judy Chu, Leeland Yee, and the TCM syndicate get their way, 
then revamped exorcism and sorcery will further infest the American healthcare
system.

And if they don’t, I can already imagine voodoopuncturists in their cubicals in 
China, just like Leonardo Monasteri predicted: “…tap, tap, tap, can you feel me 
now?”

REFERENCES:

1. Frazer JG (Author), Fraser R (Editor). The Golden Bough: A Study in Magic and
Religion: A New Abridgement from the Second and Third Editions. Oxford
University Press, USA; Abridged edition. 1998.

2. Walters D. Chinese Astrology. Aquarian Press. 1987.

3. Maciocia G. The Foundations of Chinese Medicine: A Comprehensive Text for
Acupuncturists and Herbalists. Churchill Livingstone. 1989.

4. de Vogel CJ. Pythagoras and Early Pythagoreanism. Assen: Van Gorcum; 1966.

5. Burkert W. Lore and Science in Ancient Pythagoreanism. Cambridge, MA: Harvard
University Press; 1972.

6. Ferguson G. Signs and Symbols in Christian Art. New York: Oxford University
Press, 1959.

7. Paglia C. Cults and Cosmic Consciousness: Religious Vision in the American
1960s, Arion, Winter 2003.

8. Pike SM. New Age and Neopagan Religions in America. Columbia University
Press. 2006.

9. Ulett GA. Acupuncture: archaic or biologic? Am J Public Health.
2003;93(7):1037; author reply 1037-1038.

The Reality of Ancient Wisdom: Acupuncture and TCM Weren’t So Great

Harriet Hall on September 9, 2014

Link



A Chinese barefoot doctor performing acupuncture

A mythology has grown up around traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). The ancient 
wisdom of the inscrutable Orient supposedly helped patients in ways that modern 
science-based medicine fails to understand or appreciate. A typical claim found 
on the Internet: “The ancient beliefs and practice of traditional Chinese
medicine have been healing people for thousands of years.”

As Steven Novella has said, “TCM is a pre-scientific superstitious view of
biology and illness, similar to the humoral theory of Galen, or the notions of
any pre-scientific culture”. TCM really hasn’t been doing a creditable job of
healing people for thousands of years. A book that was brought to my attention
by one of our readers (thank you!) provides a unique insight into what Chinese
medicine was really like circa 1900. I wish everyone who believes in ancient
Chinese medical wisdom would read the chapter on Chinese medicine in this book. 
It provides a much-needed reality check.

Dugald Christie was a Scottish surgeon who served as a missionary doctor in
northeastern China from 1883 to 1913. He wrote the book Thirty Years in Moukden.
1883-1913. Being the Experiences and Recollections of Dugald Christie, C. M.G. 
In providing medical care to Chinese patients, he initially met with strong
resistance. People were suspicious of foreigners and spread vicious rumors about
their evil doings. After he cured the blind with cataract surgery and helped
patients the local doctors had failed to help, the community gradually realized 
he had something to offer that was far superior to what they were used to. Not
just patients; people started flocking to his hospital to learn how to do what
he did, and he eventually established the Mukden Medical College (still
operating today under another name) to train Chinese doctors in Western
medicine. During his 30 years in China he had ample opportunity to observe the
practice of TCM.

The book is available online for free, but I’ll save you the trouble of reading 
it and describe the illuminating historical account of TCM in its pages. It
serves as a reality check to those who believe in acupuncture, in “ancient
wisdom,” and in the efficacy of non-Western medical practices.

Acupuncture

   Chinese doctors own that they know nothing at all of surgery. They cannot tie
   an artery, amputate a finger or perform the simplest operation. The only
   mode of treatment in vogue which might be called surgical is acupuncture,
   practised for all kinds of ailments. The needles are of nine forms, and are
   frequently used red-hot, and occasionally left in the body for days. Having
   no practical knowledge of anatomy, the practitioners often pass needles into 
   large blood vessels and important organs, and immediate death has sometimes
   resulted. A little child was carried to the dispensary presenting a pitiable 
   spectacle. The doctor had told the parents that there was an excess of fire
   in its body, to let out which he must use cold needles, so he had pierced the
   abdomen deeply in several places. The poor little sufferer died shortly
   afterwards. For cholera the needling is in the arms. For some children’s
   diseases, especially convulsions, the needles are inserted under the nails.
   For eye diseases they are often driven into the back between the shoulders to
   a depth of several inches. Patients have come to us with large surfaces on
   their backs sloughing by reason of excessive treatment of this kind with
   instruments none too clean.

Plasters

A black resinous plaster is applied for pain, aching, bruising, swelling, wounds
and sores.

   A boy of nine was brought in a basket, and when the plaster completely
   covering one leg was removed, the smell could almost be heard, as the Chinese
   say. A large part of the tibia was quite bare and projecting. His mother
   said that no medicine had been applied except this plaster, which had first
   been used about fifteen months before, when there was only a small sore
   place, caused by a fall. He was now much emaciated, with weak rapid pulse and
   bad cough, and death seemed not far off. We took him into the hospital,
   treated the leg rationally, and after a few days removed the diseased bone
   entirely. In a month he was walking about, rosy, strong, and merry, and with 
   great enthusiasm learning to read and sing hymns. Such cases are very common 
   in every hospital.

Manipulation

A little boy twisted his leg while playing. A well-known Chinese doctor
violently pulled and twisted his leg. Before the treatment he could walk; after 
it he couldn’t even stand. The Chinese doctor had dislocated his hip, and when
Dr. Christie saw him 3 weeks later he was in so much pain that he had to be
given chloroform just so he could be examined. Christie then replaced the hip in
its socket, and the patient recovered promptly.

Mercury for bullet wounds

He describes removing a piece of bone from a severe gunshot wound, upon which a 
quantity of pure mercury poured out. The patient said, “That is the melted
bullet!” Chinese doctors make no attempt to extract bullets, and they put
mercury into the wound saying it will “melt the lead.” The patient is easily
deceived.

Counter-irritation

   The skin is pinched up and twisted repeatedly and sharply between the fingers
   or knuckles, or with two bits of wood or copper coins, until it becomes
   livid. Cupping is also a common method. People are constantly seen with round
   livid patches on the forehead. “What is wrong?” one asks at first in alarm. 
   But the inevitable surprised answer is: “I had a headache, that is all.”
   Blisters of many kinds are also freely used, and the actual cautery.

Vaccination

They had only recently started using vaccination for smallpox. In the past, they
“vaccinated” by blowing lymph up the nostril.

Superstitions

Lucky days are chosen for taking medicines. A hair is twined around a limb above
a sore to keep the poison from going to the heart. A patient attributed his
illness to punishment for having offended the Tiger-god by eating tiger’s flesh.
A Chinese doctor brought his daughter to the Western doctor, asking him to
operate to “remove the evil thing that is preying on her life.” He believed a
tortoise was growing in her abdomen and drinking her blood three times a day. He
thought he could feel the tortoise’s head moving; he was actually feeling the
pulsations of her aorta. The child didn’t have an abdominal problem; she had
advanced tuberculosis of the lungs.

Mental illness

Madness, epilepsy and hysteria are regarded as possession by devils. To drive
the devils out, patients are forced to stand barefoot on red-hot iron and endure
beatings. A girl of 17 with a bad case of hysteria died after a red-hot poker
was thrust down her throat to expel the demon.

Doctor-shopping

Patients have little confidence in their doctors. If the medicine doesn’t cure
them in a few days, they set it aside and consult another doctor without telling
the first. It is common to use the medicines of several doctors at once.

Note: This is important to know, because people commonly assume that an herbal
treatment that has been used for centuries must be safe and effective because if
it wasn’t the herbalists would have known by now and would have stopped using
it. Patients switched doctors when the treatment wasn’t working, without telling
the first doctor. So he would assume his treatment had cured the patient and he
got no feedback about treatment failures and side effects. These ancient
herbalists had no systematic way of evaluating treatment successes vs. failures 
or of discovering adverse effects.

A plague epidemic

In the winter of 1910-11, an epidemic of what was probably pneumonic plague
swept through Manchuria. There were 43,942 cases recorded and 43,942 deaths. I
was skeptical of those numbers, but they are also reported elsewhere by
historians. 100% mortality; and we think Ebola’s bad! That’s a good
demonstration of how effective TCM was. I would have expected at least a small
percentage of patients to have survived without treatment, so this suggests that
TCM may have been actively killing some patients.

Conclusion

The book offers a glimpse into history showing how truly ineffective and
barbaric TCM really was. This information could go a long way to correct the
misconceptions of those who have succumbed to the “ancient wisdom” fallacy. If
they read it and paid attention. Which they won’t.

Plants often contain chemical compounds that act on the human body, and TCM
accidentally came across some herbal remedies that actually work, but scientific
testing is required to figure out which ones those are. And regulation of
sources is required to prevent contaminants and ensure purification and
standardization. TCM may have made a few serendipitous herbal discoveries, but
as a system of medical care it has no validity. It is a historical curiosity and
an anachronism.

Retconning the story of traditional Chinese medicine

Proponents of “integrating” traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) into medicine
paint a tale of an ancient, unified system of medicine that’s been tested over
at least two millennia and found to be effective. The real story is very
different and is best explained with a term more commonly used to discuss comic 
books. Basically, the “integration” of TCM into “Western medicine” is nothing
new. Chairman Mao started the process in the late 1940s.

David Gorski on November 10, 2014

Link



   Retcon (shortened form of RETroactive CONtinuity; first made popular in the
   comic book world):

  1. (original meaning) Adding information to the back story of a fictional
    character or world, without invalidating that which had gone before.

  2. (more common usage) Adding or altering information regarding the back story of
    a fictional character or world, regardless of whether the change
    contradicts what was said before.

Introduction: In which I confess my (relevant) geekiness

For many years, I was a comic book geek. At the height of my geekdom, I
generally purchased anywhere from eight to twenty titles a month and read them
all voraciously. This went on from around the time I was 12 or so until around
six or seven years ago, when, for reasons that I still don’t quite understand,
my interest waned. I bought fewer and fewer titles. These days there remain only
one or two to which I subscribe, and all that remains of those three decades
are around 10 long boxes full of comics dating back to the mid-1970s and even
earlier.

If there’s one thing any long-time comics geek knows, it’s the concept of
retconning, and retconning is what this post is about. To understand how, please
indulge me a moment while I discuss something unrelated to medicine, namely
comic books. “Retcon” is short for “RETroactive CONtinuity.” It’s something that
happens in virtually all comics at one time or another in which something about
the back story of character is changed, sometimes in major ways, to serve the
current story (or, not infrequently, because some editor thinks it would be
cool). There are several general forms of retconning. Sometimes retcon changes
add to the back story and lead the reader to see the fictional character or
world in a new and interesting way (retcon definition #1, above); more commonly,
they obliterate or significantly alter previous events in ways that have the
potential to ruin current enjoyment of the story (retcon definition #2, above). 
Sometimes they’re just “meh” and do neither (this can happen in retcons
following either definition #1 or #2).

In comics, TV, and literature, retconning is not inherently good or bad. It’s to
be expected when any serial story lasts decades—ofttimes even necessary. (After
all, if my favorite superhero team of all time, the Fantastic Four, hadn’t been
retconned, they’d all have to be around 90 or older, given that Reed Richards
and Ben Grimm both fought in World War II.) Admittedly, retconning does have a
bad reputation because most of the time retcons tend to range from bad to
insulting. For example, if you want to see examples of how ridiculous retconning
can get, there are articles like “The 15 Dumbest Superhero Retcons Of All
Time“, which require no knowledge of the comics discussed to appreciate the
sheer stupidity of the retcons mocked, such as the one that changed Spider-Man’s
origin so that he was new the avatar of a spider god or the one where Iron
Man/Tony Stark was revealed to be a sleeper agent for the villain Kang The
Conqueror. The latter was a storyline so bad that it had to be immediately
retconned again back to the Iron Man we all know and love. Come to think of it, 
one of those retcons, the “One More Day/Brand New Day” retcon of The Amazing
Spider-Man, was probably the bit of sheer stupidity that finally made me give up
Marvel comics, much the way arguably the most infamously lazy retcon of all
time, in which Bobby Ewing’s death and everything that happened after it was
revealed to be just a dream, led some Dallas fans to drop the show.

Finally, some retcons are useful and necessary. For instance, the retconning of 
how Susan Storm (a.k.a. the Invisible Woman of the Fantastic Four) first met and
fell in love with her future husband Reed Richards (a.k.a. Mister Fantastic)
when he was a college freshman rooming at her aunt’s boarding house to change
her from being a 12-year-old girl at the time, who then waited to be old enough 
for Reed to notice her romantically, isn’t a bad thing. That version, which
itself was a retcon of Stan Lee and Jack Kirby’s original origin story in which 
Susan was the “girl next door” that Reed left behind when he went to serve in
the OSS during World War II, comes across as profoundly creepy to 2014
sensibilities and was therefore best retconned away.

Brand New Day, part 1: The story of TCM and why Oceania has always been at war
with Eastasia

Now that you (hopefully) understand the basic concept of retconning, you’ll soon
see what I’m getting at. It’s not just fictional stories that can be subject to
retconning. The narrative of history can also be retconned. Of course, the
difference between retconning fiction and historical narrative is that
historical narrative has facts and evidence to support it. Still, as all
historians know, history is often incomplete, and there are often errors that
need to be corrected, and that doesn’t even take into account different
interpretations of the past. This is often referred to as historical
revisionism, but you can see the similarity to the concept of retconning.
Similar to retconning, revisionism is not in and of itself inherently good or
bad. It is, in fact, an accepted part of historical scholarship, given that new 
documents about various historical events often need to be put into context with
the old, altering the historical narrative. However, like retconning,
revisionism also has a very dark side. One dark version of revisionism, the
study of which served as my “gateway drug,” so to speak, into skepticism, is
Holocaust revisionism, which is in reality Holocaust denial, whose main purposes
are to minimize the suffering Jews endured, to deny or minimize the genocide of
the Holocaust, and to rehabilitate fascist beliefs that led to the Holocaust.

To be fair, the revision of history to serve a current political narrative is
not a new idea. What was the Ministry of Truth in the fictional nation of
Oceania, for which the proponent Winston Smith worked in George Orwell’s
Nineteen Eighty-Four, but an entire ministry devoted to revising historical
narratives? In that famous novel, Smith’s ministry was responsible for
continuously updating—dare I say, retconning?—news and history to be in
agreement with Oceania’s ever-changing official version of the past. The
original documents were thrown down the “memory hole,” where they were
destroyed, and people became “unpersons,” not just killed but every memory of
them erased, every document and photo indicating that they had ever existed
eliminated. This very concept of erasing “inconvenient” history led to one of
the most famous lines from the novel. When the fictional totalitarian nation of 
Oceania in which Smith lives suddenly shifts alliances in its never-ending war, 
making peace with Eurasia and going to war with Eastasia, its people are
informed that “Oceania has always been at war with Eastasia” and expected to
believe it.

Unfortunately, false historical revisionism is a very common practice. Perhaps
the key difference between retconning fiction and retconning history (i.e.,
historical revisionism) is that for fiction the reasons for changing or ignoring
past narratives are often convenience, lazy plotting, and/or a genuine desire
to flesh out a character. For history, the motivation tends to be ideological.
Such is the case with TCM, beginning with one of the greatest
retconners/revisionists of all, Chairman Mao Zedong. After all, totalitarian
regimes, as Orwell so astutely noticed, rely on controlling history in order to 
control present-day narratives. Given that TCM is, by and large, prescientific, 
pseudoscientific, and religion-based quackery grounded in vitalistic beliefs, to
make it palatable to doctors who are ostensibly advocates of evidence-based
medicine requires the retconning of its history on a massive scale. Of course,
retconning/revisionism can only work if the original narrative that is replaced 
is not well known.

Particularly galling about the ascendency of TCM in the US is the myth that is
swallowed whole by its advocates and promoted as truth. That myth is the very
history of TCM, whose true origins are unknown by all but a very few. Contrary
to popular belief (particularly about acupuncture), TCM does not go back
thousands of years into antiquity, when the ancient healing wisdom of the
Chinese was supposedly first discovered and codified and acupuncture discovered.
In actuality, very few people are aware that the single person most responsible
for the current popularity of TCM was not an ancient Chinese healer but rather 
Chairman Mao Zedong, as described in an excellent summary by Alan Levinovitz in 
Slate.com last year, “Chairman Mao Invented Traditional Chinese Medicine“:

   …Mao was under no illusion that Chinese medicine—a key component of
   naturopathic education—actually worked. In The Private Life of Chairman Mao, 
   Li Zhisui, one of Mao’s personal physicians, recounts a conversation they had
   on the subject. Trained as an M.D. in Western medicine, Li admitted to being
   baffled by ancient Chinese medical books, especially their theories relating
   to the five elements. It turns out his employer also found them implausible.

   “Even though I believe we should promote Chinese medicine,” Mao told him, “I 
   personally do not believe in it. I don’t take Chinese medicine.”

Much of the reason for the popularity of TCM in China and its spread to the US
and beyond was actually because Chairman Mao promoted it. The reason, as has
been explained by our very own Kimball Atwood, Steve Novella, Harriet Hall, and 
Ben Kavoussi, is because there simply weren’t enough doctors in China trained in
scientific medicine, as admitted by Mao (quoted by Levinovitz):

   Our nation’s health work teams are large. They have to concern themselves
   with over 500 million people [including the] young, old, and ill. … At
   present, doctors of Western medicine are few, and thus the broad masses of
   the people, and in particular the peasants, rely on Chinese medicine to treat
   illness. Therefore, we must strive for the complete unification of Chinese
   medicine. (Translations from Kim Taylor’s Chinese Medicine in Early Communist
   China, 1945-1963: A Medicine of Revolution.)

Who knew? (Well, I did.) I also knew, as Levinovitz relates, that this was the
very first “integrative” medicine, “integrating quackery with science-based
medicine more than five decades before the term “integrative medicine” caught on
in the US. A particularly pertinent quote sums this idea up:

   “This One Medicine,” exulted the president of the Chinese Medical Association
   in 1952, “will possess a basis in modern natural sciences, will have
   absorbed the ancient and the new, the Chinese and the foreign, all medical
   achievements—and will be China’s New Medicine!”

Indeed, what’s interesting about Levinovitz’s article is his description of how 
the exportation of TCM to the world was quite deliberate, as part of a strategy 
to popularize it among the Chinese. There was a problem, however. As Levinovitz 
noted, there was no such thing as “traditional Chinese medicine.” Rather, there 
were traditional Chinese medicines. For many centuries, healing practices in
China had been highly variable. Attempts at institutionalizing medical education
were mostly unsuccessful and “most practitioners drew at will on a mixture of
demonology, astrology, yin-yang five phases theory, classic texts, folk wisdom, 
and personal experience.” Mao realized that TCM would be unappealing to
foreigners, as even many Chinese, particularly those with an education,
understood that TCM was mostly quackery. For instance, in 1923, Lu Xun realized 
that “Chinese doctors are no more than a type of swindler, either intentional or
unintentional, and I sympathize with deceived sick people and their families.” 
Such sentiments were common among the upper classes and the educated. Indeed, as
we have seen, Mao himself didn’t use TCM practitioners. He wanted scientific
“Western” medicine. The same was true of educated Chinese. It still is.

Mao’s strategy to deal with these criticisms was quite deliberate—and clever. It
consisted of two strategies, both designed to mythologize TCM as being a
scientifically sound and harmonious “whole medical system” and to provide
“evidence” in the form of testimonials that it worked, as Levinovitz relates:

   His solution was a two-pronged approach. First, inconsistent texts and
   idiosyncratic practices had to be standardized. Textbooks were written that
   portrayed Chinese medicine as a theoretical and practical whole, and they
   were taught in newly founded academies of so-called “traditional Chinese
   medicine,” a term that first appeared in English, not Chinese. Needless to
   say, the academies were anything but traditional, striving valiantly to
   “scientify” the teachings of classics that often contradicted one another and
   themselves. Terms such as “holism” (zhengtiguan) and “preventative care”
   (yufangxing) were used to provide the new system with appealing foundational 
   principles, principles that are now standard fare in arguments about the
   benefits of alternative medicine.

This effort to “scientify” TCM, or, as I like to call it now, to retcon the
science, is very much a part of the promotion of TCM and continues this very
day, as you will see in the concluding section of this post.

The second part of Mao’s strategy was the dissemination of spectacular anecdotes
to “prove” the efficacy of TCM. The most famous of these was the case of James 
Reston, a New York Times editor who underwent an emergency appendectomy while
visiting China in 1971. Even though the surgeons there used a fairly standard
anesthesia technique, described by our SBM colleague Kimball Atwood as sounding 
like a “standard regional technique, most likely an epidural,” acupuncture was
used to treat cramping on second evening after the surgery, which I interpreted 
as being the evening of postoperative day one. The story is familiar to any
general surgeon; about a day and a half after surgery Reston had some cramping, 
likely due to postoperative ileus that kept the gas from moving through his
bowels the way it normally does. It passed after an hour or so. Around that
time, the staff at the hospital used acupuncture to treat his discomfort, and
the logical fallacy known as post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy (and a bunch of
credulous Westerners, eager to believe that some magical mystical “Eastern”
wisdom” could do what “Western medicine” could not) did the rest. Most likely
what happened is that Reston finally passed gas spontaneously (which is how
postoperative ileus nearly always resolves), letting the built-up gas move
through and relieving the cramps and bloating. About a day or two after an
uncomplicated appendectomy is about right for that.

Over time, reports of “acupuncture anesthesia” trickled out of China to a
welcoming, credulous “Western” press. When examined closely by doctors who know 
about anesthesia (such as an anesthesiologist), these stories universally have
big holes in them. Just a few examples were catalogued by our very own
anesthesiologist, again Kimball Atwood. In fact, you can view Levinovitz’s
article as the CliffsNotes version of the campaign by Mao to convince the West
that acupuncture (and, by extension, TCM) worked as well or better than any
“Western medicine.” Read Kimball Atwood’s epic “Acupuncture Anesthesia”: A
Proclamation from Chairman Mao (Part I, Part II, Part III, Part IV, and Part V) 
for the detailed version. Of particular interest to students of “integrative
medicine” is Part III, in which Dr. Atwood has an entire section entitled “From 
‘Co-operation’ to ‘Integration,'” in which he lists the five main party slogans 
about TCM:

  1. 1945-50 ‘The Co-operation of Chinese and Western Medicines’

  2. 1950-8 ‘The Unification of Chinese and Western Medicines’

  3. 1950-53 ‘Chinese Medicine studies Western Medicine’

  4. 1954-8 ‘Western Medicine studies Chinese Medicine’

  5. 1958- ‘The Integration of Chinese and Western Medicines’

Mao’s idea was nothing less than the complete unification of TCM and “Western”
medicine, as quoted by Kimball Atwood further from The Private Life of Chairman 
Mao:

   Mao laughed. ‘The theory of yin and yang and the five elements really is very
   difficult,’ he said. ‘The theory is used by doctors of Chinese medicine to
   explain the physiological and pathological conditions of the human body. What
   I believe is that Chinese and Western medicine should be integrated.
   Well-trained doctors of Western medicine should learn Chinese medicine;
   senior doctors of Chinese medicine should learn anatomy, physiology,
   bacteriology, pathology, and so on. They should learn how to use modern
   science to explain the principles of Chinese medicine. They should translate 
   some classical Chinese medicine books into modern language, with proper
   annotations and explanations. Then a new medical science, based on the
   integration of Chinese and Western medicine, can emerge. That would be a
   great contribution to the world.’

Moreover, acupuncture is probably not nearly as ancient as its advocates portray
it. Common portrayals of acupuncture paint it as being 3,000 years old, as
implausible as that is. Why implausible? For one thing, the technology to make
such incredibly thin needles didn’t exist 3,000 years ago. For another thing, as
Harriet Hall points out, the earliest Chinese medical texts from the 3rd
century BC don’t mention acupuncture, and the earliest reference to “needling”
is from 90 BC referring to bloodletting and lancing abscesses. Indeed, even by
the 13th century the earliest accounts of Chinese medicine reaching the West
didn’t mention acupuncture, and the first account of acupuncture by a Westerner 
in the 1600s described large golden needles inserted into the skull and left in 
place for 30 respirations. It has also been argued that acupuncture evolved from
bloodletting based on astrology. In any case, as Harriet Hall described, as
recently as less than 100 years ago, acupuncture involved the insertion of
needles that were frequently red-hot and sometimes left in the body for days, as
described by Scottish surgeon Dugald Christie, who served as a missionary
doctor in northeastern China from 1883 to 1913:

   Chinese doctors own that they know nothing at all of surgery. They cannot tie
   an artery, amputate a finger or perform the simplest operation. The only
   mode of treatment in vogue which might be called surgical is acupuncture,
   practised for all kinds of ailments. The needles are of nine forms, and are
   frequently used red-hot, and occasionally left in the body for days. Having
   no practical knowledge of anatomy, the practitioners often pass needles into 
   large blood vessels and important organs, and immediate death has sometimes
   resulted. A little child was carried to the dispensary presenting a pitiable 
   spectacle. The doctor had told the parents that there was an excess of fire
   in its body, to let out which he must use cold needles, so he had pierced the
   abdomen deeply in several places. The poor little sufferer died shortly
   afterwards. For cholera the needling is in the arms. For some children’s
   diseases, especially convulsions, the needles are inserted under the nails.
   For eye diseases they are often driven into the back between the shoulders to
   a depth of several inches. Patients have come to us with large surfaces on
   their backs sloughing by reason of excessive treatment of this kind with
   instruments none too clean.

Compare this to the prevailing narrative today of the history of acupuncture and
TCM as “ancient wisdom” that has existed for millennia. Retconning,
revisionism, or whatever you want to call it, the history that we are told does 
not match the real history, which has largely disappeared down the memory hole.

Brand New Day, Part 2: Retconning the science of TCM

Over the last 30 years or so, what was once quackery, rightly dismissed in a
famous 1983 editorial in the New England Journal of Medicine as a “pabulum of
common sense and nonsense offered by cranks and quacks and failed pedants who
share an attachment to magic and an animosity toward reason” has become
mainstream, evolving from quackery to “alternative medicine” to “complementary
and alternative medicine” (CAM) and finally to “integrative medicine.” For no
form of quackery has this been more true than for traditional Chinese medicine, 
which is now considered downright respectable in many places, practiced and
studied, as it is, in some of the most prestigious medical schools and academic 
medical centers in the US. Mao, I suspect, is laughing in his grave.

At each stage of this “evolution,” the idea was to retcon the history and
science of TCM in order to represent various ancient folk medicines from China
based on pseudoscientific, mystical, and/or prescientific beliefs as somehow
being co-equal with “Western” or “scientific” medicine through the clever use of
language. If you want to see just how successful TCM has been at not only
infiltrating itself into what should be bastions of science-based medicine but
at changing the very terms and language under which it is evaluated, just look
at this article by Shirley S. Wang that appeared in The Wall Street Journal last
Monday entitled “A Push to Back Traditional Chinese Medicine With More Data:
Researchers Marry Modern Analytical Techniques to Centuries-Old Theories on What
Makes People Sick“:

   Traditional Chinese medicine teaches that some people have hot constitutions,
   making them prone to fever and inflammation in parts of the body, while
   others tend to have cold body parts and get chills.

   Such Eastern-rooted ideas have been developed over thousands of years of
   experience with patients. But they aren’t backed up by much scientific data.

   Now researchers in some the most highly respected universities in China, and 
   increasingly in Europe and the U.S., are wedding Western techniques for
   analyzing complex biological systems to the Chinese notion of seeing the body
   as a networked whole. The idea is to study how genes or proteins interact
   throughout the body as a disease develops, rather than to examine single
   genes or molecules.

   “Traditional Chinese medicine views disease as complete a pattern as
   possible,” says Jennifer Wan, a professor in the school of biological
   sciences at the University of Hong Kong who studies traditional Chinese
   medicine, or TCM. “Western medicine tends to view events or individuals as
   discrete particles.” But one gene or biological marker alone typically
   doesn’t yield comprehensive understanding of disease, she says.

At least she acknowledges that TCM isn’t “backed up by much scientific data.” Of
course, that acknowledgment is the justification for studying TCM, the
assumption being that, because it is ancient, there must be something to it. As 
if to drive home the “integrative medicine” narrative that TCM is equivalent to 
“Western” medicine, the article even includes a truly infuriating illustration
of a stylized human body, half of which is filled with TCM-related illustrations
such as herbs and words like “fire” and “metal,” and half is filled with
illustrations covering “Western medicine” like the DNA double helix and a gel
electrophoresis:

In the illustration, “Western medicine” ascribes the cause of the disease
example used, rheumatoid arthritis, to autoimmune disease and lists treatments
such as nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs, steroids, and disease-modifying
antirheumatic drugs to slow disease progression. On the other side, TCM
postulates as the cause of rheumatoid arthritis “blockage in flow of qi and
blood in the energy pathways of the body; wind, cold, and damp penetrate the
body and get into muscles, joints; there are different forms of arthritis
depending on if wind, cold, damp, or heat predominate.” Truly, I kid you not.
And the TCM treatment? Acupuncture, tai chi, and herb thunder god vine. This is 
such a great example that I’m saving this poster for use in future talks, so
emblematic is it of the false equivalence “integrative medicine” lends to
prescientific, unscientific, and pseudoscientific ideas. The overall idea
communicated by the illustration? Clearly, the illustration is intended to imply
strongly that TCM’s magic-based description of the pathophysiology and
treatment of rheumatoid arthritis is worthy of being considered as an equal to
science-based knowledge about the disease, gathered over decades, of what causes
rheumatoid arthritis and how to treat it.

This narrative has become so depressingly common that it ought to have a name.
“They thought it was quackery but now it’s science”? Too long, but that’s the
false message of every one of these stories, which is that they thought us mad, 
mad, I tell you! But now we’re showing those nasty, close-minded, reductionistic
“Western” doctors! Except that they aren’t, and this story inadvertently shows 
why they aren’t. Still, a punchier name for the trope would be useful. “They
thought us quacks,” maybe? The “we’re really, really science, maaaan” trope,
perhaps? Perhaps you can help me out. I’ll leave thinking of a pithy, punchy
name for this trope as an exercise for the reader in the comments.

In the meantime, let’s take a closer look at the article. It’s based entirely on
the very hubris behind “integrative medicine,” namely that medicine based on
prescientific and religious beliefs, like traditional Chinese medicine, is at
least nearly co-equal with medicine based on science and rigorous clinical
trials. Or, at least, it would be equal to scientific medicine if there were
actually some evidence for it, which these brave maverick doctors and scientists
are furiously searching for, no matter how much they have to torture modern
systems biology and molecular biology techniques to shoehorn TCM’s fantasy-based
“networks” into the networks of gene activity being increasingly understood by 
modern molecular biology.

Here’s where the retconning comes in. Look at the passage above. Wan claims that
TCM views disease as “complete a pattern as possible.” This is a narrative that
we hear time and time and time again about TCM, that it considers the “whole
patient,” that it is “wholistic,” that it considers the patient as a “system.”
Of course, if that “system” isn’t based on science and evidence, then who cares?
After all, what about ancient “Western” medicine, which stated that imbalances 
in the four humors (phlegm, blood, yellow bile, and black bile) caused disease? 
It’s pretty similar in many ways to TCM postulates, which ascribes illness to
six pernicious influences. These include wind, cold, heat, dampness, dryness and
summer heat, which are, like totally not like the four humors. (There are,
after all, six pernicious influences. Can’t you count?) TCM also has the “five
elements” (fire, wood, earth, water, and metal), which are associated with
different organs. So maybe TCM is on to something because its prescientific
belief is a bit more complicated than the prescientific belief system that
undergirded “Western medicine” for many centuries before scientific medicine
arose. That means TCM must be better, right? After all, there must be a reason
why there’s all this scientific interest in studying diagnoses based on the five
elements and six pernicious influences, but no love left over for studying
diagnoses based on imbalances between the four humors, right?

At this point, I feel obligated to acknowledge that regular readers are probably
wondering why I’m using the term “Western” medicine given that I find the whole
“East-West” dichotomy favored by advocates of TCM and “integrative medicine” to
be borderline, if not outright, racist. After all, the unspoken assumption
behind this dichotomy, whether those using it realize it or not, is that the
“West” is cold, reductionistic, and scientific while the “East” is “wholistic”
and connected to the human. It’s all pernicious nonsense, of course, insulting
to Chinese and other Asian scientists. Science is science, and those in the
“East” can do science as well as we “Western” scientists can. What counts are
evidence, experiments, and reason, none of which knows “East,” “West,” “North,” 
or “South”. However, it is the language assumed in Wong’s article; so I use it
as I see fit in order to deconstruct it.

Another trope is plain in the passage above. “Western” medicine is disparagingly
presented as “reductionistic.” Note the bit about viewing events or individuals
as “discrete particles” and how “one gene or biological marker alone typically 
doesn’t yield comprehensive understanding of disease. We hear this time and time
and time again, but it’s a straw man. Yes, “Western” science tends to break
down processes to their smallest component parts but it also recognizes (and
always has recognized) the complexity of the networks made up by those component
parts. Oddly enough, no one seems able to tell me how viewing organs as related
to “five elements” (which are not actually elements) and disease as being
caused by “six pernicious influences” is in any way “wholistic” or more
“wholistic” than viewing disease as being due to imbalances in four humors.
Moreover, although in metabolism science has always looked at whole networks
(e.g., glycolysis, the Krebs cycle, oxidative phosporylation, and all the
metabolic networks that feed into these pathways), part of the reason why
science focused on single genes for so long is because it was limited by the
technology. It wasn’t until about 15 years ago that the tools were developed to 
start looking at, yes, “wholistic” changes in gene expression using whole genome
expression profiling, which allows the detection of changes in the expression
of every known gene in the genome. Since then, we’ve only become better at this.
Using next generation sequencing techniques, it’s possible to examine changes
in expression of every transcript in the genome, coding and noncoding,
simultaneously, and the technology has gotten to the point where it is now
becoming possible to examine the changes in gene expression of the whole genome 
of single cells.

Much of the second half of the article deals with what TCM refers to as “hot” or
“cold” syndrome. What’s happening with this system of diagnoses is that
credulous scientists are retconning the science, in essence shoehorning
diagnoses based on prescientific vitalism into modern, systems biology and
pretending that they were always harmonious and that systems biology supports
TCM. Oceania has always been at war with Eastasia, and ancient TCM
practitioners, in their wisdom, figured out things that science is only now
coming to understand.

I swear, when I saw this next passage I couldn’t believe an otherwise
intelligent journalist could write something so ridiculous with a straight face:

   One promising area of TCM research several independent groups of scientists
   are investigating is the notion of hot and cold syndromes. The work is still 
   in its early stages. But it could result in a new direction for TCM research 
   by using the systems biology approach and integrating it with experience
   gleaned from TCM patient care, says Yale’s Dr. Cheng, who also serves as
   chairman of the Consortium for the Globalization of Chinese Medicine.

   In a series of studies, Tsinghua’s Dr. Li and his colleagues examined people 
   with hot and cold syndromes and whether they exhibited different signs of
   illness, including gastritis, a common digestive disorder in which the lining
   of the stomach becomes inflamed or irritated.

   To gauge whether gastritis patients had cold or hot syndromes, researchers
   asked questions like whether individuals had chilly body parts or exhibited a
   preference for hot beverages or a susceptibility to catching colds. Doctors 
   dug into their subjects’ emotional states, asking whether they experienced
   so-called cold feelings like apathy. The scientists also measured proteins
   linked to gastritis and took measurements of the bacteria in the gut and
   imaged the bacteria in the tongue’s coating.

   They found some variations depending on whether patients were identified as
   hot or cold. They also found differences in the bacteria of patients’ tongues
   that corresponded with tongue coating color and whether patients had been
   diagnosed with hot or cold syndrome.

One might as well run systems biology experiments on patients subjected to
magical incantations, because that’s basically what is happening here! As I’ve
said before, if the treatments and diagnostic modalities being tested are
prescientific or pseudoscientific, using all the flashy new science in the world
won’t make the experiment science. If there’s one thing I see in common with
experiments examining whether “hot” or “cold” diagnoses correlate with changes
in biomarkers and other laboratory values is that they tend to be small studies,
prone to false positives, and to be massive fishing expeditions, with large
numbers of comparisons. In this they remind me of some homeopathy studies.

Consider what it is that TCM means by “hot” and “cold” diagnoses. The root of
the “hot-cold” dichotomy is not based on any science. Rather, it’s based in
Taoist religion, the “Yin Yang theory” of disease. As described here, TCM
states:

   The root of many of the ideas within Chinese medicine lies in the concept of 
   Yin and Yang. Yin and Yang are emblems of the fundamental duality in the
   universe, a duality that is ultimately unified. Yin and Yang are
   complementary, and not contradictory. Nor is one regarded as ‘good’ and the
   other ‘bad’. People will often state that, “I am Yin”, or “I am Yang”, but
   this would be inaccurate; they may have a Yin-Yang imbalance or tendancies
   [sic], but everyone has both qualities.

   Harmony is sought between these Yin and Yang qualities and any imbalance
   avoided when approaching the body as a holistic union. Yin is matter like
   Blood, fluids and tissue in the body. Yang is the action potential, Qi, and
   heat in the body. Chinese medicine balances Yin and Yang and can also build
   these qualities in the body when they are deficient. No one person is
   completely Yin or Yang; rather, one would look for tendencies and patterns,
   and weigh them out; one organ system may have Yang excess while another organ
   system in the same body can have Yang Deficiency.

From the same source, we learn that “yang excess” or “yin deficient” signs
include things like constipation, thirst, dark yellow urine, red tongue,
dryness, heavy loud respiration, burning bowel movement, and strong body odor.
(I suppose the last two probably go together.) We also learn that signs of “true
heat” include blood in the nose, stool, or urine; yellow green mucus; fever;
and sticky, thick excretions. These are the sorts of things that TCM
practitioners look for and ask about. I suppose it’s possible that certain
biomarkers might be different in people with true heat or yang excess or yin
deficiency, but whether those have anything to do with a disease like rheumatoid
arthritis due to anything other than coincidence is unlikely.

Oceania has always been at war with Eastasia

This whole endeavor is, of course, as perfect example of what Harriet Hall likes
to refer to as Tooth Fairy science as I’ve ever seen. Basically, Tooth Fairy
science involves applying the scientific method to phenomena that don’t exist.
As Harriet’s pointed out many times (and I’ve echoed), we can study the amount
of money left by the Tooth Fairy in different settings, but since we haven’t
determined that there really is a Tooth Fairy, any conclusions we reach will be 
falsely attributed to a magical being, rather than to the real cause. The
prescientific beliefs behind TCM are a lot like the Tooth Fairy. It’s not for
nothing that a Chinese physician has issued a TCM challenge, not unlike James
Randi’s million dollar challenge to TCM practitioners to prove their methods.

Lots and lots of research money is being wasted studying prescientific
superstition such as qi, yin and yang, and “hot” and “cold” applied to human
disease, and universities are embracing such twaddle with both arms. Just this
year, for instance, the Cleveland Clinic opened an herbal medicine clinic run by
a naturopath practicing largely TCM (mentioned in the article). Dozens of
academic medical centers offer this sort of quackery to their patients, in the
name of supposedly wanting to study it, but if they don’t know it works how can 
they offer it as anything other than experimental therapy? Instead, they offer
it as though it were validated medicine. Meanwhile, TCM advocates try to sell
this prescientific form of medicine as though it were somewhere on the same
planet, evidence-wise, as scientific medicine when it is not. Let’s just put it 
this way. You can make up all the complex “networks” and “systems” that claim to
describe human physiology and disease as you want, but if they aren’t grounded 
in reality and evidence they’re nothing more than fantasy. Indeed, fantasy is
what is being “integrated” with scientific medicine, fantasy like TCM. To make
it fit, the very history of TCM has been retconned beyond recognition, and
believers are furiously retconning the narrative about the science of TCM. This 
retcon has been a smashing success for TCM.

Sadly, the reaction of the vast majority of physicians to the popularization of 
quackademic medicine is a shrug. It is more than a little depressing to think
there are more than a few Very Serious Academic Doctors out there who have
bought into this myth and have even widened Mao’s vision of “integration” beyond
“integrating” SBM with TCM to include virtually every form of magical quackery 
in existence.

                 Acupuncture: Basic Science and Clinical Trials

Acupuncture Doesn’t Work

Steven Novella on June 19, 2013

Link

About a year ago the editors of Anesthesia & Analgesia solicited a written
debate on whether or not acupuncture is effective or simply an elaborate
placebo. Four experienced acupuncture researchers agreed to write the
pro-acupuncture article, Wang, Harris, Lin and Gan. They asked David Colquhoun
to write the con position, and David asked me to write it with him (which, of
course, I enthusiastically agreed to do).

The article is fortunately published in open access, and so I can reprint it
here (full article is below). What I think David and I convincingly demonstrated
is that, according to the usual standards of medicine, acupuncture does not
work.

Let me explain what I mean by that. Clinical research can never prove that an
intervention has an effect size of zero. Rather, clinical research assumes the
null hypothesis, that the treatment does not work, and the burden of proof lies 
with demonstrating adequate evidence to reject the null hypothesis. So, when
being technical, researchers will conclude that a negative study “fails to
reject the null hypothesis.”

Further, negative studies do not demonstrate an effect size of zero, but rather 
that any possible effect is likely to be smaller than the power of existing
research to detect. The greater the number and power of such studies, however,
the closer this remaining possible effect size gets to zero. At some point the
remaining possible effect becomes clinically insignificant.

In other words, clinical research may not be able to detect the difference
between zero effect and a tiny effect, but at some point it becomes irrelevant.

What David and I have convincingly argued, in my opinion, is that after decades 
of research and more than 3000 trials, acupuncture researchers have failed to
reject the null hypothesis, and any remaining possible specific effect from
acupuncture is so tiny as to be clinically insignificant.

In layman’s terms, acupuncture does not work – for anything.

This has profound clinical, ethical, scientific, and practical implications. In 
my opinion humanity should not waste another penny, another moment, another
patient – any further resources on this dead end. We should consider this a
lesson learned, cut our losses, and move on.

I suspect, however, human nature being what it is, that this will not happen
anytime soon.

________________

Full article reprinted from Anesthesia & Analgesia

Acupuncture Is Theatrical Placebo


  1. David Colquhoun, PhD* and

  2. Steven P. Novella, MD†

Introduction

Pain is a big problem. If you read about pain management centers, you might
think it had been solved. It has not. And when no effective treatment exists for
a medical problem, it leads to a tendency to clutch at straws. Research has
shown that acupuncture is little more than such a straw.

Although it is commonly claimed that acupuncture has been around for thousands
of years, it has not always been popular, even in China. For almost 1000 years, 
it was in decline, and in 1822, Emperor Dao Guang issued an imperial edict
stating that acupuncture and moxibustion should be banned forever from the
Imperial Medical Academy.1

Acupuncture continued as a minor fringe activity in the 1950s. After the Chinese
Civil War, the Chinese Communist Party ridiculed Traditional Chinese Medicine, 
including acupuncture, as superstitious. Chairman Mao Zedong later revived
Traditional Chinese Medicine as part of the Great Proletarian Cultural
Revolution of 1966.2 The revival was a convenient response to the dearth of
medically trained people in postwar China and a useful way to increase Chinese
nationalism. It is said that Chairman Mao himself preferred Western medicine.
His personal physician quotes him as saying “Even though I believe we should
promote Chinese medicine, I personally do not believe in it. I do not take
Chinese medicine.”3

The political, or perhaps commercial, bias seems to still exist. It has been
reported (by authors who are sympathetic to alternative medicine) that “all
trials [of acupuncture] originating in China, Japan, Hong Kong, and Taiwan were 
positive.”4

Acupuncture was essentially defunct in the West until President Nixon visited
China in 1972. Its revival in the West was largely a result of a single anecdote
promulgated by journalist James Reston in the New York Times5 after he had
acupuncture in Beijing for postoperative pain in 1971. Despite his eminence as a
political journalist, Reston had no scientific background and evidently did not
appreciate the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy, or the idea of regression to 
the mean.

After Reston’s report, acupuncture quickly became popular in the West. Stories
circulated that patients in China had open heart surgery using only
acupuncture.6The Medical Research Council (UK) sent a delegation, which included
Alan Hodgkin, to China in 1972 to investigate these claims, about which they
were skeptical. The claims were repeated in 2006 in a British Broadcasting
Corporation TV program, but Simon Singh (author of Fermat’s Last Theorem)
discovered that the patient had been given a combination of 3 very powerful
sedatives (midazolam, droperidol, fentanyl) and large volumes of local
anesthetic injected into the chest. The acupuncture needles were purely
cosmetic.

Curiously, given that its alleged principles are as bizarre as those on any
other sort of prescientific medicine, acupuncture seemed to gain somewhat more
plausibility than other forms of alternative medicine. As a result, more
research has been done on acupuncture than on just about any other fringe
practice.

The outcome of this research, we propose, is that the benefits of acupuncture
are likely nonexistent, or at best are too small and too transient to be of any 
clinical significance. It seems that acupuncture is little or no more than a
theatrical placebo. The evidence for this conclusion will now be discussed.

THREE THINGS THAT ARE NOT RELEVANT TO THE ARGUMENT

We see no point in discussing surrogate outcomes, such as functional magnetic
resonance imaging studies or endorphine release studies, until such time as it
has been shown that patients get a useful degree of relief. It is now clear that
they do not.

We also see little point in invoking individual studies. Inconsistency is a
prominent characteristic of acupuncture research: the heterogeneity of results
poses a problem for meta-analysis. Consequently, it is very easy to pick trials 
that show any outcome whatsoever. Therefore, we shall consider only
meta-analyses.

The argument that acupuncture is somehow more holistic, or more
patient-centered, than medicine seems to us to be a red herring. All good
doctors are empathetic and patient-centered. The idea that empathy is restricted
to those who practice unscientific medicine seems both condescending to
doctors, and it verges on an admission that empathy is all that alternative
treatments have to offer.

There is now unanimity that the benefits, if any, of acupuncture for analgesia, 
are too small to be helpful to patients.

Large multicenter clinical trials conducted in Germany7–10 and the United
States11 consistently revealed that verum (or true) acupuncture and sham
acupuncture treatments are no different in decreasing pain levels across
multiple chronic pain disorders: migraine, tension headache, low back pain, and 
osteoarthritis of the knee.

If, indeed, sham acupuncture is no different from real acupuncture, the apparent
improvement that may be seen after acupuncture is merely a placebo effect.
Furthermore, it shows that the idea of meridians is purely imaginary. All that
remains to be discussed is whether or not the placebo effect is big enough to be
useful, and whether it is ethical to prescribe placebos.

Some meta-analyses have found that there may be a small difference between sham 
and real acupuncture. Madsen et al.12 looked at 13 trials with 3025 patients, in
which acupuncture was used to treat a variety of painful conditions. There was 
a small difference between “real” and sham acupuncture (it did not matter which 
sort of sham was used), and a somewhat bigger difference between the acupuncture
group and the no-acupuncture group. The crucial result was that even this
bigger difference corresponded to only a 10-point improvement on a 100-point
pain scale. A consensus report13 concluded that a change of this sort should be 
described as a “minimal” change or “little change.” It is not big enough for the
patient to notice much effect.

The acupuncture and no-acupuncture groups were, of course, neither blind to the 
patients nor blind to the practitioner giving the treatment. It is not possible 
to say whether the observed difference is a real physiological action or whether
it is a placebo effect of a rather dramatic intervention. Though it would be
interesting to know this, it matters not a jot, because the effect just is not
big enough to produce any tangible benefit.

Publication bias is likely to be an even greater problem for alternative
medicine than it is for real medicine, so it is particularly interesting that
the result just described has been confirmed by authors who practice, or
sympathize with, acupuncture. Vickers et al.14 did a meta-analysis for 29
randomized controlled trials, with 17,922 patients. The patients were being
treated for a variety of chronic pain conditions. The results were very similar 
to those of Madsen et al.12Real acupuncture was better than sham but by a tiny
amount that lacked any clinical significance. Again there was a somewhat larger 
difference in the nonblind comparison of acupuncture and no-acupuncture, but
again it was so small that patients would barely notice it.

Comparison of these 2 meta-analyses shows how important it is to read the
results, not just the summaries. Although the outcomes were similar for both,
the spin on the results in the abstracts (and consequently the tone of media
reports) was very different.

An even more extreme example occurred in the CACTUS trial of acupuncture for
“frequent attenders” with medically unexplained symptoms.15 In this case, the
results showed very little difference even between acupuncture and
no-acupuncture groups, despite the lack of blinding and lack of proper controls.
But, by ignoring the problems of multiple comparisons, the authors were able to
pick out a few results that were statistically significant, though trivial in
size. Despite this unusually negative outcome, the result was trumpeted as a
success for acupuncture. Not only the authors, but also their university’s
public relations department and even the journal editor issued highly misleading
statements. This gave rise to a flood of letters to the British Journal of
General Practice16 and much criticism on the Internet.17

From the intellectual point of view, it would be interesting to know whether the
small difference between real and sham acupuncture found in some recent studies
is a genuine effect of acupuncture or whether it is a result of the fact that
the practitioners are never blinded, or of publication bias. However, that
knowledge is irrelevant for patients. All that matters for them is whether or
not they get a useful degree of relief. It seems that they do not.

There is now unanimity between acupuncturists and nonacupuncturists that any
benefits that may exist are too small to provide any noticeable benefit to
patients. That being the case, it is hard to see why acupuncture is still used. 
Certainly, such an accumulation of negative results would result in the
withdrawal of any conventional treatment.

SPECIFIC CONDITIONS

Acupuncture should, ideally, be tested separately for effectiveness for each
individual condition for which it has been proposed (like so many other forms of
alternative medicine, that is a very large number). Good quality trials have
not been done for all of them, but results suggest strongly that it is unlikely 
that acupuncture works for rheumatoid arthritis, stopping smoking, irritable
bowel syndrome, or for losing weight. There is also no good reason to think it
works for addictions, asthma, chronic pain, depression, insomnia, neck pain,
shoulder pain or frozen shoulder, osteoarthritis of the knee, sciatica, stroke
or tinnitus, and many other conditions.18

In 2009, the United Kingdom’s National Institute for Clinical Excellence did
recommend acupuncture for back pain.19 This exercise in clutching at straws
caused something of a furore.20 In the light of National Institute for Clinical 
Excellence’s judgment, the Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine updated its
analysis of acupuncture for back pain. Their verdict21 was

   “Clinical bottom line. Acupuncture is no better than a toothpick for treating
   back pain.”

The article by Artus et al.22 is of particular interest for the problem of back 
pain. Their Figure 2 shows that there is a modest improvement in pain scores
after treatment, but much the same effect, with the same time course is found
regardless of what treatment is given, and even with no treatment at all. They
say

   “we found evidence that these responses seem to follow a common trend of
   early rapid improvement in symptoms that slows down and reaches a plateau 6
   months after the start of treatment, although the size of response varied
   widely. We found a similar pattern of improvement in symptoms following any
   treatment, regardless of whether it was index, active comparator, usual care,
   or placebo treatment.”

It seems that most of what is being seen is regression to the mean, which is
very likely to be the main reason why acupuncture sometimes appears to work when
it does not.

Although the article by Wang et al.23 is written to defend the continued use of 
acupuncture, the only condition for which they claim that there is any
reasonably strong evidence is for postoperative nausea and vomiting (PONV). It
would certainly be odd if a treatment that had been advocated for such a wide
variety of conditions turned out to work only for PONV. Nevertheless, let us
look at the evidence.

The main papers that are cited to support the efficacy of acupuncture in
alleviation of PONV are all from the same author: Lee and Done (1999)24 and 2
Cochrane reviews, Lee and Done (2004),25 updated in Lee and Fan (2009).26 We
need to deal only with the latest updated meta-analysis26.

Although the authors conclude “P6 acupoint stimulation prevented PONV,” closer
examination shows that this conclusion is very far from certain. Even taken at
face value, a relative risk of 0.7 cannot be described as “prevention.” The
trials that were included were not all tests of acupuncture but included several
other more or less bizarre treatments (“acupuncture, electroacupuncture,
transcutaneous nerve stimulation, laser stimulation, capsicum plaster, an
acu-stimulation device, and acupressure”). The number needed to treat varied
from a disastrous 34 to 5 for patients with control rates of PONV of 10% and
70%, respectively.

The meta-analysis showed, on average, similar effectiveness for acupuncture and 
antiemetic drugs. The problem is that the effectiveness of drugs is itself in
doubt because an update to the Cochrane review has been delayed27 by the
discovery of major fraud by a Japanese anesthetist, Yoshitaka Fujii.28 It has
been suggested that metoclopramide barely works at all.29,30

Of the 40 trials (4858 participants) that were included in Lee and Fan,26 only 4
trials reported adequate allocation concealment. Ninety percent of trials were 
open to bias from this source. Twelve trials did not report all outcomes. The
opportunities for bias are obvious. The authors themselves describe all
estimates as being of “moderate quality” which is defined thus: “Further
research is likely to have an important impact on our confidence in the estimate
of effect and may change the estimate.” That being the case, perhaps the
conclusion should have been “more research needed.” The conclusions of Lee and
Fan26 are nowhere near as secure as the abstract implies. In fact, almost all
trials of alternative medicines seem to end up with the conclusion that more
research is needed. After more than 3000 trials, that is dubious.

CONCLUSIONS

It is clear from meta-analyses that results of acupuncture trials are variable
and inconsistent, even for single conditions. After thousands of trials of
acupuncture and hundreds of systematic reviews,18 arguments continue unabated.
In 2011, Pain published an editorial31 that summed up the present situation
well.

   “Is there really any need for more studies? Ernst et al.18 point out that the
   positive studies conclude that acupuncture relieves pain in some conditions 
   but not in other very similar conditions. What would you think if a new pain 
   pill was shown to relieve musculoskeletal pain in the arms but not in the
   legs? The most parsimonious explanation is that the positive studies are
   false positives. In his seminal article on why most published research
   findings are false, Ioannidis32 points out that when a popular but
   ineffective treatment is studied, false positive results are common for
   multiple reasons, including bias and low prior probability.”

Since it has proved impossible to find consistent evidence after more than 3000 
trials, it is time to give up. It seems very unlikely that the money that it
would cost to do another 3000 trials would be well-spent.

A small excess of positive results after thousands of trials is most consistent 
with an inactive intervention. The small excess is predicted by poor study
design and publication bias. Furthermore, Simmons et al.33 demonstrated that
exploitation of “undisclosed flexibility in data collection and analysis” can
produce statistically positive results even from a completely nonexistent
effect. They say this is “… not driven by a willingness to deceive but by the
self-serving interpretation of ambiguity, which enables us to convince ourselves
that whichever decisions produced the most publishable outcome must have also
been the most appropriate.”

With acupuncture, in particular, there is documented profound bias among
proponents.4 Existing studies are also contaminated by variables other than
acupuncture, such as the frequent inclusion of “electroacupuncture” which is
essentially transdermal electrical nerve stimulation masquerading as
acupuncture.

The best controlled studies show a clear pattern, with acupuncture the outcome
does not depend on needle location or even needle insertion. Since these
variables are those that define acupuncture, the only sensible conclusion is
that acupuncture does not work. Everything else is the expected noise of
clinical trials, and this noise seems particularly high with acupuncture
research. The most parsimonious conclusion is that with acupuncture there is no 
signal, only noise.

The interests of medicine would be best-served if we emulated the Chinese
Emperor Dao Guang and issued an edict stating that acupuncture and moxibustion
should no longer be used in clinical practice.

No doubt acupuncture will continue to exist on the “High Streets” where they can
be tolerated as a voluntary self-imposed tax on the gullible (as long as they
do not make unjustified claims).

DISCLOSURES

Name: David Colquhoun, PhD.

Contribution: Professor Colquhoun coauthored the manuscript.

Attestation: Professor Colquhoun approved the final manuscript.

Conflicts of Interest: Professor Colquhoun has no financial conflicts of
interest. Professor Colquhoun writes the “DC’s Improbable Science” blog
(http://dcscience.net/), devoted to scientific fraud and medical quackery and
education policy. Many postings to Dr. Colquhoun’s blog address the lack of
scientific evidence for alternative medicine.

Name: Steven P. Novella, MD.

Contribution: Professor Novella coauthored the manuscript.

Attestation: Professor Novella approved the final manuscript.

Conflicts of Interest: Professor Novella has no financial conflicts of interest.
Professor Novella maintains the “Neurologica blog”, described as “your daily
fix of neuroscience, skepticism, and critical thinking.” The Neurologica blog
occasionally addresses the lack of scientific evidence for alternative medicine.

This manuscript was handled by: Steven L. Shafer, MD.

Footnotes

  1. Accepted for publication February 1, 2013.

  2. Funding: None.

  3. Conflict of Interest: See Disclosures at the end of the article.

  4. Reprints will not be available from the authors.

  1. Copyright © 2013 International Anesthesia Research Society

REFERENCES

1. Acupuncture Centre. . About Acupuncture. Available at:
http://www.acupuncturecentre.org/aboutacupuncture.html. Accessed March 30, 2013

2. Atwood K. “Acupuncture Anesthesia”: a Proclamation from Chairman Mao (Part
IV). Available at:
https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/acupuncture-anesthesia-a-proclamation
-from-chairman-mao-part-iv/. Accessed September 2, 2012

3. Li Z Private Life of Chairman Mao: The Memoirs of Mao’s Personal Physician.
1996 New York: Random House

4. Vickers A, Goyal N, Harland R, Rees R. Do certain countries produce only
positive results? A systematic review of controlled trials. Control Clin Trials.
1998;19:159–66 Available at: http://bit.ly/WqVGWN. Accessed September 2, 2012

5. Reston J. Now, About My Operation in Peking; Now, Let Me Tell You About My
Appendectomy in Peking … The New York Times. 1971 Available at:
http://select.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=FB0D11FA395C1A7493C4AB178CD85F45
8785F9. Accessed March 30, 2013

6. Atwood K. “Acupuncture anesthesia”: a proclamation from chairman Mao (part
I). Available at:
https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/acupuncture-anesthesia-a-proclamation
-of-chairman-mao-part-i/. Accessed September 2, 2012

7. Linde K, Streng A, Jürgens S, Hoppe A, Brinkhaus B, Witt C, Wagenpfeil S,
Pfaffenrath V, Hammes MG, Weidenhammer W, Willich SN, Melchart D. Acupuncture
for patients with migraine: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA.
2005;293:2118–25

8. Melchart D, Streng A, Hoppe A, Brinkhaus B, Witt C, Wagenpfeil S, Pfaffenrath
V, Hammes M, Hummelsberger J, Irnich D, Weidenhammer W, Willich SN, Linde K.
Acupuncture in patients with tension-type headache: randomised controlled trial.
BMJ. 2005;331:376–82

9. Haake M, Müller HH, Schade-Brittinger C, Basler HD, Schäfer H, Maier C,
Endres HG, Trampisch HJ, Molsberger A. German Acupuncture Trials (GERAC) for
chronic low back pain: randomized, multicenter, blinded, parallel-group trial
with 3 groups. Arch Intern Med. 2007;167:1892–8

10. Witt C, Brinkhaus B, Jena S, Linde K, Streng A, Wagenpfeil S, Hummelsberger 
J, Walther HU, Melchart D, Willich SN. Acupuncture in patients with
osteoarthritis of the knee: a randomised trial. Lancet. 2005;366:136–43

11. Cherkin DC, Sherman KJ, Avins AL, Erro JH, Ichikawa L, Barlow WE, Delaney K,
Hawkes R, Hamilton L, Pressman A, Khalsa PS, Deyo RA. A randomized trial
comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low
back pain. Arch Intern Med. 2009;169:858–66

12. Madsen MV, Gøtzsche PC, Hróbjartsson A. Acupuncture treatment for pain:
systematic review of randomised clinical trials with acupuncture, placebo
acupuncture, and no acupuncture groups. BMJ. 2009;338:a3115

13. Dworkin RH, Turk DC, McDermott MP, Peirce-Sandner S, Burke LB, Cowan P,
Farrar JT, Hertz S, Raja SN, Rappaport BA, Rauschkolb C, Sampaio C. Interpreting
the clinical importance of group differences in chronic pain clinical trials:
IMMPACT recommendations. Pain. 2009;146:238–44

14. Vickers AJ, Cronin AM, Maschino AC, Lewith G, MacPherson H, Foster NE,
Sherman KJ, Witt CM, Linde K. Acupuncture for chronic pain: individual patient
data meta-analysis. Arch Intern Med. 2012;172:1444–53

15. Paterson C, Taylor RS, Griffiths P, Britten N, Rugg S, Bridges J, McCallum
B, Kite G. Acupuncture for ‘frequent attenders’ with medically unexplained
symptoms: a randomised controlled trial (CACTUS study). Br J Gen Pract.
2011;61:e295–e305

16. . Letters in response to Acupuncture for ‘frequent attenders’ with medically
unexplained symptoms. Br J Gen Pract. 2011;61 Available at:
http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/rcgp/bjgp/2011/00000061/00000589. Accessed
March 30, 2013

17. Colquhoun D. Acupuncturists show that acupuncture doesn’t work, but conclude
the opposite: journal fails. 2011 Available at:
http://www.dcscience.net/?p=4439. Accessed September 2, 2012

18. Ernst E, Lee MS, Choi TY. Acupuncture: does it alleviate pain and are there 
serious risks? A review of reviews. Pain. 2011;152:755–64

19. Colquhoun D. NICE falls for Bait and Switch by acupuncturists and
chiropractors: it has let down the public and itself. 2009 Available at:
http://www.dcscience.net/?p=1516. Accessed September 2, 2012

20. Colquhoun D. The NICE fiasco, part 3. Too many vested interests, not enough 
honesty. 2009 Available at: http://www.dcscience.net/?p=1593. Accessed September
2, 2012

21. Bandolier. . Acupuncture for back pain—2009 update. Available at:
http://www.medicine.ox.ac.uk/bandolier/booth/painpag/Chronrev/Other/acuback.html
. Accessed March 30, 2013

22. Artus M, van der Windt DA, Jordan KP, Hay EM. Low back pain symptoms show a 
similar pattern of improvement following a wide range of primary care
treatments: a systematic review of randomized clinical trials. Rheumatology
(Oxford). 2010;49:2346–56

23. Wang S-M, Harris RE., Lin Y-C, Gan TJ. Acupuncture in 21st century
anesthesia: is there a needle in the haystack? Anesth Analg. 2013;116:1356–9

24. Lee A, Done ML. The use of nonpharmacologic techniques to prevent
postoperative nausea and vomiting: a meta-analysis. Anesth Analg. 1999;88:1362–9

25. Lee A, Done ML. Stimulation of the wrist acupuncture point P6 for preventing
postoperative nausea and vomiting. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2004:CD003281

26. Lee A, Fan LT. Stimulation of the wrist acupuncture point P6 for preventing 
postoperative nausea and vomiting. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009:CD003281

27. Carlisle JB. A meta-analysis of prevention of postoperative nausea and
vomiting: randomised controlled trials by Fujii etal. compared with other
authors. Anaesthesia. 2012;67:1076–90

28. Sumikawa K. The results of investigation into Dr.Yoshitaka Fujii’s papers.
Report of the Japanese Society of Anesthesiologists Special Investigation
Committee. http://www.anesth.or.jp/english/pdf/news20120629.pdf

29. Bandolier. . Metoclopramide is ineffective in preventing postoperative
nausea and vomiting. Available at:
http://www.medicine.ox.ac.uk/bandolier/band71/b71-8.html. Accessed March 30,
2013

30. Henzi I, Walder B, Tramèr MR. Metoclopramide in the prevention of
postoperative nausea and vomiting: a quantitative systematic review of
randomized, placebo-controlled studies. Br J Anaesth. 1999;83:761–71

31. Hall H. Acupuncture’s claims punctured: not proven effective for pain, not
harmless. Pain. 2011;152:711–2

32. Ioannidis JP. Why most published research findings are false. PLoS Med.
2005;2:e124

33. Simmons JP, Leif DN, Simonsohn U. False-positive psychology: undisclosed
flexibility in data collection and analysis allows presenting anything as
significant. Psychol Sci. 2011;22:1359–66

Acupuncture and Evidence Based Medicine

Steven Novella on July 31, 2024

Link



Over the last few decades there has been a steady infiltration of acupuncture
into Western mainstream medicine. It is not unreasonable to conclude that
acupuncture’s journey from an exotic Eastern practice to a fringe treatment to
mainstream acceptance has been complete. Knowledgeable proponents of science
based medicine (SBM) who remain skeptical of acupuncture now find themselves on 
the fringe. How did this happen?

Any complex cultural phenomenon is going to have multiple causes. Acupuncture is
basically the poster child for all the inadequacies in academia and medicine in
terms of how such issues are dealt with. Most medical professionals simply are 
uneducated about the details, they have out-sourced knowledge of acupuncture to 
the “experts” (proponents), there is a layer of reluctance to criticize born of 
cultural sensitivity, and there are still perverse incentives throughout both
scientific and medical institutions.

But I will argue that core to acupuncture’s success is the rise of
evidence-based medicine (EBM) starting in the late 1980s. Proponents of
acupuncture have expertly exploited all of the weaknesses and shortcomings of
EBM, which is why it is probably the best example of why we need SBM. As a
treatment acupuncture is also optimally positioned to exploit EBM.

What Is Acupuncture?

We have explored acupuncture at length on SBM, but for a quick overview,
acupuncture is the practice of sticking thin needles into specific points on the
body in order to influence the flow of chi (a life force) to treat symptoms and
diseases. Historically, acupuncture was more similar to blood letting than its 
fairly recent incarnation, and acupuncture points were essentially astrology.
The whole using very thin needles and chi thing is a modern retconning of
acupuncture created when various mutually incompatible traditions were united
into “Traditional Chinese Medicine” (TCM).

A post-modern, if you will, further retconning of acupuncture by some
contemporary proponents try to eliminate reference to chi or life force, and
instead invoke a poorly defined and understood mysterious physiological
mechanism from sticking needles into acupuncture points. But even in this
formulation – acupuncture, by definition, requires sticking needles into
acupuncture points.

EBM on Acupuncture

You can search for articles on SBM vs EBM here to get a detailed discussion of
what we consider to be all the salient differences, and proponent of EBM will
disagree on how best to implement EBM in practice (with some essentially
morphing it into SBM and even claiming that is what it was all along). But at
its core, EBM relies upon the highest quality clinical evidence to test the
safety and efficacy of specific health interventions. While this sounds great,
David Gorski has termed this “methodolatry” because it focusses too narrowly on 
this one method, while ignoring vast swathes of science.

A narrow focus on such clinical trials allows for a lot of abuses – including
p-hacking, publication bias, poorly defining terms, inadequate blinding, and
mixing variables. SBM takes a more thorough approach that tries more rigorously 
to control for all these things by looking at the overall patterns of evidence
in the literature. SBM also explicitly considers scientific plausibility and
prior probability, and prefers a more Bayesian approach to statistics.

In brief – acupuncture exploits all of these weakness of EBM. Acupuncture
studies mix in variables like “electroacupuncture”, allow study designers to
choose acupuncture points ad hoc without any internal consistency, rely heavily 
on poorly blinded or even unblinded comparisons, and claim that when “placebo”
or “sham” acupuncture work as well as “verum” or true acupuncture, that just
means that these other forms of acupuncture also work. P-hacking is rife within 
the acupuncture literature. Further, when looking at studies from China,
publication bias is literally 100%.

Acupuncture also is almost designed to maximize placebo effects. It is an
elaborate ritual, involves an invasive procedure, and involves a lot of hands-on
attention and positive encouragement from a practitioner.

But – using EBM you can generate some statistical outcomes that proponents can
point to in order to claim that acupuncture is “evidence-based”. This has become
a powerful tool for promoting acupuncture to mainstream professionals. There is
also just enough superficial plausibility, since something physical is actually
happening (unlike, say, in homeopathy). Acupuncture researchers have also
focused on the subjective symptoms that are most amenable to placebo effects to 
make their case.

The SBM Approach

When stepping back and taking a full SBM approach to acupuncture, a very
different picture emerges than the narrow EBM approach. The plausibility of
acupuncture is very low, because there is no known mechanism, and outside of
short term pain and nausea reduction, for any medical application of acupuncture
there is no plausible even theoretical mechanism.

Perhaps most devastating is that, even after extensive research, acupuncturists 
cannot demonstrate that acupuncture points exist. They cannot even agree on
where they are and what they do. In short – scientifically speaking, acupuncture
points don’t exist. If that’s the case, than acupuncture itself does not exist.
From a basic science perspective, acupuncture fails utterly.

From a clinical research perspective, it also fails. Systematic reviews have
failed to show a consistent replicable and specific effect from acupuncture.
This is true despite decades of research and thousands of studies. If there were
a real effect there, we should be clearly seeing it by now, but we are not.

What the clinical research does reflect is mostly small and poorly designed
studies, with the better studies tending to be negative. There is lots of
p-hacking and publication bias. There is also a great deal of heterogeneity –
different acupuncture points and different outcomes. In other words – the
acupuncture literature in total has all of the red flags and features of an
intervention that does not work. If you compare this with a dubious history and 
lack of plausibility, the only SBM conclusion is that acupuncture does not work.

And yet it is increasingly promoted as an evidence-based treatment. This,
however, reflects only the failure of EBM to properly address the question. 

Do Acupuncture Points Exist? Can Acupuncturists Find Them?

Acupuncturists do a systematic review and reveal they can’t reliably locate
acupoints. No wonder: they don’t exist.

Harriet Hall on August 27, 2019

Link



Even acupuncturists themselves are beginning to wonder. A critical systematic
review of accuracy and precision in acupuncture point location was recently
published in the Journal of Acupuncture and Meridian Studies. They point out
that “Accuracy of point location is essential for safe, efficacious and reliable
treatments and valid reproducible research outcomes.” Well, duh! Of course it
is! How long has acupuncture been practiced? Why are they only now beginning to 
wonder if they can actually get an acupuncture needle into the right spot?

The 14 studies they analyzed reported “considerable variation” in localization
of acupoints among qualified medical acupuncturists. The “directional method”
was found to be significantly inaccurate and imprecise in all studies that
evaluated that method. They wondered about the role of education, training, and 
experience and suggested those be evaluated in future studies.

According to acupuncture theory, acupuncture points (acupoints) are mostly
located on meridians, and stimulating these points by insertion of a needle
somehow influences the flow of qi, which somehow improves health outcomes (how
this all works is very fuzzy). Acupoints, meridians, and qi are not recognized
by anatomists or physiologists and can be presumed to represent pre-scientific
myths. There are many different systems of acupuncture each of which has a
different list of acupoints. In 1991 a World Health Organization Scientific
Group composed of acupuncture experts from around the world published a proposed
nomenclature listing 361 acupuncture points, 14 main meridians, 8 extra
meridians, 48 extra points, and scalp acupuncture lines. The diagrams of scalp
acupuncture points superimposed on functional zones of the brain (figures 6 and 
7) are intriguing. Are they proposing a new version of phrenology?

A “point” can’t very well be an anatomical structure. Points are
one-dimensional. The tip of an acupuncture needle is three-dimensional and could
conceivably encompass a point, but how likely is it that an acupuncturist could
reliably hit that point? What would determine the depth of needle insertion?
How would this relate to ear acupuncture and electro-acupuncture?

If acupoints and meridians were real, wouldn’t they vary in location just as
other anatomical structures do? During embryologic development, DNA provides a
general recipe but not precise instructions. Just look at the veins on the back 
of your hands: the location of the veins on your two hands is not identical, and
they certainly don’t match the location of veins in other individuals. There
are diagrams of dermatomes showing which areas of the skin are innervated by
which spinal nerve. There is considerable variation. An area of skin supplied by
T6 (the 6th thoracic spinal nerve) in one individual might be supplied by T5 or
T7 in another individual. There are 12 pairs of ribs, but about 1 in 200-500
people have an extra cervical rib. A few people have a bifurcated rib. Most of
us have 5 lumbar vertebrae, but some of us have 6. Some people are born with a
solitary kidney instead of the usual pair. I could go on…So why should we assume
acupoints are more predictable?

Even when you know where a blood vessel is, it can be tricky to get a needle
into the right place from which to draw blood. As a medical student I learned to
draw blood from the radial artery at the wrist for arterial blood gas testing. 
I would feel the pulsations with each of two fingers and try to direct the
needle between them where I knew the artery had to be, but sometimes I still
failed to get a blood sample. And every phlebotomist can tell you it’s not
always easy to get blood from a big, visible vein. So I find it hard to believe 
that acupuncturists could get their needles into exactly the right spot at the
right depth.

Acupoints are located by anatomical landmarks and by measurements from those
landmarks. Imagine a massively obese 600-pound person with a belly that hangs
down to the knees. Trying to locate an acupoint on that immense belly with
reference to anatomical landmarks seems like a lost cause.

This study represents Tooth Fairy Science at its most ridiculous. They tried to 
assess the reliability of locating points that have never been shown to exist.
An exercise in futility, if you ask me.

The WHO report admits:

   An authoritative list of what conditions can effectively be treated by
   acupuncture can only be drawn up after each claim of efficacy has been
   examined and either verified or rejected. There is, so far, no such agreed
   list.

That says a lot. After centuries of practice, acupuncturists still can’t even
agree on a single claim of efficacy. Acupuncture is a theatrical placebo.

Conclusion: acupoints don’t exist, and even if they did, acupuncturists couldn’t
find them.

                Revisiting Daniel Moerman and “placebo effects”

                                 David Gorski 

                                      Link

About three weeks ago, ironically enough, right around the time of TAM 9, the
New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) inadvertently provided us in the form of 
a new study on asthma and placebo effects not only material for our discussion
panel on placebo effects but material for multiple posts, including one by me,
one by Kimball Atwood, and one by Peter Lipson, the latter two of whom tried to 
point out that the sorts of uses of these results could result in patients
dying. Meanwhile, Mark Crislip, in his ever-inimitable fashion, discussed the
study as well, using it to liken complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) as
the “beer goggles of medicine,” a line I totally plan on stealing. The study
itself, we all agreed, was actually pretty well done. What it showed is that in 
asthma a patient’s subjective assessment of how well he’s doing is a poor guide 
to how well his lungs are actually doing from an objective, functional
standpoint. For the most part, the authors came to this conclusion as well,
although their hedging and hawing over their results made almost palpable their 
disappointment that their chosen placebos utterly failed to produce anything
resembling an objective response improving lung function as measured by changes 
(or lack thereof) in FEV1.

In actuality, where most of our criticism landed, and landed hard—deservedly, in
my opinion—was on the accompanying editorial, written by Dr. Daniel Moerman, an
emeritus professor of anthropology at the University of Michigan-Dearborn.
There was a time when I thought that anthropologists might have a lot to tell us
about how we practice medicine, and maybe they actually do. Unfortunately, my
opinion in this matter has been considerably soured by much of what I’ve read
when anthropologists try to dabble in medicine. Recently, I became aware that
Moerman appeared on the Clinical Conversations podcast around the time his
editorial was published, and, even though the podcast is less than 18 minutes
long, Moerman’s appearance in the podcast provides a rich vein of material to
mine regarding what, exactly, placebo effects are or are not, not to mention
evidence that Dr. Moerman appears to like to make like Humpty-Dumpty in this
passage:

   ‘When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, ‘it means
   just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.’

   ‘The question is,’ said Alice, ‘whether you can make words mean so many
   different things.’

   ‘The question is,’ said Humpty Dumpty, ‘which is to be master — that’s all.’

Let’s dig in, shall we?

The interviewer, Joe Elia, begins by framing the question of the significance of
the NEJM placebo/asthma study as asking what matters more, subjective responses
of patients or objective responses? Right off the bat, this is a problem for
several reasons, the most glaring of which is that it’s a false dichotomy. Both 
matter, but for different diseases and conditions one can matter more than the
other. For example, in the asthma study, as all the SBM bloggers who wrote about
it pointed out, objective measures matter a lot. If, for example, a patient
with asthma has a very low FEV1, he might still feel OK or have only mild
shortness of breath and yet still be just a tiny push away from total
respiratory collapse. Another example that comes to mind is diabetes,
particularly type I diabetes. Before we had an effective treatment in the form
of injected insulin to restore blood glucose levels to something resembling
normal, many diabetics, other than symptoms such as thirst and frequent
urination, felt more or less fine. Yet they could easily be just a piece a cake 
away from diabetic ketoacidosis. In such conditions, objective improvement
matters, and it matters a lot—far more than subjective symptoms. That doesn’t
mean that subjective symptoms aren’t important, but concentrating on the
subjective and dismissing the objective can be dangerous. Moerman, not being a
physician, seems not to recognize this and doesn’t even address the issue.
Indeed, he seems blithely unaware that relying on placebo responses in diseases 
that produce a real, life-threatening physiological derangement is the way to
kill at least a few patients. But they’ll feel great—until right before they
crump.

Elia asks Moerman right off the bat what he sees in medical studies such as the 
NEJM placebo study that’s common to other human situations. Moerman responds:

   …I see actors and responders. I see uniforms. I see symbols of power. I see
   authoritarian and all sorts of other kinds of interactions between people. I 
   see lots of interactions between people. I see lots and lots and lots of
   meaning.

And I see dead people. (Sorry, couldn’t resist.)

Time and time again, Moerman returns to this word, “meaning.” But what does
he—if you’ll excuse the awkward sentence construction—mean when he uses the word
“meaning”? Elia asks him just that question, pointing out that the word
featured prominently in the title of his book Medicine, Meaning and the “Placebo
Effect”. Moerman responds with a bit of a waffle dance before he tries to
actually answer the question:

   …given that we’re talking to a bunch of physicians, let me start by saying
   why it is I put “placebo effect” in quotation marks. What we mean ordinarily 
   by “placebo effect” is unproblematic. It’s an inert substance designed to
   mimic a medical procedure. The key thing is that it’s inert. If it’s inert,
   what that means is, it can’t do anything. That’s what “inert” means. But
   there simply can’t be such a thing as a placebo effect. It’s a contradiction 
   in terms, sort of like “king of America.” So, I think that “placebo effect”
   is like “king of America.” It doesn’t exist. Now, at the same time we all
   know that if you give people inert medications they often respond
   dramatically, and they get a lot better. So, the only thing that we know for 
   sure is that it’s not the placebo that did it. So what did do it? And what I 
   argue is that what did it is all of the other meaningful stuff that’s
   associated with medicine, starting with the behavior of the parking lot
   attendant, going through the receptionist, to what’s hanging on the walls to 
   the art in hospital. I said in the article, our hospital has two helipads.

   When you walk into a place like that you know you’re in a place of great
   overweaning power. It’s incredibly meaningful. And I would argue that that
   meaning, that and all sorts of other kinds of meaning—the stethoscope around 
   the neck, the uniforms, the funny white shoes, you know, on and on and on—all
   of that stuff goes together to create a generic system of meaning which is
   then sort of instantiated by the specific red or orange or blue pills that
   the doctor gives you and tells you when to take it this way and that way and 
   to drink lots of water, which is a healing substance all of its own. And the 
   meaning that’s attached to all of that stuff can be at least as powerful as
   whatever is in the pill, whether it’s inert or not.

Alright, I’ll give Moerman credit for a bit of a sense of humor. That line about
his hospital having two helipads wasn’t half-bad. Of course, back when I was
doing residency in Cleveland, our county hospital had three helipads. So there. 
(Actually, the reason it had three helipads is because it was the main base for 
Metro LifeFlight, where I actually moonlighted as a flight physician for nearly 
three years while I was in graduate school.) In any event, Moerman seems to miss
a huge point. He seems to be arguing that placebo effects come from the
atmosphere of medicine; i.e., the lab coats, the halls of “power,” the helipads,
the medical jargon, the mysterious language that only medical personnel (the
high priests or shamans of whom are, presumably, the doctors) can understand.
Here’s the problem. In the NEJM article, the patients in the no-treatment,
“watchful waiting” group in the asthma/placebo study experienced all of that
medical awesomeness, yet they didn’t feel better. They only felt better after
they got either active treatment or placebo treatment. In fact, all that medical
awesomeness didn’t affect them very much at all. True, even some of those who
received no treatment at all reported feeling better, but that’s not uncommon in
a clinical trial, and it was a far fewer number who spontaneously felt better
than those who were treated with an albuterol inhaler or placebo treatments. In 
this study at least, the aura of medicine didn’t do much compared to the actual 
placebo intervention. Moerman completely missed the point here.

He does a bit better, although not a lot, in one of his articles from 2002 to
which he refers in his interview entitled Deconstructing the Placebo Effect and 
Finding the Meaning Response. After listing studies in which, for example,
medical students reported feeling a stimulant response after taking a red
placebo and a sedative response after taking a blue placebo; people with
headache reported more pain relief after taking a branded aspirin as compared to
aspirin in a plain bottle and after placebo aspirin in the same branded bottle 
compared to placebo in a plain bottle; and it was found that people who were
told that exercise would improve their psychological—surprise!
surprise!—reported that exercise improved their psychological well-being. In the
article, he also tries to have it both ways. While arguing time and time again 
that placebos, because they are inert, can’t do anything, he takes pains to
point out that placebo responses leading to pain relief can be blocked by an
opiate antagonist, naloxone, concluding, rather disingenuously in my opinion,
“To say that a treatment such as acupuncture ‘isn’t better than placebo’ does
not mean that it does nothing.” This is, of course, a massive straw man. If, as 
Mark Crislip jokes, placebo effects due to CAM are the “beer goggles of
medicine,” altering perceived pain and symptoms without actually affecting the
underlying physiology, it is not surprising that the brain function might—oh,
you know—actually change in response to placebo.

In the podcast, Moerman chooses two more recent studies to try to make his
point—and misinterprets them both. First, he cites a famous article from 2009 in
which patients were randomized to individualized acupuncture, standardized
acupuncture, simulated acupuncture (twirling a toothpick against the skin), and 
usual care and makes exactly the same mistake interpreting it that CAM
practitioners made in trying to promote the study. In essence, he concluded that
because sham acupuncture (the toothpicks) did as well as “real acupuncture” and
that both did better than usual care that acupuncture “works.” Wrong, wrong,
wrong. Moerman then cites a famous German acupuncture study (the GERAC study,
published in 2007) as evidence that acupuncture “works” as a “meaningful”
intervention. Wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong as well. This latter study
preselected patients with a long history of back pain whose pain didn’t respond 
well to standard treatment but who were naive to acupuncture. In other words,
these studies do not show that “acupuncture works very well for low back pain,
much better than standard care” (Moerman’s exact words). In actuality, they
showed the exact opposite.

He then mentions a study on depression in which St. John’s wort, sertraline, and
placebo all had similar results in depression and asks:

   What do you conclude from that study? That nothing has any effect against
   depression because a placebo was involved. That doesn’t follow.

Actually, yes it does. It does indeed follow. Well, it doesn’t follow that
nothing has any effect against depression; rather, it follows that in this study
apparently neither sertraline nor St. John’s wort had any effect. This, by the 
way, appears to be the study to which Moerman referred. If this is the study,
then it’s not entirely true that sertraline had no effect different from
placebo; it only affected one of three measures of depression, but it
demonstrated “much improvement” in that measure. Disappointing, but not “no
effect,” and there were a number of potential explanations. The authors note
that “Failure of established antidepressants to show such superiority occurs in 
up to 35% of trials, which illustrates the difficulties plaguing randomized
placebo-controlled trials in this population.” They also noted that only 36% of 
the sertraline group had their dose maximized, pointing out that “if any
protocol bias existed at all, it would favor hypericum [St. John's wort], which 
could be dosed to the maximum of its permissible range, whereas the maximum
permitted dose of sertraline was only 50% of its highest recommended amount.”
So, in this study, it is reasonable to conclude that neither sertraline nor St. 
John’s wort “worked” in this population at this time at the doses used, but when
the totality of evidence and the shortcomings of this trial are taken into
account, sertraline does have an effect.

Another issue that Moerman completely ignores is that placebo responses might
very well also be largely influenced by artifacts inherent in the structure of
clinical trials. It’s not as though these issues haven’t been heavily studied,
including expectancy effects (people are suggestible), observer effects (people 
often report improvement just from the process of being observed, also known as 
the Hawthorne effect), observer bias, training effects from repeated testing,
and cheerleader effects from being encouraged. One wonders what Moerman would
say about recent research, including an (in)famous NEJM meta-analysis and a
recently updated Cochrane review, that suggest strongly that, when all these
nonspecific effects and experimental biases are controlled for adequately, the
placebo effect disappears. I think it’s worth quoting each briefly.

First, the NEJM:

   …we found little evidence that placebos in general have powerful clinical
   effects. Placebos had no significant pooled effect on subjective or objective
   binary or continuous objective outcomes. We found significant effects of
   placebo on continuous subjective outcomes and for the treatment of pain but
   also bias related to larger effects in small trials. The use of placebo
   outside the aegis of a controlled, properly designed clinical trial cannot be
   recommended.

Then the Cochrane review:

   We did not find that placebo interventions have important clinical effects in
   general. However, in certain settings placebo interventions can influence
   patient-reported outcomes, especially pain and nausea, though it is difficult
   to distinguish patient-reported effects of placebo from biased reporting.
   The effect on pain varied, even among trials with low risk of bias, from
   negligible to clinically important. Variations in the effect of placebo were 
   partly explained by variations in how trials were conducted and how patients 
   were informed.

Be that as it may, in a way Moerman (sort of) agrees with Crislip, just not in a
way that supports his argument that the “meaning” behind placebos is this
wonderful, powerful thing. Crislip makes a strong argument dismissing placebo
effects as a myth. Moerman is dismissing placebo effects in a different manner, 
but in a way infused with his background as an anthropologist. He’s denying
placebo effects by renaming them. In a way, they are (again, sort of) arguing
the same thing. Crislip argues that placebo effects are an example of mild
cognitive therapy in which the pain stays the same but it’s the perception of
pain that changes. Moerman argues something similar, ascribing changes in pain
perception to all trappings of “power” and interactions with health care
providers in medical settings and the “meaning” that patients find in them. None
of this is inconsistent with placebo responses being in actuality altered
perceptions of symptoms. It’s just that Moerman seems to think that the
“meaning” that alters these perceptions is far more powerful than it is.
Unfortunately, while Crislip is rooted in hard-nosed “materialistic” science,
Moerman seems more rooted in postmodern, relativistic thinking:

   Practitioners can benefit clinically by conceptualizing this issue in terms
   of the meaning response rather than the placebo effect. Placebos are inert.
   You can’t do anything about them. For human beings, meaning is everything
   that placebos are not, richly alive and powerful. However, we know little of 
   this power, although all clinicians have experienced it. One reason we are so
   ignorant is that, by focusing on placebos, we constantly have to address the
   moral and ethical issues of prescribing inert treatments (73, 74), of lying 
   (75), and the like. It seems possible to evade the entire issue by simply
   avoiding placebos. One cannot, however, avoid meaning while engaging human
   beings. Even the most distant objects—the planet Venus, the stars in the
   constellation Orion—are meaningful to us, as well as to others (76).

One notes that reference #76 is a book by Timothy P. McCleary entitled, The
Stars We Know: Crow Indian Astronomy and Lifeways. Perusing the information
about the book, I see that the author states very early on that the purpose of
his book was to “provide insight into a little known aspect of Crow culture—Crow
ethnoastronomy. Ethnoastronomy, a fairly recent development in human sciences, 
attempts to elicit how non-Western peoples’ perceptions of cosmic phenomena are 
utilized in structuring behaviors, values, and mores.” All of this might be
fascinating reading as far as learning about the history and culture of various 
peoples, but it would appear to stretch the bounds of what is a science and what
it has to do with medicine I’m having a hard time grasping. It must be that
reductionistic “Western” scientist in me. Is Moerman trying to say that because 
humans find “meaning” (whatever that means) in stars and constellations that
placebos work? How would understanding “meaning” improve medicine above and
beyond what we currently do to understand the effect of patient-provider
interactions on health care delivery. Moerman either can’t or doesn’t specify,
nor does he provide concrete examples of how his ideas would improve medicine.
Maybe he does so in his book, but given that his article to which he referred is
billed as the “abstract” or a “synopsis” of his book, somehow I doubt it.
Worse, Moerman adds nothing new to the conversation, nor does he provide any
testable hypotheses that would allow us to use his concept of “meaning” to
better medical care by maximizing nonspecific effects as we use effective
medicines.

The lack of specific examples aside, the problem remains for diseases for which 
there is a real derangement in physiology, such as asthma, diabetes, and the
like. If placebo responses make the patient perceive his symptoms as being less 
severe, that doesn’t help the underlying pathophysiology or work to prevent the 
very real, very dangerous complications that can result from that
pathophysiology. Again, nowhere in Moerman’s editorial or podcast do I see a
recognition of that. What I do see is Moerman trying to make like Humpty-Dumpty 
and make the word “meaning” mean just what he chooses it to mean—neither more
nor less, except that, now having read his NEJM editorial and his earlier paper 
and listened to his podcast interview, I’m still not sure he even knows what
it’s supposed to mean.

The bottom line is that we as physicians are indeed called upon to relieve
patients’ symptoms, but our obligation goes far beyond that. As physicians, we
understand the pathophysiology of disease; we know the consequences of leaving a
disease untreated. It is not enough for us to make the patient feel better. If 
that were the case, then there would be no reason not to give patients sedatives
or stimulants for almost everything. Those certainly “make patients feel
better”! But there are a lot of conditions where physiology trumps subjective
complaints, or at least threatens to. Asthma, the topic of the NEJM placebo
study from last month, is, of course, a classic example. A patient can be
feeling fine (or at least not too bad) but be perilously close to a respiratory 
arrest. The same is true of diabetes, where a more or less asymptomatic patient 
can be on the verge of diabetic ketoacidosis. In these cases, our obligation as 
physicians is not just to make the patient feel better, but to make the patient 
better.

                    Acupuncture – Disconnected from Reality

                                 Steven Novella

                                      Link

The primary goal of science-based medicine (SBM) is to connect the practice of
medicine to the best currently available science. This is similar to
evidence-based medicine (EBM), although we quibble about the relative roles of
evidence vs prior plausibility. In a recent survey 86% of Americans said they
thought that science education was “absolutely essential” or “very important” to
the healthcare system. So there seems to be general agreement that science is a
good way to determine which treatments are safe and work and which ones are not
safe or don’t work.

The need for SBM also stems from an understanding of human frailty – there are a
host of psychological effects and intellectual pitfalls that tend to lead us to
wrong conclusions.  Even the smartest and best-meaning among us can be lead
astray by the failure to recognize a subtle error in logic or perception. In
fact, coming to a reliable conclusion is hard work, and is always a work in
progress.

There are also huge pressures at work that value things other than just the most
effective healthcare. Industry, for example, is often motivated by profit.
Institutions and health care providers may be motivated by the desire for
prestige in addition to profits. Insurance companies are motivated by cost
savings. Everyone is motivated by a desire to have the best health possible – we
all want treatments that work safely, often more so than the desire to be
logical or consistent. And often personal or institutional ideology comes into
play – we want health care to validate our belief systems.

These conflicting motives create a disconnect in the minds and behaviors of many
people. They pay lip service to science-based medicine, but are good at making 
juicy rationalizations to justify what they want to be true rather than what the
science supports. We all do this to some degree – but, in my opinion,
complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) is a cultural institution that is
built upon these rationalizations.  It is formalized illogic and anti-science
conceals as science under a mountain of rationalizations.

Some recent news items and reports dealing with acupuncture demonstrate this
disconnect quite well.

The BMJ

The British Medical Journal (BMJ) recently published a review of acupuncture
studies in the treatment of chronic pain. Like most other reviews of acupuncture
studies, the authors were not impressed. They concluded:

   A small analgesic effect of acupuncture was found, which seems to lack
   clinical relevance and cannot be clearly distinguished from bias. Whether
   needling at acupuncture points, or at any site, reduces pain independently of
   the psychological impact of the treatment ritual is unclear.

After decades of study and hundred of clinical trials, this remains the state of
acupuncture research.  The best studies continue to show an unclear effect,
which cannot be separated from bias – which of course is the point of clinical
trials. In other words, the signal cannot be separated from the noise. The most 
parsimonious interpretation of this fact is that there is no significant signal 
– acupuncture does not work.

But supporters of acupuncture prefer to go through a litany of rationalizations 
rather than acknowledge that simple fact (more on this later).

It was also recently announced that the BMJ group will be adding a new journal: 
BMJ Acupuncture. That’s right, an entire journal dedicated to studying (read
“promoting”) acupuncture.  The press release notes:

   Acupuncture in Medicine is a quarterly title, which aims to build the
   evidence base for acupuncture.

I thought the purpose of research was to discover if a treatment works, not to
build a case for it.

BMJ is a strange journal – it is generally of high quality but seems to have a
blind spot for certain CAM modalities, like acupuncture. While it will publish
critical reviews, like the one above, it also has published some low quality
positive reviews – such as this one of acupuncture and IVF (in vitro
fertilization).  The review glosses over the disparity in study quality and
location. Other reviews published around the same time showed no effect from
acupuncture in IVF.

And the best individual studies to date show no effect. In fact, the most recent
study showed that the placebo acupuncture group had slightly higher pregnancy
rates by some measures than the acupuncture group (while other measures showed
no difference). Again – the most parsimonious interpretation of this study is
the null hypothesis – acupuncture does not work in IVF. But proponents twisted
themselves into logical pretzels and offered up the astounding rationalization
that placebo acupuncture must have some real effect.

To be clear, I am not against journals that specialize in one area, or
practitioners that specialize in one form of treatment. Specialization is
essential to deal with the modern complexity of medicine. However, we must
recognize the significant risk of specialization – and that is the fallacy that 
is often summarized as follows: if your only tool is a hammer then every problem
will look like a nail. It is unlikely that a journal or practitioner dedicated 
to acupuncture will ever reach the conclusion that acupuncture is a dead end and
science-based medicine should move on. As an extension of this, specialty
journals and specialist should follow well-established modalities. Forming a
specialty journal dedicated to an unproven and dubious modality is problematic, 
to say the least.

More Rationalizations

A recent Washington Post article observes in its headline: “Millions embrace
acupuncture, despite thin evidence.” It seems this reporter, Ellen Edwards, has 
grasped the essential disconnect, although she does not sufficiently explore an 
answer to the implied question – why? Why do so many accept acupuncture despite 
an enduring absence of scientific evidence? Ironically, the press has much to do
with it. They are often complicit in misrepresenting the facts, and abetting
the rationalizations that are necessary for those who should know better to
continue to promote acupuncture despite the lack of evidence.

Some professional organizations are also complicit. The article notes, for
example:

   The American Medical Association takes no position specifically on
   acupuncture; the AMA groups it with other alternative treatments, saying
   “there is little evidence to confirm the safety or efficacy of most
   alternative therapies.” It says “well-designed, stringently controlled
   research” is needed to evaluate its efficacy.

Now, the AMA is not the best place to go for position papers on specific
scientific questions in medicine. But if they are going to bother having any
position, it should be better informed. They say that research is needed, giving
the impression that there isn’t already a large body of research to inform out 
opinion about whether acupuncture works or not.

The notion that more research is needed is one of the most common
rationalizations. That allows someone to put off forever concluding that their
pet modality does not work – simply make the case for more research, which is
easy to make sound like it’s a good idea. And of course anyone against more
research must be closed-minded.  For example, the story relates (standard
disclaimer – I am aware that experts are often quoted out of context by
journalists, so keep that in mind, but for the purposes of this post I will take
the quotes at face value):

   In 2007, NCCAM spent about $9.1 million on acupuncture research. While more
   is planned, Brent Bauer, an internist at the Mayo Clinic and director of its 
   complementary and alternative medicine program, said the research is in its
   “toddlerhood.”

Nice touch – “toddlerhood.”  That’s just a cute way of saying that more research
is needed and you can comfortably ignore any current negative research. If the 
assessment were fair, then it could be justified. But we have already had
several fairly sophisticated placebo-acupuncture controlled trials. This
represents reasonably mature clinical research. I suspect

Bauer just does not like the fact that these best studies (like the IVF study
above) are generally negative. I wonder – if these studies were positive would
he still think they were imature and could be ignored?

Linda Lee, a gastroenterologist who is director of Johns Hopkins’s new
Integrative Medicine and Digestive Center, is quoted as saying:

   “We have this double standard. We are completely comfortable using
   pharmacological therapies that have not been subjected to clinical trials for
   the purposes we use them, but we are super suspicious of alternative
   therapies that haven’t been tested with randomized placebo trials. From a
   research point of view, I understand the criticism. But we physicians are in 
   the healing business, and we have to go beyond the pharmacological solutions 
   to understand the whole person,” she said. “Acupuncturists start with the
   whole person.”

Ah – the “holistic” gambit.  This is just another rationalization to distract
people from the uncomfortable fact, that she acknowledged. From a “research
point of view” means “I understand that the best quality scientific evidence is 
negative.” And “we..are in the healing business” means “but I want to believe in
this anyway.”

The double standard is also an incredible claim, because the opposite is true.
SBM advocates want a single standard. What Dr. Lee is actually referring to is
prior plausibility – scientific practitioners are more accepting of treatments
that are biologically plausible, and are appropriately skeptical of treatments
that are extremely implausible.  It is also a tu quoque fallacy – we advocate
high standards of science for all treatments, even plausible ones. If some
doctors uses drugs unscientifically, that does not justify chucking science
whenever it conflicts with our beliefs and desires.

It is, in fact, the CAM proponents who want a double standard. Imagine if after 
hundreds of studies the best a drug could do for any indication is a weak effect
that is likely just placebo – the signal cannot be separated from the noise.
Imagine  a pharmaceutical company making the exact same rationalizations to put 
its failed drug on the market anyway that acupuncture proponents make for
acupuncture.

The article concludes, as most do, with a positive anecdote from a believer –
Elise Feingold:

“I decided to leave my science brain aside,” she said. “I felt it had helped
other people, and it might help me. I don’t know how it works, but it’s got
4,000 years of Chinese medicine behind it.”

She begins with what amounts to saying that anecdotal evidence is more
compelling that rigorous science. This, of course, makes no sense. The whole
point of scientific rigor is for evidence to be more objective and reliable – to
control for any many variables as possible. Anecdotes are unreliable because
they do not control for any variables. Proponents of acupuncture are happy to
cite scientific evidence when they think it supports their beliefs, but then
will chuck science in favor of low quality anecdotes as needed.

Feingold finishes with the commonplace appeal to antiquity.  The premise of this
argument is that a treatment that has no real effect could not survive for
thousands of years. History proves that this premise is false (see blood
letting), and it also profoundly underestimates the human capacity for
self-deception and therefore the need for scientific controls.

Conclusion

There is still no compelling evidence that there is any real effect to
acupuncture.  It didn’t have to turn out that way, but that is the way the
scientific chips fell. The treatment also lacks plausibility (although I usually
point out that something is happening, unlike homeopathy, and so there is the
physical possibility of an effect), and in medicine you only get two strikes. No
evidence and no plausibility means that you’re out.

But the disconnect continues. Proponents keep pretending that there is
compelling evidence, or it has not been properly studied yet, or it does not
have to be studied because historical anecdotes are enough – whichever argument 
suits the moment. Meanwhile the media keep breathlessly telling us that
acupuncture is gaining ground, while the evidence is standing still.

The premise of SBM is that support and resources should follow scientific
support. In the world of CAM, however, support follows belief, and the science
seems to be an afterthought or, worse, an obstacle.

Acupuncture Paradox?

Let’s see. Let’s put the chaise longues facing the ice berg. The blue and white 
of the ice are a nice focal point. We can alternate the chaise longue with
Adirondacks for those that don’t want to put up their feet. We should also have 
a few ottomans as well. Looks good. The band sounds nice; I always did like
Autumn Dream.

Mark Crislip on April 15, 2025

Link

I always thought it must be difficult to be a SCAM provider, like a
chiropractor, naturopath or acupuncturist. Having your whole job based on a
fiction must nag at least some of them. I suppose it must be a little like
clergy who don’t believe in God. So many people define themselves by their
occupation and the realization nagging that their occupation is bogus must grate
on some. I always followed the spirit of Bill Russell, who said, when asked if 
was a basketball player, would say

“No. That’s what I do, that’s not what I am. I’m not a basketball player. I am a
man who plays basketball.”

Such an attitude did make the transition to retirement a piece of cake. Although
saying, “I’m not a chiropractor, I’m a man who pretends to be a doctor”
probably would be a tough sell

But what do you do when reality and the medical literature points to your whole 
raison de etre as divorced from reality, no better than placebo and does little 
to nothing for the patient? I mean, besides mass firings? Contortions that rival
Cirque du Soleil performers.

Gorski and Mercola walk together into a pub but the bartender could not deal
with the paradox.

Paradoxes in Acupuncture Research: Strategies for Moving Forward showed up in my
feeds. The article is 15 years old, but interesting none the less for what it
reveals about how people can react when faced with information that strikes at
their core beliefs.

Did you know that acupuncture research has resulted in a pair of paradoxes? They
aren’t at the level of the black hole information paradox, mind you. More of
the Alanis Morissette’s ‘Ironic’ Isn’t Ironic. sort. You know, where you exhibit
a lack of understanding of what constitutes a paradox.

But what, you ask, are

The emergent potential paradoxes?

(1) A large number of well-designed clinical trials have reported that true
acupuncture is superior to usual care, but does not significantly outperform
sham acupuncture, findings apparently at odds with traditional theories
regarding acupuncture point specificity and needling technique.

(2) While many studies in animal and human experimental models have reported
physiological e\ufb00ects that vary as a function of needling parameters
(e.g.,needle insertion depth, mode of stimulation), the extent to which these
parameters influence therapeutic outcomes in clinical trials is unclear

Regular readers of this blog know the answer. No spoilers until the end. But let
us see how they deal with the irony, er, I mean, paradox.

Response to the first paradox?

The simplest explanation for Paradox 1 is that, when no differences are found
between verum and sham acupuncture treatments, the effects of both are due to
nonspecific factors (e.g., expectancy, contact time, device-related ritual)
rather than needling or other components specific to acupuncture. If this is the
case, the implication would be that the mechanisms underlying the therapeutic
effects of acupuncture are essentially placebo-related.

Wait. What? By George, I think they’ve got it. Being an Occam kind of a guy and 
having read way too many acupuncture clinical studies, I think they can stop
there. Acupuncture is a placebo.

But to admit that renders the practice of acupuncture a fraud. Can’t have that. 
How are the bills to be paid? No,

A central thrust of this White Paper is that there are other explanations that
are just as plausible.

Well, not. Let’s see what those other explanations might be. To start

  1. both verum and sham needling may have therapeutic effects,

This gets to my contention that there is no such thing as acupuncture. It is
acupunctures, plural, and there are as many forms as there are practitioners and
as many styles as there are cultures that use it. They point this out as

A major factor potentially underlying Paradox 1 is the lack of consensus on
which component(s) of acupuncture needling are therapeutically important. There 
has been little systematic investigation regarding the importance of needle
placement and depth, type and intensity of stimulation, needle number, and so
forth

They recognize that acupuncturists don’t really know what they are doing, as

Moreover, studies attempting to develop valid protocols based on consensus of
multiple acupuncturists have revealed significant pluralism regarding what
constitutes appropriate treatment.

Significant pluralism. I am glad I was not drinking milk when I read that. Now
is not the time to be buying a new laptop due to unexpected dairy induced
keyboard dysfunction.

There has been little systematic investigation regarding the importance of
needle placement and depth, type and intensity of stimulation, needle number,
and so forth [5], as well as the mechanisms by which these parameters influence 
immediate and longer-term physiological responses.

That is because there is no monolithic acupuncture that can be systematically
evaluated. Acupuncture is a 1000 points of nonsense.

It is not that verum and sham have therapeutic effects. They do. It is called
the placebo effect.

They note

The challenge in designing appropriate sham acupuncture is that ignorance of
acupuncture mechanism prevents us from knowing what to avoid when inserting a
sham acupuncture needle

That will be difficult when the whole basis of acupuncture is a fiction. Their
next rationalization

acupuncture-specific nonneedle and/or needle components may be retained in sham 
treatments,

What they are saying, but seem not to recognize it, is that placebo has the same
effect as acupuncture. These people need to run for office. And finally.

  1. the therapeutic effects of the provision of verum acupuncture treatments in
    the context of clinical trials may be suboptimal.

What they are saying is that, in the context of a clinical trial, they are
applying suboptimal treatment? Yep.

verum acupuncture treatments are less than optimal.

It is quite the excuse for why your intervention is no better than placebo: we
don’t know what we are doing and besides we are doing a lousy job of it.

It is just so hard for them to accept. Acupuncture is a fancy-schancy placebo.
And your whole career is nonsense.

What about the second paradox?

Another possible explanation is that at least some of the physiological effects 
of needling are therapeutic, but these effects are difficult to demonstrate in
the context of a clinical trial.

Acupuncturists are sticking needles in people and animals. That can be stressful
and painful. That will cause a physiologic effect. I would expect physiologic
consequences from acupuncture. Just not effects what treats any disease.

It is evident that much remains to be learned about which physiological effects 
of acupuncture needling are clinically relevant.

I can help them with that. None. It is a nonstandard treatment based on fiction.
Ain’t gonna do nothin’.

They summarize as follows

In summary, possible explanations for why specific effects of needling are
clearly demonstrable in basic science studies, but not as evident in
sham-controlled clinical trials are as follows:

(i) Some or all of the needle-related physiological effects observed in basic
science experiments are unrelated to therapeutic effects

(ii) Acupuncture needling does have therapeutic effects, but these effects are
proportionately small compared with nonneedle and nonspeciffic effects in
clinical trials.

(iii) Sham-controlled clinical trials are compromised methodologically because
(a) the influence of needling parameters for verum and sham needling are poorly 
understood, and (b) objective biomarkers relevant to the commonly treated
clinical conditions are lacking.

Boy, that’s a lot of excuses and obfuscations to avoid the realization that
acupuncture is placebo.

So what do they want to do to make acupuncture great again because of

a growing sense of puzzlement in the acupuncture research community regarding
the apparent disparities between the results of basic science and
sham-controlled trials on the one hand and the clinical practice of acupuncture 
on the other.

Besides recognizing acupuncture is a placebo? I guess finding a reality-based
job isn’t on the to-do list.

A number of interrelated challenges must be met to resolve the paradoxes
identified in this paper.

The biggest challenge appears to be the ability to recognize the significance of
a placebo-controlled trial. But then, no SCAM ever changes, or is abandoned, in
the face of evidence.

The best way is to give up on placebo trials, as they don’t provide the
justification for continued acupuncture. Go with the lessor trials, such as

“whole systems research,” pragmatic trials and surveys of real-world clinical
practice can help to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the multiple 
components that potentially underlie the therapeutic effects of acupuncture
treatment.

They want to consider the whole song and dance:

In seeking to evaluate how the parameters of acupuncture needling contribute to 
acupuncture treatment, it is also of major interest to learn what is most
important to practitioners and patients among the multiple components of
acupuncture beyond simply needling.

In other words, they recognize that acupuncture is theater. As noted by others, 
more than theater, Acupuncture Is Theatrical Placebo. They are certainly
desperate to avoid that conclusion.

And the whole issue that acupuncture is based on the fantasy that is traditional
Chinese pseudo-medicine (TCPM). They suggest finding biomarkers that correlate 
with TCPM diagnoses based on tongue and pulse diagnosis. Mapping reality onto
fiction? This is like applying horse physiology to the care and feeding of
skeletal Pegasus.

They conclude

It is conceivable, as stated above, that the therapeutic effects of acupuncture 
treatments are all or largely based on nonspecific, placebo-related responses.
If this is true, the implications for the investigation and practice of
acupuncture are profound as this would certainly raise interesting questions as 
to the value of specific acupuncture point location and needling techniques.

Lol. It has been conceived, but his paper is from an intellectual red state and 
acupuncture cannot be terminated, even if it it is not compatible with survival 
outside the acupuncture uterus.

An opinion commonly voiced in the acupuncture community is that acupuncture
cannot be studied using randomized controlled trial. We strongly disagree.

It can be, and has been, studied. The result is that acupuncture is placebo and 
its use is no longer justified. But study acupuncture in a way that obfuscates
the basic reality that acupuncture is a placebo based on fiction.

As has been shown in the field of ecology, complex phenomena are best tackled
using a pluralistic strategy including both a top-down approaches that evaluate 
the behavior of a whole intact system, as well as bottom-up approaches that
evaluate smaller-scale cause-and-effect links. Acupuncture treatments thus
should be studied both from the top down as multicomponent whole-system
interventions employing a pragmatic systems perspective, as well from the bottom
up as mechanistic studies that focus on understanding individual treatment
components and how the effects of these components interact and translate into
clinical outcomes.

So much sound and fury, signifying nothing. I remain amazed at the mental
contortions and denial humans can manifest. More depressed today than amazed.

In the end the paper is the Invisible Boy argument for studying acupuncture.
Ever see the movie Mystery Men? Been years, but I remember it as very funny. One
of the characters was Invisible Boy, who can become invisible only when nobody 
is looking at him. Similarly, acupuncture only works when no one is
investigating it. Good luck otherwise.

And this white paper? The results of Spleen.


There’s an app for that ?!?

Mark Crislip on June 1, 2012

Link

There is no shortage of technology in my household: computers, smart phones and 
tablets of one kind or another. The nice thing about being a blogger and an app 
developer is I can justify it all. Well, mostly. The “It’s probably tax
deductible” gambit can only be used so many times. It is remarkable how much of 
my life is filtered through the digital lens. I think if google glasses ever
become a reality, my kids and I will be the first up to be permanently wired
into the world. To my way of thinking, the Daemon haunted world looks like hog
heaven.

There is an app for just about anything, many of which feed into my OCD. I keep 
track of my daily walk and I have walked over 1500 miles since July 1, 2011.
When I developed my middle aged bloat I had the option of medications to control
the metabolic results or lose some damn weight. Losing weight is simple in
concept, hard in execution. Take in fewer calories than you expend and the
weight will slowly, ever so maple bar free slowly, come off. It took 9 months to
drop the 45 pounds needed, and I must say I feel just as old and creaky as I
did before, but my labs are better. The opposite of the placebo effect: I am
subjectively the same but am objectively better. I’ll take it.  One of the cool 
features of the app I used, and still use, for calorie management is that it
will take a picture of the bar code of food and give you the nutritional
information for entry in the program. Amazing.

A fellow bugdoc sent me a link to story about Chinese Tongue diagnosis. The
journal article has been accepted for publication as Automated Tongue Feature
Extraction for ZHENG Classification in Traditional Chinese Medicine 

It is as fine a piece of tooth fairy science and tooth fairy engineering as I
have ever encountered.

What is ZHENG? The paper starts with the usual blather: ancient, blah blah,
holistic blah blah enhances body resistance yada yada. The standard logical
fallacy filled introduction to justify the study nonsense. Been there, done
that. Is ZHENG based on any known anatomy, physiology, biochemistry or validated
in prior well done clinical trials. Of course not. At least no that I can find 
on the Pubmeds or the Interwebs.

They proceed with

   For thousands of years, Chinese medical practitioners have diagnosed the
   health status of a patients’ internal organs by inspecting the tongue,
   especially the patterns on the tongue’s surface. The tongue mirrors the
   viscera. The changes of tongue can objectively manifest the states of a
   disease, which can help differentiate syndromes, establish treatment methods,
   prescribe herbs and determine prognosis of disease.

Nope. Wrong. Another nonsensical mapping system. While a few diseases can
manifest on the tongue (my personal favorite being disseminated histoplasmosis) 
the tongue does not mirror the viscera any more that the ear, the head, the
hand, the foot or the iris. As I have mentioned before, damn is the body crowded
when all these mapping systems are applied to one person. They then describe
ZHENG:

   It is a characteristic profile of all clinical manifestations that can be
   identified by a TCM practitioner. ZHENG is an outcome after analyzing all
   symptoms and signs (tongue appearance and pulse feeling included). All
   diagnostic and therapeutic methods in TCM are based on the differentiation of
   ZHENG, and this concept is as ancient as TCM in China ZHENG is not simply an
   assemblage of disease symptoms but rather can be viewed as the TCM
   theoretical abstraction of the symptom profiles of individual patients. As
   noted in the abstract, ZHENG is also used as a guideline in TCM disease
   classification. For example, patients suffering from the same disease may be 
   grouped into different ZHENGs, whereas different diseases may be grouped as
   the same ZHENG. The Cold ZHENG (Cold syndrome) and the Hot ZHENG (Cot
   syndrome)are the two key statuses of ZHENG[3]. Other ZHENGs include
   Shen-Yang-Xu ZHENG (Kidney-Yang deficiency syndrome), Shen-Xu ZHENG (Kidney
   deficiency syndrome), and Xue-Yu ZHENG (Blood Stasis syndrome).

I have read and re-read the paragraph and searched the web and the Pubmeds to
better understand the concept of “patients suffering from the same disease may
be grouped into different ZHENGs, whereas different diseases may be grouped as
the same ZHENG.” Reminds be of trying to understand the classification of
Streptococci, only less helpful. ZHENG seems to lack the useful clinical ability
to classify and discriminate, but I am not certain. My summary of ZHENG: it is 
anything they want it to be.

   ‘When I use ZHENG,’ Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, ‘it means 
   just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.’‘The question is,’
   said Alice, ‘whether you can make ZHENG mean so many different things.’‘The
   question is,’ said Humpty Dumpty, ‘which is to be master — that’s all.’

As T. Jefferson noted in a different context,

   Ridicule is the only weapon which can be used against unintelligible
   propositions. Ideas must be distinct before reason can act upon them…

I am not so sanguine that reason can act upon ZHENG.

Still, they came up with a way to use computerized pattern recognition and
applied it to the tongue to identify the ZHENG state, and then compared it to
patients with ‘known’ Hot ZHENG, Cold ZHENG, Gastris and H. pylori in the mother
of all multiple comparisons and came up with…. well, I really don’t know.
Nothing really. If you judge from Why Most Published Research Findings Are
False, the authors hit 5 of 6 reasons why any positive result is probably bunk.

Mostly they concluded that, after what looks to be a huge amount of coding and
clinical effort, they have a computer program that can analyze a part of a
tongue and it somewhat correlates with the patients ZHENG status.  The effort
was more to calibrate the system than to validate it as a diagnostic tool, but
still generating useless results none the less. All sound and fury, signifying
nothing. It saddens me that so much time, effort and money was expended on
nothing of value. It is like getting a degree in homeopathy or naturopathy.

If you  think if we have problems with the money spent by NCCAM, this study was 
funded in part by The National Science Foundation of China, who has a subsection
for Chinese medicine. Can you imagine the politics and cultural background of
funding in China for their traditional forms of SCAM?  We have it so easy.

The depressing aspect of the paper is the authors intention to continue to apply
what appears to be sophisticated and complex computer programming to fiction,
and then bring out a smart phone app. Take a picture of your tongue, it will let
you know if your ZHENG is hot or cold, and then you can seek appropriate care.

   “As we continue to work on the software we hope to improve its ability.
   Eventually everyone will be able to use this tool at home using webcams or
   smartphone applications. That will allow them to monitor their zheng and get 
   an early warning about possible ailments,” Duan said.

This will not be the only app available covering some form of SCAM. Looking at
the iTunes store and the Android store all the standard SCAMs are well
represented with multiple apps, fewer in the iTunes store than the Android
marketplace. There are few apps on Blackberry and Windows phone, but then
virtually no ones uses Windows phones. You can diagnose and treat yourself (of
course they all have the appropriate disclaimer) and others with apps that
assist in homeopathy, naturopathy, chiropractic and herbology.

The Android marketplace has a lot more ‘fun’ apps, probably as it is easier to
develop and deploy on the Android app store.

The Pocket Naturopath, only a dollar, will help save you money:

   No more paying huge sums of money and waiting in line to speak to a
   Naturopath or Holistic healer.

Why do I think the app is saving people from an alternative  Lucy?  Only
charging more than a nickle. From my perspective, a dollar is a huge sum for
naturopathic advice. Or, courtesy of the Healing Frequency 528htz app:

   DNA Repairing perfect 528hz tones, in long pulses. Heal yourself with the
   scientifically proven frequency that repairs cells and is said to be the tone
   of Unconditional Love.”

or

iResist which

   accesses vast levels of knowledge along with tools that pierce the veil. The 
   iResist Hyper Portal Application keeps you “In the Know” with the most
   expansive knowledge and tools related to ascension and spiritual enhancement 
   sourced from The Resistance Community.

Few SCAMs are not represented by at least one app; applied kinesiology and
craniosacral therapy the main exceptions I could find, although they were found 
as subset of chiropractic apps. Entering “the amazing meeting” into iTunes did
lead to Bible apps. LOL.

There is a smart phone app for almost anything.  Skeptic related apps are in
very short supply. There are Logical Fallacy apps, but they only pop if you
search especially for them and evidently not used by ZHENG researchers.  
Except, it seems, Science Based Medicine. There is no shortage of medical woo
and nonsense in the app stores, but little in the way of medical science and
skepticism. For SBM, there is no app for that.

A TCM Challenge

Steven Novella on October 22, 2014

Link



In the tradition of James Randi, a Chinese doctor who is an outspoken critic of 
Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) has issued a challenge to its proponents. He 
has put up 50,000 yuan (about $8,000), which has been matched by donors for a
total of over 100,000 yuan, to any TCM practitioner who can use pulse diagnosis 
to determine with accuracy whether females subjects are pregnant.

Ah Bao is the blogging pseudonym of a burn-care doctor at Beijing Jishuitan
hospital. He is trained in scientific medicine and has criticized his country
for clinging to pre-scientific philosophy-based health care. He calls TCM “fake 
science” and now wants to demonstrate that the claims of TCM practitioners are
without factual basis.

His challenge is a good one because it focuses on a clear criterion. Subjects
will either be pregnant or not pregnant, and the TCM practitioner, using only
pulse analysis and blinded to the patient themselves, must determine with an 80%
accuracy which subjects are pregnant. A TCM practitioner, Zhen Yang, has taken 
him up on the challenge and they are now working out the details.

Pulse analysis

Scientifically-trained doctors do palpate peripheral pulses as part of the
medical exam. We look for the strength, rhythm, and rate of the pulse, compare
right-left symmetry and look for the presence of specific pulses. The purpose of
examining the pulse is to help evaluate the cardiovascular system. An
irregularly irregular pulse would indicate atrial fibrillation. A weak pulse
could indicate dehydration, heart failure, or hemorrhage (essentially low blood 
pressure).

TCM pulse analysis, however, is different. It’s possible that some of the basic 
physiological phenomena above were recognized even by pre-scientific
practitioners. It’s not a stretch to realize that a weak pulse indicates the
patient is not healthy. But they had no real understanding of cardiovascular
physiology, autonomic function, or cardiac electrical activity. Instead they
developed an elaborate scheme relating various properties of the pulse to
concepts within TCM.

Here is a description of the 29 pulses of TCM, with a notation about their cause
and in places relating to a biological etiology. For example a “hesitant” pulse
indicates, “Blood and essence failing to nourish the meridians. Blood is not
flowing smoothly.” Whereas a “wiry” pulse indicates: “Tense vascular Qi due to
the liver not gently performing its function, can also be due to the retention
of a pathogen in the liver. If wiry, Thready [sic] and forceful-like feeling the
edge of a knife is indicative of Stomach Qi exhaustion.” Most of the
descriptions relate to the Yin and Yang of Chi.

None of this has any basis in our modern understanding of biology or medicine.
It is clearly the attempt of a pre-scientific culture to impose an elaborate
system onto a complex and mysterious phenomenon.

Disconnected from reality

Pulse diagnosis and other similar aspects of TCM are, in my opinion, an
excellent example of what happens when “knowledge” is disconnected from reality.
The scientific method is primarily about creating a feedback loop in which our 
ideas are tested in some objective and systematic way against reality. Without
this feedback loop, our ideas are free to drift into any direction. Historically
the lack of scientific testing has resulted in elaborate and fanciful systems
of pretend knowledge. Humans are creative and inventive, and so we have no
difficulty imagining and embellishing such systems. Confirmation bias then
convinces us that our systems are real.

There are countless examples of this phenomenon. The many forms of astrology,
for example, represent pretend knowledge. Galenic medicine, based on the notion 
of the four humors, was the Western version of fake medical knowledge. In fact, 
bloodletting and the balance of the humors in the West was culturally connected 
to acupuncture and cupping (which actually were forms of bloodletting) and the
balance of Chi in the East. These were actually different versions of the same
basic ideas.

Another elaborate diagnostic system disconnected from reality was diagnosis by
urine color. Medieval doctors would carefully examine their patient’s urine for 
color, odor, and even taste and had a complex system of diagnosis. As with pulse
diagnosis, there are legitimate clues to health that can be gleaned from the
urine, but only in specific situations.

Medieval doctors, however, without the knowledge or technology to truly
understand what was going on with their patients, grasped onto whatever was
available. They developed elaborate charts, like the one here, relating the
subtle variations in urine color to specific (but also largely fictitious)
conditions. This is a perfect analogy to pulse diagnosis.

Pretend knowledge is very dangerous because it can create the powerful illusion 
of genuine knowledge. Confirmation bias is a persistent and subtle bias in the
way we perceive, filter, and evaluate information that systematically supports
what we already believe or wish to be true. It largely occurs without our
conscious awareness. We also tend to be unaware of the vast amounts of data we
are sifting, and so when we find bits of data that seem to support our beliefs
we find it unlikely that there is an alternate explanation.

In medicine there are other factors that also conspire to create the powerful
illusion that even entirely fake beliefs are legitimate. Chief among these
factors are placebo effects – effects that make it seem as if a treatment is
having a benefit even when it is doing nothing. Placebo effects are largely
illusory, such as regression to the mean (symptoms getting better as a matter of
course).

There are other factors as well, such as the tendency to only test our own
hypothesis rather than competing hypotheses. This is often referred to as the
toupee fallacy. It is easy to have the illusion that you always recognize when
someone has a toupee, because you don’t test the hypothesis when you don’t
recognize a toupee. Likewise, when taking a medical history you might
preferentially ask the patient questions which are designed to confirm your
diagnosis, rather than questions that will challenge the diagnosis.

For example, if you think that a “soggy” pulse is associated with breathing
problems, and you feel as if you detect a soggy pulse, you might ask the patient
about breathing problems and will take the fact that many patients respond
positively as confirming the reality of the “soggy” pulse and its association
with breathing problems. But what if you asked all your patients if they had
breathing problem, regardless of their pulse? Would the percentage who answers
in the positive be any different? That is the difference between science and
confirmation bias.

Unsurprisingly, the reality of pulse diagnosis has not been established by
scientific evidence, any more than medieval urine analysis or the four humors.
There are a few studies looking at pulse diagnosis but they amount to what
Harriet cleverly termed “tooth fairy science.” They study aspects of pulse
diagnosis without ever doing the kind of test that would establish whether or
not it is valid. For example, there is a study attempting to standardize the
position of the fingers when sensing the pulse.

Another study correlated how TCM practitioners describe the pulse to the
presence or absence of hypertension. This study is problematic in a number of
ways. First, hypertension might actually affect the pulse and therefore its
description, and so is a problematic model for TCM pulse diagnosis in general.
Further, it committed, essentially, the toupee fallacy of only testing the
desired hypothesis but not testing this against controls that could disprove the
hypothesis.

“Tooth fairy science” takes a fake belief system and transforms it into a
pseudoscience by going through the motions of scientific analysis, but only as a
more elaborate form of confirmation bias. This makes the fake belief system
more dangerous because it gives it the patina of science and therefore false
respect and legitimacy.

Conclusion

I agree with Ah Bao that there is no scientific legitimacy to TCM generally and 
pulse diagnosis specifically. It is, as he says, “fake science.” It is just one 
more example of what happens when beliefs are disconnected from reality –
elaborate and detailed, but entirely fictitious, belief systems emerge.

I look forward to following the development of the pulse diagnosis challenge.
Hopefully Ah Bao is experienced enough to design and execute a study that
precludes any form of “cheating” or inadvertent information leakage.

It’s not physiologically impossible that the radial pulse is systematically
different in pregnant vs non-pregnant women. The pulse, as I mentioned above, is
a real physiological phenomenon. I doubt, though, that any such signal will be 
consistently detected among the noise of all the other factors that affect
pulse. I would expect, therefore, that the test, if properly controlled and
sufficiently powered, would be negative. Either way the results will be
interesting.

Usually more interesting than the outcome of such challenges are the responses
of believers to the outcome.

Tongue

TCPM Tongue diagnosis. Garbage in, garbage out.

Mark Crislip on April 16, 2024

Link



I was thumbing through my wife’s Real Simple while I ate lunch. I don’t need the
beauty tips, since I already look marvelous, but I am always on the lookout for
new recipes. I saw the headline Watch Your Tongue. The opening paragraph notes

“The tongue can be a key diagnostic tool.”

Which is sort of true. A diagnostic tool? Yep. Key? No way.

At the end of my long and storied career, I fancied myself a diagnostician. Any 
primate can look up how to treat an infection. Many primates do not bother, part
of why I had a practice. But you need a proper diagnosis before you can look
up, much less start the correct treatment, of a disease. Since infections can
involve any organ and since infections can mimic non-infectious diseases and
vice versa, I always had to keep an eye out for alternative reasons for the
patients problems. The diagnosis might be something boring i.e. not an
infectious disease.

Diagnosis is usually made from the history and labs. The patient has their story
— and it is a story, an often unfocused, rambling, filled with pointless
digressions and leaving out important information story — from which you glean
the pattern of their illness. It always pissed me off when a patient would tell 
me to read their chart rather than listen to their history. For one thing, I
never trusted what others put in the chart if it concerned my consultation. I
always assumed everyone else on the case had no idea what was really going on.
They almost always did know what was going on, I worked with a bunch of great
HCWs, but it is an approach that will occasionally saved me from mistakes. As
the Russian proverb noted, Don’t trust. Verify. But more importantly, it is the 
pattern of the illness, obtained from the history, is what is likely to give the
needed information to make the right diagnosis.

Then, you confirm that diagnosis with diagnostics such as blood work, biopsies, 
and x-rays.



So how helpful is the exam? It can be fun to find disease manifestations, but is
rarely diagnostic. My pulmonary attending as a resident, said, only
quasi-humorously, the lung exam is what you did while you were waiting for the
CXR to develop. Physical findings are more of a hint or a confirmation of what
diseases the history suggests, moving them up and down the differential
diagnosis, doctor speak for the list of possible diseases for a given
presentation. As an example, if there is no heart murmur, a valve infection is
less likely. Unless it is on the pulmonic valve, which you are unlikely to hear.
Or the disease is so early that a murmur hasn’t developed. Or the valve has
been completely destroyed so no soil in which to grow a murmur. My father, a
cardiologist, was hard of hearing towards the end of his career. I asked him how
he heard subtle murmurs. He said, “What?” I repeated the question louder and he
replied, “That is why we have echocardiograms.”

That is the problem with the physical exam. Each organ has a finite number of
potential manifestations, if any, for a disease process, and is unreliable. More
often than not, the exam doesn’t help one way of the other in deciding what the
diagnosis is. Almost every finding on exam has several possible causes and the 
history is what guides you to interpreting the physical findings.Like the
tongue. There are a smattering of diseases that can manifest in the tongue. As
an infectious disease doctor, there were the manifestations of AIDS, the rare
tongue ulcer, an occasional manifestation of disseminated histoplasmosis, and my
favorite, the strawberry tongue of toxic shock diseases. It really does look,
but not taste, exactly like a strawberry. Oddly, no one has ever figured out why
the toxin results in a tongue that looks like a strawberry.

I always found the skin and eyes to be better organs to examine for hints of the
underlying diagnosis, but in the vast majority of patients, the eyes, skin, and
tongue were, as we said, WNL. Within Normal Limits, not We Never Looked. Old
joke.

So why the tongue to

infer a lot about a patient by examining their tongue- hydration level, coffee
or tobacco use, immune health and vitamin deficiencies.

All reasonable inferences from the tongue. But not really all the helpful and
not all the much information gained. A dry mouth might mean a lack of water, but
could be a sign of scleroderma. You can ask about coffee and tobacco consumptio
for a more accurate idea of use, B6 annd B12 deficiencies will have tongue
findings, but they are not specific. A bit of thrush might suggest AIDS, but
there is a broader differential diagnosis for fungal tongue involvement. Again, 
the history and the labs will be more useful in determining what the cause of a 
given tongue finding will represent.

Unless. Is there more to the story as to the vital nature of the tongue beyond
taste and rudeness? Except in Mongolia?

Oh, yes. Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine (TCPM). They quoted Dr. Michelle
Loy, an acupuncturist and specialist in Integrative Medicine at Weil Cornell
Medicine in New York, who offers many a SCAM (Supplements, Complementary and
Alternative Medicine). In TCPM

the tongue is considered the gateway to our bodies.

Not.

So I thought this would be a good opportunity to review one of the foundational 
fictions upon which TCPM is based and the ‘diagnoses’ that it renders. TCPM is
based upon a huge number of medical fictions, reflecting the size and antiquity 
of Chinese society. So I will only discuss a small sliver of this vast system,
the tongue.

One of the important diagnostic procedures in TCPM is an examination of the
tongue. All the organs map to and manifest on the tongue. As does the feet, the 
hands, the ears, the top of the head and the entire body. Although no mapping to
the buttocks. Yet. I can’t see where the body has room for all these different 
connections; perhaps it is the real cause of obesity.

And to make it confusing, there are two forms of tongue mapping. The triple
burner where the tongue is divided into thirds

The tip of the tongue corresponds to the Upper Burner (Heart, Lungs); the middle
corresponds to the Middle Burner (Stomach, Spleen), and the base of the tongue 
corresponds to the Lower Burner (Kidneys, Bladder, Intestines.

and there is the Zang fu method

The tip of the tongue corresponds with the Heart, the region at the front of the
tongue between the tip and the center corresponds to the Lung, the center
corresponds with Stomach and Spleen, the right side corresponds to the
Gallbladder, the left side corresponds to the Liver, and the base of the tongue 
corresponds to Kidney, Bladder, Large Intestine, and Small Intestine

Whose tongue mapping reigns supreme? No one cares; its like trying to decide
which of the innumerable styles of acupunctures are the right one. All of them. 
Of none. Take your pick. At least TCPM is consistent. Just as there are no
acupoints or meridians on the genitals, I cannot find where the genitals map to 
the tongue. No, I am not going to for the obvious rude commentary. You people.
Grow up.

So TCPM practitioners look at the tongue for

tongue color, tongue quality, tongue fissure, tongue fur, red dot, ecchymosis,
tooth mark, saliva, and tongue shape are identified for each tongue

and, depending on the constellation of above, make a diagnosis. Mind you, it is 
a TCPM diagnosis, not a diagnosis as understood by anatomy and physiology of
reality-based disease. A fictional understanding of disease can only lead to a
fictional diagnosis.

All the above tongue findings can also be a manifestation of a real systemic
disease, except for teeth marks. I can’t see how tongue teeth marks could be a
manifestation of a real disease. Seizure disorder maybe. TCPM practitioners are 
not looking of a real diagnosis.

It is important to remember that the TCPM diagnoses made has nothing to do with 
understanding modern anatomy, physiology or disease. These changes are
manifestations of the fictional diagnoses of TCPM. These changes in the tongue
diagnose qi stagnation or damp retention or a variety of other nonsensical
diagnoses unhinged from reality.

So one of the many modalities of TCPM is to examine the tongue based on a
fictional understanding of disease to come to a fictional diagnosis. Then they
apply a fictional therapy, like cupping or acupuncture.

Not surprisingly when the SCAM is not based on reality, the diagnostic modality 
is not reproducible:

TCM tongue inspection for specific characteristics examined was not a reliable
diagnostic method, at least for the group of TCM practitioners involved in this 
study.

And there are several other studies that show TCPM practioners can’t agree on a 
TCPM diagnosis, such as Damp Heat Retention, after tongue examination.

and

The average agreement of the diagnoses provided by 3 TCM practitioners was at
the same low level as previously reported. No association was found between the 
diagnostic methods used and the consistency of diagnosis

But that is what happens when you are essentially making up stuff as you go
along

Here is the weird thing, to my understanding, about TCPM, is they keep trying to
apply these traditional fictions of diagnosis and treatment to modern
understanding of anatomy, physiology and disease. If they can’t agree on a TCPM 
diagnosis, you want to turn them loose on diabetics?

It is a curious literature.

For example, they tried to see what TCPM would add to the diagnosis of coronary 
artery disease.

Qi deficiency was the most popular syndrome in patients with CHD (87.1%), blood 
stasis syndrome and phlegm retention syndrome took the second place, accounting 
for 79.9% and 78.7% respectively. No significant difference was shown in
comparison of tongue and pulse figures with the affected branches of coronary
artery, the dark-pale tongue with white greasy fur and taut-slippery pulse being
the dominance in patients. The blood-lipid levels in patients with various TCM 
syndrome types were similar, showing insignificant difference.

Conclusion: The TCM pathogenesis of CHD takes qi deficiency as the core, blood
stasis and phlegm retention as the important pathologic products.

One author notes

However, due to its qualitative, subjective and experience-based nature,
traditional tongue diagnosis has a very limited-application in clinical
medicine. Moreover, traditional tongue diagnosis is always concerned with the
identification of syndromes rather than with the connection between tongue
abnormal appearances and diseases. This is not well understood in Western
medicine, thus greatly obstruct its wider use in the world.

Maybe its lack of wider use is due to the fact that TCPM diagnostics and
diagnoses are useless.

But since TCPM practitioners don’t know a burro from a burrow, let a computer do
it. There are several studies where they used photos of tongues and have a
computer examine them to diagnose, say, breast cancer or gastric cancer or
diabetes.

I do not know what to make of these studies. A one level, that of TCPM, they are
a waste of time. But, AI and computer learning applied to the tongue, or some
other organ, could very well yield diagnostic hints of diseases independent of
its underlying TCPM approach. The computer can sometimes see patterns humans
can’t. They could be inadvertently be on to something. Blind pigs and acorns and
all that.

If computer analysis of tongues is successful, I am sure that TCPM will see it
as a justification of their fictional medical system. Nope. Just got lucky.

At some point I likely discuss pulse diagnosis, while you are waiting check out 
Harriet Halls piece from 2017.

Addendum

The picture is our English bulldog, Pugsly. He is a rescue, someones COVID pet, 
and when we got him around age 2 (the dog, not me) he had been ill-used, we
think mostly ignored. His qi was badly blocked at several points and he had an
excess of heat and stagnation. As you can tell from his tongue, all that has
been resolved and he is a happy, drooling, flatulent, and quite delightful, dog.
Even if I agree he is an

abomination of nature cursed with high rates of miserable health problems.

Not unlike TCPM.

Pulse Diagnostics

Perhaps the EKG of my bulldog. TCPM wouldn’t have a clue what was going on.

Mark Crislip on July 16, 2024

Link



The essence of the traditional Chinese medicine has always been the most
advanced and experienced therapeutic approach in the world.

Jingcheng Dong

For the post on tongue diagnosis, I used a picture of our bulldog, Pugsley, and 
his tongue. He also has a regularly irregular heart beat, but we have never
bothered with an EKG. His pulse skips every third beat. I imagine his EKG would 
look somewhat like the one featured above.

So does my dog have Dai Mai (Regularly Intermittent) pulse? It is not
intermittent, but would mean a

Decline of Zang Fu (organ) Qi, Wind Syndromes, Pain, Terror, Fear, Trauma.

His wind, when broken, can inspire terror and fear. I do not think that is what 
is meant. But,

Flaws: “Patients with this pulse have advanced heart disease according to
western medicine and should be immediately referred to a western doctor” AKA
someone who actually understands cardiology.

or is it Cu Mai (Rapid-Irregular, Skipping, Abrupt) pulse, due to

Excess Heat, Domination of Yang, Qi, Blood, Phlegm and Food Stagnation. This can
be from an Atrial Fibrillation.

and

This is clinically very severe, Yin and Yang are not in communication.

I wonder, does cardioversion bring Yin and Yang back into communication? Is food
stagnation an indication for Eliquis? Can you do TCPM pulse diagnosis on dogs?

Perhaps I should dig deeper into that most advanced and experienced therapeutic 
approach in the world.

I have always had a watch with a second hand, which, it occurs to me, is the
third hand. The minute hand is the second hand, with the hour hand being the
first. English. What are you going to do? Anyway, I always wanted to be able to 
count a patient’s pulse or respiration myself.

Not that the pulse was all that important in most patients. Lack of pulse? That 
can be a big deal, especially combined with lack of respiration. As an
infectious disease doctor, the only fun manifestation of measuring a pulse was
Faget’s sign, pulse temperature disassociation. For every degree the body
temperature goes up, pulse should go up about 10 beats. At least for those not
onbeta blockers. There are a half-dozen infections where the pulse does not go
up with the fever, first recognized by Dr. Faget while studying Yellow Fever. I 
have found it a useful hint as to the eitiology of some infections.

Taking the pulse, while interesting, is not that important in making a diagnosis
in modern medicine. Fast, slow, irregular, are all features that could warrant 
further evaluation as to the reason for those abnormalities. With, say, an EKG. 
And modern diagnostics have resulted in some physical findings being more
entertaining than helpful, as physical findings often lack sensitivity and
specificity. I don’t think I would recognize a water hammer pulse despite seeing
no end of aortic insufficiency in my career. I relied on the ECHO to know what 
was actually going on with the aortic valve.

In Tradition Chinese Pseudo-Medicine (TCPM), it is different. When combined with
tongue evaluation, the examination of the pulse is a critical part of making a 
diagnosis. Well, making a TCPM diagnosis. So not that impressive, as using
fiction based diagnostics to diagnose fictional problems is less than
remarkable.

TCPM is not the only pseudo-medicine that uses the pulse for diagnosis, as, in a
different forms, pulse is used in Ayurveda, Korean, and other medical
traditions. And, of course, each style does not agree in the particulars.

TCPM has two different characteristics for pulse diagnosis. One form is based on
the quality of the pulses, the other on mapping organs to the area of the
pulse. Of course. There is always multiple way to skin a cat sith.

A problem in discussing TCPM pulse diagnosis, like all pseudo-medical practice, 
is since they are not based on reality, there is no real standard to determine
sensitvity or specificty of the diagnosis. There are likely as many forms of
acupuncture as there are acupuncturists since there is no objective basis for
the practice. The same is true to TCPM pulse diagnosis. There are likely as many
forms as there are practitioners and there is very little agreement between
practitioners.

One description of the manuever is as good as any:

A TCM doctor palpates six locations, three on each wrist, with the three points 
called “cun”, “guan”, and “chi”, and describes pulses in terms of various
characteristics. By comparing the pulses at left and right cun, guan, and chi,
the health status of individual organs and of the whole body can be determined. 
As specified in the ancient texts, the Nan Jing and Mai Jing, the heart, liver, 
and kidneys lungs, spleen, and kidneys are assessed at the right cun, guan, and 
chi, respectively.

As in the above example, the spleen in mapped to the middle pulse of the right
hand. It is also mapped to the foot, the ear, the hand, and the body in various 
forms of acupuncture. The spleen sure gets around. why is the spleen on the
right and not the left? I wonder if that is reversed in situs inversus. As best 
I can determine, no TCPM practitioner has evaluated the idea.

Maya pulse diagnostics, while done differently by its last practitioner, Don
Elijio also has 28 different pulses as well (an observer tried to overlay TCPM
on to Don Elijio’s system, with variable success), but he could diagnose 42
conditions including spirit possession and witchcraft, as well as a variety of
wind conditions.

Don Elijio also would use his thumb at times to palpate the pulse, which is a
no-no in medicine as you run the risk of feeling your own pulse and the thumb is
not as sensitive.

Why the wrist? Why not one of the many parts of the body where the pulse can be 
felt? In ancient times other pulses were palpated, but these have faded in usage
over time. Why? And why do I continue to try and apply reason, logic, and
reality to a complicated work of fiction?

It is the nature of the pulse that is important in the diagnosis:

The most common 28 TCM pulse qualities were used in clinical practice come from 
the references Bin Hu Mai Xue and Zhen Jia Zheng Yan. These qualities are
floating, sunken, slow, rapid, surging, fine, vacuous, replete, long, short,
slippery, rough, string-like, tight, soggy, moderate, faint, weak, dissipated,
hollow, drum skin, firm, hidden, stirred, intermittent, bound, skipping, and
racing.

Some sources say there are 29 pulses. No pulse would be the 29th?

Like much of TCPM, how pulse diagnosis was done back in the day was different
than currently practiced:

Present-day finger placement on the radial artery for pulse diagnosis to
determine the relationship between organs and general condition vary according
to widely used Chinese or Tibetan method. Variations exist between different
historical Chinese periods on finger organ representation points and vary to
minimum extent among Tibetan historical and current writers. Present-day finger 
placement on the radial artery for pulse diagnosis to determine the relationship
between organs and general condition vary according to widely used Chinese or
Tibetan method. Variations exist between different historical Chinese periods on
finger organ representation points and vary to minimum extent among Tibetan
historical and current writers.

Modern TCPM practitioners do recognize they do not really understand what they
are doing:

These pulse qualities are largely described qualitatively and are not clearly
defined. For instance, the slippery is compared to “beads rolling” and the
string-like is like pressing the string of a musical instrument. The magnitude
of a pulse quality is, similarly, not precisely defined. The difference between 
a fine pulse and a faint pulse is that the former is a “little bit stronger”
than the latter. “A little” does not precisely determine what differentiates
fine from faint. Thus, descriptions of pulse are subject to the interpretation
of individual doctors, and this lack of quantitative standardization undoubtedly
contributes to the low inter- and intra reliability among TCM doctors.

And, as one video has it, how to take a pulse is a matter of style. Of course it
is. Can’t have a standard when each practitioner makes it up as they go along. 
But at least a given practitioner often makes it up the same way each time:

Testers tended to agree with themselves more often than they did with others
when rating the same patient’s pulses.

Different types of pulse have different meanings. For example, a hollow pulse?

It means that there is still some flow of qi at the vessel surface, but not much
blood.

A hurried pulse?

On the one hand, this can represent contraction of the qi, as in liver qi
stagnation, or it can represent deficiency of the qi.

A floating pulse?

The circulation of qi and blood is focused in the body’s surface to deal with an
external pathogenic agent. The internal circulation is temporarily sacrificed
to assure that the pathogen is eliminated before it can enter more deeply and
cause serious problems at the visceral level. Debilitated patients may show a
floating pulse that is feeble, indicating the inability to retain the qi and
yang in the interior due to the deficiency of the vital organs.

This is, well, gibberish. And if you look around the interwebs and the pubmeds
you can find many similar examples.

That is TCPM in a nutshell. An ancient, complicated, inconsistently practiced
and worthless fiction divorced from known anatomy and physiology.

So whatcha gonna do?

Not much. As best I can tell, there are few studies trying to validate TCPM
pulse diagnosis by itself for real diseases, which is a good thing.

Some researchers realize that

The results of pulse diagnosis rely heavily on the practitioner’s subjective
analysis, which means that the results from different physicians may be
inconsistent.

And, as is so frequent for fiction based medicines, trying to apply modern
technology in an attempt to standardize that unstandardizable. Hey. New word.
But that just results in lots of tooth fairy research trying, and failing, to
bring to pulse diagnosis the rigor and reproducibility of an EKG.

Using cell phones, bionic pulse diagnosis equipment (I wonder what sound that
machine makes) orcomputers and AI to analyze the unanalyzable (that’s new word
number two) is just silly. Can’t make a silk purse out of a sow’s ear.

Proponents of TCPM like to note the practice is 3000 years old. Hm. When was the
last time you wanted something from 3000, 300 or even 30 years ago? Well, from 
50 years ago, music and a classic Mustang convertible. That’s it. But I would
not want the food, the engineering, the science, the transportation, the
political system or the social hierarchies from 3000 years ago. The medical
practice? I’ll pass.

But despite its antiquity, as of 2013, they were still trying to standardize
pulse taking. In 3000 years they have not even figured out the basics:

Information on anatomy of the Cun position at wrist is lacking; whether the
blood vessel taking pulse in Cun is the radial artery or the superficial palmar 
branch is also clinically controversial.

So they investigated. In 2019, mind you. Better late than never, right?

The objective was to investigate the boundaries and contents, and the vascular
distribution and their pulse points in Cun. Thirty-two upper extremities of 16
human cadavers were investigated for dissection and observation. The boundaries,
contents, and blood vessel distribution in Cun were observed; the location of
pulse points in Cun was identified; the length of the superficial palmar branch 
in wrist pulse (L1), the pulp width of the index finger (L2), and the angle
between the radial artery and the superficial palmar branch were measured.

The results?

… suggested that it could not be generalized that the blood vessel taking pulse 
in Cun was the radial artery or the superficial palmar branch; it might depend
on the vascular distribution in Cun, the region of finger positioning, and the
patient’s pulse condition.

In normal speak, make it up as you go along.

There have been a few attempts to integrate TCPM diagnosis with reality-based
medicine, despite

However, the study of TCM still encounters serious challenges due to the almost 
irreconcilable differences from the conventional orthodox medicine (OM). There
are at least two major differences between TCM and OM: patient classification
and intervention methodology.

You mean diagnosis and treatment? Yep TCPM offers neither. OM does. It is why
TCPM is useless.

But I can’t find any studies that are not filled with incomprehensible
gibberish. As when TCPM tries to describe, say, COVID 45:

COVID-19 is located in the lung, where evil Qi first invades the body from the
mouth and nose, repressing the lung Qi. In turn, the lung fails to disperse and 
descend, with symptoms of dry cough. The “damp evil” is heavy and viscous,
blocking the Qi mechanism and causing chest tightness, body heat, and muscle
soreness. “Damp evil” traps the spleen, easily injuring Yang Qi. The spleen
dominates and transports water and food through the body. When the Qi fails to
rise, the spleen cannot be nourished, and symptoms begin to appear, including
fatigue, gastric congestion and loose stool. The spleen and stomach act as the
exterior and interior of each other; hence, the spleen’s dysfunction affects the
stomach’s absorption. The dampness accompanying the epidemic toxin into heat is
manifested as high fever, occasional yellow phlegm, obvious asthma due to the
dampness toxin, and sticky stool due to the stagnation of dampness.

One study tried to diagnose essential hypertension with pulse diagnosis and
compared their accuracy to, well, a blood pressure cuff. It was inferior, no
surprise, but why bother? Just use the BP cuff.

I just do not think that TCPM and reality-based medicine will ever find an area 
of diagnostic or therapeutic agreement.

But there is good news! Yes! Perhaps less of this gibberish is being taught.

The Oregon College of Oriental Medicine in Portland is closing. One of many.

Looks like they priced themselves out of business.

Earning a master’s degree in acupuncture at the school was expected to cost
nearly $74,000 this year. Completing a graduate program in traditional Chinese
medicine could cost students up to $120,000. Tuition, which ranged from $26,000 
to $30,000 this year,

Creative writing degrees are considerably less and have the same foundations. At
least for fantasy writers.

And yes, to answer a question at the top of the post, you can do pulse diagnosis
on animals

The pulse is assessed in various locations, depending on species. Cats, dogs,
goats, and sheep have their femoral pulses checked. Equine pulses are palpated
using the common carotid at the base of the neck or external maxillary artery,
while the ventral tail (median caudal artery) is assessed in the bovine.

In fact, the whole gamut of TCPM is inflicted on animals.

I cannot find the origin of these recommendations; I think, like most of TCPM,
it is made up as they go along, mostly for convenience of palpation.

In the meantime, I will let Pugsley be.

Note.

Science magazine reccomended 10 history of science books, one of which was The
Expressiveness of the Body and the Divergence of Greek and Chinese Medicine. It 
compares and contrasts ancient Greek and Chinese medicine with a focus on the
pulse. Meh. The history is interesting, but the author seems way to gullible
about the utility and legitamacy of TCPM diagnosis and treatment.

Neither the ancient Greeks nor the past and present practitioners of TCPM had
any real clue about the diagnosis and treatment disease. I would not intrust my 
health and well being to either. I long had an interest in the pulse. For
virtually all my life I would suddenly have a burst of fast, faint pulse that
would last a few minutes followed by the need to pee. Something was causing the 
release of atrial naturetic factor. My mom used to push on my eyes to slow the
pulse. Yep. That was a thing. Even though my dad was a cardiologist, it was rare
and brief enough it was never caught.

Until 20 years ago or so when it hit on rounds when I was on the cardiology
unit. Rapid, faint pulse. I had them put on some EKG leads and as I was standing
there looking at the monitor, a cardiologist said, “You are going to the ER.”
where they gave me a dose of adenosine to get me back on into normal sinus
rhythm. I still remember taching along then flat line of the montor. 1,2,3,…am I
dead?… sinus. Whew.

I had an aberrant cardiac conduction pathway with a supraventricular
tachycardia. They ablated the pathway and my pulse has been fine since. Neither 
the ancient Greeks nor the current practioners of TCPM would have any clue what 
was wrong with me nor how to fix it by feeling my pulse.

That is one of four diseases that could have killed me but for science based
medicine. To paraphrase

The essence of Science-Based medicine has always been the most advanced and
experienced therapeutic approach in the world.

A Misguided Study to Test the Reliability of Traditional Chinese Medicine Pulse 
Diagnosis

Pulse diagnosis and tongue diagnosis are widely used in traditional Chinese
medicine. They are based on imagination, not on anatomical and physiologic
reality.

Harriet Hall on December 26, 2017

Link



In traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), palpation of the pulse at the wrist and
inspection of the tongue are used to evaluate the patient’s state of health and 
make diagnoses. Are these actually useful diagnostic procedures?

Pulse diagnosis

History of pulse diagnosis

Pulse diagnosis was an important part of ancient medicine in Egypt, Greece,
India, Tibet, and elsewhere. The specific methods used were ambiguous and varied
widely from place to place, making them extremely difficult to test.

Ancient physicians didn’t have EKGs or even a stethoscope. The pulse was one of 
the only diagnostic tools available to them. They tried to use the pulse to
diagnose heart, liver, renal, and gastrointestinal problems, with varying
degrees of success. The pulse can indeed offer clues, but today we have much
more effective ways of reaching a diagnosis.

Reality-based pulse diagnosis

In mainstream medicine, a complete physical exam has always included palpation
of arterial pulses, observing the intensity, rate, rhythm, and whether any blood
vessel tenderness, tortuosity, or nodularity exists. Two qualities are
objective and can be confirmed by EKG: the rate and the rhythm. Arrhythmias like
paroxysmal tachycardia, premature ventricular contractions (PVCs), and atrial
fibrillation can be detected. In pulsus paradoxus, the rate slows with
inspiration; it is found in several conditions such as pericardial effusion,
pneumothorax, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).

The other qualities are more subjective, but can be confirmed more objectively
by pulse wave analysis with instruments. A weak pulse is an indication of
impaired blood flow; a thready, rapid pulse is present in shock; a “water
hammer” collapsing pulse suggests aortic insufficiency; a rapid, snapping pulse 
suggests thyrotoxicosis; a rock-hard artery reveals calcified atherosclerosis;
pulsus alternans (alternating strong and weak beats) indicates left ventricular 
dysfunction. The radial artery pulse at the wrist is most commonly used, and is 
adequate for assessing rate and rhythm; but it is not the best artery to
indicate pulse character. Comparison of pulses in various locations can help
diagnose several conditions where there is anatomical obstruction to flow.

Chinese pulse diagnosis is not reality-based

Chinese pulse diagnosis is something else entirely. Dr. Hammer, founder of the
Shen-Hammer system aka Contemporary Chinese Pulse Diagnosis (CCPD) explains
(emphasis added):

   Of all diagnostic modalities, the pulse can give us the most precise picture 
   of even the most subtle and complex deviation from this standard of health.
   The pulse record is an instant picture of the current status of a person’s
   voyage from birth to death. Clinically, it preserves us from the distraction 
   and fruitless pursuit of symptoms, and keeps us focused on the reality of the
   individual’s condition and being.

   In addition, the pulse gives information about the events in a person’s life 
   that create this deviation from the Normal, allowing our patient the
   opportunity to change his life and habits, or adapt to constitutional
   deficits in the direction of health. The precision of the diagnosis permits a
   rational therapeutic regime for the patient and is a tool for
   prognostication and prevention.

   When practiced with dedication, quiet patience and consistency, becoming
   attuned to pulse qualities is an ongoing meditation, a training ground for
   awakening and awareness into total focus and concentration. As such, pulse
   diagnosis is an opportunity for practitioners to obtain the ultimate
   satisfaction of being one with their patients, one with themselves, one with 
   the diagnostic process, and perhaps one with the universal forces that are
   expressed through the pulse.

   In the late 1950s, the Chinese government set up an experiment in which many 
   well known masters of Chinese pulse diagnosis were asked to examine a
   patient. Their findings varied widely, and as a result pulse diagnosis was
   judged to be an unreliable scientific diagnostic tool. Others have questioned
   its reliability because of the wide variety of pulse methods within the
   Chinese tradition, and especially between the Chinese and other pulse systems
   used by other cultures, such as the Tibetan and Ayurvedic systems, in which 
   the positions are in great variance from the Chinese. What is difficult to
   contemplate and absorb is that each of the Chinese masters who failed the
   government test as well as each different pulse system is correct, providing 
   not contradictory information, but different information.

In other words, everything about Chinese pulse diagnosis is considered to be
correct, and there would be no way to prove anything wrong. This makes it
unfalsifiable, and puts it outside the scientific paradigm.

Another explanation

One of Hammer’s disciples says:

   What I am most impressed with and most try to emulate is Dr. Hammer’s ability
   to understand his patient’s suffering and perception of his/her illness, his
   ability to make contact with patients and enter into a sacred therapeutic
   relationship. The pulse is a tool for this process and informs the diagnoses,
   and acts as a catalyst or jump start in the formation of this healing
   relationship.

He is talking about bedside manner and the nonspecific therapeutic effect of the
doctor/patient relationship. Contextual effects and suggestion are a big part
of what has been called the placebo effect. Of course a patient will feel better
after he has had so much attention lavished on him, along with an explanation
by a charismatic “expert.” And the long observation time gives the doctor a
chance to observe lots of other things about the patient and perhaps even to do 
some cold reading.

The apparent success of pulse diagnosis can be attributed to factors that have
nothing to do with whether the diagnosis is correct by any objective standard,
or whether clinical outcomes are improved more than could be achieved by a
theatrical placebo.

Contemporary Oriental Medicine

Contemporary Oriental Medicine (COM):

   includes over 100 unique concepts not included in TCM. Concepts that reflect 
   the realities of Chinese medicine as an evolving medicine relevant to the
   present day and age. Such concepts include: birth traumas and Heart shock,
   toxicity, Liver qi and yang deficiency, the separation of yin and yang as
   precursors to significant and debilitating illnesses, etc.

COM is a creation of Dr. Hammer. The COM Foundation website says, “At first
glance, it may appear to be a singular, personal perspective…” Yes, and after
careful consideration it still appears to be one man’s idiosyncratic creation.
He says it is “the true embodiment of tradition, seamlessly blended with modern 
insight and wisdom [not with modern science].” It “encompasses a modern, 21st
century perspective on medicine and health.” It “stresses psychology, along with
a methodology for thinking in Chinese medicine, and integrates parts of various
models including TCM and Five-Element into a unique whole.” That’s all very
nice, but is there any evidence that his methods are valid and have any
objective effect on patient health outcomes? No, there has been no validation.
He believes in what he’s doing, but he doesn’t see the need to test it.

Contemporary Chinese Pulse Diagnosis (CCPD)

CCPD is predicated on the belief that the radial artery represents the health of
the person. It incorporates eight depths, but in practice only three are used. 
The qi and blood depths represent an organ’s contribution to these substances
within the whole organism and the organ depth relates information regarding the 
organ parenchyma.

It uses 28 pulse positions on the radial artery to determine the presence or
absence of 80 pulse qualities. The positions relate to various organs, as seen
in this diagram:

Good grief! This is just another imaginary homunculus-type diagram detailing
nonexistent connections between one body part and other parts of the body. The
homunculus model is a prescientific notion of biology that has no basis in
anatomy, physiology, or any other basic science. Bogus homunculus diagrams are
found in iridology, acupuncture, reflexology, and many other pseudoscientific
belief systems. They are so prevalent that John McLachlan satirized them in his 
“butt reflexology hoax” which he described in an article for the British Medical
Journal; he had invented an inverted homunculus on the buttocks and had been
invited to speak at a conference about his “research.”

There are six basic positions and 22 complementary positions in CCPD. The
complementary positions are yang, so the three depths of the yin organ system
don’t apply.

CCPD encompasses 80 pulse qualities. In an attempt to eliminate the metaphoric
ambiguity of the classical literature, Hammer describes them according to
sensation, using “modern language.” It doesn’t sound like modern language to me,
and it clearly isn’t scientific language.

  1. Volume: a reflection of metabolic activity or the strength of qi or yang heat 
    within the body.

  2. Depth: provides information regarding the location and stage of the disease;
    superficial pulses are associated with acute disease involving the wei qi

  3. Width: reflects the condition of the blood

  4. Length: used to classify conditions of plentiful qi or deficient and stagnant 
    qi

  5. Shape: reflects excesses or deficiencies of certain substances. Divided into
    Fluid, two kinds of Nonfluid, and Miscellaneous

  6. Other categories: modifiers and anomalous

There are detailed procedures of palpation involving one or more fingers on one 
or both sides of the body.

Evaluating CCPD with science

One of the first questions to ask is whether the pulse findings are reliable. Is
there intra- and inter-observer consistency? In other words, if an examiner
repeats the exam on the same patient, does he get the same findings? If multiple
examiners examine the same patient, do their findings agree? As mentioned
above, previous studies had shown pulse diagnosis to be unreliable. Is this new 
version, CCPD, more reliable?

Karen Bilton tried to answer that question with a study reported in her thesis
submitted as partial requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the
University of Technology in Sydney. The title is “Investigating the reliability 
of Contemporary Chinese Pulse Diagnosis as a diagnostic tool in Oriental
medicine.” Bilton’s credentials include physiotherapy, acupuncture, and Chinese 
herbal medicine, and she has been studying pulse diagnosis under Leon Hammer,
the originator of CCPD, for the last 15 years. That suggests she is a true
believer with a strong bias in favor of pulse diagnosis.

The task she embarks on is an impractical, quixotic one. She is using the
methods of science to evaluate something that is not based on science or
reality, something that involves an unmanageable number of variables.

In reviewing the literature for previous studies, she found that:

  1. With increasing complexity of the pulse variable being detected, levels of
    both intra- and inter-rater agreement decrease.

  2. Inter-rater reliability decreases as the number of pulse testers increases

Well, duh! Isn’t that exactly what you would expect for a made-up method that
relies mainly on subjective assessments?

She thought she could do better, so she designed what she thought was a more
rigorous test with better defined parameters. Talking was not allowed, and the
testers were blinded to each other’s findings. Subjects remained in view of the 
testers. Open testing conditions were employed, since “reliability… was the
exclusive interest of the study, and not validity.” She wants to know whether
the results agree, not whether they’re valid. The term “validity” means the
extent to which a measurement corresponds accurately to the real world. I don’t 
think the devotees of CCPD want to live in the real world.

There were 15 subjects and six testers. The study was carried out at Dr.
Hammer’s Dragon Rises College of Oriental Medicine in Florida. One of the
testers was apparently Dr. Hammer himself; the others had studied with him for
8-10 years and had been teaching the system themselves at his college for more
than three years. For each subject, four pulse rates and 30 pulse categories
were collected on two occasions. There were 76 pulse qualities. For the large
segment of the pulse there were 11 pulse categories, each with anywhere from 4
to 51 variables. She had a lot of data to work with; she made 11,760 kappa
calculations! She found excellent to good agreement in 67% of intra-rater
comparisons and 44.1% of inter-rater comparisons. Reliability was less for the
pulse qualities of Muffled, Change of Amplitude, Blood Heat, Blood Thick, and
Flooding Deficient. For the Combined Complementary Positions, there was
unacceptable reliability. She suggests that if the definitions for those pulse
qualities and positions were modified, the reliability would improve. I suggest 
that they should be discarded rather than re-defined, because they are not
meaningful measures of anything.

Her write-up is tedious, packed with excruciating details, and trying to read it
gave me a headache. I won’t even try to comment on the validity of her
statistical analyses, except to say that calculating kappa for 11,760 different 
comparisons must have broken some kind of record! The whole enterprise was
misguided. At least she admits that the validity of using pulse information to
guide diagnosis remains questionable.

What have we learned from these experiments? For objective variables like pulse 
rate and rhythm, anyone who can count and read a clock would be expected to get 
very reliable readings. For many of the more subjective variables, it would be
expected that this very inbred group of testers, who all had the same training, 
indoctrination, experience, and constant contact with each other, would have
been trained to report similar findings whether they were real or not. So I
don’t think we have learned anything meaningful. In fact, the whole dissertation
reminds me of what Richard Feynman called cargo cult science, where it looks
like science and talks like science but doesn’t really understand how science
should work. Science doesn’t deal with claims that are unfalsifiable, and
Hammer’s claims for CCPD put it outside the realm of science.

Tongue diagnosis

Practitioners of pulse diagnosis are frequently also practitioners of tongue
diagnosis. Here we go again! They claim tongue diagnosis is an effective method 
used to diagnose diseases. They claim that different regions of the tongue
represent different parts of the body, internal organs, and “channels.” From
front to back, areas of the tongue represent the heart, lungs, stomach and
spleen, large and small intestines, kidneys and bladder; the sides of the tongue
represent the liver and gallbladder. How do you suppose they figured that out?

There are eight tongue feature indications:

  1. Tongue Body Color

  2. Tongue Body Shape

  3. Tongue Body Features

  4. Tongue Body Moisture

  5. Tongue Coating

  6. Tongue Coat Thickness

  7. Tongue Body Cracks

  8. Tongue Coat Root

There are elaborate categories under each of these tongue features. For
instance, the Tongue Body Shape can be Stiff, Flaccid, Swollen, Big or Enlarged 
Tongue, Half the Tongue is Swollen, Hammer Shaped, Local Swelling on One Side,
Swollen Sides, Swollen Between the Tip and the Central Surface, Swollen Edges,
Swollen Tip, Short and Contracted, Long, Front Swollen, and Thin. And there are 
details under each of these. For instance, if the tip of the tongue is swollen, 
it usually indicates heart problems; if it is also deep red, this may indicate
Heart Fire; and if it is normal in color or pale, this may indicate Heart Qi
Deficiency. A yellow tongue coat indicates Wind-Heat or Wind-Cold turning to
Wind-Heat. This is all very imaginative, but it is completely divorced from any 
anatomical or physiological reality.

Reality-based tongue examination

In conventional medicine, inspection of the tongue is an integral part of the
physical exam and can provide clues to many diseases. Some examples: A smooth
tongue may be caused by dentures, certain nutritional deficiencies, or
glossitis. A geographic tongue, with discolored, painless patches, is a benign
condition seen in 1-3% of the population. A hairy tongue is a sign of EBV
infection in HIV-positive individuals, and a black hairy tongue can be due to an
overgrowth of the fungus Aspergillus in patients on chronic antibiotic
treatment. Longitudinal furrows can result from syphilis. Ulcers can be benign
or a sign of systemic illnesses or cancer. Fasciculations indicate lower motor
neuron injury and may be a sign of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.

Scientific assessment of reliability

In a 2008 study, TCM practitioners were shown photos of tongues and filled out
questionnaires. There was very poor inter- and intra-practitioner reliability
even for simple dichotomous choices.

Conclusion: based on imagination, not reality

On Quackwatch, Stephen Barrett wrote an article titled “Why Traditional Chinese 
Medicine Diagnosis Is Worthless.” He concluded:

   TCM theory and practice are not based upon the body of knowledge related to
   health, disease, and health care that has been widely accepted by the
   scientific community. TCM practitioners disagree among themselves about how
   to diagnose patients and which treatments should go with which diagnoses.
   Even if they could agree, the TCM theories are so nebulous that no amount of 
   scientific study will enable TCM to offer rational care.

I agree wholeheartedly. Chinese pulse diagnosis and tongue diagnosis are based
on imaginary concepts, not on reality. If they want to bring them into the real 
world of science, perhaps the place to start would be to pick just one of the
spots on the wrist or tongue that are said to represent a given organ and test
whether that claim is true. It would be interesting to learn how the connection 
was first proposed and whether it was ever confirmed by testing. (Hint: it
wasn’t.)

Coca’s Pulse Testing to Diagnose “Allergies”

In the 1950s, Dr. Arthur F. Coca invented an elaborate method to diagnose a new 
kind of “allergy” by testing the pulse rate. He thought “allergies” were the
underlying cause of most disease. His method has never been tested, but there is
every reason to think it is bogus.

Harriet Hall on March 13, 2018

Link



I recently got an email from a gentleman who told me I was wrong about many
things because I “come from an era of incomplete medical education and
information.” He rambled on but had two main points: modern doctors fail to
recognize a kind of allergy that defies standard diagnosis and that is the cause
of pretty much every health problem, and MSG is a poison that should be banned.
He said, “…about 3,500 unsuspecting Americans are dying prematurely of
undiagnosed allergies aggravated with FDA approved food poisoning every day in
2018.”

I told him I would be glad to complete my medical education and asked for
reliable sources that would properly educate me. He answered, “therein lies the 
problem. Despite all I’ve heard about medicine and alternative medicine I don’t 
know of any. About the best I can do for now and have been doing is to suggest
the reading of Dr. Coca’s THE PULSE TEST and, much more recently, John Erb’s THE
SLOW POISONING OF MANKIND and to learn by doing.”

I’ll leave MSG for a later date; today I’ll discuss Arthur F. Coca’s pulse test 
for allergies. The full text of Coca’s book is available for free online. I read
it. I was not impressed.

The pulse test

Coca’s discovery of the pulse test was prompted by his wife’s experience. She
developed angina pectoris and noticed that her attacks of chest pain occurred
within minutes of eating certain foods, and that after eating those foods, her
pulse always accelerated. Coca deduced that harmful foods could be identified by
testing for an increase in pulse rate.

He decided that he had discovered a new kind of “allergy” that explained all
these health problems: recurrent headache, nervousness, migraine, dizziness,
constipation, canker sores, heartburn, epilepsy, overweight, underweight,
irritability, gastric ulcer, abdominal pain, gallbladder pain, gastric pain,
nervous and emotional instability (neurasthenia), abnormal tiredness,
indigestion (vomiting, gas, nausea), neuralgia, sinusitis, hypertension, hives, 
heart attacks (angina), asthma, hemorrhoids, psychic depression, diabetes, chest
pain, gastrointestinal bleeding, conjunctivitis, nose bleed, and colitis.

He claims to have treated all these conditions successfully by identifying and
avoiding the offending foods.

He developed elaborate rules for diagnosis, with no explanation of how he
arrived at them. For a baseline, patients are asked to take their pulse 14 times
a day at specified times. If the highest count is the same each day and is not 
over 84, they are probably not allergic. If the maximal count varies more than 2
beats from day to day, they are certainly allergic. Foods are then tested one
at a time and if the pulse rises, that means they are allergic to that food. In 
addition to foods, symptoms can be produced by environmental allergens like
tobacco, house dust, fumes, medicines, soap powder, and wood smoke. He notes
that there are exceptions to his rules, but he explains them away. For instance,
he says sensitivities can be temporarily lost. He is content to accumulate a
mass of examples that confirm his hypothesis but doesn’t look for examples that 
might disconfirm it. He never thinks to ask if there might be any other
explanations for his results. He doesn’t take the essential step of testing with
a control group.

There are a number of different versions of the Coca test promoted on various
alternative medicine websites, using different criteria for how many increased
beats per minute (and sometimes even decreased beats!) constitute a positive
test. And none provide any credible evidence for the test’s validity.

He provides case histories (anecdotes) of “almost miraculous” resolution of
symptoms both in patients he has seen and in patients he has not (hearsay).

He plays the “lone genius” persecution card, saying the establishment is
unwilling to even consider his findings and has prevented publication of his
results.

Here we go again!

Reading his book was a painful experience for me. I could see step by step how
he had made unwarranted assumptions, succumbed to confirmation bias, and deluded
himself. I have heard this same story so many times before! Just a few
examples: Batmanghelidj and his water cure, Jennifer Daniels and turpentine , a 
Navy neurologist’s adoption of acupuncture, Upledger’s discovery of craniosacral
therapy, Hahnemann’s discovery of homeopathy, Palmer’s discovery of
chiropractic, the origins of iridology and ear acupuncture… the list goes on.

The story goes like this:

  1. He observes something and misinterprets it.

  2. He extrapolates from one or a few cases to invent a general principle.

  3. He doesn’t even consider the possibility that he might be wrong.

  4. He doesn’t do any controlled scientific testing.

  5. He proceeds to treat patients. Many get better, perhaps because of the natural
    course of illness, regression to the mean, placebo effects, or other
    unrecognized factors, Without doing controlled studies, there is no way of
    knowing whether the treatment was responsible for the improvement, but he
    firmly convinces himself that it was.

  6. He is flattered and reinforced by feedback from grateful patients who believe 
    he cured them.

  7. Confirmation bias sets in.

  8. He becomes a true believer.

  9. When others try to point out what is wrong, he refuses to listen; instead, he 
    cries persecution and censorship.

Could there be anything to it?

Coca was born in 1875 and died in 1959, long before today’s understanding of the
concept of evidence-based medicine. He thought he had “evidence.” He didn’t
recognize that it was flawed. He didn’t understand the requirements of the
scientific method, and he never put his beliefs to any kind of a valid
scientific test. I don’t judge him too harshly; he was only doing what many
other doctors did in his era. But I think it is obvious that he was fooling
himself.The whole idea is implausible. In the first place, the heart rate is
naturally variable; in fact, a low heart rate variability (HRV) seems to be
associated with adverse health effects including an increased risk of death.
Many factors affect the pulse rate, and when patients are aware that a food is
being tested, anxiety, excitement, and other factors could affect the pulse
rate. There are just too many variables for the pulse test to be a reliable
indicator of anything.

Coca never defines what he means by “allergy,” and he offers no explanation for 
how it could cause all those disparate conditions. There is no plausible
mechanism. How could a single cause underlie epilepsy, diabetes, hypertension,
migraine, conjunctivitis, colitis, and constipation? Similar claims for “one
true cause of all disease,” are ubiquitous and bogus.

Coca’s book was published in 1956. If he was onto something, we could expect to 
have seen some confirmatory studies in the medical literature over the six
decades since he published it. There is nothing.

Conclusion: Not disproven, but not worth testing

If we can’t definitively say pulse testing for “allergies” is bogus, at least we
can say it is highly improbable, bordering on the impossible. The only way to
determine whether Coca’s hypothesis is valid is to test it properly in
controlled studies. In my opinion, authorizing such studies would be a waste of 
scarce research funds that would be better spent elsewhere.

In the absence of evidence, if patients want to try pulse testing, there’s very 
little potential for downside. Checking your pulse and experimenting with
eliminating specific foods from your diet are relatively harmless. Just be aware
that such self-experimentation can lead to false conclusions. That’s why we
need science: to keep from fooling ourselves.

                 Acupuncture, the P-Value Fallacy, and Honesty

                                 Kimball Atwood

                                      Link

Credibility alert: the following post contains assertions and speculations by
yours truly that are subject to, er, different interpretations by those who
actually know what the hell they’re talking about when it comes to statistics.
With hat in hand, I thank reader BKsea for calling attention to some of them. I 
have changed some of the wording—competently, I hope—so as not to poison the
minds of less wary readers, but my original faux pas are immortalized in BKsea’s
comment.

Lies, Damned Lies, and…

A few days ago my colleague, Dr. Harriet Hall, posted an article about
acupuncture treatment for chronic prostatitis/chronic pelvic pain syndrome. She 
discussed a study that had been performed in Malaysia and reported in the
American Journal of Medicine. According to the investigators,

   After 10 weeks of treatment, acupuncture proved almost twice as likely as
   sham treatment to improve CP/CPPS symptoms. Participants receiving
   acupuncture were 2.4-fold more likely to experience long-term benefit than
   were participants receiving sham acupuncture.

The primary endpoint was to be “a 6-point decrease in NIH-CSPI total score from 
baseline to week 10.” At week 10, 32 of 44 subjects (73%) in the acupuncture
group had experienced such a decrease, compared to 21 of 45 subjects (47%) in
the sham acupuncture group. Although the authors didn’t report these statistics 
per se, a simple “two-proportion Z-test” (Minitab) yields the following:

Sample X   N   Sample p

1            32  44   0.727273

2           21  45   0.466667

Difference = p (1) – p (2)

Estimate for difference: 0.260606

95% CI for difference: (0.0642303, 0.456982)

Test for difference = 0 (vs not = 0): Z = 2.60 P-Value = 0.009

Fisher’s exact test: P-Value = 0.017…

Wow! A P-value of 0.009! That’s some serious statistical significance. Even
Fisher’s more conservative “exact test” is substantially less than the 0.05 that
we’ve come to associate with “rejecting the null hypothesis,” which in this
case is that there was no difference in the proportion of subjects who had
experienced a 6-point decrease in NIH-CSPI scores at 10 weeks. Surely there is a
big difference between getting “real” acupuncture and getting sham acupuncture 
if you’ve got chronic prostatitis/chronic pelvic pain syndrome, and this study
proves it!

Well, maybe there is a big difference and maybe there isn’t, but this study
definitely does not prove that there is. Almost two years ago I posted a series 
about Bayesian inference. The first post discussed two articles by Steven
Goodman of Johns Hopkins:

Goodman SN. Toward evidence-based medical statistics. 1: The P value fallacy.
Ann Intern Med. 1999;130:995-1004.

Goodman SN. Toward evidence-based medical statistics. 2: The Bayes factor. Ann
Intern Med. 1999;130:1005-13.

I won’t repeat everything from that post; rather, I’ll try to amplify the
central problem of “frequentist statistics” (the kind that we’re all used to),
and of the P-value in particular. Goodman explained that it is logically
impossible for frequentist tools to “both control long-term error rates and
judge whether conclusions from individual experiments

[are] true.” In the first article he quoted Neyman and Pearson, the creators of 
the hypothesis test:

   …no test based upon a theory of probability can by itself provide any
   valuable evidence of the truth or falsehood of a hypothesis.

   But we may look at the purpose of tests from another viewpoint. Without
   hoping to know whether each separate hypothesis is true or false, we may
   search for rules to govern our behaviour with regard to them, in following
   which we insure that, in the long run of experience, we shall not often be
   wrong.

Goodman continued:

   It is hard to overstate the importance of this passage. In it, Neyman and
   Pearson outline the price that must be paid to enjoy the purported benefits 
   of objectivity: We must abandon our ability to measure evidence, or judge
   truth, in an individual experiment. In practice, this meant reporting only
   whether or not the results were statistically significant and acting in
   accordance with that verdict.

   …the question is whether we can use a single number, a probability, to
   represent both the strength of the evidence against the null hypothesis and
   the frequency of false-positive error under the null hypothesis. If so, then 
   Neyman and Pearson must have erred when they said that we could not both
   control long-term error rates and judge whether conclusions from individual
   experiments were true. But they were not wrong; it is not logically possible.

   The P Value Fallacy

   The idea that the P value can play both of these roles is based on a
   fallacy: that an event can be viewed simultaneously both from a long-run and 
   a short-run perspective. In the long-run perspective, which is error-based
   and deductive, we group the observed result together with other outcomes that
   might have occurred in hypothetical repetitions of the experiment. In the
   “short run” perspective, which is evidential and inductive, we try to
   evaluate the meaning of the observed result from a single experiment. If we
   could combine these perspectives, it would mean that inductive ends (drawing 
   scientific conclusions) could be served with purely deductive methods
   (objective probability calculations).

   These views are not reconcilable because a given result (the short run)
   can legitimately be included in many different long runs…

It is hard to overstate the importance of that passage. When applied to the
acupuncture study under consideration, what it means is that the observed
difference between the two proportions, 26%, is only one among many “outcomes
that might have occurred in hypothetical repetitions of the experiment.” Look at
the Minitab line above that reads “95% CI for difference: (0.0642303,
0.456982).” CI stands for Confidence Interval: in the words of BKsea, “in 95% of
repetitions, the 95% CI (which would be different each time) would contain the 
true value.” We don’t know where, in the 95% CI generated by this trial (between
6.4% and 45.7%), the true difference lies; we don’t even know that the true
difference lies within that interval at all (if we did, it would be a 100%
Confidence Interval)! Put a different way, there is little reason to believe
that the “center” of the Confidence Interval generated by this study, 26%, is
the true proportion difference. 26% is merely a result that “can legitimately be
included in many different long runs…”

Hence, the P-value fallacy. It is that point—26%—that is used to calculate the
P-value, with no basis other than its being as good an estimate, in a sense, as 
any: it was observed here, so it can’t be impossible; when looked at from the
point of view of whatever the true proportion difference is, it has a 95% chance
of being within two standard deviations of that value, as do all other possible
outcomes (which is why we can say with ’95% confidence’ that the true
proportion is within two standard deviations of 26%). You can see that the CI is
a better way to report the statistic based on the data, because it doesn’t
“privilege” any point within it (even if many people don’t know that), but the
CI will also steer us away from being wrong only in “the long run of
experience.” CIs, of course, will be different for each observed outcome. The
P-value should not be used at all.

Now let’s look at a graph from the acupuncture report:

Mean NIH-CPSI total scores of 89 chronic prostatitis/chronic pelvic pain
patients treated with 20 sessions of either acupuncture (n = 44) or sham
acupuncture (n = 45) therapy over 10 weeks. Error bars represent the SD. To
enter into the study, each participant had a minimum NIH-CPSI total score of at 
least 15 (range 0-43) on both baseline visits (indicated as the average in the
baseline value). The primary criterion for response was at least a 6-point
decrease from baseline to week 10 (end of therapy). There was no significant
difference between the NIH-CPSI total scores in the acupuncture and sham
acupuncture groups at baseline, week 5 (early during therapy), or weeks 14, 22, 
and 34 (post-therapy) evaluations. *Of 44 participants in the acupuncture group,
32 (72.7%) met the primary response criterion, compared with 21 (46.7%) of 45
participants in the sham acupuncture group (Fisher’s exact test P = .02). ‡At
week 34, 14 (31.8%) of 44 acupuncture group participants had long-term responses
(with no additional treatment) compared with 6 (13.3%) of 45 sham acupuncture
group participants (RR 2.39, 95% CI, 1.0-5.6, Fisher’s exact test P = .04).

Figure 3. Mean NIH-CPSI total scores of 89 chronic prostatitis/chronic
pelvic pain patients treated with 20 sessions of either acupuncture (n = 44) or 
sham acupuncture (n = 45) therapy over 10 weeks. Error bars represent the SD. To
enter into the study, each participant had a minimum NIH-CPSI total score of at
least 15 (range 0-43) on both baseline visits (indicated as the average in the 
baseline value). The primary criterion for response was at least a 6-point
decrease from baseline to week 10 (end of therapy). There was no significant
difference between the NIH-CPSI total scores in the acupuncture and sham
acupuncture groups at baseline, week 5 (early during therapy), or weeks 14, 22, 
and 34 (post-therapy) evaluations. *Of 44 participants in the acupuncture group,
32 (72.7%) met the primary response criterion, compared with 21 (46.7%) of 45
participants in the sham acupuncture group (Fisher’s exact test P = .02). ‡At
week 34, 14 (31.8%) of 44 acupuncture group participants had long-term responses
(with no additional treatment) compared with 6 (13.3%) of 45 sham acupuncture
group participants (RR 2.39, 95% CI, 1.0-5.6, Fisher’s exact test P = .04). 

Hmmm. I dunno about you, but at first glance what I see are two curves that are 
pretty similar. They differ “significantly” at only two of the six observation
times: week 10 and week 34. Why would there be a difference at 10 weeks (when
the treatments ended), no difference at weeks 14 and 22, and then suddenly a
difference again? Is it plausible that the delayed reappearance of the
difference is a treatment effect? The “error bars” don’t even represent what
you’re used to seeing: the 95% CI. Here they represent one standard deviation,
not two, and thus only about a 68% CI. Not very convincing, eh?

OK, I’m gonna give this report a little benefit of the doubt. The graph shown
here is of mean scores for each group at each time (lower scores are better).
That is different from the question of how many subjects benefited in each
group, because there could have been a few in the sham group who did especially 
well and a few in the ‘true’ group who did especially poorly. It is bothersome, 
though, that this is the only graph in the report, and that the raw data were
not reported. Do you find it odd that the number of ‘responders’ in each group
diminished over time, even as the mean scores continued to improve?

Just for fun, let’s see what we get if we use the Bayes Factor instead of the
P-value as a measure of evidence in this trial. Now we’ll go back to the primary
endpoint, not the mean scores. Look at Goodman’s second article:

Minimum Bayes factor = e-Z²/2

At 10 weeks, according to our statistics package, Z = 2.60. Thus the Bayes
factor is 0.034, which in Bayes reasoning is “moderate to strong” evidence
against the null hypothesis. Not bad, but hardly the “P = 0.009″ that we have
been raised on and most of us still cling to. The Bayes factor, of course, is
used together with the Prior Probability to arrive at a posterior probability.
If you look on p. 1008 of Goodman’s second paper, you’ll see that as strong as
this evidence appears at first glance, it would take a prior probability
estimate of the acupuncture hypothesis being true of close to 50% to result in a
posterior probability (of the null being true) of 5%, our good-ol’ P-value
benchmark. Some might be willing to give it that much; I’m not.

On the dangers of using valid placebo controls in clinical trials of acupuncture

                                  David Gorski

                                      Link

I don’t recall if I’ve ever mentioned this before on this blog, but there was a 
time when I was less skeptical of acupuncture than I am now. It’s true. Don’t
get me wrong, though. I never for a minute considered that the whole rigamarole 
about “unblocking” or “redirecting” the flow of that mystical life force known
as qi had anything to do with whether or not acupuncture did or did not have
efficacy treating disease or other conditions. That was clearly a holdover from 
the pre-scientific medicine times in which most beliefs about the causes of
disease involved either the wrath of the gods or vitalism, the latter of which
is, when you come right down to it, the philosophical basis upon which many
“complementary and alternative” (CAM) modalities are based, especially the
so-called “energy healing” modalities, such as reiki, therapeutic touch, and, of
course, acupuncture.

However, because unlike so many other “energy healing” methods, acupuncture
involved an actual physical action upon the body, namely the insertion of thin
needles into the skin to specified depths, it did not seem to me entirely
unreasonable that there might be some sort of physiological effect that might
produce a therapeutic result. At least, that’s what I used to think until I
actually started paying attention to the scientific literature on acupuncture.
That’s when I started to realize that “there’s no ‘there’ there,” if you know
what I mean. Horribly designed studies with either no controls or utterly
inadequate controls tend to be the norm in the acupuncture “literature” (if you 
can call it that). Moreover, acupuncture was touted as having value for
conditions and procedures for which there is no plausible (or even mildly
plausible) physiological mechanism by which it could be reasonably postulated to
have an effect. Arthritis, allergies, headache, back pain, gastroesophageal
reflux disease (GERD), Parkinson’s disease, post-operative nausea, hot flashes
in breast cancer patients caused by the anti-estrogen drugs they have to take,
infertility, it doesn’t matter. Seemingly acupuncture can do it all; it’s the
Swiss Army knife of CAM therapies. Moreover, the “explanations” given to explain
“how acupuncture works” seemed increasingly less plausible to me. Most of these
explanations involve counterirritation or the release of opioids, and I’ve had 
an increasingly hard time believing that, even if these mechanisms are at play, 
they could have anything other than nonspecific effects, with no mechanism to
explain how acupuncture could possibly do all things attributed to it. One rule 
of medical skepticism is that you should be very skeptical of modalities that
are touted to be useful for a wide variety of medical conditions that have very 
different pathophysiology. Indeed, a funny thing happens when rigorous placebo
controls are introduced, and that’s sometimes the placebo control does better
than the “true” acupuncture; i.e., the evidence for acupuncture, taken in its
totality, is completely compatible with placebo effect.

As Harriet Hall put it in her excellent analysis of a study purporting to show
that acupuncture is useful for GERD:

   This study falls into the category of what I call Tooth Fairy science. You
   could measure how much money the Tooth Fairy leaves under the pillow, whether
   she leaves more cash for the first or last tooth, whether the payoff is
   greater if you leave the tooth in a plastic baggie versus wrapped in Kleenex.
   You can get all kinds of good data that is reproducible and statistically
   significant. Yes, you have learned something. But you haven’t learned what
   you think you’ve learned, because you haven’t bothered to establish whether
   the Tooth Fairy really exists.

One area that acupuncturists keep needling away at is infertility. Somehow, in
the CAM community it’s become conventional wisdom that acupuncture can somehow
increase the chance of success for couples undergoing in vitro fertilization
(IVF). Indeed, early this year I wrote about a meta-analysis that concluded that
acupuncture did actually increase the success rate of IVF and why it did not
show what its authors thought it showed. Tooth fairy science, indeed.

Now comes yet another study being publicized in the media that examines once
again the question of whether sticking needles into women before they undergo
IVF can increase their chances of conceiving. I could not help but be extremely 
amused by the title given to the ScienceDaily story about it: Placebo
Acupuncture Is Associated With Higher Pregnancy Rate After IVF Than Real
Acupuncture. You have to love a headline like that, and opening paragraphs like 
this:

   A study comparing the effects of real and placebo acupuncture on pregnancy
   rates during assisted reproduction has found that, surprisingly, placebo
   acupuncture was associated with a significantly higher overall pregnancy rate
   than real acupuncture.

   The study, published online in the journal Human Reproduction, looked at real
   and placebo acupuncture given on the day of embryo transfer in 370 patients 
   in a randomised, double blind trial (where neither the patients nor the
   doctors knew which treatment was being given).

   The researchers found that the overall pregnancy rate (defined by a positive 
   urinary pregnancy test) for placebo acupuncture was 55.1%, versus 43.8% for
   the real acupuncture.

I bet that result caused some head-scratching.

This reminds me of a study not too long ago that found a similar–shall we
say?–disconcerting result in which acupuncture was studied for its ability to
relieve arm pain from repetitive use injuries, which was funded, amusingly
enough, by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine
(NCCAM). Naturally, I had to go straight to the source. Fortunately, you, too,
can do the same because the manuscript is available online for free for
everyone, unlike most such papers, which are hidden behind a subscription
firewall, not easily accessible by any but academics. The study, coming out of
China, is entitled A randomized double blind comparison of real and placebo
acupuncture in IVF treatment, and its lead investigator is Dr. Ernest Hung Yu
Ng, Associate Professor in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at the
University of Hong Kong (People’s Republic of China. So, let’s take a look at
this study.

The hypothesis, not surprisingly, is that acupuncture could improve the efficacy
of IVF and result in a higher pregnancy rate. The specific acupuncture regimen 
consisted of two 25-minute sessions, one before embryo transfer and one after
embryo transfer was completed. Patient were informed of the study on the day of 
transvaginal ultrasound-guided oocyte retrieval (TUGOR), at which time a
practitioner of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) “diagnosed” thusly subjects
who agreed to participate in the study:

A registered traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) practitioner (E.W.S.S.)
categorized these patients’ conditions by the four diagnostic methods:
observation, auscultation, interrogation and palpation according to the TCM
principles (Maciocia, 1998). They were classified into the related syndromes
which included Kidney Yang/Yin deficiency, Liver Qi stagnation with blood
stasis, Spleen Qi deficiency with Phlegm and combination of those syndromes.

I wonder if spleen qi deficiency requires a splenectomy or if we can prescribe
more yang or yin for a Yang/Yin deficiency. Sorry, couldn’t resist.

Patients were randomized to receive either “real” acupuncture of “sham” (a.k.a. 
placebo) acupuncture, and the placebo acupuncture needle was described thusly:

   The Streitberger’s placebo needles (Streitberger and Kleinhenz, 1998;
   Asiamed, Pullach, Germany; 0.30 x 30 mm) were used. The appearance of the
   placebo needle was the same as the needle used in the real acupuncture group.
   The placebo needle was not fixed into the copper handle and the tip of the
   needle was blunt. When it was pushed forward against the skin, the needle
   slid into the handle and the whole needle appeared shortened. This also gave 
   patients a pricking penetration sensation. To place the placebo needle in
   position, the Park’s placebo device (Park et al., 1999; Dong Bang AcuPrime,
   Exeter, UK) was used. The same acupoints and procedures as in the real
   acupuncture group were applied.

Overall, the design of the trial appears pretty sound. It was randomized and
double-blinded to the extent possible with a treatment like acupuncture, and, as
all good double-blind studies do, patients were asked afterward to guess
whether they were in the treatment group or the placebo group in order to assess
the quality of blinding. The study was powered to detect a 15% increase in the 
rate of pregnancy based on the clinic’s usual success rate of 35%, which
required 370 patients. (Note how it was assumed that acupuncture would increase 
the success rate of IVF.) Overall, on first glance, the two groups seemed to be 
comparable, although I was a bit disturbed to see that the statistics showing
that they were, in fact, comparable in all the parameters measured were not
included in the table summarizing the two groups. My other quibble is that I was
a bit surprised that the primary outcome the investigators chose to look at was
pregnancy rates as assessed by urine pregnancy tests. As anyone who’s ever
undergone IVF knows, not all positive pregnancy tests result in an ongoing
pregnancy or a live birth, not by a longshot. When discussing the success rate
of IVF, what patients are interested in is the live birth rate. Anything less is
a failure. Looking at the table of the results, I think I see why the authors
were more interested in the overall pregnancy rate. It is the only outcome
measure the produced a statistically significant difference between the two
groups.

Let’s take a closer look. The overall pregnancy rate (a positive urine pregnancy
test) was 43.8% for the “real” acupuncture group and 55.1% for the placebo
acupuncture group (p =0.038). However, the numbers become less and less
different as we go deeper into measurements of pregnancy that matter more. For
example, generally after a round of IVF that results in a positive pregnancy
test, the first big hurdle afterward is the 4 week ultrasound that is done to
see if there is a fetal sac, and ongoing pregnancy is usually defined as a
pregnancy resulting in a fetal heartbeat detectable by ultrasound at 8 weeks.
The definition of live birth is fairly self-explanatory, although for purposes
of this study it was defined as a live birth occurring after 24 weeks. In any
case, clinical pregnancy rates for “real” acupuncture and placebo acupuncture
were 38.9% and 49.2%, respectively (p=0.059); ongoing pregnancy rates, 31.9% and
40.5% (p=0.105); live birth rates, 29.7% and 38.4% (p=0.100). There was
similarly no difference between implantation rates, miscarriage rates, or
ectopic pregnancy rates. In fact, this study is not a study showing that
acupuncture does anything to improve or harm success rates for IVF. It’s a
negative study. There is no statistically significant difference between the
outcomes in the only measure that patients really care about, live births.
Indeed, there was in addition no difference between the groups in endometrial or
subendometrial vascular density, nor were there any statistically significant
differences in serum cortisol levels. Add to that the fact that the authors
appear not to have controlled for multiple comparisons using an appropriate
statistical correction (remember, the more comparisons one makes, the more
likely there is to be a statistically “significant” difference by chance alone),
and my conclusion is that this study would show us absolutely no difference
between the groups if the appropriate statistical correction were applied.

That doesn’t stop the authors from doing all sorts of contortions over the
results in the Discussion section. For example, the authors did find a
significant decrease in serum cortisol after both “real” and placebo
accupuncture, as well as an improvement in uterine blood flow parameters. To me 
this suggests decreased stress in both groups more than anything else, entirely 
compatible with the placebo effect. What’s more interesting is how the authors
try to explain their result after first expressing their surprise in the
discussion:

   We found a significantly higher overall pregnancy rate following placebo
   acupuncture when compared with that of real acupuncture. There was a trend of
   higher rates of clinical pregnancy, ongoing pregnancy, live birth and
   implantation in the placebo acupuncture group, although the differences did
   not reach statistical significance. Surprisingly, significant changes in
   endometrial and subendometrial vascularity, serum cortisol concentration and 
   the anxiety level were documented following both real and placebo
   acupuncture.

Why surprising? After all, this is exactly what would be predicted by the
hypothesis that acupuncture acts primarily as a placebo; specifically, no
differences in primary outcomes (ongoing pregnancy rates and live birth rates)
but possibly differences in measurements related to patient anxiety, such as
cortisol levels and uterine blood flow. No surprise there, unless you believe in
acupuncture. The authors do go on to make a point that I actually somewhat
agree with. Specifically, they lament that they didn’t include a no-acupuncture 
group as a control. Of course, the problem with adding such a group is that it
would make it impossible to blind the study subjects in the no-acupuncture
control group to their experimental group assignment and thus render this study 
no longer double blind. That is not an insignificant problem. However, it might 
be interesting to do in order to estimate the magnitude of the placebo effect.

More amusingly, Dr. Ng went into some contortions to try to explain his
“surprising” result in an interview. In essence, he likened placebo acupuncture 
to acupressure and then waved his hands thusly:

   Dr Ng gave two possible explanations for the results: “Placebo acupuncture is
   similar to acupressure and therefore is good enough to improve the pregnancy
   rate. Or else, it’s possible that real acupuncture may, in some way, reduce 
   the pregnancy rate of acupuncture.

   “So far there is no evidence that real acupuncture would adversely affect IVF
   outcomes because, in a previous meta-analysis of several acupuncture
   studies, the pregnancy rate was higher in the acupuncture groups than in the 
   control groups. However, we cannot draw a firm conclusion about this from our
   current study as we did not compare the two groups with a third control
   group patients who received neither forms of acupuncture. Further studies
   should be conducted to compare placebo or non-invasive acupuncture and
   controls without acupuncture.”

You can sense the desperation. At least, I can, especially looking at his
rationalization for the latter explanation, namely that “real” acupuncture
somehow reduces the pregnacy rate. Of course, such a result would in fact be
interesting if true, because it would indicate a physiological effect due to
“real” acupuncture distinguishable from placebo acupuncture, just a negative
one. In reality, the best explanation for this result is that there is no
difference between the two groups (there isn’t, in fact) combined with a random 
finding of a seemingly “statistically significant” difference in one parameter, 
namely the overall pregnancy rate as measured by the rate of positive urine
pregnancy tests in each subject group. Combine that with a hypothesis with a
very low prior probability, which significantly increases the likelihood of a
false positive result, as John Ioannidis has shown, and there’s no real
difficulty in explaining Dr. Ng’s result. The only thing unusual in this case is
that the false “positive” result was a “positive” in the wrong direction. Alas 
for poor Dr. Ng, he was tripped up by the vagaries of comparing two different
(and almost certainly equal) placebos against each other. Do such studies long
enough, and inevitably sometimes the “wrong” placebo will win.

REFERENCES:

E. W. S. So, E. H. Y. Ng, Y. Y. Wong, E. Y. L. Lau, W. S. B. Yeung, P. C. Ho
(2008). A randomized double blind comparison of real and placebo acupuncture in 
IVF treatment Human Reproduction DOI: 10.1093/humrep/den380

              EMDR and Acupuncture – Selling Non-specific Effects

                                 Steven Novella

                                      Link

The scientific approach to understanding the world includes the process of
carefully separating out variables and effects. Experiments, in fact, are
designed specifically to control for variables. This can be especially
challenging in medicine, since the body is a complex and variable system and
there are always numerous factors at play. We often characterize the many
variables that can influence the outcome in a clinical study as “placebo
effects” or “non-specific effect” – things other than a specific response to the
treatment in question.

A common error to make when interpreting clinical studies is to confuse
non-specific effects – those that result from the therapeutic interaction or the
process of observation – with a specific effect from the treatment being
studied. While this is broadly understood within the scientific medical
community, it seems that within certain fields proponents are going out of their
way to sell non-specific effects as if they were specific effects of the
favored treatment.

This is perhaps most true for acupuncture. As has been discussed numerous times 
on SBM, the consensus of the best clinical studies on acupuncture show that
there is no specific effect of sticking needles into acupuncture points.
Choosing random points works just as well, as does poking the skin with
toothpicks rather than penetrating the skin with a needle to elicit the alleged 
“de qi”.

The most parsimonious interpretation of the evidence is that the needles (i.e.
acupuncture itself) are superfluous – any perceived benefit comes from the
therapeutic interaction. This has been directly studied, and the evidence
suggests that the way to maximize the subjective effects from the ritual of
acupuncture is to enhance the interaction with the practitioner, and has nothing
to do with the acupuncture itself. Acupuncture is a clear example of selling a 
specific procedure based entirely on non-specific effects from the therapeutic
interaction – a good bedside manner and some hopeful encouragement.

This phenomenon is by no means limited to acupuncture. Perhaps another example
is Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR), a practice that is
increasingly popular among psychiatrists.

The concept of EMDR – how it is supposed to work – sounds pseudoscientific to
this neurologist. According to the EMDR Institute:

   During treatment various procedures and protocols are used to address the
   entire clinical picture. One of the procedural elements is “dual
   stimulation” using either bilateral eye movements, tones or taps. During the 
   reprocessing phases the client attends momentarily to past memories, present 
   triggers, or anticipated future experiences while simultaneously focusing on 
   a set of external stimulus. During that time, clients generally experience
   the emergence of insight, changes in memories, or new associations.

The external stimulus – whether moving the eyes or tapping on the client or
playing certain tones – is supposed to help the brain reprocess memories and
information, and is alleged to be useful for a wide range of psychiatric
symptoms. The proposed mechanism sounds highly dubious. While the brain
certainly has plasticity, the ability to change its wiring through use, it is
hard to imagine how such a simple procedure could have a significant effect on
this plasticity. There are many who suspect that the eye movement component to
EMDR therapy may be the equivalent to the needle component of acupuncture.

In psychotherapy there are many sources of non-specific effects that would need 
to be carefully controlled for before the effects of any specific component can 
be determined. The interaction with the therapist, the time taken to focus on
ones problems and symptoms, and the introduction of a novel element into the
therapeutic relationship are all recognized factors. In addition, EMDR (not
surprisingly) has evolved into a multifaceted treatment approach, that includes 
many standard elements of therapy. This always reminds me of the commercials who
proudly advertise that their products are “part of this nutritious breakfast.” 
Yes, but are they an important part – or is the breakfast nutritious without it?

A 2002 review of EMDR in general concluded:

   Current component analyses of EMDR have failed to effectively evaluate
   the relative weighting of its procedures.

And a more recent 2006 review of EMDR compared to cognitive-behavioral therapy
for post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) concluded:

   Our results suggest that in the treatment of PTSD, both therapy methods
   tend to be equally efficacious. We suggest that future research should not
   restrict its focus to the efficacy, effectiveness and efficiency of these
   therapy methods but should also attempt to establish which trauma patients
   are more likely to benefit from one method or the other. What remains unclear
   is the contribution of the eye movement component in EMDR to treatment
   outcome.

The last line is most significant – what contribution, if any, does the actual
EMDR have? The research has not clearly established that the eye movements are
having a specific neurological or psychological effect. Perhaps it’s just all
the other components of the therapy that is having the perceived effect. And yet
EMDR has been widely accepted as a treatment modality. This acceptance seems
premature.

It also seems that this is another failure of the evidence-based medicine (EBM) 
approach – EMDR  is being hailed as an evidence-based practice. There are indeed
studies that show that EMDR therapy works. But a science-based approach would
consider more deeply the question of plausibility and mechanism, and from this
question whether or not EMDR has indeed been established as having specific
efficacy.

Conclusion

EMDR, like acupuncture, is likely nothing more than a ritual that elicits
non-specific therapeutic effects.  While there are some who may consider this a 
justification for both modalities, there is significant risk to this approach.
First, the non-specific effects are often used to justify alleged specific
mechanisms of action which are likely not true. This sends scientific thought
and research off on a wild-goose chase, looking for effects that do not exist.
Science is a cumulative process built on consilience – scientific knowledge must
all hang together. These false leads are a wrench in the mechanics of science.

Second, the false specificity of these treatments is a massive clinical
distraction. Time and effort are wasted clinically in studying, perfecting, and 
using these methods, rather than focusing on the components of the interaction
that actually work.

And in the end these magical elements do not add efficacy. For example, as the
review above indicates, EMDR is no more effective than standard
cognitive-behavioral therapy.

Rather than getting distracted by alluring rituals and elaborate
pseudoscientific explanations for how they work, we should focus on maximizing
the non-specific elements of the therapeutic interaction, and adding that to
physiological or psychological interventions that have specific efficacy.

Acupuncture and Endorphins: Not all that Impressive

Mark Crislip on July 22, 2016

Link 



Pictured: A great way to get a staph infection, not a great way to get an
endorphin rush.  Try jogging.  Or heroin.*

I was reading, and deconstructing, a particularly awful bit of advice for
acupuncture by Consumer Reports. It was the same old same old, but it was the
source that made it particularly awful. I expect more from Consumer Reports than
the uncritical regurgitation of the standard mythical acupuncture narrative.
The report included the quote

   One possible reason for the benefits of acupuncture: Studies show that it
   causes us to release feel-good hormones, called endorphins, that suppress
   pain.

I have never bothered to go back and see what the original literature was to
support endorphins as a potential mechanism for a beneficial effect of
acupuncture on pain.

That endorphins are released as a result of a noxious stimulus didn’t surprise
me; that is what endorphins are for. And endorphins are unlikely to be the
mechanism for all the other diseases for which the WHO suggests acupuncture
benefits.

To my surprise, my brief search that day came up with very little information on
the endorphins and acupuncture.

What I wanted to know was the evidence behind the universal meme that
acupuncture releases feel-good hormones. If Consumer Reports says it is so, it
must be true, right? So I plugged ‘acupuncture endorphin’ into PubMed and went
to work.

I decided to start in the beginning, so let’s take a trip down memory lane and
see what the reality is behind endorphins and acupuncture.

The first paper was from 1977 and was called “Increased cerebrospinal fluid
levels of endorphins after electro-acupuncture.”

Electro? You mean electric shocks? That ain’t acupuncture, at least not classic 
acupuncture in all its forms.

And naloxone (an opiate antagonist) blockade of acupuncture effect? The first
report is from 1978 and also electro-acupuncture and with a less than a
compelling result, in 5 patients with low back pain (cancer and postherapeutic
neuralgia)

   related a certain analgesic effect during electrotherapy, with a reduction in
   pain of more than 50 per cent. During electroanalgesia we administered
   Naloxone (an antagonist of morphine). In 3 cases we observed a clear,
   although short, return of algic symptomatology. At the contrary, in other two
   patients Naloxone caused briefly a further and clear reduction in the pain.

The next year they decided to puree some rabbits:

   The brain and serum extracts of acupunctured rabbits injected into rabbits
   produced a marked analgesic effect on the recipient, as shown by a great
   increase of their pain threshold. This effect is counteracted by a specific
   opiate anatagonist, naloxone. The data suggest that the release of the
   endogenous substances with morphine-like biological properties, endorphins,
   is increased by acupuncture stimulation, thus inhibiting pain perception.

As we know from the veterinary literature, pets owners assessment of their pets 
pain is suspect, so not compelling, but perhaps a good way to generate a super
rabbit.

There was another electro-acupuncture study in 1978, and again and again and
again:

   heroin addicts showing features of heroin withdrawal basal beta-endorphin
   levels were elevated in both blood and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and did not 
   change during electroacupuncture,

and again and again and again, but not always with positive results:

   The dental pain threshold elevation produced by non-painful, low-frequency
   transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) in healthy humans was not 
   reduced by the administration of 0.8 mg of naloxone i.v

Well, you get the picture. It is always ELECTRO acupuncture that sometimes
results in an endorphin release. Oh, and yes, TENS increases endorphins.
Sometimes. Some of the studies are positively cringe inducing:

   Acupuncture analgesia was quantitated in the phenylquinone induced writhing
   test in mice. Both manual acupuncture and electroacupuncture significantly
   reduced the number of writhes, i.e. 47% and 51% reduction respectively.
   Naloxone (2 mg/kg) pretreatment abolished this antinocicpetive effect
   suggesting that an endogenous opiate-like substance was involved.
   Hypophysectomy did not alter the electroacupuncture induced inhibition of
   writhing.

But how about non electro-acupuncture as a source of feel-good hormones?
Standard acupuncture to unblock the flow of qi down meridians. Even less
impressive.

In one headache study, traditional Chinese acupuncture led to an increase in
serum beta-endorphin in controls but NOT those who received acupuncture. Hard to
credit endorphins for acupuncture pain relief with headache.

In another negative study naloxone failed to block classic acupuncture effects
on pain:

   Immediately following the post-acupuncture pain assessment, the patient was
   injected intravenously with a 1 ml. injection of 400 micrograms of Naloxone
   or a 1 ml. injection of 0.9% Sodium Chloride on a randomised double-blind
   basis. The effect on pain relief was noted immediately and after thirty
   minutes. No significant change in pain relief already obtained was noted
   after Naloxone in any patient. This does not support the hypothesis that
   acupuncture therapy is mediated by endorphin.

A result duplicated in other studies with headache and tooth pain:

   Subjects who demonstrated acupunctural analgesia during electrical
   stimulation of the LI–4 point on the hands received either 1.2 mg naloxone or
   normal saline under double blind conditions. Pain thresholds elevated by
   acupuncture failed to reverse when naloxone was given

And for chronic pain:

   No significant differences were observed in this immunoreactivity after prs, 
   and the clinical analgesic effect was independent of the level of this
   immunoreactivity and its changes during these procedures. On the other hand, 
   a positive correlation was demonstrated between plasma beta-endorphin
   concentration and the neuroticism index as evaluated by Eysenck’s personality
   inventory.

And:

   In twenty patients with chronic pain syndrome, acupuncture treatment resulted
   in significant improvement of both pain and psychiatric symptoms and higher 
   plasma concentrations of metenkephalin. Plasma beta-endorphin concentrations 
   were unchanged.

There is a consistent lack of change in plasma endorphin levels with
acupuncture-like interventions.

Or endorphin levels in pregnancy:

   beta-endorphin are not significantly influenced by acupuncture and are
   therefore not likely to mediate acupuncture-related effects during labor.

Or patients with chronic pain:

   beta-endorphin immunoreactive material in blood is not released by any type
   of acupuncture as tested under low stress conditions.

Or knee pain:

   The study did not confirm earlier reports of release of plasma beta-endorphin
   during acupuncture.

Perhaps it is the CNS, not plasma, endorphins that are involved with
acupuncture. Except in pregnant women. Acupuncture does not alter CSF endorphin 
level.:

   There was no significant difference in CSF dynorphin A or beta-endorphin
   levels between the AP-treated women and non-treated controls in late
   pregnancy.

I suspect I missed the clinical trials that convincingly demonstrate the
importance of endorphins in all the forms of acupuncture that are not electric. 
I looked, but I couldn’t find them.

Conclusion: Endorphins are myth, not history

Does acupuncture release feel-good hormones called endorphins? It is a bad
question since, as is so often the case, exactly what is meant by acupuncture is
never specified.

For electro, a tarted up a form of TENS, the answer is often a yes, but
electro-acupuncture isn’t acupuncture. Of the dozens and dozens and dozens of
forms of what passes for acupuncture only electro acupuncture uses electricity. 
I know. Duh

All the other forms of acupunctures? Almost all of the data suggests that for
the more traditional forms of acupuncture, feel-good hormones have nothing to do
with its alleged analgesic effects. That effect, as we know, is actually the
same mechanism as beer goggles.

Given how totally picky CR is in their product reviews, it is odd they did not
bother to investigate the basis of the idea that ‘acupuncture’ releases
feel-good hormones, it is electricity. Yet another fail when CR accepts the
standard mythical narrative of acupuncture without actually reviewing the
supporting information and then giving terrible advice. But that is the standard
approach to reporting SCAM. Same as it ever was. I do wonder if I can actually 
trust their advice on the best car or laundry detergent when they have such a
fail with health care, a topic far more important.


*Note: Do not try heroin, it is also a great way to get a staph infection

 Needles in the skin cause changes in the brain, but acupuncture still doesn’t
                                      work

                                  David Gorski

                                      Link

I don’t recall if I’ve mentioned it on SBM before, but I went to the University 
of Michigan. In fact, I didn’t go there just for undergraduate studies or
medical school, but rather for both, graduating with a B.S. in Chemistry with
Honors in 1984 and from medical school in 1988. In my eight years in Ann Arbor, 
I came to love the place, and I still have an affinity for it, even though it’s 
been over 20 years since I last walked about the campus as a student, although I
have been back from time to time for various functions, most recently to see
Brian Deer speak last winter. True, I’m not fanatical about it, as some of my
contemporaries and friends who attened U. of M. with me back in the 1980s (and, 
sadly, the string of losses to Ohio State and the definitively mediocre last
season Michigan had last year make it very hard to be a Michigan football fan
these days). However, I do have considerable affection for the place. It molded 
me, trained me in science, taught me medicine, and provided me the basis for
everything I do professionally today.

I mention all of this because I’ve become very disappointed with the University 
of Michigan Medical School of late. The reason is that it’s “distinguished
itself” as a leading institution teaching and promoting the mish-mash of
sometimes mutually contradictory modalities, the vast majority of which are
either based on mysticism or pseudoscience, known commonly as either
“complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” (IM).
The University of Michigan Integrative Medicine Program (UMIM) describes itself 
thusly:

   University of Michigan Integrative Medicine, an interdisciplinary program, is
   committed to the thoughtful and compassionate integration of complementary
   therapies and conventional medicine through the activities of research,
   education, clinical services and community partnerships. As a
   healing-oriented approach to medical care, integrative medicine takes into
   account the whole person (body, mind, spirit and emotion), including all
   aspects of lifestyle.

   The vision, mission and values of the University of Michigan Integrative
   Medicine (UMIM) program reflect our belief that patients and our community
   are best served when all available therapies are considered in concert with
   an approach that recognizes the intrinsic wholeness of each individual. It
   also reflects our belief that the best medicine is practiced in collaboration
   with a wide variety of healthcare professionals and with our patients.

Alas, my alma mater could well be featured in Kim’s old feature, the Weekly
Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo (W5). Indeed, look at the medical student
curriculum supported by this program:

   Supported by a five-year grant from the National Institutes of Health (NIH), 
   University of Michigan Integrative Medicine (UMIM) piloted its first
   Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) courses for medical students
   during the Fall Term of 2000. A unique aspect of the CAM course sequence is
   that it is longitudinal, extending across the entire four-year U-M Medical
   School curriculum.

   To date, implementation of the curriculum has involved the participation of
   approximately 600 undergraduate medical students and 200
   physicians/practitioners. Instruction has touched upon the following five CAM
   domains as identified by the National Center for Complementary and
   Alternative Medicine (NCCAM):

  1. Alternative medical systems

  2. Mind-body interventions

  3. Biologically based therapies

  4. Manipulative and body-based methods

  5. Energy therapies

Energy therapies? As you can see my alma mater, my beloved U. of M., appears to 
have wholeheartedly embraced what Dr. Robert Donnell has referred to as
“quackademic medicine.” Indeed, it now has a fellowship in IM that is described 
thusly:

   Fellows design elective experiences in integrative medicine using resources
   found within the university health care system. Topics may include (but are
   not limited to): Aromatherapy, Health System Management, Herbal Therapies,
   Holistic Nutrition, Integrative Pharmacy, Manipulative Therapies, Mind-Body
   Medicine, and Naturopathic Medicine. Fellows also participate in weekly
   formal learning activities through U-M Integrative Medicine and the
   Department of Family Medicine.

   Financial support is provided to achieve competency in one defined core
   curricular area.

   [...]

   Graduates of this program will model best practices in integrative health
   care by embracing healing-oriented medicine that takes into account the whole
   person (body, mind and spirit), including all aspects of lifestyle. This
   philosophy emphasizes therapeutic relationships and recognizes use of all
   appropriate therapies, both conventional and alternative.

W5 indeed. Notice how no mention is made of science or the scientific basis of
any of these therapies. To read the educational objectives is to see just how
little science matters in IM.

All of this is yet another in the series of my characteristically
self-indulgently logorrheic introductions to an analysis of a study. It turns
out that U. of M. is trying to do something resembling science about CAM. The
problem is that, like many investigators and universities do, it’s falling for
the same problems and fallacies when true believers try to do what Harriet Hall 
has so delightfully termed “Tooth Fairy science.” I never thought I’d be saying 
it, but it looks as though my alma mater is doing a bit of the ol’ Tooth Fairy
science. Several readers sent me this study, and, since it came from U. of M., I
figured it falls upon me, among the SBM bloggers, to take it on. Let us start
with how I found out about this study, a credulous article published last week
and entitled Acupuncture boosts effects of painkillers, natural or prescription:

   High-tech images of the brains of chronic pain sufferers have found that the 
   ancient practice of acupuncture fights pain by making key brain cells more
   sensitive to the pain-dampening effects of opioid chemicals. The study,
   published online in the August issue of the journal NeuroImage, comes less
   than a year after the publication of a controversial study that concluded
   acupuncture was no more effective than sham treatment at reducing pain.

   Researchers at the University of Michigan’s Chronic Pain and Fatigue Research
   Center used a positron emission tomography (PET) scanner to view the brains 
   of 20 women diagnosed with fibromyalgia who reported suffering nerve and
   muscle pain at least 50% of the time. The PET scans were conducted during
   each woman’s first acupuncture session and, a month later, her eighth.

   In the regions of the brain that process and dampen pain signals — the
   amygdala, caudate, cingula, thalamus and insula — the PET scans showed an
   increase in the receptivity — and possibly the number — of brain cells to
   which opioid substances bind. Study author Richard E. Harris said that
   suggests that acupuncture appears to make the body more responsive to opioid 
   painkillers.

It turns out that Dr. Harris is not only a molecular biologist but a licensed
acupuncturist, which goes to show just how much people can compartmentalize
science and belief, walling them off from each other. There are, not
unexpectedly, methodological problems with this article that render its
conclusions questionable, but in reality it’s more a problem of interpretation. 
There’s a famous line from The Princess Bride, where the character Inigo Montoya
says of a word, “I do not think it means what you think it means.” In the case 
of this study, I would paraphrase that famous line to say, “I do not think your 
results mean what you think they mean.” Here’s why.

Harris acknowledges up front that several studies have now shown acupuncture to 
be no more efficacious than sham acupuncture. Indeed, we have written about such
studies right here on SBM that show that acupuncture is no more effective than 
sham acupuncture. It doesn’t matter if the sham acupuncture is needles inserted 
in the “wrong” acupuncture points or fake needles that do not penetrate the skin
or even toothpicks. The most reasonable scientific conclusion from all of these
studies is that acupuncture, as practiced by adherents of traditional Chinese
medicine, does not work. At the very best, it’s a nonspecific effect that
doesn’t rely on anything resembling a system. More likely, acupuncture is
nothing more than an elaborate placebo. None of this, however, stops Harris’
group from trying to show that there is a different between sham acupuncture and
real acupuncture at some sort of level, and this study is their attempt to do
just that. Here is the background as Harris states it in the introduction to his
study, entitled Traditional Chinese acupuncture and placebo (sham) acupuncture 
are differentiated by their effects on μ-opioid receptors (MORs):

   Recent controversy in the field of acupuncture research was generated when
   several large scale randomized controlled trials in chronic pain patients
   failed to show superiority of acupuncture over sham acupuncture methods
   (Brinkhaus et al., 2006; Linde et al., 2005; Melchart et al., 2005; Harris et
   al., 2005). This has lead opponents of acupuncture therapy to suggest that
   it is no more effective than a placebo intervention. Since placebo
   administration also induces activation of opioid receptors, specifically the 
   μ-opioid receptor (MOR) class (Benedetti and Amanzio, 1997; Zubieta et al.,
   2005; Amanzio and Benedetti, 1999; Levine et al., 1978; Pomeranz and Chiu,
   1976), acupuncture may indeed operate in part via placebo mechanisms.

There’s almost certainly no “may” about it, and you can also almost certainly
safely scratch “in part,” but that’s just me being a nasty skeptic or, as I like
to think, a good scientist. I also find it curious why Harris would refer to
investigators who are telling it like it is, so to speak, and pointing out
accurately what these studies show “opponents” of acupuncture. It suggests a bit
of an adversarial, defensive, “I’ll show you” mindset right from the start.

Be that as it may, the hypothesis to be studied is that long term acupuncture
therapy somehow results in increased μ-opioid receptor availability and that
this effect would not be seen in a sham acupuncture group. Harris chose
fibromyalgia (FM) patients for his study because previous work of his had shown 
that FM patients have reduced central μ-opioid receptor (MOR) binding potential.
In that study patients with greater clinical pain were found to have reduced
MOR binding potential, and Dr. Harris wondered if acupuncture could somehow
increase that binding potential and thus relieve pain. Thus, this study is the
classic example of a researcher taking a technique developed for the study of
one question and applying it to another question, and what Harris asks is
whether acupuncture and sham acupuncture have different (or any) effects on
these receptors. Specifically, the technique used is positron emission
tomography (PET) designed to look at the binding of opioids to these receptors
using 11C-carfentanil (CFN) positron emission tomography (PET) with the μ-opioid
selective radiotracer [11C]carfentanil.

The study involved randomizing 20 women with FM into one of two groups, either
sham acupuncture or “real” acupuncture. Subjects were blinded to which group
they were in, but investigators were not, and a questionnaire was given to see
if patients could guess what group they were in. The results in each group were 
no more accurate than random chance, suggesting that patient blinding, at least,
was good. It was not clear to me, however, from the text whether those who were
evaluating the PET scans were also blinded to which experimental group each
patient was in. That is such a mind-numbingly obviously necessary part of
designing any imaging experiment such as this that I will assume that the
physicians reading the scans were in fact blinded to what experimental group
each scan came from, but it’s disturbing that this very basic experimental
design point wasn’t explicitly stated anywhere. Also, it’s clear that the
investigators doing the acupuncture or sham acupuncture were not blinded. There 
are now retractable sham needles available that do a pretty good job of hiding
from even acupuncturists whether a real needle went in or not; I wonder why
those weren’t used.

In any case, there were no significant differences between the groups with
respect to demographics or initial pain scores, and patients were excluded who: 
had previous experience with acupuncture; had current use or a history of use of
opioid or narcotic analgesics; had a history of substance abuse; had the
presence of a known coagulation abnormality, thrombocytopenia, or bleeding
diathesis that may preclude the safe use of acupuncture; had the presence of
concurrent autoimmune or inflammatory disease; had concurrent participation in
other therapeutic trials; were pregnant and nursing mothers; had severe
psychiatric illnesses; or had contraindications to PET. Outcome measures
included clinical pain scores using the Short Form of the McGill Pain
Questionnaire and measures of μ-opioid binding.

As in many other studies of acupuncture versus sham acupuncture, non-insertional
sham needles were used for the sham acupuncture procedure. Patients underwent a
total of nine acupuncture or sham acupuncture treatments over the course of a
month, undergoing PET scans at treatment #1 and tretament #9. At each of the two
PET sessions, study participants first underwent a baseline scan for minutes
10-40 after infusion of the radiotracer, then the acupuncture or sham procedure,
then another scan at 45-90 minutes. The researchers reported both short term
increases in μ-opioid binding in various parts of the brain involved in sensory 
processing, including the cingulate, amygdala, insula, thalamus, and caudate.
Longer term increases in MOR binding were also observed in a subset of the same 
structures, including the cingulate, caudate, and amygdala. There were no such
increases in the sham acupuncture group, and in some regions small reductions of
MOR binding were observed. Consistent with the other acupuncture studies that
Harris mentioned, there was no difference in pain scores between the sham and
“true” acupuncture groups.

Well, at least that much is consistent with previous results.

Here’s one big problem with this study. Needles were retained for the
acupuncture group, but there were no needles in the sham acupuncture group
because no needles had been inserted. It’s not clear to me from the methods
whether the sham needles were left attached to the skin or not. Even if the
subject were blindfolded, as these subjects were, I would think that would be
very important in order to make the groups as much “alike” as possible. Whatever
the true case was, the fact remains that, during the second PET scan period
there was a definite difference between the two groups. The “true acupuncture”
group had needles sticking into their skin at acupuncture points. The sham
acupuncture group did not. Couldn’t that more or less completely explain the
short term results? In essence, what Harris studied was differences in
neurobiology between subjects who had needles sticking out of their skin and
those who did not.

Here’s the second big problem. Take a look at this figure, which is Figure 1B
from the paper:

Notice something? The “true acupuncture” (left side, in red) procedure is not
only different from the sham in that the sham doesn’t actually insert any
needles. It uses different locations! The text calls them “similar” because they
are in the same body part. Not how, for example, sham point #1 is on the head, 
but not in the same location as Du 20); sham point #2 is on the ear but on the
earlobe instead of the pinna; sham point #3 is on the anterior surface of the
right arm instead of the posterior surface of the left arm; most of the sham
points in the leg are on the thigh, rather than the lower leg, where the “true” 
acupuncture points are.

Does anyone see a problem with this?

I do. In designing a good placebo control for an acupuncture study (or any other
randomized clinical study), you shouldn’t, if you can possibly help it, mix and
match changes in the procedure to produce your sham procedure. When you choose 
a sham acupuncture procedure, either insert the needles as usual in the “wrong” 
places or use the sham needles that don’t pierce the skin in the “right” places.
Or have two groups and compare both. Don’t place sham needles that don’t pierce
the skin in the “wrong” places. That’s two differences between the sham
procedure and acupuncture and opens the door to a lot of confounders. Again,
couldn’t this using a sham procedure that uses the “wrong” points and needles
that don’t pierce the skin also partially explain the results of this study?
Couldn’t the combination of using different locations and no insertion for the
sham confound the results sufficiently as to render the results of this study
virtually meaningless. I argue that they potentially can. I can’t prove it, but 
certainly the methodological shortcomings of this trial make it hard to take as 
any definitive evidence that there is different neurobiology going on between
real acupuncture and sham acupuncture. All it does is to show that maybe there
is a neurobiological difference between having needles sticking out of the skin 
and not having needles sticking out of the skin, which would be of little
surprise, although the exact difference could be of interest. What this study
does not show is that acupuncture “works.” I suppose it’s possible that sticking
needles in the skin may have nonspecific effects that might alleviate pain, but
this very study shows that they are no different than placebo. After all, there
was no difference in pain relief between subjects receiving sham acupuncture
and real acupuncture. Both experienced the same amount of subjective pain
relief!

Not that that stops Harris from trying to imply that sham and true acupuncture
“work” through different mechanisms:

   Another intriguing result from the present study is that although MOR BP
   values were differentially altered by TA and SA, reduction in clinical pain
   was similar between groups. In a clinical trial, when an active treatment
   does not exhibit superior efficacy to a sham or placebo, the active treatment
   is assumed to be ineffective and only operating via a placebo effect.
   However this study suggests that this may be an erroneous conclusion. In this
   instance, our non-insertion sham procedure evoked a similar reduction in
   pain as our true acupuncture and we speculate that this occurred via a
   different mechanism. The analgesic effects of SA could have been due to
   regional reductions in MOR BP, consistent with activation of this class of
   receptors during placebo effects (Zubieta et al., 2005), whereas TA evoked an
   increase in receptor binding availability.

Alternatively, the perceived pain relief accorded by sham acupuncture and true
acupuncture could be occurring by placebo mechanisms entirely unrelated to the
observation of this study, which may have had nothing to do with the clinical
placebo effects seen. That’s a rather more simple explanation for these results 
than all that handwaving (and, yes, it is mostly handwaving) in the paragraph
above. I’m rather surprised the reviewers didn’t make Harris revise his
manuscript to consider this possibility and discuss it. Harris could be correct.
I doubt that he is, but he could be. However, my alternate explanation could
also be correct. Moreover, even if he is correct, so what? It might be
intellectually interesting and useful for understanding the placebo effect to
determine the differences in neurobiology underlying two different placebo
treatments, but none of this validates acupuncture as anything more than an
elaborate placebo. It’s also a long run for a short slide, so to speak, in that 
nine sessions in a month of sticking needles into the body seems a lot to
undergo for such minimal results based on such tenuous mechanisms.

It’s also depressing to see how the press has spun this study. Reports on the
study are more or less reporting it exactly as Harris represented his results in
the Discussion section of his paper. I have yet to see a news story with
anything more than a very token skeptical view. Instead, they all proclaim this 
study as evidence that acupuncture can somehow crank up the level of opioid
receptors to the point where they make opioid drugs work better. Heck, the
article I cited said that this study shows that acupuncture can increase the
efficacy of opioid analgesics, either natural or prescription! There’s zero
evidence presented in this paper that shows that.

This paper represents to me the latest in a line of rationalizations of
acupuncture. Acupuncturists start out saying that “acupuncture works” based on
nonblinded studies for which placebo effects are not adequately controlled for. 
Then, when better studies show that true acupuncture is no better than sham
acupuncture (or, amusingly, sometimes that the sham acupuncture “works” better),
they rationalize it by saying either that the sham was not a good sham or that 
these studies don’t say anything because sham acupuncture “works” too. Harris
takes a different tack in saying that, yes, there’s no difference in perceived
pain due to sham acupuncture or true acupuncture not only because they both work
but because they both work by different physiological mechanisms. He might have
had a (weak) point were it not for his seemingly willful misinterpretation of
his results and his changing too many things at the same time in his sham
control group. Instead, all he’s shown is that opioid receptors light up more if
there are needles in the skin than they do if there are not–hardly a finding
that shows that acupuncture “works” and certainly not any sort of finding to
validate the entire system of acupuncture, which relies upon the idea of qi
flowing through meridians, flows that can be altered to therapeutic effect by
sticking needles into those meridians.

“I do not think your results mean what you think they mean,” indeed.

REFERENCE:

Harris, R., Zubieta, J., Scott, D., Napadow, V., Gracely, R., & Clauw, D.
(2009). Traditional Chinese acupuncture and placebo (sham) acupuncture are
differentiated by their effects on μ-opioid receptors (MORs) NeuroImage, 47 (3),
1077-1085 DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2009.05.083

               Potential New Mechanism of Pain Relief Discovered

                                 Steven Novella

                                      Link

The development of drugs and other treatments for specific symptoms or
conditions relies heavily on either serendipity (the chance finding of a
beneficial effect) or on an understanding of underlying mechanisms. In pain, for
example, there are limited ways in which we can block pain signals – such as
activating opiate receptors or inhibiting prostaglandins. There are only so many
ways in which you can interact with these systems. The discovery of a novel
mechanism of modulating pain is therefore most welcome, and has the potential of
leading to entirely new treatments that may have better side-effect profiles
than existing treatments and also have additive clinical effects.

A recent study by Nana Goldman et. al., published in Nature Neuroscience, adds
to our understanding of pain relief by identifying the role of adenosine in
reducing pain activity in the peripheral nervous system. The researchers, in a
nice series of experiments, demonstrated that producing a local painful stimulus
in mice causes the local release of ATP (adenosine triphosphate) that peaks at 
about 30 minutes. This correlates with a decreased pain response in the mice.
Further, if drugs are given that prolong the effect of adenosine, the analgesic 
effect itself is prolonged.

Also, if drugs are given that activate the adenosine A1 receptor, the observed
analgesic effect is replicated. When these experiments are replicated in
knockout mice that do not have the gene for the adenosine A1 receptor, there is 
no observed analgesic effect.

Together these experiments are fairly solid evidence that local pain results in 
the local release of adenosine that in turn binds to the adenosine A1 receptor
inhibiting the pain response. This is potentially very exciting – it should lead
to further investigation of the adenosine A1 receptor and the effects of
activating and inhibiting it. This may lead to the development of drugs or other
interventions that activate these receptors and may ultimately be a very useful
addition to our ability to treat acute and chronic pain.

Now Comes the Spin

In a rational science-based world, the above would be the end of this blog
entry. But that is not the world we currently live in. In this study, the chosen
method of provoking pain was the insertion of an acupuncture needle into the
“Zusanli point” of the lower extremity and rotating it. This allowed the authors
of this study to spin the results as if they were validation for acupuncture
itself – and the mainstream press dutifully followed suit.

The introduction to this study is an apology for acupuncture itself, and sets
the tone for the rest of the paper as well as the press release and comments to 
follow:

   Acupuncture is a procedure in which fine needles are inserted into an
   individual at discrete points and then manipulated, with the intent of
   relieving pain. Since its development in China around 2,000 B.C., acupuncture
   has become worldwide in its practice. Although Western medicine has treated 
   acupuncture with considerable skepticism, a broader worldwide population has 
   granted it acceptance. For instance, the World Health Organization endorses
   acupuncture for at least two dozen conditions and the US National Institutes 
   of Health issued a consensus statement proposing acupuncture as a therapeutic
   intervention for complementary medicine. Perhaps most tellingly, the U.S.
   Internal Revenue Service approved acupuncture as a deductible medical expense
   in 1973.

That this paragraph appears in a high-impact peer-reviewed journal is very
curious (to put it mildly). It is full of misinformation and logical fallacies. 
Acupuncture is used for more than pain relief, and so making statements about
the efficacy of “acupuncture” go way beyond the scope of this study, which
involves only pain. The authors should have specifically pointed out that this
study cannot be used to explain any indication for acupuncture that does not
involve local pain relief. Acupuncture as it was practiced in China 4,000 years 
ago bears little resemblance to what is practiced today, and may have been more 
of a form a bloodletting.

The authors then make a false dichotomy between “Western medicine” and,
presumably, “Eastern medicine” – which is an anti-scientific and culturally
bigoted point of view. This is followed by an argument from popularity, and a
particularly bizarre argument from authority – noting that the IRS accepts
acupuncture as a medical expense. I was unaware that the IRS is a scientific
medical organization.

The authors also fail to put this study into its proper context by reviewing
existing evidence – the more traditional use of the introduction to
peer-reviewed research. The clinical research on acupuncture, which is quite
extensive, finds that any measured symptomatic effect is almost certainly due
mostly or entirely to placebo effects. Further, it does not matter where you
stick the acupuncture needle, nor even if you do not stick the needle through
the skin. Twisting toothpicks against the skin in random locations has the same 
effect.

My interpretation of the research is that acupuncture (placing needles at
specific acupuncture points to manipulate chi) does not work. There may,
however, be non-specific physiological responses to the mechanical stimulation
of sticking needles at random locations, or just poking toothpicks. This study, 
if anything, supports this interpretation – it, in fact, has identified a local 
mechanism of analgesia that can help explain a non-specific response to
acupuncture, sham acupuncture, or placebo acupuncture and therefore is
consistent with the clinical evidence showing no difference among these
interventions.

This is also not the first study to identify potential local mechanisms of pain 
relief from mechanical stimulation. A 2002 study correlated insertional activity
(depolarization of muscle fibers in response to needle insertion) or electrical
stimulation with pain relief. This would explain why, in this study, constant
twisting of the needle was needed to provoke pain relief – perhaps insertional
muscle activity is needed to release adenosine, or increases its release.

By focusing on what is really going on here we can best understand how to
develop methods to capitalize on these local mechanisms optimally for pain
relief. It must be noted, however, that needle insertion gives very unimpressive
results in clinical trials. It may be that the effect is too temporary to be
worthwhile, at least as mechanically provoked – pharmacologically activating the
adenosine A1 receptor may be a better strategy. Also, it is very difficult to
extrapolate from mouse data as the subjects are much smaller than humans, and
therefore their nerves and motor end-plates (the locations where the nerves
innervate the muscles) are much closer together and superficial – closer to the 
skin.

Mechanisms are interesting, but net clinical outcomes in humans are the only
kind of scientific data that really tells us if a modality works or not.

Conclusion

Finally, it has to be emphasized that this study says nothing about acupuncture 
itself, except for providing a possible mechanism for a non-specific local
response. The term “acupuncture,” in fact, is becoming increasingly problematic 
and is confusing the scientific literature, not to mention the public. What is
acupuncture? If we use the term broadly enough to mean any use of needles, with 
or without electrical stimulation, at any points, with or without skin
penetration, etc. then the term is too broad to be useful. If we use the term
narrowly – to mean sticking needles to a certain depth in specific acupuncture
points that work through a novel mechanism specific to those locations, then we 
can say, based upon extensive research, that “acupuncture” does not work and its
proposed underlying mechanisms are nothing more than pre-scientific
superstition.

This study is an excellent example of the mischief caused by confusing the
non-specific use of the term “acupuncture” with its more traditional use.
Research involving acupuncture in its vaguest sense is used to promote
“acupuncture” in the traditional sense. This is highly deceptive and
scientifically sloppy.

The researchers of this current study could have used other controls to see if
the effect they discovered is in any way specific to any acupuncture variables. 
For example – they could have used a non-acupuncture point as a control, or
other forms of mechanical pain production that do not involve needles. I suspect
any local pain production or mechanical trauma beyond a certain threshold would
result in the same adenosine response – which certainly seems like a
non-specific mechanism to modulate pain.

Because the authors did not do this, they did not actually research
“acupuncture”. The description of this research in the published paper and in
the press should have been as I discussed in the opening of this post. Instead, 
genuinely interesting research that may lead to novel pain treatments is being
diverted as propaganda for an ancient superstition.

                         Acupuncture and Acoustic Waves

                                Steven Novella 

                                      Link

Here is yet another study claiming to show “how acupuncture works” when in fact 
it does nothing of the kind. It does, however, reveal the bias of the
researchers – it is, in fact, surprising that it was published in a
peer-reviewed journal. Unfortunately, the mainstream media is dutifully
reporting the biased claims of the researchers without any independent
verification or analysis.

There are numerous fatal problems with this study. The first, like in many
physiological studies that purport to be about acupuncture, is that the
connection to acupuncture is tenuous. The researchers claim that they are
testing the effects of an acupuncture needle – but what makes a needle an
acupuncture needle? Other such studies were ultimately just seeing the effects
of local tissue trauma. The fact that this trauma was induced by an “acupuncture
needle” is not necessarily relevant.

This study is far worse, because it is simply using the acupuncture needle as a 
mechanism for inducing an unrelated physiological stimulus. This is similar to
“electroacupuncture” where electrical current is applied through an acupuncture 
needle – what you are actually studying is the effects of electricity, not
“acupuncture.” Applying electrical stimulation, or some other physiological
stimulus, is the equivalent of injecting morphine through a thin needle and then
claiming this demonstrates how “acupuncture works.”

This is the most significant fatal flaw of this study. What the researchers did 
was use an”acupuncture needle” (i.e. a needle) to apply a mechanical vibration
(through a piezoelectrical device – one that converts electricity to mechanical 
force, or vice versa) to the tissue. They justify this procedure by likening the
vibration to manual manipulation that acupuncturists will do to the needle
after insertion.

However – they were vibrating the needle at up to 50 hz – 50 times per second.
There own data shows that low frequencies have no physiological effect.
Essentially the researchers were measuring acoustic shear waves (ASW) in the
tissue in response to this vibration. This is less than shocking – vibrational
waves in tissue in response to vibration. But they also measured the release of 
calcium by the cells. They argue that the ASW cause the local cells to release
calcium which then in turn triggers the release of endorphins – and that’s how
acupuncture works.

What they actually showed, if anything, is that acupuncture does not work
through this mechanism. They proved the opposite of what they claim, because
their own data shows that the calcium release is present at 40hz, it is barely
present at 20hz, and completely absent at 10hz and 5hz. So, to be generous,
unless the acupuncturist is continuously vibrating the needle at 20 times per
second, the physiological mechanism they are seeing is not relevant. It’s
impossible, using just your hands, to vibrate a needle at 20hz. Further –
acupuncturists don’t vibrate the needle, they may twist them or move them up and
down, but not at anything approaching 20hz. The authors themselves state:

   In studying acupuncture, an important and frequently overlooked procedure is 
   the manual needle manipulation performed by acupuncturists after needle
   insertion. The needle manipulations are typically a series of rapid
   bidirectional rotation or up-and-down piston movements.

The authors failed in the most basic sense to demonstrate that their
physiological model is at all relevant to acupuncture; they failed to note the
relevance of the frequency of the vibrations they were using or the plausibility
that this relates to the “rapid” movements of the needle that acupuncturists
sometimes make.

It should be further noted that in clinical studies the movement of the needle
by the acupuncturist, when controlled for, does not contribute to a measured
clinical effect. The effect of the needle movement is the major premise of this 
research, and yet it does not appear to be true.

The study also looked at the acoustic waves themselves and claim that they were 
more pronounced when the needle was inserted at an acupuncture point than when
at a non-acupoint. I find this result frankly unbelievable. A review of the
research does not support the notion that acupuncture points or meridians exist.
Further, the clinical research shows that there is no difference in effect
between needling acupuncture points or non-points (sham vs “true” acupuncture). 
About this the authors write:

   Along with it is a system of tracks called meridians by the practitioners but
   invisible anatomically.

By “invisible anatomically” they mean – there is no evidence they exist.
Meridians are the floating, invisible heatless dragons of Carl Sagan.

The fact that these researchers found results that depend on the existence of
acupuncture points seriously calls into question their methods. Their results
should be viewed as the equivalent of N-rays or Bem’s future cognition results –
likely artifacts of sloppy research and researcher bias.

It should also be noted that this study did not even look at clinical effects
from acupuncture, so they were unable to correlate any of the physiological
parameters they were looking at with any putative effect. Therefore there are
good reasons for thinking the effects they are seeing are not relevant to
acupuncture, and the researchers provide no evidence that they are.

The flaws outlined above are enough to render this study useless as support for 
acupuncture, but I think it’s also worthwhile to consider the bias of the
researchers. I usually don’t spend time doing this, but there are a few points
worth making with respect to this study. This study comes out of Hong Kong.
There is a Columbia University author, but he is a non-MD electrical engineer
who provided only technical assistance, and is not a medical researcher. This is
relevant because a prior review of acupuncture research published in 1998
showed that 100% of the acupuncture studies coming out of Hong Kong (and several
Asian countries) were positive. This is in stark contrast to acupuncture
studies from the West or overall.

The most reasonable conclusion to draw from this is that there is extreme
researcher and/or publication bias in these countries. Proponents might argue
that Asian researchers know how to do acupuncture properly, but that explanation
is not credible, and doesn’t apply to physiological studies like the current
one.

I also note that one of the lead authors, Siu Kam Lam, was convicted of stealing
3.8 million dollars in donations while in public office and served jail time
for this crime. Facts like this are always difficult to deal with. Withholding
this information from this article seems like an omission, as this might be
relevant in putting the honesty of the researchers into context. But it can also
be interpreted as poisoning the well. In any case – I see it as full
disclosure, and the reader can make of it what they will.

I will also note that the authors, in their introduction, give a glowing review 
of acupuncture, and shamelessly cherry pick the evidence to make it seem as if
there is good published support for acupuncture. The opposite is true –
systematic reviews show that there is no specific effect from acupuncture. It is
nothing more than a ritualized placebo.

Conclusion

There is no evidence for any of the underlying claims of acupuncture – not even 
the existence of acupuncture points. The clinical research shows that
acupuncture does not work – in other words, that it does not matter where or
even if you stick the needles. Acupuncture is a placebo treatment.

Acupuncture proponents, however, continue to study the non-specific local
physiological effects of sticking needles into tissue, and often even producing 
a physiological stimulus through the needle that has nothing to do with how
acupuncture is practiced. They then claim that “finally” they have discovered
how acupuncture works – begging the question of if acupuncture works.

This current study is no exception. But interestingly, this study may be the
first that actually proved that they found a mechanism by which acupuncture
cannot work. The effect they found was only present when the needle was vibrated
at 20hz or more – something which is not done and seems impossible for the
acupuncturist to achieve.

                         The Hazards of “CAM”-Pandering

                                 Kimball Atwood

                                      Link

Steven Salzberg, a friend of this blog and Director of the Center for
Bioinformatics and Computational Biology at the University of Maryland, is on
the editorial boards of three of the many journals published by BioMed Central
(BMC), an important source of open-access, peer-reviewed biomedical reports. He 
is disturbed by the presence of two other journals under the BMC umbrella:
Chinese Medicine and BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine. A couple of
days ago, on his Forbes science blog, Dr. Salzberg explained why. Here are some 
excerpts:

   The Chinese Medicine journal promotes, according to its own mission
   statement, studies of “acupuncture, Tui-na, Qi-qong, Tai Chi Quan, energy
   research,” and other nonsense. Tui na, for example, supposedly “affects the
   flow of energy by holding and pressing the body at acupressure points.”

   Right. What is this doing in a scientific journal?… I support BMC…But
   their corporate leaders seem to care more about expanding their stable than
   about maintaining the integrity of science. Chinese Medicine simply does not 
   belong in the company of respectable scientific journals.

   Forming a scientific journal whose goal is to validate antiquated,
   unproven superstitions is simply not science, whatever the editors of Chinese
   Medicine claim.

   BMC should be embarrassed to be publishing journals that promote
   anti-scientific theories and otherwise muddy the literature. By supporting
   these journals, they undermine the credibility of many excellent BMC
   journals. They should cut these journals loose.

Matthew Cockerill, a molecular biologist and self-described skeptic who is
Managing Director of BMC, responded. Quoting Tim Minchin’s poem Storm (“You know
what they call alternative medicine that’s been proved to work?…Medicine”), he 
wrote:

   Well-known examples of “alternative medicines” that have made the
   transition to “medicine” include aspirin (explicitly cited in ‘Storm’) and
   artemisinin, a compound identified in a type of traditional Chinese herbal
   medicine, derivatives of which are now used to treat malaria.

   Clearly for this transition to be possible, there must be a way for
   effective aspects of Complementary/Alternative Medicine (CAM) to prove
   themselves and to become “Medicine”. Journals focused on evaluating CAM are
   not the only approach to doing this (such research might also be published in
   a regular medical journal), but they are one valid approach…

   … Regular medical journals may tend to be dismissive of anything with
   CAM-associations…

In a second comment (which at the time of this writing is unavailable, but Dr.
Salzberg sent me a copy) Dr. Cockerill continued:

   Steven,

   In your post you suggest that journals relating to
   complementary/alternative medicine (CAM) including Traditional Chinese
   Medicine have no place in BioMed Central’s portfolio, and your broader
   implication is that these fields represent nothing but pseudoscience and are 
   unworthy of (or indeed are incompatible with) scientific investigation.

   BioMed Central does not share this view. We accept that this is a
   challenging and controversial area, and that one of the problems to be
   addressed is that much CAM research is lacking in scientific rigor. However, 
   to dismiss all aspects of CAM out-of-hand and to exclude research on CAM from
   scientific discourse would only give ammunition to those who try to
   characterize the scientific process as being close-minded and based on
   presumptions which are not open to question.

   You refer to BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine as a
   “pseudoscience journal” which “promote[s] anti-scientific theories”, but this
   is really not the case.

Dr. Cockerill argued that standards of peer-review and methodological rigor for 
that journal are not different from those for the rest of the BMC group. He
named Edzard Ernst as a member of the editorial board. More:

Moving to the field of Traditional Chinese Medicine – while it is true that 
there are some aspects of TCM as traditionally practiced that are likely to hold
only anthropological/psychological interest from a scientific point of view, it
is also clear that there are many active ingredients in traditional Chinese
Herbal Medicine (CHM) which are worthy of further investigation in terms of
biological mechanism and clinical effectiveness. This is an area that has
attracted significant funding from commercial and public sources – see for
example this article from Science magazine in 2003.
http://www.sciencemag.org/content/299/5604/188.long

Looking at articles published in the journal Chinese Medicine, the
evaluation of active components within herbal remedies accounts for a large
fraction of research articles published, and this cannot easily be dismissed as 
either irrelevant or inherently pseudoscientific.

In an earlier email to Steven Salzberg, Dr. Cockerill had written:

   The major problem I have with such a blanket dismissal is that it lumps
   everything together as being equally valueless, whereas the goal of the
   scientific process is to winnow the wheat (however rare) from the chaff…

   If you look at articles published in Chinese Medicine, you will find
   little if anything on “Energy fields” (not a fruitful area for scientific
   investigation, I quite agree, and not something which I believe should be in 
   the scope of the journal), but a great deal on biochemical and functional
   genomic work in relation to traditional herbal medicine, which is quite a
   different matter.

Bait and Switch: the Yin and the Yang

Sigh. Where to begin? Let’s start by trying a slight revision of Dr. Cockerill’s
own words: The major problem I have with such a blanket acceptance is that it
lumps everything together as being equally valuable, whereas the goal of the
scientific process is to winnow the wheat (however rare) from the chaff…

That’s more like it. I imagine that Dr. Cockerill will find that statement
unfair, in that it fails to acknowledge that there may be reports in the two
journals that disconfirm hypotheses that are not fruitful for scientific
investigation (if you catch my drift). I concede that, but the point here is a
different one: Dr. Salzberg objects to including anti-scientific topics in the
journals precisely because doing so gives the appearance that real scientists
believe that they must be intriguing enough to warrant space in real biomedical 
journals.

But they are not: it is clear, after a moment’s reflection, that natural
products research is the ONLY worthwhile scientific endeavor within the
editorial purview of Chinese Medicine, so why pretend that it justifies the
rest? Matthew Cockerill may agree that “energy fields” should not be included;
nevertheless they are—which was Dr. Salzberg’s point. Tim Minchin, bless his
heart, probably doesn’t realize that his statement about “alternative medicine
that’s been proved to work” is itself purely hypothetical: there has yet to be
an example of such a medicine. Dr. Cockerill ought to know that, as I will
explain a bit later in this piece.

An Article Brings Homeopathy to Mind

I have little time to investigate the non-[natural products pharmacology]
articles in Chinese Medicine; Dr. Salzberg cited one, which he characterized as 
“a laughably bad study.” I’ll tell you a bit about another, just published in
January:

Misdiagnosis and undiagnosis due to pattern similarity in Chinese medicine: a
stochastic simulation study using pattern differentiation algorithm

The article is nearly incoherent. Passages such as this abound:

   In Chinese medicine, diagnosis is also important. Practitioners recognise
   and label nosological conditions based on inspection (Ip, wang),
   auscultation and olfaction (AO, wen), inquiry (Iq, wen) and palpation (P,
   qie), also known as the Four Examinations (Sizhen). According to traditional 
   literature, these methods should be applied in order to enhance recovery of
   the patients. Manifestations (ie signs and symptoms) collected from patients 
   are interpreted using Chinese medicine theories (eg eight principles, five
   phases, vital substances, six channels, four levels, triple burner and
   Zangfu), which were developed on the basis of some observations of Nature.
   Similar to Western medicine, the collected manifestations are interpreted
   collectively; however, diagnosis is established through a pattern
   differentiation process whereby a unique, stable manifestation profile is
   obtained for the identification of a pattern among other diagnostic
   hypotheses.

The article appears to torture statistics to show that each additional
Examination among the Four confers a slightly greater degree of certainty that
the examiner will not confuse two different “diagnoses” (in the TCM sense of the
term). At least I think that’s the point. But the investigator didn’t determine
this by testing actual practitioners, as far as I can tell; he did it using “a 
stochastic computational simulation based on Monte Carlo method implemented for 
patient simulation from ZFSP in a dataset.” And a good thing, too, because if
there’s anything useful to be gleaned from this paper, it’s found in references 
19-24. They show, unsurprisingly, that there isn’t much agreement from one TCM
practitioner to the next about either “diagnoses” or treatments.

Hmmm. No surprise when you consider what those diagnoses, i.e., patterns,
involve. Here is the pattern of “Deficient Cold of Small Intestine…often
discussed as Deficient Spleen Qi,” according to Ted Kaptchuk, an American who
seems to have invented the “OMD” degree that won him a professorship at the
Harvard Medical School, and who is on the editorial board of Chinese Medicine:

   Signs: slight, persistent discomfort in lower abdomen; gurgling noises in
   abdomen; watery stools.

   Tongue: pale material; thin white moss

   Pulse: empty

Here is the pattern of “Deficient Cold in Stomach…often called Deficient Spleen 
Yang”:

   Signs: chronic diarrhea; slight persistent pain in epigastrium;
   discomfort relieved by warmth, eating, and touching; shy; easily influenced
   by others

   Tongue: pale material; most white moss

   Pulse: deep or moderate without strength

And so on, for hundreds of patterns. According to Kaptchuk, “pulse examination
can be the most important of the Four Examinations and is crucial to pattern
discernment in general.” Paul Unschuld, a prolific historian of Chinese
medicine, explains how this is done:

   The physician has the choice of either feeling the (radial) pulse with
   three fingers or with one finger. Using three fingers, light pressure with
   the index finger above the imaginary line level with the styloid process
   allows him to feel the state of the lung and heart, greater pressure with the
   middle finger on the imaginary line enables him to feel the state of the
   spleen, and greater pressure still with the ring finger allows him to feel
   the liver and kidney. According to a third (and certainly not the last)
   variant, he can, with one finger, apply a pressure equal to the weight of
   three beans to feel the lung, a pressure of six beans to feel the heart, a
   pressure of nine beans to feel the spleen, a pressure of twelve beans to feel
   the liver, and finally a pressure that brings the fingertip almost to the
   bone, to feel the kidney.

What does “correct” pattern recognition mean, in the practical sense? Well, it
means that the correct therapeutic intervention will occur. Kaptchuk again:

   The goal of all treatment methods in Chinese medicine is to rebalance
   those aspects of the body’s Yin and Yang whose harmonious proportion and
   movement have become disordered…inappropriate anger such as that
   characterized by excessive Liver activity must be calmed…insufficient
   activity, say of the Kidney Yang, must be tonified to avoid lack of sexual
   energy…If there is not enough Qi in the Lungs, it must be replenished…If the 
   Qi in the Spleen descends, causing chronic diarrhea, it must be lifted; if
   the Qi of the stomach ascends, it causing nausea, it must be sent down.
   Stagnant Qi must be moved…Too much Cold in the Kidney must be warmed; extra
   Fire in the Lungs must be cooled. Whatever is out of balance must be
   rebalanced. The complementary aspects of Yin and Yang must be harmonious.

Here’s how it’s done:

   …the insertion of very fine needles into points along the Meridians can
   rebalance bodily disharmonies. A related technique [is] moxibustion…The
   action of the needles or of moxibustion affects the Qi and Blood in the
   Meridians, thus affecting all the fundamental textures and Organs. The
   needles can reduce what is excessive, increase what is deficient, warm what
   is cold, cool what is hot, circulate what is stagnant, move what is
   congealed, stabilize what is reckless, raise what is falling, and lower what 
   is rising.

OK, enough already. Is it not obvious that this is the classic assortment of
metaphors, myths, traditions, and appeals to authority that is common to the
medicine of pre-scientific cultures? Were Chinese medicine theories developed on
the basis of some observations of Nature? I don’t think so.

The claims regarding pulse examination are quite fanciful, to say the least:
that changing the pressure of the examining finger would allow the practitioner 
to feel the state of the various, named organs is hard to conceive, given what
is now known about anatomy and physiology; it’s also clear that pre-modern
Chinese physicians would have had no way test this claim. There is a smattering 
of empirically gathered symptoms and signs that are based on history taking and 
external examinations, some of which are repeatable and might have eventually
become useful, if pre-modern Chinese medicine had pursued anatomy, physiology,
and pathology before those fields were developed elsewhere—thus making that
aspect of “TCM” moot.

Funny: the “patterns” remind me of another conspicuous pre-scientific “school”
of medicine: homeopathy, with its elaborate ‘symptom’-gathering scheme, its
voluminous repertories, rubrics, and simillima. And, of course, its lack of
agreement from one homeopath to the next regarding the ‘correct’ constellation
of ‘symptoms’ and therefore the correct ‘remedy.’

Pharmacognosy is neither “CAM” nor “Chinese Medicine”

Dr. Cockerill’s other points are a mixture of reason and misunderstanding.
Legitimate natural products research is not “CAM,” and should neither be billed 
as such (or as some other misnomer such as “Chinese Medicine”) nor should it be 
purported to justify “CAM,” which, if anything, hinders such research. Aspirin
is not an example of an “alternative medicine that made the transition to
medicine” any more than quinine or atropine or digoxin are such examples. Nor is
artemisinin. Everyone with a modicum of education knows that many useful drugs 
have been, and will continue to be, derived from natural sources, exactly as
biology would predict. This is completely unsurprising. The term “alternative
medicine,” along with its various synonyms, refers to a recent political and
quasi-religious movement, not to a longstanding branch of drug development that 
is scientific and that has not required the help of pseudoscientific zealots to 
pursue its investigations.

If Chinese Medicine were limited to pharmacognosy and had a more appropriate
title—Asian Pharmacognosy, for example, referring to the geographic origin of
the products studied, not to some pre-scientific medical ‘system’—I’d have
little problem with it, assuming that the natural products reports are as
rigorous as Cockerill claims them to be.

“Chinese Medicine” is a misnomer in several ways. First, the medicine
overwhelmingly used in China today is modern, scientific medicine. Second,
pre-scientific Chinese medicine was not one or even a few schools of medicine
but many disparate schools, occurring at various times over millennia and in
various places over a huge geographical region. Some schools were completely
unrelated or even contradictory. There was much influence from abroad, including
India and Greece. Third, the term “Traditional Chinese Medicine” was coined
only about 55 years ago in the PRC, mainly for pitching to (gullible)
Westerners. It heralded something that, paradoxically, had never before been
true in China: a forced standardization, such as to make ‘Chinese Medicine’
appear to be something that it was not: a conceptual whole.

Last Thoughts

I’m running out of gas, but another straw man used by the “CAM” movement,
repeated by Matthew Cockerill, is that “Regular medical journals may tend to be 
dismissive of anything with CAM-associations.” There was a time in the 1990s
when editors of the major journals had to answer this charge on a regular basis,
and each time it went something like this:

   Dr. Siegel’s charge that medical journals will not publish studies of
   alternative medicine comes out of thin air. Journals compete avidly to
   publish important new clinical research, if it is rigorously done. As we
   indicated in our editorial, the problem with the studies funded by the Office
   of Alternative Medicine in 1993 was not their size, as suggested by Dr.
   Cherkin and Ms. Street, but their quality.

In fact, major medical journals have, to their own embarrassment and to the
detriment of uninformed readers, bent over backward to accommodate substandard
“CAM” treatises.

“CAM” advocacy journals, moreover, have become far more evident in the past few 
years, thanks in part to political pressure applied by anti-intellectual
demagogues such as Dan Burton—even as the only journal committed to an
appropriate, skeptical view of “CAM” was excluded from listing by the US
National Library of Medicine after similar political pressure.

Perhaps someone else will look at some of the articles in BMC Complementary and 
Alternative Medicine. I have neither the time nor the inclination, but I would
like to reiterate a point that Steven Salzberg and we have all made at one time 
or another: even the subsequent publication of a reasonable scientific report
doesn’t justify creating a journal for the purpose of “helping aspects of CAM
prove themselves.” If there’s scientific promise for some new way to solve a
problem, and if a legitimate study is done, there are plenty of opportunities to
report it in the medical literature.

                   Pragmatic Studies and Cinderella Medicine

                                  Harriet Hall

                                      Link

Explanatory studies are done under controlled conditions to determine whether a 
treatment has any efficacy compared to a placebo. Pragmatic studies are designed
to assess how the intervention performs in everyday real world practice.
Pragmatic studies measure practical success but don’t determine actual efficacy:
that requires a proper randomized controlled trial (RCT) with an appropriate
control. Pragmatic studies have their place, but they can sometimes make an
ineffective treatment look good: a phenomenon I have christened Cinderella
Medicine.

Research studies don’t always predict how a treatment will perform
post-marketing. A study might be done on men aged 30 to 70 with no other
illnesses. Once the drug is out on the market, it will probably be taken by
women, by people who are under 30 or over 70, and by those who have concurrent
diseases like diabetes or atherosclerosis or are taking a lot of other
medications; and the dose or frequency may vary from the study protocol.

A good example is the clot-busting drug t-PA. In clinical trials, it clearly
improved the outcome of stroke patients, but in actual use in community ERs the 
death rate was almost twice as high in patients who received it as in patients
who did not. There are many possible explanations: perhaps it was offered to
patients with more severe strokes, perhaps the protocol wasn’t followed as
carefully, perhaps some patients were mis-diagnosed, perhaps they had
confounding factors that were not present in the research studies.

Pragmatic studies are useful for the questions they are designed to answer: how 
a treatment performs outside the limited environment of a research study, which 
of two treatments should be preferred by doctors, patients, and policymakers,
deciding how limited resources can be best utilized. They are an integral part
of comparative effectiveness research.

But they have limitations. They are unblinded and the patients are generally
self-selected. Larger studies are needed to compare two active treatments than
to compare an active treatment to a placebo. Lack of compliance and a high
drop-out rate can skew results. Patient self-assessments of subjective outcomes 
are not as reliable as objectively measurable outcomes.

Pragmatic trials can’t determine which components of a “package” of care are
essential, and they can’t assess the contributions of the therapeutic
relationship. When used for studying a treatment with a strong placebo effect,
they may make an ineffective treatment look better than an effective one. CAM
proponents like pragmatic studies because they are often the only studies that
seem to support them. They are attempting to bypass good science by showing
that, in practice, their methods seem to work.

Cinderella didn’t look very pretty in her rags and ashes. Imagine that her Ugly 
Stepsister had a complete makeover, with hair styling, expertly applied
cosmetics, jewels, and a beautiful designer dress. Maybe tooth whitening or even
orthodontia, charm school, modeling classes, and elocution lessons. If you
entered her in a beauty contest along with the unadorned, dirty Cinderella in
her original rags, the Ugly Stepsister might win hands down. But it wouldn’t be 
a fair beauty contest unless both were in their original unenhanced state or
unless you compared the makeover-enhanced stepsister to the
Fairy-Godmother-enhanced Cinderella. (Or if, for a really well-controlled study,
you managed to persuade the FG to do her magic on both of them.)

Acupuncture’s makeover

Studies comparing acupuncture to standard treatment have shown that acupuncture 
works better. Standard treatment is like the original Cinderella in her rags:
plain and unenhanced in any way. The doctor may only see the patient for one
visit and tell him “You have a common garden variety backache; we don’t know why
people get these, but they usually resolve spontaneously in a few weeks; while 
it is going away on its own, I could offer you a prescription for pain pills or 
a referral to physical therapy.” He doesn’t spend much time with the patient and
may seem bored and unsympathetic.

Acupuncture is like the Ugly Stepsister after her complete makeover. The
treatment itself (insertion of needles) is like the Ugly Stepsister before her
makeover. It doesn’t have any specific effects (it is no more effective than
touching the skin with a toothpick). But the acupuncturist surrounds the
treatment with all kinds of enhancements that produce “nonspecific effects” that
are not due to the treatment itself, but rather to the interaction with the
provider.

  1. The acupuncturist assures the patient that he knows how to relieve the
    back pain, and he provides a complicated explanation with all kinds of
    impressive, esoteric oriental terminology.

  2. He explains that his system is derived from ancient Chinese wisdom and
    that his needles will adjust the flow of qi through the patient’s meridians 
    to restore health.

  3. He takes the patient into a quiet back room, has him lie down and relax,
    and spends half an hour or more doing up-close-and-personal hands-on
    treatment.

  4. He is charismatic, shows great interest in the patient, asks a lot of
    questions, and may uncover another unrelated problem that needs treatment.

  5. After treatment, he prompts “You feel better now, don’t you?” and the
    patient feels a social pressure to agree.

  6. Instead of dismissing the patient with a prescription, he asks him to
    return over and over, maybe 3 times a week for several weeks; and when the
    initial course of treatment is finished, he may want the patient to keep
    seeing him for treatments to maintain health and prevent future problems. He
    develops a strong, caring doctor-patient relationship.

The plain needle insertion has been given the Cinderella treatment and
transformed into an enhanced package of suggestion, expectation, relaxation,
ancillary psychological effects, personal interactions, etc. Acupuncture
treatment is ready to go to the ball and wow the prince. It is the ideal placebo
package; it’s hard to imagine how anything could be devised that would be
better at eliciting placebo responses.

So acupuncture, with no specific effects but many nonspecific treatment effects,
will appear to outperform a standard treatment that offers some small specific 
effects but little in the way of nonspecific enhancements.

The common argument is that it doesn’t matter how a treatment succeeds: it
should be used because patients report feeling better faster than with standard 
care, that it is more effective in a practical sense. But fooling patients with 
nonsense about imaginary meridians, qi, and acupuncture points amounts to lying.
Using placebos and offering fantastic explanations undermine the doctor-patient
relationship; and this kind of thing leads people to think non-critically, to
accept other kinds of pseudoscience, and to reject science-based treatments that
might help them objectively or even save their life in the future.

Cinderella treatments: beautified and dressed up with added enhancements. Why
not add as many as possible of these Cinderella enhancements to standard,
science-based treatments? Without lying or misrepresenting our knowledge? These 
pragmatic trials don’t show that acupuncture works; they show that the way
standard treatments are offered provides fewer nonspecific effects and could
stand a bit of a makeover. That should be our goal.

                    Pragmatic Studies – More Bait and Switch

                                Steven Novella 

                                      Link

The course of research into so-called alternative medicine (CAM) over the last
20 years has largely followed the same pattern. There was little research into
many of the popular CAM modalities, but proponents supported them anyway. We
don’t need science, they argued, because we have anecdotes, history, and
intuition.

When media attention, which drove public attention, was increasingly paid to CAM
then serious scientific research increased. A specific manifestation of this
was the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). CAM 
proponents then argued that their modalities were legitimate because they were
being studied (as if that’s enough). Just you wait until all the positive
evidence comes rolling in showing how right we were all along.

But then the evidence started coming in negative. A review of the research
funded by NCCAM, for example, found that 10 years and 2.5 billion dollars of
research had found no proof for any CAM modality. They must be doing something
wrong, Senator Harkin (the NCCAM’s major backer) complained. They engaged in a
bit of the kettle defense – they argue that the evidence is positive (by cherry 
picking, usually preliminary evidence), but when it is pointed out to them that 
evidence is actually negative they argue that the studies were not done fairly. 
But then when they are allowed to have studies done their way, but still
well-controlled, and they are still negative, they argue that “Western science
cannot test my CAM modalities.”

But at the same time, they cannot shake the need for scientific evidence to
continue to push their modalities into the mainstream. The “your science can’t
test my woo” defense only goes so far. So they have put themselves into a pickle
– they demanded funding for CAM research, but now have to deal with the fact
that the research is largely negative. CAM proponents are mostly not interested 
in finding what really works, and abandoning what does not work (I have an open 
challenge to anyone who can point to a CAM modality that was largely abandoned, 
rejected, or condemned by CAM proponents because of evidence of lack of
efficacy). They are interested in using science to support and promote what they
already believe works (a cardinal feature of pseudoscience).

And so they have entered the next phase of CAM research – the post-RCT
(randomized controlled trial) phase. They have discovered the “pragmatic” study.
You have to give it to them for their cleverness. A pragmatic study is meant to
be a comparison of treatment options in real-world conditions. It studies
treatments that already have proven efficacy from RCTs to see how they work, and
how they compare, when applied in the less controlled environment of real-world
practice. Pragmatic studies are useful for addressing the weaknesses of RCTs,
mainly their somewhat contrived conditions (having strict inclusion criteria,
for example).

But pragmatic studies are not efficacy trials themselves. They cannot be used to
determine if a treatment works, because they do not control for variables and
they are not blinded, so they are susceptible to placebo and non-specific
effects. It is an abuse of the pragmatic study design to test a treatment that
is not proven or to make efficacy claims based upon them. That has not stopped
CAM proponents from doing just that.

In the news recently is just the latest example. Let me tell you the results of 
the study before I tell you what the study is of – just look at the data (I
replaced the name of the treatment in the tables with just the word
“treatment”):

Link to graphic

This is what you need to know about the trial. There were two groups, treatment 
and control. Subjects were those with frequent doctor visits for symptoms that
have not been diagnosed. While they were randomized, they were completely
unblinded – everyone involved with the subjects knew who was getting treated and
who wasn’t. At 26 weeks the control group was crossed over to receive treatment
– so the difference up to 26 weeks is most important.

On two of the measures, quality of life and general practitioner consultation
rates, there was no difference. In the other two measures there was a slight
improvement in the treatment group, barely statistically significant. If this
were an efficacy trial, this data would be unconvincing. What can fairly be
concluded from this trial is that the treatment has no to minimal effect, and
the tiny and inconsistent effect seen cannot be separated from placebo or
non-specific effects. Further, it shows how anemic even placebo effects are for 
this treatment in this patient population. As a pragmatic trial, it’s
essentially negative. As an efficacy trial, it’s worthless.

The study author’s, however, concluded that their treatment was effective and
recommended it be incorporated into general practice.

The treatment in question is five-element acupuncture – acupuncture designed to 
balance the five elements of fire, water, metal, earth, and wood. This is the
equivalent of balancing the four humors – in other words, it is pre-scientific
superstitious nonsense. The study authors are all proponents. What is most
amazing is how they got their paper, complete with unsupported conclusions, past
peer-review.

The study authors are using the “part of this nutritious breakfast” con. Even as
a child I understood that the sugary cereal, or whatever the commercial was
trying to sell to me, was only “part of this nutritious breakfast” because the
rest of the breakfast was nutritious all by itself. A doughnut would be “part of
this nutritious breakfast.” So the authors of this study include five-point
acupuncture with an hour of kind attention from a practitioner along with
lifestyle advice and encouragement. They admit that they cannot separate out the
variables here. Then they conclude that acupuncture is “part of this healthy
regimen.” There is every reason to believe that it is an irrelevant part – as
irrelevant as the doughnut is to the nutrition of a complete breakfast.

Conclusion

The pragmatic study bait and switch is here – it is now a firm part of the CAM
strategy for promoting implausible therapies that don’t work. Editors and
peer-reviewers need to be more aware of this scam so they don’t fall for it and 
inadvertently promote it, as they did in this case. Further, the results of this
trial are not impressive even at face value – it’s basically negative, so it’s 
a double swindle.

All of this has not stopped the headlines from declaring that “acupuncture
works” – which appears to be the only goal of such research.

Mel asks and I do my best to answer. On acupuncture.

Mark Crislip onJ anuary 9, 2015

Link



Several snarks were painfully maimed in the writing of this blog post

I read a lot of the pseudo-medical websites. The writing is at best pedestrian, 
often turgid, and, at its worst, incoherent. It is rarely either engaging or
clever.

Wit, the clever bon mot, the amusing turn of phrase or retort, is rare at best. 
So rare I cannot think of an example. It is ironic that those who engage in
fantastical treatments are so often lacking in cleverness with language and
thought. The closest you get to humor are the painfully-lame cartoons at the
Natural News. I am sure that the readers will flood the comments with examples
of all the clever writing I have missed in the world of pseudo-medicine just to 
prove me wrong. Not that the reality-based world is much better. It is the rare 
author on the internet whose style keeps me coming back for more.

But for some reason I found “Dear Science Based Medicine, Just a Few Questions
About Acupuncture” funny and engaging, at odds with most of the purple
quasi-paranoid articles I normally read. Just the right amount of chatty
snarkiness to be enjoyable, at least for me. So refreshing given the style of
the usual pro-acupuncture comments. Your millage may vary.

I thought when reading the article that I would enjoy discussing acupuncture
over a beer with Mel. And may I call you Mel? It is how you signed the entry,
but I do not want to be creepy, so I am a find-and-replace away from changing it
to Ms. Koppelman. If there is any personality in an article I tend to form a
totally-erroneous mental picture of the writer. Oh, and sorry Mel, the first few
times I read the article I didn’t look at your bio or picture (it was on a
phone) and assumed Mel was a male name. My bad. It says something about my
biases, n’est pas?

Mel asks many questions of SBM and I will try to answer them as best I can,
although I lack the time to reply to all of them. And I will take the
opportunity to ask some of my own questions as well. Mel can have a part two to 
her article. The gift of blog fodder keeps on giving.

Before she gets to the questions, Mel makes a key statement:

   I now understand that the positive results I see in practice are due to the
   subjective impression of improvement without actual improvement and the lack 
   of a controlled setting and basically people in general being, how do you
   describe them? Kinda simple and a bit moronic? I mean, people actually think 
   that they’re in less pain, sleeping better, feel better in themselves,
   pooping more when they were constipated, pooping less when things were moving
   too quickly, taking less medication, and taking fewer days off of work, etc 
   etc. What a bunch of gullible dodo brains, am I right? That post hoc, ergo
   propter hoc gets them over and over (and over and over) again. Poor dears.

To be clear I never think of users of pseudo-medicine as ‘kinda simple’ or a
‘bit moronic’ or as having ‘gullible dodo brains’. Mel: can you give me a
half-dozen examples from the bloggers (as opposed to the commenters). I would be
curious of an example. Oh yeah. Food Babe. But as my kids would say, based on
her content, objectively those adjectives may very well apply. So besides the
Food Babe.

While I may think acupuncture is a bit moronic, I (and I would wager my
colleagues as well) do not have the same opinion of most of its users or
practitioners. I try hard in my dotage to disparage the message, not the
messenger, but I have no doubt you can find examples where we have referred to
those who use acupuncture as some version of an idjit.

Proponents of most pseudo-medicines are human and, like me, are at risk for the 
innumerable ways, the many cognitive biases, that make our interpretation of
causality suspect. We are horrible at understanding reality. Being wrong does
not make a person a gullible dodo brain. Only wrong. Otherwise we would all be
dodo brains, perhaps a poor example.

So Mel, I would ask the question, what criteria would you use to judge whether a
therapy works? Subjective endpoints? Objective endpoints? Personal experience? 
Careful clinical trials?

And what do you mean by “works”? When I say acupuncture does not work, I mean it
does not alter any primary anatomical or physiologic processes causing the
disease in question. Do patients perceive benefit from acupuncture or other
pseudo-medical therapies? You bet. Like all effective placebos, it can have
positive psychological effects. Interactions with other, caring humans have a
perceived benefit, the same benefit that occurs when a child has a boo boo
kissed or two apes groom each other.

And Mel, how would you control for the endless ability of people to see what
they want to see, to have their biases confirmed? To quote the masters:

   There’s an old saying in Tennessee — I know it’s in Texas, probably in
   Tennessee — that says, fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you
   can’t get fooled again.

Or perhaps more coherently:

   The first principle is that you must not fool yourself — and you are the
   easiest person to fool.

I always remember N-Rays: at the beginning of last century some physicists ‘saw’
a new form of radiation that made no sense based on their understanding of
radioactivity, and published hundreds of articles in physics journals on the
topic. The researchers continued to see N rays even after the machine was
disabled without their knowledge; it turned out N rays were a figment of their
imagination.

And that is in the hardest of the hard of sciences, experimental physics.
Whenever I see an alleged therapeutic effect, due to a pseudo-medicine or a
reality-based intervention, I always ask if they are publishing the equivalent
of N rays. And a good deal of the time, unfortunately, they are.

I would note up front that Mel and I differ in our standards: I never, ever,
trust my experience for determining if a therapy is effective. There are too
many ways I can be fooled into thinking what I am doing is effective. It is why 
the three most dangerous words in medicine are “I lack insurance.” No. Sorry.
“In my experience.” And I remember every day that I am the one most likely to be
fooled by my experience.

It is why I generally trust independent studies where bias is removed and the
endpoint is not dependent on the whims of the patient and researcher: the
double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. One of the issues I look for in
acupuncture trials is whether the patient and researcher were blind and if the
blinding was successful, since there is:

   empirical evidence of pronounced bias due to lack of patient blinding in
   complementary/alternative randomized clinical trials with patient-reported
   outcomes.

And:

   Lack of blinded outcome assessors in randomized trials with subjective
   time-to-event outcomes causes high risk of observer bias. Nonblinded outcome 
   assessors typically favour the experimental intervention, exaggerating the
   hazard ratio by an average of approximately 27%

Warping bias can even happen in animal studies:

   Lack of blinding of outcome assessors in animal model experiments with
   subjective outcomes implies a considerable risk of observer bias.

Combine the above with the issues of placebo effect and bias for pain:

   We did not find that placebo interventions have important clinical effects in
   general. However, in certain settings placebo interventions can influence
   patient-reported outcomes, especially pain and nausea, though it is difficult
   to distinguish patient-reported effects of placebo from biased reporting.
   The effect on pain varied, even among trials with low risk of bias, from
   negligible to clinically important.

And I conclude that it can be very difficult to know if therapeutic effects are 
real if blinding is not fastidious, especially if the endpoints are subjective. 
People see what they want to see.

So Mel, I ask, since we here at SBM are often called arrogant (although not by
you I hasten to add), what is more arrogant given the sins to which memory is
prone? Those who rely on their experience, or those who are skeptical of that
experience?

Why do you trust your experience as valid given all the potential biases that
could be coloring your perception of efficacy? In other words, Mel, how do you
know that you are not seeing N rays when you see acupuncture efficacy?

Mel continues:

   On your site, you define acupuncture as “the practice of placing very thin
   needles through the skin in specific locations of the body for the purpose of
   healing and relief of symptoms.”

Mel does not object to the definition; it describes acupuncture but is
inadequate. So I would ask, as long we are asking questions: Mel, are all
30–40–50 styles of acupuncture (Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Ear, Wonli etc. etc. 
etc.) equally legitimate?

I ask because as I understand symptoms, such as ‘pain, sleeping better, feel
better in themselves, pooping more when they were constipated, pooping less when
things were moving too quickly’ as due to the result of different physiologic
processes and anatomy.

The causes of insomnia are different from the causes of diarrhea, and each can
have multiple different potential etiologies. The insomnia of existential angst 
and guilt (am I over sharing?) is not the same as too much coffee. The
constipation of hypothroidism is not the constipation of narcotic abuse.

From my reductionist reality-based approach to disease, each process would
require a different intervention. Different mechanisms result in different
treatments of the underlying process. And yes, I try to treat underlying
processes, not symptoms. If all forms of acupuncture are equally effective for
all forms of healing and relief of symptoms, then what is the underling
mechanism? Because I cannot see needles in the skin having an effect of such a
wide variety of fundamentally-diverse processes. Or any process for that matter,
at least based on known anatomy and physiology.

According to the World Health Organization, the following are amenable in some
way to acupuncture (Mel, any you disagree with?):

   Diseases, symptoms or conditions for which acupuncture has been proved—
   through controlled trials—to be an effective treatment:

   Adverse reactions to radiotherapy and/or chemotherapy, Allergic rhinitis
   (including hay fever), Biliary colic, Depression (including depressive
   neurosis and depression following, stroke), Dysentery, acute bacillary,
   Dysmenorrhoea, primary, Epigastralgia, acute (in peptic ulcer, acute and
   chronic gastritis, and, gastrospasm), Facial pain (including craniomandibular
   disorders), Headache, Hypertension, essential, Hypotension, primary,
   Induction of labour, Knee pain, Leukopenia, Low back pain, Malposition of
   fetus, correction of, Morning sickness, Nausea and vomiting, Neck pain, Pain 
   in dentistry (including dental pain and temporomandibular, dysfunction),
   Periarthritis of shoulder, Postoperative pain, Renal colic, Rheumatoid
   arthritis, Sciatica, Sprain, Stroke, Tennis elbow,

   Diseases, symptoms or conditions for which the therapeutic effect of
   acupuncture has been shown but for which further proof is needed:

   Abdominal pain (in acute gastroenteritis or due to gastrointestinal spasm),
   Acne vulgaris, Alcohol dependence and detoxification, Bell’s palsy, Bronchial
   asthma, Cancer pain, Cardiac neurosis, Cholecystitis, chronic, with acute
   exacerbation, Cholelithiasis, Competition stress syndrome, Craniocerebral
   injury, closed, Diabetes mellitus, non-insulin-dependent, Earache, Epidemic
   haemorrhagic fever, Epistaxis, simple (without generalized or local disease),
   Eye pain due to subconjunctival injection, Female infertility, Facial spasm,
   Female urethral syndrome, Fibromyalgia and fasciitis, Gastrokinetic
   disturbance, Gouty arthritis, Hepatitis B virus carrier status, Herpes zoster
   (human (alpha) herpesvirus 3), Hyperlipaemia, Hypo-ovarianism, Insomnia,
   Labour pain, Lactation, deficiency, Male sexual dysfunction, non-organic,
   Ménière disease, Neuralgia, post-herpetic, Neurodermatitis, Obesity, Opium,
   cocaine and heroin dependence, Osteoarthritis, Pain due to endoscopic
   examination, Pain in thromboangiitis obliterans, Polycystic ovary syndrome
   (Stein–Leventhal syndrome), Postextubation in children, Postoperative
   convalescence, Premenstrual syndrome, Prostatitis, chronic, Pruritus,
   Radicular and pseudoradicular pain syndrome, Raynaud syndrome, primary,
   Recurrent lower urinary-tract infection, Reflex sympathetic dystrophy,
   Retention of urine, traumatic, Schizophrenia, Sialism, drug-induced, Sjögren 
   syndrome, Sore throat (including tonsillitis), Spine pain, acute, Stiff neck,
   Temporomandibular joint dysfunction, Tietze syndrome, Tobacco dependence,
   Tourette syndrome, Ulcerative colitis, chronic, Urolithiasis, Vascular
   dementia, Whooping cough (pertussis)

That is one hell of a list Mel. How can needles in the skin have so many
effects? What is the mechanism that ties them all together, the one ring to bind
them, the commonality underneath acne, schizophrenia, Whooping cough and excess
saliva? Or is there a different mechanism for each disease? To my way of
thinking either these all have the same underlying mechanism to provide healing 
from acupuncture OR it is all N-Rays. Which brings us to the quote:

   But when you say that acupuncture doesn’t work, the main argument you repeat 
   over and over (and over and over again) is that acupuncture doesn’t work
   because there’s no such thing as qi.

It is, by the way, a side comment but when writing a blog entry do you presume
that the reader has the background of all the prior blog entries or should the
entry be self-contained? I choose self-contained, and that does lead to lots of 
repetition. As this entry no doubt confirms.

Mel: if there is no qi, how does so many one process (needles in the skin)
accomplished dozens of different ways (Chinese, Japanese, etc) effect so many
radically different processes? Seems far-fetched to me.

Mel continues with a good point:

   Whether or not inserting and stimulating small needles for therapeutic
   benefit is effective for symptom reduction or disease resolution really
   doesn’t rely on the existence of qi as an explanatory model.

That is true. Acupunctures could work for both infertility and pain as well
everything else on the list from an as-yet unknown underlying unified mechanism.
Because I can’t see how acupuncture could work for all those processes based on
what we do know about anatomy and physiology.

But the plausibility of the mechanism is important if you are Bayesian kind of
gal. If you have an implausible intervention then any efficacy is likely to be a
false positive and due to bias/poor methodology

Needles in the skin to alter constipation and fertility and acne and
schizophrenia seems highly implausible. And as much as Bayes makes my head hurt,
it appears to be the way the world works, so that it is highly probable that
any effect of acupuncture is likely bias.

Smarter people than I have written about Bayes and its application of
pseudo-medicine. There is some arbitrariness to deciding prior plausibility. But
given the above discussion of the issues of bias and the difficulty in
ascribing one therapy with such a multitude of effects, you can see how I could 
rate the prior plausibility of acupuncture as close to zero as you can get
without reaching it. And in your essay you do not offer compelling reasons for
me to change my mind:

   You’re basically saying that in order for sticking needles into someone to
   have a therapeutic effect, then qi must exist and if qi doesn’t exist, then
   acupuncture has no therapeutic benefit.

Yes and no. I am saying that if qi does not exist than you have no mechanism to 
account for the effects of acupunctures on a multitude of processes that are all
fundamentally different. You have no reason for a specific effect on a specific
process.

That is different from a therapeutic benefit. To repeat my favorite metaphor,
acupunctures are beer goggles: it gives the appearance of improvement with no
actual change. Kind of a Zen koan, huh? Although the only thing I got out of my 
time in the Zen temple in Kyoto all those years ago was a welt on the back from 
being hit by a board during meditation to shock me into enlightenment. Fail.

Penicillin will cure S. mitis endocarditis every time, whether you believe in
germs or not. Acupuncture works best when the patient believes they are getting 
acupuncture and believes that acupuncture is effective. When a therapeutic
effect depends primarily on belief it suggests that any effect on the conditions
WHO lists is illusory given the lack of a reasonable mechanism.

But Mel, you remain vague throughout, and vagueness is a wee bit harder to
discuss than specifics. What then is acupuncture, and which style and how does
it work and for what process?

Mel continues:

   One of your main arguments against acupuncture is that it “lacks a plausible 
   mechanism.”

   But you also argue that the copious amount of research into acupuncture’s
   mechanisms is “not relevant to the argument” of whether or not acupuncture
   works. I find this really confusing because you say that “basic science
   considerations are, in essence, ignored in determining whether there is

   sufficient prior scientific plausibility of acupuncture to treat, for
   instance, infertility (1) or depression (2), and equivocal, bias-prone
   clinical trials are ranked much higher than the basic science considerations 
   that make the hypothesis that acupuncture can do anything for infertility so 
   implausible as to border on impossible, barring new evidence speaking to its 
   plausibility.”

   So, if I understand you correctly, you’re saying that acupuncture as a
   treatment modality is implausible but you’re not going to look at the
   research that explores its plausibility because it’s irrelevant to the
   argument? In order to take a “science-based” approach to the question of
   acupuncture’s biological plausibility, you are going to make a conscious
   decision not to evaluate the research into its effects on

   the brain using fMRI studies, purinergic signalling, autonomic tone using
   heart rate variability, effects on gene expression using high throughput
   metabolimics, and mechono-transduction studies compared to sham. That’s an
   interesting stance to take.

Assuming of course that these results are valid. To paraphrase another:

   According to Professor John Ioannidis’ very well-respected and highly cited
   article on research methods, most published research findings are actually
   false.

   Yep, you read that correctly.

   For a variety of reasons, including funding sources, poor research design,
   and good old bog standard bias, most published research findings end up being
   unrepeatable and/or overturned. And it is on these very results that the
   entire institution of medical acupuncture is poised. Shaky foundations,
   indeed. When your acupuncturist prescribes you a needle or recommends an
   herb, assuming that these decisions are even based on the most up to date and
   highest quality research, there’s a good chance that those conclusions will 
   be shown to be flat out wrong in due course.

   Sobering, ain’t it?

Yep. Sobering. Most of the positive research on acupuncture is likely wrong.

An you note later that:

   Wow, that’s a very … nuanced position. I feel relieved that the good people
   of Science Based Medicine are equipped to tease out these subtleties

Nuance is important in these issues. The devil, and the fascination, is in the
details of a topic. Precision of language hopefully reflects precision of
thought, so here’s hoping I can be precise and clear. Wish me luck.

Sticking needles in animals, especially as part of healing ritual in humans, is 
going to have local effects and effects in the brain. So will stubbing your toe.
The question is whether it is more than the effects of the needle in the skin
and results in altering the panoply of processes the WHO says are amenable to
treatment from acupuncture.

I see the literature about the alleged mechanism(s) of acupunctures as than the 
literature of the effects of poking needles in the skin. It has no wider
applicability to treating any disease or symptom, the raison d’être of
acupuncture

So Mel, how do those fMRI studies, purinergic signalling, autonomic tone using
heart rate variability, effects on gene expression using high throughput
metabolimics, and mechono-transduction studies compared to sham shed light on
mechanism for using acupunctures for stroke, leukopenia and depression? Or the
GI issues noted in your opening statement?

And I wonder. As I understand it, in TCM the diagnoses for which acupuncture is 
used is based on tongue and pulse characteristics. Mel, just how do you
translate the tongue/pulse diagnosis to reality-based diagnosis and fMRI and
purinergic signalling as examples?

   Any mechanistic studies about acupuncture that you have managed to read that 
   do show a plausible mechanism don’t actually address acupuncture, just the
   insertion of tiny acupuncture needles in an acupuncture treatment-reminiscent
   fashion. Got it.

Correct. By Jove, I believe she’s got it! The nee(dle) near knee does nothing to
the qi. The pin near the shin does nothing… The point near the joint… I really 
should edit that out… Trying way too hard but so close…

And think back to N rays. They had all sorts of research and theories to explain
how N rays worked. Or cold fusion. If the effect you are seeing is an illusion,
then the research explaining it is either an illusion or, more likely,
irrelevant.

Harriet coined the term tooth fairy science:

   “Tooth Fairy science” is an expression coined by Harriet Hall, M.D., (aka the
   SkepDoc) to refer to doing research on a phenomenon before establishing that
   the phenomenon exists…Fairy Tale scientists mistakenly think that if they
   have collected data that is consistent with their hypothesis, then they have 
   collected data that confirms their hypothesis. Tooth Fairy science seeks
   explanations for things before establishing that those things actually exist.
   For example:

   You could measure how much money the Tooth Fairy leaves under the pillow,
   whether she leaves more cash for the first or last tooth, whether the payoff 
   is greater if you leave the tooth in a plastic baggie versus wrapped in
   Kleenex. You can get all kinds of good data that is reproducible and
   statistically significant. Yes, you have learned something. But you haven’t
   learned what you think you’ve learned, because you haven’t bothered to
   establish whether the Tooth Fairy really exists.

Given issues of prior plausibility and issues of bias in studies, I am more
inclined to see such explanatory studies through the lens of Tooth Fairy
science.

And:

   By assigning a low prior plausibility score to acupuncture, any positive
   studies now magically have very little positive predictive value – in other
   words the chances that a positive study is a true, rather than false
   positive, are inversely proportional to the prior plausibility value that you
   made up off the top of your head without reading the literature! Bravo!!

You got it. Perfect. You do understand. Except for the reading the literature
part. I did. You just cannot apply it to your own practice.

Mel continues with:

   Pragmatic studies – Better to be a skeptic with a migraine than a pain free
   idiot, am I right? (Up high!!)

Mel notes:

   If we take a condition like migraines, for example, we see in double blind
   RCTs that needling acupuncture points is roughly equal in effectiveness as
   needling non-acupuncture points and that both of these are very very
   effective, indeed.

The classic interpretation is that if an intervention is no better than placebo,
it does nothing specific for the process being treated and you are seeing the
sum total of the nonspecific and usually beneficial effects of a medical
intervention a.k.a. the placebo effect.

My favorite example is internal mammary artery ligation, which was used for
angina in the 1960’s until it was shown that fake surgery had the same effects
as the procedure.

Mel: How would you interpret the internal mammary artery ligation studies and,
more importantly, how would you apply it? By your interpretation should we still
being doing internal mammary artery ligation?

Or arthroscopic partial meniscectomy? Both are equal to a sham procedure. Look
at the graphs: real and sham surgery had an equal decrease in their knee pain,
about 50%. About the same degree of effect you credit to both real and sham
acupuncture. As a Gedankenexperiment let’s ignore the specifics and say
acupuncture and arthroscopic partial meniscectomy cause an equal (50%) decline
in knee pain and ignore the cost/risk/morbidity of surgery. So would you say
arthroscopic partial meniscectomy works for knee pain as well as acupuncture and
should be used? And how about sham arthroscopic partial meniscectomy? I mean,
if you wanna be all ‘pragmatic-study’ about it?

Although not done, I would wager both sham and arthroscopic partial meniscectomy
are better than wait list or medical therapy. The more complicated the placebo,
the larger the effect. I see all of them as not working: not affecting a
specific anatomical or physiologic process. They do have beneficial effects.
They are placebos. Like acupuncture.

It is one of the ongoing ethical/interesting questions. Are placebos ethical? I 
think no, since to use them requires lying to the patient.

   And if you’re saying that these studies show that acupuncture doesn’t work
   because acupuncture and minimal acupuncture are similarly effective, what do 
   they say about the pharmaceuticals?

Some pharmaceuticals are often overrated in their effects? Water is also wet and
fire is hot. The numerous issues with modern medicine and the perversion of
clinical trials are a different question. It is the “there are issues with
airlines, so let’s use flying carpets” argument.

   Don’t you like people and want to learn more about what’s effective in making
   them better?), doesn’t it at least make you ask a couple of questions about 
   the so called “science-based medical treatment” and why it’s not more
   effective than “SCAM” (as you so cleverly call it) in the real world? I mean,
   if being nice to someone for an hour a week while duping them into buying
   expensive woo is more effective than science-based medical drugs, with all
   the risks that they entail, then shouldn’t that be further explored? I mean, 
   if you wanna be all ‘science-based’ about it?

I suspect you are using the term ‘duping’ ironically as is the rest of the
sentence, but at a fundamental level that is how I un-ironically see virtually
all the pseudo-medicines discussed on this site, except the duping part, which
implies willfully fooling people.

Which again raises interesting questions of approach to health care. Here is
mine.

My job as a physician is to accurately diagnose my patient, tell the patient
what is going on, what their options are and make them better if I can. They
have entrusted me with their health, their life, their hope, their money and
their time, all of which are precious and I take that responsibility very
seriously. Although an atheist all my life, I curiously see being in health care
a calling (although a calling to what I will be damned if I know).
Pseudo-medicines like acupuncture can and do waste health, waste time, waste
money, waste hope because at their core they are N rays.

So no, it shouldn’t that be further explored. The answer to bad medicine is to
improve it, not to explore magic systems divorced from reality.

   Don’t you like people and want to learn more about what’s effective in making
   them better?

Mel. Mel. Mel. Such a wonderful snarkfest ruined by disparaging the motives of
the messenger rather than addressing the message, albeit a minor example. I have
to admit it fries my bacon, gripes my cookies or whatever angry food analogy
that whips your smoothie. I am proud of the work I have done for the last 33
years and have always strived to do the best I can for my patients. I do this
gig, and medicine, because I hope I am a caring, committed healthcare provider
whose primary motivation is to help my patients. Certainly that is true of
almost every HCW I have known, reality-based or otherwise. But that is another
difference between pseudo-medicine providers and those of us at SBM; we usually 
do not presume malign intent. I think you are wrong about acupuncture, but I
presume your motives are beneficent. But as someone said

   some haters always gonna hate. That’s ok, we’ll let them.

I know. Boo hoo, poor poor pitiful me. I have an issue, where is my tissue?

Mel has more questions and I lack the time to address them further. I have a
finite amount of time for SBM and need some time with my family and other parts 
of my growing multi-media empire. I usually do the final draft Thursday nights
but with my eldest off for his final semester of college I will be taking him
out for dinner instead of answering the rest of your questions. Damn. Time does 
fly.

Mel, I hope that helps answers at least some of your questions. I also learn a
lot by writing these articles and I hope you did too.

I do not think we will ever agree, but I enjoy your style on the blog even if I 
do not agree with the content. I look forward to your answers and, I hope, at
least one laugh at my expense.

All the best to you as well,

Mark

                  The Bait and Switch of Unscientific Medicine

                                Steven Novella 

                                      Link

Savvy consumers are familiar with the classic scam of the “bait and switch” – in
practice if not the term itself. My wife and I ran across it when we were
shopping for our first car. We needed a bargain and so we were attracted to the 
ads that promised a new Colt for only $9,000 (that’s the bait). Of course when
we got to the dealership they were all out of Colts with the configuration
advertised, but they had plenty of others that had different options that cost
several thousand dollars more (that’s the switch).

It’s a basic and very successful form of deception, and so even though there are
laws against such practices it is impossible to eliminate in all its various
and more subtle forms. It even permeates scientific, political, and other
intellectual endeavors – anytime a more palatable idea or claim is put forward
to represent the less acceptable truth.

Science, however, requires transparent honesty to function properly, and
therefore scientific practitioners must vigilantly guard against the cognitive
bait and switch. Generic intellectual virtues incorporate this vigilance – they 
include the need to unambiguously define terms, to make claims as specific and
operational as possible, and the use of valid logic. Beware of any claims that
subtly violate these rules because they are probably setting you up for a bait
and switch.

The purveyors of unscientific medical claims have become as expert at this
classic deception as the slickest used-car salesman – in fact they have left the
hawkers of dubious transportation in the dust.

Practitioners of health fraud, unscientific and sectarian medical practices have
learned how to apply the bait and switch at multiple levels – with respect to
specific modalities and at higher categorical levels. First I will address some 
of the more common sectarian practices and show how they apply this deception,
whether consciously or out of intellectual sloppiness.

Chiropractic

Chiropractic is perhaps the most common and egregious example of the bait and
switch in medicine. The deception begins with the name itself – “chiropractic”
fails the basic test of transparency because it is not unambiguously defined.
There are in fact numerous professions doing very different things and employing
mutually exclusive philosophies under the banner of “chiropractic.”

Therefore someone may go to see a chiropractor and think they will be seeing a
medical professional who will treat their musculoskeletal symptoms, but in
reality they will see the practitioner of a cult philosophy of energy healing.
So-called “straight” chiropractors (who make up an estimated 30% of all
chiropractors) still adhere to the original philosophy of chiropractic invented 
by “magnetic healer” D.D. Palmer, which is based upon the claim that an
undetected life energy called “innate intelligence” flows through the spinal
cord and nerves and is responsible for health. Such chiropractors will treat any
disease or ailment with spinal manipulation.

Most other so called “mixer” chiropractors reject the notion of innate
intelligence either partially or entirely, but still incorporate other
pseudosciences into their practice. Chiropractors are the primary practitioners 
of homeopathy, applied kinesiology, and iridology in the US. The bait – claims
that chiropractors are medical practitioners with expertise in the
musculoskeletal system. The switch – practitioners of discredited pseudosciences
that have nothing to do with the musculoskeletal system.

A more subtle form of the bait and switch among chiropractors is the treatment
of musculoskeletal symptoms with standard physical therapy or sports medicine
practices under the name of chiropractic manipulation. Ironically, the more
honest and scientific practitioners among chiropractors are most likely to
commit this subtle deception. The problem comes not from the treatment itself
but the claim that such treatments are “chiropractic.”

Using techniques like massage, range of motion exercises, strength-building
exercises, and mobilization of joints are all legitimate science-based
techniques used by physical therapists and physicians with specialties in
physiatry, orthopedics, and sports medicine. Some chiropractors also use similar
techniques -and with good results. But by doing so and calling it
“chiropractic” it legitimizes the pseudoscientific practices that are very
common within the profession – like treating non-existent “subluxations” in
order to free up the flow of innate intelligence.

Acupuncture

Many studies of acupuncture employ this latter form of bait and switch –
studying something that is not really acupuncture but calling it acupuncture and
thereby legitimizing pure pseudoscience. Acupuncture refers to a Traditional
Chinese Medicine (TCM) pre-scientific philosophy of health and illness that is
based (very similarly to straight chiropractic) on the flow of life energy
called “chi”. Fine needles are inserted into special locations on the body
called meridians for the purpose of improving, freeing, and balancing the flow
chi.

No study has demonstrated that chi exists, or that acupuncture of the meridians 
has any specific effect. A look at the entirety of the acupuncture literature,
in fact, clearly demonstrates that it does not matter where the needles are
placed (or how deeply, or if they are manipulated in ways that are designed to
manipulate chi). This means that any effects of sticking acupuncture needles
into a patient are non-specific – they are not related to the flow of chi. There
may be some small non-specific physiological effects – such as
counter-irritation reducing pain or inhibiting nausea – but even these claims
remain elusive and controversial.

But some studies of “acupuncture” show a larger and more reliable effect,
usually on pain. What these studies have in common is that they employ
“electrical acupuncture” (for example). Electrical acupuncture, however, is not 
acupuncture – it’s transdermal electrical stimulation, which is a scientific
practice that has proven efficacy in the treatment of pain. Giving transdermal
electrical stimulation through acupuncture needles, calling that “electrical
acupuncture” and then using positive results to conclude that acupuncture works 
– is an elaborate bait and switch.

Homeopathy and Herbal Medicine

Homeopathy is another dubious practice based upon pre-scientific notions long
discredited. A truly homeopathic remedy is diluted to the point that no active
ingredients remain – so a homeopathic remedy is pure solvent, either water or
alcohol, sometimes placed on a sugar pill (making a homeopathic pill a literal
placebo). But much of the public believes that “homeopathic” simply means
“natural” or “herbal”. Few realize that it means that the so-called medicine
contains nothing.

But some homeopathic products are not even truly homeopathic – meaning they are 
not based upon homeopathic principles but rather contain measurable amounts of
real drugs. This is now not uncommon for over-the-counters lotions and cold
remedies. For example, this pimple cream contains many active ingredients at a
“1x” dilution – that’s only 1:10, meaning there is still actual molecules of
drugs in the cream. That’s not homeopathic.

A similar and more subtle deception is used in the marketing of herbs. They are 
sold and regulated as “natural supplements” when in fact they are drugs. Herbs
contain chemicals that have pharmacological activity and they are usually taken 
in doses that are insignificant in terms of their nutritional content, but are
significant in terms of their pharmacological activity. The bait is that they
are nutritional supplements, the switch is that they are unpurified drugs.

CAM – the Biggest Bait and Switch

All of these modalities fall under an artificial category – so called
“complementary and alternative” medicine (CAM) or “integrative” medicine that
was created as the ultimate bait and switch.

The deception is largely two-fold. The first is to include modalities within
this false category that are legitimate, like nutrition, exercise, physical
therapy, relaxation, etc., – and then claim that these legitimize the entire
category of CAM, even the far-out stuff like homeopathy. This is just a
higher-order version of including physical therapy modalities within the
umbrella of chiropractic, for example.

Essentially, at every level terms are used that are vague and poorly defined,
and in practice are designed to be all-inclusive so that the purely
pseudoscientific can ride on the coattails of the barely plausible or even the
legitimate.

This is the opposite of what happens within scientific disciplines – where
terminology evolves over time to become more discriminating, unambiguous, and
specific. To take an example from my specialty, multiple sclerosis (MS) has been
divided into sub-diagnoses: relapsing remitting and chronic progressive.
Divisions multiplied and now there are seven subtypes – for example, primary
progressive, and progressive remitting.

This increased “splitting” as it is called is not just a pedantic dedication to 
precision, but a recognition that such divisions may reflect differences in
underlying mechanism of the disease. Also, different subtypes of MS respond
differently to different treatments. Some drugs work in relapsing remitting but 
not in primary progressive. Part of the motivation for finer categories is to
more accurately predict which MS patients are likely to respond to which
treatments.

Contrast this to the maximally broad and imprecise but common marketing slogan
“chiropractic works.”

The second kind of deception created by the category of CAM is in the language
used itself – “complementary” and “integrative.” What, exactly, are CAM
modalities integrating? On close examination it is quite clear – the movement is
an effort to mix unscientific, disproved, and dubious modalities into
scientific medicine. The bait is that CAM offers legitimate alternatives, the
switch is that it primarily promotes treatments that don’t work or are at best
untested and highly implausible.

If there were truth in marketing then we would have the Office of Implausible
Medicine, the Journal of Bad Medical Science, the Center for Rejected Therapies,
and the Institute of Dubious Medical Claims – all under the umbrella of
unscientific medicine. It used to be called, even more simply, “health fraud.”

Conclusion

The public would be best served if they were given a reasonable expectation of
honesty and clarity in the health marketplace. Instead, increasingly they are
being given the old bait and switch, and increasingly the governments and
institutions of medicine that should know better are instruments of this
deception.

Science and intellectual honesty require that terms mean something specific and 
definable. Unscientific health modalities have become very savvy at using
terminology to confuse rather than inform, to deceive rather than to illuminate.

It is the simplest form of the bait and switch – just call a product or service 
something that it isn’t.

               Another overhyped acupuncture study misinterpreted

                                  David Gorski

                                      Link

Perhaps the most heavily studied of “alternative medicine” modalities is
acupuncture. Although it’s hard to be sure as to the reason, I tend to speculate
that part of the appeal to trying to do research in this area is because
acupuncture is among the most popular of actual “alt-med” modalities, as opposed
to science-based medical modalities co-opted by believers in alt-med and
rebranded as “alternative” (diet and exercise, for instance, to which is all too
often added the consumption of huge quantities of unproven nutritional
supplments) or activities that make people feel better, whether they’re healthy 
or ill (massage, for instance). In contrast, acupuncture involves actually
sticking needles into the skin. Never mind that the rationale for acupuncture,
namely “redirecting” the flow of the “life energy” known as qi when it is
blocked by sticking needles in “meridians” like some electrodes in some
imaginary qi battery, is pure bunkum, as we’ve pointed out here at SBM time and 
time again. Somehow the image of needles sticking out of the skin, apparently
painlessly and making some extreme acupuncture practices resemble Pinhead from
the Hellraiser movie series, seems “sexy” as far as “alternative” therapies go, 
particularly since it’s “Eastern” as opposed to that reductionistically evil
“Western medicine,” and, as we all know at SBM, “Western” is bad and “Eastern”
is good.

So the fascination with acupuncture remains, so much so that an inordinate
amount of research dollars are spent on studying it. Unfortunately, that money
is largely wasted. As Steve Novella has pointed out, in general in medicine (at 
least these days), the trajectory of research is usually from bench research to 
animal models to small scale, less rigorous, pilot studies in humans to large
scale, rigorously designed studies using many subjects. True, this order doesn’t
always hold. For instance, if physicians make a compelling observation “at the 
bedside” of response to therapy or how a disease progresses, frequently, after
making closer observations to confirm the initial observation, researchers will 
jump back to animal models and bench top research to try to figure out what’s
going on. For such a progression to be useful, though, scientists have to be
sure that the phenomenon in human patients under study actually exists.

Unfortunately, in acupuncture, the evidence is still unconvincing that there is 
any “there” there in that acupuncture effects appear to be no greater than
placebo effects. As larger, more well designed studies using real placebo or
sham acupuncture techniques, have increasingly shown that acupuncture does not
function any better than placebo in human beings (and sometimes even worse),
acupuncturists and acupuncture believers have been reversing the usual order of 
things, doing smaller studies and “pragmatic” (i.e., uncontrolled) clinical
trials, where the placebo effect is not controlled for. Never mind that it
doesn’t matter where the needles are placed (thus blowing the whole “meridian”
idea out of the water) or even if the needles puncture the skin. Toothpicks work
just as well as needles. Also never mind that the mythology of acupuncture as
having been routinely practiced for over two thousand years (or, sometimes, four
thousand years, is largely a creation of Chairman Mao, who elevated what was a 
marginal practice at the time to a modality that the state supported and
promoted (1,2,3,4). Unfortunately, even the National Center for Complementary
and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) falls for this mythology.

Every so often, I’m amazed when an acupuncture study ends up in a high impact
journal like Nature Neuroscience. Of course, when I read such articles,
virtually inevitably I discover that what is being studied is not really
“acupuncture” per se, but rather sticking needles into either people or animals.
Sometimes, “electroacupuncture” (which is in reality not acupuncture at all,
given that there was no source of electricity hundreds of years ago in China
when acupuncture was supposedly invented) is misrepresented as acupuncture.
Since a bunch of readers, both here and at my other blog, have deluged my mail
box with this particular study, I felt obligated to have a look at it, even if
Steve Novella has already weighed in with his excellent deconstruction. This
particular study is especially annoying, because it’s been hyped to the nth
degree, and even some news sources where the reporters should know better have
fallen for it.

Before I get to the study itself, though, let’s take a look at the press
release:

   The research focuses on adenosine, a natural compound known for its role 
   in regulating sleep, for its effects on the heart, and for its
   anti-inflammatory properties. But adenosine also acts as a natural
   painkiller, becoming active in the skin after an injury to inhibit nerve
   signals and ease pain in a way similar to lidocaine.

   In the current study, scientists found that the chemical is also very
   active in deeper tissues affected by acupuncture. The Rochester researchers
   looked at the effects of acupuncture on the peripheral nervous system – the
   nerves in our body that aren’t part of the brain and spinal cord. The
   research complements a rich, established body of work showing that in the
   central nervous system, acupuncture creates signals that cause the brain to
   churn out natural pain-killing endorphins.

   The new findings add to the scientific heft underlying acupuncture, said 
   neuroscientist Maiken Nedergaard, M.D., D.M.Sc., who led the research. Her
   team is presenting the work this week at a scientific meeting, Purines 2010, 
   in Barcelona, Spain.

   “Acupuncture has been a mainstay of medical treatment in certain parts of
   the world for 4,000 years, but because it has not been understood
   completely, many people have remained skeptical,” said Nedergaard,
   co-director of the University’s Center for Translational Neuromedicine, where
   the research was conducted.

I’ll cut to the chase before proceeding with my usual infamously in depth and
long-winded discussion of the study. Nedergaard’s study is interesting, but it
really doesn’t show that “acupuncture works” any more than it really shows
compelling evidence for a specific mechanism behind acupuncture. Unfortunately, 
as is commonly the case, much of the press reporting this study earns a big fat 
F for the spin being put on it. The Guardian, for instance, states:

   The discovery challenges a widely held view among scientists that any
   benefit patients feel after having acupuncture is purely due to the placebo
   effect.

   “The view that acupuncture does not have much benefit beyond the placebo 
   effect has really hampered research into the technique,” said Maiken
   Nedergaard, a neuroscientist at the University of Rochester Medical Centre in
   New York, who led the study.

   “Some people think any work in this area is junk research, but I think
   that’s wrong. I was really surprised at the arrogance of some of my
   colleagues. We can benefit from what has been learned over many thousands of 
   years,” Nedergaard told the Guardian.

I love the “arrogance” gambit, don’t you? This time, it’s even coupled with the 
“appeal to ancient wisdom” fallacy. Nice. If you want to irritate me, pull the
“arrogance” gambit and then couple it with appeals to ancient wisdom. After all,
physicians from ancient civilizations were heavily into bleeding and purging,
not to mention treating with toxic heavy metals. Go back to the ancient
Egyptians, and you’ll see that praying and believing that the gods were
responsible for diseases, with physicians and priests often serving the same
purpose, were the rule fo the day. Does that mean such treatments were “wise” or
efficacious. Meanwhile The Daily Mail entitled its report Let’s get straight to
the point, acupuncture DOES ease pain, and The Telegraph entitled its report
Acupuncture does work as it stimulates a natural pain killer, scientists find,
while The Raw Story exulted, Researchers prove acupuncture’s effectiveness in
pain therapy and the Wall Street Journal opined How Acupuncture May Work:
Adenosine is Key to Acupuncture’s Effectiveness. Perhaps the silliest and most
credulous commentary on this study comes from Elizabeth Armstrong Moore on CNET,
who even entitled her post Think Acupuncture’s a hoax? Think again (Scientific 
research shows natural healing compounds), where Moore represented herself as a 
“skeptic” being “converted” to believing that acupuncture works, while Ars
Technica writer Yun Xie laps this story up credulously. Even what I would
normally consider more scientifically rigorous sources were not immune to the
woo. For example, ScienceNow entitled its article on the study How Acupuncture
Pierces Chronic Pain; The New Scientist‘s blog Short Sharp Science, How
acupuncture eases pain – maybe (which, despite the slightly skeptical title, was
pretty much completely accepting of the spin placed on the study); and Nature‘s
blog The Great Beyond, Acupuncture ‘works in mice’.

So, with all this hype going on, even during a holiday weekend in the U.S. and
the U.K., what does this overhyped study actually show? Are the headlines of
“acupuncture works” and “scientists discover how acupuncture works” justified?
Not so fast, there, pardner.

Perhaps the most infuriating aspect of all the hype is that the study being
hyped actually describes a fair bit of interesting biochemistry behind the pain 
response. Unfortunately, what it doesn’t show is that “acupuncture works,”
despite all the whining about “arrogance” from the study’s lead investigator.
All it shows are two things: (1) that a chemical called adenosine is released
when needles are stuck into the skin of mice and twisted and (2) that adenosine 
decreases the pain response. These are actually very interesting findings,
albeit, as people I’ve corresponded with have pointed out to me, nothing new at 
all. Contrary to the way these results are being spun, they in now way validate 
the belief system behind acupuncture or show that “acupuncture works.”

Let’s get to the science in more detail, although I hate to do it by pointing
out the Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo-worthy credulous and
annoying opening paragraph of the paper that reviewers should have shot down in 
flames but didn’t:

   Acupuncture is a procedure in which fine needles are inserted into an
   individual at discrete points and then manipulated, with the intent of
   relieving pain. Since its development in China around 2,000 B.C., acupuncture
   has become worldwide in its practice. Although Western medicine has treated 
   acupuncture with considerable skepticism, a broader worldwide population has 
   granted it acceptance. For instance, the World Health Organization endorses
   acupuncture for at least two dozen conditions and the US National Institutes 
   of Health issued a consensus statement proposing acupuncture as a therapeutic
   intervention for complementary medicine. Perhaps most tellingly, the U.S.
   Internal Revenue Service approved acupuncture as a deductible medical expense
   in 1973.

This is yet another example of an appeal to ancient wisdom, but this time it’s
coupled with argumentum ad populum, better known as the appeal to popularity. I 
never thought I’d see the introduction to a scientific article appeal to, much
less mention, the fact that the IRS allows a modality to be a deductible medical
expense, but here it is. Where the hell were the reviewers? I could equally
point out that the IRS allows medical deductions for the services of Christian
Science prayer healers. Does that mean that Christian Science prayer is an
effective treatment for anything? No, it does not. Add to that the whole false
dichotomy between “Western” and “Eastern” medicine (yes, I know I mentioned it
at the beginning of this post), a particularly odious and borderline racist
construct in which the mythical “East” is represented as more “wholistic” and
“spiritual” compared to the “reductionistic” and scientific brand of medicine.
True, in the second paragraph, Nedergaard does mention the possibility of the
release of opiod receptors, but there is zero discussion of the evidence for and
against acupuncture, not even much of an acknowledgment other than that nasty
“Western medicine” being so nastily “skeptical” of the practice, as though that 
were a bad thing.

The model used by Nedergaard is a model of inflammation that involves injecting 
complete Freund’s adjuvant (CFA) into the mice’s paws. As a result, the mice’s
paws would become inflamed by the irritant properties of the CFA and thus more
sensitive to innocuous stimuli, with a decreased latency period for withdrawal
to painful or innocuous stimuli; in other words, the mice’s paws would be more
sensitive, and the mice would react more strongly and rapidly to the stimuli of 
heat or touching. This sensitivity peaked at day four or five and then
decreased. As a preliminary experiment, the investigators noted that, after the 
insertion of acupuncture needles into the mouse limb at the “Zusanli point,”
which is located near the knee a microdialysis probe inserted less than a
millimeter away registered a spike in extracellular adenosine levels, as well as
ATP (which is broken down to adenosine outside of the cells), ADP, and AMP,
that peaked at around 30 minutes.

Having established that adenosine was increased within 30 minutes of an
acupuncture stimulus, Nedergaard then injected an chemical that binds to the
cell receptor activated by adenosine, the A1 receptor agonist,
2-chloro-N(6)-cyclopentyladenosine (CCPA). Injecting CCPA into the Zusanli point
greatly improved touch sensitivity and in essence reversed the increased
sensitivity to heat. So far, so good. Apparently in the mouse adenosine has a
lot to do with modulating pain response in peripheral nerves, and apparently a
fair number of pharmaceutical companies are interested in developing adenosine
agonists to take advantage of this effect in humans. Even better, this effect
was not observed in mice genetically engineered not to make the adenosine A1
receptor, known as A1 receptor knockout mice, strong evidence that it was the A1
receptor that was responsible for the observed blunting of the pain response.
Investigators also tested CCPA in a model of neuropathic pain (pain due to nerve
dysfunction) and found it worked as well as it did in their model of
inflammatory pain.

So what’s the link to acupuncture? Actually, that’s what I was wondering myself.
Up until now, this paper was a fairly straightforward neuroscience paper
looking at some interesting results. However, I doubt this paper would have
gotten into Nature Neuroscience if all the investigators did was to show that a 
bit of local inflammation resulted in the secretion of adenosine into the
extracellular fluid and then showed that that adenosine blunted the pain
response in nearby nerve endings. That would have been much less interesting,
because there is already a fair amount of literature implicating the A1 receptor
as a target for the relief of neuropathic pain. But add the acupuncture to it, 
and you sex it up and get a paper into a high impact journal, which is
apparently what happened here.

The unfortunate “bait and switch” of this paper is that it failed to mention
that the Zusanli acupuncture point that the investigators used, apparently to
the exclusion of all others, is not actually a leg or a pain acupuncture point. 
Although it is located on the leg, just inferior and lateral to the knee, the
Zusanli point is described among traditional Chinese medicine (TCM)
practitioners as the leg portion of the stomach meridian. According to TCM, this
point is also known as Stomach-36 and its current indications are:

   The current standard indications for zusanli, as reviewed in Advanced
   Textbook of Traditional Chinese Medicine and Pharmacology (21) are: stomach
   ache, abdominal distention, vomiting, diarrhea, dysentery, indigestion,
   appendicitis, flaccidity and numbness of the lower limbs, edema, mastitis,
   mania, epilepsy, cough, vertigo, palpitation, and emaciation due to
   consumptive disease. This latter indication corresponds to the concept that
   needling this point can tonify the sea of qi and thereby help to stop the
   wasting disease and restore ones body weight and vitality.

   To illustrate the uniformity of indications amongst the Chinese
   authorities, the following were listed in Chinese Acupuncture and Moxibustion
   (22, 23), with slight differences on translation between the original
   Chinese and later Western publications: gastric pain, hiccup, abdominal
   distention, vomiting, diarrhea, dysentery, emaciation due to general
   deficiency, constipation, mastitis, intestinal abscess (acute appendicitis), 
   numbness (motor impairment) and pain of the lower extremities, edema
   (beriberi), manic depressive psychosis.

Thus, according to acupuncturists, most associated with stomach and abdominal
problems far more than lower extremity pain. Strange that the investigators
didn’t mention that. I must say, though, it’s such a multipurpose acupuncture
point, that I suppose I can’t harp on the investigators too much for using it
for this indication, although I can’t help but note that the point seems mighty 
close on the mouse to where the sciatic nerve divides in the leg.

Be that as it may, here’s a concise summary of what the investigators found:

   In normal mice of adenosine, acupuncture reduced discomfort by
   two-thirds.

   In A1 receptor knockout mice, acupuncture had no effect on the reactions 
   of the mice to the stimuli of touch or heat.

   During and after an acupuncture treatment, adenosine levels in the
   tissues near the needles was 24 times greater than before the treatment.

   Deoxycoformycin, a drug that inhibits the removal of adenosine by the
   tissues, increased the length of time that the adenosine remained in the
   tissues (surprise! surprise! given its known mechanism of action) but also
   appeared to increase the length of time that acupuncture treatment was
   effective.

   In mice who had acupuncture but in which the needle wasn’t rotated every 
   five mintues, acupuncture had no effect.

So what does this all mean? First of all, this study is actually interesting for
its implications for adenosine as a mediator of both inflammatory and
neuropathic pain. I can’t fault its methodology, at least as far as it
implicates the adenosine A1 receptor as a mediator of neuropathic and
inflammatory pain in the lower extremity. It’s pretty clear in supporting the
conclusion that mimicking the action of adenosine or somehow increasing its
local concentration around a nerve might be a good strategy for relieving pain
in humans. But do the results of this study actually support the efficacy of
acupuncture, as Nedergaard claims?

Not so fast, there again, pardner.

This study actually says very little about acupuncture. What this study shows is
that sticking needles in mice causes adenosine production and that that
adenosine can blunt the pain response in nerves by binding to the A1 receptor.
Nothing more. That’s all well and good, but it doesn’t validate acupuncture. The
only thing in common with acupuncture in this study is the needle sticking
part, and the investigators might as well conclude that this study validates ear
piercing for pain relief. (Egads! Battlefield acupuncture strikes back!) So,
it’s quite possible that needles twisted in the area near a nerve might release 
a flood of adenosine that might bind to A1 receptors in nearby neurons and blunt
the pain sensation. No “meridians” or qi is needed to explain that. Moreover,
this study notwithstanding, Nedergaard seems at a loss to explain how her
results might be reconciled with numerous studies in humans that show clearly
that (1) it does not matter where you stick the needles and (2) it doesn’t even 
matter if the needles are stuck through the skin. As I’ve pointed out before,
just twisting the end of a toothpick against the skin produces the same effect
as acupuncture. She does, however, give it the old college try to explain this
result, although she does so using the hated term “allopathic” to describe
“Western” medicine:

   One may speculate that other non-allopathic treatments of chronic pain,
   such as chiropractic manipulations and massage, modalities that involve the
   mechanical manipulation of joints and muscles, might also be associated with 
   an efflux of cytosolic ATP that is sufficient to elevate extracellular
   adenosine. As in acupuncture, adenosine may accumulate during these
   treatments and dampen pain in part by the activation of A1 receptors on
   sensory afferents of ascending nerve tracks. Notably, needle penetration has 
   been reported to not confer an analgesic advantage over nonpenetrating
   (placebo) needle application, as opposed to our observations (Supplementary
   Figs. 2 and 3) and those of others. However, it is possible that ATP release 
   from keratinocytes in response to mechanical stimulation of the skin results 
   in an accumulation of adenosine that transiently reduces pain, as A1
   receptors are probably expressed by nociceptive axon terminal in epidermis.
   In fact, vibratory stimulation applied to the skin depressed the activity of 
   nociceptive neurons in the lower lumbar segments of cats by release of
   adenosine. However, this effect differs from the anti-nociceptive effect of
   acupuncture, which does not depend on the afferent innervation of the skin.
   Acupuncture is typically applied to deep tissue, including muscle and
   connective tissue, and acupoints may better overlap with their proximity to
   ascending nerve tracks than to the density of cutaneous afferents.

This is pure speculation without any compelling evidence, no more convincing
than saying that rubbing a boo-boo makes it feel better, which is in essence
what she’s saying. Worse, her speculations would also have been easy enough to
test, given that she had the experimental model up and apparently running
smoothly. Contrary to her implication, Supplemental Figures 2 and 3 do not
refute the results showing that non-penetrating acupuncture works as well as
penetrating acupuncture. In Figure S2, all that is shown is that using
acupuncture at the Zusanli point on the contralateral leg doesn’t affect the
reaction of ipsilateral leg receiving the acupuncture. All Figure S3 shows is
that failing to rotate the needle results in loss of the analgesic effect.
Neither refute findings in humans that non-penetrating acupuncture “works” just 
as well as penetrating acupuncture, where the needles are inserted to the
“correct” points. Absent evidence from the current study showing that
stimulating the skin results in the release of adenosine and subsequent blunting
of the pain response in the extremities of these mice, Nedergaard would have
been better off leaving this entire paragraph out of the paper. Moreover,
contrary to the claim that “merdians” map to ascending nerve tracts is
stretching it a bit, if you look at these maps. For instance, the kidney,
stomach, and spleen acupuncture points line up somewhat with nerves at certain
points in the body but are nowhere near ascending nerves in other parts.

Finally, there are two remaining huge problems with this paper. Here’s the
second biggest first. Mice are much, much smaller than humans. The Zusanli point
in a mouse is going to be within a couple of millimeters of the sciatic nerve
or one of its major branches. In the human, it’s going to be at least a couple
of centimeters away, possibly considerably further. In the mouse, the size of
the needle relative to the size of the leg and distance from the sciatic nerve, 
as well as the nerve’s branches, the tibial and peroneal nerves, is going to be 
very close. The tissue damage, virtually no matter where the needle is stuck, is
going to be close to these nerves. In humans, this is unlikely to be the case, 
particularly since the nerves are much further beneath the skin than they are in
mice; that is, unless we want to start scaling things up and sticking nails
into people’s knees. Thus, there is no good reason to think that these results
will be unlikely to translate easily to humans.

What really bugs me about this article, though, is that it’s actually pretty
cool science, for the most part. It’s not as new as I thought it was before some
of my readers corresponded with me and I did a few PubMed searches, but in
general its conclusions about the role of the A1 receptor and local adenosine
release in response to tissue trauma seem sound. These guys have found something
that may even have a potential clinical application. For instance, they found
that local injection of A1 receptor agonists works the same as the “acupuncture”
and that adding compounds that slow the removal of adenosine from the tissues
improves the efficacy of the adenosine released into the tissues by minor
trauma. Scientists can work with that. Scientists could take these observations 
and use them as the scientific justification to work on better, more specific,
and longer acting A1 agonists. Perhaps they could even develop oral drugs that
are broken down into adenosine or A1 receptor agonists in the peripheral
tissues. If this paper’s conclusions regarding the importance of adenosine in
pain signaling are correct, these would represent stragies that could very well 
work and very well improve pain control. One could even envision implantable
pellets that could be placed in wounds or near relevant nerves to release A1
receptor agonists right where they’re needed over a long period of time.

Unfortunately, Nedergaard and her team are too enamored of the woo that is
acupuncture to emphasize the true significance and potential usefulness of their
findings. Worse, they were rewarded for their infatuation with acupuncture with
not just a paper in a high impact neuroscience journal but with all sorts of
publicity around the world. Instead of working to turn these observations into
usable therapies, now Nedergaard and her collaborators will likely use their
preliminary data to apply to NCCAM for a grant to study adenosine in acupuncture
further, rather than pursuing this observation in a manner far more likely to
lead to a clinical benefit in human beings. So much the pity. Woo poisons the
real science it touches.

Finally, when you see aficionados of acupuncture cite this paper as “evidence”
that acupuncture “works,” remember this: This study says absolutely nothing at
all about all the other myriad claimed benefits of acupuncture in fertility
treatments, headache, or hot flashes after menopause, to name a few. Sadly, it
doesn’t even say that much about the use of acupuncture for chronic pain.

REFERENCE:

Goldman, N., Chen, M., Fujita, T., Xu, Q., Peng, W., Liu, W., Jensen, T., Pei,
Y., Wang, F., Han, X., Chen, J., Schnermann, J., Takano, T., Bekar, L., Tieu,
K., & Nedergaard, M. (2010). Adenosine A1 receptors mediate local
anti-nociceptive effects of acupuncture Nature Neuroscience DOI: 10.1038/nn.2562

                             The World Has Moved On

                                 Mark Crislip 

                                      Link

I do a lot of driving as part of my job.  I am the sole Infectious Disease
doctor at three hospitals and I can spend an hour or two a day in the car,
depending on traffic.  What prevents me from going crazy sitting in traffic is
listening to podcasts and audible books.    I especially like reading (and yes, 
audio books is reading, pedant) multivolume epics.   Currently I am reading
Steven King’s Dark Tower series, which occurs in a universe “where the world has
moved on.”  In Mid-world there was once a world with science and beauty and
art, but something changed, what I do not know yet (I am only on the third
volume; no spoilers in the comments), and the world moved on, leaving behind
some artifacts of science and technology, but it appears to be an increasingly
primitive world.  Being fantasy, there is, unlike the world I live in, magic as 
well.

I like that phrase: “the world has moved on.” I have an understanding of the
world and medicine, based mostly, but not entirely, on science.  My
understanding of the natural world is not complete, but mostly consistent and
validated by hundreds of years of research.  My undergraduate degree was in
physics, and, like all premeds and medical school students, have an extensive
education in chemistry, biology, biochemist, physiology, anatomy, biochemistry, 
etc.  It all ties together nicely, especially in my specialty , where I have the
most knowledge.  I consider infections at many levels, from issues of single
molecule changes that may confer antibiotic resistance, up through the patient
and their family, and sometimes at the level of the entire planet.  Truly
wholistic, not the pseudo-wholism of SCAM.

The sciences gives a mostly coherent understanding of the world.  Mostly
coherent. It does give an understanding of the possible, the probable, the
improbable and the impossible.  Most of the sciences, unlike parts of medical
science,  are not concerned with the impossible.  There is not complementary and
alternative physics, or chemistry, or biochemistry, or engineering.  These
disciplines compare their ideas against reality, and, if the ideas are found
wanting, abandoned.   Perpetual motion is not considered seriously by any
academic physicist; if perpetual motion were an alternative medicine it would be
offered at a Center by a Harvard Professor of Medicine.

Most scientists outside of medicine are aware of how easy it is to fool
themselves and, by extension, others. As Richard Feynman said.

   “We’ve learned from experience that the truth will come out. Other
   experimenters will repeat your experiment and find out whether you were wrong
   or right. Nature’s phenomena will agree or they’ll disagree with your
   theory. And, although you may gain some temporary fame and excitement, you
   will not gain a good reputation as a scientist if you haven’t tried to be
   very careful in this kind of work. And it’s this type of integrity, this kind
   of care not to fool yourself, that is missing to a large extent in much of
   the research in cargo cult science.”

My archetype for scientists fooling themselves, and others, is the story of
N-rays, which I have discussed before.

For whatever reason, and I do not pretend to understand why, medical people are 
occasionally unable to incorporate the simple concept that unless they are very 
careful, they can be fooled.  The result is complementary and alternative
medicine.  It is the place that remains after the world has moved on.

That phase constantly popped into my head as I looked at the Huffington Post
sections on Intergratve Medicine. The world of medicine, at least, has moved on 
and left the Huffington Post behind.  So much on the HuffPo Intergrative
medicine site is at odds with reality that I will mention only a few of the more
egregious examples of medical nonsense.  HuffPo is giving Natural News a run
for their money in the production of fantasy. Most striking was the homeopathic 
(the facts being seriously deluded; isn’t that an underlying principle of
homeopathy?) article by Dana Ulman entitled Homeopathy for Radiation Poisoning. 
Water for radiation toxicity.  Seriously.  And not even heavy water, which
might catch the extra neutron.  And the reasoning for its use is even more
goofy, if possible, than that of oh-so-silly-ococcinum.

   “Because one of the basic premises of homeopathic medicine is that small 
   doses of a treatment can help to heal those symptoms that large doses are
   known to cause, Ludlam suggested to Grubbe that radiation may be a treatment 
   for conditions such as tumors because it also causes them. This incident is
   but one more example from history in which an insight from a homeopathic
   perspective has provided an important breakthrough in medical treatment.”

I suppose since smoking causes cancer you should treat lung cancer with
cigarettes and since alcohol causes cirrhosis you should treat cirrhosis is with
vodka and guns cause acute lead poisoning so maybe we should shoot gunshot
victims. That I suppose, would be reasonable conclusions from homeopathic theory
derived from metaphor and faulty metaphor that.

What nostrums are recommend for radiation therapy? Cadmium iodatum, Ceanothus,
and Cadmium sulphuratum, for which there are no Pubmed references to support
treating radiation toxicity, even though the author says they are a well-known
remedies for that condition. Not well known to medical science I suppose.  Ah
the wisdom of homeopathy, where saying it makes it so.

Then the author suggests

   “Calendula (marigold) is a well-known herbal and homeopathic medicine.
   Highly respected research has found excellent results in using Calendula
   ointment on people who experienced radiotherapy-induced dermatitis.”

Now why is Calendula a homeopathic medicine? I went to the original reference
and it appears from the literature to be a worthwhile agent  for the prevention 
of radiation term burns. But  I am not so sure I would classify Calendula as a
homeopathic preparation. According to the producers site it is “Calendula Fresh 
Plant 4%” and in the original article it is “is fabricated from a plant of the
marigold family, Calendula officinalis. The digest is obtained by incubation at 
75°C in petroleum jelly to extract the liposoluble components of the plant.” 
The authors  do not use the word homeopathic anywhere in the reference.

Real product came containing real parts of the plant at a measurable
concentrations, hardly homeopathic in nature.  Calendula ointment has not been
subjected to proving, nor has it been potentiated, as if either are helpful.  It
is not a homeopathic preparation  just because a preparation made by a producer
of homeopathic nostrums, although that appears to be the reason. It is a new
definition of a homeopathic preparation: if it is made by a homoepathic producer
it is therefore a homeopathic preparation. By this standard, the effluent of
the Boiron toilets would also be considered homeopathic preparations.

When it comes to homeopathy, not only has the world moved on,  rational thought 
and consistency has moved on.

And there is acupuncture. There is a link to an article entitled As Medical
Costs Rise More Americans Turn to Acupuncture. This is an article from AOL
linked from the Huffington Post (now owned by AOL). If you want to get the
heebie-jeebies take a look at the opening picture on that page. The text says
“Practitioners must use needles produced and manufactured according to U.S. Food
and Drug Administration standards, which require needles to “be sterile,
nontoxic, and labeled for single use by qualified practitioners only.” The
needles may be sterile, but what good is a sterile needle used by a bare hand?

Look at the accompanying photograph. That middle finger does not inspire
confidence. It is no wonder that acupuncture is associated with outbreaks of
hepatitis C, hepatitis B, and MRSA infections. Most the pictures of acupuncture 
on this website  demonstrate that acupuncturists lack understanding of basic
technique. It is hard to infect people with an injection.  Heroin users inject
themselves with a rich melange of bacteria every day without getting infections.
It is hard to infect patients in the hospital with blood draws and IV’s.  But 
if an infection can happen, it will happen. And those fingers, just recently in 
a nose, or picking a tooth, or scratching a butt, will spread an infection with 
an acupuncturist’s needle to one unlucky patient. Not only has the world moved
on for acupuncture, it took with it an appreciation of germ theory.

The Huffington Post  seems to be immune from advances in understanding of all of
so-called intergrative medicines, or even basic anatomy and physiology. They 
link to a video entitled The Meridian System in Oriental Medicine. They might
have linked to the anatomy of Orcs or the physiology of Dementors, for all the
application to reality it represents.   The video is gibberish when compared to 
nature as we understand it. The world has moved on.

When Huffington Post published absolute nonsense, I have to wonder how good
their analysis is on issues like politics, war,  the environment and other
important areas. I was always taught to judge a man by the company he keeps. I
have the same problem with my local newspaper, the Oregonian, which publishes
the occasional nonsense piece in the Living section.  They often get things
wrong in Infectious Diseases, the one area I have expertise.  If they are wrong 
in areas I know,  can I trust their writings on other topics?

When I finish the series, I’ll let you know, metaphorically, what the alt med
Dark Tower is.

                               It’s just a theory

                                  Mark Crislip

                                      Link

   I am afraid that the experiments you quote, M. Pasteur, will turn against
   you. The world into which you wish to take us is really too fantastic.

   La Presse, 1860

It’s just a theory. Not evolution. Germ theory. Just a theory, one of many that 
account for the etiology of diseases.

I should mention my bias up front. I am, as some of you are aware, an Infectious
Disease doctor. My job is simple: me find germ, me kill germ, me go home. I
think there are three causes of disease: wear and tear, genetic, and germs.
Perhaps a bit of an exaggeration, but not much. My professional life for the
last 22 years has been spent preventing, diagnosing, and treating the
multitudinous germs that a continually trying to kill or injure us. It is a
fundamentally futile job, as in the end I will be consumed by the organisms I
have spend a lifetime trying to kill.

I would have though that the germ theory of disease was a concept that was so
grounded in history, science and reality that there would be little opposition
to the idea that germs (a broad term for viruses, bacteremia, fungi, parasite
etc) cause infections and some other diseases.

Wrong. There are people who deny the validity of germ theory. Add there are
people who deny gravity. And evolution.

Opponents of germ theory come in two flavors:

Germ theory deniers.

Those who propose alternative mechanisms of disease.

There is great overlap between the two categories, and the division serves more 
as a literary device for the sake of exposition than a true description of
reality.

Germ Deniers

The germ deniers put forth as their patron Saint Antoine Bechamp, a contemporary
of Louis Pasteur. Bechamp lived from 1816 to 1908, the dawn of modern medicine 
and the beginning of microbiology. No one had a clue in the 1800′s as to the
cause and treatment of diseases and there were many speculations and experiments
performed in an attempt to understand and treat diseases. Most people had a
life expectancy less than 50 years and the predominant cause of morbidity and
morality was infectious. Since we do not die young of infections and we get to
live long enough to die of cancer, heart and vascular disease. Before the
1900′s, if you could understand what caused infections, you could understand
most diseases.

The foundations of microbiology and infectious diseases are based on the work of
Pasteur and Robert Koch. Like Darwin, the insights of Pasteur and Koch are not 
the end of understanding of infectious diseases, but the beginning. The world is
far more complicated and subtle than Pasteur and Koch could appreciate with the
scientific tools of the time.

Pasteur, of course, performed the experiments that proved that germs existed and
were a cause of some diseases. His name is well known and lives on in
pasteurization, the heating of milk to kill microorganisms and prevent the
spread of disease, one of many contributions he made to medical sciences. His
insights, which lead to antibiotics, hygiene, and vaccines have undoubtedly
prevented more morbidity and mortality than any human in history.

Another contemporary of Pasteur was Robert Koch, who, among many accomplishments
formulated Koch’s postulates, conditions that were to be met to prove the
infectious cause of disease:

The organism has to found in all cases of the disease

The organism has to prepared and maintained in a pure culture

The organism had to be capable of producing the original infection, even after
several generations in culture

The organism retrievable from an inoculated animal and cultured again.

Modern biochemistry and molecular techniques have refined Kochs postulates. We
can’t always grow the organism but we can isolated its DNA. Given the species
specificity of some germs, we cannot always infect animals to prove causation. I
doubt anyone would want to prove the cause of Ebola by re-inoculating a human
with cultured virus. Also, there is great variability in the ability of many
germ strains to cause disease and great variability in the hosts immune system
to combat diseases. Some germs are more virulent than others. Some people are
some or less susceptible to disease, and the last 10 years have seen an
explosion in understanding of the variability in the human immune system
(polymorphism’s) that explain why some people get ill from a given pathogen and 
others do not.

The combination of germ theory and Koch’s postulates, improved and refined by
biotechnology, are still the cornerstones of infectious diseases. Pasteur, Koch 
and their contemporaries began the science of infectious diseases and
microbiology, a field that has lead to more benefits to mankind than perhaps any
other.

What do the germ deniers offer as a alternative to Pasteur et. al.? The theory
of Antoine Bechamp and others called pleomorphism (1).

   CELLULAR THEORY (BECHAMP)

   Disease arises from micro-organisms within the cells of the body.

   These intracellular microorganisms normally function to build and assist in
   the metabolic processes of the body.

   The function of these organisms changes to assist in the catabolic
   (disintegration) processes of the host organism when that organism dies or is
   injured, which may be chemical as well as mechanical.

   Microorganisms change their shapes and colours to reflect the medium

   Every disease is associated with a particular condition.

   Microorganisms become “pathogenic” as the health of the host organism
   deteriorates. Hence, the condition of the host organism is the primary causal
   agent.

   Disease is built by unhealthy conditions.

   To prevent disease we have to create health.

Bechamp’s hypothesis was, at the time, no more or no less reasonable than other 
ideas. Unfortunately for him, a century and a half of research has demonstrated 
that there he was wrong on all the particulars of his ideas, except for 7 and 8.
Postulates 1, 2, 3, 4, and 6 are all flat out false. From 1950 to November 2nd 
2008 at 9:50 am PST, there were 909, 599 citations on Pubmed relating to
infections. How many papers and experiments were done in the 100 years prior to 
1950 I do not know, but it is a safe bet that germ theory is supported by over a
million studies and experiments. A Pubmed for terms to support pleomorphism
finds zero references. Germ theory is as confirmed a concept as science can
offer. Cellular theory lost the battle to experiment. Reality and science
supports the ideas of Pasteur, not Bechamp.

Alternative practitioners are drawn to the concepts of Bechamp because the
reason for disease is that the body fails. Alternative providers are all about
supporting health to allow the body to heal itself. Bechamp lends credibility to
many alternative practices.

Here is where it gets weird.

Rather than look at the mountains of evidence to support germ theory and the
complete lack of evidence to support pleomorphism as the reason for the
dominance of germ theory, they resort to paranoid sounding conspiracy theories.

The Whale is a good source for this kind of thinking and is representative of
what you will find if you browse the web:

   How did Pasteur’s ideas become the foundation of organized medicine?
   Politics. Pharmaceutical economics.

   Early in his career, Pasteur was decorated by the Emperor Napoleon. His
   position as a scientist was thereby secured, even though he was only a
   chemist and had no credentials at all in medicine or physiology…..

   For the first time in history, things were coming into focus. Discoveries
   were being made about fundamental issues, but in a piecemeal fashion. It was 
   perfect timing for an opportunist to take advantage of the general
   uncertainty and lack of understanding and to claim that he understood all the
   issues involved, and furthermore had thought of them first. Pasteur was
   noted for his habit of playing both sides of the fence on issues he didn’t
   understand, and then later, to quote the parts of his earlier writing that
   supported the later finding, always with the claim that he had been there
   first. Only the scientists understood the complexities of these emerging
   ideas. The royal court and the press just knew that something was going on,
   and though they didn’t know what, were going to act as though they did. And
   for them, a chameleon like Pasteur was the perfect frontman.

   Politics never changes. The same type of thinking that imprisoned Galileo
   long ago for discovering that the earth went around the sun, the rulers’
   eternal attempt to control the minds of their subjects, these are the forces 
   that cast Pasteur, an ambitious opportunist, into a position he may not have 
   deserved – the supposed Trailblazer in the science of modern biomedicine.

   Funny how things often don’t really get “discovered” until the commercial
   aspects of that discovery have been worked out.

or

   Béchamp’s research revealed that the inner condition of a person’s cellular
   terrain determined whether disease would manifest or spread in the body. He
   proved through rigorous scientific method that disease was not due to germs
   attacking the body from the outside as Louis Pasteur later convinced the
   world. What you eat, breathe, drink, and bathe in are the primary factors
   that determine your body’s inner condition.

   Instead of incorporating Béchamp’s discoveries to bring about a health
   revolution in the world and save countless lives, greedy, power hungry
   industrialists decided to ostracize his work and put their dollars behind
   Louis Pasteur’s “Germ Theory of Disease” because it was a way for them to
   build a colossal pharmaceutical/medical empire for profit. No pharmaceutical 
   company in the world today cares one iota about curing disease. They want to 
   control disease and focus on symptom suppression so they can make huge
   profits by getting you to become a lifelong user until you die from their
   poison. That’s why they go to war against disease with all their “anti” this 
   and “anti” that medications instead of addressing the inner condition of a
   patient and re-establishing homeostasis in the body. (2)

This is weird not only because it denies over a million interrelated studies
that confirm germ theory, but Pasteur’s fundamental ideas were confirmed about
60 years before the discovery of penicillin. That is just how subtle and clever 
big Pharma is: they suppressed a theory because they knew that 60 years in the
future they would make a fortune selling antibiotics. Someone needs to send Big 
Pharma the JREF million dollar prize.

Then there are HIV deniers, who live in a bizarro world of their own. My medical
career started with the onset of the HIV epidemic. I have seen HIV go from zero
understanding about the disease and a 9 month life expectancy to amazing detail
about the biochemistry and pathophysiology of HIV and an almost normal life
expectancy for many AIDS patients. There are 191,000 plus articles on Pubmed
concerning HIV research. The astounding accumulation of data to support HIV as a
cause of AIDS and the benefits of applying that understanding to the treatment 
of AIDS is triumph of the modern medical-industrial complex. It is why I have
one AIDS patient die this century after a decade of AIDS deaths. Application of 
germ theory saves lives. Millions and millions of lives.

Of course, that is just what they told me to say.

Alternative mechanisms of disease

There are a multitude of alternative mechanisms of disease: blocked chi in
acupuncture, blocked innate intelligence in chiropractic, toxin build up in the 
colon, etc etc. What these alternative therapies share is a lack of appreciation
or understanding of germ theory. Since germs cannot be seen, and since it is
not germs but their alternative theory that causes disease, why would you expect
alternative providers to behave as if germs exist? The result of believing that
germs do not exist is infections. The germs will always win.

Acupuncture and Infections

Acupuncture is unique compared to most alternative practices in that it is
invasive and because acupuncturists actually do something to accomplish nothing.
Stick needles into people and you can drag in all kinds of germs. I have a
healthy respect for needles and the damage they can cause by practitioners who
understand germ theory. A review of adverse events associated with acupuncture
demonstrated that “Infection accounted for 204 primary reports and 91 secondary 
reports. Over 60% of these cases were hepatitis B. The next most common
infection was of the external ear, as a complication of auricular acupuncture
(3).”

Cellulitis, bacteremia, endocarditis, empyema, osteomyelitis, endophthalmitis,
abdominal abscesses, epidural abscesses and infected joints are well described
complications of acupuncture. Blood borne pathogens such as HIV, hepatitis C and
hepatitis B are associated with acupuncture. Mycobacterium abscesses and
Mycobacterium chelonae outbreaks have occurred due to acupuncture. Needles are
dangerous, and while the body has good defenses against infectious complications
of minor trauma, the defenses fail on occasion.

One would think acupuncturists would clean the skin before needle insertion, but
a review of skin disinfection for acupuncture states: “Disinfection of clean
skin before injection is not generally considered necessary and observations of 
lack of infection following injections without prior skin disinfection support
this (4).” Another review suggests that “none the less, good infection control
is essential” but that assumes the practitioner understands and appreciates germ
theory as a cause of infectious diseases. Infection after penetrating trauma is
uncommon, a rare event under most circumstances. I would guess that many
reading this have evidence of minor skin trauma right now and are not infected. 
It is what the immune system is for.

One of the lessons you learn in medicine is there is a difference between what
one can get away and what is the best practice for all patients. Most of the
time you do not need to wash your hands or prep the skin or do any of the
procedures that decrease the risk of infections. Most of the time you can get
away with being sloppy. But the more you practice infection control procedures, 
the greater the odds that the patient will avoid infection. Of course, there is 
the underlying assumption that you think germs cause disease. If not, why
bother? There are a smattering of infections treated with acupuncture (UTI, skin
infections, arthritis) in the medical literature; one can only wonder why. I
suppose the acupuncture will support immune health a foster the innate healing
process. I would rather kill bacteria. But then, I would.

Chiropractic and Infections

Two studies have cultured chiropractic exam tables and found pathogens,
including methicillin resistant staphylococcus. Apparently chiropractors are not
particularly fastidious at disinfecting their exam tables. Why would they?
Germs are not necessarily the cause of disease in their world view.

I am particularly drawn to one of the conclusions: “Rudimentary behavioral
changes to improve chiropractic clinic infection control are needed.”
Rudimentary. Not an enthusiastic vote that the education chiropractors received 
in school was in infection control. I note chiropractic schools offer
microbiology, and again I wonder why. It would not appear to be for the purpose 
of learning rudimentary infection control. But why should they feel inclined
towards good infection control practices? The cause of disease is not germs, it 
is due to blocked innate intelligence.

It maybe less of an issue currently, but chiropractors long opposed germ theory 
and a google using chiropractor and germ theory as search terms finds no
shortage of chiropractors who oppose the concept of germs causing disease. Given
the huge variability in chiropractic practice, it is difficult to know if such 
lack of understanding of germ theory is typical of the field or not.

Other practices

There was an outbreak of colonic amoebiasis associated with colonic irrigation. 
Thirty six people developed the disease and 10 required colectomy. “Tests of the
colonic-irrigation machine after routine cleaning showed heavy contamination
with fecal coliform bacteria. The severity of disease in this outbreak may have 
been related to the route of inoculation.” Colonic irrigation is done to cleanse
the colon of toxin build up that causes disease. It is an idea for the cause of
diseases that has no bearing on reality and colonic irrigation is useless for
removing toxins or curing diseases. Why concern yourself with germs and their
transmission to others, since they are not a cause of disease. It is no surprise
that the cleaning was not optimal

Moxibustion has been associated (and yes I know association is not causation)
with a spinal epidural abscess and with a Pasturella abscess. The other
complication of moxibustion is burn injury, which is fertile soil for
infections. It is no surprise that this procedure would be associated with
infection.

Naturopathic care is associated with a case of prosthetic valve endocarditis
with P. acnes after unnecessary vitamin injections.

Other alternative modalities have fewer or no reported infections associated
with them probably because they do not do anything. The recent 50 facts about
homeopathy suggested “The chances of contracting MRSA or C. Difficile at a
Homeopathic Hospital are extremely rare.” Of course it is. An intervention that 
does nothing cannot have an infectious complication. Doing nothing results in
nothing.

What unites many alternative practitioners is their opposition to vaccines.
Germs don’t cause disease, so why prevent infections with vaccines? Like many
practices with alternative medicine practitioners, it is difficult to know how
pervasive anti-vaccine sentiments are.

CAM also lends support to the “anti-vaccination movement. In particular,
sections of the chiropractors, the (non-medically trained) homoeopaths and
naturopaths tend to advise their clients against immunization. The reasons for
this attitude are complex and lie, at least in part in the early philosophies
which form the basis of these professions (5).” In other words belief in magic
prevents understanding of infectious diseases and germ theory.

Chiropractors often advise against vaccination and do not vaccinate their own
children. There is a contingent chiropractors of who are against vaccines, but
to what degree they represent chiropractors as a whole I cannot say. Since
Chiropractors are not required to use evidence to base their practice, there
appears to be fewer standards and greater variability as to what what
constitutes chiropractic practice. Attitude by health care professionals can
influence decisions to vaccinate, and 27% of chiropractors in one survey advised
against childhood vaccination (7). In another series where a fictitious patient
asked for vaccination advice on the internet, of 93 homeopaths and
chiropractors, “no homeopath and only one chiropractor advised in favor of the
MMR vaccination (8).”

Advice from chiropractors, homeopaths, naturopaths and other alternative
practitioners against vaccinations abounds on the web, it is difficult to tell
from the published studies if this dangerous advice is the norm for these
practitioners or the deviant recommendations of the more extreme of the already 
irrational. The studies are few and small in number, but disturbing in their
implications. Chiropractors and naturopaths are pro childhood infection.

Anti-vaccination is often spun as an issue of choice “Concerning immunization
information, a much higher proportion of faculty (91%) and students (80%) than
practitioners (62%) felt chiropractors should provide both pro and con
information to patients (6).”

It may be that the biggest source of infections from alternative medicine
practitioners is not what they do but what they do not do. The only studies I
can find on vaccine refusal concerns religious exemptions. I wonder how many who
refuse vaccinations do so because of information obtained from chiropractors,
homeopaths, naturopaths and other alternative practitioners.

I looked for, and could not find, studies that examined how compliant various
alternative providers are with rudimentary hand hygiene and other infection
control recommendations. In science based medicine, where germs are an accepted 
etiology of disease, compliance with hand hygiene has historically been poor.
Rates for hand washing have typically been less than 50% in a group of people
who allegedly think germs exist. Thanks to intensive education and focus this
century, hand hygiene rates have gone up at all my hospitals. It has been
gratifying to see as the compliance with infection control has increased, the
rates of hospital acquired infections have dropped. The last 19 years that I
have been the Chair of our Infection Control committee has seen the continuous
and relentless decline in infections at all my hospitals. That is one of the
side effects of applying evidence based medicine and germ theory to the
hospital: infections decrease.

Any useless anecdotes from readers? Did your chiropractor wash her hands? Your
naturopath? Your primary care doc? If not, you should perhaps seek care
elsewhere.

All of the infections associated with alternative medicine modalities are
unusual. I also suspect that the infectious complications associated with
alternative medicine are under reported because it takes time and effort to
report cases. I have seen a handful of infections (and other complications)
associated with alternative therapies and have neither the time nor inclination 
to report them formally to a journal.

I am certain someone will mention in the comments all the morbidity and
mortality us real doctors cause on a regular basis. Health care is not,
unfortunately, risk free, and I know all too well the improvements that could be
done to improve patient safety. I also know the enormous strides we have made
in preventing hospital acquired infections during my career. I used to be able
to make a living off hospital acquired infections and the last 19 years have
shown a steady decrease in nosocomial infections at my hospitals to the point
where some have not had a nosocomial pneumonia in over a year.

In medicine we have to weigh the risks of what we do with the benefits we hope
to gain. In the world of alternative medicine, there is all risk with no
benefit. See http://whatstheharm.net/ for more anecdotes (not data).

Beliefs in disease causation have consequences. Believing that germs do not
cause disease doesn’t affect the germs. They are out there waiting for the
opportunity to invade and try and kill you. Job security.

References

(1) http://whale.to/p/bechamp.html

(2)
http://www.healthtruthrevealed.com/full-page.php?page=article&&id=11421316206

http://whale.to/v/bechamp1.html

Acupuncture references:

(3) Acupunct Med. 2004 Sep;22(3):122-33. A cumulative review of the range and
incidence of significant adverse events associated with acupuncture.

(4) Acupunct Med. 2001 Dec;19(2):112-6. Skin disinfection and acupuncture.

Outbreak of invasive methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus infection
associated with acupuncture and joint injection. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 
2008 Sep;29(9):859-65. PMID: 18684094.

Acupuncture-associated Listeria monocytogenes arthritis in a patient with
rheumatoid arthritis. Joint Bone Spine. 2008 Jul;75(4):502-3. Epub 2008 May 2.
PMID: 18455948

Outbreak of acupuncture-associated cutaneous Mycobacterium abscessus
infections.J Cutan Med Surg. 2006 Jul-Aug;10(4):166-9.PMID: 17234114

[Risk of hepatitis C related to traditional medicine: a case control study in Ho
Chi Minh City, Vietnam] Rev Epidemiol Sante Publique. 2007 Apr;55(2):107-12.
French. PMID: 17 442516

Paraplegia caused by spinal infection after acupuncture.Spinal Cord. 2006
Apr;44(4):258-9.PMID: 16151454

Multiloculated pleural empyema following acupuncture.Infection. 2005
Aug;33(4):297-8. PMID: 16091905

HIV infection after Chinese traditional acupuncture treatment.Complement Ther
Med. 2003 Dec;11(4):272. PMID: 1496979

Soft tissue abscess and osteomyelitis secondary to acupuncture.ANZ J Surg. 2003 
Sep;73(9):770. PMID: 12956798

Group B Streptococcus endogenous endophthalmitis : case reports and review of
the literature.Ophthalmology. 2002 Oct;109(10):1879-86. Review. PMID: 12359609

Chiropractic References

Chiropr Osteopat. 2007 Jun 7;15:8. Assessment and risk reduction of infectious
pathogens on chiropractic treatment tables.

Am J Infect Control. 2006 Apr;34(3):155-7. The role of chiropractic adjusting
tables as reservoirs for microbial diseases.

Chiropr Hist. 1996 Jun;16(1):72-87 Chiropractic’s tension with the germ theory
of disease.

Other Practices

N Engl J Med. 1982 Aug 5;307(6):339-42.Links An outbreak of amebiasis spread by 
colonic irrigation at a chiropractic clinic.

Spinal epidural abscess associated with moxibustion-related infection of the
finger. J Spinal Cord Med. 2008;31(3):319-23. PMID: 18795486

Pasteurella multocida infection of the calf in a patient who had moxa cautery
treatment for degenerative arthritis. Yonsei Med J. 1982;23(1):65-70

Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 1991 Sep 20;111(22):2741-2. [Bacterial endocarditis
after treatment by a natural healer]

Vaccines and alt med

(5) Vaccine. 2001 Oct 15;20 Suppl 1:S90-3; discussion S89. Rise in popularity of
complementary and alternative medicine: reasons and consequences for
vaccination.

(6) J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2004 Jun;27(5):287-98. A survey of US
chiropractors on clinical preventive services.

http://www.chirobase.org/06DD/chiroimmu.html

(7) Vaccine. 2004 Dec 2;23(3):372-9. here to read Beliefs and behaviours:
understanding chiropractors and immunization; Association between Health Care
Providers’ Influence on Parents Who Have Concerns about Vaccine Safety and
Vaccination Coverage.: Smith PJ, Kennedy AM, Wooten K, Gust DA, Pickering
LK.Pediatrics, November 2006; 118(5):e1287-e1292

(8) Vaccine. 2003 Mar 7;21(11-12):1044-7. MMR vaccination advice over the
Internet.

                              Compare and Contrast

                                  Mark Crislip

                                      Link

I have been in Infectious Diseases for almost 25 years. I have two major jobs: I
see inpatient consults and I chair the Infection Control program. I have been
involved in quality improvement, especially as it relates to hospital acquired
infections, for my entire career. It has been an interesting quarter century.
Year after year we have driven down infection rates and other kinds of mortality
and morbidity in hospitalized patients. Everyone recognizes that medicine is
difficult and dangerous and its biggest problem is medicine is practiced by
humans, who, I would venture to observe, are prone to mistakes and any number of
cognitive errors.

It has not been a easy journey. People hate change and there has not always been
certainty as to the best options to choose to solve a problem, a problem that
continues today. For example, how best to treat a patient with potential
methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus colonization (MRSA). Should we
screen everyone? Screen high risk patients? Surgical patients? Do we decolonize,
with the long term consequence of accelerating antibiotic resistance? Do we
place everyone with MRSA in isolation, with the known decrease in care that
patients in isolation may have? Everything we do has potential downsides and
unintended consequences. No good deed ever goes unpunished.

When I was a resident every PVC (preventricular contractions) in cardiac patents
was suppressed as we thought PVC’s were the sentinel event that led to
ventricular tachycardia and death. So patients received IV lidocaine and we
often sent patients home on quinidine or other antiarrhythmics. Subsequent
studies demonstrated that antiarrhythmics may have killed more people than they 
saved, and doctors no longer suppress every PVC in the ICU. Medicine changes,
one hopes for the better, offering old geezers like me the opportunity to
‘reminisce’ about the old days, when I tied an onion to my belt, which was the
style at the time. Now, to take the ferry cost a nickel, and in those days,
nickels had pictures of bumblebees on ‘em. Give me five bees for a quarter,
you’d say. Now where were we? Oh yeah: the important thing was I had an onion on
my belt, which was the style at the time.

Sorry. I digress. A couple of months ago I had a patient with severe malaria
that needed IV quinidine (the dextrorotatory diastereoisomer of quinine, but
that is obvious) and there was none in the pharmacy; we had to get some shipped 
in by our dealer, er, distributor. In medicine, if it discovered that what was
thought to be a beneficial intervention turns out to cause more harm than good, 
the intervention is abandoned.

When To Err is Human was published, it caused quite a brouhaha. Depending on
whose numbers you want to believe, 44 to 98 thousand Americans died each year
from medical errors. I did not have issues with the numbers. There are about
5700 hospitals in the US, so that would be about one death every month and a
half. Knowing what I did about infections and other complications in the
hospital, that did not seem like an unreasonable estimate. A bit high, perhaps, 
but in the ballpark of my understanding of reality.

That is old data, and no longer applicable. Due, in part, to To Err is Human,
the last decade has led to innumerable studies evaluating the causes of
infections and complications in hospitals and the best approaches to decrease
them. My institutions have invested huge time and effort to implement these
quality improvements with great success.

When I started in Infection Control, the infection data was considered
protected. The thought was that institutions would be more likely to collect and
evaluate data about infections if there were not discoverable by lawyers. The
downside was, as I was informed, if I informed anyone about the data, it would
no longer be protected, and the institutions would be open to expensive
lawsuits. This century my institutions are much more transparent about
disseminating information about our practice. I thought I would have a
conniption the first time I saw the infection data for the ICU posted in the ICU
for all too see. It turns out, like so many deeply held convictions, that
keeping the data protected was a bad idea. Transparency has not led to an
increase in lawsuits but it has led to a decline in all manner of hospital
associated complications. Our staff takes a great deal of pride in their work.
They took the data as a personal affront and worked to improve all aspects of
patient care. When they saw harm potentially occurring, practice changed for the
better.

So there are three reactions to new data in medicine that demonstrates that a
given medical practice may cause harm.

First, the data and the conclusions are challenged, as they should be. All
studies are open to analysis and improvement. In medicine we continuously try to
improve care, and that requires good information.

Second, further studies are done to confirm and refine the problem and other
studies are done to see how practice can be improved.

The third is practice change, which is often slower than we like. But change we 
do. I am old enough that I often bore the residents with how it used to be in
the old days. Medicine today is drastically different than 20 years ago, and
many logs better.

The most impressive example of improvement in the last 20 years is hand hygiene.
Hand washing adherence 20 years ago was an embarrassment. Part of the problem
was the time it took to wash hands; I have heard that if a nurse spent her time 
appropriately washing her hands, 80% of his shift would be spent at the sink.

Alcohol foam changed that. When we introduced the foam in the hospital, even
when compliance was only 20%, we had a 50% drop in hospital infections, and as
compliance has increased to 90 to 95%, the infections had a parallel decline.
And the effects of alcohol foam improved once I discovered it was not a po
agent, to be used like Cheez Whiz. Our biggest problem now is fall prevention.
Most falls occur when the patient doesn’t want to bother the nurse and, in the
process of moving about the room without help, falls. We are investigating ways 
to remove gravity from the hospital.

The threshold for changing and abandoning a therapy can be very small. Last
century there was a drug called trovafloxacin that caused several hundred cases 
of hepatitis and a half a dozen deaths when it was being prescribed at a rate of
300,000 new prescriptions a month. Hepatitis was an extremely unusual
complication, but the small risk was not worth the potential benefits since
there were equally efficacious alternatives.

Compare and contrast medicine and alt med.

Most alt med interventions are, of course, based on eternal truths that cannot
be improved or changed. They are often immune to reality induced change. Studies
that confirm their eternal truth are always accepted. Studies that show harm or
lack of efficacy? Not so much.

Certainly, when complications of alternative medicines are published the data is
up for discussion. That is good and as it should be. But that is where the
similarities with medicine ends.

There is an ongoing issue of safety in the two most invasive alternative
interventions: acupuncture and chiropractic.

There were two reviews concerning chiropractic safety published recently. Safety
of chiropractic interventions: a systematic review, which found

   A total of 376 potential relevant articles were identified, 330 of which were
   discarded after abstract or complete article analysis. The search identified
   46 articles that included data concerning adverse events: 1 randomized
   controlled trial, 2 case-control studies, 7 prospective studies, 12 surveys, 
   3 retrospective studies, and 115 case reports. Most of the adverse events
   reported were benign and transitory, however, there are reports of
   complications that were life threatening, such as arterial dissection,
   myelopathy, vertebral disc extrusion, and epidural hematoma. The frequency of
   adverse events varied between 33% and 60.9%, and the frequency of serious
   adverse events varied between 5 strokes/100,000 manipulations to 1.46 serious
   adverse events/10,000,000 manipulations and 2.68 deaths/10,000,000
   manipulations.

   CONCLUSION: There is no robust data concerning the incidence or prevalence of
   adverse reactions after chiropractic. Further investigations are urgently
   needed to assess definite conclusions regarding this issue.

That is impressive complication rates, although the authors suggest the data to 
support the rates are not robust, for an intervention that only has at best
proven efficacy for low back pain and safer alternatives. Also published
recently was Deaths after chiropractic: a review of published cases.

   Twenty six fatalities were published in the medical literature and many more 
   might have remained unpublished. The alleged pathology usually was a vascular
   accident involving the dissection of a vertebral artery.

That is about three times the number of deaths from trovafloxacin, an excellent 
antibiotic that we abandoned in the U.S. as too dangerous. Of course, we have
safer alternatives with equal efficacy.

Also recently published was Acupuncture-related adverse events: a systematic
review of the Chinese literature which found

   that in total reported on 479 cases of adverse events after acupuncture.
   Fourteen patients died. Acupuncture-related adverse events were classified
   into three categories: traumatic, infectious and “other”. The most frequent
   adverse events were pneumothorax, fainting, subarachnoid haemorrhage and
   infection, while the most serious ones were cardiovascular injuries,
   subarachnoid haemorrhage, pneumothorax and recurrent cerebral haemorrhage.

Based on the reported complications of the two interventions, if they were a
medical therapy regulated in a manner similar to medications and medical
devices, they would certainly have, at a minimum, a black box warning and, in
the case of chiropractic, no longer be used. Especially as there are no good
indications for chiropractic or acupuncture.

What you do not see in the medical literature or the chiropractic blogs is any
concern that harm may be done and investigations into changes in practice that
could minimize the morbidity and mortality.

Instead you get The Self Importance of Being Ernst and Death by Chiropractic
Another Misbegotten Review

Two essay that show zero interest in considering that chiropractic could
potentially cause harm, the latter including the argument that it is real
doctors that kill people and in comparison out ‘an order of magnitude greater
than the side-effects attributed to spinal manipulation.’ See. If you kill small
numbers of people, it is not important. Safety only matters when you kill
people in large numbers. In the risk/benefit calculus of medicine, an
intervention that has no benefit should cause no harm.

If there are concerns in the chiropractic community expressed about these
complications, I can’t find them. If there is to improve chiropractic care, I
can’t find it. If there is any quality/safety research being done, please rub my
nose in it. I would love to know and those involved or aware of such research
should trumpet the results for all to read. All the literature and letters to
the editor I can find concerns denying there is a problem at all.

At least I could find concerns in the acupuncture literature : ‘A single injury 
– let alone a fatality – caused by acupuncture is one too many.” Exactly right. 
If you are practicing prescientific magic, it should have a mortality and
morbidity of zero. Again if there is ongoing research into improving the safety 
of acupuncture, I cannot find it either.

Both seem far more interested in the messenger (Dr. Ernst) and his malevolent
intent rather than the message.

It is, I think, a key difference between medicine and its ‘alternatives’. The
former takes safety and quality seriously and strives constantly with research
and its application to improve care. The alternatives? Nope. Not yet. And
probably never.

UK Recommendations Wrong on Acupuncture

NICE draft recommendations on acupuncture don’t even make sense from an EBM
perspective, and utterly fail to consider SBM principles.

Steven Novella on August 5, 2020

Link



The draft of the latest recommendations from the National Institute for Health
Care Excellence (NICE) from the UK includes a recommendation to consider
acupuncture for chronic pain (within some limits that primarily have to do with 
cost-effectiveness). They write:

   Consider a course of acupuncture or dry needling, within a traditional
   Chinese or Western acupuncture system, for people aged 16 years and over to
   manage chronic primary pain,

Here is their justification for this recommendation:

   Many studies (27 in total) showed that acupuncture reduced pain and improved 
   quality of life in the short term (3 months) compared with usual care or sham
   acupuncture. There was not enough evidence to determine longer term
   benefits. The committee acknowledged the difficulty in blinding for sham
   procedures, but agreed that the benefit compared with a sham procedure
   indicated a specific treatment effect of acupuncture. There was a wide
   variation among the studies in the type and intensity of the intervention
   used, and the studies were from many different countries. The committee
   agreed that the type of acupuncture or dry needling should depend on the
   individual needs of the person with pain.

This recommendation and justification represent, in my opinion, not only a
failure of NICE but a great example of the inadequacy of evidence-based medicine
(EBM) in dealing with topics such as acupuncture, and the need for
science-based medicine (SBM). A review of their supporting evidence (published
separately) reveals the disconnect.

They summarize the evidence:

   Very low quality evidence from 13 studies with 1230 participants showed a
   clinically important benefit of acupuncture compared to sham acupuncture at
   ≤3 months. Low quality evidence from 2 studies with 159 participants showed a
   clinically important benefit of acupuncture compared to sham acupuncture at 
   ≤3 months.

Their recommendation for acupuncture benefits ≤3 months is based, by their own
admission, mostly on very low quality evidence and some low quality evidence.
What does this mean? Mostly that the trials are not properly controlled or
blinded. Given that acupuncture has a high placebo effect, this renders the
results mostly worthless. Even within a pure EBM framework, this is an extremely
weak justification for a recommendation.

Edzard Ernst, also writing critically of this recommendation, points out that
the most extensive review of the literature to date came to a different
conclusion – that the evidence for acupuncture in various chronic pain
conditions reveals weak evidence of a transient and small effect only. So again,
even taking a pure EBM approach, the evidence is insufficient to conclude that 
acupuncture has a “specific effect” as NICE claims.

But now let’s take a more thorough SBM approach. What are the NICE guidelines
and other reviews leaving out? First – what does it mean that acupuncture has a 
“specific effect”? It means that acupuncture points are real, and that sticking 
needles into acupuncture points (which vary depending on the style of
acupuncture) has an effect other than just a theatrical placebo. This
conclusion, however, is demonstrably false. There is no scientific or objective 
basis to conclude that acupuncture points have any basis in reality. In short – 
they don’t exist. Even when acupuncturists review their own literature they
conclude that you cannot localize specific acupuncture points.

Further, the last century of research, since the modern reformulation of
acupuncture into something a little less barbaric and medieval, has failed to
find any physiological, neurological, biochemical, or anatomical correlate to
alleged acupuncture points. This is an argument from absence of evidence, but
given the extensive research it is very telling.

If acupuncture points don’t exist, either theoretically or empirically, then how
can there be a specific effect from interacting with them? Short answer – there
can’t be.

Experts reviewing acupuncture who are not familiar with the principles of SBM or
the characteristics of pseudoscience also tend to miss the fact that
acupuncture studies tend to mix their variables, in the hopes of passing off
non-acupuncture effects as if they are specific effects of acupuncture. The most
common example is using “electroacupuncture” in pain studies. This means,
essentially, doing electrical stimulation – which is a treatment for pain
(although with modest evidence itself) and selling it as acupuncture. This would
be exactly like injecting morphine through acupuncture needles and calling it
acupuncture.

Another glaring problem with the acupuncture literature is that much of it comes
from China. Independent reviews have found that acupuncture studies coming out 
of China are 100% positive. This would be statistically near impossible even if 
acupuncture had a real and robust effect. Given that, at best, studies show a
weak and tiny effect, the 100% positive results from China is solid evidence of 
systematic fraud and/or publication bias. The fact that you can be jailed in
China for criticizing Traditional Chinese Medicine might have something to do
with this.

There is also a clear pattern in the literature, but you need to go beyond
counting up studies to see it. The better controlled and blinded a study of
acupuncture, the more likely it is to be negative (outside of China, that is).
There is a clear negative relationship between quality and effect size, with the
effect decreasing to zero for the best studies.

If we put everything together, in a holistic SBM review of the evidence for
acupuncture, we can only conclude that it does not work – there is no specific
effect. What we see is exactly the kind of noise that we expect, and see in
other areas, when there is no real effect at work. The data, for example, is
virtually identical in pattern as for things like homeopathy or ESP. You can
never seem to nail down a specific effect with high-quality evidence. Combine
this with the very low prior probability (due, for example, to the non-existence
of acupuncture points) and we can only come to one clear scientific conclusion.
Acupuncture is a placebo-only intervention; acupuncture doesn’t work.

There is another important layer here as well, that NICE fails to consider in
their review (including their cost-effectiveness review), and that is the
downstream effects of recommending pseudoscience typically administered by
pseudoscientists. Acupuncturists don’t just use acupuncture for pain, they use
it for hundreds of indications, all unproven, up to and including serious
illnesses like cancer (not all acupuncturists, of course, but many do). By
recommending acupuncture for pain, based upon very weak evidence of a clinically
tiny effect in the face of a lack of a plausible mechanism, you are throwing
patients to the wolves. To think otherwise is extremely naïve – and that is
exactly what I find when I deal with health care experts who are not steeped in 
SBM or medical pseudoscience.

The public comment period for the NICE recommendations is open until Sept. 14.
Hopefully they will get the feedback they need.

  Spin City: Using placebos to evaluate objective and subjective responses in
                                     asthma

                                 David Gorski 

                                      Link

As I type this, I’m on an airplane flying home from The Amazing Meeting 9 in Las
Vegas. Sadly, I couldn’t stay for Sunday; my day job calls as I’ll be hosting a
visiting professor. However, I can say—and with considerable justification, I
believe—that out little portion of TAM mirrored the bigger picture in that it
was a big success. Attendance at both our workshop on Thursday and our panel
discussion on placebos on Saturday was fantastic, beyond our most optimistic
expectations. There was also a bit of truly amazing serendipity that helped make
our panel discussion on placebo medicine an even bigger success.

If there’s one thing about going away to a meeting, be it TAM or a professional 
meeting, it’s that it suddenly becomes very difficult for me to keep track of
all the medical and blog stuff that I normally keep track of and nearly
impossible to keep up with the medical literature. This is the likely
explanation for why I had been unaware of a study published in the New England
Journal of Medicine (NEJM) on Thursday that was so relevant to our discussion
and illustrated out points so perfectly that it was hard to believe that some
divine force didn’t give it to us in order to make our panel a total success.

Just kidding. It was TAM, after all. It was, however, embarrassing that I didn’t
see the study until the morning of our panel, when Kimball Atwood showed it to 
me.

Before I get to the meat of this study and why it fit into our nefarious plans
for world domination, (or at least the domination of medicine by science-based
treatments), a brief recap of the panel discussion would seem to be in order.
First, for the most part, we all more or less agreed that the term “placebo
effect” is a misnomer and somewhat deceptive because it implies that there is a 
true physiologic effect caused by an inert intervention. “Placebo response” or
“placebo responses” seemed to us a better term because what we are observing
with a placebo is in reality a patient’s subjective response to thinking that he
is having something active done having something done. In general, we do not
see placebo responses resulting improvement in objective outcomes; i.e.,
prolonged survival in cancer. The relative contributions of components of this
response, be they expectancy effects (if you expect to feel better you likely
will feel better), conditioning, or one that is frequently dismissed or
downplayed, namely artifacts of the design of randomized clinical trials and
even subtle (or even not-so-subtle) biases in trial design. This issue of
placebo responses being observed only in subjective patient-reported clinical
outcomes (pain, anxiety, and the like) and not in objectively measured outcomes 
is an important one, and it is one that goes to the heart of the NEJM study that
so serendipitously manifested itself to us. As Mark Crislip so humorously
pointed out, the placebo response is the beer goggles of medicine (this is not a
spoiler or stealing Mark’s line; several TAM attendees have already tweeted
Mark’s line), and much of what is being observed are changes in the patient’s
perception of his symptoms rather than true changes in the underlying
pathophysiology. This study drove the point home better than we could.

Another point discussed by the panel is also quite relevant. As more and more
studies demonstrate very convincingly that “complementary and alternative
medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” (IM) therapies do not produce
improvements in symptoms greater than placebo. Moreover, multiple studies,
including a famous NEJM meta-analysis and a recently updated Cochrane review,
demonstrate, placebo responses probably do not constitute meaningful responses. 
In light of these findings, CAM apologists, driven by ideology rather than
science and masters of spin, have begun to admit grudgingly that, yes, in
essence their treatments are elaborate placebos. Not to be deterred, instead of 
simply concluding that their CAM interventions do not work, they’ve moved the
goal posts and started to try to argue that it doesn’t matter that CAM effects
are placebo effects because placebos are “powerful” and good and—oh, yes, by the
way—there are a lot of treatments in science-based medicine that do little
better than placebos. In other words, CAM advocates elevate the subjective above
the objective and sell the subjective, and that’s exactly what they are doing
with this study.

Perception versus physiology

The study under question was performed at Harvard, with Michael E. Wechsler as
its first author and Ted Kaptchuk as its senior author. Studies done by groups
including Ted Kaptchuk have actually presented us here at SBM with copious blog 
fodder before, all designed to promote placebo medicine, either through making
an argumentum ad populum, claiming in a truly Humpty Dumpty moment that it is
possible to have placebo effects without deceiving the patient, and or
rebranding of exercise as “alternative” in the New England Journal of Medicine
(NEJM) last year.

The current study is entitled, Active Albuterol or Placebo, Sham Acupuncture, or
No Intervention in Asthma. Personally, I like this title. It’s a fine title, as
it tells the reader in essence what the trial design is in only a few words.
And it’s actually a reasonably good pilot study. Of course, it’s not so much the
trial design that goes disastrously awry. Rather, it’s the interpretation of
the results of the RCT that devolves into propaganda for quackademic medicine in
which subjective improvement is used to argue that placebo medicine is good,
even when no objective improvement is observed in a disease for which we have
good drugs that produce objective improvements as well as subjective
improvements.

This study basically compared four different interventions

  1. Treatment with Albuterol

  2. Sham acupuncture using the classic retractable needle (note that this was only
    single-blinded)

  3. Placebo inhaler

  4. No treatment at all

Inclusion criteria were as follows:

  1. Men and women age>or= 18 with a diagnosis of asthma

  2. Meet American Thoracic Society diagnostic criteria for asthma

  3. Currently using a stable asthma regimen (no med. changes for 4 weeks)

  4. Ability to withhold short-acting bronchodilators for 6 hours prior to each
    visit (see Spirometry description)

  5. Ability to withhold long-acting bronchodilators for 48 hours prior to each
    visit (see Spirometry description)

  6. Presence of reversible airflow obstruction as demonstrated by an improvement
    in FEV1 of at least 12 % following the inhalation of a β-agonist after 10
    am. at screening visit.

Exclusion criteria were straightforward:

  1. Lung disease other than asthma

  2. Respiratory tract infection within the last month

  3. Active tobacco use

  4. Asthma exacerbation requiring the use of systemic

  5. corticosteroids within the past 6 weeks

  6. Prior experience with acupuncture

These criterial guaranteed that the patients selected have only mild to moderate
asthma with no complications from the asthma, such as pneumonia or pulmonary
fibrosis. Of course, it would be highly unethical to take people with severe
asthma off of their bronchodilators; so medical ethics pretty much prevents
testing placebos on people with more severe disease. Still, I can’t help but
wonder whether the results reported would have been different in more severe
asthma and if the subjective improvement would have been nearly as great. In any
case, this study ended up including 39 patients, after 79 were screened, 46
underwent randomization, and 7 dropped out during the protocol. Patients who
completed the protocol underwent the following procedure:

   These patients returned within a week and were assigned to a randomly ordered
   series of four interventions — active albuterol inhaler, placebo inhaler,
   sham acupuncture, or no-intervention control — administered on four separate 
   occasions, 3 to 7 days apart (block 1) (Figure 2). This procedure was
   repeated in two more blocks of four visits each (blocks 2 and 3), during
   which the interventions were again randomly ordered and administered. Thus,
   each subject received a total of 12 interventions. Albuterol and the placebo 
   inhaler were administered in a double-blind fashion and sham acupuncture in a
   single-blind fashion, and the no-intervention control was not blinded. As
   before, short-acting and long-acting bronchodilator therapy was withheld for 
   8 hours and 24 hours, respectively, before each intervention. The
   no-intervention control condition differs from the natural history of asthma,
   since it controls for nonspecific factors such as attention from study
   staff, responses to repeated spirometry, regression to the mean, natural
   physiological variation, and any effects arising from the hospital setting.
   Nonetheless, no-intervention controls are the best approximation of no
   treatment in an experimental design. The study was conducted in accordance
   with the protocol (available at NEJM.org).

I’m not entirely sure why Kaptchuk thought he had to place a comment in there
about no-intervention controls being only an approximation of no treatment in an
experimental design. After all, that’s the sort of thing that clinicians and
clinical researchers simply know; it does not need to be pointed out to them,
much as it shouldn’t need to be pointed out that an RCT is an intentionally
artificial method designed to remove as many biases as possible. Be that as it
may, one thing that is clear is that these patients could not have truly severe 
asthma. Ruling out anyone requiring steroids for an acute exacerbation in the
recent past and only including patients who could be off their long-acting
bronchodilators for 48 hours and their short-acting bronchodilators for 6 hours 
pretty much guaranteed that.

Everyone’s heard the old cliche that a picture is worth a thousand words, and
this is exactly the sort of situation where that’s true. All I need to do is to 
show you two graphs, and instead of one of my usual 5,000 word blog posts, you
can have a 4,000 word post. Funny how that works. In any case, for your
edification, here a graph of the objective results of this study, namely the
FEV1 for the four groups:

Link

Not surprisingly, a known, effective bronchodilator had a very strong effect on 
the actual, objectively measured lung function of these patients. However, it
should be noted that all groups improved, even the no-treatment group; it just
improved much less than the albuterol group, and the sham acupuncture and
placebo albuterol groups were indistinguishable from the no-treatment arm. In
fact, in the supplemental data, there is also a table showing that in 32 of the 
patients exhaled nitric oxide (FENO) was measured, with identical results.
Immediately after treatment, FENO increased in patients treated with
double-blind albuterol by 5.9%, in contrast to patients treated with placebo
inhaler, placebo acupuncture, and no treatment, all of whom demonstrated no
significant change in FENO. This graph is about as clear and compelling evidence
as there can be within the limits of a relatively small trial, that placebo
responses do not change the underlying physiology of the disease of asthma or
produce any objectively measurable improvements in lung function the way that
real medicine does.

Now, for your edification and comparison, here is a graph of the self-reported
subjective improvements.

Link

The results are pretty striking, aren’t they? They were so striking that Steve
couldn’t resist flipping back and forth between these two graphs for several
seconds in order to drive home the point to the audience. The albuterol, sham
acupuncture, and placebo albuterol groups all demonstrated a significant
improvement in symptoms, while the no-intervention control did not. However,
here’s an important point. The scale used was a visual analog scale from 0 to 10
in which 0 means no improvement and 10 means complete resolution. So, again,
even though the albuterol, sham acupuncture, and placebo albuterol groups all
demonstrated subjective improvement, so did the no-treatment control arm, just
less. In other words, all groups reported improvement, even those who received
no treatment.

There’s another graph buried in the back of the supplemental data that I now
wish we had also shown. Basically, it’s a look at how many patients responded
objectively to treatment, as defined by an improvement in FEV1 of 12% or more,
at each of the three sessions they did. The results and pattern are striking:

Link

Notice that, as expected, the vast majority of the patients responded at each
session to the albuterol (3/3 sessions). In contrast, only 3% of patients
responded 3/3 times to placebo, sham acupuncture, or no treatment. In fact,
what’s striking is how similar the three graphs look and how different they look
from the graph of patient responses to albuterol. Again, the message is very
clear: Real medicine produces real, objectively measurable changes in physiology
towards a more normally functioning state. Placebo medicine does not. In any
rational, science-based discussion, this would be the end of the story. Placebos
don’t work in asthma.

But that’s not the message that was being spread about this story, and here’s
where the NEJM, less than a year after its massive fail in publishing a
credulous Michael Berman acupuncture article and a clever bait-and-switch
article looking at Tai Chi in fibromyalgia, allowed quackademic language to try 
to make left right, up down, and a negative result an indication that placebo
medicine is a good thing.

Spin, spin, spin, spin

As I read the discussion of this paper, I could almost hear the cracking of
bones as Kaptchuk went into major contortions to try to explain his negative
result. Even though nowhere did the authors really explicitly state their real
hypothesis, the design of the study made it painfully clear to anyone who
understands clinical research that their hypothesis going in was that placebo
responses would result in changes in objectively measured lung function in
asthma. They were sorely disappointed, and the contortions of language that went
into the discussion were plain to see. The authors implied that it might have
been their use of a new, not really validated, patient-reported measure of
asthma improvement. Or maybe, they argue, FEV1 isn’t a good measure of the
severity of constriction of the airways in asthma, even though spirometry has
been a reliable, well-validated test for asthma severity for decades. This is
especially true in an academic medical center with a lot of pulmonary
specialists. While spirometry can be unreliable in primary care settings and
other settings where there isn’t a lot of experience performing it, such a
description does not apply to Harvard-affiliated hospitals. At least I would
hope not.

Overall, the spin on this study is not that placeboes don’t result in
objectively measurable improvements, which is the correct conclusion. Rather,
the spin is that subjective symptoms are as important or more important than
objective measures; so let’s use placeboes. In the paper itself, Kaptchuk
doesn’t quite say that. He first makes a perfectly reasonable point that, if
subjective and objective findings don’t correlate, go with the objective
findings. Then he does some handwaving:

   Indeed, although improvement in objective measures of lung function would be 
   expected to correlate with subjective measures, our study suggests that in
   clinical trials, reliance solely on subjective outcomes may be inherently
   unreliable, since they may be significantly influenced by placebo effects.
   However, even though objective physiological measures (e.g., FEV1) are
   important, other outcomes such as emergency room visits and quality-of-life
   metrics may be more clinically relevant to patients and physicians.

My jaw dropped when I read this. “Other outcomes” besides objective measures of 
disease severity may be “more clinically relevant”? The spin goes way beyond
that, though. I have to think that the reviewers kept the authors from getting
too frisky with their desire to advocate placebo medicine and promote subjective
outcomes as being more important than objective outcomes. No such restraint
seemed to inhibit the author of the accompanying editorial, Daniel E. Moerman,
Ph.D., who, alas, appears to be based practically in my back yard at the
University of Michigan-Dearborn. I had never heard of him before; so I did what 
all bloggers do when they encounter an unknown. I Googled him. His CV is here,
and this is what I found:

   Daniel E. Moerman is the William E. Stirton Professor of Anthropology at the 
   University of Michigan — Dearborn, so recognized for his distinguished
   scholarship, teaching, and professional accomplishments. Because of his work 
   in the field of Native American ethnobotany, Professor Moerman often receives
   calls from the American Indian community, such as an inquiry from the
   Menominee in Wisconsin, asking him what kinds of plants they should include
   in the restoration of their indigenous ecosystem. He acknowledges that we are
   deeply indebted “to those predecessors of ours on the North American
   continent who, through glacial cold in a world populated by mammoths and
   saber-toothed tigers, seriously, deliberately, and thoughtfully studied the
   flora of a new world, learned its secrets, and encouraged the next
   generations to study closer and to learn more. Their diligence and energy,
   their insight and creativity, these are the marks of true scientists,
   dedicated to gaining meaningful and useful knowledge from a complex and
   confusing world.”

He’s also known for having written a book entitled Medicine, Meaning and the
“Placebo Effect,” part of which can be found here, in particular this doozy of a
quote:

   There is much objection among physicians to the very existence of something
   called the placebo effect. It often seems to bother doctors enormously that
   the fact of receiving medical treatment (rather than the content of medical
   treatment) can initiate a healing process. Why? I think it is because
   medicine is rich in a particular kind of science. Medical education is filled
   with science. In the US, all students must score high on the “Medical
   College Admission Test” in order to be admitted to medical school. Students
   are allowed a total of 345 minutes to complete the exam. Eight five minutes
   are devoted to “verbal reasoning,” and 60 minutes to “writing sample.” The
   remaining 200 minutes (58.5%) are split evenly between “physical sciences”
   and “biological sciences.” It is apparently important that physicians
   understand levers, inclined planes, the acceleration of falling bodies, the
   life cycle of insects, and the process of photosynthesis. The kind of science
   that doctors have to learn is the simpler sort of science, the mechanical
   kind. Physicists worked out the mechanics of simple machines (levers, planes)
   in the seventeenth century. In our times, they have been working on much
   slipperier subjects: quarks, chaos, the “weak force,” and the oddest of
   quantum phenomena. Cause and effect are far less easy to detect in these
   matters than in the study of falling bodies…But it is the latter, not the
   former, in which physicians are schooled. And there is very little social
   science in medical education where one must address the complexities and
   subtleties of, say, emotion, or ritual, or culture.

If you detect shades of Deepak Chopra in there, you are correct, all with a
dollop of utter contempt for Newtonian physics, which, I will remind you, are
still accurate enough for most real-world purposes here, where few things we do 
reach relativistic speeds. Instead, Moerman invokes quarks, quantum theory, and 
other complexities and contrasts it to the “simpler” sciences that physicians
apparently learn. One can almost feel the contempt for us poor, deluded
physicians. Perhaps if I had known a bit about Professor Moerman, my jaw ouldn’t
have dropped so far when I read this in the editorial accompanying the NEJM
study:

   What do we learn from this study? The authors conclude that the patient
   reports were “unreliable,” since they reported improvement when there was
   none — that is, the subjective experiences were simply wrong because they
   ignored the objective facts as measured by FEV1. But is this the right
   interpretation? It is the subjective symptoms that brought these patients to 
   medical care in the first place. They came because they were wheezing and
   felt suffocated, not because they had a reduced FEV1. The fact that they felt
   improved even when their FEV1 had not increased begs the question, What is
   the more important outcome in medicine: the objective or the subjective, the 
   doctor’s or the patient’s perception? This distinction is important, since it
   should direct us as to when patient-centered versus doctor-directed care
   should take place.

Apparently Moerman thinks that patient-centered care means inducing a patient
through placebo responses to think that he feels better when in actuality the
disease-impaired function of his organ (in this case, the lungs) puts him at
risk for serious complications. He then goes on to write:

   For subjective and functional conditions — for example, migraine,
   schizophrenia, back pain, depression, asthma, post-traumatic stress disorder,
   neurologic disorders such as Parkinson’s disease, inflammatory bowel disease
   and many other autoimmune disorders, any condition defined by symptoms, and 
   anything idiopathic — a patient-centered approach requires that
   patient-preferred outcomes trump the judgment of the physician. Under these
   conditions, inert pills can be as useful as “real” ones; two inert pills can 
   work better than one; colorful inert pills can work better than plain ones;
   and injections can work better than pills.

I find it hard not to notice that Moerman has cast a very wide net; virtually
any condition outside of trauma could fit into his definition. I can’t help but 
think that, if I, for instance, had asthma and the severity of my symptoms
didn’t correlate well with my objectively measured lung function as estimated by
FEV1, then I would want my lung function tuned up. And if I didn’t want my lung
function to be improved, I would hope that my doctor would be able to educate
me as to why it is important to make my lungs function better, even though I
feel OK. Moerman would seem to advocate telling me, “Oh, no, Dr. Gorski, don’t
worry about those blue lips you have. That’s just an ‘objective’ finding. You
feel OK, and, since I practice ‘patient-centered’ care, which teaches, among
other things, that symptoms are the most important thing and the reason why you 
come to a doctor in the first place, your feeling better is all that matters!”

I’ll give you another example. Consider an epidural hematoma. If you crack your 
head hard enough, it can sheer or damage one of the epidural arteries. The
typical clinical course is that the patient will be knocked unconscious due to
head trauma. Later, he will regain consciousness and experience what is known in
the biz as a “lucid interval” that can last several hours. What’s happening
during that “lucid interval” is that the blood is still accumulating, but the
hematoma hasn’t reached a large enough size yet to cause damage, but when it
does the patient deteriorates rapidly. Frequently, one of those “objective
findings” is a CT scan that shows a little epidural hematoma, which may or may
not blossom into a life threatening epidural hematoma that can squash the brain 
against the inside of the skull. That’s an “objective” finding. Even though the 
patient feels well; that hematoma could expand and kill him in a few hours.

No doubt Professor Moerman or Ted Kaptchuk would claim that these are ridiculous
and unfair examples. No doubt they would say that this is not what they’re
talking about, and that’s probably true. I’ll even concede that the example of
the epidural hematoma example was a bit over the top, but that was intentional.

However, whether they realize it or not, by elevating the subjective beyond the 
objective, and then offering placebo medicine for the subjective, these are
exactly the sort of arguments they are making, when you strip them to their
essence. No doubt Moerman or Kaptchuk would like to think that they would never,
ever use such an approach for diseases with such potentially bad outcomes, but 
where do they draw the line? When, exactly, do we decide that subjective
improvement is more important than objective improvement and by what
criteria?Moerman makes a great show of saying, “First, do no harm”:

   Do we need to control for all meaning in order to show that a treatment is
   specifically effective? Maybe it is sufficient simply to show that a
   treatment yields significant improvement for the patients, has reasonable
   cost, and has no negative effects over the short or long term. This is, after
   all, the first tenet of medicine: “Do no harm.”

Clearly implicit in Moerman’s statement is the assumption that not intervening
in the abnormal physiology of some diseases (for instance, asthma) doesn’t do
harm. He’s wrong. Sometimes doing nothing is harmful, as it allows the disease
to continue unchecked, possibly resulting in permanent end organ damage or even 
the death of the patient, and placebo medicine does nothing to prevent that.

Let’s return to asthma, since that is the disease that this study examined. Even
if a person with asthma seems to feel fine with a lowered FEV1, there is a
price to be paid for leaving asthma untreated, which, let’s face it, is what
placebo medicine is, leaving the functional disorder untreated. For instance,
there is evidence that early treatment after the diagnosis is made can prevent
the airway remodeling that occurs in chronic asthma, in which airway
constriction and inflammation lead to further narrowing of the airway and
further functional decline. Moreover, if a case of asthma’s severe enough, a
patient could be walking on the proverbial tightrope, where all it would take is
a small insult to push him over into a life-threatening asthma exacerbation or 
pneumonia, whereas if lung function in an asthmatic is tuned up as well as it
can be, I’ll have a lot farther to deteriorate to reach that dangerous point.
Let’s also not forget: Asthma can and does kill, some 250,000 deaths per year
worldwide. Choosing alternative medicine over effective asthma treatment because
placebo responses lead to feeling better without altering the underlying
illness, could very well lead to preventable asthma deaths.

In the end, I’m a bit torn about this study. On the one hand, it irritates me to
no end how it is being sold to the public as evidence of “powerful” placebo
effects and as evidence that we physicians should be doing more placebo
medicine. On the other hand, the fact that CAM advocates are reduced to spinning
studies like this the way they are is pretty darned conclusive evidence that
they now know that, from the standpoint of therapy, the vast majority of CAM
modalities do nothing and are in fact placebo medicine. The problem is, in some 
diseases, such as asthma, placebos run the risk of allowing serious harm from
lack of effective intervention that actually alters the course of disease. If
the therapeutic relationship is so damaged in the U.S. that the beneficial
effects of provider-patient interactions are not being realized, whether you
want to refer to these effects at the “placebo response” or something else, the 
answer is to fix medicine to make it easier and more rewarding for physicians to
spend that time with patients. The answer is not to embrace magical thinking
like that behind acupuncture, homeopathy, and huge swaths of CAM. To argue
otherwise is a false dichotomy.

Infinite Variety? So many styles of acupuncture.

Mark Crislip on October 31, 2014

Link 



Acupuncture: a medicine that diverges as the science accumulates.

   Age cannot wither her, nor custom stale. Her infinite variety.– William
   Shakespeare

This is not a typical post for me, but something I have been meaning to do to
satisfy my own curiosity. I have wondered, how many variations of acupuncture
are there? I suspected a lot, but I thought I would go looking and make a list. 
Since acupuncture is not based in reality but is instead a collection of
pseudo-knowledge, there is no reason for acupuncture to have fidelity to
fundamental concepts. I suspect in the US that in the future acupuncture will
become less heterogenous as schools start teaching to the test that allows for
acupuncture licensure. For now variation rules.

So this will be a list, with description and commentary. If a missed form of
acupuncture is noted by others, and I am sure I have, I will expand the list in 
an addendum.

Chinese acupuncture

The Granddaddy of acupuncture. Readers of this blog are well aware of the
underlying fantasy of meridians and acupoints that comprise classic Chinese
acupuncture.

If you are a lumper you could call this one style of acupuncture. If a splitter,
it is hard to know how many styles there are. There are variations in the
points used, with the number expanding over time and location on the body. There
are points on meridians, points off the meridians and points that wander around
the body (A-shi points). Even Dong evidently has unique extra-points.

Similarly there are also minor branching meridians off the main qi highway. It
seems that any point on the body has the potential to be an acupuncture point,
at least as long as it is not on the male genitals.

There is also variability in how the needles are placed and manipulated. It
appears that with traditional Chinese acupuncture no one needles the same way:

   We observed significant differences in rotation amplitude and duration in
   motion samples among practitioners. GAMM showed marked variations in average 
   regression curves of motion patterns among practitioners.

There is Professor Wu Lian-Zhong‘s technique:

   which is characterized as soft, flexible, fast, plucking and activating
   antipathogenic qi.

Or that of Professor Li Yan-Fang:

   hold the needle with the right hand, press gently along the running course of
   meridians with the left hand to promote qi circulation, hard pressing should
   be applied at acupoints to disperse the local qi and blood, insert the
   needle gently and quickly into the subcutaneous region with the right hand,
   and stop the insertion when patient has the needling sensation. While the
   fast needling is characterized with shallow insertion and swift manipulation:
   the left hand of the manipulator should press first along the running course
   of the meridian, and fix the local skin, hold the needle with the right hand
   and insert the needle quickly into the acupoint. Withdrawal of the needle
   should be done immediately after the reinforcing and reducing manipulations.

Or the slow needle aka the Eric Clapton technique:

   From the basic factors of slow needle insertion, the requirements of this
   manipulation, main points of 4 steps (to straight the needle, to press
   softly, to twirl the needle and to hold without brute force).

Professor Wu Lian-zhong prefers the four needling method:

   4 needling methods, oblique needling, horizontal needling, deep needling and 
   transversal needling.

But is countered by Professor Zheng Kui-shan and his innovative needling methods
of “warm reinforcing technique” and “cold reducing technique”.

And we cannot forget the stylings of Professor WU Xu’s:

   The main technique posture is one-hand holding needle with middle finger for 
   pressing, the needle is hold by thumb and index finger, and is assisted by
   middle finger.

I know how important the middle finger can be in some human interactions.

Perhaps not as elegant nor as good as Professor Chen Quan-xin’s proper
application of reinforcing-reducing manipulation. There is also the prizing
technique although there are those who prefer the twirling reinforcing-reducing 
method or perhaps instead the force feedback method. But I still go with
Professor WU Lian-Zhongs:

   needling technique of ascending the clear and descending the turbid, clinical
   evidence-based needling technique at special acupoints.

“Ascending the clear and descending the turbid” should have been the motto of
the blog.

I suspect that all the variations of how to needle that I found on Pubmed
represent a fraction of the variations on the theme of traditional Chinese
acupuncture.

In addition to traditional Chinese acupuncture there are also a variety of
personal schools of acupuncture, all with their own master:

  1. Chengjiang acupuncture school

  2. LI Zhi-dao’s “tonifying three qi”acupuncture

  3. Regulating marrow sea acupuncture

  4. Yan Ming-guang and Xu Feng’s Najia fa

  5. Doctor Huang Shi-ping’s acupuncture with golden needles

  6. Meihua acupuncture-moxibustion school

These are limited to the hagiographic descriptions on Pubmed; I suspect there
are many more but lack the Chinese language skills for deep investigation.

Even the Chinese wonder about the validity of these styles:

   The expression of DOU Han-qing on “playing a role of meridians, collaterals, 
   qi and blood” is not so accurate, which is suggested to modify as “attaching 
   the importance to needles.” “Theory of heaven, human being and earth” “theory
   of acupuncture on qi regulation” and “the eight therapeutic methods in
   treatment of disease” in Jinzhenfu (Ode to Golden Needles) are valuable
   academically and suggested to be supplemented. The expression of XI Hong on
   “reinforcing and reducing technique by following or against the running
   course of meridian” and the expression of XU Feng on “the magic turtle eight 
   techniques” are not concrete. It is required to elaborate them in detail.

Really, what could be more concrete than the magic turtle eight technique? I
would have suggested that the magic turtle 8 has a hazy reply try again.

  1. All the above could be combined with electricity making electro-acupuncture.
    Or

  2. Laser acupuncture: using lasers instead of needles. Or

  3. Acupressure using pressure of the fingers instead of needles.

Japanese acupuncture

Japanese acupuncture uses thinner needles at less depth with less manipulation. 
They also have different form of pseudo-diagnosis:

   Chinese acupuncturists use the patient’s pulse, tongue, and face to make
   their diagnosis. Japanese acupuncturists rely more on palpatory findings of
   the pulse, abdomen, back and meridians. They also look at the tongue, but do 
   so more to tell what’s going on in the stomach and from there make their
   diagnosis.

So I guess the Chinese are doing it all wrong.

The Japanese also have their subsytems including:

  1. Taikyoku Therapy and

  2. Ryodoraku acupuncture, the latter using a neurometer to evaluate your
    autonomic nervous system, reminiscent of the

  3. Electroacupuncture of voll

Korean acupuncture

Korean acupuncture also has many varieties:

  1. hand

  2. ear

  3. and they often use the Saam style (originated by a monk) which only use four
    needles as well as a unique, constitutional, method of pseudo-diagnosis

  4. motion style acupuncture

  5. VST (Vertex Synchronizing Techhique) Acupuncture

Others

  1. Hook Needle

     With the unique structure and manipulation techniques of blood-letting and
    cutting, hook needle serves as a role in dredging meridians, removing blood 
    stasis, purging heat for resuscitation and relaxing synechial tissues. There
    are three needling techniques of hook needle: swift pricking, bleeding and 
    pricking.

  2. The painful-appearing Wonli Acupuncture

     directly approaching the intervertebral foramen and interlaminar space with
    acupuncture needles

     and digging out tissues. Ouch.

  3. Ankle-wrist acupuncture where they only put needles in the ankle and wrist

  4. Five Element Traditional Acupuncture

  5. 3-Phase Hand Acupuncture

  6. Micro Acupuncture Point Systems (MAPS), with multiple variations, mapping the 
    acupuncture homunculus on different parts of the body:

    1. Oral acupuncture

    2. Scalp acupuncture

    3. Foot acupuncture

    4. Tongue acupuncture

  7. Sonoacupuncture: some using ultrasound waves on the acupoints while others use
    various tuning forks. It is the close cousin of:

  8. Music acupuncture, using music instead of needles for an effect that

     is similar to a cleaning shower or deep massage on quantum, cell and molecular
    level.

     I do love me my quantum cleansing shower in the morning. I have a shower box
    for my cat. I have yet to open it.

And of course there is:

  1. Quantum acupuncture

  2. Fire acupuncture (but no ice acupuncture much to my surprise):

     Red hot heated tungsten needles are inserted into the skin for a microsecond
    and pulled out again.

  3. As well as a one version of which can be used to torture horses

And we finish up with:

  1. Kiiko Matsumoto-style acupuncture

  2. Bee venom acupuncture

  3. Cat gut acupuncture

  4. Acupuncture injection therapy

  5. Bloodletting acupuncture, not to be used if worried about infection
    transmission since:

     The current situation is that acupuncturists have understanding insufficiency 
    in hospital infection management, lack the sterile concepts and
    consciousness of disinfection and isolation. Aseptic technic principles
    aren’t strictly followed; disinfection and isolation systems are unsound;
    sanitary condition of hand of medical staff is unsatisfied.

  6. Moxibustion

  7. Last and least, the most ridiculous form, Tong Ren, aka voodoo acupuncture
    where:

     the Tong Ren practitioner uses a small human anatomical model as an energetic 
    representation of the patient, tapping on targeted points on the model with 
    a lightweight magnetic hammer.

     Really. Not a joke. Watch a video but not, I repeat NOT, with liquids in your 
    mouth.

I am saddened to note that there is no beer acupuncture, although that may
represent an opportunity for someone with fewer scruples than I.

So let’s see. All told that’s a minimum of 32 styles if a lumper, double or
triple if you want to add electricity or lasers to an existing style. More if
you add a particular style of needle manipulation. All equally valid and equally
efficacious, right? So many permutations on a theme of pseudo-knowledge.

Dr. Novella refers to acupuncture as theatrical placebo. It would appear to be a
multitude of one-act plays, all farce.

Acupuncture’s Big Myth

The great acupuncture myth? No spoilers from me. Read the entry or skip to the
penultimate paragraph to find out.

Mark Crislip on January 6, 2017

Link



Are the needles in acupoints?

There was a discussion this week by Dr. Ernst concerning “The most important
myth about acupuncture.” It was in response to a blog entry at the Acupuncture
Now Foundation who suggested

The most important myth that needs to be put to rest is the idea promoted by a
small group of vocal critics that acupuncture is nothing more than a placebo.

Well, no, that is not a myth. Acupuncture is a placebo.

Dr. Ernst does not think that the placebo effect is the biggest myth of
acupuncture:

So, what IS the most important myth about acupuncture? I am not sure and –
unlike the ANF – I do not feel that I can speak for the rest of the world, but
one of the biggest myths FOR ME is how acupuncture fans constantly manage to
mislead the public.

I like his reply but with all due respect to Dr. Ernst, I disagree. Having a
Beeblebroxian ego, I know and I can, and will, speak for the rest of the world.

I meta lotta analyses I didn’t like

I read a lot of meta-analyses, both for work and for my hobby here at SBM. It is
always nice to think about what goes into the meta-analysis. They are unlike
sausages and laws as you really do need to know goes into their production.

For example, consider the effects of statins. Statins are pretty much
interchangeable from a mechanistic point of view and are comparable.

Beta blockers? Not quite so much. Beta blockers are a bit more variable in their
effects, so you would be cautious of a meta-analysis that compared ß1, ß2 and
those with beta agonist properties and it would depend on the pathophysiology
treated, hypertension or heart attack or migraine.

Infections? The use of nafcillin, ciprofloxicin or metronidazole are vastly
different. I can think of no process where it would make any sense in comparing 
these three antibiotics in a meta-analysis for any process: “A meta-analysis &
systematic review of antibiotics for meningitis” would be ridiculous.

Proponents of acupuncture like to use favorable meta-analyses as evidence of
efficacy. For example take “Acupuncture as an intervention to reduce alcohol
dependency: a systematic review and meta-analysis.” Please.

They:

aimed to ascertain the effectiveness of acupuncture for reducing alcohol
dependence as assessed by changes in either craving or withdrawal symptoms.

And after reviewing 15 RCT’s, came to the conclusion that:

acupuncture was potentially effective in reducing alcohol craving and withdrawal
symptoms and could be considered as an additional treatment choice and/or
referral option within national healthcare systems.

Of course, the studies were of poor methodological quality. That is almost
always the case with pseudo-medical studies.

But here is an observation.

On the many varieties of acupunctures

Throughout most of the paper they discuss acupuncture as if were a single
intervention, similar to how penicillin VK is a single intervention for strep
throat.

But there is no one acupuncture I have counted dozens upon dozens of different
styles of acupuncture. I suspect that there are actually as many styles of
acupuncture as there are acupuncturists and that if an intervention was not
imposed upon them by a study protocol that no two acupuncturists would ever
puncture the same way.

And why would they? After all, the diagnostic modalities of Traditional Chinese 
Pseudo Medicine (TCPM) (pulse and tongue evaluation) are not based on reality
but upon the delusions of the practitioner.

And it holds true in this meta-analysis as well.

They compare 4 different kinds of acupuncture (acupuncture, auricular
acupuncture, auricular electro-acupuncture, and electro-acupuncture) as if they 
were all the same.

And no two studies used the same acupoints.

To digress.

And just how big is an acupoint? The size of a needle point? If so, those
acupuncturists have good aim. Or a dime? A quarter?

The structure and size range of an acupoint are determined not only by the
outlook of depression and blood vessel areas, but also its relationship with
other acupoints in its vicinity. The different manipulations of puncturing
recorded in the Yellow Emperor’s Canon of Medicine also show the ambiguous
nature of the structure and size range of an acupoint. In theory, an acupoint
has been characterized as various forms, which should not be limited to a mere
round dot shape. Without such understanding, an acupuncture practitioner will be
limited to a large extent in clinical application and the studies on acupoints 
will also go into a wrong direction.

It seems that acupoints are whatever the acupuncturists needs them to be,
although I wonder what the deqi effect on Staysha Randall was.

Do we really know that when a study says the needle is was in a given acupoint
that it actually was? It would be nice, like in x-ray studies, to have
photographic documentation of needle placement evaluated by blind readers to
conform the needles were indeed in the ‘correct’ space.

I remember my young days as an intern, placing a subclavian catheter by
landmarks. Half a centimeter makes a big difference in whether you are hitting
lung, artery or vein. Why not a similar requirement for acupuncture needles?

I digress further, but I also wonder: are acupoints reversed in situs inversus? 
If acupoints are actual structures and not a mythical metaphor, are their
structures controlled by genes? And on what chromosome? Are there polymorphisms 
that lead to more or less active acupoints? Can you make a mouse knockout with
no acupoints? Questions with answers if acupuncture is not a pseudo-science.
Which it is.

And no two studies use the same frequency or duration of acupuncture.

None of the included studies are even remotely equivalent and cannot really be
compared or pooled. It is like concluding pills are useful for treating
hypertension, with the caveat that, being based on reality, some pills, like
antihypertensives, do have actual effects.

They do note this weakness:

The clinical heterogeneity associated with the different acupuncture techniques 
limits our ability to identify which technique was more effective for treatment 
of alcohol disorders. Acupuncture treatments also varied in duration, frequency,
and the acupuncture points used, making it difficult to assess the key
characteristics that might be associated with the effectiveness of the
intervention.

But are unworried by it.

Garbage in, sausage out

A quick look at acupuncture meta-analysis you see the same pattern. No two
compared interventions are the same.

“Acupuncture for Spinal Cord Injury and Its Complications: A Systematic Review
and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials“? A hodgepodge of acupuncture 
techniques were evaluated but compared as if they were all equivalent. But the
conclusion suggests that

The results of our systematic review and meta-analysis suggest that the evidence
for the effectiveness of acupuncture as a symptomatic treatment for SCI and its
complications is encouraging but limited.

And if acupuncture works by way of neurologic pathways, why would it be
effective in spinal injury?

For gout? 28 studies, each acupuncture different in points and/or style. They
didn’t care that:

The acupoint selection was inconsistent among included studies; nevertheless,
Sp6, St36, and Ashi point were the most commonly used acupoint. In our present
study, data was combined without differentiating acupoint selection and
acupuncture techniques.

And suggested benefit from ‘acupuncture’, whatever ‘acupuncture’ could be. Ashi 
points, by the way, are essentially trigger points that vary from patient to
patient. So the third most used acupoint was a random point.

Hot flashes? 12 different interventions. Yet they conclude ‘acupuncture’ is
effective in decreasing hot flashes, as if ‘acupuncture’ were one intervention.

Sleep apnea? 5 different interventions, yet ‘acupuncture’ has efficacy?

And on and on and on.

There is no squaring this circle

In no meta-analysis are there ever two interventions that were even remotely the
same.

I would suggest the great variability in the interventions with similar results 
is further evidence that the effects of acupuncture are that of a nonspecific,
theatrical placebo. And journals really need to start using the plural form with
these kinds of worthless meta-analysis. It is acupunctures.

And the myth? The greatest myth of acupuncture, perpetuated by the language used
by proponents and skeptics, is that there is one intervention that can be
called acupuncture. There is no acupuncture but a multitude; as many
acupunctures as there are practitioners.

And they all do nothing.

Acupuncture Myths

Utilizing an evidence-based approach to evaluate acupuncture myths? Mmmmm. Not
so much.

Mark Crislip on April 18, 2023

Link



The article Puncturing Acupuncture Myths showed up in my feeds. My first thought
was really? You had to use puncturing in the title? It is so been there done
that. SCAM articles on acupuncture, perhaps by law, need to have point or
puncture in the title.

My next thought was the only thing acupuncture will puncture is the occasional
lung, although my favorite example is the dry needling video (dry needling is
acupuncture without the traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine component). I do not
know what gives me the willies more: dropping the lung or the total lack of
infection control including the needle bouncing off the ungloved hand.

The abstract says

   We have explored and dispelled ten misconceptions common to the practice of
   acupuncture, utilizing an evidence-based approach.

Ohhh. Utilizing an evidence-based approach? I get a nearly physical sensation of
pleasure at the thought of utilizing an evidence-based approach on acupuncture.
I’d describe myself as tingly.

So, let us see what they have to offer, shall we?

Their Myths

Myth 1: Acupuncture only treats pain.

Well, you got me there. Acupuncture can be used to treat every disease, real and
imagined (since all diagnoses in traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine (TCPM),
based on pulse and tongue examination are imaginary). But efficacy for every
disease, including pain, is zero. It is interesting that in their listing of
other processes for which acupuncture is allegedly efficacious, anxiety, nausea 
and vomiting, all have an important subjective component. Otherwise, they mostly
mention variations of, well, pain.

They note

   Acupuncture also remains underutilized in hospice and palliative settings. A 
   recent survey on the use of complementary and alternative medicine in hospice
   and palliative care revealed usage of around 86% for massage therapy, but
   only 32% for acupuncture.

As if it were a bad thing. 32% of those at the end of life spending limited time
and money on useless magical thinking is sad. When my time comes, I am relying 
on a pitcher of boulevardiers. Oh. And no harp. The music thanatologists at my
hospital play a harp. Ain’t no harps where I am going. Electric blues guitar for
me. Leave any suggestions in the comments, although I’m not dead yet.

Myth 2: Acupuncture is painful

I can’t really comment, as I can find no studies that evaluate the relative pain
of an acupuncture needle. Unless dropping a lung, which would hurt, the needles
are too thin to cause much pain, not that I have experienced it. Acupuncturists
are lucky that there are no meridians to be unblocked in the ever so sensitive 
eyes, under the nail beds or in the genitalia. Funny how that works.

It is not pain that you are feeling, oh no says Gaslighting R Us:

   “Most of the time what might be described as pain is a chi sensation. It can 
   be heavy, throbbing, or jumping, all of which are positive responses.”

And

   once a needle reaches its intended depth, you’re likely to feel a mild, dull 
   ache or a slight tingling sensation. This may be a sign that the treatment is
   working and the acupuncture point is being activated. You may also feel a
   heavy or electric sensation. Feelings of warmth may arise at the acupuncture 
   points.

That sensation from a splinter? A bee sting? A mosquito? It is only the
activation of an acupuncture point. It is good. Embrace it.

Myth 3: Acupuncturists have minimal education or medical knowledge.

They have extensive edumacation in nonsense. Acupuncture is a system based on
ideas of health and disease with zero basis in reality. There are no meridians, 
there is no chi. TCPM isn’t worth a pair of fetid dingo’s kidneys. What use,
really, is mastering the fictions that comprise TCPM? None. Me? I have mastered 
the healing techniques in Lord of the Rings and always had a batch of Athelas in
my satchel. So many of the illnesses I see are due to retained metal after
stabbing by a Morgul-knife. Frodo was involved in a sort of anti-acupuncture, I 
suppose.

The same concepts apply to regulation and licensure of acupuncture, it is
fiction that is being regulated and licensed.

You might as well consult Dr. Science. He Knows More Than You Do!

Myth 4: Acupuncture only works through a placebo effect

They note:

   Acupuncture treatment is an intervention of synthesized experiences,
   including dialogue of lifestyle recommendations, diagnostic discussion, and
   the actual placement of acupuncture needles. This often results in a
   therapeutic relationship. For this reason, many studies find little
   statistical significance between real acupuncture and sham acupuncture, which
   could produce a placebo effect.

That kind of defines a placebo effect. All the alleged beneficial effects of
acupuncture are placebo, as has been discussed numerous times here at SBM. The
dropped lungs? Those are the real deal.

Myth 5: Acupuncture treatment puts me at risk for infection

They note

   Upon review of 12 prospective studies surveying more than one million
   acupuncture treatments, only 204 primary reports of infection were found.

Using “infection due to acupuncture” as search criteria to utilize an
evidence-based approach, I found PubMed had 1983 hits and Google scholar had
75,900 hits, a wee bit more than their vaunted 204 infections. Admittedly, not
all the hits represented infections as a consequence of acupuncture, but I
suspect there may be a bit of selective reporting here. No. That would not
happen. Right? If you are utilizing an evidence-based approach you will utilize 
the evidence, or so I would suppose. Myth 5 appears to be that the authors did a
thorough search of the medical literature and, well, utilized the evidence.
Unless ‘utilizing an evidence-based approach’ is a synonym for cherry pick? Not 
in my thesaurus.

Medicine is all about risk vrs benefit. If a procedure has zero benefit, it
should have a zero infection rate. So even one infection is one too many.

If you google acupuncture and look at the images: still no gloves in most of the
pictures. It is, fortunately, difficult to infect people. I spent a career
taking care of injection drug users who have even worse infection control
practices than acupuncturists: licking needles, mixing drugs with tap, puddle or
toilet water, reusing needles, etc. Infection is still the exception, not the
rule, after an injection. Acupuncturists are just lucky it is hard to infect
people.

Myth 6: Serious injury can occur with acupuncture treatment

They noted

   According to a review of over a million treatments, 54 primary reports of
   pneumothorax were related to acupuncture resulting in four fatalities (<0.000
   4%). This review concluded that acupuncture treatment is a safe procedure
   when performed by a skilled and trained acupuncturist.

It was the only review of acupuncture-related complications noted. Odd how they 
focused on pneumothorax.

If you were to, say, utilize an evidence-based approach, you might run across a 
2010 review that found

   About 90 deaths after acupuncture have been anecdotally documented in the
   medical literature.

Using “acupuncture complication” to utilize an evidence-based approach, I found 
4443 Pubmed hits and 48,000 Google Scholar hits, again with the same caveats as 
noted for acupuncture and infection. Myth 6 appears to be that the authors
utilized an evidence-based approach and reported the findings of a thorough
search of the medical literature.

A procedure that does nothing should have no serious complications, much less 90
deaths. The suggestion that the solution is to

   make sure that all acupuncturists are well-trained.

is risible. I suspect there is no such thing as a skilled and trained
acupuncturist. The best way to avoid complications is to avoid the useless
intervention that is acupuncture.

Myth 7: I cannot have acupuncture if I am taking an anticoagulant medication

That does seem to be the case based on the Korean study quoted. A subsequent
systematic review I found utilizing an evidence-based approach noted

   Bleeding deemed unrelated to acupuncture during anticoagulation, and more
   likely resulting from inappropriately deep needling damaging tissue

Huh? Isn’t inappropriately deep needling damaging tissue due to acupuncture? I
guess by that criterion, dropping a lung isn’t due to acupuncture either, but
from inappropriately deep needling. SCAMs can be so Humpty Dumpty. But it
reinforces the understanding that acupuncturists really do not know what they
are doing with their needles.

Myth 8: Acupuncture is not safe during pregnancy

Probably true, the data, such as it is, suggests

   Total AE incidence was 1.9%, and the incidence of AEs evaluated as certainly,
   probably or possibly causally related to acupuncture was 1.3%.

Again, why have a side effect from a useless procedure? Acupuncturists do fret
about allegedly ‘forbidden’ points that can induce abortion, but that is a crock
as well.

Myth 9: Acupuncture works after a single treatment

The most important myth, as it affects the income. Like chiropractic, you must
keep coming back for more of the $ame.

   Acupuncture is known to have a cumulative effect, meaning one treatment
   builds on the next. Many factors influence the effectiveness of acupuncture, 
   including the timing of treatment and discontinuing treatment earlier than
   recommended. Many people seek acupuncture treatment after they have exhausted
   other options, which can reduce the effectiveness of acupuncture treatment
   and/ or require a longer series of treatment.

Cha-Ching.

Myth 10: I have to choose between acupuncture and my traditional medical
treatment, I cannot do both

That is true. I am usually reading both a fiction and non-fiction book at the
same time, one audio, one print. Your patient can certainly do reality-based
medicine and acupuncture at the same time. But, to quote me, and I am so
quotable, if you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste 
better; it makes the apple pie worse.

Most remarkable is the amount of evidence they either did not read or chose to
ignore while “utilizing an evidence-based approach.” Insert Princess Bride meme.
I am no longer quite so tingly. Sigh.

The authors are from the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Mn. As an aside, I did my
internal medicine residency at Hennepin County Medical Center in Minneapolis. It
was not unusual for patients to go to the Mayo for a second opinion (1) and
return with no change in the diagnosis or treatment but with a lot of repeated
tests and smaller bank accounts. It remains as true today and 40 years ago:
“Hold the Mayo.” Except when it is cool.

My Myths

Myth 1 Acupuncture is a monolithic intervention.

There is no such thing as acupuncture as a unified, consistent, intervention.
Which is to be expected as acupuncture is divorced from reality. I once counted 
32 different styles of acupuncture, each with different points and needlings. I 
got tired of counting them, there are so many more. There are likely as many
styles of acupuncture as there are acupuncturists. It is nonsense to say
‘acupuncture’ does anything given the heterogenous nature of the intervention.

Myth 2 Acupuncture is grounded in anatomy and physiology aka reality

Meridians, chi, tongue and pulse diagnosis, the entire foundation of traditional
Chinese pseudo-medicine, is built on smoke and mirrors. Acupuncture is all
sound and fury, signifying nothing.

Myth 3. Acupuncture ‘works’

Acupuncture does nothing for any process with an objective endpoint. It is all
placebo, all the time. Dr. Novella has characterized acupuncture as theatrical
placebo, an excellent description. Like all placebo effects, many feel better
for the participation. I think of the placebo effect as primate grooming.
Primates that groom and are groomed experience many salubrious effects. The main
difference between grooming and alternative medicine such as acupuncture is one
removes parasites, the other is a parasite.

Myth 4 Acupuncture is ancient

Go back to the beginning of this blog for multiple articles on the details,
where there were many entries debunking the idea that acupuncture is ancient.
The title. Yeah. I know.

Really good myths? Listen to Stephen Fry’s Mythos. Those are some myths worthy
of your consideration.

(1) I always think of this old chestnut when someone suggests a second
opinion:Doctor: You’re crazy.Patient: I want a second opinion.Doctor: You’re
ugly as well.

Mediocre Expectations: Acupuncture

Mark Crislip on April 17, 2015

Link



Pictured: Relevant. Oh yeah, it’s going to get weird.

I had a dickens of a time writing this entry. The last week has been spent in
New York for NECSS. It is safe to say that New York has plenty of distractions
for us Dug the Dog types. Reality may be a honey badger, but New York is a
squirrel. I say that when I travel I usually do not come across food better than
I can find in Portland. Nope. Not true of New York. It joins Paris and New
Orleans in the holy trinity of good eats, although I will stick with Pacific
Northwest beer. And the rule is that for every day you are gone, three days’
worth of work piles up. I really need to stop taking time off.

I spoke at NECSS on a favorite topic of mine, how acupuncture works. It doesn’t.
But I discussed a few studies that I found interesting. Like all studies, no
single paper is definitive. The third law of the medical literature states that 
for every study, there is an equal and opposite study. A bit of an exaggeration 
perhaps but I do find the direction that the following studies point interesting
both as to acupuncture’s mechanism of inaction and how the mind functions,
making them worth collecting in an essay.

In a weird way, the Secret is true. Expectations can influence the outcomes of
an intervention such as acupuncture. If you have confidence in the procedure and
believe you are going to have a salubrious effect, acupuncture will work. In
“The impact of patient expectations on outcomes in four randomized controlled
trials of acupuncture in patients with chronic pain” they took:

   864 patients [who] received either 12 sessions of acupuncture or minimal
   (i.e. sham) acupuncture (superficial needling of non-acupuncture points) over
   an 8 week period. Patients were asked at baseline whether they considered
   acupuncture to be an effective therapy in general and what they personally
   expected from the treatment. After three acupuncture sessions patients were
   asked how confident they were that they would benefit from the treatment
   strategy they were receiving. Patients were classified as responders if the
   respective main outcome measure improved by at least fifty percent.

The patients had four kinds of pain: migraine, tension-type headache, chronic
low back pain, and osteoarthritis of the knee, (one each; no one suffered from
all four) and had 12 sessions of acupuncture or sham acupuncture, in this case
superficial needling of non-acupuncture points. Since the only places on the
body that do not have acupuncture points (depending on the acupuncture style)
are the eyes, under the nails and the genitals, this must have been a very
unhappy control group.

If the patient had the expectation that acupuncture was going to be effective in
relieving pain, then they were better off than their long-suffering skeptical
compatriots with a decrease in pain, and the response lasted for 6 months.

This is not the only study to show that the expectation that acupuncture will be
effective is important in causing a beneficial effect. “Practice, practitioner,
or placebo? A multifactorial, mixed-methods randomized controlled trial of
acupuncture” found that fake acupuncture was equal to real acupuncture but it
was the:

   beliefs about treatment veracity [that] shape how patients self-report
   outcome.

It is not just the patients’ belief:

   The individual practitioner and the patient’s belief had a significant effect
   on outcome

There have been other studies that show a similar correlation between
expectation and acupuncture outcome, but in concordance with the third law:

   Eight trials analyzed the association between pre-randomisation expectations 
   for assigned treatment and outcomes, and six the effect of pre-randomisation 
   expectations across all patients independent of treatment allocation. Some
   showed associations but others did not.

   CONCLUSIONS:

   There is some evidence that response expectancies interact with outcomes in
   acupuncture trials however the variety of question phrasing and analysis
   methods precludes drawing a firm conclusion about for whom and under which
   circumstance.

Adequate blinding of patient and practitioner and patient expectations need to
be controlled for and reported in any future acupuncture trial in order for the 
study to be properly performed and interpreted. Although I would suggest that
based on the data to date, no further acupuncture studies need be done nor are
such studies ethically justified.

Also, if a patient is told that a needle is being used to cause pain instead of 
to relieve pain they will have a different response to the same jab. A needle
perceived as beneficial activates different parts of the brain than a needle
perceived as painful, but it is the same needle stuck in the same place:

   Although the applied stimuli were physically identical in both groups, the
   verbal instructions differed: participants in the AS group were primed to
   consider the acupuncture as a painful stimulus, whereas the participants in
   the AT group were told that the acupuncture was part of therapeutic
   treatment. Acupuncture yielded greater brain activation in reward-related
   brain areas (ventral striatum) of the brain in the AT group when compared to 
   the AS group. Brain activation in response to pain stimuli was significantly 
   attenuated in the bilateral secondary somatosensory cortex and the right
   dorsolateral prefrontal cortex after prior acupuncture needle stimulation in 
   the AT group but not in the AS group. Inserting needles into the body in the 
   context of treatment activated reward circuitries in the brain and modulated 
   pain responses in the pain matrix.

Except for a masochist I suppose. And people can be conditioned to have the
‘right’ response to being jabbed with a therapeutic needle. Pain relief from
acupuncture is a learned response, probably not unlike ‘heat’ from hot sauce
being added to food to ‘enhance’ it.

If I had no ethics I would train our phlebotomy techs to tell patients that when
they were searching for a good vein from which to draw blood they were also
looking for acupoints and that they were going to draw the blood using an
acupuncture needle technique to decrease pain and discomfort. I bet it would
work and it would make for an interesting study of placebo effects.

But it gets even weirder. All the above studies involve touching people, albeit 
with needles. There is a spooky literature of inducing the same effects as
acupuncture but not even touching the person.

There is this curious effect called the rubber hand illusion. First you place a 
rubber hand in such a manner that it is positioned as if it is part of a
person’s body, and hide their real hand. Then you simultaneously stroke the real
and rubber hand with a brush. By doing this you trick the brain into thinking
that the rubber hand is the real hand. If you touch the rubber hand with an ice 
cube, or even a fake ice cube, the brain will feel cold. Or hit the hand and the
brain will feel pain. Weird.

If you do acupuncture on the rubber hand? Meridians and chi spontaneously form
in the rubber hand and the patient will experience some of the effects of
acupuncture. They will have some of the same physiologic effects of acupuncture 
to a real hand if sham or real acupuncture is done to the rubber hand. And
acupuncture on a rubber hand will induce the same fMRI changes in the brain as
real acupuncture on a real hand.

Weird yes, but it gets even weirder.

Someone (probably a former mime, doing acupuncture against the wind or some
such) developed phantom acupuncture, where the therapist goes through the
motions of acupuncture but does not actually touch the patient. Some people find
the phantom credible, even having the Deqi sensation. The result is the same:
some of the physiologic responses of real acupuncture occur with phantom
acupuncture. And the physiologic response to the phantom intervention varied
depending on whether the subject was convinced by the phantom acupuncture.

So real acupuncture has the same effects as sham acupuncture such as twirled
toothpicks. It never matters where the needles are placed, or even if needles
are used. Effects depend in large part on expectancy and beliefs that can
conditioned in patients. And the effect of acupuncture can, in part, be induced 
in a rubber hand or even thin air.

Steve Novella refers to acupuncture as a theatrical placebo, or as one author
stated,

   a complex, ritualistic somatosensory intervention,

but these studies would suggest that all the effects of acupuncture are
manufactured in the mind, with no cause or effect in external reality. We create
our own acupuncture reality from the quantum…man…oh…hell. Chopra was right.

Just kidding. He is still full of shit.

Further reading

– Acupuncture Doesn’t Work. The definitive review.

Bias and Spin: Acupuncture and Chiropractic

Mark Crislip on March 6, 2015

Link



We all construct our narrative based on our biases and spin the facts so that
the narrative confirms our biases. Among other characteristics, what separates
an SBM provider from a SCAM provider is realizing that biases are always active 
and apply to me as well as everyone else.

My biases are simple: I am skeptical that humans can reliably understand reality
without assistance and the best source of assistance is science.

I have a job where the expectation is that I will change practice as information
changes. How I practiced medicine 30 years ago is very different from how I
practice it today. Still, I note it is harder and harder to change my approaches
as I get older. I get more set in my ways and it takes more effort to change as
new studies are published. Sometimes it seems almost physically difficult.

Again, it is expected that not only will I change my mind over time, as the sole
ID doctor at my hospitals, I will be the one to lead the change. Imagine how
much harder it would be to change your mind if you were committed to a universal
truth such as those that are alleged to underlie reiki or chiropractic. Years
committed to a pseudo-medicine probably renders changing one’s mind virtually
impossible.

I will admit there is one bias I cannot fathom, the conspiracy/pharmaceutical
shill world view. The idea that those of us concerned with pseudo-medicine are
doing so because we are paid by big pharma is just so weird. There are a number 
of articles on Pubmed concerning medical conspiracies, but the search term
“pharmaceutical shill’ yields nothing on either Google scholar or Pubmed. It is 
a bias that evidently has no research to help understand why people have that
opinion. I suspect it is derived in part from the often-remarkable sums paid to 
some doctors to pimp medications to other doctors. But I can’t even find how
common the belief is.

I can kind of understand why people practice and/or participate in the various
SCAMs given my understanding of the various fallacies and dysfunctional ways the
mind works. It is easy to see how both the practitioners and patients misjudge 
the efficacy of pseudo-medicine. We have evolved to survive reality, certainly
not to understand it.

Bias leads to spin, and it is curious how bias can warp the reports in the
medical literature.

It is a curious fact that acupuncture studies from the East are virtually always
positive:

   Research conducted in certain countries was uniformly favorable to
   acupuncture; all trials originating in China, Japan, Hong Kong, and Taiwan
   were positive, as were 10 out of 11 of those published in Russia/USSR. In
   studies that examined interventions other than acupuncture, 405 of 1100
   abstracts met the inclusion criteria. Of trials published in England, 75%
   gave the test treatment as superior to control….No trial published in China
   or Russia/USSR found a test treatment to be ineffective.

I find that fascinating. Is it publications bias i.e. only positive studies are 
published? Or is it, due to deep cultural bias combined with poor methodology
(adequate blinding and placebo), that all studies are indeed positive, a massive
example of N-rays in action?

Given that:

   pronounced bias due to lack of patient blinding in complementary/alternative 
   randomized clinical trials

leads to:

   nonblinded patients exaggerated the effect size by an average of 0.56
   standard deviation

and the effect is more pronounced in acupuncture trials, I suspect it is a
combination, especially given a similar results with yoga studies out of India:

   Positive conclusions were reached in 277 RCTs (91%); with more positive RCTs 
   being conducted in India than elsewhere (odds ratio=24.8; 95% confidence
   interval=3.3, 184.5; p<0.001) while type of journal was not associated with
   the direction of the conclusions (odds ratio=1.2; 95% confidence
   interval=0.5, 2.9; p=0.828).

   CONCLUSIONS:

   RCTs on yoga that are conducted in India have about 25 times the odds of
   reaching positive conclusions as those conducted elsewhere.

Amazing how the positive results of large swaths of pseudo-medical studies can
be biased by the culture in which they are done. It would appear that the
country of origin may have a far more positive effect on a SCAM study outcome
than the effect of when a real medication trial is funded by pharmaceutical
companies. Money, as Cindy Lauper noted, changes everything, but world view with
its concomitant bias is likely more important. Ioannidis was understating the
issue when he noted:

   Prejudice may not necessarily have financial roots. Scientists in a given
   field may be prejudiced purely because of their belief in a scientific theory
   or commitment to their own findings. Many otherwise seemingly independent,
   university-based studies may be conducted for no other reason than to give
   physicians and researchers qualifications for promotion or tenure. Such
   nonfinancial conflicts may also lead to distorted reported results and
   interpretations.

It is amazing how such bias can lead to the inability to see effects even when
it is staring you in the face. My favorite example is “Decreased Risk of Stroke 
in Patients with Traumatic Brain Injury Receiving Acupuncture Treatment: A
Population-Based Retrospective Cohort Study” where they conclude:

   Patients with TBI receiving acupuncture treatment show decreased risk of
   stroke compared with those without acupuncture treatment.

even though patients:

   with acupuncture treatment had higher proportions of using anticoagulants
   (2.3% vs. 1.7%, p = 0.0003), antiplatelet agents (28.7% vs. 22.3%, p<0.0001),
   and lipid-lowering agents (24.7% vs. 18.4%, p<0.0001) compared with those
   had no acupuncture treatment.

The use of anti-stoke medication was then ignored as the possible explanation of
the ‘effects’ of acupuncture.

Of course, acupuncturists are not the only ones who cannot look at data and see 
the obvious.

Chiropractors like to point to “Risk of Vertebrobasilar Stroke and Chiropractic 
Care Results of a Population-Based Case-Control and Case-Crossover Study” as
evidence that their particular pseudo-medicine does not cause strokes.

   We found no evidence of excess risk of VBA stroke associated chiropractic
   care compared to primary care.

Although as I have mentioned in the past the paper does suggest that in a group 
that should not be having strokes, the young, seeing a chiropractor is
associated with having a stroke.

   Table 3 has the smoking gun. The highest odds ratio (14) for a stroke is 12, 
   4 times any other, in the age less than 45 in the first 24 hours after a
   visit to a chiropractor.

Saying that a paper does not support chiropractic as a risk of stroke when the
data suggests it probably does continues. In the study “Risk of Stroke After
Chiropractic Spinal Manipulation in Medicare B Beneficiaries Aged 66 to 99 Years
With Neck Pain” by a chiropractor, suggests the older you are, there may be
greater the risk of stoke after visiting a chiropractor.

They conclude that

   Among Medicare B beneficiaries aged 66 to 99 years with neck pain, incidence 
   of vertebrobasilar stroke was extremely low. Small differences in risk
   between patients who saw a chiropractor and those who saw a primary care
   physician are probably not clinically significant.

Given that the chiropractic cohort was both younger and healthier, and the
rarity of stroke, I am not sanguine that this study can be used as evidence that
chiropractic neck manipulation is safe and it suggests that, as the older you
get, the more likely chiropractic will be associated with a late stroke, a 10%
increase at 30 days that was statistically significant.  But if due to
chiropractic cannot be determined from the study

They suggest it may not be clinically important. While a 10% change in a pain
scale may not be clinically relevant, I am not so sure a 10% increase in stroke 
has the same degree of triviality.

I am also not sanguine the study supplies evidence that chiropractic is safe; it
is more spin than fact. Like the Cassidy study, it suggests that a risk of
stroke is lurking in the background in some populations, is rare, and hard to
see. For now I will stick with the preponderance of data, nicely summarized by
the AHA position paper:

   Although current biomechanical evidence is insufficient to establish the
   claim that CMT causes CD, clinical reports suggest that mechanical forces
   play a role in a considerable number of CDs and most population controlled
   studies have found an association between CMT and VAD stroke in young
   patients. Although the incidence of CMT-associated CD in patients who have
   previously received CMT is not well established, and probably low,
   practitioners should strongly consider the possibility of CD as a presenting 
   symptom, and patients should be informed of the statistical association
   between CD and CMT prior to undergoing manipulation of the cervical spine.

And when I see an article called “Is there a role for neck manipulation in
elderly falls prevention? – An overview“, I think NONONONONONO.

That’s my bias, and I am sticking to it.

Catgut Acupuncture

Catgut acupuncture is but one example of how acupuncture’s basis in
pseudoscience provides an infinitely malleable template for fabricated
mechanisms of action and feigned health benefits.

Jann Bellamy on April 22, 2021

Link



A weekly email from the NIH’s National Library of Medicine posting search
results for the term “acupuncture” recently turned up this gem of a journal
article:

   Effect of acupoint catgut embedding in chronic fatigue syndrome patients: A
   protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis

Most of the authors are associated with the Acupuncture-Moxibustion School of
Chengdu University of Traditional Chinese Medicine or its affiliated hospital. I
predict one of two possible outcomes: (1) the results will be inconclusive (but
perhaps “promising”), thus more research is needed, or (2) the authors will
conclude that acupoint catgut embedding is safe and effective treatment for
chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), because GIGO. What I can guarantee is they will 
not decide that the whole affair is tooth fairy science, that acupoint catgut
embedding is fantasy-based, and that there is no reason whatsoever to consider
it for CFS, or for anything else for that matter.

Those were not my first thoughts on reading the title however. My initial
reaction was: What the hell is “acupoint catgut embedding”?

As it turns out, this is not the first appearance of acupoint catgut embedding
on SBM. Back in 2014, former SBM blogger Mark Crislip set out to satisfy his
curiosity:

   I have wondered, how many variations of acupuncture are there? I suspected a 
   lot, but I thought I would go looking and make a list. Since acupuncture is
   not based in reality but is instead a collection of pseudo-knowledge, there
   is no reason for acupuncture to have fidelity to fundamental concepts.

All told, he found 32 different styles, “double or triple if you want to add
electricity or lasers to an existing style. More if you add a particular style
of needle manipulation”. And there we find, listed just after (deadly) bee venom
acupuncture, catgut acupuncture, as it is also known.

But what, exactly, is catgut acupuncture? Let’s break this down into its two
components.

From Wikipedia:

   Catgut (also known as gut) is a type of cord that is prepared from the
   natural fiber found in the walls of animal intestines. Catgut makers usually 
   use sheep or goat intestines, but occasionally use the intestines of cattle, 
   hogs, horses, mules, or donkeys. Despite the name, catgut manufacturers do
   not use cat intestines.

[References omitted.]

Catgut’s primary uses are for stringed instruments, tennis racquet strings, and 
surgical sutures, although for all of these it has given way to other materials,
such as synthetics.

Acupuncture is a theatrical placebo based on pre-scientific notions of anatomy
and physiology. It proposes a system of “meridians” throughout the body carrying
“qi”, or energy, which, when blocked, causes disease and other maladies.
Unblocking the flow of this energy by sticking needles in “acupoints” located
all over the body (although there is no agreement on where they are) is the
putative point of acupuncture.

So, catgut acupuncture does not involve actual cats, although there is such a
thing as cat acupuncture.

Putting the two together, catgut acupuncture is, according to one article:

   a new method of acupuncture which has developed in the recent 3 decades.
   Catgut . . . is embedded in the acupuncture points and enhanced the point
   stimulation for 7-14 days. Catgut implantation is one kind of acupuncture,
   where specific acupuncture points are gently and continuously stimulated till
   the ailment is improved and designed results are achieved.

Apparently the idea is that if briefly sticking something in an acupoint is
beneficial, sticking something in an acupoint for 7-14 days is even better.

But how does it “work”? From 5,000 papers collected in a literature search of
the China Academic Journal Network Publishing Database, the authors of this
article

   summarized that TCM effect mechanism of catgut-point embedding therapy
   includes the effects of needle retaining and embedding, harmonizing yin and
   yang, balancing zangfu organs, promoting meridian qi, regulating qi and
   blood, tonifying for the deficiency and reducing for the excess,
   strengthening the antipathogenic qi and eliminating pathogens. From the point
   of view of western medicine, the effect mechanism of catgut-embedding
   therapy refers to recovering nerve function, regulating neural reflex,
   increasing human immunity, improving local circulation, inhibiting the
   release of inflammatory factors, reducing apoptosis, regulating cellular
   factor and improving body metabolism. It was found that the effects of
   catgut-embedding therapy were not only related to the effects induced by
   common acupuncture, but also to the persistent treatment through prolonged
   stimulation duration, especially in the treatment of chronic diseases with
   many systems involved.

Really, one could hardly ask for more. But, of course,

   further studies are requested.

Because all of this is made up, other authors apparently feel free to fabricate 
different explanations, here again from the “western” perspective:

   AE [acupoint embedding] artificially creates a mild inflammation and
   activates the interaction of the immune system with the neuroendocrine
   system.

Well, which is it: Does catgut acupuncture inhibit the release of inflammatory
factors or does it create a mild inflammation?

As is claimed for needle acupuncture, catgut acupuncture is a virtual panacea.
Proponents tout it (based on unconvincing studies, such as those with an A+B
versus A design) for IBS, obesity, postmenopausal osteoporosis, insomnia,
diabetes and “its common chronic complications”, post-adolescent acne,
ulcerative colitis, joint attention and social communication in children with
autism spectrum disorder, dysmenorrhea, allergic rhinitis, and intractable
facial paralysis, among other disparate conditions lacking a common etiology or 
any other reason to think a single therapy would be effective for all.

But scientific progress marches on, at least, for those promoting pseudoscience,
when it’s convenient. As has happened in surgery, newer materials may replace
catgut in acupoint embedding because “catgut induces a variety of immune
responses, including allergic reactions and subcutaneous nodules”. This led
researchers to try polyglactin 910, a synthetic suture material, in patients
with chronic pain from cervical spondylotic radiculopathy because acupoint
catgut embedding in the neck had already proven to have “significant therapeutic
effects”. And guess what? The new material worked like a charm!

I can’t find that catgut acupuncture has taken off in the U.S. This may be
because – and this is a guess – sutures are medical devices regulated by the FDA
and acupoint embedding employing catgut or any other suture material is not an 
FDA-approved use. This is not to say that the federal government might not be
willing to permit it, given the fact that the Department of Health and Human
Services (the FDA’s parent agency) has already demonstrated it is happy to
ignore the lack of evidence in announcing Medicare coverage for acupuncture.

I suppose the only certainty here is that, given the near-infinite variety that 
can be shoehorned into fantasy-based paradigms like acupuncture, we can expect
even more iterations, all supported by nonsensical mechanisms of action and
dubious “studies”..

Bee Venom is Snake Oil

Bee venom acupuncture is a double-barrel pseudoscience that provides new example
of an old problem – the use of poor quality preclinical research to justify the
inclusion of nonsense in medicine.

Steven Novella on April 25, 2018

Link



In March Clay Jones reported on an unfortunate case of a 55 year-old Spanish
woman who died after receiving bee venom acupuncture. This week the Food
Standards Agency (FSA) has ordered New Zealand company Nelson Honey & Marketing 
to stop selling pots of honey laced with bee venom in Britain. Their reason is
that the venom has not been demonstrated to be safe for oral consumption.

In short, bee venom is the new snake oil. The term “snake oil” has come to refer
generically to fake medicine because actual oil made from snakes was popular in
the 19th century, and more recently in Traditional Chinese Medicine, as a
patent medicine. Perhaps in a hundred years people will be referring to “bee
venom salesmen” the same way we refer to their snake-oil counterparts today.

Apitherapy

The use of bee venom and bee products as a medicine is referred to by believers 
as “apitherapy.” This is a great example of the appeal to nature fallacy – bee
venom is sold with the idea that because it is “natural” it is somehow superior 
as a therapeutic. Marketing of a health halo around anything considered vaguely 
natural has been so thorough that many people think voluntarily injecting
themselves with venom (by definition a “poisonous substance”) is a good idea.
Venoms evolved to be efficiently deadly. They are a great example of why being
natural does not equate to being benign.

Venoms can be exploited as pharmaceuticals, because they contain potent drugs.
Once identified, purified, studied, and tweaked as necessary, and then given in 
specific doses, they might be useful. Raw venoms, however, tend to be a witches 
brew of multiple poisonous substances meant to cause harm to the victims that
are injected with them. Here is a chemical breakdown:

   Bee venom is a mixture of histamine, pheromones (discussed on the pheromone
   page), enzymes, peptides, amino acids and other acids, with 63 components in 
   total. The main enzymes present are phospholipase A, hyaluronidase, and
   lecithinase; while the main peptides are mellitin, apamin and peptide 401.
   Bee venom is cytotoxic (ie. cell-destroying), and has the contradictory
   effects of inhibiting the nervous system, while stimulating the heart and
   adrenal glands.

   Mellitin, a 26 amino acid peptide, makes up 50% of the dry weight of bee
   venom, and acts to destroy blood cells by breaking up their membranes. It
   also lowers blood pressure, causes histamine release, and is the main
   pain-causing component.

Sounds lovely. I particularly like the part where the venom destroys blood cells
by breaking down their membranes. Of course, the body responds to this outright
attack by releasing countermeasures. Cortisol is released as an
anti-inflammatory, for example. That is often used as the justification for
using bee venom, to provoke the body’s response. Plausibility here, however, is 
extremely thin. The chemical assault is likely to be worse than the response,
and this is an awfully crude way to release cortisol in the body. Why not just
give corticosteroids in precise doses, bypassing the venom? Any trauma, of
course, will provoke a healing or compensatory response, and the alternative
guru can always point to markers of healing as the mechanism of any claimed
benefit. This logic assumes that the response will somehow be greater than the
original trauma, an assumption that does not really make sense or hold up to
investigation.

What about the scientific research? Here we find the typical results anyone
familiar with alternative pseudoscience should expect. Most studies of bee venom
are basic science, meaning they are looking at markers of biological activity
in vitro or in animals. This research is all interesting, and entirely
unsurprising. As I noted, bee venom evolved to be highly biologically active,
and the research finds that it is indeed highly biologically active. There is
definitely potential here to isolate useful compounds.

However, basic science studies such as these cannot be used as a basis for
clinical claims. The vast majority of interesting effects seen in basic science 
studies do not translate to useful clinical outcomes. There are many things that
can go wrong on the way from the petri dish to the clinic. These include low
bioavailability, poor pharmacodynamics or kinetics, short half-life, drug-drug
interactions, and excessive toxicity.

Therefore we need clinical studies to see the net effects of using a particular 
form of a substance in people with the target condition. There are a number of
such studies with bee venom, again showing an all-too-familiar pattern. Let’s
look at so-called bee-venom acupuncture (BVA) – which conveniently combines two 
pseudosciences into one treatment.

Acupuncture itself, the sticking of thin needles into alleged acupuncture
points, does not work for anything. Proponents, however, have tried to keep this
superstition alive by combining with other actual treatments, such as
“electroacupuncture.” I used to joke that you could inject morphine into
acupoints and call it “pharmacoacupunture.” That is essentially what BVA is,
except with snake oil rather than an effective drug.

There are several published reviews of BVA for painful conditions. For
musculoskeletal pain the review concludes:

   A meta-analysis produced suggestive evidence for the effectiveness of BVA in 
   musculoskeletal pain management. However, primary data were scarce. Future
   RCTs should assess larger patient samples for longer treatment periods and
   include appropriate controls.

For post-stroke shoulder pain:

   This review provided evidence suggesting that BVA is effective in relieving
   shoulder pain after stroke. However, further studies are needed to confirm
   the role of BVA in alleviating post-stroke shoulder pain. Future studies
   should be conducted with large samples and rigorous study designs.

For rheumatoid arthritis:

   There is low-quality evidence, based on one trial, that BVA can significantly
   reduce pain, morning stiffness, tender joint counts, swollen joint counts
   and improve the quality of life of patients with RA compared with placebo
   (normal saline injection) control. However, the number of trials, their
   quality and the total sample size were too low to draw firm conclusions.

The pattern is the same regardless of indication – there is scant and low grade 
evidence suggestive of an effect, but we can’t really conclude that it works
because of the lack of rigorous data. I suspect there is a reason why this
pattern is so ubiquitous when it comes to dubious “alternative” treatments.
Proponents figured out that when you do really rigorous studies, they
frustratingly tend to be negative. Far better to do a preliminary study with a
weak design, that way you can p-hack your way to whatever result you want. This 
is especially useful when using subjective outcomes, like pain.

Every poorly designed or small study is another headline, promoting the
alternative treatment. But we never get across the finish line – we never get to
the point that we have reproducible high quality evidence for efficacy.

Further, many of the studies used in these systematic reviews come from China or
Chinese researchers. This is a problem because of the demonstrated bias in this
research. A 2014 update of prior research found that 99.8% of acupuncture
studies from China report positive results. That is clear evidence of a positive
bias, and is even suggestive of fraud. There is simply no way to get near 100% 
positive results from clinical trials, even for an effective treatment, without 
putting a massive thumb on the scale. Yet this clearly biased research is always
included in systematic reviews, with predictable results.

Here is a clear example of such bias, from a BVA study of back pain. The authors
begin:

   Bee venom acupuncture (BVA) is an effective treatment for chronic low back
   pain (CLBP) through the pharmacological effects of bee venom and the
   simultaneous stimulation of acupoints. However, evidence of its efficacy and 
   safety in humans remains unclear.

See the contradiction? BVA is effective, but the evidence is unclear. Then how
do you know it is effective? They essentially naively admit in their own
write-up of the study that the point of the study was to confirm what they
already knew to be true, that BVA works. In this case the research comes from
Korea, which has almost as strong a positive bias toward acupuncture as China.

There is a reason for advocating for a relatively high threshold of evidence
before accepting a new treatment and integrating it into the practice of
medicine. We know have over a century of experience using science to determine
which treatments are safe and effective. We can look back over this long
experience and reasonably determine where that threshold should be. We can
clearly see that when we use a lower threshold, we end up adopting treatments
that are likely to not work when the definitive evidence comes in. In short, we 
cause more harm than good.

Alternative treatments such as acupuncture (with or without bee venom) live
below this threshold. They thrive in a world of low quality clinical studies
where p-hacking can thrive, and researcher bias reigns. It is unfortunate that
this alternative world has so thoroughly infected mainstream medicine, largely
sneaking in under the radar by pretending to be scientific. Meanwhile the
academics and experts who should be gatekeepers are asleep at the switch.

A Woman Dies from a Severe Allergic Reaction After Live Bee Acupuncture Session

A woman in Spain has died from a severe allergic reaction after a session of
live bee acupuncture. With low plausibility, the potential for fatal outcomes,
no evidence to suggest that benefits outweigh even minor side effects, and lots 
of dead bees, this is an intervention that should be avoided.

Clay Jones on March 23, 2018

Link



On SBM we often discuss the harm, both direct and indirect, that can be
attributed to unscientific approaches to healthcare. Sadly, it seems as if there
is an unending supply of cases to illustrate our concerns. In today’s post, I
will discuss yet another example of how the belief in quackery can have an
unexpected cost.

Death by live bee acupuncture

Earlier this month, two Spanish Allergy and Immunology specialists published a
case report involving a 55-year-old woman who died from a severe allergic
reaction (anaphylaxis) after undergoing live bee acupuncture. Although healthy
in general, she had been going to this particular apitherapy clinic every month 
for the prior two years for treatment of musculoskeletal concerns and stress.
She had never reported a reaction to the therapy in the past and there was no
history of allergic conditions, and specifically no history of allergy to bites 
or stings from any related insects.

Unfortunately, the absence of prior allergy to a particular substance does not
rule out the future development of allergy. It is not uncommon for people
repeatedly exposed to bee venom, the classic example naturally being bee
keepers, to develop an allergy. The patient discussed in the report had been
stung a minimum of 24 times, but perhaps many more than that depending on how
many stings took place per session. And yes, the first sign of allergy can be a 
severe reaction, even death.

After the sting, the woman developed wheezing and difficulty breathing, and she 
quickly lost consciousness, classic signs of anaphylaxis. An ambulance arrived
30 minutes after the development of symptoms, which is obviously unacceptable.
Even worse is the fact that the clinic did not have epinephrine, the only
medication that could have saved her life, or even an epinephrine autoinjector
on site in case of just such a reaction.

This, in my opinion, is criminal negligence. I wonder if the patient was even
made aware of the risk. None of the many news articles covering this report
revealed if proper informed consent had been obtained. Though the clinic did not
have epinephrine, the did have access to the IV steroid methylprednisolone,
which is commonly included in acute management of anaphylaxis but has never been
proven to actually improve any outcome, in particular restoration of normal
blood pressure or the ability to breath.

Once the ambulance arrived, she was found to have a systolic blood pressure of
42, which is too low for a premature newborn let alone an adult, and an
abnormally rapid heart rate, more classic signs of anaphylaxis. She was quickly 
given epinephrine and boluses of IV saline to improve her blood pressure, more
steroids, and an antihistamine (really only helpful if you have itchy hives with
your anaphylaxis). Her vital signs did stabilize but the damage had already
been done.

The sudden and severe drop in blood pressure resulted in decreased blood flow to
her brain and she suffered what is known as a “watershed stroke“. This occurs
when the neuronal injury involves vulnerable regions of the brain that on a good
day don’t get the best perfusion thanks to their anatomic position on the
borders of cerebral blood supply. By the time the ambulance had arrived she had 
entered what would be a permanent comatose state, requiring the placement of a
breathing tube to protect her airway, and would go on to develop multisystem
organ dysfunction and ultimately die a few weeks later.

Wait, live bee acupuncture?

Several years ago Steven Novella wrote about bee venom therapy (BVT), which
falls under the bogus umbrella of apitherapy, the general use of bee products
such as honey, venom, and royal jelly for medicinal purposes. He specifically
covered the purposeful exposure to bee stings as a possible treatment for MS,
pointing out that while bee venom may be an interesting compound with potential 
therapeutic uses, evidence of clinical benefit was lacking. Six years later,
nothing has changed.

The subject of the recent case report wasn’t simply allowing bees to randomly
sting her, as described in the two posts by Steve. She was undergoing live bee
acupuncture, where bees are manipulated by a practitioner so that they sting a
patient in specific points on the body. It’s acupuncture, just with bees, like
you might see in an episode of The Flintstones. And it has the same level of
evidence in support of clinical benefit.

Live bee acupuncture is popular in China and Korea, and is apparently making
headway in other countries, although I would still think of it as a fairly
uncommon intervention. Proponents claim that it is an ancient technique,
practiced by Hippocrates and Galen, that can reduce inflammation, treat MS,
arthritis, even HIV and Lyme disease. They cite uncontrolled and unblinded
studies like this one on the use of live bee acupuncture for depression, which
involved 37 volunteers with moderate to severe depression who were not receiving
any psychiatric care and were game for being stung by a bunch of bees.

Meanwhile, in reality, no good studies have shown that live bee acupuncture
provides any benefit for any condition. And to make matters worse, it has been
linked to high rates of adverse outcomes besides just the obvious issues with
allergic reactions. Localized skin reactions are so common they have a name:
live bee acupuncture dermatitis. There is a published case report where a
session of live bee acupuncture caused a patient to develop a condition called
Stevens-Johnson syndrome, which causes your skin to slough off and is treated in
a burn unit.

Something something something dark side. Something something something goop

In 2016, Gwyneth Paltrow was interviewed for The New York Times Style section
about, among other things, how she stays fit and healthy. The article included
the following gem:

   I’ve been stung by bees. It’s a thousands of years old treatment called
   apitherapy. People use it to get rid of inflammation and scarring. It’s
   actually pretty incredible if you research it. But, man, it’s painful.

It is incredible, if you research it. But I don’t think that Gwyneth, who was
already a huge acupuncture fan, is using that word in quite the same way that I 
am. I wonder if the woman in Spain was influenced by reading about live bee
acupuncture being used by ignorant celebrities who like to think of themselves
as health gurus.

A refreshing conclusion: “Unsafe and unadvisable”

The authors of the case report are not believers, but are highly trained experts
who saw the potential for horrific tragedy that comes along with bogus health
remedies first hand. They point out the clear need for patients to be tested for
bee venom allergy, and for proper informed consent to be obtained, prior to
each treatment session. They also advise that all providers be capable of
initiating treatment of anaphylaxis immediately upon recognition as well as
ensuring rapid access to real medical care. Their ultimate conclusion is
refreshing:

   However, these measures may not be possible. Therefore, the risks of
   undergoing apitherapy may exceed the presumed benefits, leading us to
   conclude that this practice is both unsafe and unadvisable.

No call for more research. No begging the question of efficacy. No downplaying
of risks. I would have gone further, however, and called for this practice to be
better regulated. A woman died at the hands of a practitioner of an implausible
and dangerous therapy lacking any evidence to support a favorable risk benefit 
assessment. Hopefully her tragic story will at the very least convince others to
avoid it.

As if bees weren’t having enough problems, every sting incorporated into a live 
bee acupuncture treatment session kills the bee. This is yet another example of 
traditional Chinese medicine doing its level best to wipe out a species. And
bees are kind of a big deal.

One last thing that I stumbled on looking for a picture to accompany this post. 
In the United States, the FDA has not approved the use of live bee stings as a
treatment for any condition. At least one acupuncturist has lost his license for
providing live bee acupuncture, primarily it seems because he didn’t have an
epinephrine autoinjector on site.

Zeno’s Paradox

An elderly German experiments with a new form of acupuncture.Time says
acupuncture is entering the mainstream. Acupuncture has been trying to enter for
decades. Still not close.

Mark Crislip on July 28, 2022

Link



   And you may find yourself living in a shotgun shackAnd you may find yourself 
   in another part of the worldAnd you may find yourself behind the wheel of a
   large automobileAnd you may find yourself in a beautiful hospital, getting
   beautiful acupunctureAnd you may ask yourself, “Well, how did I get here?”–
   Talking Heads. Sort of.

I had a lot of indecision trying to come up with a title for this entry. I
considered Frozen Blather, MAGA: Making Acupuncture Great. Again. and Plus c’est
la même chose, plus c’est la même chose (the more things stay the same the more
things stay the same). Perhaps a Waiting for Godot reference? But I decided on 
Zeno’s paradox. Zeno was a warrior princess who, for revenge, published her
spine-injured doctor’s address on the internet. Something like that.

The headline, over at Time.com reads “Why Acupuncture Is Going Mainstream in
Medicine“.

It is? Again? Still? Acupuncture, and all the other SCAMs, have been going
mainstream since long before I developed an interest in the topic, circa 2006.
There are 16,900,000 hits using ‘alternative medicine goes mainstream’ as a
search term. 1,590,000 for ‘acupuncture goes mainstream’. As best I can
determine, alternative medicine has been going mainstream on the net since 1998 
and acupuncture since 2002. The earliest Pubmed article goes back to 1993.

That mainstream must be choked with a log jam of SCAM pollution by this point.
But SCAMs, and acupuncture, never really reached the mainstream. I am not
convinced that acupuncture has moved an inch in that direction. Maybe I should
have called the entry Red Queen Acupuncture.

Decisions, decisions.

In my first round at SBM I always enjoyed deconstructing acupuncture articles,
and it is quite striking to see that in the five years I have been away, nothing
has changed. Not that I expected it to. Nothing ever changes in the world of
SCAM. I was told that half of everything I learned in medical school would be
found to be incorrect, which is part of why there is ongoing medical
information. When, as in the case of most SCAMs, 99% of what you learn in school
is BS, you just stick with the BS and rarely if ever learn anything new. So
much easier.

So let’s take a trip down memory lane courtesy of Time magazine, or Time digital
magazine. As we will see, with the usual SCAM tempest in a teapot, what’s past 
is prologue. 

First, the accompanying photo. Acupuncture sans gloves. As always. As an
infectious disease doctor, gloveless needling gives me the willies. Looking at
Google images for acupuncture, no one wears gloves. MRSA, here we come. I did
search for acupuncture gloves and, unlike the last time I used those search
criteria, there are actually a few photos of acupuncture (not dry needling,
although the same thing) using gloves. Not as many as acupuncture gloves, a form
of hand covering to stimulate acupressure points on the hand. There were even
practitioner’s using masks, although I was not certain if it was due to COVID or
for infection control purposes. Or to hide their identity while performing an
unnatural act.

So let’s wander through the content.

It starts with a pain specialist (relieving not inflicting) who “wanted to
recommend a remedy that was safer and still effective [than opiates] That turned
out to be acupuncture.” Wrong.

I feel sorry for those with chronic pain. Opiates are without a doubt a bad
therapeutic option. But with a shortage of interventions, some medical
practitioners encouraged to turn to the magic of acupuncture. And magic doesn’t 
work. But I will grant magic is safer than opiates. Sometimes.

   When I started looking into studies, I discovered how much evidence there was
   behind this treatment.

Bad evidence from poorly done studies, yes. But not quality evidence you would
want to apply to patients. Quantity can be impressive. I would be impressed by a
Mt Hood-sized pile of cow dung but I would not want it for dessert.

   That blend of anecdotal success, research-backed results, and growing level
   of openness from the medical community are all driving the popularity of
   acupuncture as a therapy.

Always remember, the plural of anecdote is anecdotes, not data, although the
pleural of infection is empyema. The research, as noted above and at length on
this blog, is lousy.

The openness of the medical field? Probably stems from the need, when presented 
with humans suffering, to do something, anything, to help the patient. At least 
sending the patient to the acupuncturist is doing something. Well, not really.

   Although scientists don’t yet understand all the nuances of how it works,

Yes, they do: acupuncture is a Theatrical Placebo.

Time then pulls a Louie and reproduces the usual acupuncture myths and factoids.

The first is that acupuncture is a unique thing, a monolithic approach to
disease. Acupuncture should be a plural word there are so many variations of the
intervention. Or maybe, like dirt, acupuncture is both the singular and plural 
of the word. And there is Control Dirt – Master’s Tung’s Acupuncture Point,
which is useful of Smeagols ‘herpeses’. I need to apply Master Tung’s approach
to our English Bulldog.

But I digress. Which is what I want on my tombstone.

There are innumerable acupuncture styles, likely as many as there are
practitioners. Since acupuncture is divorced from reality, each practitioner
can, and does, use a unique style of acupuncture. Whose style reigns supreme?
They all do.

Acupuncture is thousands of years old. Nope, acupuncture as we know it is a
recent invention. Until recently acupuncture was quite barbaric, using tools and
techniques more appropriate for Marathon Man than a medical office. Animal
bones and stones gave way to devices no one would want stuck in them long before
thin steel needles and sterile techniques were understood.

   The practice is based on how energy, or qi, flows through the body along a
   series of channels called meridians—similar to the way nerves and vessels
   carry messages and blood throughout every system.

It cannot be similar to nerves and vessels because meridians and qi do not
exist.

It is lunacy to try and treat disease effectively when your key concepts are
completely unhinged from reality. You might as well credit the ancient concepts 
of humors as the basis of your medical interventions.

But Time states this stop-the-steal-level fantasy as fact. Or perhaps they are
only certain “…each meridian is related to a specific organ, and placing thin
needles at certain points along these meridians can effect certain changes in
the body to restore homeostasis”.

When I write I try to get rid of any ‘it’ as it is often not clear what it is
referring to. Like ‘is’. And like ‘certain’ in the above paragraph. Clear as
mud.

Ever wonder how these superficial meridians connect to deep organs? And how
altering something on the skin can cause effects on the heart or liver? Never
really explained is how these superficial interactions cause changes deep within
organs. Wait. I bet it is quantum. You know, that spooky action at a distance
of quantum entanglement. This is the truth. I wrote that penultimate sentence
and then did a search, thinking, no way. Way. I found “Discussion on quantum
entanglement theory and acupuncture“:

   …the quantum entanglement phenomenon is mutually verified with the holism,
   yinyang doctrine, the theory of primary, secondary, root and knot in TCM,
   etc. It can be applied to interpret the clinical situations which is
   difficult to be explained in clinical practice, such as the instant effect of
   acupuncture, multi-point stimulation in one disorder and the points with
   specific effects. On the basis of the discovery above, the quantum
   entanglement theory achieved the mutual treatment among the relatives in
   acupuncture clinical practice and the therapeutic effects were significant.
   The results suggest that the coupling relationship in quantum entanglement
   presents between the diseases and the acupoints in the direct relative.

Good gods. Although the article was retracted because it “has some defects”. You
think?

And my usual question: why are there no acupuncture points/meridians in the
eyes, nail beds, or the genitals? One would think that the something as vital to
life as qi would be in the life-producing organs. The answer is obvious to all 
but the most committed masochist. But good news for erectile dysfunction
patients, the problem lies distant.

   TCM believes that the etiology and pathogenesis of ED is related to spleen
   and kidney deficiency and qi and blood block.

A particular relief if fire acupuncture or the plum needle is to be used for ED.
I really do not want to know.

Time continues:

   Placement along the meridians is believed to cause reactions like sending
   more blood or lymphatic fluid to specific organs or allowing muscles to
   release in a way that reduces tension on joints and bones.

I have read that over and over and I do not really understand it.

Belief is what you have when there are no facts to support your contention.
Also, I thought the effect of acupuncture was restoring proper qi flow. Now, it 
is altering blood and lymph flow to organs. And, by the way, I was under the
impression that lymph flowed away from organs, a way of returning fluid to the
circulation. And “allowing muscles to release in a way that reduces tension on
joints and bones”. Huh? Muscles have more than one way to relax?

And once the needles are removed from these points, what keeps the qi from
returning to its prior abnormal flow state? And if the qi is flowing like blood 
through meridians, why and how do the needles cause the flow of qi to normalize?
If I were to stick a needle in your radial artery for 20 minutes, I doubt it
would improve the blood flow. And how does one know the qi is normalized? You
don’t.

   The needles may also stimulate nerves and tweak nervous system regulation to 
   result in a relaxation response, which relieves pain.

May stimulate? Or may not. Now is not the qi flow, or blood, or lymph, but a
tweaked nerve? But consistency, internal or otherwise, is not a strong point for
any SCAM.

   Research on acupuncture has been extensive, and so far, robust evidence
   supports its effectiveness for some, but not all, conditions.

As this blog consistently points out when evaluating SCAM studies, while there
is extensive research, none are robust and the better the study, the poorer the 
acupuncture effect.

   According to one analysis published in February 2022 in the BMJ that analyzed
   more than 2,000 scientific reviews of acupuncture therapies, the science is 
   strongest behind acupuncture’s efficacy for post-stroke aphasia; neck,
   shoulder, and muscle pain; fibromyalgia pain; lactation issues after
   delivery; lower back pain; vascular dementia symptoms; and allergy symptoms.

Science? You keep using that word, I do not think it means what you think it
means. One can only apply science to reality, not fiction. What do any of these 
diseases have in common pathophysiologically? What does post-stroke aphasia have
in common with lactation issues?

I need to come up with a pill that people can take that has the same widespread 
effects as acupuncture. I would make a fortune.

Remember, originally in Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine (TCPM), diagnosis of
‘disease’ is accomplished by examining the tongue and pulse. Acupuncture has
nothing to do with reality-based anatomy, physiology, chemistry, etc. that is
the foundation of medicine. How the fiction of TCPM gets mapped onto real
disease is never explained.

What all these processes have in common is a large subjective/psychological
component. Acupuncture, like all SCAMs, have nothing to offer for diseases like 
endocarditis, hypothyroidism, pancreatitis, or the myriad of diseases I see or
treat every day.

   Northwestern Health Sciences University in Minnesota, which focuses on
   integrative health professions, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, and
   Traditional Chinese Medicine. For cancer patients, sessions there can focus
   on reducing nausea, numbness, and tingling (called neuropathy), brain fog,
   low appetite, acute and chronic pain, and mood challenges that come with
   cancer care.

I think it is a shame that patients are charged for SCAMs that offer nothing but
placebo, the lack of effect being obliquely referred to:

   Often, people with cancer want to add complementary treatment that doesn’t
   affect their chemotherapy or radiation, and that’s where an option like
   acupuncture can be helpful

It doesn’t affect their chemotherapy or radiation because it does nothing.
Placebo for symptoms from reality based therapies?

Medical debt in the US is tremendous and the number one cause of bankruptcy.
When I order tests for patients, I remember I am spending their money and they
will often end up with a copay. I was in the hospital for less than 24 hours a
couple of years ago for small bowel obstruction and this year in the ER for 12
hours with a nasty case of Campylobacter. The former cost $10,000, the latter
$8,000. My copay was 10%, not an issue for a physician at my income level. But
half of Americans can’t come up with 500 bucks in an emergency.

Here is an unfortunately typical example.

   Multiple surgeries, radiation, and chemotherapy controlled the cancer. But,
   despite having insurance, Peters was left with more than $30,000 of debt,
   threats from bill collectors, and more anxious nights thinking of her kids.

Should patients acquire debt for this nonsense? I would be one angry dude if I
was in horrible debt due, in part, to paying for worthless therapies based on
fantasy.

Then Time briefly gets real. After asserting that the basis of acupuncture has
validity and that there is robust evidence, they then say

   Acupuncture is far from a proven and accepted therapy for most conditions—
   even for the ones that show promise. That’s in part because the studies that 
   support it are sometimes not high quality, and the field lacks standardized
   protocols that would better allow it to be scientifically evaluated…the
   researchers found substantial variations in study quality, acupuncture
   frequency, how long needles were left in the body during treatment, which
   points along the meridians were used, and other potentially important
   factors. That made it difficult to evaluate how effective the acupuncture
   really was. The field also lacks clear terminology and universally accepted
   agreement about the location of acupuncture points, researchers argue.

Which is it? ‘Show promise’ or ‘the science is strongest behind acupuncture’s
efficacy’? Or ‘studies that support it are sometimes not high quality’?

Time tries to have it both ways, and as is usual, the critical part falls at the
end of the article, after the favorable puff piece at the beginning.

The real reason acupuncture is far from proven or accepted, as I mentioned at
the beginning, is that acupuncture is totally unhinged from reality.

   International experts in the field are pushing to make clinical trials more
   rigorous in order to prove acupuncture’s utility for patient care and to help
   providers adopt the best practices as more benefits become clear.

Interesting phrasing. But it is what acupuncture research tries to do: “prove
acupuncture’s utility.” When rigor is applied to fantasy, the fantasy fails.
Which is why despite decades of research, rigor and SCAM do not mix.

The article mentions future areas for defrauding patients, er I mean,
acupuncture application: fertility, depression, and menopause.

   As the evidence base expands, acupuncture will likely continue to grow in
   popularity.

More bad studies in the expanding evidence base? Or the rigorous studies that,
like Zeno’s finish line, will never be reached?

   Although acupuncture has been used for centuries, only in the past decade has
   there been a seismic shift in acceptance by both Western medical doctors and
   patients,

As Talking Heads noted,

   Same as it ever was, same as it ever wasSame as it ever was, same as it ever 
   wasSame as it ever was, same as it ever wasSame as it ever was, same as it
   ever was

   Ongoing research efforts and increased interest from health systems means
   that the treatment may be part of more conversations like Mikhael had with
   his patients.

I sure hope not, but really, is there any aspect of the current human condition 
that offers even a glimmer for optimism? There are no more Choco Taco’s for
God’s sake. And just as the world is heating up. Oh, the humanity.

   “At the end of the day, doctors want their patients to feel better, and many 
   people are looking for non-pharmaceutical paths for wellness,” Menard says.
   “Depending on the condition, those little needles can make a huge impact.”

Huge impact? Perhaps. But not in the manner acupuncturists think.

Ours is a healthcare ‘system’ that is remarkable for its dysfunction. We have
some of the most incredible treatments and diagnostics wrapped in a thick layer 
of bureaucracy and BS.

The solution? Got me. But it is not in offering the nonsense of acupuncture and 
other SCAMs.

And Time? Recently they rated Portland as one of the world’s greatest places.
Having been a lifelong resident, I can say no. Portland has become, to quote the
former guy, a shithole. Maybe Time based their recommendation after
binge-watching Portlandia.

Pericles said, “Time is the wisest counselor of all.”

Nope.

When it comes to SCAM, I prefer Dion Boucicault: “Men talk of killing time,
while time quietly kills them”.

Cries the acupuncturist, “Medicine is biased against us, and there’s a double
standard!”

A recent article in Popular Science argues that medicine has a bias against
acupuncture, holding it to a higher standard of evidence than conventional
medical interventions. Even if there is a double standard, the answer is not to 
recommend acupuncture, but rather to stop recommending medical procedures that
don’t work.

David Gorski on May 8, 2017

Link



Of all the modalities of alternative medicine currently in use, arguably
acupuncture is the one that has achieved the most mainstream acceptance in
medicine. I’ve often asked why it has become so common in academic medical
centers and elsewhere, despite the evidence being overwhelmingly in favor of the
conclusion that it is nothing more than a theatrical placebo. It doesn’t matter
that acupuncture is part of a prescientific system of medicine now known as
traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), whose concepts are rooted in vitalism. It
doesn’t matter that what has passed for acupuncture since the 1940s and 1950s
bears little resemblance to what was practiced hundreds or thousands of years
ago and even 100 years ago more resembled the bloodletting that was common in
ancient European medicine more than the use of thin needles along “meridians” to
“redirect the flow” of the life energy or qi to alleged healing effect. It
doesn’t even matter that acupuncture, along with the rest of TCM, was basically 
foisted upon the world when Chairman Mao Zedong, unable to provide real medicine
for his people after World War II, decided to make up the difference with folk 
healers even though he himself basically didn’t believe in TCM and chose
“Western” medicine instead. At that point, the history of TCM and acupuncture
were effectively “retconned” into the form we know them today. In the case of
acupuncture in particular, the retconned version, which posits acupuncture as
being thousands of years old and having been practiced in basically the same
form over all that time, has little resemblance to the original, which wasn’t
documented until the 17th century. Basically, TCM is more philosophy than
medicine. None of this has stopped China from continuing to support and do its
best to export TCM to the world, even in 2017.

We’ve discussed acupuncture many, many times on this blog because it’s an
excellent alternative medicine modality to use to discuss placebo effects,
shortcomings of clinical trials, and how alternative medicine is sold to the
public—even revisionist history. In particular, it’s interesting to note how
very many forms of acupuncture have developed, and how they are used, and how
many conditions that acupuncture can supposedly treat, which encompass basically
everything. It’s also a great jumping off point to discuss appropriate placebo 
controls, something that many acupuncture studies conveniently leave out, and
how, the larger and more rigorous a study is, the smaller the effect observed
is, until the largest, most rigorous studies show no difference between “sham”
acupuncture and “real” acupuncture, and how meta-analyses sold as showing the
therapeutic efficacy of acupuncture in actuality show no such thing. Basically, 
it doesn’t matter where you stick the needles or even if you stick the needles
in; the effect is the same. And I haven’t even pointed out how studies of
acupuncture from China are virtually always positive.

Not surprisingly, acupuncturists and believers in acupuncture always think that 
their favorite modality is being treated unfairly. Also not surprisingly, many
of them publish in the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine (JACM).
Unfortunately, at least one of them writes for Popular Science.

In which medicine is accused of a “double standard” with respect to acupuncture

What made me think about these issues was an article by Kendra Pierre-Louis in
Popular Science entitled “Why it’s so hard to figure out if acupuncture actually
works: Should you stick a needle in it?” Notice the statement in the title.
Yes, I agree that it’s hard to figure out whether acupuncture works. Past tense 
would be better, though, as figuring out whether acupuncture works is something 
that has already been done over the last three decades. It doesn’t.

Pierre-Louis, however, doesn’t seem to think so:

   Does medicine have a bias against acupuncture?

   That’s the verdict of a paper (and an accompanying commentary) published
   earlier this week in The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine.
   While there’s still no medical consensus on acupuncture, and most reputable
   medical organizations do not support its use for arthritic knee pain, the
   authors’ critique lends interesting insight into the process by which medical
   procedures are accepted—and which are excluded.

   How does alternative medicine get to be plain-old medicine?

In fairness, that last question is a very good question that plays off a common 
adage in skepticism and science-based medicine: What do you call alternative
medicine that has been scientifically proven to work? Medicine. But what does
“scientifically proven to work” mean? If Pierre-Louis had focused on that
question, using acupuncture as an example, even if I ended up disagreeing with
her conclusion, the article would have been much more worthwhile. Unfortunately,
Pierre-Louis is not about exploring that question; she’s about proving that
acupuncture actually works and the UK’s National Institute for Health and Care
Excellence (NICE), which provides guidelines for recommended treatments for
diseases and conditions, has a bug up its butt about acupuncture:

   Led by Stephen Birch of Kristiania University College in Norway, the
   researchers behind the new study allege that the United Kingdom’s National
   Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), which details recommended
   treatments for given ailments, holds acupuncture to a higher standard than it
   does traditional medical modalities.

   If all of the treatments that NICE recommend for knee arthritis—including
   weight loss and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory (NSAID) drugs like
   ibuprofen—had to meet the minimum required standards that NICE sets for
   acupuncture, “opiates would become the first line of drug prescription,”
   wrote Birch et al.

I’d hardly call Birch’s article a “study.” It’s more of an opinion piece with
some data backing it up kvetching about how NICE came up with its guidelines for
the treatment of osteoarthritis of the knee. Before coming back to the rest of 
Pierre-Louis’ piece, let’s take a look at Birch’s article, whose title gives
away the game, “The U.K. NICE 2014 Guidelines for Osteoarthritis of the Knee:
Lessons Learned in a Narrative Review Addressing Inadvertent Limitations and
Bias.”

Bias. You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.

Birch’s complaint is stated most succinctly in the abstract:

   Several systematic reviews suggest that acupuncture is effective for knee
   osteoarthritis (OA), and furthermore a safe and cost-effective treatment for 
   this condition. A recent clinical practice guideline (CPG) from the National 
   Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), in the United Kingdom,
   recommended against the use of acupuncture on the grounds that the effect
   size (ES) in comparison with sham acupuncture is too small.

I read this, and couldn’t help but think, “You say that as though it were a bad 
thing.” And, yes, Birch does think it’s a bad thing:

   The 2014 NICE guideline on OA (CG177) was not a complete revision of the 2008
   guidelines, it was more limited. Although originally intended to be more
   extensive including a broader review of drugs such as NSAIDs, it was decided 
   to review those at a later date. Not only did the update focus on only a few 
   of the interventions, it also applied different criteria for evaluating and
   accepting interventions. In effect, as will be described, the process
   selected for evaluating acupuncture required the treatment to meet higher
   standards than many other included treatments. A key problem in this NICE
   update is the introduction of a focus on the development of recommendations
   based on the consideration of which interventions make ‘‘minimal important
   differences’’ (MIDs) to patients as a replacement for usual CPG comparisons
   of evidence. The MID was set as an effect size (ES) of 0.5 or greater. The
   analysis of the evidence for acupuncture in this review emphasized results
   from sham studies with a de-emphasis on evidence from pragmatic comparator
   studies. Despite the fact that the assessment of MIDs should include analysis
   of benefit and harm, this review did not include an analysis of safety data 
   on acupuncture. This coupled with the lack of usual CPG head-to-head
   comparison of interventions excluded data relevant to the use of acupuncture 
   as an intervention for knee OA in comparison with other standard recommended 
   care options, namely that it is much safer than many other accepted
   interventions for knee OA pain. This shift in methodological approaches might
   have inadvertently biased against acupuncture.

Notice the main complaint about the NICE guidelines: That they’re too rigorous. 
The dead giveaway in the paragraph above is this sentence: “The analysis of the 
evidence for acupuncture in this review emphasized results from sham studies
with a de-emphasis on evidence from pragmatic comparator studies.” I’ve
discussed before how much acupuncture advocates love pragmatic studies.
Pragmatic studies are designed to demonstrate the “real world” effectiveness of 
a treatment. Often they are not randomized and don’t have a placebo or sham
control. Clinical trials are very regimented, with clearly defined protocols,
rigorous inclusion and exclusion criteria for subjects, endpoints, and
reporting. When a treatment that’s been shown to be efficacious in randomized
clinical trials gets out into the real world, the inclusion criteria inevitably 
expand and the exclusion criteria contract. When that happens, patients who
wouldn’t have been eligible for the clinical trials used to demonstrate the
efficacy of the treatment receive the treatment, and the possibility of the
treatment not working in these patients or causing adverse reactions becomes a
real concern. The idea of a pragmatic trial is to study how well a treatment
that has already been demonstrated to be effective and safe works in the real
world. Here’s the thing. Pragmatic trials are not meant to be the first to
demonstrate efficacy. They are meant to see if a treatment proven in randomized 
clinical trials still works as well when released “into the wild,” so to speak.

Unfortunately, acupuncture advocates flip the order and put the cart before the 
horse, emphasizing pragmatic trials. The reason is obvious. Pragmatic trials,
because they often don’t have a placebo control arm or a sham treatment arm, by 
their very nature, will produce positive results. That’s acceptable for
pragmatic trials used properly, because they aren’t meant to be the first
demonstration of efficacy of a trial. That’s exactly what Birch et al. are doing
here, and the reason they focused on osteoarthritis of the knee is because they
can point to a meta-analysis that acupuncturists love to cite as evidence that 
acupuncture “works.” It was discussed many times on this blog when it was first 
published, and its author, Andrew Vickers, was most unhappy at the criticism.

See what I mean in the accompanying commentary by Hugh MacPherson:

   Second, a new methodological approach was used in 2014. Different thresholds 
   were used for the recommendations in 2008 from those made as part of the 2014
   update. The new guidance introduced the concept of the minimum clinically
   important difference (MCID), and required those interventions such as
   acupuncture that were within the scope of the update to show an MCID of an
   effect size of 0.5, a difference that is commonly considered ‘‘moderate.’’
   When acupuncture is compared with usual care, there is an effect size of
   approximately 0.5, as has been shown in an individual patient data
   meta-analysis of acupuncture for osteoarthritis.

As I pointed out, the Vickers meta-analysis did not show an MCID for acupuncture
compared to sham acupuncture. That’s why MacPherson harps on an MCID between
acupuncture and no treatment/usual treatment, a measure that maximizes placebo
effects.

Does acupuncture do anything besides leaving little holes in the skin?

I’ll have more to say about Birch et al., but this seemed like a good point to
jump back to Pierre-Louis’ article, because she asks the very pertinent
question: Does acupuncture do anything? She seems quite taken by the fact that
earlier this year the American College of Physicians listed acupuncture as a
minimal invasive treatment of low back pain. But did it? Yes, it sort of did,
but it was hardly a ringing endorsement. The actual studies used to justify the 
recommendations were questionable. For example, this study showed that there was
no difference between “true” acupuncture and sham acupuncture (which is what
pretty much all well-designed acupuncture studies show). In other words, it
showed that acupuncture is a placebo intervention. This study tested a sort of
“scalp acupuncture” that I’ve never heard of before. Another study was from
China, and, as has been discussed before, pretty much all acupuncture studies
out of China are positive.

What about chronic low back pain? Take a look:

   Low-quality evidence showed that acupuncture was associated with moderate
   improvement in pain relief immediately after treatment and up to 12 weeks
   later compared with sham acupuncture, but there was no improvement in
   function (125–130). Moderate-quality evidence showed that acupuncture was
   associated with moderately lower pain intensity and improved function
   compared with no acupuncture at the end of treatment (125). Low-quality
   evidence showed a small improvement in pain relief and function compared with
   medications (NSAIDs, muscle relaxants, or analgesics) (125).

I laughed. At least, I laughed when I looked over the list of references. The
authors actually included the GERAC study in its list, which basically showed
that acupuncture does not work, given that sham acupuncture was
indistinguishable from acupuncture. Another study was a “bait and switch” in
that it studied “electroacupuncture,” which is in reality TENS. We’re talking
thin gruel indeed.

However, that’s not enough. Pierre-Louis has to pick out another study that
really impressed her.

Carpal tunnel and acupuncture a-go-go



Don’t Taze me Bro!!! This is not acupuncture, although it is frequently
represented as such.

The study that impressed Pierre-Louis so much is one that has special resonance 
for me, because I once suffered from the condition for which acupuncture was
tested. I’m referring to carpal tunnel syndrome. Yes, around 16 years ago, I
developed a really bad case of carpal tunnel syndrome in my left hand. Given
that I’m a surgeon, you can appreciate the anxiety and fear that that caused me.
I saw my career as potentially being over. The pain and numbness were
manageable for a long time, but I saw the progressive nature of my carpal tunnel
syndrome threatening my ability to operate. I even endured a nerve conduction
study, which is basically torture with electricity. In the end, I was begging
the hand surgeon to operate on me because I couldn’t take it anymore.
Eventually, he did, and I recovered. My career was saved, and, other than an
occasional twinge, I haven’t had any symptoms since.

So Pierre-Louis invokes a recent study that I meant to blog about when it first 
appeared, but for some reason never did:

   A more intriguing example is a March study that appeared in the journal
   Brain, which found that acupuncture improved the outcomes for carpal tunnel
   syndrome by literally remapping the brain. Researchers came to that
   conclusion after exposing subjects diagnosed with carpal tunnel
   syndrome—broken into three groups—to acupuncture treatments.

   Patients in the first group received an acupuncture treatment as prescribed
   by traditional Chinese Medicine—that is, needles were inserted at the site of
   the pain. The researchers exposed the second group to something known as
   distal needle acupuncture, in which acupuncture needles aren’t inserted where
   it hurts, but rather at other sites that practitioners say are connected to 
   the painful regions by “channels of energy.” Yes, we know this sounds like
   snake oil—and the study authors aren’t alleging that the so-called channels
   exist. But if you want to know if something—a drug, a workout regimen, or in 
   this case an acupuncture technique—has any effect, you have to test it.

   Finally, a third group received what’s known as sham acupuncture, which is
   essentially the sugar pill of acupuncture. In this case, sham acupuncture
   involved non-penetrating placebo needles designed to convince participants
   that they had undergone a real acupuncture treatment. Each participant
   received 16 treatments of their designated form of acupuncture over the
   course of eight weeks.

   At the end of the study, all groups equally reported that their symptoms had 
   improved. That’s proof that acupuncture is a sham, right? Not exactly.

This is the study. Each group of patients with mild to moderate carpal tunnel
syndrome received 16 sessions of acupuncture over eight weeks, with
before-and-after carpal tunnel symptom questionnaires, median nerve conduction
studies, and, of course, functional MRI (fMRI). In any event, the reason why all
three groups improved in the short term should be obvious. All are placebo.
This result is exactly what I would have predicted. Of course, the other thing
that is obvious is that this is a typical “bait and switch” acupuncture study.
It’s not acupuncture at all. It’s electroacupuncture, which is in reality a form
of transcutaneous nerve stimulation (TENS). Let’s just put it this way: There
was no electricity hundreds or thousands of years ago. Hooking up electrodes to 
acupuncture needles is a 20th century “innovation” that serves no apparent
reason other than to “sex up” acupuncture. It also makes no anatomic sense. The 
distal acupuncture, for instance, was administered to acupuncture points in the 
lower leg; there is no anatomic reason to believe that this should have any
effect on nerves in the distal arm. Remember, carpal tunnel syndrome is due to a
very specific anatomic issue, entrapment of the median nerve as it goes through
the carpal tunnel, defined by bones and ligaments in the wrist. That’s why the 
surgical treatment, cutting the transverse carpal ligament, works; it frees the 
entrapped nerve.

Now here’s where this study has some interesting results. They are not results
that have anything to do with acupuncture, as this is in reality the application
of electrical current at acupuncture points. But they are somewhat interesting.
First, there was a modest (and not strongly statistically significant)
improvement in median nerve conduction in both the distal and local acupuncture 
groups compared to the sham. This result makes little sense from an anatomic
standpoint, although it’s not entirely implausible that running a weak
electrical current along the lower arm might potentially affect nerve conduction
studies in the same arm. In fMRI studies, the investigators reported brain
remapping associated with symptom improvement only in those receiving the local 
acupuncture, a result that’s somewhat plausible. Of course, again, none of these
results has anything to do with acupuncture, the existence of meridians, or
TCM, even as they are sold as slam dunk evidence that “acupuncture” remaps the
brain.

This study also has some significant flaws. For instance, although it was
blinded, it appears not to have been truly double-blinded. Patients were blinded
to allocation, as were the study physicians who evaluated patients for
inclusion. Experimenters, the people who did the nerve conduction studies and
evaluated the fMRIs, were blinded as well. You know who weren’t blinded? The
acupuncturists. I’ll give the investigators credit for inserting all the needles
in the distal and local acupuncture groups to hide from the patient the
allocation. However, the acupuncturists knew which experimental group each
patient was in at the first treatment session. So that’s a huge problem right
there, especially since adequacy of blinding was only evaluated after the first 
treatment and the patients were unblinded after the fMRI. There’s also another
huge defect in that the sham acupuncture specifically does not pass current
through the needles. A much better control would have been to use random
acupuncture points and actually run the same current through the needles. My
guess is that this group, had it been included, would have shown the same
results as the distal and local acupuncture groups.

So basically, what this study shows is mildly interesting, but is not evidence
that acupuncture relieves symptoms and function in patients with mild to
moderate carpal tunnel. The most generous interpretation is that passing current
through the forearm 16 times over eight weeks might improve nerve conduction
somewhat. That’s about it. Unfortunately, in a statement issued by Massachusetts
General Hospital (which ran the study) and Harvard, the study’s principal
investigator Nataly Napadow basically sells this as showing that “true
acupuncture” works by a different mechanism than the “placebo” of sham
acupuncture:

   Even after years of clinical research, controversy continues as to whether
   acupuncture works primarily by the placebo effect, especially given the
   slight differences between the efficacy of real and sham acupuncture. The
   findings of the Brain study help to address this question. Sham acupuncture
   may produce a stronger placebo effect than a pill because it sends inputs to 
   the brain via skin receptors and is coupled with a specific ritual. But the
   symptom improvement produced by sham treatment for conditions like CTS also
   might derive from entirely different mechanisms than those elicited by real
   acupuncture, the mechanisms of which may more specifically target CTS
   pathophysiology.

No, no, no. Maybe running electricity through the leg or arm causes an effect,
but acupuncture doesn’t. After all, what was the main difference between both
“true” acupuncture groups and the sham acupuncture group? It was the application
of electrical current!

Studies like this and how they are sold infuriate me and are not evidence that
acupuncture “works.” In this case, though, the press pretty much credulously ate
up the given narrative, and I couldn’t find a single skeptical take on the
study anywhere.

When is a placebo not a placebo?

Pierre-Louis, unfortunately, completely buys into Napadow’s narrative:

   Recall that if you were to throw out the objective measure’s—the fMRI and
   nerve conductivity tests—Napadow’s study looks like a dud, because patients
   expressed equal levels of pain reduction whether they experienced real
   acupuncture or sham acupuncture.

   The whole point of a placebo is that it’s inert. It doesn’t actually have an 
   effect on the body, making it an excellent control. But physical
   interventions aren’t quite the same as sugar pills: even in sham acupuncture,
   there is some pressure or sensation being inflicted on the patient’s body.
   In fact, some cases of “sham” acupuncture even involve the insertion a
   needle, though Napadow’s study did not.

   “There’s a controversy as to what sham acupuncture is,” said Napadow, “you
   still have a tactile sensation and a somatosensory input as a result of sham 
   acupuncture.”

No, there really isn’t a controversy over what sham acupuncture is. At least,
there shouldn’t be. The idea behind a placebo is to isolate the aspect of the
treatment that has a specific physiologic effect, which sham acupuncture does in
studies of acupuncture. Napadow failed to do that in his carpal tunnel syndrome
study. The way his study was designed, whether you believe the results or not, 
all it could do was to isolate the electricity, not the “true” acupuncture, as
the part of the treatment modality that causes a physiologic effect. His study
shows nothing about acupuncture. Again, repeat after me: It doesn’t matter where
you stick the needles. It doesn’t even matter if you stick the needles in.

In his commentary, MacPherson argues that acupuncture for knee osteoarthritis
was given a bum rap by NICE, that NICE applied a double standard. He points out 
that the evidence for surgical interventions for this condition, such as
arthroscopic debridement and lavage, is not very strong and that these
interventions don’t reach the threshold for effect size required by NICE, even
though NICE still recommends these procedures. Like so many alternative medicine
apologists, he frames it in terms of the opioid epidemic:

   As news of these questionable recommendations spreads, many people will be
   misled, such that acupuncture services may be commissioned less often,
   conventional medical practitioners may refer their patients less, and
   patients might find access to acupuncture more difficult. Moreover,
   misleading guidance related to chronic pain may inadvertently drive up the
   utilization of opioids, which is already emerging as an epidemic in the
   United States.

Birch et al. go even further, using the NICE recommendations as an excuse to
advocate pragmatic trials:

   If NICE were to apply the same criteria to OA [osteoarthritis] treatments,
   only opioids would be left and with their adverse events profile that may not
   be acceptable to some patients suffering from OA of the knee. Furthermore,
   in agreement with other authors, it is time to stop performing sham
   acupuncture as a control treatment in acupuncture studies.

Just a reminder: No sham acupuncture control = pragmatic study.

So basically, Birch et al. and MacPherson are arguing that the new NICE criteria
are too strict and exclude acupuncture without excluding conventional surgical 
treatments that don’t reach the designated effect size and are not superior to
sham surgery. They use these observations to argue that acupuncture should be
included in NICE recommendations for osteoarthritis, too.

Pierre-Louis then asks the right question, but implies the wrong answer:

   The researchers ask a simple question: if most of the recommended treatments 
   fail to meet this threshold, why is acupuncture excluded while arguably more 
   invasive procedures are included? But as patients, we should perhaps be
   asking a different question. Why are we being recommended procedures that
   don’t work?

An excellent question, actually. Unfortunately, the answer given by Birch et al.
and MacPherson—for NICE to start recommending acupuncture for osteoarthritis—is
the wrong answer. The correct answer is that, if surgical interventions for
osteoarthritis truly don’t reach the new NICE threshold for MID, then the answer
is not to include acupuncture in NICE recommendations for osteoarthritis, but
rather to stop including those surgical interventions. That’s not how
alternative medicine practitioners and apologists see the world, though. When
conventional therapies don’t reach a given standard of evidence for efficacy and
safety, instead of advocating that those treatments be abandoned, as those of
us who advocate for science-based medicine do, they use that as a reason for
accepting their quackery as valid treatments too. If it requires weakening the
standards of evidence to let their quackery stand “integrated” with
science-based medicine, so much the better.

The Primo Vascular System: The N-rays of Acupuncture?

Harriet Hall on June 7, 2016

Link



Is this a PVS structure or something else?

Acupuncture meridians and acupoints are imaginary until proven otherwise.
Anatomists have never been able to detect them by microscopy or autopsy, and
they are not mentioned in anatomy textbooks. For decades, acupuncturists have
been trying to prove that their pre-scientific belief system is grounded in
scientific reality. Now they are telling us that acupuncture meridians and
acupoints have been discovered in the form of the Primo vascular system (PVS). A
typical website trumpets “Science Finally Proves Meridians Exist.”

The available information is confusing.

Primo vessels were supposedly missed by anatomists because they are so small.
They are reported to only be visible by electron microscopy, yet researchers
have used dye to show them under a regular microscope. There has been
speculation about their involvement in cancer metastasis: one paper provides
images of a putative PVS cancer metastasis thread afloat in a lymph duct.  PVS
vessels are said to be too tiny to study by the usual methods of science, but
some researchers say they have somehow learned that they are characterized by
high resistance and low capacitance. They are allegedly studded with
electrically charged nodes that attract nutrients, oxygen, and regulatory
hormones. They allegedly transmit energy to organs and integrate the features of
the cardiovascular, nervous, immune, and hormonal systems and serve as the
physical substrate for acupuncture points and meridians.

Qi is re-interpreted as an electromagnetic wave involved very closely with the
DNA in the PVS. “The PVS is the communication system between living organisms
and the environments, and it lies at the lowest level of life.”  The PVS
consists of double-coated PVs that contain multiple subvessels, and PNs, nodes
that gather and distribute the PVs and control the PVS fluid’s flow speed,
direction, and contents. They hypothesize that DNA in PVS microcells stores
information obtained from environmental physical fields such as electromagnetic 
fields. There is much speculation involving biophonons, biophotons, stem cells, 
etc.

I tried to read and understand this information, but I failed to make sense out 
of it. When that happens, I can’t help but wonder whether it’s my failure or the
fact that the material simply doesn’t make sense. In this case, I strongly
suspect the latter. Some of the material is close to incoherent, and some of it 
is self-contradictory.

The history of PVS research

The PVS was discovered by a North Korean researcher named Bong-Han Kim in 1962. 
He originally referred to his findings as Bonghan ducts and Bonghan corpuscles, 
corresponding to acupuncture meridians and acupoints. He also spoke of Bonghan
liquor, a liquid circulating in the Bonghan ducts that he characterized as
abundant in DNA and RNA, with a nitrogen content of 3.23-3.4%, hyaluronic acid
170.4 mg%, more than 19 amino acids, and 16 free mono nucleotides. (How do you
suppose he got enough liquid out of these tiny structures to analyze?) He
claimed that the system is proven to exist in all animals and even in plants,
and is made up of several subsystems that are interconnected to form a single
coherent system. You can read a synopsis of his results here.  He published five
“research reports” (not formal articles in peer-reviewed journals) that
apparently didn’t provide enough detail for others to replicate successfully.
His laboratory in North Korea abruptly closed in 1966, and Kim disappeared. His 
fate is still unknown. Interest in his research later resurfaced in South Korea.
Many attempts at replication failed, but in 2002 researchers in South Korea
claimed they had confirmed the existence of the PVS and they continue to
investigate its properties. This webpage summarizes the studies that have
allegedly confirmed Kim’s results.

Why I’m skeptical

More than half a century has elapsed since these structures were first
described. After all this time, they have not been accepted by mainstream
anatomists. They have not found their way into textbooks and are not being
taught in medical schools. Keep in mind that scientists have been using electron
microscopes for decades now, and if these structures existed in all animals and
even plants, they would have been hard for electron microscopists to miss.
Other researchers not connected to the group in South Korea have been unable to 
detect the PVS. Its existence is highly questionable, but never fear: “Richard
C. Niemtzow has seen it [emphasis added] at the Nano Primo Research Center,
Advanced Institute of Convergence Technology under the Direction of Dr.
Kwang-Sup Soh in Seoul, South Korea.”  You may remember Niemtzow as the Air
Force colonel who made up battlefield ear acupuncture out of thin air.  Even if 
he were a reliable, unbiased observer, it would be foolish to simply accept his 
assertion that he had “seen” the PVS as proof.

The language on PVS websites is metaphysical and pseudoscientific, not the
language of science. I had to laugh out loud when I read that the PVS liquid
could “aggregate to form stem cells”! I don’t know what to make of the pictures 
that have been published showing alleged PVS structures. They could be anything.
I am reminded of the pictures of rope worms.  There is indeed something in the 
pictures, but it’s not worms.

I am also reminded of the N-rays discovered by the French physicist Blondlot in 
1903.  They were supposedly a new form of radiation. Researchers around the
world jumped on the N-ray bandwagon: in short order, over 300 published articles
confirmed Blondlot’s findings. But other physicists were unable to reproduce
the findings. The journal Nature sent in Robert W. Wood to investigate. He
surreptitiously rendered the N-ray detection device inoperable by removing the
prism, and the rays were still detected. When Blondlot’s assistant caught Wood
replacing the prism, he assumed he was removing it, so the next experiment (with
the device fully operable) found no N-rays. N-rays were demonstrated to be
nothing but illusion and self-deception. Those 300 published studies were all
wrong.

Anyway, PVS doesn’t validate acupuncture

In the first place, since acupuncture has not been shown to work (except as a
theatrical placebo),  the whole enterprise of trying to find out how it works
amounts to chasing after moonbeams.

Even if the PVS were accepted by mainstream science, that would not mean its
structures were acupuncture meridians and acupoints. In fact, the structures are
reported to be ubiquitous, not limited to traditional meridian locations. And
how could the insertion of acupuncture needles affect the PVS to relieve pain
and affect human health? If the structures are so tiny, how could you even hope 
to find them with a needle? And what would all this mean for the many systems of
acupuncture that have nothing to do with the traditional meridians, like ear
acupuncture and Korean hand acupuncture?

Conclusion: N-rays with needles

I don’t know whether the structures described as the PVS exist. If they are
real, we should be seeing some better evidence soon. I’ll stick my neck out and 
bet my two cents that they are not real; I suspect they are as illusory as the
infamous N-rays. But even if they were real, they wouldn’t begin to prove that
acupuncture works.

Dry Needling

Mark Crislip on May 27, 2016

Link



Pictured: The difference between the acupunctures and dry needling.

   War, huh, yeahWhat is it good forAbsolutely nothingUh-huh huhWar, huh,
   yeahWhat is it good forAbsolutely nothingSay it again, y’allWar, huh,What is 
   it good forAbsolutely nothingListen to meOhhh, war, I despiseCause it means
   destructionOf innocent livesWar means tearsTo thousands of mothers eyesWhen
   their sons go to fightAnd lose their livesOoh, war, huhGood God, y’allWhat is
   it good forAbsolutely nothingSay it againWar, whoa,What is it good
   forAbsolutely nothingListen to meWar, it ain’t nothingBut a
   heartbreakerFriends only to the undertakerOoooh, warIt’s an enemy to all
   mankindThe point of war blows my mindWar has caused unrestWithin the younger 
   generationInduction then destructionWho wants to dieAaaaah, war-huhGood God
   y’allWhat is it good forAbsolutely nothingSay it againWar, huhWhat is it good
   forAbsolutely nothingListen to meWar, huh, yeahWhat is it good forAbsolutely
   nothingCome on, let me hear yaWar, it ain’t nothing but a heartbreakerIt’s
   got one friendThat’s the undertakerWar has shatteredMany a young man’s
   dreamsMade him disabled, bitter and meanLife is much to short and preciousTo 
   spend fighting wars these daysWar can’t give lifeIt can only take it
   awayOoooh, war, huhOoh yeahWhat is it good forAbsolutely nothingSay it again,
   y’allWar, whoa,What is it good forAbsolutely nothingCome on, sing itWar,
   whoa,Come on and shout it, y’allWhat is it good forAbsolutely nothingCome on,
   come on nowIt ain’t nothing but a heartbreakerFriends only to the
   undertakerPeace, love and understandingIs there no place for them todayThey
   say we must fight to keep our freedomBut Lord knows there’s got to be a
   better wayOoooooh, war, huhGood God y’allWhat is it good forabsolutely
   nothingSay it again, y’allWar, huhWhat is it good forAbsolutely nothingSay it
   again, y’allWhat is it good forAbsolutely nothing– Edwin Starr

I’m convinced. War is bad. But I have a solution. To the 54 current armed
conflicts in the world: forget about it. Then no shots will be fired and no one 
will be injured or killed. It’s that easy. Problem identified, problem sol-ved. 
Go Science and Big ‘S’ Skepticism. Any complaints about my solution aren’t worth
responding to.

Now that the problem of war is settled, let’s move on to dry needling.

What is dry needling?

Well there is its yin, wet needling, which is the use of hollow-bore needles to 
inject, well, wet things: steroids, anesthetics, etc.

Contrast to the yang that is dry needling, which in its original manifestation
used small hypodermic needles placed directly into trigger points, but which now
often uses thin monofilament/filiform needles (not acupuncture needles, oh no. 
It’s a filiform needle) placed into various soft tissues primarily to treat
chronic pain such as myofascial pain syndromes and ISN’T ACUPUNCTURE NO IT
ISN’T. IT MAY LOOK LIKE ACUPUNCTURE BUT REALLY IT IS NOT.

Sorry I shouted. You will see why later.

Dry needling has nothing to do with chi and meridians and acupoints and the rest
of the fantastical underpinnings of traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine with
its tongue and pulse diagnosis. Nor is dry needling used for every human
aliment. Nope. Because it’s not acupuncture. No siree-Bob. It’s dry needling.

Although that presupposes that there is a single form of acupuncture of which
dry needling is not, but as has been noted in the past there as likely as many
forms of acupuncture as there are acupuncturists, so dry needling is not like
the multitudinous forms of the acupunctures.

Since dry needling isn’t the acupunctures, oh no, it isn’t, how does it work?

Well, in correctly-done dry needling a needle is placed into a myofascial
trigger point, causing a local twitch response (LTR aka muscle contracture)
which activates endogenous opioids, which is not how acupuncture is supposed to 
relieve pain. Totally different mechanism.

Other mechanisms by which dry needling is alleged to work include:

   …mechanical disruption of the integrity of dysfunctional endplates,
   alterations in the length and tension of muscle fibers and stimulation of
   mechanoreceptors, increased muscle blood flow and oxygenation, and endogenous
   opioid release affecting peripheral and central sensitization, among others.

Proposed mechanisms mind you. They really don’t know the mechanism of action.
Not at all like the foundations of acupuncture  where:

   modern research into acupuncture, the potential therapeutic mechanisms of
   acupuncture have been explored and include Pavlovian conditioned reflexes,
   nerve segment theory, gate theory, somato-autonomic nerve reflexes and
   others.

Dry needling is ‘among others’ where the acupunctures is ‘and others’. Big
difference. Presuming an efficacy, dry needlers keep looking for anatomical and 
physiologic correlates to back up their clinical practice and they do find a
variety of structures and associations, although:

   the lack of anatomical information about these structures constitutes a major
   obstacle to obtaining a complete understanding of the pathophysiology and
   widespread clinical treatment of MTrP.

I sense they are finding what they want to find. Not at all like the
acupunctures.

Does dry needling work?

As always, it depends on who you ask and for what.

One meta-analysis suggested that:

   DN was less effective on decreasing pain comparing to the placebo group.
   Other treatments were more effective than DN on reducing pain after 3–4
   weeks.

I think that is a first for a meta-analysis of a pseudo-medicine. It was
actually worse than placebo.

Another suggests:

   dry needling is effective in reducing pain associated with lower quarter
   trigger points in the short-term. However, the findings suggest that dry
   needling does not have a positive effect on function, quality of life,
   depression, range of motion, or strength.

But it is not as effective as wet needling aka lidocaine:

   Dry needling can be recommended for relieving MTrP pain in neck and shoulders
   in the short and medium term, but wet needling is found to be more effective
   than dry needling in relieving MTrP pain in neck and shoulders in the medium
   term.

Others are more optimistic:

   strong evidence for dry needling to have a positive effect on pain intensity.

Reading through the literature is not at all like the acupunctures literature: a
hodgepodge of studies with a variety of methodologies with variable results.

So, it’s acupuncture then, right?

Dry needlers are adamant that dry needling is not acupuncture, although
acupuncturists as just as adamant that it is and keep trying to draw dry
needlers into the fold; acting the goody two shoes of looking out for patient
welfare.

But really. Given the innumerable forms of acupuncture, it is safe to say that
for all practical purposes dry needling is yet another form of the acupunctures 
and likely just as ineffective. Dry needlers have simply abandoned 2,000 years
of nonsensical baggage that accompanies the acupunctures and have added a ducks 
breath of science and modernity to their placebo.

I suspect that dry needling is at somewhat of a disadvantage when compared to
the acupunctures: acupuncturists have the whole mystique of Eastern medicine on 
their side to help with their theatrical placebo, although I can’t find any
head-to-head comparisons.

Dry needlers just have trigger points, a concept that upon review comes across
as only just a little more believable than chi and meridians. Although as best I
can tell my wife sure as hell has trigger points as defined in her trapezius
and she has never used the term.

But the real reason that dry needling is not the acupunctures is turf wars,
since dry needling is the “number-one threat to the existence of the acupuncture
profession”.It is quite amusing to see how upset acupuncturists are, getting
their medians twisted into a knot over physical therapists taking their
business, and how acupuncturists want:

   to protect the public’s health safety, welfare and to stop all insufficiently
   trained and unlicensed practitioners from unsafe acupuncture.

When from my perspective there are no sufficiently-trained acupuncturists who
practice safely. Extended training in nonsense doesn’t make for better nonsense.

   It is our [acupuncturists’] professional duty to change the message that a
   weekend seminar is comparable to the more than 700 hours of clinically
   supervised training obtained by the LAc.

I agree. Two days of education on pseudo-medicine is not the same as three
months of education on pseudo-medicine. In this, the principles of homeopathy
are probably valid; less is better.

If you are practicing the pseudo-medicine of the acupunctures, then you have to 
have gone through the education and training of an acupuncturist, which is 99.9%
nonsense, and are subject to state licensing and oversight.

If dry needling is not acupuncture, then a PT or a DC or an ND or whoever is
free of those onerous requirements and can needle without the worry of
acupuncture boards and regulations.

There have been lawsuits in a variety of states to try and prevent physical
therapists from offering dry needling, saying dry needling is acupuncture and
beyond their scope of practice. Physical therapists beg to differ.

WWCD?

Me? I would take a PT over an acupuncturist any day. They are not trained in the
nonsense of chi and meridians, with the somewhat-more-plausible trigger point
as a clinical guiding principle. PTs are grounded in reality-based medicine, and
I want my pseudo-medicines with a modern patina. PTs are not going to needle
for fertility, blindness, schizophrenia, and more. Or so I would hope. And I
suspect we will never see the equivalent of “A case of perforating injury of
eyeball and traumatic cataract caused by acupuncture” from a dry needler. Or so 
I would hope.

But more importantly, as often as not practitioners of dry needling use gloves
during their needling, which is NEVER seen in the practice of acupuncture. Give 
me good infection control with my pseudo-medical practice any day.

                             Acupuncture Revisited

                                 Harriet Hall 

                                      Link

Believers in acupuncture claim it is supported by plenty of published scientific
evidence. Critics disagree. Thousands of acupuncture studies have been done
over the last several decades, with conflicting results. Even systematic reviews
have disagreed with each other. The time had come to re-visit the entire body
of acupuncture research and try to make sense out of it all. The indefatigable
CAM researcher Edzard Ernst stepped up to the plate. He and his colleagues in
Korea and Exeter did an exhaustive study that was published in the April 2011
issue of the medical journal Pain:   “Acupuncture: Does it alleviate pain and
are there serious risks? A review of reviews.” It is accompanied by an editorial
commentary written by yours truly: “Acupuncture’s claims punctured: Not proven 
effective for pain, not harmless.” (The editorial is reproduced in full below.)

Ernst et al. systematically reviewed all the systematic reviews of acupuncture
published in the last 10 years: 57 systematic reviews met the criteria they set 
for inclusion in their analysis. They found a mix of negative, positive, and
inconclusive results. There were only four conditions for which more than one
systematic review reached the same conclusions, and only one of the four was
positive (neck pain). They explain how inconsistencies, biases, conflicting
conclusions, and recent high quality studies throw doubt on even the most
positive reviews.

They also demolished the “acupuncture is harmless” myth by reporting 95
published cases of serious adverse effects including infection, pneumothorax,
and 5 deaths. Some but not all of these might have been avoided by better
training in anatomy and infection control.

Their analysis does not prove that acupuncture doesn’t work (negatives are hard 
to prove) but it unquestionably sheds serious doubt on the claim that it does
work. Overall the evidence is inconsistent, and the results tend to be negative 
among those studies judged to be of the highest quality. Where the results are
positive, the reported benefits can be explained by the surrounding ritual, the 
beliefs and expectations of patient and practitioner, and other nonspecific
effects of treatment. There is no evidence to support the vitalistic concept of 
qi or the prescientific mythology of acupuncture points and meridians; it
doesn’t seem to matter where you put the needles or whether the skin is pierced.
More modern science-based explanations like increased endorphin production are 
not convincing, since placebo pills can produce the same effects.

I was delighted when the editor of Pain asked me to write a commentary to
accompany the article. It gave me a soapbox in a major medical journal to say
all the things I thought needed to be said about acupuncture.

My commentary was edited, but it was a very different experience from the kind
of editing I experienced with O,The Oprah Magazine. It was a pleasant
collaborative process aimed only at improving the clarity of the writing and
strengthening the impact of what I wanted to say.

The journal thought our articles were important enough to warrant a press
release. Both Ernst’s article and my commentary immediately got some attention
in the media: Science Daily, Medical News Today, e! Science News, and the
American Council on Science and Health all reported on them.

Believers in acupuncture will not be pleased. I expect a hostile response and am
wondering if Ernst and I should invest in needle-proof vests.

Here is the entire text of my commentary. Thank you to the publishers of Pain,
the IASP and Elsevier, for their permission to reproduce it here.

Acupuncture’s claims punctured: Not proven effective for pain, not harmless

Commentary from Hall H. Acupuncture’s claims punctured: Not proven effective for
pain, not harmless. PAIN 2011 Apr; 152(4): 711-712

© 2011 International Association for the Study of Pain. Published by Elsevier
B.V. All rights reserved. This article has been reproduced on
ScienceBasedMedicine.org with permission of the International Association for
the Study of Pain® (IASP®). The commentary may not be reproduced for any other
purpose without permission. Permission to alter the article is not permitted.
Permission to translate the article is not granted.

In this issue of Pain Ernst et al. [1], systematically reviewed a decade’s worth
of systematic reviews of acupuncture. They found a mix of negative, positive,
and inconclusive results. There were only four conditions for which more than
one systematic review reached the same conclusions, and only one of the four was
positive (neck pain). They explain how inconsistencies, biases, conflicting
conclusions, and recent high quality studies throw doubt on even the most
positive reviews. Ernst et al.’s analysis cannot prove that acupuncture does not
work (negatives are hard to prove) but their study unquestionably sheds serious
doubt on the claim that it does work. Overall the evidence is inconsistent, and
among those studies judged to be of the highest quality, the results tend to be
negative.

Acupuncture is based on pre-scientific concepts of a vitalistic entity (qi) and 
of meridians and acupuncture points unknown to anatomists. More scientific
explanations have been offered as to how it might work, including a
counterirritant effect or the gate control theory of pain. There is evidence
that acupuncture can stimulate endogenous endorphin production, but there is
evidence that placebo pills can do that as well. Importantly, when a treatment
is truly effective, studies tend to produce more convincing results as time
passes and the weight of evidence accumulates. When a treatment is extensively
studied for decades and the evidence continues to be inconsistent, it becomes
more and more likely that the treatment is not truly effective. This appears to 
be the case for acupuncture. In fact, taken as a whole, the published (and
scientifically rigorous) evidence leads to the conclusion that acupuncture is no
more effective than placebo.

Acupuncture research is inherently riddled with pitfalls. What constitutes an
adequate control? People can usually tell whether or not you are sticking
needles in them. Various controls have been devised, such as comparing ‘‘true’’ 
acupuncture points to ‘‘false’’ ones. The best control so far is an ingenious
retractable needle similar to a stage dagger, where the needle just touches the 
skin and retracts into a sheath. Unfortunately, there is no way to blind the
practitioner, so double blind studies are impossible.

The practice of acupuncture is also not sufficiently standardized, which makes
it difficult, if not impossible to pin down reliably for objective study: there 
are various schools of acupuncture with different acupoints, and studies of
acupuncture have included ‘‘electroacupuncture’’ (with or without needles), ear 
acupuncture, cupping, moxibustion, and other loosely related procedures. In
their book, The Biology of Acupuncture, Ulett and Han [3] showed that
transcutaneous electrical stimulation at a single arbitrary point on the wrist
was just as effective as piercing the skin at traditional acupuncture points.

In more than one recent study, researchers have chosen not to use a sham
acupuncture control group. Their reasoning? Since sham acupuncture has been
shown to work as well as real acupuncture, then sham acupuncture must be an
effective treatment too! Imagine applying this reasoning to a drug trial: if the
drug and placebo got the same results, would you decide that the drug worked
and that the placebo was just as therapeutic as the drug?

It does not make any difference where you put the needles or whether you use
needles at all. Touching the skin with toothpicks works just as well. The
crucial factor seems to be whether patients believe they are getting true
acupuncture. It is becoming increasingly clear that the surrounding ritual, the 
beliefs of patient and practitioner, and the nonspecific effects of treatment
are likely responsible for any reported benefits.

Is there really any need for more studies? Ernst et al. point out that the
positive studies conclude that acupuncture relieves pain in some conditions but 
not in other very similar conditions. What would you think if a new pain pill
was shown to relieve musculoskeletal pain in the arms but not in the legs? The
most parsimonious explanation is that the positive studies are false positives. 
In his seminal article on why most published research findings are false,
Ioannidis points out that when a popular but ineffective treatment is studied,
false positive results are common for multiple reasons, including bias and low
prior probability [2]. More studies are not the answer. No matter how many
studies showed negative results, they would not persuade true believers to give 
up their beliefs. There will always be ‘‘one more study’’ to try, but there
should be a common-sense point at which researchers can agree to stop and divert
research time and funds to areas more likely to produce useful results.

Of course, advocates of acupuncture have argued that it is worthwhile even if it
only produces a placebo response; and that it is harmless, so it does not hurt 
to try it. Ernst et al. however, have shown that acupuncture is not harmless.
While many of the reported adverse effects could be avoided by proper training
in sterile precautions and anatomy, they correctly point out that even one
avoidable adverse event is too many. With any treatment, we have to consider the
risk/benefit ratio. If there is no benefit, any risk is too much. And there are
other harms that they did not mention: time and money wasted, effective
treatment delayed, unscientific thinking encouraged.

Placebos are unethical: our patients trust us not to prescribe them. With the
current state of the evidence, I do not think we should be recommending
acupuncture to our patients. On the other hand, if patients ask about it and
want to try it, we should not try to stop them. We have a responsibility to
educate them, but not to make decisions for them. We can tell them that although
some patients believe it has helped them, the evidence does not show that it
works any better than placebo, and there is a small risk of infection and other 
complications. With this information, they can then make their own informed
decision.

In summary, Ernst et al. have shown that the evidence for efficacy of
acupuncture for the treatment of pain is questionable, to say the least, and of 
particular concern is that its use can be dangerous. If the 57 systematic
reviews they surveyed had been for a prescription drug and a similar list of
serious adverse effects had been reported for that drug, we would hesitate to
prescribe that drug. Is there any reason not to hold acupuncture to the same
standards?

Conflict of interest statement

I have no conflicts of interest to report.

References

  1. Ernst E, Lee MS, Choi TY. Acupuncture: Does it alleviate pain and are
    there serious risks? A review of reviews. Pain 2011;152:755–64.

  2. Ioannidis JP. Why most published research findings are false: author’s
    reply to Goodman and Greenland. PLoS Med 2007;4:e215.

  3. Ulett GA, Han SP. The biology of acupuncture. St. Louis, USA: Warren H.
    Green Inc.; 2002. 160p.

Hype over science. Does acupuncture really improve the chances of success for in
                              vitro fertilization?

                                  David Gorski

                                      Link

There it was on Friday greeting me on the ABC News website: “Study: Acupuncture 
May Boost Pregnancy” in bold blue letters, with the title of the webpage being
“Needles Help You Become Pregnant.” The story began:

   It sounds far-fetched sticking needles in women to help them become pregnant 
   but a scientific review suggests that acupuncture might improve the odds of
   conceiving if done right before or after embryos are placed in the womb.

   The surprising finding is far from proven, and there are only theories for
   how and why acupuncture might work. However, some fertility specialists say
   they are hopeful that this relatively inexpensive and simple treatment might 
   ultimately prove to be a useful add-on to traditional methods.

By the end of the day, the story was all over the media, including radio, TV,
news websites, the blogosphere, and various other outlets, all trumpeting the
message that a scientific study says that acupuncture can help infertile couples
conceive. Nary a skeptical word seemed to be found. Knowing very well just how 
far parents will go to conceive, I was curious: Did this study actually say what
the media says it said? What was so new and radical about this study that it
rated a press release and a lot of promotion? Do we here at SBM (particularly
Steve) need to rethink our extreme skepticism about acupuncture, given the poor 
quality evidence and lack of even a glimmer of a convincing physiologic
mechanism to explain its supposed activities?

First, let’s see what the ABC News story said about it:

   The analysis was led by Eric Manheimer, a researcher at the University of
   Maryland School of Medicine, and paid for by a federal agency, the National
   Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine. Results were published
   Friday in the British medical journal, BMJ.

   Acupuncture involves placing very thin needles at specific points on the body
   to try to control pain and reduce stress. In fertility treatment, it is
   thought to increase blood flow to the uterus, relax the cervix and inhibit
   “fight or flight” stress hormones that can make it tougher for an embryo to
   implant, Manheimer said.

   The analysis pools results from seven studies on 1,366 women in the United
   States, Germany, Australia and Denmark who are having in vitro fertilization,
   or IVF. It involves mixing sperm and eggs in a lab dish to create embryos
   that are placed in the womb.

Right away, this tells us that the study is not an original study at all, but
rather an meta-analysis of existing studies. Moreover, its appearance on the
very same day that my co-blogger Dr. Kimball Atwood IV explained how
evidence-based medicine (EBM) was never designed to deal with so-called
complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) because it does not take into
account scientific prior probability is a fantastic coincidence. This study
seems almost custom-made to illustrate his point. Before I examine the study
itself, I’ll tell you what I mean.

Consider the use of acupuncture in the situation of infertility. Why would
anyone think that it would do anything at all to aid acupuncture? Let’s see what
the study authors themselves say:

   Acupuncture has been used in China for centuries to regulate the female
   reproductive system. Three potential mechanisms for its effects on fertility 
   have been postulated. Firstly, acupuncture may mediate the release of
   neurotransmitters, which may in turn stimulate secretion of gonadotrophin
   releasing hormone, thereby influencing the menstrual cycle, ovulation, and
   fertility. Secondly, acupuncture may stimulate blood flow to the uterus by
   inhibiting uterine central sympathetic nerve activity. Thirdly, acupuncture
   may stimulate the production of endogenous opioids, which may inhibit the
   central nervous system outflow and the biological stress response.

Note first the appeal to ancient knowledge, which is in itself a fallacy. After 
all, bloodletting and purging with toxic metals were also used for centuries as 
remedies; that does not mean that they actually did anything therapeutic. The
rest is mostly speculation. For instance, the reference supporting the claim
that acupuncture may stimulate bloodflow to the uterus was not looking at
acupuncture but electroacupuncture, which is an entirely different beast.
Moreover it was a small study (ten women), and it was not randomized and had no 
control group. Even so, given that electric current was passed through the
lumbosacral area, this may well have stimulated nerves leading to the uterus. In
other words, this study does not show that acupuncture itself does anything to 
uterine blood flow. If correct, it shows that passing an electric current
through L4-S3 levels may stimulate uterine blood flow. (Indeed, it states in the
paper itself that acupuncture points were chosen for innervation of the
uterus.) Moreover, the reference used to justify the claim that endogenous
opiods may be the mechanism behind an acupuncture effect is not even an
acupuncture study. The bottom line, is that no plausible physiologic mechanism
has been shown or proposed. As we now know, when clinical studies are done about
a hypothesis with a very low prior plausibility, noise predominates, producing 
a disturbingly high proportion of seemingly “positive” studies.

Doing a meta-analysis of such studies can be a very effective means of
amplifying that noise.

Let’s look at the meta-analysis itself. Perhaps the most unusual thing about
studies of acupuncture for IVF is that, unlike most conditions for which
acupuncture is claimed to work, the outcomes are not subjective. There’s not
much in the way of interpretation. Outcomes include pregnancy, continued
pregnancy (more than 12 weeks), and live births. Not present are the usual sorts
of subjective measures that make the placebo effect such a concern in most
studies requiring double-blinding. Basically, the authors scanned multiple
databases for articles, including Medline, Embase, Cochrane Central, and the
Chinese Biomedical Database. They also searched the proceedings of three major
annual conferences on assisted reproduction for abstracts. Selection criteria
were fairly stringent. A total of 108 initial studies were identified and then
ultimately whittled down to only 7, with a total of 1,366 patients. Because the 
authors were looking at acupuncture as an adjuvant to embryo transfer, only
trials in which acupuncture was administered within one day of the procedure
were included. Outcomes on clinical pregnancy, ongoing pregnancy, or live birth 
had to be extractable. Unfortunately, no data regarding a number of factors that
affect the chance of successful IVF were included, such as age, duration of
infertility, number of previous attempts at IVF). So what did the authors find? 
Overall, three studies reported a benefit, three reported a statistically not
significant trend towards a benefit, and one showed no benefit. In essence, the 
authors determined that, according to these studies, women undergoing
acupuncture before IVF had a “relative risk” of pregnancy of 1.65 (95%
confidence interval 1.24 to 2.14) compared to those who did not, 1.87 (95%
confidence interval 1.40 to 2.49), and 1.91 (95% confidence interval 1.39 to
2.64).

Looking at the actual seven studies themselves, I note that three of them were
not blinded. In other words, no sham acupuncture was administered to controls.
The authors go through a lot of contortions and arguments to justify including
studies that were not blinded, much less double-blinded on the basis that the
placebo effect is much less likely to affect objective outcomes. I do not
believe that this is a valid argument for two reasons. First, if nervousness
during implantation of the embryo has any role in inhibiting successful
implantation, a woman who believes she is getting an effective adjuvant may be
more relaxed during the procedure and thus more likely to conceive. Indeed,
there is suggestive evidence, albeit weak, that acupuncture may indeed produce
relaxation, and there’s even an anecdote from the ABC News article:

   Dr. Ann Trevino, a 37-year-old family physician who recently moved to
   Houston, is pregnant, and a believer. She had three unsuccessful pregnancy
   attempts with intrauterine insemination before trying acupuncture with IVF at
   a fertility clinic in San Antonio where she used to live.

   “I had been reading about acupuncture, probably like every other patient on
   the Internet. I was just willing to do anything possible to improve our
   chances,” she said. With acupuncture, “I just felt very warm and relaxed”
   when the embryos were placed.

If it’s the case that either relaxation promotes implantation or nervousness
inhibits it, then anything that results in relaxation during embryo placement
would result in higher fertility rates. No needles would be needed. Second, and 
more importantly, the obstetrician implanting the embryos knows who is and is
not getting acupuncture. There’s no way of knowing whether that might have
affected how the procedure was done or the decision regarding the number of
embryos to be implanted. The authors try to sidestep this important issue
thusly:

   Blinding of physicians performing the embryo transfer is another potential
   source of bias (performance bias), and three of the seven included trials did
   not blind the physicians.w1 w6 w7 Considering the cost of embryo transfer
   and the importance of successful transfers to maintaining high pregnancy
   rates at clinics, we think that physicians would be motivated primarily to
   perform a successful procedure for all patients, rather than to show that
   acupuncture, a non-proprietary treatment, is an effective adjuvant procedure.
   In subfertility trials in general, where outcomes are entirely objective,
   blinding of either patients or physicians is “infrequently attempted,”17 and 
   such blinding components are not always considered as critical elements
   related to the evaluation of risk of bias.35

It is correct that reference 17 states that blinding is infrequently attempted. 
However, this is also what was said:

   Blinding is important because trial personnel are naturally susceptible to
   hunches about the effectiveness of one or both trial treatments and only if
   they are blinded can anyone be confident that decisions and assessments are
   not affected by such intuitive influences. Double-blinding in assisted
   reproductive technology trials is infrequently attempted, and most
   gonadotrophin trials are either not blinded, or the outcome assessors are
   blinded to allocation as a reasonable compromise. It is logical to assume
   that double-blinding would bring about an increased confidence in clinical
   trial results and in theory this is simply a matter of making equivalent
   preparations for each drug. However, in reality the investigational drug
   would need to have indistinguishable primary packaging material compared to
   the approved comparator. This is very difficult to arrange and most likely
   would require new qualification studies. True double-blinding would be
   optimal, but in practice it remains very difficult.

Funny, but in oncology we manage to produce placebos that have packaging
indistinguishable from that of the drug being studied. I wonder why this is so
much more difficult in IVF. In any case, this reference does not support the
contention that blinding of the treatment team to experimental group is not
important in IVF. Moreover, reference 35, although its title states that it’s
about design and statistics, in reality seems to be mainly about statistics and 
reporting rather than overall trial design. Moreover, this is what it says about
blinding (or “concealment of allocation”):

   Concealment of allocation has received increased attention since an empirical
   study by Schulz et al. (1995) found it to be one of the quality criteria for
   randomized trials most strongly associated with bias. Their study of 250
   trials in the field of pregnancy and childbirth found 32% to be adequately
   concealed and 18% stating a specific method of randomization. Our figures of 
   34 and 64% respectively suggest an improvement in reporting of randomization 
   over recent years, but demonstrate that there is still a widespread lack of
   appreciation of the importance of reporting allocation concealment.

This reference does not support the authors’ claim that double blinding is
unimportant in IVF trials either. In fact, what it does suggest is that far too 
many studies of IVF, not just those looking at IVF and acupuncture, are poorly
designed. Remember, it’s not an issue of whether or not the physicians are
sufficiently motivated to want to do their best for their infertile patients.
It’s about unconscious changes in procedure or clinical decision-making that can
result from a failure to be blinded to the intervention.

One of the most telling conclusions of the study comes from the subgroup
analyses. The authors found that out of nine subgroups studied, only one
grouping mattered. When the analysis was restricted to three studies in which a 
higher rate of pregnancy was noted in the control group than the other studies, 
the “effect” of acupuncture virtually evaporated, and the relative risk fell to 
1.24 (95% confidence range 0.86 to 1.77). This could suggest one of two things: 
either the “effect” (if effect there is) is greater in groups with lower success
rates, or it could mean that noise and/or standardization in these groups is
greater or more prone to bias.

Finally, we haven’t yet considered the issue of publication bias, which was
recently discussed in the context of trials of antidepressant drugs on this very
blog. One of the biggest problems in both conventional medicine, and probably
even more so in “CAM,” is that positive studies that show a result are more
likely to be published. They’re more interesting, and investigators (not to
mention reviewers) are more excited about them. Negative studies are less likely
to be published or, if published, are more likely to show up in lesser
journals. The authors of the study under discussion even admit this, although
they try to discount it.

I suppose it is possible that acupunture might increase IVF success rates,
although there is no physiologically plausible reason for it to do so other than
possibly the ability of acupuncturists to soothe and relax their patients. Even
so, this study does not provide particularly compelling evidence to support
such a conclusion. Certainly, it does not provide evidence worthy of the hype
that it got after its release. A combination of failure to blind in most of the 
studies included coupled with the likelihood of publication bias serve to cast
extreme doubt on the conclusion of this study. It also shows the peril of
applying meta-analysis to CAM modalities. Here we have researchers going to huge
effort to apply the scientific method to a hypothesis for which there is no
plausible mechanism, which is based on a concept that has never been detected or
measured (meridians through which life force, or qi, flows), and studies that
are most likely dominated by noise and false positives of the type Dr. John
Ioannidis warned us about. In other words, it’s a really long run for a really
short slide.

REFERENCE:

Manheimer E, Zhang G, Udoff L, Haramati A, Langenberg P, Berman BM, Bouter LM.
Effects of acupuncture on rates of pregnancy and live birth among women
undergoing in vitro fertilisation: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ
2008;0(2008):bmj.39471.430451.BEv1 (7 February),
doi:10.1136/bmj.39471.430451.BE.

           Acupuncture for IVF Revisited – More Tooth Fairy Science? 

                                  Harriet Hall

                                      Link

I read this Reuters Health article on MedlinePlus, and then I read the study the
article referred to (The impact of acupuncture on in vitro fertilization) and
now my head hurts. The study found that acupuncture was not effective in
increasing the pregnancy rate (PR) during in vitro fertilization (IVF). As
quoted on MedlinePlus, the lead author, Alice Domar, seems to blame her patients
(the presumably poor quality of their embryos) rather than acupuncture for the 
lack of success, and then she recommends using acupuncture even if it doesn’t
work. That was bad enough, but “poor quality embryos” is a hypothesis that was
actually tested and rejected in the study itself. Has Domar forgotten?

The headline of the MedlinePlus article says “acupuncture doesn’t boost IVF
success for all” – suggesting that it boosts success for some? Then the first
sentence says the study suggested that acupuncture doesn’t work, period. But
wait…

   The lead researcher says acupuncture may not have worked in her study
   because, unlike past research, her investigation wasn't limited to women who 
   had good quality embryos available for transfer. "I'm wondering if my sample 
   was just not a good sample, in that most of the patients in my study were
   probably not the best-prognosis patients,"

Domar and her team say the most likely explanation for the lack of an
acupuncture effect in their study was the fact that they included many women who
didn't have good quality embryos available for transfer. While acupuncture may 
help a woman become pregnant after the transfer of a healthy embryo, the
researcher noted in an interview, it can't repair an embryo with chromosomal
defects or other abnormalities.

Hold the boat!! In the Discussion section of the paper itself, Domar et al point
out that previous research has included mostly patients with good quality
embryos. They ask if perhaps acupuncture only works for good quality embryos?
They test that hypothesis by separately analyzing the subjects in this study who
had good quality embryos. There was no increase in PR with acupuncture in this 
sub-group; the results were the same as for the entire sample.

This study not only had an objective endpoint (pregnancy) but it also had
several subjective psychological endpoints (optimism, confidence, and anxiety as
measured by perceived relaxation). The women who received acupuncture felt more
relaxed and enjoyed the IVF procedure more, the researchers found. They were
also more optimistic about getting pregnant, but not more confident that they
would get pregnant."

Despite the results of my own study, I still recommend acupuncture to women
going through IVF because there's no downside," Domar added, aside from the $150
an acupuncturist would typically charge -- a small fraction of the $12,000 to
$14,000 couples typically spent on a single round of IVF.

It seems to me this translates as: Acupuncture works. It didn’t work in this
study, but that can’t be the fault of acupuncture, because acupuncture works. So
it must be the fault of the patients for producing poor quality embryos, (our
data don’t support that hypothesis, but let’s just ignore that). Acupuncture is 
harmless and people like it, so let’s use it on every patient whether it works
or not. Patients will have to pay $150 extra, but I’m willing to decide for them
that the expense is worth it. What?!

Domar’s study was intended to replicate an earlier study by Paulus from 2002,
the first randomized, controlled, prospective study on the impact of acupuncture
in 160 IVF patients with good quality embryos. The treatment group got 25
minutes of acupuncture before and after the IVF procedure, and the control group
rested for 25 minutes. The pregnancy rate was significantly higher in the
acupuncture group.

Domar also mentions a subsequent study that the Paulus’ group did with the same 
protocol but using sham acupuncture as a control. There was no significant
difference. They proposed an “acupressure” effect of sham acupuncture, assuming 
that both groups achieved a greater pregnancy rate than they would have with no 
treatment; but the data don’t support that hypothesis since there was no
comparable control group of untreated patients selected for good quality
embryos. For some reason, they opted not to publish this second, negative study.
It was only presented orally at a conference in Madrid in June 2003. (Paulus
WE, Zhang M, Strehler E, Seybold B, Sterzik K. Placebo-controlled trial of
acupuncture effects in assisted reproduction therapy. 2003: Oral presentation,
ESHRE, Madrid, Spain, June 2003;18(Suppl1): xviii18.)

Domar’s intent was to repeat Paulus’ study and also investigate the potential of
a placebo effect. Double blind acupuncture studies are impossible: the patients
know they are getting acupuncture and the acupuncturist knows he’s giving it.
But for the first time Domar tried to blind the rest of the IVF treatment team
so no one else knew which group a patient was in. She expected the acupuncture
patients not only to have a higher pregnancy rate (PR), but also to be more
optimistic and confident that their cycle would be successful, thus
demonstrating a placebo effect. The acupuncture patients were indeed less
anxious and more optimistic, but they were not more confident, and the PR was
not higher.

They were asked “how optimistic do you feel” and “how confident do you feel”
about the outcome of the current cycle of IVF. I’m not sure where I would draw
the line between optimism and confidence; the whole thing is a bit nebulous. And
one could argue that false optimism may not be a good thing. If a patient is
confident that the IVF will work this time, she will have to deal with greater
disappointment when it doesn’t work.

They can’t understand why they got negative results when previous studies got
positive results; but to my mind if acupuncture is no better than placebo, the
very fact that the IVF treatment team was blinded would tend to reduce part of
the apparent placebo effect. They point out that this is the first study from
the United States. In R. Barker Bausell’s book Snake Oil Science, he shows why
studies from other countries are more likely to get positive results.
(Anecdotally, I recently heard from a friend with contacts in China that a
political officer in at least one Chinese research institution reviews all
studies before they are submitted for publication and routinely vetoes any
studies with negative results.) It is common for a new study in the US to
contradict previous studies from elsewhere. And it is common for a well-designed
study to contradict results of previous studies.

Now here’s the part that really blew my mind. In 2005, Alice Domar wrote
“Acupuncture and infertility: we need to stick to good science.”   She pointed
out flaws in existing IVF/acupuncture research and mentioned several studies
that got negative results (studies that are not mentioned in the review of the
literature in the introduction to the current study). She also mentioned one
where the acupuncture group had greater pregnancy loss after a second session.
She clearly postulated that the apparent effects of acupuncture might be only a 
placebo effect, and she suggested that there could even be harmful effects. Then
she recommended that future studies include a sham treatment. Why, oh why, did 
she ignore her own advice and do this new study without a sham treatment? She
offers no explanation. Even her psychological findings are suspect because she
compared a relaxing acupuncture treatment (“how relaxed did you feel during the 
sessions?”) to an inadequate control: no treatment at all. Would a relaxing
massage have produced even better psychological results than acupuncture?

The whole thing smells of “I want to use acupuncture no matter what.” Indeed,
Domar heads the Domar Center for Mind/Body Health, where acupuncture and other
kinds of “mind/body medicine” are offered.

She does not question the choice of acupuncture points. They were chosen for
their sedative effect as well as to increase uterine blood flow. How can she be 
sure they have these effects? She offers no references to support those claims. 
If they do have these effects, is there any evidence that sedation and increased
uterine blood flow increase fertility? How would that work? Do we have any
evidence that anxiety or deficient uterine blood flow impair IVF? (In fact, this
study found that the patients in the acupuncture group report reported less
anxiety but did not have better outcome).

Isn’t this an example of what I have called Tooth Fairy Science? We can study
the amount of money left by the Tooth Fairy in different settings, but since we 
haven’t determined that there is really a Tooth Fairy, any conclusions we reach 
will be falsely attributed to an imaginary being rather than to the real cause
(parental behavior). In acupuncture studies, the acupuncture points/meridians/qi
may be imaginary and we may be studying an elaborate placebo rather than a real
physiologic phenomenon.

This study fits a pattern. The original study by Paulus showed an effect of
acupuncture on PR but only compared to a no-treatment control group. When he
repeated the study with a sham acupuncture control group, there was no
difference between the “real” acupuncture and the sham acupuncture groups. When 
Domar improved on the methodology by blinding the treatment team, acupuncture
had no effect on PR. As controls are tightened, the effect disappears.

If this same pattern appeared in successive studies of a prescription drug, I
doubt if Domar would be recommending it for all patients, even if the drug had
no reported side effects and the patients felt better when they took it – and
even if it “only” cost $150. Of course, if the same pattern appeared in drug
studies, the drug would not even be on the market.

Domar et al have tried to do good science and have contributed to the evidence
against acupuncture. Unfortunately, they seem not to want to accept the
implications of their own results; and the poor reporting in the MedlinePlus
article only muddied the waters further.

  Acupuncture for Hot Flashes – Or, Why So Many Worthless Acupuncture Studies?

                                 Steven Novella

                                      Link

In yet another round of science by press release, a particularly unimpressive
acupuncture study is making the rounds of the major news outlets proclaiming
that acupuncture works. I guess that is a sort-of answer to my title question – 
why are so many scientifically worthless acupuncture studies being done?

Let’s take a look at this particular study to see why it is so weak. All I have 
to go on is the press release, since the study is not published. It was
presented at a scientific meeting – which is legitimate, I just don’t have
access to it. (The bar for publication in a peer-reviewed journal is much higher
than presentation at a meeting, and there may, in fact, be changes to the text 
prior to publication.) But we can still say a great deal about this study from
the information provided.

Acupuncture for Hot Flashes

The study looks at acupuncture vs Effexor for the treatment of hot flashes and
other symptoms in women who have had breast cancer and are on Tamoxifen or
Arimidex. These therapies cause vasomotor side effect, like the hot flashes or
night sweats. Normally hormonal therapy can be used to treat these symptoms, but
women who have had certain kinds of breast cancer cannot take those hormones so
other treatments are necessary. One standard treatment is the anti-depressant
Effexor (venlafaxine – a serotonin/norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor).

There were 47 patients in the study followed for 12 weeks in one of two arms –
either acupuncture or standard treatment with Effexor.  The study showed that
acupuncture was as effective as Effexor but had fewer side effects and lasted
longer after treatments stopped.

The press release also reports:

   Findings also show there were additional benefits to acupuncture treatment
   for breast cancer patients, such as an increased sense of well being, more
   energy, and in some cases, a higher sex drive, that were not experienced in
   those patients who underwent drug treatment for their hot flashes.

Evaluating Clinical Trials

Readers of this blog will know that not all clinical trials are created equal,
and there are some basic assessments that should be made in order to properly
weigh the results of a study.

This study has many weaknesses – enough to make the results uninterpretable,
which is jargon for “worthless.”

The fatal problem with this study is that it is not blinded – there is no sham
acupuncture. Patients, therefore, knew if they received the novel treatment that
was being studied. The long list of non-specific “benefits” perceived by the
subjects who received acupuncture (such as an increased sense of well-being) is 
evidence for the placebo effect in this group.  This weakness is enough to
condemn the study.

Further, the study is small, with only 47 subjects. This is especially a problem
for an equivalence outcome – the study showed no difference in degree of
benefit between acupuncture and Effexor (although there was a difference in
duration). This could simply mean that the study was not powerful enough to see 
any difference.

This small study size is also exacerbated by the fact that there was no placebo 
group – acupuncture was being compared to Effexor. It is therefore possible that
in this study neither treatment worked – since we do not have a placebo control
to gauge the absolute effectiveness of either treatment.

Prior studies indicate that Effexor is only “moderately” effective in treating
hot flashes. So it is not an unreasonable control treatment, but the modest
effectiveness of Effexor as a treatment makes the small sample size even more
problematic.

Also, Effexor does have side effects because it is biologically active. It may
be that Effexor has moderate benefit for hot flashes but these benefits are
offset by the side effects in some cases. Meanwhile, acupuncture may have no
effects or side effects -and so the net effect may have been similar.

The Disconnect Between Science and Press Release

Such a study as this is best described as a pilot study – meaning a small
preliminary study. I have nothing against pilot studies – they serve an
essential purpose in the arc of clinical research. They are useful for deciding 
if a clinical approach is worthy of further more definitive study. They should
not be used as a basis for clinical decisions, however. They certainly should
not be used to conclude that a highly implausible treatment has biological
function.

There are two problems with this study, however. The first is the press release,
which states:

   “Our study shows that physicians and patients have an additional therapy for 
   something that affects the majority of breast cancer survivors and actually
   has benefits, as opposed to more side effects. The effect is more durable
   than a drug commonly used to treat these vasomotor symptoms and, ultimately, 
   is more cost-effective for insurance companies,” Eleanor Walker, M.D., lead
   author of the study and a radiation oncologist at the Henry Ford Hospital
   Department of Radiation Oncology in Detroit, said.

I find these statements to be completely misleading (to the point of being
irresponsible) and not justified in any way by this study. It would only have
been appropriate to say that this study shows acupuncture “may” be of use but
requires further study – that’s what pilot studies are for.

The media, however, picked up the press release without criticism or meaningful 
analysis.

The Arc of Clinical Trials

My second problem with this study is to question the purpose of doing pilot
studies at this stage of acupuncture research. Clinical research has a typical
progress. It begins with observations, usually published as case reports or case
series, suggesting a possible new connection or treatment. This then progresses
to pilot studies (like this one) which are small and may be blinded or open.

If pilot studies are promising, or at least rule out any major risk or downside 
to a treatment, then larger studies are done that are designed to be definitive.
However, this usually takes a few rounds, with protocols being refined in
response to criticism or alternate interpretations of the data. Eventually,
truly definitive or consensus trials are done and the clinical question is
largely settled. (New data, however, can always revive an old question.)

Acupuncture has been studied for years, and trial design has evolved to
well-designed trials that are double-blind and controlled by either sham
acupuncture (where needles are inserted, but in the “wrong” place or not to
depth) or, even better, placebo acupuncture where opaque sheaths hide from the
practitioner and the patient whether or not a needle is inserted at all (the
pressure from the sheath can disguise the sensation of the thin acupuncture
needle being inserted).

At this point there is no reason to do pilot studies for acupuncture – this
represents a regression of the typical research process. The only research that 
is of value at this point are well-blinded trials. However, such trials have
failed to demonstrate that acupuncture has any specific effect (anything beyond 
placebo effects or perhaps non-specific effects from the process of getting
acupuncture, such as relaxation).

It is reasonable to speculate that proponents of acupuncture are shying away
from well-controlled trials because they have not given the positive results
they desire. If this is not true, and pilot studies are being performed to
explore the potential of specific applications of acupuncture, then the
statements of these researchers in their press releases and to the public should
reflect that – but they don’t. Rather, poorly designed or preliminary studies
(which at this point are scientifically worthless) are used to make glowing
endorsements of the effectiveness of acupuncture to the public.

This is not an isolated case. Three weeks ago a similarly worthless study of
acupuncture for the treatment of headaches was published. This study, too, was
not blinded and yet was used to promote the alleged effectiveness of
acupuncture.

Conclusion

Acupuncture remains a highly implausible treatment. For this reason the
threshold for evidence should be higher than for more plausible treatments.
Acupuncture has also been studied enough for the technology of acupuncture
research to have matured to fairly definitive studies, and to conclude that
there is probably no large or easily detectable biological effect from
acupuncture.

In addition, the popularity of acupuncture (while still small in absolute
numbers) far outstrips the evidence for its effectiveness, making acupuncture a 
controversial treatment. This controversy is exacerbated by the existence of
dedicated practitioners (acupuncturists), who have a vested interest in this one
modality.

For these reasons any further testing of acupuncture should aspire to the
highest scientific standards. Pilot studies of acupuncture are worse than
worthless – they do nothing to further the scientific question, and they are
abused to promote a dubious treatment through the credulous media.

                           Another Acupuncture Claim

                                Wallace Sampson

                                      Link

News bulletin on BBC NEWS International version, 8 Feruary 2008:“Acupuncture
‘boosts IVF chances.’ Acupuncture may increase the success rates of fertility
treatment, according to a study. “

(Manheimer E, Zhang G, Udoff L, Haramati A, Langenberg P, Berman BM, Bouter LM. 
Effects of acupuncture on rates of pregnancy and live birth among women
undergoing in vitro fertilisation: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ.
2008 Feb 7)

First off, how plausible is the claim? The press release states that acupuncture
had been used in China fior thousands of years for infertility. Has it? No
medical historian writing I have seen made such an interpretation of ancient
texts. Maybe I missed something…possible. But acupuncture was not used for
specific disorders or purposes, but was used as a sort of panacea to cause
balance of either the Yin and Yang or of the relationship of the individual with
the 5 elements and the cosmos and the earth. There is nothing specific in
claims of acupuncture in traditional Chinese Medicine history. Who gave the news
people that misleading lead-in?

Second, what is the plausibility that acupuncture could possibly affect a
laboratory procedure on tissue removed from the subject, regardless of timing?
Negligible to none. There is no consistent and credible information that
acupuncture is effective for anything, except as a conditiong agent for
perception of symptoms.

So, does acupuncture increase the success of IVF?

This study, making international news wires, was not another randomized clinical
trial (RCT,) but a Systematic Review (SR) of previous trials. We have several
layers of potential error to contend with: 1) The quality and accuracy of each
RCT, 2) The quality and accuracy of the SR itself, 3) The accuracy of the news
release, which emanates from publicity departments of the respective
universities, 4) The relevance and selection of the quotations and the data.

Individual RCTs display yet another layer of potential error. Some of the
difficulties in evaluating RCTs were delineated in Dr. Atwood’s review of
homeopathy. They include the biases of the sponsoring organization, the
heterogeneity of treatment and control subjects from one trial to another,
differing end points, differing methods of pain and other symptom measurements, 
the problems of quantifying symptoms – which are multiple and difficult to
overcome, differing (in this case) acupuncture techniques, and differing
statistical analyses and expressions. Acupuncture studies are particularly prone
to problems of breaking of the blinding. None of these is known to have been
adequately controlled for in RCTs to date. Ioannidis in his now classic paper in
PLoS Medicine 1996 listed a number of similar faults responsible for his thesis
that most clinical results are false. (I would say, just erroneous.)
Nevertheless, most positive acupuncture trials are defective and their results
are unreliable.

As for sponsoring organizations, RCTs sponsored by pharmaceutical companies are 
generally suspect and show inordinate degrees of “efficacy.” So far, RCTs
sponsored by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine,
supplement companies, sectarian method treatment centers, ideologically oriented
granting agencies, have not received the same attention for conflict of
interest. They should. They all show an excess of “positive” trials for
ineffective treatments.

As for SRs, no SR system accounts for those embedded biases. Nor is there an
accepted, proved methodology for performing SRs. One count of different SR
methods came to over twenty. Some have entry criteria for RCTs, which eliminate 
lower quality individual studies. Other SRs include as many studies as possible.
Whichever general method is used, most SRs differ from one another as to which 
studies qualify for inclusion.

Not only that, there are no current universally accepted standards for RCT
evaluation, or as to how the evaluators judge and negotiate their differences.
Nor is there an accepted level or measure for when to declare a method effective
or ineffective or indeterminate. Add to that the facts that there are no
qualifications for systematic review reviewers – and worse, most reviewers of
“CAM” or sectarian methods are the practitioners and advocates of those methods.
Talk about biases…

We have been collecting Srs and analyzing the conclusions from varying subjects 
and treatment methods.

Comparing acupuncture Srs with those of anti-hypertensive drug efficacy, or with
other ineffective methods shows an apparent bias in how results are reported,
and their conclusions.

Regarding this BBC report, so far I have not seen the original paper, just the
news release. Nevertheless, the release states an obvious clue that contradicts 
the headline conclusion, which I assume is the conclusion of the SR authors. The
standard known success rate in the best of hands for in vitro fertilization
(IVF) is about 25 percent. We went through this material in analyzing and
reporting on the infamous Cha/Wirth report of positive results on IVF from
distant prayer, now with mountains of evidence to have been fraudulent. In this 
acupuncture SR, the authors admit that in the most successful labs, there was no
improvement in IVF success when subjects received acupuncture. Apparently, the 
successes came in labs in China which had lesser success rates before the study.
There are several reasons why a success might be increased in a low success
rate lab. Data selection would rise to the to the top, as would any study that
allowed a timing bias – with comparisons of later vs. earlier data, which would 
allow improvement with experience and expertise development. Editors should
require all raw data from those overseas labs.

One might ask, in view of that latter fact alone, why this article was accepted 
for publication, and why such a headline conclusion was allowed to be broadcast.
The British Medical Journal seems to have been printing reports on sectarian
medicine methods more frequently than have many other journals. The editorship
recently changed and we had hoped for a significant change in that policy.
Change is slow.

                    Another Acupuncture Study – On Heartburn

                                  Harriet Hall

                                      Link

Patients with heartburn are often diagnosed with GERD (gastroesophageal reflux
disease) and treated with a drug called a proton pump inhibitor (PPI) to reduce 
stomach acid production. It is pretty effective, but it doesn’t always work.
When it doesn’t, standard practice has been to double the dose of PPI. Doubling 
the dose only improves symptoms in 20-25%. Most patients who fail the single
dose turn out to have normal esophageal acid exposure, or “functional”
heartburn. In other words, the symptoms appear to be due to something other than
excess acid – so it really may not make much sense to double the PPI dose. What
else could doctors try?

How about acupuncture? A recent clinical trial compared acupuncture to doubling 
the proton pump inhibitor dose in refractory heartburn.

There were 30 patients randomized into two comparable groups. Patients in the
PPI doubling group got no intervention but a doubling of the PPI dose. Patients 
in the acupuncture group remained on the original dose of PPI but also got
acupuncture. The acupuncture protocol was developed using Traditional Chinese
Medicine (TCM) pattern diagnosis and five acupuncture points were chosen. A
sixth point was used if the patient had any characteristics of “dampness” such
as loose stools or sensation of gastric heaviness. 10 sessions of traditional
acupuncture according to TCM principles were scheduled over 4 weeks.
Acupuncturists told patients to expect a unique needle sensation known as “de
qi.” They conducted a thorough TCM evaluation, decided whether to include the
6th acupuncture point, and then took patients to a quiet treatment room. They
stimulated the needle and adjusted the depth of insertion until the patient
reported a “de qi” sensation. This was repeated every 5 minutes for 20 minutes
total. Otherwise, they tried to minimize patient-provider interactions. The end 
points were subjective (self-reported heartburn and acid regurgitation). There
was no improvement in the group that got a double dose of PPI, but the
acupuncture group reported significant improvements in symptoms and in mean
general health score.

They concluded that adding acupuncture to PPI is significantly more effective in
relieving symptoms than doubling the PPI dose.

Research methodologist R. Barker Bausell, in Snake Oil Science, offers some
simplified guidelines to see if a study could be considered credible scientific 
evidence. Let’s see how this study measures up.

(1) Random assignment and a credible placebo control group. Random assignment – 
yes. Placebo – no (more about this later).

(2) At least 50 subjects in each group. No, only 15.

(3) Less than 25% dropout rate. Yes, everyone completed the study protocol.

(4) Published in a high-quality, prestigious, peer-reviewed journal. This was
published in Alimentary Pharmacology & Therapeutics which according to its
website is ranked 14/48 in Gastroenterology and Hepatology and 47/199 in
Pharmacology and Pharmacy, with an overall impact factor of 3.287. For
comparison, the New England Journal of Medicine has an impact factor of 34.83.

So Bausell would probably have a few doubts about this study right off the bat.

But what completely discredits this study for me is the authors’ flawed
reasoning in the discussion section. Here is the most offensive paragraph in its
entirety:

   “We did not add a sham acupuncture arm to this study because of the
   increasing recognition in the acupuncture literature that superficial
   (needling of the skin), sham (needling of non-acupuncture points) and placebo
   (needling with blunt tip that does not penetrate the skin) acupuncture also 
   provide an active therapeutic effect.37 This is particularly the case in pain
   conditions that are predominantly associated with an affective
   component.38–40 A recent study demonstrated that a system of slow-conducting 
   unmyelinated (C) afferents responds to light touch.41 By using functional
   magnetic resonance imaging, the authors showed that stimulation of C tactile 
   afferents after light touch results in activation of the insular region but
   not of the somatosensory cortex. Activation of the C tactile afferents
   results in a ‘limbic touch’ that may underlie emotional and hormonal
   responses commonly seen following caressing, for example.41 Thus, it is
   likely that control procedures used in many acupuncture studies aimed at
   being inert may activate the C tactile afferents that alleviate
   unpleasantness and re-establish patients’ sense of well-being.37 Therefore,
   neither minimal, superficial, sham acupuncture nor placebo needles may be
   regarded as placebo, because they are not inert.37″

I could hardly believe my eyes when I read this. The authors are aware of the
research showing that acupuncture is no better than placebo, but instead of
accepting the obvious, they are trying to rationalize that the placebos are
therapeutic too! This hypothesis has been refuted by other research showing that
patients get more pain relief when they believe they have gotten conventional
acupuncture, regardless of whether they got the conventional or sham or placebo 
acupuncture! Patients who believed they were receiving true acupuncture had a
mean pain level VAS score of 21.0 (range 17.2-24.8), and patients who believed
they were receiving a sham or placebo acupuncture treatment had a level of 40.4 
(range 31.9-48.8). There was not even any overlap between the groups. It doesn’t
matter what you do to the patient; all that matters is what the patient
believes you did.

Then, think about the implications of their rationalizations about C tactile
afferents. What they are saying is that maybe any kind of light touching of the 
skin can produce the effects traditionally attributed to acupuncture. If this
were true, it would completely destroy any reason to use acupuncture. Why on
earth would anyone bother with TCM methods, needles, or “de qi” if it works just
as well to caress the skin?

Another small thing that bothers me is that in previous studies, 20-25% of
patients improved after the PPI dose was doubled, and in this study there was no
improvement whatsoever. They don’t say whether their subjects had previous
experience with acupuncture. One possible explanation might be that patients
volunteered for this study because they believed acupuncture worked, and
assignment to the PPI-doubling group disappointed them and made them think they 
would not improve.

This study falls into the category of what I call Tooth Fairy science. You could
measure how much money the Tooth Fairy leaves under the pillow, whether she
leaves more cash for the first or last tooth, whether the payoff is greater if
you leave the tooth in a plastic baggie versus wrapped in Kleenex. You can get
all kinds of good data that is reproducible and statistically significant. Yes, 
you have learned something. But you haven’t learned what you think you’ve
learned, because you haven’t bothered to establish whether the Tooth Fairy
really exists.

These researchers learned something, but not what they think they learned. They 
learned that doubling the PPI dose is pretty much useless, and that providing a 
placebo intervention is much more effective. To my mind, the next logical step
would be to find the simplest, most effective method to help the patient in the 
same way that they were helped by acupuncture placebo, but without any
make-believe about imaginary meridians and qi. If the authors’ speculations
about light touch are correct, it’s quite possible that some form of light
massage would be equally effective. And perhaps personal attention, relaxation, 
and reassurance would do even more good.

We may be able to learn a great deal from alternative medicine practices, but
not necessarily what they would like to teach us. All the acupuncture research
to date is compatible with the hypothesis that it’s nothing more than an
elaborate placebo with maybe a touch of counter-irritant thrown in. No one has
seen a meridian or measured the qi. Isn’t it time to stop doing junk science and
Tooth Fairy research, to discard needles and meridians and mystical nonsense,
and to try reality-based approaches to improving patient comfort and
satisfaction?

                        Puncturing the Acupuncture Myth

                                  Harriet Hall

                                      Link

Note: This is slightly revised from an article I originally wrote as a “SkepDoc”
column for Skeptic magazine. It was pre-released online in eSkeptic and it has 
already generated a lot of comments, including “a truly amazing piece of peurile
pseudo-intellectualism,” “an ad hominem attack on one form of alternative
medicine so beset by poor thinking that one must come to the conclusion this
woman might just be paid to write such propaganda,” and “twaddle wrapped in
swaddling rhetoric.” (I treasure comments like those as evidence that my critics
are so bankrupt of real arguments that they have to dip into the insult pouch
for ammunition.)  I thought it would be interesting to post it here on the blog 
and see how much controversy it would stir up among my co-bloggers and readers. 
Please keep in mind that it was written for a popular audience and excuse the
lack of scholarly citations. You may recognize some of the studies I refer to
from previous blog entries.

———

“Alternative” medicine is by definition medicine that has not been
scientifically proven and has not been accepted into mainstream scientific
medicine. The question I keep hearing is, “But what about acupuncture? It’s been
proven to work, it’s supported by lots of good research, more and more doctors 
are using it, and insurance companies even pay for it.”

It’s time the acupuncture myth was punctured – preferably with an acupuncture
needle. Almost everything you’ve heard about acupuncture is wrong.

To start with, this ancient Chinese treatment is not so ancient and may not even
be Chinese! From studying the earliest documents, Chinese scholar Paul Unschuld
suspects the idea may have originated with the Greek Hippocrates of Cos and
later spread to China. There’s certainly no evidence that it’s 3000 years old.
The earliest Chinese medical texts, from the 3rd century BC, don’t mention it.
The earliest reference to “needling” is from 90 BC, but it refers to
bloodletting and lancing abscesses with large needles or lancets. There is
nothing in those documents to suggest anything like today’s acupuncture. We have
the archaeological evidence of needles from that era – they are large; the
technology for manufacturing thin steel needles appropriate for acupuncture
didn’t exist until 400 years ago.

The earliest accounts of Chinese medicine reached the West in the 13th century: 
they didn’t mention acupuncture at all. The first Westerner to write about
acupuncture, Wilhelm Ten Rhijn, in 1680, didn’t describe acupuncture as we know 
it today: he didn’t mention specific points or “qi;” he spoke of large gold
needles that were implanted deep into the skull or “womb” and left in place for 
30 respirations.

Acupuncture was tried off and on in Europe after that. It was first tried in
America in 1826 as a possible means of resuscitating drowning victims. They
couldn’t get it to work and “gave up in disgust.” I imagine sticking needles in 
soggy dead bodies was pretty disgusting.

Through the early 20th century, no Western account of acupuncture referred to
acupuncture points: needles were simply inserted near the point of pain. Qi was 
originally vapor arising from food, and meridians were channels or vessels. A
Frenchman, Georges Soulie de Morant, was the first to use the term “meridian”
and to equate qi with energy – in 1939. Auricular (ear) acupuncture was invented
by a Frenchman in 1957.

The Chinese government tried to ban acupuncture several times between 1822 and
WWII, when the Chinese Nationalist government tried to suppress it. Mao revived 
it in the “barefoot doctor” campaign in the 1960s as a cheap way of providing
care to the masses; he did not use it himself and he did not believe it worked. 
It was Mao’s government that coined the term “traditional Chinese medicine” or
TCM, to include acupuncture, herbal medicine, moxibustion, and other traditional
practices.

In 1972 James Reston accompanied Nixon to China and returned to tell about his
appendectomy. It was widely believed that his appendix was removed under
acupuncture anesthesia. In reality, acupuncture was used only as an adjunct for 
pain relief the day after surgery, and the relief was probably coincident with
the expected return of normal bowel motility. A widely circulated picture of a
patient allegedly undergoing open heart surgery with acupuncture anesthesia was 
shown to be bogus. If acupuncture is used in surgery today, it is used along
with conventional anesthesia and/or pre-operative meds, and it is selected only 
for patients who believe in it and are likely to have a placebo response.

As acupuncture increased in popularity in the West, it declined in the East. In 
1995, visiting American physicians were told only 15-20% of Chinese chose TCM,
and it was usually used along with Western treatments after diagnosis by a
Western-trained physician. Apparently some patients choose TCM because it is all
they can afford: despite being a Communist country, China does not have
universal health coverage.

There were originally 360 acupuncture points (based on the number of days of the
year rather than on anatomy). Currently more than 2000 acupuncture points have 
been “discovered” leading one wag to comment that there was no skin left that
was not an acupuncture point. There were either 9, 10, or 11 meridians – take
your pick. Any number is as good as another, because no research has ever been
able to document the existence of acupuncture points or meridians or qi.

Does acupuncture work? Which acupuncture, and what do you mean by work? There
are various different Chinese systems, plus Japanese, Thai, Korean and Indian
modalities, most of which have been invented over the last few decades. Whole
body or limited to the scalp, hand, ear, foot, or cheek and chin. Deep or
superficial. With electrified needles. With lasers. With dermal pad electrodes
and no skin penetration.

Acupuncture works, but placebos work too. Acupuncture has been shown to “work”
to relieve pain, nausea, and other subjective symptoms, but it has never been
shown to alter the natural history or course of any disease. It’s mostly used
for pain today, but early Chinese practitioners maintained that it was not for
the treatment of manifest disease, was so subtle that it should only be employed
at the very beginning of a disease process, and was only likely to work if the 
patient believed it would work. Now there’s a bit of ancient wisdom!

Studies have shown that acupuncture releases natural opioid pain relievers in
the brain: endorphins. Veterinarians have pointed out that loading a horse into 
a trailer or throwing a stick for a dog also releases endorphins. Probably
hitting yourself on the thumb with a hammer would release endorphins too, and it
would take your mind off your headache.

Psychologists can list plenty of other things that could explain the apparent
response to acupuncture. Diverting attention from original symptoms to the
sensation of needling, expectation, suggestion, mutual consensus and compliance 
demand, causality error, classic conditioning, reciprocal conditioning, operant 
conditioning, operator conditioning, reinforcement, group consensus, economic
and emotional investment, social and political disaffection, social rewards for 
believing, variable course of disease, regression to the mean – there are many
ways human psychology can fool us into thinking ineffective treatments are
effective. Then there’s the fact that all placebos are not equal – an elaborate 
system involving lying down, relaxing, and spending time with a caring authority
can be expected to produce a much greater placebo effect than simply taking a
sugar pill.

There are plenty of studies showing that acupuncture works for subjective
symptoms like pain and nausea. But there are several things that throw serious
doubt on their findings. The results are inconsistent, with some studies finding
an effect and others not. The higher quality studies are less likely to find an
effect. Most of the studies are done by believers in acupuncture. Many subjects
would not volunteer for an acupuncture trial unless they had a bias towards
believing it might work. The acupuncture studies coming from China and other
oriental countries are all positive – but then almost everything coming out of
China is positive. It’s not culturally acceptable to publish negative results – 
researchers would lose face and their jobs. In a recent survey, “No trial
published in China or Russia/USSR found a test treatment to be ineffective.” We 
can’t reach a valid conclusion based on positive published studies if we don’t
know about negative studies that never saw the light of day.

The biggest problem with acupuncture studies is finding an adequate placebo
control. You’re sticking needles in people. People notice that. Double blinding 
is impossible: you might be able to fool patients into thinking you’ve used a
needle when you haven’t, but there’s no way to blind the person doing the
needling. Two kinds of controls have been used: comparing acupuncture points to 
non-points, and using an ingenious needle in a sheath that appears to have
penetrated the skin when it hasn’t.

In George Ulett’s research, he found that applying an electrical current to the 
skin of the wrist – a kind of TENS (transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation)
treatment – worked just as well as inserting needles, and one point on the
wrist worked for symptoms anywhere in the body.

Guess what? It doesn’t matter where you put the needle. It doesn’t matter
whether you use a needle at all. In the best controlled studies, only one thing 
mattered: whether the patients believed they were getting acupuncture. If they
believed they got the real thing, they got better pain relief – whether they
actually got acupuncture or not! If they got acupuncture but believed they
didn’t, it was less likely to work. If they didn’t get it but believed they did,
it was more likely to work.

Acupuncturists can rationalize with great ingenuity. In a recent study using
sham acupuncture as a control, both the sham placebo acupuncture and the true
acupuncture worked equally well and were better than no treatment. The obvious
conclusion was that acupuncture was no better than placebo. Their conclusion was
that acupuncture worked and the placebo acupuncture worked too!

One researcher decided it’s not meaningful to use placebo controls in
acupuncture research because any stimulation of the skin might be effective –
which seems to me to pretty much destroy the whole rationale for acupuncture,
but he didn’t seem to notice that. If that’s true, why not just caress or
massage our patients instead of lying about imaginary qi and meridians?

Considering the inconsistent research results, the implausibility of qi and
meridians, and the many questions that remain, all the current evidence is
compatible with this hypothesis: acupuncture is nothing more than a recipe for
an elaborate placebo seasoned with a soupcon of counter-irritant. That is what
R. Barker Bausell concluded in his book Snake Oil Science. The world’s first
professor of complementary medicine, Dr. Edzard Ernst, is more accepting of
low-prior-plausibility evidence than some of us; but even he used the words
“tentative” and “might” when he recently wrote, “While there is tentative
evidence that acupuncture might be effective for some forms of pain relief and
nausea, it fails to deliver any medical benefit in any other situations and its 
underlying concepts are meaningless.”

Acknowledgement: Part of this article was adapted from a PowerPoint presentation
prepared by the late Dr. Robert Imrie. That entire presentation is available
on-line . It’s well worth a visit; it includes great pictures of camelpuncture, 
goatpuncture, and chickenpuncture.

ADDED AFTER ORIGINAL POSTING:

At the request of several readers, I am adding these references. They are by no 
means comprehensive. Many of these references contain long lists of primary
sources.

History of Acupuncture:

Unschuld P. Medicine in China: A History of Ideas (Comparative Studies of Health
Systems and Medical Care). University of California Press, 1988.

Imrie RH, Ramey DW, Buell PD, Ernst E, Basser SP. “Veterinary Acupuncture and
Historical Scholarship: Claims for the Antiquity of Acupuncture” The Scientific 
Review of Alternative Medicine. 2001, 5: 133-9.

Imrie, RH, Ramey DW, Buell PD. “Veterinary Acupuncture and Historical
Scholarship: The ‘Traditions’ of Acupuncture and TCM.” The Scientific Review of 
Alternative Medicine. 2003-4. 7:61-8.

Basser S. “Acupuncture: A History” The Scientific Review of Alternative
Medicine. 1999. 3: 34-41.

Imrie R, Ramey D, Buell P. “Veterinary Acupuncture and Historical Scholarship,
Part III: Politics , Popularity, and the Promotion of TCM” The Scientific Review
of Alternative Medicine. 2005. 9: 69-74.

Acupuncture for Heart Surgery:

Posner G and Sampson W. “Chinese Acupuncture for Heart Surgery Anesthesia” The
Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine. 3:2, p. 15-19. 1999.

Posner G. Questioning Dr. Isadore Rosenfeld’s China Acupuncture Story, Skeptical
Inquirer. 1999: Vol. 23 No. 4.

Mao not believing in acupuncture:

Zhi-Sui, Li. The Private Life of Chairman Mao. Random House, 1996.

Origin of ear acupuncture:

“Organ Representation on Extremities” on the American Acupuncture website.
http://www.americanacupuncture.com/ear_ac.htm. Accessed Oct 21 2008.

James Reston’s Appendectomy:

James Reston. “Now, About My Operation in Peking” New York Times, July 26, 1971.

Current status of acupuncture in China.

Beyerstein B and Sampson W.“Traditional Medicine and Pseudoscience in China: A
Report of the Second CSICP Delegation” (Part 1). Skeptical Inquirer. 1997.

http://www.csicop.org/si/9607/china.html

Beyerstein B and Sampson W. “Traditional Medicine and Pseudoscience in China: A 
Report of the Second CSICOP Delegation (Part 2)” Skeptical Inquirer, 1996.
http://www.csicop.org/si/9609/china.html

Sham acupuncture studies, research methods, meta-analyses:

Bausell, RB. Snake Oil Science: The Truth about Complementary and Alternative
Medicine. Oxford University Press, 2007.

Ulett’s research:

Ulett, GA and Han, S. The Biology of Acupuncture. Warren H. Green, 2001.

Preponderance of positive studies from China:

Vickers A, Goyal N, Harland R, Rees R. “Do certain countries produce only
positive results? A systematic review of controlled trials.” Control Clin
Trials, 1998: 19(2):159-66.

Excuse for not using placebo controls: http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=44

Why ineffective treatments seem to work:

Beyerstein B. “Psychology and ‘Alternative Medicine’: Social and Judgmental
Biases That Make Inert Treatments Seem to Work.” The Scientific Review of
Alternative Medicine. 1999. Vol 3.

http://www.sram.org/0302/bias.html

Beyerstein B. “Why Bogus Therapies Often Seem to Work”
http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/altbelief.html

General:

Singh,S and Ernst, E. Trick or Treatment: The Undeniable Facts about Alternative
Medicine. W.W. Norton, 2008.

Bausell, RB. Snake Oil Science: The Truth about Complementary and Alternative
Medicine. Oxford University Press, 2007.

Carroll, R. “Acupuncture” The Skeptic’s Dictionary.
http://skepdic.com/acupunc.html

Acupuncture Watch website. http://www.acuwatch.org/

Barrett, S. “Be Wary of Acupuncture, Qigong, and ‘Chinese Medicine’”
http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/acu.html

Imrie, Robert. “Acupuncture: The Facts.” 2005. PowerPoint presentation available
online at http://drspinello.com/altmed/acuvet/acuvet_files/frame.htm

      “Acupuncture Anesthesia”'  A Proclamation from Chairman Mao (Part I)

                                 Kimball Atwood

                                      Link

James Reston’s Appendectomy

For many Americans, the current wave of public fascination with “complementary
and alternative medicine (CAM)” can be traced to a single event: New York Times 
columnist James Reston’s appendectomy in China during the summer of 1971, which 
Reston reported in an interesting and amusing article on July 26 of that year.
Many of those who noticed the publicity following this event erroneously
concluded that Mr. Reston had undergone “acupuncture anesthesia.” A few years
ago, a Google search for “acupuncture and Reston” revealed that approximately
50% of the numerous “hits” reported this, as though it were an uncontroversial
fact. Other sources have suggested the same, but in veiled language. Here are
examples of each: 

   In the 1970s, interest in the procedure was sparked when New York Times
   editor James Reston wrote an article about his experience with acupuncture.
   Reston was covering Richard Nixon’s visit to China when Reston needed an
   emergency appendectomy, and acupuncture was used as an anesthetic.—UPenn News
   1995 

   In 1972 President Nixon opened the doors to China. A New York Times
   journalist James Reston was in China at the time and had an emergency
   appendectomy with acupuncture used as the anesthetic.—American Acupuncture 

   [Acupuncture] made its official appearance in the U.S. in 1971 when an
   article by J. Reston was published in the New York Times describing his
   personal experience with acupuncture. While in Beijing reporting on a
   Ping-Pong tournament, he underwent an emergency appendectomy. Acupuncture was
   used as surgical anesthesia and to relieve post-operative pain. —Center for 
   the Healing Arts, P.C.

   The first US national media coverage concerning Acupuncture was in 1971
   during President Nixon’s visit to China. There, visiting columnist James
   Reston told of his emergency appendectomy performed under Acupuncture
   anesthesia.— AZ Multicare

   When New York Times columnist James Reston underwent an appendectomy while
   accompanying the Nixon entourage to Beijing in 1971, he wrote about a medical
   discovery called “acupuncture anesthesia.” Eisenberg, David, with Thomas Lee
   Wright: Encounters with Qi (p. 28) 

About a month after his appendectomy, Reston did write about acupuncture
anesthesia—but not referring to his own operation.

Those who don’t report that Reston had acupuncture anesthesia are likely to
write, also erroneously, that his “intense post-operative pain was relieved by
acupuncture”:

   In 1971, a journalist named James Reston was travelling in the People’s
   Republic of China. He had received an emergency appendectomy and was
   suffering from extreme post-surgical pain. To his surprise, acupuncture
   relieved the pain.— http://www.acupuncturehealingarts.com/pain.html

   New York Times reporter James Reston’s account of how physicians in Beijing
   eased his post-surgery abdominal pain with needles.—
   http://www.nih.gov/news/pr/nov97/od-05.htm

   After the emergency operation was completed, Reston was in extreme discomfort
   and pain. To give him relief, the Chinese doctors performed an ancient
   practice of inserting needles into special areas of the skin to safely deaden
   the pain. This is called acupuncture.—
   http://www.school-for-champions.com/history/acupuncture.htm

   Reston wrote a front-page story in the Times—”an obituary to his appendix,”
   as Eisenberg recalls it—that described how his intense postoperative pain was
   relieved by acupuncture, an ancient technique of Chinese medicine then
   unknown in the West. “This was an intellectual shot heard round the world,”
   Eisenberg says. “It resulted in NIH sending teams of scientists and
   clinicians to China to see if acupuncture anesthesia had any validity.”

   The 17-year-old Harvard freshman was fascinated. “It was something out of
   Star Trek—the idea that acupuncture needles could change pain sensations in a
   human being was like magic,” Eisenberg recalls. (Harvard Magazine,
   March/April 2002)

The “Intellectual Shot” was a Blank

What is the reality of Reston’s report and of “acupuncture anesthesia” in
general? The front-page article, “Now, About My Operation in Peking,” appeared
in the New York Times on July 26, 1971. Aside from the removal of Reston’s
appendix, the account is quite different from what is commonly believed. There
are only two passages pertaining to the anesthetic itself:

   …removed my appendix on July 17 after a normal injection of Xylocain and
   Benzocain, which anesthetized the middle of my body.

   …and then pumped the area anesthetic by needle into my back.

Thus the anesthetic was a standard regional technique, most likely an
“epidural.” There is only one passage that pertains to the treatment of Mr.
Reston’s post-operative incisional pain:

   I was back in my room…by 11 [PM]. The doctors came by to reassure me…gave me 
   an injection to relieve the pain…

In other words, he got a standard injection of narcotic. This may have been
repeated, but he didn’t report this. Only during the following night, more than 
24 hours after the operation, did Mr. Reston have his brief encounter with qi:

   I was in considerable discomfort if not pain during the second night after
   the operation, and Li Chang-yuan, doctor of acupuncture at the hospital, with
   my approval, inserted three long, thin needles into the outer part of my
   right elbow and below my knees and manipulated them in order to stimulate
   them and relieve the pressure and distention of the stomach.

   That sent ripples of pain racing through my limbs and, at least, had the
   effect of diverting my attention from the distress in my stomach. Meanwhile, 
   Dr. Li lit two pieces of an herb called ai, which looked like the burning
   stumps of a broken cheap cigar, and held them close to my abdomen while
   occasionally twirling the needles into action.

   All this took about 20 minutes, during which I remember thinking that it was 
   rather a complicated way to get rid of gas on the stomach, but there was a
   noticeable relaxation of the pressure distension within an hour and no
   recurrence of the problem thereafter.

So, at a time when his incisional pain was waning, Mr. Reston experienced a
“discomfort.” Not “pain,” not “severe,” not even “cramping”–descriptions that
are common in others’ accounts of the event, offering only the Times article as 
a reference. The discomfort passed within an hour, during the first 20 minutes
of which Reston was needled and subjected to “moxibustion.” We can’t be certain 
of the cause of the discomfort, but bowel distention is a reasonable guess, and 
is consistent with its timing after the appendectomy. If this had been the case,
it would be surprising only if the discomfort had not been transient. There is 
no need to invoke acupuncture in its resolution, other than Reston’s reasonable 
suggestion that the pain from the needles was, at first, a distraction.

Actual Accounts of Acupuncture Anesthesia

Wide-eyed Westerners have offered several extraordinary accounts of acupuncture 
anesthesia. Dr. Eisenberg, in his book Encounters with Qi, reported having
observed a brain operation performed with acupuncture and moderate sedation, and
two thyroidectomies performed with acupuncture alone. He wrote that the Chinese
had explained to him that the first open-chest operation with acupuncture had
been performed in Liuzhou in 1957. He wrote that abdominal and chest surgeries
had originally required several acupuncturists and more than 100 needles, but
that over a period of a few years the number of needles was markedly reduced,
sometimes to only one. He reported that according to Chinese sources,
“acupuncture failed to give adequate pain relief in 20 to 30 percent of all
abdominal, gynecological, or chest surgery.”

Typical of accounts by westerners, shortly after Nixon made his rapprochement
with China, was this one by E. Grey Dimond, published in JAMA in 1971:

   This patient was a 40 year-old man with a large non-toxic adenoma of the
   thyroid. On the night before surgery he had received at bedtime 400 mg of
   meprobamate (Miltown). There were no preoperative medications. The patient
   walked into the operating room, took off his pajama top, retaining the pants,
   and stretched out on the operating table. One stainless steel acupuncture
   needle was inserted in the extensor aspect of each forearm, at a point
   approximately 4 inches proximal to the wrist, at a depth of 1 to 11/4 inches,
   between the radius and ulna. This point was carefully selected and
   identified as the most effective for anesthesia in thyroid surgery. A small
   clip was attached to the shaft of each needle and then connection made to a
   direct current battery power unit delivering 9 volts at 105 cycles per
   minute. Details of the wave form, current, or circuitry could not be supplied
   by the anesthetist. An intravenous drip of 5% dextrose was begun and to it
   was added 50 mg of meperidine hydrochloride (Demerol). Typing and
   crossmatching had been done. During a 20-minute “induction” period surgical
   preparation and draping were done. No other anesthetic agent was added. The
   patient remained fully conscious and normally alert. He advised me, through
   the interpreter, that he was noting numbness and tingling of both hands; no
   motor change occurred. After 20 minutes surgery began and a skillful team
   moved rapidly through the operating procedure. At one point the patient took 
   a sip of water. A large adenoma, approximately 2 cm by 3 cm in size, was
   removed and the wound closed. The patient sat up, had a full glass of milk,
   held up his little red book, and said in a firm voice: “Long live Chairman
   Mao and welcome American doctors.” He then put on his pajama top, stepped to 
   the floor, and walked out of the operating room.

Isidore Rosenfeld, the grandfatherly cardiologist and health editor of Parade
magazine, reported having observed an open-heart operation in China in the
1970s. Several other American physicians accompanied him. The patient was a
28-year-old woman. According to Dr. Rosenfeld, who took a photograph of the
patient during surgery, her only anesthetic had been a single acupuncture needle
in the right ear, connected to an electrical source. Dr. Rosenfeld reported
that she underwent repair of her mitral valve through a midline sternal (breast 
bone) incision and remained awake throughout the procedure. He also wrote that
the patient had “no intravenous needle in her arm.”

Skeptic Gary Posner, an internist, read Rosenfeld’s account in the August 16,
1998 issue of Parade and immediately recognized a problem in physiology: even if
the patient had experienced no pain whatsoever, Star Trek style, she wouldn’t
have been able to breathe after her chest was opened because of an inability to 
generate negative intrathoracic pressure. This phenomenon, known as “flail
chest,” would also have been a problem for the 1957 Liuzhou patient reported by 
Eisenberg.

Posner and our fellow blogger Wally Sampson, the editor of the Scientific Review
of Alternative Medicine, offered a plausible explanation. Their examination of 
Rosenfeld’s photograph suggested that the operation was not open-heart surgery, 
but a “closed” mitral valve commissurotomy through a small subcostal (below a
rib) incision. This would have allowed the patient to breathe spontaneously,
while also requiring minimal analgesia.

But doesn’t acupuncture offer some analgesic or anesthetic effect that can’t be 
explained by ordinary phenomena? One of the first accounts to cast doubt on that
assertion, and still the most rational early Western assessment of “acupuncture
anesthesia,” was that of cardiac surgeon Michael DeBakey in The Reader’s Digest
of September, 1973. After witnessing actual open-heart surgery in Shanghai on a
21 year-old boy who “apparently had been anesthetized with acupuncture
needles,” DeBakey wrote that he was

   as doubtful of [acupuncture’s] importance to medicine today as I was before I
   visited China. It is understandable that many observers have been startled
   by what they have seen of acupuncture. The sight of a fully conscious
   “needled” patient submitting to a surgeon’s knife without flinching is
   awe-inspiring. But, to a trained surgeon, the procedure is not so
   astonishing.

Dr. DeBakey explained that prior to the operation the patient was drowsy, having
been given phenobarbital and morphine. Several acupuncture needles were then
inserted in various places and connected to an electrical source, which caused
the patient’s muscles to twitch. The next step was more revealing:

   But before the surgeon reached for his scalpel, he injected a local
   anesthetic into the skin and tissues about the young man’s breastbone. Other 
   members of the surgical team said later that such locals were often used,
   because otherwise patients felt the pain of the first surgical incision in
   their skin. This was the only time I saw a local used before the initial
   incision. If it was used in every operation, there would be no mystery to
   acupuncture at all—it would be virtually identical to operations that we
   performed routinely many years ago using only local anesthetics.

Although DeBakey didn’t make this point specifically, the infiltration of local 
anesthetic explained not only the patient’s insensitivity to the skin incision, 
but also to the splitting of the sternum: the description suggests that the
surgeon anesthetized the intercostal nerves, which would have served to block
all sternal sensation.

DeBakey’s account also provides an alternative explanation for the problem of
“flail” chest in an awake, spontaneously breathing patient undergoing open-chest
surgery: in this case the patient had cardiopulmonary bypass accomplished via
the “fem-fem” route. If this had begun prior to the chest being opened, it would
have provided adequate gas exchange for the patient even in the absence of
spontaneous ventilation. Although DeBakey reported that the patient “actually
talked occasionally to the anesthetist while the heart was stopped,” the ability
to make small tidal volumes—enough to make soft utterances, but not to sustain 
adequate ventilation—would not be surprising in this circumstance.

DeBakey also reported other facts of “acupuncture anesthesia” that were later
confirmed by others. Not only were most patients who underwent acupuncture for
surgery given sedatives, narcotics, and local anesthetics, but they were a
carefully selected group who “met very strict criteria.” DeBakey’s hosts told
him that “most people can’t take it” and that those even willing to try ranged
from only 7 to 30 percent of the population, depending on the location. These
percentages are remarkable in light of the intense political and cultural
pressure to showcase traditional Chinese medicine that existed at that time, as 
will be discussed in Part II of this series.

This was Nothing New

As surprising as it may sound to the modern ear, it had been known for centuries
that a small percentage of people can undergo surgery or other typically
painful procedures, such as tooth extractions, with minimal or no apparent pain.
Melvin Gravitz, writing about hypnosis or ’Mesmerism,’ cited numerous such
examples from the 19th and 20th centuries. Petr Skrabanek, writing in Stalker
and Glymour’s Examining Holistic Medicine, cited others that were strikingly
similar to the case reported above by Dimond:

   Formal hypnosis, however, is not necessary. Parker operated on many patients 
   in China without any anesthesia (or acupuncture) and was astonished by their 
   apparent insensibility to pain. In 1843, he performed a mastectomy on a
   patient, who, when the operation was over, “raised herself from the table
   without assistance, jumped on the floor and made her bow to the gentlemen
   present, in the Chinese style, and walked into another room as though nothing
   had occurred.” Similar observations were made by other Western surgeons in
   China, such as Lockhart, McPherson, and others. “The manner in which they
   bear the pain of an operation is perfectly astounding,” wrote Gordon in 1863,
   “a large proportion of those upon whom operations were performed had no
   chloroform…some did not even clench their hands or teeth, but lay upon the
   table perfectly motionless, while their muscles were being cut by the knife
   and their bones divided by the saw.”

     “Acupuncture Anesthesia”'  A Proclamation from Chairman Mao (Part II)

                                 Kimball Atwood

                                      Link

An Anesthesiologist’s Perspective

The late John Bonica (1917-1994), one of the great anesthesiologists of the 20th
century, has been called “The Founding Father of the Pain Field.” He developed 
this interest while treating wounded soldiers at Fort Lewis, Washington, during 
WW II. Shortly thereafter he became a pioneer of epidural analgesia and other
forms of safe pain relief for labor and delivery. In 1947 he created the first
multidisciplinary pain clinic, at Tacoma General Hospital, and in 1960 brought
it to the University of Washington School of Medicine when he became the founder
and first chairman of its Department of Anesthesiology. In 1953 he published
the first comprehensive textbook on the subject of pain, the 1500 page
Management of Pain. In 1973 he founded what is now the largest professional
organization devoted to pain relief, the International Association for the Study
of Pain (IASP).

Dr. Bonica was born in Italy. He came to New York City with his family when he
was 11. His father died four years later and he became the major breadwinner for
the family. He competed in wrestling while in high school and won both the New 
York City and state championships. Later he worked his way through college and
medical school by wrestling professionally under the pseudonym ‘Johnny (Bull)
Walker’, and according to several sources he was the “Light Heavyweight
Wrestling Champion of the World.” He continued to wrestle while in the army but 
concealed his military identity by becoming, in the ring, the “Masked Marvel.”

At the time of the burgeoning Western interest in acupuncture in the early
1970s, Dr. Bonica became the Chairman of the Ad Hoc Committee on Acupuncture of 
the National Institutes of Health (NIH). In 1973 he was “selected by the
Committee on Scholarly Communication with the People’s Republic of China of the 
National Academy of Sciences to be a member of the first official American
medical delegation to visit the People’s Republic of China, and was given the
responsibility of evaluating acupuncture and anesthesia as practiced in that
country.”

The delegation spent three weeks in China beginning on June 15, 1973. Dr. Bonica
subsequently reported his findings in three articles: “Anesthesiology in the
People’s Republic of China” (Anesthesiology. 1974 Feb;40(2):175-86);
“Therapeutic acupuncture in the People’s Republic of China; Implications for
American medicine” (JAMA. 1974 Jun 17;228(12):1544-51); and “Acupuncture
anesthesia in the People’s Republic of China; Implications for American
medicine” (JAMA. 1974 Sep 2;229(10):1317-25). Of these, the Anesthesiology
article is available online and is well worth reading.

I’ll provide generous excerpts (emphases added). First, more evidence that James
Reston had an epidural anesthetic for his appendectomy:

   Data provided me suggest that continuous epidural block is used more often
   than all of the other techniques combined. Virtually all abdominal
   operations, including gastrectomies and cholecystectomies, are done with
   segmental (T5-T12) continuous epidural block…

Next:

   Acupuncture Anesthesia

   In contrast to its use for therapy of disorders, acupuncture anesthesia is a 
   new development, first used in Sian in 1958…The first operations done were
   tonsillectomies, changing of burn dressings, and other simple procedures. The
   initial report created a great deal of excitement and interest because this 
   was an exclusively Chinese discovery, unrelated to Western medicine which
   still had the taint of Western imperialism. Anesthesiologists began to
   attempt the technique, but it did not become as widely used as expected. In
   fact, during the early 1960s its use was abandoned in some (many?) hospitals.
   During the six years preceding the Cultural Revolution, only one article was
   published in major medical journals. From the guarded comments made by
   several anesthesiologists, I concluded that this disuse was the result of
   disappointing failures in a significant proportion of patients. During the
   Cultural Revolution this “negative” trend of not using acupuncture was
   considered the work of revisionists, and subsequently greater emphasis was
   given to the widespread use of acupuncture in all hospitals.

   The reports of previous American visitors to The People’s Republic of China
   have given the American medical community and public the impression that
   acupuncture anesthesia is being used widely there for many, if not most,
   operations, but I found this not to be the case. From data given to me by
   anesthesiologists and surgeons in hospitals we visited, I estimate that
   acupuncture anesthesia is being used in 5 per cent or less of the operations 
   done in three commune hospitals, 10 per cent or less of the cases in four
   hospitals, and in 10-15 per cent of the rest [with one exception]. No
   accurate statistics on the total number of acupuncture anesthesias are
   available, but according to some newspaper accounts, it has been used for
   400,000 to 600,000 operations since it was introduced 15 years ago. Assuming 
   that most of these…were done since the onset of the Cultural Revolution in
   1966 (when its use was markedly increased), even the higher figure accounts
   for a little more than 1 per cent of the operations done during this
   seven-year period.

   Among the physicians with whom I spoke, there was unanimity of opinion
   regarding the indications, advantages, disadvantages, and limitations of
   acupuncture anesthesia, which were cited with so much sameness that one is
   tempted to believe these have been made national policy. Advantages claimed
   include complete safety with no physiologic disturbance to the patient,
   [etc.]…However, when I pressed some of these issues, some of the
   anesthesiologists did admit that in most instances it is better to use
   chemical anesthesia, especially in intrathoracic operations…

   Selection and Preparation of Patients

   In response to repeated questions about criteria used for selection of
   patients for acupuncture anesthesia, the answers were vague and varied…The
   decision to use this method is usually made by the surgeon, who tells the
   patient that he or she is a good candidate for acupuncture. Although the
   patient is said to have a choice, I gained the impression that by the time
   the surgeon finishes his discussion it is difficult for a patient to refuse
   acupuncture. The surgeon emphasizes that: 1) this is a new Chinese invention 
   which resulted from the great teachings of Chairman Mao; 2) it does not harm 
   the body, whereas chemical anesthesia has serious toxic effects. All
   respondents emphasized the importance of avoiding acupuncture in nervous,
   apprehensive, or anxious patients because these usually fail to achieve good 
   results. It is also important that the patient be in good physical condition,
   without serious systemic disease and with no adhesions or other
   complications in the area of operation. Patients who undergo intrathoracic
   operation are admitted to the hospital several days prior to surgery to
   practice abdominal breathing under the instruction and supervision of
   therapists. The Chinese believe this is essential to prevent the usual
   disturbances of surgical pneumothorax…

   The anesthesiologist usually sees the patient the day before the operation
   and re-emphasizes the advantages of acupuncture anesthesia, as well as the
   disadvantages and side-effects and complications of chemical anesthesia…The
   patient is also informed of the sensation he will feel with the surgical
   incision (“a feeling of coldness across your neck”) and other surgical
   maneuvers, such as traction on the trachea and neck muscles during
   thyroidectomy, or feeling of traction or heaviness within the abdomen or
   chest. Patients who are to undergo thoracotomy are told that they will
   probably experience shortness of breath, a feeling of heaviness, or inability
   to breathe—all of which are important signs to breathe with the diaphragm as
   previously instructed…

   Techniques

   Initially, acupuncture anesthesia was achieved with numerous needles (as many
   as 50-90) inserted into traditional acupuncture points in the four
   extremities, face, and trunk by four to six acupuncturists. With development 
   of this technique, this was gradually reduced to three to five needles; in
   some cases only one needle is used. Some still use manual twirling, but but
   most operators us electrical stimulation…In a demonstration I requested of
   one colleague, the insertion of the needle through the skin of my forearm was
   painless, but the location of acupuncture point and the needle twirling were
   uncomfortable. The anesthesiologist locates the acupuncture point by a
   feeling of “heaviness and vibration.” Induction of analgesia usually consumes
   15-20 minutes, but at times it takes longer. After the feeling of local
   soreness and destention, the patient develops a sense of numbness, but no
   demonstrable area of analgesia to pin prick or other sensory stimulation… An 
   intravenous narcotic is often given at the beginning of the operation. In
   addition, surgeons often inject 1-2 per cent procaine into the thoracotomy
   incision and hilum of the lung and into the parietal peritoneum just prior to
   laparotomy.

   Personal Observations

   I personally observed 15 patients undergoing operations with acupuncture
   anesthesia alone, including four patients undergoing thyroidectomy; three,
   lobectomy; one, mediastinal tumor; two, partial gastrectomies; one,
   hysterectomy; one, renal operation; one, operation in the lower limb; two,
   tooth extraction with acupressure. Of these 15 patients, two showed obvious
   facial expressions, shivering, and other signs of pain during incision of the
   skin, but on questioning denied having felt discomfort. About a third of the
   patients developed significant changes in heart rate and blood pressure,
   flushing of the face, muscle tension, and other signs of reflex responses to 
   noxious stimulation. All six patients who underwent thoracotomy manifested
   signs and complained of symptoms of serious ventilatory and circulatory
   alterations, such as dyspnea, hypoxia, and paradoxical breathing (despite
   repeated instructions to the patient to breathe abdominally).

In his JAMA article, Bonica was more blunt:

   In the event the patient experiences discomfort, he is encouraged to breathe 
   as instructed, is continuously supported, and is asked to mobilize positive
   mental activities, such as thinking of Chairman Mao’s teachings. Patients
   undergoing thoracotomy who develop severe dyspnea (shortness of breath) are
   often given oxygen under positive pressure with a mask. In some instances,
   tracheal intubation is done. Patients experiencing severe pain are given
   additional doses of narcotics and sedatives. General anesthesia is reserved
   for those situations in which the acupuncture fails and the operation cannot 
   otherwise be continued.

   Efficacy

   Most reports made by the Chinese claim that acupuncture anesthesia is
   effective in about 90% of patients—a figure that has been accepted and
   reported by most other visitors to China. However, my own observation and
   analysis of data recently published by the Chinese suggest that this figure
   does not mean that the pain is eliminated and good surgical conditions are
   achieved…

In that article Dr. Bonica supplied two tables made from data provided to him by
the Chinese:

Table 1 shows the criteria used by the Shanghai group, who recently reported
that in more than 100 different types of operations done in more than 80,000
patients given acupuncture anesthesia, the overall success rate was between 81% 
and 96%.

   Grades 1, 2, and 3 were considered effective, and were combined to give the
   overall success rate of 94%. The data, particularly of those operations on
   the head, neck, and thorax, which are considered the most suitable for
   acupuncture, show that pain and reflex responses to noxious stimulation
   occurred in most of the patients and therefore must be considered as
   unsatisfactory when compared with successful regional or general anesthesia.

I agree with that assessment. The most generous conclusion is that only those
patients in “Grade 1″ could be considered ‘successes’. They constituted 30% of
an already tiny minority—1% of all surgical patients, according to Dr. Bonica;
“a carefully selected group who ‘met very strict criteria’,” according to Dr.
DeBakey. Such a conclusion also presumes that the data for “Grade 1″ patients
were legitimate.

More from Dr. Bonica’s Anesthesiology paper:

   There is great variation in the numbers of needles used and the sites of
   needling…I saw four thyroid operations being done with three different
   techniques of acupuncture.

   …

   Although every respondent claimed that the needles were inserted along
   traditional acupuncture points, in a number of cases I saw the needles were
   inserted not through classic acupuncture points but parallel or perpendicular
   to spinal nerves.

   …

   If acupuncture is in fact harmless, I wonder why it is not taught to surgeons
   and nurses who work in commune and district hospitals, which usually lack
   complicated anesthetic machines and trained personnel…

   Another paradox relevant to the above is that if the technique is harmless,
   why not use it in poor-risk patients, e.g., patients with poor pulmonary
   function…or those in poor physical condition because of complicating disease.

   …

   Research on Acupuncture Anesthesia

   I was disappointed to learn that there has been virtually no clinical
   research done on patients operated upon under acupuncture anesthesia. This is
   especially surprising in regard to intrathoracic operations, in view of the 
   fact that anesthesiologists and surgeons are fully appreciative of the
   problems of surgical pneumothorax and they do have the personnel and
   equipment capable of making appropriate measurements. I was informed that “a 
   few” studies of blood gases had been done in “a few” patients in Peking and
   Shanghai, showing a modest rise in PaCO2 and slight decrease in pH, but there
   are virtually no data on oxygen tension.

   In contrast, basic neurophysiologic research is being done to determine the
   mechanisms of acupuncture analgesia…

An Aside on Basic Research

I am gazing at some reports of this research, which I’ve had for many years. The
very first issue of the American Journal of Chinese Medicine , published in
January of 1973, included “Four Articles on Acupuncture Anesthesia,” each
emanating from a hospital in the PRC. I’ll not review these in detail, but a
couple of points are worth mentioning. First, these articles are unanimous in
asserting that the technique can be successful only if both acupuncturist and
patient experience Teh-Ch’i: the “feeling of ‘heaviness and vibration’ ” by the 
acupuncturist, and the “feeling[s] of local soreness and destention, [and] a
sense of numbness” by the patient—as reported by Dr. Bonica. Thus, according to 
this article:

   It has been mentioned in Chinese medicine that acupuncture therapy stresses
   Teh-Ch’i. Teh-Ch’i is a principle expressing the function of the meridians
   and anastomoses. It states that effective results occur only when the patient
   feels sore, swollen, heavy and numb sensations after needles have been
   inserted in the correct loci and when at the same time the physician feels
   that the needle has been lightly attached or sucked in by the flesh. The Nei 
   Ching reports the “Correct insertion can be effective only when it meets the 
   Ch’i.” This explains the importance of the Teh-Ch’i sensation accompanying
   needle insertion. If the physician does not continuously twirl the needle
   after its insertion and merely leaves it in situ, then after a certain length
   of time the feelings of soreness, swelling, heaviness and numbness of
   Teh-Ch’i will soon gradually weaken in the patient until they disappear.

Similarly, from this article:

   The most important technique of acupuncture anesthesia is to make the patient
   Teh-Ch’i. [sic] If there is no such feeling from the needle, even the
   application of many needles with prolonged twirling will be of no avail.

Teh-Ch’i is also rendered ‘de Qi‘ and sometimes described as “needle grabbing.” 
I have experienced the patient’s version of it twice—during episodes of acute,
severe back pain when I subjected myself to acupuncture to see if it might
pleasantly surprise me (it did not). My take on my own de Qi is straightforward:
it was reflex muscle spasm triggered by needling. It seems to me that this is a
hypothesis that could be investigated fairly easily, as could de Qi’s effect on
the needle itself (perhaps it has been). It might be interesting to compare
subjective impressions and measurable effects of needles inserted into muscles, 
as in my case, to those of needles inserted elsewhere.

The articles in the Am J Chin Med also suggested, contrary to the “meridians and
anastomoses” statement quoted above, that nerves have more to do with how
acupuncture anesthesia ‘works’ than do traditional notions of acupuncture points
and meridians, thus explaining one of Dr. Bonica’s observations. According to
this article:

   …when comparative study is made between the positions of the loci on the
   meridians and anastomoses and the distributions of nerves, half of the loci
   are found to be scattered on the nerve trunks, while the rest lie near the
   nerve trunks. Thus, we think it to be more precise to use the nervous system 
   in explaining the principles of acupuncture anesthesia and analgesia.

And in this article:

   …we observed that the nearer the selected points for stimulation were to the 
   nerves of the operating location, the better the anesthetic effect.

One article, however, asserted that although the nervous system and the “theory 
of Ching-Lo” (‘meridians and anastomoses’ which “connect the hollow and solid
organs of the body and various locations on the surface of the body”) are
closely related, they are not entirely so:

   …the theory of Ching-Lo can at least partly explain the nerve effect in
   reflecting rules of control…

   However, some of the rules and relationships of the different locations of
   the human body covered by the theory of Ching-Lo cannot be explained by
   current knowledge of neural anatomy and physiology. For example, according to
   the theory of Ching-Lo the locus Kuang-Ming (Bright Light) on the lower leg 
   is a principle [sic] locus for treating eye diseases. We obtained good
   effects using this locus to produce acupuncture anesthesia for eye
   operations. But, how can stimulation at Kuang-Ming affect the eye region and 
   what relationship exists between these two locations? It is very difficult to
   explain these phenomena with our knowledge of modern neuroanatomy and
   neurophysiology.

One of the articles made another point that is nearly ubiquitous in contemporary
discussions of acupuncture anesthesia:

   Besides material considerations in acupuncture anesthesia, the emotional
   situation of the patient also influences the analgesic effect of acupuncture 
   anesthesia. If the patient has an accurate understanding of and confidence in
   acupuncture anesthesia, the inhibitive action of acupuncture is promoted and
   its effect is better. If a patient’s state of mind is tense, and if he has a
   doubtful attitude toward acupuncture anesthesia, the cerebral cortex is
   strongly excited and hence cannot be inhibited by the action of acupuncture. 
   On the contrary, the patient may easily receive pain impulses from the
   operating region.

Other investigators, both in China and elsewhere, have performed basic research,
including with animals, regarding acupuncture’s apparent analgesic properties. 
Most reviews make much of endorphins being stimulated by needling, particularly 
if electrified, but this is not necessarily specific to such needling and is
hardly ‘acupuncture’ per se. Some investigators, such as JiSheng Han in China
and George Ulett in St. Louis, have been quite convinced that the analgesic
properties are real, even if they have nothing to do with pre-scientific Chinese
medical ‘theory.’ This is not so different from other techniques, involving
electrical stimulation of peripheral nerves, that have been investigated for the
treatment of painful syndromes but that have shown modest effectiveness at
best.

The topic apparently remains an active area of investigation. A recent review
concluded:

   After 30 years of acupuncture research, there are still many puzzles left to 
   be solved regarding the mechanism of AA.

Is Acupuncture Anesthesia Real?

My own view differs from even that of rational authors who, I worry, have failed
to see the forest for the trees: there is NO acupuncture anesthesia or
analgesia—at least not to an extent that is either humane or clinically useful
for surgery. Even Dr. Bonica, after offering numerous hints of this truth, was
unwilling to dismiss the method altogether. Perhaps this reflected his
scrupulous politeness or studied diplomacy, for in the JAMA article he continued
to hint at the reality when he concluded:

   These comments are intended to place the procedure in perspective and not to 
   distract in any way from this very important Chinese achievement. The fact
   that acupuncture analgesia permits the completion of surgical operations in
   some patients is an important gain in a country that has a severe shortage of
   anesthetic personnel. The Chinese are more successful with the procedure
   than are others for a variety of reasons, including intense preoperative
   counseling and preparation, their admirable ability to tolerate moderate to
   severe pain, the intense motivation provoked in the patient and surgical team
   by the necessity created by shortage of anesthetic personnel and by
   political and ideological factors, and the skill, gentleness, and dexterity
   of Chinese surgeons and their willingness to accept less than optimal
   operating conditions.

Dr. Bonica knew, obviously, that even a severe shortage of anesthesia personnel 
could not explain an inadequate technique used in only 1% of cases. I’d be
interested to learn of Dr. Bonica’s private views of acupuncture anesthesia, and
I imagine that there are, among his surviving colleagues and family, those who 
can tell us.

I agree with Wally Sampson, Petr Skrabanek and others that apparent analgesic
effects of acupuncture are most economically explained by counter-irritation and
non-specific ‘placebo’ effects, including expectation and ‘hypnosis’-like
states (whatever those may be). I also think that some of the apparent effects
in ‘acupuncture anesthesia’ demonstrations had to do with the patients being
highly motivated to appear comfortable. I agree with Dr. DeBakey that the
addition of sedatives, narcotics, and local anesthetics made ‘acupuncture
anesthesia’ irrelevant in many of the operations in which it appeared to be
successful.

The 20-minute “induction” periods described in ‘acupuncture anesthesia’ case
reports suggest a phenomenon of partial “extinction” (increasing tolerance),
over time, to the pain of the needling itself. This may be real, in a biological
sense, and could have manifestations in other parts of the body—as would occur 
with the secretion of endogenous molecules that have opiate-like effects, for
example. Nevertheless, even if real I view it as a wash at best: it occurs in
response to a stimulus which is sufficiently noxious to elicit it. If it
subsequently dulls, to some small extent, the painful shock of a surgical
incision, how would that be a net benefit?

The endorphin hypothesis is problematic in other ways, as reviewed by Skrabanek 
in Examining Holistic Medicine and by Beyerstein and Sampson here. While in
Bejing discussing research with the aforementioned Dr. Han, Drs. Beyerstein and 
Sampson

   …wondered if he would agree, as we had read, that a number of other, less
   invasive stimuli can also raise endorphin levels in the central nervous
   system. We asked if it were not true, as Dr. Victor Herbert had shown, that
   any irritative stimulus, such as a pinch, might produce a similar rise in
   endorphin levels (this is conceded by many acupuncturists who use
   “acupressure” where the skin points are simply massaged rather than needled).
   He replied that yes, that is so, but acupuncture does not hurt as much as a 
   pinch.

   …

   In a personal communication, Herbert presented the following account of a
   demonstration of animal acupuncture he had observed in China. The
   experimenter inserted needles into the animal subject and took a blood sample
   that showed a rise in endorphin levels. Herbert asked if he could try
   pinching the skin to see if it would have a similar effect on endorphin
   levels to that of the needles. It did.

When we consider, finally, that patients were selected according to “very strict
criteria” and were under extreme pressure, during the Cultural Revolution, to
please their physicians and other authority figures, it becomes unnecessary to
invoke any special analgesic powers of acupuncture. Skrabanek was particularly
cynical:

   The Chinese inventors of acupuncture anesthesia used initially more than 50
   needles, but the number gradually dropped to one or two. Would the same
   effect be achieved with no needles whatsoever? Those who dared ask such
   awkward questions were branded as “counter-revolutionary revisionists.”

Rather than being an important Chinese achievement, was ‘acupuncture anesthesia’
more a form of torture perpetrated by a totalitarian government on its own
citizens, with the forced complicity of physicians? It is that issue—the
relation of ‘acupuncture anesthesia’ to Chinese politics—that we will consider
in Part III.

      “Acupuncture Anesthesia” a Proclamation from Chairman Mao (Part III)

                                 Kimball Atwood

                                      Link

A Digression: The Politics of Chinese Medicine in the People’s Republic of China
(The Early Years)

***

A Partial Book Review: Chinese Medicine in Early Communist China, 1945-63: a
Medicine of Revolution, by Kim Taylor

   Mao’s was a complex personality. He was by nature a control freak, highly
   secretive, quickly suspicious, ruthless in revenge. These were all personal 
   characteristics that were to determine the flow of politics in early
   Communist China. (Taylor, p. 4)

We have already seen that attempts to create ‘acupuncture anesthesia’ began in
the People’s Republic of China (PRC) in 1958. As suggested by the title of this 
series, this resulted from neither rigorous research nor the serendipity that
occasionally heralds important discoveries. Rather, the apparent prominence of
acupuncture in health care in the PRC was a matter of governmental fiat. Even
before the Communist victory in 1949, it was clear to Chairman Mao Zedong that
there were not enough ‘Western’ trained physicians to handle the massive health 
problems of the country, which included an infant mortality rate of 1 in 5, an
overall death rate of 30 per 1000 per year, and widespread disability. Most of
this was due to malnutrition and infectious diseases, including many that sound 
exotic and ominous to the modern ear:

   …schistosomiasis, filariasis, ancyclostomiasis, Kala-azar, encephalitis, 
   plague, malaria, smallpox and venereal disease…measles, dysentery, typhoid,
   diphtheria, trachoma, tuberculosis, leprosy, goitre, Kaschin-Beck’s
   disease…(Taylor, p. 103)

Pre-scientific Chinese medicine, acupuncture in particular, was identified by
Mao and other Communist leaders as worthy of cultivating:

   Our nation’s health work teams are large. They have to concern themselves
   with over five hundred million people [including the] young, old, and ill.
   This is a huge enterprise, and one that is extremely important. Thus our
   responsibility weighs heavily…At present, doctors of Western medicine are few
   [10,000-20,000], and [thus] the broad masses of the people, and in
   particular the peasants, rely on Chinese medicine to treat illness.
   Therefore, we must strive for the complete unification of Chinese medicine.
   –Mao Zedong, 1950, quoted in Taylor (p. 33)

Taylor writes that there may have been 500,000 doctors of ‘Chinese Medicine’ at 
the time. It is tempting to conclude that Mao’s call for the ‘unification of
Chinese medicine’ was a cynical way to make it appear that the Chinese Communist
Party (CCP) could provide adequate health care in a much shorter time than
would be required to train sufficient numbers of modern physicians and to build 
and equip modern facilities. This is undoubtedly true, but Taylor argues that
there were additional considerations:

   …Mao evidently saw the profession of Chinese medicine not so much as a
   therapeutic practice, but more as a large, and therefore significant, body of
   people. Mao’s support of Chinese medicine during this time can be linked to 
   a concern for adequate health care manpower, and by extrapolation, to a
   concern for social stability. If the Chinese medical practitioners were
   ignored and not forcibly, as it were, integrated into the new Communist
   society, and if their medicine was not encouraged, it would mean hundreds of 
   thousands of people would be without a livelihood. Including their
   dependents, this would mean that there would be hundreds of thousands of
   people without any means of support. It is likely that Mao interpreted the
   more serious problem to be one of economics, and the importance of keeping
   people usefully employed within society, rather than the dangers of
   supporting a potentially ineffective medicine. (Taylor, p. 35)

Mao also wrote:

   Although we should have an all-round and correct understanding of Chinese
   medicine, Chinese medicine also has to transform itself. We must accept this
   slice of our old heritage critically. To look down upon Chinese medicine is 
   not correct. To claim that everything about Chinese medicine is good, or too 
   good, this is also not correct. Chinese and Western medicines must unite.
   (Mao Zedung, 1954, quoted in Taylor, p. 35)

Thus there was, according to Taylor, to be a ‘scientification’ of Chinese
medicine. This did not mean ‘scientific’ in the familiar sense:

   In Mao’s definition of this ‘new democratic culture’, he was to use three
   words which were to describe its development. These were ‘new’ (xin),
   ‘science’ (kexue), and ‘unity’ (tuanjie). The term ‘new’ implied free from
   superstition and the heavy links to a feudal past. Instead the components of 
   the new culture would have to be forward moving and enterprising. Mao
   advocated that such a change would be possible through the use of ‘science’. 
   By ‘science’ Mao was not so much referring to the science linked with the
   Western investigation of nature, but more to the Marxist ideal of science as 
   the criteria for true knowledge. For Mao stated that ‘this type of new
   democratic culture is scientific. It is opposed to all feudal and
   superstitious ideas; it stands for seeking truth from facts, it stands for
   objective truth and for unity between theory and practice’. ‘Unity’ was the
   third criterion in the building up of a new China. Everybody had to join
   together and fight for the same cause, and this included all classes of
   Chinese society, from the upper bourgeoisie to the peasantry, so long as
   their beliefs were not against those of the Party. It also implied a unity of
   knowledge, and this had particular implications for the revolutionary
   intellectual. (Taylor, pp. 15-16)

In other words, as Mao later asserted,

   In the future there will be only one medicine; that is to say a [single] 
   medicine guided by the laws of dialectical materialism, and not two
   [separate] medicines. (Quoted in Taylor, p. 35)

The ‘New Acupuncture’: Simplified and ‘Scientified’

Taylor gives several examples of the sort of ‘science’ that was applied to
acupuncture in the early years of the PRC. Zhu Lian, a Western-trained
physician, wrote a book on The New Acupuncture, published in 1949. It was filled
with military and administrative metaphors, as befitted the book’s conception
during the civil war. According to Taylor,

   This tendency illustrates the way in which the perception of the body and
   the language used to describe it will reflect prevailing ontological
   concepts of a society. Shifts in these philosophical orientations will lead
   to shifts in the explanation of health and disease, and accordingly the
   medicine is reshaped to suit the values and customs of the new society.
   (Taylor, p. 20)

I agree with that assertion when it is applied to pre-scientific views of health
and disease. Previous treatises on Chinese medicine were also filled with
administrative and military metaphors, as well as meteorogical ones (‘wind’,
‘dampness’, ‘heat’, ‘cold’). Ancient acupuncture treatises even included
correspondences between the number of days in a year and the number of
acupuncture ‘points’ on the body, and the relation of these to the four seasons.
See here (p. 130) for an example, ca. 200 C.E., of several of these metaphors
used to ‘explain’ acupuncture. I can’t tell, from reading Taylor’s book, if she 
appreciates the difference between this and the reality of scientific medicine: 
in the latter case, some of the language may consist of metaphors referable to
social structures and familiar events, but the science, i.e., the “perception of
the body,” is not “[shaped] to suit the values and customs of the…society.”
Rather, the science precedes any such metaphorical descriptions.

For Zhu Lian, however, as for her ancient predecessors, social metaphors
preceded ‘science’:

   Zhu Lian’s form of the ‘new acupuncture’ had in many ways been an attempt
   at reducing acupuncture to a few basic principles in order to facilitate its
   application. She made significant inroads in simplifying the presentation of
   the layout of the acupuncture points on the body by dividing the body into
   ‘sections’ (bu), ‘divisions’ (qu), ‘lines’ (xian) and ‘stimulation points’
   (cijidian). The most period-relevant of these were the ‘divisions’ in which
   acupuncture points that could not conveniently be placed on a line were
   enclosed in a ‘division’, reminiscent of the army divisions and border
   regions of wartime China. (Taylor, p. 49)

During the early 1950s others continued these sorts of revisions, in some cases 
to the point of absurdity:

   Such a structural layout continued to characterize the ‘new acupuncture’ 
   after Liberation, but where Zhu Lian had been responding to the military
   influences of her time, other physicians now responded to the bureaucratic,
   systematic outlook of the period of reform in China. The result, in some
   cases, was the portrayal of the body as a form of drawing chart. Ma Jixing in
   particular took pains to reduce the body to measurable terms, and described 
   the body and its functions, this time not in relation to war but rather with 
   the values of the mathematical art of quantity surveying. The result was a
   complete disembodying of the human figure, so much so that Ma Jixing did not 
   produce a single illustration of the human body. Rather, it was reduced to a 
   chart of measurable statistics, and it was through such a listing of
   well-defined criteria that he described the human body… (Taylor, pp. 49-50)

   His description of the body is pervaded with mathematical terms.
   Obviously it lent some status to the ‘new medicine’ but it is not exactly
   clear in what way, apart from the distinction given by maths [sic] as the
   purest form of natural science… (Taylor, p. 52)

From ‘Co-operation’ to ‘Integration’

Mao’s ‘unification’ edict was not merely pragmatic, but ideological. It has
persisted until this time, with Party slogans marking the different epochs in
its history:

   1945-50 ‘The Co-operation of Chinese and Western Medicines’

   1950-8 ‘The Unification of Chinese and Western Medicines’

   1950-53 ‘Chinese Medicine studies Western Medicine’

   1954-8 ‘Western Medicine studies Chinese Medicine’

   1958- ‘The Integration of Chinese and Western Medicines’

   (Taylor pp. 12-13)

In the early years of the PRC, doctors of Chinese medicine were recruited and
trained to help introduce modern public health measures to the enormous
population, particularly in the most underserved rural areas, but they were not 
expected to use their Chinese medical knowledge in this effort:

   Chinese medicine…was to be used at the least medical level of Western
   medicine–public health. Chinese medical practitioners were enlisted to give
   inoculations and to educate the peasants in basic hygiene. Their own skills
   in indigenous medicines were not required by the Ministry of Health in the
   face of these acute diseases. This would accord with general Western medical 
   prejudices. It is likely that the Ministry of Health, not convinced of the
   efficacy of Chinese medicine, but bound by official decree to include it
   within national health care projects, was determined not to give the Chinese 
   medical practitioner any healing autonomy of his/her own. (Taylor pp. 34-5)

Taylor argues that this led to Mao’s attack, in 1953, on the Ministry of Health.
Although his objections were several, one was this:

   The Central Committee’s directive concerning the unification of Chinese
   and Western medicine has not as yet been put into effect, and the genuine
   unification of Chinese and Western medicines had also not been realized. This
   is wrong. The problem definitely must be solved, and the error definitely
   must be corrected. First of all, every level of health administration must
   change its ideology. (Mao Zedong, Jan. 1954. Quoted in Taylor, p. 44)

Thus, according to Taylor,

   …Chinese medicine was used as a political tool during the excesses of the
   Anti-rightist Campaign and the Great Leap Forward, in order to correct the
   bourgeois thought of Western doctors of medicine. (Taylor, p. 109)

Mao’s Personal Physician Weighs In

Mao’s ‘complex, control freak’ personality is illustrated by his own, ambiguous 
view of Chinese medicine, which differed substantially from what was suggested
by his public persona. Another useful reference for those interested in Mao and 
the early years of the PRC is a memoir written by Mao’s personal physician, the 
Western-trained Li Zhisui: The Private Life of Chairman Mao. In 1955, during one
of Dr. Li’s “countless nocturnal chats” with Mao (who “had no friends”), was
this exchange:

   Mao attributed China’s large population to the efficacy of Chinese
   medicine. For thousands of years, he told me, China had gone through
   continual war and natural disaster. But our population now was more than 500 
   million. Was it because of Western medicine that we had this many people?
   Western medicine had been practiced in China for only one hundred years. For 
   thousands of years before, our people had depended on Chinese medicine. Why
   were there still people who dismissed Chinese medicine? The only Chinese
   books he had not yet read, he said, were those on Chinese medicine and
   Buddhism. He wondered if I had read books on Chinese medicine.

   My ancestors had been devoted to Chinese medicine, but my training had
   been Western and I had never given much thought to the contributions of
   traditional medicine. But I did not believe that China’s large population was
   the result of Chinese medicine. I told Mao that I had read some ancient
   Chinese medical books but could not really understand them, especially those 
   relating to the theory of the five elements–metal, wood, water, fire, and
   earth. I did not understand the theory.

   Mao laughed. ‘The theory of yin and yang and the five elements really is 
   very difficult,’ he said. ‘The theory is used by doctors of Chinese medicine 
   to explain the physiological and pathological conditions of the human body.
   What I believe is that Chinese and Western medicine should be integrated.
   Well-trained doctors of Western medicine should learn Chinese medicine;
   senior doctors of Chinese medicine should learn anatomy, physiology,
   bacteriology, pathology, and so on. They should learn how to use modern
   science to explain the principles of Chinese medicine. They should translate 
   some classical Chinese medicine books into modern language, with proper
   annotations and explanations. Then a new medical science, based on the
   integration of Chinese and Western medicine, can emerge. That would be a
   great contribution to the world.’

   He paused to reflect. ‘Even though I believe we should promote Chinese
   medicine, I personally do not believe in it. I don’t take Chinese medicine.
   Don’t you think that is strange?’

   I agreed that it was strange. Publicly, the Chairman was the leading
   advocate of traditional medicine, but he refused to use it himself.

The Modern Introduction of ‘Traditional Chinese Medicine’

It is tempting to quote voluminously from Kim Taylor’s book, which is a great
treasure-house of information about medicine and policy in the early years of
the PRC. I’ll limit this discussion to another key point, which will lead us
back to ‘acupuncture anesthesia’: The ‘Traditional Chinese Medicine’ (TCM) that 
has been fostered in the PRC is not traditional. The very adjective
‘Traditional’, in regard to Chinese medicine, was not formally used in China
until the mid-1950s, and even then was applied “exclusively in English language 
literature produced by the Chinese mainland press…” (Taylor, p. 86)

The term, moreover, heralded a ‘standardization’ of Chinese medicine for which
there was no historical precedent. In 1955, the Research Academy of Traditional 
Chinese Medicine opened its doors:

   The setting up of the Research Academy was declared to be ‘a pivotal
   measure in developing the medical legacy of the motherland, enriching medical
   science, uniting and improving Chinese and Western medicine’. The role of
   the Research Academy was to organize systematically Chinese medical and
   herbal knowledge, and to compile Chinese medical and herbal books. It would
   also serve to train teachers… In other words…Chinese medical knowledge could 
   be sculpted and moulded into a format more conducive to the teaching and
   practising of Chinese medicine in modern Chinese society, in preparation for 
   its ultimate union with Western medicine. (Taylor, p. 87)

Taylor quotes Lu Zhijun, a Western-trained colleague of Zhu Lian, speaking at
the opening ceremony of the Research Academy:

   ‘Every tiny result in the research into it [Chinese medicine] adds to the
   glory of our nation’s medical legacy. It increases [our] contribution to our
   nation’s people and to the whole of mankind. At the same time, it will
   further prove the mistakenness of those who look down upon and [want to]
   obliterate our nation’s medicine. [It will also] incite more people to come
   and correctly understand and take on the enterprise of our nation’s
   medicine’. (pp. 89-90)

(Veteran SBM readers will recognize, in that passage, a plausible basis for some
of the findings of this study).

In 1956, four Academies of TCM were created, and shortly thereafter standard
curricula and textbooks appeared. These were, necessarily and arbitrarily,
simplified distillations of myriad Chinese medicines that had existed in various
places and times for hundreds of years. This was done, in keeping with the
‘integration’ edict, to reconcile Chinese medicine with ‘Western’ notions of
analysis, and also to conform to ‘revolutionary’ ideology:

   The theories [of TCM] had to be, first and foremost, politically correct,
   and in this revolutionary society, all scientific investigation was to be
   guided by the Communist philosophy of dialectical materialism (bianzheng
   weiwu zhuyi). Dialectical materialism holds that change is the result of
   opposing forces, the resulting dynamic of which produces change. In terms of 
   medicine, this found an expression in a ‘new’ form of diagnosis…

   The streamlining of Chinese medicine according to Communist criteria was 
   to take place at every level of diagnosis…(Taylor, p. 148)

Egg on the Faces of Honkies

Taylor states that at least three books about ‘Traditional’ Chinese Medicine,
written by Westerners in the aftermath of James Reston’s acupuncture experience,
were based on PRC-generated textbooks–and were therefore less about traditional
Chinese medicine than they were about contemporary Chinese textbooks “created
as part of a revolutionary programme”: specifically, the program known as
‘Western medicine studies Chinese medicine’. (Taylor, pp. 144-147) Those books
by Westerners are this, this, and this.

It is interesting to compare the history discussed here, especially the comments
made above about PRC-promoted research in Chinese medicine, with this passage
on pp. 19-20 of one of the books published in the West:

   After the victory of the Chinese Revolution in 1949, the Chinese decided 
   to take a fresh look at their traditional medical system. Many of China’s new
   leaders were tempted to discard their prescientific medical inheritance,
   along with other old-fashioned practices and remnants of underdevelopment.
   Their overall desire was to emulate the developed countries–to industrialize,
   electrify, and modernize. Another faction of the leadership, however, saw
   that although China did need to accept modern medicine, there might also be
   some practical and theoretical usefulness in the traditional medicine. The
   issue was whether or not it would prove efficacious from a modern
   perspective. To answer that question, the Chinese performed thousands of
   experiments and clinical studies during the fifties. The result was that in
   1958 the Central Committee decided to give traditional and modern medicine
   equal respect and place in China.

   The medical reports are still produced incessantly…

   The pages of such studies fill entire libraries, yet it is not their
   quantity that is important, but rather their conclusions: that traditional
   Chinese medicine can hold its own, that it does work clinically.

   It is now evident that Chinese medicine is an effective healing method.

When that passage was published in 1983, its author perhaps could have been
forgiven for not having known the timeline of Mao’s advocacy of Chinese
medicine, and perhaps even for not having appreciated the intimate relation
between ideology and ‘science’ in TCM research. Such forgiveness no longer
applied to the 2nd edition of the book, published in 2000 with slight revisions 
(in bold):

   After the victory of the Chinese Revolution in 1949, the Chinese decided 
   to take a fresh look at their traditional medical system. Many of China’s new
   leaders were tempted to discard their prescientific medical inheritance,
   along with other old-fashioned practices and remnants of underdevelopment.
   Their overall desire was to emulate the developed countries–to industrialize,
   electrify, and modernize. Another faction of the leadership, however, saw
   that although China did need to accept modern medicine, there might also be
   some practical and theoretical usefulness in the traditional medicine. At
   least partially, the issue was whether or not it would prove efficacious from
   a modern perspective. To answer that question, the Chinese performed
   thousands of experiments and clinical studies during the 1950s. The result
   was that In 1958, for reasons that included scientific as well as cultural
   and economic concerns, the Central Committee decided to give traditional and 
   modern medicine equal respect and place in China.

   The medical reports, which are still used to support the official
   adoption of Chinese medicine, are still produced incessantly…

   The pages of such studies fill entire libraries, yet it is not their
   quantity that is important, but rather their conclusions: from the modern
   Chinese perspective, traditional Chinese medicine can hold its own; that it
   does work clinically.

   Even for thoroughly modernized Chinese, Chinese medicine has come to be
   accepted as an effective healing method.

‘Standardizing’ Chinese Medicine: a Dubious Proposition

If some Western authors have been duped by Communist ideology, others, more
scholarly, have asserted the impossibility of ‘standardizing’ Chinese medicine, 
both because it is such a large amount of disparate material and because there
is no basis for determining what might be valid and what is not:

   …the question arises as to what “Chinese medicine” should be transmitted 
   to the West. The practices and theoretical conceptions that in the political 
   climate of the People’s Republic of China have been chosen from the
   heterogeneous heritage as meaningful? The varied practice free of political
   influence, based on personal interpretation of traditional opinion and
   techniques among representatives of Chinese, for example, on Taiwan? The
   pragmatic approach that is widespread in Japan? Or any of the various Chinese
   approaches of the last two millennia? In trying to answer this question, one
   problem lies in the fact that there is no criterion for judging any one of
   these approaches in relation to another. They all have their effects.
   Practitioners of each of them can point to satisfied patients. Failure is of 
   course common to them all. (Unschuld, Paul. Chinese Medicine. pp. 118-9)

Taylor herself laments the project as a “petrifying of Chinese medical
knowledge” (p. 127) and worse:

   The reduction of its theories to a few easily identifiable syndromes,
   many of which have been designed to correlate with major Western disease
   categories, has greatly undermined the potential to plumb the considerable
   depths of TCM theory. Nowadays, in many cases, before the patient has even
   stepped into the clinic, his/her bianzheng lunzhi pattern has already been
   ascribed…The medicine is also taught in an increasingly formulaic manner.
   (Taylor, p. 149)

   In general, the main aim of these ‘Basic Theories of TCM’ was to simplify
   Chinese medicine and to reduce two thousand years of controversy and debate 
   into one easy-access nutshell. This compromises every level of the
   physician’s encounter with the patient, from examination to diagnosis through
   to prescription. (Taylor, p. 150)

It will not surprise the reader to learn that although I accept Taylor’s
assertion about the simplification of real Chinese medicine, I don’t share her
apparent conviction that this has resulted in a diminution of its power to
heal–which was never, I would argue, substantial in the first place.

Back to ‘Acupuncture Anesthesia’

As suggested above, there was also a mercantile flavor to the PRC’s
standardization project:

   The approach shifted from creating One, New Medicine, to exploiting the
   therapeutic assets of Chinese medicine, and having these work in conjunction 
   with Western medical science, to perform miracle cures. These ‘miracle
   cures’, such as acupuncture analgesia, were then loudly advertised abroad.
   (Taylor, p. 109)

   …it becomes obvious that TCM was being advertised to the West in
   foreign-language publications as a medicine capable of greater feats in
   science than the scientific medicine of the West. (Taylor, p. 137)

   One of the CCP’s biggest publicity generators for its modernized Chinese 
   medicine was acupuncture analgesia. (Taylor, p. 138)

Thus we’ve come back to the point of this series. Before leaving Taylor
altogether, let me quote from her conclusion:

   It is hoped that by this stage in the reading of this book, the reader
   will have formed a different impression of the nature of Chinese medicine
   than that with which he/she had perhaps started. The main impact which this
   book is hoped to have had is to dispel the notion that the availability of
   Chinese medicine in China and abroad was simply a matter of course. It was,
   rather, the product of an undetermined and piecemeal process which was more a
   careful manipulation of its value as a ‘cultural legacy’ with the particular
   political, social and economic circumstances of the early PRC, than any
   consideration of its actual therapeutic value. The fact that circumstances
   led the CCP to promote Chinese medicine during the 1950s accounts for its
   continuing presence in mainland China. (Taylor, p. 151)

   …

   However, as we enter into the twenty-first century, we are approaching a 
   stage where the original revolutionary criteria which legitimated Chinese
   medicine in CCP China begin to no longer apply. This declining political
   justification exposes the medicine as belonging to an outdated philosophy of 
   life. In modern Chinese society, in those areas of life where the use of
   Chinese medicine is optional, Chinese medicine appears to continue to
   function on a level of general well-being and for the treatment minor
   illnesses. In cases of distress, Chinese medicine comes a resounding second
   to the more popular Western medicine. This attitude is evident both in terms 
   of the form of treatment patients seek, and also in its declining popularity 
   as a subject of study for prospective medicine students. Thus while the
   institutional system set up during the 1950s still maintains the presence of 
   Chinese medicine in Chinese society, one wonders at the future of the
   medicine if the Communist values of the present government system are to
   continue to erode. The ‘medical legacy of the motherland’ could indeed become
   a legacy of China’s past. (pp. 152-3)

As mentioned above, I have some disagreements with Kim Taylor that in other
contexts would be formidable: her lamentation about the ‘standardization’ of TCM
implies that she believes that the real versions were better—not just in the
poetic, metaphorical sense, but for medical care. I don’t. Her assertion that
medicine reflects “prevailing ontological concepts of a society” suggests that
she subscribes to a kind of medical relativism. Unless I’ve misinterpreted her, 
she would, presumably, include modern medicine as merely reflecting “prevailing 
ontological concepts.”

I disagree. Modern, scientific medicine is different from all traditional
medicines, because it is founded in biological facts common to all times and
places, not in metaphors peculiar to particular times and places. I suspect that
‘real’ Chinese medicine is about as effective as the formulaic TCM of the 20th 
century PRC, and that each of those is about as effective as the humoral
medicine of 18th century Europe or the homeopathy of the 19th century (risks may
differ).

For those who are interested in the recent history of something akin to Chinese 
medicine, however, particularly during the early Communist era and particularly 
regarding its advocacy in the West, Ms. Taylor’s book is essential.

We know from John Bonica’s writings that although ‘acupuncture anesthesia’ was
first tried in 1958, it was rarely used until the Great Proletarian Cultural
Revolution, which began in 1966. It is that era, and its aftermath, that we will
discuss in the final part of this series.

      “Acupuncture Anesthesia”: a Proclamation from Chairman Mao (Part IV)

                                 Kimball Atwood

                                      Link

The Cultural Revolution

After investigating ‘acupuncture anesthesia’ in the People’s Republic of China
in 1973, John Bonica wrote:

   From the guarded comments made by several anesthesiologists, I concluded that
   this disuse [of 'acupuncture anesthesia,' after its introduction in 1958
   until the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution began in 1966] was the result
   of disappointing failures in a significant proportion of patients. During
   the Cultural Revolution this “negative” trend of not using acupuncture was
   considered the work of revisionists, and subsequently greater emphasis was
   given to the widespread use of acupuncture in all hospitals.

Similarly, according to Petr Skrabanek,

   Those who dared ask such awkward questions [about 'acupuncture anesthesia']
   were branded as “counter-revolutionary revisionists.”

Skrabanek’s reference for that assertion was this 37-page pamphlet:

It had been published by the Beijing Foreign Languages Press in 1972, smack in
the middle of the Cultural Revolution and only one year after James Reston’s
trip to China. It is the epitome of ‘revolutionary’ literature, as these
excerpts and photos attest:

The text is filled with extravagant claims for the success and widespread use of
acupuncture anesthesia, which we know from Dr. Bonica’s reports are untrue.
From Kim Taylor we learned that the ‘science’ underpinning the new TCM is not
science in the usual sense, and this pamphlet bears that out. Dialectical
materialism and Chairman Mao (who is praised on nearly every page) are credited 
with providing not only the motivation, but the conceptual basis for the
practice:

   During the Great Cultural Revolution, medical workers at the P.L.A. Kwangchow
   Units Central Hospital, the Peking Tuberculosis Research Institute, the No. 
   1 Tuberculosis Central Hospital in Shanghai and other hospitals
   conscientiously studied Chairman Mao’s philosophical works to guide their
   practice. Boldly experimenting on themselves with needles to determine the
   degree of pain, they eliminated the unnecessary points and, by grasping the
   main contradiction and bringing into play the role of the main points,
   succeeded in reducing the needles to a few and sometimes even to one…

   Chinese medical and scientific workers are making still greater efforts in
   studying Marxism-Leninism-Mao Tsetung Thought and are using dialectical
   materialism to guide their medical work and scientific research. Daring in
   practice and in breaking new ground, they are bending their efforts to
   perfect acupuncture anesthesia.

The pamphlet also makes extravagant claims for other uses of acupuncture:

   Chinese medical workers have in the last few years discovered many new points
   and cured many ‘incurable’ diseases. Deep needling of the yamen point, for
   instance, enables deaf-mutes to hear and speak, and in some cases of
   infantile paralysis or paraplegia, suitable stimuli from needling certain
   points can, after a period of treatment, restore the functions of limbs
   paralysed for years.

Skrabanek’s assertion about “awkward questions” must have been based on this
passage (emphasis in the original):

   ‘New things always have to experience difficulties and setbacks as they
   grow.‘

   No sooner had acupuncture anaesthesia appeared than it was suppressed by Liu 
   Shao-chi‘s counter-revolutionary revisionist line and attacked by bourgeois
   ‘experts.’ In a vain attempt to nip it in the bud, they raved that it was
   ‘not scientific,’ ‘without any practical value,’ and a ‘retrogression’ in the
   history of anaesthesia.

   Repeatedly studying Chairman Mao’s teaching ‘We cannot just take the beaten
   track traversed by other countries in the development of technology and trail
   behind them at a snail’s pace,’ the medical workers made up their minds to
   break new ground for anesthesiology. Disregarding ridicule and attacks, they 
   persisted in accumulating experience through clinical practice and constantly
   raising the efficacy and widening the scope of applying acupuncture
   anaesthesia in operations.

   The Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution swept away the bourgeois trash, and
   revolutionary medical workers relentlessly criticized Liu Shao-chi’s
   counter-revolutionary revisionist line in health work and scientific
   research. This facilitated great development and improvement in acupuncture
   anaesthesia.

Conclusion: Seeking Truth from Facts

In Part I of this series we saw that in many of the operations witnessed by
Westerners in the 1970s, ‘acupuncture anesthesia’ had been supplemented with
sedatives, narcotics, and local anesthetics. We also saw that some people seem
surpisingly tolerant of surgical procedures performed without anesthesia, and
that during the 19th century Western surgeons had been particularly impressed by
that capacity in Chinese patients. In Part II we saw abundant, albeit indirect 
evidence that many patients undergoing surgery with ‘acupuncture anesthesia’ in 
China during the early 1970s felt substantial pain, but upon questioning denied 
it. Part II ended with this question:

“Rather than being an important Chinese achievement, was ‘acupuncture
anesthesia’ more a form of torture perpetrated by a totalitarian government on
its own citizens, with the forced complicity of physicians?”

Historian Paul Unschuld, considering the time of Nixon’s visit to China,
observed in 1997:

   Attempts to use needles instead of drugs to achieve anesthesia even in major 
   surgical operations have in the meantime slipped into deserved oblivion, just
   as much as collective management and public self-criticism. It was not until
   after the ‘Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution’ in 1976 and the opening of
   China in 1978 that Chinese doctors were able to report, without personal
   risk, about the pain that patients had been expected to endure through
   therapy applied in operating theaters not on the basis of scientific
   knowledge, but in accordance with the ideological precepts of the Communist
   Party.

Readers who are familiar with the origin of the People’s Republic of China or
who have read Part III of this series will recognize the subtitle of this
section as a quotation from Chairman Mao. It was also part of the title of an
essay written in 1980 by two of the doctors referred to by Paul Unschuld: Keng
Hsi-chen and T’ao Nai-huang. An English translation of their essay is printed in
another of Unschuld’s books and is intermittently available almost in its
entirety here, beginning on p. 360. Here are the essential excerpts:

   The pushing of acupuncture anesthesia into large areas of clinical
   application cannot be separated from the peculiar historical conditions in
   our country of that time. During the period of the ‘Cultural Revolution,’
   acupuncture anesthesia served politically as a standard to judge progress or 
   backwardness, revolution or nonrevolution. Physicians and patients were under
   the pressure of the political requirements of that time. They had no choice 
   but to have exceptional courage in order to carry out or undergo surgery,
   especially as the patients who felt pain could not cry out. Some resorted to 
   shouting political slogans during surgery in a loud voice. At one place, the 
   chairman of ophthalmology was enthusiastic about acupuncture anesthesia, and 
   he tried the knife at his own eyelid. Finally he reached the conclusion: the 
   effects are not good, it should not be extended. He wrote a report to higher 
   authorities and as a result he was labeled one with three hats [i.e., an
   intellectual not interested in practice] and met the criticism of the masses.
   Under this type of political pressure, not a few people made statements
   against their will and acted against their conscience. Thus, in some
   hospitals the rate of acupuncture anesthesia utilization reached 20 percent, 
   but among these, 80 percent were ligation operations. In other hospitals
   before clinical application of acupuncture anesthesia, the patients were
   given already sufficient amounts of anesthetic drugs through injection and
   then, in addition, needles were pierced into their ears pretending
   acupuncture anesthesia. Only joy was reported but no sorrow; one did not dare
   to tell the facts. This of course had decisive influence on how the
   concerned leadership department passed correct decisions regarding the real
   situation of acupuncture anesthesia.

   …

   Our opinions expressed here are not taken out of thin air. We, the authors,
   have in the past, from 1969 through 1977, as part of our work in the
   hospital, conducted more than thirty thousand surgical operations under
   acupuncture anesthesia as an exploratory practice in order to warmheartedly
   promote acupuncture anesthesia. This represents about 1.5% of all cases of
   surgery under acupuncture anesthesia in our country. This tremendous amount
   of practice has led us to publish the opinions offered above. Also, these
   opinions are not really our own original ideas, they are extensively
   discussed and acknowledged among medical personnel of anesthetics and
   surgery. It is just that due to the political pressure of the past period,
   nobody dared to state them openly.

The answer to the question, then, is clear. Most Westerners—Michael DeBakey,
John Bonica, and Arthur Taub being exceptions—who observed ‘acupuncture
anesthesia’ in China during the Cultural Revolution seem to have failed to
recognize what was going on right under their noses. No surprise, then, that
many Westerners continued to have an insatiable appetite for the exotic
‘healing’ wares of the Mysterious Orient, and even post-Mao China has been only 
too willing to accomodate them.

Epilogue: if not Anesthesia, is there Acupuncture Analgesia?

A few years after his trip to China, John Bonica reported his experience using
acupuncture to treat patients in his pain clinic:

   At the University of Washington Pain Clinic, a self-selected series of 100
   patients suffering from chronic pain refractory to other forms of
   conventional therapy undertook a trial of acupuncture analgesia at weekly
   intervals. Although the initial results were often spectacularly successful, 
   following the third treatment, long-term benefit from acupuncture analgesia
   was as disappointing as other forms of therapy for this intractable group of 
   patients. None of the 100 patients showed any continued objective evidence of
   pain relief, ie, medication intake and functional impairment continued
   despite claimed subjective relief in a small percentage of the patients. Only
   three out of the hundred patients claimed long-term (upwards of three
   months) pain relief from a course of acupuncture at approximately weekly
   intervals, but they did not, as a result of this claimed relief, decrease
   analgesic medicines or improve their activity levels.

   Similar patterns of response to acupuncture therapy for chronic pain states
   have been noted by other investigators. In a well-controlled clinical trial, 
   Lee and associates demonstrated that it did not matter if the needles were
   inserted in traditional meridian points or in “control” points. The results
   were similar: temporary relief. Only 18% of their 261 patients obtained good 
   relief (15%) beyond four weeks after a series of four acupuncture treatments…

Funny: such findings are remarkably similar to those that continue to be
reported more than 30 years later. Is that telling us something?

‘Acupuncture Anesthesia’ Redux: another Skeptic and an Unfortunate Misportrayal 
                                  at the NCCAM

                                 Kimball Atwood

                                      Link

A Neglected Skeptic

Near the end of my series* on ‘Acupuncture Anesthesia’, I wrote this:

   Most Westerners—Michael DeBakey and John Bonica being exceptions—who observed
   ‘acupuncture anesthesia’ in China during the Cultural Revolution seem to
   have failed to recognize what was going on right under their noses.

I should have added—and I now have—Arthur Taub’s name to that tiny, exceptional 
group. Taub, a neurologist and neurophysiologist at Yale, was a member of a
delegation of Americans sent to China to observe ‘acupuncture anesthesia’ in May
of 1974, about a year after Dr. Bonica‘s visit. The delegation included several
prominent anesthesiologists. Their report,  Acupuncture Anesthesia in the
People’s Republic of China: A Trip Report of the American Acupuncture Anesthesia
Study Group, was published in 1976 and is available in its entirety here.
Excerpts follow (emphasis added):

   Pain is a subjective experience. Judging whether an individual is in a state 
   of pain depends on observations of the subject’s behavior, including verbal
   reports to the observer…When there is no evidence of pain, the observer can
   adopt one of three positions:

   A judgment about pain cannot be made because of lack of evidence. The
   corollary of this position is that only the presence—not the absence—of pain 
   is recognized.

   Pain is present in spite of lack of evidence. This position accepts the
   notion that pain-associated behavior and autonomic responses can be withheld 
   by the subject, but that the presence of pain can be inferred from other
   factors, such as the presence of extensive tissue damage. This position also 
   implies that the observational measures currently available are too crude to 
   form the sole basis for judgment.

   Since there is no evidence for pain, there is no pain. Although this is the
   position most often adopted by clinicians and pain researchers, it relies
   heavily upon the observer’s skill and accepts the notion that a judgment
   about the presence or absence of pain can be made on the basis of behavioral 
   observations.

   The major area of disagreement among members of the group derived from the
   above issue…The grading system employed indicates acceptance of the last
   position by most members of the delegation…It was not possible for the group 
   to reach complete accord regarding the degree of hypalgesia under
   acupuncture, since it could always be argued that, for whatever reason, our
   observations were inadequate to judge the extent of private pain experience. 
   The realities of life and patient management, however, continually force us
   to make judgments about pain on the basis of the best evidence available. To 
   the extent that this is possible, then, the group could conclude that the
   majority of patients were not in pain during surgery.

The delegation was quick to dispense with the term “acupuncture anesthesia”:

   It must be clearly understood that acupuncture does not produce conventional 
   surgical anesthesia. In no instance is sensation totally abolished or
   consciousness disturbed; thus, acupuncture anesthesia is a misnomer. There is
   considerable evidence, however, that acupuncture affects the pain
   experience, although our observations suggest that complete analgesia may not
   occur. Therefore, the term acupuncture analgesia is similarly inappropriate.
   In view of these limitations, it seems more reasonable to refer to the
   phenomenon as acupuncture hypalgesia (AH), which may then be graded according
   to the effectiveness of pain relief.

The group used a grading system similar to that devised by Chinese physicians in
Shanghai, previously reported by Dr. Bonica. The 1974 delegation, however,
accepted Grades I and II as being satisfactory, whereas Dr. Bonica had implied
acceptance of only Grade I (the Chinese considered Grades I-III to be
“effective” and “successful,” according to Dr. Bonica). Using that scale, the
1974 delegation found 22 of the 48 observed cases to have been in Grade I and a 
further 13 in Grade II, for an overall “satisfactory” rate of 73% (compared to
30% reported by Dr. Bonica). They further reckoned–were told, that is, by their 
hosts–that about 15% of operations in China were being performed under
acupuncture anesthesia (also a much higher percentage than Dr. Bonica’s
estimate), and thus concluded that acupuncture provided satisfactory anesthesia 
for 10% of all operations being done in China at that time.

The 1974 delegation barely addressed political issues, but some of their
observations seem telling in retrospect:

   According to our Chinese colleagues, only good-risk patients, who are not
   apprehensive and express their willingness to accept AH are selected after a 
   visit by the acupuncturist or the surgeon…To the best of the study group’s
   knowledge, coercion is not employed…Selection of patients is also determined 
   to a major degree by the type of pathology anticipated. A precise diagnosis
   is necessary since extensive exploration produces pain during AH. The
   procedure should offer no untoward problems such as adhesions, infiltrative
   tumors, or hemorrhagic complications…

(Unlike Dr. Bonica, this delegation did not wonder why, if acupuncture was so
safe and effective, it was not used preferentially for high-risk patients or
procedures).

   Certain other patients are also considered inappropriate candidates for AH.
   Children under the age of 15 are rarely included because, as we were told,
   they cannot be relied upon to remain quiet during the procedure…The role of
   peer acceptance and national pride on the part of patients were believed to
   be important factors by some of our colleagues, but there was no objective
   evidence for or against these opinions.The majority of patients received 100 
   mg of phenobarbital and/or 50 mg to 100 mg of meperidine (Demerol) from 20 to
   60 minutes prior to the operation. With the exception of a case of near or
   actual coma due to a brain tumor, all patients entered the operating room
   awake and alert.

The delegation observed one veterinary case:

   A healthy aging horse was observed during demonstration of an exploratory
   laparotomy performed with the aid of acupuncture hypalgesia. It seemed less
   than a dramatically successful performance, as the horse appeared glassy-eyed
   and frequently struggled.

In their conclusion, the group wrote:

  1. Acupuncture stimulation can be effectively used for the control of pain in
    approximately 10 percent of surgical patients in the People’s Republic of
    China. It is important to recognize that this is an experimental technique
    at present.

  2. Acupuncture appears to modify the pain experience at times to a remarkable
    degree…

  3. AH is a significant human biological phenomenon of unknown mechanisms. The
    induction of a hypnotic trance is not necessary. Social factors may be
    important in some instances but are not, of themselves, sufficient to
    account for the effects observed. Some psychophysiologic process appears to 
    be important in modifying the experience of pain.

  4. The effectiveness of acupuncture hypalgesia varies in different procedures,
    between different patients, and even within the same patient at different
    times…

Compared to some of the early reports by Westerners, these statements were
cautious. Knowing what we now know about ‘acupuncture anesthesia’ in China
during the Cultural Revolution, however, the analysis appears to be an example
of academics being “overconfident in their ability to understand how things
work.” In particular, most of the members of this group failed to distinguish
between patients who were free to report pain and those who were not, and failed
to recognize that their Chinese hosts were motivated,  by threat of exile from 
job, home, and family, to make the appearance very different from the reality.

Arthur Taub had a different point of view. A footnote to the report is this:

   One member of the study group, Arthur Taub, dissents from the conclusions
   expressed in this report. His views on acupuncture hypalgesia have been
   published in various scientific journals…

You can read those views here.

An Unfortunate Misportrayal

In contrast to Dr. Taub’s views are those of one of his colleagues, Yale surgeon
Sherwin Nuland, who witnessed ‘acupuncture anesthesia’ in China in 1990. He
told of this experience at the first “Stephen E. Straus Distinguished Lecture in
the Science of Complementary and Alternative Medicine,” given at the NIH on
March 10, 2009. Dr. Nuland is an author of some note. I’ve read parts of several
of his books and have found him to be a good writer who seems particularly
committed to accurate history. This lecture, unfortunately, was an exception.

Dr. Nuland suggested that the recent advent of acupuncture anesthesia in China
had entirely to do with the paucity of modern anesthesia practitioners and
equipment. He credited Mao Zedong with having encouraged it, but gave no
indication of the political complexity of Mao’s decisions or of the coercion
involved in executing them.

Dr. Nuland did not mention the reports or opinions of Drs. Bonica, DeBakey, or
Taub. He cited the report of the 1974 delegation, implying that it was the first
of its kind, but opined that it had been too skeptical:

   …Remarkably, they came to the conclusion that the method might be useful in
   only about 10% of cases…and this was in spite of the fact that if you look
   into this report, and look at the individual cases, in more than half of
   those situations, acupuncture went perfectly well; the procedure went well,
   there was no problem with it, and it’s a little difficult to know why they
   were hesitant to write in favor of it except that they had no idea how it
   worked, and maybe that was the reason: Western physicians, Western
   scientists, are not prone to use technologies whose origins they have no
   understanding of.

Perhaps Dr. Nuland misunderstood the report: the “10%” figure was derived from
the delegation’s view of the success rate, about 70%, multiplied by the 15% of
operations that their Chinese hosts had informed them were appropriate for
acupuncture anesthesia. Thus the 1974 delegation (with the exception of Dr.
Taub) did, in essence, “write in favor” of the method. Whether or not Dr. Nuland
understood this, he used the occasion to accuse “Western scientists” of being
petty and closed-minded—much to the delight, I’ve no doubt, of his hosts at the 
National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). Like the
late Director for whom the lecture had been named, Dr. Nuland seems to have
quickly grasped the power of misleading language in addressing such an audience.

This was a theme throughout his talk. Regarding nature, suggested Nuland, the
Chinese philosophy of ‘harmony’ trumps Western notions of ‘subjugation’:

   Let’s talk about Traditional Chinese Medicine: the basic principle is the
   concept of harmony, and, in this configuration, man is such an integral part 
   of the natural world that he can only survive, he can only do well, by doing 
   everything he can to fit into the functioning of the natural world, unlike
   Western science, which analyzes every characteristic of nature, with a view
   toward influencing or perhaps subjugating it.

   The Chinese philosophy seeks an understanding of nature’s world, so that Man 
   may bow to its laws, and remain unhindered as a part of its never-ending
   cycle. The inter-relatedness of the universe extends to all things and is
   exemplified by the principles, and here come two very familiar words, of yin 
   and yang…

In studying natural phenomena, holism and mysticism are preferable to
small-minded Western reductionism:

   One of the most fundamental teachings of Western science is that natural
   phenomena are best studied by separating them into their component parts, to 
   observe them, uninfluenced by surrounding variables; but it’s fundamental to 
   Chinese medical teaching that attempts to do this are senseless, ’cause you
   can’t really find out how something functions unless it’s functioning in
   harmony with the other characteristics that are involved with it.
   Interdependence, and inter-relatedness, in this philosophy, are at the very
   basis of why things happen the way they do. Involved in the inter-relatedness
   of all things is the principle of Qi…an abstract form of influence analogous
   to what an American might call vital energy or life force. We’re not quite
   sure what they are, but many of us believe there is such a thing.

Rigid, orthodox, Western scientific dogma points to the need for a new paradigm:

   Traditional Chinese Medicine is a vast collection of never-proved,
   time-honored theories, many of which have also been honored by a considerable
   degree of success. So far, the basis of that success has never been shown,
   or explained, to a degree that is completely acceptable to orthodox, Western 
   scientists using orthodox, Western, investigative techniques…what is needed
   is a new paradigm; a new way of looking at, and interpreting, all of the
   evidence and observations that we make of the processes of diseases and
   health…there are phenomena that cannot be fully explained by today’s
   biomedical science.

Stubborn Western scientists would, it seems, sacrifice the practical for the
theoretical, even when faced with overwhelming evidence for the former. Nuland
quoted James Reston’s report about Chinese surgeons and acupuncture anesthesia:

   …while they cannot agree on the theory of how needle anesthesia works, they
   are increasingly convinced that it does work, and they’re operating on the
   pragmatic evidence and they are not waiting for theoretical justification.
   There is enough objective evidence of practical medical information in the
   use of acupuncture to justify exploration by somebody more scientific than
   newspaper reporters.

Dr. Nuland, like so many others, misrepresented James Reston’s personal
experience with acupuncture:

   …postoperatively, he had a significant amount of pain, pain in the wound, gas
   pain, this sort of thing, and they treated the wound with acupuncture on
   each occasion that it occurred, and it worked every single time.

He also offered the standard, exaggerated claim of acupuncture’s antiquity:

   The earliest description of acupuncture that has been found was written in
   about 900 B.C.

Dr. Nuland reported having observed a woman undergoing excision of thyroid cysts
under acupuncture anesthesia. She had received phenobarbital, 40 mg, prior to
arriving in the operating room.

   Just before the surgical drapes were put into place Mrs. Hu had been given an
   intravenous dose of 40 mg of Demerol, also not an awful lot, and 4 mg of
   droperidol, which is a tranquilizing agent. Small to moderate amounts, they
   seemed to have no effect whatsoever on her level of consciousness.

Perhaps not, but the combination of Demerol (a narcotic) and droperidol (a
neuroleptic ) would have had a substantial effect on her perception of pain.
Such a combination was in vogue in anesthetic practice 2-3 decades ago, and
produced a remarkable state of indifference to pain in awake patients. The
quoted droperidol dose was not small to moderate, moreover, but substantial.
Nevertheless,

   I’m convinced that what I saw of surgical acupuncture is exactly what people 
   claim it is: it’s a profound elevation of the pain threshhold and tolerance
   brought about by a mechanism or mechanisms that have not yet been fully
   explained in terms that are acceptable to Western science–its paradigm of
   biomedical science.

Dr. Nuland mentioned nothing of the Cultural Revolution, of the overwhelming
political pressures that had occurred at that time, or of the exposés of
surgical torture that appeared in its aftermath—although this information had
been available for nearly three decades. Even if he believes that there is
something to ‘acupuncture anesthesia,’ this information should have been part of
a Distinguished Lecture given to the NCCAM in 2009.

Dummy Medicines, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 1: a Curious Editorial 
                 Choice for the New England Journal of Medicine

                                 Kimball Atwood

                                      Link

Background

This post concerns the recent article in the New England Journal of Medicine
(NEJM) titled “Active Albuterol or Placebo, Sham Acupuncture, or No Intervention
in Asthma.” It was ably reviewed by Dr. Gorski on Monday, so I will merely
summarize its findings: of the three interventions used—inhaled albuterol (a
bronchodilator), a placebo inhaler designed to mimic albuterol, or ‘sham
acupuncture’—only albuterol resulted in a clinically important improvement of
bronchial airflow; for that outcome the two sham treatments were equivalent to
“no intervention.” For all three interventions, however, self-reported
improvements were substantial and were much greater than self-reported
improvements after “no intervention.” In other words, dummy treatments made the 
subjects (report that they) feel better, whereas real medicine not only made
them feel better but actually made them better.

Before proceeding, let me offer a couple of caveats. First, the word ”doctors”
in the flippant title of this post refers mainly to two individuals: Daniel
Moerman, PhD, the anthropologist who wrote the accompanying editorial, and Ted
Kaptchuk, the Senior Author of the trial report. It does not refer to any of the
other authors of the report. Second, I have no quarrel with the trial itself,
which was quite good, or with the NEJM having published it, or even with most of
the language in the article, save for the “spin” that Dr. Gorski has already
discussed.

My quarrels are the same as those expressed by Drs. Gorski and Novella, and by
all of us on the Placebo Panel at TAM. This post and the next will develop some 
of those points by considering the roles and opinions of Moerman and Kaptchuk,
respectively.

A True Story

Late one night during the 1960s a friend and I, already in a cannabis-induced
fog, wandered into a house that had been rented by one of his friends. There
were about 8-10 ‘freaks’ there (the term was laudatory at the time); I didn’t
know any of them. The air was thick with smoke of at least two varieties. After 
an uncertain interval I became aware of a guy who was having trouble breathing. 
He was sitting bolt upright in a chair, his hands on his knees, his mouth open, 
making wheezing sounds. He took short noisy breaths in, followed by what seemed 
to be very long breaths out, as though he was breathing through a straw. You
could hear the wheezing in both directions. Others had also noticed that he was 
in distress; they tried to be helpful (“hey, man, ya want some water or
somethin’?”), but he just shook his head. He couldn’t talk. My friend, who had
asthma himself, announced that this guy was having an asthma attack and asked if
he or anyone else had any asthma medicine. No one did.

No one had a car, either, and for obvious reasons no one, not even the wheezing 
guy himself, was about to call 911. The nearest hospital was about 5 miles away.
My friend said that the thing to do when someone has an asthma attack is leave 
him alone so he won’t get too excited, and he’ll get through it. Yeah, that must
be right, we all figured; he has asthma too so he knows. We were all blowing
smoke into the wheezing guy’s face as we expressed our concern.

At some point my friend and I left. The next day I heard that the guy with the
asthma attack was eventually taken to the ER after another freak had come along 
who happened to have a car. The guy did all right, I guess. I don’t really know,
but if he’d died I probably would’ve heard about it.

Several years later I went to medical school and began to learn about asthma,
and as an internal medicine resident I saw enough patients with acute asthma
attacks to realize, in a way that still makes me cringe, just how sick that guy 
had been and how totally clueless and selfish were we, his supposedly concerned 
companions. If the freak with the car hadn’t shown up…

Cultural Anthropology and Cultural Relativism

All of which has something to do with the surprise I felt a few days ago upon
reading the following in the aforementioned editorial in the NEJM, the world’s
most prestigious medical journal:

   For subjective and functional conditions — for example, migraine,
   schizophrenia, back pain, depression, asthma, post-traumatic stress disorder,
   neurologic disorders such as Parkinson’s disease, inflammatory bowel disease
   and many other autoimmune disorders, any condition defined by symptoms, and 
   anything idiopathic — a patient-centered approach requires that
   patient-preferred outcomes trump the judgment of the physician. Under these
   conditions, inert pills can be as useful as “real” ones…

Let’s see: asthma is a “subjective and functional condition”? In the bad old
days of paternalistic medicine, the term “functional” meant “without
demonstrable pathology.” It was usually synonymous with ”in your head”—whether
the physician openly expressed that opinion or not. Doesn’t sound very
“patient-centered” to me. I’m happy to report that you hardly ever hear
”functional” anymore, which reflects at least some measure of social progress
for the profession. Since the term’s other possible meanings are nearly
limitless and therefore vague beyond utility—every complaint or medical
condition is in some way “functional,” after all—it seems reasonable to assume
that the editorial’s author intended the old meaning, even if it and
“subjective” are redundant.

Yet asthma is based in demonstrable pathology, as are most of the other named
conditions, and in most of those (migraines, Parkinson’s disease, inflammatory
bowel disease, and “many other autoimmune disorders”) there are specific
treatments based on pathophysiology that, like albuterol for asthma, effect
substantial, objective and subjective improvements. ”Idiopathic” refers to any
condition whose cause is unknown, which includes most of those already mentioned
and many other diseases for which medicines are effective for both objective
and subjective outcomes (diabetes, Grave’s disease), and even some that are, for
practical purposes, curable: Hodgkin’s disease, acute lymphocytic leukemia in
children, some testicular cancers (remember Lance?), temporal arteritis,
pernicious anemia, and many more. How could the author of a NEJM editorial be
unaware of such commonplace medical facts?

The answer is that the author, Daniel Moerman, is not a doctor or even a
biomedical scientist. He’s an anthropologist who seems to have confused
sentimental and poetic aspects of his major academic interests—native American
culture, medicinal plants, and healing rituals—with modern science and medicine.
I urge you to consider his CV and the excerpts from his book Medicine, Meaning 
and the “Placebo Effect,” discussed by Dr. Gorski a few days ago. In the very
first chapter he betrays more ignorance of medicine when he expresses surprise
that a gastroenterologist didn’t find it odd that in a cohort of experimental
subjects given only placebos for peptic ulcer disease, nearly half demonstrated 
healed ulcers after 4 weeks—about the percentage, I’d wager, whose ulcers would 
have healed with no trial intervention.

Regarding Prof. Moerman’s view of the sort of science that physicians need to
know, along with Dr. Gorski I detect shades of Deepak Chopra, although I also
detect a bit of down-home, folksy, isn’t-he-wise midwestern ambiguity, possibly 
delivered in a Mr. Ed voice, such as to give the good professor a way to deny it
all. Consider this excerpt from the NEJM editorial, also noted by Dr. Gorski:

   What do we learn from this study? The authors conclude that the patient
   reports were “unreliable,” since they reported improvement when there was
   none — that is, the subjective experiences were simply wrong because they
   ignored the objective facts as measured by FEV1. But is this the right
   interpretation? It is the subjective symptoms that brought these patients to 
   medical care in the first place. They came because they were wheezing and
   felt suffocated, not because they had a reduced FEV1. The fact that they felt
   improved even when their FEV1 had not increased begs the question, What is
   the more important outcome in medicine: the objective or the subjective, the 
   doctor’s or the patient’s perception? This distinction is important, since it
   should direct us as to when patient-centered versus doctor-directed care
   should take place.

Does he really believe that the subjective is the more important outcome? It
certainly seems so; next he writes:

   In a number of other trials in which both sham and actual treatments were
   evaluated, results were very similar. In one study of major depressive
   disorder, placebo, hypericum (St. John’s wort), and sertraline all resulted
   in about the same level of improvement on the Hamilton Rating Scale for
   Depression. Similarly, in studies of low back pain in both the United States 
   and Germany, true acupuncture and sham acupuncture had about the same
   effectiveness yet were substantially better than usual medical care in
   relieving the pain. A number of surgical procedures — such as arthroscopic
   knee surgery and spinal vertebroplasty — have led to similar results with
   actual and sham treatments. In these studies and many more, inert treatments 
   have had effects similar to their “active” analogues.

Woah! Sure, the subjective results of those trials “were very similar” to those 
of the albuterol trial, but so what? What distinguishes those trials from the
albuterol trial is that there were no objective outcomes to measure! Moerman has
missed the point of the distinction. He seems to prefer that medicine be about 
“a profound meaning response,” as he explained in an article written jointly
with homeopath Wayne Jonas a few years ago, which comes awfully close to
asserting that all “healing” is culturally determined:

   Anthropologists understand cultures as complex webs of meaning, rich skeins
   of connected understandings, metaphors, and signs. Insofar as 1) meaning has 
   biological consequence and 2) meanings vary across cultures, we can
   anticipate that biology will differ in different places, not because of
   genetics but because of these entangled ideas…

In the NEJM editorial Prof. Moerman doesn’t seem bothered by an inconvenient
truth about objective outcomes. That is, maybe he doesn’t:

   Maybe it is sufficient simply to show that a treatment yields significant
   improvement for the patients, has reasonable cost, and has no negative
   effects over the short or long term. This is, after all, the first tenet of
   medicine: “Do no harm.”

Prof. Moerman, what about the harm that comes from the NEJM seeming to judge
treatments that offer favorable subjective outcomes as being equivalent to those
that offer favorable objective outcomes? This kind of harm, for example. Asthma
isn’t just a “subjective and functional condition,” whatever that is. It’s a
real and potentially lethal disease. Oh, but you wrote “maybe.” Silly me.

Dr. Drazen, Where art Thou?

It is especially puzzling, considering the identity of its Editor-in-Chief, that
the New England Journal of Medicine asked Daniel Moerman to write the editorial
to accompany the report of the albuterol study. Jeffrey Drazen is not only a
pulmonologist, but an expert in the pathophysiology of asthma. He has been
instrumental in developing new drugs for asthma, drugs whose effects—I’m willing
to bet, but I’ve no time to research right now—have been demonstrated
objectively. If memory serves, Dr. Drazen trained at the old Peter Bent Brigham 
Hospital under ‘Reggie’ McFadden, whose chapter on asthma in my 2001 edition of 
Harrison’s Principles of Internal Medicine includes this passage:

   The most effective treatment for acute episodes of asthma requires a
   systematic approach based on the aggressive use of sympathomimetic agents and
   serial monitoring of key indices of improvement. Reliance on empiricism and 
   subjective assessment is no longer acceptable.

I’d be surprised if Dr. Drazen had ever heard of Moerman before the albuterol
report was accepted for publication, and I wonder who recommended him. Kaptchuk,
perhaps? Heh.

Unfortunately, someone isn’t minding the NEJM store when it comes to certain
dubious topics, as Dr. Gorski mentioned and as I’ve written about previously.

Good News, Bad News

Perhaps Dr. Drazen imagines that the editorial won’t do any real damage, because
real doctors will immediately identify it for what it is: Bullshit. That is
probably true, except for the small but possibly growing number of “integrative”
aficianados out there. I worry more about other Dummy Docs, such as naturopaths
(ND=Not a Doctor, according to one apostate), who already believe
wholeheartedly what Prof. Moerman “maybe” believes, and a lot more:

   For an acute asthma attack try a steam inhalation (draping a towel over your 
   head and a bowl of hot water) with a few drops of eucalyptus oil in the
   water. Be careful that the water is not so hot that the steam burns your
   face.  Some doctors recommend taking baths with a cup or so of 3% hydrogen
   peroxide in the water to bring extra oxygen to the entire surface of the
   skin, thus making the lungs somewhat less oxygen hungry. This method  can be 
   performed preventively. Another technique for an acute attack is to drink
   some hot water with the juice of one clove of garlic. [etc.]

And:

   How Can Homeopathy Help Asthma?

   Like with Traditional Chinese Medicine, each individual is analyzed for their
   specific symptoms and an appropriate  therapy is chosen, not for the
   disease, but for the person displaying signs of health out of balance.  This 
   is a very  important distinction, and, very generally speaking, one of the
   main differences between conventional and  “complementary” approaches to
   health care.

   After the homeopath, naturopath or medical doctor trained in homeopathy (they
   should have the title “Diplomat  of Homeopathy” after their other
   credentials) listen carefully to your story, one of the following remedies
   are likely to  be prescribed. [etc.]

   What Kind of Subtle Energy Techniques Are Useful for Asthma?

   Some folks like to work with flower essences.  Some of the more popular ones 
   to help with asthma are:

  1. oak

  2. mimulus

  3. larch

  4. wild rose

  5. hornbeam

  6. crab apple

  7. impatiens

  8. gentian

  9. Shasta daisy

  10. blackberry

  11. chamomile

  12. agrimony

  13. clematis

   Other people find it useful to work with color, either by using thin plastic 
   filters over light sources in their home or office environment, or by wearing
   clothes of specific colors.  The following serves as a guide to experiment
   with color therapy to help asthma.

   During an asthma attack try:

  1. purple (raises the threshold of pain and is soporific; is a vasodilator; slows
    heart rate) on face, throat and chest

  2. scarlet (acts as a stimulant to the kidney and adrenals) on kidneys

  3. orange (an antispasmodic) on throat and chest

  4. indigo or violet on throat, chest and upper back for 15 minutes

Etc., ad nauseam. Boy, do Dummy Docs love it when their pet treatments seem to
be endorsed by real medicine, especially the highest bastions of real medicine. 
Science, even! Is it any surprise when something like this happens? Josephine
Briggs, are you reading this? If so, please look here for more discussion of
that case. You also won’t want to miss the sequels to this post.

…

The Dummy Series:

Dummy Medicines, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 1: a Curious Editorial 
Choice for the New England Journal of Medicine

Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.0: Harvard Medical
School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD

Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.1: Harvard Medical
School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont.)

Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.2: Harvard Medical
School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont. again)

Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.3: Harvard Medical
School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (concluded)

…

The Harvard Medical School series:

Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part I)

Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part II)

Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part III)

Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part IV)

Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part V)

Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part VI)

Dummy Medicines, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 1: a Curious Editorial 
Choice for the New England Journal of Medicine

Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.0: Harvard Medical
School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD

Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.1: Harvard Medical
School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont.)

Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.2: Harvard Medical
School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont. again)

Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.3: Harvard Medical
School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (concluded)

  Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.0: Harvard Medical
                School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD

                                 Kimball Atwood

                                      Link

Review

The recent albuterol vs. placebo trial reported in the New England Journal of
Medicine (NEJM) found that experimental subjects with asthma experienced
substantial, measured improvements in lung function after inhaling albuterol,
but not after inhaling placebo, undergoing sham acupuncture, or “no treatment.” 
It also found that the same subjects reported having felt substantially improved
after either albuterol or each of the two sham treatments, but not after “no
treatment.” Anthropologist Daniel Moerman, in an accompanying editorial, wrote, 
“the authors conclude that the patient reports were ‘unreliable,’ since they
reported improvement when there was none”—precisely as any rational clinician or
biomedical scientist would have concluded.

In Part 1 of this blog we saw that Moerman took issue with that conclusion. He
argued, with just a bit of hedging, that the subjects’ perceptions of
improvement were more important than objective measures of their lung function. 
I wondered how the NEJM editors had chosen someone whose bibliography predicted 
such an anti-medical opinion. I doubted that Editor-in-Chief Jeffrey Drazen, an 
expert in the pathophysiology of asthma, had ever heard of Moerman. I suggested,
in a way that probably appeared facetious, that Ted Kaptchuk, the senior author
of the asthma report, might have recommended him.

Editorial Cronyism?

I wasn’t being facetious, even if I was a bit snide. In a 2009 article Kaptchuk 
touted Moerman’s notion of “the meaningresponse,” also discussed in Part 1. In a
1998 article, one of Kaptchuk’s early forays into the placebo topic, he had
thanked Moerman and others “for advice, discussion, and feedback.” In the
Acknowledgments for his 2002 book Meaning, Medicine, and the “Placebo Effect,”
Moerman returned the complement to Kaptchuk. In a very recent essay on “placebo 
studies and ritual theory,” Kaptchuk showed some serious cultural anthropology
chops with a serviceable impression of Moerman:

   …healing rituals are never simply enactments of plots, stories or assertions 
   of truth. Instead, they are compelling multi-sensory dramas involving
   evocation, enactment, embodiment and evaluation. Rituals and their sensory,
   affective, moral and aesthetic components transmute the mythos into an
   experiential reality for participants. Metaphors and symbols, the healer’s
   prestige, social interactions with relatives and community members in the
   course of preparation and performance of the ritual, and gesture, recitation,
   costume, iconography, touch, ingestion and the physical ordeal—all provide
   vehicles for and multi-dimensional guideposts to a process that is meant to
   transform a patient from brokenness to intactness.

Authorship by Committee and Mixed Messages

The asthma trial authors themselves seemed ambivalent about the meaning of their
results. Here is the larger passage from which Moerman culled the “unreliable” 
comment:

   …although improvement in objective measures of lung function would be
   expected to correlate with subjective measures, our study suggests that in
   clinical trials, reliance solely on subjective outcomes may be inherently
   unreliable, since they may be significantly influenced by placebo effects.
   However, even though objective physiological measures (e.g., FEV1) are
   important, other outcomes such as emergency room visits and quality-of-life
   metrics may be more clinically relevant to patients and physicians.

David Gorski has previously mentioned that his “jaw dropped” when he read those 
words; so did mine, and so, everywhere, should jaws of asthmatic patients and
competent physicians drop. The two sentences are contradictory: if the first is 
true, the second—essentially similar to the theme in Moerman’s editorial, weasel
words and all—is perverse. How could the same authors have written both?
Perusing the list of authors provides some hints:

   Michael E. Wechsler, M.D., John M. Kelley, Ph.D., Ingrid O.E. Boyd, M.P.H.,
   Stefanie Dutile, B.S., Gautham Marigowda, M.B., Irving Kirsch, Ph.D., Elliot 
   Israel, M.D., and Ted J. Kaptchuk

Thus there were eight authors, suggesting that there may not have been a
unanimity of opinion. Of the eight, five—M.E.W., I.O.E.B., S.D., G.M., and
E.I.—are identified as “from the Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care
Medicine, Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Harvard Medical School” (the same
Division, as I mentioned in Part 1, that spawned NEJM Editor Jeffrey Drazen).
It’s a safe bet that those five subscribed to the first sentence quoted above,
but not to the second.

I don’t know about the other two authors, but Ted Kaptchuk would appear to agree
with the second sentence. Here he’s quoted in the Brigham and Women’s Hospital 
press release:

   “We chose to study patients with asthma because earlier evidence had
   suggested that placebos would change the underlying medical problem,”
   explains senior author Ted Kaptchuk, Director of the Program in Placebo
   Studies at BIDMC and Associate Professor of Medicine at HMS. “While I was
   initially surprised that there was no placebo effect in this experiment
   [after looking at the objective air flow measures] once I saw patients’
   subjective descriptions of how they felt following both the active treatment 
   and the placebo treatments, it was apparent that the placebos were as
   effective as the active drug in helping people feel better.”

   …adds Kaptchuk, the study results imply that placebo treatment is just as
   effective as active medication in improving patient-centered outcomes.”It’s
   clear that for the patient, the ritual of treatment can be very powerful,”
   notes Kaptchuk. “This study suggests that in addition to active therapies for
   fixing diseases, the idea of receiving care is a critical component of what 
   patients value in health care. In a climate of patient dissatisfaction, this 
   may be an important lesson.”

Let’s see: “patient-centered outcomes” are now defined as feeling better but not
being better? (I wonder if Don Berwick, the nation’s most influential exponent 
of patient-centered care, would agree). According to whom? Other press reports
were even worse:

   Treatment, not medicine, helps asthma patients feel better

   NEW YORK, July 15 (Reuters Life!) – Inhaling albuterol helps asthmatic lungs 
   work better, but patients who get it don’t feel much better than those
   treated with a placebo inhaler or phony acupuncture, according to a U.S.
   study.

   The results, which appeared in the New England Journal of Medicine,
   demonstrate the importance of, literally, caring for patients and not just
   providing drugs, said co-author Ted Kaptchuk of Harvard Medical School.

   The findings also demonstrate the impact of the so-called “placebo effect,”
   or the phenomenon seen in clinical trials when people given inactive, fake
   “treatments,” such as a sugar pill or saline, show improvements.

   “My honest opinion is that a lot of medicine is the doctor-patient
   relationship,” Kaptchuk told Reuters Health.

   “A lot of doctors don’t know that, they think it’s their drugs. Our study
   demonstrates that the interaction between the two is actually a very strong
   component of healthcare.”

…

   Treatment of Asthma now Possible with Placebo Treatments

   A New study says, “Placebo treatments are equally effective in the treatment 
   of asthma like [sic] any asthma medications.”

   According to the researchers, the main reason behind proposition of this
   study is that several asthma patients have reported that they felt
   improvement in their asthma symptoms after they received placebo treatments. 
   These treatments also include inhaler treatments and fake acupuncture. The
   improvement is similar to what they feel after taking asthma medication such 
   as albuterol.

   But the researchers also mentioned that unlike asthma medications, the
   placebo treatments are not capable of affecting the functioning of the lung.

   The researcher of the study, Mr. Ted Kaptchuk said, “The practice of
   treatment can be highly effective for the patients”. “The study also
   recommends that patients should value not only the treatments for improving
   diseases but also the intensive care they receive from their healthcare
   providers” he added.

   Mr. Ted Kaptchuk also said, “In the initial stage of the experiment, placebo 
   treatments fail to make any impact. But later, when I observed that patient’s
   subjective descriptions about what they felt after receiving the two
   treatments then I concluded that placebo treatments work as well as other
   asthma treatments”.

At least one blog, citing the Reuters report quoted above, reported that
“placebos were just as effective as real therapy” without even mentioning the
trial’s having found a discrepancy between objective findings and subjective
reports.

I am aware that authors of journal articles can’t be expected to control how
every reporter characterizes those articles, but it’s fair to say that the
emphasis of the various quotations attributed to Kaptchuk—which, as far as can
be gleaned from the web, are accurate—was essentially the opposite of the
study’s most important finding.

From Campus Radical to AltMed Superstar

You might have noticed that Kaptchuk’s is the only name on the list of authors
that is not accompanied by the mark of an advanced degree, as I will eventually 
discuss. Like Moerman, Kaptchuk lacks formal training in either modern medicine 
or biomedical science, although he has learned a lot about the history and
methods of clinical trials. How did he get to be Senior Author of an article
published in the New England Journal of Medicine, and how did he become
Associate Professor at the Harvard Medical School?

Here is the short version:

   I was interested in science for a long time. In college, I studied religion
   and philosophy. Then I studied Chinese medicine in China and I came back and 
   was a practitioner of Chinese medicine. When people became interested in
   alternative medicines, they asked me to help out at Harvard Medical School. I
   realized that in order to survive there, one had to become a scientist. So I
   became a scientist.

Here is the beginning of the longer version. Kaptchuk graduated from Columbia
University in 1968, having majored in Asian philosophy. While there he was
Chairman of the radical group Students for a Democratic Society (SDS), just
prior to the emergence of its more famous chairman, Mark Rudd. I mention this
not to commie-bash, but because it helps to elucidate some of Kaptchuk’s later
opinions (hint: he has no trouble agreeing with both sentences in the
jaw-dropping paragraph quoted above) and to demonstrate some of the ironies of
his later choices.

After graduation, in Kaptchuk’s own words, ”I worked in the welfare and social
services trying to help people.” During this time “I decided that I wanted to
learn a healing art but was disillusioned with some of the aspects of Western
allopathy and decided to learn acupuncture.” Kaptchuk pursued training with
Asian practitioners in California and “studied every book in English on the
subject,” but by 1972 had decided that this would not be sufficient:

Because of the relative unknowness [sic] among non-Chinese Americans of
acupuncture and Dr. Hong’s limited practice, I cannot get enough experience to
adequately master this healing art. In addition, there is a greater reluctance
among other Chinese doctors who have more patients to have a student observe
because of legal restrictions concerning their practice in the United States.

Kaptchuk reports having next spent a year in Taiwan, followed by 2.5 years in
Macau (click on the image to enlarge):

Within a few years of his return to the United States, Ted Kaptchuk published
the book that made him an alt-med superstar:

It is this book that I will discuss in the next part of this series.

  Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.1: Harvard Medical
            School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont.)

                                Kimball Atwood 

                                      Link

Rave Reviews

In 1983, Ted Kaptchuk, the senior author of the recent “albuterol vs. placebo”
article, and soon to become the long-time Second-in-Command of the Harvard
Medical School “CAM” program, published The Web that Has No Weaver.

The book received rave reviews:

   A major advance toward the synthesis of Western and Eastern theory. It will
   stimulate all practitioners to expand their understanding of the causes and
   treatment of disease.

   –Paul Epstein, MD, Harvard Medical School

   A lucid and penetrating exposition of the theory and practice of Chinese
   medicine. While the book’s rich detail makes it of great use to practicing
   healers, it is in its entirety very simply written, enjoyable reading for the
   layman…it brings a demystifying balance…Instructive, profound, and
   important!

   Professor Martin Schwartz, University of California, Berkeley

   …demystifies Oriental medicine in a remarkably rational analysis…

   —Science Digest, Nov. 1982

   …an encyclopedia of how to tell from the Eastern perspective ‘what is wrong.’

   —Larry Dossey

   Dr. Kaptchuk has become a lyricist for the art of healing…

   —Houston Chronicle

   Although the book is explicitly detailed, it is readable and does not require
   previous knowledge of Chinese thought…

   —Library Journal

The 2nd edition was published in 2000, to more acclaim:

   …opens the great door of understanding to the profoundness of Chinese
   medicine.

   —People’s Daily, Beijing, China

   …weaves a picture…that is eminently understandable from a Westerner’s point
   of view…adds a valuable analysis of the current scientific understanding of
   how the therapies work and their effectiveness.

   —Brian Berman

   Ted Kaptchuk’s book was inspirational in the development of my acupuncture
   practice and gave me a deep understanding of traditional Chinese medicine…

   Dr. George T. Lewith

   …a gift for all who share an interest in deep understanding of healing. This 
   new edition is essential reading…

   —Michael Lerner, President, Commonweal

Even Edzard Ernst, still in his foggy period, called the 2nd edition “a
brilliant synthesis of traditional and scientific knowledge…compulsory reading…”

Andrew Weil, who wrote a forward for the 2nd edition, praised Kaptchuk for
“merg[ing] the insight of a Taoist sage with the skepticism of a modern,
inquiring scientist,” and asserted that

   …the emphasis of Chinese practitioners on energy and its balanced flow
   throughout the body is a stumbling block for Westerners who cannot see beyond
   the limitations of the paradigm of materialistic science.

Margaret Caudill, who wrote forwards to both editions, praised Kaptchuk for
having written

   …an important exposition of the ancient art of Chinese medicine in terms that
   can be understood by a Western audience. The author has deftly avoided, as
   much as possible, the pitfall of interpreting Chinese theory through Western 
   terminology, thereby leaving the central Chinese concept of medical patterns 
   and disharmonies undisturbed.

(One wonders if Caudill had read the book that she introduced. Kaptchuk himself,
on the third page of his own introduction, states that he tried to “explain
Chinese concepts with a Western vocabulary,” although he’d found that “at times 
[this] was a very great problem.”)

What readers might expect to find, then, is a book that is easy to read and
understandable to Westerners, that is rational, that ‘demystifies’ its subject, 
that will provide a ‘deep’ understanding of healing, that will “expand their
understanding of the causes and treatment of disease,” and that heralds a
‘synthesis’ of Eastern and Western medicine.

I perused the first edition of The Web around 10 years ago, when I was trying to
learn something about acupuncture for my work on the Massachusetts Special
Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners. A friend had 
it on his bookshelf, and let me borrow it; he hadn’t read it himself. A few days
later I reported back to him: “there is sophistry on nearly every page.”

This review is mostly concerned with the first edition; I’ll mention some things
about the 2000 edition in the subsequent posts.

“A Coherent and Independent System of Thought”

Kaptchuk begins by dismissing two, presumably dominant Western notions of
Chinese medicine:

   Some…see it as hocus-pocus—the product of primitive or magical thinking. If a
   patient is cured by means of herbs or acupuncture, they see only two
   possible explanations: either the cure was psychosomatic or it was an
   accident, the happy result of hit-or-miss pin-sticking that the practitioner 
   did not understand. They assume that current Western science and medicine
   have a unique handle on truth—all else is superstition.

   Other people have an equally erroneous view of Chinese medicine. Deeply and
   often justifiably disturbed by many of the products of Western science and
   culture, they assume that the Chinese system, because it is more ancient,
   more spiritual or more holisitic, is somehow more “true” than Western
   medicine. This attitude threatens to turn Chinese medicine from a rational
   body of knowledge into a religious faith system. Both attitudes mystify the
   subject—one by arrogantly undervaluing it, the other by setting it on a
   pedestal. Both are barriers to understanding.

But no more a barrier to understanding than the passage just quoted. We who
‘arrogantly’ undervalue Chinese medicine do so not because we see only two
possible explanations for its apparent successes; we see many explanations, none
involving hit-or-miss pin-sticking, accidental or otherwise. We deny that
science is ‘Western,’ any more than the physics of Einstein was ‘Jewish’ (I
confess to having used this quip repeatedly, but in my opinion it can’t be
repeated enough). We immediately detect, in the phrase “current Western
science,” the Galileo Gambit, and we reject that bit of sophistry. We’ve seen
precious little evidence of cures by means of herbs or acupuncture, and 28 years
later we’re still waiting. Those who think Chinese medicine is more true than
‘Western medicine’ have a problem with science other than merely being disturbed
by its “products.” They are, er, deeply ignorant of it.

What, then, is Kaptchuk’s view of Chinese medicine?

   Actually, Chinese medicine is a coherent and independent system of thought
   and practice that has been developed over two millennia. Based on ancient
   texts, it is the result of a continuous process of critical thinking, as well
   as extensive clinical observation and testing. It represents a thorough
   formulation and reformulation of material by respected clinicians and
   theoreticians. It is also, however, rooted in the philosophy, logic,
   sensibility and habits of a civilization entirely foreign to our own. It has 
   therefore developed its own perception of the body and of health and disease.

If you’re bracing for an onslaught of the usual sCAMbits—unfalsifiable
assertions, propaganda language devices, arguments from ignorance, arguments
from tradition, special pleading, changing the rules ad lib, breezy
contradictions, and all the rest—you’re on the right track. Right off the bat,
Kaptchuk asks that you check your own critical thinking skills at the door:

   In order to understand it, we must first accept two principles: that another 
   perspective, though different from our own, can be logical and have
   predictive validity, and that there can exist another method of healing. In
   other words, the world can contain two rational and effective medical
   systems, both describing the same phenomena, but describing them differently.
   Once we accept these premises, we can begin to understand the Chinese view
   of physiology.

I’ll give you a taste of that ‘physiology’ below, but first know that for
Kaptchuk, Western medicine suffers from a severe case of reductionism, whereas
Chinese medicine is far more interested in you as a whole person:

   Western medicine is concerned mainly with isolable disease categories or
   agents of disease, which it zeroes in on, isolates, and tries to change,
   control, or destroy. The Western physician starts with a symptom, then
   searches for the underlying mechanism—a precise cause for a specific disease…

   The Chinese physician, in contrast, directs his or her attention to the
   complete physiological and psychological individual. All relevant
   information, including the symptom as well as the patient’s other general
   characteristics, is gathered and woven together until it forms what Chinese
   medicine calls a “pattern of disharmony.”…Oriental diagnostic technique does 
   not turn up a specific disease entity or a precise cause, but renders an
   almost poetic, yet workable, description of a whole person.

“An Effective Healing Method”

Kaptchuk asserts that Chinese medicine considers some things important that
Western medicine does not, and vice versa:

   …Chinese medical theory does not have the concept of a nervous system.
   Nevertheless, it has been demonstrated that Chinese medicine can be used to
   treat neurological disorders. Similarly, Chinese medicine does not perceive
   an endocrine system, yet it is used to treat what Western medicine calls
   endocrine disorders. Nor does traditional Chinese medicine recognize the
   bacteria Streptococcus pneumoniae as a pathological cause of pneumonia [sic],
   yet often it effectively treats the disease.

The first two claims are trivially true, of course, but beg the relevant
question: the humoral system of medicine was also used to treat all sorts of
diseases, as has every pre-scientific form of medicine. The pneumonia claim is
another matter, for which Kaptchuk doesn’t offer particularly convincing
evidence:

   …the Chinese performed thousands of experiments and clinical studies during
   the fifties. The result was that in 1958 the Central Committee decided to
   give traditional and modern medicine equal respect and place in China…

   The pages of such studies fill entire libraries, yet it is not their quantity
   that is important, but rather their conclusions: that traditional Chinese
   medicine can hold its own, that it does work clinically.

   It is now evident that Chinese medicine is an effective healing method.

Kaptchuk proceeds to cite numerous, presumably positive or at least promising
studies from China, involving heart disease, cancer, kidney disease, asthma,
encephalitis, diphtheria, acupuncture anesthesia, and more. He points out that
when these are “diseases recognized by the West,”

   the actual application and methodology are clearly Western in orientation.
   The theory of Yin and Yang and other traditional concepts are left behind…

   Fortunately for its future, however, the results of the studies generally
   demonstrate that traditional Chinese medicine does work best when left in the
   context of Chinese logic.

He continues to plead the case for the unfalsifiable:

   …the Chinese view of health and disease as inseparable from a specific person
   means that the treatment will be well tailored to that person. Such personal
   shaping seems to maximize the effectiveness of the therapies.

Nevertheless,

   Western clinical studies (done in China) of traditional Chinese medicine, by 
   proving its practical efficacy, have helped it win its battle for survival in
   the twentieth century, and promise it a place in the future of medicine.

Later, in a footnote, Kaptchuk mentions that those weren’t, like, real studies: 
they weren’t controlled, and many used “imprecise assessment methods. They would
most properly be called clinical observations.” Throughout the book he
continues to cite them in support of various unlikely cure claims.

Sometimes he just makes stuff up without even attempting to justify it:

   Chinese remedies are often more effective than Western ones, and they are
   always gentler and safer. Chinese prescriptions, for example, do not produce 
   side effects because they are balanced to reflect a patient’s entire state of
   being.

   Chinese medicine, because it emphasizes balance and relationship more than
   measurable quantity, can also frequently discover and treat a disorder before
   it is perceptible by the most sophisticated Western diagnostic techniques.
   Chinese medicine is capable of touching those places that evade the
   microscope…

Woah. Dr. Epstein, did you even read this stuff? Dr. Ernst? OK: Dossey, Weil,
Berman, we expect them to quack right along, but really. Dr. Delbanco? (He’s not
one of the reviewers quoted above, but one of my former mentors at Harvard. He 
told me a few years ago that he’d been Kaptchuk’s patron. Did he read this
book?)

Kaptchuk never explains the real reasons that “the Central Committee decided to 
give traditional and modern medicine equal respect and place in China,”
previously discussed here. In that post I also showed how one of the passages
quoted above morph’d from the 1983 edition to the 2000 edition of The Web; it
isn’t flattering to the ideal of intellectual honesty.

“Images of the Macrocosm”

What about that Chinese view of physiology? It turns out that Kaptchuk, who
coined the phrase, asserts only a few pages later that there is no such thing.
We already suspected that, but let’s play along:

   The highly developed constructs [sic] of chemistry, biochemistry, anatomy,
   and physiology that form the groundwork for modern Western medicine are of
   little importance to the Chinese…Chinese medicine therefore has a very
   limited theory of the human organism itself.

But didn’t he tell us that the Chinese physician directs his or her attention to
the complete physiological and psychological individual? I guess it depends on 
what your definition of “truth” is:

   The essential ideas of Chinese medicine…are cultural and speculative
   constructs that provide orientation and direction for the practical patient
   situation…The ‘truth’ of these ideas lies in the way the physician can use
   them to treat real people with real complaints.

Maybe we’re getting somewhere, because the essential ideas are certainly
cultural and speculative constructs; but there are those real complaints again, 
such as pneumococcal pneumonia. I thank Kaptchuk for now having made it clear
that I needn’t go into excruciating detail about what I’d imagined he meant by
the “Chinese view of physiology,” even as I cringe when I consider that he
probably hadn’t intended to insult Chinese people in general.

But wait:

   For the Chinese, Qi is not a metaphor; it is a real phenomenon that makes
   possible integrative descriptions of bodily changes.

Such contradictions are rampant throughout the book (and ya gotta love those
“integrative descriptions”):

   Chinese medicine is not primarily quantitative.

But:

   It has standards of measurement that allow practitioners systematically to
   describe, diagnose, and treat illness.

Aren’t measurements quantitative? Silly, Western me:

   Its measurements, however, are not the linear yardsticks of weight, number,
   time, and volume used by modern science but rather images of the macrocosm.

Hmmm. Images of the macrocosm: simple, lucid, rational, understandable,
demystifying—and each one a measurement to boot! Heck, no less a measurement
than Dolores Krieger’s, and the macrocosm’s been around for a helluva lot
longer.

The “Chinese View of Physiology”

The ancient Chinese, according to Kaptchuk, were totally into Functions and
Relationships. I had therefore imagined that by “physiology” he must have meant 
the “Fundamental Substances”—Qi (“we can perhaps think of Qi as matter on the
verge of becoming energy, or energy at the point of materializing”), Blood (“not
the same as what the West calls blood”), Jing (“Essence”), Shen (“Spirit”) and 
Fluids (“bodily liquids other than Blood”)—; and the Organs (“The Harmonious
Landscape”: Yin Organs are Heart, Lungs, Spleen, Liver, and Kidneys; Yang Organs
are Gall Bladder, Stomach, Small Intestine, Large Intestine, Bladder, and
Triple Burner; Curious Organs are Brain, Marrow, Bone, Blood Vessels, Uterus,
and Gall Bladder again); and, of course, how they all work together to get
things done. That’s physiology!

The Chinese view, according to Kaptchuk? Let’s see:

   The Heart:

  1. ‘rules the Blood and Blood vessels’

  2. ‘stores the Shen [Spirit]‘

  3. ‘opens into the tongue’

   The Lungs:

  1. ‘rule Qi’

  2. ‘move and adjust the Water channels’

  3. ‘are the upper origin of water’

  4. ‘rule the exterior of the body’

  5. ‘open into the nose’

   The Spleen:

  1. ‘rules transformation and transportation’

  2. ‘governs the blood’

  3. ‘rules the raising of the pure’

  4. ‘rules the muscles, flesh,’ and the four limbs

  5. is the origin of Qi and Blood

  6. ‘opens into the mouth’

Organs vs. organs

It goes on and on, but I think you get the point. Kaptchuk insists that the
ancient Chinese did not seriously intend to portray those Organs as real:

   …the Chinese have no system of anatomy comparable to that of the West.

   In China, internal anatomy is generally irrelevant to clinical practice.

   The Heart, Lung and Kidneys of this volume are not a physical heart, lung, or
   kidneys; instead they are personae in a descriptive drama of health and
   disease.

   The Organs of the body, defined as they are by their functions and
   relationships, are another part of the bodily web. They cannot be discussed
   out of context. The Chinese notions about Organs (or anything else) are not
   meant to be hard pieces of a theory that can be proved or disproved. They are
   part of an organizing network to be used when convenient. The Chinese would 
   be indifferent to proof in our accustomed scientific sense.

   China’s lack of an anatomical theory like the West’s does not mean its system
   is unscientific; it means only that there exist alternate systems of
   thought, one Eastern, one Western.

What are the differences between the two? Here is the remainder of the paragraph
partially quoted above:

   The tendency of Chinese thought is to seek out dynamic functional activity
   rather than to look for the fixed somatic structures that perform the
   activities. Because of this, the Chinese have no system of anatomy comparable
   to that of the West. Thus, for example, the Organ known as the Liver is for 
   the Chinese very different from the Western liver. The Chinese Liver is
   defined first by the functions associated with it, the Western liver by its
   physical structure. This divergence makes it possible for Chinese medicine to
   identify Organs not recognized by the West—such as the Triple Burner—and for
   it not to recognize organs and glands clearly identified by Western
   medicine—such as the pancreas and the adrenal glands.

So it seems that in the West, physicians view organs in much the same way that
butchers do: as mere “somatic structures,” without regard to their functions and
relationships. This is nonsense, of course. I’m sure that every MD who was
trained at least since the Flexner Report has thought of organs as being part of
an anatomical and physiological whole, with countless, real functions and
functional relationships among them, more of which are being discovered all the 
time. That’s physiology!

In reality, the ancient Chinese rarely dissected cadavres, so a straightforward 
explanation for their Organ confusion is the same as that for the centuries-long
persistence of Galen’s erroneous anatomy in the West: prior to the last few
hundred years the Chinese, like the Europeans, didn’t know any better. What
anatomical information they had likely came from fleeting observations of
mangled soldiers on battlefields, by extrapolating from the butchery of farm
animals or occasional dissections of primates, and from very rare, mostly
secretive dissections of human cadavres. Because such dissections were frowned
upon, and Arguments from Authority were ‘privileged’ in both cultures until
recently, even legitimate challenges to conventional wisdom, if there were any, 
were not appreciated.

Kaptchuk knows some of this but, once again, you have to go to the small print
of a footnote at the end of the chapter to find the relevant passage:

   China…had Confucian religious and ethical prohibitions against dissection…

The straightforward explanation is supported by some of Kaptchuk’s Organ
descriptions being crudely accurate (the lungs really do “open into the nose”;
the Stomach does “receive and ripen” food) and by some being inaccurate in ways 
that are understandable from a simplistic, purely anatomical point of view. For 
example, according to Kaptchuk, the “Kidneys are called the ‘root of life’…the
source of reproduction,” and dysfunctions thereof are responsible for “sterility
or impotence…or lack of sexual maturation.” Well, no, the kidneys have almost
nothing to do with those things, but you might think otherwise if you knew only 
that there are tubes that connect them to the bladder and the bladder to the
external genitalia. So much for an understanding of function and relationships.

An “Important Taoist Notion”

There is nothing shameful about a pre-scientific history; all cultures have gone
through it. So why the subterfuge? Apparently the straightforward explanation
evokes a Pattern of Disharmony with Kaptchuk’s central claim:

   Chinese medicine is a coherent system of thought that does not require
   validation by the West as an intellectual construct. Intellectually, the way 
   to approach Chinese concepts is to see whether they are internally logical
   and consistent, not to disguise them as Western concepts or dismiss them
   because they do not conform to Western notions. And the system is internally 
   consistent—it is an organization of all the observable manifestations of the 
   body into an integrated set of functions and relationships. Understanding of 
   these functions and relationships enables the practitioner to identify and
   treat a disharmony in them.

And finally, his absolute, you-got-no-answer-for-this trump card:

   The important Taoist notion—that the Tao (or Dao, the balanced and harmonious
   Way) that can be talked about and described is not the Tao—pervades
   medicine.

Ya gotta love the Gish Gallop. You also gotta appreciate how that important
Taoist notion morphs, almost seamlessly, into current Quantum Quackery, with its
own purported trump cards, misplaced versions of the Observer Effect and of
Quantum Entanglement. This is no mere coincidence: Quantum Mysticism was all the
rage during the 1970s, especially with the publication of Fritjof Capra’s
annoying book, The Tao of Physics. Kaptchuk had apparently read another such
book, The Dancing Wu-Li Masters, from which he borrowed this quotation
attributed to physicist David Bohm:

Parts…are seen to be an immediate connection, in which their dynamical
relationships depend, in an irreproducible way, on the state of the whole system
(and, indeed, on that of broader systems in which they are contained, extending
ultimately and in principle to the entire universe). Thus, one is led to a new 
notion of unbroken wholeness which denies the classical idea of analyzability of
the world into separately and independently existent parts…

That works perfectly for someone who is hell-bent on dissing “reductionism” in
Western medicine. There is that little problem of physiology, though…ya gotta
wonder how all those wise reviewers missed it and just about everything else.

But back to ‘observable manifestations of the body’: doesn’t their being
‘observable’ imply that they are real, not just ‘internally logical and
consistent’? Which, by the way, sounds awfully ‘Western’ to me. Oops, I stumbled
again: throughout the book Kaptchuk refers to “Chinese logic”; that must be
different from Western logic.

OK, I’ll try to be a little less snide. It’s possible that a system of thought
can be coherent and internally logical and consistent, and yet still not be
valid. Astrology, or at least some schools of it, could be such a system.
Homeopathy could be another. So could the activities of the Tooth Fairy. There
is also the question of just how coherent and logical and consistent Chinese
medicine is. I hope this is becoming evident throughout this review.

Meridians: Interior vs. Exterior

Meridians are another important part of the Chinese view of anatomy and
physiology:

   Meridians are channels or pathways that carry Qi and Blood through the body. 
   They are not blood vessels. Rather, they comprise an invisible network that
   links together all the Fundamental Substances and Organs…The Nei Jing says:
   ‘The Meridians move the Qi and Blood, regulate Yin and Yang, moisten the
   tendons and bones, benefit the joints.’

Are we to take such pronouncements literally? After all, “The Chinese notions
about Organs (or anything else) are not meant to be hard pieces of a theory that
can be proved or disproved.” Remember, there are many contradictions in this
book:

   In Chinese Meridian theory, these channels are unseen but are thought to
   embody a physical reality—the Substances Qi and Blood move along them,
   carrying nourishment and strength.

   The Meridians connect the interior of the body with the exterior. (As has
   been said earlier, the distinction between inner and outer has more to do
   with significance than with place—the interior is more important than the
   exterior.)

Huh? But we were just told that the Meridians embody a physical reality. So do
they or don’t they?

   This is the basis for acupuncture theory, that working with points on the
   surface of the body will affect what goes on inside the body, because it
   affects the activity of the Substances that are traveling through the
   Meridians. Most acupuncture points relate to the Meridians and most herbs a
   doctor prescribes will enter one or more Meridian pathways.

Well, the ‘exterior’ seems to really mean the exterior, i.e., the surface. But
does “inside the body” not mean the “interior”? After all, “the interior is more
important than the exterior.” But “the distinction between inner and outer has 
more to do with significance than with place,” and elsewhere Kaptchuk tells us
that “in China, internal anatomy is generally irrelevant to clinical practice.” 
This is making me dizzy.

Kaptchuk next discusses the number of meridians and the number of acupuncture
points, without mentioning their relation to astrology. Throughout the book he
also fails to deal adequately with the abundance of military, political,
geographical, and meteorological metaphors in pre-scientific Chinese medicine,
as well as the conspicuous numerology (the number 5 recurs over and over again).

More rigorous historians, such as Paul Unschuld, have made compelling arguments 
that the Chinese actually thought of those entities as offering important
insights—not merely convenient terms—for medical ‘theory.’ Unschuld reports that
what Kaptchuk calls “Yin and Yang Organs,” the Chinese call “depot and palace
organs,” respectively, even if they are “yin-yang pairs.” Unschuld does not
agree with Kaptchuk’s mythologic view of Chinese ‘organs’; he (Unschuld) states 
that they were “understood as actual morphologic entities.” He also spells them 
in the lower case. According to Unschuld, such concepts as “stagnant qi” or
“blocked qi” were likely derived from irrigation systems in farming. Such views 
would be an embarrassment to the claim that

   …the world can contain two rational and effective medical systems, both
   describing the same phenomena, but describing them differently.

Patterns of Disharmony

Kaptchuk tells us that the Chinese are (were) not concerned with ultimate
causes, but with patterns:

   There is no distinction between the illness itself and the factor that
   “caused” it. The question of cause becomes incidental. In this sense, the
   word ’cause’ is almost a synonym for ‘effect.’ In Chinese pattern-thinking,
   what might at first seem to be a cause becomes part of the pattern,
   indistinguishable and inseparable from the effect. Pattern-thinking subsumes 
   the cause, defining it in terms of the effect and making it part of the total
   pattern. What we in the West call a cause has little importance in Chinese
   thought. The lines of causality are bent into circles.

This concept is the basis for the title of the book: The Web that Has no Weaver.
I have no reason to doubt that such circular thinking was true for some periods
or for some aspects of pre-scientific Chinese medicine, because I don’t really 
know all that much about it other than what I’ve read in Kaptchuk’s book, in a
couple of Unschuld’s books, and in a few essays here and there. I do suspect
that Chinese physicians who held this view would have nevertheless jumped at the
chance to learn about the real causes of disease, as they did in the late 19th 
century when the Germ Theory reached them, and as modern Chinese physicians are 
now doing through scientific research.

It seems, moreover, that not all pre-scientific Chinese physicians subscribed to
the “cause has little importance” doctrine. According to Unschuld,

   When a doctor who felt bound to the tradition of the medicine of systematic
   correspondence treated a patient, it was necessary for him to determine
   categorically which evil was afflicting the patient, via what organ the evil 
   (if of exogenous origin) had found its way into the body, where it was
   currently located in the organism, what damage it had already caused in the
   economy of qi, and what other spheres it could possibly move into.

Back to Kaptchuk. Here are some of the “signs” that he would call ‘both cause
and effect’ in Patterns of Disharmony: the Six Pernicious Influences (also
called the Six Evils)—Wind, Cold, Fire or Heat, Dampness, Dryness, Summer Heat; 
the Seven Emotions—joy, anger, sadness, grief, pensiveness, fear, fright. Here
are the Eight Principal Patterns of Disharmony: Yin/Yang, Interior/Exterior,
Deficiency/Excess, Cold/Hot. According to Kaptchuk, the Eight Principal Patterns
“are the fundamental model for mediating between [the] two realms” of Yin/Yang 
and the “signs of disharmony.”

Various combinations of these, which are countless, are beyond my patience to
attempt to comprehend. The book is sprinkled with “clinical sketches,” however, 
which can help to give a flavor of how such Patterns are used. I’ll reproduce a 
couple of them shortly.

Tongue Diagnosis, Pulse Diagnosis and the $1 Million Challenge

Of the Four Examinations in Chinese medicine—Looking, Listening and Smelling,
Asking, and Touching—there are two “pillars”: observing (Looking) at the tongue 
and feeling (Touching) the pulse. Kaptchuk writes that one of his own teachers
“described the tongue as a piece of litmus paper that reveals the basic
qualities of a disharmony.” Let’s see if this is credible. The following is a
small sample of nearly four pages of tongue descriptions:

   A scarlet tongue is deeper red than a red tongue, and points to an extreme
   Heat condition. In a disharmony characterized by External Heat, it indicates 
   that Heat has entered the deepest levels of the body.

   A purple tongue usually indicates that the Qi and Blood are not moving
   harmoniously and that there is a pattern of Stagnant Qi or Congealed Blood…A 
   purple tongue may also be associated with the Liver’s failure to flow or
   spread properly.

   Moss that is puddled with moisture is a sign of Excess Fluids, usually due to
   Deficient Yang (or Fire, the body’s internal Heat), but is also a possible
   sign of other patterns, such as Dampness.

   A moss that appears firmly implanted on the tongue body, like grass sprouting
   from the ground, signifies strong Spleen and Stomach Qi. Moss that appears
   to be floating on the surface of the tongue is a sign of weak Spleen and
   Stomach Qi.

   A greasy moss appears to be a thick, oily film covering the tongue or a
   portion of it. It can resemble a layer of white petroleum jelly or butter,
   and is a sign of Mucus or Dampness in the body.

   A peeled tongue may be a sign of Deficient Yin or Fluids, or of Spleen Qi too
   weak to raise smoke.

   A stiff tongue lacks flexibility…This type of tongue usually implies a Wind
   Pernicious Influence or Mucus obstructing the Heart Qi.

   A trembling tongue seems to wiggle uncontrollably. When this type of tongue
   is pale, it is a sign that Qi is insufficient to regulate proper movement. If
   the tongue is red, the diagnosis is usually Internal Wind moving the tongue.

   …particular areas of the tongue are said to correspond to particular
   Organs…which are helpful but are never considered absolute.

I quoted those passages not so much to demonstrate their absurdity—though absurd
they most certainly are—as to demonstrate their obvious hopelessness as
repeatable, agreed-upon physical findings (remember that there are many more
where those came from). They remind me of the 35 or so shades of sputum that are
listed in homeopathic repertories, each one requiring a match with about the
same number of sputum textures, that must further be matched to each of hundreds
or thousands of other multi-faceted “symptoms”; and even one little “mistake”
among all those choices will purportedly make the crucial difference between
choosing the simillimum and choosing a dud. (Look here, pp. 79-81)

Has a study ever shown inter-rater reliabilty for Chinese tongue diagnosis? Not 
that I know of. A couple of abstracts suggest the opposite, as you’d expect.

What about pulse diagnosis? This is the most important of all the Examinations, 
and is “far more complex than what we know in the modern West.” Kaptchuk takes
it quite seriously. He spends about 16 pages describing “the 28 basic pulses.”
They are categorized according to Depth, Speed, Width, Strength, Shape, Length, 
and Rhythm; some of them are the Floating Pulse, Sinking Pulse, Thin Pulse, Big 
Pulse, Full Pulse, Empty Pulse, Slippery Pulse, Choppy Pulse, Tight Pulse, Short
Pulse, Long Pulse, Knotted Pulse, Flooding Pulse, Soggy Pulse, Leather Pulse,
Spinning Bean Pulse. If these weren’t trouble enough, according to Kaptchuk they
“are more often found in combination than in their pure form…”

Thus, writes Kaptchuk,

   …pulse taking approaches the subtlety and complexity that bespeaks an art. It
   requires thorough training, great experience, and the gift of sensitivity.
   When the physician takes a pulse, he or she is alert to a tremendous array of
   sensations that must be expertly understood and arranged as a unity—the
   “feel” of an individual pulse…

   …it is clear that the system is extremely complex, capable of infinite
   refinement. Pulse diagnosis is a very sophisticated art. It demands sublety
   and wisdom on the part of the physician to discern the relative importance of
   each variable and to make of them all an intelligent and precise
   diagnosis—to weave a useful pattern.

Wiser Weasel Words of Woo have Warely been Weaved.©

How is the pulse taken and what can it tell the physician? Rather than quote
Kaptchuk, I’ll turn to Unschuld, who explains it in a clearer fashion, complete 
with a topographical metaphor that the ancient Chinese apparently took
seriously. He notes that there are several methods:

   One method was based on the notion that at the high point of the styloid
   process below (medial to) the wrist there was an imaginary line, called the
   “pass,” as a narrow passage through mountains. When a finger feels the pulse 
   with light pressure above the “pass,” i.e., toward the wrist, the pulse
   offers evidence about the state of the lung and heart. The connection lies in
   the fact that the imaginary line, the “pass,” corresponds to the diaphragm
   in the human body. The lung and heart are located above this separation, in
   the yang area of the body. The lung and heart therefore manifest in pulse
   above the “pass” in the yang region. Below the pass, in the yin region, the
   pulse reflects the condition of the liver and kidney, organs which lie below 
   the diaphragm in the yin region of the body. Right on the pass, the middle of
   the three fingers feels the state of the spleen, the organ that lies closest
   to the diaphragm.

   A second method of pulse taking uses the pressure of a single finger. The
   finger exerts a light pressure in the area of the pass and feels the pulse
   just below the skin, that is, in a yang region, which provides information
   about the lung and heart. Somewhat greater pressure allows the finger to
   penetrate the level where the pulse of the spleen can be felt. Applying still
   greater pressure so that the fingertip enters the yin region and almost
   reaches the bone, the level of the liver and kidneys is reached.

   This method stands alongside yet another by which the finger, by application 
   of different degrees of pressure, feels the state of the five organs each at 
   five different levels.

The “states” of the organs include the same possibilities that we saw for tongue
diagnosis, e.g., dampness, cold, heat, congealed blood, stagnant qi, etc. It
should be obvious to anyone with even a passing knowledge of anatomy and
physiology, and with even a passing sense of reality—which apparently excludes
the reviewers quoted above, assuming that they read the book—that the claims
made for ancient Chinese pulse-taking are ridiculous. Dampness aside, if I were 
in charge of the Randi $1 million challenge, I’d offer it to anyone who could
demonstrate that the maneuvres described above can repeatably yield information 
distinctly referable to each of the named organs, other than, of course, the
heart.

The reports of dismal inter-rater reliability for tongue diagnosis also apply to
pulse diagnosis.

“Clinical Sketches”

   A patient suddenly gets a high fever and a severe sore throat. She has a red 
   face, a dry, hacking cough, and no fear of cold. A Western physician takes a 
   throat culture and discovers the presence of Group A beta hemolytic
   streptococcus. Antibiotics are prescribed, with good results. If the same
   patient had gone to a Chinese physician, he very likely would have diagnosed 
   a Heat Pernicious Influence. Herbs like Coptis and Scutellena, which disperse
   and cool Fire, would have been prescribed. The results would have been
   adequate though perhaps slower to achieve than with the antibiotic treatment.
   Modern research shows, incidentally, that both Coptis and Scutellena inhibit
   the growth of streptococcus bacteria. Acupuncture treatment, such as
   needling Large Intestine 4 (He-gu, Adjoining Valleys), to cool Fire, would in
   this case have offered some symptomatic relief and heightened the body’s
   resistance, but would have been less effective than herbs.

Oh really? I haven’t pursued the claim made for the two herbs, but I suspect it 
goes something like this. Acupuncture would have “heightened the body’s
resistance”? Spare me. The bigger problem is the blithe, ignorant dismissal of
effective medicine: antibiotics don’t shorten the duration of uncomplicated
acute streptococcal pharyngitis, so the ‘results’ of Chinese intervention, at
least the results that Kaptchuk seems to be talking about, would have been no
“slower to achieve.” What antibiotics do in this case—and the entire reason for 
taking them—is to prevent complications, most importantly post-streptococcal
rheumatic fever. And you can bet, dollars to donuts, that neither the herbs nor 
acupuncture will accomplish that. Oops.

Here’s another Clinical Sketch, “taken from the author’s private practice”:

   A woman, aged twenty-six, complained of wheezing, difficulty in breathing,
   and coughing, especially in the middle of the night. The pattern had begun
   suddenly when the patient was sixteen years old and had gotten steadily
   worse. The patient constantly felt tightness in her chest, unrelated to
   seasonal changes, and when an attack started, there was much sneezing and
   coughing. Phlegm with a thick and yellow quality was produced. The patient’s 
   medical history was otherwise insignificant. Her appetite was good and her
   stools and urination were normal. She was very thin, with dark rings under
   her eyes. Her energy level was good except during an attack, and she did not 
   report any emotional stress but seemed jumpy and anxious. Otherwise, her Shen
   was harmonious and clear. Her tongue was red and cracked in the middle and
   had scattered red dots. Her pulse was rapid (ninety-six beats per minute) and
   also slippery and slightly thin.

   When she came for treatment, she was taking Western medication but wanted an 
   alternative because the drugs made her dizzy, tired, and nauseated.

   Many of the signs pointed to the pattern of Heat in the Lungs: yellow phlegm,
   rapid pulse, red tongue, and thirst. Other signs, such as the thin body, the
   chronic nature of the disorder, the peeled and cracked tongue, and thin
   pulse, pointed to Deficient Yin. The wheezing, thick phlegm, and slippery
   pulse indicated that Mucus was present. A combination of acupuncture and
   herbal treatments was administered to cool the Lung Heat, nourish the Yin of 
   the Lungs, and eliminate Mucus. This therapy brought the symptoms under
   control within two weeks.

   Although the patient is still subject to occasional attacks, they are much
   less frequent and intense. When needed, she takes herbs or uses an herbal
   inhalator [sic].

Kinda sounds like asthma, no? You’d think he might’ve asked about cigarette
smoke, or maybe cats or dust in her abode. How about listening to her lungs, or 
maybe even considering (gasp) an objective test? Wasn’t he expected to gather
“all relevant information?” (No matter, he nailed the tongue and pulse exams.)
An “herbal inhalator”?

Conclusion

How does the Web that Has No Weaver measure up (in the macrocosmic sense, of
course) to the reviewers’ promises? Let’s see: is it a book that’s easy to read 
and understandable to Westerners, that is rational, that ‘demystifies’ its
subject, that will provide a ‘deep’ understanding of healing, that will “expand 
[our] understanding of the causes and treatment of disease,” and that heralds a 
‘synthesis’ of Eastern and Western medicine?

Wow. No. In a nutshell, there is sophistry on nearly every page. It continues to
astound me that such drivel could have been taken seriously by academic
physicians. I suppose the two most likely explanations are, in this order, that 
they didn’t read the book—can’t say I blame’em, it was like wading through
molasses—or that they were utterly fooled by the rampant, misleading language.
This post could have been the rilly advanced course in that little bundle, and
let’s face it, most academics have just not had the privilege of learning about 
such esoterica. Whatever else you can say about Kaptchuk, he’s a Master of
Misrepresentation.

Some might quibble with my not having cited some reasonable or even insightful
passages in the book. It’s true that there are a few, and if taken out of
context they can make the author look quite respectable, if you’ll excuse the
tongue-in-cheek Bostonian observation. Put’em back in context, however,
juxtaposed with all the meaningless adjectives, fallacies, contradictions,
unsupported claims and the rest, and it’s ever more clear: sophistry. Ya gotta
look at the whole.

I heard Kaptchuk speak at the 2001 Harvard Medical School “CAM” conference.
Early in his talk he recounted, in a defiant and triumphant tone that brought
cheers from the partisan audience, an episode during the 1980s—perhaps at about 
the time that he’d treated the woman in the second clinical sketch—when he’d
been under threat of arrest for practicing medicine without a license. Go
figure.

Systematic Review of Systematic Reviews of Acupuncture

No surprise – there is precious little evidence that acupuncture does anything.

Steven Novella on December 14, 2022

Link



Systematic reviews are a good way to see the big picture of what the evidence
for a particular medical intervention looks like. However, they are very
difficult to do well and often fall prey to their own methodological limitations
and biases. Therefore it is even better to look at a systematic review of
systematic reviews as a way of looking at the overall pattern of the evidence.
As we have discussed many times on SBM, it is that overall pattern that tells us
if we are dealing with a real phenomenon or an illusion of the research (or
just a placebo effect).

A systematic review of systematic reviews of acupuncture for a variety of
indications published in November 2022 gives us an opportunity to look at that
pattern. This is the same evidence we have been reviewing here for years, and so
I don’t expect any surprises; still, a thorough look at the evidence is
instructive. Before I dive into the study, let’s review what acupuncture is and 
why I am skeptical of its efficacy.

Acupuncture is generally defined as a practice involving inserting thin needles 
into acupuncture points on the body that correspond to specific physiological
functions and therefore can be used to produce specific clinical outcomes. I
recently reviewed an acupuncture systematic review for back pain in pregnancy
and went over many of the problems with acupuncture research and claims. I also 
published a detailed analysis of acupuncture with David Colquhoun that was very 
critical. Here are my main criticisms of acupuncture as a medical practice and
belief system:

  1. Acupuncture points have no basis in anatomy, physiology, or neuroscience and
    essentially they don’t exist.

  2. Acupuncture has no plausible or established mechanism, and many practitioners 
    reference “chi” which is a nonexistent magical life force.

  3. Acupuncturists claim that acupuncture can work for a wide variety of medical
    conditions that have nothing functionally to do with each other.

  4. Acupuncturists can’t agree on where alleged acupuncture points are and what
    they do. Therefore, different studies of the same condition often use
    different sets of points.

  5. After decades of research and thousands of studies there isn’t a single
    clearly established condition for which acupuncture has demonstrated
    efficacy.

  6. There is evidence of extreme researcher and publication bias in the
    acupuncture literature.

In short, acupuncture has all the red flags of fake science and placebo
medicine, and there is no legitimate scientific reason to think that it is real.
There have been thousands of clinical studies looking at acupuncture for
various conditions, most of which are very low quality and even fatally flawed. 
But when you conduct thousands of studies, especially with some wiggle room in
the methods, many of them are going to be positive, even with a completely null 
effect. We see this, for example, in the homeopathy literature. Therefore, if my
analysis above is fair and accurate, we would expect the same pattern of
outcome in the acupuncture literature that we see in the homeopathy literature.

One particular feature that acupuncture research shares with homeopathy research
is that it is culture-dependent (another red flag). For acupuncture, the effect
is even more dramatic. A 1998 systematic review, with an update in 2014, showed
that acupuncture clinical trials based in China are 100% positive. Edzard Ernst
characterizes this as an “open secret” that data is simply fabricated in China 
to support acupuncture. Even if a treatment worked with a large effect size, we 
still would not see a 100% positive rate in the literature. That is essentially 
slam-dunk evidence for some combination of publication bias and researcher bias.
Of course, these biased Chinese acupuncture studies contaminate all systematic 
reviews of acupuncture (unless they are systematically excluded, which I have
never seen).

Further, as we saw with my most recent review of acupuncture for back pain in
pregnancy, even systematic reviews which are clearly negative are presented as
if they are positive. The current reviewers seem to take the author’s
conclusions at face value, which is highly problematic when dealing with
acupuncture.

So – taking all these caveats into consideration, what does the current review
of reviews show? It’s actually amazing how weak and negative the evidence is,
given all the biases in the literature. Here is the author’s overall big picture
take on the evidence:

   Despite a vast number of randomized trials, systematic reviews of acupuncture
   for adult health conditions have rated only a minority of conclusions as
   high- or moderate-certainty evidence, and most of these were about
   comparisons with sham treatment or had conclusions of no benefit of
   acupuncture. Conclusions with moderate or high-certainty evidence that
   acupuncture is superior to other active therapies were rare.

In other words – most of the acupuncture evidence is crap. This is another
pattern we see commonly with fake treatments, and we have to seriously ask –
after decades and thousands of studies of acupuncture, why do a low-quality
study at all? The methods and technology for high quality acupuncture studies
exist. But of course, high quality studies are frustratingly negative, which may
be why there are so many low quality studies still being performed.

Of the 56 health condition reviewed here, only 4 had high-quality evidence. Of
those four, one was negative – for assistive reproduction, essentially there
were no increases in the chance of success with implantation. One, dealing with 
stroke recovery, used electroacupuncture, which is not acupuncture but rather
electrical nerve stimulation. This intervention also included conventional
interventions. Meanwhile, another review of stroke not including
electroacupuncture was negative.

The other two that involved acupuncture with positive results were for shoulder 
pain and fibromyalgia, and they both had low numbers of studies. There wasn’t a 
single indication which had a high number of high quality studies showing a
positive effect. The fibromyalgia review contained only 8 studies, two of which 
were electroacupuncture, with mixed results. Even though some of these studies
compared acupuncture to acupuncture on the “wrong” points, there was no
agreement across studies which were the correct and which were the wrong points,
rendering the comparison meaningless.

The review of shoulder pain was actually part of a larger review looking at a
variety of musculoskeletal conditions. This suffered the same problem as the
fibromyalgia review – low number of studies, and heterogeneity in terms of
controls and the alleged acupuncture points used. Risk of bias in these studies 
also tends to be high. And again, none control for the clearly demonstrated
publication bias in Chinese studies.

Given that there are several thousand published clinical trials looking at
acupuncture, over decades, if acupuncture actually worked for anything I would
think that by now we would be seeing a clear signal in the data – but we are
not. As this review demonstrates, most of the evidence is low quality, and
almost none is deemed high quality evidence. Only two subsets had high quality
evidence of acupuncture showing an effect, and these suffered from small numbers
and methodological issues that were overlooked by the reviewers. Further, if
you do enough studies for enough conditions, you’re going to come up with some
positive evidence just by chance alone, especially if you throw in a little
publication bias.

The overall pattern of the acupuncture literature, therefore, is clearly
negative. It is consistent, I would even argue highly predictive, of a null
phenomenon. We see this same pattern with other scientifically implausible
claims, such as ESP and homeopathy. It’s likely not a coincidence.

An Acupuncture Meta-Analysis

Steven Novella on September 12, 2012

Link

A recent meta-analysis of acupuncture studies for chronic pain by Vickers et al 
is getting a great deal of press. The authors’ conclusions are:

   Acupuncture is effective for the treatment of chronic pain and is therefore a
   reasonable referral option. Significant differences between true and sham
   acupuncture indicate that acupuncture is more than a placebo. However, these 
   differences are relatively modest, suggesting that factors in addition to the
   specific effects of needling are important contributors to the therapeutic
   effects of acupuncture.

News reports generally reflect this conclusion – acupuncture works, but mostly
(although not entirely) through placebo effect, but that’s OK.

I took a close look at the study and find that the authors display considerable 
pro-acupuncture bias in their analysis and discussion. They clearly want
acupuncture to work. That aside, the data are simply not compelling, and the
authors, in my opinion, grossly overcall the results, which are compatible with 
the conclusion that there are no specific effects to acupuncture beyond placebo.

The meta-analysis looked at 29 randomized clinical trials of acupuncture in back
pain, neck pain, headache, and osteoarthritis, involving both sham and
no-acupuncture controls. The differences between acupuncture and no-acupuncture 
were large, reflecting an absolute reduction in pain of about a 30% (50%
relative reduction). However, the authors acknowledge:

   Because the comparisons between acupuncture and no-acupuncture cannot be
   blinded, both performance and response bias are possible.

In other words – the unblinded comparison between acupuncture and no acupuncture
is entirely overwhelmed by bias and completely useless. The no acupuncture
control groups involved patients continuing to receive usual care (whatever they
were already receiving that was not effective, or sometimes just being told not
to get acupuncture). This was not a comparison to any specific medical
intervention. In other words, the subjects were aware they were receiving no
treatment.

It is curious that the authors would even bother to include such an analysis,
but they reveal their purpose in their discussion:

   Even though on average these effects are small, the clinical decision made by
   physicians and patients is not between true and sham acupuncture but between
   a referral to an acupuncturist or avoiding such a referral.

This is the agenda of acupuncture proponents – to use the non-specific effect of
receiving an intervention to promote the use of acupuncture. If a study shows
no significant difference between true and sham acupuncture, then they argue
that this placebo effect is enough to justify treatment. If the study (or in
this case a meta-analysis) shows a small difference, then they use that small
difference to justify the conclusion that acupuncture is real (even though the
specific effects are negligible) and then use the large non-specific effects to 
justify the treatment.

Either way, proponents are inappropriately leveraging placebo effects (which are
largely biases) to promote a treatment that has an effect size that is very
small and, in my opinion, overlaps with no effect at all.

The authors make much of the small effect difference in their meta-analysis
between true and sham acupuncture. They summarize their results by saying, if
the no intervention group has a pain of 60%, then true acupuncture reduces it to
30% and sham acupuncture to 35%. While this difference was statistically
significant in this meta-analysis, it is highly dubious to claim that the 5%
difference is clinically significant, or even perceptible. To me this is no
difference at all.

The primary difference between my opinion of this data and the authors’,
however, is that the authors are quick to conclude that because their data was
statistically significant that means there is a real physiological effect (if
modest) to acupuncture. This conclusion, however, reflects probable bias, but
certain naivete with regards to the reliability of clinical trials. This level
of difference is within the noise of clinical trials, which are simply not
precise enough to detect such a small difference.

The authors acknowledge:

   Similarly, while we considered the risk of bias of unblinding low in most
   studies comparing acupuncture and sham acupuncture, health care providers
   obviously were aware of the treatment provided, and, as such, a certain
   degree of bias of our effect estimate for specific effects cannot be entirely
   ruled out.

This is the understatement of the paper – a certain degree of bias cannot be
ruled out. What the last century of clinical research has clearly shown is that 
a significant amount of bias is guaranteed. All it takes is a little bias,
innocent exploitation of researcher degrees of freedom, and you have your 5%.

The authors acknowledge that there are a couple of studies that are outliers –
those by Vas et.al. had effect sizes 5 times that of the average. When you
remove these studies the effects are still significant. There is also researcher
bias in that the larger the study the smaller the effect size, but when you
remove small studies the effects are still significant. They also argue that
unpublished studies (publication bias) would be unlikely to cause their results.

However – when you add the effects from outliers, small studies, and publication
bias all together I wonder what the total effect is on the data (not even
including the fact that it is a certainty the data is polluted in the false
positive direction by researcher degrees of freedom).  The performance of a
meta-analysis introduces yet another layer of potential bias or distortion in
the methods of the meta-anslysis itself – how are studies chosen for inclusion, 
for example, and all the researcher degrees of freedom that apply to any study.

Conclusion

The Vickers acupuncture meta-analysis, despite the authors’ claims, does not
reveal anything new about the acupuncture literature, and does not provide
support for use of acupuncture as a legitimate medical intervention. The data
show that there is a large difference in outcome when an unblinded comparison is
made between treatment and no treatment – an unsurprising result that is of no 
clinical relevance and says nothing about acupuncture itself.

The comparison between true acupuncture and sham acupuncture shows only a small 
difference, which is likely not clinically significant or perceptible. More
importantly, this small difference is well within the degree of bias and noise
that are inherent to clinical trials. Researcher bias, publication bias,
outlying effects, and researcher degrees of freedom are more than enough to
explain such a small difference.   In other words – this data is insufficient to
reject the null hypothesis, even if we don’t consider the high implausibility
of acupuncture.

Further, meta-analysis itself is an imperfect tool that often does not predict
the results of large, rigorous, definitive clinical trials.  The best
acupuncture trials, those that are well-blinded and include placebo acupuncture,
show no specific effects.

Can we finally just say that acupuncture is nothing more than an elaborate
placebo?

David Gorski on September 16, 2012

Link

I realize that Steve blogged about this study earlier in the week, but since I
also commented on this particular study as my not-so-super-secret alter ego, I
figured it rated a place on SBM as well. I emphasized different aspects of the
study and tried to quantify exactly why, under even the most charitable
interpretation of the study possible, the effects are not clinically
significant. Besides, if the level of comments and e-mails is any indication,
there is sufficient interest in this particular study to rate a second post.

Not suprisingly, this study is about about acupuncture. Well, it’s not exactly a
study, it’s a meta-analysis that aggregates a whole lot of acupuncture studies 
in which this most popular of woos is administered to patients with chronic pain
from a variety of causes. It’s also being promoted all over the place with
painfully credulous headlines like:

  1. Study: Placebo or not, acupuncture helps with pain (What a horrible headline; 
    the very definition of “helping” is to do better than placebo. This was an
    AP story. Where’s Marilyn Marchione when you need her?

  2. Acupuncture May Actually Work for Pain After All

  3. Biological Implausibility Aside, Acupuncture Works (Uh, no. Not quite.)

  4. Acupuncture works, one way or another

  5. Does acupuncture work? New research suggests it does, for certain conditions

  6. Acupuncture may be helpful for chronic pain

  7. Not just a stab in the dark: The ancient Chinese therapy of acupuncture ‘does 
    help to relieve pain’ say US researchers

  8. Time for acupuncture to come in from the cold?

  9. Acupuncture Superior to Placebo, Usual Care for Chronic Pain (Et tu,
    Medscape?)

  10. Not Quackery: Acupuncture Does Relieve Pain

In deference to that last article, I was half-tempted to call this post
Quackery: Acupuncture does not relieve pain. Then there were news reports like
this:

              Unfortunately your browser does not support IFrames.

Watch More News Videos at ABC|2012 Presidential Election|Entertainment &
Celebrity News

And, of course, on accompanying the above news segment there was a story like
this describing a patient with chronic pain:

   In January 2009 she was referred to Dr. Jun Mao, a licensed physician and
   acupuncturist at the University of Pennsylvania.

   “The only thing I had not tried was acupuncture,” Zierler said.

   Now, a new review of research suggests that this ancient technique may truly 
   hold benefits for those suffering from certain forms of chronic pain.

   In a review of 29 previous well-designed studies, which together looked at
   almost 18,000 patients, researchers at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center
   found that acupuncture does, indeed, work for treating four chronic pain
   conditions: back and neck pain, osteoarthritis, chronic headache and shoulder
   pain.

   Even “placebo” acupuncture, where the practitioner only pretends to place the
   needle or places the needle in a random site, is effective at relieving
   pain, though true acupuncture works better.

And so was born the propaganda line for this particular study, namely that it’s 
huge; that it is the most compelling evidence thus far that acupuncture “works”;
that all that stuff about “sham acupuncture” being as good as “real
acupuncture” isn’t true. But is this study strong evidence of any of this? Let’s
go to the tape, as I like to say.

The study itself is from a group called the Acupuncture Trialists’
Collaboration. I don’t know about you, but the very existence of something
called the Acupuncture Trialists’ Collaboration is disturbing to me. Be that as 
it may, the study is Vickers et al, Acupuncture for Chronic Pain: Individual
Patient Data Meta-Analysis. It was just published online in the Archives of
Internal Medicine.

My first inclination when reading this was to apply a dictum to it that applies 
to all meta-analyses, no matter what the research question is; GIGO, Garbage In,
Garbage Out, just like a meta-analysis of acupuncture to treat headache four
years ago. On the other hand, on the surface, this meta-analysis looks like it’s
a big deal. It uses patient level data instead of aggregated data, which allows
for a better meta-analysis in most cases. It tries to restrict its included
studies to those with the highest methodological quality (although that doesn’t 
completely inoculate it from the GIGO label, as you will see).

So what the authors did was to search MEDLINE, ClinicalTrials.gov, and the
Cochrane Collaboration Central Register of Controlled Trials for studies testing
acupuncture against chronic pain. They then winnowed the pile of studies they
found using several criteria:

   Randomized controlled trials were eligible for analysis if they included at
   least 1 group receiving acupuncture needling and 1 group receiving either
   sham (placebo) acupuncture or no-acupuncture control. The RCTs must have
   accrued patients with 1 of 4 indications—nonspecific back or neck pain,
   shoulder pain, chronic headache, or osteoarthritis—with the additional
   criterion that the current episode of pain must be of at least 4 weeks
   duration for musculoskeletal disorders. There was no restriction on the type 
   of outcomemeasure, although we specified that the primary end point must be
   measured more than 4 weeks after the initial acupuncture treatment.

Do you see a problem yet? I do. It is not required that all studies included
have a sham placebo group. That means some studies were acupuncture versus no
acupuncture controls, the latter of which could include groups that got anywhere
from nothing to regular care. That’s just one problem that I see, because
mixing studies that compare acupuncture to no treatment, to sham treatment, or
to sham treatment and no treatment are comparing apples and oranges in a way.
Pooling such studies is inherently problematic.

There are other problems, but let’s first discuss what the study showed. First, 
Vickers et al reported that patients who underwent acupuncture had less pain.
That’s true. However, I find it very hard to be impressed by these results.
Indeed, they were most…underwhelming. Basically, the study reported that “real” 
acupuncture resulted in pain scores that were 0.23, 0.16, and 0.15 standard
deviations lower than sham controls and 0.55, 0.57, and 0.42 standard deviations
lower than no-acupuncture controls for back and neck pain, osteoarthritis, and 
chronic headaches, respectively. What does this mean? The authors themselves try
to put it into context:

   To give an example of what these effect sizes mean in real terms, a baseline 
   pain score on a 0 to 100 scale for a typical RCT might be 60. Given a
   standard deviation of 25, follow- up scores might be 43 in a no acupuncture
   group, 35 in a sham acupuncture group, and 30 in patients receiving true
   acupuncture. If response were defined in terms of a pain reduction of 50% or 
   more, response rates would be approximately 30%, 42.5%, and 50%,
   respectively.

One notes that Vickers et al have chosen a rather dramatic example, with large
numbers. For patients with chronic pain, it’s uncommon to have a 50% reduction
in pain scores, and the standard deviation they chose was rather large. By their
own argument, even if there weren’t any methodological issues with the
meta-analysis and their conclusions were completely justified, Vickers et al
have just unwittingly made the argument that the effect of acupuncture might be 
statistically significantly greater than placebo effects but that it’s almost
certainly not clinically significant. What Vickers et al are arguing is that a
change of 5 on a 0-100 pain scale (which would be a change of 0.5 on a 0-10 pain
scale), a subjective scale, is noticeable by patients. It’s probably not. There
is a concept referred to as “minimally clinically important difference” (MCID) 
defined as “the smallest difference in score in the domain of interest which
patients perceive as beneficial and which would mandate…a change in the
patient’s management.” A recent review looking at minimal detectable and
clinically relevant changes in pain scores in arthritis found a range in
absolute terms between 6.8 and 19.9. Tubach et al assessed only the improvement 
aspect of the MCID and defined the minimal clinically important improvement
(MCII) as the minimum improvement in the pain score reported by 75% of
osteoarthritis patients ranking their response as “good” and reported that the
MCII was -15.3 for hip osteoarthritis and -19.9 for knee osteoarthritis.

Here’s a hint: -5 (the difference between sham acupuncture and “real”
acupuncture) is not clinically significant. The only way you can even approach
clinical significance is to compare no-acupuncture controls versus acupuncture, 
in which case you’re adding placebo effects into any other effect observed, even
if that effect is real (which I highly doubt it to be). Indeed, Vickers et al
labor mightily to try to convince readers that this tiny effect, if it exists,
is not just statistically significant, but clinically significant. They doth
protest too much, methinks. In fact, I very much like how the grand master of
the scientific analysis of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM),
Edzard Ernst, put it:

   Edzard Ernst, emeritus professor of complementary medicine at the University 
   of Exeter, said the study “impressively and clearly” showed that the effects 
   of acupuncture were mostly due to placebo. “The differences between the
   results obtained with real and sham acupuncture are small and not clinically 
   relevant. Crucially, they are probably due to residual bias in these studies.
   Several investigations have shown that the verbal or non-verbal
   communication between the patient and the therapist is more important than
   the actual needling. If such factors would be accounted for, the effect of
   acupuncture on chronic pain might disappear completely.”

Which brings me to another major problem with this meta-analysis. It’s one that 
I noticed and one that Ernst also comments on. None of the studies included that
I perused were double blind, which means that there was the potential for
observational bias to creep into the study. While I concede that the authors did
a pretty good job of making sure that studies in which there was a possibility 
of what is known in the biz as unconcealed allocation; i.e., failure to protect 
the randomization process to guarantee that the treatment to be allocated is not
known before a subject is enrolled in the study (in studies with subjective
outcomes, like pain, unclear allocation concealment is associated with bias
towards beneficial effects), no attempt was made that I could identify to make
sure included trials were double blind. In studies of subjective outcomes,
blinding is almost certainly as important or more important than allocation
concealment, and double blinding is essential. As Ernst put it so well, a trial 
is “either both patient and therapist-blind, or not blind at all.” The
investigators appear to have only assessed the selected studies for whether
patient blinding was adequate, looking for descriptions of questionnaires in
which patients are asked to guess which group they were assigned to. Without
double blinding, it’s hard to call any of these trials included in this
meta-analysis “high quality.” And, yes, it is possible to double blind
acupuncture studies, as much as acupuncture fans try to argue otherwise.

Finally, there’s the issue of heterogeneity in the trials. The authors report a 
lot of heterogeneity for most of the analyses that were performed but gave one
of the sketchiest descriptions of how they actually calculated that
heterogeneity that I’ve ever seen in a meta-analysis anywhere. One wonders what 
the reviewers were thinking. For supposedly ascribing to the PRISMA methodology 
for high quality meta-analyses, which specifies the calculation of a statistic
(I2) for describing the heterogeneity of each meta-analysis comparison that is
done, the authors don’t live up to its principles in at least this one respect. 
They don’t report that statistic. That strikes me as more sloppy than anything
else, given that the authors concede considerable heterogeneity in their
studies, making combining them problematic.

Finally, there’s the issue of publication bias. Publication bias, as most of my 
readers probably know, is the tendency for positive studies to be more likely to
be published than negative studies. That’s because scientists don’t like
publishing negative studies (they seem like “failures”) and journals don’t like 
publishing them either (because editors don’t consider them very interesting).
That’s why, it’s essential that a meta-analysis include an analysis looking for 
publication bias. One very common way of doing this is a funnel plot. Yet there 
is no funnel plot included that I could find (I couldn’t get access to the
supplemental material because I had to have someone e-mail the study to me and
forgot to ask). Instead, they talk about looking at effect sizes in small
studies and large studies and then calculate that “only if there were 47
unpublished RCTs with n = 100 patients showing an advantage to sham of 0.25SD
would the difference between acupuncture and sham lose significance.” How they
calculated this number is not described. I must say, I’ve never seen this sort
of analysis in a meta-analysis before, which is why it stuck out like the
proverbial sore thumb, as did the lack of a description of how this estimate was
calculated. Modeling? Why 47 unpublished RCTs of 100 subjects and not a smaller
number of larger RCTs? The whole thing looks like a number the authors pulled
out of their nether regions and then plugged into their meta-analysis software
in order to see if it would affect anything. In fact, I have a sneaking
suspicion that they probably tried a lot of combinations in order to find the
one that would make it look as though it would take a whole boatload of studies 
going the other way to eliminate the statistical significance of their results. 
Is that unfair to say so? Well, the authors have no one to blame but themselves,
and if I missed the description of how that was calculated I’ll take my lumps.

In the end, I am less than impressed by this study, and it doesn’t surprise me
at all that it was funded by the National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) and the Samueli Institute.

In fact, I’m pretty much unimpressed at the whole study, although no doubt it
will be touted by acupuncturists for years to come as “proof” that acupuncture
really and truly works and isn’t just placebo medicine. It doesn’t, and it is.
In fact, the study strongly suggests that any effect of acupuncture observed is 
almost certainly due to nonspecific and placebo effects and that the “positive” 
result is, as Ernst describes, likely due to small residual biases. Even if we
concede that there might be the small effect of “true” acupuncture reported by
Vickers et al, it is almost certainly a finding that is statistically
significant but clinically insignificant or, as I like to put it because I like 
baseball analogies, a really long run for a really short slide. As they say,
garbage in, garbage out. Can we finally just say that acupuncture is nothing
more than an elaborate placebo?

Acupuncture, the Navy, and Faulty Thinking

Harriet HallonJanuary 10, 2012

Link

A Navy neurologist, Capt. Elwood Hopkins, has posted a 3-part article on  “The
Power of Acupuncture” on Navy Medicine Live, the official blog of Navy and
Marine Corps Health Care. It can serve as a useful lesson in how not to think
about medicine. It is a prime example of how an intelligent, educated doctor can
be fooled and can fool himself into thinking that a placebo is an effective
treatment.

To set the scene: acupuncture has been increasingly accepted in military
circles. The Air Force is teaching its doctors “battlefield acupuncture” based
on the faulty evidence of one Air Force doctor, Richard Niemtzow.  The Army is
using it to treat PTSD.  The Navy offers it too.

Hopkins says that after 40 years of practicing neurology, “It was only natural
to begin thinking about something else.” (Why? Boredom? And why pick
acupuncture?) When he got an e-mail from his Specialty Leader announcing the
opportunity for Navy doctors to learn how to do acupuncture, he submitted his
application that same day. He was undoubtedly impressed that this training was
being offered by the Navy, lending it the imprimatur of authority. His prior
impression of acupuncture was that it was a “mysterious tool” that seemed to
work; and instead of asking critical questions, he says he was looking for “a
fundamental scientific understanding of acupuncture” and asking to see the
supporting research and data. 

Mistake #1: Prior prejudice. It sounds like he already had a favorable opinion
of acupuncture and was predisposed to accept it.

Mistake #2: Confirmation bias. He was looking only for confirmation rather than 
also looking for any disconfirming research.

He says his intellect was actively engaged by the teacher, a “charismatic master
acupuncturist,” who laid a neurophysiologic foundation for how acupuncture
works (never mind showing that it does work!).

Mistake #3: Getting information from a questionable source. A “master”
acupuncturist is hardly likely to present a balanced picture of the evidence for
and against his source of livelihood. Hopkins himself calls the teacher
“charismatic,” so he could have suspected that he might be influenced by that
charisma to accept things he would not have accepted as readily from a dry,
objective presentation of scientific evidence.

He was told about local physiologic changes in tissues stimulated by needles. He
was not told that non-needle “acupuncture” (with electrical stimulation through
intact skin or with simple touching with toothpicks) had been shown equally
effective, even when acupuncture points are avoided. He was told that needles
caused reversal of tissue acidosis. (This is a claim I don’t remember hearing
before, and I think it is based on a couple of Chinese studies in animals. Even 
if true, its clinical relevance would be questionable.) He was told about the
“gate control” hypothesis, but was not told that after half a century of
investigation it has not been accepted as the explanation for acupuncture’s
effects. He was told about MRI findings and endorphin release, but was not told 
that the same findings can be elicited by placebo pills. I see them as evidence 
of the mechanism for acupuncture’s placebo effects; he interprets them as
evidence that acupuncture “resets normal controls within the autonomic nervous
system and maintains CNS homeostasis.” What does that even mean? Sounds to me
like typical CAM pseudoscientific doublespeak.

Mistake #4: Cherry-picking the literature. The charismatic master acupuncturist 
snowed Hopkins with every shred of data that might possibly support a
physiologic mechanism for acupuncture, even providing “an extensive reference
library.” Did he disclose that it doesn’t matter where you put the needles? Did 
he list the high-quality trials showing that sham acupuncture works just as
well? Did he list all the negative systematic reviews or Edzard Ernst’s recent
systematic review of systematic reviews of acupuncture for pain?  It is obvious 
that he cherry-picked the literature to support his claims. This is easy to do
with acupuncture. Many low-quality studies of acupuncture are available.

In part 2 Hopkins actually asks if the clinical effects might be due to placebo.
He wonders how we would know, since there is “no honest way” to do a properly
controlled double blind study. His teacher says it is better to go by the
functional outcome rather than by patient reports of pain levels. So far, so
good. But then Hopkins throws science out the window and never mentions placebo 
again. He actually says

   There is nothing like personal experience to convince one of an effect. It is
   a bit like not requiring a double blind placebo controlled cross-over study 
   to establish that an open parachute is more effective than a closed one.

Wow! Unbelievable! This sounds like it was written by someone ignorant of
science and logic rather than by a neurologist. His analogy is a clichéd
fallacy: we don’t accept the effectiveness of parachutes because we have had
personal experience jumping out of planes. I think he meant to say that not
every claim requires proof by placebo-controlled trials, which is true but not
pertinent here. We don’t need to do controlled trials to find out if it is
effective to do appendectomies for appendicitis or to set broken bones, but we
do require controlled trials to find out if acupuncture works. In a way it’s
true that personal experience is the best way to convince someone there is an
effect, but it’s useless for determining whether there really is an effect. To
rephrase his statement, there is nothing like solid scientific data to convince 
a scientist who knows better than to accept personal experience as evidence.

Mistake #5: Not understanding why science is necessary. It’s hard to believe
that this was written by someone who has gone through medical school and
residency training. It’s a sad indictment of our educational system.

The instructor asks for volunteers and Hopkins offers himself as a guinea pig.
The instructor treats him for his Raynaud’s disease, telling him he believes
that it is due to prior cervical injury. As a neurologist, Hopkins should know
that the term “Raynaud’s disease” refers only to idiopathic cases and if the
condition is secondary to some instigating factor, it is called “Raynaud’s
syndrome.” Also, while repetitive trauma from vibrating tools like jackhammers
and prior injuries to the hands or feet have been recognized as causes of
Raynaud’s, “cervical injury” has not. There are studies showing that acupuncture
is more effective for Raynaud’s than drugs or than no treatment, but they are
not convincing because they didn’t use placebo control groups. After the
treatment, Hopkins’ symptoms resolved, and he became a believer.

Mistake #6: Relying on his personal experience. True believers ask us to “try it
yourself” and they say “I saw it with my own eyes.” We have ample evidence that
seeing something with our own eyes is often misleading, and that trying
something for yourself can interfere with your ability to objectively assess the
evidence.

Mistake #7: The post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy. Hopkins assumes that because 
his symptoms improved after the treatment, they improved because of the
treatment. He doesn’t even consider that there might be other explanations or
confounding factors. (For one thing, emotional stress is a known trigger for
Raynaud’s symptoms.)

His classmates were treated for various conditions including radiculopathies and
interstitial cystitis, and they all “benefitted.” He calls acupuncture a “safe 
and inexpensive tool that has been time-tested for several thousand years.”

Mistake #8: Relying on the personal experience of others. Testimonials abound
for even the quackiest of quack treatments. No matter how many anecdotes we
manage to accumulate, the plural of anecdote is not data: that’s why we do
science.

Mistake #9: The ancient wisdom fallacy. He is dead wrong about acupuncture being
several thousand years old. Even if it was, length of use is no  indication of 
truth. Astrology has been around for longer than acupuncture: does he think it’s
valid because it has been time-tested? Blood-letting was “time-tested” for many
centuries, but it turned out to do more harm than good.

In Part 3, Hopkins relates how he has implemented acupuncture in his practice.
He has given over 1000 acupuncture treatments for everything from headaches to
prostatitis. (One wonders why a neurologist would be treating prostatitis.) He
claims a 90% success rate with many spectacular responses. He actually uses the 
word “miracle.” He admits that some patients don’t respond, saying it is “never 
clear why.” (I think I can guess why!) He reports improvements in control of
diabetes and hypertension, less need for medication, better sleep, etc. He
concludes that “It is now evident to me that there truly is a great benefit to
acupuncture.” He says it is safe (although the Ernst study documented rare but
serious adverse effects including death). He says there are no
contraindications, but numerous lists of contraindications are easily found on
the Internet both on acupuncture websites and on mainstream medical websites. He
says the only time he would not use it was if the patient didn’t want it. He
recommends that anyone caring for patients should consider adding this tool to
their kit.

Mistake #10: Making uncontrolled observations. His patients improved, but how
many of them would have improved without any treatment or with a credible
placebo offering some of the non-specific treatment effects of acupuncture?

Mistake #11: Proselytizing on the basis of his own uncontrolled observations.
Now that he has convinced himself, he wants to persuade others by simple
assertions and by the same kind of unreliable “evidence” that convinced him.

Mistake #12: Not doing his own research. He might have checked PubMed. He might 
have read a neat new study confirming previous evidence that acupuncture is no
more effective than placebo.  It showed that patients were more likely to
improve if they believed in acupuncture and believed they got the real thing
rather than a placebo, regardless of which they actually got. He might have read
what Yale neurologist Steven Novella wrote after actually researching the
literature on acupuncture himself. He might have read the many negative
systematic reviews, such as the one  showing  that a  “small analgesic effect of
acupuncture was found, which seems to lack clinical relevance and cannot be
clearly distinguished from bias” or the recent systematic review of systematic
reviews by Edzard Ernst showing “numerous contradictions and caveats.” He might 
have read the many skeptical articles on science blogs. He might have read The
Skeptic’s Dictionary entry on acupuncture. He might have consulted Quackwatch’s 
affiliate Acupuncture Watch. Even reading the acupuncture article on Wikipedia
might have raised some doubts in his mind.

At this point, even if he is willing to look at the great mass of disconfirming 
evidence, he is probably not capable of judging it objectively. Once someone has
become a true believer on the basis of personal experience reinforced by
grateful patient feedback, there is rarely any hope. He has drunk the Kool-Aid. 
I just hope he doesn’t go on to seek training from a charismatic homeopath or a 
reiki master!

I can understand why many doctors are less skeptical than they should be about
most of the CAM information they encounter: they are used to having
pre-digested, accurate scientific information presented to them by experts. They
were (sadly) not taught to question what their teachers said in medical school 
and residency. They were taught about evidence-based medicine, but they have
poor understanding of what we mean by science-based medicine. They rely on
published information in medical journals, but they may not realize that half of
the studies they read are wrong. Even if they are good at critically evaluating
scientific medical information, they may not be used to critically analyzing
information from the realm of CAM. They may not have learned to recognize the
common logical fallacies and the pitfalls.

The One Big Mistake: Not Following the SkepDoc’s Rule of Thumb. My rule, which
applies to critical thinking in every sphere: before accepting any new claim,
find out who disagrees with it and why. Once you fully understand the arguments 
on both sides, only then are you qualified to judge whether the claim is
credible. What if a jury listened to the prosecution but not to the defense?

For those of us who have made an effort to develop our critical thinking skills 
and have not been influenced by personal experience or charismatic apologists,
all indications are that acupuncture amounts to an elaborate placebo system.
Using placebos on patients is unethical. As a retired Air Force colonel and as a
physician, I am saddened to see acupuncture infiltrate the military health care
system. And I am saddened to see how Dr.  Hopkins’ faulty thinking led him
astray. To salvage a bit of good from the bad, I hope his experience can serve
as a bad example for others to learn from.

.

                           “Battlefield acupuncture”?

                                  David Gorski

                                      Link

THE SCENE: Iraq, Afghanistan, or anywhere where U.S. troops are risking life and
limb.

THE TIME: The not-too-distant-future. Maybe even 2009.

Joe is on patrol.

It’s the middle of summer in the desert town. The air hangs heavy, hot, dry and 
dusty, like a blast furnace firing steel. The heat penetrates Joe’s 80 lb pack
in much the same way the heat from boiling water penetrates the shell of an
unfortunate lobster. Joe’s heart races. His squad is on edge; their eyes dart
furiously to and fro, looking for the deadly threat that might lurk in the
shadows. Every shadow is a potential source of death, every alley a refuge from 
which the enemy can attack and kill him or his buddies, every rooftop a fortress
from which the enemy can rain death upon the squad. The area is known to be
thick with terrorists and insurgents. Joe pictured them waiting unseen from
every nook and cranny for the opportunity to attack. The skin on Joe’s back is
all prickly. He distinctly feels as though he has a huge bullseye pointed on his
back. He feels a bead of sweat dripping down his forehead and onto his eyelid, 
all slimy and salty. Joe desperately wants to wipe it away, but that would
necessitate removing one of his hands from his weapon. The split second it would
take for him to put it back might mean the difference between life and death
for him or one of his buddies.

A loud roar fills Joe’s ears, and suddenly he feels as though he has no weight. 
The scene unfolds in slow motion, just like in the movies. Dazed, Joe hears a
tumult as though from a great distance, but can see nothing. Yelling and gunfire
all around, he becomes conscious enough to realize that he’s lying flat on his 
back. He feels searing pain in his legs and a hot liquid oozing around them. It 
occurs to Joe that it must be his own blood or even perhaps his own urine, but
he’s just too dazed to care.

“Medic!” Joe hears someone scream. He feels someone pull his helmet from his
head and realizes that the sound of gunfire and yelling is receding. His unit
must be driving away the ambushers. Good! He thinks. Give those assholes hell,
guys! He opens his eyes, and realizes that his buddy’s got his back, and turns
to see another man, a medic, drop to his knees at his side. His uniform is
stained a disturbing red. Joe feels the medic wrapping something around his
thigh. It’s a tourniquet, and Joe cries out in pain as he feels it constricting 
around his upper thigh.

“Bleeding’s better!” Joe hears the medic say to his buddy. “I’ll take it from
here.” Joe’s buddy runs off to join the rest of his unit, and the medic moves
his face close to Joe’s. He feels himself being moved from side to side and then
his legs being moved. More pain. Joe cries out.

The medic leans in to talk to Joe, “I think we’ve got the bleeding under control
for now. I put a tourniquet on your leg. Let’s get you out of here. The docs’ll
patch you up in no time.” Joe is vaguely aware of another corpsmen with a
stretcher nearby. The medic leans in again, “Are you in pain, soldier?”

“What do you think? My leg hurts like a sonofabitch! I could really use
something for the pain,” Joe hears himself yelling, again as if from a distance.
Pain is shooting through his leg, setting every nerve on fire, and the
tourniquet is biting into raw muscle through the edge of a wound that comes all 
the way up to his groin. The flayed edges of his skin shoot fire to his brain,
and he can feel his broken bones grinding against each other every time he moves
in spite of the splint.

“I’ve got something better that’ll help,” the medic screams over the din.

Better? Joe thinks. I’m in agony here. I need something! Anything!

The medic pulls a small box out of his pack. Joe sees that it’s a small case. He
opens it. Its contents look something like this:

Joe is puzzled. Where’s the morphine? He wonders. “What are those needles?” Joe 
asks. “What are you doing? I’ve never seen syringes that look like that before!”

“Acupuncture,” replies the medic. “I’ll take care of you.”

“What are you going to do with them?” Joe replies.

“Stick them into your earlobe. It’ll take the pain away really fast.”

“Are you shittin’ me?” Joe screeches, trying to get up to grab the medic by the 
front of his uniform. “My leg’s a bloody mess, I’m in agony, and you’re tellin’ 
me you’re gonna stick little needles in my ear and make it all better? Like
that‘s going to do anything! I need real pain medicine! Give me morphine! NOW!”

******

If there’s any class of citizen who deserves nothing but the best care
science-based medicine has to offer, it’s our men and women in the military,
especially during wartime, when they are putting themselves in the line of fire,
risking death or horrific injury to fight in the name of our nation. We
citizens through our representatives send them off to foreign lands to fight; we
are obligated to do our best to care for those who come back missing a limb or 
having suffered a serious injury. During this war, we have achieved much towards
this end, too. I know colleagues who served in the military, and this war, like
many wars, has seen amazing advances in the care of wounded soldiers. Wartime
has always been a time of incredible experimentation and innovation, as doctors 
look for newer, better, more efficacious, and more efficient ways to care for
our wounded soldiers. Necessity drives innovation, and the history of military
medical innovations go back at least to the Civil War. Two examples come to
mind. For example, World War II saw the widespread of plasma and blood
transfusions on the battlefield, as well as the use of morphine and penicillin, 
and the end of World War II and the Korean War saw the deployment of MASH units.
Truly, some advances during this war have been spectacular Particularly
impressive is how the wounded can now be evacuated from the battlefield to
nearby hospital bases, stabilized (and operated on emergently if necessary to
stablize them), and then evacuated either to regional military hospitals in
nearby countries or even to hospitals like Landstuhl Regional Medical Center in 
Germany, which receives a significant percentage of soldiers wounded in Iraq or 
Afghanistan. If there’s one thing that we’ve learned during the last six years
of war, it’s that getting casualties to definitive treatment faster does indeed 
save lives that would otherwise be lost. Using this strategy of rapid evacuation
to facilities where definitive treatment could be undertaken, by the end of
2004 the military medical system had achieved an unprecedented 90% survival rate
for soldiers wounded in combat.

This culture of experimentation to save lives can occasionally lead to perhaps a
bit more openness than is scientifically justified to measures before they are 
validated than would be the case under less severe circumstances. Sometimes this
takes the form of deploying treatments and devices that are later found to be
ineffective or even harmful. Usually, these sorts of failures come about because
they’re being tested in under extreme battlefield condidtions, There often
isn’t adequate time to do the sorts of rigorous studies to prove or disprove the
efficacy of a new trauma treatment modality because the chaos of battlefield
conditions precludes it and the culture of military medicine is to save
soldiers’ lives, whatever it takes. However, military innovation, forged in the 
heat of battle, can be a messy process. Worse, sometimes our military hospital
system and the Veterans’ Administration don’t always live up to their charge to 
provide the best care for our wounded veterans.

Whatever failures the military and veterans’ medical system may have, however,
it does not help us as a nation achieve the end of caring for injured soldiers
and vets if we subject them to unscientific modalities. Yet that’s exactly what 
the Air Force is poised to do. Yes, I did exaggerate just a bit what the
military is planning with my little story above in order to make a point, but
unfortunately, I’m sorry to say that I’m probably exaggerating considerably less
than I wish I were. Earlier this year, I said hello to Battlefield Acupuncture:

   LANDSTUHL REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, Germany – A medical procedure dating back 
   thousands of years was introduced to patients and medical staff for one week 
   in March at Landstuhl Regional Medical Center.

   A limited form of acupuncture, called battlefield acupuncture, was introduced
   to LRMC doctors who applied the procedure to war-wounded servicemembers and 
   local patients for pain relief, and often with significant results.

   Major (Dr.) Conner Nguyen was exposed to acupuncture as both a patient and
   physician and was equally impressed in both roles. As a patient, Major Nguyen
   experienced 25 percent increased range of motion and a 50 percent reduction 
   in pain for chronic shoulders and upper back pain he endured for several
   years.

True, Major Nguyen is not giving acupuncture on the battlefield, but when I
first read this article several months ago, I wondered: Can using acupuncture on
the battlefield be far behind? Battlefield acupuncture is the creation of
another officer Col. (Dr.) Richard Niemtzow, who is a radiation oncologist by
training but also one of 40 Department of Defense doctors trained as certified
acupuncturists. An article from WTOP News two years ago describes how Col.
Niemtzow discovered acupuncture:

   Col. Richard Niemtzow, a radiation oncologist, received a brochure on
   acupuncture in 1994. At first he threw it out, but then he decided to learn
   more about the ancient practice and attended a conference on acupuncture. He 
   was sold. Niemztow started the first acupuncture clinic at McGuire Air Force 
   Base in Ohio and now practices acupuncture at Andrews Air Force Base, the
   Pentagon and Walter Reed Army Medical Center.

   Three or four doctors at Walter Reed practice acupuncture on their patients. 
   Niemtzow visits each week, to help relieve the pain for amputees back from
   Iraq. He says he helps 50 percent of amputees suffering from phantom pain.

   I had the opportunity to sit in on patient visits who were referred to
   acupuncture at Walter Reed and received the treatment for the first time. I
   witnessed men and women finding relief in a matter of minutes after suffering
   chronic pain for years.

   Niemtzow used various techniques on the patients he developed and are now
   taught throughout the country. In one technique, he places acupuncture
   needles into the ear, since the ear is integrated to the central nervous
   system.

   Niemtzow says you interfere with the processing of pain and in a way, turn
   off the pathway and that’s why pain may go away. Each of the patients he saw 
   were referred back to the clinic for follow-up treatments. He says it is
   possible their pain will come back.

“Possible”? How about “virtually inevitable”?

Let’s look at the “progress” of the use of acupuncture in the military. Its
infiltration into the normally hard-nosed military is directly attributable
primarily to one man, Col. Niemtzow. Two years ago the use of acupuncture in the
military was uncommon, with Col. Niemtzow lamenting how few acupuncturists
there were. In the article in Military.com from earlier this year, it’s clear
that the program has expanded considerably. Another thing that I note is that
there is no mention of science or well-designed clinical trials to test whether 
“battlefield acupuncture” does anything at all. I did a little PubMed search for
“battlefield acupuncture” and found nothing. Searching for Col. Niemtzow on
PubMed, all I found was a slew of articles in that repository of bad studies of 
woo, the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine. There was one
article in Military Medicine and one in JACM, the latter of which is a photo
essay. The article in Military Medicine is indeed a pilot study, but even on
those terms it’s not impressive. It was completely unblinded, and no sham
acupuncture was used for the controls. Even more odd, the auricular acupuncture 
needles, which are considerably smaller than standard needles, were left in
place in the ear for up to several days until they fell out. Even given the
shortcomings of the study that could lead to bias, the results were still not
particularly impressive. Although the acupuncture group was reported to decrease
by 23% initially and the conventional therapy group not at all, within 24 hours
there was no difference. Even by the usually low standards of poorly done “CAM”
studies, these results here were not striking.

I wondered at the time: That’s it? This is what Col Niemtzow is basing his
assessments of the “success” of acupuncture in phantom limb pain syndromes and
various other chronic pain conditions resulting from combat injuries? It’s thin 
gruel indeed. But apparently it’s enough for the Air Force.

Let’s fast forward to last Thursday. Harriet will probably clutch her chest in
pain when she reads what’s coming next. At the very least, she’ll have one hell 
of a headache. (Maybe she should get some acupuncture for that.) It would appear
that Col. Niemtzow is about to get his wish. The Air Force announced a program 
to train physicians in battlefield acupuncture before their deployment to Iraq:

   ANDREWS AIR FORCE BASE – Using ancient Chinese medical techniques, a small
   team of military doctors here has begun treating wounded troops suffering
   from severe or chronic pain with acupuncture.

   The technique is proving so successful that the Air Force will begin teaching
   “battlefield acupuncture” early next year to physicians deploying to Iraq
   and Afghanistan, senior officials will announce tomorrow.

   The initiative marks the first high-level endorsement of acupuncture by the
   traditionally conservative military medical community, officials said.

   Using tiny needles that barely penetrate the skin of a patient’s ear, Air
   Force doctors here say they can interrupt pain signals going to the brain.

   Their experience over several years indicates the technique developed by Col.
   Richard Niemtzow, an Air Force physician, can relieve even unbearable pain
   for days at a time.

   That enables badly wounded patients who arrive here by medevac aircraft to
   begin to emerge from the daze of pain-killer drugs administered by surgeons
   in the field.

   “This is one of the fastest pain attenuators in existence – the pain can be
   gone in five minutes,” said Niemtzow, a physician, acupuncturist and senior
   adviser to the Air Force surgeon general.

That’s right. Your tax dollars are being spent to turn physicians into
acupuncturists and then deploy them to Iraq to treat wounded soldiers.

As for “successful”? How would Col. Niemtzow know that his program is a success 
thus far? I redid my searches of PubMed to see if perhaps had had published
anything new since earlier this year that has led him to this conclusion. He
hasn’t. Indeed, his most recent publication in a peer-reviewed journal remains
his pilot study in Military Medicine. Next, I did a brand new PubMed search for 
“battlefield acupuncture.” Nothing. Nada. Zip. A search for “acupuncture AND Air
Force.” Ditto. No, there’s nothing new in the peer-reviewed medical literature 
that I can find that would be compelling enough to justify investing in training
physicians and medics in acupuncture techniques before they are deployed to
Iraq. So why do Col. Niemtzow and his acolytes believe so intensely that their
program is a success?

I think the key is the phrase “their experience over several years.” In other
words, Col. Niemtzow is relying on anecdotal experience and nothing else. At
least, it certainly appears that way. I’m open to being shown something
scientifically rigorous about this program, but, quite honestly, I have yet to
see anything, and I’ve looked. Col. Niemtzow’s CV lists two publications “in
preparation” entitled Rapid Electroacupuncture Technique for the Treatment of
Peripheral Neuropathies Induced by Cancer Chemotherapy and Xerostomia Secondary 
to Radiation and its Treatment Employing Acupuncture: Mechanisms of Actions, but
that’s about it. There’s nothing more there about the use of battlefield
acupuncture. My finding of Col. Niemtzow’s CV next led me to Col. Niemtzow’s
website, and it’s clear that he is a true believer. For example, Col. Niemtzow
asserts, without any convincing evidence, that acupuncture can be used to treat 
macular degeneration, xerostomia (I note the ASTRO study listed on this page
used “electroacupuncture,” which is not acupuncture), and obesity. I don’t see
listed even a single high quality study that supports any of his assertions. I
wish I did, but I don’t. Worse, Col. Niemtzow spouts the same “ancient
knowledge” fallacy about acupuncture that Harriet demolished a few weeks ago:

   “We use acupuncture as an adjunct” to traditional therapy, said Niemtzow.
   “The Chinese have used it for 5,000 years. It works, and it’s powerful.”

   The procedure developed by Niemtzow is a variation of traditional Chinese
   acupuncture in which long, hair-thin needles are inserted into the body at
   any of hundreds of points to ease pain.

   Niemtzow’s variation uses one or more needles inserted into any of five
   points on the ear. The needles, which penetrate about a millimeter (or
   4/100ths of an inch) into the skin, fall out after several days. The
   procedure can be repeated.

   The ear acts as a “monitor” of signals passing from body sensors to the
   brain, he said. Those signals can be intercepted and manipulated to stop pain
   or for other purposes.

   Even 18th-century pirates were convinced of the value, piercing their lobes
   with earrings “to improve their night vision,” Niemtzow said with a grin.

That last comment caused me serious pain. I hope Niemtzow was joking when he
made the crack about the pirates. Also note the extreme scientific
implausibility. This “ear acupuncture” is based on a physiological principle
that makes every bit as much sense as reflexology, and I mean that in the worst 
way possible. In any case, our seriously wounded veterans are what the Common
Rule would refer to as a “vulnerable” population. They’ve suffered grievous
injury and are in a system in which they are accustomed to “following orders.”
If a military physician tells them to try acupuncture, they’re not likely to
argue. If a military physician approaches them with a clear attitude that he or 
she believes acupuncture works, they’re not likely to express skepticism.
Indeed, if a military physician approaches a soldier to recommend “alternative” 
therapies, I have to wonder if the hierarchical structure of the military and
the soldier’s duty to follow orders might actually enhance the placebo effect.

I said initially that my story above was an intentional exaggeration, but now
I’m not so sure. There is clearly a movement to take battlefield acupuncture to 
the next level: the actual battlefield. Indeed, Army Rangers are considering
using it:

   Battlefield acupuncture caught the eye of U.S. Army Rangers, who often
   operate in remote locations. At their invitation, Niemtzow and his team
   trained some Rangers last summer.

Meanwhile, military acupuncturists pat themselves on the back for their
enlightenment in the face of skepticism:

   Nonetheless, advocates of the practice recognize that they must overcome
   skepticism within the ranks of military doctors.

   “Oh, sure, some haven’t gotten the word,” said Burns, the clinic chief. “We
   are very much ahead of the curve.”

Hello, Galileo gambit.

I realize that Col. Niemtzow is acting out of a genuine desire to help our
wounded veterans, especially those currently enduring difficult or intractable
chronic pain due to wounds suffered in combat. I don’t doubt that he is a caring
physician and only wants the best for his patients. Unforutnately, Col.
Niemtzow has fallen prey to the disease that affects this blog’s “favorite”
antivaccine pediatrician, Dr. Jay Gordon; namely, the inability or unwillingness
to understand or accept just how easy it is for a clinician to be fooled when
he relies on “case reports” or “personal clinical experience” to evaluate the
efficacy of therapies. Indeed, it’s not arrogance on the part of advocates of
science-based medicine that lead us to emphasize the importance of good science 
and well-conducted clinical trials; rather, it’s the humility of knowing that
we, as humans, are just as prone to being fooled as anyone else. If anyone is
arrogant, it’s physicians like Dr. Gordon and Col. Niemtzow, who believe that
their clinical acumen inoculates them from making the mistakes of confusing
correlation with causation, of not recognizing regression to the mean, or not
believing just how potent the placebo effect can be in chronic pain syndromes.
Traveling down the road to hell with only the best of intentions towards their
patients, they fall right down the rabbit hole of pseudoscience.

Our wounded soldiers, indeed all our soldiers, deserve only the finest in
science- and evidence-based medicine that can be delivered to them, be it on the
battlefield, the mobile hospital, or military hospitals overseas or in the U.S.
Unfortunately, as I and my cobloggers have documented for academia, there
appears to be a major push by its advocates to introduce so-called
“complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) into military medicine. For
example, earlier this year, initiatives were reported to use yoga, “Samurai
meditation,” and even reiki and other “energy treatments” to treat PTSD. In
October, it was reported that the military is testing out more and more
“alternative” therapies:

   WASHINGTON — The Pentagon is seeking new ways to treat troops suffering from 
   combat stress or brain damage by researching such alternative methods as
   acupuncture, meditation, yoga and the use of animals as therapy, military
   officials said.

   “This new theme is a big departure for our cautious culture,” Dr. S. Ward
   Casscells, the Pentagon’s assistant secretary for health affairs, told USA
   TODAY.

   Casscells said he pushed hard for the new research, because “we are
   struggling with” post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) “as we are with
   suicide and we are increasingly willing to take a hard look at even soft
   therapies.”

   So far this year, the Pentagon is spending $5 million to study the therapies.
   In the previous two years, the Pentagon had not spent any money on similar
   research, records show.

Not surprisingly, some “old friends” mentioned on SBM are involved in promoting 
the infiltration of CAM into the military. Niemtzow’s work is funded by the
Samueli Institute for Information Biology. Meanwhile, the Samueli Institute has 
reportedly been receiving earmarks attached to military appropriations bills,
one of which was for $2 million for the purpose of developing “a national
program for evaluation and research on complementary, alternative and holistic
medical practices (also called integrative medicine) for military personnel and 
veterans.”

The virus is spreading. Acupuncture, yoga, and other “soft” CAM modalities are
just the foot in the door. They allow woo to creep in, as they have done in
academic medicine. How long will it be before we see homeopathy being used in
military and VA hospitals? How long will it be before my little story above is
no longer a fanciful exaggeration written to make a point? I don’t know, but I
fear the worst. I truly hope I’m just being alarmist, because our soldiers
deserve much better. They deserve science-based medicine and surgery.

 Battlefield acupuncture revisited: That’s it? That‘s all Col. Niemtzow’s got?

                                  David Gorski

                                      Link

It’s like the zombie that wouldn’t die, isn’t it?

I’m referring to so-called “battlefield acupuncture,” a topic that I wrote about
last week for this very blog. With a week separating my usual posts, I normally
don’t write about the same topic two times right in a row, but I’m making an
exception for this topic. There are three reasons. First, I remain appalled at
how one ideologue, Col. (Dr.) Richard Niemtzow, a radiation oncologist and Air
Force physician turned number one advocate of acupuncture use in the military,
has succeeded in introducing acupuncture into not only military hospitals like
Walter Reed Army Medical Center and Landstuhl Regional Medical Center (which is,
by the way, the first stop outside of the Middle East for our wounded soldiers 
from Iraq and Afghanistan), but has even started to train U.S. Army Rangers in
the technique. While before I thought the term “battlefield acupuncture” was a
misnomer because it wasn’t actually being used on the battlefield, but rather
for phantom limb pain and other chronic pain conditions, this latter development
shows just how far Col. Niemtzow wishes to go with this “technique.” Second,
Col. Niemtzow’s acupuncture technique isn’t even “real” acupuncture. He calls it
“auricular acupuncture,” and it involves sticking needles a mere 1 mm into the 
earlobe. Worse, he justifies this technique through ignorance of anatomy,
claiming that “the ear acts as a ‘monitor’ of signals passing from body sensors 
to the brain” and that “those signals can be intercepted and manipulated to stop
pain or for other purposes.” He even made a comment about 18th century pirates 
wearing a lot of earrings in order to improve their night vision. I kid you not.
Third, and finally, Col. Niemtzow has published another one of his “studies” to
support the use of acupuncture in chronic pain syndromes among our combat
wounded veterans.

Last time around, I referred to an earlier study by Col. Niemtzow published in
Military Medicine in 2006. This study was clearly labeled as a “pilot study.”
Although it was randomized (good), it was small (tolerable for a pilot study);
it was unblinded (bad); and there was no placebo or “sham acupuncture” control
group (horrible). There were multiple other serious shortcomings, but those are 
the main ones. In other words, Col. Niemtzow’s 2006 study was custom-designed to
show a “positive” result that could be entirely explained by the placebo
effect, and that’s exactly what it did. Indeed, even by that standard, its
results were unimpressive. Although the pain scores in the acupuncture group
were reported to have decreased by 23% initially, compared to the conventional
therapy group, which did not decrease measurably, within 24 hours after
treatment there was no difference between the two groups. I’ve referred to this 
study as “thin gruel” upon which to base the creation of a military acupuncture 
program, much less expanding that program into combat and training military
physicians and medics being sent to combat zones in Iraq and Afghanistan to do
auricular acupuncture. I still say it’s thin gruel,.

So what about this new study by Col. Niemtzow, hot off the presses in the latest
issue of Medical Acupuncture?

Before I get to that study, let me refer you back to the words of our fearless
leader Steve Novella when it comes to the normal manner in which medical
evidence accumulates to support a therapy:

   Clinical research tends to follow a certain arc: first smaller and
   preliminary studies are done to see if there is a potential for a new
   treatment or approach, then larger and more tightly designed studies are done
   exploring the relevant research questions, and finally large, double-blind, 
   placebo-controlled consensus trials are completed and the basic question of
   efficacy is settled.

This is, of course, a reasonable manner in which to progress. It doesn’t make
sense to spend the millions of dollars a double-blind, placebo-controlled
prospective randomized trial can cost if there isn’t good preliminary evidence
that the therapy is likely to be efficacious, and that preliminary evidence
comes from smaller, less expensive trials. I’ll expand upon what Steve wrote a
bit. Often the very first evidence of potential efficacy of a new therapy comes 
from anecdotes. Yes, anecdotes. However, these anecdotes are not like the
“testimonials” so beloved of so-called “complementary and alternative medicine” 
(CAM) practitioners. Oh, no. real anecdotes are carefully documented and contain
objective measures, complete with laboratory tests not performed by
quack-friendly laboratories where all too often it is found, for instance, that 
virtually everyone with a vague complaint is suffering from “heavy metal
toxicity.” By their very nature, however, anecdotes are not definitive evidence 
of anything. They are only hypothesis generating, suggesting questions that
require further research. They can’t be definitive. There’s way too much
variability in human biology and the natural history of disease. A perfect
example is autism, which is not a condition of devleopmental stasis but rather
delay. Moreover, it can have a hugely varying course from child to child, with
periods of rapid development followed by periods of stasis or even some
regression. Some children–perhaps as high as 19% of them–even improve enough to 
lose their diagnosis; i.e., they improve to the point where they no longer meet 
the diagnostic criteria for an autistic spectrum disorder. Consequently, saying 
that this or that “biomedical intervention” has “worked” based on testimonials
without a control group is meaningless.

Steve also noted that in acupuncture, the progression did initially trend from
anecdotes and small pilot studies to more and more rigorous studies. The problem
is, as is usually the case for CAM modalities, the bigger and more rigorously
designed the study, the smaller the effect observed until in the biggest and
best studies no effect distinguishable from that of a placebo is detectable. So 
it has been with acupuncture, as we’ve documented on SBM. A normal medical
scientist, faced with such results, would abandon the therapy. Oh, he or she
might persist for a while doing more studies, not wanting to believe the
accumulating negative evidence, but sooner or later science will persuade a
scientist. What do acupuncturists do?

They go in reverse.

That’s right. They start doing less rigorous studies. That’s exactly what Col.
Niemtzow has done with his latest article. First, let’s compare it to his
previous article from 2006. That study, as I mentioned, was a randomized trial
involving 87 patients culled from the emergency room at the Malcolm Grow Medical
Center at Andrews Air Force Base. Right there, that means at least Col.
Niemtzow was still trying. He even tried (utterly ineffectively) to blind ER
personnel to which patient was in which group by putting small pieces of tape
over every study participant’s ears. Of course, neither the acupuncturist nor
the patient were blinded, which renders this effort pretty close to pointless,
but, again, at least Col. Niemtzow tried. He might even be forgiven for this
lack back in 2006, as the preferred sham acupuncture needle, with a retractable 
point that gives a realistic appearance of entering the skin, was not as widely 
available then. On the other hand, the other form of sham acupuncture, namely
inserting needles into the “wrong” points, was easily done. In any case, in 2006
Col. Niemtzow was at least trying to be somewhat objective and to follow
somewhat proper clinical trial design.

Not so in 2008, unfortunately.

Let’s take a look at his study. First off, the very fact that it was published
in the woo-friendly Medical Acupuncture should be a tip off that this is not
likely to be a good study, and it’s not. Indeed, I can’t help but think that
Col. Niemtzow probably tried to submit this manuscript to other journals and
ended up “settling” for Medical Acupuncture. In fact, agreeing with Steve
Novella’s complaint about acupuncture studies, it’s a step backward. Once again,
it was carried out at the Malcolm Grow Medical Center at Andrews Air Force
Base. This time, however, there was no attempt to randomize patients. None. Nor 
was there any attempt to control for or standardize the acupuncture therapy
used. All manner of acupuncture was used, as described in the Methods section:

   The physician first treated all patients with auricular acupuncture. Each
   treatment was adjusted based on whether the pain was focal, regional, or
   systemic. If auricular acupuncture was determined to be less than fully
   successful, the physician then selected another appropriate modality: dry
   needling, French Energetics, 18 microcurrent, electroacupuncture (CraigPens),
   electro-auriculotherapy, or piezo-electric stimulation. Administration of
   either auricular, traditional, or electroacupuncture was adjusted based on
   assessment of the patient’s response to treatment. The physician made
   adjustments until the subject experienced complete or near complete pain
   relief (0–1 on the NRS), at which point that treatment ended. The physician
   sometimes elected to use several modalities in 1 therapy session.

Of course, one can’t help but wonder on what scientific basis acupuncturists
chose different treatments based on whether the pain was focal, regional, or
systemic. Worse, it’s a single arm uncontrolled observational study. Because the
article is behind a password-protected wall and is also not in PubMed yet, I’ll
reproduce the abstract in full:

   Background: Acupuncture may play a significant role in the management of
   acute and chronic pain. A United States Air Force (USAF) acupuncture clinic
   managed pain for active duty members, dependents, and retirees. The majority 
   of these patients had unsuccessful control of their pain when employing
   conventional medications and therapies.

   Objective: To study the benefits of acupuncture to control acute and chronic 
   pain in active duty military members, dependents, and retirees who were not
   successfully palliated with conventional Western care. Design, Setting, and
   Subjects: Measurements of pain were made on adult male (n=58) and female
   (n=60) patients ranging in age from 21 to 85 at Malcolm Grow Medical Center
   (MGMC), Andrews Air Force Base, Maryland, USA, from October 2003 to September
   2005.

   Intervention: Various acupuncture modalities were employed on patients with
   pain: acupuncture, electroacupuncture, auriculotherapy, and
   electroauriculotherapy. The choice of the acupuncture modality and the actual
   points used were based on the decision of the treating physicians, who were 
   also trained medical acupuncturists.

   Main Outcome Measures: We delineated anatomic areas of most frequent pain,
   pain scales before, during, and after therapy, pre- and post-treatment
   quality of life, and post-treatment patient satisfaction.

   Results: Patients had significant improvement in pain control and a highly
   significant improvement in their scores on standardized Quality of Life
   scores at the end of the 4-week study.

   Conclusions: Acupuncture appears to be helpful as adjunctive therapy for
   controlling acute and chronic pain in patients for whom standard care is not 
   wholly effective. Possibly as a result of this intervention, patients
   demonstrated a highly significant improvement in both the mental (P < .01)
   and physical (P < .001) subscales of the SF-8 quality of life measure, 4
   weeks following the first acupuncture treatment.

To boil it down, basically Col. Niemtzow took 118 patients, subjected them to a 
grab bag of different acupuncture modalities, including one (electroacupuncture)
that’s not really acupuncture at all but a real modality used by pain
management specialists in a different form based on actual neuroanatomy, not the
fantasy anatomy of “meridians” favored by acupuncturists. Worse, he did not
even bother to break down the numbers of patients who received each modality.
How many received “electroacupuncture,” which could function like transcutaneous
electrical nerve stimulation, TENS for short? Worse still, he did not even
attempt to control for the usage of other pain medications. Patients could start
and stop pain medications as they wished and take anything they wished. Col.
Nietmtzow acknowledges this problem, but waves it away:

   One limitation of the study was that the usage of pain medication was not
   controlled or effectively tracked. Subjects could start and stop taking
   various pain medications at their own discretion and thus, their medication
   use may have confounded the results. In addition, patients often did not
   accurately recall medication names, dosages, or usage. This limitation should
   be considered in the context of the fact that the acupuncture clinic only
   treated patients referred by their primary care physician. In most cases,
   these referrals were made because the standard care (often involving pain
   medication) was not effective. Hence, for many of these subjects, medication 
   was ineffective or unsatisfactory. If so, the reduction in pain scores can
   more credibly be attributed to the acupuncture treatments, rather than to
   concurrent use of pain medication.

Actually, the modest 2 to 2.5 point reduction in pain scores (based on a scale
of 10) and the modest improvement in quality of life scores could be more
credibly attributed to the placebo effect. Indeed, in patients for whom other
treatments appear not to have worked, it’s more likely that this “treatment
effect” was in actuality no greater than what would be expected due to placebo, 
and this study is completely consistent with acupuncture as practiced at MGMC
being nothing more than a placebo. Again, without a proper prospective
randomized clinical trial with a placebo acupuncture control, Col. Niemtzow
cannot validly conclude that acupuncture (or “auricular acupuncture”) is
anything more than an elaborate placebo. There’s another aspect to this tale,
too, and that is the question of whether doing such studies in a military
setting, in which the patients are soldiers trained to follow orders working in 
a hierarchical culture where it is expected that orders from higher-ranking
soldiers will be followed, either enhances the placebo effect or makes soldiers 
less willing to report no relief to a superior officer. After all, if you’re a
PFC and a colonel comes in and tells you that acupuncture’s going to make your
pain all better, it’s not at all implausible that it might enhance the placebo
effect and it’s even more plausible that the PFC might be reluctant to admit it 
if there was no pain relief. I will have to look into the literature to see if
there is any research that might answer these questions for me.

Of course, it’s clear to me that Col. Niemtzow is a True Believer. His titles
include

Chief Medical Consultant for Alternative Medicine for the Air Force Surgeon
General

Editor-in-Chief of Medical Acupunture

Executive Editor of the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine (this 
is the same journal that published homeopathy “research” by people like Lionel
Milgrom.

Chairman of the American Association of Medical Acupuncture Research Committee

President of the Medical Acupuncture Research Foundation

More disturbingly, his lectures have included topics like:

Niemtzow RC. Lecture: The Role of Acupuncture in Breast Cancer: Medicine or
Magic? Department of Defense, Breast Conference. San Diego, California. Sept
1998.

Niemtzow RC. Lecture: The Role of Acupuncture in Breast Cancer: Medicine or
Magic? Breast Cancer Survival Day, Naval Medical Center. San Diego, California, 
Sep 1998.

Niemtzow RC. Guest Speaker: Acupuncture and Cancer. Breast Cancer Clinic, Naval 
Medical Center. San Diego, California, Oct 1998.

But his piece de resistance comes in an editorial written for Medical
Acupuncture entitled Acupuncture and Wizards:

   In Volume 13/Number 3 of Medical Acupuncture, my editorial addressed the role
   of Spirits and Healers and how they related to my own beliefs and practice
   of acupuncture. I stated then that healers could not be real and spirits were
   not part of the Western medical educational experience. In time, I realized 
   that in the practice of acupuncture, the concept of “spirit” played a vital
   role in patients’ clinical outcome, and that Qi is the driving force behind
   the “spirit.” Now I ask, what about wizards?

He answers:

   Acupuncture is not “magic,” but a definite science that may even eclipse
   Newtonian physics. Some of us recognize this. Yet on the other hand, as we
   begin to talk about energies and spirits that are so important in our art,
   this notion may conjure up the slightest sense of magic. We become “wizards” 
   when we place our needles into the symbolic points of our belief, and direct 
   the flow of energy through the channels known to our ancestors.

   After all, it is our patient’s desire to become cured. Are we wizards or
   healers or a little of both? Modern medical science may not have room for
   this kind of thinking. After all, as I alluded in my previous editorial, we
   are like a chemical factory. Many of us can see even deeper than the
   molecular structures of the atoms that make up the chemicals in our bodies
   and thus, as acupuncture became ingrained in our souls, we acquired some of
   the wizard and healer qualities.

I would submit to you that this sort of language has no place in a medical
scientific journal. Of course, Medical Acupuncture is not a medical scientific
journal, and is related to a medical scientific journal solely by coincidence. I
would also submit to you that a physician who not only bases his belief in an
implausbile medical modality that is based, in essence, on pre-scientific
magical thinking invoking “spirit” and being “wizards.”

I’ve said it before, and it seems appropriate to conclude by emphasizing it
again. Our soldiers, grievously wounded in combat, deserve only the best
science-based therapy available. They also deserve compassion and as much of hte
“human touch” as our military medical can provide for them. They do not deserve
magical thinking based on pre-scientific superstition and magical thinking that
came about because at the time healers simply did not know enough about how the
human body functions and, more importantly, how that functioning can go wrong, 
to be able to do much about most diseases and conditions. Worse, because
acupuncture is supposedly “Eastern” and “ancient” (although how “Eastern” or
“ancient” is very much a topic for dispute, as Harriet explained so well), its
invocation of qi and the lack of evidence for meridians are given a pass. If I
were to propose treating our injured soldiers with bloodletting and toxic metals
(both common methods in the 1700s and early 1800s) based on the concept that it
would put the “imbalance of the four humors” back into balance, the Pentagon
and the military medical establishment would toss me out on my ear as a
dangerous quack–and rightly so. But introduce a method that claims “ancient
Chinese wisdom” based on somehow magically redirecting the flow of a mysterious 
“life energy” by sticking small needles into parts of the body that correspond
to no known anatomic structures through which “qi” flows, and suddenly the Air
Force is funding a program to train medics and physicians treating our wounded
soldiers how to do this method based on the same amount of convincing scientific
evidence that qi exists as for the four humors (none) and in the face of no
strong clinical evidence that it’s any better than a placebo.

What’s wrong with this picture? And is that all Col. Niemtzow’s got?

Sadly, it is.

On the pointlessness of acupuncture in the emergency room…or anywhere else

As incredible as it seems, advocates of “integrative medicine” are on the verge 
of creating a new specialty, emergency acupuncture. I wish I were joking, but
I’m not.

David Gorski on July 25, 2016

Tweet





“This patient’s qi isn’t flowing the way it should. Consult Acupuncture, STAT!!”

Sometimes there is a strange confluence of events that dictate what I feel that 
I need to write about when my turn here at SBM rolls around each Monday. Last
week, a reader sent me a rather bizarre acupuncture study, and I thought I might
write about that. Then I saw Mark Crislip’s (as usual) excellent deconstruction
of the frequent claim by acupuncture apologists that acupuncture “works” by
releasing endorphins and thought, “Maybe another topic.” But then, over the
weekend, the Friends of Science in Medicine sent me a link to their latest
article, a review of acupuncture entitled “Is there any place for acupuncture in
21st century medical practice?” Not surprisingly, the FSM (Friends of Science
in Medicine, not the Flying Spaghetti Monster) concludes that the answer is no. 
However, in stark contrast to that conclusions are studies like the one
mentioned above, studies so ridiculous that, when I discuss it, you will hardly 
believe that anyone thought it was a good idea to utilize the money, time, and
precious, precious human subjects to answer such a ridiculous question. After
that discussion, I’ll come back to the FSM’s statement and discuss the evidence 
base (or rather, lack thereof) for acupuncture for pretty much anything.

Emergency acupuncture!

As Mark noted, one of the most commonly invoked “explanations” (other than that 
it “releases adenosine“) is that acupuncture somehow stimulates the release of
endorphins, natural, endogenous substances that suppress the sensation of pain. 
Based on dubious science, acupuncture apologists are frequently seen touting its
benefits and explaining them to credulous media outlets such as Consumer
Reports. Since endorphins are basically neurotransmitters (substances that
transmit a chemical message from neuron to neuron or neuron to muscle) that
stimulate the same receptors as morphine, namely opioid receptors, they function
as a natural system to decrease the sensation of pain, among other functions.
There are basically four types of endorphins: alpha (α), beta (β), gamma (γ) and
sigma (σ), all of them peptides and distinguished by having different numbers
and types of amino acids making up their structure. To put it simply, opioid
pain relievers like morphine or Fentanyl mimic natural endorphins. There’s a lot
of woo out there whose advocates invoke endorphins, basically any
“complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) that claims to reduce pain or
make one feel better.

Enter emergency acupuncture. No, I’m not kidding you. Instead of battlefield
acupuncture, which is helping to pave the way for acupuncture to infiltrate the 
VA Medical Center system, here we have a clinical study examining the use of
acupuncture in the emergency room, published in The American Journal of
Emergency Medicine, entitled “Acupuncture versus intravenous morphine in the
management of acute pain in the emergency department.” No, I kid you not. Click 
on the link if you don’t believe me. This is a clinical trial randomizing people
with acute pain to acupuncture versus intravenous morphine. Its
ClinicalTrials.gov identifier is NCT02460913.

Let’s take a look at this study.

It is a phase 2 clinical trial that randomizes patients in the emergency room
with acute pain to either titration of intravenous morphine or acupuncture. As
you can probably imagine, it is completely unblinded. There is no sham, nor is
there even an attempt at blinding. Given that, I bet you can guess the result
before I even describe the study in more detail, because the results of such a
study are very predictable. Let’s move on, anyway.

First, how do the investigators, who are based at two different hospitals in
Tunisia affiliated with the University of Monastir, justify their study? First, 
they invoke a systematic review of acupuncture use in the emergency department, 
which, amazingly, found 102 studies. Not amazingly, only two RCTs and two
uncontrolled observational studies were deemed eligible. Also not surprisingly, 
in line with the methodolatry that characterizes evidence-based medicine (EBM), 
the authors concluded that “current evidence is insufficient to make any
recommendations concerning the use of acupuncture in the ED” and recommended
that the “effectiveness and safety as well as the feasibility of acupuncture
should be tested in future RCTs.” Of course, the science-based medicine (SBM)
retort to this conclusion is that, given the extreme lack of prior plausibility 
of acupuncture, coupled with such equivocal clinical evidence, the most
parsimonious explanation is that acupuncture doesn’t work.

Not to these investigators:

   The World Health Organization (WHO) has recognized acupuncture as a safe and 
   effective therapy for a myriad of conditions causing pain and discomfort [4].
   However, the introduction of acupuncture in the treatment of pain in the ED 
   is rare. Acupuncture was shown to be as effective as morphine and it has a
   better safety profile which makes it a suitable method of pain control in
   certain circumstances such as headaches, migraines, back pain, cervical pain 
   and osteoarthritis [5].

Again, that damned WHO report. Basically, it was a report written by
acupuncturists who made statements at odds with the evidence. Actually, in this 
case, the authors referenced a 2002 acupuncture report that appears to be an
update to the original that acknowledges the “debt” to the acupuncturists who
authored the original report. In any case, the rationale for using acupuncture
in the emergency room is, as you would expect, quite weak.

Now let’s take a look at the study design, specifically the two interventions.
The first part that sends up a red flag to me is this:

   Patients were screened for inclusion in the triage unit during the day
   between the hours of 8 a.m. to 7 p.m., Monday through Friday. Eligible
   patients were those who presented for moderate to severe acute onset pain
   with stable clinical conditions that did not require any resuscitation
   measures or specific procedures except for treatment of painful condition.

That sounds fair enough at first, but think about it a bit more. Basically,
anyone in pain could be randomized, as long as they didn’t have a clinical
condition that needed immediate treatment, rather only “treatment of painful
condition.” Now here’s the rub. Look at the inclusion criteria:

   Patients were included in the protocol if they were aged ≥18 years and met
   the following criteria: Acute onset pain <72 hours of the ED presentation,
   pain intensity ≥40 of the VAS or NRS (ranging from 0 for no pain to 100 for
   maximum imaginable pain), acute musculoskeletal pain with no evidence of
   fracture or dislocation, including ankle and knee sprains without signs of
   severity (ligament rupture, laxity), shoulder and elbow tendinitis, upper and
   lower limb mechanical pains and lower back pain with no evidence of
   neurological deficit, acute abdominal pain with no urgent surgical
   intervention including renal colic and dysmenorrhea and acute headache that
   meets the criteria of primary headache, as described by the international
   headache society [7].

As you will see later, these criteria lead to some real problems with the study,
but I’ll forego discussion of that aspect until I get to the results in favor
of pitching a TV show to Lifetime called “Emergency Acupuncturists!” Don’t
worry, I’ll get back to this problem soon enough, but I will hint now that the
mix of patients in each group was not comparable. I’ll also mention that if I
came in with pain from a kidney stone, there’s no way in hell that I would let
an acupuncturist near me or agree to be randomized.

The other major problem with the study design, as I discussed before, is that it
is completely unblinded. Patients, doctors, acupuncturists, everyone knew which
group the patient was in. This sort of design is almost guaranteed to produce a
result in which the acupuncture group shows a high degree of pain relief,
thanks to placebo effects. Whether that pain relief will be more, less, or the
same as the standard of care to which acupuncture is being compared varies
depending on the study, but I rarely go wrong predicting that an unblinded
acupuncture study will show a lot of benefit for acupuncture, sometimes even the
same as or greater than standard of care.

Now let’s look at the two interventions. First, the acupuncture:

   After allocation to this group, patients were redirected to the ED
   acupuncture unit. The acupuncturist was an ED doctor with medical acupuncture
   qualification accredited by the National Tunisian Council of Doctors with 10
   years experience in the field. Treatment protocols were determined through
   review of major clinical manuals and textbooks, literature review, and a
   panel of specialist acupuncturists from Chinese medicine backgrounds [8]. The
   protocols, which allow acupuncture points to be selected from a pool of
   pre-determined points for each condition, provide sufficient standardization 
   to assist replication, yet are flexible enough to allow individualized
   treatments. These protocols also allow for additional points, such as ‘ashi
   points’, to be used at the discretion of the acupuncturist. The location of
   the points, angle of insertion and depth of insertion were sourced from a
   popular text “A Manual of Acupuncture” [9] and described in the annexe table 
   (annexe1). The average time to place needles is five minutes.

So basically acupuncturists could choose any points they wished. Of course, as
I’ve pointed out before, acupuncture “works” (i.e., produces placebo effects)
whether you put the needles into the “right” points or not. It doesn’t even
matter if you actually insert the needles, as long as you touch the skin (even
with toothpicks instead of needles)! Be that as it may, there was not even an
attempt to include a sham acupuncture group.

The morphine group involved titrating morphine, starting with a dose of 0.1
mg/kg and repeating the morphine at 0.05 mg/kg every five minutes until the
desired decrease in pain was achieved, with a maximum total dose being 15 mg.
This is a fairly standard ER protocol for treating acute pain, although other
evidence suggests that a titration scheme using a protocol with an initial dose 
of 2 mg (body weight < 60 kg) or 3 mg (body weight > 60 kg) with subsequent
administration of 3 mg of morphine every 5 minutes until desirable or adverse
effects occurred is more effective. Be that as it may, we are basically seeing a
test of acupuncture versus one widely utilized protocol for dosing morphine for
acute pain. Also, patients were allowed to receive other treatments suitable to
their conditions if judged necessary, such as ice application, compression,
elevation and rest. It wasn’t clear to me if this was also the case with the
acupuncture arm.

So what were the results? Here you go:

   Success rate was significantly different between the two groups (92% in the
   Acupuncture group vs. 78% in the Morphine group P < .01). Resolution time was
   16 ± 8 minutes in the acupuncture group vs. 28 ± 14 minutes in the morphine 
   group. The difference was statistically significant (P < .01). The mean
   absolute difference in pain score between the two groups was 7.7. This
   difference is not clinically significant since the minimal clinically
   significant absolute difference reported by Todd et al. is 13. In Morphine
   group the mean total dose of Morphine administered was 0.17 ± 0.08 mg/Kg
   (Table2).

I’ll give the investigators credit for mentioning that a statistically
significant difference does not necessarily mean a clinically significant
difference in pain scores. I only wish Andrew Vickers would learn this lesson.
One also notes that a titration scheme like the one above to reduce acute pain
using morphine will likely take at least 20 minutes, given that it consists of
administering subtherapeutic doses of morphine, assessing reduction in pain
after five minutes, and then giving an even smaller dose, rinse, lather, repeat.
The reason for this, of course, is that morphine can depress respiration and
decreased blood pressure, which is why clinicians need to be cautious, but such 
an approach inherently takes longer.

Excuses and incomparable (uncomparable?) groups!

Now, I’ll revisit what I alluded to earlier about an uneven distribution of
conditions. It’s hard not to note in Table 1 that there were significantly more 
abdominal pain patients in the morphine group (79) than the acupuncture group
(60) and that there were significantly fewer low back pain patients (27 in the
morphine group vs. 44 in the acupuncture group). Given that in general we try to
avoid opioids for low back pain and that low back pain often resolves with
relaxation and rest, one has to wonder if these skewed the results. Similarly,
the most common condition causing abdominal pain that doesn’t require immediate 
surgery for which it is safe to administer opioid analgesics is likely to be
kidney stones, which are extremely painful and not likely to pass quickly. Given
that patients with abdominal pain were the single largest group in this trial, 
making up close to half the total patients, one wonders why the authors didn’t
break out the pain scores for this group, given that there was such an imbalance
between the groups. It also concerns me that this ER is administering morphine 
for so many people with abdominal pain. While that is appropriate for kidney
stones, it is seldom, if ever, appropriate for dysmenorrhea (painful menses).

Also, there is a big problem with the reporting of this clinical trial, so much 
so that I’m surprised this journal published it. There is no CONSORT flow
diagram to show allocation of subjects, dropout rates, and analysis. Indeed,
seeing a clinical trial in which there are exactly 150 subjects in each arm
always makes my skeptical antennae start twitching. No one dropped out of the
study? No one was randomized but decided not to go through with the trial? I
suppose it’s possible for a short term intervention in the ER, but consider
this: Accrual was exactly perfect for each group. This almost never happens in a
clinical trial.

Finally, the authors try to excuse their lack of blinding:

   First, the main flow of this trial is the lack of blinding. In fact, in these
   settings sham acupuncture has been proposed to provide a comparable
   experience to the study subjects and to minimize the effects of nonblinding. 
   However, in our study sham acupuncture use would be impossible given the
   workload of a single acupuncturist.

I’m sorry, but there is no excuse here. If you can’t properly blind the subjects
and the practitioners, then you shouldn’t even bother to do the trial, because 
it will be crap. Actually, the authors’ failure in blinding is double. Here’s
how I would have designed the trial:

  1. Morphine titration + sham acupuncture

  2. Placebo morphine (i.e., normal saline injections) + acupuncture

This way, both patients get what they believe to be an identical experience, and
you can compare acupuncture to morphine in this setting. Of course, the better 
design would have two more groups:

  1. Morphine titration + acupuncture

  2. Placebo morphine (i.e., normal saline injections) + sham acupuncture

If this were a study of acupuncture for a more chronic condition, I’d
incorporate some sort of crossover design, but it isn’t; so I won’t.

Having these four groups would allow a complete analysis of the two
interventions with far less potential for bias and placebo effects. However, in 
a pinch, if there aren’t resources to recruit patients for four groups like
this, just including the first two groups would do nicely for a pilot project.
Of course, this is an EBM standpoint. From an SBM standpoint, in which basic
biology indicates a prior plausibility for acupuncture that is incredibly low, I
would judge this study not worth doing, but I’d also say that if you insist on 
doing it anyway you should at least do it right.

Unfortunately, such is the quality of the vast majority of acupuncture studies, 
which brings us to the FSM statement.

Acupuncture is pointless

The FSM paper is an excellent primer on why acupuncture is pseudoscience. I
encourage you to read the whole thing; I’ll only hit the highlights. First, they
point out exactly what I’ve been saying about traditional Chinese medicine
(TCM) for years and years now:

   TCM, also present in Japan, where it is called Kampo, is, together with
   Indian Ayurveda and pre-Enlightenment European medicine, one of the major
   pre-scientific medicines. They share common roots, probably from ancient
   Indian philosophies, according to which the equilibrium of the healthy human 
   body is believed to be the result of a balance of a number of elements.
   Diseases are thought to be due to their imbalance.

   In TCM, these elements are wood, water, fire, earth and metal, a belief
   similar to that of ancient Indian Unani medicine, with its four humours
   (akhlaat) – air, earth, fire and water, and Indian Ayurveda medicine’s air,
   water and fire. Pre-scientific European (from Greco-Roman) medicine proposed 
   four humours, each associated with the four natural universal elements (blood
   – air; phlegm – water; yellow bile – fire; black bile – earth). Although
   these theoretical constructs represented an initial attempt to unify
   knowledge about the world and ourselves, none has any scientific foundation.

This is exactly why I like to ask: Where’s the love for traditional European
medicine? Teach the controversy, I say:



Traditional Chinese medicine is based on principles very similar to the “four
humors” of ancient European medicine. So why the love for TCM and not for
Hippocrates? Teach the controversy!

Many of the points (get it—”points,” acupuncture?) made by FSM are points
familiar to regular readers of SBM. Acupuncture is not really ancient, given
that early Chinese medical texts don’t mention it. It appears to have been more 
based on lancing abscesses with a larger lance and ancient bloodletting not
unlike what was practiced in Europe, possibly with a bit of astrology added.
Even as recently as 103 years ago, acupuncture was practiced in a barbaric
fashion with very large needles, often heated, left in the body for days,
sometimes resulting in death. Then, of course, there was the retconning of TCM
by Chairman Mao Zedong, who didn’t really believe in TCM but didn’t have the
resources to bring SBM to his entire country. So he tried to “integrate” TCM
into modern medicine and dispatched hordes of “barefoot doctors” practicing TCM 
to fill in the breach. Then, starting in the 1960s and 1970s, stories of the
wonders of acupuncture filtered to the West from China, thanks to credulous
journalists.

Then there’s the veritable catalog of proposed “mechanisms” by which acupuncture
“works,” including adenosine (wrong) and endorphins (again, wrong). Add to that
the variability in studies, the oft-repeated observation that it doesn’t matter
where you stick the needles or even if the needles pierce the skin, and it
becomes clear that acupuncture is merely “theatrical placebo.” As Steve Novella 
likes to point out, the better designed the study, the more likely it is to show
no discernable effect attributable to acupuncture greater than placebo effects.
No wonder acupuncturists like unblinded studies.

Is there any justification for the use of acupuncture in modern medicine?

FSM concludes by asking the question: Is there any justification for the use of 
acupuncture in modern medicine? You know our answer here at SBM, but it’s worth 
quoting FSM:

   As acupunctures loses support in Medicine, it is increasingly used as part of
   larger constellations of alternative treatments within private enterprises
   which mix together, almost randomly, any of the many pseudoscientific
   interventions under a generally attractive umbrella of ‘wellness’. This makes
   acupuncture even less reliable and hides it from public scrutiny.

   Acupuncture has been studied for decades and the evidence that it can provide
   clinical benefits continues to be weak and inconsistent. There is no longer 
   any justification for more studies. There is already enough evidence to
   confidently conclude that acupuncture doesn’t work. It is merely a theatrical
   placebo based on pre-scientific myths.

   All health care providers who accept that they should base their treatments
   on scientific evidence whenever credible evidence is available, but who still
   include acupuncture as part of their health interventions, should seriously 
   revise their practice.

   There is no place for acupuncture in Medicine.

I, of course, agree wholeheartedly with FSM that there is no place for
acupuncture in science-based medicine, but I must quibble with FSM on one point.
Acupuncture, unfortunately, is not “losing support in medicine,” at least not
in the US. Rather, it is, at the very least, remaining popular, if not outright 
gaining support; indeed, of all the quackery in CAM that is out there,
acupuncture is the one with the most “respectability.” You can find it being
offered in “integrative medicine” programs in most academic medical center in
the US, including some of the most prestigious, like the Memorial
Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, Stanford University,
and many more. It’s also offered in most large private health systems as well. 
Currently, 45 states plus the District of Columbia license acupuncturists, and, 
as Jann Bellamy noted last week, in their quest for licensure in all 50 states, 
acupuncturists scored a victory in Kansas, winning licensure with a very broad
scope of practice. According to the National Certification Commission for
Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (NCCAOM), in California alone, there are over 
10,000 licensed acupuncturists, and a total of nearly 28,000 licensed
acupuncturists in the US, although the number of active diplomates is
considerably lower.

While FSM is correct that acupuncture is often included with a slate of other
pseudoscientific medical interventions, it is still the one form of quackery
accepted as potentially plausible by most doctors (or perhaps as least
implausible). Perhaps it’s because it involves sticking actual needles into the 
body, but for whatever reason, there appears to be the least resistance to
acupuncture and any medical center, academic or private, that has an integrative
medicine program almost certainly offers acupuncture. For that reason there is 
a lot of interest in studying acupuncture, which will inevitably lead to more
dubious studies, particularly because the physical act of inserting needles
allows for all sorts of questionable hypotheses explaining how acupuncture
“works,” facilitating its “integration” into quackademic medicine.

Indeed, studies like the one I deconstructed in this post are part and parcel of
the “evidence base” for acupuncture, as FSM has noted in its magnificently
thorough discussion of acupuncture. Unfortunately, acupuncture is now so
well-entrenched in “integrative medicine” programs that it will be incredibly
difficult to dislodge.

Emergency acupuncture!

For whatever reason, acupuncturists and acupuncture believers think that
acupuncture can be useful in emergency situations, be they in the field
(“battlefield acupuncture,” anyone?) or in the ER. They even do studies
purporting to show that. This is yet another of such a clinical trial, albeit
larger than usual. Guess what? It doesn’t really show what it’s advertised to
show. I explain why with the help of the staff of Rampart General Hospital and
the paramedics who bring patients there.

David Gorski on July 3, 2017

Link



[Ed. Note: I spent a great weekend at NECSS in New York, both imbibing knowledge
and opinions on skepticism, giving a talk myself, and participating in three
panels. Consequently, I didn’t have time to produce the voluminous new material 
that I usually do for every Monday. However, I realized that I had never covered
a certain acupuncture study that was published last month. I remedy this
situation now. This post might look familiar to some, but it’s never appeared in
SBM. As for the Emergency! images? Well, that just shows my age, and, besides, 
I’m a fan of the show and am quite sure that the doctors at Rampart General
Hospital would disapprove of this study, and that Paramedics John Gage and Roy
DeSoto would not be willing to be trained for battlefield acupuncture. At least,
I like to think so.]



You can be quite sure that John Gage and Roy DeSoto would laugh at you if you
proposed that they carry acupuncture needles into the field. Note Gage’s
disapproving look.

If there’s one form of quackery that is among the most “respected,” it has to be
acupuncture. I’ve often speculated about why this might be, and the best that I
can come up with is that doctors are a bit more open to acupuncture because it 
involves sticking actual needles into the body. It’s very easy to ignore the
mystical, vitalistic BS about “redirecting the flow of qi” because doctors can
easily handwave and postulate other, more scientific-sounding explanations, such
as that it releases endorphins or adenosine. If that doesn’t work, then
acupuncturists add electricity and thereby rebrand transcutaneous electrical
nerve stimulation (TENS) as “electroacupuncture.” At the risk of being too
anecdotal, a decade or two ago I was more open to acupuncture for this very
reason. I never accepted the idea that sticking needles into specific points
somehow redirected the flow of a mystical, magical “life energy,” but I could
imagine that somehow sticking needles into the skin might “do something.” What, 
I wasn’t sure, but something. Of course, over the years, the more acupuncture
studies and literature I read, the more I realized just how little “there” was
there and how acupuncture is no more than a theatrical placebo.

One thing that I’ve always had a hard time understanding about acupuncture
advocates is their desire to represent acupuncture as a useful treatment
modality for emergency situations. The first time I encountered this sort of
thinking was nearly ten years ago, when I first learned of “battlefield
acupuncture.” Yes, it is exactly what it sounds like, and unfortunately it’s
becoming more common in the military. Indeed, in 2017 flight surgeons are being 
trained in the technique, to be used on wounded soldiers in Afghanistan and
wherever US troops are in harm’s way. Then there’s “emergency acupuncture,”
which is, as it sounds, the use of acupuncture in the emergency room. I’ve
deconstructed various studies of acupuncture use in the emergency room over the 
years, and it never ceases to amaze me how any emergency medicine physician
could think this was a good idea. Well, here’s another one out of Australia by
Cohen et al entitled, “Acupuncture for analgesia in the emergency department: a 
multicentre, randomised, equivalence and non-inferiority trial.”



You can be sure that Dr. Brackett is not writing an order for emergency
acupuncture. If he did, you can be equally sure that Dr. Early (watching) would 
slap him upside the head.

Before I dig into the study itself, I often like to look at how the study is
being reported in the press. The Conversation let the first author of the paper,
Marc Cohen, Professor of Health Sciences, RMIT University, basically pimp his
paper’s findings under the title “Emergency doctors are using acupuncture to
treat pain, now here’s the evidence.” It’s basically a recounting of the study
itself, touting it as the “largest of its kind in the world,” as though size
guaranteed scientific rigor. First, he notes:

   Using acupuncture to relieve pain involves placing needles in various parts
   of the body to stimulate the release of endorphins and other neurochemicals, 
   which can act as the body’s naturally occurring pain relievers.

   For generations various cultures around the world have used acupuncture to
   treat multiple conditions, including providing pain relief. And in Australia,
   it is reimbursed through the Medicare Benefits Schedule when administered by
   a medical doctor.

Of course, this is just the usual nonsense acupuncture apologists routinely lay 
down as a justification for their theatrical placebo. It’s basically handwaving 
and impressive, sciencey-sounding babble. He does, however, provide a succinct
explanation of what an “equivalence” or “non-inferiority” study is:

   Our trial was an “equivalence” study, which means we aimed to see if the
   different treatments were equivalent rather than seeing if they were better
   than placebo. We did this as it would not be ethical to give a placebo to
   people coming to an emergency department for pain relief.

This is, of course, a reasonable enough rationale to run a non-inferiority
study. It’s the reason most such studies are run, because, for whatever reason
(usually ethical), a placebo control arm can’t be used. I also note that this is
a pragmatic trial as well. The idea is to show that the novel treatment is not 
inferior to existing standard-of-care treatments. What is usually done is to
decide upon a non-inferiority margin, which is basically how much different by
whatever scale measured than control an effect has to be before it is considered
clinically inferior. It’s also reasonable to do a randomized controlled
clinical trial using a design appropriate for a non-inferiority trial. Those are
the pluses of the trial, such as they are. And, yes, it’s a decent-sized trial,
although by no means really large. Indeed, that this is being touted as the
largest such trial of its kind in the world rather speaks poorly of the state of
acupuncture research. In any case, the study involved 1,964 patients who were
assessed between January 2010 and December 2011, resulting in the randomization 
of 528 patients with acute low back pain (270 patients), migraine (92) or ankle 
sprain (166) to acupuncture alone (177 patients), acupuncture plus
pharmacotherapy (178) or pharmacotherapy alone (173). (1,112 patients did not
meet inclusion criteria, and 324 declined to participate.) The study itself was 
carried out at four different tertiary hospitals in Melbourne, Australia.
Finally, the primary outcome measure assessed was pain at one hour (called T1 in
the study). Clinically relevant pain relief was defined as achieving a pain
score on a 10-point verbal numerical rating scale (VNRS) below 4, and
statistically relevant pain relief as a reduction in VNRS score of greater than 
2 units.



Nurse Dixie McCall, upon hearing that someone did a study of acupuncture in the 
emergency room. She does not approve.

The interventions themselves included:

   Acupuncture alone. Acupuncture was provided by either a registered Chinese
   medicine practitioner or an ED physician with medical acupuncture
   qualifications. Treatment protocols (online Appendix), determined by a panel 
   of specialist acupuncturists, provided predetermined points for each
   condition, as well as additional points for individualising treatment.

   Pharmacotherapy alone. Pharmacotherapy was administered according to a
   standardised protocol based on the relevant national guidelines of the
   National Institute of Clinical Studies and the National Health and Medical
   Research Council. This protocol included first and second line drugs, as well
   as rescue medication administered at the discretion of the treating
   physicians, regardless of group allocation.

   Combined treatment. Combined therapy included both acupuncture and
   pharmacotherapy, with acupuncture administered 15 minutes before or after
   pharmacotherapy to maintain blinding of the acupuncturist.

You can see the pragmatic trial design. The acupuncturists could individualize
treatment within limits, and pharmacotherapy could also be personalized within
the context of Australian national guidelines for the pharmacotherapy of pain.
Here I consider it important to mention that I’ve discussed the use of pragmatic
trials in acupuncture more times than I can remember. There is one requirement 
for a pragmatic trial, and it’s a requirement for a non-inferiority trial as
well. That requirement is that the novel modality being tested against
standard-of-care must already have been demonstrated to work in randomized
clinical trials. As much as acupuncturists like to try to claim that acupuncture
has been shown to work for the various health issues for which it is used, in
reality when you look closely it’s not hard to see that the studies are most
consistent with acupuncture “working” through placebo effects, not through any
specific physiologic effect. As I like to say when discussing acupuncture
studies, doing pragmatic studies on acupuncture is putting the cart before the
horse. The same is true of non-inferiority studies. Show that acupuncture works 
in randomized clinical trials first, and then do the pragmatic or
non-inferiority trials, if applicable.

So back to this study. There’s another aspect to the design of the study that
should make you immediately question its results. Before I get to that, I’ll
tell you the results. Quite predictably the trial showed noninferiority.
Basically, acupuncture was not detectably inferior in short turn pain relief in 
any of the conditions tested. Depressingly, overall, only 16% of patients had
clinically relevant pain relief and 36.9% statistically relevant pain relief at 
T1. That’s a rather low number. Then there were no statistically significant
differences between the three groups. Now what would you think if I were to tell
you that this was only a single-blind study? Neither the patients nor the
practitioners were blinded to experimental group. Those who assessed pain scores
were blinded, and so were the statisticians who carried out the analysis. Thus,
the potential for placebo effects was maximized.

There’s also another little tidbit buried in the results that no one seems to be
reporting on, and that’s the use of rescue analgesics. “Rescue” therapy is
additional therapy given at the discretion of the treating physician after the
primary therapy, usually because there hasn’t been sufficient improvement. In
the case of this study:

   The acupuncture only group received significantly more rescue medication
   therapy than the groups that received pharmacotherapy (at T1: p=0.016; after 
   T1: p=0.008; Box 6). Oral opiate medication was offered as first line rescue 
   medication to patients in the acupuncture group and parenteral opiates to the
   two pharmacotherapy groups.

Basically, the acupuncture-only group was nearly twice as likely to require
rescue opioids as pharmacotherapy alone after T1. To me this suggests that
acupuncture doesn’t work for the types of pain for which it was being tested.
The authors grudgingly concede this possibility too, but can’t help but adding
some hand waving in an effort to explain this result:

   While pain reduction at T1 was similar for all three groups, patients in the 
   acupuncture group were almost twice as likely to receive rescue analgesia.
   This may indicate that acupuncture was ineffective and patients sought
   alternative analgesia or that they were more likely to accept pharmacotherapy
   because they felt they had missed out on standard care, whereas patients who
   had already received oral opiates were reluctant to accept parenteral
   opiates. Patients treated with acupuncture who received rescue medication
   were classified as having received pharmacotherapy in the PP analysis, in
   which the equivalence and non-inferiority of groups were maintained, but we
   cannot discount the possibility that this may partly reflect the potentially 
   self-limiting nature of the treated conditions.

So, basically what we have here is a pragmatic non-inferiority study that is
only single blinded that purports to find no difference between acupuncture and 
pharmacotherapy for several different kinds of pain with different etiologies.
(Seriously, migraine headaches are very different from ankle sprains and low
back pain.) The lack of full double-blinding easily explains the positive result
of the trial as very likely due to placebo effects, after all. Moreover, this
study finds significantly increased use of rescue treatments for the
acupuncture-alone group, which implies that the subjects in the
acupuncture-alone group were not getting adequate pain relief.

Of course, none of this tops the authors from concluding:

   There is a clear demand for analgesia in the ED and a multimodal approach is 
   desirable given concerns about the use of opioids and the potential for
   addiction. Some Australian EDs already offer acupuncture as an alternative
   when trained staff are available, and the relative efficacy, acceptability
   and safety of acupuncture support its playing a role in non-pharmacological
   analgesia in acute care settings. Acupuncture may also improve patient
   satisfaction by providing analgesia to patients with contraindications for
   certain drugs, and for those who prefer acupuncture. Pain management in EDs
   in general must be improved. The potential role of acupuncture should also be
   further explored, including determining the conditions in which it is most
   useful and the feasibility of employing it in emergency settings, including
   acupuncture training for emergency physicians and allied health personnel.

I’ll agree that there’s a clear demand for effective analgesia in the emergency 
room, although for short term use for pain relief opioids are acceptably safe.
Increasingly, there has been a narrative among advocates of “integrative
medicine” that equates nonpharmacological methods of pain management with woo.
What this study does is basically to use the opioid epidemic as an excuse for
embracing quackery. Quackademic medicine marches on.

Oh, and, given that this is the Fourth of July weekend, if you or anyone you
know happen to blow a finger off with fireworks, demand real analgesia.

False Claims for Acupuncture

Acupuncture proponents claim that acupuncture works for a long list of medical
indications, and claiming that this is supported by evidence. Meanwhile the
actual evidence, fairly and rigorously evaluated, is negative.

Steven Novella on December 6, 2017

Link



The principles of science-based medicine include using all available scientific 
evidence to assess the safety, efficacy, and risk vs benefit of any medical
intervention. Further, treatments supported by rigorous evidence should be
preferred over those with less scientific support, and there should be a lower
boundary of plausibility and evidence below which it is unethical to recommend
treatments. Finally, the ethics of patient autonomy require transparency and
honesty. Patients cannot make informed decisions and cannot protect their
autonomy if they are lied to.

There are regulations about what kinds of claims can be made for medical
products and services, but they vary from country to country, and generally are 
fairly loose. Even when regulations exist, enforcement is largely inadequate.
This leaves consumers fending for themselves when it comes to important medical 
decisions involving complex and technical scientific data.

This is an endemic and significant problem in the arena of “alternative”
medicine. This artificial category was created in order to market dubious
treatments that lack scientific support. Proponents have been working for
decades to weaken standards of care for themselves and their treatments, change 
the rules of science, and carve out a favorable regulatory space in which to
operate. When you lower standards in this way it should be no surprise that all 
standards suffer – including basic transparency and honesty. 

A review of acupuncture claims

A recent study published in the New Zealand Medical Journal reviews claims made 
for acupuncture on practitioner websites. They found:

   A search of acupuncturists’ websites shows that many claim to be able to
   treat a wide range of conditions, despite a lack of evidence showing the
   efficacy of acupuncture in the treatment of those conditions. Practitioners
   and owners of websites likely to be in breach of the Medicines Act include
   many committee members from acupuncture’s professional bodies.

The study was performed by Daniel Ryan from the Society for Science Based
Healthcare. He compared the claims to a list of medical conditions that it is
illegal to claim to treat without approval, and found:

   … for the 101 included websites, the three most frequent claims were around
   the treatment or prevention of mental illness, infertility and arthritis (all
   on the list).

   Combined, these claims appeared on 73 per cent of the websites. He also found
   11 per cent of sites claimed acupuncture could treat or prevent cancer, 23
   per cent made diabetes claims, 19 per cent targeted thrombosis and 14 per
   cent offered help for heart disease.

For comparison, I did a quick survey of 10 acupuncturist websites local to me in
Connecticut. Two sites did not make specific disease claims, only offered
acupuncture for a “variety of conditions.” The other eight sites made specific
claims to be able to treat many conditions, including arthritis, hypertension,
migraine, Lyme disease, anxiety, allergies, insomnia, Bell’s palsy, stroke
symptoms, and more. Half of the sites claimed to treat over 50 conditions with
acupuncture. None claimed to treat cancer, but half claimed to treat the side
effects of chemotherapy or cancer pain.

Kate Roberts from Acupuncture New Zealand, in response to Ryan’s article, said
in an interview:

   Roberts said Ryan was also a member of the Skeptics Society and the report
   was part of a “witch hunt” against acupuncture that was “tiresome, often
   misinformed and misleading”.

   “They say acupuncture has no evidence base, but that’s absolutely incorrect. 
   There are huge numbers of systematic reviews on acupuncture proving that it
   is a good treatment for many conditions and that is why it is in 1000
   clinical guidelines worldwide.”

That, of course, is the question – what does the evidence say about the
effectiveness of acupuncture?

Acupuncture does not work

A science-based review of acupuncture finds that the claims made for it are
highly implausible and there is no single indication for which there is robust
evidence of efficacy. Yet proponents, like Roberts, claim that there is
evidence. Why the disconnect?

I won’t speculate about the honesty of proponents like Roberts – I don’t know
what she really believes, but that does not really matter. It is possible that
she simply has a very different idea of what constitutes scientific evidence
than I do. I my experience when a proponent of alternative medicine claims that 
a treatment is evidence-based or backed by science they mean that there is some 
study somewhere that was positive. They do not mean that the evidence meets a
reasonable science-based standard.

To review that standard (which bears frequent repeating):

  1. Claims should be clearly defined. For example, with acupuncture, proponents
    need to define exactly what it is. There is a consistent definition of
    acupuncture on the sites I reviewed and in general – sticking thin
    acupuncture needles into specific acupuncture points. However,
    acupuncturists cannot change the definition as needed when the evidence is
    negative (by counting poking the skin in random locations as acupuncture, or
    electrical stimulation as acupuncture).

  2. There should be rigorous trials of sufficient power that are properly blinded 
    with a reasonable assessment of the blinding, showing clinically and
    statistically significant positive results.

  3. Independent replication showing an overall pattern of effectiveness in the
    literature.

  4. The clinical evidence needs to be proportional to the scientific plausibility 
    of the claims being made.

Even if we do not count the fourth criterion regarding plausibility, acupuncture
does not meet these basic standards for being science based for any indication.
Acupuncture studies generally are of poor quality. High quality well-controlled
studies generally are negative.

So how can Roberts claim that there are systematic reviews showing acupuncture
works? There are several possible reasons for this. First – she is simply wrong.
She is mischaracterizing the medical literature.

We have published many reviews of acupuncture systematic reviews over the years 
on SBM – all negative. But just to take a fresh look at the literature, I
searched for “acupuncture systematic reviews” in Pubmed to see what came up.

The first was a systematic review of various treatments for fatigue from cancer 
and in hematopoietic stem cell transplant recipients – no benefit from
acupuncture.

The second was acupuncture for neuropathic pain, concluding:

   Due to the limited data available, there is insufficient evidence to support 
   or refute the use of acupuncture for neuropathic pain in general, or for any 
   specific neuropathic pain condition when compared with sham acupuncture or
   other active therapies.

The third was for chronic knee arthritis, which found that while there may be a 
benefit:

   However, given the heterogeneity and methodological limitations of the
   included trials, we are currently unable to draw any strong conclusions
   regarding the effectiveness of acupuncture for chronic knee pain.

Next was endometriosis-related pain, finding:

   Of the 10 studies included, only one pilot study used a placebo control and
   assessed blinding

Laser acupuncture for obesity:

   Although some studies have indicated beneficial effects for LA on obesity,
   the lack of evidence with high methodological quality made it impossible to
   reach a definitive conclusion about the efficacy of LA for obesity
   management.

These were just the first reviews to come up, and so is not a thorough or
systematic assessment. However, this is generally what we find – there may be
some positive evidence, but we can’t really say, the study quality is too low,
etc. When we do get really rigorous clinical trials, they generally show that
acupuncture does not work – it does not matter where you stick the needles, if
they even penetrate the skin, or if you even use needles at all.

So part of the problem comes from proponents interpreting weak preliminary and
flawed evidence as if it is definitive, when it is not even adequate (especially
given the low scientific plausibility of acupuncture).

However, the problems go deeper than that. The evidence base itself, including
the systematic reviews, are rigged in favor of acupuncture. Edzard Ernst, who
has published many reviews of acupuncture, lays out the problems:

First, all acupuncture studies coming out of China are positive. Even if
acupuncture worked, this should not be true. This unequivocally indicates
massive bias in the Chinese acupuncture literature. This further means that any 
acupuncture systematic review that includes studies from China are contaminated 
with unreliable, and positively biased, data.

He also points out that many reviews include Chinese studies that are only
available in Chinese, which means many reviewers will not be able to read the
original articles. Further, many included studies have fatal methodological
flaws. He concludes:

   Given this situation, the conclusions of any review for which there are only 
   Chinese acupuncture studies might as well be written before the actual
   research has started. If the authors are pro-acupuncture, as the ones of the 
   present article clearly are, they will conclude that “acupuncture is
   efficacious”. If the research team has some critical thinkers on board, the
   same evidence will lead to an entirely different conclusion, such as “due to 
   the lack of rigorous trials, the evidence is less than compelling.”

That right there is the difference between the conclusion of proponents and the 
conclusion of advocates of science-based medicine.

But there are some other problems that Ernst did not mention, at least not in
that one article. A recent review of registered clinical trials of Traditional
Chinese Medicine (54.4% of which are acupuncture trials) found that only 8.7% of
completed trials had reported their results. This survey was done two or more
years after study completion – that is an extremely low publication rate. The
implication is that there may be massive publication bias in the acupuncture
literature, with negative studies less likely to see the light of day.

Also, as I mentioned, many systematic reviews include things like
electroacupuncture, which muddies the waters by including electrical
stimulation, which may have an effect that has nothing to do with acupuncture.

Further, it is difficult to properly blind acupuncture studies because it is an 
invasive treatment. Studies should assess the effectiveness of the blinding in
the study, and if they don’t that calls into question the results. This is
especially true when following a subjective outcome and an invasive treatment.

Even with all these factors, essentially rigging the game in favor of
acupuncture, systematic reviews do not show that acupuncture works for anything.
It is not uncommon for reviewers who are pro-acupuncture to try to spin their
conclusion to be as positive as possible, as Ernst points out, but the actual
results do not support the conclusion that acupuncture works.

We are left with a situation in which acupuncture proponents claim that
acupuncture works for a long list of medical indications, and claiming that this
is supported by evidence. Meanwhile the actual evidence, fairly and rigorously 
evaluated, is negative.

Chinese Systematic Reviews of Acupuncture

Brennen McKenzie on October 12, 2012

Link

I’ll begin with the possibly shocking admission that I’m a strong supporter of
the collection of ideas and techniques known as evidence-based medicine (EBM).
I’m even the current President of the Evidence-Based Veterinary Medicine
Association (EBVMA). This may seem a bit heretical in this context, since EBM 
takes a lot of heat in this blog. But as Dr. Atwood has said, “we at SBM are in 
total agreement…that EBM “should not be without consideration of prior
probability, laws of physics, or plain common sense,” and that SBM and EBM
should not only be mutually inclusive, they should be synonymous.” So I have
hope that by emphasizing the distinction between SBM and EBM and the limitations
of EBM, we can engender the kind of changes in approach needed to address those
limitations and eliminate the need for the distinction. One way of doing this
is to critically evaluate the misuses of EBM in support of alternative
therapies.

One of the highest levels of evidence in the hierarchy of evidence-based
medicine is the systematic review. Unlike narrative reviews, in which an author 
selects those studies they consider relevant and then summarizes what they think
the studies mean, which is a process subject to a high risk of bias, a
systematic review identifies randomized controlled clinical trials according to 
an explicit and objective set of criteria established ahead of time.
Predetermined criteria are also used to grade the studies evaluated by quality
so any relationship between how well studies are conducted and the results can
be identified. Done well, a systematic review gives a good sense of the balance 
of the evidence for a specific medical question.

Unfortunately, poorly done systematic reviews can create an strong but
inaccurate impression that there is high-level, high-quality evidence in favor
of a hypothesis when there really isn’t. Reviews of acupuncture research
illustrate this quite well.

Acupuncture is one of the most studied practices in complimentary and
alternative medicine (CAM), and this means there is a large volume of research
to evaluate. While one might expect this to be a good thing, making it easier to
tell whether acupuncture is effective for any specific medical problem, the
amount of research studies actually makes for muddy waters in which the truth
about the clinical efficacy of acupuncture is difficult to discern. The more
studies there are, the greater the chance of getting some positive results even 
for an ineffective therapy. If the quality or methodology of the studies is
poor, the results will be unreliable. And if numerous such studies of
questionable quality exist, it becomes easier to generate systematic reviews
which appear to provide high-level supporting evidence that doesn’t actually
mean what it looks like it means.

For example, a recent systematic review of the use of acupuncture for pain
following stroke appeared in the Journal of Alternative and Complementary
Medicine.

Jung Ah Lee, Si-Woon Park, Pil Woo Hwang, Sung Min Lim, Sejeong Kook, Kyung In
Choi, and Kyoung Sook Kang.  Acupuncture for Shoulder Pain After Stroke: A
Systematic Review. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine.
September 2012, 18(9): 818-823.

The conclusion seems quite promising; “It is concluded from this systematic
review that acupuncture combined with exercise is effective for shoulder pain
after stroke.” Given that a systematic review is high-level evidence, this ought
to provide us with a fair degree of confidence that acupuncture is useful for
this problem.

But a more detailed look casts a bit of doubt on this conclusion. For one thing,
453 studies were identified and only 7 met the quality criteria for inclusion. 
This suggests that, even in the eyes of acupuncture researchers, most
acupuncture research is lousy. And the 7 studies that were chosen for evaluation
were all conducted and published in China and all showed positive results.
Their results may have as much to do with how research is conducted and
published in China as with the efficacy of acupuncture for this problem.

While there is no question that some great scientific research is done in China,
there is evidence for a systematic problem with the conduct and publication of 
alternative medicine studies there. Studies reported as randomized are  most
often not actually properly randomized. And one review in 1998 found that  no
negative study of acupuncture had ever been published in China. This strongly
suggests that the acupuncture literature coming from China is unreliable due to 
poor methodological quality and a high risk of publication bias.

A review of systematic reviews published in the same journal as the review of
acupuncture for shoulder pain also supports a skeptical interpretation of the
first paper.

Bin Ma, Guo-qing Qi, Xiao-ting Lin, Ting Wang, Zhi-min Chen, and Ke-hu Yang. 
Epidemiology, Quality, and Reporting Characteristics of Systematic Reviews of
Acupuncture Interventions Published in Chinese Journals.  The Journal of
Alternative and Complementary Medicine. September 2012, 18(9): 813-817.

These authors identified and evaluated systematic reviews of acupuncture
research published in China and these were their findings:

   Results: A total of 88 SRs were identified; none of the reviews had been
   updated. Less than one third (27.3%) were written by clinicians and one third
   (35.2%) were reported in specialty journals. The impact factor of 53.4% of
   the journals published was 0. Information retrieval was not comprehensive in 
   more than half (59.1%) of the reviews. Less than half (36.4%) reported
   assessing for publication bias. Though 97.7% of the reviews used the term
   “systematic review” or “meta-analysis” in the title, no reviews reported a
   protocol and none were updated even after they had been published after 2 or 
   more years.

   Conclusions: Although many SRs of acupuncture interventions have been
   published in Chinese journals, the reporting quality is troubling. Thus, the 
   most urgent strategy is to focus on increasing the standard of SRs of
   acupuncture interventions, rather than continuing to publish them in great
   quantity. This suggest that most systematic reviews of acupuncture published 
   in China don’t search the literature thoroughly and don’t evaluate it
   properly. Given existing evidence that much of the research being reviewed is
   itself questionable, there is ample reason to be suspicious of the
   conclusions of such systematic reviews.

When supporters of acupuncture claiming to follow the principles of
evidence-based medicine cite systematic reviews, there is a strong possibility
that these reviews don’t actually fairly present the balance of the evidence. If
they are poor quality reviews based on a biased sample of questionable studies,
then they can only serve to create an inaccurate impression of the efficacy of 
acupuncture.

And there are  systematic reviews of the systematic reviews for acupuncture
which have found that the balance of the evidence does not suggest a benefit
from acupuncture: “In conclusion, numerous systematic reviews have generated
little truly convincing evidence that acupuncture is effective in reducing
pain.” A large number of studies makes it possible to generate high-level
evidence both for and against a hypothesis, in this case concluding both that
acupuncture does and does not relieve pain. That only further clouds the issue
since naturally everyone cites those reviews which support their a priori
position on acupuncture.

Another way of evaluating the state of the evidence on a given intervention is
to compare the quality of studies with the likelihood of positive results. Dr.
R. Barker Bausell has reviewed the acupuncture this way in his book  Snake Oil
Science. As it turns out, the highest-quality studies of acupuncture
consistently find  acupuncture works no better than placebo and that using  fake
needles and  even jabbing the skin in random places with toothpicks work just
as well as “real” acupuncture. Lower quality studies are more likely to be
positive. This too sheds doubt on the reliability of positive clinical trials.

As supporters of acupuncture will undoubtedly point out, this doesn’t prove
acupuncture doesn’t work in those conditions for which systematic reviews have
stated it does work. It does show, however, that a lot of time, energy, and
money has been spent on acupuncture research without generating a consistent
body of evidence that can support it or justify any great confidence.

Which raises the issues of plausibility and prior probability, often cited as
the primary sources of contention between between SBM and EBM. In theory, I do
not object to clinical trial testing of interventions without well-established
theoretical foundations. As  Sir Austin Bradford Hill, one of the early
luminaries of clinical epidemiology, put it, “What is biologically plausible
depends upon the biological knowledge of the day.” As CAM proponents delight in 
pointing out, sometimes wacky ideas prove true.

What they often fail to acknowledge, though, is that science does a pretty good 
job of accommodating such surprises if they can prove themselves through
rigorous testing. The theory that Helicobacter could cause duodenal ulcers was
considered implausible when proposed in 1982, and it won a Nobel prize for the
proponents of the idea in 2005. That’s a pretty quick acceptance of an initially
controversial idea, and it’s not consistent with the caricature of mainstream
science as closed-minded and dogmatic.

In the real world, however, crazy ideas are far more likely to turn out to be
wrong than revolutionary.  Dr. Sanden’s Electric Belt was at least as wacky as
the idea that bacteria cause ulcers, but it has faded into history without any
recognition from the Nobel committee. When time, money, and talent are limited
(and they always are), spending them on ideas unlikely to bear fruit is hard to 
justify.

While a perfect world might allow for thorough, methodical testing of every
possible practice, in this world we owe it to our patients to focus our energies
on those ideas most likely to result in real help for them, those ideas which
build on established knowledge rather than asking us to ignore or overturn it.

Finally, some sort of reasonable limit on the time and resources committed to
investigating an idea is needed. When an adequate effort has been made and a
strong, consistent body of evidence has failed to emerge, it is time to move on.

In the case of acupuncture, the original theoretical mechanisms invoked to
explain why it should help (Ch’i, meridians, and so on) are vitalistic and
inconsistent with established science. Attempts to find alternative mechanisms
have yielded some interesting information about physiology and the mediation of 
pain sensation, but they have not turned up a coherent, unified theory of action
supported by good evidence. And enormous numbers of clinical trials have been
done over decades, again without yielding a consistent body of evidence
supporting a specific therapeutic effect for acupuncture beyond the placebo
effects of the therapeutic ritual.

So determining the truth about acupuncture requires more than simply looking for
published systematic reviews. The quality of these reviews, and the studies
they evaluate, must be critically appraised and the evidence at all levels, not 
simply clinical trials, must be considered. Finally, the proposed mechanisms by 
which acupuncture might work must also be critically evaluated to see if they
are supported by good evidence and are not strongly at odds with established
scientific knowledge. It is a misuse of evidence-based medicine to simply
conduct poor quality systematic reviews on poor quality trials with a high risk 
of bias and then take the conclusion of these reviews at face value. A more
comprehensive look at the question and the evidence at all levels is required.
This is what is meant by science-based medicine, and it is what good
evidence-based medicine should be.

                    Acupuncture Does Not Work for Back Pain

                                 Steven Novella

                                      Link

A new study which randomized 638 adults to either standard acupuncture,
individualized acupuncture, placebo acupuncture using tooth picks that did not
penetrate the skin, and standard therapy found exactly what previous evidence
has also suggested – it does not seem to matter where you stick the needles or
even if you stick the needles through the skin. The only reasonable scientific
conclusion to draw from this is that acupuncture does not work.

But let me back up a minute. Imagine if we were evaluating the efficacy of a new
pain drug. This drug, when tested in open trials (no blinding or control) has
an effect on reducing pain – it is superior to no treatment. When compared to a 
placebo, however, the drug is no more effective than the placebo, although both 
are more effective than no treatment.

Now imagine that the pharmaceutical company who manufactures this drug sends out
a press release declaring that their drug is effective for pain, but that their
research shows that a placebo of their drug is also effective (FDA applications
are pending). Therefore more research is needed to determine how their drug
works.  Would you buy it?

That is the exact situation we are facing with acupuncture research.

Acupuncture is the traditional Chinese medicine practice of placing thin needles
to a specific depth through the skin in specific acupuncture points in order to
treat illness and relieve symptoms. Claims for acupuncture, including the
number and location of acupuncture points, have changed greatly over the
centuries, but there is no scientific evidence base for any of these claims.
Acupuncture is philosophy-based medicine, not science-based medicine. The
presumed mechanism for acupuncture, according to TCM, is that the needles
unblock the flow of chi (life energy) through the body. Acupuncture points are
supposed to corresponds to the pathways through which chi flow, correlating to
specific organs or functions in the body.

Modern proponents of acupuncture come in two basic flavors – those who promote
so-called medical acupuncture, and those who restrict their claims to
symptomatic relief of pain, nausea, and other symptoms. Medical acupuncture is
the claim that acupuncture can actually treat real medical diseases, like
cancer. It is dependent entirely on the TCM philosophy of acupuncture, including
the flow of chi. Medical acupuncture is pure pseudoscience without any basis in
science or evidence and does not require further consideration.

Some proponents of symptomatic acupuncture have divorced their claims from the
original philosophy of acupuncture, claiming that the needling works through
more prosaic mechanisms, such as the release of pain-relieving endorphins or
through nerve stimulation. While these explanations are plausible, they are
post-hoc speculations and have not been demonstrated to occur to a clinically
relevant degree.

But before we speculate about possible mechanism, we need to establish that
acupuncture has an effect – that it works for some specific indication. This has
not been established, despite rather robust clinical research efforts. If there
were not a cultural inertia to the notion of acupuncture the existing research 
would have been sufficient to abandon this modality as a dead end.

To understand the clinical research into acupuncture we need to understand how
clinical scientific studies work. Typically they are designed to isolate
specific variables to measure the effect, if any, of those specific variable.
That is the purpose of using controls – comparing an active treatment to an
inactive treatment or some other intervention. Subjects are randomized to
control or treatment so that other variables will, on average, cancel each other
out. Larger numbers are required for randomization to work, so larger trials
are better. And subjects and evaluators are blinded to treatment so that
psychological biases will be factored out.

A well-designed trial, therefore, isolates the specific treatment variable to
see what effect it has.

There are two treatment variables when it comes to acupuncture. (Actually, there
can be more if we include other treatments that use acupuncture, such as giving
electrical stimulation through acupuncture needles – but those variables should
be considered separately and they are not acupuncture itself.) The two
variables specific to acupuncture are sticking needles through the skin, and the
locations on the body where the needles are placed.

Here is the key to understanding acupuncture research – when these two variables
are properly isolated the evidence shows that there is no measurable effect
from either.  It does not matter where you stick the needles, or even if you
stick them through the skin. Since these two variables are specific to
acupuncture it is safe to conclude that acupuncture does not work.

This latest study, one of the largest to date, supports this conclusion. The
three acupuncture arms – placing needles in a standard pattern, placing needles 
in an individualized pattern according to acupuncture philosophy, and touching
the skin with tooth picks without penetrating the skin – showed almost exactly
the same degree of symptom relief both short and long term. However, all three
treatments were more effective than standard therapy. The authors conclude:

   Although acupuncture was found effective for chronic low back pain, tailoring
   needling sites to each patient and penetration of the skin appear to be
   unimportant in eliciting therapeutic benefits. These findings raise questions
   about acupuncture’s purported mechanisms of action. It remains unclear
   whether acupuncture or our simulated method of acupuncture provide
   physiologically important stimulation or represent placebo or nonspecific
   effects.

The first sentence is misleading, that acupuncture was found to be effective.
This is based entirely on the fact that the three acupuncture arms showed more
effect than the standard treatment arm. However, this was not a blinded
comparison, and did not control for al the nonspecific aspects of acupuncture
treatment.

The second sentence is correct but understated. This study (and others with
similar results) does not just call into question the purported mechanisms of
action of acupuncture – it blows them out of the water.

The final sentence is the meat of the conclusion, but again is trying to tip toe
over the obvious scientific conclusion. The authors recognize that the results 
of their study are consistent with placebo or nonspecific effects, without the
need to invoke any specific effects from acupuncture itself. But I would say
that this study, combined with other studies, does not leave the question
“unclear” – it makes is very clear that there are no specific effects from
acupuncture, and any effects are either due to placebo effects or are a response
to the therapeutic ritual surrounding the delivery of acupuncture.

These nonspecific effects may derive from the attention of the acupuncturist,
the relaxing atmosphere in which the treatment is given, and the expectations
derived from introducing a novel modality into treatment. These are variables
known to have a symptomatic effect. Therefore if you give treatment X plus these
nonspecific effects you will measure a symptomatic benefit. Treatment X can
only be said to work if it provides symptomatic benefit in excess of these other
variables – which acupuncture does not.

And yet the news reports of this study almost invariably declare that “Tooth
pick acupuncture works” or that “Acupuncture, real or fake, helps aching back.” 
They are all buying the deceptive press release. This study was not designed
and is not capable of showing that “fake acupuncture works” any more than a
negative drug trial shows that “sugar pills relieve pain.” This is because, as
the authors admit, you cannot separate out the nonspecific and placebo effects
from the acupuncture treatment.

The spin that acupuncture proponents are placing on this type of evidence turns 
scientific logic onto its head. In the scientific literature the authors need to
be more circumspect, probably to get past peer-review. But then to the lay
press the spin begins. Study author, Dr. Daniel Cherkin, is quoted as saying:

   “We found that simulated acupuncture, without penetrating the skin, produced 
   as much benefit as needle acupuncture – and that raises some new questions
   about how acupuncture works.”

This is wrong – these results call into question if acupuncture works.

Conclusion

Once again we see that the best acupuncture clinical trials show that it does
not matter where or if you place the needles. Since these are the two
interventions specific to acpuncture, we can conclude (confidently, at this
point) that acupuncture does not work and that any perceived benefit from
acupucture is due to placebo or nonspecific effects.

The acupuncture industry needs to be called on their continued promotion of a
medical modality which has already been shown to be ineffective by clinical
research. The mainstream media needs to be criticized for uncritically accepting
the propaganda of the acupuncture industry.

                      Acupuncture and Back Pain – Part II

                                 Steven Novella

                                      Link

Last week I discussed a clinical trial comparing standardized acupuncture,
individualized acupuncture, placebo-acupuncture, and usual care. In that
discussion I emphasized the comparison between the three acupuncture groups,
which did not show any difference in outcome. These results are consistent with 
the overall acupuncture literature, which shows in the better controlled trials 
that it does not matter where you stick the needles or even if you stick them
through the skin. Therefore the scientific evidence fails to reject the null
hypothesis (that acupuncture does not work). This did not stop the press from
declaring, almost uniformly, that acupuncture works for back pain, contributing 
to the public misunderstanding of clinical science.

This week I am going to focus on the other aspect of the trial – the one the
researchers and the press chose to focus on – the comparison of the two real and
one placebo acupuncture arms to “usual care.” This too was misrepresented by
the press, encouraged by the overinterpretation of the evidence by the
researchers.

In the comments to Part I of this discussion David Gorski correctly pointed out 
that the study in fact did not even constitute a comparison of acupuncture to
standard medical treatment. He is absolutely correct, and the many reasons for
this are worth explaining in detail. Understanding the technology of clinical
trials is central to science-based medicine, including all of their pitfalls and
limitations. For practical and logistical reasons there is almost never a
perfect clinical trial, but mischief only ensues when limitations are not
understood, leading to a misinterpretation (and almost always an
overinterpretation in the direction of the researcher’s bias) of the evidence.

The primary reason why this study did not constitute a direct comparison of
standard medical care to acupuncture for chronic lower back pain is (again, as
David pointed out) because this was not a variable among the treatment groups.  
In the methods to this study it is explained that patients were chosen for
having chronic low back pain, among other entry criteria. All patients in the
study were allowed to continue their “usual” care – which means whatever they
were doing to treat their back pain prior to entry into the trial.

Although it is not explicitly stated in the methods, the acupuncture groups also
continued whatever care they were receiving for back pain. There is no
indication that they were made to stop. Further, one of the secondary outcomes
tracked in the trial was the use of anti-inflammatory pain medications. The
study reports:

   The use of medications for back pain in the past week (mostly nonsteroidal
   anti-inflammatory drugs) was similar across groups at baseline (ie, 62% to
   65%), but by 8 weeks, it had decreased to 47% in the real and simulated
   acupuncture groups vs 59% in the usual care group (P=.01). This difference
   persisted at 26 and 52 weeks.

So clearly those receiving acupuncture were allowed to continue to take pain
medication – their usual care.  Therefore what the trial compared was usual care
+ a new intervention vs usual care. The group not receiving any new
intervention was not blinded at all to that fact. The author’s acknowledge that 
a weakness of their trial was the “exclusion of a medical attention control
group.”

The press, and the majority of the public (which I estimate based upon my
copious feedback on this issue and from reading blog and article comments) seems
to have completely missed the distinction between “medical attention” (standard
care) as a control, and “usual care”, which essentially means doing nothing at 
all.

Given the unblinded nature of this comparison it is to be expected that there
would be a significant placebo effect associated with introducing a novel
treatment for subjective symptoms, especially one that involves personal
attention and direct physical contact. Therefore this study only demonstrated a 
previously documented placebo effect from adding such a new intervention. This
data cannot be used to conclude that acupuncture or placebo-acupuncture had any 
specific physiological effects. Any attempt to draw such a conclusion from this 
data, or to compare acupuncture to standard medical treatment, is misleading.

It also must be pointed out that study participants were included because they
had chronic low back pain (more than three months) of a certain severity or
greater despite their usual care.  Therefore these subjects constitute a group
that has already failed usual care, and it is not surprising that the usual care
group showed little improvement.

Further, this means that this study was not a prospective study of usual care,
or any specific medical intervention.

The study authors also introduced another variable into the mix. They report:

   All participants received a self-care book with information on managing
   flare-ups, exercise, and lifestyle modifications.

So really the comparison was between real or fake acupuncture + usual care +
self-care education compared to usual care + self-care education.The data on
education for back pain indicates that it is as effective as medical
interventions for acute and subacute low back pain, and effective but not as
effective as medical intervention for chronic low back pain. While its overall
effectiveness is still unclear, the contribution of this intervention in this
trial should not be overlooked. It is likely responsible for some of the
improvement reported in all the groups.

It is also plausible that the impact of exercise and lifestyle education on
symptoms differed between the intervention groups (real or fake acupuncture) and
the non-intervention group (usual care).  While there was no difference
reported in the percentage of subjects who read more than two-thirds of the
self-education booklet, motivation to comply with exercise and lifestyle changes
was not measured. Therefore one of the nonspecific effects of being in an
intervention group could have been increased motivation to comply with exercise 
and lifestyle changes.

Conclusion

In part I of my analysis of this study I demonstrated that the results fail to
reject the null hypothesis of a lack of effect from acupuncture for chronic low 
back pain – which is scientific jargon for “acupuncture does not work.” This
depends upon a meaningful definition of “acupuncture” (scientific questions
depend upon unambiguous definitions). Acupuncture is placing needles at
specified acupuncture points through the skin to a specific depth. This study,
and previous evidence, clearly shows that these two variables (placing needles
through the skin at acupuncture points) have no clinical effects.

Acupuncture proponents have engaged in misdirection from this unavoidable
conclusion of their own research. They have done this largely by playing with
the definition of “acupuncture.” One such method of misdirection (not involved
in this latest study) is to mix acupuncture with another intervention, such as
electrical stimulation, and then ascribe effects which are likely due to the
other intervention to acupuncture. (Even calling it “acupuncture” is
misleading.)

In this and other placebo-controlled acupuncture studies, proponents have
attempted to expand the definition of acupuncture to include placebo or fake
acupuncture. This allows them to use nonspecific and placebo effects from the
ritual of receiving a novel intervention from a caring practitioner to promote
the notion that “acupuncture works.”

In this study we also see the confusion of unblinded comparison to no
intervention (other than usual care and self-education) with standard medical
treatment. While the study authors did not make this false comparison in the
paper itself, their misinterpretation of the implications of their data and the 
promotion of the study results to the media has resulted in widespread
misreporting of this study.

In fact this study was not designed to compare acupuncture to standard medical
care. Such a study would involve randomizing patients to a new medical
intervention they have not already been receiving without effect and acupuncture
vs placebo acupuncture. In order to be reliable such a study should also be
blinded as much as possible.

The inclusion of a usual care arm in this study was appropriate, however. This
is standard practice and serves the purpose of demonstrating that the study
design and power were adequate to detect an effect.  In other words, the
presence of a usual care group helps calibrate the study so that the difference 
between the acupuncture and placebo groups can be properly interpreted. If there
were no difference between the usual care and the real or placebo acupuncture
groups then one might conclude that the study was simply not able to detect a
difference between acupuncture and placebo-acupuncture.

Therefore, ironically, the fact that the acupuncture and placebo acupuncture
groups performed better than usual care allows us to more strongly interpret the
lack of difference between acupuncture and placebo-acupuncture as being due to 
a lack of effectiveness of acupuncture – because if an effect existed this study
was powerful enough to detect it.

There remains no compelling evidence for any of the claims made for acupuncture.
When the variables specific to acupuncture are properly isolated there is
consistently no demonstrable effect. This study adds to previous studies to
allow the confident conclusion at this point that acupuncture is a failed
medical hypothesis. There is also a complete lack of scientific support for the 
underlying claims of acupuncture – for the presence of “chi” or life energy that
flows through meridians that can be manipulated to influence health and
illness.

Acupuncture For Backpain in Pregnancy – More Terrible Reporting

Another meta-analysis shows that acupuncture is nothing but an elaborate
placebo, and again is misrepresented in the press.

Steven Novella on November 23, 2022

Link



The press release declares: “Acupuncture can relieve lower back/pelvic pain
often experienced during pregnancy.” This is based on a meta-analysis of 10
studies. However, taking even a slightly close look at the data reveals a very
different picture. This may reflect the difference between EBM (evidence-based
medicine) and SBM (science-based medicine), the latter of which takes a more
complete picture of how to analyze the patterns of evidence in the literature.
But honestly, any competent EBM analysis should come to the same conclusion.

The study itself is a great example of the dictum “garbage in, garbage out” that
plagues meta-analysis. Taking a bunch of flawed studies and adding them
together does not create good data. These studies also reflect how deeply flawed
the acupuncture literature is, and the frustratingly persistent pattern of
reporting essentially negative studies or worthless studies as if they are
positive. This meta-analysis, in my opinion, is not only completely consistent
with acupuncture being nothing but placebo, it strongly points toward that
conclusion.

The ultimate author conclusion was:

   Acupuncture significantly improved pain, functional status and quality of
   life in women with LBPP during the pregnancy. Additionally, acupuncture had
   no observable severe adverse influences on the newborns. More large-scale and
   well-designed RCTs are still needed to further confirm these results.

This type of conclusion is now a cliché here at SBM – “more study is needed” is 
a euphemism for “the data is negative, but we really want this to work”. The
study reveals both generic problems with meta-analysis, and the persistent
problems with acupuncture studies, in an overall pattern that screams “this is a
placebo intervention”. Let’s dive into the details.

Here is a table of the 10 included studies, showing the main quality
characteristic of each study. You will notice that no study is green across the 
board – which is not only a reasonable standard, it is absolutely necessary for 
an intervention with a subjective outcome. Specifically, eight of the ten
studies did not have a blinded outcome assessment. That alone means that the
pooled data is essentially worthless. An unblinded assessment of a subjective
endpoint, like pain, is essentially measuring placebo effects, with no way of
teasing out any non-placebo effects. The two studies that had blinded outcome
measures did not have blinded participants. Therefore, no single study was
adequately double blinded. Would anyone accept this kind of data for a
non-“alternative” intervention?

But it gets worse. Only two of the studies compared acupuncture to placebo
acupuncture. One study compared acupuncture at two different times. The other
seven studies compared acupuncture to no intervention or standard of care. So of
course people in the no-intervention group know they are in the placebo group. 
These types of comparisons are essentially worthless for pain studies.

Two of the studies had a >20% drop out rate in the non-intervention group. A
large drop out rate is always problematic, because of the possibility that it is
not random. But it’s worse when the drop out is high specifically in the
non-intervention group. This also tends to happen when you don’t properly blind 
subjects – why stay in a study when you know you are in the placebo group?

One way to support a subjective outcome in a clinical trial is to combine it
with secondary outcomes that are more objective and quantifiable, even if they
are indirect. In pain studies it is common practice to assess use of rescue pain
medications. Whether or not a subject takes pain medication may say much more
about how much pain they are in than what they subjectively report. In this
meta-analysis, there was no difference in the use of analgesic medication
between treatment and non-treatment groups. That is a pretty fatal blow to the
overall results.

Essentially unblinded subjects who knew they were in the intervention group
being assessed by study participants that also knew they were in the study group
subjectively said they felt better, while still taking as much pain medication.
There is zero reason to conclude from this data that the intervention is
anything but placebo.

The individual studies are all of dubious quality, but is there also any
evidence of publication bias? Funnel plots are often used to evaluate
publication bias, because they provide a rapid visual representation of the
data. A funnel plot has study quality on the vertical axis and effect size on
the horizontal axis. What we like to see is symmetry, which means there is a
fair statistical spread of results around the true effect size, with higher
quality studies being closer to the mean (hence the inverted funnel shape).

What we see here is decidedly asymmetrical. This is a classic outcome indicating
publication bias, with more studies on the right side of the funnel. But there 
is something else here which is so classic it merits pointing out specifically. 
You will notice the two outlier studies in the upper left of the funnel. This
shows that the two highest quality studies hover around zero effect. In fact
there is a general trend that can easily be seen in this plot, with the higher
quality studies having smaller effect sizes, and the best studies being
negative. This pattern, arguably more than anything else in the data, strongly
points toward the null hypothesis – acupuncture is just placebo. We consistently
see this pattern in studies of dubious phenomena.

There is a final feature of this meta-analysis that is specific to acupuncture –
heterogeneity in treatment methods. Heterogeneity itself (differences from
study to study) are a generic problem of meta-analysis, but especially plague
acupuncture research. To understand this problem we have to back up a bit and
ask – what is acupuncture? Basically, it is sticking fine needles into
acupuncture points to elicit a physiological response that is supposed to be
specific to the points used (though there is also an incredible amount of
diversity packed into this basic idea). If you can poke the skin randomly with
toothpicks (without penetration and at random points) is that really
acupuncture?

In fact, the totality of the acupuncture literature itself is consistent with
the conclusion that acupuncture points do not exist. Further, in the last
century no basic science has emerged to support or explain the existence of
acupuncture points. If acupuncture points don’t exist, then acupuncture is not
real. One important line of evidence for this conclusion is that acupuncturists 
can’t agree on where acupuncture points are precisely, and what they are used
for. If acupuncture points were real, then the evidence should start to converge
on reality. If acupuncture is astrology (which it is), then acupuncture points 
will remain in the realm of personal opinion.

In this meta-analysis, seven studies used body acupuncture while three used
auricular acupuncture (on the ear). Are these even really studying the same
intervention? As you can see in the comparison table, none of the ten studies
used the same acupuncture points as any of the other studies. There are a few
points of overlap, but the points chosen are far more different than they are
similar. In most acupuncture studies the points are chosen by consensus of the
study designers. There is no standardization – because acupuncture points are
not real.

Conclusion: For acupuncture, GIGO rules

This meta-analysis should properly be interpreted as negative – as consistent
with the null hypothesis that there is no specific effect of acupuncture in the 
studied intervention beyond placebo. I outlined above why this is overwhelmingly
true. But again, the most damning evidence is the inverse relationship between 
study quality and effect size, with the best studies being negative.

This evidence certainly does not justify rejecting the null hypothesis, and
that’s all that really matters. This is especially true of an intervention with 
an extremely low prior plausibility, and lack of a known or plausible mechanism.
No matter how you look at acupuncture, from a historical, basic science, or
clinical evidence perspective, it is nothing but an elaborate placebo. This
meta-analysis is perfectly consistent with that conclusion. And yet, studies
like this are consistently misrepresented to falsely support acupuncture.

AI (Acupunctures Inevitable) Slop

Mark Crislip on November 18, 2025

Link

Years ago, when I was a mere lad using Word Perfect on MS DOS, it was 4 a.m. and
I just finished the final draft of a grant proposal that was due to the next
day. I spun around in my chair and managed to kick out the power cord. I was a
Mac user then, but had to use a PC for work. Mac had autosave. Word Perfect?
Nope. Its one imperfection, I suppose. And I had not saved for hours, assuming
autosave. All that work lost. I felt like crying. But in the process I became
hyper compulsive about back-ups. One copy on the computer, one on an SD card,
one on the web for any active project and backup every day. And then the whole
computer backed up once a week.

Somehow my first draft of this essay vanished. No backup anywhere. Poof. Must
have been around the time my prior machine died. So have I have recreate all
that work from scratch and there are few things as boring as recreating prior
work.

Expletive deleted. But here goes.

These are odd times. Fringe ‘medicine’ has become mainstream and mainstream
medicine has become fringe. So, is writing about SCAMs now doing what the
occasional critic has suggested: that we debunk mainstream medicine? No quite
yet. But we are getting there.

This showed up in my feeds: Study supports acupuncture as a safe and effective
treatment for chronic low back pain in older adults.

Really? News to me.


Most of the coverage on the internet reported pretty much the same thing:

According to a recent study, older Americans with chronic low back pain who
received acupuncture had greater improvement in physical function and reduced
pain than those who received usual medical care only, generally prescribed
medications or physical therapy.

Cut and paste forever. Not that anyone took the time to read the original report
with a critical eye.

Does repetition make it so? Maybe for big lies. But howz about the middlin’ lie 
that acupuncture has efficacy for back pain? Data to date suggests nope.

The meta-analysis suggests the usual beer goggle effect from acupuncture:
subjective but not objective improvements;

Immediately after the acupuncture treatment, we found statistically significant 
differences in pain reduction between acupuncture and sham or placebo therapy
(standardized mean difference (SMD) -0.40, 95% CI -0.54 to -0.25; I2 7%; 753
participants; 9 studies), but there were no differences in function

But as is often the case, different meta-analyses can give different
conclusions, so take your pick. It is the old support not illumination metaphor.
The metas often note these are the results are based on poor quality studies. I
have never been a fan for metas when the subject is fictional. I still think if
you put a large number of cow pies in a pile, you don’t get gold, just a large 
pile of BS.

But maybe they have done the clinical trial to end all clinical trials for
acupuncture and back pain. I mean, after decades of time and money spent on
profoundly flawed trials, in 2025 did someone finally do it right?

What do you think? So I went to the source: Acupuncture for Chronic Low Back
Pain in Older Adults A Randomized Clinical Trial.

This is a pragmatic study. A pragmatic study is defined as one that ignores all 
the subtleties and biases that might render a study negative. Pragmatic SCAM
studies are likely to be positive, although I cannot find where that has been
rigorously evaluated.

They compared acupuncture, extended acupuncture, and usual care for non-specific
low back pain. No sham control. No real blinding (just between those who
received usual or extended acupuncture). No objective endpoints, all patients
reported outcomes.

You know in advance that acupuncture will be superior to usual care. We have
known for decades the powerful placebo effect of invasive procedures staring
with mammary artery ligation for angina. No sham, no way to know if the effects 
one sees are the real deal or not. No sham, no conclusion. Know sham, know
conclusion.

And so it was a ‘positive’ study. I mean, why even bother to waste the time and 
money on such a worthless study. It tells us nothing and does not add to our
understanding. To quote the bard,

It is a study

Told by PhD,

full of sound and fury, Signifying nothing.

And they find that acupuncture works. My usual quibble. Acupuncture. Singular.

What is acupuncture? This study used acupuncture based on traditional Chinese
acupuncture, as if this were a single entity. Why not Korean or Japanese or ear 
or head or any of the other literally too numerous to count versions of
acupuncture? There are probably as many forms/styles of acupuncture as there are
practitioners, since the intervention is completely divorced from reality and
each practitioner makes it up as they go along, i.e., individualize the care.
Pft.

To bring the point home, the patients were referred to one of 50 acupuncturists,
so there were 50 different interventions.

You would think that after 3000 years they would know how to needle a common
problem like low back pain.ling a

Nope. They had to use a Delphi method (no, not inhaling hallucinogenic gas to
see into the future) to determine where to needle and decided

Through the Delphi process, our Acupuncture Advisory Panel recommended including
a total of 113 named acupoints (214 acupoints total if counting bilaterally):
low back acupoints (29; 58 if bilateral; 4 central for total of 62), acupoints
on the mid and upper back (33; 66 if bilateral; 2 central for total of 68),
front of the body, including distal leg acupoints (33; 66 if bilateral; central 
points for total of 72) and ear acupoints (6; 12 if bilateral). Ashi points
(tender upon palpation) are also permitted.

So it is likely each patient received a unique needling. The same response to a 
wide variety of interventions suggests a placebo effect. Which we know is the
case, that acupuncture is only a fancy schamncy theatrical placebo. But the
study design was such that if you give the article a casual reading, you would
not notice this fatal flaw, one amoung many.

But I wondered. Why do they keep doing these awful, useless clinical trials that
waste time and money?

I do not think the authors are stupid. Willfully ignorant of the issues of most 
SCAM clinical trials? True believers in nonsense? Is there a special resource
for SCAM providers where they have lousy protocols produced on demand that will 
only confirm the usefulness of their nonsensical intervention? Seems that way.

For hoots and giggles, I asked ChatGPT for a “protocol for evaluating the
efficacy of acupuncture for low back pain.”

Did a pretty good job and certainly much more rigorous than this study.

  1. Type: Prospective, randomized, controlled, patient-blinded, assessor-blinded
    clinical trial

  2. Arms:

  1. True Acupuncture

  2. Sham Acupuncture (placebo control)

  3. Usual Care (optional third arm)

  1. Randomization ratio: 1:1 (or 1:1:1 if 3 arms)

  2. Blinding:

  3. Patients blinded between true vs. sham

  4. Outcome assessors blinded

  5. Practitioners not blinded (inherent to acupuncture)


5. Participant Selection

Inclusion Criteria

  1. Adults aged 18–75

  2. Chronic low back pain ≥ 12 weeks

  3. Pain score ≥ 4/10 on average

  4. Ability to give informed consent

Exclusion Criteria

  1. Previous acupuncture for LBP in last 12 months

  2. Radicular pain or progressive neurological deficit

  3. Severe spinal pathology (fracture, cancer, infection)

  4. Coagulopathy or anticoagulation contraindicating needling

  5. Pregnancy

  6. Current participation in another interventional trial


6. Interventions

A. True Acupuncture (STRICTA-compliant)

  1. Points selected: e.g., BL23, BL25, BL40, GV3, GV4, plus additional
    individualized distal points

  2. Needle type: sterile, single-use stainless steel needles

  3. Insertion depth: per standard anatomical guidelines

  4. De qi sensation: elicited when appropriate

  5. Retention time: 20–30 minutes

  6. Number of sessions: 10–12 treatments over 6 weeks

B. Sham Acupuncture

Options:

  1. Non-penetrating Streitberger needles

  2. Superficial needling at non-acupuncture points

  3. Same schedule and duration as true acupuncture

  4. No elicitation of de qi

C. Usual Care (optional arm)

  1. Standard primary care management (analgesics, exercise advice)

  2. No acupuncture allowed during study period


7. Outcome Measures

Primary Outcome

  1. Pain intensity measured by Numeric Rating Scale (NRS 0–10) at 6 weeks.

Secondary Outcomes

  1. Functional disability: Oswestry Disability Index (ODI)

  2. Quality of life: SF-12 or EQ-5D

  3. Patient global impression of change (PGIC)

  4. Use of analgesic medications

  5. Durability: pain and ODI at 3 and 6 months post-treatment

  6. Safety: adverse events, needling complications


8. Sample Size Calculation

  1. Based on detecting a 1-point difference on the NRS (clinically meaningful)

  2. Assumptions: SD ≈ 2.0, α = 0.05, power = 0.8

  3. Required sample ≈ 64 participants per group

  4. After dropout (15–20%), target enrollment ≈ 75–80 per group

(Adjust once pilot data or institutional parameters are known.)


9. Randomization and Allocation

  1. Computer-generated randomization list

  2. Block randomization to balance groups

  3. Allocation concealed using sealed opaque envelopes or REDCap randomization
    module

  4. Only the acupuncturist has access to group assignment


10. Blinding Procedures

  1. Participants informed that they may receive one of two types of acupuncture
    with no disclosure about which is “real”

  2. Sham needles specifically designed to maintain blinding

  3. Outcome assessors and statisticians fully blinded


11. Data Collection Timeline


                                   Time point
    Measures Even asked ifWould you like this turned into a full IRB-ready
                                    protocol
Baseline
NRS, ODI, SF-12/EQ-5D, demographics
Each Treatment Visit
AE monitoring
6 Weeks (end of treatment)
Primary & secondary outcomes
3 Months
Secondary outcomes
6 Months
Secondary outcomes
It even asked

Would you like this turned into a full IRB-ready protocol

Grok came up with a similar protocol, although the Acupuncture Arms included a
Nazi salute. Joke.

The old joke was, to err is human, to really screw up takes a computer.

There is a lot of fretting about AI slop drowning out real music, art, etc. At
least when it comes to acupuncture study protocols, if you want state-of-the-art
slop, you can still rely on humans to give the purist form. Not so sure we
should be proud of that.

Image by Tim McReynolds from Pixabay


Acupuncture for Migraine

Steven Novella on March 14, 2012

Link

A recent study looking at acupuncture for the prevention of migraine attacks
demonstrates all of the problems with acupuncture and acupuncture research that 
we have touched on over the years at SBM. Migraine is one indication for which
there seems to be some support among mainstream practitioners. In fact the
American Headache Society recently recommended acupuncture for migraines. Yet,
the evidence is simply not there to support this recommendation, which, in my
opinion, is a failure to understand a science-based assessment of the clinical
evidence.

The recent study, like many acupuncture studies, was problematic, and was also
negative. It showed that acupuncture does not work for migraines, but of course 
also contains the seeds of denial for those who want to believe in acupuncture. 
From the abstract:

   METHODS:We performed a multicentre, single-blind randomized controlled trial.
   In total, 480 patients with migraine were randomly assigned to one of four
   groups (Shaoyang-specific acupuncture, Shaoyang-nonspecific acupuncture,
   Yangming-specific acupuncture or sham acupuncture [control]). All groups
   received 20 treatments, which included electrical stimulation, over a period 
   of four weeks. The primary outcome was the number of days with a migraine
   experienced during weeks 5-8 after randomization. Our secondary outcomes
   included the frequency of migraine attack, migraine intensity and
   migraine-specific quality of life.RESULTS:Compared with patients in the
   control group, patients in the acupuncture groups reported fewer days with a 
   migraine during weeks 5-8, however the differences between treatments were
   not significant (p > 0.05). There was a significant reduction in the number
   of days with a migraine during weeks 13-16 in all acupuncture groups compared
   with control (Shaoyang-specific acupuncture v. control: difference -1.06
   [95% confidence interval (CI) -1.77 to -0.5], p = 0.003; Shaoyang-nonspecific
   acupuncture v. control: difference -1.22 [95% CI -1.92 to -0.52], p < 0.001;
   Yangming-specific acupuncture v. control: difference -0.91 [95% CI -1.61 to 
   -0.21], p = 0.011). We found that there was a significant, but not clinically
   relevant, benefit for almost all secondary outcomes in the three acupuncture
   groups compared with the control group. We found no relevant differences
   between the three acupuncture groups.

There are multiple methodological problems with this study. The first is that it
is single-blind, which means the acupuncturists knew what type of acupuncture
they were giving, including sham acupuncture, which was their control. Previous 
studies have shown that the perceived empathy of the practitioner affects the
outcome, and so unblinded acupuncturists who are giving “real” acupuncture may
just be a bit more enthusiastic than those who know they are giving sham
acupuncture. This would tend to result in a false positive outcome.

Second, the acupuncture treatments used electrical stimulation. This is very
problematic because it mixes modalities – acupuncture and transcutaneous
electrical stimulation – therefore we cannot say which component is responsible 
for the outcome. Mixing variables is sloppy research, and I wonder why, with
three acupuncture arms, they did not include one without electrical stimulation 
to control for that variable.

Also, the number of treatments given was very aggressive, and not practical.
Some have noted that perhaps this is a difference between Chinese and Western
application of acupuncture, and that in the US doing 20 treatments over 4 weeks 
is expensive and not practical. This is a good way to maximize placebo effects, 
however.

Despite all of these shortcomings, all of which would bias the study in the
direction of being positive, the study was negative. For the primary outcome
measure there was no statistically significant difference between any of the
acupuncture groups and the sham acupuncture group. Once again we see that it
does not matter where you stick the needles. Since acupuncture is the practice
of stimulating acupuncture points with needles, we can conclude that acupuncture
does not work for migraines.

Some of the secondary outcome measures were significantly different, but
clinically irrelevant. You always have to be cautious about secondary outcome
measures. It is easy to look at many secondary outcomes and choose the ones
(even subconsciously) that show the biggest effect. Also, researchers often
forget to control for multiple comparisons when doing the statistics. Simmons et
al recently pointed out that exploiting researcher “degrees of freedom” can
easily result in a false positive result. What this means is that researchers
make many decisions about how to look at the data and which data points to look 
at, and can innocently bias those decisions in the direction of seeing a
positive outcome. The degrees of freedom are greater when you have lots of
secondary outcome measures to choose from. Picking a primary outcome at the
beginning of a study, however, is more constraining.

The study also did not include a placebo acupuncture group – one in which there 
is no needle penetration, or tooth picks are used instead of needles. Studies
using blinded placebo acupuncture generally show no difference in outcome,
leading us to conclude that not only does it not matter where you stick the
needles, it doesn’t matter if you stick the needles. In short – the needles
don’t matter. The training of the acupuncturists doesn’t matter. All of the
cultural beliefs about meridians, acupuncture points, and chi do not matter. All
that matters is the kind and amount of attention given by the acupuncturist to 
the patient. In other words – acupuncture is entirely a non-specific placebo
intervention. It is the irrelevant magical ritual surrounding the attention from
an empathic practitioner. This study is further confirmation of that basic
conclusion.

The most recent Cochrane review of acupuncture for migraine reflects the above
difficulties, and is also another great example of the difference between
evidence-based medicine and science-based medicine. The authors conclude:

   There is no evidence for an effect of ‘true’ acupuncture over sham
   interventions, though this is difficult to interpret, as exact point location
   could be of limited importance. Available studies suggest that acupuncture
   is at least as effective as, or possibly more effective than, prophylactic
   drug treatment, and has fewer adverse effects. Acupuncture should be
   considered a treatment option for patients willing to undergo this treatment.

The authors find it difficult to interpret the fact that there is no evidence
for a difference beetween “true” acupuncture and sham acupuncture. Let me help
them. The key point that acupuncture supporters miss when reviewing the evidence
is the difference between blinded and unblinded comparisons. In general blinded
comparisons are much more reliable than unblinded comparisons, in any area of
science. In medicine, and with acupuncture specifically, we have evidence for a 
large placebo effect, which is strongly affected by practitioner empathy and the
attention that goes with the ritual of acupuncture.

What the evidence essentially shows is that blinded comparisons with acupuncture
are negative, and unblinded comparisons are positive. This is not hard to
interpret at all – it means acupuncture does not work. Whenever we see a
phenomenon disappear with the application of proper blinding, we conclude the
phenomenon is not real. A phenomenon that depends upon not being blinded is an
illusion. Acupuncture is the N-rays of medicine.

Until acupuncture researchers can show a consistent, statistically significant, 
and clinically relevant effect from blinded comparisons of acupuncture to sham
or placebo acupuncture, there is no reason to think that there is any underlying
reality to acupuncture as a specific intervention. The best conclusion we can
make today, based on all available evidence, is that acupuncture adds nothing to
the non-specific effects of the attention from the practitioner. Acupuncture
does not work for migraine, and recommendations to use acupuncture are misguided
and unscientific.

I generally do not see this confusion in non-CAM areas of medicine. CAM, it
appears, has an anti-science field around it that confuses researchers and
prevents them from properly interpreting negative outcomes.

Acupuncture and Migraine – New JAMA Study

Yet another poorly designed acupuncture study with dubious results is being
presented as if it were compelling evidence.

Steven Novella on February 22, 2017

Link



The most recent issue of The Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) 
published a study which concludes:

   Among patients with migraine without aura, true acupuncture may be associated
   with long-term reduction in migraine recurrence compared with sham
   acupuncture or assigned to a waiting list.

In the same issue they published an invited commentary by Amy Gelfand which
concluded:

   However, this study does not convincingly demonstrate acupuncture’s efficacy 
   for migraine prevention.

Which conclusion do you think was more widely published in the media?

How do we know what works?

The meta-question here, one which we are primarily concerned with here at SBM,
is how do we know when a treatment works? I think we have built a robust case
over the years that we need a fairly high bar of scientific rigor before we can 
make reliable conclusions about efficacy, especially when dealing with
subjective symptoms.

The case for a high bar of evidence includes the fact that most preliminary
studies are wrong in the false positive direction. There is a reproducibility
problem in the biomedical sciences. P-hacking is prevalent, combined with an
over-reliance on p-values and frequentist statistical analysis.

We can further take a look at areas where we have a large body of clinical
research looking into a treatment that we can be highly confident does not work.
The poster-child for this scenario is homeopathy. Homeopathy cannot possibly
work, and when you systematically review the totality of clinical research it
shows that homeopathy does not work. We can then flip the analysis – now that we
can say with the highest degree of scientific confidence that homeopathy does
not work for anything, what does the clinical literature look like? That is what
the medical literature looks like when you study a treatment that does not
work.

What we see are a lot of flawed preliminary studies with mixed results but with 
a bias toward positive outcomes. The more rigorous the study design, the smaller
the effect size and less likely the study is to be positive (a phenomenon
dubbed “the decline effect”). The most rigorous studies are consistently
negative. In other words, we only get reliable results when we do clinical
studies of high scientific rigor. Preliminary studies are all over the place and
mostly wrong.

The next obvious question is – why ever do preliminary studies? The good answer 
is that preliminary studies help assess safety and plausibility prior to
investing in large rigorous studies. Further, they help in the design of
rigorous studies by identifying potential flaws and confounding factors. The bad
answer is – because they are cheaper, easier, and quicker to conduct. The
horrible answer is – because they produce the results you want.

The JAMA Acupuncture Migraine Study

Zhao et al. performed this study of acupuncture for migraine prevention in
several locations in China, including acupuncture and TCM hospitals. There are
three treatment groups in the study, true acupuncture, sham acupuncture, and
wait-list no intervention. They found:

   The mean (SD) change in frequency of migraine attacks differed significantly 
   among the 3 groups at 16 weeks after randomization (P < .001); the mean (SD) 
   frequency of attacks decreased in the true acupuncture group by 3.2 (2.1), in
   the sham acupuncture group by 2.1 (2.5), and the waiting-list group by 1.4
   (2.5);

Not mentioned in the abstract, but contained in the main article itself, is the 
fact that acute medication use frequency did not differ among the groups. There 
are a number of fatal flaws in this study which led to Dr. Gelfand’s correct
conclusion that this study does not convincingly show efficacy.

While the p-value was highly significant, the effect size was very small – a
difference of one migraine attack over four months (I would not consider that a 
successful treatment). That combination, significant p-value but with small
effect size, is always a red flag. Essentially, the p-value does not make up for
the small effect size (that is the frequentist delusion). This is because
subtle systematic errors in the study can produce consistent results that are
biased in one direction. P-values don’t detect the bias, they just measure the
consistency.

Not only is the effect size small, but the more objective outcome measure, use
of acute migraine medication, showed no difference. Subjects may tell you their 
headaches are better, but if they are still using the same amount of pain
medication to treat them they probably aren’t. This means that, despite all the 
other fatal flaws in this study, the results themselves are not compelling.

The comparison to the no-intervention group is of no clinical significance. An
unblinded no-intervention group is included only for calibration, to show that
the study is capable of measuring a difference, and to show baseline placebo
effects, such as regression to the mean. The comparison cannot properly be used 
to support any efficacy claims.

There are much greater flaws, the biggest probably being that the study was only
single-blinded. The subjects were blinded, but the acupuncturists were not. We 
know from prior acupuncture studies that the interaction between the
acupuncturist and the patient is the most significant (and perhaps only)
variable that influences outcome. In fact, unblinding of subjects is a chronic
problem plaguing the acupuncture literature. This is a known issue, and
therefore any study that does not properly double-blind everyone involved, and
asses that blinding, is of limited use.

This fact alone – poor blinding – easily explains the small effect size in
subjective outcome in this study.

This was also not a study of acupuncture, but of “electroacupuncture.” In my
opinion, electroacupuncture (using electrical stimulation through the
acupuncture needles) is not a real thing. It is just transdermal electrical
stimulation through needles that the researchers are calling acupuncture
needles. Electrical stimulation is an intervention being researched for
migraines. I cannot say it has proven efficacy, but it is far more plausible
than acupuncture.

This means that the study mixed variables in a way that cannot later be teased
apart. While I do not think this study showed convincing efficacy, any effect
observed could have been entirely due to the electrical stimulation. The
“acupuncture” was as much a part of the overall effect as a Danish is a part of 
“this nutritious breakfast”.

Finally, it must be pointed out that this study was conducted in China. This is 
relevant because systematic reviews have shown that essentially 100% of
acupuncture studies conducted in China show a positive outcome in their primary 
outcome measure. Edzard Ernst has this to say about such results:

   The question why all Chinese acupuncture trials are positive has puzzled me
   since many years, and I have quizzed numerous Chinese colleagues why this
   might be so. The answer I received was uniformly that it would be very
   offensive for Chinese researchers to conceive a study that does not confirm
   the views held by their peers. In other words, acupuncture research in China 
   is conducted to confirm the prior assumption that this treatment is
   effective. It seems obvious that this is an abuse of science which must cause
   confusion.

This essentially means that acupuncture trials out of China are worthless.
Because they are 100% positive they have no predictive value. Keep in mind, even
treatments that work do not produce 100% positive studies, which would be
statistically highly improbable, and is therefore a marker for bias.

In summary, this study shows very weak results, with the most objective outcome 
measure being negative, using fatally-flawed methodology, and showing signs of
significant bias. The results are unreliable even before you consider that the
hypothesis is highly implausible, and that prior research has convincingly shown
that acupuncture does not work. The study has apparently served its primary
purpose, however – to generate a round of positive press for acupuncture and
further the myth that acupuncture is evidence-based.

Acupuncture for migraine

What about other research into acupuncture for migraine prevention? This is
where there seems to be a profound effect from acupuncture’s positive PR.
Multiple systematic reviews have concluded that the evidence suggests a positive
role for acupuncture in the management of migraine and other headache types.
When you dive into the details, however, a very different picture emerges.

A 2009 Cochrane systematic review is representative:

   Fourteen trials compared a ‘true’ acupuncture intervention with a variety of 
   sham interventions. Pooled analyses did not show a statistically significant 
   superiority for true acupuncture for any outcome in any of the time windows, 
   but the results of single trials varied considerably.

Even taken at face value, the research does not show that true acupuncture is
superior to sham acupuncture. Acupuncture is superior to no treatment, which as 
I stated above tells us nothing.

The results are further questionable, however, when you consider two significant
confounding factors. The systematic reviews contain studies that use
electroacupuncture, which is a confounding variable that makes the result
uninterpretable. Further, the reviews include studies from China. We know from
reviews that acupuncture studies from China are guaranteed to be positive, which
means there are certainly false-positive studies in the mix. Therefore any
systematic review or meta-analysis that incorporates data from China is
contaminated and the results are not reliable.

Conclusion: Acupuncture still doesn’t work

The plausibility of acupuncture is extremely low, even for the indications for
which it is mostly advocated (subjective symptoms like pain). The overall
literature on acupuncture is also negative. What the studies show is that it
does not matter where you stick the needles, if you even stick needles through
the skin, or if you elicit the dequi sensation which is supposed to be necessary
for an effect. The training of the acupuncturist does not matter. The evidence 
shows that acupuncture points do not exist, and they have no plausible basis in 
anatomy, physiology, or any aspect of biology.

The clinical research on acupuncture is a mess. Most studies have major design
flaws, mix variables, have poor blinding, and variable outcomes. The overall
patterns in the acupuncture literature mirror those of the homeopathy
literature, meaning that it is consistent with a treatment that does not work.

Despite this negative evidence and lack of plausibility, acupuncture enjoys
perhaps the best public relations among alternative medicine treatments. The
flow of poor quality and biased research, reviewed largely by proponents, has
managed to convince the unwary that acupuncture works.

While I applaud JAMA for including an invited commentary with this latest
acupuncture study, they have, I think, overall done a disservice by publishing
yet another crappy acupuncture study that will simply lend to the pervasive myth
that acupuncture works.

Acupuncture for Migraine Unconvincing

The evidence for the effectiveness of acupuncture in migraines remains
unconvincing, and a new study changes nothing.

Steven Novella on April 1, 2020

Link



A recent study published in the BMJ nicely illustrates many of the reasons I
find the evidence for the effectiveness of acupuncture for migraines (or
anything else, really) very unconvincing. Acupuncture is the practice of
sticking needles into acupuncture points for various symptoms and disease
modification. While often touted as an “ancient” therapy, what currently passes 
for acupuncture is a very modern (20th century) reinvention. But still, it is
based on the prescientific notions of life force (chi) occurring in two
different flavors (yin and yang) and flowing through meridians in the body.
There is no scientific basis for any of this.

In fact, not only is there no evidence supporting the existence of acupuncture
points, a 2019 review by acupuncturists nicely demonstrated their lack of
existence in practical terms. They reviewed studies of qualified acupuncturists 
and found that the location of acupuncture points were, “significantly
inaccurate and imprecise”. Not only do different acupuncturists not agree on
where the alleged points are, they don’t agree on which points to use for which 
indications. From a scientific perspective, therefore, acupuncture points have
no validity.

Further, after thousands of studies, research has failed to adequately
demonstrate a clinical effect beyond placebo from acupuncture for any
indication. In short, the theoretical basis for acupuncture is non-existent and 
the clinical evidence is unconvincing. All this must be considered when a new
study claims to show that acupuncture works, as in the current study for
migraines. The authors conclude:

   Twenty sessions of manual acupuncture was superior to sham acupuncture and
   usual care for the prophylaxis of episodic migraine without aura.

But how can this be true when acupuncture points objectively don’t exist? If we 
take a deep look into the study the answer emerges. The first red flag, which
may sound like bias but it is based on published research, is that the study was
conducted entirely in China. A systematic review in 1999, with a follow up in
2014, showed that 99.8% of acupuncture studies coming out of China reported
positive outcomes. Even for a treatment that works, this is statistically
implausible without significant researcher/publication bias.

The existence of chi and the effectiveness of acupuncture are strong cultural
beliefs in China. Also, being poked with needles has a high placebo effect,
especially in a culture that equates needles with healing. This is why protocols
and blinding need to be air tight in any clinical acupuncture study. The
current study – not so much.

The next huge, even fatal (especially given the documented bias outlined above),
problem with this study is that it is single-blind only. The patients were
blinded to their group allocation, but not the acupuncturists. Blinding was not 
really assessed – they only asked subjects if they thought a needle has been
inserted, which was not different between the two needle groups. They were not
asked if they had real or sham acupuncture. We also know from prior studies that
the attitude and the emotional connection of the acupuncturist has the
strongest effect on outcome than any other variable. So when the acupuncturist
knows they are giving “fake” acupuncture, that is likely to be conveyed to the
subject. At the very least, there is likely to be less of a placebo effect from 
the interaction.

In short, single-blinded acupuncture studies are all but worthless.

The results of the study show a small but statistically significant reduction in
migraine days and migraine attacks from weeks 16-20 of the study. These are all
subjective reports, by patients with a strong cultural belief in the treatment 
from practitioners who knew if they were giving “real” or “fake” acupuncture. In
all honesty, my immediate question was – what about use of rescue medication?
That is a good way to tell the difference between reporting reduced pain and
actually experiencing reduced pain. Remember – studies like this do not measure 
pain, they ask patients how much pain they feel. If patients know what the
desired answer is, that can bias their reporting. One way to address this issue 
is to look at slightly more objective measures, such as the use of pain
medication and other measures of quality of life. These were secondary outcomes 
in this trial:

   The total scores on the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index and Migraine
   Disability Assessment Score were significantly lower in the manual
   acupuncture group than in the usual care group at week 20. However, we found 
   no significant difference in these scores between manual acupuncture and sham
   acupuncture. We also found no significant difference in the mean dose of
   rescue medication or in Beck Anxiety Inventory and Beck Depression Inventory 
   II scores among the three groups at week 20.

No difference in MIDAS, which attempts to measure the effect of migraines on
quality of life. And, most importantly in my opinion, no reduction in rescue
medication. So while subjects reported fewer migraines, they took the same
amount of pain medication to treat migraines. That brief paragraph is the only
mention of this in the study, and the implications of this are completely
ignored in the discussion and conclusion.

In the end we have a study with high risk of bias showing a small reduction in
subjective reports but no reduction in more objective measures of migraine. In
total, this is extremely unconvincing, especially given that by all accounts the
acupuncture points they say made a difference in this study don’t actually
exist. The authors do acknowledge:

   However, our findings are not completely consistent with those of several
   randomised clinical trials, [they reference five trials – SN] which found no 
   significant differences between true acupuncture and sham acupuncture in
   reducing migraine headaches. The inconsistency might be driven predominantly 
   by differences in treatments received by the control group.

Or the difference might be due to the lack of proper blinding in this study,
which plausibly lead to a higher placebo effect in the treatment group without a
reduction in actual migraine disability or medication used.

A Worthless Acupuncture Study in Cancer Patients

This study does not test the efficacy of acupuncture and was never designed to
do so.

Steven Novella on March 24, 2021

Link



Yet another study promoting acupuncture for chronic pain is being touted, and
yet again the study is scientifically essentially worthless. The study is the
Personalized electro-acupuncture versus auricular-acupuncture comparative
effectiveness (PEACE) protocol conducted at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer
Center (MSK). MSK is promoting this as the largest clinical trial of its kind,
showing that two kinds of acupuncture (electroacupuncture and auricular
acupuncture) work for chronic pain following recovery from cancer.

The TLDR version of the critique is that – this study is not placebo controlled.
There are three arms to the study: electroacupuncture, auricular acupuncture,
and usual care. Evaluators are blinded to group allocation, but the subjects
themselves are not blinded in any way. They know they are getting acupuncture,
and they know what it is supposed to do. Why would anyone bother to do a large
clinical trial with pain as the main outcome that is not properly blinded? The
answer is clear when you read the promotion of the study results.

The main outcome of the study was reported pain level at week 12, with the
electroacupuncture group reporting 1.9 points lower pain on the 1-10 scale, and 
auricular acupuncture 1.6 points. Two points on the scale is generally
considered to be clinically significant, so this would be generally considered a
modest result at best. This is also well within range of what we can see from
pure psychological placebo effects. Introduce any novel element into a
therapeutic management, and there will be some expectation of benefit. Further, 
the more invasive the treatment, the greater such placebo effects are – so
needles produce more of a placebo effect than pills, and add electrical shocks
and you will get a little more placebo effect.

In short, the results of this trial are completely compatible with placebo
effects. There is absolutely no justification for concluding that the
acupuncture interventions produced any physiological effect on pain. The trial
was never designed to demonstrate efficacy. So why do it at all?

This and similar studies are designed for one thing, to promote acupuncture and 
more broadly Traditional Chinese Medicine, and all of “Integrative” Medicine.
This is propaganda, not science.

Ostensibly the study justification was to show non-inferiority of auricular
acupuncture to electroacupuncture, which it actually failed to do. The study was
therefore not designed to show that either intervention has actual efficacy,
just that the former is as good as the latter. But again, the study did not
reach this outcome, and so in that sense this is a negative study. But negative 
studies never get in the way of promoting acupuncture. Despite failure to
demonstrate non-inferiority, and the fact that this was not an efficacy study,
MSK promotes the study results as “Two Kinds of Acupuncture Can Relieve Pain in 
Cancer Survivors”.

The MSK promotion, by their Integrative Medicine Service, reveals the strategy. 
First, they assume that acupuncture works:

   Studies have shown that acupuncture can help with pain, fatigue, insomnia,
   neuropathy, and nausea.

No, actually they haven’t. The myth of acupuncture is built upon studies just
like this one – that are not designed to show efficacy, or that have serious
methodological problems, or that are negative in their outcomes but promoted as 
positive anyway. When you finally get to acupuncture studies that are properly
blinded and controlled, the results are generally negative. Systematic reviews
generally conclude that the evidence is weak but an effect cannot be ruled out, 
or simply that more rigorous studies are needed. For no indication, however, has
acupuncture met the burden of evidence, showing a consistent statistically
significant and clinically significant effect under proper blinding conditions.

The research is also contaminated, as this study is, with mixed interventions,
like “electroacupuncture”, which is essentially transdermal electrical nerve
stimulation. Doing TENS at alleged acupuncture points does not stop it from
being TENS – this is deliberately muddying the waters in order to falsely claim 
a specific effect from acupuncture.

We also know that acupuncture has almost zero plausibility. There is no “map”
from the ear to the physiological function of the body. There is no chi or other
mysterious force at work. Acupuncture points don’t even exist. There is no
consistency among acupuncture trials as to which are the “correct” points to
use. There is no relationship between training and outcome. You can clumsily
fake your way through an acupuncture treatment, pretending to stick needles in
random places, and as long as you are friendly and positive with the patient,
you will get the full “acupuncture” effect.

This is all consistent with acupuncture being an elaborate placebo, and nothing 
else. This study does nothing to change that conclusion.

But it is easy to see how the study is being used. In the MSK promotion, when
asked about what he hopes comes from the results, study author Jun Mao said:

   I hope these results lead to more insurance coverage for cancer survivors
   receiving acupuncture.

That is the reason for the study – design a study that does not test efficacy
and can only have positive outcomes so that it can be used to promote your brand
and lobby for insurance coverage. Acupuncture promoters are also not above
exploiting a crisis for this purpose (as David Gorski pointed out here several
years ago). The first three words of the abstract are, “The opioid crisis…”

Studies like this one are, in my opinion, unethical. Acupuncture is a disproven 
hypothesis that should be rejected. But if there are those who still cling to
this mythology and wish to study it, the only ethically appropriate studies are 
ones that ask if acupuncture works and are properly designed to answer that
question. This study is not.

Journal of Clinical Oncology editorial: “Compelling” evidence acupuncture “may
be” effective for cancer related fatigue

James Coyne on November 28, 2012

Link


Journal of Clinical Oncology (JCO) is a high impact journal (JIF > 16)  that
advertises itself as a “must read” for oncologists. Some cutting edge RCTs
evaluating chemo and hormonal therapies have appeared there. But a past blog
post gave dramatic examples of pseudoscience and plain nonsense to be found in
JCO concerning psychoneuroimmunology (PNI) and, increasingly, integrative
medicine and even integrations of integrative medicine and PNI. The prestige of 
JCO has made it a major focus for efforts to secure respectability and
third-party payments for CAM treatments by promoting their scientific status and
effectiveness.

Once articles are published in JCO, authors can escape critical commentary by
simply refusing to respond, taking advantage of an editorial policy that
requires a response in order for critical commentaries to be published. An
author’s refusal to respond means criticism cannot be published.

Some of the most outrageous incursions of woo science into JCO are accompanied
by editorials that enjoy further relaxation of any editorial restraint  and peer
review. Accompanying editorials are a form of privileged access publishing,
often written by reviewers who have strongly recommended the article for
publication, and having their own PNI and CAM studies to promote with citation
in JCO.

Because of strict space limitations, controversial statements can simply be
declared, rather than elaborated in arguments in which holes could be poked. A
faux authority is created. Once claims make it into JCO, their sources are
forgotten and only the appearance a “must read,” high impact journal is
remembered. A shoddy form of scholarship becomes possible in which JCO can be
cited for statements that would be recognized as ridiculous if accompanied by a 
citation of the origin in a CAM journal. And what readers track down and examine
original sources for numbered citations, anyway?

A recent article concerning a RCT of acupuncture for cancer related fatigue
(CRF) was accompanied by an editorial by Julienne Bower, who lists her
affiliation as the Cousins Center for Psychoneuroimmunology of UCLA. The
editorial is more transparent than most in displaying some rhetorical, i.e.,
marketing, strategies for PNI and CAM. This blog, I will show what tricks can be
uncovered in a close read, things to be alert for when decoding and debunking
promotions of PNI and CAM.

The editorial’s opening paragraph declares that “up to 99% of patients
experience some level fatigue” and the paragraph suggests fatigue may last “for 
10 years or more” and ends with the tie-in of fatigue with recurrence-free and
overall survival time.

Okay, CRF is a common complaint, but the “up to 99%” depends on a dubious
stretching of the prevalence of fatigue with the highest of the high estimates
that depend on the lowest of the low thresholds for counting patients as
fatigued. Similarly, for the “10 years or more.” And the tying of fatigue to
prognosis and survival is classic PNI hype. Correlation is not causality, and in
this instance any association may even be reverse causality, with persistent
fatigue indicating disease processes that can be related to prognosis and
survival. There is hedging here with the “up to” and “10 years or more, but the 
foundation is being laid for the familiar, but unsubstantiated claims of CAM and
PNI-derived techniques that influence the course and outcome of cancer.

The message is ‘Fatigue is common, sometimes long-lasting, and can accelerate
progression of your cancer and shorten your life, but now we are going to talk
about something you can do about it.’ There is only a string of juxtapositions
here, not a formal argument that can be disputed. In the larger literature,
there has been no demonstration that altering PNI response has an influence on
course or survival time or even identification of a plausible mechanism by which
this effect could occur. But the message comes through and finds a receptive
audience in vulnerable cancer patients hungry for something they can do to take 
control of their disease.

The next paragraph of the editorial concedes the strong evidence that the most
effective treatment for CRF is exercise, although the citations omitted the
Cochrane collaboration review that yields even larger effect sizes for longer
follow up. Instead, tertiary sources are cited for lower estimates of the
efficacy of exercise. The implication of exercising being the most effective
treatment is blunted by following up with citations of meta-analyses for
psychological interventions that find small effects, but at least the largest
effect for psychological interventions reported in a meta-analysis matches the
smallest effect found for exercise. I have reviewed in detail one of these
meta-analysis for psychological interventions and found it horribly deficient as
a systematic review and integration of data. See for yourself here.

Having collapsed differences in effectiveness of interventions for fatigue, the 
next paragraph declares

   it would be reasonable to recommend physical activity to patients during and 
   after cancer treatment (preferably under supervision of a rehabilitation
   professional) and provide them with tired education about CRF. However, we do
   not know whether these strategies will be helpful for patients with more
   severe or persistent fatigue, given that very few intervention studies have
   specifically targeted these patients.

Why the parenthetical “under supervision of a rehabilitation professional”?
Exercise is a lifestyle activity that does not necessarily require a
professional, an aerobics class will do. However, free or low-cost lifestyle
activities threaten legitimizing third-party payments for other activities that 
are unlikely to be as effective. What is going on here is the reframing of
exercise as not just an activity, but an evidence-based treatment requiring a
professional. This is a move in the game of establishing yoga and acupuncture as
evidence-based i.e., reimbursable treatments when provided by a professional.

There are lots of reasons for cancer patients to do yoga or to exercise, other
than to reduce cancer related fatigue. The idea of making these activities into 
treatments reimbursable by third-party payers might at first seem attractive to 
yoga teachers and aerobics instructors and consumers alike. However, the
medicalization of such activities inevitably brings the bureaucracy of
credentialing, and then licensing, required workshops and continuing education, 
etc. These costs are passed onto consumers, not all who have suitable insurance.
The net result is that formally free or low-cost activities become more
expensive and less accessible.

The editorial recommends extending evaluation of exercise with patients having  
moderate to  severe fatigue. There may be practical problems in doing so, such
as more severe fatigue being associated with more severe pain that would inhibit
patients from adhering to regular exercise, as well as the problem of other
cancer and non-cancer related morbidities, but nonetheless worth a try. But this
is not where this editorial is going….

The next paragraph flies up to the thin air of the woo-osphere. Stating that
there are only a handful of RCTs targeting patients with moderate or severe
fatigue, it cites some cognitive behavioral therapy studies that get modest
effects, but also–here it comes–integrative medicine approaches (yoga, biofield 
therapy, mindfulness-based therapy) that may have beneficial effects. More
foundation is being laid for an acupuncture study. But let’s look at the
citations for integrative medicine approaches.

The first citation is to a study of yoga conducted by the author of the
editorial. Missing is any citation of a meta-analysis that concludes that a
flawed literature reveals only small effects for yoga for fatigue associated
with chronic illness and that a considerable proportion of studies have
significant differences between patients assigned to the intervention versus
control conditions. The editorial author’s own yoga study is another small study
(31 patients) of Iyengar yoga techniques emphasizing

   postures and breathing technique, believed to be effective for reducing
   fatigue among women with a history of breast cancer, with a focus on passive 
   inversions (i.e., supported upside-down postures in which the head is lower
   than the heart) and passive backbends (i.e., supported spinal extensions). In
   supportive postures, the shape of the pose is supported by props. (i.e.,
   blocks, bolsters, blankets, wall ropes, belts) rather than being held by the 
   strength of the body, so that participants can perform, and maintain the
   postures without stress and tension).

Participants were self-selected for interest in yoga, based on responses to
mailings, advertisements, and flyers. The control group received didactic health
education classes that were not matched in frequency or duration to the yoga
being provided to the women assigned to that condition. Maybe upside
down-postures and backbends reduce fatigue by some mysterious, unarticulated
mechanisms, but maybe, consistent with studies of exercise, yoga is a structured
way of getting activated and stronger with the necessary support and attention 
to keep participants on track. Unlike the appeal to the wisdom of the ages
concerning yoga, this possibility is testable and potentially disconfirmable
with a RCT with a suitable control condition.

The second citation is to an unbelievable bit of woo science, a RCT of
therapeutic touch (TT) for CRF that actually yielded null findings for fatigue. 
The article describes TT as targeting “energy fields that purportedly surround
and penetrate the human body for the purposes of healing,” and assumes that it
reduces fatigue by improving the immune system. The intervention was chosen by
the one authors Reverend Rosalyn L. Bruyere of the  Healing Light Center Church 
who is described elsewhere as having extensively studied Egyptian temple
symbology, sacred geometry, shamanic practices, pre-Buddhist Tibetan Bon-Po
Ways, and various Native American Medicine traditions. The control condition
consisted of practitioners of TT administering it without the (mental) intention
of affecting energy fields. Christoffer Johanssen, David Gorski and myself
published a scathing critique in Cancer of the study and David also covered it
in a Science Based Medicine blog post.

The third citation is to a modest study of mindfulness-based therapy that found 
differences between a mindfulness therapy that aimed to help patients become
more aware of and inhibit potentially maladaptive responses and a waitlist
control in analyses that had differential retention of intervention and control 
patients.

In the next paragraph, the editorial gets to its raison d’etre, a commentary on 
the RCT of acupuncture it is intended to introduce. The segue is that this RCT
addresses this gap in the literature, i.e. the lack of studies with patients
with at least moderate fatigue. Some basic details of the RCT are presented, but
then editorial flies back up to the woo-osphere:

   findings from a study by Molassiotis et al, together with earlier trials,
   provide compelling evidence that acupuncture may be effective for reducing
   CRF, at least in the short term, it will be important to determine how
   enduring the effects of this treatment are, given that only the immediate
   post-treatment effects were described this report and to identify the
   frequency and duration of acupuncture that are necessary for improvement.

Note the incoherent hedging that I highlighted with italicizing… If these three 
studies are so compelling, why the hedge may be effective? Anyone who has ever
criticized premature and exaggerated claims of PNI and CAM will recognize this
clever defensive strategy. If critics take aim at the claim of compelling
evidence, they will be neutralized by being reminded of the may be.

So now the editorial has arrived at a declaration in JCO, even if incoherently
hedged, that the evidence for acupuncture is compelling, advancing requests for 
reimbursement and a call for the urgency to further research of acupuncture for 
fatigue that can be cited in a NCAM proposal.

The Molassiotis et al study compared self-referred patients answering ads for an
acupuncture study who actually got acupuncture versus those who got a booklet. 
This was no control for the positive expectations, ritual, attention, support,
and feedback that might account for any differences, which could have been
achieved with a sham acupuncture condition administered by interventionists
blinded as to whether they were providing a sham condition.

The JCO article reporting the Molassiotis et al study conceded that it was
unknown why acupuncture might work for fatigue, but strongly advised against any
study comparing acupuncture and sham acupuncture:

   a sham acupuncture needling method was not included because of debate
   surrounding sham methods. It is increasingly believed a sham controlled trial
   is only appropriate when two acupuncture interventions are compared. In
   addition, sham acupuncture designs cannot detect the whole placebo effect,
   may generate false-negative results,21-24 and may introduce ethical and
   practical dilemmas.25 Experimental and clinical studies have also shown that 
   minimal or sham acupuncture used as placebo control is not necessarily inert 
   from a physiologic perspective, and its relevance as placebo acupuncture must
   be questioned,26,27 even when it is not used as per acupuncture
   principles.22,28 Instead of reducing bias, sham designs may introduce bias
   against the treatment being tested.29 To regard placebo acupuncture as a
   universally effective super placebo would be inappropriate, and results
   should be interpreted with care.30

Me thinks Molassiotis and colleagues doth protest too much. What about bias in
favor of acupuncture, and risk of false positive results when a sham condition
is not provided? What about the ethical and practical dilemmas of offering
acupuncture if it is no better than a sham treatment? But before you get worked 
up and write a critical letter to JCO, remember that Molassiotis or colleagues
can simply block it getting published by refusing to respond.

Characteristically for such editorials in JCO, this one does not really offer
any serious criticisms of the RCT it accompanied. The editorial concludes

   what advice can we offer patients with persistent fatigue? Acupuncture may be
   helpful, particularly for women with nonmetastatic breast cancer, though
   patient should be urged to follow the specific protocol that was found to be 
   safe and effective in the study by Molassiotis et al.

Ah, the hedge again that I italicized, but why the urging that the specific
protocol of Molassiotis et al. be followed? It comes down to the silly ritualism
of promoting CAM with calls for rigid adherence to specific procedures, whether
they be variants of yoga, biofield touch therapy, or acupuncture. Accept no
substitutes. Such rigid adherence allows distinguishing between what is proposed
for reimbursement and what cannot because it is untested.  No matter that such 
specificity in procedures or even a credible putative mechanism for this versus 
that procedure has been established.

Spinning a negative acupuncture study: Same as it ever was

Investigators at M.D. Anderson Cancer Center reported the results of a trial of 
acupuncture for xerostomia (dry mouth) secondary to radiation therapy for head
and neck cancers. It was a negative trial, but investigators still tried to spin
it as positive, but with a twist. There was a large difference between results 
found at M.D. Anderson and the second site in China. What could be going on?

David Gorski on December 9, 2019

Link



I’m going to start this post by asking you to think a moment about spit. Saliva 
serves several functions, from being a first step in the digestive process, to
add moisture to food to aid swallowing, and to lubricate the mouth and to aid in
detecting the taste of food. You really begin to appreciate just how important 
saliva is when you see patients who no longer make it or make too little of it. 
This condition is known as xerostomia, or dry mouth resulting from reduced or
absent saliva flow. Although xerostomia can be caused by medications and
disease, one of the most common causes is as a complication due to cancer
treatment, specifically radiation for head and neck cancer that encompasses the 
salivary glands. It turns out that the salivary glands are very sensitive to
radiation, which can damage the glands, resulting first in a reduction in
salivary output and increased viscosity of the saliva, and ultimately permanent 
cessation of gland function if the total dose is above a certain level.

The complications of xerostomia can range from minor to quite serious. Common
problems include constant sore throat, difficulty speaking and swallowing, and
hoarseness. Because xerostomia decreases the pH in the mouth, it contributes to 
dental caries, gum disease, and tooth decay. Ulcers can form in the mouth, and
candida infections can set in. Treatment for xerostomia due to radiation damage 
to the salivary glands is not easy, either. Although there are drugs that can
stimulate saliva production, they only work if some gland function remains.
There are saliva substitutes, but their duration of action tends to be short,
necessitating frequent use.

Because it’s such a common complication of the treatment of head and neck
cancers, xerostomia is a major concern at cancer centers, where it can have a
negative effect on the quality of life of cancer patients. As a result, a lot of
research goes on at cancer centers looking for ways either to protect the
salivary glands from the effects of radiation or to treat xerostomia after
radiation therapy. This leads me to a study from M.D. Anderson that hit the news
on Friday, thanks to a press release and some news stories:

“Dry mouth is a serious concern for head and neck cancer patients undergoing
radiation therapy,” says our @DrLCohen.

In a recent study, he found #acupuncture may help reduce symptoms:
https://t.co/WjWXrRGaUp #hncsm #endcancer pic.twitter.com/VcA3hzH4rw

— MD Anderson Cancer Center (@MDAndersonNews) December 6, 2019

From the press release:

   After receiving acupuncture treatment three days a week during the course of 
   radiation treatment, head and neck cancer patients experienced less dry
   mouth, according to study results from researchers at The University of Texas
   MD Anderson Cancer Center.

   The trial results, published in JAMA Network Open, is the first randomized,
   placebo-controlled, Phase III trial to evaluate the use of acupuncture during
   radiation therapy to reduce the incidence and severity of radiation-induced 
   xerostomia, or dry mouth. Acupuncture treatment has very few side effects and
   is relatively low cost compared to standard treatments such as medication
   and saliva substitutes. These results support a 2011 study that found
   symptoms improved up to six months after radiation treatment with concurrent 
   acupuncture sessions.

   “Dry mouth is a serious concern for head and neck cancer patients undergoing 
   radiation therapy. The condition can affect up to 80% of patients by the end 
   of radiation treatment,” said the study’s principal investigator, Lorenzo
   Cohen, Ph.D., professor of Palliative, Rehabilitation, and Integrative
   Medicine and director of the Integrative Medicine Program. “The symptoms
   severely impact quality of life and oral health, and current treatments have 
   limited benefits.”

This passage from the press release caught my attention:

   A secondary analysis showed a significant difference between sites in
   response to placebo. The Chinese patients had little to no placebo response
   to sham acupuncture whereas the MD Anderson patients had a large placebo
   response, showing both forms of acupuncture worked. More studies are needed
   to understand these site differences, but it has been suggested that it could
   be due to the environment in which the acupuncture is delivered, cultural
   influences or the relationship between patient and practitioner.

So I went to the original study, published in JAMA Network Open  and noticed
that there was a rather odd invited commentary by Matthias Karst and Changwei Li
accompanying the study entitled “Acupuncture—A Question of Culture” that tries 
to explain the observation above. It was upon reading this invited commentary
that I knew this had to be my SBM topic for today, because it shows how
acupuncture enthusiasts try to spin what was in essence a negative study and how
acupuncture is one form of alternative medicine that all too many physicians
seem far too open to.

A negative acupuncture trial for xerostomia

The acupuncture trial by Cohen’s group at U.T-M.D. Anderson Cancer Center is the
result of a collaboration between multiple investigators at M.D. Anderson and
the Department of Integrative Oncology at Fudan University’s Shanghai Cancer
Center. The study is a two-center phase 3 randomized clinical trial of
acupuncture in cancer patients with treatment-associated xerostomia. The three
groups include a standard care control (SCC) group, which was compared with a
true acupuncture (TA) group and a sham acupuncture (SA) group. The subjects
enrolled in the trial included patients with oropharyngeal or nasopharyngeal
carcinoma who were undergoing radiation therapy in comprehensive cancer centers 
in the United States and China. There was one unusual thing about this trial,
namely that it used a mixture of “sham acupuncture” methods as placebo controls:

   Treatments were given by 6 qualified, hospital-credentialed acupuncturists
   with a mean (range) of 10 (5-25) years of experience. Quality control was
   maintained by having members of the study team, including acupuncturists,
   from MD Anderson visit Fudan, and vice versa, approximately every 6 months
   during the study period. Patients were treated in a comfortable supine or
   semisupine position on the day of radiation therapy, either before or after
   radiation therapy. Upon insertion, needles were manipulated until the de qi
   sensation was elicited at the appropriate points. They were not manipulated
   further during the needle retention period. The specific acupuncture points
   and needling methods used are reported in detail elsewhere12,15 and are
   provided in eTable 3 in Supplement 2. Patients were told that the purpose of 
   the study was to test 2 different acupuncture approaches but that 1 approach 
   might not target their dry mouth symptoms. This language was used to avoid
   deception while maintaining naiveté as to the existence of a sham group. The 
   sham procedure in this randomized clinical trial involved a real needle at a 
   real point not indicated for xerostomia, real needles at sham points, and
   placebo needles at sham points. The mixture of real and sham points and
   needles used is defined as acupuncture. The Park system, a validated,
   nonpenetrating, telescoping needle with a separate device that attaches it to
   the skin, was used for the placebo needles.16,17

I also can’t help but quote from the supplemental material how specific
acupuncture points were chosen, because it demonstrates better than anything
else how much magical thinking goes into traditional Chinese medicine and
acupuncture:

   Although many point combinations could be used, the investigators attempted
   to identify a set of acupuncture points that integrated TCM and biomedicine, 
   with a focus on using a minimal number of sites. The active acupuncture
   points for this study were selected on the basis of successful experience
   from our pilot studies as well as on previously published trials Points were 
   also selected on the basis of their indications according to the classical
   theory of TCM 1,2 and current understanding of the various anatomical
   locations and neurovascular tissues associated with each point.16

   The body acupuncture points selected for this protocol were Ren 24, Lung 7
   (LU 7), and Kidney 6 (K6). One placebo needle was placed at Gallbladder 32
   (Gb32) on the right side. This was intended to provide participants in the
   active treatment group with a stimulus that did not elicit De Qi sensation.
   Ear points selected were Shenmen, Point Zero, Salivary Gland 2′ (SG 2-prime),
   and Larynx. Except for Ren 24, which is located in the midline and the
   placebo needle at Gb32, all points will be treated bilaterally. The only
   facial point used in this study was Ren 24. We chose not to use points on the
   face that were selected in some prior studies (i.e., Stomach 4-7). Even
   though problems are rare, we preferred to err on the side of precaution and
   avoid needling tissues that could still be friable or easily injured after
   radiation. Furthermore, Johnstone et al.4,12,13 obtained good results without
   using facial points. Ren 24 is located in the midline and did not pose a
   problem. Patients were excluded from the study, if there was any indication
   of skin irritation or infection at this location.

So many hoops to jump through to take a treatment based on a prescientific
understanding of the human body. It’s also a treatment with considerable—shall
we say?—reinvention throughout history, or even, as I would put it, retconning
and, today, promotion by the Chinese government. Indeed, acupuncture as
practiced now is not even ancient, but rather a practice that reached its
current form roughly 90 years ago. Before that, it was a brutal practice, more
akin to “ancient Western” medicine involving bloodletting. (Indeed, if you want 
to read what acupuncture was like over 100 years ago, read Harriet Hall’s review
of a book by a Scottish surgeon Dugald Christie, who was stationed in China
from 1883 to 1913. The descriptions feature children with needles left plunged
deep in their bodies for days, including one who died.) Around 90 years ago a
Chinese pediatrician named Cheng Dan’an (承淡安, 1899-1957) proposed that needling 
therapy be resurrected because (he thought then) its actions could be explained 
through neurology, which is why he also proposed moving the needling points away
from blood vessels. He also replaced the previously used coarse needles with
the fine filiform needles in use today in part because he wanted to do
acupuncture on children and babies.

I will give the investigators credit for the elaborateness of their placebo
control group and how they managed to deceive the patients (stating that two
different acupuncture approaches were being tested and that one might not work) 
while claiming that they weren’t deceiving them. Here’s what I mean by
“elaborateness”:

   Non-penetrating needles with the Park device17,18 were placed at inactive
   points as follows: Sham Location 1 – placebo needle at inactive point located
   0.5 cun below and 0.5 cun lateral to CV 24 on the chin (for participants
   with beards this point was omitted and indicated on treatment forms); Sham
   Location 2 – placebo needle at inactive point located 0.5 cun radial and 0.5 
   cun proximal to SJ 6 between SJ and LI Channels (bilateral upper
   extremities); Sham Location 3 – placebo needle at inactive point located 1.0 
   cun below and 0.5 cun lateral to St 36, between St and Gb Channels (bilateral
   lower extremities). In order to elicit De Qi in the control group, one 0.25 
   x 40mm acupuncture needle was used at Gb 32 above the right knee. This point 
   is not indicated for dry mouth. Finally, four 0.16 x 15mm acupuncture needles
   on the helix of each ear (8 ear points) was included.

   The sham treatment was given according to the same schedule as the true
   acupuncture treatment. A total of 14 points was used in both groups. As the
   active acupuncture group received treatment using a placebo needle and the
   placebo acupuncture group received active treatment at a real acupuncture
   point (both at Gb 32) and with acupuncture needles inserted at inactive
   points on the ear, the blinding of the two groups was maintained.

Patients were randomized to one of the three groups: TA, SA, or SCC. An adaptive
randomization plan was used to ensure equal distribution of all factors across 
all groups and balance at each site. Patients were thus stratified by stage of
disease, age (running mean), sex, the mean planned parotid dose (left and right 
calculated separately and balanced between groups, <10, 10 to <20, 20 to <26, 26
to <30, 30 to <35, 35 to <40, 40 to <50, 50 to <60, or ≥60 Gy), induction
therapy (yes or no), and concurrent chemotherapy (yes or no). Patients assigned 
to either TA or SA received acupuncture 3 days per week (same day as radiation
treatment) during a 6- to 7-week course of radiation therapy. Patients in the
SCC group received standard care for xerostomia, including information about
oral hygiene (brushing with fluoride toothpaste, flossing, and daily use of
fluoride tray applications).

The study endpoints included scores on validated patient-reported Xerostomia
Questionnaires (XQs). Sialometry data (measuring saliva output) were collected
at baseline, at the end of radiation therapy (week 7), and 3, 6, and 12 months
after the end of radiation therapy. The primary hypothesis being tested was
whether TA is more effective than SA or SCC for reducing the severity and
incidence of radiation-induced xerostomia among patients with cancer at MD
Anderson and Fudan 1 year after the end of radiation therapy.

Overall, 680 patients were screened (300 patients at Fudan and 380 patients at
MD Anderson), and 60 patients from Fudan and 221 patients from MD Anderson were 
excluded, either because they did not eligibility criteria (eg, having
previously received acupuncture, not having intact parotids), were part of a
different randomized clinical trial, were unwilling to consent, or could not
accommodate the study schedule. The remaining 399 eligible participants
consented to participate and were randomized. There was a total of 132 patients 
in the TA group, including 79 patients at Fudan and 53 patients at MD Anderson; 
134 patients in the SA group, including 81 patients at Fudan and 53 patients at 
MD Anderson; and 133 patients in the SCC group, including 80 patients at Fudan
and 53 patients at MD Anderson. Ultimately 60 patients dropped out at various
stages during the one year followup period, leaving 339 for the final analysis.

Now, before I present the final results, I’m going to pause and ask you to
predict the result of this trial. Go on. Take a second, I bet you can if you’ve 
been reading about acupuncture studies here at SBM. Here’s a large picture of
puppies that you’ll have to scroll past in order to read on. True fact, this is 
a puppy from a litter that my wife and I fostered about a year ago, along with
their mother, who’s in the background of this picture:

For the primary aim, the adjusted XQ xerostomia score in the TA group was
significantly lower than in the SCC group (26.8 versus 34.8, p=0.001) and
marginally lower than the SA group, but not statistically significantly
different from it (26.8 versus 31.3, p=0.06). The SA and TA groups were not
statistically distinguishable (p=0.16). In other words, this is a negative
study. I also note that the effect sizes reported were not particularly
impressive, very much consistent with placebo effects. “True” acupuncture is
indistinguishable from sham acupuncture. Did that stop these intrepid
researchers? Of course not. So what did they do next?

This:

   In secondary analysis, the acupuncture groups (TA and SA) were combined and
   compared with SCC, revealing significantly lower adjusted least square mean
   (SD) XQ scores for acupuncture (28.3 [18.7] vs 34.0 [18.9]; P = .008). All
   analyses were also conducted controlling for baseline XQ, age, sex, stage,
   treatment type (induction and concurrent chemotherapy), and radiation therapy
   dose, and the results remained the same. There were no group differences
   when comparing dose sparing to both sides, 1 side, or neither side.

And this:

   Although sham-controlled clinical trials impart important information toward 
   understanding putative mechanisms and a validated approach was used in this
   study, the choice of sham comparators in acupuncture trials is still highly
   debated. Thus, as other large, 3-arm acupuncture trials24 have demonstrated, 
   the most relevant comparison is between TA and SCC. However, combining the 2 
   acupuncture groups also revealed significant differences vs SCC.

Now imagine, if you will, a drug company, finding that the effect of its drug on
the primary endpoint of a clinical trial that included a no-treatment group for
estimation of placebo effects, decided to combine the placebo and drug groups
and do an analysis like this. They would be strongly criticized, and rightly so!
Yet in clinical trials of acupuncture, I see this sort of intellectually
dishonest analysis being done all the time. This is a negative trial, period.
That doesn’t stop the authors from writing in the discussion:

   This is the first phase 3 randomized clinical trial to evaluate the use of
   acupuncture to reduce the incidence and severity of RIX [radiation-induced
   xerostomia] in patients with head and neck cancer undergoing radiation
   therapy, to our knowledge. These results support previous findings from
   several smaller trials.10-13,15,22,23 As current methods for treating
   established RIX have shown little benefit, our findings indicate acupuncture 
   may be a compelling adjunct to standard treatment for patients at risk of
   developing RIX, particularly since acupuncture has a low adverse effect
   profile and relatively low cost.

And:

   On the basis of these findings, acupuncture may be considered an adjunct to
   standard care for patients who are interested in receiving acupuncture and at
   risk of developing RIX.

Your treatment is indistinguishable from sham treatment, but whatever.

There is a wrinkle, though.

Culture and the efficacy of acupuncture

The aforementioned wrinkle comes in the form of a post hoc analysis that the
authors did. I know, I know, post hoc analyses are always to be suspected, but
this one is particularly revealing. To drive the point home, here are Tables 2
and 3 from the paper, with Table 2 breaking out the results by institution for
XQ scores at one year and Table 3 doing the same for the incidence of clinically
significant xerostomia:

Notice anything? The results for the combined group from both institutions is as
described above. However, look at the results from M.D. Anderson! The study
there was very negative, with TA not even close to statistically significantly
different from SA for XQ scores or incidence of xerostomia. Now look at the
Fudan Cancer Center results. There, there is a difference in XQ score between TA
and SA that’s statistically significant (p=0.004) and no difference between SA 
and SCC (p-0.92), or no apparent placebo effects. There’s also a huge difference
in the incidence of xerostomia between TA (22.7%) and the SCC and SA groups
(48.7% and 46.4%, respectively; p=0.003). How can we explain this? The authors
certainly do some major handwaving to try:

   This study had some limitations. Importantly, participants in China were
   treated as inpatients, whereas US participants were treated as outpatients.
   Owing to logistics at Fudan, the acupuncture sessions were delivered in a
   busy, loud, semiprivate clinical space. At MD Anderson, treatments were
   delivered in a quiet, private room with dimmed lighting. Although it is
   unclear how this may have affected the study results, it could have
   influenced the sham response.

And:

   We did not monitor verbal interactions or document factors related to
   relaxation during the clinical encounter. This may explain some of the
   differences between centers and the lack of a placebo effect in Fudan.

And:

   It is also possible that Chinese patients in this trial became unblinded,
   which could partially explain the significant group by institution effect. As
   there is greater cultural awareness of acupuncture in China, the patients
   may have noticed the use of more sham needle devices in the SA group, which
   could have changed their perception of the procedure.

Interestingly, although the authors reported the use of the Acupuncture
Expectancy Scale during the treatment, there did not appear to be a
questionnaire to evaluate adequacy of blinding, a major flaw in a study like
this. The Acupuncture Expectancy Scale only evaluates only the patient’s
expectancy that acupuncture will have a beneficial effect.

Enter the accompanying editorial:

   Findings in the study by Garcia et al3 support the idea that acupuncture
   exerts its effects not only or not mainly by needle site activity and
   specific neurophysiological mechanisms but also by expectations,
   conditioning, and suggestibility of clinicians and patients.5 The effects of 
   these unspecific factors may be quite large. Together with many other 3-arm
   acupuncture trials in Western countries, results of the study by Garcia et
   a.3 has disclosed what is referred to in the literature as the efficacy
   paradox,6 that is, even though TA and SA were similarly effective, the size
   of overall effect of any acupuncture was superior to standard therapy.

   In a previous randomized, single-blind, placebo-controlled, multifactorial,
   mixed-methods clinical trial on chronic pain, the personality of individual
   practitioners (not the empathic behavior) and patient’s beliefs about
   treatment veracity independently had significant effects on outcomes.7
   However, patients and acupuncturists are embedded in a larger cultural
   context in which acupuncture appears to support the therapeutic ritual of the
   patient in a unique way and plays a crucial role in the therapeutic outcome 
   of the patient. In support of this, recent research has shown that these
   complex, ritual-induced biochemical and cellular changes in a patient’s brain
   are very similar to those induced by drugs.8

   With these ideas in clinical acupuncture trials in mind, the cultural
   background should increasingly move to the center of attention. What was
   predicted in a small interview among patients with back pain came true: “In
   China, outcomes of active acupuncture will be still better than the outcomes 
   of sham acupuncture.”9

The authors are quoting this paper in that last sentence.

The “efficacy paradox” is no paradox at all. It’s exactly what you would expect 
if acupuncture for xerostomia is pure placebo: That both interventions should
provide a some nonspecific symptom relief and that there is no actual effect
from “true” acupuncture versus “sham” acupuncture. Both are theatrical
placeboes. So let me help the authors out here and propose a couple of far more 
likely explanations for the difference in results from subjects at M.D. Anderson
compared to those at the Fudan site other than increased cultural awareness of 
acupuncture in China resulting in more inadvertent unblinding, which is pure
speculation, given that the investigators didn’t assess adequacy of blinding. I 
understand why they didn’t, given that they were trying to claim that they
weren’t deceiving patients while still hiding the existence of a sham group in
the study from the participants, but it’s still a flaw.

One potential explanation could be that in China the acupuncturists there
inadvertently gave the game away, not because of “cultural awareness” in their
patients identifying the “sham” acupuncture but rather because they strongly
believed in acupuncture (they are, after all, acupuncturists) and their bias
gave the game away. This is, after all, not a double blind trial, only a single 
blind trial. It’s possible that acupuncturists at the Fudan site, knowing they
were administering “sham” acupuncture, interacted with subjects in subtly
different ways, producing different cues that patients could pick up on. We
already know that placebo effects are highly dependent upon the interaction
between practitioner and patient, so this possibility is not entirely
implausible or an unreasonable explanation.

There’s another explanation, though, one that the investigators won’t like
hearing. All it takes is to read Prof. Edzard Ernst to know why. Basically, as
he and others have reported multiple times, with rare exceptions all acupuncture
studies published by Chinese investigators are positive studies. Indeed, a 1998
meta-analysis of clinical trials concluded that for acupuncture “all trials
originating in China, Japan, Hong Kong, and Taiwan were positive.” A more recent
systematic review from 2014 looked at 840 randomized controlled clinical trials
of acupuncture from China and reported that 838 studies (99.8%) reported
positive results from primary outcomes and only two trials (0.2%) reported
negative results. It’s also important to note that the authors of the
meta-analysis were Chinese investigators sympathetic to integrative medicine who
published in The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine.

Authors concluded that “publication bias might be major issue in RCTs on
acupuncture published in Chinese journals reported, which is related to high
risk of bias. We suggest that all trials should be prospectively registered in
international trial registry in future.”

Prof. Ernst concludes:

   The question why all Chinese acupuncture trials are positive has puzzled me
   since many years, and I have quizzed numerous Chinese colleagues why this
   might be so. The answer I received was uniformly that it would be very
   offensive for Chinese researchers to conceive a study that does not confirm
   the views held by their peers. In other words, acupuncture research in China 
   is conducted to confirm the prior assumption that this treatment is
   effective. It seems obvious that this is an abuse of science which must cause
   confusion.

   Whatever the reasons for the phenomenon, and we can only speculate about
   them, the fact has been independently confirmed several times and is now
   quite undeniable: acupuncture trials from China – and these constitute the
   majority of the evidence-base in this area – cannot be trusted. The only way 
   to adequately deal with this problem that I can think of is to discard them
   outright.

It’s also possible that fraud was involved. As Prof. Ernst and Mark Crislip have
discussed, a 2016 survey of clinical trials in China found that more than 80%
of clinical data was fabricated:

   The scandal came as no surprise to industry insiders, however.

   “Clinical data fabrication was an open secret even before the inspection,”
   the paper quoted an unnamed hospital chief as saying.

Steve Novella also wrote about the issue on his own blog just last month,
discussing concerns about the published research of Xuetao Cao, a Chinese
immunologist, President of Nankai University, and chairman of research integrity
in all Chinese research. In brief, a pattern of research fraud involving
falsified and doctored figures was discovered by data integrity advocates in
many papers spanning decades. Steve made the argument that this was clearly a
systemic problem, and observed, after correctly noting that when “your head of
research integrity is exposed for massive scientific fraud, you have a problem”:

   There is also strong cultural pressure in China to prove that the core
   beliefs of their culture (traditional Chinese medicine and Qi) are real and
   powerful. This is ideological science. As powerful evidence for this effect
   is acupuncture research. Two reviews, in 1998 and again in 2014, found that
   100% of acupuncture studies coming out of China were positive. This is
   statistically impossible, even if acupuncture worked (and it almost certainly
   doesn’t). This is also a bit much even for just publication bias. It could
   all be incredible researcher bias, but bias blurs imperceptibly into fraud.
   When you are fudging your research methods, and you know this isn’t pristine,
   how much of that is bias and how much fraud? In the end, it doesn’t really
   matter.

I can’t help but note that Cao’s career was first launched when he was 26
because of a paper he published in which he claimed to cure melanoma metastases 
in mice through energy healing with Qigong.

Whether the divergence in results between the M.D. Anderson site and the Fudan
Cancer Center site were due to extreme bias leading the acupuncturists at the
Fudan site to inadvertently give off cues that let patients to suspect they
weren’t getting the “good acupuncture” or outright fraud, I can’t know, although
I can already sense any M.D. Anderson researcher who might come across this
post starting to bristle with indignation and anger that I would even bring up
the possibility of fraud among their Chinese collaborators. I understand the
reaction, but it’s hard not to speculate about the possibility, though, given
what we know based on the Chinese government’s own inspection and report. At the
very least there is a lot of bias in favor of traditional Chinese medicine
among Chinese researchers, as evidenced by the near 100% positive results
reported from their clinical trials of acupuncture, and, even without outright
fraud, this sort of bias can affect the reporting of results in a number of ways
that are very hard to pin down even if you are looking for them.

What I can know is that this result, which seemed to surprise Dr. Cohen and his 
M.D. Anderson colleagues so much that they had a hard time explaining it, should
not have come as a surprise at all. (Of course, one does wonder why they did
the post hoc analysis to begin with; they must have suspected something
was…odd…about the results from the Fudan site.) The divergence between the
results reported out of M.D. Anderson and out of Fudan is entirely consistent
with what we have known for over 20 years about the unreliability of clinical
trials of acupuncture from China, a result that has been replicated several
times over the last two decades. Indeed, having briefly brought it up, for now
I’m going reject the possibility of fraud at the Fudan site, barring evidence.
As Steve wrote, it almost doesn’t matter if it’s bias, fraud, or a combination
of the two, and outright fraud isn’t necessary to explain the different results 
from the US and Chinese sites. The end result is the same. So, instead, let me
conclude by asking: How could anyone doing a major multinational clinical trial 
of acupuncture have been unaware that more than 98% of all acupuncture clinical 
trials from China are positive and that, because of that, many “integrative
medicine” researchers consider Chinese trials of acupuncture to be unreliable?
How could the investigators at M.D. Anderson have thought that it would be a
good idea to partner with an institution in China to do a clinical trial of a
modality like acupuncture, for which the track record of such institutions is
terribly biased?

In the end, there’s no need to wrap oneself into all manner of contortions to
“explain” the results of this post hoc analysis as being due to various cultural
differences that enhance the “sham acupuncture” effect” in Westerners and/or
tip off Asians that they’re not getting the “real acupuncture” when a much
simpler explanation is more likely to be correct.

More evidence that acupuncture doesn’t work for chronic pain

Acupuncture is a theatrical placebo whose real history has been retconned beyond
recognition. A new systematic review of systematic reviews of acupuncture for
chronic pain highlights that conclusion and catalogues the many weaknesses in
the design of acupuncture clinical trials.

David Gorski on January 6, 2020

Link



So it’s 2020, a new year and the dawn of a new decade. Unfortunately, new year
or new decade or not, we will be continuing to deal with the same old topics.
Don’t get me wrong. I’m sure that there will be new issues to deal with, new
pseudomedicine to analyze, new attempts to legitimize quackery as we proceed
through the 20s, but there are some forms of pseudomedicine that just never die.
Worse, one of these, acupuncture, is, if anything, gaining more acceptance, as 
its proponents promote it as a “nonpharmacologic treatment for pain” and thus a 
powerful tool to combat the opioid addiction epidemic, even to the point of
fooling gullible legislators to have Medicare and Medicaid fund it while
forcibly tapering chronic pain patients from opioids they had been taking for a 
long time with success. Promoting acupuncture and other pseudomedicine as
“nonpharmacologic treatments for pain” has been an explicit policy of the
National Center for Complementary and Integrative Medicine (NCCIH) for at least 
four years now.

So, with the end of the last decade and the dawn of the new, the publication of 
a large new synthesis of systematic reviews for acupuncture for chronic pain
conditions by Carol Paley and Mark Johnson of the National Health Service and
Leeds Beckett University, respectively, is a welcome addition to the medical
literature. Even better, they break down their analysis by several common
chronic pain conditions. Spoiler alert: Paley and Johnson find that the evidence
for the efficacy of acupuncture for chronic pain is “conflicting and
inconclusive, due in part to recurring methodological shortcomings of RCTs”.
They can’t say it, but I will, yet again: Acupuncture is nothing more than a
theatrical placebo, to quote David Colquhoun and our very own Steve Novella.

While I like what Paley and Johnson have done, I can’t help but point out that
they do fall for some of the common tropes about acupuncture:

   Acupuncture is an age-old technique which became part of modern medicine in
   the 1970s. In modern medicine, traditional forms of acupuncture, based on the
   ancient Chinese concept of qi and meridians, have been superseded by
   acupuncture based on a neurophysiological model [5,6]. The unique identity of
   acupuncture lies in the process of inserting needles (‘acu’) in the skin
   (‘puncture’), although a modern definition should include the need to do this
   at specific points in accordance with known physiological or anatomical
   rationale [7].

Of course, acupuncture was and still is based on the concept of qi in
traditional Chinese medicine, the needles being stuck into specific sites on
specific “meridians” (or channels for the mystical magical life energy known as 
qi) supposedly “redirecting” the flow of that energy, to healing effect. Doctors
who believe in acupuncture have twisted themselves into knots trying to come up
with seemingly plausible physiologic mechanisms by which acupuncture could
“work,” ranging from the local release of adenosine, to local opioid release, to
interactions with connective tissue, to even a whole new “organ.”

Acupuncture is also a treatment with considerable—shall we say?—reinvention
throughout history, or even, as I would put it, retconning and, today, promotion
by the Chinese government. Indeed, contrary to how it’s sold (and how Paley and
Johnson describe it), acupuncture as practiced now is not even ancient, but
rather a practice that reached its current form roughly 90 years ago. Before
that, it was a brutal practice, more akin to “ancient Western” medicine
involving bloodletting. (Indeed, if you want to read what acupuncture was like
over 100 years ago, read Harriet Hall’s review of a book by a Scottish surgeon
Dugald Christie, who was stationed in China from 1883 to 1913. The descriptions 
feature children with needles left plunged deep in their bodies for days,
including one who died.) Around 90 years ago a Chinese pediatrician named Cheng 
Dan’an (承淡安, 1899-1957) proposed that needling therapy be resurrected because
(he thought then) its actions could be explained through neurology, which is why
he also proposed moving the needling points away from blood vessels. He also
replaced the previously used coarse needles with the fine filiform needles in
use today, in part because he wanted to do acupuncture on children and babies.
It’s amazing how even scientists who are skeptical that acupuncture has any
value don’t know its true history and how that history has been extensively
retconned.

An overview of the systematic review

Let’s dig into the review. The authors note in the introduction that by 2013 it 
was “estimated that over 3,000 clinical trials had been published with over one 
hundred systematic reviews (SRs) (some with meta-analyses) attempting to
synthesise available evidence.” So you’d think that, with that many publications
and clinical trials of acupuncture, we’d have a good idea of whether it works
or not and for what conditions. You would, of course, be wrong:

   In the face of conflicting evidence and continually changing guidance, it is 
   unsurprising that acupuncture practitioners are finding that an intervention 
   that, anecdotally at least, is often well received by patients in the clinic 
   and appears to have good results, is rejected by commissioners and policy
   makers and regarded in some quarters as a ‘theatrical placebo’ [8,14]. One
   reason for this uncertainty may be related to the clinical research
   methodologies used to determine clinical efficacy.

Well, yes, most acupuncture studies are crap, poorly designed and prone to bias,
particularly studies carried out in China, which are never negative. However,
one thing we do know: The larger the study, the more well-controlled the study, 
the more rigorous the design, the less of an effect is seen, to the point where 
in the largest, best controlled studies, “true” acupuncture is indistinguishable
from sham acupuncture.

Still, it’s worthwhile to evaluate the existing evidence base:

   The aim of this review is to synthesise evidence from previously published
   SRs of RCTs evaluating the clinical efficacy of acupuncture to alleviate
   chronic pain from any source. We have made judgements from a Western medical 
   perspective. Our approach is to outline research findings through commentary 
   rather than a comprehensive objective appraisal of SRs. We appreciate that
   the non-systematic approach is vulnerable to selection and evaluation biases 
   and opinion-orientated arguments. Nevertheless, our approach enables
   consideration of issues surrounding the quality and adequacy of the evidence,
   including RCT design, and provides practitioners and policy makers with a
   comprehensive source of SRs published to date.

To approach this issue, the authors did a search of the standard electronic
databases (MEDLINE, the Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effects (DARE) and
the Cochrane Library) using the terms “acupuncture,” “chronic pain,”
“analgesia,” “pain management,” “systematic review,” and/or “meta-analysis,”
restricting their results to English language reviews. The inclusion criteria
were systematic reviews with or without meta-analyses of studies using manual
acupuncture, electroacupuncture, dry needling, or auriculotherapy (ear
acupuncture) for any chronic pain condition. Reviews were also included in which
acupuncture was compared with sham or placebo acupuncture, no treatment, or
another intervention (pharmacological or non-pharmacological). Cochrane and
non-Cochrane reviews and overviews were included as well. Reviews were excluded 
if they didn’t evaluate acupuncture involving actual needling (i.e., acupressure
and laser acupuncture were excluded), as were reviews examining acupuncture for
acute but not chronic pain and variants of acupuncture like bee venom
acupuncture.

Then:

   One review author (CAP) extracted information from reviews including type of 
   pain, number of RCTs, treatments, conclusion and quality of evidence stated
   by the authors of each included review taken as a direct quote from the
   Conclusion, Abstract or Discussion sections of their manuscript. In addition,
   we ascribed a judgement of efficacy of each review according to whether the 
   sample size met criteria based on the work of Moore et al. [16,17] and
   adopted by the Pain, Palliative and Supportive Care group from Cochrane
   Collaboration in their risk of bias assessment. They suggest that trial arms 
   with fewer than 200 participants in RCTs or fewer than 500 participants in
   meta-analyses are at a high risk of bias, which seriously undermines
   confidence in findings. Thus, reviews were categorized as meeting our
   criteria for adequacy if they contained a pooled analysis of 500 events or at
   least one RCT with >200 participants in each arm of the trial. We
   categorised efficacy as: Sufficient evidence and in favour of acupuncture
   (+), sufficient evidence in favour of control/placebo (−), sufficient
   evidence but conflicting/inconclusive (=) and insufficient evidence to make a
   judgement (?).

The authors found a total of 177 reviews of acupuncture for the relief of
chronic pain published over the last 30 years (1989-2019), including two
overviews of Cochrane reviews, ten overviews of non-Cochrane reviews, and 145
non-Cochrane systematic reviews. That’s a lot of reviews. Let’s look at the
results.

Acupuncture for chronic pain irrespective of etiology

Analyzing the literature, the authors note:

   We found 20 SRs of acupuncture for chronic pain irrespective of aetiology or 
   pathophysiology. In 2014, SRs reported that evidence supported the efficacy
   of wrist-ankle acupuncture and auricular acupuncture for alleviating chronic 
   pain [30,31]. Since then, SRs were generally inconclusive because of
   methodological shortcomings and small sample sizes in primary studies
   [32,33,34,35,36]. In 2018, Vickers et al. concluded that evidence supported
   the efficacy of acupuncture for various chronic pain conditions associated
   with musculoskeletal disorders, headache and osteoarthritis, with beneficial 
   effects persisting at long-term follow-up (39 RCTs, [37]). The long-term
   effects of acupuncture were consistent with evidence from an earlier SR by
   MacPherson et al. [38].

   Evidence from SRs suggests that there are insufficient high-quality RCTs to
   judge the efficacy of acupuncture for chronic pain associated with various
   medical conditions.

We’ve discussed the original Vickers meta-analysis for acupuncture for
osteoarthritis. I haven’t been impressed by his followup studies, but maybe I
should do a summary sometime. In any event, I would phrase the conclusion
differently: Inconclusive literature plus no plausible physiologic mechanism for
acupuncture to work equal an ineffective treatment whose effects are
nonspecific placebo effects.

Acupuncture for headache

Regarding the use of acupuncture for headache (including migraine headaches),
the authors conclude:

   The earliest SR was published in 1999 and judged there to be too few RCTs of 
   sufficient methodological quality to determine efficacy of acupuncture for
   recurrent headache (22 randomised or ‘quasi’ randomised trials, Melchart
   [54]) or tension-type and cervicogenic headache (8 RCTs [47]). A similar
   pattern of ‘promising’ but not definitive evidence continued through the next
   decade (27 RCTs [53]; 8 RCTs [46]), including a Cochrane review of 26 RCTs
   of acupuncture for idiopathic headache [52]. Nevertheless, some reviewers
   have claimed that there is evidence that acupuncture is superior to sham for 
   chronic headache (31 RCTs, only 2 RCTs were of high quality and adequately
   powered, Sun [48]), and a recent Cochrane review providing evidence of
   superiority of acupuncture over placebo for the prevention of tension-type
   headache ([44] 12 RCTs, including two adequately powered RCTs) and episodic
   migraine ([49], 22 RCTs, including two adequately powered RCTs). A systematic
   review published in 2016 is consistent with the latter finding that
   acupuncture was superior to sham acupuncture for migraine (10 RCTs [50]).

   Evidence from the SRs suggests that acupuncture prevents episodic or chronic 
   tension-type headaches and episodic migraine, although long-term studies and 
   studies comparing acupuncture with other treatment options are still
   required. The current NICE guidance (clinical guideline CG150) is that a
   course of up to 10 sessions of acupuncture over 5–8 weeks is recommended for 
   tension-type headache and migraine [12].

Perusing these lists of systematic reviews, I am…underwhelmed. The Cochrane
review, for instance, showed an effect of acupuncture versus sham that was small
and of questionable clinical significance. The last reference (50) was from a
Chinese study at very high risk of bias. Steve Novella has discussed how
acupuncture advocates like to spin negative studies of acupuncture for migraine 
as positive, and I’m getting the feeling that the authors bought into the hype a
bit too much.

Chronic low back and/or neck pain

Regarding acupuncture for back pain, the authors again note that there are
insufficient high quality clinical trials:

   Evidence suggests that there are insufficient high-quality RCTs to judge the 
   efficacy of acupuncture for low back pain. In 2009, NICE published guidance
   for the management of non-specific low back pain that recommended a course of
   acupuncture as part of first line treatment [10]. This guidance produced
   much debate. Subsequently, NICE have updated guidance for the management of
   low back pain and sciatica in people over 16 (NG59) and currently recommend
   in Section 1.2.8 “Do not offer acupuncture for managing low back pain with or
   without sciatica”, even though the evidence had not significantly changed
   [9].

This tends to be the most common indication used to justify acupuncture, mainly 
because chronic low back pain is such a common complaint. Of course, as I can’t 
help but note that twirling toothpicks against the skin works just as well for
back pain as “true” acupuncture.

Myofascial pain syndromes

The mantra stays the same, a vague possibility of improvement plus a comment
that there is insufficient evidence:

   In 2017, Espejo-Antúnez et al. published a SR that evaluated the clinical
   efficacy of dry needling to alleviate pain associated with myofascial trigger
   points (15 RCTs [106]) and found a possible short-term benefit following dry
   needling. In 2017, SRs have found tentative evidence that acupuncture alone 
   or combined with other therapies improved outcomes associated with myofascial
   pain syndrome (10 RCTs [108]; 33 RCTs [107]), although substantial
   heterogeneity and a high risk of bias, including inadequate sample sizes in
   the primary RCTs, undermined confidence in the findings.

   Evidence from SRs suggests that dry needling acupuncture might be effective
   in alleviating pain associated with myofascial trigger points, at least in
   the short-term, although there are insufficient high-quality RCTs to judge
   the efficacy with any degree of certainty. There is no guidance from NICE on 
   the management of myofascial pain syndrome.

I note that reference 107 is another review from China at a very high risk of
bias. Remember, the Chinese rarely, if ever, publish negative studies of
acupuncture.

Cancer pain

This is getting repetitive, but repetition is worthwhile when it serves a
purpose:

   Evidence from the SRs suggests that there are insufficient high-quality RCTs 
   to judge the efficacy of acupuncture for cancer-related pain and more
   high-quality, appropriately designed and adequately powered studies are
   needed. The most recent guidance from NICE (CSG4) recognises that patients
   who are receiving palliative care often seek complementary therapies, but it 
   does not specifically recommend acupuncture. It recognises that “Many studies
   have a considerable number of methodological limitations, making it
   difficult to draw definitive conclusions” (Section 11.27) [199].

And, again, more than one of the systematic reviews are from China. Speaking of 
acupuncture for cancer pain, there is a recent systematic review in JAMA
Oncology of acupuncture for cancer pain. Edzard Ernst let me know about it and
thinks it’s so bad that it should be investigated for consideration of
retraction. Why? It suffers from many of the problems we see in such systematic 
reviews of acupuncture. For example, roughly half the studies included were
Chinese, including ones written in Chinese, and, as Edzard Ernst, Steve Novella,
and I have repeatedly emphasized, virtually 100% of acupuncture studies that
come out of China, particularly those published in Chinese, are positive. Also, 
as Prof. Ernst notes, one study is a doctoral thesis, which is usually not
peer-reviewed, and the quality of the studies included is generally extremely
poor, with one study entitled “Clinical observation on 30 cases of moderate and 
severe cancer pain of bone metastasis treated by auricular acupressure”
appearing to be a case series rather than a randomized clinical trial. He also
notes:

   The authors state that they included only clinical trials that compared
   acupuncture and acupressure with a sham control, analgesic therapy, or usual 
   care. However, this is evidently not true; many of the studies had the
   infamous A+B versus B design comparing acupuncture plus a conventional
   therapy against the conventional therapy. As we have discussed ad nauseam on 
   this blog, such trials cannot produce a negative finding even if ‘A’ is a
   placebo.

“Methodological limitations,” indeed. I saw most, but not all, of the
limitations that Prof. Ernst enumerated, probably because I didn’t delve as
deeply into the list of publications as he did. In any event, this meta-analysis
was even worse than I thought it was. Disappointingly, one of the authors of
this systematic review and meta-analysis is Dr. Jun Mao, chief of the
integrative medicine service at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center. I have
to wonder if that had anything to do with how such a shoddy paper was accepted
for publication by such a high impact journal.

And all the rest

As I said before, this review got very repetitive to read very quickly; so I’ll 
summarize the conclusions for the remaining conditions, which include
fibromyalgia, pelvic pain, inflammatory arthritis, neuropathic pain, and other
pain conditions: Evidence from the systematic reviews suggests that there are
insufficient high-quality RCTs to judge the efficacy of acupuncture for any of
these conditions. Of course, I would spin it a bit differently. If there are
hundreds of studies for an intervention for a variety of indications, and we
still can’t conclude confidently that it’s effective for any of them, then it’s 
almost certainly ineffective and the “positive” studies are nothing more than
random statistical noise that will produce a few seemingly “positive” studies by
random chance alone, more if bias is present. Add to the mix the observation
that there is no physiologically plausible mechanism for acupuncture to “work”, 
and the most reasonable conclusion is that acupuncture is nothing more than an
elaborate theatrical placebo with no specific effects on pain.

In their discussion, the authors bring up three main challenges of acupuncture
research: inadequate sample size, of appropriate controls, and of adequacy of
dose. The first part, about using an adequate sample size, is a no-brainer, but,
as the authors note, bigger trials cost more money to carry out, making them
more difficult, particularly for an intervention like acupuncture. Low sample
sizes are associated with overestimation of treatment effect size. These are all
reasonable observations, but then the authors go off the deep end about how to 
deal with them:

   Often, pain data used as the primary outcome within RCTs is a continuous
   variable, such as pain intensity measured on a visual analogue scale (VAS)
   and expressed as an average. Averages of pain intensity data from VAS can be 
   misleading because averages may obscure good and poor responders to
   acupuncture [206,207]. There is a likelihood that scores of pain intensity
   produce U-shaped rather than bell-shaped distributions, with some
   participants experiencing large reductions in pain and others not. Thus, pain
   intensity data from acupuncture responders may be diluted by data from
   non-responders [208]. For this reason, the Pain and Palliative Support and
   Care group of the Cochrane collaboration recommends the use of primary
   outcome responder rates of participants reporting relief of 30% or greater
   (i.e., at least moderate pain relief) or 50% or greater (i.e., significant
   pain relief) expressed as frequency (dichotomous) data.

There are a lot of assumptions here, particularly the assumption that designing 
acupuncture studies this way would actually result in finding an effect that’s
currently obscured.

The authors also discuss the role of proper sham acupuncture groups in clinical 
trials of acupuncture. They actually (surprisingly) do a pretty good job
discussing why a sham acupuncture control is necessary and the argument that
sham needling is not physiologically inert is not a reason not to use a sham
control group in acupuncture trials. This discussion, however, included this
rather curious passage:

   Placebo controls are research tools that enable isolation of effects
   associated with the active ingredient(s) of the treatment. Thus, a comparison
   of effects during real needling versus sham needling, whereby needles touch 
   but do not penetrate the skin, enable investigators to isolate the magnitude 
   and incidence of effects associated with needles piercing the skin per se
   (i.e., the ‘acu’ and ‘puncture’). If puncturing the skin with needles
   produces equivalent benefits to touching without puncturing the skin, then it
   may be safer not to puncture the skin in clinical practice, providing that
   the sham needles do less harm. Interestingly, a system of evaluating the
   physiological effects of sham needling has been proposed to assist
   researchers [212].

If the needles don’t penetrate the skin, then it isn’t really acupuncture, is
it? Similarly, if it doesn’t matter where you stick the needles, given that
there is no reliably detectable difference in effect between sham and “real”
acupuncture, then the entire edifice and rationale behind acupuncture, both from
a traditional Chinese medicine standpoint (magical “life energy” qi) and the
tortured “neurophysiological” basis of acupuncture made up by acupuncture
apologists who want there to be a scientific basis to the practice, become
meaningless.

Finally, the authors discuss “dose”, leading to my favorite quack gambit of all,
an appeal to “individualization”, the idea that standardizing treatments for a 
randomized clinical trial guarantees that some patients are “underdosed” with
acupuncture. Of course, the authors never seem to consider that some patients
would be “overdosed” as well. In any event, they authors tout Standards for
Reporting Interventions in Controlled Trials of Acupuncture (STRICTA), a set of 
standards for reporting the exact acupuncture interventions used in a clinical
trial. I can only be reminded of what Harriet Hall likes to call “Tooth Fairy
science“.

The authors conclude by arguing that a way to study acupuncture in a manner more
likely to produce interpretable results is a different trial design:

   It has been argued that enriched enrolment with randomised withdrawal (EERW) 
   study designs are of value for treatments influencing symptoms but not
   necessarily the course of the underlying disease or pathology, as is the case
   for acupuncture in the management of chronic pain [224]. The potential for
   using such designs in the assessment of pharmacological agents has been
   recognised [225], although EERW designs are rarely used to assess
   non-pharmacological interventions. The EERW trials consist of (i) an
   observational ‘open-label’ phase with all participants receiving active
   treatment (acupuncture), during which treatment technique and dosage would be
   titrated and optimized, followed by (ii) a RCT phase, whereby participants
   who had potential for response were enrolled (i.e., an enriched sample) and
   randomised to receive either experimental (real needling) or control
   interventions (sham needling). Selection of participants for the enriched
   sample of the RCT is based on the findings from phase one and would exclude
   participants who did not wish to continue treatment or experienced
   non-manageable adverse events, although their data from phase one would be
   analysed. Trials with EERW designs increase sensitivity to detect treatment
   effects by enriching the sample of participants enrolling into the randomised
   controlled phase of the trial, thus reducing the need for large sample sizes
   [207].

So, basically, the authors propose to use the EERW design to enrich the
subsequent randomized clinical trial with patients prone to experiencing more
intense placebo effects than average. (Remember, acupuncture is just theatrical 
placebo; so “enriching” the study population for responders means enriching for 
those who experience more intense placebo effects.) Yeah, that’ll work: To
pollute the literature with more “positive” acupuncture trials that really
aren’t.

I might be a bit sarcastic about what the authors propose as a way forward to
study acupuncture and also snark on them a bit because they did this review with
an eye towards clinical trial designs more likely to find a significant
treatment effect from acupuncture. However, don’t let that lead you to think
that I don’t find this systematic review useful. For believers in acupuncture,
the authors were surprisingly honest and blunt about how poor the evidence-base 
is for the practice. Acupuncture for chronic pain is, as it is for all
conditions for which it’s currently used, theatrical placebo. This systematic
review is more evidence supporting that conclusion.

Ear Acupuncture for Procedural Pain in Neonates: More Randomized Controlled
Nonsense

A recently published multicenter randomized and placebo controlled study
attempted to answer the question of whether or not magnetic acupuncture beads
stuck on premature baby ears reduced pain during a common screening exam. They
don’t. And they might have made things worse for these babies.

Clay Jones on March 19, 2021

Link



Proponents of the theatrical placebo known as acupuncture continue to push the
limits of my ability to maintain sanity in these uncertain times. In December of
last year, researchers at hospitals in Australia, Canada, and Malaysia ran a
“multicentre randomized controlled trial” designed to test the efficacy of ear
acupuncture in the management of procedural pain in premature infants. The
specific procedure in this case was an eye exam performed to evaluate for a
condition called retinopathy of prematurity, and it is potentially
uncomfortable. It’s more than a little bit like that scene from A Clockwork
Orange. You know the one.

Allow me to explain.

What is retinopathy of prematurity?

Retinopathy of prematurity, or ROP for short, is a common cause of visual
impairment in former premature infants. Though typically affecting babies born
at less than 32 weeks of competed gestation, it is most likely to cause severe
disease, including blindness, in those born much earlier. The eyes of
prematurely born infants have important differences when compared to babies born
closer to term, particularly when it comes to the development of a blood
supply. Vascularization of the eye occurs in a certain sequence, with retinal
blood vessels normally coming on line at around 15 to 18 weeks of gestation.
They begin where the optic nerve enters to back of the eye and grow
peripherally, usually completing the process by 40 weeks unless the baby is born
very early.

ROP occurs when the healthy sequence of vascularization becomes derailed in two 
stages after delivery of an at risk preterm infant. The first is when there is
injury to the developing retinal blood vessels, as often occurs in the setting
of low systemic blood pressures or inadequate levels of oxygen. Another
potential cause of injury occurs when there is too much oxygen in the blood,
resulting in the development of damaging free radicals.

This state of hyperoxia, an excessive amount of oxygen in the blood, tends to
happen during our attempts to resuscitate and/or stabilize premature infants.
Older protocols involved the use of 100% oxygen for all newborns and we used to 
cause a lot of blindness. Over the years, as our understanding of the
pathophysiology of ROP improved, we have refined these protocols and they can be
quite stingy at times when it comes to how much we crank up the oxygen. These
days oxygen is treated much more like a medication with potential serious
adverse effects than in the past.

The second stage of ROP occurs during the healing process after the initial
injury when new blood vessels can begin to grow abnormally. Instead of
peripheral growth, they can actually start to grow into the vitreous, the gel
that fills the eye between the lens and the retina. These new vessels are prone 
to leaking, which can cause swelling and bleeding. Abnormal fibrous tissue can
also form which pulls on the retina, potentially causing distortion or even
detachment.

Thankfully, in many cases this abnormal growth of blood vessels regresses
without intervention. Although we have learned a lot about the underlying causes
of ROP, we still don’t know what determines whether or not these abnormal
retinal blood vessels will resume healthy growth or progress and disrupt vision 
permanently without intervention. There are treatments, including laser
photocoagulation of abnormally developing blood vessels or injections of a
medication that arrests blood vessel growth into the vitreous, that can improve 
outcomes.

Despite our improved understanding of the risk factors for the development of
ROP, it continues to be a common issue faced by former premature infants.
Iatrogenic hyperoxia can’t always be avoided because many of these babies have
severely immature lungs and require 100% oxygen for resuscitation/stabilization.
So even in resource rich regions such as the United States, ROP is not going
away any time soon. In fact, the incidence is actually on the rise. As our
ability to keep babies alive even when born at the extremes of prematurity, we
are seeing more of them live long enough to develop ROP despite the overall
lower risk in individuals because of more judicious use of oxygen.

Babies at risk for ROP require screening by pediatric ophthalmologists trained
in the detection of abnormal retinal vascularization. The initial screen takes
place a few weeks after birth and the exam is repeated every 1-3 weeks depending
on the severity of disease in order to track progression. Prior to screening, a
baby’s eyes are dilated and often a topical anesthetic is administered. But
because of the need to use a speculum to force the eyes open, it can be
uncomfortable and maybe even outright painful.

Which brings us back to the study of ear acupuncture as a means of reducing
procedural pain during ROP evaluation.

Magnetic Auricular Acupuncture (MAA) for infant pain: Introductions are in order

Before I get into the specific details of the study, I feel compelled to point
out that while the authors frequently use the word acupuncture, I don’t think it
means what they think it does. At least it’s decidedly unfair to make claims
regarding the pre-test plausibility of MAA based on the history of traditional
acupuncture involving the insertion of needles:

   Acupuncture, a field of traditional Chinese Medicine, has been used for
   thousands of years to provide analgesia for a gamut of illnesses in adults
   and older children…

Readers of SBM should be quick to point out that this is both historically and
medically inaccurate. Acupuncture as commonly understood today has been around
for several decades and is not supported by high quality evidence as a treatment
for any condition. They go on to point out, however, that shoving needles into 
premature infants is impractical, particularly when the patients are in a
neonatal intensive care unit. We are then reassured that “acupuncture effects”
can be achieved through the use of other forms of stimulation, such as heat,
pressure, and magnets.

Here is where it really goes off the rails, and we aren’t even done with the
study introduction. To support the acupuncture needle and magnetic bead
switcheroo they are about to propose, they cite their own previous study:

   …we demonstrated that magnetic auricular acupuncture (MAA), where small
   magnets are placed around specific points around the ear, significantly
   decreased procedural pain perception in 40 infants undergoing routine heel
   pricks.

Not so fast! I was actually familiar with the earlier study and almost wrote
about it back in 2017. My twitter buddy Michael Narvey (@NICU_Musings) did write
a brief post about it on his All Things Neonatal blog and I agree with his take
home message:

   The second and perhaps biggest issue I have here is that although the primary
   outcome was reached it does seem that there was some fishing going on here. 
   By that I mean there were three PIPP scores examined (before, during and
   after) and one barely reached statistical significance. My hunch is that
   indeed this was reached by chance rather than it being a real difference.

   The last concern is that while the intervention was done in a blinded and
   randomized fashion, the evidence supporting the use of this in the first
   place is not strong. Taking this into account and adding the previous concern
   in as well and I have strong doubts that this is indeed “for real”. I doubt 
   this will be the last we will hear about it and while my skepticism continues
   I have to admit if a larger study is produced I will be willing and
   interested to read it.

I think that Michael pulled his punches a bit there. Basing a conclusion of
efficacy on the PIPP (Premature Infant Pain Profile) in the way that the authors
did is highly problematic and for more than just cherry picking outcomes. Not
to mention the trial was tiny and billed as a pilot study. But the particular
problem with using the PIPP also applies to the latest study and I’ll get to it 
shortly. It’s pretty damning though. Kudos to Michael for his prescience
regarding future studies. Of course, in the world of irregular medicine there
must always be more studies.

In the more recent study, the authors actually get off on a very good foot in
their overview of pain in newborns. As a newborn hospitalist, I worry about pain
in my patients a lot. As discussed in their introduction, it’s true that some
amount of pain is unavoidable in the care of premature infants in the NICU
setting, and that there are well-established acute and chronic adverse outcomes 
that can occur when it is poorly managed. The situation is further complicated
by the fact that pharmaceutical interventions expose these babies to some pretty
serious potential risks.

Newborn pain management is inconsistent. It largely depends on the facility, and
the often-unique protocols in place that can vary from place to place, but also
on which nurse, physician, or therapist happens to be running the show at any
given moment. As I’ll explain shortly, this study is a perfect example of this
because it sure looks like one or more of the involved facilities did not
maximize proven safe and effective non-pharmaceutical approaches to reducing
pain in babies. This is ironic considering that it’s the entire point of what
they were trying to do with this study.

Those pesky details…

This was a study that was coordinated across hospitals in Australia, Canada, and
Malaysia that was randomized, blinded, and placebo-controlled. It involved the 
randomization of infants requiring an initial ROP screening into either a group 
that had magnetic acupuncture beads taped to specific acupuncture points on the 
ear using a small round sticker or a placebo group that only got the sticker. Of
note, the acupuncture points used in this study were completely different from 
the ones used in the earlier trial that the authors cited as justification,
again raising concerns of applicability. The 100 babies that were eventually
signed up were appropriately matched.

In order to prevent the caregivers, and more importantly the nurses who would be
assessing the study subjects for pain responses, from knowing which babies were
in the active treatment group a dab of white correction fluid was applied.
There is a picture provided in the paper and I encourage you all to check this
for yourselves; in my opinion, it looks like the magnetic bead is visible under 
the concealer and would also be palpable. As a result, I’m not confident that
blinding was maintained, and that would render this study worthless.

Prior to each ROP exam, the babies were all given a dose of oral sucrose, a very
common and well supported means of treating minor to moderate pain, or at least
distracting from it, in the first several weeks of life. A topical anesthetic
was also applied to the eyes of each baby prior to insertion of the speculum to 
hold the eyes open. Additional doses of sucrose, use of a pacifier, and even
swaddling during the procedure were considered to be additional analgesia and
only provided if it was determined to be clinically indicated.

The primary outcome in the study was the difference in pain perception using the
PIPP mentioned earlier. Scores were calculated prior to the procedure, during, 
and 60 minutes afterwards by a “blinded” nurse trained in using the tool.
Secondary outcomes were changes in heart rate, arterial oxygen saturation, and
the need for additional pain control measures during and 60 minutes after
completion of the exam. Heart rate and oxygen levels would be expected to rise
and fall respectively when a premature infant is distressed by pain, but they
are already a part of the PIPP so I’m not sure why they double dipped like that.
It doesn’t add anything.

The big reveal…

Compared to babies who were in the active treatment group, those in the placebo 
group were found to have a statistically significant increase in PIPP scoring
during the ROP exam and at the one hour post procedure mark. The differences,
expressed in average PIPP scores were 1.6 and 1.5 respectively. To provide
another layer here, the average PIPP score during the ROP exams were 13.5 in the
placebo group and 11.9 in the active treatment group. At 60 minutes, the two
groups had decreased to average scores of 3.1 and 1.6.

Mean heart rate was significantly lower in the treatment group, 172 compared to 
184 beats per minute, during the procedure. Oxygen levels were also higher in
the treatment group, 93.8% compared to 91.7%, during the exams. There were no
differences in the use of additional measures to treat pain and there were no
safety concerns.

The authors of the paper concluded that “magnetic auricular acupuncture
significantly reduced scores associated with pain, discomfort and distress in
preterm infants during and up to 1 hour after the ROP examination”. They also
claimed that the differences in heart rate and oxygen saturation were signs of
an improved sympathetic pain response. They believe that the magnetic beads are 
cheap, easy to apply, and do not interfere with routine NICU care. They wondered
if acupuncture involving needles, lasers, or heat might be even more effective 
and called for further research to answer that question. They also questioned
whether the beneficial effect seen in the study came from the pressure applied
by the tape against the bead or the magnetic stimulation from the 100 Gauss
magnet.

Magnets, how do they not work?

So according to the authors of the study, we’ve now got a safe and effectiveness
new tool in our analgesia toolbox when it comes to managing pain in premature
infants, but if that sounds a bit too good to be true it’s because it most
certainly is.

Where to begin?

How about the extremely low prior plausibility? There just isn’t any reasonable 
basic science or good clinical data to support an expectation that extremely
light pressure on the surface of the ear would have cause any meaningful changes
in baby physiology. And there is even less reason to believe that a 100 Gauss
magnet, which is the equivalent of a standard refrigerator magnet, would have
any effect either. Auricular acupuncture of any kind is pure nonsense. These
particular authors were inspired by tales of “battlefield acupuncture”, a topic 
well known to long time readers of SBM.

With such low prior plausibility, the results of this study would need to be
extremely robust in order to tilt the needle towards acceptance. The authors
sure seemed impressed. But there are some significant issues with their
interpretation. First off, as I previously mentioned, I think that the blinding 
in this study was well-intentioned but likely not particularly effective. The
study did not include an exit interview to determine if blinding broke down,
which would have been very helpful.

Assessing pain in children is hard. It’s particularly challenging in infants and
even more prone to error in premature infants. The PIPP is a validated tool but
it is still very subjective, even with the inclusion of seemingly objective
measurements such as heart rate and pulse oximetry. Both are not always reliable
when obtaining a one-time measurement and clinical usefulness improves with
repeated measurements over longer periods of time.

Even if we could be confident that blinding held and the PIPP scores obtained
were free of potential bias, the differences found in this study were not
clinically meaningful. As we have written many times on the pages of this blog, 
statistical significance does not necessarily mean the same thing as clinical
significance. On the PIPP, a score of 0-6 is generally interpreted as minimal or
no pain. Infants at the 1-hour post procedure check in both treatment and
placebo groups had scores in this range. It’s not fair to count an average
difference of 1.5 as a success.

PIPP scores of 7-12 are typically interpreted as slight to moderate pain and
scores from 12 to the maximum of 21 may indicated severe pain. During the ROP
exam, babies in both groups had an average PIPP score hovering around 12. Yes,
the babies in the placebo group were a little higher than in the treatment
group, but the same issue of clinical versus statistical significance applies.
Again, a difference of 1.6 is not very meaningful even if we could rule out
bias.

Conclusion: Why this matters

I’m obviously not convinced in the slightest that magnets or magnetic ear
acupuncture should play any role whatsoever in the management of pain in the
NICU. And though it is almost certainly safe, it is a waste of time and
resources. And the introduction of this kind of pseudoscience into medicine
helps to further erode the already crumbling bulkhead separating science-based
medicine from prescientific belief.

But that’s not what bothered me the most about this study. What made me
downright angry was something that it might have unintentionally revealed, that 
focusing on nonsense like ear magnets and acupuncture beads might actually have 
resulted in these babies experiencing more pain than if they hadn’t been
enrolled in this ridiculous study. Let me explain.

One of the secondary outcomes that the authors decided to focus on was the use
of additional pain management interventions after a one-time dose of oral
sucrose drops given prior to the procedure. And I mentioned that there was no
difference found in this outcome between the treatment and placebo groups. In
fact, less than a quarter of babies in either group were given sucrose during
the procedure when the average PIPP scoring showed that they were at least
experiencing mild if not moderate pain. And not even a third of the babies in
each group were allowed a pacifier. 75% in each group weren’t even swaddled!

Sucrose, pacifiers, and swaddling are safe and proven non-pharmaceutical
interventions used to reduce pain. They should have been used in 100% of these
babies during the procedure. So I’m left wondering why they weren’t. Was it
perhaps because these babies were in a trial and there was subconscious bias
against their use? Maybe these institutions have protocols that limit use of
these methods? I don’t know. But I found it ironic that they were focusing on a 
bogus intervention in the hopes of reducing the need for medications while
ignoring the ways we already do that.

                         A Pair of Acupuncture Studies

                                 Steven Novella

                                      Link

Two recent acupuncture studies have received some media attention, both
purporting to show positive effects. Both studies are also not clinical efficacy
trials, so cannot be used to support any claims for efficacy for acupuncture – 
although that is how they are often being presented in the media.

These and other studies show the dire need for more trained science journalists,
or science blogging – they only make sense when put into a proper context. No
media coverage I read bothered to do this.

The first study comes out of South Korea and involves using acupuncture in a rat
model of spinal cord injury. The researchers used a standard method of inducing
spinal cord injury in rats, and compared various acupuncture locations to
no-acupuncture control. They followed a series of metabolic outcomes, as well as
the extent of spinal cord injury and functional recovery. They conclude:

   Thus, our results suggest that the neuroprotection by acupuncture may be
   partly mediated via inhibition of inflammation and microglial activation
   after SCI and acupuncture can be used as a potential therapeutic tool for
   treating acute spinal injury in human.

The notion that acupuncture will actually improve outcome after acute spinal
cord injury is, of course, extraordinary. This goes far beyond a subjective
decrease in pain or some other symptomatic benefit. Therefore similarly
extraordinary evidence should be required to support such a claim – and this
study does not provide that.

In reading through the details of the study several factors caught my attention.
The first is that there is no indication that the researchers were blinded.
This alone calls the results into serious question. It is all too easy for
researchers to allow personal bias to affect study results, even when they seem 
quantitative. We need look no further than the homeopathy research of Jacques
Benveniste to see this (initial impressive results were investigated by Nature
and found to be the result, charitably, if inadequate blinding).

Further, the researchers looked at several acupuncture points and then chose the
ones that seemed to have an effect. This allowed for retrospective cherry
picking – it is possible, in other words, that they received a scattering of
random effects and chose the ones that appeared positive.

The effect sizes themselves, while statistically significant, were not
clinically impressive. If they were real they would be useful in the treatment
of spinal cord injury, but that is the point. Such small effect sizes are easily
the product of randomness or bias.

And finally it should be noted that the study is coming out of South Korea. It
is well established that countries where acupuncture is culturally important
tend to have a much higher positive outcome rate than the same research in
Western countries. The motivation to prove acupuncture seems to be a significant
bias. Similarly, we recognize that there is a bias in favor of efficacy for
pharmaceutical company sponsored research – the principle is the same. The bias 
of the researchers, even when well-controlled on paper, is measurable.

The bottom line with this study is that it provides weak evidence for a very
extraordinary claim. It is of no practical use unless and until it is
independently replicated with proper blinding. If you believe what you read in
the media, however, you would be led to the conclusion that spinal injured
patients could be made to walk again simply by sticking needles into magical
locations on their body.

The second study uses quantitative sensory testing (QST) to look at pain
threshold at baseline and after acupuncture and “electroacupuncture”. They
conclude:

   There were congruent changes on QST after 3 common acupuncture stimulation
   methods, with possible unilateral as well as bilateral effects.

In other words – acupuncture decreases the perception of pain. This small study 
suffers from the same primary problem as the other – it is described as only
single-blinded. The subjects themselves were not blinded to whether or not they 
were getting “real” acupuncture vs a sham or placebo. The totality of prior
acupuncture research has clearly demonstrated that such unblinded studies are
all but useless. There is a significant placebo effect from getting poked with
needles, and this is sufficient to explain the results of this study.

While QST is quantitative, it is still subjective. In fact, using QST has fallen
a bit out of favor in neurological studies because the elaborate procedure is
no more reliable as an outcome measure than straightforward sensory testing. QST
is still reliant on the subjective report of the subject.

Further, this study mixed acupuncture with “electroacupuncture.” I strongly
maintain that there is no such thing as “electroacupunture” – it is, rather, the
application of transcutaneous electrical stimulation through an acupuncture
needle. This is no more acupuncture than the application of morphine through a
hollow acupuncture needle should be considered acupuncture.

It is possible that needling and electrical stimulation do decrease subjective
pain perception (although we can’t conclude that based upon this study). One
pain or sensory stimulation can certainly distract you from another. There is
also the principle of counter-irritation – the inhibition of pain pathways by
activating parallel sensory pathways. Bang your elbow and you will rub it to
decrease the sharp pain.

Conclusion

Given the state of the acupuncture literature, such small and insufficiently
blinded studies are of little value. It has already been established that there 
is a significant placebo effect surrounding the ritual of acupuncture and there 
are mechanisms of non-specific effects, such as counter-irritation. None of this
can be logically used to support the underlying assumptions of acupuncture –
that there is anything special about the designated acupuncture points, or that 
they can be used to manipulate “chi” or some other mysterious energy.

We are already well past the stage of preliminary studies in acupuncture. Only
rigorously controlled studies are of any use. And the term “electroacupuncture” 
causes only confusion and cannot be meaningfully used. It is the blurring of
variables when good science should endeavor to isolate variables.

Also, in a perfect world, the general press would not report on every
preliminary study as if they were a definitive medical breakthrough. Such
medical news stories should be covered in more focused outlets that have the
space and expertise to put the results into a reasonable context.

A Trilogy of (Acupuncture) Terror

David Gorski on July 8, 2013

Link


TAM is fast approaching, and I’ve been frantically trying to get my talks
together. The theme this year is “Fighting the Fakers,” and one of my talks will
be for the Science-Based Medicine Workshop on Thursday, in which I will attempt
in a mere 15 minutes to explain what Science-Based Medicine is and how it can
be used to combat the infiltration of quackademic medicine into medical
academia. Then, the second talk will be a tag-team spectacular with Bob
Blaskiewicz about Stanislaw Burzynski as an example of how some cranks skirt the
edges of science-based medicine. That doesn’t make them any less dangerous (if 
anything, it makes them more dangerous), but it does make them not as easy to
identify as someone like, say, Hulda Clark.

Unfortunately, between working on these talks, revising some papers, and having 
an unusually busy weekend on call, I wasn’t sure what I was going to come up
with for the edification of you, our readers. Fortunately, right on the 4th of
July holiday, there was an article that gave me my idea, particularly given that
I had noticed a couple of studies on the very subject of the article in the
week leading up to the long holiday in the US (at least for people not on call).
As a result, I’m half tempted to refer to this article as a trilogy of
acupuncture terror.

Oh, wait. I just did.

Book I: Acupuncture is harmless, right?

One myth that acupuncture apologists like to promote relentlessly is that
acupuncture is completely harmless, that it almost never causes complications or
problems. While it’s true that acupuncture is relatively safe, it still
involves sticking needles into the skin, and, given that, it would be delusional
to think that it couldn’t cause injuries. Rarely, however, have I seen a story 
like this in the Canadian newspaper the National Post, “Canadian Olympian’s
‘nightmare’ after acupuncture needle collapses her lung“. It is the story of
what happened to Kim Ribble-Orr, a world-class judoka who had competed in the
Olympics in 2000 and was harboring dreams of competing in the Olympics again, as
a mixed martial artist. Those dreams were cast in doubt by a stray acupuncture 
needle:

   When a massage therapist tried to treat the headaches she suffered after a
   2006 car crash with acupuncture, however, he set off a cascade of health
   problems that would shatter Ms. Ribble-Orr’s sports-centred life — and raise 
   questions about the popular needle therapy.

   The therapist accidentally pierced Ms. Ribble-Orr’s left lung during
   acupuncture treatment that was later deemed unnecessary and ill-advised,
   causing the organ to collapse and leaving it permanently damaged. An Ontario 
   court has just upheld the one-year disciplinary suspension imposed on
   therapist Scott Spurrell, rejecting his appeal in a case that highlights a
   rare but well-documented side effect of acupuncture.

   Mr. Spurrell, who learned the ancient Chinese art on weekends at a local
   university, had no reason to stick the needle in his patient’s chest, and had
   wrongly advised Ms. Ribble-Orr that the chest pain and other symptoms she
   reported later were likely just from a muscle spasm, a discipline tribunal
   ruled.

Ribble-Orr had suffered many injuries due to her competition, including a
dislocated elbow and shoulder, a broken hand, head injuries and repeated knee
injuries. She had overcome them all to compete again, but appears unable to
overcome this one. Basically, what happened is that in 2006, Ribble-Or was
trying to get into mixed martial arts competition and was eying a job as a
police officer. However, she was also recovering from injuries suffered in an
auto collision and seeing Scott Spurrell, a massage therapist who had learned
acupuncture during a weekend course at a local university. She was suffering
from pounding headaches, and Spurrell convinced her that he could relieve those 
headaches by inserting a two-inch needle, according to the disciplinary ruling, 
“into a muscle located between the clavicle bone and ribs.” From the
description, it’s not clear to me exactly which muscle they meant, although it
could conceivably have been the scalenes, the sternocleidomastoid, or perhaps
even just the pectoralis major. Whatever muscle Spurrell was targeting, going
between the clavicle and the ribs is basically where surgeons stick the needle
when trying to place central venous catheter into the subclavian vein, and, yes,
a pneumothorax is a known potential complication of placing such lines. What
also puzzles me is how on earth Spurrell could have stuck the needle in deep
enough to cause a pneumothorax? It would be one thing if Ribble-Orr were a
fragile little old lady, but she wasn’t. She was an athlete, presumably with
well-developed musculature. It would take a lot to get a needle through all of
that muscle and into the pleural cavity.

As can happen from a pneumothorax, even in a healthy person, Kibble-Orr
developed pneumonia and required a thoracotomy. To be honest, it’s not clear
from the account provided why she needed a thoracotomy, but it’s clear that the 
pneumothorax led to a cascade of complications, as described:

   Shortly after leaving the clinic, Ms. Ribble-Orr began having difficulty
   breathing, chest pain and a “grinding” sensation. She returned to the
   therapist later, wondering if she had suffered a pneumothorax. He told her it
   was more likely a muscle spasm, but said she could go to the hospital if she
   felt it was more serious or if the symptoms worsened.

   The next morning, she did feel worse and finally headed to the emergency
   department. Ms. Ribble-Orr’s lung had indeed collapsed and she spent the next
   two weeks in hospital, as a serious lung infection and then a blood
   infection followed. She was left with just 55% function in one lung.

One notes that if you do not have the knowledge to recognize symptoms and signs 
of potential complications resulting from your treatment, you have no business
administering that treatment. It used to be that if you didn’t know how both to 
recognize and treat potential complications of your treatment, you shouldn’t be 
administering that treatment, but those days are gone. For instance,
gastroenterologists do colonoscopies, even though they are not able to repair
the inevitable (and thankfully uncommon) colon perforations that are a
recognized risk of the procedure. But they can recognize the signs and symptoms.
They know how to diagnose a potential perforation and when to call a surgeon to
fix it. Spurrell was clearly utterly clueless, basically dodging responsibility
by telling Kibble-Orr that she could go to the ER if she wanted to. Obviously, 
he didn’t think that she needed to. What should have happened, if Spurrell knew 
what he was doing, was a quick physical exam, which likely would have diagnosed 
a significant pneumothorax through decreased breath sounds or elevated diaphragm
on the affected side, or both.

While the ruling against Spurrell is heartening, what is rather depressing is
how Canadian authorities came around to it. Acupuncture is a licensed specialty.
So authorities had to “prove” that Spurrell had no valid reason to insert a
needle there (“valid” being defined within the system of traditional Chinese
medicine undergirding acupuncture). In other words, they had to show that there 
was no reason under TCM to think that a needle stuck in that particular location
would treat Kibble-Orr’s recurrent headaches. Moreover, it wasn’t the College
of Acupuncturists who had jurisdiction, but rather the College of Massage
Therapists, and the College only requires a certain number of hours of extra
training to be able to administer acupuncture, a requirement that Spurrell had
met. Of course, we at SBM would argue that there’s no science-based reason at
all to think that sticking a needle in a point between the clavicle and the ribs
would have any effect whatsoever on recurrent chronic headaches, and that
should be enough. That’s the problem with regulating quackery; to prove
misconduct or malpractice, you have to do it within the system of magical
thinking of the quackery that has been licensed. If, for instance, Spurrell had 
been able to show that there was a valid rationale under TCM for inserting the
needle there, he still might have been nailed for incompetence because he stuck 
the needle in too deep, but quite possibly he might not have been.

Particularly depressing are the comments. For instance, one commenter named Dr. 
Joanny argues:

   Only a bonafide doctor of Chinese medicine or acupuncture is qualified to
   practice Chinese medicine. The problem is not acupuncture but who is
   inserting the needles into your body. Only someone who has trained and
   studied for several years, who has passed board/state/provincial exams, is
   qualified to practice. All reports of puncturing lungs involve people who are
   people who took a little bit of training.

Yes, this acupuncturist is seriously arguing that “well-trained” TCM
practitioners wouldn’t have had this complication and then goes on to cite a
paper from a very acupuncture-friendly source that shows a surprising number of 
serious complications from acupuncture, including cardiac tamponade, infection, 
various reports of needles breaking off and migrating elsewhere in the body
(shades of the President of South Korea!), and even neurological injury. One
remembers a recent review of the Chinese literature by Edzard Ernst describing
complications of acupuncture, including pneumothorax (201 cases), spinal
epidural hematoma (9 cases), subarachnoid hemorrhage (35 cases), right
ventricular puncture (2 cases), intestinal perforation (5 cases), and a whole
lot of other complications and infections. Indeed, Ernst found that pneumothorax
was by far the most common significant complication of acupuncture, and, as
we’ve discussed, acupuncture is not harmless. There are quite a few potential
complications up to and including 90 deaths in the world literature.

All medicine is a risk-benefit analysis. All effective treatments have risks,
and those risks have to be weighed against the potential benefits. When the
benefits are significant (e.g., saving life), then greater risks are tolerable. 
When the potential benefits are minimal, then even minor risks might not be
acceptable. When the potential benefits are none, no risk is acceptable. That is
the case for acupuncture. It does not work, no matter how much acupuncturists
try to prove it does.

Books II and III of The Trilogy of Acupuncture Terror are simply more evidence
that this is true.

Book II: In which regression to the mean in a subgroup is mistaken for a real
result

That acupuncture is nothing more than an elaborate placebo is now quite clear.
In any case, none of this stops acupuncturists from claiming they can help in
conditions with “hard” endpoints, such as in vitro fertilization for
infertility. It’s all Tooth Fairy science, but they keep trying, and so they
tried again recently. At least, Brian Berman tried again. Berman, as you might
recall, makes his quackademic home at the University of Maryland, and last week 
my Google Alerts did their job, alerting me to a new systematic review published
online late last week in the Journal of Human Reproduction Update. Berman is
the corresponding author (of course!), and a research associate by the name of
Eric Manheimer is the lead author, and together with other colleagues, they have
produced yet another fine analysis of tooth fairy medicine entitled, The
effects of acupuncture on rates of clinical pregnancy among women undergoing in 
vitro fertilization: a systematic review and meta-analysis.

Of course, as is the case for many acupuncture studies (actually, nearly all
acupuncture studies), there is no prior plausibility. Think about it. How on
earth would sticking needles into the skin improve the odds of conception? It
wouldn’t, and it doesn’t. Through what biological mechanism would sticking
little needles into the skin along fantastical “meridians” improve the
likelihood of conception when embryos are transferred into the uterus? None that
makes any sense, that’s for sure. That doesn’t stop acupuncturists and
acupuncture apologists from heavily selling acupuncture as somehow managing to
do just that, against all physiology and reality.

So here’s how the systematic review is being sold:

   Acupuncture, when used as a complementary or adjuvant therapy for in vitro
   fertilization (IVF), may be beneficial depending on the baseline pregnancy
   rates of a fertility clinic, according to research from the University of
   Maryland School of Medicine. The analysis from the University of Maryland
   Center for Integrative Medicine is published in the June 27 online edition of
   the journal Human Reproduction Update.

   “Our systematic review of current acupuncture/IVF research found that for IVF
   clinics with baseline pregnancy rates higher than average (32 percent or
   greater) adding acupuncture had no benefit,” says Eric Manheimer, lead author
   and research associate at the University of Maryland Center for Integrative 
   Medicine. “However, at IVF clinics with baseline pregnancy rates lower than
   average (less than 32 percent) adding acupuncture seemed to increase IVF
   pregnancy success rates. We saw a direct association between the baseline
   pregnancy success rate and the effects of adding acupuncture: the lower the
   baseline pregnancy rate at the clinic, the more adjuvant acupuncture seemed
   to increase the pregnancy rate.”

It’s hard not to be a bit snarky here and say that if your clinic is doing well 
with its pregnancy rate, then obviously you don’t need mumbo-jumbo. However, if 
you’re not doing so well, maybe some bread and circuses will help.

So let’s look at the study itself or, as I like to say, go to the tape (or
journal, or whatever). Basically, Berman and company examined sixteen trials
with a total of 4,201 participants that compared needle acupuncture administered
within one day of embryo transfer to sham acupuncture or no treatment. They
left out studies that examined electroacupuncture (a famous bait-and-switch form
of acupuncture frequently mixed in with regular acupuncture). Well, actually,
not exactly. Their rationale for not using electroacupuncture studies was not
what you would think, namely because they didn’t want to mix acupuncture studies
with studies involving electricity, which didn’t exist at the time when
acupuncture was allegedly invented. Rather, the rationale was that these studies
involved studying electroacupuncture as an alternative to conventional
anesthesia during oocyte retrieval and the points are therefore not chosen to
improve fertility bur rather to reduce pain. Electroacupuncture was okay, as
long as its intent was pregnancy. I kid you not. In other words, the authors
excluded electroacupuncture, except when they didn’t.

In any case, the methods used were fairly standard systematic
review/meta-analysis methodology, and when they were through they had 16
randomized trials. Now here’s the annoying thing. This is a negative study. Oh, 
the authors, as you can see from the press release, jump, jive, and wail to try 
to extract something out of it that can fool the rubes into seeming positive,
but the bottom line is this. When they looked at the pooled studies, there was
no statistically significant difference in pregnancy rates between the
acupuncture and control groups. None. Nada. Zero. Zip. And any other word you
can think of for “no” or “zero.” Or, as the authors put it, there was “no
statistically significant difference between acupuncture and controls when
combining all trials [risk ratio (RR) 1.12, 95% confidence interval (CI),
0.96–1.31; I2 = 68%; 16 trials; 4021 participants], or when restricting to
sham-controlled (RR 1.02, 0.83–1.26; I2 = 66%; 7 trials; 2044 participants) or
no adjuvant treatment-controlled trials (RR 1.22, 0.97–1.52; I2 = 67%; 9 trials;
1977 participants).”

That’s a negative trial. Acupuncture does not improve pregnancy rates. Did I say
that enough times? Heck, consistent with what one would expect for an
intervention that doesn’t have an effect, the asymmetric funnel plot showed a
tendency for the intervention effects to be more beneficial in smaller trials.
We see the same thing in virtually all clinical trials, but especially in
clinical trials of CAM modalities. Homeopathy, in particular, is notorious for
demonstrating this effect. So is acupuncture.

Of course, in so-called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or
“integrative medicine” trials, there’s never such a thing as a negative study.
So we have subgroup analysis, the better to seek statistically significant
results in smaller pools of patients, where there might be more variability. All
too often it’s not clear whether that subgroup analysis is prespecified or
cooked up post hoc. To Berman’s credit, in this case, the subgroups were
specified before the meta-analysis:

   We conducted subgroup analyses on five clinical characteristics that might
   influence the effect of adjuvant acupuncture on clinical pregnancy success
   rates: (i) two acupuncture sessions or more than two; (ii) selection of
   meridian acupuncture points the same as the points selected in the first
   published trial (Paulus et al., 2002) that evaluated acupuncture as an
   adjuvant to embryo transfer, and which showed a large effect, or a modified
   version of this trial’s acupuncture point selection protocol; (iii) control
   group clinical pregnancy rate (as an estimate of the baseline clinical
   pregnancy rate) dichotomized as higher [32% or greater, which is the European
   average of pregnancy rate per embryo transfer (de Mouzon et al., 2012)] or
   lower; the control group clinical pregnancy rate was also analysed as a
   continuous variable to test whether the relation was linear and consistent
   with the findings of the categorical analysis; (iv) explanatory trials
   conducted to test the effects of adjuvant acupuncture under controlled
   conditions in which the acupuncture was administered onsite at the IVF clinic
   or pragmatic trials conducted to test the effects of adjuvant acupuncture
   delivered off-site, which might better approximate every day, ‘real life’
   conditions since most IVF clinics do not have onsite acupuncturists (Arce et 
   al., 2005); and (v) trials that involved a treating acupuncturist who was
   judged as adequately experienced or not adequately experienced, with such
   judgments made by acupuncturist assessors who were blinded to the identities 
   and results of the trials.

One wonders what objective criteria these acupuncturist assessors use to judge
other acupuncturists as “adequately experienced.” They also prespecified six
“risk of bias” domains to be examined: random allocation sequence generation;
concealment of allocation of randomization sequence; blinding of patients (i.e. 
use of sham control); blinding of embryo transfer physicians; incomplete outcome
data; and unequal co-intervention. And guess what? These were nearly all
negative, too. There was only one exception, which of course was touted in the
press release above. Oh, the authors dance around several variables that they
describe as “almost” statistically significant, but “almost” only counts in
horseshoes and hand grenades (and nuclear weapons). To be honest, these
subgroups weren’t even that close to being statistically significant. If I were 
reviewing this paper, I would have told the authors to cut out at least a couple
paragraphs worth of verbiage dancing around these topics, although it is
somewhat interesting to note that one of these “almost significant” subgroups
was whether or not the physician doing the IVF embryo transfer was blinded to
the acupuncture status of the subject.

In any case, there was an inverse correlation between the baseline pregnancy
rate observed in a study and the effect of acupuncture. Studies reporting
greater than average pregnancy rates (32% or greater) showed no effect of
acupuncture. In fact, the risk ratio for such studies was 0.90 [95% confidence
interval 0.80 to 1.01]. That’s almost, but not quite, a statistically
significant negative effect on pregnancy rates! In contrast, studies for which
the baseline pregnancy rate was less than 32%, produced a risk ratio of 1.53
[95% confidence interval 1.28 to 1.84]. Why is this? Who knows? The authors
speculate that additional interventions have little or no value when pregnancy
rates are already high, but acupuncture can help when pregnancy rates are low,
but there are so many factors that determine pregnancy rates, including embryo
selection, prevailing practice, number of embryos transferred, and many others. 
There could very well be a confounder there that the authors didn’t pick up.

There’s a better explanation, or maybe two explanations. First, there is the
Hawthorne effect. Basically, it is quite possible that low-performing clinics,
knowing that they were being watched carefully in a clinical trial, stepped up
their procedures and did a much more rigorous job. That’s one possibility.
Another possibility is even simpler. This could simply be regression to the
mean. Think about it. The clinics that were low-performing before being involved
in a clinical trial got better, and the clinics that were high performing
beforehand got a little bit worse. True, the latter wasn’t quite statistically
significant, but the trend is suggestive.

The hilarious thing about this study is that, no matter how much Berman tries to
argue otherwise, it confirms what we already know. Acupuncture does not work.
It does not improve the pregnancy rate. There is no physiological mechanism to
think that it should, and this meta-analysis confirms it. The questions of
whether a sham control intervention is needed or not, whether multiple
treatments are needed or not, whether sticking to the meridians matters or not
are all the equivalent of what Harriet Hall likes to call Tooth Fairy science.

Book III: Keep those acupuncture needles away from my lymphedematous arm!

So we’ve had in essence a case report of a horrible complication after
acupuncture for headaches, followed by a systematic review/meta-analysis that
tries to convince readers that acupuncture can improve pregnancy rates in IVF,
even though the clear conclusion based on the studies analyzed is that it does
not. Now let’s look at a study that tries to convince you that it’s OK to stick 
needles where they shouldn’t be stuck.

Lymphedema is a complication of breast cancer surgery that all surgeons who do
breast surgery fear. Patients, of course, fear and detest it even more because, 
after all, they have to live with it. The limb swelling that is the primary
symptom of lymphedema comes about because surgery on the axillary lymph nodes
(the lymph nodes under the arm) that is part and parcel of surgery for breast
cancer can interrupt lymph vessels and cause backup of lymph fluid in the
affected arm. This backup has consequences, including skin changes, a tendency
towards infections, and, in extreme cases, elephantiasis (which is, fortunately,
rarely seen these days as a result of breast cancer surgery). Unfortunately,
lymphedema is incurable, and the risk of developing it never goes away after
breast surgery.

Lymphedema used to be much more of a problem back in the old days (say, more
than 10-15 years or so ago), when surgery for breast cancer routinely involved
an axillary dissection, or removal of most of the lymph nodes under the arm.
(For surgery geeks, in breast surgery level 1 and 2 lymph nodes out of three
levels, unless, of course, level 3 nodes are grossly involved with tumor, in
which case they’re taken out too.) Frequently radiation therapy was needed as
well, and the combination of axillary dissection and radiation therapy could
produce a risk of lymphedema as high as 50%. Of course, in recent years sentinel
lymph node biopsy, which involves removing many fewer nodes (usually 1-3) has
supplanted axillary dissection for most cases of breast cancer, and, consistent 
with fewer nodes being taken, the risk of lymphedema from sentinel lymph node
biopsy is much lower. However, none of this means that lymphedema isn’t still a 
problem after breast surgery; it’s just less of a problem.

There are only a few basic strategies for treating lymphedema. These strategies 
are sometimes referred to as decongestive lymphatic therapy. For the most part, 
these treatments involve physical therapy, compression sleeves to “squeeze” the 
fluid out of the affected limb, and sometimes the use of mechanical compression 
stockings that “milk” the fluid back. It’s all very inconvenient and unpleasant.
There’s no doubt that this particular complication can take a major toll on a
patient’s quality of life and sometimes even lead to hospitalizations for
infection. It might be less of a problem than it was in years past, thanks to
the increased frequency of much less invasive surgery, but it’s still a problem.
As long as we need to evaluate the axillary lymph nodes in breast surgery, it
will always be a problem. That’s why it needs better treatments.

Acupuncture is not one of those better treatments

Not that proponents of acupuncture don’t try to convince people that acupuncture
is a treatment for lymphedema. To be honest, knowing the mechanism by which
lymphedema develops, I can never quite figure out why anyone would think that
acupuncture would do anything for lymphedema. How, pray tell, would sticking
needles into the body, often in areas of the body not involved by lymphedema, be
expected to cause lymphedema to get better? Yet, acupuncturists keep claiming
that acupuncture can be used to effectively treat lymphedema. Indeed, if there’s
one image that causes me to cringe when I see it, it’s the image of needles
being stuck into a lymphedematous arm, often with the acupuncturist not wearing 
gloves. That’s why I cringed when I saw a recent study out of Memorial
Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center (MSKCC) examining acupuncture as a treatment for
breast cancer surgery-associated lymphedema in the ASCO Post:

   Arm lymphedema affects approximately 30% of breast cancer survivors, with
   rates increasing with longer follow-up and cases presenting well beyond the
   active treatment period. Lymphedema is observed even with use of
   less-invasive surgical techniques for staging, and risk is further increased 
   by such factors as radiation therapy, positive lymph node status, increased
   tumor burden, postoperative seroma or infection, obesity, and increased age. 
   Current treatments for lymphedema after breast cancer treatment are expensive
   and require ongoing intervention. As reported by Barrie R. Cassileth, MS,
   PhD, of the Integrative Medicine Service at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer
   Center and colleagues in Cancer, acupuncture may be an effective treatment.

The study appeared in the journal Cancer and was entitled “Acupuncture in the
treatment of upper-limb lymphedema: Results of a pilot study“. It’s as fine an
example of quackademia as I’ve ever seen, its lead investigator being our old
friend Barrie Cassileth, the director of the integrative medicine department at 
Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center. This time around, it’s acupuncture for
lymphedema. Truly, acupuncture is the therapy that can do anything, which is
consistent with it being quackery. Certainly, no one has ever postulated a
mechanism by which acupuncture can do all the things claimed for it, including
(but not limited to) relieving pain, relieving hot flashes, treating
infertility, improving asthma symptoms, and, of course, treating lymphedema.
What’s the common unifying biological mechanism that could explain therapeutic
effects in all these diseases and conditions? There is none, at least none that 
any acupuncturist has ever been able to explain convincingly to me, nor was any 
claimed in the ClinicalTrials.gov entry for this.

So what does this study purport to show? It’s a pilot study involving 33
patients with breast cancer-related lymphedema for at least six months but not
longer than five years. This time period was chosen to make sure that the
subjects were all out of the immediate postoperative period but not so many
years out that they started to develop skin complications from chronic
lymphedema. These patients all underwent twice weekly 30-minute acupuncture
sessions for four weeks as follows:

   Alcohol swabs were applied prior to insertion of sterile single-use filiform 
   needles (32-36 gauge; 30-40 mm in length, Tai Chi brand, made in China and
   distributed by Lhasa OMS, Weymouth, MA) that penetrate 5-10 mm into the skin.
   A total of 14 needles were inserted: 4 in both affected and unaffected
   limbs, 2 in acupuncture points on both legs, and 2 in unilateral points on
   the torso. Selected acupuncture points (Fig. 1) were stimulated manually by
   gentle rotation of the needles with lift and thrust. The acupuncturists did
   not intentionally seek to achieve a de qi sensation.

   Specific acupuncture points used in this study were determined on the basis
   of historical context, the published literature, and the consensus of our
   experienced group of MSKCC staff acupuncturists.[18-20, 34, 37] Many of these
   acupoints are used to treat pain, weakness, and motor impairment; others are
   traditionally used to drain “dampness,” a TCM concept similar to edema.

Did I just read what I thought I read? Seriously? The rationale for choosing
these points was based on their being related to traditional Chinese medicine
concepts to drain “dampness”? This is utter nonsense, the sort of silliness in
which quackademic medicine corrupts academic medicine with concepts that have
nothing to do with science. Just read about “dampness” in TCM:

   In nature, dampness soaks the ground and everything that comes in contact
   with it, and stagnation results. Once something becomes damp, it can take a
   long time for it to dry out again, especially in wet weather. The yin
   pathogenic influence of dampness has similar qualities: It is persistent and 
   heavy, and it can be difficult to resolve. A person who spends a lot of time 
   in the rain, lives in a damp environment, or sleeps on the ground may be
   susceptible to external dampness.

   Similarly, a person who eats large amounts of ice cream, cold foods and
   drinks, greasy foods, and sweets is prone to imbalances of internal dampness.
   Dampness has both tangible and intangible aspects. Tangible dampness
   includes phlegm, edema (fluid retention), and discharges. Intangible dampness
   includes a person’s subjective feelings of heaviness and dizziness. A
   “slippery” pulse and a greasy tongue coating usually accompany both types of 
   dampness. In general, symptoms of dampness in the body include water
   retention, swelling, feelings of heaviness, coughing or vomiting phlegm, and 
   skin rashes that ooze or are crusty (as in eczema).

As I said, none of this has anything to do with science.

So, based on a TCM concept of “dampness” being tortuously related to lymphedema,
quackademics at MSKCC subjected patients to acupuncture and measured their limb
circumferences. There are a few ways to measure lymphedema. One is water
displacement, in which the subject puts her arm into a cylinder of water, and
the volume displaced is measured. This method isn’t used much anymore because
it’s messy and inconvenient to do, although it is arguably the most accurate. In
most cases, lymphedema is measured by comparing the circumference of each arm
at different locations defined by anatomy. Generally, this is done in four
locations, the metacarpal-phalangeal joints, the wrist, 10 cm distal to the
lateral epicondyles, and 15 cm proximal to the lateral epicondyles. Differences 
of 2 cm or more at any point compared with the contralateral arm are considered 
by some experts to be clinically significant. The authors used a two-point
technique performed by trained research assistants 10 cm above (upper arm) and 5
cm below (lower arm) the olecranon process using nonstretch tape measures,
which is said to be as sensitive and specific as any other methods. The median
age of subjects was 55, and they were a mean of 3.9 years out from surgery. They
were on the obese side, with a mean BMI of 30.4, which is above 30 and thus in 
the obese range.

The results were as follows. A 30% or greater decrease in arm circumference was 
observed in 11 patients (33%) and 18 had a reduction of at least 20%, a
reduction reported to be across the whole range of severity of lymphedema. One
notes that 31 subjects (94%) used other standard therapies during the study,
although 30 reported no change in their standard regimen. Now here’s where how
you present the data makes all the difference in the world. These percentages
seem huge, but you have to remember that the way they were calculated was in
terms of the difference between the two arms in circumference, normalized to the
pre-treatment difference. If the pre-treatment difference is small, then it
doesn’t take much of a decrease in lymphedema to produce a large percentage.
That’s why the really telling figure comes from Table 3, which shows that the
mean difference between pre-treatment and post-treatment arm circumference was
0.9 cm (95% confidence interval 0.72 to 1.07 cm). That is spectacularly
unimpressive, particularly in a population that skews obese. It sure sounds a
hell of a lot more impressive when expressed as a percentage.

Of course, the biggest problem with this pilot study is that it was
uncontrolled. There is no control group. So we have no idea whether acupuncture 
had anything to do with the modest decrease in lymphedema reported. I will give 
Dr. Cassileth credit in that she does acknowledge this in the paper:

   Whether acupuncture alone was responsible for this reduction was not
   evaluable in this pilot study. Our focus was on safety and potential
   efficacy, as current clinical practice to protect the lymphedematous arm
   prohibits needling.

Yet she also concludes, unfortunately:

   The therapeutic and cost-reduction potential of acupuncture for lymphedema
   may yield an important tool in the arsenal of lymphedema management. Although
   randomized clinical trial results await, including our ongoing study,
   acupuncture can be considered to treat this distressing problem confronted by
   many women with no other options for sustained reduction in arm
   circumference.

This study is not good evidence that acupuncture works for lymphedema. There is 
no reason from a standpoint of prior plausibility informed by biology to think
that acupuncture would do anything for lymphedema. On a Bayesian basis,
exceedingly low prior probability plus an equivocal result (and, yes, this
result is equivocal) equals a very high likelihood that the effect observed is a
false positive. Even worse, the randomized clinical trial being carried out
isn’t one that is likely to provide much of an answer. It’s a phase 2 clinical
trial comparing immediate acupuncture to wait list for six weeks, after which
wait listed subjects will cross over and receive acupuncture for six weeks. In
other words, everyone in the study will receive acupuncture. I mean, really. Why
are they even bothering? This study is unlikely to provide strong evidence that
acupuncture works. Most likely, it will be another equivocal acupuncture trial.
Of course, the ironic thing is that the crossover design was probably
necessitated by the seemingly “positive” result of Cassileth’s currently
reported trial. The IRB probably wouldn’t approve a no acupuncture arm in light 
of that, because then there wouldn’t be clinical equipoise.

Oh, the ironies of quackademic medicine, when the inevitable false positives
that occur when treatments of low prior probability are tested in clinical
trials complicate the next steps! It’s just infuriating how much time and
resources are being wasted on studies that are so highly unlikely ever to
produce useful results.

The Trilogy is complete

So what have we learned today? First of all, we’ve learned that, contrary to the
claims of its practitioners and apologists, acupuncture is not perfectly safe. 
No one’s claiming that it’s particularly dangerous, but it’s definitely not
perfectly safe. On rare occasions, it can even cause serious complications.
Next, consistent with the overwhelming clinical evidence that acupuncture does
not work, we’ve see two studies that desperately try to convince you that
acupuncture helps infertile couples undergoing IVF to conceive and that it can
be used for lymphedema. In the case of IVF, the study showed exactly the
opposite of what the authors claim it shows. It shows that acupuncture doesn’t
work for IVF. Finally, we learned that, despite what Barrie Cassileth says,
there is no good evidence that acupuncture works for lymphedema, just as there
is no good evidence that acupuncture works for anything. Even if its risk is
very small, it is all risk and no benefit, and there is no science-based reason 
to ever use it.

Knee Osteoarthritis: Thumbs Down for Acupuncture and Glucosamine

One more time: acupuncture and glucosamine are useless for osteoarthritis.

Harriet Hall on June 11, 2013

Link


Osteoarthritis is the “wear and tear” kind of arthritis that many of us develop 
as we get older.  Cartilage becomes less resilient with age, collagen can
degenerate, and inflammation and new bone outgrowths (osteophytes) can occur. 
This leads to pain, crepitus (Rice Krispie type crackling noises with movement),
swelling and fluid accumulation in the joints (effusion), and can severely
limit activity for some patients. Patellofemoral pain is one of the most common 
of the repetitive strain injuries and is like an early onset of arthritis.

Since knee osteoarthritis is such a ubiquitous annoyance, home remedies and CAM 
offerings abound.  Previously we have covered a number of CAM options on this
blog, including glucosamine, acupuncture, and several others. The American
Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) has just issued a 1200 page report
evaluating the evidence for various treatments for knee osteoarthritis short of 
total knee replacement surgery. A 13 page summary is available online. They have
done the heavy lifting for us, reviewing all the available scientific studies
for evidence of effectiveness. Here’s what the science says: (I’ve highlighted
the ones where the evidence is strong.) 

1. Exercise – strong evidence for effectiveness

2. Weight loss – moderate evidence for

3. Acupuncture – strong evidence against

4. Physical agents (TENS, ultrasound, etc.) – inconclusive

5. Manual therapy (chiropractic, massage) – inconclusive

6. Valgus-directing force brace – inconclusive

7. Lateral wedge insoles – moderate evidence against

8. Glucosamine and chondroitin – strong evidence against

9. NSAIDs – strong evidence for

10. Acetaminophen, opioids, pain patches – inconclusive (this is particularly
interesting since acetaminophen is the standard first-choice drug)

11. Intraarticular corticosteroid injections – inconclusive

12. Hyaluronic acid injections – strong evidence against (and if injections are
ineffective, those oral diet supplements certainly don’t have a chance)

13. Growth factor injections and/or platelet-rich plasma – inconclusive

14. Needle lavage – moderate evidence against

15. Arthroscopy with lavage and debridement – strong evidence against

16. Partial meniscectomy in osteoarthritis patients with torn meniscus –
inconclusive

17. Valgus-producing proximal tibial osteotomy – limited evidence

18. Free-floating interpositional device – no evidence; consensus against

They apparently didn’t think it was worthwhile even mentioning such things as
copper bracelets, magnets, prayer, or supplements like boswellia. Or homeopathy!

Naturopaths and other critics of mainstream medicine claim that MDs don’t
recommend lifestyle measures like exercise and weight loss, but here is a
mainstream medical organization that clearly does, and even puts them first on
its list. Critics who claim doctors are just out to make money, take note: if
they were the evil money-grubbers some make them out to be, wouldn’t these
surgeons want to promote income-generating arthroscopic lavage and debridement? 
Wouldn’t they want to suppress information about conservative treatments and
keep patients in pain until they were desperate enough to consent to expensive
joint replacement surgery? Gee, do you suppose maybe they really are just trying
to do what’s best for their patients?

I was glad to see that the AAOS reached the same conclusions we did on SBM
regarding acupuncture and glucosamine, but I wasn’t surprised. After all, we are
looking at the same published evidence. Unbiased scientific minds think alike. 
Recommendations on other websites like WebMD and the Mayo Clinic still favor
acupuncture and glucosamine. It will be interesting to see if they modify their 
websites in response to the AAOS report. I’m not holding my breath.

I was curious: if AAOS is an American Academy, why do they spell Orthopaedic the
British way?  I looked it up: Orthopaedic is the correct medical spelling! So
thanks to the AAOS, I learned something about spelling as well as about knees.

Curse Removal from the Annals. More Acupuncture Nonsense.

Mark Crislip on February 5, 2016

Link



Pictured: Joshua Tree. Not pictured: My bleached bones.  I hope.

A short post this week. Last weekend was a busy call weekend and as I type this 
I am heading for Palm Springs for a long weekend of hiking in the desert. If
there is no entry in 14 days, look for my bleached bones somewhere in Joshua
Tree.

Some observations about a recent article in the once-respected Annals of
Internal Medicine, whose recent articles on acupuncture suggest their motto
should be “The Annals: we have one too many ns.”

First there was, “Alexander Technique Lessons or Acupuncture Sessions for
Persons With Chronic Neck Pain: A Randomized Trial,” and now “Acupuncture for
Menopausal Hot Flashes: A Randomized Trial.”

Spinning yin deficiency

Why do the study? Why do any acupuncture study? Negative studies will not change
practice. There are no reality-based reasons to think that acupuncture would be
effective for any process. All the high quality studies show no efficacy.

As of the last Cochrane review of acupuncture for hot flashes, the data
suggested:

   When acupuncture was compared with sham acupuncture, there was no evidence of
   any difference in their effect on hot flushes. When acupuncture was compared
   with no treatment, there appeared to be a benefit from acupuncture, but
   acupuncture appeared to be less effective than [hormone therapy].

Treatment is no different than placebo, so for any real therapy it would be
concluded that the intervention is not effective.

And the results continue in this new study:

   Chinese medicine acupuncture was not superior to noninsertive sham
   acupuncture for women with moderately severe menopausal [hot flashes].

Nicely said. Expressing the proper and rigorous interpretation of the study,
acupuncture is not effective. For once the take on the web was correct:
acupuncture doesn’t work for hot flashes. This probably suggests the authors of 
the study never learned to spin their results. So often when acupuncture is
equal to placebo, acupuncture is declared effective since it has the “power of
the placebo”. You probably do not remember, but two years ago there was a
similar study where acupuncture and sham acupuncture were equal for reducing hot
flashes. Then the spin was “Acupuncture may reduce severity and frequency of
menopausal hot flashes.”

The lead author needs to get her SCAM speak down better, instead saying:

   “Acupuncture has been shown to be more effective than placebo for a number of
   conditions, specifically chronic pain,” said the lead author, Dr. Carolyn
   Ee, a family physician trained in both Western and Chinese medicine. “To say 
   that it doesn’t work for hot flashes is not the same as saying it doesn’t
   work.”

Chronic pain is singular, so I guess the number of conditions specifically is
one. The loneliest number as I remember. And while I agree it isn’t the same,
acupuncture still doesn’t work.

It would be an interesting sociological study. Do a test of acupuncture vs sham 
acupuncture vs wait list. Doesn’t matter the symptom as long as there is a
subjective endpoint. Real and sham will be equal in symptom relief and superior 
to doing nothing. Then send out two identical press releases except one that
concludes acupuncture does nothing and one concludes it is effective.

It would be interesting to see if anyone actually cognates on the releases.

And why would the Annals publish an article that says the study was using:

   Chinese medicine needle acupuncture designed to treat kidney yin deficiency

My first google hit using “kidney yin deficiency” as a search term suggests
kidney yin deficiency

   usually presents as lumbar soreness

And

   follows the rules of yang vacuity internal cold; therefore it usually
   presents cold symptoms, e.g. cold and pain in the lumbar area and cold limbs.
   Kidney qi deficiency is a common clinical diagnosis and does not usually
   present with cold symptoms. When the kidney’s astringent or storage functions
   are poor with a kidney qi deficiency, associated symptoms appear, e.g.
   frequent urination, copious amounts of clear urine, incontinence, enuresis,
   seminal emission, abortion, or miscarriage

Nowhere on the search result do they mention hot flashes.

Next hit. Menopause hot flashes? Nope

The next? Nope.

So I searched for menopause and kidney yin deficiency and found it.

   When hot flashes or sweating are the major complaints, TCM regards these as
   internal damage problems due to such things as blood and qi deficiency,
   kidney yin deficiency, spleen and heart deficiency, phlegm stagnation, heat
   or phlegm irritating heart.

It goes to the heart of Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine. They have zero
standards and basically make stuff up as they go along.

When I see kidney yin deficiency as a rationale for a clinical intervention, I
wonder if the Annals would have published a similar trial using the Traditional 
European Pseudo Medicine of four humors as the basis of a study and bleeding as 
the treatment. It would have the same result. It is a hoax that needs to be
played.

The ethics of cursing

One last thought about acupuncture. I like the concept of acupuncture as a
complex therapeutic ritual. But the longer I am in the SCAM world, the more I
think this gives acupuncture, and other pseudo-medicines, too much benefit of
the doubt.

Occasionally there is an article about the arrest of a fortune teller. The
fortune teller has convinced someone that they or their material goods are
cursed and the curse is the source of problems or discontent in the household.
In modern times the curse is sometimes referred to as negative energy.

The fortune teller then helps lift the curse. It may be money to help perform a 
ritual to lift the curse or remove the negative energy. Sometimes the valuables 
are cleansed and then disappear. Magic? In the legal system this behavior is
considered fraud and theft and the fortune teller, if caught, often goes to
jail.

I cannot find if the victims of the curse scam feel better after their curse has
been lifted or the negative energy banished. There are no studies I could
locate on the topic. At least I could find no studies outside of the literature 
for pseudo-medicines.

Is the practice of acupuncture, reiki, homeopathy, chiropractic and the other
pseudo-medicines any different from the practice of curse removal? Not that I
can see. They have the same basic principles, just different language. Barely.

Acupuncture is a ritual; it is a curse removal ritual. At its center, so is most
of CAM.

Do the ends justify the means? It depends on the ends and the means. But in
medicine there are those who consider it OK to do the equivalent of the curse
removal, fraud and theft, as long as the patient reports benefit.

There is little information on curses as a cause of illness outside of Biblical 
references, so it would appear to be an area with the potential for growth.

It would be simple enough to do. Get an online pseudo-medical degree like ND, DC
or Lac. Then you can do virtually anything and call it therapy. Then set up a
clinic to remove the negative energies and curses for medical purposes. The
authorities will never look twice. And in a year or two you will probably be
hired by the local University Medical Center’s Integrative Medical Clinic. I bet
the Cleveland Clinic will be the first.

Now my seat back needs to be in the upright and locked position and my computer 
stowed under the seat in front of me. Later.

Alternative Reproduction?

Are there effective forms of SCAMs for birth control or reproduction? Of course 
not.

Mark Crislip on September 22, 2022

Link



I usually start these blog entries with an idea and then see where the research 
takes me. Certainly I go down many rat holes. Thanks to the recent reversal of
reproductive rights by the SCOTUS, with perhaps more to come, I wondered what
SCAM alternatives were available when/if reality-based reproductive
interventions were no longer an option. I wonder no longer.

There are four aspects of reproduction I will consider, along with some rat
holes: contraception, infertility, erectile dysfunction, and pregnancy
termination.

As I start this, my assumption was there would be few SCAM approaches to
pregnancy prevention, as SCAMs have no efficacy when there is a hard end point
to the intervention. There are no SCAM therapies for the infections I see most
days as many have almost 100% mortality rates. No one, I would hope, would use a
SCAM for the sole treatment of endocarditis or meningitis – although there is
the occasional person who will rely solely on SCAMs for cancer treatment. It
does not end well.

I have told this story before, but I first learned about SCAMs early in my
practice when I was called to see a case of wet gangrene of the leg. A young
female had a sarcoma of her leg that would have likely been cured with
amputation. She chose naturopathy instead and the cancer advanced until most of 
her leg was cancer, much of it dead and putrefying. That is why they called me, 
not there was anything I could do. She refused any care (she was admitted
because she had passed out) and that night the cancer eroded into an artery and 
she bled out. That is where I first encountered naturopathy and the first of
many cases where cancer denial was an important aspect of the patient’s care.

Contraception

Like SCAM cancer therapies, it is obvious when contraception fails. I would
think pregnancy would be harder to deny than cancer, but I will not be surprised
if the comments have stories that demonstrate otherwise. The “if only they had 
used our SCAM sooner” gambit is unlikely to be a convincing argument as to why
birth control failed.

Before I wander the SCAMs, though, I wondered how people avoided pregnancy in
the era before oral contraceptives. Sure, there are barrier methods, abstinence 
(like that ever works), and the rhythm method. And you know what we call people 
who use the rhythm method for contraception? Parents.

If you visit the old towns of the West, it appears that most of the hotels and
restaurants were once bordellos. I wonder where they found all the workers for
these bordellos. It would seem that most of the female population of the Old
West would have to be employed in these houses of ill repute.

But how did the prostitutes, and others, avoid pregnancy? Were there, for lack
of a better term, natural forms of birth control? Or were the bordellos filled
with their offspring? Besides a variety of barrier methods (half a lemon used as
a cervical cap!), the techniques used were not that different than ‘modern’
SCAM ideas:

   Roman women put a leather pouch filled with cat’s liver on their left foot
   during sexual intercourse to prevent pregnancy. Some women believed that
   spitting three times into a frog’s mouth was a good method of birth control. 
   European women thought that they could prevent pregnancy by turning backwards
   a wheel of a mill at midnight. And, in many cultures women constantly wore
   various necklaces and amulets, which were supposed to have the power of
   controlling the act of conception. Women were advised to hold their breath
   and draw their bodies back during sex in order to stop the sperm from
   entering her body. It was also suggested a woman to jump backwards seven
   times after sexual intercourse or take something to cause sneezing.

As one website noted:

   Until modern contraceptives were invented, women relied on all kinds of
   ancient birth control methods that had inconsistent results. Some were even
   dangerous, including the use of heavy metals such as mercury, lead, and
   arsenic, which did prevent conception but also led to organ failure and brain
   damage.

I was also amazed to learn that the relationship between ovulation and menses
was not discovered until the 1930s, so that method of contraception was unknown 
for most of human history.

Also used were:

   syringes to inject mercury, arsenic, and vinegar into the body to induce
   abortions or treat diseases.

Much to my amusement, one Boston brothel had:

   …a homeopathic doctor “considered to be crackpotty at the time,” according to
   Beaudry. He prescribed unusual remedies for the women, most likely for
   treating sexually transmitted diseases and inducing abortions.

He would likely be considered crackpotty today.

One would think, wouldn’t one, that if acupuncture is efficacious in aiding in
pregnancy and given its numerous alleged salubrious effects on female and male
reproductive physiology, acupuncture and traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine
could also be used for contraception. I can think of one application where
acupuncture might be efficacious, but there are no acupuncture points on the
genitals.

While I was not surprised to find zero papers on the Pubmeds on using
acupuncture for birth control, I could also not find any with a general Google
search.

There are no SCAMs that are touted for contraception. Not acupuncture, not
homeopathy, not chiropractic, not naturopathy. No surprise. There would be no
way to rationalize away pregnancy.

One site mentioned in passing, stone seed root, thistle, wild carrot seed, and
ginger root as potential contraceptives. I would suggest not.

Since, as noted above, the goal is to adjust and harmonize the state of the
female body from a holistic approach and there is no useful form of SCAM
contraception, the harmonized state appears to be barefoot and pregnant.

Infertility

Infertility has a complex differential diagnosis with a variety of anatomical
and hormonal abnormalities leading to an inability to conceive. It also makes
for a huge literature, although like most of the SCAM literature, high-quality
studies are few and far between. I am going to discuss a few I find instructive 
and or amusing.

SCAM providers are fond of claiming that their raison d’etre is to help return
the body to its optimal state of homeostasis or as one review noted, to “…adjust
and harmonize the state of the female body from a holistic approach”.

There are a vast number of SCAMs that are used as an adjunctive therapy for
infertility. In China, not unsurprisingly, Traditional Chinese Pseudo Medicine, 
especially acupuncture and moxibustion, are used as primary treatment for
infertility. And, as is always the case in studies out of China, the studies are
uniformly positive.

It is a massive literature of Tooth Fairy science and I will note here an
infertility study that was randomized and double-blind comparing real
acupuncture with placebo acupuncture (same thing) in patients undergoing IVF
treatment. The results? No difference, really; p=0.038. But what was amusing was
that the pregnancy was increased in the placebo group:

   The overall pregnancy rate was significantly higher in the placebo
   acupuncture group than that in the real acupuncture group (55.1 versus 43.8%,
   respectively).

But there is no “real” acupuncture, as I have argued before. And their
conclusion? Not that doing two interventions with no reality-based reason for
efficacy is going to lead to random noise that looks significant. Nope:

   Placebo acupuncture was associated with a significantly higher overall
   pregnancy rate when compared with real acupuncture. Placebo acupuncture may
   not be inert.

LOL. What is inert is the critical thinking functions of the researchers.

Reading even the meta-analysis is the usual mess, because acupuncture, as
always, is a heterogeneous intervention, with traditional, electro, cat gut, and
warm being some of the variations used and compared. It is quite the mess for
drawing any conclusions about whether a specific intervention is effective. But 
as I have mentioned before, it is not the specific intervention that is
allegedly useful, it is the concept of acupuncture that is allegedly effective.

But if limited to quality studies, the efficacy of acupuncture is not
impressive:

   There was no statistically significant difference between the acupuncture
   group and no acupuncture (intervention) controls around the time of embryo
   transfer (ET; risk ratio, RR, 1.24, 95% confidence interval, CI, 1.02-1.50)
   or in unblinded trials, trials blinded to physicians and double-blind trials 
   (95% CI 1.26-1.88, 0.82-1.33 and 0.89-1.25, respectively). This was also the 
   case when comparing acupuncture with sham acupuncture controls around the
   time of ET (RR, 1.03, 95% CI 0.87-1.22) or when restricting to unblinded
   trials, trials blinded to physicians and double-blind trials (95% CI
   0.80-2.02, 0.82-1.18 and 0.77-1.17, respectively).

Much of the primary literature is in China and, for example, I could not find
the Chinese Journal of Family Planning and similar journals to see the details
about the effects of TCM retention enema on tubal obstructive infertility. Yes. 
Really.

   A warm enema containing Chinese medicine is administered before going to bed 
   to treat fallopian tube adhesion. The drug can be absorbed directly by rectal
   mucosa, which is beneficial to improve the congestion, edema, adhesion, and 
   hyperplasia of local tissues, and thus restoring the function of the
   fallopian tube.

What continues to amaze me is how health care professionals, well versed in
anatomy, physiology, biochemistry, etc., apply the techniques of reality on
fiction. It only happens in medicine. You do not see engineers trying to apply
the physics of Warner Brothers cartoons to the building of bridges and tunnels. 
There is no alternative engineering or aviation but doctors continue to act like
acupuncture and other SCAMs are not ludicrous.

Huge numbers of herbal preparations have been tried for male and female
infertility, more than I have time to review except to note the “efficacy” is
often secondary endpoints like cervical mucus consistency or sperm motility and 
concentration, not conception rates.

Chiropractic has been used for infertility but:

   There are very few original data articles documenting responses of infertile 
   females treated with spinal manipulation.

And:

   In the absence of a robust body of primary data literature, the use of spinal
   manipulation the management of female infertility should be approached with 
   caution.

The Journal of Vertebral Subluxation Research (not on Pubmed as Pubmed does not 
list science fiction) has papers purporting to show benefit of chiropractic in
infertile patients. And, to no one’s surprise, chiropractors tout the benefits
of their interventions on the web.

I can find next to nothing on Pubmed using homeopathy or naturopathy for
infertility. Well, for homeopathy preparations it would be exactly nothing.

Erectile dysfunction

The acupoints for erectile dysfunction are distant from the problematic organ,
in one study being, slightly below the navel, slightly above the hairline at the
back of the head, between the inside ankle bone and the achilles tendon, in the
inside wrist. And the results?

   No definite conclusions can be drawn.

A conclusion supported in the most recent meta-analysis where:

   Low quality evidence shows beneficial effect of acupuncture as adjunctive
   treatment for people mainly with psychogenic ED.

And the best results were:

   Acupuncture combined with tadalafil appeared to have better effect on
   increasing cure rate.

Lol. It takes a ‘Western’ medicine to get the best results.

There is the also creepy “Clinical Holistic Medicine: Holistic Sexology and
Acupressure Through the Vagina (Hippocratic Pelvic Massage)“.

Noted in one clinical study:

   The most difficult problem of this procedure seems to be that it makes it
   very difficult to be sure that the procedure and all the involved steps are
   always necessary and rational.

Eye roll and head shake.

There is nothing on the PubMeds for using chiropractic, homeopathy or
naturopathy for ED, but no shortage of websites promoting their use.

I wondered about homeopathy, so I picked a website at random. The first
suggestion is Agnus castus:

   This remedy may be helpful if problems with impotence develop after a man has
   led a life of intense and frequent sexual activity for many years. A cold
   sensation felt in the genitals is a strong indication for Agnus castus.
   People who need this remedy are often very anxious about their health and
   loss of abilities and may have problems with memory and concentration. This
   remedy is one of the best homeopathic medicine for ED.

Agnus castus is the chaste berry, which one site says:

   The fruit has been historically used for reducing sexual desire.

As one site notes:

   The leaves of this plant were used to adorn the beds of Greek women during
   the absence of their husbands so as to prevent any impure thoughts from
   entering their minds and also by medieval monks to repress sexual desire. In 
   the actual provings the remedy has shown that it does repress sexual instinct
   and desire.

And:

   Agnus castus is indicated for promiscuous young people who have abused their 
   sexual energies through either homosexual or heterosexual multiple contacts
   and who have contracted repeated venereal infections, especially gonorrhea.

Huh? Homeopathic teaching is that a product that causes the symptoms undergoes
serial dilution and succussion to make a more potent medication. Somehow a
medication that reduces sexual desire increases libido when homeopathized?
Writing these entries leads to some of the weirdest stuff.

Abortion

While no trials can be identified in the Pubmeds, acupuncture was used for
abortions in China although it was unreliable. Cue Louie. Acupuncture does have 
“forbidden points”. Specifically if you stimulate:

   San Yin Chiao (SP6) in conjunction with He Gu (LI4). The abortion is
   generally realized within 24 hours.

But that’s in humans, in Wistar rats stimulating the forbidden points does
nothing:

   We found no evidence that acupuncture in LI4-SP6 and sacral points could be
   harmful to the pregnancy outcome in Wistar rats.

But then, why would it? Was trying to confirm or deny a fiction worth abusing
and killing rats? I doubt it.

I have often wondered how they map human acupoints and meridians onto animals;
evidently so do acupuncturists in search of One Acupuncture. One Acupuncture to 
rule them all, One Acupuncture to find them, One Acupuncture to bring them all
and in the darkness bind them, I suppose.

   Moving toward a neuroanatomically accurate veterinary acupuncture system
   requires rethinking current atlases and embarking upon a systematic analysis 
   of the human points in terms of where, if at all, corresponding sites exist
   in the nonhuman.

Good luck with that. Because you might run into issues such as those with Boa
constrictors, although why one would want to torture a snake with acupuncture is
uncertain.

   Thus, the objective of this study was to map and describe the main points of 
   acupuncture in the species Boa constrictor, and their indications to promote 
   the balance of this species. The unprecedented result of the mapping was the 
   discovery of specific acupoints with individual location indications without 
   distribution in specific meridians and dispersedly distributed in the body.

Careful, clever, scientists, they measured the heart rate:

   HR was obtained by counting heart rate.

And if you wondered how they found acupuncture points?

   Use of the electrostimulator and location of EL points 30 – 10/100 Hz
   NKLpoints of Brazilian origin. The EL30 is an electronic device that is
   intended exclusively for non-invasive applications in the technique called
   electro-acupuncture. It was conceived as a point detection instrument, where 
   an electrostimulation therapy, used in different media with a purpose of
   detection and determination of qualities as stimulus conditions for different
   species and for different points. It was traversed with an exploratory tip
   of the animal’s body points to an occurrence of an audible signal indicating 
   the localized point and an impedance. The sensitivity controller has been
   adjusted to find a better setting.

More animal abuse for no good reason. But I digress. Again.

Consistency not being a strong point in acupuncture, when acupuncture was used
as an adjunct to medical abortion they used Hegu (LI 4), Sanyinjiao (SP 6),
Neiguan (PC 6) and Kunlun (BL 60). I suspect the increased efficacy was due to
BL 60.

Acupuncturists can get quite wiggens over the forbidden points, going as far as 
to suggest the auricular acupuncture should be avoided in pregnancy. I would add
it should be avoided when not pregnant as well. Several reviews suggest
acupuncture is safe in pregnancy “when correctly applied”, whatever correctly
applied might be.

While I can find papers where acupuncture is purported to prevent spontaneous
abortion, and I can find nothing to confirm the abortifacient effects of
acupuncture.

I can find nothing on using homeopathy, chiropractic or naturopathic techniques 
to induce abortion, although they allege they can help prevent spontaneous
abortion/miscarriage. The one-way street that is SCAM.

Herbs? There’s a problem. I will admit, I am not one for social media. Twitter
is a time suck and Facebook opaque and pointless. I certainly do not grok the
concept of influencers. So TikTok? So out of my geezer understanding. But, per
the Rolling Stone (geezer cred?) TikTok is a popular source for information on
DYI abortions using pennyroyal, blue cohosh, and mugwort. Herbs that are not
efficacious but are certainly toxic and could be fatal. As one PubMed review
noted:

   the ingestion of plants to induce abortion involves the risk of severe
   morbidity and mortality.

Hard to believe, but when it comes to medical advice it is suggested:

   not to “listen to what you hear on TikTok.”

It is a question with no real answer: would a SCAM provider be any better?

It turns out self-managed abortion is not that uncommon, with 7% of “US women of
reproductive age” (kind of redundant, women not in their reproductive age are
unlikely to need an abortion) going the DYI route, often with herbs and without 
success.

With the Handmaiden’s Tale decision this year, I expect DYI abortions will only 
increase with resultant morbidity and mortality. Desperate people will do
desperate things.

Acupuncture, Infertility, and Horrible Reporting

Harriet Hall on February 28, 2012

Link



Did acupuncture help a Detroit family doctor get pregnant? Probably not.

An article (and associated news video clip) from ClickOn in Detroit is titled
“Alternative treatment helps Michigan doctor beat infertility.” This is a
misleading title, and the report is an example of poor science reporting.

Was she infertile?

The patient in question was a 33-year-old family practice doctor who believed
she was infertile. By definition, infertility is failure to conceive after a
year of regular intercourse without contraception. She didn’t meet that
definition. She only tried for 6 months before seeing a doctor, and then for 2
more months (with some kind of unspecified medicine) and then she consulted a
reproductive endocrinologist who apparently told her she was infertile because
of a high FSH level. Then she “did her own research” and supposedly found that
acupuncture was a key part of infertility treatment. So she sought infertility
treatment from an acupuncturist.

What do FSH levels mean?

High FSH can indicate menopause or poor ovarian responsiveness. In the treatment
of infertility with in vitro fertilization (IVF), FSH level measured on day 3
of the menstrual cycle is predictive of fertility within that IVF cycle. But for
diagnosing infertility, one measurement is not enough to base predictions on.
Lab values vary, and FSH levels are known to fluctuate with factors like stress 
and illness.

It sounds like she was told she was infertile based on one FSH test; if so, that
was an unwarranted diagnosis. Then, during acupuncture treatment, the FSH
levels dropped. Did they drop because of the acupuncture? Did they drop for
other reasons like a reduction in stress? Would they have dropped anyway without
any treatment at all? We don’t know. She attributes it to the acupuncture, but 
she may be committing the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy (“correlation is not
causation”).

The treatment

After six months of acupuncture, she became pregnant and subsequently gave birth
to a healthy baby. The treatments consisted of needle insertions and
supplements (not identified) from an acupuncturist who claims to “treat the
whole person” and restore the woman’s normal healthy reproductive cycle “as best
as can be naturally done.” He admits:

   I’m not a doctor, I don’t pretend to be a doctor, and I don’t have the
   diagnostic tools of a doctor.

The evidence

One literature review found that acupuncture “may have a role” in the treatment 
of polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS) (which this patient did not have), but a
controlled study showed no difference between true and sham acupuncture for
PCOS. A study with a sham acupuncture control claimed to show an improvement in 
menopausal symptoms with acupuncture, but no difference in FSH levels was
detected. A study from China showed an increase in FSH in aging men with partial
androgen deficiency when they were treated with acupuncture and medication, but
not with acupuncture alone.

A search of PubMed didn’t turn up any credible evidence for the effectiveness of
acupuncture for treating infertility per se. One systematic review found no
evidence of effectiveness for infertility except in one specific area of embryo 
transfer. There were a number of articles about IVF. A Cochrane review looked at
embryo transfer in assisted conception and concluded that acupuncture:

   shows a beneficial effect on the live birth rate; however, with the present
   evidence this could be attributed to placebo effect and the small number of
   women included in the trials. Acupuncture should not be offered during the
   luteal phase in routine clinical practice until further evidence is available
   from sufficiently powered RCTs.

One study showed an improvement in measures of stress in infertility patients. I
wrote about a study of acupuncture for IVF that showed it didn’t work: the
researchers tried to blame the patients for not having good quality embryos.
When that didn’t turn out to be true, they still recommended using acupuncture. 
The Skeptic’s Dictionary has a good overview of the published evidence on
acupuncture for infertility. Steven Novella has written about a study that
showed that using CAM (several modalities included) resulted in lower pregnancy 
rates.

In short, I don’t know where she did her research, but I couldn’t find any
credible evidence to support using acupuncture either for infertility or for
raising FSH levels. And there is no plausible physiologic mechanism by which it 
could be expected to help other than perhaps by assisting relaxation and
reducing worry, anxiety, and stress.

The story

The news story was credulous, didn’t adequately explain the facts, and didn’t
present any conflicting data or opinions. It provided two links for readers to
get more information: both are extremely biased and contain misinformation. One 
link is to another credulous example of poor reporting from the popular media,
and the other is a link to the website of the Acupuncture Center of Ann Arbor,
which offers a number of questionable treatments including DHEA and bioidentical
hormones.

There was nothing from skeptics or from patients who had acupuncture and did not
get pregnant. There wasn’t even the usual token effort to present “both sides” 
of a controversial story. This is not good science journalism. It isn’t even
science journalism. It amounts to irresponsible sensationalism and free
advertising for the Acupuncture Center of Ann Arbor.

Bottom line

This woman did not meet the criteria for a diagnosis of infertility when she
started seeking treatment. There’s every reason to think she got pregnant just
in the natural course of things, and no reason to think acupuncture had any
effect. The news report and article are a travesty. Detroit deserves better.

Acupuncture for Menopausal Symptoms

Steven Novella on July 16, 2014

Link

A newly published meta-analysis of studies looking at acupuncture for symptoms
resulting from natural menopause (not drug or surgically induced) by Chiu et.
al. is entirely negative. That is not what the authors or the press release
conclude, however.

This disconnect between the study results and the interpretation of those
results is a persistent problem in medicine generally to some degree, but is
endemic and profound within the CAM (complementary and alternative medicine)
culture. Acupuncture in particular is promoted almost entirely based on this
type of misinterpretations – the kind that can magically turn negative studies
into positive studies.

In the abstract the authors conclude:

   This meta-analysis confirms that acupuncture improves hot flash frequency and
   severity, menopause-related symptoms, and quality of life (in the vasomotor 
   domain) in women experiencing natural menopause.

Let’s take a close look at the results, however. Indeed, when comparing
acupuncture to no treatment controls there was a significant decrease in
subjective symptoms in the pooled data. Outcomes were hot flash frequency, hot
flash severity, other menopausal symptoms, and quality of life. Some of the
included studies were large controlled trials, which the authors used to argue
that their results are valid. They also point out that their results showed
heterogeneity and lack of publication bias.

There are two major problems with the results, however, that contradict the
authors’ conclusion, one moderate and one fatal. The moderate problem is that
there is a lack of dose response. The authors write:

   The effect size of acupuncture on hot flash frequency was not significantly
   associated with the number of treatment doses, the number of sessions, and
   the duration of treatment in weeks.

The same was true of hot flash severity. We like to see a dose-response effect
to help confirm that the treatment effect is real. You might argue that
acupuncture does not work that way, that even a brief treatment is sufficient
and there is an early plateau in effect. This might be true (in which case
longer sessions are unnecessary), but this argument amounts to special pleading,
and at the very least implies caution in concluding the treatment works.

The second problem with the data, however, directly contradicts the authors’
conclusions:

   Arguably, our findings showed that sham acupuncture could induce a treatment 
   effect comparable with that of true acupuncture for the reduction of hot
   flash frequency. This result is in line with previous reviews. A compelling
   finding from a previous systematic review concluded that approximately 60% of
   RCTs revealed that sham acupuncture was as efficacious as true acupuncture, 
   especially when superficial needling was applied to nonpoints.

A Cochrane review from 2013 concluded:

   We found insufficient evidence to determine whether acupuncture is effective 
   for controlling menopausal vasomotor symptoms. When we compared acupuncture
   with sham acupuncture, there was no evidence of a significant difference in
   their effect on menopausal vasomotor symptoms. When we compared acupuncture
   with no treatment there appeared to be a benefit from acupuncture, but
   acupuncture appeared to be less effective than HT.

Both reviews are essentially showing the same thing – when you compare
acupuncture to sham acupuncture, there is no difference in outcome. The spin on 
these results, however, is entirely different. The Chiu review goes on to
speculate about why sham acupuncture might also “work.”

We have pointed out this invalid logic many times. Especially when dealing with 
subjective symptoms, the only comparison that tells us anything reliable is a
blinded comparison between a treatment and a control. Unblinded comparisons
(such as between sham acupuncture and no treatment) are essentially useless, as 
subjective outcomes will be contaminated with placebo effects.

You also have to consider the quality of the study. Acupuncture studies in
particular have a problem with unblinding (the subjects figuring out if they had
real or sham acupuncture). The Chiu review summarized the rigor of the studies 
they reviewed, many of which had problems with allocation concealment, blinding 
of outcome assessment, and selective reporting. Such flaws easily explain the
40% of studies that show some small difference between treatment and control.

This pattern is typical of the acupuncture literature. The best quality studies 
consistently show no difference in blinded comparisons between treatment and
control groups. The variables that define acupuncture – sticking needles into
acupuncture points – do not make any difference to the outcome, therefore
acupuncture (by any reasonable definition) does not work. The therapeutic ritual
surrounding acupuncture has predictable placebo effects and nothing more.

A possible explanation for the dramatic difference in interpretation of the same
data between the Chiu and the Cochrane reviews could be in a conflict of
interest in the Chiu review. Although they disclose no conflicts of interest,
all the authors are from Taiwan. A 1998 review found:

   Research conducted in certain countries was uniformly favorable to
   acupuncture; all trials originating in China, Japan, Hong Kong, and Taiwan
   were positive, as were 10 out of 11 of those published in Russia/USSR.

From this data it is reasonable to conclude that being from Taiwan is a conflict
of interest for acupuncture studies.

Conclusion

Yet again we see that the clinical data with acupuncture studies is essentially 
negative. In this case acupuncture does not work for menopausal symptoms.
Proponents of acupuncture, however, turn the logic of science and clinical
trials on its head by bizarrely concluding that no difference between treatment 
and control means the control works also (rather than the usual interpretation
that the treatment does not work).

Believers apparently buy into this invalid logic. For example, the website
Science 2.0 (a straight-up science news site) has the headline: Acupuncture
Works To Reduce Menopause Hot Flashes – Meta-analysis. This is followed by a
gullible article that accepts the authors’ biased conclusions without any
critical analysis. The comments are also revealing, one stating the CAM party
line very well:

   You actually are quite uninformed here as to what “placebo” is. It is a mass 
   misconception that “placebo effect” means something doesn’t work. The placebo
   effect actually proves that the body has a remarkable ability to heal
   itself. This is most relevant in the field of acupuncture – sadly, to fit
   acupuncture into the realm of “double blind studies” (which you would
   understand are horribly flawed if you spent any time in medical schools and
   in research classes (I have for instance) they had to come up with “sham
   acupuncture” which is completely flawed, because there’s no way to fake it.

No difference between treatment and placebo does mean that, as far as the
clinical trial is concerned, the treatment has no specific effect. Sham
acupuncture nicely controls for one aspect of acupuncture – alleged acupuncture 
points. At the very least we can conclude that acupuncture points have no basis 
in reality, which undercuts the traditional philosophy of acupuncture (at least 
as it is received today).

Other studies show that needle insertion, or insertion to depth, or elicitation 
of the alleged “de Qi“, also have no effect. You can actually “fake it” by using
opaque sheaths and dull needles or even toothpicks that are not inserted, but
neither the patient nor the acupuncturist can tell the difference.

Again, at the very least from all the data we must conclude that coaching a
completely untrained person to poke the skin randomly with toothpicks, while
putting on a halfway decent show, is just as effective as individualized
acupuncture from a trained and credentialed acupuncturist with decades of
experience. Therefore there is absolutely no basis for acupuncture philosophy,
and no justification for training or credentialing of acupuncturists. Whatever
they are teaching seems to be worthless.

A reasonable person can only conclude that acupuncture does not work, and that
all the clinical research consistently shows that acupuncture conveys only
illusory and nonspecific placebo effects for subjective symptoms.

Acupuncture does not work for menopause: A tale of two acupuncture studies

David Gorski on April 18, 2016

Link



Women looking for relief from hot flashes will be disappointed if they think
acupuncture will help them.

Arguably, one of the most popular forms of so-called “complementary and
alternative medicine” (CAM) being “integrated” with real medicine by those who
label their specialty “integrative medicine” is acupuncture. It’s particularly
popular in academic medical centers as a subject of what I like to refer to as
“quackademic medicine“; that is, the study of pseudoscience and quackery as
though it were real medicine. Consider this. It’s very difficult to find
academic medical centers that will proclaim that they offer, for example, The
One Quackery To Rule Them All (homeopathy). True, a lot of integrative medicine 
programs at academic medical centers do offer homeopathy. They just don’t do it 
directly or mention it on their websites. Instead, they offer naturopathy, and, 
as I’ve discussed several times, homeopathy is an integral—nay, required—part of
naturopathy. (After graduation from naturopathy school, freshly minted
naturopaths are even tested on homeopathy when they take the NPLEX, the
naturopathic licensing examination.) Personally, I find this unwillingness of
academic medical centers that offer naturopathy to admit to offering homeopathy 
somewhat promising, as it tells me that even at quackademic medical centers
there are still CAM modalities too quacky for them to want to be openly
associated with. That optimism rapidly fades when I contemplate what a
hodge-podge of quackery naturopathy is and how many academic integrative
medicine programs offer it.

If you believe acupuncturists, acupuncture can be used to treat almost anything.
Anyone with a reasonable grasp of critical thinking should recognize that a
claim that an intervention, whatever it is, can treat many unrelated disorders
is a huge red flag that that intervention is almost certainly not science-based 
and is probably quackery. So it is with acupuncture; yet, that hasn’t stopped
the doyens of integrative medicine at the most respected medical schools from
being seduced by the mysticism of acupuncture and studying it. I can’t entirely 
blame them. I must admit, there was a time when even I thought that there might 
be something to acupuncture. After all, unlike so many other CAM interventions, 
acupuncture involved doing something physical, inserting actual needles into the
body. However, as I critically examined more and more acupuncture studies, I
eventually came to agree with David Colquhoun and Steve Novella that acupuncture
is nothing more than a “theatrical placebo.”

As I’ve said before, if you look at the evidence for acupuncture critically and 
in its totality, acupuncture has no specific effects and no effects
distinguishable from placebo. Indeed, it doesn’t matter where the needles are
inserted, in “real” or “sham” acupuncture points, or even if the needles are
actually inserted in the skin (a point that will become important later in this 
post). It’s all the same. Basically, acupuncture is the gateway drug of
“complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) that is often a harbinger of the 
harder stuff, like naturopathy and homeopathy. But, if you believe its
adherents, acupuncture can work for practically any symptom caused by pretty
much any condition.

Acupuncture and menopause

One of the most popular uses for acupuncture is to treat menopausal symptoms.
I’m familiar with this literature because the anti-estrogen drugs used to treat 
hormone-responsive breast cancer nearly always produce menopausal symptoms, and 
it is these symptoms that all too often hurt patient compliance with treatment
and sometimes even lead patients to discontinue the drugs. Indeed, among
practitioners of “integrative medicine” (the art of integrating quackery with
real medicine), there’s a great deal of enthusiasm for acupuncture for
menopausal symptoms, particularly hot flashes, which can be very troublesome for
both women undergoing natural menopause and even more so for women experiencing
medication-induced menopause as part of their breast cancer treatment. Worse,
in the case of cancer treatment, oncologists can’t use supplemental estrogen to 
treat them, hence the search for other treatments. Never mind that clinical
studies have been consistently unimpressive. None of this, however, prevents
acupuncture advocates from continuing to do clinical trials. In fact, in just
the first quarter of 2016, there have already been published two major studies
examining acupuncture as an intervention to relieve menopausal symptoms. They
are studies that support what we at Science-Based Medicine (SBM) have been
saying all along: The more rigorous the study, the more likely it is to find no 
specific effect greater than that of placebo.

Acupuncture and menopause: Acupuncture doesn’t work

The first study I’ll examine was carried out in Australia. It is a perfect
example of what Harriet Hall likes to refer to as “Tooth Fairy science.” To
paraphrase Harriet, Tooth Fairy Science is science that studies a phenomenon
that doesn’t exist. You can do studies on the Tooth Fairy comparing how much
money she leaves for kids in different socioeconomic groups. You can do studies 
on the memory of homeopathic water. You can do studies on the therapeutic
effects of manipulating imaginary human energy fields with therapeutic touch.
The problem is that the phenomena under study haven’t yet been shown to exist;
so Tooth Fairy science is, in essence, putting the cart before the horse. Prove 
the phenomenon exists before doing studies of it; this is particularly important
in human trials, because doing human subjects research without having first
developed a robust preclinical science base for the intervention to be studied
is considered unethical—and rightly so.

No one, for instance, has ever shown that human life “energy” (qi) exists, much 
less that sticking little needles into the pathways in the body through which
the qi flows (acupuncture meridians) can unblock or redirect the flow of qi for 
healing effect, nor has anyone ever shown that meridians even exist.
Unfortunately, the authors the Australian study recently published in the Annals
of Internal Medicine by Carolyn Ee and investigators from Melbourne Medical
School, the University of Melbourne; the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology
University; Southern Cross University; Queen’s University in Ontario; and
Monash Health in Clayton, Victoria, Australia seem aware of that, as you will
see. It is a randomized clinical trial of acupuncture for hot flashes that occur
during normal menopause entitled “Acupuncture for Menopausal Hot Flashes: A
Randomized Trial.” Although there is much to admire about this trial, even with 
a pretty rigorous clinical trial design the authors couldn’t resist bringing
traditional Chinese medicine mysticism into the mix.

This trial enrolled women older than 40 in the late menopausal transition or
postmenopause with at least seven moderate hot flashes daily. Hilariously (I
have to laugh so that I don’t cry) the authors further note that these women
thus met the criteria for traditional Chinese medicine diagnosis of kidney yin
deficiency. Curious just what “kidney yin deficiency” is, I looked it up. Here’s
a description. First of all, kidney yin is:

   When The [sic] theory of yin and yang is used to explain the organic
   structure of the human body; the physical form pertains to yin, while
   activities or functions pertain to yang. The physical forms are the material 
   basis for functions, while functions are the motivating power for physical
   forms. They are mutually complementary. TCM views the kidneys as the center
   of the body’s yin and yang, the “congenital foundation,” or the origin of
   life. In other words, the kidneys store the primordial yin and primordial
   yang (also called kidney yin and yang), which is the place where nutrients
   are stored and physiological functions take place.

   Kidney yin, also called primordial yin, true yin or true water, is the
   foundation of the yin fluid of the whole body; it moistens and nourishes the 
   organs and tissues.

   TCM kidneys Kidney yang, also called primordial yang, true yang or true fire,
   is the foundation of the yang qi of the whole body; it warms and promotes
   the functions of the organs and tissues.

This is, of course, utterly unscientific, based as it is on concepts not at all 
unlike the concepts behind “traditional Western medicine,” namely the idea that 
“imbalances” in something are the cause of all disease. In the case of
traditional Western medicine, it’s an imbalance in the four humors. In
traditional Chinese medicine, it’s an imbalance in the five elements. In any
case, what are the symptoms of kidney yin deficiency? Not surprisingly, some of 
them resemble menopause:

   Presentations of kidney yin deficiency include: soreness and weakness of the 
   lumbar regions and knees, dizziness, ringing in the ears, hearing problems, a
   dry mouth and throat, a hot sensation in the palms, soles and chest,
   spontaneous sweating, constipation, and seminal emission. The pulse is weak
   or fine and rapid; the tongue is red and covered with a light coating of fur.
   Kidney yin deficiency syndrome always produces signs of yin vacuity internal
   heat.

Now, here’s where kidney yin deficiency comes into the trial, according to Ee et
al:

   Women were included if they were postmenopausal (>12 months since their final
   menstrual period) or in the late menopausal transition
   (follicular-stimulating hormone level ≥25 IU, amenorrhea ≥60 days, and VMSs),
   had a mean HF score of at least 14 (equal to 7 moderate VMSs daily) (16), or
   had kidney yin deficiency diagnosed using a structured Chinese medicine
   history as well as a tongue and pulse examination performed by experienced
   acupuncturists (Appendix Figures 1 and 2). Kidney yin deficiency, of which
   night sweats is a cardinal symptom, is a Chinese medicine clinical syndrome
   diagnosed in 76% to 81% of symptomatic postmenopausal women (17, 18).

They were even kind enough to provide a questionnaire to diagnose kidney yin
deficiency (click to embiggen):



Yes, this is the actual questionnaire used in this study.

As you can see, this questionnaire is so vague as to be pointless. Certainly,
it’s not enough to diagnose menopause. After all, there are no questions about
frequency of menstrual periods or when the subject’s last menstrual period was, 
and the questionnaire includes information about Chinese pulse diagnosis, which 
is not reproducible, and Chinese tongue diagnosis, which is basically
reflexology on the tongue.

The women were also assessed for kidney yang deficiency. (I kid you not.) Kidney
yang deficiency involves sore and/or weak back/knees, sensation of cold,
aversion to cold, weak lower limbs, lassitude, clear copious urine, poor
appetite, loose stools, edema (which can be severe). Here’s the questionnaire Ee
et al used (click to embiggen):



Again, yes, this is the actual questionnaire used in the study.

According to the paper, the final scores for kidney yin and yang deficiency were
compared, and women who scored higher for kidney yin deficiency were eligible
for the trial.

So far, not so good. If only the authors had stuck to standard “Western” medical
definitions of menopause, instead of bringing in prescientific mystical beliefs
of traditional Chinese medicine.

Leaving aside the study’s inclusion and exclusion criterial, I note that 327
women were randomly assigned to acupuncture (n=163) or sham acupuncture (n=164).
The study was blinded, but not completely. Study design was a stratified, blind
(participants, outcome assessors, and investigators, but not treating
acupuncturists), parallel, randomized, sham-controlled trial with equal
allocation. Overall, it wasn’t a bad design as far as acupuncture studies go.
Its main defect is that the treating acupuncturists were not blinded, which
would have been required for a true double-blind study design, but other than
that the study did use a pretty good acupuncture sham, the Park-style fake
retractable needles that don’t break the skin, which were also inserted in the
“wrong” places. In any case, participants received 20 minute acupuncture
sessions (or sham acupuncture sessions) twice weekly for two weeks and then
weekly thereafter.

So what were the results? Do you even have to ask? Basically, this was a
completely negative trial, which is why I wasn’t as concerned about whether or
not the acupuncturists were blinded or not. (This would have been a much bigger 
issue if there had been a positive result.) At the end of the eight week
treatment period, mean hot flash scores were 15.36 in the acupuncture group and 
15.04 in the sham group (P=0.77). Hot flash scores declined about 40% in both
groups and persisted for six months. The investigators couldn’t find evidence of
an advantage of acupuncture over sham acupuncture on quality of life, anxiety, 
or depression. That’s about as negative as it gets. I do have to give the
investigators credit. They didn’t try too hard to torture the data to provide
the result they wanted with post hoc analyses, as many investigators carrying
out clinical trials of CAM (and, let’s admit it, non-CAM) are often tempted to
do.

The authors did, however, try to make excuses. Indeed, the shorter version of
the whole discussion section seems to be: How can it possibly be that we didn’t 
find acupuncture to be superior to sham acupuncture for menopausal hot flashes?

They noted:

   Our findings are consistent with those from a recent Cochrane review (10),
   which reported that acupuncture was more effective than no treatment and had 
   a moderate effect size but was not efficacious when compared with sham.
   Although another recent meta-analysis reported moderate standardized effect
   sizes of acupuncture of −0.35 and −0.44 for HF frequency and severity (13),
   this analysis pooled data from sham-controlled trials and trials comparing
   acupuncture with no treatment. In addition, the shortcomings of the included 
   studies (small sample sizes, high attrition rates, and failure to use
   intention-to-treat analyses) may have inflated the treatment effects.

I can’t help but note that “more effective than no treatment” + “not efficacious
when compared with sham” = not efficacious.

This observation, of course, leaves the question of why bother to do this study 
in the first place, given that there’s enough evidence out there to do a
Cochrane review and that review found no evidence that acupuncture was more
efficacious in menopausal hot flashes than sham acupuncture, and that there was 
enough evidence to do a meta-analysis whose results were probably due to the
inclusion of low quality evidence. There was (and is) no strong clinical or
scientific rationale to do randomized studies of acupuncture for menopausal hot 
flashes.

This next paragraph made me chuckle out loud as I read it:

   The first limitation of our trial and acupuncture clinical research more
   broadly is the lack of an inert sham comparison treatment. Although the Park 
   sham device was the best available sham acupuncture method at the time of
   study design, its validity as an effective control treatment needs further
   determination. It creates a needle-prick sensation, essential for the patient
   to believe that a needle has been inserted; however, this sensation produces
   minor physiologic effects (26). The interpretation of sham-controlled
   acupuncture trials must occur within this context. However, what we have
   successfully examined is the effect of needling compared with pressure from a
   blunt needle. Second, despite our broad recruitment strategy, our findings
   can only be generalized to Caucasian Australian women with kidney yin
   deficiency. Nonetheless, 87% of otherwise eligible women met criteria for
   symptoms of kidney yin deficiency, consistent with previous studies (17, 18).
   Third, our method of Chinese medicine diagnosis was a simplified version of 
   usual practice and failed to define secondary diagnoses. In addition, our
   acupuncturists could not be blinded, but we provided comprehensive training
   and performed quality assurance visits to minimize bias. Finally, our
   findings cannot be generalized to women with bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy 
   or worsening of VMSs after breast cancer; we excluded these women because
   they have more severe VMSs (47, 48). Future research should examine the role 
   of acupuncture in breast cancer.

Yes, let’s count the excuses, which sound increasingly desperate. One: The sham 
needles weren’t an adequate control. (Never mind that they’ve been used in many 
studies and found to be quite good.) Two: Our findings can’t be generalized to
all women with menopause but only to Caucasian Australian women who also—by the 
way—have kidney yin deficiency. (Are they saying that menopause is so different 
in other races that this result can’t be generalized? That’s even leaving aside 
the insistence on an unvalidated, pre-scientific method of diagnosis.) Three:
Our method of traditional Chinese medicine diagnosis was too simplified. (If
only we could have brought all our woo diagnosis criteria to bear, there’d have 
been a positive result!) Four: Our acupuncturists couldn’t be blinded.
(Actually, this one deficiency with the study was in the investigators’ favor
and made a seemingly “positive” result more likely. They didn’t get one.) Five: 
We can’t generalize our findings to women with menopause due to surgery or to
breast cancer treatment. So let’s study the role of acupuncture in alleviating
menopausal symptoms in breast cancer patients! (Stay tuned for the next study I 
discuss here.)

So once again, we have yet another study that shows that acupuncture doesn’t
work, and once again we have investigators who refuse to believe their own
results and have to be dragged, kicking and screaming, by the data to the
conclusion that their hypothesis was false. Even then, they can’t help making
lots of excuses and planning their next study even though this one was totally
negative.

Same as it ever was. So is the next study, which turns the normal rationale for 
using a good “sham” or placebo intervention in a clinical trial on its head.

Acupuncture and menopause: Acupuncture “works,” but only compared to nothing

There’s already sufficient evidence out there (e.g., studies like this one) to
show that acupuncture doesn’t work for menopausal symptoms in breast cancer
patients undergoing treatment with anti-estrogen drugs and/or chemotherapy
(which can also induce menopausal symptoms); that is, other than studies that
don’t bother to blind anybody. This has not prevented, for example, the Society 
for Integrative Oncology from including acupuncture in its clinical guidelines
for breast cancer patients. Nor did it stop what is considered to be one of the 
top journals for oncology, The Journal of Clinical Oncology (or, as we
affectionately call it, JCO), from publishing a study like this one conducted in
Italy, “Acupuncture As an Integrative Approach for the Treatment of Hot Flashes
in Women With Breast Cancer: A Prospective Multicenter Randomized Controlled
Trial (AcCliMaT),” by Lesi et al from the Unit of Medical Oncology Civil
Hospital. The study was published as an Epub Ahead of Print late last month and 
even featured a week ago in the ASCO Connection, which is the news outlet of the
American Society of Clinical Oncology, one of the largest oncology professional
societies in the world.

AcCliMaT is what we in the biz like to call a “pragmatic” trial. Those who have 
been regular readers of SBM know what “pragmatic” means in this context.
Basically, pragmatic trials are clinical trials designed to test how well an
intervention that has already been validated in rigorous randomized controlled
trials (RCTs) works in “real world” situations. The key assumptions behind a
pragmatic study design are that we already know that a treatment works and that 
we are examining how well it works outside the tightly controlled environment of
a clinical trial. Why do pragmatic trials? Simple. It’s because often in the
real world treatments don’t work as well as they do in RCTs due to many reasons,
including, for example, application of the treatment to patients who wouldn’t
have met the inclusion criteria of the RCT, less rigorous adherence to the
treatment protocol, and patient noncompliance.

Of course, doing a pragmatic trial is putting the cart before the horse for
treatments that have not been shown to work through rigorous RCTs, but that’s
exactly what AcCliMaT does. In fact, the rationale for AcCliMaT almost made me
spew the iced tea I was drinking as I wrote this all over my MacBook Pro’s
screen. Check out the interview with one of the study’s co-authors, Giorgia
Razzini, in ASCO Connection:

   According to study coauthor Giorgia Razzini, PhD, the strength of the study
   published in JCO is its rigorous and pragmatic design. Previous studies have 
   compared acupuncture for hot flashes to “sham” or non-optimal acupuncture,
   with the goal of controlling for the therapeutic response that might arise
   from patients receiving increased attention and a laying on of hands (i.e.,
   the placebo effect). However, this study compared acupuncture to the
   treatment women with breast cancer would actually receive in clinic, that is,
   self-care. To further strengthen the study’s design, the acupuncturists paid
   great attention to minimizing behaviors that could potentially contribute to
   a placebo effect.

   “The acupuncturists worked with a multidisciplinary team of oncologists and
   clinical trial managers to share their expertise and their knowledge and made
   an effort to standardize the acupuncture as much as possible to reduce the
   placebo factors present in many complementary medicines. In fact,
   acupuncturists delivered the intervention without talking to the patient, or 
   at least keeping the talking to a minimum. The study was conducted with
   extreme attention to trying to minimize the placebo effect,” said Dr.
   Razzini.

There’s so much wrong here and only so much verbiage even I can devote to it.
The key misconception at the root of this study is simple. Razzini seems to
assume that placebo effects derive only from patient interaction, the “laying on
of hands,” and the like. No doubt these are important contributors to placebo
effects, but it’s nonsense to think that placebo effects can be minimized so
much by not having the practitioners talk to the patients that a comparison of
an intervention + self-care to self-care alone wouldn’t still yield a positive
result. It will, and, not surprisingly at all, in this study it did. Basically, 
this study had no good control group and failed to control for placebo effects, 
given that everyone involved was unblinded and knew which group each subject was
in. It’s also unclear what, exactly, was done to minimize interaction. All it
says in the paper is this: “Conversation between acupuncturists and patients was
kept to a minimum to limit nonspecific treatment effects.”

So basically, this study was a randomized controlled trial of two interventions.
The first is “enhanced self-care”:

   To standardize usual care recommendations, we enhanced self-care by providing
   all patients with a detailed information booklet about climacteric syndrome 
   management. The booklet (Appendix, online only) was developed by the research
   team after a consensus process and included details about hot flashes and
   cancer and recommendations on diet, physical exercise, and eventual
   psychological support. The content of the booklet was explained to all
   patients before random assignment, and booklets were then distributed.
   Patients were asked to follow self-care recommendations for at least 12 weeks
   from random assignment.

So basically, the control group was given a booklet and told to follow its
recommendations. I wonder how well that usually works out. (Hint: Not very.)

The experimental group received enhanced self-care plus acupuncture:

   Within 2 weeks of random assignment, in addition to self-care
   recommendations, the acupuncture group was offered 10 traditional Chinese
   medicine (TCM) acupuncture sessions once per week for 12 weeks. The treatment
   protocol identifies six TCM menopausal syndromes according to Maciocia’s
   recommendations (Table 1).22 At the beginning of each acupuncture session, a 
   TCM evaluation of the tongue and radial pulses was performed to identify the 
   prevailing syndrome and consequently choose appropriate acupoints in addition
   to three common acupoints (ie, SP 6, LI 11, CV 4). Patients received
   20-minute acupuncture treatments based on the diagnosed TCM syndrome;
   moxibustion was provided as per TCM diagnosis. In some cases, supplementary
   points were punctured, but no more than 11 acupoints were used for each
   session. Sterile disposable 0.30 × 0.40 mm Huan Qiu needles (Suzhou Huanqiu
   Acupuncture Medical Appliance, Suzhou, People’s Republic of China) were
   inserted bilaterally to a depth of 0.5 to 1 cm in most areas, except the hip,
   where the depth was 1 to 2 cm. They were manually manipulated to elicit the 
   de qi sensation. No flicking or rotation of the needle took place once
   inserted. Participants with lymphoedema were not treated in the affected arm.
   No other complementary therapy was recommended during the course of
   acupuncture.

Here’s a hint. In any study of nothing (in essence) versus nothing plus an
intervention, the nothing plus intervention group will almost always come out on
top, because it’s not just the patient-practitioner interaction that is
responsible for placebo effects. It’s the intervention itself, the more
invasive, the more powerful the placebo effects. It’s not as though this isn’t
known and hasn’t been studied, including how more costly sugar pills induce
stronger placebo effects. It’s even known that sham surgery is the most powerful
placebo of all. This study was, whether intentional or inadvertently, designed 
to produce a positive response to acupuncture. It could hardly do otherwise.

And that’s what happened.

A total of 190 women with breast cancer were randomly assigned. Inclusion
criteria included, but were not limited to: diagnosis of breast cancer, age 18
to 65 years, intention to continue hormonal treatment at least through the
length of the study, mean number of six or more hot flashes and/or daily mean
score of 15 or greater on the Greene Climacteric Scale (GCS) during the week
before enrollment, and vasomotor syndromes for at least 6 weeks. Some exclusion 
criteria included: treatment of climacteric syndromes such as systemic
phytoestrogens, tibolone or analog, veralipride, or specific homoeopathic drugs 
and use of hormone replacement therapy and/or antidepressant drugs in the
previous month and no intention to discontinue. The primary outcome measure was 
the hot flash score at week 12 (end of treatment), which was calculated as the
frequency multiplied by the average severity of hot flashes. Secondary outcomes 
measured included climacteric symptoms and quality of life, measured by the
Greene Climacteric and Menopause Quality of Life scales. Outcomes were measured 
for up to 6 months after treatment.

The results, which are utterly unsurprising given the trial design, are
summarized in this graph:

The authors also found that women in the acupuncture plus enhanced self-care
group reported a higher quality of life in terms of vasomotor, physical, and
psychological symptoms, with most scores on the various measures being around
25%-30% improved compared to the control group.

Based on these utterly unsurprising results, the authors concluded:

   In conclusion, AcCliMaT—a multicenter pragmatic trial with a standardized TCM
   acupuncture protocol—confirmed that acupuncture is an effective and safe
   intervention for severe menopausal symptoms in women with breast cancer.
   Further research could help to identify which variables predict treatment
   response and the optimal duration of acupuncture. Because these findings seem
   both statistically and clinically meaningful, we hope the practice of
   treating vasomotor symptoms in women with breast cancer will change.

No, what this trial found is that the acupuncture group did better than the
control, but we have no way of knowing if this result was due to placebo effects
or not because there was no sham acupuncture control. Of course, the authors
know that their results don’t show that acupuncture works better than sham
acupuncture. They even admit it:

   We acknowledge that this design does not allow estimation of the size of the 
   effect resulting from needling itself or from other placebo-related factors, 
   such as patient−provider interaction. Attempts were made to balance and
   control the potential impact of the latter by providing both groups with a
   booklet about climacteric syndrome management options and ensuring that
   therapists in the acupuncture group limited the communication and time spent 
   with patients to the minimum needed for quality treatment. Notably, study
   participants did not differ in acupuncture response expectancy.

“Attempts were made…” Sure, utterly inadequate attempts. I could have saved the 
authors a whole lot of money and effort and predicted the results just by
reading the study protocol. Sadly, no one asked me. I will say right now,
though: Anyone thinking of designing a similar study, drop me an email or call. 
I’ll predict the results. And JCO editors: The next time you get a manuscript
describing a trial like this, consider me (or Steve Novella) as a reviewer. Your
peer reviewers dropped the ball big time on this one, as did your publicity
department for writing up a glowing article about this study.

The bait and switch continues

It’s not as though we didn’t already know that acupuncture doesn’t work for
menopausal symptoms, either. For instance, a systematic review published in JCO 
in 2013 found no benefit for acupuncture for any cancer-related symptom other
than chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting (CINV), all due to high risk of
bias (ROB) in the studies included and evaluated. (Personally, I find the
evidence that acupuncture helps with CINV unpersuasive, because it relied almost
entirely on one trial with a low ROB and mixed electroacupuncture and
acupuncture studies, but that’s a topic for another post.) Similarly, a Cochrane
review from 2013 (noted above in the discussion of the first paper) also found 
no benefit over placebo. Yet none of this stops acupuncture advocates from
believing that acupuncture works to alleviate menopausal hot flashes, be they
natural or breast cancer treatment-induced, or from doing more studies like the 
two I just discussed.

We at SBM, particularly Steve Novella and I, have discussed on multiple
occasions the ways that advocates try to make ineffective treatments seem
effective and how they spin negative results as being positive, particularly how
CAM advocates substitute low quality evidence for high quality evidence because
high quality evidence shows that their interventions don’t work. In these two
studies, we have a perfect representation of this. The Italian study, whose
design was decent for a pragmatic study but assumed what lawyers would call
facts not in evidence (i.e., that acupuncture works for hot flashes), produced a
seemingly “positive result.” However, it did not adequately control for placebo
effects. (An understatement!) When investigators do control for placebo effects
adequately, as the Australian investigators did, the results show that
acupuncture has no detectable specific effects greater than placebo. This is
often much to the disappointment and consternation of the investigators, as the 
contortions the Australian group went through in its Discussion section
illustrate rather amusingly.

Overall, there is no convincing evidence that acupuncture is anything but
elaborate, theatrical placebo. The Australian study is quite consistent with
this conclusion, and the Italian study provides no evidence to refute it. The
Australian investigators, their attempts to explain their negative results
notwithstanding, do deserve at least some praise for having followed the results
of their study where they led. In contrast, the editors at JCO and ASCO itself 
should be ashamed for having published and promoted this study.

PLOS ONE, peer review, and a “crappy” acupuncture study

Meta-analyses can sometimes suffer from the “GIGO problem” (garbage in, garbage 
out). The publication of a “crappy” acupuncture “network meta-analysis” for
acupuncture and chronic constipation illustrates the GIGO problem on steroids
and reveals a problem with peer review.

David Gorski on May 7, 2018

Link



We write about acupuncture a lot here on SBM because it’s the form of quackery
that is arguably the most “respectable” and accepted among academic medical
institution and “conventional” doctors. Indeed, a decade or more ago I used to
be (almost) among the doctors who thought that there might be something to
acupuncture. Obviously, I never believed in any of the mysticism underlying
acupuncture meridians and “unblocking” the flow of qi with needles. However,
because needles actually penetrate skin in acupuncture, I thought that maybe
there was a mechanism by which acupuncture could “do something” therapeutic. Of 
course, the more I read the medical literature and actual studies purporting to 
show a therapeutic effect due to acupuncture, the more I realized how poor the
evidence was and how the highest quality evidence out there showed that
acupuncture is basically nothing more than a theatrical placebo. Basically, it
doesn’t matter where you stick the needles or even if you stick the needles in. 
The effect is the same. Unfortunately, many journals are complicit in spreading 
pseudoscience.

Such were my thoughts as I was made aware by a reader of a new acupuncture
meta-analysis published late last month in PLOS ONE out of the Shenzhen Longhua 
District Central Hospital in China entitled “Comparison of acupuncture and other
drugs for chronic constipation: A network meta-analysis.” It is truly one of
the worst acupuncture meta-analyses that I’ve ever seen and reveals a real
problem with peer review at PLOS ONE.

A meta-analysis is a type of study that seeks to aggregate data from high
quality studies in order to come to a conclusion about an intervention or
therapy. When done rigorously and without bias, meta-analyses can be a very
useful method for assessing the state of the evidence with regard to a
particular treatment. However, meta-analyses are subject to the rule of GIGO
(garbage in, garbage out). Basically, aggregating a bunch of poor-quality
studies does not result in reliable conclusions.

This, however, is something I hadn’t encountered much before, mainly a network
meta-analysis. So I had to look it up:

   Systematic reviews use explicit, pre-specified methods to identify, appraise,
   and synthesize all available evidence related to a clinical question. When
   appropriate, systematic reviews may include a meta-analysis, that is, the
   statistical combination of results from two or more separate studies. Some
   systematic reviews compare only two interventions, in which a conventional
   pair-wise meta-analysis may be conducted, while others examine the
   comparative effectiveness of many or all available interventions for a given 
   condition. When the comparative effectiveness of a range of interventions is 
   of interest, appropriate statistical methodology must be used for analysis.

   Also called mixed treatments comparison or multiple treatments comparison
   meta-analysis, network meta-analysis expands the scope of a conventional
   pair-wise meta-analysis by analyzing simultaneously both direct comparisons
   of interventions within randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and indirect
   comparisons across trials based on a common comparator (e.g., placebo or some
   standard treatment) [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. In the simplest case, one may be
   interested in comparing two interventions A and C. Indirect evidence can be
   obtained from RCTs of either A or C versus a common comparator B (Figure 1), 
   keeping intact the randomized comparisons within the RCTs [1, 2, 3, 4, 5].
   When both direct and indirect evidence are available, the two sources of
   information can be combined as a weighted average when appropriate.

Right off the bat, network meta-analysis sounds very suspect as a methodology.
Certainly, if regular meta-analyses are subject to GIGO and cherry picking
studies, this sort of meta-analysis is even more so. In any case, the reason the
authors chose a network meta-analysis is obvious. There are no studies directly
comparing acupuncture to the various laxatives and drugs to which the authors
wish to compare them. I knew that the study would be bad right from the
introduction, where the authors opine:

   The methods of treating chronic constipation currently include drugs and
   acupuncture. Common drugs include lactulose, polyethylene glycol,
   linaclotide, lubiprostone, bisacodyl, prucalopride, tegaserod, etc. But most 
   of drugs have some side effects which couldn’t be tolerated by patients,
   complementary or alternative treating methods with less side effect [sic] are
   needed in our practice. An increasing number of studies have shown that
   acupuncture may have certain effects on chronic constipation. However, there 
   have been no studies comparing acupuncture and commonly used oral drugs. The 
   comparison between drugs and acupuncture will bring us a clear understanding 
   of those interventions. Furthermore, various acupoints have been targeted to 
   treat chronic constipation. Therefore, this study was designed to solve these
   unanswered questions.

   This study was a systematic review of the literature and collected data from 
   published randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of acupuncture and common oral 
   drugs in the treatment of chronic constipation up to December 2017. This
   study aimed to answer the following questions: (1) what are the curative
   effects and side effects of acupuncture and drugs to improve chronic
   constipation?; (2) what is the curative effect of sham acupuncture as a
   placebo?; and (3) what are the acupoints to cure constipation?

See what I mean? The authors state as a fact that acupuncture is a method of
treating chronic constipation. While that is true on a trivial level (obviously 
there are quacks out there treating constipation with acupuncture), the
implication behind the statement is that it is an accepted method of treatment. 
Also notice the false dichotomy: Drugs used to treat constipation are framed as 
having unacceptable side effects, while acupuncture is framed as somehow more
desirable. In any case, the authors searched PubMed, the Cochrane Library,
Embase and 4 Chinese databases [China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), 
Wanfang Database, VIP Database and Chinese Biomedical Database (CBM)] for
randomized clinical trials, using as their criteria:

  1. Clinical trials of adult patients

  2. Clinical trials of single drugs

  3. Clinical trials with treatment duration greater than two weeks

  4. Publications that were not comments or commentaries

  5. Studies that excluded pregnant or lactating women, patients with peptic
    ulcers, rectal disease, or liver or other systemic disease, and patients
    with previous history of gastroduodenal surgery, neurologic diseases or
    neurologic surgery

The authors identified a total of 1,516 articles were obtained from their
literature search, of which 36 duplicates were deleted and 1,438 articles were
excluded, leaving a total of 40 trials including 11,032 patients with chronic
constipation. The studies encompassed a total of 10 treatment modalities
including A: prucalopride; B: tegaserod; C: lubiprostone; D linaclotide E:
bisacodyl; F: PEG; G: lactulose; H: acupuncture; I: sham acupuncture; and J:
placebo (sucrose, etc.). So right there is a problem, namely that there are ten 
interventions and only forty studies. Given that there are 12 studies involving 
acupuncture (7 of acupuncture versus lactulose, 4 involving acupuncture versus
sham, and one comparing two different forms of acupuncture), for some
interventions, there are only two studies (range: 1-8). None of this stopped the
authors from paddling bravely up the river of bad science by comparing all the 
studies and comparing acupuncture with each of the other interventions and
concluding:

   By including more than 40 articles for network meta-analysis (NMA),
   acupuncture was found to be more effective than drugs in treating chronic
   constipation with nearly no side effects. The mechanism of action of
   acupuncture for the treatment of chronic constipation remains unclear, but
   previous studies have also shown its possible role in the treatment of
   chronic constipation. An important cause of chronic constipation is the
   decreased motility of the colon, resulting in a decreased urge to defecate,
   bloating, and abdominal pain or discomfort. [51] Existing studies indicate
   that acupuncture at heterotopic acupoints facilitates distal colonic motor
   ability by activating M3 receptors and somatic afferent C-fibres in normal,
   constipated, or diarrhoeic rats. Acupuncture can also increase distal colonic
   motility in normal and abnormal mice with a possible role of M3 receptors
   [52]. Previous studies have suggested that the ST36 acupoint can change the
   motor function of the colon. [53]

That’s right. The authors concluded that acupuncture was more effective than any
drug commonly used to treat chronic constipation and that it had “nearly no”
side effects. That’s rather convenient, given that only one of the acupuncture
studies included in the meta-analysis even bothered to report side effects.

That’s not all, either. There’s the way that the authors assessed effect size.
Basically, they measured and compared the proportion of patients “with
improvement in chronic constipation.” No measure is made of how much
constipation improved, whatever tool various investigators might have chosen to 
use to assess severity of constipation in each study. Think of it this way by
considering two hypothetical studies. One study shows that 50% of patients saw
their constipation improve based on one treatment, and those 50% averaged a 90% 
improvement. Now consider another study that shows that 50% of patients
improved, but by only an average of 20%. Those two studies would count the same 
because both report that 50% of their patients got better, but obviously they do
not show the same result. Obviously, you’d want the treatment with an average
improvement of 90% rather than 20%.

But that’s still not all. Let’s take a look at the Forest plot of the
conventional paired meta-analysis that the authors carried out before doing
their network thing:


Forest plot acupuncture and medications

The authors report that, compared with placebo (J), acupuncture significantly
improved the symptoms of chronic constipation, as did most of the other
interventions. Note also, though, that sham acupuncture also improved chronic
constipation symptoms with an odds ratio of 3.1 (95% confidence interval
1.5-7.2). Just look at the lower panel. That’s as good as many of the drugs.
There’s a red flag right there, as far as I’m concerned. There’s a reason for
this, as described by Ross Pomeroy:

   The vast majority of the laxative studies were double-blind, randomized,
   placebo-controlled trials published in peer reviewed journals. On the other
   hand, all of the acupuncture studies were unblinded, four were not
   peer-reviewed, five were published in questionable journals like the Shanghai
   Journal of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, and all were based in China, which
   is notoriously friendly to acupuncture and alternative medicine. Thus, it’s
   no surprise that acupuncture showed stronger results in those studies.

So basically what we have here is a perfect example of what acupuncturists do to
try to “prove” that their quackery works for a wide variety of conditions. It
is, however, a new wrinkle in bad acupuncture meta-analyses. Instead of just
GIGO, it compares garbage (the results of most acupuncture studies) with the
results of better quality studies (the studies of medications) in order to
conclude that the garbage is even better than medicine. Never mind that ten
different acupuncture points were used, that sham acupuncture “worked” almost as
well as acupuncture, and that, well, their study is the best meta-analysis so
far:

   However, a previous meta-analysis showed no significant curative benefits of 
   acupuncture compared with sham acupuncture in the treatment of chronic
   constipation. Only some studies from China have shown that acupuncture is
   superior to drugs. [54] A previous study from China showed that acupuncture
   and sham acupuncture had similar effects on functional constipation, but
   moxibustion was used with ST23 and ST27 acupoints in this study. Moreover,
   this study was based on a small sample size [55], and therefore, we are
   unable to ensure the accuracy of these findings. In addition, the curative
   effect of sham acupuncture remains to be confirmed.

   Our study was unique in that the included studies of acupuncture used the
   deep pricking method instead of the ordinary acupuncture method. The depth of
   the deep pricking method is deeper than that of ordinary acupuncture method.
   Further studies are needed to confirm whether the deep pricking method has a
   better curative effect on chronic constipation than ordinary acupuncture. In
   the present study, many studies conducted after 2012 were included and the
   studies using the same acupuncture points were included to ensure
   consistency. RCTs using consistent acupuncture points will yield more
   definitive results.

I note that the outcome evaluated in the meta-analysis mentioned above was the
change in the number of weekly spontaneous bowel movements.

This is the sort of thing acupuncturists do, though. Here’s another example, but
not a meta-analysis. Rather, it’s a recently published randomized controlled
acupuncture trial to treat chronic constipation that compares He acupuncture,
Shu‐mu acupuncture, He‐shu‐mu acupuncture, and orally administered mosapride.
Notice something? There’s no placebo control, no sham acupuncture control, and, 
you’ll notice if you read further, no blinding. Believe it or not, the mosapride
group functioned as the control group. Surprise! Surprise! All groups improved,
which is exactly what one would expect in such an unblinded trial. Basically,
this is as worthless a clinical study as I’ve ever seen, and
Neurogastroenterology & Motility should be ashamed for having published it.

Back to the meta-analysis, though. Not surprisingly, physicians and scientists
were puzzled at how PLOS ONE could publish dreck as bad as this and took
Twitter:

There’s bad studies, but this #acupuncture nonsense is on a whole other level,
shame on @PLOSONE https://t.co/L2u127tZwG by @RCScience (via @ACSHorg) cc
@CaulfieldTim @gorskon @McGillOSS @ScienceBasedMed

— Philippe Chouinard (@DrPChouinard) April 29, 2018

Steve Salzberg even resigned from the editorial board over this article:

I agree, this is appalling bad pseudoscience that never should have been
published. I just wrote to @PLOSONE and officially resigned from their Editorial
Board. https://t.co/9bbBQtvlY0

— Steven Salzberg (@StevenSalzberg1) April 29, 2018

PLOS ONE even responded:

Thank you very much for bringing these concerns to our attention. We are looking
into this matter and will also be in touch with you separately to discuss
further.

— PLOS ONE (@PLOSONE) April 30, 2018

We’ll see what happens. After all, as James Coyne has noted, it took PLOS ONE a 
long time to retract a more obviously dubious study:

Please to see @PLOSONE today retracted stealth #homeopathy article, but process 
should not have taken years, even if authors objected. https://t.co/WhJXU3X8rI
#retraction https://t.co/QlPxm75UhQ

— James C.Coyne (@CoyneoftheRealm) May 3, 2018

Here’s the retraction notice:

   Following publication of this article [1], concerns were raised about the
   scientific validity of the study as well as a potential competing interest
   that was not declared. The PLOS ONE Editors discussed the concerns with the
   authors and consulted external experts. In light of our editorial assessment 
   and advice received in the expert consultations, we are retracting this
   article due to concerns about the scientific validity of the research
   question, study design, and conclusions.

   Specifically, we are concerned about the overall design of the study, which
   aims to detect effects of a reagent diluted to such a degree that the
   solution is not expected to contain biochemically relevant levels of
   antibody. The consulted experts also raised concerns about the validity and
   rigor of the immunoassay system used in the study. The enzyme-linked
   immunosorbent assay (ELISA) used was adjusted to give barely detectable
   signals, which renders the assay particularly susceptible to interference. In
   light of these issues, we consider that the article does not present
   sufficient or reliable evidence to support the conclusions.

Stealth homeopathy paper indeed. I note that this paper was first published in
2014. PLOS ONE also notes undisclosed conflicts of interest.

Scientific and clinical studies of pseudoscience like acupuncture and homeopathy
pose a significant challenge to journals, including PLOS ONE. The number of
people who both know enough about the modalities being tested to evaluate them
and are not advocates of those modalities is small. This results in reliance on 
peer reviewers who are supporters or practitioners of the quackeries being
evaluated. Still, I have to wonder what went wrong at PLOS ONE in this
particular case. I can sort of see how the stealth homeopathy paper could fool a
peer reviewer not familiar with homeopathy, but I have a hard time seeing how
this network meta-analysis paper could pass muster. Whatever the case, PLOS
appears to have a problem, and acupuncture still doesn’t work—for constipation
or anything else.

Systematic Review claims acupuncture as effective as antidepressants: Part 1:
Checking the past literature

James Coyne on January 18, 2013

Link


A recent systematic review in PLOS One raised the question whether acupuncture
and other alternative therapies are as effective as antidepressants and
psychotherapy for depression. The authors concluded

   differences were not seen with psychotherapy compared to antidepressants,
   alternative therapies [and notably acupuncture] or active intervention
   controls

or put it differently,

   antidepressants alone and psychotherapy alone are not significantly different
   from alternative therapies or active controls.

There are clear messages here. To consumers: Why take antidepressants with their
long delay and uncertainty in showing any benefits–but immediate side effects
and potential risks–when a few sessions of acupuncture work just as well? To
promoters of acupuncture and alternative therapies: you can now cite an
authoritative review in the peer-reviewed PLOS One as scientific evidence that
your treatments is as effective as scary antidepressants and time-consuming
psychotherapy when you make appeals to consumers and to third-party payers.

The systematic review had five co-authors, of whom three have been involved in
previous meta-analyses of the efficacy of antidepressants. However, fourth
author Irving Kirsch will undoubtedly be the author most recognizable to
consumers and policymakers, largely because his relentless media campaign
claiming antidepressants are essentially worthless, no better than placebo. For 
instance, in an interview with CBS 60 Minutes Irving Kirsch: The difference
between the effect of a placebo and the effect of an antidepressant is minimal
for most people.

   Irving Kirsch: The difference between the effect of a placebo and the effect 
   of an antidepressant is minimal for most people.Lesley Stahl: So you’re
   saying if they took a sugar pill, they’d have the same effect?

   Irving Kirsch: They’d have almost as large an effect and whatever difference 
   there would be would be clinically insignificant.

The article opens up a new front in the antidepressant wars: Past claims,
notably from Irving Kirsch, were that that any advantage of antidepressants over
pill placebo was clinically trivial. Now he and his co-authors assert that
antidepressants have an advantage over placebo, but only are equivalent to
psychotherapy,or alternative treatments such as  exercise and acupuncture.

At first glance, this article proceeds methodically and consistently to its
conclusions. I’m sure that many consumers and journalists will be persuaded
unless they have strong preconceptions or an intimate familiarity with the
existing literature. However, when I gave the article repeated close reads and
checked citations against what was actually said in cited articles, I was struck
by the

  1. Inconsistencies with what is said in high quality available literature.

  2. Unorthodox use of meta-analysis and voodoo statistics.

  3. Idiosyncratic use of common terms that usually mean something else.

  4. Ideologically driven conclusions, i.e,  a persistent commitment to previously 
    strongly stated opinions in the face of contradictory evidence.

The article lacks transparency—i.e., the inclusion of basic details of what was 
done with what studies– and leaves readers either forced to accept the authors’ 
conclusions or to undertake themselves a labor-intensive independent search of
the literature without the benefit of sufficient clues from the article as to
where to look. Exploring these problems together, we can learn something about
the use of systematic reviews as propaganda and marketing tools. Journalists
covering the antidepressant war, please take note.

Yet,  I was also left with unsettling concerns about the vulnerability of the
PLOS journals in the editing and peer review of cleverly packaged poor science, 
and also the inability of the PLOS journals to give proper recognition to post
publication peer commentary and correction. Lapses in editing and peer review
happen all the time, even in high impact traditional journals, but the issue is 
how readily and prominently they can be corrected. I am an Academic Editor of
PLOS One and donate my time because I recognize the fallibility of
prepublication peer review and my commitment to post publication peer
commentary. I think, though, that this article highlights the need to fix some
key aspects of the PLOS journals’ current editorial policies so that proper
recognition can be given to post publication peer review in indexed, citable
commentary, not just in blogs or elsewhere– something that does not happen now.

Here’s how I will build my case in two blog posts that this article presents a
distorted view of antidepressants versus acupuncture for depression and that it 
makes unwarranted conclusions. In this first blog post, I will compare what is
said about what is known about antidepressants and acupuncture in this article
to what I found in key sources. In a second blog, I will examine the manner in
which this systematic review was conducted and reported, and the deviations from
best practices by which the authors reaching their foregone conclusions.  In
the second blog I will also draw upon points that I extracted from the
literature discussed in the first blog.

One of the many advantages of open access journals like PLOS One is that anyone 
in the world with Internet access can readily obtain copies of articles without 
charge. This allows bloggers to have to provide lots of details in order for
readers to evaluate independently their claims. I will capitalize on this in
encouraging readers to go directly now to the open access article and form their
own opinions. In the first of two blogs on this topic, I mainly summarize here 
how the authors frame the research questions in the introduction and discuss
their findings in their conclusion in terms of the fit with the existing
literature. But, please, don’t depend solely on what I say, when you can readily
look for yourself at the open access article and, if you’d like, follow up on
the citations there.

What the article says

The Introduction claims

   a number of recent articles have emphasized the inability of antidepressant
   medication to consistently demonstrate superiority to placebo pills.

As for psychotherapies for depression, they

   have also come under scrutiny for the inability to demonstrate substantial
   superiority to various treatment controls as opposed to waiting-list (no
   treatment) controls. Similarly, “alternative therapies such as acupuncture
   and exercise have shown promise of individual published studies…, [But] the
   profile is less impressive according to independent review such as Cochrane
   reviews… and those conducted by the National Institute of Health and Clinical
   Excellence.”

Where does this leave us?

   Given this level of ambiguity, it is unclear if pharmacological treatments
   are any better or worse and psychotherapies or psychotherapies are any better
   than non-traditional treatments such as exercise and acupuncture.

Thus, the groundwork is laid for the current systematic review.

The Discussion restates its context:

   Much has been made of the inability of antidepressants to demonstrate
   clinically significant superiority to placebo in antidepressant clinical
   trials.

Then, the key conclusion of the study

   Although antidepressants alone and psychotherapy alone did differ
   significantly from placebo controls, treatment-as-usual and waiting list
   controls, they did not different from alternative therapies such as exercise 
   and acupuncture or active treatment control procedures.

However

   Although combination therapy did not statistically separate from exercise and
   acupuncture in the blinded trials, these alternative therapies themselves
   were not statistically superior to placebo… This may be due to the small
   number of trials evaluating these.

And getting provocative,

   Our results indicate that in acute depression trials using blinded raters the
   combination of psychotherapy and antidepressants may provide a slight
   advantage whereas antidepressants alone and psychotherapy do not
   significantly different [sic] from alternative therapies such as exercise and
   acupuncture or active intervention controls such as bibliotherapy or sham
   acupuncture.

Consumers, journalists, and promoters of alternative therapies please take note 
that what conclusions come from a comprehensive review of the scientific
evidence.Comparison with the existing literature: Antidepressants

Let’s start with the phrase in the introduction “Inability of antidepressant
medication to consistently demonstrate superiority to placebo”? and its echo in 
the discussion, the “inability of antidepressants to demonstrate clinically
significant superiority to placebo in antidepressant clinical trials.”

The authors cite four sources, two of them by the authors of this PLOS One
article. The first source that is cited, “Evidence b(i)ased medicine – selective
reporting from studies sponsored by pharmaceutical industry…” was important in 
demonstrating publication bias in antidepressant studies submitted to the
Swedish drug regulatory authority, but it’s irrelevant to evaluating the
efficacy of antidepressants in clinical practice. The Swedish authority
evaluates whether antidepressants achieve a 50% reduction in scores on the
Hamilton Depression Rating Scale in four-to-eight week trials. In such short
trials, placebo effects are maximized and drug effects often have not yet
occurred, although side effects are occurring. So, this article really can’t be 
entered into evidence as to the inability of antidepressant medication to
demonstrate efficacy.

The second cited source, “Listening to Prozac but hearing placebo…” was
co-authored by Irving Kirsch. The most relevant and provocative claim in the
article is

   a confident estimate that the response to inert placebos is approximately 75%
   of the response to active antidepressants medication. Whether the remaining 
   25% of the drug response is a true pharmacological effect or enhance placebo 
   effect cannot yet be determined…

Citation of the article, as opposed to others, particularly a later high profile
article in PLOS Medicine by Kirsch is odd. I have blogged about the cited
article (1,2) elsewhere, and I will shamelessly draw on those blog posts in the 
following comments.

In one of my blog posts, I stated

   The article is quite dense and difficult to follow in its twists and turns in
   logic and sudden declarations of definitive conclusions. Kirsch and
   Saperstein claimed [their] interpretations were based on rather complicated
   meta-analyses, which were described in a way that it is unlikely that anyone 
   else could replicate them. Their examination of past reviews and computer
   searches had yielded 1500 publications, but only 20 were retained as meeting 
   inclusion criteria. What was important technically was that calculation of
   within-condition effect sizes was nonstandard, and involved calculating for
   measures of depression the mean posttreatment score minus the mean
   pretreatment score, divided by the pooled standard deviation.

The article was published in a soon-to-be defunct Internet journal, Prevention
and Treatment that was suffering from a lack of submissions. The action editor, 
psychologist Annette Stanton later conceded on the SSCPnet listserve that she
was over her head in selecting reviewers and making editorial decisions about
the article. The article was accompanied by scathing, but authoritative
commentaries. One of the commentaries was by psychiatrist Don Klein who resigned
as founding co-editor of Prevention and Treatment because of its editorial
policies. He did not mince words in describing the Kirsch article as relying on

   a miniscule group of unrepresentative, inconsistently and erroneously
   selected articles arbitrarily analyzed by an obscure, misleading effect size…
   The attempt to further segment the placebo response, by reference to
   psychotherapy trials incorporating waiting lists, is confounded by disparate 
   samples, despite Kirsch and Saperstein’s claim of similarity.

He concluded by labeling the article as representing a failure of peer review.

Psychologist Robyn Dawes’ brief critique of Kirsch’s article was almost as
scathing as Klein’s and zeroed in on an odd way of calculating effect sizes:

   “the simple posttreatment minus pretreatment difference in an outcome
   variable for treatment group over placebo group does not define either a
   treatment effect or a placebo effect, even for groups randomly constructed.
   Such differences must be compared with the difference obtained from a
   (randomly selected) no-treatment group in order to evaluate the effect of
   treatment or placebo… Effect involves a comparative judgment, not just a
   pre-post one. And even when a legitimate effect is found for placebo, it
   often (almost always?) makes little sense to talk of a proportion of a
   treatment effect has been accounted for by a placebo effect. The logic of
   Kirsch and Saperstein (1998) is the seriously flawed. Science (like art and
   life) is not that easy.”

Dawes didn’t let up

   the unusual—to use a kind word—nature of this analysis is best illustrated in
   the first sentence of the discussion section… “No-treatment effect sizes and
   effect sizes for the placebo response were calculated from different sets of
   studies.” There’s no such thing as a no treatment effect size.

Dawes ends with:

   If knowledge were as simply attained as implied by Kirsch and Saperstein’s
   article – by just defining effect sizes as a pre-post comparison—it would not
   even be necessary to randomize. We would know enormous amounts more than we 
   currently do. Unfortunately, we don’t.

In my next blog in which I get into the specifics of the acupuncture versus
antidepressant question, we will find it is subject to the same criticisms of
the earlier Kirsch study provided by Don Klein and Robyn Dawes. I haven’t been
able to find other examples in the literature except for studies by Kirsch in
which summary effect sizes are calculated separately for active treatments and
placebos and then compared. But will be finding more flaws than just that. But
back to the literature review….

The second article that is cited is by Fournier and colleagues and is available 
open access here. The article is notable in claiming

   The magnitude of benefit of antidepressant medication compared with placebo
   increases with severity of depression symptoms and may be minimal or
   nonexistent, on average, in patients with mild or moderate symptoms. For
   patients with very severe depression, the benefit of medications over placebo
   is substantial.

It ends with a complaint that in efforts to promote antidepressant treatment

   There is little mention of the fact that efficacy data often come from
   studies that exclude precisely those MDD patients who derive little specific 
   pharmacological benefit from taking medications.

The article has received considerable media attention, although a lot less than 
the work of Irving Kirsch. However, it is also been subject to withering
criticism. Among the most telling criticisms:

  1. The systematic search of the literature identified 2164 citations, of which
    281 were retrieved, but only six studies were included in the analysis
    because of the need for individual patient-level data.

  2. The analysis was restricted to only trials of two antidepressants, imipramine 
    and paroxetine. Imipramine is not a first-line antidepressant, and use of
    paroxetine is restricted because of concerns about side effects and a
    withdrawal syndrome, and discouragement of its use with pregnant and nursing
    women.

  3. Only a small proportion of the patients entered into these trials scored in
    the in the mild range of depression and so even the authors concede that
    results may not generalize to mild depression.

  4. The claim of “minimal or nonexistent” benefits for antidepressant was based on
    arbitrary criterion that to be otherwise, effect size of at least .5 had to
    be achieved.

Harriet Hall has already blogged about the effect sizes of antidepressants and
provided an excellent link to a discussion of effect size (ES), and so I won’t
reproduce her arguments here. However, I will point out that that the criterion 
of ES  > .5 originally came from Jacob Cohen’s proposed cut off for a large
effect size which he warned (page 567) was quite arbitrary and ran the risk of
being misunderstood. I asked psychiatrist Simon Gilbody, who has conducted key
meta-analyses of enhancements of care for depression what he thought about this 
criterion and he replied:

   “I never believe any study these days which finds an ES > 0.5. it usually
   means the science is wrong and we haven’t found the bias(es) just yet.”

The third of the four articles is co-authored by Erick Turner, a psychiatrist
and former FDA reviewer of antidepressant data submitted by Pharma.  The NEJM
article involved a meta-analysis of published and unpublished antidepressant
trials submitted to the FDA as part of the drug approval process.

According to analyses of data obtained from the FDA, only half of the trials
were positive, but according to the published journal articles, almost all of
the trials were positive. In almost a dozen cases, trials that were negative or 
questionable according to the FDA were published as if they were positive. Once 
unpublished reports were taken into account, the overall effect size (ES) for
antidepressants relative to placebo lowered from 0.41 to 0.31, where ES is the
standardized mean difference in improvement. However, in all cases,
antidepressants were significantly superior to pill placebos. So, Turner and
colleagues found that antidepressants were not they are cracked up to be, but
they did not dismiss them as ineffective. As Turner was later quoted, “the glass
is far from full but far from empty.”

The fourth source cited in opening statements of the antidepressant/acupuncture 
meta-analysis is by two of its authors, Khan and Brown. It involves a study of
the severity of depression in response to antidepressants using the FDA
administrative database. It concludes that severity of initial symptoms affects 
clinical trial outcomes. While doesn’t seem to present an overall effect size
for antidepressants versus placebo, it notes that 48% of clinical trial showed
the superiority of investigational antidepressants over placebo, and 64% of the 
clinical trial showed superiority for established antidepressants relative to
pill placebo.

It’s noteworthy which meta-analyses by the authors of the
antidepressant/acupuncture meta-analysis were not acknowledged in that article. 
A PLOS Medicine meta-analysis by Kirsch is among the most highly cited articles 
in that journal and has been widely discussed in the media. However, its claim
that the relative advantage of antidepressants versus placebo are minimal and
insignificant would seem to contradict the claims in the present
antidepressant/acupuncture article that the effects of antidepressants are
significantly superior to pill placebo, although no better than acupuncture.
Furthermore, a 2005 study by two of the co-authors of the
antidepressant/acupuncture meta-analysis involved 329 depressed patients from
their antidepressant clinical trials center who had been entered in 15
multicenter trials. Effect sizes were .51 in the low/moderate group, .54 in the 
high/moderate group, .77 in the moderately severe group, and 1.09 in the severe 
group. Effect sizes obtained in multisite trials are known to vary across
specific sites, but these relatively strong effects would seem to undermine
claims that antidepressants are no better than placebo or no better than
acupuncture.

In sum, this seems to be a marked difference in the portrayal in the
antidepressant/acupuncture article of the past literature concerning
antidepressants versus placebo, and even between the past work of the authors of
this article and what they say here. A commentary co-authored by Erick Turner
in the British Medical Journal on the discrepancy between Kirsch and his
interpretation of similar results aptly notes “we agree that the antidepressant 
‘glass’ is far from full, we disagree that it is completely empty.

Acupuncture

The PLOS article comparing acupuncture and antidepressants states

   “Alternative therapies such as acupuncture and exercise have shown promise…
   [But] the profiles are less impressive according to independent reviews”.

Let’s see how much less impressive. An updated Cochrane review (2010) found
insufficient evidence to recommend acupuncture for depression, and insufficient 
evidence of a consistent beneficial effect from acupuncture compared to wait
list or sham acupuncture control. There were obvious difficulties that could not
be readily overcome in the blinding of providers and patients as to whether a
medication or acupuncture were received. There was further a high risk of bias
across studies. Overall, the study of acupuncture for depression was
characterized by a lack of consistently rigorous scientific study and poor
reporting. There was unexplained heterogeneity, i.e., inconsistency of results
across studies they could not readily be interpreted. Most of the studies were
from China, including all of the antidepressant/acupuncture comparisons, with
participants largely recruited from inpatient populations. Very few of the
American RCTs comparing antidepressants to pill placebo entered into
meta-analyses involved in patient samples.

A more recent systematic review of systematic reviews of acupuncture for
depression found that all of the positive reviews and most of the positive
primary studies originated from China and that there was reason to believe that 
the reviews were less than reliable. The authors concluded that acupuncture was 
essentially unproven as a treatment for depression.

A systematic review and meta-analysis of Chinese randomized trials concerning
the antidepressant venlafaxine concluded that all trials were of low quality and
underpowered.

Yet another systematic review revealed an astonishing publication bias to
randomized trials of acupuncture more generally: no trial published in China, or
for that matter Russia/USSR had found an acupuncture treatment to be
ineffective relative to a comparison treatment.

An interview study with the authors of 2235 apparently randomized trials
published in the approximately 1100 medical journals help published in China
found that less than 10% adhered to accept a methodology for randomization and
only 6.8% could be deemed authentic randomized controlled trials.

To say the least, these reviews suggest the need for caution in accepting data
from China and in synthesizing and comparing data from RCTs conducted in China
with those conducted in the West without some consideration of quality of the
trial and risk of bias. Given the quality of the literature, we are not even in 
a position to evaluate acupuncture for depression, much less make statements
about its efficacy relative to antidepressants or placebo.

In summary, I don’t think that someone would anticipate what is said in the
existing literature from how it is portrayed in the acupuncture/antidepressant
meta-analysis. Furthermore, we can anticipate some formidable challenges to
integrating data from antidepressant versus pill placebo trials with acupuncture
trials and acupuncture-compared-to-antidepressants. There appear to be few
head-to-head comparisons and a lack of comparability of the control conditions
in acupuncture versus antidepressant trials. Both patients and providers are
well aware of treatment assignment in ways that cannot be blinded and so the
repeated references in the antidepressant/ acupuncture article to controlling
for blinding stands out as odd. Finally, there is good reason to doubt the
quality and credibility of acupuncture studies conducted in China, where most
studies are conducted. In my next blog post, we will see how these problems were
addressed or ignored.

Is acupuncture as effective as antidepressants? Part 2. Blinding readers who try
to get an answer

James Coyne on January 27, 2013

Link


This is the second blog post about a recent PLOS One review claiming that
alternative therapies such as acupuncture are as effective as antidepressants
and psychotherapy for depression. The article gives a message to depressed
consumers that they should consider alternative therapies as a treatment option 
because they are just as effective as conventional treatments. It gives
promoters of alternative therapies a boost with apparent evidence from a
peer-reviewed journal that can be used to advertise their treatment and to
persuade third-party payers that alternative treatments are just as effective as
antidepressants and should be reimbursed.

In my first post, I could not reconcile what was said in this article with the
citations that it provided. The authors also failed to cite some of their own
recent work where it would have been embarrassing to arguments they made in the 
review. Most importantly, other meta-analyses and systematic reviews had raised 
such serious concerns about the quality of the acupuncture literature that they 
concluded that any evaluation of its effectiveness for depression would be
premature

I will show in this blog post that the review article is misleading junk
science, but that it also demonstrates the need for PLOS journals to publish
citable critiques when they inevitably have let bad articles be published.
Editorial oversight and prepublication review can never be perfect, but lapses
in quality should be correctable in citable articles with the same status as the
work they are correcting. Readers who find junk science in PLOS should not be
left with the only options of blogging or commenting in a thread that requires
handsearching to find, as they are now.

I will be criticizing the review for not providing readers with a means of
independently evaluating what was being claimed, the idiosyncratic use of common
terms that typically mean something else in other contexts, the unorthodox
analyses integrating data across studies with voodoo statistics, and the
ideologically driven conclusions.  Having read and re-read the article numerous 
times, I can find no better critique that what Don Klein said of an earlier
article by one of the review article’s authors, Irving Kirsch:

   a miniscule group of unrepresentative, inconsistently and erroneously
   selected articles arbitrarily analyzed by an obscure, misleading effect size

The article lacks transparency in not providing the basic background and data
that one needs to interpret a systematic review and should expect to find there.
Quantitative data for statements in the abstract and discussion sections are
largely missing from the results section, except for what is presented in a bar 
graph claiming to make comparisons among 10 possible treatment and control
conditions. But just try to figure out from the article which studies of what
treatments went into constructing the bars.



Trust our authority, we did a systematic review.

Playing sleuth with obscure and misleading clues

I thought I knew was meant by “alternative treatments” because the introduction 
stated simply “alternative treatments such as acupuncture and exercise” and the 
method section said “we conducted a similar search for controlled trials of
alternative therapies (exercise and acupuncture) for depression.” I couldn’t
find any further formal definition of alternative treatments for the rest of the
article.

However, when I accessed appendix S2 (I wonder how many readers actually go to
the trouble of doing this), I found that the alternative therapies evaluated in 
combination with antidepressants for the “combination therapy” bar in the graph 
included sham acupuncture (1 study),  verum acupuncture (1), brief dynamic
therapy (1), nurse led problem-solving (1), social skills training (1),
relaxation training (2), and one cognitive behavioral session plus task
assignment (1). This appendix also noted that the treatments that went into the 
bar graph as “alternative therapies” were aerobic training (3), autogenic
training (1), exercise (8), running (2), acupuncture (3), and laser acupuncture 
(1). Active intervention control groups included acupuncture control (3) bright 
light therapy (1), inactive laser acupuncture [what’s that?] (1), low intensity 
stretching (1) massage therapy (1), relaxation training (2), and weightlifting
(1). These were further lumped together with 16 other conditions including
bibliotherapy, counseling, client centered therapy, parenting education, brief
cognitive therapy, and marital therapy in order to form the “active intervention
controls” group summarized in the another bar in the graph.

Some of this mixed bag of “active intervention control groups” are evidence
supported therapies for depression, others are evidence supported, but not for
depression, and others are simply untested or unproven treatments lacking a
scientific rationale. But they are all simply lumped together in a single
summary statistic.

The text of the article gave no citations for which study provided what
treatment, so I went to Appendix S1 where all of the 115 treatment trials
included in the analysis were listed (Again, who would bother to do this?
Figuring out what-is-being-said-about-what should not be so difficult.) I could 
not consistently tell simply from the titles which articles evaluated which of
these treatments or provided which control group or when acupuncture was being
considered an active treatment or an active control.

There were only five acupuncture studies listed and so I looked them up. Three
were from a single American research group, two from China. All were
methodologically flawed, underpowered studies explicitly labeled as preliminary 
or exploratory. Only one involved antidepressants and only combined with
acupuncture. None involved a test of acupuncture against psychotherapy. With no 
head to head comparisons provided by these studies, I do not understand why
these authors did not give up and simply declare that there was insufficient
quality literature for a comparison of acupuncture versus antidepressants or
psychotherapy. Instead, the authors continued undeterred with their integration 
and meta analysis. I guess that they had a conclusion to get to.

The legend for the bar graph indicates the results for unblinded treatments are 
in red and blinded treatments are in blue. Try to figure out what is meant by
“blinded,” because it is probably not what you came to the article expecting.
Investigators evaluating psychotherapy are faced with the problem that their
raters of outcomes might be biased if they knew which treatment patients had
been receiving. Trials are commonly considered blinded if the raters do not know
what treatment patients got, or if evaluations of outcome came directly from
patients. There is evidence that patient self-report is actually a conservative 
means of evaluating interventions for depression, relative to interviewer
ratings.

In contrast, this review considered ratings coming directly from patients as
unblinded, i.e., inferior, and lumped self-report with results obtained in
studies where raters who knew to which treatments patients they were assigned.
There is no way of unpacking the studies considered unblinded because of patient
self-reported outcomes versus those considered unblinded by the usual
definition. So there is no way of comparing the results of this review with the 
existing literature. Readers relying on their familiarity with the psychotherapy
literature to interpret these results will be misled.

A meta-analysis by any other name….

The article had already gotten off to a bad start with the title and abstract
identifying it as a systematic review, but not labeling it as a meta-analysis. I
had a lively debate with colleagues about whether this article can even be
considered a meta-analysis. We all agreed that it violates basic rules in
conducting and reporting a meta-analysis and would yield unreliable results.

My opinion is that the systematic review is a meta-analysis because it involves 
integrating and analyzing  results from different clinical trials (therefore,
meta-analyzing). There are established ways for systematically amassing and
integrating data from clinical trials and well-known problems when alternative
methods are used. Authors should not escape from these standards by simply
failing to call their work a meta-analysis. The authors of the present
“systematic review” should know better, because three of them have published
peer-reviewed meta-analysis.

Meta-analyses are supposed to be the new gold standard for evaluating evidence
from clinical trials. Best evidence was once the blinded randomized controlled
trial, but such trials are often methodologically flawed and inconsistent in the
results, and the failure of positive results to replicate is notorious.
Meta-analysis supposedly holds the promise of being able to integrate data from 
across trials in ways that overcome the flaws of individual trials and resolves 
the apparent contradictions in their results.

But investigators conducting meta-analysis are often arbitrary in deciding what 
trials are included, how differences in their individual quality are taken into 
account, and how the various trials are lumped or split in integrating a set of 
trials and arriving at an overall interpretation. The ability of readers to
determine exactly what was done and to evaluate for themselves whether
conclusions are appropriate depends on authors adhering to standards with at
least a minimal level of transparency. Authors must give readers enough
information to decide for themselves. In the case of this article, Caveat
Lector, unless you are willing to simply accept the authors’ sometimes
outrageous claims, you going to have to either simply dismiss them or take the
time to do your own literature search without much help from what is presented
in this article.

A standard for evaluating meta-analyses and systematic reviews

The ‘Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews’ (AMSTAR) is a brief validated
checklist for evaluating meta-analyses and systematic reviews, and can be
accessed here. Following the numbering of the AMSTAR items, the article is
flawed in in the following ways if:

3. Was a comprehensive literature search performed? The article claims there was
a comprehensive search of the literature and even provides a flow chart of
searches. But I could not map the flow of searches into the small number of
articles ultimately included in the analyses, as seen in numbers in Appendix S2.
And things were otherwise confused and confusing. The citations included in the
text for the first search column indicates that the search largely overlapped
with the searched indicated in the second column. Different search strategies
were used for exercise and acupuncture than for psychotherapy. The authors
started only with a Cochrane Collaboration review of exercise for depression and
a Cochrane Collaboration review of acupuncture for depression, ignoring other
meta-analysis of these treatments. In contrast, the author searched the
literature for meta-analyses of psychotherapy and drew on them for studies to be
included in their review.

5. There was no list of excluded studies. Readers are thus not in a position to 
evaluate whether the exclusion was appropriate and therefore whether the
meta-analysis is balanced or biased. Obviously, lots of studies were excluded,
but we are given no reason why. For instance, the flow chart says the authors
started with an updated Cochrane Collaboration review of acupuncture and
depression. I checked and found that Cochrane Collaboration review identified 41
trials and retained 30 for meta-analysis. Are we to believe that in only
retaining five acupuncture studies , these authors of this review were wiser and
had stricter standards than the Cochrane group? Maybe, but that should require 
some explaining.

Usually, peer reviewers insist on a table of excluded studies, and with an open 
access, internet journal, there is no worry about page limitations restricting
what can be provided to readers.

6. Basic characteristics of the included studies were not provided. These data
are critical for a reader to be able to evaluate the appropriateness of
inclusion, as well as getting a clinical sense of the appropriateness of lumping
or splitting studies for analyses. Again, why didn’t the PLOS One editor or
peer reviewers insist on this?

7. There was no assessment of the scientific quality of the included studies.
The authors note that some of the results included in the meta-analyses were
limited to patients who completed the trial (but they do not say which or how
many), while other studies were intention-to-treat analyses, i.e., all patients 
who were randomized included, regardless of whether they were full exposure to
the treatment.

Consider this: it is meaningful information that substantial numbers of patients
assigned to a treatment are not around to be assessed at the end of treatment. 
Not being available for follow up assessment is seldom random, and often occurs 
because of dissatisfaction with the treatment received. The purpose of a
randomized trial is thus defeated if only data from completers are analyzed.
Intention to treat analyses are the gold standard and we could expect that
trials that did not rely on them were biased, and perhaps by other
methodological flaws.

The scientific quality of included studies varied, depending on whether they
were evaluations of alternative treatments like acupuncture versus
antidepressants or psychotherapy. I already noted the poor quality of the
acupuncture studies, as the Cochrane Collaboration and others have done. In
contrast, the FDA Registry of antidepressant trials has rather strict
methodological requirements, and so these trials should be of better quality,
particularly after unpublished trials were accessed, as these authors did. To
investigate the issue of systematic variability in the quality of trials being
considered, I took another quick look at the titles of psychotherapy studies
listed in Appendix S2.

Some appeared not even to be the main reports of a clinical trial, but post hoc 
secondary analyses. A number of the titles indicated that the studies were
preliminary, exploratory, or pilot studies. Anyone familiar with the
psychotherapy literature knows the authors often so label their studies after
the fact, especially when something has gone wrong so they were unable to
complete the study as planned or when they want to pass off statistically
improbable positive findings from an underpowered study as valid. So, we need to
keep in mind that type of intervention being evaluated is probably confounded
with quality and bias in ways we really can’t readily disentangle.

8. The article’s provocatively stated conclusions did not take into account the 
scientific quality of research that was reviewed. It’s appropriate to qualify
conclusions of systematic reviews and meta-analyses with acknowledgment of the
limitations to the quantity and quality of available studies. For instance, it’s
common for Cochrane reviews to declare that the quality of studies is
insufficient to decide if an intervention is effective, as was the case in the
updated Cochrane review from acupuncture. In contrast, authors of this review
boldly and confidently stated conclusions when there are ample reasons to be
skeptical and even to avoid yet making any conclusions.

9. Combining the findings of studies was patently inappropriate and there was no
test of whether it should have been done. There was no quantitative evaluation 
of whether it was statistically appropriate to combine studies (statistical
heterogeneity) nor consideration of whether the specific lumping of studies and 
conditions made sense clinically (clinical heterogeneity). As we saw, lots of
questions could be raised about the lumping and splitting, particularly in the
creation of the group of active intervention control conditions, which don’t at 
all seem to belong together.

10. There was no conventional assessment of publication bias, yet based on the
past systematic reviews I covered in my last post, there was good reason to
suspect rampant publication bias.

Combining results from different clinical trials

The authors’ strategy for abstracting results from different trials was flawed, 
produced biased results, and, like other aspects of this article, should have
been caught by the PLOS editor and reviewers.

The standard way of summarizing results from trials is to calculate pre-post
differences for the contrasting groups, take the difference in change between
the groups, and standardize it.  So, we calculate how much patients in the
intervention group changed, how much patients in the control group changed, the 
difference between the two groups, and then standardize this so that results
have the same metric and can be combined with results of other trials.

Think of it: We might expect the results for interventions to vary with the
trial in which they were evaluated, depending on how depressed the sample of
patients were that was being studied and whether results for all patients who
had been randomized were analyzed. We also should expect differences in the
performance of antidepressants whether the drugs are administered in a trial
advertised as recruiting patients for a comparison of antidepressants versus
psychotherapy versus a trial advertised as comparing antidepressants versus
acupuncture. Patient characteristics including their preferences and
expectations matter. These are just some of many contextual factors that might
influence the differences in effects that are found.

Thus, treatments do not have effect sizes, only comparisons of treatments do,
and analyses have to take into account that the differences that occur are
nested within trials and vary across trials. And the assumption that a set of
trials are sufficiently similar in their results to be combined can be examined 
with statistical tests of heterogeneity—whether results of studies taken to be
similar are sufficiently homogeneous or, if they are too
different—heterogeneous–what the source of this heterogeneity  might be. The
conclusion of many meta analysis is that results observed in a set of trials are
too variable for the results to be meaningfully integrated.

So, if authors intend to lump under the heading “combination treatment,”
antidepressants plus acupuncture, antidepressants plus nurse delivered
problem-solving, and antidepressants plus relaxation training,  they are
assuming that these are all equally representative of alternative treatment and 
results from them being added together generalize back to the individual
treatments. In conventional meta analysis, whether this is reasonable can be
tested, but it was not in this review.

What the authors did was radically different, simple, but nonsensical. They
calculated standardized pre-post differences for each intervention separately
and then averaged them into the numbers for the groups represented in the bar
graph. They thus compared summary effects of particular broad groups of
treatment to each other and to various lumpings of control conditions. I have
never seen  this done except in other meta-analyses conducted by one of the
authors, Irving Kirsch, and he routinely gets roundly criticized for his
idiosyncratic method. Critics have noted that this method produces different
results than the conventional method applied to the same data.

The authors’ method of calculating the effects of treatments ripped the
treatments from the context in clinical trials and ignored all differences among
those trials. They considered the treatments going into a group as if they were
equivalent, and then made comparisons with other treatments and control groups.
If the authors approach were valid, we would not even need to conduct
randomized clinical trials. Rather all we would have to do is simply recruit
groups of patients, expose them to treatments, and collect and compile the
results.

The authors also ignored whether the comparisons they were making were
head-to-head, i.e, actually occurred in the clinical trials, or were indirect,
artificially constructed by comparing the results for  treatments from very
different trials. There is ample evidence that head-to-head comparisons are more
valid.

In summary, the authors conclude that antidepressants and psychotherapy were not
significantly more effective than alternative therapies such as acupuncture and
exercise or even active control conditions. They arrived at this conclusion
having only one flawed preliminary study from China comparing acupuncture to
antidepressants and no comparisons between acupuncture and psychotherapy. They
arrived at this conclusion when other meta-analyses were concluded that the poor
quality of the existing acupuncture literature for depression did not allow any
statements about its efficacy and when other meta-analyses of exercise for
depression were concluding that it had at best short-term effects. A recent
large-scale study failed to find effects of exercise for depression.

[I think an evidence-based case could be made for exercise as the first step in 
a stepped care approach to mildly and moderately depressed persons, or maybe the
first step in a stepped diagnosis of persons who are having mood problems. If
they recover and their improved mood continues, then a diagnosis of major
depression and more intensive care are not appropriate. But the authors of this 
review are not interested such subtleties.]

They are quite impressed with their conclusions and state even more boldly

   Our results also suggest the interpretation of clinical research evaluating
   relative efficacy of depression treatments using the randomized, double-blind
   paradigm is problematic. With the exception of waiting-list control and
   treatment-as-usual, it is difficult to differentiate active treatments from
   “treatment controls” in adequately designed and highly blinded trials.

Nonsense. I think that what they’ve really shown is that if one adopts
idiosyncratic approaches to selecting trials and summarizing the data derived
from them, one can arrive at conclusions that are quite different from more
conventional syntheses of clinical trial data.

Postscript

At about the same time that this article was being accepted at PLOS One, one of 
its authors, Irving Kirsch was hyping in his CBS 60 Minutes News interview his
conclusions from an article he had previously published in PLOS Medicine. His
message was that any differences between antidepressants and pill placebo were
clinically trivial. Even though the PLOS Medicine paper is among the most
accessed and cited of any PLOS Medicine articles to date, the systematic review 
did not cite it, perhaps because of the apparent contradiction that its
conclusion and the one being made in the review that antidepressants are better 
than pill placebo, but no better than acupuncture or exercise.

In either case, there is junk science and misleading mischief being perpetrated 
with the credibility of publishing in a PLOS journal attached. Kirsch’s PLOS
Medicine article received lots of scathing commentary in that journal, but these
are not citable nor directly accessible with electronic bibliographic databases
such as ISI Web of Science or PubMed. Readers must have the persistence to get 
past the misleading abstract posted at these resources, go back to the actual
article in the PLOS journal, and scroll down through the many comments. A number
of frustrated commentators ultimately, and often much later, published extended
critiques elsewhere. But readers should be able to find critiques going
directly to PLOS.  I think the readers of PLOS journals deserve active
post-publication debate in these journals that is citable and accessible through
electronic bibliographic sources. If misleading abstracts of PLOS articles
appear in those electronic resources, and they inevitably will, abstracts of
critiques ought to appear there also. Let readers decide which side to believe.

It’s time for PLOS journals to stop allowing themselves to be used for
dissemination of junk science and propaganda without the opportunities for
debate and correction. The reputation of PLOS journals is at stake.

        Acupuncture for Chronic Prostatitis/Chronic Pelvic Pain Syndrome

                                  Harriet Hall

                                      LInk

Chronic prostatitis/chronic pelvic pain syndrome (CP/CPPS) is a somewhat
nebulous diagnosis with unknown etiology and no effective treatment. To make the
diagnosis, bacterial infection must be excluded and the symptoms must last at
least 3 months. Symptoms include pain in various locations (between rectum and
testicle, in the testicles, at the tip of the penis, in the lower back, in the
abdomen over the pubic or bladder area), pain or burning with urination,
frequent urination, pain or discomfort during or after sexual climax. There are 
also systemic features like decreased libido, myalgias, and fatigue, and there
is a higher incidence of chronic fatigue syndrome in these patients. The
connection to the prostate is uncertain; in one study, women with chronic pelvic
pain reported more of these symptoms than men did. Diagnosis is based on
self-reported symptoms; there are no objective diagnostic markers. Somewhere
between 2 and 10% of the male population are reported to suffer from this
syndrome.

Since there is no effective mainstream treatment for this disorder, why not try 
acupuncture? Two randomized, placebo-controlled studies have reported positive
results from acupuncture treatment. Is this enough evidence for us to recommend 
it to patients?

The Malaysian Study

This well-designed study was done in Malaysia, in a hospital with traditionally 
trained acupuncturists on its staff, in conjunction with the University of
Washington Department of Urological Surgery. It was funded by the NIH and
published in the American Journal of Medicine. There were 90 subjects randomized
into two groups. They compared acupuncture at traditional points to sham
acupuncture with more superficial needling 15 mm to the left of traditional
points. They used no adjunctive treatments. They minimized interaction between
participants and acupuncturists. They looked for a primary endpoint of a 6 point
decrease from baseline to week 10 in a validated scale of symptoms, the NIH
Chronic Prostatitis Symptom Index (NIH-CPSI), and for secondary outcomes
including complete resolution and decreased scores at other intervals. They
treated twice weekly for 30 minutes for 10 weeks, then followed the patients for
an additional 24 weeks. They tested blinding by asking participants which
therapy they thought they had received: 95% of those receiving acupuncture and
82% of those receiving the sham treatment thought they had received acupuncture.
They found that acupuncture was twice as effective as sham acupuncture for the 
primary endpoint (73% vs. 48%, p=0.02) at 10 weeks, that more acupuncture
patients had complete resolution of symptoms (18 vs. 10, p=0.07), and that
acupuncture recipients had a greater long-term response 20 weeks after
completing therapy (32% vs. 13%, p=0.04).

The Korean Study

The other study was done in Korea and was published in the journal Urology. It
was a three-arm study comparing advice and exercise (A & E) alone to A&E plus
electroacupuncture (where the acupuncture needles were electrically stimulated) 
to A&E plus sham acupuncture. There were only 13 men in each group. The sham
acupuncture involved (1) more superficial needling, (2) placement 15 mm to the
left of acupuncture points, and (3) the sound of the pulse generator without
actual electrical stimulation. In the acupuncture group they found a significant
reduction in the NIH-CPSI scores for pain, but no reduction in the scores for
urinary symptoms or quality of life. On another scale, the International
Prostate Symptoms Score, there were no significant differences. There is no
mention of an exit poll to see if patients could guess which treatment they had 
received.

This study had one other intriguing wrinkle. There had been some hints of a
correlation between prostatitis symptoms and prostaglandin E and beta endorphin 
levels, so they measured these in post-massage urine samples. They found a
significant decrease in prostaglandin level in the electroacupuncture group
(p=0.023) and a non-significant increase in the other two groups. They present a
bar graph that makes it look like the increase in the sham group was more
significant than the decrease in the electroacupuncture group, but they don’t
provide the raw data or even report calculated p values, so we can only guess
what the bars mean.

EA pain

There was no significant change in endorphins for any group. It’s intriguing
that they were able to measure something objective, but at this point, without
replication, it’s impossible to say what the data mean, if anything.

Other Studies

A PubMed search for “clinical trials, chronic prostatitis and acupuncture”
brought up these two studies and only 5 others that were a mish-mash of
different kinds of prostatitis and different treatments: warm needle
moxibustion, suspended moxibustion (where a burning stick is held above the
acupuncture point with no skin contact), abdominal cluster needling, sometimes
in association with herbal enemas and other treatments. A meta-analysis of
case-control studies out of China found a significantly higher cure rate with
acupuncture than with controls, but they were looking at studies of a different 
diagnosis: chronic prostatitis, not chronic prostatitis/chronic pelvic pain
syndrome. And none of the studies were randomized controlled trials.

Additionally, the Korean study referenced another study that did not come up on 
my PubMed search for some reason. This study of CP/CPPS involved three sets of
acupuncture points totaling 30 points (8 points were electrically stimulated)
given alternatively twice weekly for 6 weeks. It showed an even more impressive 
effect: 83% of subjects reported marked improvement, but it was an uncontrolled 
pilot study with only 12 subjects.

So we don’t have a lot of evidence, but the evidence we do have consistently
supports acupuncture for CP/CPPS. Acupuncturists can say their treatments are
evidence-based.

Discussion

As you may have guessed, I have some reservations. In the first place, what do
they mean by acupuncture? The Malaysian study used 4 acupuncture points: CV1,
CV4, SP6 and SP9. The Korean study used acupuncture points BL 32, Bl33, GB30
bilaterally, for a total of 6 entirely different points. The Malaysian study
used only needle insertion; the Korean study used electrical stimulation. The
pilot study used 30 points with electrical stimulation of 8 of them. If you were
going to do acupuncture based on these studies, which points would you choose?

Studies can’t really support each other if they’re not testing the same
treatment, can they? In addition, even the Malaysian study was not a test of
acupuncture per se. The “true” acupuncture arm did not even attempt to elicit
the “de qi” sensation that many acupuncturists consider essential to the
acupuncture effect. They followed a rigid protocol rather than offering the kind
of individual treatment adjustments acupuncturists typically use in practice.
And they did not twirl or stimulate the needles in any way after insertion. If
their results had been negative, they might well have argued that their study
didn’t discredit acupuncture because it didn’t represent the practice of
acupuncture at all.

More importantly, we need to look at these studies in the context of everything 
else we know. Good studies with better controls (retracting needles) have shown 
no difference between acupuncture points and non-points. Other studies with
toothpicks and with simple electrical transcutaneous stimulation have shown that
it doesn’t matter whether the skin is penetrated. So many studies have shown
sham acupuncture to be equal to “true” acupuncture that in several recent
studies acupuncturists themselves have chosen not to use a sham acupuncture
control on the theory that it is not a placebo control because any skin
stimulation is effective. (But then what is acupuncture??!!) And even the best
studies are not double blind: double blind studies would be extremely difficult 
to design, since the acupuncturist is aware of what he is doing.

Another concern is that studies from Asian countries are prone to the “file
drawer effect” where negative studies are filed away rather than submitted for
publication. This is a bigger problem in Asia than elsewhere: 98% of published
acupuncture trials from Asia are positive, versus 30% of acupuncture trials from
Canada, Australia and New Zealand. What if most of the evidence is really
negative? What if 4 studies were done, 3 with negative results and one with
positive results, and only the one with positive results was submitted for
publication? Replication in a country with a better track record would make the 
results more credible.

We know there are many things that can go wrong with experiments, and that most 
published research findings are false. When initial findings are mixed for a
treatment that really works, there is a gradual accumulation of more convincing 
data that tips the balance over time. Acupuncture studies have never shown any
such progress.

I will admit to being prejudiced by the fact that acupuncture is based on
pre-scientific thinking and on points, meridians and vitalistic forces whose
existence can’t be demonstrated. But we wouldn’t have to know “how” it worked if
it clearly “did” work. The evidence is inconsistent and not robust enough to
convince rigorous scientists that acupuncture is more effective than placebo for
any medical condition.

A Question Rather Than a Conclusion

Since medical science has little to offer for CP/CPPS, is recommending
acupuncture ethically justified; and if so, should patients be told it is
evidence-based?

Acupuncture versus breast cancer treatment-induced joint pain: Spinning another 
essentially negative study

The investigators behind a recent clinical trial testing acupuncture to treat
joint pain caused by aromatase inhibitors used to treat breast cancer are
spinning it as a positive study. As is usually the case for acupuncture studies.
It isn’t

David Gorski on September 10, 2018

Link


Acupuncture is a frequent topic on this blog because it’s the perfect example of
the failure of evidence-based medicine (EBM). The modality, which involves
sticking thin needles into the skin along various “meridians” so that they
“unblock the flow of qi” (qi being the “life energy” or “vital force”) in order 
to treat…well…just about everything is a classic example of a prescientific
treatment that ignores anatomy, given that the “acupuncture meridians” into
which the needles are stuck do not correspond to any known structure. If you
believe its advocates, acupuncture is useful to treat such a wide variety of
illnesses and symptoms that it beggars imagination. Pain, infertility,
menopausal hot flashes, constipation, migraines, Parkinson’s disease,
chemotherapy-induced nausea, post-traumatic stress disorder, fibromyalgia,
carpal tunnel syndrome, asthma, anxiety, depression, acute bronchitis, diarrhea,
allergies, low libido, and a lot more. And those are just the conditions that
the World Health Organization mentioned, not the ones that acupuncturists claim,
which is a more expansive list. Of course, acupuncture can also help you lose
weight, if you believe advocates, because why not? If there’s a rule of thumb
about medicine that works pretty well, it’s that if a treatment is recommended
for everything chances are good that in reality it treats nothing. Indeed, as
our fearless leader Steve Novella and his collaborator once stated, acupuncture 
is a “theatrical placebo.”

We’ve discussed so many studies of acupuncture on this blog that it’s hard to
remember, find, or list them all. However, in general, we’ve pointed out how,
the claims of its advocates notwithstanding, the advocates’ own studies show
that acupuncture doesn’t work for menopausal hot flashes (or hot flashes due to 
the antiestrogen treatment used for breast cancer), pain, infertility, asthma,
lymphedema (also here), depression, and just about anything else. (And
acupuncture especially doesn’t work in the emergency room or on the battlefield 
or in the Veterans Administration). Unfortunately, it appears to be time to dive
in again, because another acupuncture study is making the rounds. It was
published in JAMA in July, and somehow I missed it. However, my attention was
drawn back to it a few days ago, when I was catching up on my journal reading
and came across a Medical News & Perspectives article by Jennifer Abbasi
entitled “Can Acupuncture Keep Women on Their Breast Cancer Drugs?” in the
August 28 issue. Fortunately, this gave me the opportunity to discuss the trial.

Let’s dig in, shall we?

The problem of hormonal therapy for breast cancer

Hormonal therapy for breast cancer is indicated for hormone-responsive breast
cancer. What “hormone”-responsive generally means is that the cells in the tumor
express the estrogen and/or progesterone receptor on their surface. Blocking
the action of estrogen in these tumors can thus be an effective treatment,
either adjuvantly to prevent recurrence after successful surgical treatment of
breast cancer or as a primary first treatment for metastatic disease. Indeed,
the responsiveness of some tumors to estrogen was first suspected in the late
1800s, when Thomas William Nunn reported the case history of a perimenopausal
woman with breast cancer whose disease regressed 6 months after her menstruation
ceased. At the time estrogen had not yet been isolated (that wouldn’t happen
until 1929), but this observation strongly suggested a link between ovarian
function and breast cancer, as did another report of a woman with breast cancer 
who experienced a spontaneous remission after menopause by A. Pearce Gould in
1896.

This link was also established in 1895 when George Thomas Beatson removed the
ovaries of a woman with metastatic breast cancer with extensive soft tissue
involvement and achieved a complete remission that lasted for four years.
Beatson also treated the woman with thyroid extract, which was being used at the
time to treat various ailments based on George Redmayne Murray’s report of
successfully treating a patient who had myxedema with sheep thyroid extract.
That it was the oophorectomy and not the thyroid extract was demonstrated by
Stanley Boyd, who performed oophorectomy on five women with inoperable breast
cancer, one of whom survived 12 years, publishing data in 1900 indicating that
one-third of patients undergoing oophorectomy clearly benefited. (Given that
roughly two-thirds of breast cancers are estrogen-responsive, we now know that
that was about half of the patients with estrogen-responsive cancers deriving a 
clinical benefit.) He therefore championed oophorectomy as a useful, albeit not 
curative, treatment for breast cancer. Unfortunately, oophorectomy, as was the
case for any pelvic or intraabdominal surgery in the early 1900s, had a high
rate of mortality and complications; so this treatment never caught on until the
1950s, when Charles Huggins and Thomas Dao brought oophorectomy combined with
adrenalectomy back to the mainstream of breast cancer therapies.

Then came the advent of Tamoxifen. This particular drug’s history is quite
interesting. Tamoxifen was first made in 1966 by scientists working for Imperial
Chemical Industries Pharmaceuticals (ICI, now AstraZeneca). These scientists
had been tasked with finding a new emergency contraceptive. Unfortunately, early
versions of the drug had no contraceptive effect in humans, and the drug was
almost abandoned. However, V. Craig Jordan re-invented this failed
“morning-after pill” to treat estrogen receptor-positive [ER(+)] breast cancer. 
A clinical trial demonstrated its effectiveness and the drug was licensed in the
UK in 1972.

Of course, these days, we have a lot more than Tamoxifen to treat ER(+) breast
cancer. There’s another class of drug known as aromatase inhibitors, as well as 
others. Basically, they fall into two categories; drugs that block estrogen’s
action (e.g., Tamoxifen and Faslodex®) or drugs that block the production of
estrogen (aromatase inhibitors). In some patients, ovarian function is blocked
using “chemical castration” with drugs such as Zoladex® and Lupron®.

Given that over two-thirds of breast cancers are estrogen-responsive, there are 
a lot of patients undergoing treatment with estrogen-blocking drugs.
Unfortunately, these drugs can often have a serious deleterious effect on a
woman’s quality of life, causing menopausal symptoms in premenopausal women and 
worsening menopausal symptoms in post-menopausal women. These symptoms,
particularly hot flashes, are very hard to treat with anything other than
estrogen. Indeed, I still remember the first patient I ever operated on as a new
attending and how she simply could not tolerate her Tamoxifen, no matter how
much her oncologist tried to work with her to make it possible for her to take
it. The seriousness of the effects of these drugs on patient quality of life
should not be underestimated.

One significant potential complication associated with aromatase inhibitors
(almost always the first choice of antiestrogen drug for postmenopausal women)
is osteoporosis. However, the most vexing side effect for most women on these
drugs is severe musculoskeletal pain, specifically arthralgia (joint pain). The 
mechanism causing this joint pain is poorly understood, but it can be
debilitating enough that the only choice is to stop the medication. This brings 
us to the rationale for the study, as described by Ms. Abbasi:

   A class of drugs called aromatase inhibitors (AIs) are a cornerstone of
   breast cancer treatment, but they come at a steep physical price. About half 
   of women who take this form of hormone therapy develop arthritis-like joint
   stiffness and pain for still-unknown reasons.

   “When we started using these medicines, the first thing that women would say 
   is, ‘This medication makes me feel like an old lady,’” said oncologist Dawn
   Hershman, MD, who leads the breast cancer program at Columbia University
   Medical Center’s cancer center in New York City.

   The drugs—anastrozole, exemestane, and letrozole—are prescribed for 5 to 10
   years in postmenopausal women with hormone-sensitive breast cancer, but the
   life-limiting pain they cause compels many to abandon the treatments before
   that. And it’s feared that this could lead to cancer recurrence and death.

You can tell where this is going next:

   Eight years ago, in an effort to encourage women to keep taking their AIs,
   Hershman and her collaborators set out to find a way to alleviate the pain. A
   pill wouldn’t cut it. “We know that when a patient has side effects from the
   medicine, they don’t want to take another medicine that has the potential to
   cause more side effects,” she said. “Natural remedies or modalities are more
   acceptable to patients.”

   So they chose to study acupuncture, a form of traditional Chinese medicine
   that some clinical evidence suggests can effectively treat chronic
   musculoskeletal pain. The results from their National Institutes of
   Health–funded randomized clinical trial recently appeared in JAMA.

Yes, we had a medical problem whose solution we haven’t determined yet; so let’s
try magic. Why not? Of course, the evidence cited that acupuncture could treat 
chronic pain was nothing more than an update of a meta-analysis that was
extensively discussed here when the first version came out and has nothing new
that changes my conclusion about it. In any event, the study reported on by
Abbasi is, as you will see, not very convincing.

Blinded by the light (reflected off the shiny needle)

Let’s take a look at the study, “Effect of Acupuncture vs Sham Acupuncture or
Waitlist Control on Joint Pain Related to Aromatase Inhibitors Among Women With 
Early-Stage Breast Cancer“, by Dawn L. Hershman, MD, MS; Joseph M. Unger, PhD,
MS; Heather Greenlee, ND, PhD; et al. Dr. Hershman, as was noted above, is based
at Columbia University. Heather Greenlee, ND, you might recall, is a naturopath
(i.e., the ND stands for “Not-Doctor”) based at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer
Research Center in Seattle. We’ve met her before, most recently when the
guidelines for the “integrative oncology” care of breast cancer patients
published by the Society for Integrative Oncology (SIO) were endorsed by the
American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO).

The study involved eleven academic medical centers and clinical sites, which
recruited: Women with early stage ER(+) breast cancer who scored at least 3 on
the Brief Pain Inventory Worst Pain (BPI-WP) item (score range, 0-10; higher
scores indicate greater pain) and who were either (1) postmenopausal and taking 
an aromatase inhibitor or (2) pre- or perimenopausal whose ovarian function had 
been suppressed with a gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonist and were taking an
aromatase inhibitor. Exclusion criteria included prior acupuncture treatment
for joint symptoms at any time; history of bone fracture or surgery of the
affected joints within 6 months prior to enrollment; severe bleeding disorder;
or a latex allergy. Also, study participants must not have received opioid
analgesics, topical analgesics, oral corticosteroids, intramuscular
corticosteroids, or intra-articular steroids, or any other medical therapy,
alternative therapy, or physical therapy for the treatment of joint pain or
joint stiffness within 28 days prior to registration. The trial ran from March
2012 to February 2017 (final date of follow-up, September 5, 2017).

Patients were randomized in a 2:1:1 ratio to receive either true acupuncture,
sham acupuncture, or to be on a wait list. As for the acupuncture used:

   The acupuncture study interventions were developed by a consensus of
   acupuncture experts based on previous studies of acupuncture for aromatase
   inhibitor–related arthralgias with adherence to the Standards for Reporting
   of Controlled Trials in Acupuncture (STRICTA) recommendations.13 The details 
   of the acupuncture point protocol (ie, body site of needle placement) and
   extensive training and standardization methods (in-person training, study
   manuals, monthly phone calls, and remote quality assurance monitoring) have
   been previously described.17

   Briefly, both true acupuncture and sham acupuncture consisted of twelve 30-
   to 45- minute sessions administered over a period of 6 weeks (2 per week)
   followed by 1 session per week for 6 weeks. For true acupuncture, stainless
   steel, single-use, sterile and disposable needles were used and inserted at
   traditional depths and angles. The joint-specific protocol was tailored to as
   many as 3 of the patient’s most painful joint areas.18 Needles were
   restimulated manually once during each session. The sham acupuncture
   consisted of a core standardized prescription of minimally invasive, shallow 
   needle insertion using thin and short needles at nonacupuncture points. The
   sham acupuncture protocol also included joint-specific treatments and an
   auricular sham based on the application of adhesives to nonacupuncture points
   on the ear. The waitlist control group received no acupuncture treatments
   and received no other intervention for 24 weeks after randomization. At 24
   weeks, all patients received vouchers for 10 true acupuncture bonus sessions 
   to be used prior to the 52-week visit.

The reason I quoted that so extensively is so that you can see any issues I
point out (and because the article is behind a paywall). This is not an unusual 
sham control procedure, using needles in nonacupuncture points. I must admit, I 
had a heck of a time finding the one thing I immediately look for whenever I see
a trial design like this, the answer to the one question I always have about
any acupuncture trial: Was it double-blinded? Yes, the authors state that it was
impossible to blind the wait list control, but that’s OK. That’s what wait list
controls are for: To estimate the magnitude of placebo effects. Not blinding
the wait list control is fine. Then it dawned on me! Of course this trial wasn’t
double-blinded. The acupuncturists knew they were sticking needles in
non-acupuncture points. Indeed, in Abbasi’s article, the authors try to justify 
not using a double blind design and having only the patients blinded to group:

   Still, Hershman knows critics will take issue with the sham treatments, which
   weren’t double-blinded. Practitioners knew they were giving fake treatments 
   and may have sent subconscious signals to their patients.

   Using retractable needles designed to blind practitioners to the sham
   wouldn’t have helped, Hershman said, because studies suggest that both
   patients and acupuncturists can tell the difference.

   “We looked at a whole slew of studies…of different sham modalities,” Hershman
   said. “They all had advantages and disadvantages. We felt in looking at the 
   collective literature out there that this was probably the best approach.”

Yes, I do take issue with the sham treatments. It’s simply not true that sham
needles don’t work. I’ve lost track of the number of studies I’ve read where
sham retractable needles were used and double-blinding was fine. My guess is
that the acupuncturists probably didn’t want to use them. So right away, you
know all the crowing about how “rigorously designed” this trial was in Abbasi’s 
article is a load of fetid dingos’ kidneys, especially given that subjects in
the true acupuncture group were more likely to believe that they were receiving 
true acupuncture (68%) than those in the sham group (36%). Yeah, the masking
worked real well there! I’ll grant that the rest of the study was pretty
well-designed, particularly given that a waitlist control was included, but the 
inadequate blinding, along with other factors, should be enough to invalidate
the results of the study, as I’ll explain.

Before I go into the results, though, let’s look at the endpoints to be
assessed. The first prespecified primary endpoint used the Brief Pain
Inventory-Short Form (BPI-SF), which consists of 14 questions asking the
subjects to rate their joint pain over the prior week and the degree to which
the pain interferes with activities using a 0- to 10-point scale. Thus, the
primary end point was the BPI Worst Pain Item (BPI-WP) score at 6 weeks of
treatment, with the authors noting that a reduction of 2 points on the BPI-WP
has been identified as a clinically meaningful change for a patient.

Secondary endpoints included a number of measurements, including:

  1. Brief Pain Inventory-Short Form (BPI-SF) worst pain, worst stiffness (items 15
    & 16), pain severity, and pain-related interference scores at 6, 12, 16,
    20, 24, and 52 weeks.

  2. Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis (WOMAC) index (pain, 
    stiffness, and function) for the hips and knees at 6, 12, 24, and 52 weeks.

  3. Modified-Score for the Assessment and Quantification of Chronic Rheumatoid
    Affections of the Hands (M-SACRAH) (pain, stiffness, and function) at 6, 12,
    24, and 52 weeks.

  4. PROMIS Pain Impact-Short Form (PROMIS PI-SF) at 6, 12, 24, and 52 weeks.

  5. Quality of life as assessed by the FACT-ES Trial Outcome Index (Version 4) at 
    6, 12, 24, and 52 weeks.

  6. Functional testing of the hands (grip strength) and legs (‘Timed Get Up and
    Go’) at 6, 12, 24, and 52 weeks.

  7. Analgesic and opioid use at 2, 4, 6, 12, 16, 20, 24, and 52 weeks.

  8. Aromatase inhibitor (AI) adherence at 12, 24, and 52 weeks.

  9. Urine AI metabolites at 24 and 52 weeks.

  10. Serum hormone biomarkers (estradiol, FSH, LH) and inflammatory biomarkers
    (serum TNFα, IL-6, IL-12, CRP; urine CTX-II) at 6, 12, and 24 weeks.

There were others, but these are the most relevant. As for the analysis:

   For a 2-point difference between groups and an assumed 3.0-point standard
   deviation at 6 weeks, 208 eligible patients were required for 82% power
   (using 2-sided tests; α = .025) for true acupuncture vs sham acupuncture and 
   true acupuncture vs waitlist control. The design further specified an
   estimated 5% nonadherence and 10% dropout rate at the primary end point
   evaluation time of 6 weeks. In addition, the design incorporated a 10%
   contamination rate. The primary outcome was analyzed using the
   intention-to-treat principle (ie, as randomized), using a complete-case
   approach given limited missing data (<10%), without using imputation.

So let’s see what the results were. Those of you who’ve read ahead or read more 
of the actual study and/or Ms. Abbasi’s article know that the authors reported a
“positive” result that was quite underwhelming. Surprise, surprise! I know.

The theatrical placebo that is acupuncture remains theatrical

Overall, 226 patients were randomly assigned to the true acupuncture (n = 110), 
sham acupuncture (n = 59), or waitlist control (n = 57) group according to the
diagram below:

Interesting observations include:

  1. The median age was lower in the sham acupuncture group (57.0 years) than in
    the waitlist control (60.6 years) or true acupuncture (60.8 years) groups.

  2. Fewer Hispanic patients were randomized to the waitlist control group.

  3. More Asian patients were randomized to the true acupuncture group (10%
    compared to 3% in the sham acupuncture and 4% in the wait list control).

Overall, the groups were pretty similar in relevant characteristics, although
one has to wonder if having more Asians in the true acupuncture group could have
affected the results, given the cultural affinity for traditional Chinese
medicine, but who knows? I couldn’t find any investigation whether that was the 
case.

So let’s look at the primary outcome:

   Compared with baseline, the mean observed BPI-WP score was 2.05 points lower 
   (reduced pain) at 6 weeks in the true acupuncture group, 1.07 points lower in
   the sham acupuncture group, and 0.99 points lower for the waitlist control
   group, with differences in adjusted 6-week mean BPI-WP scores between true
   acupuncture vs sham acupuncture of 0.92 points (95% CI, 0.20-1.65; P = .01)
   and between true acupuncture vs waitlist control of 0.96 points (95% CI,
   0.24-1.67; P = .01).

Remember how the authors stated that they had hoped to see a change in the pain 
score of greater than two? They didn’t get it. As is often the case in clinical 
trials, everyone got better, including the waitlist control group, and in the
end there was a statistically significant difference in the change in pain
score, but that difference is by definition almost certainly not clinically
significant. Yes, it’s exactly the same thing the Vickers meta-analysis found
back in 2012: A statistically significant difference, but a difference too small
to be clinically relevant.

What about all the secondary endpoints? Well, if you really look at the data,
the only consistent finding is that the true acupuncture group had lower pain
scores than the waitlist control by all measures used. Given that no correction 
for multiple comparisons was made for secondary analyses, I have no idea what to
make of these results; certainly I was unimpressed by the findings of
differences between true and sham acupuncture for some measures but not others.

As for the primary outcome measure, in the mixed effects model:

   Through 24 weeks, adjusted mean BPI-WP scores were 0.59 points lower (95% CI,
   0.34-1.14; P = .04) in the true acupuncture group compared with the sham
   acupuncture group and were 1.23 points lower (95% CI, 0.66-1.80; P< .001) in 
   the true acupuncture group compared with the waitlist control group

So there was a (barely) statistically significant effect of true over sham
acupuncture remaining at 24 weeks, but the only real difference was, as
expected, between true acupuncture and waitlist. This brings me back to the
issue of blinding, where, as I mentioned above, patients in the true acupuncture
group were considerably more likely than those who received sham acupuncture
(68% versus 36%; p < 0.001) to believe that they had received “true
acupuncture.” The authors try to wave this away by stating that the intervention
effect for BPI-WP did not differ between those believing vs not believing they 
were receiving true acupuncture when interaction tests were applied, noting that
P for interaction = 0.16. Remember how I said that statistically significant ≠ 
clinically significant? Well, it’s also true that statistically insignificant
does not necessarily mean an effect is insignificant. Remember, the cutoff for
statistical significance is p<0.05, but that’s an arbitrary cutoff. Basically, a
p-value less than 0.05 implies that there’s only a 5% chance of observing the
difference found (or a larger difference) if the null hypothesis (i.e., that
there is no difference in the value measured between the two groups) is true.
Yes, P=0.16 is not considered anywhere near statistically significant and I
won’t try to argue that it is, but it’s low enough that I wouldn’t be nearly as 
confident as the authors are that there was that there was no interaction at all
between the masking and the intervention effect. Think of it this way: P=0.16
implies 16% chance of getting the observed result (or more extreme result) if
the null hypothesis is true. That’s still rather low, just not what anyone would
accept statistically. If the p-value were something like 0.5 I’d be absolutely 
down with the conclusion that there was no interaction between a subject’s
perception of which group she was in and whether an effect was observed. Right
now, I’m not so sure.

I’m sure I’ll be ripped by a statistician somewhere who was pulling his or her
hair out while reading the above paragraph because I’m being too simplistic, but
such is the risk I take as a scientist who’s had a biostatistics course or two 
and not an actual statistician. (This is as close to humility as you’ll likely
see me.) So I might as well go all in and phrase it in a way that might annoy
even more people. Think of the p-value as an estimate of how likely it is that
the difference you found between the groups you’re comparing is not real, and
then 0.16 (or 16%) doesn’t sound quite so reassuring, although it’s perfectly
fine as being “statistically insignificant”. Think of it yet another way. You
have a 16.666667% chance of rolling a one on a six-sided die. How many times
have you observed that? Quite a few, I’ll bet.

Hopefully, though, one thing we can all agree on is that post hoc analyses are
often abused, because the authors, having found not much of anything
particularly convincing (a clinically nonsignificant difference in pain scores
between the true and sham acupuncture groups that’s not particularly strongly
statistically significant), clearly weren’t happy. So they compared the
percentage of patients in each group who achieved as their primary measure a
2-point or greater BPI-WP at 6 weeks. What they found was that the number of
those experiencing that level of decrease in BPI-WP was was 58.0% (n = 58) for
the true acupuncture group, 33.3% (n = 18) for the sham acupuncture group (RD,
24.7% [95% CI, 8.8%-40.5%]; RR (relative risk), 1.64 [95% confidence interval,
1.10-2.44]; P = .02), and 31.4% (n = 16) for the waitlist control group
(difference for true acupuncture vs waitlist control, 26.6% [95% CI,
[10.6%-42.6%]; RR, 1.75 [95% CI, 1.13-2.69]; P = .01; eFigure 2 and eTable 2 in 
Supplement 2). The authors at least admit that the post hoc analysis was
hypothesis-generating, which is all that post hoc analyses are generally good
for.

The spin

Ms. Abbasi’s story appears to me to be in essence an attempt to spin a study
with very unimpressive results and, when you come right down to it, failed to
reach its primary endpoint. That doesn’t stop JAMA from taking what I view to be
an extraordinary step. It’s not the authors so much who are defending their
study, but rather JAMA editors, Deborah Schrag, MD, the associate editor who
handled the article, and Ed Livingston, MD, a deputy editor at JAMA. I can’t
recall ever seeing this in an op-ed published in JAMA before:

   “In the formal sense, this study did not reach its primary end point,” said
   Deborah Schrag, MD, an oncologist at Dana-Farber Cancer Institute in Boston
   and the JAMA associate editor who handled the article. But, she added, “they 
   did achieve a clear and consistent reduction in women’s symptoms.”

No, they didn’t, for reasons I explained in my usual fashion above.

Next up:

   Ed Livingston, MD, a deputy editor at JAMA, said there is some debate
   regarding how to interpret the findings of a study when the primary end point
   is negative but many of the secondary end points trend in the positive
   direction, suggesting an effect of the intervention. “Some believe this is
   good enough to conclude that an intervention is effective,” he said.

Those “some” who believe that are likely acupuncturists and “integrative
oncologists” who believe in acupuncture. In fairness, he’s not entirely wrong.
There are always physicians who are willing to prescribe treatments they believe
in based on weak evidence like the evidence in this study. That doesn’t make it
right.

Finally, before we get to Dr. Hershman again:

   Acupuncture’s unknown mechanism of action is also likely to arouse criticism.
   Schrag understands the skepticism. “I agree that that’s perturbing about
   acupuncture,” she said, “but when there are rigorous studies that demonstrate
   a benefit, I think it’s still hard to ignore. If this were a very toxic or
   expensive intervention, there might be less enthusiasm, but acupuncture is
   widely available and well known to be quite safe.”

Except that this study didn’t really show a benefit, except maybe if you squint 
your eyes real hard and wish as hard as you can. I can’t help but think that Dr.
Schrag is feeling some heat over the decision to publish this study in a
journal as prestigious as JAMA.

Finally, take it away, Dr. Hershman:

   But at the end of the day, Hershman’s belief is that it doesn’t really matter
   why acupuncture works, as long as it does: “Ultimately what matters is
   making sure that patients feel better and stay on their medicine. If 60% of
   patients had a significant reduction [in pain], then I think that we may have
   done them a real service.”

The problem, of course, is that, when you take into account the lack of blinding
of the acupuncturists and other shortcomings Dr. Hershman’s study is most
compatible with acupuncture having no detectable effect above placebo on the
joint pain caused by aromatase inhibitors. If I were to go all Bayesian on her, 
I’d point out that taking into account the prior probability of acupuncture
working for this condition based on what we know would rapidly render the
posterior probability that the observed result is correct to a very low value.
This is just another crappy acupuncture study that doesn’t show what its authors
think it shows and is already being used to promote quackery in oncology in the
name of “integrative oncology”.

Aromatase inhibitors and acupuncture in breast cancer: Spinning a negative
study, four years later

Four years ago, I wrote about an essentially negative study looking at whether
acupuncture could alleviate joint pain caused by aromatase inhibitors, a common 
treatment for estrogen-sensitive breast cancer. The study’s back, and it doesn’t
look any more positive.

David Gorski on November 14, 2022

Link



Before the pandemic, acupuncture was a frequent topic on this blog because it
was a perfect example of what we at SBM mean when we distinguish between
evidence-based medicine (EBM) and science-based medicine (SBM). In
evidence-based medicine, randomized controlled clinical trials (RCTs) and
meta-analyses of RCTs are at the very top of the pyramid of evidence. In
general, this is a reasonable pyramid of evidence with a caveat: The treatments 
being tested need to have biological plausibility as well as preclinical (cell
culture and animal studies) and early clinical evidence, such as small
preliminary clinical trials, to justify RCTs. Where this concept breaks down is 
for what is now known as “integrative medicine“, having been rebranded from its 
previous name, “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM). The reason is
that the treatments being “integrated” into “integrative medicine” by and large 
tend to be treatments that have very low biological plausibility and/or are
based on prescientific mysticism and belief, such as homeopathy, reiki and other
forms of “energy medicine“, and, yes, acupuncture, particularly for conditions 
for which the primary endpoints are subjective and therefore very prone to
placebo effects, such as, of course, pain. For such conditions, the clinical
trial results are nearly always equivocal, even when positive, and tend to
reflect more the noise and bias inherent in even well-designed RCTs than any
actual positive results. As I like to ask about, for example, homeopathy, what
is more likely, that a remedy diluted to nonexistence—in other words, water—has 
clinically relevant therapeutic effects or that a noise- and bias-laden clinical
trial came up with a false positive result? You can ask the same thing about
reiki and “energy healing”.

This is why, before the pandemic, we at SBM used to argue routinely for a more
Bayesian approach that takes into account prior plausibility and probability in 
analyzing clinical trial results. Basically, prior plausibility informs how
likely a “positive” result of a clinical trial is likely to be truly positive,
the lower the prior plausibility the lower the required p-value. That is, of
course a simplistic discussion, but it is in essence what we argue—and have
argued since the very beginning of this blog.

Implausible treatments…like acupuncture

Unsurprisingly, acupuncture advocates like to try to argue that acupuncture is
different, that it’s not like the faith healing of reiki or the sympathetic
magic of homeopathy because it’s a physical intervention. The acupuncturist is
sticking needles into the patient, after all! Unfortunately, though, all the
concepts behind acupuncture are based on prescientific Asian mysticism,
particularly the meridians through which qi (or life energy) flows and that the 
acupuncture needles supposedly impact. Moreover, modern acupuncture is nothing
like ancient acupuncture, having been reinvented with the development of thin,
filiform needles in the 1930s and then its entire history was retconned by
Chairman Mao in the 1950s, along with the rest of traditional Chinese medicine. 
In brief, the narrative became that this “ancient treatment” demonstrates a
near-miraculous efficacy for, well, just about everything. Never mind that the
filiform needles associated with modern acupuncture didn’t exist until around
1930, when a Chinese pediatrician named Cheng Dan’an proposed that needling
therapy be resurrected because its actions could be explained through neurology 
and replaced the previously-used coarse lancet-like needles with the fine
needles in use today. Of late, during the pandemic, I have pointed out how the
lessons of acupuncture trials should have been applied to hydroxychloroquine and
ivermectin, repurposed drugs touted as highly effective treatments for COVID-19
based on in vitro activity against SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, 
in cell culture. The problem was that the concentrations required were many
times higher than what could be safely achieved in human blood, which presented 
a serious plausibility problem on the basis of pharmacodynamics and
pharmacokinetics alone. That’s why I was not surprised when RCTs ultimately
demonstrated that neither drug works against COVID-19, leading me to call
ivermectin the “acupuncture of COVID-19 treatments“, because it was always a
highly implausible treatment that nonetheless was subjected to way more RCTs
than its preclinical evidence justified.

All of this brings us to an acupuncture study published in JAMA that I discussed
four years ago that tested whether acupuncture could alleviate joint pain
caused by a class of estrogen-blocking drugs known as aromatase inhibitors. I
called it “spinning another essentially negative study“, particularly based on
interviews with one of the main authors in which it was spun that way. Over the 
weekend, a reader sent me a link to another acupuncture study, published on
Friday, this time in JAMA Open Network and titled “Comparison of Acupuncture vs 
Sham Acupuncture or Waiting List Control in the Treatment of Aromatase
Inhibitor–Related Joint Pain“. I immediately thought: This looks very, very
familiar. So I did a search for acupuncture and aromatase inhibitors on SBM, and
I found my post from 2018. Looking at the author list, I saw the same names.
Looking at the ClinicalTrials.gov number, I saw that it was the same,
NCT01535066. It was the same study! So what was the difference? Basically, this 
was a long-term follow-up that claimed that acupuncture could result in
long-term relief of the joint pain symptoms commonly associated with aromatase
inhibitors like anastrozole.

Aromatase inhibitors and arthralgias

Before I move on to discuss the study design, first let me discuss the problem
for which acupuncture was being studied. Given that over two-thirds of breast
cancers have the estrogen receptor, that means that they are estrogen-responsive
and blocking estrogen can inhibit breast cancer growth. Consequently, there are
a lot of patients undergoing treatment with estrogen-blocking drugs.
Unfortunately, these drugs can often have a serious deleterious effect on a
woman’s quality of life, causing menopausal symptoms in premenopausal women and 
worsening menopausal symptoms in post-menopausal women. These symptoms,
particularly hot flashes, are very hard to treat with anything other than
estrogen. Indeed, I still remember the first patient I ever operated on as a new
attending and how she simply could not tolerate her Tamoxifen, no matter how
much her oncologist tried to work with her to make it possible for her to take
it. The seriousness of the effects of these drugs on patient quality of life
should not be underestimated.

One significant potential complication associated with aromatase inhibitors
(almost always the first choice of antiestrogen drug for postmenopausal women)
is osteoporosis. However, the most vexing side effect for most women on these
drugs is severe musculoskeletal pain, specifically arthralgia (joint pain). The 
mechanism causing this joint pain is poorly understood, but the side effect can 
be debilitating enough that the only choice is to stop the medication and try
another class of drugs. As a result, it would be highly useful to be able to
alleviate the joint pain that aromatase inhibitors can cause, given that
aromatase inhibitors are associated with a large decrease in the risk of
recurrence after successful initial treatment of breast cancer. So one can
understand why acupuncture advocates would want to test acupuncture on women
undergoing aromatase inhibitor therapy.

As I like to put it, we have a medical problem whose solution we haven’t been
able to identify yet; so let’s try magic. Why not?

The study

As I perused the list of authors, now as in 2018, one name jumped out right
away: Heather Greenlee. You might recall that she is a naturopath at the Fred
Hutchinson Cancer Center at the University of Washington in Seattle. We’ve met
her before, for example, when the guidelines for the “integrative oncology” care
of breast cancer patients published by the Society for Integrative Oncology
(SIO) were endorsed by the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO). Also,
now as in 2018, I was also disappointed to see that the University of Michigan, 
my medical alma mater, was one of the sites at which this study was carried out.
Of course, U. of M. has gone all-in with “integrative medicine”, even to the
point of embracing anthroposophic medicine, acupuncture, homeopathy, and
naturopathy, with its family medicine department including a naturopath. So I
guess that I shouldn’t have been surprised.

The study involved eleven academic medical centers and clinical sites, which
recruited: Women with early stage ER(+) breast cancer who scored at least 3 on
the Brief Pain Inventory Worst Pain (BPI-WP) item (score range, 0-10; higher
scores indicate greater pain) and who were either (1) postmenopausal and taking 
an aromatase inhibitor or (2) pre- or perimenopausal whose ovarian function had 
been suppressed with a gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonist and were taking an
aromatase inhibitor. Exclusion criteria included prior acupuncture treatment
for joint symptoms at any time; history of bone fracture or surgery of the
affected joints within 6 months prior to enrollment; severe bleeding disorder;
or a latex allergy. Also, study participants must not have received opioid
analgesics, topical analgesics, oral corticosteroids, intramuscular
corticosteroids, or intra-articular steroids, or any other medical therapy,
alternative therapy, or physical therapy for the treatment of joint pain or
joint stiffness within 28 days prior to registration. The trial ran from March
2012 to February 2017 (final date of follow-up, September 5, 2017).

Patients were randomized in a 2:1:1 ratio to receive either true acupuncture,
sham acupuncture, or to be on a wait list. As for the acupuncture used:

   Study participants were randomized 2:1:1 to TA vs SA vs WC, with
   randomization dynamically balanced by study site. Both TA and SA consisted of
   twelve 30- to 45-minute sessions administered during 6 weeks (2 sessions per
   week) followed by 1 session per week for 6 more weeks. For TA, stainless
   steel, single-use, sterile, and disposable needles were used and inserted at 
   traditional depths and angles. The SA protocol consisted of a core
   standardized prescription of minimally invasive, shallow needle insertion
   using thin and short needles at nonacupuncture points. The SA protocol also
   included joint-specific treatments and an auricular sham based on the
   application of adhesives to nonacupuncture points on the ear. The WC group
   received no acupuncture during the initial 24 weeks of study participation.
   At 24 weeks, all patients received vouchers for 10 TA sessions to be used
   before the 52-week visit.

The outcomes were:

   The original protocol-specified primary end point was the BPI-WP score at 6
   weeks. The short-form version of the BPI was administered at 6, 12, 16, 20,
   24, and 52 weeks. For this long-term analysis, the primary end point was the 
   52-week assessment of BPI-WP (which was not previously reported), examined
   using multivariable linear regression. Secondary end points for this
   long-term evaluation included the BPI average pain, pain interference, pain
   severity, and worst stiffness scores at 52 weeks. All BPI scores range from
   no symptoms to worst on a 0- to 10-point scale (with higher scores indicating
   worse symptoms). In addition, we evaluated pain using the PROMIS Pain
   Interference–Short Form (PROMIS PI-SF), which has scores ranging from 6 to
   30. This instrument was also administered at 6, 12, 24, and 52 weeks and has 
   5 response levels (low scores [not at all] to high scores [very much]), with 
   higher scores reflecting worse symptoms.

   We examined 2 functional measures: grip strength and Timed Get Up and Go
   test. Grip strength was measured with a digital hand grip strength
   dynamometer (DHS 88, Detecto) in kilograms. Patients were asked to make 3
   maximal voluntary contractions with 1 minute between each. The maximum
   contraction was used. The Timed Get Up and Go test is a physical function
   assessment tool of speed that is an estimate of impairments in balance and
   gait.

It’s useful now to discuss the specific acupuncture interventions and controls. 
First, there’s nothing wrong with including a waitlist control; it’s a perfectly
valid way to assess for placebo effects, but what about the sham intervention
chosen? The first thing I noticed the first time around was that there was no
blinding of the acupuncturists to intervention. Of course, not blinding the
waitlist control is fine. That’s why there is a waitlist control in the first
place, to estimate the magnitude of placebo effects. The important control is
the sham acupuncture. At the time of the publication of the first study, the
authors tried to justify not blinding the acupuncturists to the experimental
group:

   Still, Hershman knows critics will take issue with the sham treatments, which
   weren’t double-blinded. Practitioners knew they were giving fake treatments 
   and may have sent subconscious signals to their patients.

   Using retractable needles designed to blind practitioners to the sham
   wouldn’t have helped, Hershman said, because studies suggest that both
   patients and acupuncturists can tell the difference.

   “We looked at a whole slew of studies…of different sham modalities,” Hershman
   said. “They all had advantages and disadvantages. We felt in looking at the 
   collective literature out there that this was probably the best approach.”

As I said at the time, I did take issue with the sham treatments. It was simply 
not true that sham needles don’t work. I’ve lost track of the number of studies 
I’ve read where sham retractable needles were used and double-blinding was fine.
My guess at the time was that the acupuncturists recruited to participate in
the study didn’t want to use them, and I see nothing to reassess that guess. So 
right away, we knew all the crowing about the “rigorous design” of this trial is
still a load of fetid dingos’ kidneys, especially given that, according to the 
2018 study, subjects in the true acupuncture group were more likely to believe
that they were receiving true acupuncture (68%) than those in the sham group
(36%). I’ll still grant that the rest of the study was pretty well-designed,
particularly given that a waitlist control was included, but the inadequate
blinding, along with other factors, was enough then to explain the results of
the study, and remains so.

To help explain why, I will reproduce the graph comparing adjusted mean group
difference in Brief Pain Inventory Worst Pain Scores in true acupuncture (TA)
versus sham acupuncture (SA) and TA vs waiting list control (WC) at 6, 12, 16,
20, 24, and 52 weeks:



Adjusted Mean Group Difference in Brief Pain Inventory Worst Pain Scores in True
Acupuncture (TA) vs Sham Acupuncture (SA) and TA vs Waiting List Control (WC)
at 6, 12, 16, 20, 24, and 52 Weeks.

So what do you think? Can you see what this result shows? Notice how, short
term, there is a highly statistically significant difference in the pain score
between the TA group and both the SA and WC control groups. There are two
explanations for such a result. Either the study was unblinded, or there was an 
actual difference between TA and SA. As I argued above, I think the lack of
blinding explains the result quite well. I also note that the authors had stated
that they had hoped to see a difference of 2.0 or greater in the pain score,
which further reinforced my conclusion that this result was due to the lack of
blinding. Now look at the graph. None of the differences reported are greater
than 2.0, and the only one that approaches 2.0 is the difference in pain scores 
at 12 weeks between TA and WC.

Notice also, how for the timepoints at 16, 20, and 24 weeks the differences
between TA and SA were not statistically significant and were at most a half a
point. As a commenter said after the last post:

   After the fact, Dr. Hershman asserts (without citations) that differences in 
   pain scores as low as 0.7 points are clinically significant. You must be
   f***ing kidding me. Okay, maybe on a scale of 0-2. The references I’ve seen
   say 1.5 – 2 points on a 0-10 scale, and this makes sense. Keep in mind, this 
   is the MINIMUM clinically significant difference. That is, patients are
   willing to say that their pain was lessened a little bit. That’s different
   from “this treatment provided me with adequate pain relief.”

Exactly. The same applies now in the new study.

Admittedly, the final data point at 52 weeks shows both TA versus SA and TA
versus WC having roughly 1.0 point difference that is statistically significant.
Given the timeframe after the intervention (twelve 30- to 45-minute sessions of
TA or SA administered during 6 weeks (2 sessions per week) followed by 1
session per week for 6 more weeks) and the fact that the WC group, although it
received no TA or SA treatment during the first 24 weeks, did receive vouchers
for acupuncture treatments afterward, which can muddy the analysis. Also, again,
a mere one-point difference in pain scores has at best questionable clinical
significance.

Now here’s the most important issue that I have with the study, having thought
about it some more. What is the reason that we want to alleviate the symptoms
that can be caused by aromatase inhibitors? True, we don’t want women to suffer 
unnecessarily, but we also want them to stick with the treatment for at least
five years, something they are less likely to do if they are having severe joint
pain. That brought up a question that I should have hammered home in my first
post about this study: Why wasn’t one of the primary endpoints the
discontinuation rate of aromatase inhibitor (AI)? Usually, patients who can’t
tolerate AI therapy for their breast cancer will be forced to discontinue the
drug within the first several months. In this study, what did the authors
report? They reported that the “overall AI discontinuation rate within the 52
weeks of follow-up was 12.1% and did not differ by intervention group.” In other
words, TA made zero difference in the only outcome that really matters for
purposes of treating the patients’ breast cancer, their continuation of their AI
therapy.

The authors then looked at pain medication use among patients who reported
taking no pain medication at the start of the study:

   To examine incident use of pain medications during the study, we also
   evaluated patterns among patients who did not report pain medication use at
   baseline (n = 91 [40.3%]). Among these patients, new use of pain medications 
   during the study occurred in 20 of 44 patients (45.5%) in the TA group, 16 of
   23 (69.6%) in the SA group (P = .06), and 16 of 24 (66.7%) in the WC group
   (P = .09). Taken together, pain medication use was less likely for patients
   in the TA compared with the SA or WC groups combined (20 of 44 [45.5%] vs 32 
   of 47 [68.1%], P = .03).

In other words, there was no statistically significant difference in the rate of
initiation of pain medications between TA and SA; so the authors combined the
SA and WC group to compare to the TA group and found a significant difference.
That’s a bit dodgy to me right there.

Finally:

   No differences were observed between groups in assessments of grip strength
   (eTables 3 and 4 in Supplement 2) or Timed Get Up and Go (eTables 5 and 6 in 
   Supplement 2) for any assessment time compared with baseline.

These are functional measures that are objective, and acupuncture did not affect
them at all. My conclusion: Four years later, with follow-up out to 52 weeks,
this is still a negative acupuncture study. The authors, however, did not see it
that way:

   In this randomized clinical trial, we found that among postmenopausal women
   with early breast cancer who experienced AI-related arthralgias, a 12-week
   intervention of TA compared with SA or WC resulted in statistically
   significant sustained reduction in joint pain at 52 weeks. This study
   highlights the durability of the acupuncture response through 1 year, as well
   as the importance of having both SA and WC groups to fully evaluate the
   effect of the acupuncture intervention.

No. Just no. This study, although barely “positive” for some measurements, was, 
due to lack of blinding and the low effect size observed, functionally,
clinically, and practically a negative study. TA didn’t result in any functional
improvement. It didn’t decrease the percentage of patients who had to stop
their AI therapy. It only barely showed any improvement in a subjective pain
score, and even then that effect varied wildly at different time points and was 
at most time points not statistically significant. (I didn’t even get into the
uneven subject allocation to groups, something I discussed in my 2018 post.)
Because of the lack of blinding and the very low prior scientific plausibility
of acupuncture as a treatment for AI-induced joint pain, the SBM conclusion is
that acupuncture didn’t work in this study for the outcomes studied. In
contrast, EBM ignores these considerations, so that the analysis of this study
left room to conclude that acupuncture does work against AI-induced joint pain
or is at least promising.

Science-based medicine vs. evidence-based medicine

Before the pandemic, a not-infrequent criticism of our discussions of
acupuncture studies like these tended to be based on methodolatry. This is a
term that I learned in 2009 from an eminent epidemiologist defined as the
profane worship of the RCT as the only valid method of clinical investigation.
Let’s just say that there is a lot of methodolatry in EBM, which is how a
treatment represented as ancient that is really a reinvention less than a
century ago of a significantly different ancient treatment whose history has
been heavily retconned can even reach the stage of being subjected to an RCT
despite its extreme biological implausibility and its basis in ancient vitalist 
beliefs. It would be one thing if any well-designed RCT of acupuncture were ever
to show a large, undeniable effect size against a clinical endpoint of interest
that can’t be explained by placebo effects. Then one might start to ask whether
we were wrong and there actually is a biological basis for acupuncture to work 
for that condition. Such is not the case, however, and so we continue to do
study after useless study testing whether the magic of acupuncture works against
condition after condition, finding equivocal results along the way because
clinical trials are messy, and it’s not uncommon to find marginally
statistically significant results if you do enough of them. Given the extreme
biological implausibility of a modality like acupuncture for arthralgias due to 
AI treatment, in light of findings like this the SBM conclusion is that
acupuncture doesn’t work.

In the age of the pandemic, the difference between EBM and SBM is even more
salient. The perfect example is ivermectin for COVID-19. As I wrote many moons
ago, SBM mavens all immediately realized that, even if you accepted the
rationale proposed at face value, ivermectin was incredibly implausible as an
effective therapy for COVID-19 just based on the in vitro data alone. It was
basic pharmacology. A drug (like ivermectin) that only inhibits the target
protein at a concentration that is at least nearly 70-fold higher than the
highest blood concentration of drug that can be safely achieved using standard
dosing is incredibly unlikely to be an effective treatment. It’s also a general 
principle that most highly effective drugs inhibit their target at nanomolar or 
ng/ml concentrations, not micromolar or μg/ml concentrations. Candidate drugs
that only inhibit their target at such high concentrations, in general, tend to 
be incredibly unlikely to be useful drugs. Surprise! When higher quality RCTs
were completed (compared to a number of low quality RCTs that showed an effect
of ivermectin on COVID-19), it turned out that ivermectin is ineffective against
the disease.

My hope now, as it was the last time I wrote about ivermectin, is that SBM
thinking will be more likely to sway EBM adherents who don’t really take into
account prior plausibility in evaluating RCT evidence and therefore take much
longer to reach a conclusion that is obvious to SBM about a treatment, in the
case of ivermectin that it doesn’t work against COVID-19. Unfortunately, the
example of acupuncture tells me that it’s unlikely that this will ever happen,
given that decades after it was apparent that acupuncture is nothing more than a
theatrical placebo, studies like this one are still being carried out and
reported as positive when, for all practical purposes, they are not.

More Acupuncture Misrepresentation

Steven Novella on January 22, 2014

Link


Poorly done acupuncture studies are published every week, so I can’t write about
every one that comes out. I probably would have passed this one by, except for 
the New York Times article using it to tout the effectiveness of acupuncture.

The headline reads: “Acupuncture, Real or Not, Eases Side Effects of Cancer
Drugs.”

I know that authors, in this case Nicholas Bakalar, often do not write their own
headlines, but in this case the article itself is just as bad. It begins:

   Both acupuncture and sham acupuncture were effective in reducing menopausal
   symptoms in women being treated with aromatase inhibitors for breast cancer, 
   a small randomized trial found.

This is, in fact, not true, but this fallacy has become the centerpiece
deception of acupuncture promotion. See if you can spot the fallacy, but before 
I discuss it let me review the study itself.

The one thing Bakalar gets right is that it was a small study. The study had two
arms, real acupuncture (RA – 23 subjects) and sham acupuncture (SA – 24
subjects). These were all women with breast cancer on an aromatase inhibitor
(AI) who were getting musculoskeletal side effects from the medication. They
were treated for 8 weeks with either RA or SA. Outcomes included several scales 
that essentially involve reporting subjective symptoms.

The study found that both groups reported improvement in symptoms with
treatment, but there was no statistically significant difference between the
two. In the real world we refer to this as a negative study.

Trying to rescue something interesting from the results, the authors also
report:

   Post-hoc analysis indicated that African American patients (n = 9) benefited 
   more from RA than SA compared with non-African American patients (n = 38) in 
   reducing hot flash severity (P < .001) and frequency (P < .001) scores.

Those P-values are completely worthless, because you cannot interpret P-values
of a post-hoc analysis. What we don’t know is how many post-hoc analyses were
done, and there does not seem to be any correction for multiple comparisons.
There are many possible subgroups that could have been pulled out – by age,
weight, and severity of symptoms, for example. There were also multiple possible
comparisons as multiple subjective outcomes were measured at different time
points. The fact that one subgroup had an outlier result is meaningless. Also,
this study is far too small for such subgroup analysis – only 9 subjects in the 
African American group.

I think it was deceptive to even report these results with those P-values. The
authors conclude from this:

   Racial differences in response to acupuncture warrant further study.

Even that tepid conclusion (probably all they could get away with in
peer-review) is not justified by this data, in my opinion. It seems like they
wanted to show some positive trend to make it seem like acupuncture has promise.

The only justified conclusion one can make from this study is that it failed to 
show any effect from acupuncture for treating AI side effects – this is a
negative study. The authors conclude, however:

   Both RA and SA were associated with improvement in PROs among patients with
   breast cancer who were receiving AIs, and no significant difference was
   detected between arms.

While accurate, it is misleading, which gets back to the core fallacy of recent 
acupuncture promotion. When the treatment and control groups, in a blinded
comparison, show no difference, the only conclusion to draw from that is that
the treatment had no measurable effect in that study (in plain terms, the
treatment did not work).

Stating that both the treatment and the control showed improvement is a
non-sequitur in the context of a controlled clinical trial. The comparison of
baseline symptoms to post treatment (real or sham) is unblinded, and therefore
it is not possible to make any efficacy claims from that change alone,
especially with subjective outcomes. Comparison to baseline or historical
controls is only justified with objective outcomes (like death). Even then the
data is suspect, unless there are blinded controls.

Interestingly, the authors provide a working definition of acupuncture in the
introduction to the published study:

   Acupuncture is a traditional Chinese medicine technique that involves
   inserting filiform stainless steel needles into specific points in the body
   to achieve therapeutic effect.

Acupuncture is sticking needles into specific points – those are the two
variables that define acupuncture. If the specific points do not matter (sham
acupuncture is sticking needles in the “wrong” points) then acupuncture, as
defined, does not work.

The New York Times article reports:

   The results may be attributable to a placebo effect, but the scientists
   suggest that the slight pricking of the skin could cause physiological
   changes. In any case, the lead author, Dr. Ting Bao, a medical oncologist at 
   the University of Maryland, Baltimore, said there is no harm in trying
   acupuncture.

The results are attributable to placebo effects, by definition – there was no
difference between the treatment and placebo groups. The authors (still trying
to put a positive spin on their negative data) suggest that perhaps it is the
sticking of needles that works, and not the specific points. However, their
study did not control for the sticking of needles, so it is disingenuous to
speculate about this variable.

We do have acupuncture studies, however, that control for the sticking of
needles – so-called placebo acupuncture where the skin is poked with toothpicks 
or a dull needle and there is no penetration. Most famously is this study of
acupuncture for back pain, which used the toothpick control.

What the evidence shows is that poking the skin randomly with tooth picks is as 
effective as traditional acupuncture performed by a trained acupuncturist. But
“as effective” could mean not effective at all, because all we have are
unblinded comparisons to no treatment for subjective outcomes.

Dr. Bao also makes the “what’s the harm” fallacy. The study was negative.
Stating that patients should try the treatment anyway is not justified. It is
also untrue that there is no possible harm. There is harm in wasting time and
resources on a treatment that demonstrably does not work. Promoting implausible 
and ineffective treatments also instills health misinformation in the public.
Further, acupuncture is not without risks. Even if the risks are small, they are
not justified when the evidence indicates no benefit.

The NYT article ends with this further quote from Dr. Bao:

   “Acupuncture as a medical procedure has been practiced for thousands of
   years,” she said. “It has a minimal risk and potentially significant
   benefits.”

This is propaganda, not science. Acupuncture, as it is practiced today, is a
fairly recent invention of the early 20th century. What was practiced for
thousands of years bears more of a resemblance to bloodletting than modern
acupuncture. In any case, this is nothing but the argument from antiquity
logical fallacy. Culture and mechanisms of deception can propagate ineffective
treatments for thousands of years.

Saying that a treatment has “potentially significant benefits” is unjustified
opinion, and is especially odd coming from a scientist who just published a
completely negative study showing the treatment is ineffective.

In fact there have been several thousand acupuncture studies over decades. After
all of this clinical research, acupuncture has not been clearly demonstrated to
be effective for any indication. In short, acupuncture does not work. It is too
late to talk about acupuncture’s “potential,” as if we just need to study it
more. It has been studied. It doesn’t work.

Proponents, however, will continue to publish poorly conducted studies where
biases and degrees of freedom can generate positive results, and more rigorous
studies with negative results that they will promote nonetheless as if they were
positive.

For acupuncture true believers, acupuncture research is a “heads I win, tails I 
win” situation.

                     Acupuncture and the Hazard of Nonsense

                                Steven Novella 

                                      Link

A recent study published in the Archives of Opthalmology compare patching of one
eye vs acupuncture in the treatment of amblyopia in older children, and finds
positive results from acupuncture. The study, and its press, are a good example 
of the hazards of studying highly implausible modalities.

First let’s dissect the study itself – from the abstract:

   In a single-center randomized controlled trial, 88 eligible children with
   an amblyopic eye who had a best spectacle-corrected visual acuity (BSCVA) of
   0.3 to 0.8 logMAR at baseline were randomly assigned to receive 2 hours of
   patching of the sound eye daily or 5 sessions of acupuncture weekly. All
   participants in our study received constant optical correction, plus 1 hour
   of near-vision activities daily, and were followed up at weeks 5, 10, 15, and
   25. The main outcome measure was BSCVA in the amblyopic eye at 15 weeks.

For background, amblyopia occurs when the brain tends to ignore visual
information from one eye. This results from a variety of causes, but commonly
from the two eyes having different refractive errors (anisometropic) – one eye
may be more near-sighted or far-sighted than the other. The brain cannot combine
information from both eyes, so it ignores one. This can be corrected in younger
children, up to age 7, by correcting the vision for the refractive problems. If
visual correction alone is not enough, then patching one eye (the strong eye)
to force the brain to use the weak eye can be effective. This is usually done
for only 2 hours a day, otherwise amblyopia of the patched eye can occur.

In children over 7 years old amblyopia is harder to treat. As the brain matures 
it becomes less plastic and less responsive to interventions used to treat
amblyopia. In this study the researchers investigated standard treatment –
constant optical correction plus near-vision activities – plus either patching
or acupuncture. Not surprisingly, both groups improved:

   The mean BSCVA of the amblyopic eye at 15 weeks improved from baseline by
   1.83 and 2.27 lines in the patching and acupuncture groups, respectively.
   After baseline adjustment, the mean difference of BSCVA between the 2 groups 
   was 0.049 logMAR (95% confidence interval, 0.005-0.092; P = .03), meeting the
   definition of equivalence (difference within 1 line). The BSCVA had improved
   by 2 lines or more in 28 (66.7%) and 31 (75.6%) eyes in the patching and
   acupuncture groups, respectively. Amblyopia was resolved in 7 (16.7%) and 17 
   (41.5%) eyes in the patching and acupuncture groups, respectively.

The weaknesses of this study make interpretation of the results difficult. It is
a small, single-center study. Follow up was relatively short for this outcome. 
But most importantly – both groups received some standard therapy, and the
variables of interest were not blinded at all. Further, there were no
acupuncture controls – no sham or placebo acupuncture.

At best this is a pilot study. In the abstract the authors conclude: “Further
studies are warranted to investigate its value in the treatment of amblyopia.”
That is the only conclusion warranted by pilot studies. However, in the
discussion the authors go further:

   “Because of the good results obtained in our study, the acupoints that we
   used could be considered for use in clinical practice.”

Changes to clinical practice are not warranted based upon an unblinded pilot
study such as this. The history of acupuncture specifically is one in which
unblinded pilot studies tend to be positive, but then follow up well-controlled 
blinded acupuncture studies have tended to be negative. If history is any judge,
these results will not hold up under further study, and therefore changes to
clinical practice are premature.

This episode is just one example of the hazard of studying was is essentially a 
nonsensical system – the notion that acupuncture needles placed in specific (and
non-existent) acupoints can cause specific physiological effects. The authors
write:

   “Although the treatment effect of acupuncture appears promising, the
   mechanism underlying its success as a treatment for amblyopia remains
   unclear,” the authors write. Targeting vision-related acupoints may change
   the activity of the visual cortex, the part of the brain that receives data
   from the eyes. It may also increase blood flow to the eye and surrounding
   structures as well as stimulate the generation of compounds that support the 
   growth of retinal nerves, they note.

There is no evidence for such wild speculation about possible mechanisms of
acupuncture, and speculating about mechanisms is premature when the best
acupuncture studies all find no effect.

This is the merry-go-round of such highly implausible but culturally supported
therapies. Studies that carefully control for the specific elements of
acupuncture (sticking needles through the skin at specific points) show no
effect from those specific elements. As I have written many times before – it
doesn’t matter where you stick the needles or even if you stick the needles.
What we get from acupuncture, at best, are very non-specific effects from the
therapeutic ritual that surrounds acupuncture. There also appears to be
non-specific effects from the local trauma of piercing the skin with needles,
essentially mechanisms that dampen down pain and inflammation following local
trauma.

Proponents of acupuncture typically will justify the claim that “acupuncture
works” with these non-specific effects, missing the point (either naively or
disingenuously) that non-specific effects do not justify specific claims or
mechanisms. Often the claim is made that it does not matter how acupuncture
works (again, missing the point) if it shows some clinical utility –
non-specific effects (the argument goes) are worthwhile.

But such arguments are ultimately a bait-and-switch, a desperate attempt at
misinterpreting the literature to justify the specific interventions of
acupuncture. And then – with the next acupuncture study that does not control
for needle location or insertion (those elements that define acupuncture) the
authors happily credit a positive result to the specific elements of acupuncture
and start speculating wildly about possible specific physiological mechanisms.

And around we go again on the merry-go-round of acupuncture – a
poorly-controlled and unblinded study with (not surprisingly) positive results. 
The authors are superficially circumspect, but ultimately promote the findings
as sufficient to justify clinical practice and continued speculation about the
magical mechanisms of acupuncture. Follow up studies (when they occur) tend to
be negative, meaning that any positive effects have nothing to do with the
acupuncture itself, in which case proponents trumpet the non-specific and
placebo effects as also supporting acupuncture (head I win, tails I win).

The ultimate problem is that the underlying notions of acupuncture itself – that
there are specific acupuncture points on the body, and that there are
mysterious energies that can be manipulated by sticking needles in these points 
that then have specific physiological effects – are highly implausible. They
are, in fact, nothing but pre-scientific superstition. The energy and
acupuncture points of acupuncture, according to decades of research and multiple
independent lines of evidence, simply do not exist. Acupuncture is ultimately a
shell game of preliminary unreliable results and misinterpreted
non-specific/placebo effects.

Acupuncture for Coronary Artery Disease

Mark Crislip on March 4, 2016

Link



Pictured: Really, really bad idea, on all levels; literal, metaphorical,
pedagogical, tautological, hemodynamic, pathological, basically all the -ics,
-cals, and -als.

I have spent the last 35 years mostly in acute care medicine. Spending my day in
the hospital gives me the bias that we are fragile creatures who can die
unexpectedly and easily. Much of the time we pull patients through, but I have a
great respect for acute diseases. Over the years I have seen too many people
wake up feeling good and dead by dinner time

There is a reason the phrase is “as serious as a heart attack”. Heart attacks
and heart arrhythmias can kill. About 5% of patients admitted to the hospital
with a heart attack die. And 250,000 have sudden death each year, never making
it to the hospital, succumbing to their ventricular fibrillation precipitated by
acute coronary ischemia. Ted Cruz notwithstanding, you need a functioning heart
to live.

Scary stuff. So when I read Pubmed articles like “Effects of Acupuncture at the 
Yintang and the Chengjiang Acupoints on Cardiac Arrhythmias and Neurocardiogenic
Syncope in Emergency First Aid“, I wonder what is going on in the minds of some
people.

And now for a terrible idea

The authors, acupuncturists and non-MDs (physiotherapists as best I can tell),
note in their introduction that:

   Epidemiological studies report overall mortality rates of 30% on average,
   with half the deaths occurring in the first 2 hours of the event and 14% of
   the deaths occurring before the patient receives any medical care.

So what do they do? Think their experience with guitar hero makes them ready for
play in place of Jimmy Page.

   A 45 year old woman … had a previous history of a valvuloplasty for rheumatic
   disease and two acute myocardial infarctions, followed by four
   catheterizations and an angioplasty.

So a patient with severe cardiac disease, someone who could easily die from
their heart disease. When the patient has syncope, tachycardia, hypotension,
tachypnea, and precordial pain, all signs of impending death, these
acupuncturists responded by calling 911 and then? They needled and pushed:

   …the YinTang acupoint and stimulation of the ChengJiang acupoint through
   acupressure were performed for 20 minutes…The harmonization of an acupuncture
   point was performed with the needle inserted perpendicular to the energy
   channel…Needles were inserted at the YinTang and the ChengJiang acupoints,
   and the patient received nonstop 1 minute stimulation…Stimulations by using
   the needles were then performed every 5 minutes, and the vital signs were
   monitored by using a pulse oximeter, a sphygmomanometer, a stethoscope, and
   RR and blood glucose measurements. The needles remained in place for 20
   minutes and were then removed, and the stimulation ceased. The patient’s
   condition was stabilized. After 20 minutes and after the acupuncture
   procedure had been completed, the mobile ICU arrived at the scene.
   Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) states that the treatment of the heart
   must be addressed indirectly and not by the emperor (the heart itself), but
   rather through the emperors ministers (masters of the heart); in this case,
   however, the masters of the heart were not used because the purpose was to
   restore the vital functions through a harmonization of Shen.

I get chest pain reading this nonsense being performed on a high risk cardiac
patient as if the gibberish means something.

Fortunately for the patient the episode was self-limited, as is sometimes the
case. Of course, the acupuncturists took the credit for the improvement,
believing the:

   acupuncture at YinTang and ChenJiang acupoints induced cardiovascular
   responses, increased the limits of the body’s homeostasis, and normalized the
   patient’s condition in the case of syncope. Acupuncture using a combination 
   of ChengJiang and YinTang acupoints had an immediate effect on the autonomic 
   nervous system and on maintaining homeostasis and energy balance in the body.

This demonstrates how delusional alternative providers can be. They conclude:

   However, it is worth mentioning that even though this technique is effective,
   the patient may still need to be referred to the Emergency Room.

You think? It gives me the willies to think people with potentially fatal
processes are getting this kind of nonsense waiting for the ambulance to arrive.
And it wasn’t in Asia, where acupuncture is part of the culture, but Brazil.

Who brags in the medical literature that they treated an acute cardiac event
with pseudo-science and then, as an aside, suggests real medicine? The authors
do not need a publication and approval of their Ethics committee, they need to
be reprimanded for putting patients at risk through incompetence, since as best 
I can tell none of the authors are physicians who might take care of acute
cardiac pathology. Which makes it worse. Next they will open a clinic in
Florida.

Also, I have to mention that they have what look to be computer drawn
representations of the acupuncture points on the human head and they have a
black bar across the eyes so we can’t recognize the people in the drawing. What?
It is so obvious that one is DB Cooper. After bailing from the plane he escaped
to Brazil to become an acupuncture point model. Case sol-ved.

Sometimes I suspect I am spoiled by journals like Clinical Infectious Disease
and The New England Journal Medicine where the articles are not produced by an
8th grader with a mimeograph machine.

Yet more terrible ideas

Others are trying to die from their heart attack. When Russ Mason of Micronesia 
was having his second heart attack his wife, who evidently wants the life
insurance, took off for an acupuncturist:

   In the 40 minutes I had to wait while she drove from Santa Lourdes to As
   Matuis and back, I was in dire distress. I couldn’t lay down, I couldn’t sit 
   up, I couldn’t do much of anything. I took my meds and some aspirin and
   immediately felt the need to vomit, but nothing came out. What a wretch I
   was. I sipped some water with baking soda and that soothed me.

The acupuncturist took his pulse, knew the problem, and gave acupuncture to fix 
his heart. And for added measure:

   Sometimes the doctor grabs me, vigorously rubs my head, my eye sockets, and, 
   at one point, got me into a hammer lock and yanked me up in my chair. He said
   that my spine was out of alignment but that it was OK now.

Whoa.

Russ liked the personal attention:

   Instead of one serious practitioner who did everything, there was a steady
   stream of doctors, nurses and other personnel who would breeze in, do
   something important and then breeze out again. I like the Chinese doctor
   better, frankly. It’s more personal and immediate.

And he concludes about his heart condition

   I think I’ll be OK. That is my hope, anyway.

I hope so too. But given his current “doctor”, I would not be so optimistic.

I never meta worse analysis of terrible ideas

I keep wondering what in the hell Institutional Review Boards are doing. I was
surprised to find there are enough clinical trials for angina and acupuncture to
do a meta-analysis:

   Total 8 RCTs, including 640 angina pectoris cases with 372 patients received 
   acupuncture therapy and 268 patients received conventional drugs, were
   included.

They note:

   Angina pectoris is a common symptom imperiling patients’ life quality.

Quality, hell, how about life?

   In patients with stable [coronary heart disease], the annual mortality rate
   is 1% to 3%, and the annual rate of major CV events is 1% to 2%. In a
   registry of 38 602 patients with stable CHD, the 1-year rate of CV death was 
   1.9% (95% confidence interval, 1.7 to 2.1) and of CV death, myocardial
   infarction (MI), or stroke was 4.5% (95% confidence interval, 4.2 to 4.8).

Who in their right mind allows a theatrical placebo, or as I prefer, a curse
removal, to be used in a clinical trial for a disease that kill 3% of people a
year? China. I suppose it is a form of population control.

As is always the case, the ‘acupuncture’ was acupunctures: acupuncture or
acupuncture plus moxibustion or acupuncture plus cupping or acupuncture plus ear
pressure or electroacupuncture. As I have mentioned before, there is not
acupuncture, but acupunctures, as many kinds as there are practitioners. And the
authors do not see this as limitation of the studies.

And these studies compared acupuncture with controls that included Shanhai Dan
capsule (a popular angina treatment) or, on occasion, real medications. The only
saving grace for the poor soon-to-have-sudden-death patients enrolled in the
studies is that the interventions lasted at most 4- 6 weeks.

None of the studies had a sham acupuncture control and the authors were unaware,
or didn’t care, about the classic Western (used sarcastically) studies of
internal mammary artery ligation for angina back in the 1960s, where sham
surgery was as effective as the real procedure for improving angina. Those who
do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it.

They suggest that:

   Acupuncture may be an effective therapy for stable angina pectoris.

Which can only be met with a snort of derision and a suggestion that Chinese
cardiac patients to not buy any long-term magazine subscriptions.

Another (!!!) meta-analysis of acupuncture for angina suggested:

   However, compared with conventional treatment, acupuncture showed a longer
   delay before its onset of action. This indicates that acupuncture is not
   suitable for emergency treatment of heart attack.

Oh, Brazil, are you paying attention?

Of course, the studies are all are “high risk of bias” and as a result:

   The findings showed very low evidence to support the use of acupuncture for
   improving angina symptoms and ECG of angina patients. However, the quality of
   the trials included in this study was low. Large and rigorously designed
   trials are needed to confirm the potential benefit and adverse events of
   acupuncture.

A problem with many of these studies is the studies are in China, published in
Chinese journals and, as has been pointed out before, there are no negative
acupuncture studies in China.

Conclusion: Treating a heart attack with acupuncture is a terrible idea

Angina is treated both chronically and acutely. You can’t be pushing a
lawnmower, have chest pain, then run, or walk slowly, to get acupunctures. For
the duration of the study, they get to stop the routine of their day and go lie 
down somewhere, relax, and get acupunctures, removing, for a time, any risk for 
angina. Nothing like nap time to reduce demand on the heart. These patients are 
compared to people who continue to live their normal lives. Not a surprise that 
people who take time off to lie down have fewer anginal attacks than those who
remain active. It is a methodological hole you could fly a 747 through.

At least no one, well almost no one, uses acupuncture for an acute myocardial
infarction (heart attack).

Study on Acupuncture for Angina

Another acupuncture study claims positive results, but is plagued by
methodological flaws and dubious results.

Steven Novella on July 31, 2019

Link



The cycle should by now be very familiar – a new acupuncture study purports to
show that acupuncture works for something. The press eats it up gullibly.
Proponents shout it from the rooftops, declaring that they finally have proof.
But then skeptics point out the deep flaws in the study and that it really
doesn’t prove anything. Unfortunately this cycle has resulted in the slow creep 
of acupuncture into medicine, because most people don’t pay attention long
enough to read the critical analysis.

So let’s complete the cycle for yet another acupuncture study, this one for
chronic stable angina – heart pain resulting from poor circulation. Here are the
main findings:

   This randomized clinical trial that included 404 patients with chronic stable
   angina found that acupuncture on the acupoints in the disease-affected
   meridian significantly reduced the frequency of angina attacks compared with 
   acupuncture on the acupoints on the nonaffected meridian, sham acupuncture,
   and no acupuncture.

Superficially it seems reasonable. The size is not huge but it’s not small
either. There are appropriate controls, and they said it was blinded. The
results are all statistically significant:

   Mean changes in frequency of angina attacks differed significantly among the 
   4 groups at 16 weeks: a greater reduction of angina attacks was observed in
   the DAM group vs the NAM group (difference, 4.07; 95% CI, 2.43-5.71;
   P < .001), in the DAM group vs the SA group (difference, 5.18; 95% CI,
   3.54-6.81; P < .001), and in the DAM group vs the WL group (difference, 5.63 
   attacks; 95% CI, 3.99-7.27; P < .001).

OK, so why am I not convinced? Of course, one clinical study is never convincing
by itself, but beyond that there are plenty of reasons to be suspicious of this
study. First, it purports show that acupuncture in the “correct” meridians is
more effective than in the “incorrect” meridians. I use scare quotes because
over a century of medical science leads to the extremely firm conclusion that
meridians do not exist. They have no basis is anatomy, physiology, biology, or
reality. They are based entirely on prescientific notions of life energy. So it 
is appropriate to look skeptically on any study that claims suddenly they are
real, just as I would be skeptical of a study that claimed that the four humors 
or miasmas were real.

We also have thousands of clinical studies which overwhelmingly show no
difference in effect from doing acupuncture in different locations. The few
studies that do show a difference are outliers. Further, it’s not just the
number of studies, but the quality of studies that matter. The better studies
tend to show no difference, and it only seems like you see a difference if there
is one or more major flaws in the study. So what about this one?

One major flaw you have to read deep into the study to find is that the
“acupuncture” treatments included electrical stimulation. Electrical stimulation
is a treatment unto itself, with its own physiological effects.
“Electroacupuncture” is simply a way to mix two different interventions, so that
they cannot be teased apart. So we then have no idea which component had the
effect. History here is a guide, however, as many of the studies that purport to
show acupuncture works cheat by actually doing electrical stimulation in the
guise of acupuncture.

Further, the study was single-blinded in that the acupuncturists who were doing 
the acupuncture were not blinded. They knew if they were in the treatment group 
or not. This is a critical flaw, and prior studies show that the interaction
with the acupuncturist is actually the most important factor in determining a
subjective response. To compound this weakness, there was no attempt to measure 
the success of patient blinding. So it is highly possible that the
acupuncturists influenced the subjects, and that this was entirely responsible
for the observed effect.

In support of this conclusion is the fact that there was very little difference 
between the sham acupuncture and no intervention groups. This flies in the face 
of usual outcomes in such trials. In prior acupuncture trials looking at
subjective outcomes, there is almost always a difference in the unblinded
comparison between getting some type of acupuncture (real, sham, or simulated)
and the no intervention group. The lack of a significant difference in this
study to me strongly suggests that the sham acupuncture group was unblinded by
their interactions with the acupuncturist.

Underlying this conclusion is the fact that the outcome was entirely subjective 
– reports of angina. There were no objective physiological measures to back up
simply recording symptoms.

So once again, we have a purely subjective outcome, with poor blinding, no
assessment of the blinding, and dubious outcomes (lack of a difference between
sham acupuncture and nothing). Further, the results are muddied by the use of
electrical stimulation.

Finally there is a meta-reason, if you will, to be suspicious of this study – as
noted by Edzard Ernst, the authors are all Chinese and affiliated with schools 
of acupuncture or Traditional Chinese Medicine. It is legitimate to consider the
role of bias in assessing a study, and cultural and political biases can be
powerful. But we don’t have to speculate about this, we have evidence.

In 1998 Vickers et al published a review of acupuncture studies in various
countries and found that:

   No trial published in China or Russia/USSR found a test treatment to be
   ineffective.

That’s right – 100% of acupuncture studies published in China were positive.
Even for a treatment that clearly works, this result is all but statistically
impossible. It is powerful evidence of bias, probably a combination of
researcher bias and publication bias. Lest you think this result is 21 years old
and therefore perhaps no longer valid, an updated study in 2014 again found
that:

   This review found 847 reported randomized clinical trials of acupuncture in
   Chinese journals. 99.8% of these reported positive results.

There is even evidence to partially explain these suspicious results. Reviews
have found lower methodological standard in Chinese acupuncture studies,
compared to the West:

   The methodological quality was lower than the international standard and only
   one RCT paper described the trial technological process. And there were a
   less reports about influencing RCT quality, such as acupuncturist’s
   qualification and education background (3.06%), adverse reaction (4.23%),
   blind method (5.98%) and follow-up (14.43%).

Meanwhile a 2017 review found that only 8.7% of clinical trials of TCM (half of 
which are acupuncture studies) that were registered in clinicaltrials.gov had
reported their findings. So there is evidence of poor methodology and
publication bias. The current study is a great example of what we typically see 
– there is always wiggle room in the methodology for a little bit of bias,
sufficient to explain the results.

After decades and thousands of acupuncture studies, there is simply no reason
for these methodological flaws, which have all been pointed out numerous times
before. Unless, of course, they are a feature and not a bug. The really rigorous
studies of acupuncture tend to be negative, and consistently show no effect
from needle position or penetration. The totality of the clinical evidence
strongly favors the conclusion that acupuncture is a theatrical placebo will
little actual specific therapeutic effect.

Cutting corners on methodological rigor is one way to manufacture positive
evidence. There is strong cultural and political pressure to promote TCM, and
China has been plagued by scientific misconduct and fraud that dwarfs other
countries in its magnitude.

Once again we have a study being promoted as a game-changer for acupuncture, but
is actually just more of the same – highly flawed, and completely unconvincing.

                           Acupuncture for Depression

                                 Steven Novella

                                      Link

One of the basic principles of science-based medicine is that a single study
rarely tells us much about any complex topic. Reliable conclusions are derived
from an assessment of basic science (i.e prior probability or plausibility) and 
a pattern of effects across multiple clinical trials. However the mainstream
media generally report each study as if it is a breakthrough or the definitive
answer to the question at hand. If the many e-mails I receive asking me about
such studies are representative, the general public takes a similar approach,
perhaps due in part to the media coverage.

I generally do not plan to report on each study that comes out as that would be 
an endless and ultimately pointless exercise. But occasionally focusing on a
specific study is educational, especially if that study is garnering a
significant amount of media attention. And so I turn my attention this week to a
recent study looking at acupuncture in major depression during pregnancy. The
study concludes:

The short acupuncture protocol demonstrated symptom reduction and a response
rate comparable to those observed in standard depression treatments of similar
length and could be a viable treatment option for depression during pregnancy.

Plausibility

The study compared acupuncture designed specifically to treat depression, and in
fact tailored to the individual patient, according to principles of Traditional
Chinese Medicine (TCM). This was compared to two control groups – a control
acupuncture that was not specific to depression and massage. The comparison to
massage was obviously not blinded and therefore, in my opinion, of very little
value as depression is highly susceptible to non-specific therapeutic effects
and both interventions – acupuncture and massage – would be likely to create
such non-specific effects.

The interesting aspect of this study is the comparison between treatment
acupuncture (targeted for depression) and control acupuncture (not targeted for 
depression). The purpose of the study was to control, as much as possible, for
any other variables so as to determine if the underlying TCM principles have any
validity – does it matter where the needles are placed?

We can really only put this study into context if we first consider the prior
probability of this claim. I would argue that there is already a large body of
acupuncture research that collectively shows needle placement as a variable has 
no effect on clinical outcome. This one study does little to alter the balance
of that evidence.

Further, from a basic science point of view, the TCM principles have essentially
no plausibility. The underlying theory is that there is an undetected life
force (chi) that is partly responsible for health and illness, that acupuncture 
needles placed in specific acupuncture points alters the flow and strength of
this energy, resulting in a clinical outcome. Chi has no existence in science,
however. Vitalistic philosophies such as chi were discarded over a century ago
as both unnecessary and without any empirical foundation.

Any modern attempts to explain acupuncture effects with known physiological
phenomena might explain non-specific needling effects, but cannot explain any
differences due to needle placement, and do not provide any explanation for the 
location of alleged acupuncture points.

Therefore, given the extremely low prior probability of the claims of this
study, nothing short of a large rigorous and replicated study would alter our
assessment of validity of acupuncture as a specific intervention.

The Current Study

This new study, published in the Obstetrics and Gynecology, is not of sufficient
quality to justify the conclusions of the authors. The authors did do a decent 
job of trying to rigorously control the comparison between the two acupuncture
groups. Subjects were blinded to which group they were in, as were those
evaluating the outcome. Standard depressions scales were used. They even made a 
reasonable attempt to blind the acupuncturists, using a novel method (to my
knowledge).

They had experienced acupuncturists design a treatment and control acupuncture
regimen for each subject, and then had a “junior acupuncturist” (less than two
years experience) perform the treatment without being told which one they were
giving.

This, in my opinion, in the crux of the methodology – were the treating
acupuncturists properly blinded. The study authors took the very useful step of 
assessing the degree of blinding of the acupuncturists and the subjects.
Unfortunately for the validity of the study, they found that the treating
acupuncturists were significantly more likely to have positive expectations for 
the treatment group than the control group – so their blinding methods failed
with respect to the treating acupuncturists. The study was therefore, at best,
single blinded. Test subjects did not have any significant difference in
expectations.

Because depression is so amenable to non-specific therapeutic effects, the
expectations of the treating acupuncturist can plausibly have had a significant 
effect on the final outcomes. This is the primary weakness of the study – but
there are other worth mentioning.

The author also, for some reason, did not stratify the test subject according to
race, and there turned out to be significantly more African Americans in the
control acupuncture group than the treatment group. Cultural beliefs can have a 
significant effect on responses to different kinds of placebos, particularly
needles. This is therefore a potential, if unknown, confounder.

The results were also not impressive. The study used the Hamilton Rating Scale
for depression:

Interpretation of Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression scores is as follows:
less than 7, nondepressed; 8–13, mild depression; 14–18, moderate depression;
19–22, severe depression; more than 23, very severe depression.

At 8 weeks the control acupuncture groups has about a 9 point drop in the scale,
while the treatment acupuncture group dropped 11.5 points. On this scale that
is a modest clinical effect. There was also no difference in remission rates
among the three groups. In addition this was a relatively small study (141
treated in total, divided among the three groups) with a 23% drop out rate.

Conclusion

Therefore we have a small and improperly blinded and randomized study showing a 
modest clinical effect. This does not significantly alter the low prior
probability of a treatment effect from needle placement.

This study should also be considered in the context of other trials looking at
acupuncture and depression. This very recent Cochrane review concluded:

We found insufficient evidence to recommend the use of acupuncture for people
with depression. The results are limited by the high risk of bias in the
majority of trials meeting inclusion criteria.

Specifically – there was no difference between verum acupuncture and sham
acupuncture in the clinical trials reviewed.

Given the low plausibility and overall negative character of the clinical
evidence, it is reasonable to conclude that no further research into acupuncture
for any indication is warranted. However, acupuncture is a modality with
dedicated practitioners (acupuncturists) and proponents (by contrast, for
example, there is no medical specialty dedicated to a particular drug – there
are no penicillinists). And therefore it is likely that further research will be
conducted.

In that event, given existing research, it would be useful to conduct only
highly rigorous trials, using sham and/or placebo acupuncture (where the needle 
or fake needle does not penetrate the skin) with adequate blinding. Such trials 
would need to be large with consistent replicated positive results in order to
have sufficient weight to overturn the current mass of basic and clinical
evidence.

Does Acupuncture Increase Red and White Blood Cells and T-Cells?

An article by a medical acupuncturist claims that acupuncture increases red and 
white blood cells and T-cells. The evidence is far from convincing.

Harriet Hall on January 25, 2022

Link


Will this increase red and white blood cells and T-cells? I don’t think so!

One of my fans sent me a clipping from a community newsletter, Colorado
Serenity, with an article by acupuncturist Christina Fick, who calls herself a
doctor. The title is “Give Your Immune System Some Love!” It is full of
pseudoscientific advice about the things that harm and help the immune system.
My correspondent thought it was “a cornucopia of questionable medical advice and
treatments, including her own proprietary mushroom medley, which is bad
enough.” But what really concerned him was the claim that acupuncture increases 
your red and white blood cell counts, along with your T-cell counts. He searched
the Internet and found a few supporting articles about red and white blood
cells; but none were from a reputable medical source, and he was unable to find 
any mention of T-cells.

My own review of the evidence

I did my own search online, consulting sources like PubMed and Google Scholar.

This study by a Turkish author in a Korean acupuncture journal discussed
acupuncture and autoimmune diseases. The language is too garbled to make any
sense out of it. Example: “What we said? Autoimmun diseases’ starting places are
spesific and same all of them. And all of them is starting from mesodermal
layer. This is a detail that we noticed and highligtened.”

An article in US Pharmacist asked “Does Acupuncture Have a Role in Managing
Chemotherapy-Induced Leukopenia?” It was a systematic review but the authors
characterized it as “preliminary” and “hypothesis-generating.”

Many acupuncture websites claim that acupuncture improves immunity, for
instance:

   acupuncture is commonly used for post chemotherapy cancer patients to help
   alleviate side effects of chemo such as anemia (low red blood cell count),
   leukopenia (low white blood cell count). Multiple studies have shown that
   Acupuncture in form of Electro-acupuncture and/or acupuncture with Moxa
   increase leukocytes (White blood cells) and may improve immunity.

Note: oncology websites that discuss treatment of chemotherapy-induced
neutropenia do not mention acupuncture.

A 2013 systematic review found that acupuncture was an effective adjunct for
chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting but found that efficacy for other
symptoms was undetermined due to high risk of bias in the studies.

Many of the supporting studies were in animals. One found that helper T cells
derived from the bone marrow were activated via the sympathetic nervous system
stimulated by acupuncture – in mice!

A 2015 study found that bee venom acupuncture(!) alleviates experimental
autoimmune encephalomyelitis by upregulating regulatory T-cells.

Who is Christina Fick?

She bills herself as “one of the top acupuncturists’s [sic] in the nation.”
After suffering from Lyme disease she studied acupuncture to learn how it had
helped her. She runs Evergreen Medical Acupuncture in Evergreen, Colorado, with 
two other acupuncturists. They offer a number of questionable “holistic” and
“functional medicine” treatments including electric dry needling, cupping,
kinesio taping, cosmetic acupuncture, and fertility acupuncture. They treat
“chronic Lyme disease”. Their store sells Fick’s Orvience line of overpriced
supplements, vitamins, detox, nootropics, superfoods, luxury soaps, and skin
products.

Conclusion: The evidence that acupuncture increases red and white blood cells
and T-cells is far from convincing

    2. I had to agree with my correspondent. It is possible to find studies that
      support those claims, but they are scattershot, often in animals rather
      than humans, are from unreliable sources, and are obviously biased in
      favor of acupuncture. Even if it can be established that acupuncture has
      those effects on blood tests, that doesn’t necessarily mean it will have
      clinically significant effects on health outcomes in humans. Fick’s
      article recommends all sorts of things that she says will boost your
      immune system or impair it, from margarine and sugar (bad) to vitamins,
      supplements, mushrooms, 60 ounces of water a day, apple cider vinegar, and
      steam showers (all good). Her advice is mere speculation and opinion.
      Since it is not based on credible scientific evidence, it can be
      disregarded.

Acupuncture for Infantile Colic

Another low-quality acupuncture study falls victim to p-hacking and spreads
unsupported claims for the efficacy of this failed treatment.

Steven Novella on January 25, 2017

Link



A recent study [PDF] looks at the use of acupuncture in the treatment of
infantile colic. If it seems counterintuitive to stick needles into a crying
baby, in this case your intuition is a reasonable guide. Time reports about the 
study in an article titled “The Soothing Benefit of Acupuncture for Babies,”
which begins:

   Acupuncture may help babies who cry too much, according to a new study
   published in the journal Acupuncture in Medicine.

The BBC did a better job with the headline: Can acupuncture ease baby colic?
which begins:

   The crying of babies with colic may be reduced if they are treated with
   acupuncture, according to controversial research from Sweden.But UK experts
   say no conclusions can be drawn from the small study of 147 babies aged two
   to eight weeks.

The difference between the two reports seems to be that the BBC consulted Dr.
Edzard Ernst to help put the study into context. Dr. Ernst is an expert in
complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) but is known for taking a
science-based approach to the field. Meanwhile Time quotes a doctor of
Integrative Medicine who gave only fawning praise for the study.

Acupuncture research

Unfortunately, this is a common pattern. There have been several thousand
studies of acupuncture, and despite this massive effort to demonstrate that
sticking thin needles to a certain depth into specific points of the body has a 
therapeutic effect, the research has failed to do so. Systematic reviews of
acupuncture show several clear patterns that are most consistent with the
conclusion that acupuncture does not work. First, when properly controlled for, 
it does not seem to matter where you stick the needles. It also does not seem to
matter if you actually stick needles through the skin. Gently poking the skin
with toothpicks seems to be enough.

What this means is that properly blinded comparisons of acupuncture tend to show
no difference. The only comparisons that show a difference are unblinded –
typically between some type of acupuncture (including fake acupuncture) and no
treatment at all. There does not appear to be any dose-response, the details of 
the treatment do not matter, and the training of the acupuncturist does not
matter. The only reasonable scientific interpretation of this fact is that there
is no specific effect from acupuncture, that it is merely a theatrical placebo 
and any observed effects are non-specific placebo effects.

This would be similar to a drug that only had an effect with unblinded
comparisons to no treatment, but never showed a clear difference to blinded
placebo treatments, that showed no dose response, and where the dosing interval 
or other details did not seem to matter. Further, it was claimed based on this
level of evidence that the drug worked for hundreds of completely unrelated
conditions, without the slightest plausible mechanism. If a drug company
promoted such a drug there would be cries of the evils of “Big Pharma.”

It could be reasonably argued (and we have) that after several thousand studies 
there is simply no reason for further acupuncture research. This is a failed
hypothesis that was never plausible in the first place. If, however, you are
going to conduct acupuncture research at the very least you should do a rigorous
study. We are way past the preliminary research stage with acupuncture, and it 
has already been clearly established that preliminary acupuncture studies are of
no use at all. Such studies tend to be false positive and not replicated by
more rigorous studies. The only reason to do a preliminary acupuncture study at 
this stage is to pad your CV and to promote acupuncture through a credulous
media.

Acupuncture for colic

Colic simply refers to an excessively fussy baby that cries more than three
hours a day, three or more days a week, for three weeks or longer. This is a
benign condition, but can be extremely stressful for the caregivers. The main
treatment is to simply provide some TLC for the baby by holding and cuddling
them. It may also be helpful to remove milk from their diet, and to make sure
they are properly burped after feeding.

There is no reason to think that sticking needles into a colicky baby will be of
any benefit, but acupuncture is a treatment looking for an application, and any
application will do. There have been a few studies of acupuncture for colic.
The only review I could find concluded that the evidence for acupuncture in
colic was limited and inconclusive. Landgren, lead author on the current study, 
responded to this review by publishing the following comment:

   Inconclusive results in the few published articles on the subject can be due 
   to different acupuncture points, different insertion time, different needling
   methods, differences in the outcome variables, in how the crying was
   measured and insufficient sample sizes. Further research is needed on
   understanding the utility, safety, and effectiveness of acupuncture in
   infants with colic.

There is no justification for this conclusion in the acupuncture literature,
which clearly shows that methods, insertion times, and acupuncture points do not
matter. All these details, however, provide endless opportunities to dismiss
negative results. I would also point out that while small sample size does limit
the power of a study to detect a small effect, small studies are more
susceptible to p-hacking and are more likely to be false positive.

It is interesting to note that Landgren went on to do a follow up study, which
was larger than previous studies, but still lacking in sufficient rigor to
definitively answer the question of whether or not acupuncture works for colic. 
He just added another preliminary study generating another round of misleading
promotion of acupuncture.

The study looked at three treatment groups, including two types of acupuncture
(varying in needle location) and usual care, meaning no intervention. There was 
no sham or placebo acupuncture, which in my opinion is a fatal flaw. Again – at 
this point in acupuncture research, a study without at least sham acupuncture is
worthless. The study found no difference between the two acupuncture groups, so
they pooled both of those groups and compared it to the no treatment group and 
found some advantages for acupuncture.

Here is the critical fatal flaw in the study, however. David Colquhoun spells it
out nicely, so I will quote him:

   Table 1 of the paper lists 24 different tests of statistical significance and
   focuses attention on three that happen to give a P value (just) less than
   0.05, and so were declared to be “statistically significant”. If you do
   enough tests, some are bound to come out “statistically significant” by
   chance. They are false positives, and the conclusions are as meaningless as
   “green jelly beans cause acne” in the cartoon. This is called P-hacking and
   it’s a well known cause of problems. It was evidently beyond the wit of the
   referees to notice this naive mistake. It’s very doubtful whether there is
   anything happening but random variability.

Yes, this paper screams p-hacking. In fact table three showed 32 different
statistical analyses, with four being barely or minimally significant, without
any clear pattern. This is consistent with random noise. It should also be noted
that the primary outcome did not achieve statistical significance, which means 
that technically the study was negative. The secondary measures that barely made
it over the 0.05 line were cherry picked.

I would also point out that the study showed no difference between the two types
of acupuncture. Again – it does not matter where you stick the needles, because
acupuncture points are pure pseudoscience. They do not exist. Also, the
researchers decided, because they were treating infants, not to stick the
needles to the “proper” depth to elicit the de qi sensation, the feeling of
tension, ache, or pressure that often accompanies full-depth needling. Rather
they used superficial needling. So this study also demonstrates that it does not
matter if or how you insert needles.

The frequentist fallacy is to conclude that if you can make the numbers show
statistical significance, then there is a real effect. This ignores the very
real problem of p-hacking, which involves massaging the data to squeeze out
statistical significance from noise. Even without p-hacking, p-values are a poor
predictor of whether or not an effect is actually real. David also points out
that a p-value close to 0.05 indicates a false positive rate of 30%. This
increases if you do multiple comparisons, which this study did, and also
increases if the prior plausibility is low, which it is.

The net effect of all this is that the alleged positive effects in this study
(which is really negative) are almost certainly false positive. This study
failed to achieve the rigor necessary to provide reliable results. The results, 
as they are, are technically negative and do not justify the conclusions of the 
authors, nor the press release claiming that acupuncture is a viable option for 
colic.

Conclusion: Acupuncture is not a viable treatment for colic

It is really unacceptable at this point in the arc of acupuncture research to
publish small studies with poor rigor and questionable results. This only serves
to muddy the waters further and cause confusion both professionally and in the 
public. Only the most rigorous studies, with proper control groups and
statistical rigor, address the criticisms of acupuncture and acupuncture
research. This study does not do that.

There is still no reason to recommend acupuncture for colic in infants. There is
no plausible mechanism, the bulk of the vast acupuncture research shows that
acupuncture does not work, and the research for colic specifically is limited
and unconvincing.

Acupuncture for Infant Colic Part 2: Acupuncture Boogaloo

A detailed discussion of infant colic plus a few more thoughts on why
acupuncture does not play a role in science-based management.

Clay Jones on January 27, 2017

Link



On Wednesday, Steve Novella published a post discussing a recently-published
study investigating the use of acupuncture for infant colic, as did a friend of 
SBM back on January 19th. As expected, they did a masterful job pointing out
weaknesses in the study design and the absurdity of the authors’ conclusion when
put into the context of a science-based understanding of acupuncture’s
plausibility and research base. The study is unethical and doesn’t actually
support claims that acupuncture has a specific effect on the amount of daily
infant crying.

But as the pediatrician on the team, I couldn’t resist adding my two cents to
the discussion because it involved infant colic. Colic, and infant crying in
general, is an extremely common concern and it can result in significant
caregiver and family stress. Many parents feel overwhelmed when caring for a new
baby and seek out the help of medical professionals when they believe that
their baby is crying too much. Although this complaint rarely results in the
diagnosis of a serious medical condition, these babies are at higher risk for
abuse and neglect as well as excessive medical diagnostic and treatment
interventions.

I doubt many days go by where a general pediatric medical professional doesn’t
discuss crying with at least one family. And the way we handle these
conversations is incredibly important because we can change the way that
caregivers perceive the health of their child. Our responses can also negatively
impact how parents feel about the medical system in the future.

Back in 2013 I compared postthe science-based medical approach to colic with
that of chiropractic. In that post, I go into a bit more detail on possible
causes of colic as well as various treatment approaches, so I encourage readers 
to check it out. In this post, I’ll cover the important highlights along with a 
few new thoughts before coming back around to the aforementioned study.

What is colic?

All babies cry to varying degrees, usually only intermittently and in response
to their environment. And babies are no different than the rest of us in that
they have a range of temperaments. There is a normal distribution of crying in
healthy babies with some falling on either end of a spectrum, particularly in
the first 3-4 months of life when most crying takes place.

Sometimes crying in infants crosses what is essentially an arbitrary threshold
of “too much.” That is all colic really is. We have traditionally used the
Wessel criteria, or “rule of three”, which states that colic is an appropriate
designation when an otherwise-healthy infant cries for more than three hours per
day, more than three days a week, and it lasts longer than three weeks. But
widespread use as a nebulous descriptor for any young baby who is fussy for
unclear reasons has essentially rendered the label meaningless.

There is also a normal distribution of caregiver responses to crying. Some take 
it in stride while others are much more sensitive. Some see any crying beyond
some arbitrary personal cutoff in duration or severity as a sign of pain or
illness. Perception is reality and some parents subjectively assess their
children as crying both longer and more intensely than a more objective
determination would show. Being forced to rely on parental report can result in 
some infants being given a medical label, which can serve as a self-fulfilling
prophecy of sorts.

We often focus on anecdotal descriptions of colic that many believe to be
specific to it, such as the belief that episodes of colic start and stop
suddenly, with no clear inciting event or environmental variable. Many believe
that colic is more common in the evening (“the witching hour“) and is
subjectively more intense, urgent, or painful than “normal” crying. Many believe
that colic spells don’t respond to soothing as easily as regular crying. All of
this may be true, but then again many caregivers and pediatricians also falsely
believe that they can predict when a tooth will emerge based on a particular
constellation of symptoms.

Ultimately, we don’t really know if colic represents actual pathology or if it
is primarily a psychosocial construct. I tend to lean towards the latter and
believe that many babies diagnosed with colic have temperaments that are a poor 
fit with their caregivers’ tolerance levels. But as I’ll discuss shortly, I
believe that the subjective nature of the assessment of crying and the symptom
overlap with a very short list of possible medical ailments, forces me to leave 
some cerebral wiggle room.

A very little colic epidemiology

According to the lore passed down from one generation of medical professionals
to the next, about one out of every three infants will develop colic in the
first few months of life. But we don’t really know if this is true. Depending on
criteria used, the incidence is anywhere from 8 to almost 50 percent in various
surveys.

Most babies labeled as colicky don’t fit any strict criteria. No matter how you 
slice it, the determination is entirely based on subjective parental report.
Perhaps this is a question that big data and the “internet of things” will be
able to eventually answer as baby monitors are fairly ubiquitous these days.

Nothing has been shown to reliably increase the likelihood of developing colic, 
not even when comparing formula and breast fed babies. Probably the closest we
have to a solid association are psychosocial factors such as parental stress and
a lack of parental self-confidence. But does stress somehow impact parental
interactions with the infant, leading to more crying? Does it alter the
intrauterine environment? Or does stress and parental insecurity alter the
caregiver’s perception of how much their baby is crying?

What causes colic?

By definition, babies diagnosed with colic cry a lot but are healthy as far as
we can tell based on a thorough history and physical exam. But not every
possible underlying pathology is obvious and easy to diagnose. It is extremely
likely that there is a self-limited but treatable organic etiology in a small
subset of these babies that has gone undiagnosed.

Despite the plausibility of some cases of colic having an organic cause, we
don’t have a lot of good evidence to support this. What we have, such as it is, 
breaks potential causes down into three general categories: the gut, biologic,
and psychosocial. The gut is by far the category which has garnered the most
attention. Again, for a much more detailed discussion of these categories please
read my 2013 post on the subject.

Allergy to cow milk protein is probably the most plausible potential disease
process leading to a diagnosis of colic. It is fairly common and can result in a
persistently fussy baby. Most babies will develop visibly bloody stools, but
milder cases might not. I actually agree with the authors of the acupuncture
study when they recommend that a specialized formula, or maternal dairy
restriction if breastfeeding, should be considered when crying is felt to be
excessive.

Other proposed causes involving the gut are fruit juice intolerance (don’t give 
babies juice), differences in intestinal microflora (isn’t everything these
days?), and gas.

Conditions in the biologic category include migraines (not likely), feeding
difficulties (almost certainly plays a role in some cases), immaturity (brain
and/or gut), and prenatal/postnatal nicotine and/or tobacco smoke exposure
(plausible). There are some correlation-versus-causation concerns in this
category, but it isn’t hard to imagine some of these playing a role in excessive
crying in some infants.

The most important category in my opinion is psychosocial. This includes infant 
temperament, hypersensitivity to stimuli, and the parental factors I’ve
mentioned several times already. I say it is the most important not just because
of the causal role I believe it plays in labeling a baby as colicky but also
because caregiver stress and their ability to manage it is important regardless 
of whether or not the child is actually crying a lot.

How is colic managed?

When a caregiver is worried about crying, it is of extreme importance to
evaluate for any condition or environment that could put the child at risk of
harm. It really doesn’t matter if a caregiver’s description meets any potential 
diagnostic criteria for infant colic. Even if the baby only cries for 30 minutes
a week, it is vital to take any parent asking for help seriously.

To make sure that a baby is safe, and does not suffer from a serious illness or 
live in a home where caregiver stress is a possible risk factor for neglect or
abuse, there are many important questions to ask besides those that cover the
nature of the crying itself. It is perhaps equally if not more important to ask 
how the caregiver, and the family as a whole, feels about the crying and how
they have reacted to it. This can serve as an entry into a broader discussion
about stress and anxiety and reveal areas of childcare that may be amenable to
reassurance and education.

After discussing the problem, a thorough exam is necessary. Are there any
concerning physical finding that could be a clue to illness or abuse? Are there 
any signs of pain that might not be related to possible colic? Again, infant
colic is a diagnosis of exclusion.

There is no one-size-fits-all treatment approach to infant colic. But, if after 
a thorough evaluation and assessment of the need for parental support, a
diagnosis of colic is made, then a reasonable approach in many cases may be to
simply reassure and educate as needed. Infant colic will stop on its own, often 
by 3 months of age, and nearly all infants have significantly improved by 4
months. This is why infant colic is such a perfect condition for practitioners
of irregular medicine. Crying duration and severity is subjective and colic will
get better on its own, so it is easy to assume incorrectly that an intervention
has worked.

So what is the appropriate approach when a pediatrician and family decide
together that an intervention is necessary? I do not think anyone would describe
any of the proposed treatments as well-supported in the pediatric literature,
but some have a better evidence base than others. First and foremost is
addressing and managing parental stress. This may lead to a new perspective on
the crying and remove the desire to intervene medically. Teaching simple
soothing techniques can be an instant cure in many cases.

Based on the available evidence, the additional intervention that has the best
chance of helping decrease the duration and intensity of crying episodes is
initiating a trial of specialized formula containing no intact cow’s milk
protein, or having a breastfeeding mother remove dairy from her diet. All other 
interventions likely only seem to work because of parental placebo and colic’s
natural course. These include feeding techniques to reduce swallowed air,
probiotics, and the use of pacifiers, baby swings and infant massage.

No medication is both effective and safe for use in the treatment of infant
colic and drugs are rarely prescribed. Even the extremely popular OTC drug
simethicone (Mylicon) has failed to demonstrate benefit. Other potential
treatment modalities that have failed the test of science are numerous herbal
remedies, homeopathy, various manipulative techniques such as chiropractic and
craniosacral therapy, and acupuncture.

Now back to that study

As I mentioned in the introduction, Steve and Orac did a damn good job
dismantling the conclusions made by the authors of this abysmal study. Just in
case you didn’t read their posts, I’ll provide a quick review. Acupuncture
research methodology is generally pretty awful and in many cases seemingly
designed to be positive by avoiding the use of proper blinding and placebo
controls. When evaluating the acupuncture literature, the only rational
conclusion is that acupuncture doesn’t work for any condition. It doesn’t matter
where the needles are inserted, or even if they were inserted. What matters is 
that subjects, parents, or in some cases the researchers themselves, believe
that they were.

Specifically regarding the use of acupuncture for colic, Steve and Orac
correctly point out that there is no plausible mechanism for this to work. I’ll 
add that this includes so-called medical acupuncture which attempts to shed the 
vestiges of its prescientific past by replacing beliefs about the flow of Qi
with scientific concepts such as neuromodulation. Sounding more like science
doesn’t make it more like science, however.

They also pointed out that p-hacking almost certainly played a role in the
positive outcome, such as it was, concluded by the study authors. That outcomes 
were cherry picked was painfully obvious. The results represent noise in the
data, and if critically appraised this study is actually negative. But there are
a few additional interesting details that I wanted to mention.

More excuses from biased researchers

The primary outcome being investigated in the study was the difference in total 
crying time, as reported by caregivers, between two groups of infants receiving 
different types of acupuncture. Data was collected multiple times during the
first and second week of the study, and again during a follow-up phone call six 
days after the last treatment. The initial secondary outcome was how many of the
infants in either acupuncture group still met criteria for colic during the
same intervals. They planned on recruiting 192 patients in order for the study
to be sufficiently powered but stopped recruitment well short of that because,
according to the authors, “acupuncture for colic became available in other
clinics without the need for randomization.”

In order to continue the study at that point, they decided to pool the two
acupuncture groups together and compare them to babies that did not undergo any 
acupuncture treatments. This was after they had already been collecting data for
over a year. This is highly suspicious of p-hacking, even if unintentional. In 
their conclusion, they mention that a comparison of the two acupuncture groups
showed no difference in any outcome, which they claim was because of the lack of
power, not appearing to even entertain the possibility that it is because they 
are both equally ineffective beyond placebo. It is clear when reading this paper
that the authors had already decided that acupuncture works.

An embarrassment of outcomes

As I mentioned above, the primary and secondary outcomes of the study as
initially developed involved comparing two acupuncture groups and looking at
total crying time and resolution of colic. They hedged their bets by breaking
crying down into three categories: fussing, crying, and colicky crying. There is
no reason to do this as the diagnostic criteria for colic does not and these
are extremely subjective/meaningless distinctions.

So after a post hoc switch to comparing the combined acupuncture groups to a no 
acupuncture group, they then looked at more than 30 different possible tertiary 
outcomes and found four to be barely statistically significant. Considering the 
questions regarding p-hacking, the small number of patients, and the numerous
potential outcomes, these are likely falsely positives. Then there is the issue 
of blinding.

The issue of blinding

There is no sham acupuncture group in this study, something that actually
doesn’t bother me all that much although it would have been a nice addition.
That’s a study design that must be used if measuring acupuncture outcomes in
older patients but it isn’t that important in babies. But blinding is extremely 
important because parental placebo effects can completely account for the meager
benefits claimed in studies like this.

Blinding was attempted in this study by completely separating the acupuncture
provider from the caregivers. Even the nurse who brought the subject into and
out of the treatment room was supposedly unaware of whether acupuncture was
administered or the baby just sat in the room for a few minutes untouched. They 
even included an assessment of parental blinding at multiple visits and at
follow-up.

One would have expected that parents would guess right about 50% of the time if 
truly blinded. This was roughly true at the first assessment. However, what the 
authors found was that parents of children who received some form of acupuncture
increasingly believed that their child received acupuncture, with 72% correctly
guessing at the follow-up phone call. Less than half of parents of children not
being poked guessed correctly.

The authors, again showing bias, chalked this discrepancy up to the assumption
that the acupuncture was working. So either acupuncture worked really well,
which we know from the actual data would be an unlikely parental conclusion, or 
blinding was not successful. Perhaps the acupuncturist forgot to put the needles
away.

Conclusion: Acupuncture can’t fix colic

Colic is a troublesome entity in the world of pediatric medicine as well as for 
parents. It is an essentially arbitrary distinction that in many cases appears
to result in more harm than benefit. Rather than being seen a simply a child who
tends to cry a bit more than others, or in many cases is simply perceived to do
so, these babies are given a label which promoters of all manner of bogus
treatments can use to effectively manipulate tired and stressed out caregivers.

Believers in acupuncture, even if well-meaning, are doing this. They are denying
the evidence when they recommend their pet therapy and, in the case of the
authors of the acupuncture for colic study, allowing their bias to influence
methodology such that the ultimate conclusion is known before the first subject 
is recruited. Treating an infant like a pincushion is not an effective means of 
reducing their crying or learning how to cope with it.

Acupuncture for Withdrawal Symptoms in Critically Ill Infants

Clay Jones on January 2, 2015

Link



Like acupuncture, Weebles wobble, but they don’t fall down.

The practice of medicine, particularly our pharmaceutical and surgical
interventions, involves a constant struggle between risk and benefit. If the
physiology or anatomy of the human body is altered, even with the best of
intentions, there is always a potential downside. There are certainly instances 
where the risk to benefit ratio is extremely favorable or unfavorable and the
right recommendation is obvious, and unfortunately there are times when it isn’t
entirely obvious what the next step should be. But there has been a trend of
steady progress in regards to improved safety and efficacy over the past several
decades.

The treatment of pain has of late been one of those areas where the picture is
becoming a bit less cloudy. We are learning more and more about the potential
negative outcomes related to the long term use of opioid medications, such as
physical dependence, addiction and even chronic pain. The way that these drugs
have been prescribed in many patients has caused more harm than expected, and in
some instances more hurt than help. Doctors generally strive to alleviate pain 
and suffering but, once again, good intentions don’t decrease risk.

In the neonatal and young infant population, the management of pain has had a
rocky history. I’ve written about pediatric pain in the past, in particular the 
potential difficulties in managing acute pain. I won’t go into detail (read my
prior post), but we have truly come a long way since the days of performing
major surgery on newborns without any analgesia at all. There are areas where we
need to do better, however. Children are still less likely than adults to be
adequately treated for pain.

But things have improved. And as more children receive appropriate management
for pain, the side effects of that management must increasingly be dealt with by
healthcare professionals, the patients and their families. One of the issues
that is typically observed and managed in neonatal and pediatric intensive care 
units is physical dependence and the subsequent occurrence of withdrawal
symptoms.

What are dependence and withdrawal?

No different than with adults, children experience pain for a variety of
reasons, and some require the use of opioid medications for extended periods of 
time. Physical dependence with opioids can occur after just five to seven days
of daily exposure. In the setting of the intensive care unit, there are children
that are sometimes on medications for pain and sedation for weeks and even
longer.

The American Academy of Pediatrics, in their 2014 clinical report on the
subject, provides the following definition for physical dependence:

   Physical dependence is a state of adaptation that is manifested by a drug
   class–specific withdrawal syndrome that can be produced by abrupt cessation, 
   rapid dose reduction, decreasing blood level of the drug, and/or
   administration of an antagonist.

Withdrawal symptoms occur when there is less of the drug in the patient’s
system, which happens for essentially three reasons. As the patient recovers,
opioid pain medication dosing is often decreased or spaced out. Intravenous
medications are switched to oral formulations, which isn’t always a predictable 
transition. And sometimes the absorption of medications is decreased because of 
illness or injury to the gastrointestinal tract. Also, as referred to in the
above definition, a medication that blocks the action of another drug, such as
naloxone (Narcan) used for opioid overdose, can lead to withdrawal symptoms even
when there hasn’t been a drop in the blood level.

Not every pediatric patient experiences withdrawal, and when they do it can be
mild enough to escape the awareness of caregivers or to be blamed on something
else. Is the baby fussy because of mild withdrawal from morphine, or is it just 
gas, for example. Of course the symptoms of more serious conditions can be
blamed on withdrawal as well. When significant withdrawal does occur, it can
interfere with recovery of the patient, expose them to increased risk of
medication side effects and increase caregiver anxiety tremendously.

The most common and obvious changes seen during withdrawal in children are
behavioral. Anxiety, agitation, difficulty sleeping and jitteriness are frequent
examples. Also common in withdrawal are stiffening of the muscles, nausea and
vomiting, poor feeding/appetite, increased respiratory and heart rate, elevated 
body temperature, sweating, and elevated blood pressure.

Allow me to plant a seed and point out that there can be significant
subjectivity to the assessment of most of these manifestations when caring for
neonates and older infants. Was that just a little spit up or should we count it
as an episode of vomiting? Is the baby not interested in the bottle because of 
withdrawal or because premature infants who have been ill sometimes just need
more time to work up on feeds? Is the baby agitated, or just a little
overstimulated? Perception is reality in the case of withdrawal.

There are validated assessment tools, the most well-known probably being the
modified Neonatal Abstinence Scoring System and the Withdrawal Assessment Tool-1
(WAT-1), that can used to help determine if an infant is undergoing symptoms of
withdrawal. These tools can be used in the setting of potential withdrawal from
opioids or benzodiazepine medications. The WAT-1, which I’ll focus on for
reasons that will soon become clear, involves eleven items with a total possible
score of twelve and is performed every twelve hours by a nurse caring for the
patient.

How is the WAT-1 performed?

It breaks down as follows:

  1. The nurse will review what happened over the previous twelve hours. Infants
    score a point (points are bad) for having had any loose/watery stools,
    retching/gagging/vomiting, or temperature elevations above 37.8°C (100°F) up
    to a maximum of 3 points. Again, I’d like to point out the subjectivity
    inherent in this assessment. The nurse must decide if the baby’s stool is
    loose/watery compared to normal baby stools, which are often considered
    loose/watery. Also perfectly healthy babies have spit ups and brief gagging 
    episodes all the time.

  2. The nurse will then observe the baby for two minutes to get a sense of their
    behavioral state prior to any stimulation. A baby will only get 0 out of 5
    possible points if they are asleep or awake and completely calm. They score 
    a point for any crying, moderate to severe tremor (subjective), sweating,
    moderate to severe uncoordinated/repetitive movements (subjective), or more 
    than one yawn or sneeze.

  3. The nurse will then progressively stimulate the baby over one minute. They get
    a point for a moderate to severe startle reaction to touch or if they
    demonstrate increased muscle tone, both subjective assessments. Finally, the
    baby is left alone and the nurse documents how long it takes for the baby
    to calm. One point is scored if it takes the patient between two and five
    minutes. Greater than five minutes results in a score of two points.

I hope it doesn’t sound like I am trying to say that an assessment like the
WAT-1 is worthless. It definitely isn’t. It is an improvement over previous
methods which were much more cumbersome, involving many more items and more
frequent assessments. And it is certainly less subjective than relying solely on
the clinical judgement of the nurses and physicians. Although, tools like the
WAT-1 are validated by comparing them to just such previous methods. They all
must be taken with a grain of salt. Their greatest benefit is likely the fact
that their use forces us to consider the possibility of withdrawal and to
approach it systematically.

How is withdrawal managed?

The best approach to withdrawal in the pediatric population, and I imagine in
adult patients as well, is anticipation and prevention of withdrawal if at all
possible. If a child has been on a daily opioid for more than one week, although
there are reports of withdrawal occurring after only five days, the medication 
should probably not be discontinued abruptly. And an assessment tool like the
WAT-1 should be used consistently and as recommended.

It is common practice in hospitals to take into account how long the patient has
been on a daily opioid, how high the doses are at the time weaning begins,
concurrently administered medications (benzodiazepines, paralyzing agents,
etc.), and the patient’s overall medical condition. It is also standard of care 
to follow an approved weaning protocol, generally with only one drug (if the
patient is on more than one associated with withdrawal) being weaned at a time
and the rapidity of the wean being determined by the length of time the patient 
had been on the drug. Naturally there are potential individual differences
between patients, so signs and symptoms of withdrawal trump following a strict
algorithm.

A typical approach would be to transition the patient to a stable dose of a
longer-acting form of the drug to be weaned, and then to decrease the amount by 
10%-20% every couple of days if excessive rescue medication dosing hasn’t been
needed. An approved assessment tool should be used to determine signs or
symptoms of withdrawal and the need to delay a decrease in dosing or to give
rescue dosing of a short-acting version of the drug being weaned. A WAT-1 score 
greater than or equal to three, for example, is a typical cut-off for
consideration of rescue dosing. Depending on the individual circumstances it can
take a few days to weeks for a child to be successfully weaned and ready for
discharge home.

Is there a role for acupuncture in the management of withdrawal in neonatal and 
pediatric intensive care units?

No, no there isn’t.

Weaning babies off of these medications can go smoothly or be a frustrating
roller coaster ride. I confidently speak for parents, patients and medical
professionals when I say that we would all love a safe and effective means of
weaning these medications more quickly and with less occurrence of withdrawal.
If such a means exists, there is no reason to think that it would consist of
placing tiny steel needles through the skin or pressing on the ears in order to 
manipulate the flow of nonexistent mystical energy through nonexistent pathways 
in the human body.

But thanks to a team of pediatric anesthesiologists at Stanford University,
there is now another in a very long line of studies seemingly designed to be
positive and to serve as fodder for believers looking for some science, any
science, to hold up as proof of their beloved alternative medical belief system.
This “research” was published in the October issue of Medical Acupuncture, a
journal which has been discussed in the pages of Science-Based Medicine before, 
and not in a good way. The Editor-in-Chief happens to be Richard Niemtzow, the
man who brought us “battlefield acupuncture.”

The authors start off by lamenting the need for painful procedures in young
infants and the possible repercussions of poorly managed pain in the very young,
such as an amplified pain response down the road. This is true…sort of. Some
neonates exposed to a few painful experiences, such as heel sticks or
circumcision, may have an exaggerated response to the jab from routine
immunizations during the first year of life. But babies who experience repeated 
and prolonged pain, such as those riding vents for weeks or having major
surgeries, are actually at risk of having blunted responses to pain during the
first year of life. What is clear however, is that pain causes remodeling of our
response to it, perhaps for a long time, and we should do our best to reduce it
whenever it is safe and possible to do so.

They also point out the downsides to our new and improved approach to pain
management, which to be honest is simply the fact that we have an approach to
pain management at all in neonates. But, as I discussed above, it can lead to
dependence and withdrawal as well as possible acute side effects with overdoses 
such as respiratory suppression and death. They mention the possible need for
adding additional medications to the mix, like clonidine, to help manage
withdrawal. I didn’t get into that in detail, but it’s true. And like every
other drug, there are potential risks when prescribed.

So far, so good.

The authors then go off track, although not unexpectedly, when they begin to
praise the successes of acupuncture for withdrawal. They state that there is a
long history of safety and efficacy starting with the incidental discovery of
the indication in 1972 when “acupuncture anesthesia” was performed on a man
addicted to opium in China. As Dr. Atwood’s excellent four part series explains,
acupuncture anesthesia was and is a fiction, and anything associated with it is
highly suspect.

They describe the protocol for acupuncture detoxification as established by the 
National Acupuncture Detoxification Association (NADA), which initially involved
multiple points on the body and ears as well as electrical stimulation. Because
of logistical issues and “reasons of efficiency in clinics”, both the
electricity and the body points were eventually abandoned, luckily without any
negative impact on the effectiveness of the treatments. That’s curious. The
current NADA protocol consists of “bilateral ear acupuncture of the following
five points: Kidney; Liver; Lung; Shen Men; and Sympathetic.

They claim that acupuncture treats anxiety, pain and agitation in a variety of
pediatric contexts. After admitting that the only prior study related to
pediatric withdrawal, which involved using acupressure in neonates suffering
from abstinence syndrome, did not work, they point out the “suggestive trend
toward less need for pharmacologic support.” All of this is used to bolster
their case for an “exploration of the feasibility and efficacy of performing
acupuncture on infants in the ICU.”

The study

The authors enrolled ten neonates and infants in the study with the goal of
determining the feasibility and efficacy of acupuncture as part of the
management of withdrawal in the ICU. They obtained IRB approval from Stanford
and informed consent from caregivers. These infants had few similarities. They
were on different doses of medications or were on different medications
entirely. One was on a ventilator and still getting doses of a paralyzing agent.
They were at varying stages of their wean off of medications, and had extremely
different reasons for why they were on these medications in the first place.

The treatment protocol consisted of NADA-approved ear points but they also threw
in some body points to “help stabilize symptoms of autonomic dysfunction.” They
state this without a reference, as if it’s just a well-accepted thing that
doctors do. Like stating that “fevers were treated with standard dosing of
acetaminophen.” The authors did their own acupuncture and inserted the needles
until they felt the De Qi sensation. After needling the babies, acupressure
beads were placed on the points for 24 hours or until the next session. The NADA
protocol they were supposedly following only calls for 30 minutes. All but one 
of the subjects had five sessions. That one went home after three days.

The authors report that all ten of the patients improved while receiving
acupuncture and acupressure. Based on WAT-1 assessments, they needed fewer doses
of rescue medications and their opioid and/or benzodiazepine infusions were
weaned. There were no major complications, although one child suffered a minor
skin abrasion from an acupressure bead. And although the nature of the study did
not permit any statistical analysis, a survey of bedside caregivers (nursing,
physicians, parents) revealed universal belief that the patients benefited from 
the intervention. The authors even provide several comments from the surveys,
such as “Can we please do this for other patients?” and “She really likes her
acupuncture.”

So to sum up, ten babies received an intervention for a highly-subjective
process, and were assessed without any blinding using a tool that is very
susceptible to placebo. The authors of the study, two pediatric
anesthesiologists, performed the intervention themselves at the bedside for all 
to see and included in their methods for no clear reason a means to make sure
that anyone assessing the patients during a different shift knew which babies
were involved. Then to cap it off, they included a likely non-anonymous survey
that is even more subjective than the WAT-1 as part of their evidence for
efficacy. I would have been shocked if the results were any less positive.

There are three possible explanations for the results of this study that I can
think of. One is that acupuncture and/or acupressure works, not only for
withdrawal from opioids but also benzodiazepines, and in a patients with a
variety of medical histories. Or we accept that acupuncture functions as a
theatrical placebo and the biased perception of the caregivers led to the
infants receiving fewer rescue medications and continuing on their weans. If
this is the case, which in my opinion it almost certainly is, some or all of the
infants may not have received medication that they truly needed. Finally, it
all may just be the result of random factors. Placebo didn’t play a role,
acupuncture doesn’t work, the process of withdrawal and weaning is highly
variable and this was a very small number of subjects.

Regardless, I would love to have been privy to those IRB discussions and to the 
informed consent process. The latter isn’t described in the paper unfortunately.
But this was not one of those papers where the researchers attempt to come up
with a scientific-sounding explanation for the proposed benefits of acupuncture.
In addition to the “De Qi” reference, they state that “children may require
less stimulation than adults because their Qi may be more responsive to
stimuli.” So did they really discuss Qi with the parents? Did they mention that 
a better study looking at this very issue, which was published in the same
journal in 2011 and even cited by the authors, showed no benefit whatsoever?

Why does this matter?

Although merely a collection of ten worthless anecdotes published in a journal
that warps the concept of peer review beyond all meaning or recognition, there
are already individual acupuncture practices touting it as evidence that
acupuncture “truly is for everyone!”

   Stanford researchers have found that acupuncture helps newborns in intensive 
   care. Acupuncture has been effective for pain relief and sedation, the study 
   showed. “High doses of opioids and benzodiazepines are often required for
   neonates and infants for the purposes of pain management and sedation.
   Cessation from medications lead to withdrawal symptoms and irritability. The 
   researchers cite acupuncture’s documented ability to reduce pain,
   irritability and withdrawal symptoms in adults.”

Here is a website offering continuing medical education credits based on the
study.

This study, a painfully unnecessary attempt to determine the feasibility and
efficacy of acupuncture in neonatal and pediatric intensive care unit patients
at risk of withdrawal, was a complete waste of time. You cannot determine
efficacy at all based on it and the question of feasibility was answered a long 
time ago. This study added nothing to our understanding of withdrawal or even of
acupuncture.

Considering the reams of research showing that there are no benefits associated 
with the insertion of needles into, or pressing on, particular points on the
body beyond placebo, it never should have happened. But it can’t be undone. It’s
out there, adding to the cultural inertia of acupuncture. It will find its way 
to more websites and it will be cited in future poorly designed studies.
Although less of a fuss was made about this paper than I would have expected,
there are almost certainly many more people that are believers now because of
it.

Although many forms of alternative medicine are like this to varying degrees,
acupuncture really is the best Weeble of the bunch. It has proven time and time 
again to be able to right itself despite devastating blows in the literature.
It’s nearly ubiquitous in academic centers and the modality that shruggies will 
usually cite when pressed for a reason for their lack of motivation. It’s widely
accepted by the public as legitimate. Acupuncture doesn’t appear to be going
anywhere anytime soon. 

Acupuncture for Amblyopia

David Weinberg on November 25, 2011

Link


An recent article in the journal Ophthalmology reported the results of a
clinical trial that evaluated acupuncture as an adjunctive treatment for
anisometropic amblyopia. In the abstract, the authors conclude:

   Acupuncture is a potentially useful complementary treatment modality that may
   provide sustainable adjunctive effect to refractive correction for
   anisometropic amblyopia in young children. Further large-scale studies seem
   warranted.

A little background information is in order.

In a healthy visual system the various structures in the eye focus light ambient
light to form a sharp image on the retina. The retina functions like the CCD in
a digital camera. Light energy is transduced to electrical signals, which are
transmitted through the optic nerve. The signals from the optic nerve are
relayed to the occipital cortex (at the very back of the brain) where they are
interpreted into the experience of vision.

Amblyopia is often called “lazy eye”. If during childhood the brain is deprived 
of quality visual information it does not mature properly and loses the
potential for good vision. Any opacity within the eye which significantly
degrades the quality of the image forming on the retina (such as congenital
cataract) can cause amblyopia. Strabismus (misalignment of the 2 eyes) can also 
cause amblyopia. If the eyes are not aligned, the brain has difficulty
reconciling the disparate images from the 2 eyes. In order to avoid double
vision the brain may “ignore” the input from one eye, and corresponding part of 
the visual cortex will not develop properly. Extreme, uncorrected, refractive
errors (nearsightedness, farsightedness or astigmatism) can cause amblyopia.
Patients with different refractive errors in their 2 eyes, a condition known as 
anisometropia, can also develop amblyopia in one eye.Diagnosing and treating
amblyopia during childhood is important. If the cause of the amblyopia is
corrected during childhood, the brain can “learn” to see properly. As the child 
grows older, treatment becomes less effective, and amblyopia can become
permanent. Often, intermittent patching of the unaffected is also used in the
treatment of amblyopia.

The study under discussion involves the treatment of anisometropic amblyopia and
was performed at the Joint Shantou International Eye Hospital in Shantou China.
All children were treated with appropriate glasses to correct the refractive
error. Patients were randomized into 2 treatment groups. For the first 15 weeks 
group 1 was treated with glasses alone; group 2 was treated with glasses plus
acupuncture. After the initial 15 weeks, there was a crossover, and Group 1 was 
treated with glasses + acupuncture and Group 2 was treated with glasses alone
for an additional 15 weeks. Both groups were then treated for 15 more weeks with
glasses alone. Vision was measured every 5 weeks. The total duration of the
study was 45 weeks, but the primary endpoint was considered to be at 15 weeks.

While assigned to acupuncture, patients received treatment 5 days per week for
15 weeks. Each treatment consisted of needling of 5 acupuncture points. They are
described in greater detail in the paper, but in layman’s terms, needle
placements were Baihui (in the scalp), Taiyang (beside the eye), Cuanazhu (in
the eyebrow), Hegu (on the back of the hand), and Fuyang (in the lower leg).
There was no sham acupuncture, or any attempt at masking patients to treatment
assignment.

Imagine yourself as a patient with an eye problem reading a consent form
describing a “double- blind study.” Because of the possible misinterpretation,
in ophthalmology we avoid the terms “blind” or “blinding”, as in “double-blind
study” to indicate measures taken to hide treatment assignment. We usually
substitute the terms “masked” or “masking”.

At the primary (15 week) endpoint of the study both groups had improvement in
vision, but Group 2 had improved 0.77 logMAR lines more than Group 1, a
difference reported as statistically significant. LogMAR is an abbreviation for 
the logarithm of the minimal angle of resolution. I won’t go in to the arcane
and tedious explanation of what 0.77 logMAR lines means, but it is quite a small
difference. If you are familiar with audiology, one logMAR line is analogous to
1 decibel. On a relative scale a .77 logMAR line difference is roughly
proportional to the difference between 14 and 12 point type. Within the context 
of clinical trials, differences of this magnitude are usually considered
clinically insignificant.

At 30 and 45 weeks (after the crossover phase), the vision for the 2 groups was 
essentially equal.

First, the authors should be complimented for many things they did right. The
designed a prospective, randomized trial. They used standardized methodologies. 
They reported well-characterized study groups. The sample size was fairly high
for a pilot study, and followup was quite good. The paper was clearly written.
However, all these virtues are outweighed by the omission of a sham acupuncture 
treatment group.

Measuring visual acuity is a deceptively complicated task. Ideally, it is an
objective measure of the resolving power of the entire visual system. In
practice, measurement of vision is never completely objective. It depends on
patients reporting of their observations. In general, patients are asked to read
progressively smaller letters on a chart until they can no longer reliably
identify the letters. Surprisingly little is known about placebo effects on
visual acuity. It is well known, however, that visual acuity measurement is
highly dependent on the motivation, attention, and cooperation of the patient.
This is especially true in children.

In clinical trials, vision is usually measured under highly controlled
conditions, with standard lighting, a standard eyechart, etc. Because motivation
and attention are so important in vision testing, the technician measuring the 
vision can have a significant influence on a patient’s performance. Call it the 
“cheerleader effect”. A highly engaging, encouraging tester, can generally
squeeze a few additional letters from a patient compared to tester who is
apathetic. The expectations of the tester can influence the way they collect and
report the visual acuity measurements. In order to minimize potential bias,
visual acuity examiners should be unaware of treatment assignment of the
patients they are testing.

The paper states that vision was measured by an examiner who was masked to
patient treatment assignment. Can an examiner can be truly masked to treatment
when one group is having needles placed in their hand and face 5 days a week, 15
weeks at a time? By the time the patient reaches the primary 15 week endpoint, 
he or she has had needles placed at the same 5 spots 75 times, each. There were 
likely to be visible clues at some visits in some patients. Bruising was
reported as an adverse event in 7.2% of participants. More subtle marks seem
inevitable in a higher proportion of patients. If acupuncture treatments and
visual acuity measurements were performed in the same building, visual acuity
examiners could be unmasked simply by seeing the acupuncture kids in the
building 25 times more frequently than the glasses-only kids. Given the very
small differences in vision between the 2 groups, the possibility that examiners
were unmasked in a small subset of patients could be significant.

Another important bias in this study is the very different experiences of the
patients during different phases of the study. During the glasses-only
intervals, patients came in every 5 weeks and had their vision measured. During 
the acupuncture intervals patients were brought to the office 5 days a week for 
15 weeks and had needles pierce the skin at 5 points on their body. If the
placebo effect influences vision measurement, this would seem to be a very
provocative protocol.

Remember, also, that in this study acupuncture was an adjunctive treatment. The 
primary treatment, administered to every patient, was refractive correction
(glasses). In order to get the benefit of the primary treatment, the children
had to actually wear their glasses. Compliance is a known issue in amblyopia
therapy, and getting 3 to 7 year old children to wear glasses is not as trivial 
as it may sound. Children with amblyopia in one eye generally do not perceive
that they have any problem with their vision, and often find glasses more an
annoyance than a help.

By receiving acupuncture treatment 75 times over 15 weeks, the children and
their parents received constant reminders of their condition, and to the fact
that they were in a clinical trial. During these visits they are under the real 
or perceived scrutiny of eyecare professionals. Sometimes know as the Hawthorne 
effect, these factors are strong motivators for compliance with any medical
treatment. In comparison, patients in the glasses only group came to the
hospital once every 5 weeks to have their vision measured.

The authors of the paper did attempt to address the question of compliance with 
glasses. Parents were asked to keep calendars documenting the use glasses over
the first 30 weeks of the study. The parents reported that every child wore
their glasses >90% of their waking hours. The authors concluded that
differential compliance in use of glasses between the treatment groups did not
likely explain the difference in visual acuity. Perhaps parents and children in 
this study were especially compliant, but universal >90% compliance challenges
credibility. Patient (or parent) reported compliance is a flawed metric. Can any
parent know what their 3-7 year-old is doing 90% of the time? I could find no
studies looking at the reliability of parent-reported diaries of glasses use,
but a found a quite interesting paper looking at use of orthodontia headgear.
The authors devised an ingenious way of objectively monitoring the actual hours 
of use. Parents estimated that their children used their headgear about twice as
long as documented by the objective measuring tool. I suspect this study has
some relevance to parent reported use of eyeglasses. The difference in vision
between the 2 groups was so small, that even a small difference in hours of
glasses use could be significant.

In the discussion the authors did acknowledge that omission of sham treatment
was a weakness of the study, and concede the possibility that placebo effects
may have contributed to their observations.

   Finally, we did not include a sham acupuncture group, which is considered
   necessary for evaluation of the effectiveness of acupuncture for such
   conditions as pain control. Although VA [visual acuity] testing is relatively
   objective and may thus be less influenced by psychological effects, we
   cannot totally rule out the possibility that part of the observed treatment
   effects were attributed to a placebo effect from acupuncture.

They go on to say that further studies using sham controls are warranted. It
remains to be seen whether of not such trials will be done. Given the very small
treatment effect seen in this open-label study, is likely that any measurable
effect will vanish with appropriate controls and masking. The authors appear to 
anticipate this result as well, and have given themselves a preemptive fail-safe
explanation.

   It is also possible that sham acupuncture may activate the same mechanism as 
   true acupuncture, leading to similar treatment effects.

In other words, acupuncture works, it just doesn’t require actual acupuncture.
This gambit has been used before to explain the inconvenient truth of data
showing that acupuncture works no better than sham acupuncture. This fantasy has
also been deconstructed in previous SBM posts.

In conclusion, the authors of this study reported a statistically significant,
but clinically insignificant benefit associated with the use of acupuncture as
an adjunctive treatment for anisometropic amblyopia. Given the implausibility of
the treatment modality, and the lack of masking, it is likely that the very
small difference between groups is due to one or more sources of bias inherent
in the study design.

Neuro-Acupuncture and Stroke

Steven Novella on October 15, 2014

Link



On the home page of Zhu’s Neuro-Acupuncture Center there is a video relaying a
testimonial of how scalp acupuncture helped a patient recover from acute stroke.
The use of testimonials is very common in the promotion of dubious health
treatments. A personal story and endorsement is psychologically more compelling 
than dry data. Testimonials are completely unreliable, however, and in fact I
would argue that they are ethically questionable. I would even go as far as
saying that the presence of testimonials is almost a sure sign that the
treatment being promoted is not legitimate.



What I could not find on Zhu’s website were links to published scientific
researcher establishing the safety and efficacy of his treatments. You would
think if they existed, he would display them prominently.

Acupuncture for stroke is a common claim, contradicting the notion that
acupuncture is primarily used for the symptomatic treatment of subjective
symptoms. That, in my experience, is part of the promotional strategy for many
CAM treatments. They are presented as benign treatments for symptomatic
treatment only, so what’s the possible harm. In reality, proponents will claim
they can actually treat diseases whenever given the chance.

Treating stroke

A stroke results from an acute lack of blood supply to a portion of the brain,
usually caused by a blockage in a cerebral artery, but can also be caused by
overall lack of blood flow to the brain. Brain cells are metabolically very
hungry, and can only go a few minutes without a steady blood supply before they 
start to die.

When the blockage of blood flow occurs brain cells will immediately stop
functioning. Depending on how completely the blood flow is blocked, the amount
of collateral flow from other arteries, and the duration of blockage, brain
cells might be temporarily stunned, damaged but capable of recovery, severely
damaged and likely to die, or they may be already dead. Clinically (based on
patient symptoms and neurological exam) it is not possible to tell the
difference, because stunned and dead brain cells look the same. They don’t
function.

In fact some patient who present with a stroke actually have a transient
ischemic attack (TIA), which is essentially a stroke that leaves behind no
permanent damage and completely resolves within 24 hours.

Some patients with acute stroke are candidates for a drug called TPA that can
break up a clot and restore flow. In the best cases, treatment with TPA can
rapidly reverse the clinical signs of stroke, and so apparently restore flow
before permanent damage occurs.

Therefore, when a patient presents with, for example, paralysis of one side of
the body due to stroke, it is possible that they may recover very quickly, or
they may recover over days as stunned brain cells recover, or over weeks as
damaged but viable brain cells recover. Or, the patient may have permanent
deficits due to dead brain tissue from the stroke. Modern imaging such as MRI
scanning can help us predict to some extent how bad the damage is, but not
completely. So in practice we mostly have to wait and see how the patient
recovers.

What all this means is that, in order to study the effects of any treatment in
the recovery from acute stroke, you need to perform careful double-blind
placebo-controlled trials. Cherry picking for testimonials can produce
seemingly-amazing stories of recovery no matter what treatment you are looking
at, and therefore testimonials for stroke recovery are completely useless.

The testimonial promoted on Zhu’s homepage is just such a case. The story
appears to be that of a patient with an acute stroke who recovered most of his
function over several days, and then had rehab to complete his recovery. This is
a very common outcome and therefore says nothing about the effects of the scalp
acupuncture he received. It is therefore also deceptive (and unethical) to use 
this testimonial to promote a treatment that has not been scientifically
validated.

Recovery long after stroke is another claim made for acupuncture, and other
questionable treatments. Here the issues are a little different, because we are 
dealing with patients with chronic symptoms, sometimes for years. They are
unlikely to make a rapid genuine neurological recovery, therefore.

However, when evaluating chronic stroke patients we need to consider both
neurological recovery and functional recovery. Neurological recovery means
making new connections between neurons, recruiting neural stem cells to lay down
new circuits, and engaging the plasticity of the brain to have healthy areas
take over for damaged areas.

Functional recovery means having improved function with stable neurological
deficits. This type of recovery is often neglected by inexperienced stroke
researchers (such as when non-neurologists study dubious treatments). For
example, you can take someone who is weak from a stroke they had 10 years
earlier and they can improve their function even without any further
neurological recovery. They may be deconditioned and not fully rehabbed. Getting
them exercise, mobilizing their joints, and training them to function better
with their weakness can result in a significant functional improvement. There is
also what stroke researchers call the “cheerleader effect.” Simply encouraging 
someone to try harder can have a measurable effect.

So again we see that unless a treatment is properly controlled for, it can be
easy to present non-specific functional recovery as if it were a specific
neurological effect of a treatment.

The literature

Are there any well-designed trials of acupuncture for stroke? Not many. There
are many preliminary or poor-quality studies and some moderate quality. There is
no single definitive study, however.

The most recent Cochrane systematic review of acupuncture for acute stroke is
from 2005, and concludes:

   Acupuncture appeared to be safe but without clear evidence of benefit. The
   number of patients is too small to be certain whether acupuncture is
   effective for treatment of acute ischaemic or haemorrhagic stroke. Larger,
   methodologically-sound trials are required.

The most recent Cochrane systematic review of acupuncture for chronic stroke
rehab is from 2006, and concludes:

   Currently there is no clear evidence on the effects of acupuncture on
   subacute or chronic stroke. Large, methodologically-sound trials are
   required.

A 2009 systematic review of acupuncture for post-stroke spasticity concluded:

   A reliable conclusion can not be drawn from the present data because of the
   defects in methodological quality and insufficient numbers of trials,
   especially lack the long-term terminal outcomes, although it appears a
   tedency [sic] that acupuncture can improve the conditions of post-stroke
   spastic paralysis.

A 2012 systematic review concluded:

   The evidence for the effectiveness of acupuncture for stroke was
   inconclusive, mainly due to poor methodological quality and small samples.

And a 2014 systematic review concluded:

   The available evidence suggests that acupuncture may be effective for
   treating poststroke neurological impairment and dysfunction such as
   dysphagia, although these reported benefits should be verified in large,
   well-controlled studies. On the other hand, the available evidence does not
   clearly indicate that acupuncture can help prevent poststroke death or
   disability, or ameliorate other aspects of stroke recovery, such as
   poststroke motor dysfunction.

There is a clear consensus, agreeing with my own take on the literature, that
the current evidence does not establish that acupuncture is effective for
stroke, post-stroke rehab, or post-stroke symptoms such as spasticity. Most of
the studies are poorly controlled, and therefore non-significant trends are of
no value.

Conclusion

Acupuncture is a highly implausible treatment for stroke in any phase. While it 
is possible to make hand-waving speculations about possible mechanisms by which 
inserting a needle into the skin might reduce pain (even though a benefit has
never been reliably demonstrated), there is nothing approaching a plausible
mechanism for stroke recovery.

Needling the scalp or any part of the body will not restore blood flow to the
brain, dissolve clots, or help neurons recover. Some acupuncturists will resort 
to claims based on Chi or life energy, but this is a pre-scientific belief
without a shred of support from our modern scientific understanding of biology.

I do disagree with the reviewers above in that I do not think that larger
well-controlled trials are necessary to conclude that acupuncture is not an
effective treatment for stroke. Acupuncture is a highly implausible treatment,
it has not been shown to work for any indication, and preliminary data for
stroke is unimpressive. This is sufficient evidence to abandon a treatment as
likely useless.

The expense and trouble of a large rigorous trial is only justified if a
treatment is likely to be safe and effective based on a reasonable combination
of prior plausibility and encouraging preliminary data. In this case we have
neither.

One might argue that because acupuncture is already culturally embedded,
definitive trials will be useful to convince proponents and the public that it
does not work, if nothing else. However, history has shown this to not be the
case. We already have large definitive trials showing acupuncture does not work 
for several indications, and this has not altered the enthusiasm for which
proponents continue to support and use acupuncture. They simply ignore the
negative evidence, or spin the results as somehow being positive – because
placebo acupuncture works too. The entire exercise is therefore fruitless.

It should simply be acknowledged by the scientific and medical community that
acupuncture is a failed hypothesis and the position of any self-respecting
science-based organization should be the complete abandonment of this
anachronistic treatment.

Acupuncture for Macular Degeneration: Why I Reject the Evidence

Harriet Hall on June 24, 2014

Link



What AMD does to vision

This post is dedicated to two people who are frequent commenters on SBM, Stephen
S. Rodrigues and Peter Moran. Rodrigues is an MD/acupuncturist who tries to
persuade us that acupuncture is effective. Moran is a retired surgeon who
objects to insulting language and thinks more can be accomplished by trying to
better understand why people turn to CAM and by explaining the facts and reasons
politely and dispassionately. He has claimed that he “could probably help
[Rodrigues] understand better why his views are not having much impact.”

I recently wrote about supplements for age-related macular degeneration (AMD).
There is evidence that the supplement mixture tested in the AREDS trial slows
the progression of moderate to advanced disease. That is based on a good
scientific study, although the study has not been replicated and there is reason
to interpret its results with caution. Dr. Rodrigues commented with a link to a
website advertising the Santa Fe acupuncture protocol, saying that he uses the 
method in his office and it helps some of his patients with AMD. The website
claims that the Santa Fe acupuncture protocol will reverse vision loss from
macular degeneration in 4 days or your money back. That is a bold claim. I will 
try to explain, as politely as possible, why I reject the claim, and why the
evidence for it is unacceptable.

Two kinds of AMD: dry and wet

90% of AMD patients have dry AMD, where there is a thinning and breakdown of the
retinal epithelial cells that support the photoreceptor cells (the rods and
cones). It is asymptomatic in the early stages; then, as the disease progresses,
visual acuity is lost and the unsupported photoreceptor cells die off. There is
no medical or surgical treatment for dry AMD.

The other 10% have wet AMD, where blood vessels proliferate, leak, interfere
with vision, and eventually destroy photoreceptor cells. Conventional treatment 
can’t cure AMD; it can slow progression of the disease but until the recent
introduction of anti-VEGF drugs  it seldom improved visual acuity. Treatments
include injecting potentially dangerous medications directly into the eye,
intravenous injection of drugs with retinal photoactivation, photocoagulation
with lasers (which can cause immediate reduction in visual acuity of three lines
on the eye chart), and surgical removal of retinal lesions.

Why people turn to CAM

I fully understand the attraction of the Santa Fe protocol. People with AMD are 
desperate; they are going blind, and conventional treatments offer them little
or no hope and are frankly scary. When they are told that an alternative
treatment can reverse the damage that has already occurred, and when they are
told the treatment is supported by testimonials, scientific studies, and a
money-back guarantee, how could they not grasp at the only available straw of
hope? Hope makes people feel better; but raising false hopes only to have them
collapse after a substantial investment of time and money would ultimately make 
them feel worse. Does this protocol offer true hope or false hope? Let’s examine
the evidence.

I can understand the attraction for acupuncturists, too. They want to believe
they can help patients with a condition that can’t be treated any other way.
Their patients report improvement and thank them profusely. Those who don’t
improve are not likely to come back, so practitioners don’t see their successes 
in perspective with their failures. Confirmation bias takes over. Practitioners 
are gratified and reinforced. That kind of personal experience is very powerful 
but can be misleading. As Mark Crislip says, the three most dangerous words in
medicine are “In my experience.” Humans regularly misperceive and misinterpret
the meaning of their experiences, and that’s why we have to rely on the
scientific method to correct our errors.

What is the Santa Fe protocol?

Dr. Alston C. Lundgren is a family physician turned acupuncturist. His website
claims that his Santa Fe protocol is the only documented treatment to reverse
vision loss in cases of both wet and dry AMD.

Apparently there are several versions of the protocol, as he added treatments
through the years. On his website he describes three components:

  1. Small steel studs are inserted in regions of the ear whose nerve endings have 
    been shown to correspond with specific areas of the brain. By stimulating
    these nerves, cortisone and oxygen-rich blood are induced in the region of
    the retina.

  2. Needle electrodes are inserted in the fat around the eyeball and are
    stimulated with a mild electrical current. These electrodes stimulate the
    retina and surrounding tissues and probably increase blood flow to the
    retina.

  3. In Spring 2007, a 3rd component was added – electrically stimulating the scalp
    over the visual cortex which occupies a considerable portion of the brain.

In one of his links, he describes his protocol as combining five types of
acupuncture:

  1. German Ear Acupuncture to indirectly stimulate the optic nerve, the retina,
    and production of cortisol. (David Alimi, MD, Professor of Neurology and Ear
    Acupuncture at the University of Paris Medical School has demonstrated the 
    one-to-one correspondence between points on the ear and areas of the brain.)

  2. Canadian Neuroanatomic Acupuncture with needle/electrodes surrounding the
    orbit which may increase blood circulation or directly affect the retina
    itself when electrically stimulated.

  3. Chinese scalp acupuncture – electrical stimulation over the visual cortex of
    the brain, hence reversing the damage of a stroke there.

  4. Japanese scalp acupuncture at points identified as stimulating the optic nerve
    and probably other areas of the brain involved in vision.

  5. French Energetics acupuncture to stimulate classic Chinese points affecting
    the eye, increase parasympathetic stimulus, and add energy to the patient
    for self-healing.

He says he has performed over 10,000 treatments on 1,500 patients and has
improved the vision of 85% of them. He states that black eyes are a very common 
complication, so he routinely uses ice packs. He charges $250 per treatment, and
typically administers five treatments on five successive days.

Dr. Lundgren is the only one who has published data on his method. He has no
articles listed in PubMed. His website provides references, but they are all
either articles he has written for an acupuncture journal that is not listed in 
PubMed (I couldn’t find it in any list of medical journal impact factors either)
or PowerPoints he has presented at conferences. They all cover essentially the 
same material at different points in his journey, reporting data from his
patients.

His published study

The most recent published article is this one published in the journal Medical
Acupuncture in 2005. It reports a 69% improvement in vision. I will concentrate 
on the evidence for the Santa Fe protocol as presented in that study.

It reports a case series  of 108 consecutive patients with
ophthalmologist-diagnosed AMD who were treated by him at his clinic in New
Mexico. 32% had wet AMD; 50% had dry AMD; 18% didn’t know which type they had.
The patients gave informed consent, but there is no mention of oversight by an
IRB. Treatment consisted of three acupuncture techniques:

  1. Auricular acupuncture to indirectly stimulate appropriate parts of the brain

  2. Neuro-anatomical acupuncture to directly stimulate the retina and periorbital 
    tissue

  3. French Energetic Liver cerebral circulation stimulation to enhance eye
    function

For auricular acupuncture he says he does not clean the surface of the ear
before inserting needles unless there is gross contamination. He leaves the
needles in the ear until they fall out, anywhere from 2 days to more than a
month later. He installs a gold semi-permanent needle (a stud?) for chronic
stimulation of the most electrically active point. He applies electrical
stimulation to the needles in techniques 2 and 3, but I couldn’t tell from his
write-up whether he also uses electricity on the ear. He reports elsewhere that 
he treats daily for 5 days; but in this study he used weekly treatments, saying 
patients did not benefit from more than 3 treatments per week, and claiming that
gaps of up to 4 months between treatments had no effect on the degree of
improvement achieved. Each treatment session lasted 25-35 minutes. Patients were
treated until they either dropped out or showed no further gains in 2
consecutive vision tests. He does not say how many patients dropped out. He says
visual acuity improvements “did not seem to deteriorate for a year-and-a-half” 
but he provides no data. He describes other subjective improvements reported by 
patients: color vision seemed to improve (said to have been confirmed by testing
in “several” patients), less contrast required for reading, improved ability to
see in dim light or drive at night, straight objects no longer had wavy edges, 
scotomas shrank and disappeared, the “film over vision” or “fog” disappeared.

There were minor complications: ecchymosis in 10% of treatments, and a few
infections around indwelling ear studs.

He is aware of some of the limitations of his study. He acknowledges that
further research is needed to determine that the results are due to the
acupuncture protocol and are not skewed by patients’ increased experience in
taking the tests, their desire to please the investigator by performing well, or
the Hawthorne effect from simply being part of a study. He wonders if the
improvement might be due to effects on eye muscle rather than on the retina. He 
recommends further research to optimize the protocol.

Why I reject this study

I will refrain from commenting on the rationale of using acupuncture for AMD and
the possible underlying mechanisms. I’ll just say that the prior plausibility
is very low. Of course, prior probability would have to be re-assessed if
acupuncture could clearly be shown to work better than a placebo. Does this
study constitute evidence that it works? I don’t think so.

I’ll try to explain in simple terms why I reject this study as evidence.

  1. There was no control group. When you do almost anything, patients seem to
    improve; sometimes they improve if you do nothing, just from fluctuations in
    the natural course of illness. With any kind of intervention, they will
    consistently get better results than if they were just assigned to a waiting
    list. We can’t conclude a treatment is effective until we can be certain
    that patients wouldn’t have improved to the same degree without the
    treatment. Lundgren himself has pointed out several factors that could have 
    invalidated the results and that could have been ruled out by using a
    control group (increased test-taking experience, desire to please the
    doctor, the Hawthorne effect).

  2. Selection bias could have influenced the results. Subjects were not a
    representative sample of patients with AMD; they were self-selected and were
    a sample of convenience (consecutive patients in his practice). It was not 
    representative of the general population, since it included far more
    patients with wet AMD than expected. He is known for using acupuncture, so
    those who sought him out probably had a prior belief in acupuncture, or at
    least were favorably inclined. They were paying him out of pocket and had a 
    vested interest in the treatment. I don’t know if that would make a
    difference, but good science tries to control for all such possible
    confounders.

  3. There was no blinding. The researcher himself treated all the patients. When
    testing visual acuity, he knew if it was a pre-treatment or post-treatment
    test, so he may well have been consciously or unconsciously biased in the
    way he conducted the test. Anyone who tests eyes can tell you encouragement 
    improves performance. When I read the lowest line I can read on the eye
    chart, if the examiner encourages me to try the next line, I can usually
    read most of that line correctly too, although it feels to me like I’m just 
    guessing.

  4. The study design and reporting were sloppy. Treatments were given at varying
    intervals, techniques from different schools of acupuncture were combined in
    an apparently arbitrary fashion and sometimes were chosen because of
    anecdotal reports for other eye conditions. The number of dropouts was not
    reported, and he said some subjects dropped out because they weren’t
    improving, which would skew results based only on those who remained. It was
    scattershot: there were so many interventions at so many acupoints that
    there is no way to determine which were important.

  5. The protocol is inconsistent with his descriptions elsewhere. I am left in
    confusion as to exactly what “The Santa Fe protocol” is. He keeps changing
    it. Is it eye/ear, eye/ear/scalp or eye/ear/elsewhere-in-body or eye/ear/two
    different kinds of scalp acupuncture? Is it daily for 5 days or weekly or
    at even longer irregular intervals?

  6. Inadequate followup. He says the duration of improvement was “substantial” but
    provides no supporting data. He doesn’t report trying to follow up on
    dropouts.

  7. No ophthalmologist was involved. Patients reported having been diagnosed with 
    AMD, but we have no details; many of them didn’t even know whether they had 
    the wet or dry type. A retinal specialist would have been able to examine
    the retina with an ophthalmoscope and dilation and do tests like fluorescein
    angiography, visual field testing for scotomas, and optical coherence
    tomography to determine whether the improved visual acuity was a reflection 
    of improvement of the AMD or a spurious finding.

  8. The results were inconsistent with his reports elsewhere: 69% improvement vs. 
    85-93%. It appears that efficacy was lower when more acupuncture techniques 
    were added.

  9. No IRB approval. It is unethical to do human experimentation without prior
    approval by an institutional review board to protect the rights of human
    subjects.

  10. Publication in an obscure journal. It may be peer-reviewed, but only by other 
    acupuncturists who would be inherently biased in favor of their discipline. 
    I don’t know if he tried submitting it to any respected mainstream medical
    journals, but I am sure it would not meet their standards without
    substantial revision.

  11. More. I could go on, but that’s enough to make my point.

In my opinion, this study is not good science and we cannot trust its results.
It gives the appearance of having been designed not to rigorously investigate
whether acupuncture might be effective for AMD, but to justify and promote the
researcher’s own practice and to provide support for other acupuncturists who
want to use it for that purpose.

What it could have been

This could have been good science. He could have recruited a retinal specialist,
blinded the testing of visual acuity, documented detectable changes in the
status of the disease itself, used an acceptable control group (perhaps
stimulating the “wrong” acupoints, or randomizing with patients under routine
care by a retinal specialist). He could have gotten IRB approval and been
published in a PubMed-listed mainstream medical journal so others could have
checked his work.

Conclusion

Studies like this are legion. We know that half of published research findings
are false. When early positive studies, especially uncontrolled studies, are
followed by more rigorous studies with an appropriate control group, the
positive findings all too often evaporate. The only research on the Santa Fe
protocol is by one acupuncturist; his work has not been replicated, and there
has been no independent confirmation of any effect of acupuncture in AMD. The
only other study I could find through a PubMed search for “acupuncture” and
“AMD” is in Chinese and it is not relevant to the Santa Fe method: it compares a
single method, traditional Chinese acupuncture, to treatment with medication. I
don’t read Chinese, but as far as I could tell from the abstract, it doesn’t
even seem to have any acupoints in common with Lundgren’s study.

It is highly unlikely that acupuncture or any other treatment could restore
visual function in a part of the retina where the rod and cone cells have died; 
just as unlikely as the re-growth of an amputated limb. That would be
extraordinary and would require extraordinary evidence, far stronger than the
evidence of this study. I can’t rule out the possibility that acupuncture might 
improve vision in the undamaged areas of the retina by some mechanism, but in
view of the entire body of evidence from acupuncture studies, that seems
unlikely.

OK. I was as polite as I could possibly be. I was nice. I expressed
understanding and sympathy for patients and providers. I didn’t insult or
disparage the researcher. I didn’t say “It doesn’t work.” I didn’t advise people
not to try the treatment. I looked at the evidence, found it wanting, and
explained why. Does my post measure up to Dr. Moran’s ideals of civility? I
think so. Will it help Dr. Rodrigues understand better why his views are not
having much impact? I suspect it will not.

I welcome comments on the persuasiveness of this kind of post in comparison to
posts with other approaches.

Even in a pandemic, bait-and-switch acupuncture studies still get published in
Nature

Last week, a study claiming to have identified a neurologic mechanism by which
acupuncture reduces inflammation was published in Nature. It does no such thing.
it’s another bait-and-switch mouse study that likely would never have been
published in such a high profile journal if it hadn’t rebranded electrical
stimulation as “electroacupuncture”.

David Gorski on October 18, 2021

Link



Before the COVID-19 pandemic hit in early 2020, an unfortunately all-too-common 
topic for me was the proliferation of dubious acupuncture studies from
practitioners of what I like to refer to as quackademic medicine. These studies 
ranged from basic science studies using animal models to clinical trials that
were not even really designed to test whether acupuncture works but instead were
practically designed to produce a “positive” result, even when the result was
negative, while still other studies rebrand “electroacupuncture” as
“acupuncture.”

Unfortunately, the fascination with acupuncture in quackademic medicine has been
so intense over the last three decades that a disturbing number of doctors
appear to believe that acupuncture works (or is at least “worth a shot”). Nearly
all of them are unaware of how the history of this “ancient Chinese” treatment 
(which was, in reality, merely the Asian version of European bloodletting) was
retconned by Mao Zedong, producing a narrative that this “ancient treatment”
demonstrates a near-miraculous efficacy for, well, just about everything. Never 
mind that the filiform needles associated with modern acupuncture didn’t exist
until around 1930, when a Chinese pediatrician named Cheng Dan’an proposed that 
needling therapy be resurrected because its actions could be explained through
neurology and replaced the previously-used coarse lancet-like needles with the
fine needles in use today. Unfortunately, belief in acupuncture has gotten to
the point where not only is the director of the National Center for
Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) a “true believer” in acupuncture,
but other health regulatory authorities, including in the VA hospital system, in
their desperation over the opioid epidemic, have embraced it and other quackery
as “nonpharmacological treatments for pain” even though it is no more than a
theatrical placebo. You can even find credulous discussions of acupuncture in
The New England Journal of Medicine and at the American Society of Clinical
Oncology.

Last week, I was reminded that even a global pandemic can’t stop dubious
acupuncture studies from being published. However, even I was surprised at where
the study that I chose as the topic of this week’s post was published: Nature. 
As most of you know, Nature is considered one of the premier general science
journals in the world, publishing papers on everything from medicine, to
biology, to geology, to astronomy, to just about every science under the sun.
Unfortunately, as I’ve documented in the past, Nature has also demonstrated
enough credulity about acupuncture and traditional Chinese medicine to have
published a large advertising edition promoting them in 2011 and then, in 2015, 
a full-throated defense of acupuncture and related quackery.

This time around, my Google alerts (and some readers) picked up a news item and 
a podcast hawking a study in Nature. The titles were quite—shall we
say?—promotional, with the podcast being titled “How electric acupuncture zaps
inflammation in mice” and the news article “Electroacupuncture activates neurons
to switch off inflammation“. The article itself, from investigators at the
Dana-Farber Cancer Institute and from two institutions in China that included
the Institute of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, Department of Integrative Medicine
and Neurobiology, and Institutes of Brain Science at Fudan University in
Shanghai, as well as the Meridians Research Center, Institute of Acupuncture and
Moxibustion, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences in Beijing, is the less 
promotional but still misleading “A neuroanatomical basis for electroacupuncture
to drive the vagal–adrenal axis“.

The first thing I noticed, as I have for so many other papers like this, was
that this is not an acupuncture paper at all! After all, electricity, its
properties, and how to generate and use it were not known to the Chinese
“millennia ago”, nor did the technology exist to produce the fine filiform
needles currently used in acupuncture. Moreover, acupuncture “meridians,” the
lines along the body through which the mysterious life force (a.k.a., “qi”)
supposedly flows, the blockage of which sticking needles into them supposedly
corrects, were never based on known human anatomic structures, much less those
of mice, which were used in the study by Liu et al. I’ve characterized this sort
of thing as a “bait and switch” going back many years. Basically, therapy is
described as acupuncture (the “bait”) but is in reality nothing more than
transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) clumsily grafted onto
acupuncture (the “switch”) because acupuncture itself doesn’t work.

One might not-unreasonably expect that electrical stimulation of certain nerves 
could produce physiological effects. That’s a no-brainer that has nothing to do 
with whether acupuncture works or not. For instance, anyone who’s ever undergone
a nerve conduction study, as I once did a couple of decades ago when I had the 
misfortune to develop carpal tunnel syndrome, knows this. (It’s a study that
could easily be used as torture, let me tell you.) The very basis of nerve
conduction is electrochemical, and it can be influenced by electrical currents. 
That doesn’t make it acupuncture just because you hook electrodes up to
acupuncture needles stuck into “acupoints”. Worse, the insistence of using
acupuncture points, instead of nerves that might actually have physiological
relevance, only muddies the waters, making it less likely that an actual, useful
therapy might be derived from the mix of electricity and the vitalism of
traditional Chinese medicine that is “electroacupuncture”.

Basically, “electroacupuncture” is nothing more than a “rebranding” of
acupuncture (which doesn’t work) that disguises it using something that might
work (electrical nerve stimulation), labeling that something that might work as 
somehow being acupuncture too. After all, the Chinese people of hundreds (or
thousands) of years ago who supposedly invented acupuncture did not have
knowledge of electricity, nor did they have the technology to construct
batteries or generators to run electricity through anything. Reviewers should
not let authors of manuscripts submitted to journals get away with calling
electroacupuncture “acupuncture,” because it’s not. The editors of Nature should
know that, but apparently do not.

Another thing about this article that really disturbed me. Let’s take a look at 
the abstract and then compare it to actual experimental models used to see.
First, here’s the abstract:

   Somatosensory autonomic reflexes allow electroacupuncture stimulation (ES) to
   modulate body physiology at distant sites1,2,3,4,5,6 (for example,
   suppressing severe systemic inflammation6,7,8,9). Since the 1970s, an
   emerging organizational rule about these reflexes has been the presence of
   body-region specificity1,2,3,4,5,6. For example, ES at the hindlimb ST36
   acupoint but not the abdominal ST25 acupoint can drive the vagal–adrenal
   anti-inflammatory axis in mice10,11. The neuroanatomical basis of this
   somatotopic organization is, however, unknown. Here we show that
   PROKR2Cre-marked sensory neurons, which innervate the deep hindlimb fascia
   (for example, the periosteum) but not abdominal fascia (for example, the
   peritoneum), are crucial for driving the vagal–adrenal axis. Low-intensity ES
   at the ST36 site in mice with ablated PROKR2Cre-marked sensory neurons
   failed to activate hindbrain vagal efferent neurons or to drive catecholamine
   release from adrenal glands. As a result, ES no longer suppressed systemic
   inflammation induced by bacterial endotoxins. By contrast, spinal sympathetic
   reflexes evoked by high-intensity ES at both ST25 and ST36 sites were
   unaffected. We also show that optogenetic stimulation of PROKR2Cre-marked
   nerve terminals through the ST36 site is sufficient to drive the
   vagal–adrenal axis but not sympathetic reflexes. Furthermore, the
   distribution patterns of PROKR2Cre nerve fibres can retrospectively predict
   body regions at which low-intensity ES will or will not effectively produce
   anti-inflammatory effects. Our studies provide a neuroanatomical basis for
   the selectivity and specificity of acupoints in driving specific autonomic
   pathways.

This sounds pretty benign, doesn’t it? Now let’s look at how inflammation was
induced in these mice:

   Activation of the vagal–adrenal axis can suppress systemic inflammation
   induced by lipopolysaccharide (LPS), a bacterial endotoxin10,11,20. Without
   LPS treatment, proinflammatory cytokines, including tumour necrosis factor
   (TNF) and interleukin-6 (IL-6), were barely detected in serum (Extended Data 
   Fig. 6a).

As a news report on this study notes:

   Neuronal networks have evolved to control organ functions. A technique called
   electroacupuncture, in which specific points on the body called acupoints
   are stimulated electrically, has long been used to activate these networks
   and thereby modulate the functions of certain organs to treat various
   disorders. It is a key part of an emerging medical field known as
   bioelectronic medicine1,2. However, little is known about the neuronal
   networks that mediate the effects of electroacupuncture at specific
   acupoints1,3. Writing in Nature, Liu et al.4 show in mice that a set of
   neurons expressing the protein Prokr2 are needed for electrical stimulation
   of a hindlimb acupoint to rein in the unbridled inflammatory responses that
   characterize lethal sepsis.

That’s right. The model used in the experiments involved using
electroacupuncture in a mouse model of the inflammatory effects of sepsis.
Basically, the authors tortured mice in the name of rebranding electricity as a 
form of acupuncture by injecting one of the main mediators of bacterial sepsis, 
lipopolysaccharide (LPS, a bacterial endotoxin), applied electroacupuncture to
the mice at the leg Zusanli (ST36) acupoint, located about 2 cm below the knee
in humans. If you’ve been reading SBM for a long time, you have, whether you
remember it or not, encountered discussions of studies using this acupoint
before, for example, once in a study published in Nature Neuroscience that Steve
Novella deconstructed, another in two studies that were misinterpreted and
claimed that adenosine was the common mediator of acupuncture effects, and
another in which the levels of various cytokines were measured after applying
differing voltages of “electroacupuncture” to this acupoint. As former
contributor Mark Crislip put it in his own inimitable way about this last study:

   So they stuck a needle in the ST36 Zusanli point of mice. Which is in the
   leg, below the knee. Who knew that mice and humans had the same meridians and
   acupoints? Then they cranked in some voltage and measured various cytokines 
   and other inflammatory mediators under various conditions to see what
   happens.

The ever-inimitable Dr. Crislip then wrote:

   They did not use a random peripheral site to apply the voltage or another
   acupuncture point as a control. As best I can tell, the study actually had
   nothing to do with acupuncture. What they demonstrated was electrical
   stimulation of peripheral nerves or the vagus nerve had anti-inflammatory
   effects. The use of the specific acupuncture point was, well, pointless.

   This is the kind of study that drives me nuts. You could remove all the
   references to acupuncture and the results would be just as applicable. I
   suppose it would then lack the sexiness that acupuncture adds. Without
   acupuncture as a hook, I wonder if it would have been published in Nature
   Medicine or get the notice it did.

He’s right, the rebranding sells the study, as none of this has anything to do
with the prescientific vitalistic quackery that is acupuncture. It’s somewhat
interesting neuroscience, but could easily get lost in a whole lot of other
somewhat interesting neuroscience, hence the acupuncture hook.

Basically, the Zusanli acupoint seems to be one of the favorite go-to acupoints 
on one of the magical meridians that acupuncture believers like to study. In any
event, it should never be forgotten that inducing the physiological effects of 
sepsis is in mice is never something that should be undertaken lightly, and
doing it in the name of trying to make acupuncture seem to have a scientific
basis is incredibly unethical, in my book. I can see why work like this could be
done in China, but where was Dana-Farber’s IACUC to protect the interests of
the experimental animals and minimize their suffering, given that the Methods
section leads me to believe that most of the animal experiments were done at
Dana-Farber? Moreover, even the Nature podcast seems to acknowledge the
bait-and-switch, albeit unknowingly, by characterizing electroacupuncture as
delivering electrical current to nerves (at around 2:45), which has nothing to
do with acupuncture, meridians, or qi. The announcer even says:

   Although the evidence supporting conventional acupuncture is controversial,
   electroacupuncture has been shown in several studies to decrease inflammation
   in mice, if the mouse body is stimulated in just the right way.

I will admit that the current study is definitely more sophisticated than that
study from several years ago to which Mark Crislip applied his inimitable
description, but all that sophistication went to support a narrative that seeks 
to demonstrate that acupuncture works. An example of this more sophisticated
approach, the authors produced transgenic mice (mice genetically manipulated to 
make specific proteins in specific neurons and the nerve tracts associated with 
them) to test electroacupuncture applied to the Zusanli acupoint:

   For this study, the goal was to investigate why ES can drive the recently
   reported vagal–adrenal axis from the hindlimb Zusanli (ST36) acupoint but not
   from the abdominal Tianshu (ST25) acupoint, at which ES instead drives
   spinal sympathetic reflexes10,11 (Fig. 1a). We postulated that
   somato–vagal–adrenal reflexes are driven by sensory pathways that innervate
   tissues unique to the hindlimbs compared to the abdomen, such as joints,
   bones and skeletal muscles. One candidate pathway includes DRG neurons marked
   by PROKR2Cre (in which with Cre-mediated recombination marks neurons with
   persistent or transient expression of prokineticin receptor 213). These
   neurons innervate deep limb tissues but not skin epidermis13.

So, for some reason, electricity to the hindlimb can stimulate the nerve
pathways that lead to stimulation of the vagus nerve, which inhibits the release
of inflammatory molecules from the adrenal glans and thereby decrease
inflammation, but stimulation of other mouse acupoints doesn’t. To study this,
the authors did this with dorsal root ganglia (DRG) neurons (don’t worry, I’ll
explain):

   To characterize PROKR2Cre neurons, we generated Prokr2Adv-tdTomato mice, in
   which the tdTomato reporter was restricted to DRG neurons defined by the
   developmental co-expression of PROKR2Cre (ref. 13) and AdvillinFlpo (ref. 14)

And:

   To study the functions of PROKR2ADV neurons, we generated Prokr2Adv-DTR mice,
   in which the expression of the diphtheria toxin (DTX) receptor (DTR) was
   restricted to PROKR2ADVDRG neurons (Extended Data Fig. 5a, b). Four weeks
   after DTX injections, 98.0 ± 0.5% of PROKR2Cre-marked DRG neurons were
   ablated (Extended Data Fig. 5c), which led to 44.5 ± 7.0% and 72.4 ± 5.7%
   reductions in TUBB3+ and NEFH+ fibre densities, respectively, in the
   periosteum (Extended Data Fig. 5d). Notably, no ablation was observed in the 
   spinal cord or brain (Extended Data Fig. 5e). We refer to these mice as
   PROKR2ADV-Abl.

I’ll sum it up. The authors used the a method known as cre-lox to introduce the 
gene for the diphtheria toxin specifically in specific neurons using DNA
sequences that drive the expression of two genes specifically restricted to the 
DRG. In doing so, they noticed that DRG neurons expressing this tdTomato
reporter had a higher representation at limb levels than at thoracic levels and 
did not overlap with neurons that innervate skin epidermis (the outermost layer 
of the skin). Next, they used mice in which the diphtheria toxin receptor
introduced into the mouse embryos in order to similarly restrict its being made 
to these neurons. They then eliminated these neurons and nerve fibers by
treating the mice with diphtheria toxin, which only destroys the cells that make
the receptor for the toxin, to observe the effect of lack of these fibers on
electroacupuncture through the Zusanli acupoint. The authors observed that
eliminating these neurons also eliminated the observed inhibitory effects due to
electroacupuncture in decreasing inflammation and concluded that these neurons 
have a “role in activation of the vagal–adrenal axis by low-intensity ES,” the
vagal-adrenal axis being a neurologic pathway and ES being electroacupuncture
stimulation.

Using this model, the authors reported:

   In LPS-treated control littermates, 0.5-mA ES at the ST36 site caused a 50%
   reduction in TNF and IL-6 induction and a 40% increase in survival rates
   compared with sham ES, and these effects were abolished in PROKR2ADV-Abl mice
   (Fig. 2d–g). We have previously reported11 that 0.5-mA ES of the abdominal
   ST25 acupoint does not drive vagal or sympathetic reflexes and is unable to
   suppress systemic inflammation. High-intensity ES of the ST25 site can drive 
   sympathetic reflexes and produce weak (through 1.0-mA ES) or strong (through 
   3.0-mA ES) anti-inflammatory effects independent of vagal efferents11. These 
   effects were unchanged in PROKR2ADV-Abl mice (Extended Data Fig. 6b–j).
   High-intensity (3.0-mA) ES of the hindlimb ST36 acupoint also drove spinal
   sympathetic reflexes and produced anti-inflammatory effects independent of
   PROKR2ADV neurons (Extended Data Fig. 7a, b). Thus, PROKR2ADVneurons are
   uniquely required for low-intensity ES to drive the vagal–adrenal
   anti-inflammatory axis from the hindlimb ST36 acupoint.

Yes, you read that. Stimulation of the Zusanli acupoint led to a 40% increase in
survival after systemic inflammation induced with LPS, an effect abolished in
the mice in which this neurological pathway had been ablated. In terms of
absolute numbers, only 20-40% of the mice in the control groups survived. Again,
from my perspective, one might justify an experiment like this for a purpose
that isn’t delusional or self-deceptive, such as studying what happens after a
certain nerve is stimulated with electricity and determining the mechanism for
these effects. While that is sort of what these experiments do, everything is
overlaid with the language and pseudoscience of acupuncture, even though what
this study shows is nothing more than that there is a nerve pathway in mice
that, when stimulated with electricity, can lead to a decrease in systemic
inflammation. That’s it.



A diagram showing how the ST36 accupoint is hypothesized to stimulate DRG cells 
and result in activity of the vagus nerve.

A number of other experiments were performed. One set of experiments showed that
stimulation of PROKR2ADV fibers activates an anti-inflammatory axis controlled 
by the vagus nerve. Those with some knowledge of neuroscience will recognize
that the vagus nerve is important in the parasympathetic nervous system, as
opposed to the sympathetic nervous system. In general, stimulation of the
sympathetic nervous system results in the “fight-or-flight” reflex and tends to 
be pro-inflammatory, while the parasympathetic nervous system counters that
stimulation and tends to be anti-inflammatory. This is a simple (but hopefully
not simplistic) way of describing the systems that boils it down to its essence 
for a lay presentation will allow you to understand the importance of the vagus 
nerve.

In another set of experiments, the authors cut the peroneal nerve (a nerve in
the leg that contains fibers that innervate the deep fascia) and showed that
doing so eliminated the anti-inflammatory effect that they had observed due to
stimulating the Zusanli acupuncture point, while they noted that cutting the
lateral cutaneous nerve, which innervates the skin, had no effect. There are a
number of other experiments that were done for various controls and to rule out 
other possibilities, but I won’t go into them here. Let’s for the moment, take
the findings at face value, with one exception. This is not acupuncture,
contrary to how Nature’s accompanying news article and podcast characterize its 
findings with passages like:

   Liu and colleagues’ findings reveal the cellular route by which ST36 ES
   activates the vagal–adrenal network. The cell bodies of the sensory neurons
   that express Prokr2 are located in structures called dorsal root ganglia in
   the lower spinal cord, and have long processes in the sciatic (hindlimb)
   nerve that innervate the ST36 acupoint.

And:

   The ST36 acupoint is situated at the point at which the sciatic nerve splits 
   into the sural, tibial and peroneal nerves that extend down the calf, and it 
   was not known which of these nerves is most effective for stimulation with
   acupuncture7,11. The location of Prokr2-expressing neurons in the deep
   tissues below ST36 predicts that the anti-inflammatory effects of
   low-intensity ST36 ES depend on the deep innervations of the common peroneal 
   nerve, rather than on the more-superficial skin innervations of the cutaneous
   sural nerves. Indeed, the authors confirmed that cutting the peroneal nerve,
   but not the tibial or sural nerves, blocks the anti-inflammatory effects of 
   ST36 stimulation.

Personally, I like to think of it more like this. Somehow, one point in one
acupuncture meridian as described by acupuncturists who use one system (of
several) of acupuncture, by coincidence, appears to correspond to a location (on
the mouse, at least), where the application of electrical current can stimulate
one nerve that produces a signal along a neurologic pathway that leads to
stimulation of the vagus nerve and inhibition of the release of pro-inflammatory
molecules by the adrenal glands. After decades of searching, some acupuncture
believers, having failed to find an effect on much of anything from just
acupuncture, figured out that the electrical stimulation of a handful of
acupuncture points (which were never based on physiology or any anatomic
structure) could lead to physiological effects, which, as a general concept,
should not be a surprise at all given that the entire nervous system works
through electrochemical signaling and it would be expected that the application 
of electricity to certain nerves can affect physiology somehow.

In that vein, let me rephrase the concluding paragraph of the Nature news story 
about this study, to describe what was really found, and it takes just one
relatively minor change in verbiage, which I’ll denote by crossing out one word 
of the original and inserting a very brief bold italicized phrase:

   If electroacupuncture targeted electrical stimulation of a nerve can
   selectively activate specific neuronal networks, it might be feasible to
   design ES treatments to induce local effects, similar to pacemakers
   (electronic devices implanted into the chest to control the heartbeat). Thus,
   it might eventually be possible to use ES to evoke local anti-inflammatory
   mechanisms in certain parts of the body — such as an arthritic knee or
   specific sections of the digestive tract in individuals with chronic
   inflammatory bowel disorders — without suppressing the whole immune system,
   increasing the risk of infection or leading to side effects elsewhere in the 
   body.

Notice how little I changed the text. The findings of this study, in fact, have 
even less to do with acupuncture than the adenosine studies that I wrote about a
decade ago. Unlike this new study, those studies, at least, didn’t use
electroacupuncture—or even electricity of any kind.

Is the neuroscience interesting? Sure. Nature-level interesting? That’s an
interesting thought, which brings me back to Mark Crislip’s question that I
quoted above and will rephrase for this study: Without acupuncture as a hook to 
make it “sexy,” I wonder if this study would have been published in as high
profile a journal as Nature or get the notice it did.

    2. Personally, I would bet that the answer would have been “no” to both
      questions. In fact, I’d bet that this study would never have made it to
      the pages of Nature if it hadn’t so blatantly rebranded targeted
      electrical stimulation as acupuncture. (Excuse me, “electroacupuncture”.) 
      If the study had been honest and simply reported its observations that the
      stimulation of the peroneal nerve at a specific point with low level
      electricity can produce systemic anti-inflammatory effects in mice through
      the activation of specific nerve fibers in it that can stimulate a nerve 
      pathway that in turn stimulates the vagus nerve to inhibit the adrenal
      glands from making epinephrine and other catecholamines, it likely would
      have been accepted for publication in a perfectly respectable mid-level
      neuroscience journal somewhere, but, then, that wouldn’t have been a
      Nature paper, now, would it?

An Industry of Worthless Acupuncture Studies

Steven Novella on August 26, 2015

Link



Even more interesting to me than the question of whether or not acupuncture is
effective for any particular symptom is the meta-question of how acupuncture
proponents have managed to promote a treatment with systematically terrible
scientific data. A new study provides a fresh example of this, which I will
discuss below.

I think the behavior of acupuncturists reflects the fact that there are
subcultures within science, where each community has its own standards, culture,
and typical practices. You see this reflected in how they conduct their
research and support their claims. Chiropractors, for example, have what is in
my opinion a very unscientific culture. Their treatments are not science-based; 
science is an afterthought cherry-picked to support what is ultimately their
philosophy.

The culture of acupuncture

The world of acupuncture has its own culture as well. Within this world there
are special, very permissive rules of science that allow acupuncture to work for
almost anything. One trend is to look for anything that happens locally in the 
skin when you stick a needle into it and then declare that a “mechanism for
acupuncture.” The rules of the acupuncture culture also allow for a shifting
definition of what acupuncture actually is, allowing the definition to conform
to whatever the evidence shows. It’s a neat and subtle trick that allows
acupuncture proponents to completely subvert the purpose of science.

The most common definition of acupuncture given, even in the very studies that
then violate that definition, is the practice of sticking acupuncture needles
into acupuncture points. The definition may also include eliciting the “de qi,” 
which is a sensation perceived when the needle achieves the proper depth or is
manipulated. The site “evidencebasedacupuncture.org,” for example, gives this
definition:

   Acupuncture is the method of treatment based on influencing the body by
   inserting needles in the specific points of human body, called acupoints.

The problem (for acupuncturists) with this definition is that carefully
controlled scientific studies consistently show that it does not matter where
you stick the needles or even if you insert needles (as opposed to just poking
the skin with dull needles, or retracting needles, or even tooth picks). To
further support this conclusion, the perceived effectiveness of acupuncture does
not depend on the degree of training or experience of the acupuncturist (so
whatever they are learning has no effect), but only upon how warm and nice they 
are to the patient. In short, acupuncture is an elaborate placebo.

One strategy to get around this pesky scientific evidence is to redefine
acupuncture as needed. Depending on the results of any particular study, sham
acupuncture (at the “wrong” positions) or placebo acupuncture (without needle
penetration) may count as acupuncture.

Further, it is common practice now to rebrand transcutaneous electrical nerve
stimulation (TENS) as acupuncture. TENS is a treatment that involves, as the
name suggests, providing small non-painful current of electricity to modulate
pain and other subjective symptoms. TENS is probably effective for pain (I could
not find any studies with hot flashes, the topic of the next section).

What the acupuncture community has done is magically transform TENS into
acupuncture and call it electroacupuncture, by delivering TENS through needles
that they call acupuncture needles (which are just thin needles). Again,
acupuncture points do not matter – because they do not exist.

Acupuncture for hot flashes

The new study falls squarely into the bait-and-switch strategy that is now very 
popular among acupuncture proponents. They looked at women breast cancer
survivors with hot flashes and compare four groups: “electroacupuncture” (EA),
sham acupuncture (SA), gabapentin, and placebo pill (PP). They found:

   By week 8, SA produced significantly greater reduction in HFCS [hot flash
   composite score] than did PP (-2.39; 95% CI, -4.60 to -0.17). Among all
   treatment groups, the mean reduction in HFCS was greatest in the EA group,
   followed by SA, GP, and PP (-7.4 v -5.9 v -5.2 v -3.4; P = < .001). The pill 
   groups had more treatment-related adverse events than did the acupuncture
   groups: GP (39.3%), PP (20.0%), EA (16.7%), and SA (3.1%), with P = .005. By 
   week 24, HFCS reduction was greatest in the EA group, followed by SA, PP, and
   GP (-8.5 v -6.1 v -4.6 v -2.8; P = .002).

The p-values are for the primary outcome, which was SA vs. PP. I thought that
was an odd choice for primary outcome – essentially a competition between two
placebos. In the end what this study shows is that sticking needles into someone
has a larger placebo effect than taking a pill. This is something we already
knew. Overall, the more invasive the procedure the larger the placebo effect. I 
should also point out that you cannot blind allocation to acupuncture vs pill – 
subjects know if they are getting stuck or taking a pill.

The comparison between EA and SA was not significant. So yet again, whenever you
control for the variables that actually define acupuncture (acupoints and
needle insertion) there is no significant effect.

A 2013 systematic review of acupuncture for hot flashes shows essentially the
same thing:

   We found insufficient evidence to determine whether acupuncture is effective 
   for controlling menopausal vasomotor symptoms. When we compared acupuncture
   with sham acupuncture, there was no evidence of a significant difference in
   their effect on menopausal vasomotor symptoms. When we compared acupuncture
   with no treatment there appeared to be a benefit from acupuncture, but
   acupuncture appeared to be less effective than HT (hormone therapy). These
   findings should be treated with great caution as the evidence was low or very
   low quality and the studies comparing acupuncture versus no treatment or HT 
   were not controlled with sham acupuncture or placebo HT. Data on adverse
   effects were lacking.

That conclusion is very common in the acupuncture literature. You could almost
cut and paste that in to the conclusion of any systematic review of acupuncture 
and just replace the name of the condition being treated. There is no difference
between acupuncture and sham acupuncture. When comparing acupuncture to no
acupuncture there is a difference, because that comparison is unblinded and
needle insertion has a known placebo effect. Overall the data quality is poor
with high heterogeneity.

Again, what is most interesting is why the authors decided to spend the
resources on the current study given the status of the literature.

Conclusion: Why indeed?

Medical science progresses by designing and performing more and more rigorous
studies, controlling for specific variables, until we can say with a high degree
of confidence what the risks and benefits are for a specific intervention in a 
specific subset of patients. The operative word there is “specific.”

The acupuncture literature does include the occasional well-designed study that 
follows this trend. The Archives of Internal Medicine acupuncture study in back 
pain published in 2009 was one such study – excellent control groups isolating
specific variables. But then the authors blew it by completely misinterpreting
their own data, confusing sham and placebo acupuncture for acupuncture.

More commonly we see a study similar to the current one – not designed to
actually answer the question of whether or not there is any specific efficacy to
acupuncture. We already have a pile of low quality studies, and now we have one
more to throw onto the pile.

It seems almost that these types of studies are designed not to ask if
acupuncture works, but to show that it works. The studies seem rigged to be
positive – of course there is going to be a difference in an unblinded
comparison between needle insertion and taking a pill.

There is a role for preliminary studies in medicine. They tell us where to focus
our resources and how to design safer and better trials. They don’t answer the 
question of whether or not a treatment works.

There are now thousands of acupuncture studies looking at every indication you
can imagine (which stretches credulity that there is any common underlying
mechanism). We are well past the time for preliminary studies. Despite thousands
of studies, there isn’t a single indication for which real acupuncture has been
shown to work to a high degree of confidence. At this point I would say that
acupuncture should be abandoned as a scientific concept. It is a failed
hypothesis that has added no real knowledge to our understanding of health and
disease.

If, however, you are going to spend the resources to do an acupuncture study,
make sure it is rigorous enough to add new information, and isn’t just another
preliminary study to throw on the pile and get another round of misleading
headlines about how “acupuncture” works. Of course a cynical person might
suspect that this is the real goal of these studies.

Latest Acupuncture Pseudoscience

Steven Novella on October 16, 2024

Link


JAMA Internal Medicine just published an article titled: Acupuncture vs Sham
Acupuncture for Chronic Sciatica From Herniated Disk, A Randomized Clinical
Trial. In an accompanying editorial comment, Jerard Z. Kneifati-Hayek and
Mitchell H. Katz write: “This was a methodologically rigorous study; there were 
multiple experienced acupuncturists, the comparison group used a well
thought-out sham control, and patients were followed up for 1 year—with
persistent improvements.”

So – is that it, then? Should SBM alter our general stance on the scientific
status of acupuncture? Nope, not even close. We will see why shortly, but first 
lets review why proponents of science in medicine remain skeptical about the
claims for acupuncture.

First, we must consider scientific plausibility. Acupuncture is the claim that
sticking needles in specific locations in the body (acupuncture points) can have
specific and even remote effects on physiology and symptoms. There are many
scientific problems with this claim. After more than a century of promotion,
acupuncturists have been unable to demonstrated that acupuncture points exist,
that there is even any internal validity or consistency in where they are and
what they do, or any meaningful potential mechanism by which they could
function. Science, in other words, cannot see acupuncture points – anatomically,
biochemically, or physiologically. They remain a figment in the mind of the
acupuncturist.

The traditional explanation for how acupuncture works is chi – a life energy
that flows through the body and is influenced by sticking needles in key
locations of flow. Chi also remains a scientific figment, with no basis in
reality. Some proponents have therefore tried to set chi aside and offer more
scientific explanations for the existence of acupuncture points and the efficacy
of acupuncture, but they have been unable to do so. They frequently point to
non-specific effects (what you would expect from sticking a needle through the
skin) but nothing consistent, replicable, or able to explain acupuncture’s
putative effects.

Plausibility, in short, remains extremely low. But in medicine we can look for
efficacy in the absence of a known mechanism. However, a key principle of SBM is
that plausibility should always be taken into account. Efficacy evidence is
complex and fraught with potential pitfalls, not the least of which is observer 
bias and many forms of placebo effects. Especially for subjective outcomes (like
pain), therefore, we need the most rigorous studies to draw any useful
conclusions. The baseline for efficacy research should be extremely high – and
higher still when evaluating a treatment with no plausible mechanism.

History is clear that if we do not take this very rigorous approach, and make
sincere efforts to prove efficacy claims wrong, then we can easily fall into a
culture of self-deception. The history of medicine has many examples of
treatments enjoying wide support, but that eventually collapsed under rigorous
scientific evidence. There are also copious examples of treatments, and even
entire professions, that are clearly pseudoscientific, but persist because of a 
culture that is soft on scientific rigor in medicine.

Acupuncture is perhaps the best example of this phenomenon – a treatment with
lots of cultural inertia, but never able to cross the line of scientifically
verifiable. Where is that line?

For any treatment, but especially one that is inherently implausible, we like to
see a few things. There needs to be a statistically significant and clinically 
relevant effect with rigorous methodology, and this effect needs to reliably
replicate. We do not have that with acupuncture – and we still don’t.

Let’s look at the current study that so impressed the editors at JAMA Internal
Medicine. Your first clue that something is amiss is in the title – “A
Randomized Clinical Trial”. Studies that are double-blind always bill themselves
as a “double-blind” clinical trial. Perhaps this was a strange oversight, so I 
verified the status of the trial:

“Given the nature of acupuncture manipulation, acupuncturists in this trial were
not blinded. The semistandardized treatment scheme was aligned with our recent 
expert consensus.”

The acupuncturists were not blinded. They tried to justify this by saying how
the acupuncturists need to know what they are doing, in order to do proper
acupuncture. But this has never been established. In fact, studies have shown
that the experience of the acupuncturists does not matter to efficacy. It also
does not matter if the treatment is standardized – this is because the treatment
does not matter, only the interaction of the acupuncturist seems to matter.

Regardless of justification – a non-blinded study with a subjective outcome is
not rigorous, it is scientifically worthless. In fact it is worse than
worthless, it is actively harmful because it is useful for propaganda and
deception. The editors of JAMA Internal Medicine have now played into this
propaganda.

It also has to be noted that this is an entirely Chinese study. This is relevant
for acupuncture studies because reviews have found that Chinese studies on
acupuncture are essentially never negative. They have a near 100% positive bias.
This is statistically impossible, and absolutely calls into question the
results of acupuncture studies coming out of China. In the context of this
clearly documented bias, any methodological wiggle room (such as not blinding
the acupuncturists) is unacceptable.

Even if the study were reported as rigorous, given this extreme bias, I would
remain skeptical of the outcome unless it were reliably replicated in countries 
without a massive cultural bias.

Keep in mind what we are being asked to accept. Look at the protocol and the
difference between true and sham acupuncture – the difference in needle location
is based entirely on “meridians”, which scientifically do not exist.

What this study is great evidence for is exactly what SBM promotes – the notion 
that we really do need highly rigorous studies in order to make confident
conclusions in medicine. Further, we need to close the loop on mechanism of
action. All of the science needs to work together toward a consistent
understanding. We cannot gloss over mysteries, unknowns, or inconsistencies.
Acupuncture represents a medical self-deception on a massive scale, one that has
been exported from China to the West.

Doctors, other clinical professional, and medical scientists need to maintain
the highest levels of skepticism toward any claims or treatments in medicine.
Otherwise we will slide into pseudoscience. History is very clear on this fact.

More “bait and switch” acupuncture studies

David Gorski on May 21, 2012

Link

Acupuncture has been a frequent topic on this blog because, of all the
“complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) modalities out there, it’s
arguably the one that most people accept as potentially having some validity.
The rationale behind acupuncture is, as we have explained many times before,
little different than the rationale behind any “energy healing” method (like
reiki, for example) in that it claims to redirect the flow of “life energy” (the
ever-invoked qi). The only difference is that acupuncturists claim to bring
this therapeutic qi rearrangement about by sticking thin needles into the
pathways in the body through which this qi is fantasized to flow. These
pathways, called meridians, are just as much a fantasy as qi itself or the
“universal source” that reiki masters claim to be able to channel through
themselves and into believers. Contributing to the popularity of acupuncture is 
its mythology as having been routinely practiced for over two thousand years, a 
myth that was the creation of Chairman Mao, who elevated what was a marginal
practice at the time to a modality that the state supported and promoted
(1,2,3,4).

In addition, because acupuncture involves sticking actual metal objects into the
skin rather than simply laying on hands or making magical gestures over the
patient, it retains some credibility, even among doctors. It doesn’t matter
that, reviewing the totality of the research, one finds that it doesn’t matter
where you stick the needles or even if you stick the needles in the skin. The
results are the same and indistinguishable from placebo. The inescapable
conclusion is that acupuncture is placebo medicine with needles. Personally, I’d
prefer my placebo medicine without needles, but that’s just me.

Yet, the studies keep rolling in, trying desperately to demonstrate that
acupuncture works or assuming that acupuncture works . Two more popped up within
the last couple of weeks, and one of them, if you read the press releases,
sounds really convincing. As is frequently the case, for this latter study,
there is less to it than meets the eye. I’ll start, however, with a study that
is a followup to a study I blogged about a couple of years ago that I
characterized as another overhyped acupuncture study misinterpreted. This one,
thankfully, is not nearly as hyped as the study from two years ago—or as the
second study I will discussed, but it is very instructive how the original
misinterpreted story is leading to a classic CAM “bait and switch” applied to
acupuncture.

Adenosine. It had to be adenosine.

Two years ago, I came across a study that claimed to have found the mechanism by
which acupuncture “works.” It made quite the splash, having been published, as 
it was, in a high profile journal, Nature Neuroscience. It was an animal study
using mice in which acupuncture was tested in a model of inflammation that
involves injecting complete Freund’s adjuvant into the mice’s paws. As a result,
the mice’s paws become inflamed by the irritant properties of the CFA and thus 
more sensitive to innocuous stimuli. This results in a measurably decreased
latency period for withdrawal to painful or innocuous stimuli. To boil the test 
down to its essence, after CFA injection, the mice’s paws would be more
sensitive, and the mice would react more strongly and rapidly to stimuli of heat
or touching. The complete discussion by yours truly can be found here, but the 
CliffsNotes version is that the authors noticed a peak of adenosine after
acupuncture and did some work that suggested that adenosine mediated the
“effects” of acupuncture. As I put it at the time, I doubt this paper would have
gotten into Nature Neuroscience if all the investigators did was to show that a
bit of local inflammation (i.e., sticking acupuncture needles into the mouse’s 
limb at one of the “correct” acupuncture points) resulted in the secretion of
adenosine into the extracellular fluid and then showed that that adenosine
blunted the pain response in nearby nerve endings. That would have been much
less interesting, because there is already a fair amount of literature
implicating the adenosine A1 receptor as a target for the relief of neuropathic 
pain. Acupuncture sexed up the findings.

Fast forward two years.

Now we’re faced with the offspring of an interesting, but largely irrelevant,
observation about the adenosine A1 receptor in acupuncture. This comes from a
different research group than those who published the original A1 paper, a group
at the University of North Carolina. Its authors, Julie Hurt and Mark Zylka,
have made what I consider to be a rather…interesting decision with regards to
how they spin their results. Let me just put it this way, even though this new
paper didn’t appear in Nature Neuroscience but rather in an open-access journal 
called Molecular Pain, what Hurt and Zylka did is the same as what was done in
the previous group, but on steroids. It is a classic bait and switch. Think of
it this way. When I wrote about the previous results, which showed that locally 
released adenosine appears to block pain transmission through local nerves, I
pointed out that that might well turn into a useful strategy to alleviate pain, 
if a way could be found to generate adenosine where you want it and when you
want it. The problem with adenosine is that its half life is pretty short; so
just injecting adenosine into the local area would not be nearly as useful as
just injecting local anesthetic into the area. No acupuncture is necessary.
Indeed, I rather suspected that the only reason acupuncture “worked” in the
original study to generate measurable quantities of adenosine locally is because
thin needles stuck into a mouse limb are like sticking a spear through a human 
leg, proportionally speaking. Unlike the case in humans, the needle is never far
from a major nerve bundle, and the local trauma is much more as a fraction of
the limb area.

So what do Hurt and Zylka do with this previous result? Do they propose a
strategy for generating adenosine near local nerves? Yes, indeed, they do, and
it appears, for the most part, to work, at least in this model. What do they
call this proposed therapy? The title of their article says it all: PAPupuncture
has localized and long-lasting antinociceptive effects in mouse models of acute
and chronic pain. Why PAPupuncture? Here’s why, as described in the
introduction:

   We previously found that the transmembrane isoform of prostatic acid
   phosphatase (PAP) functions as an ectonucleotidase and hydrolyzes
   extracellular AMP to adenosine in nociceptive dorsal root ganglia neurons
   [10,11]. PAP is expressed in several other tissues, including skeletal muscle
   that surrounds the Zusanli acupuncture point, and could be the rate limiting
   ectonucleotidase at this location [9,12]. PAP is a very stable enzyme when
   administered in vivo, with an 11.7 d half-life in blood [13]. Likewise, we
   found that intrathecal injection of a secretory version of human PAP (hPAP)
   had long-lasting (3 days), A1R-dependent antinociceptive effects in
   pre-clinical models of inflammatory pain and neuropathic pain [10,14]. These 
   long-lasting antinociceptive effects could be transiently blocked with a
   short-acting A1R antagonist, providing strong evidence that hPAP remains in
   tissue for days [10,15]. In contrast, adenosine has a very short half-life in
   blood (a few seconds) [16]. hPAP injections thus provide a novel way to
   generate a short-acting compound over a sustained time period [17].

So, basically, what PAPupuncture is, according to Hurt and Zylka, is injecting
an enzyme near the nerves that breaks down AMP in the extracellular fluid
into…drumroll, please…adenosine! To see the the blatantness of this
bait-and-switch going on here, I can’t resist pointing out that the authors
themselves write:

   Essentially all acupuncture points are located in muscle and are in close
   proximity to peripheral nerves [2]. The axons of nociceptive (“pain-sensing”)
   neurons course through peripheral nerves [3-5]. This proximity of
   acupuncture points to nociceptive afferents could explain why acupuncture is 
   modestly effective at treating pain in humans [1,6-8].

So, let me see. If Hurt and Zylka are correct, acupuncture is a very inefficient
method of “generating local inflammation” near peripheral nerves (i.e.,
sticking tiny needles into points not related to peripheral nerves by anatomy
other than by sheer coincidence). In other words, it’s useless, even by their
criteria. So what do they do? They turn it into regional anesthesia but still
call it a variant of “acupuncture.” In fact, all Hurt and Zylka have done is to 
inject an enzyme that turns a substrate into adenosine in the local area. They
even injected it into the popliteal fossa (in humans, the area right behind the 
knee), noting blithely that “clinicians inject local anesthetics into this same 
location for regional anesthesia.” No kidding. Anesthesiologists and surgeons do
inject local anesthetic right there. It’s called a popliteal block or sciatic
nerve block. A popliteal block can anesthetize the leg from the knee down
without the need for a spinal or epidural anesthetic, making it useful for
procedures involving the foot and ankle.

So what did this study find? Basically, it found that injecting PAP into the
popliteal fossa relieved pain for up to three days in different models of pain; 
that there was a dose-response effect in which injecting more PAP resulted in
more pain relief; and that adding more substrate (i.e., AMP, the starting
material that PAP converts to adenosine) also increases the response and
duration of the pain relief. It’s all fairly straightforward, and there’s
nothing really glaringly wrong with the experimental design, which is basically 
all designed to determine the parameters under which this technique works. It’s 
also a potentially useful technique in that adenosine doesn’t affect motor nerve
function (blocks targeted at nerves with motor and sensory components can
result in temporary paralysis distal to the injection site) and that the enzyme 
can generate adenosine for a prolonged period of time. This latter aspect of the
technique would be useful because prolonged analgesia from nerve blocks can
require catheters to keep injecting local anesthetic.

None of this is surprising, and it all might actually be useful, but acupuncture
it ain’t, not by any stretch of the imagination, which makes the authors’
insistence on calling this technique “PAPupuncture” puzzling indeed. A far
better name would be something like a “PAP block” or just a nerve block using
PAP. Similarly the insistence on using acupuncture point nomenclature is not
justified either. Why not simply call it a different form of popliteal fossa
block instead of “PAPupuncture”?

The discussion might give us a clue:

   Clinicians inject local anesthetics into the popliteal fossa to treat pain
   following foot and ankle surgery. However, this regional anesthesia procedure
   requires catheterization to block pain for more than a day [21,30]. Local
   nerve blocks are administered at many other locations of the body to
   regionally treat pain. While our work was focused on the popliteal fossa,
   PAPupuncture could in principle be performed in any body region where
   acupuncture and nerve blocks are performed and has the potential to reduce
   pain for a significantly longer period of time. Given that PAP works via an
   A1R-dependent mechanism, PAPupuncture would also bypass side-effects
   associated with opioid-based analgesics, and hence could provide a novel
   abuse-resistant way to treat pain. Ultimately, our study reveals that key
   mechanisms associated with Eastern and Western medicine can be merged and
   exploited to locally inhibit acute and chronic pain for an extended period of
   time.

This is all, of course, utter nonsense. What Zylka has done is interesting from 
a scientific standpoint. It might turn out to be useful in humans. It might even
turn out to be better than existing strategies for peripheral nerve blocks when
long-lasting analgesia is needed. It is not, however, acupuncture, which makes 
Zylka’s insistence on calling it “PAPupuncture” the purest form of bait-and
switch. His experiment was a good example of scientific medicine, a preclinical 
“proof-of-principle” animal experiment that could just as easily have been done 
without a single mention of acupuncture because acupuncture has nothing to do
with it. It is not a merging of “key mechanisms associated with Eastern and
Western medicine.” In fact, the reviewers who approved this paper need to be
taken to task for falling for the false CAM meme that there is “Western”
medicine, which is always portrayed as scientific medicine, and “Eastern”
medicine, which is always portrayed as more mystical and “wholistic.”
Personally, I find the whole construct not-so-subtly racist, and if I were Asian
I’d be offended by having “Eastern” medicine associated with quackery based on 
mystical pre-scientific ideas. Everything else Zylka does appears to be rigidly 
science-based. So why does he muddy it up by associating it with woo like
acupuncture, which is based on prescientific, vitalistic beliefs?

In fact, so little does this have to do with acupuncture that pharma is
interested. According to the press release from UNC:

   The next step for PAP will be refining the protein for use in human trials.
   UNC has licensed the use of PAP for pain treatment to Aerial BioPharma, a
   Morrisville, N.C.-based biopharmaceutical company.

Finally, what makes this more of a bait-and-switch is that acupuncturists don’t 
just claim that acupuncture can be used as a form of local or regional
anesthesia. They claim it is good for nearly everything that ails you, be it
infertility, asthma, chronic back pain, and any of a whole host of aches, pains,
conditions, diseases and maladies. Calling regional anesthesia with PAP
“PAPupuncture” is nothing more than a ploy to suggest that acupuncture works,
when PAPupuncture is not acupuncture. It’s all about marketing, not science.

Speaking of other diseases and conditions, let’s look at our second study.

Acupuncture for COPD

The second acupuncture study being touted in the press recently was a lot more
highly touted. I suspect that the reason for this is that it claims to provide
relief for a condition that, given the number of people who smoke, is very, very
common, namely chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). More importantly, 
the story doesn’t involve explaining things like an adenosine receptor, using an
enzyme to generate adenosine in the tissues, and other scientific details that 
bog down the story. This other study is much simpler to explain, and try to
explain it several journalists did, with a distinct lack of skepticism:

  1. Acupuncture May Help Ease Symptoms of COPD

  2. Acupuncture May Be Worth a Shot for COPD: Small Study Shows Acupuncture May
    Help People With COPD Breathe Easier

These news stories refer to a study from Japan by Suzuki et al published online 
a week ago in the Archives of Internal Medicine entitled A Randomized,
Placebo-Controlled Trial of Acupuncture in Patients With Chronic Obstructive
Pulmonary Disease (COPD): The COPD-Acupuncture Trial (CAT). It is just what it
sounds like: A test of acupuncture on COPD. First, let’s see what these news
stories say about it, beginning with U.S. News and World Report:

   For patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), acupuncture
   may help relieve shortness of breath during activity, Japanese researchers
   suggest.

   COPD is a progressive lung condition that makes it hard to breathe; it is
   commonly caused by smoking or exposure to other toxins.

   “The effects of acupuncture are large,” said Dr. George Lewith, from the
   University of Southampton in Hampshire, England, co-author of an editorial
   accompanying the study. “This is particularly remarkable in a condition that 
   seems largely unresponsive to more conventional treatments.”

And WebMD, whose writers should know better but apparently do not:

   Exactly how acupuncture improves symptoms of COPD is not fully understood.
   Researchers speculate that needling the acupuncture points on the rib cage
   area may help relax muscles involved in breathing.

   This makes perfect sense to Tong-Joo Gan, MD. He is a professor of
   anesthesiology at Duke University Medical Center in Durham, N.C. It also may 
   help reduce anxiety levels, he says. “When you become breathless, your
   anxiety goes up, so relaxation is another possible explanation for the
   benefit.”

   Acupuncture has been shown to release chemicals that relax the lungs and
   dilate the airways, he says.

   “Clearly it looks like a viable alternative to treat chronic COPD,” Gan says.
   “The downside is so little and the upside is so huge that acupuncture is
   well worth a try for those who find it difficult to control their COPD
   despite medications.”

Wow! If this study is any indication, acupuncture is the greatest thing since
sliced bread, at least for COPD. I’d also be interested in seeing the studies
that claim that acupuncture “releases chemicals that relax the lungs and dilate 
the airways.” I wonder if she meant this study, which looked at acupuncture with
electrical stimulation (which is not acupuncture but TENS) and appeared to find
an elevation in endorphin levels. Be that as it may, if you believe the hype
machine that revved up to promote this study, just as it does for any seemingly 
“positive” acupuncture study, you’d think acupuncture is the greatest thing
since sliced bread for COPD. But is it right this time? Is this study really
good evidence that acupuncture “works” for COPD? Not so fast, there, pardner.
The study, despite the breathless descriptions of it popping up in the press
yesterday, is—shall we say?—underwhelming.

The study itself is fairly straightforward in that it is a randomized study of
patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (i.e., COPD) treated with
standard therapy plus either “real” acupuncture or sham acupuncture. In this
case, the sham acupuncture consisted of needles that didn’t puncture the skin
rather than needling the “wrong” acupuncture points. The device used was a Park 
sham device, which comprises a needle (real or blunt-tipped placebo) with a
guide tube. The blunt needles appear to penetrate the skin but actually
telescope back into the tube. The primary endpoint measured was breathlessness
as measured by an instrument called the modified Borg scale after a test known
as the six-minute walk test. The modified Borg scale measures from 0 (no
breathlessness) to 10 (maximal). They also measured lung functions. Acupuncture 
treatments (sham or “real”) were administered once a week for twelve weeks, and 
the acupuncture points chosen were as shown below:

After twelve weeks of sham acupuncture or “real” acupuncture, the placebo
acupuncture group (PAG) and real acupuncture group (RAG) were compared for
various measurements after the six minute walk test. Again, the primary outcome 
measured was the modified Borg scale, which is a subjective measurement of
breathlessness, with a whole bunch of other secondary endpoints. Whenever I see 
such a large number of endpoints, I wonder about whether any control was made
for multiple comparisons, and, as far as I can tell from reading the
methodology, there wasn’t. So what did Suzuki et al find? After randomizing 68
patients, the found a significant improvement in the Borg scale after the six
minute walk test. They also reported a small improvement in oxygen saturation
(86% to 89%) while FEV1 didn’t change. (The significance of FEV1 was discussed
in a previous post about acupuncture and asthma.)

Many of the usual caveats with a study of this type apply. First of all, it’s a 
small study, and it’s very easy to have a false positive in a small study like
this. I have a hard time making much of this study without replication or a
larger study. Second of all—and this is the biggest flaw in the study, a flaw so
large that in my mind it pretty much invalidates the study—the study was only
single-blinded. The subjects were blinded to experimental group, but the
researchers and acupuncturists were not. There is no good excuse for this lapse,
given how many other investigators have successfully carried out double-blinded
acupuncture studies. The authors simply state that “we were unable to mask the 
acupuncture therapists.” Again, other groups have managed to blind the
acupuncturists using specially constructed needles; why couldn’t Suzuki et al?

Another thing that drove me crazy about this article was that the authors piled 
endpoint after endpoint into tables. About half the endpoints appeared to be
statistically significantly different, but with wide confidence intervals. For
example, adjusted differences between PAG and RAG in three of eight biomedical
measures listed in one table (Table 5) and six of eleven physiological measures 
(Table 6) were not statistically significant. Others that were “statistically
significant” appeared not to be particularly impressive. A lot of these
measurements, such as pulmonary function tests and the like, can also be
influenced by patient effort, which could easily be affected, either
intentionally or unintentionally, by how much the investigators measuring
ventilatory function encouraged them. In other words, what we have here is a
bunch of outcome measures, subjective and objective but potentially influenced
by investigators, that are not particularly impressive in a trial that is not
double-blind.

Another thing that one has to remember. For a treatment that does absolutely
nothing to the outcome measures being examined, at a statistical significance
level of p homeopathy, for example), by random chance alone we would expect
about 5% of studies to find an apparent “statistically significant” difference
between treatment group and control. That’s the random noise inherent in doing
research, and long ago it was somehow decided that we could tolerate a one in
twenty chance in a perfectly designed study of a false positive even in the case
where the treatment does nothing. Of course, it’s worse than that, as I’ve
written about many times before. As John Ioannidis has taught us, because no
clinical trial is designed and executed flawlessly and because there are always 
biases and imperfections in any clinical trial, the number of false positive
trials for something like homeopathy (which, being water, does absolutely
nothing) will actually be considerably higher than 5%. That’s why one has to
fall back on the totality of the scientific literature filtered through the lens
of plausibility as estimated by basic science considerations.

For COPD, the plausibility that acupuncture would be expected to have a
physiological effect is slim to none. Perhaps it’s not as close to “none” as
homeopathy is (acupuncture does, after all, involve sticking needles into the
body and it’s just barely plausible that that might do something), but it’s
pretty darned low, particularly considering the vitalistic ideas that underlie
acupuncture. Thus, filtering this study through the considerations of prior
probability, the lack of double blinding, and the lack of controlling for
multiple comparisons, and I am profoundly underwhelmed. That doesn’t even take
into account the fact that I don’t see any evidence that the data were analyzed 
in a strict intent-to-treat analysis, in which all the endpoints were chosen
before the study was undertaken and included in its design from the beginning.
There were drop-outs in both groups, but in the RAG group three dropped out
because they suffered acute exacerbation due to a respiratory infection. In such
a small study, that could easily have skewed the results if a strict
intent-to-treat analysis weren’t used.

None of this stops the authors from speculating wildly about a “mechanism” by
which acupuncture can allegedly improve lung function in COPD:

   We therefore speculate that a similar phenomenon is evoked in the accessory
   respiratory muscles by needling on the acupuncture points on the rib cage.
   Decreased muscle tone consequently caused the recovery of the muscle strength
   in the rib cage, resulting in the increased mobility in the rib cage.
   Relaxation of accessory respiratory muscles may also contribute to rib cage
   motion. In fact, the present study showed increases in maximum inspiratory
   mouth pressure, maximum expiratory mouth pressure, and range of motion in the
   rib cage at the end of acupuncture treatment.

   In this study, vital capacity, FVC, percentage of FEV1, and percentage of
   DLCO significantly increased after acupuncture treatment. These findings
   suggest that acupuncture treatment might improve DOE and exercise endurance, 
   at least to some extent, through the improvement of pulmonary function. It is
   not clear why acupuncture improves pulmonary function; however, we speculate
   that the relaxation of hyperactivated respiratory muscles and the correction
   of the autonomic tone might cause the beneficial effect on pulmonary
   function.22 Further investigations are needed to clarify this.

Go back and take a look at the acupuncture points used. Look at how few of them 
are actually over the ribcage. Is it the least bit plausible that a mere six
needles in the ribcage could accomplish this result? I think not. In fact, I
think the acupuncture apologists are doing some major contortions reaching for
this “explanation.”

Finally, there is another issue to consider. This study came from Japan, and the
corresponding author Dr. Masao Suzuki is listed as being affiliated with the
Department of Clinical Acupuncture and Moxibustion, Meiji University of
Integrative Medicine, Kyoto, Japan. As both Kimball Atwood and Steve Novella
have pointed out in the past, good evidence has been reported that acupuncture
studies from certain countries are significantly more likely to produce positive
results, and Japan is one of those countries. True, its published studies are
not as uniformly positive as those from China or Taiwan, but they appear to be
significantly more likely to be positive than European studies. R. Barker
Bausell discussed this very problem in his excellent book Snake Oil Science.

Given the inherent implausibility of acupuncture, combined with the large body
of evidence that shows that it doesn’t matter where you stick the needles or
even if you stick the needles in the skin. You get the same result, which is
indistinguishable from placebo effects. For a study to overcome that large body 
of evidence, it has to be far more compelling than Suzuki et al. In the end,
Suzuki et al is not nearly as rigorous as it has been represented and, as a
result, not nearly as persuasive as acupuncture apologists would like you to
think.

Conclusion

Acupuncture is a CAM modality that is considered part of traditional Chinese
medicine (TCM), although acupuncture in its current form appears to be a
phenomenon that is much more recent than it is portrayed by its supporters. In
particular, it was popularized, along with the rest of TCM, by Mao as a means of
giving the appearance of providing adequate health care to his people when he
did not have the resources to provide them scientific medicine. Despite its
roots in bloodletting, mysticism, and vitalism, acupuncture remains popular, so 
much so that even apparently conventional neuroscientists like Dr. Zylka take
the claims of its practitioners at face value and somehow find reasons to
“rebrand” acupuncture. Because acupuncture appears not to work as anything other
than an elaborate placebo, it is not surprising that using PAP injections is
far more effective than actual acupuncture. That is why there is no reason to
“brand” PAP anesthesia as “PAPupuncture.” Yet Zylka did it anyway. Meanwhile,
true believers like Suzuki (who is an acupuncturist, which is why I refer to him
as a “true believer”) produce studies that on the surface appear sound but are 
riddled with problems when examined more closely.

No wonder, of all the CAM modalities other than supplements, people tend to
think that acupuncture “works” more than any others. It is, after all, sticking 
needles into the skin. That’s one reason why acupuncture also makes a most
excellent Trojan horse. After all, doctors stick needles into people, don’t
they? So it’s easy enough for a scientist curious about acupuncture and perhaps 
not so well-versed in placebo effects to allow his curiosity to lead him to
stick some needles into some mice, measure some adenosine levels, and then
rebrand a science-based mechanism of analgesia that could be turned into a new
technique of anesthesia as somehow being based on acupuncture, and the message
is that acupuncture works. As that message, as unjustified as it is, spreads, by
extension the idea spreads that there might just be something to all this CAM
stuff.

That is how and why quackademic medicine is on the rise.

Some Sepsis Stuff

Sepsis interventions. Some don’t work and some don’t work.

Mark Crislip on October 20, 2022

Link



Sepsis. Bad stuff. Sepsis is when an infection, and occasionally other medical
conditions, set off a cascade of out of control inflammation, damaging or
destroying any number of organs and often leading to death.

As I said, bad stuff. Sepsis, in all its manifestations, has been one of the
mainstays of my practice. Sepsis can be transient and respond rapidly to
antibiotics and modern ICU supportive care. It can also be a relentless crash
and burn, a rapid and uncontrolled spiral into death.

I have seen a few young meningococcal patients who were fine at breakfast and
dead by dinner. Bad stuff.

For whatever reason, patients have recently been made aware of sepsis. For the
past few years, it has not been unusual to have been asked by families if the
patient was septic.

We have improved the management of sepsis over the years, mostly as we are
better and more aggressive at supporting failing organs. But the basic approach 
has been the same for the 36 years I have been in infectious diseases:
antibiotics, supportive care, and a gobbet of good luck.

Why some die and some survive is often a mystery. There is always variation in
both the infecting organism and the host. All E. coli are not the same, for
example, where different strains infecting identical mice will have different
mortality rates. Conversely, the same E. coli strain will have different
mortality rates in different strains of mice.

There are innumerable variations in the immune system that increase or decrease 
the risk of acquiring or dying from a variety of infections. My personal
favorite is how variations in snot can increase the risk of meningococcal
disease. As the Bard said, “The Sepsis, dear Brutus, is not in our stars / But
in ourselves”. I will be long retired (3 months, 9 days, 2 hours, 11 minutes as 
I write this, but who is counting?) before we can scan the genome of a patient
with a tricorder and point to the polymorphism that increased, or decreased, the
chance of infection and death.

Vitamin C

Every once in a while a patient does survive sepsis who really should not have. 
It always fries my bacon when the family credits God with the save. They have no
idea of the work and training the ICU team had accomplished to produce the
‘miracle’. Give credit where credit is due.

I have been around long enough to see many an adjunctive therapy come and go for
sepsis. Xigris, steroids, and others. It is common in the ICU, perhaps more
often for processes in which our interventions often fail and death is common,
for doctors to glom onto therapies that appear to work based on suboptimal
trials.

I have referred to it in the past as medical cold fusion: an effect that makes
little sense, if any, when compared to known reality. What follows is a flurry
of explanations about how the effect could be the real deal, some enthusiastic
embracing of the intervention, slow discouragement, finally ending in better
clinical trials that show, nope, the intervention did not do anything at all.

Sherman, set the Wayback machine to March 31, 2017, when you will find my last
entry of the first series of my SBM bloggin’, “Vitamin C and Sepsis. All Sound
and Fury? Much Ado About Nothing?”

At the time I was, for lack of a better word, skeptical (me? Hardly.) that
intravenous vitamin C and thiamine were actually effective in decreasing
mortality in sepsis. But I noted at the time:

   Never go in against vitamin C when death is on the line!

So the study was grudgingly embraced by our intensivists. For a while. You could
not tell at the time if the intervention made any impact on outcomes. It did
drive up the price of both IV vitamin C and thiamine. A lot. And then there were
more clinical trials.

What had been impressive was the decrease in mortality in the vitamin C/thiamin 
study I evaluated last decade. From 40% to 8.5%. I mean, wow. That seemed too
good to be true. And you know what follows. Was that result replicated?

Of course not. Based on eleven studies:

   In this meta-analysis, the use of IV high-dose vitamin C in patients with
   sepsis was not associated with lower short-term mortality.

And:

   A total of 17 studies including 3133 patients fulfilled the predefined
   criteria and were analyzed. Pooled analysis indicated no mortality reduction 
   in patients treated with vitamin C when compared to reference.

So another one bites the dust.

There were a few minor potential beneficial effects, which often show up in
these studies. And they are likely meaningless, the usual background noise seen 
in complex medical interventions that looks promising in subgroup analysis or
secondary endpoints. It’s usually crap:

   …although it was associated with significantly shorter duration of
   vasopressor use and greater decline in the Sequential Organ Failure
   Assessment score at 72–96 hours.

And:

   …subgroup analyses revealed an improved survival if vitamin C treatment was
   applied for 3–4 days

Subgroup analysis is a Latin term used by statisticians for ‘likely bullshit’.
Subgroup analysis invariably leads to nothing in later studies. I long ago
learned to ignore subgroup analysis.

It was noted that:

   …interestingly, six studies reported no adverse events related to the
   intervention, while three studies documented more frequent adverse events in 
   patients treated with intravenous vitamin C (hypernatremia n= 24,
   hospital-acquired infections n= 14, hyperglycemia n= 13, gastrointestinal
   bleeding n= 3, and fluid overload n= 1).

Interesting? Naw. The usual noise in clinical trials.

Perhaps more interesting was the NEJM trial, published after the above
meta-analyses:

   In adults with sepsis receiving vasopressor therapy in the ICU, those who
   received intravenous vitamin C had a higher risk of death or persistent organ
   dysfunction at 28 days than those who received a placebo.

Oops. The numbers:

   At day 28, 191 of 429 patients (44.5%) in the vitamin C group had died or had
   persistent organ dysfunction, as compared with 167 of 434 patients (38.5%)
   in the placebo group (risk ratio, 1.21; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.04 to
   1.40; P=0.01).

I have been convinced that a p needs to be at least .005 to perhaps represent a 
‘real’ effect. So really? Vitamin C was no different than placebo. All the
effects, good and bad, noted in these trials are, I would bet, just noise. More 
sound and fury, signifying nothing.

I mean, they didn’t even bother to collect “information regarding specific
pathogens and the appropriateness of antimicrobial therapy”.

And that is a finding across all the studies that I could hunt down. No one
cared about the microbiology, the source of infection, the host (for example,
while transplant patients have more bacteremia, they may die less often) or the 
appropriateness of antibiotics. All of which make a difference in outcomes.

From the perspective of an ID doc, it renders all the studies of marginal
applicability. Not all sepsis is the same, a concept apparently only an ID doc
cares about. Perhaps why every study has demonstrated that ID involvement with
infections of all kinds, including sepsis, improves outcomes: less morbidity and
mortality. Odd how having someone who actually knows that they are doing
improves care. Of course, since most of these studies were done by self-serving 
ID docs, well, go to Midas, get a muffler.

But it probably doesn’t matter. Vitamin C has a long history of no practical
benefit for any process outside of scurvy, because there is no reason it should.
Add sepsis to that list.

NRLM

As mentioned above, having healthcare providers who know what they are doing
improves care. What a concept. It makes me wonder how the opposite end of the
spectrum impacts healthcare. Not just knowing nothing about diseases but having 
your medical approach is based on the nonsensical ravings of a lunatic mind
(NRLM) cannot be good.

Great Britain at one time had 5 homeopathic hospitals, one as recently as 2018. 
I cannot tell if these institutions operated like real hospitals or not.

   The Bristol Homeopathic Hospital continued to provide a full range of
   services.

Whatever those services that might cover. I can’t imagine presenting at a
homeopathic hospital with sepsis where all they had to offer is nothing.

No one would rely solely on homeopathy for sepsis, or so one would hope.
Homeopathy has been used as an adjunctive therapy, with no benefit. Much to my
surprise, I discussed homeopathy and sepsis in 2009. The things I have done for 
which I have no memory. Sigh.

Despite being an “excellent piece of work on the role of homeopathy in
critically ill patients“, at least according to a homeopath, there has been
little research since I wrote that blog entry.

Part of the problem is the inability of septic patients to provide the bizarrely
detailed and pointless history that guides the selection of homeopathic
nostrums. Fear not. There is now, in caps:

   …the Protocol for Objective Homeopathic Semiology for patients with an
   altered state of consciousness.

The Protocol is available online, but I will confess after reading the paper
upon which it is based, I have no clue how one would apply it. The author’s
website, in Portuguese, has no explanation I can find. “[S]eeking the actual
characteristic symptomatic totality, with the hierarchization of homeopathic
symptoms” is, I fear, beyond me.

The author goes on to demonstrate how the protocol was applied to a series
(three) of septic patients:

   Choice of patients for homeopathic intervention was based upon recognition
   that they were not responding satisfactorily to conventional treatment as
   judged by the attending ICU medical team.

This was followed by the application of 5 drops of a 30 C or 200 C homeopathic
nostrum. A perforated gastric ulcer, a meningococcemia, and a pneumonia, all of 
whom survived. The conclusion?

   The practice of homeopathy may effectively be extended beyond treating
   chronic cases toward the less familiar but highly important frontiers on the 
   verge of life and death.

They actually thought homeopathy added to care of the patients. I keep wondering
why the practice of homeopathy is not considered a DSM-IV delusional illness.
NRLM indeed.

Acupuncture

One meta-analysis notes:

   Acupuncture has been used for various diseases, including severe infection,
   in China for more than 2,000 years.

That is true. There are multiple reports of infection and sepsis caused by
acupunc… oh wait. This is acupuncture used to TREAT infection and sepsis. That’s
different. Nevermind.

Supposedly,

   Previous studies reported that acupuncture at Zusanli (ST36) might be
   effective in treating sepsis

The point is just below the knee and lateral.

It is quite the point, stimulation of which has wide-ranging effects besides
treating sepsis. In animal models,

   …acupuncture at ST36 could be useful in reducing sepsis-induced injuries in
   heat, lung, kidney, liver, gastrointestinal tract, and immune system.
   Moreover, its potential mechanisms for antisepsis might include decreasing
   oxidative stress and inflammation, improving microcirculatory disturbance,
   and maintaining immune balance during sepsis.

I mean wow, truly the wonder drug that works wonders despite:

   Poor methodological quality and publication bias exist.

How about in humans? And here we have a problem. I can’t access most of the
original data from the review “Efficacy and safety of acupuncture as a
complementary therapy for sepsis: a systematic review and meta-analysis” that
purports to show a mortality benefit to adding acupuncture to standard care.

All the studies are from China, and as a result, are unfortunately suspect as
has been mentioned before. As is always the case, a  were included in the
review, so there was no one acupuncture intervention that ‘worked’ – it is the
concept that is effective.

The same issue, by the way, was in the meta-analysis that demonstrated decreased
mortality in sepsis with Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine: each trial in the
series had a different treatment intervention but the collected data showed:

   Addition of TCM has better effects in participants with sepsis.

It just does not matter the specific form of TCPM. I find that so…weird that
these meta-analyses include very different interventions as if they were all the
same. Meta-analyses are supposed to compare apple and apples, not dog shit and 
cow pies.

For the acupuncture trials:

   Most included studies had an unclear risk or high risk of bias in allocation 
   concealment and blinding of participants. In addition, included studies were 
   mostly small sample single-center RCTs. Therefore, the degree of certainty
   around our findings is low to very low.

My certainty is high that acupuncture does nothing for any process so why would 
it alter the course of sepsis?

I went through the bibliography seeing if I could glean much from the titles and
abstracts. Nope. More than a few dead links. None of the articles appeared to
be evaluating mortality as a primary outcome, mostly looking at lab parameters
or effects on the GI tract, such as “Electroacupuncture Improves Intestinal
Dysfunction in Septic Patients: A Randomized Controlled Trial“, which found:

   However, there were no significant differences in the days on MV, length of
   stay in ICU, and 28d mortality between two groups ( P>0.05).

And Yang et al., noted in the references, demonstrated that:

   There was no significant difference of mortality in the 28th day between the 
   two groups, with 5 deaths of 29 patients in the intervention group (17.2%)
   and 9 of 29 in the control group (31.0%).

But not included in the mortality section of the meta-analysis. Odd.

So in the end I can’t make detailed analysis of the meta-analysis, but that
always begs the question: why bother to apply the concepts of reality to
fiction?

Because it is what we do at SBM.

             Acupuncturist’s Unconvincing Attempt at Damage Control

                           Published by Harriet Hall 

                                      Link

Acupuncture has been in the news recently. A former President of South Korea had
to undergo major surgery to remove an acupuncture needle that had somehow
lodged in his lung.  A recent study in Pain compiled a list of 95 published
reports of serious complications of acupuncture including 5 deaths. Meanwhile,
acupuncturists continue to insist that their procedures are “safe.”

Edzard Ernst et al.’s article “Acupuncture: Does it alleviate pain and are there
serious risks? A review of reviews“ was published in the journal Pain in April 
2011. It had two parts: (1) it was a systematic review of 57 systematic reviews 
showing that there was “little truly convincing evidence that acupuncture is
effective in reducing pain,” and (2) it tabulated published reports of 5 deaths 
and 90 other serious complications of acupuncture treatments. I wrote an
accompanying commentary, “Acupuncture’s claims punctured: Not proven effective
for pain, not harmless.”

William Morris chastised me for not declaring a conflict of interest (!?) in my 
commentary. Now, in Acupuncture Today, he has criticized the Ernst et al. study 
itself.

Morris’ first criticism is that the study

   did not examine iatrogenic deaths due to conventional drugs,
   chemotherapy, radiotherapy and surgery. It was more focused on the safety and
   efficacy of acupuncture.

I laughed out loud when I read this. It was focused on the safety and efficacy
of acupuncture because it was a study about the safety and efficacy of
acupuncture. Duh!  A study of acupuncture for pain is not the appropriate place 
to examine iatrogenic deaths from four conventional treatment methods that are
used for every disease from pneumonia to cancer. We need to know about
acupuncture’s efficacy and safety (for pain) before we can even consider making 
any meaningful comparisons with other treatments (for pain). He says “it would
be interesting to see results an [sic] in-depth ‘review of reviews’ on the
safety and efficacy of conventional medicine and surgery.” Sure it would, but
this is hardly the place.  He tries to forestall protests by insisting this is
not a tu quoque argument; but it sure sounds like it, or like something worse.

Comparing iatrogenic deaths from different treatments would be a valid subject
for a different article. But why does he single out conventional medicine
instead of including deaths from all forms of alternative medicine? What about
the risk of stroke from neck manipulation? Neck manipulation would be a
particularly pertinent comparison to acupuncture because it is used by many
chiropractors to treat pain as an alternative to both conventional medicine and 
acupuncture. And why single out deaths instead of looking at all serious adverse
events? Most importantly, why not look at risks in the context of proven
benefits?

Curiously, Morris does not address the results of the systematic review of
acupuncture’s efficacy or attempt to counter its conclusions in any way. He only
briefly criticizes its methodology, and then he focuses on the reports of
adverse effects.

The Systematic Review of Systematic Reviews

He criticizes Ernst et al. for lack of detail in describing how they quantified 
the quality of the studies they included in their analysis. But they supplied a 
footnote to an article describing their method, indicating that they followed
Oxman and Guyatt’s validated checklist. Does Morris think they should have
reproduced the entire checklist and evidence for its validation in the text of
their article? I can’t fault them for using a footnote to save space.

“For data on efficacy, it doesn’t provide information about how the studies were
controlled.” He wants to know whether it was “acupuncture alone, skin
penetrating, non-penetrating or adjacent to the point location.” This only
highlights the imprecision of acupuncturists’ own definitions of what qualifies 
as acupuncture and what constitutes appropriate controls. In my commentary I
pointed out:

   there are various schools of acupuncture with different acupoints, and
   studies of acupuncture have included “electroacupuncture” (with or without
   needles), ear acupuncture, cupping, moxibustion, and other loosely related
   procedures.

If he had any evidence that his preferred version of acupuncture was more
effective or safer than other versions, or that one type of control is more
appropriate than another, he could have presented it. He expresses doubts rather
than offering data.

Safety

Morris criticizes Ernst et al. for including case reports where causality was
uncertain, but each case report was listed individually and its causality
categorized as certain or probable. The deaths were categorized as “certain”
causality. Even if you eliminate the uncertain ones, the data show that
acupuncture cannot be characterized as risk-free.

Bizarrely, he criticizes Ernst et al. for not including other complications such
as fainting, vomiting, or bruising that are more common adverse effects. These 
are not “serious” risks, which is why they were not included in a study of
“serious risks.” In essence, Morris seems to be arguing that acupuncture is even
less safe than Ernst et al. depicted.

He says “Ernst and his colleagues do not reference previous studies showing
acupuncture as safe,” citing a 2003 article by Lao and Berman published in an
alternative medicine journal. That article’s conclusion included the authors’
opinion (a value judgment) that acupuncture is “a generally safe procedure”; but
its text identified 202 adverse events, over twice as many as the Ernst et al. 
article. It included minor events like fainting and nausea, while the Ernst
study was limited to serious events. I don’t have access to the full study. I
wonder if it is exempt from the same criticisms: did its authors describe how
they quantified the quality of the reports they included, did they assess the
certainty of causation, and did they follow a validated checklist like Ernst et 
al. did?

Morris quotes a researcher who says “acupuncture is seen as an extremely safe
therapeutic system whose complications are very rare and are easily avoided or
rectified.”  This is not at all in conflict with the findings of the Pain study.
Ernst et al. found a number of complications that was quite small in relation
to the large number of acupuncture treatments, and they called for better
training of acupuncturists to minimize the chance of complications. The real
point is that there is no reason to accept any degree of risk, no matter how
little, if there is no benefit to the treatment. Safety by itself is no
recommendation: homeopathy is probably the safest treatment going.

Conflict of Interest

Morris criticized me for not declaring a conflict of interest in my commentary. 
I have no conflict of interest: it makes no difference to me whether
acupuncture works or not; I would follow the evidence wherever it led and write 
about it.  He, on the other hand, has a clear interest in defending his
occupation, and I don’t see any declaration of his conflict of interest in his
Acupuncture Today article. The Ernst et al. study is solid: it shows that there 
is little evidence that acupuncture is truly effective in reducing pain. Taken
as a whole, a rigorous evaluation of the published evidence leads to the
conclusion that acupuncture is no more effective than placebo, and it is not
risk free.  Morris doesn’t want to accept this. He is biased in favor of
acupuncture and is doing whatever he can to limit the damage from the Pain
study. He can’t do much: his efforts are unconvincing and rather sad.

Acupuncture and Allergic Rhinitis: Another Opportunity for Intellectual
Sterility

Mark Crislip on March 8, 2013

Link


You need to keep an open mind.

A common suggestion offered to naysayers of nonsense.

The usual retort concerns not letting one’s brain fall out.

Evaluating SCAM’s is less about having an open mind and more about having
standards, a conceptual framework that is used to interpret and analyze new
information. One of the benefits of writing and reading topics covered by
science-based medicine (SBM) is it has clarified and sharpened the ideas by
which I understand the world. Those concepts were nicely summed up by Steve
Novella at Neurologica, and I reproduce them here, slightly modified. They
should be on stone tablets, not quite commandants, but strong suggestions. The 8
strong suggestions somehow doesn’t cut it however.

  1. Respect for knowledge and truth – SBM values reality and what is true. We
    therefore endeavor to be as reality-based as possible in our beliefs and
    opinions. This means subjecting all claims to a valid process of evaluation.

  2. Methodological Naturalism – SBM believes that the world is knowable because it
    follows certain rules, or laws of nature. The only legitimate methods for
    knowing anything empirical about the universe follows this naturalistic
    assumption. In other words – within the realm of the empirical, you don’t
    get to invoke magic or the supernatural.

  3. Promotion of Science – Science is the only set of methods for investigating
    and understanding the natural world. Science is therefore a powerful tool,
    and one of the best developments of human civilization. We therefore
    endeavor to promote the role of science in our society, public understanding
    of the findings and methods of science, and high quality science education.
    This includes protecting the integrity of science and education from
    ideological intrusion or anti-scientific attacks. This also includes
    promoting high quality science, which requires examining the process,
    culture, and institutions of science for flaws, biases, weaknesses, and
    fraud.

  4. Promotion of Reason and Critical Thinking – Science works hand-in-hand with
    logic and philosophy, and therefore SBM also promotes understanding of these
    fields and the promotion of critical thinking skills.

  5. Science vs. Pseudoscience – SBM seeks to identify and elucidate the borders
    between legitimate science and pseudoscience, to expose pseudoscience for
    what it is, and to promote knowledge of how to tell the difference.

  6. Ideological Freedom/Free Inquiry – Science and reason can only flourish in a
    secular society in which no ideology (religious or otherwise) is imposed
    upon individuals or the process of science or free inquiry.

  7. Neuropsychological Humility – Being a functional SBM proponent requires
    knowledge of all the various ways in which we deceive ourselves, the limits 
    and flaws in human perception and memory, the inherent biases and fallacies 
    in cognition, and the methods that can help mitigate all these flaws and
    biases.

  8. Consumer Protection – SBM endeavors to protect themselves and others from
    fraud and deception by exposing fraud and educating the public and
    policy-makers to recognize deceptive or misleading claims or practices.

An excellent list of the mindset I strive to achieve, with variable success. I
have always been reasonably well versed in methodological naturalism. Science in
general (physics, chemistry, etc.), and the basic sciences of medicine
(physiology, anatomy, biochemistry, etc.) have always been the starting point of
my understanding of the world and the practice of medicine. The breadth and
depth of understanding of the natural world these disciplines provide is
amazing.

My time in science-based medicine has reinforced the validity of methodological 
naturalism, already strong, but added components that had never been addressed
in my formal education. One is the importance of prior probability. In the
teaching program at my hospital prior probability is usually invoked in the
context of determining if a test result is likely to a true positive. In the
real world of medical practice prior plausibility for therapeutic interventions 
is rarely a consideration. In my 30 years I have seen a lot medical
interventions come and go, but none have been attempted or abandoned because of 
a priori implausibility.  Mine has not been a practice where magic is attempted.
Good ideas for therapy, based on interfering with known pathophysiology,
sometimes are not effective.

With an understanding of how the natural world functions, a consideration of
prior plausibility, combined with knowledge of the multitudinous ways in which
we can fool ourselves and others, allows for near-instant pattern recognition
that a medical intervention is nonsense, that it cannot be effective. Like
treating a stuffy nose.

One of my favorite goofy therapies is the wet sock treatment, beloved by
naturopaths and, along with homeopathy, evidence that naturopathic practice is
divorced from any reality I know:

    1. Take a pair of cotton socks and soak them completely with cold/ice water. Be
      sure to wring the socks out thoroughly so they do not drip. (May place
      the wet, wrung out thin socks in the freezer as well. Hang them on a
      freezer shelf so they are easy to remove).

    2. Warm your feet first. This is very important as the treatment will not be as
      effective and could be harmful if your feet are not warmed first. Place
      and soak your lower legs into the bucket of hot water which you have
      prepared (be sure the water is quite hot (an indicator for the proper
      temperature is one may slowly place their lower legs into the bucket as
      they tolerate the heat).

    3. Soak your lower legs in the bucket for approximately 3 to 5 minutes or
      taking a warm bath beforehand can accomplish warming.

    4. Dry off feet with a dry towel.

    5. Remove socks from the ice water bucket. Wring out well. – OR have someone
      remove your socks from the freezer and bring them to you.

    6. Place cold wet socks on feet.

    7. Cover with thick wool socks.

    8. Go directly to bed, lay down and watch a movie, or read a book. Avoid
      getting chilled.

    9. Keep the socks on overnight. Place the second set of pajamas next to the
      bed.

    10. During the night, you may wake up with your whole body wet from sweat. If
      so, change into the dry pajamas, but leave on the socks. You will find
      that the wet cotton socks will be dry in the morning.

    11. Do nightly if your symptoms have not yet improved

    12. Stop the Wet Sock Treatment if your symptoms have abated or gone altogether

How does wet sock treatment work?

   This treatment acts to reflexively increase the circulation and decrease
   congestion in the upper respiratory passages, head, and throat. It has a
   sedating action and many patients report that they sleep much better during
   the treatment. This treatment is also effective for pain relief and increases
   the healing response during acute infections.

While nonsense, practitioners swear by it. Readers of this blog are well aware
of the multitudinous potential biases with assigning efficacy to wet sock
treatment. At a fundamental level there is no difference between wet sock
therapy, homeopathy, acupuncture or any other SCAM for the treatment of a stuffy
nose. When contrasted with known reality they can’t work, and when
neuropsychological humility is factored in, it is highly likely that any effects
that are noted can be accounted for by unrecognized bias on the part of patient
and practitioner.

The big difference is that acupuncture is a form of magic that is likely to get 
published in formerly reliable journals complete with positive spin: Acupuncture
in Patients With Seasonal Allergic Rhinitis. A Randomized Trial. 

Allow me to evaluate the study with

   …ad hominem remarks, anonymous criticism, phony expertise and the use of
   opinion to contradict data, (as a) self-proclaimed sceptic.

with a

   … a near complete absence of substantive scientific critique, (A) lack of any
   reasoned debate… and intellectual sterility.

There multiple flaws, evidently ignored or missed by the editors of the Annals, 
that render the optimistic conclusions of the paper untenable.

The first is the basic protocol. I have read it multiple times and upon each
reading it appears more ludicrous than the time before.

The study takes place during allergy season, springtime for needling and
Germany, Deutschland is happy and gay!

Patients were randomized to get real (I will avoid putting real in quotes, like 
‘fresh’ fish) or sham acupuncture, 12 treatments over 8 weeks. Their symptoms
were followed by three surveys:

   Rhinitis Quality of Life Questionnaire (RQLQ), which has 28 questions in 7
   domains (activity limitation, sleep problems, nose symptoms, eye symptoms,
   other symptoms, practical problems, and emotional function) ranked from 0 (no
   impairment) to 6 (severe impairment) (12). Medication need was measured
   using an RM score (RMS), comprising the weekly sum of daily assessments
   (cetirizine, 10 mg/d, or equivalent [1 point]; cetirizine, 20 mg/d, or
   equivalent [2 points]; and any form of systemic steroids for SAR [3 points]) 
   (daily range, 0 to 3; weekly range, 0 to 21) (13). Secondary outcomes
   included proportion of responders, defined as patients with a decrease in
   RQLQ score (mean scores at weeks 7 and 8) of at least 0.5 point compared with
   baseline; change in symptoms, assessed using a VAS (0 to 100 mm) for overall
   SAR symptom severity and for nasal, eye, pharyngeal, and common symptoms;
   and health-related quality of life, assessed with a German version of the
   Short Form-36 Health Survey (SF-36).

Two weeks ago I have the pleasure of listening to Dr. Ben Goldacre discuss his
new book and during the talk he covered the utility of using multiple
questionnaires in assessing antidepressant efficacy. He listed a dozen
questionnaires in a frenetic manner that should win the title for worlds fastest
talker, then he pointed out that if you ask enough questions, some of them will
show significant positive effects.

They evaluated the effect of the acupuncture at baseline, at weeks 7 and 8 of
the first year, at weeks 15 and 16 (two months after the acupuncture) of the
first year, and at weeks 7 and 8 of the second year. A year later.  That is
where ludicrous wanders into the study.

The results, from the abstract:

   Compared with sham acupuncture and with RM, acupuncture was associated with
   improvement in RQLQ score (sham vs. acupuncture mean difference, 0.5 point
   [97.5% CI, 0.2 to 0.8 point; P < 0.001]; RM vs. acupuncture mean difference, 
   0.7 point [97.5% CI, 0.4 to 1.0 point; P < 0.001]) and RMS (sham vs.
   acupuncture mean difference, 1.1 points [97.5% CI, 0.4 to 1.9 points; P <
   0.001]; RM vs. acupuncture mean difference, 1.5 points [97.5% CI, 0.8 to 2.2 
   points; P < 0.001]). There were no differences after 16 weeks in the first
   year. After the 8-week follow-up phase in the second year, small improvements
   favoring real acupuncture over the sham procedure were noted (RQLQ mean
   difference, 0.3 point [95% CI, 0.03 to 0.6 point; P < 0.032]; RMS mean
   difference, 1.0 point [95% CI, 0.2 to 1.9 points; P < 0.018]).

As they note:

   After the 8-week follow-up phase in the second year, small improvements
   favoring real acupuncture over the sham procedure were noted.

suggesting efficacy of the intervention up to a year later. That is one powerful
intervention if it can have an effect on outcomes up to a year later.

From my research the RQLQ has to change by more than 0.5 to be considered
minimally significant.  So the response as measured by the RQLG is just at the
level of normal variation in the score. Hardly impressive.

The hypothetical mechanism by which acupuncture is alleged to work?

   … studies have shown a potential effect of acupuncture on atopic diseases via
   different mechanisms, including changes of the endogenous opioid peptides in
   the central nervous system; reduction of prostaglandin E2 levels in the
   brain and serum; suppression of IgE production and modulation of Th1/Th2 cell
   response; central influence of acupuncture stimulation with specific
   activation of brain regions, including the influence of neu- ronal structures
   containing encephalin or beta-endorphin; and reduction of allergen-induced
   basophil activation.

Outside of vaccines and some biologics such as Rituxan, I cannot think of any
medical intervention whose affect upon disease physiology persists longer than a
few days after cessation. To continue to alter physiology a year later would
make acupuncture one of the most powerful and longest-lasting medical
interventions ever discovered.  Especially if applied to the usually transient
effects noted above.

Or, as is more likely, the differences are all noise and bias.

And is there the potential for noise and bias? As my in-laws would say, oh yeah,
you betcha.

First, they

   …developed the trial interventions in a consensus process using a Delphi
   approach with experienced acupuncture experts.

Which means? It means there is no standard treatment for allergic rhinitis with 
acupuncture. Everyone did it a different way and the Delphi approach is a method
of achieving a consensus when there is no standard. And even then there was
variability in how many needles each patient received and where they were
placed.

I went looking on the Googles for information concerning the validity of the
acupuncture points used in the trial and I will admit to defeat. Most of what I 
found concerned acupressure points, which were mostly around the nose.  If they 
used well defined points for allergic rhinitis, I cannot find them.  Which is
not surprising as traditional Chinese medicine is not concerned with the
underlying pathophysiology of a disease like allergic rhinitis.  TCM
practitioners look at the tongue and feel the pulse, among other techniques, to 
determine a therapeutic intervention.  If acupuncture actually did something to 
underlying pathophysiology, and there is no reason to suspect it would, it would
be like choosing an antibiotic based on the reading of goat entrails.  And I
sometimes suspect that is how antibiotics are chosen.

The sham acupuncture patients

   …were needled in at least 5 of 7 predefined non acupuncture points
   bilaterally, with only superficial insertion of needles (maximum 20 mm in
   length). Needle type and diameter were not defined (10). De qi and manual
   stimulation of the needles were avoided.

So in essence what they did was come with a quasi-arbitrary quasi-random form of
needling and compared it to sham acupuncture, a different quasi-arbitrary
quasi-random form of needling.

We all know it is skull, ear and oral acupuncture that is best for ENT problems.
No wait, it’s laser acupuncture.  That’s the ticket. Lasers for allergic
sinusitis. And of course we all know that acupuncture works better for rhinitis 
if done during the dog-days.  Such is the state of published acupuncture for
rhinitis.  No consistency.

Given the thousands of acupuncture points, the lack of precision of defining
these points and the various acupuncture schools (Chinese, German, Japanese,
etc) how do they know they were not in another school’s acupuncture point? The
only part of the human body that is routinely free of acupuncture points in the 
genitalia. I doubt they were needling there. Maybe the sham acupuncture was in
active sites that were inadvertently altering Japanese or ear qi to make the
rhinitis worse.

The sham group was not the same in that they had fewer needles on average: 10
needles (range 4 − 14) compared to the real acupuncture’s 16,  (range 9 to 25). 
The sham group also had no manipulation, the needles were shallow and they were
not irritated to generate de qi.

The variation in the number of needles also suggests acupuncture is a therapy
practitioners just make up as they go along.  In the SCAM world that is referred
as individualization. Since bigger placebo and more placebo will have increased
effect compared to smaller and lesser placebo, one would suspect a better
effect from the real acupuncture.

The sham acupuncture was less of an intervention: fewer needles, less
penetration and no manipulation. It was an inferior substitute for real
acupuncture, not a valid placebo, which they admit in the study protocol.

Patients were told:

   In this study different types of acupuncture will be compared. One type is
   similar to the acupuncture treatment used in China. The other type does not
   follow these principles, but as also been associated with positive outcomes
   in clinical trials.

I suspect that a quick search of the interwebs by patients could suggest if they
were getting needled in valid acupuncture points, although not if they were the
right valid points.

There is probably sufficient qualitative differences in the two intervention  to
account for any differences in comparative efficacy and it is likely that
unblinding occurred. Did they check for unblinding?

They did ask the patients:

   How confident do you feel that acupuncture can alleviate your complaint? How 
   confident would you be in recommending acupuncture to a friend suffering from
   similar complaints? How logical does this treatment seem to you? How
   successful do you think this treatment will be in alleviating other
   complaints?

The acupuncture groups scored higher in the “How confident do you feel that
acupuncture can alleviate your complaint?” question and they note:

   Although some degree of unblinding might have influenced the overall result
   (33), a major bias seems unlikely because we informed patients that 2 types
   of acupuncture treatment were being compared without mentioning such terms as
   “placebo” or “sham,” because similar strategies of informed consent have
   been used in most previous acupuncture trials (34–38), and because post hoc
   analyses suggested that differences in study outcomes could not be explained 
   by patient beliefs about treatment or other baseline differences.

So they assessed belief in acupuncture but in an impressive manifestation of
don’t ask, don’t tell, they did not inquire of the patients what they thought
they had received. A key question that was artfully avoided.

And given the differences in number of needles and the techniques used, although
practitioners “were instructed to deliver both in the same context and with the
same behaviors.” I am skeptical they were successful. Plenty of opportunity for
the Clever Hans effect where the patient would note unconscious behaviors of
the acupuncturist that suggests they are, or are not, receiving the real deal.

So there is ample opportunity for noise and bias to be the reason the
acupuncture group was barely better than the sham group.  And the differences
were trivial at best.

When you look at the overlapping error bars you would conclude that acupuncture 
= sham acupuncture = doesn’t work. If the graphs were for angina treated with
mammary artery ligation verus sham surgery, you would not advise the surgery for
the patient nor suggest, as they do in accompanying editorial for acupuncture, 
that mammary artery ligation is effective.

This article is why I have long given up in the Annals. The editors seem to have
turned off the part of the brain that allows for critical thinking.

In the summary they say:

Acupuncture led to statistically significant improvements in disease-specific
quality of life and antihistamine use measures after 8 weeks of treatment
compared with sham acupuncture and with RM alone, but the improvements may not
be clinically significant.

May? The study is flawed in a way to suggest any effect is bias and that
acupuncture has yet to find a clinical indication with clear cut efficacy. Which
one would expect since it is based on nonsense. The editorial? They say:

   With this study lending compelling support to the effectiveness of real world
   acupuncture for SAR…

Can you say cognitive disconnect? While the patient summary says:

   Acupuncture seemed to improve symptoms for people with seasonal allergic
   rhinitis, but the effects were modest and did not last much beyond treatment.
   The improvement might have been caused in part by the volunteers’
   preexisting beliefs about the treatment.

I do not mind bad studies. Well, I do. But I realize that what appears to be a
good idea for a protocol at the beginning may turn out to have issues when
carried out. Or the researchers cannot see the flaws of their design and
outcomes because they are too enamored of the intervention.

But that is why there are editors of journals and peers to review the paper. Are
the editors paying any attention to their content? The patient summary
contradicts the editorial contradicts the paper. A careful and critical reading 
of the paper gives compelling evidence that acupuncture does nothing, in line
with all the other well-designed acupuncture studies. The cognitive disconnect
between the editorial and conclusion and the data presented in the paper is a
wonder to behold. And most people will read only the spin in the abstract and
the editorial, not noticing the fatal flaws, and erroneously conclude that
acupuncture has efficacy.

Yet another reason why I am glad I let my Annals subscription lapse years ago.
The editors of the Annals really need to keep a copy of the 8 strong suggestions
on the wall.

I also wonder if this is an example of editorial Dunning-Kruger. Most of us
spend our time in biomedical medicine. Pathophysiology leads to disease and we
try to alter the disease by altering the pathophysiology. We implicitly evaluate
papers with that approach in mind. The assumption is the therapy is doing
something.

SCAM papers are not biomedical papers. Acupuncture does nothing as delivered
that would be expected to alter the course of rhinitis or any other disease.

Acupuncture is a participatory passion play whose function is not to alter
physiology but is a method of psychological manipulation to alter perception. 
It is a ritual based on fantasy.  That is not to say rituals do not have
powerful and long lasting effects.  The ritual of marriage objectively adds a
ring to a finger, but there are many changes in perception of ones position in
society after the ritual.

The researchers and editors behave as if the study is representative of an
actual physical intervention, when all the good studies of acupuncture strongly 
suggest that all the benefits are subjective and dependent solely on the belief 
that acupuncture will work, as in this case.

Somehow I suspect the editors and reviewers at the Annals had the same approach 
to the paper that they would for an antibiotic being used to treat cellulitis,
as if a real physiologic process is being modified. You cannot read a SCAM paper
that way.

Properly evaluating a SCAM paper is a learned skill and it has taken a long time
for me to recognize that when evaluating results whose efficacy is unlikely and
whose success is subjective, you need to look carefully for differences in
treatment groups where potential bias, often subtle, could account for treatment
differences that are often just above random noise.  Because nothing is
actually be altered in the patient, as occurs in this study.

Or just revert to the ad hominem, point at the paper and say neener neener,
you’re ugly.  Works for me.

An ideal acupuncture study would have 4 groups: one that receives real
acupuncture and is told they are receiving either real or sham and a group that 
receives sham acupuncture and is told they are receiving real or sham. There
would be a subjective endpoint and an objective endpoint and I predict in
advance the results:

The group that is told they are receiving real acupuncture will have more
subjective benefit regardless of whether they receive real or sham when compared
to those who are told they are receiving sham regardless of whether they are
receiving real or sham. No group will have improvement in the objective
endpoint.

That sums up the effects of acupuncture.  It is like all SCAM: the beer goggles 
of medicine;  it changes nothing but the symptoms appear better for a short
period of time.

And acupuncture for allergic rhinitis?  There are enough flaws in this study to 
make any effect unlikely to be due to anything but noise and bias.  Coors Light 
at that.

Treating the Terrain of Chronic Sinus Infections. A LAc of understanding.

Acupuncture Today. “Das ist nicht nur nicht richtig; es ist nicht einmal
falsch!” It is because they LAc an understanding of medicine.

Mark Crislip on March 17, 2017

Link



A perfect crystal. Just not of ‘duh’.

“Das ist nicht nur nicht richtig; es ist nicht einmal falsch!”

German sounds so sharp and final, perhaps due to all the consonants pronounced
at the end of words. Neunundneunzig Luftballons is so much better than the
English version.

I get all sorts of articles in my feeds and there are some, well, let’s say
interesting, understandings of disease.

Acupuncture Today is an online newspaper promoting acupuncture and traditional
Chinese pseudo-medicine. It is a rich vein to be mined if you want to know how
acupuncturists think. Well, not so much how as what. They have over 2,500
articles and I thought I would take a quick look at one covering the treatment
of sinusitis.

A view from a different universe

It is a hodgepodge of alternative understandings of physiology and disease.
Let’s see what they have to offer.

   The dominant medical belief that was strengthened by Pasteur’s findings
   purported that disease was caused by pathogens that, if eliminated, would
   cure the infection and its resultant symptoms.

Believe is what you do when you have no evidence. It is pretty clear as an
infectious disease doctor that infections, as opposed to disease, are caused by 
germs and if you remove the germs then patients get better. Unlike
pseudo-medicine, I can cure serious infections. There is a good reason
“endocarditis treated with acupuncture” and “meningitis treated with
acupuncture” have zero hits on Google. When it comes to infection, germ theory
is like gravitational theory. You ignore it at your peril. And I would bet that 
no LAc (Licensed Acupuncturist pronounced, oddly enough, lack) would rely solely
on her theatrical placebo for the treatment of any infection I take care of on 
a daily basis.

But forget that Germ Theory is just a theory, a myth that I discussed way back
in 2008. And judging from the picture of the author at work, with a LAc of
gloves while manipulating needles, a typical TCPM germ theory fan. Let’s
continue with a simplistic false dichotomy that demonstrates a complete lack of 
understanding of the complex relationship between pathogens, commensal
organisms, and the host immune system:

   Pasteur’s critics argued that virulence of the microbe was not as important
   as resistance of the body, known at that time as the biological terrain or
   “milieu intérieur” (internal milieu), a concept developed by Bernard.

Pseudo-medical providers seem to think of germs and microbes, as interchangeable
objects. Pseudo-medical providers also tend to act like the immune system is a 
monolithic thing, like a bicep, that can somehow be strengthened, as we shall
see. And, as we shall also see, pseudo-medical providers seem to not understand 
that many organisms have evolved to infect us as their mechanism of reproduction
that no amount of immunity can resist.

No one would argue that the host immune system, aka the terrain, is not
important, but the interactions with germs are subtle and often beyond either
clinical intervention or diagnosis. Organisms have variable virulence between
genus (MRSA is more virulent than P. acnes) and within genuses (genii?) (MRSA is
more virulent than MSSA) and even within strains (some MRSA are more virulent
than others).

   This comes as no surprise to practitioners of traditional Chinese medicine,
   who have long understood the concepts of “wei qi” and the transmission of
   pathogenic factors from the exterior of the body toward the interior.

I am glad they understand wei qi, as I sure as hell don’t.

According to one site:

   In Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), the Wei Qi circulates on the surface
   of the body, protecting the body from pathogens such as bacteria and viruses;
   this concept is loosely related to how modern medicine views the immune
   system and is thousands of years old. In western medicine, only viruses can
   cause viral infections. In Chinese medicine, viruses and other pathogens are 
   ever present and do not generally pose a threat to health unless the Wei Qi
   is weak and cannot protect the body.

See? As is so often the case in pseudo-medicine, the fault lies in ourselves. As
confirmed in:

   holistic medicine practitioners stuck to their roots (both metaphorically and
   medicinally) by employing herbal therapies that lower populations of
   microbes while at the same time strengthening the body’s immune system. The
   latter strategy is also used preventively with the idea that if the body is
   sufficiently bolstered, a healthy individual should withstand all but the
   most virulent infectious diseases.

Which is just not true. No matter how bolstered, if you get exposed to measles
or norovirus you WILL get infected if you have no pre-existing antibody. As to
the Wei Qi? No wei.

I wonder just what is meant by lowering populations of microbes? Wiping out the 
normal microbiome? Knocking down the mystical ever present viruses and other
pathogens? Using herbs like broad-spectrum antibiotics? If it were possible, and
fortunately it isn’t, herbs would be a bad idea.

And the concept of ‘strengthening the immune system’ is as non-specific as it is
futile. What are they going to do? Increase antibody levels? Improve WBC
function? Get rid of dangerous polymorphisms in Toll-like receptors? Increasing 
cytokines? Activating platelet-derived cationic proteins? Puh-leaze.

None of that is likely. Probably just going to make the nonexistent wei qi work 
better. As I have said before, if a pseudo-medicine could really boost the
immune system they would be inducing an inflammatory response, which could be
dangerous as well, perhaps leading to stroke, heart attack, and pulmonary
embolism. Don’t mess with the immune system. It will bite back.

   …there is always a portion of the population exposed to a pathogenic factor
   that does not contract the expected illness. We see patients who catch every 
   cold that comes along and others who seem miraculously immune.

Such a simplistic understanding of disease. Not everyone is exposed to
contagion, or at the right inoculum, some have preexisting immunity, and some
have polymorphisms that render them resistant. They are many reasons people may 
not get an infection but I suppose if you LAc understanding of medicine it would
seem a miracle. As Arthur C. Clark said (kind of), “Any sufficiently advanced
physiology is indistinguishable from magic”.

The author doesn’t seem to recognize, at least with clear language, the
difference between chronic and recurrent sinusitis and the different reasons
people get symptomatic sinusitis.

They suggest two approaches. The first is boosting the immune system.

   …we can provide acupuncture and herbal therapy. Yu Ping Feng San and
   high-potency Echinacea angustifolia root are an excellent combination for
   long-term immune support.

Yu Ping Feng San, based on what few articles I could find is, if anything, an
anti-inflammatory, which in the real world, is considered immunosuppressive and 
the only clinical trial is in allergic, not infectious, rhinitis. There is no
reason by prior plausibility to think an herbal concoction couldn’t have
anti-inflammatory effects, especially given the habit of the herbal preparations
to be adulterated with real medications. But only in the world of
pseudo-medicine would an immune suppressant anti-inflammatory perhaps useful for
allergic rhinitis be touted as an immune booster for infection. Another LAc of 
understanding. Yes, I can beat a pun to death. I LAc the self-control. But I am 
avoiding all the ‘point’ and ‘needle’ and ‘stick’ puns so beloved by headline
writers.

And the data is clear. Echinacea LAcs efficacy.

   Echinacea products have not here been shown to provide benefits for treating 
   colds, although, it is possible there is a weak benefit from some Echinacea
   products: the results of individual prophylaxis trials consistently show
   positive (if non-significant) trends, although potential effects are of
   questionable clinical relevance.

But the LAc of understanding continues.

   A biofilm is a colony of microbes banded together and adhered to the lining
   of epithelial tissue, the formation of which may persist along the sinus
   passages in a patient suffering from chronic infections.

Not quite. Biofilms are a notorious virulence factor, but important in biofilms 
is the extracellular matrix made by the organisms. Key phrase there. Made by the
organism. Not:

   Stubborn biofilms are often the result of lifestyle factors that predispose a
   person to their growth. One of the most common in the ear, nose, and throat 
   area is the consumption of dairy, especially pasteurized dairy, in
   individuals who tend to accumulate phlegm from eating cheese or drinking
   milk.

Phlegm is not biofilm. Oh, and milk/dairy LAcs the ability to increase mucous,
much less make biofilm:

   Milk and dairy product intake was not associated with an increase in upper or
   lower respiratory tract symptoms of congestion or nasal secretion weight. A 
   trend was observed for cough, when present, to be loose with increasing milk 
   and dairy product intake; however, this effect was not statistically
   significant at the 5% level. Those who believe “milk makes mucus” or reduce
   milk intake with colds reported significantly more cough and congestion
   symptoms, but they did not produce higher levels of nasal secretions. We
   conclude that no statistically significant overall association can be
   detected between milk and dairy product intake and symptoms of mucus
   production in healthy adults, either asymptomatic or symptomatic, with
   rhinovirus infection.

The author LAcs the understanding that mucous production is not the reason for
biofilm.

   The second part of treatment is targeted herbal therapy to lower populations 
   of pathogenic microbes that are overwhelming the body. Antibiotic therapy
   will do this but at a cost.

Yeah. The cost of efficacy.

   Antibiotics pose a risk to our gut microbiome, predisposing us to a buildup
   of pathogenic yeasts that are unaffected by antibiotics.

The author evidently believes in the fictional yeast connection, a disease that 
has the same support as phone tapping. While there are many potential downsides 
to antibiotics, the idea of the Candida syndrome LAcs a connection with reality 
(and yes, I know about thrush etc.)

   If antibiotics are prescribed without confirming the nature of the infection 
   by culturing a swab test

I think he means

   If antibiotics are prescribed without confirming the nature of the infection 
   by culture with a swab

aAthough perhaps not given the preceding LAc of clear understanding. Or it was
just LAckadaisical editing.

   We can never fully eliminate these bugs from our system

Well, actually we can. Pathogens are usually eradicated once the infection has
resolved.

Then he finishes with the Kellyanne alternative fact:

   Looking back, we come to an interesting twist of fate at the end of their
   story as on Pasteur’s deathbed he came to finally admit that Bernard was
   right by stating, “The microbe is nothing, the terrain is everything.”

Dude. There is an internet. You can look it up. If you are in the job of having 
evidence.

   Louis Pasteur died on Sept. 28, 1895. His last words were, “One must work;
   one must work, I have done what I could.”

A LAcluster article from Acupuncture Today. A pure crystal.

   Like, if you just take all of the stupid and just cook it down, and then
   scrape just the pure ignorance. Like crystal “duh.” It’s like crystal “duh.” 
   —Jon Stewart, The Daily Show

                            Short Attention Span SBM

                                  Mark Crislip

                                      Link

The bar on this blog is set high. The entries are often complete, with no turn
left unstoned. Yet, not every topic needs the full monty with every post. The
blog has extensive evaluations on many topics, and new medical literature
doesn’t require another complete analysis. Many new articles add incrementally
to the literature and their conclusions need to be inserted into the
conversation of this blog, like a car sliding into heavy traffic. My eldest son 
just received his driver’s license, and car metaphors are on my mind. As are
crash metaphors and insurance metaphors.

So in response to this need, a need only recognized by me, I give you Short
Attention Span SCAM. Occasionally I will summarize a few recent studies and
their key points as they relate to prior posts at SBM.

Influenza

…any man’s death diminishes me, because I am involved in mankind, and
therefore never send to know for whom the bells tolls; it tolls for thee. — John
Donne

Influenza season will be starting soon. There are multiple misstatements made
about influenza and its treatment in the SCAMosphere. The first concerns death. 
Flu does not kill, or so it is asserted, or it only kills a thousand people a
year. During last year’s H1N1 season I took care of a pair of patients who died 
of acute influenza, not its complications. Direct deaths from influenza are
always a fraction of the deaths from indirect causes: worsening of heart failure
or lung disease or a secondary infections. I try to never use the word ‘only’
when discussing direct flu deaths; perhaps I take it too personally. Not patient
of mine was ever an ‘only’ and it annoys me no end when the deaths of others
are diminished.

How influenza deaths are calculated was discussed in the past, but the CDC
released new information on influenza deaths from 1976 to 2007. Calculating flu 
deaths is not easy. The number lies somewhere between direct deaths from flu,
and the deaths from other acute, but related causes:

   Deaths from pneumonia and influenza causes are highly correlated with the
   circulation of influenza and can be considered a lower bound for deaths
   associated with influenza. However, a diagnosis of influenza virus infection 
   often is not confirmed with sensitive and specific laboratory diagnostics,
   particularly among older persons, and even when identified is rarely recorded
   on death certificates (5). Many deaths associated with influenza infections 
   occur from secondary infections such as bacterial pneumonia or complications 
   of chronic conditions such as congestive heart failure and chronic
   obstructive pulmonary disease. Therefore, estimates using underlying
   respiratory and circulatory mortality data (which include pneumonia and
   influenza causes) can provide an upper bound for influenza- associated
   deaths.

The striking result is that, on average, there is no average flu season. Deaths 
vary from year to year and depends on the circulating strain of influenza.

Over 31 consecutive flu seasons, on average there were about 23,600 deaths a
year linked to the flu varying from a low of 3,349 deaths in 1986-1987 to a high
of 48,614 in 2003-2004.

When H3N2 predominated, deaths were 2.7 times higher than compared to other
strains. As a comparison, 8,330 to 17,160 are estimated to have died from H1N1.

The ‘classic‘ number given is about 36,000 deaths a year, but the number is an
average and, like so much in medicine, it depends. As the CDC says,

A single estimate should not be used to summarize influenza-associated
deaths; a range of estimates should be described in the context of circulating
virus strains and underlying causes of death among age groups.

Death is often a bad outcome and it is better to not die of the flu or its
complications. A recent case controlled study compared flu vaccinated vs
unvaccinated and found that the receipt of the flu vaccine decreased the risk of
heart attack.

   We included 78 706 patients, of whom 16 012 were cases and 62 694 were
   matched controls. Influenza vaccination had been received in the previous
   year by 8472 cases (52.9%) and 32 081 controls (51.2%) and was associated
   with a 19% reduction in the rate of acute myocardial infarction (adjusted
   odds ratio [OR] 0.81, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.77-0.85). Early seasonal
   influenza vaccination was associated with a lower rate of acute myocardial
   infarction (adjusted OR 0.79, 95% CI 0.75-0.83) than vaccination after
   mid-November (adjusted OR 0.88, 95% CI 0.79-0.97).

The authors do not speculate on the mechanism of the protection, but that will
not stop me. Infections are pro-inflammatory and pro-thrombotic. Myocardial
infarctions, strokes and pulmonary embolisms are increased during and after
acute infections, perhaps in part due to increased stress on the heart, but
also, perhaps due to the pro-thrombotic state. It is reasonable to suggest that 
flu leads to increased inflammation and thrombosis which leads to MI. No flu, no
pro-thrombotic state, no MI. If one could “boost the immune system“, and you
can’t, what you would get is a inflammatory/thrombotic state that should lead to
more vascular events: strokes, MI and pulmonary embolism.

Vitamin D

Dont get the vaccine, many a site will say, all you need is vitamin D to prevent
and treat flu. I am not going to deny the importance of having sufficient
vitamin D to keep immune function optimal.

Having higher vitamin D serum levels does decrease the risk of a viral
infection, although the effect is modest.

   During 114 days of the fall and winter in a temperate zone a serum
   concentration of 25-hydroxyvitamin D of 38 ng/ml or higher was associated
   with a two-fold decrease (p<0.0001) in the risk of developing acute viral
   infections of the respiratory tract.

A modest decrease in risk, and enough to keep me drinking milk shakes all winter
to keep my vitamin D levels elevated.

The question is, if you supplement vitamin D in patients, can you treat or
prevent influenza? There is zero data for influenza. But there is data for viral
upper respiratory tract infections. In Finland they they did a
placebo-controlled double-blinded study in 164 young Finnish men (1828 years of 
age) who were randomly assigned to 400 IU (10 mg;) vitamin D3 daily or placebo.

The treatment and placebo group had the same initial levels of Vitamin D and a
difference in levels at the end of the trial.

   Intervention (78.7+- 14.9nmol/L) and placebo (74.4+- 20.8 nmol/L groups
   (P p .35)…after daily supplementation with 400 IU vitamin D or placebo for 6 
   months, the mean serum 25(OH)D concentrations were 71.6 +- 22.9 nmol/L in the
   intervention group and 51.3 +- 15.5 nmol/L in the placebo group.

Let’s see: moles to molecular weight to Avogadro’s number to … it’s late and I
am tired and do not have there intellectual wherewithal to convert nmol/l to
mg/ml. I must have a homeopaths understanding of concentrations. I will leave
that as an exercise for the comments (yes, it is also fun to whitewash a fence) 
to see if they started at the 38 ng/ml that was effective to decreasing risk.
Hey. I can’t be expected to do everything can I?

The results were, again, modest.

   The main outcome variable, which was the number of days absent from duty 
   due to respiratory tract infection, did not differ between groups. Mean
   number of days absent was 2.2 +-3.2 days in the intervention group and
   3.0+-4.0 days in the placebo group . There was an effect during the first 6
   weeks of the study, with a mean of 0.7+-2.1 days of absence in the
   intervention group and 1.4 +- 2.6 days absent in the placebo group. After the
   first 6 weeks, there tended to be no difference between groups.
   Nevertheless, the proportion of men remaining healthy throughout the 6-month 
   study period was greater in the intervention group (41 [51.3%] of 80) than in
   the placebo group (30 [35.7%] of 80).

Not impressive, but something, and when it comes to avoiding illness, something 
is better than nothing. Better still, being replete in vitamin D will increase
the response to the flu vaccine, so taking vitamin D, especially if you are
deficient, may increase the antibody levels after the flu vaccine, still the
best way to avoid the disease.

So would I suggest vitamin D? Yes, as part of a healthy breakfast and if you are
deficient. It is one of a number of interventions you can use to prevent
getting ill in the viral season. But is vitamin D the be-all and end-all of flu 
prevention and treatment. No. Not even close.

Acupuncture

Man is the only animal that blushes. Or needs to. — Mark Twain

Acupuncture is all placebo effect, what ever that is. This was re-confirmed in
“A randomized controlled trial of acupuncture for osteoarthritis of the knee:
Effects of patient-provider communication“.

In this trial, patients had real acupuncture or sham acupuncture (as if there is
a difference) and they had neutral or enthusiastic acupuncturists. Those that
had an enthusiastic acupuncturist had a better decrease in reported pain,
whether the acupuncture was real or sham.

   TCA was not superior to sham acupuncture. However, acupuncturists styles 
   had significant effects on pain reduction and satisfaction, suggesting that
   the analgesic benefits of acupuncture can be partially mediated through
   placebo effects related to the acupuncturists behavior.

This result is of no surprise. Expectations will often color people’s
perceptions. More expensive wine is rated higher than the same vintage labeled
as cheaper. An expensive placebo is more effective than an cheap placebo.

But does perception of reality mean reality was altered?

I play golf with my kids almost every night in the summer and towards the end of
the season I get right elbow tendinitis. As I make my downswing the pain fibers
fire and can mess up my swing if I am not focused on hitting through the pain. 
If I take 400 milligrams of ibuprofen before I play, I have less pain and my
swing is unchanged. Not enough to beat my son, but that is another matter.

Decreasing pain leads to improved function when pain limits function. If you
have a musculoskeletal problem, you usually have a reproducible limit to your
function due to the pain. If the pain is decreased, the function should improve.

As I have discussed at length, I do not think there is really a placebo effect. 
Certainly for objective endpoints, there is no placebo effect. Buried in the
acupuncture paper were two objective end points: range of motion and the Timed
Up and Go Test. For objective endpoints there were no changes in any of the
groups. So it makes me wonder just what improvement these patients ‘really’ had.
Subjectively better, objectively no change.

Is the placebo effect no more than a patient convincing themselves they are
better when in fact nothing has changed? That is my interpretation. If function 
is not improved, if they are still limited by pain, is the pain really gone? Is 
this response a milder example of the same cognitive processes that can lead to 
hysterical blindness or not seeing tumors the size of a large mushroom? Man is
the only animal with the ability to convince themselves that the tangible is
unreal or that the unreal is tangible.

“Always keep your words soft & sweet in case you have to eat them!”

I have said numerous times that I was envious of SCAM practitioners as they live
an essentially never-changing world. Once the ideas of homeopathy, reiki,
acupuncture were codified, there is no change. Learn once … use forever.

Not so, it turns out, thanks to a report in Medscape (COI warning: I am a paid
Medscape blogger).

New acupuncture points have been discovered! Acupuncture advances.

   We generally modify acupoints to make them effective and more appropriate
   for cancer patients…For example, the acupoints which are predetermined
   places on the body where needles are inserted for therapeutic effect for hot 
   flashes for normal menopause are “not necessarily the same ones for early
   menopause due to chemotherapy”.

Unfortunately, this breakthrough in acupuncture has yet to be published,
although this pioneering work was done at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer
Center. Evidently, the only way you can learn this incredible clinical
breakthrough is by paying $495 dollars and taking the online acupuncture class
offered by Sloan-Kettering. I guess there are some medical cures they really
dont want you to know about unless you pay first. It worked for Kevin Trudeau,
it works for Sloan-Kettering.

When this phenomenal pioneering work is finally published, I suppose in the
NEJM, I will have a second helping of words.

Make Acupuncture Great Again

Calling a losing study a win. Making acupuncture great again.

Mark Crislip on December 19, 2023

Link



Unwieldy title. I need to shorten the concept to some sort of acronym. I can’t
come up with what that would be. Hm. I will think about it.

More acupuncture nonsense this week, this from the Annals of Internal Medicine. 
I will give the Annals this: they have been consistent in embracing the nonsense
that is SCAM for decades. It was their reviews of the topic back in the 90s
that got me interested in SCAM. And, by the way, Annals always has two n’s. If
you are looking for a review on, say, the treatment of S. aureus bacteremia that
was published in the Annals and you forget an n? Lets say the resultant search 
that pops up on the screen at the nursing station is NSFW.

I digress.

The topic today is Efficacy of Acupuncture for Chronic Spontaneous Urticaria. A 
negative study that is spun as a win. That’s so Annals.

Lets go through the study and see just how they they are attempting to make
acupuncture great again.

The Intro

They discuss chronic spontaneous urticaria, a miserable itching disease, with
therapies that are either less than efficacious or costly. So what do you do
when you lack an effective and inexpensive treatment? Acupuncture. Which is
expensive and ineffective, as we will see.

First, as always, is a nod to the ‘appeal to antiquity’ fallacy. Of course.

   Acupuncture has been used to treat pruritus for more than a thousand years.

As has bleeding and cupping. Doesn’t mean the intervention actually works, mind 
you, and the myth of the antiquity of acupuncture has been discussed many a time
here at SBM.

I suppose once upon a time acupuncture was great, back before science-based
medicine and randomized clinical trials revealed the nothing-burger that is
acupuncture. Time to make acupuncture great again.

   …relevant studies have found that acupuncture can inhibit the peripheral and 
   central transmission of pruritus by altering the signaling pathway and
   transcriptional activity.

It can? So acupuncture doesn’t work with meridians and chi. Great. That quote
references a review of acupuncture and itch, Acupuncture for the Treatment of
Itch: Peripheral and Central Mechanisms.

The review is interesting in that it is mostly about mouse models and mostly the
results of electroacupuncture. Which isn’t acupuncture, at least in the classic
sense of the antiquity of acupuncture. Unless you consider the 1950s ancient.
Having been born in 1957, I do feel increasingly ancient.

I will admit, I do have a bias towards therapies that are very narrow in their
application. The fewer the effects, the better. I would be hesitant to give an
intervention for urticaria, like acupuncture, that had simultaneous effects on

   neuropeptides and hormones, including β-endorphin, serotonin, oxytocin,
   adrenocorticotropic hormone, gonadotropin-releasing hormone,
   corticotrophin-releasing hormone, cholecystokinin, and acetylcholine, as well
   as insulin sensitivity, immunomodulation (anti-inflammation), and autonomic 
   nerve activity.

They then note that the studies of acupuncture and urticaria stink on ice and
quality studies need to be done to make acupuncture great again. At least for
chronic urticaria.

They reference a meta-analysis that I found curious in that it was a hodgepodge 
of treatment durations, forms of acupuncture, and acupoints. the usual dumpster 
fire trying to pass as a single coherent medical intervention.

   In total, all the treatments adopted in the included trials were based on
   traditional Chinese medicine theory. Electroacupuncture was applied in 2
   RCTs, while manual acupuncture was used in the other 4 RCTs. Xuehai (SP 10), 
   Zusanli (ST 36), and Quchi (LI 11) were applied the most frequently in the
   included studies (4/6, 66.7%). Other acupoints used were Sanyinjiao (SP 6),
   Hegu (LI 4), Pishu (BL 20), Ganshu (BL 18), and Shendao (GV 11).

They specifically excluded non-TCPM (traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine)
acupunctures in the meta-analysis. Why? They don’t say. But curious.

That is one of the ongoing issues in trying to make acupuncture great again:
acupuncture proponents always act like acupuncture is a monolithic thing, when
there are dozens and dozens of acupuncture styles. Which is supreme? Trick
question. They are all crap. Except Tong Ren. The only legitimate form of
acupuncture. But no two acupuncture studies uses the same style, duration, or
acupoints.

The Study

300 patients were randomized to either real or non-penetrating sham acupuncture.
As if there is a difference. And there was a wait list. Patients were blinded, 
but the acupuncturists were not. The patients kept a diary of the symptoms and
antihistamine use.

Why the traditional Chinese form of acupuncture and not Tong Ren and why the
particular acupoints were used are not discussed.

Yet another recurrent mystery in an acupuncture study. A system of interventions
based on nonexistent anatomy and physiology (chi and meridians) and a fanciful 
diagnostic modality (tongue and pulse examination) is somehow mapped onto a
process that is mostly mediated by abnormal histamine release. How and why is
not explained. And why those seven acupoints used? Not mentioned. I looked at a 
couple of acupoints for clarification.

How about the Quchi (aka Charo) point in the arm. It’s quite the acupoint.

   According to the etiology, allergic diseases are related to wind and heat;
   according to the pathogenesis, most of allergic diseases are qi-blood
   diseases; from the theory of zangfu, allergic diseases are closely related to
   the depressed heat of yangming and stomach-intestine, and the common
   elements of the pathogenesis of allergic diseases are wind, heat, qi, blood
   and yangming. With reviewing the ancient literature and modern research, the 
   key therapeutic effect of Quchi (LI 11) and its special treatment effect on
   allergic diseases are summarized. It is suggested that the key therapeutic
   characteristics of Quchi (LI 11), including dispelling the wind, clearing the
   heat, cooling the blood and regulating stomach-intestine function, are in
   accordance with the common causes and pathogenesis of allergic diseases.
   Therefore, Quchi (LI 11) is considered an important acupoint for the
   treatment of allergic diseases. Emphasis added

I understand the individual words, but they sum to meaninglessness. And how
dispelling the wind, clearing the heat, cooling the blood and regulating
stomach-intestine function that relates to the altering the signaling pathways
and transcriptional activity  is not mentioned, although it is the alleged
justification of acupuncture efficacy for urticaria.

The next point used in Xuehai, near the knee. According to Master Tungs
Acupuncture it

   invigorates and cools blood, dispels blood stasis and harmonizes
   menstruation.

and is used for irregular menstruation, dysmenorrhea and uterine bleeding as
well as urticaria, eczema and erysipelas. Certainly, diseases that are very
closely related. That is sarcasm, btw.

I wonder. Each acupoint usually has two or more very different functions. If you
treat, say, urticaria at Xuehai in someone with normal menses, will you induce,
say, dysmenorrhea?

The closest I can find is

   Moreover, acupoints have a bidirectional regulation effect (the idea that an 
   intervention pushes the patient toward a homeostatic state rather than having
   a unidirectional effect that may help or harm). For example, acupuncture not
   only lowers blood pressure, but also modulates low blood pressure in
   patients and animal models . Acupuncture can increase enterogastric
   peristalsis for constipation symptom while also has anti-diarrhea effect . In
   addition, acupuncture at the same point also has the bidirectional
   regulation effect. Acupuncture at Bahui (GV20) has been shown to be effective
   in treating both hypertension and hypotension. Siguan (a combination of LI4 
   and LR3 bilateral meridian points) is one of the most important acupoints to 
   treat multiple gastrointestinal symptoms including constipation and diarrhea 
   . Despite the fact that the opposite regulatory effect of acupoints has been 
   used for treating specific symptoms and/or diseases, it is not fully
   understood how the effect at acupoints works.

That last sentence did make me smile. As the proverb says, you can’t make a silk
purse from a sows ear. Or a USB drive out of a breath mint.

How acupuncturists focus the effects of acupuncture at each point to get the
desired effects and avoid the other potential interactions is not mentioned and 
is one of the mysteries of acupuncture.

Here is how to find the Xuehai point per Master Tung:

   When the knee is flexed, the point is 2 cun proximal to the superior medial
   border of the patella, on the bulge of the medial portion of quadriceps
   femoris muscle. Or with the patient’s knee is flexed, place the heel of your 
   right palm on the patient’s left patella, with the thumb and fingers fully
   extended and the thumb at a 45° angle with the index finger. The point is
   where the tip of your thumb rests.

And given the variation in hand and leg size, it is not a surprise that this is 
a difficult acupoint to locate:

   The position of Xuehai (SP10) is clear, but its locating method is vague,
   resulting in the disunity of clinical application and even possibly affecting
   the curative effect. Also, when learning the meridians and acupoints, the
   beginners are often confused by this issue

So you have to wonder if they were indeed needling the correct acupoint in the
urticaria study.

And they used the Shenmen point, which not only is used for

   amnesia, stupor, mania, insomnia, palpitations due to fright, irritability,
   and chest pain

This point is so powerful it can be used alone, without the need for other
complementary acupoints. Why the authors did not make use of this unique feature
and spare the patient multiple needles can only be speculated.

I could go on with the others, but it would be…..pointless.

See what I did there? Acupuncture. They use needles. Needles, unlike
acupuncture, have a point. Thast was a never before used play on words for the
ages; classic comedy. It is why you read my blog entries. But I digress. Again.

So we know the acupoints used, but not why they were chosen or how their other
effects were avoided.

The sham acupuncture was non-penetrating at non-acupoints. Although given the
inexactness of acupoints and the multiple acupuncture styles it could be argued 
that every point on the body is a potential acupoint. Except, as I have noted,
the eyes, the nail beds, and the genitals are oddly lacking in acupoints.

Patients kept a diary of symptoms and medication use. Perhaps not the most
reliable method for reliable data. The primary outcome was the Weekly Urticaria 
Activity Score at 4 weeks. Secondary outcomes were a variety of other symptom
scores. All subjective endpoints and so subject to bias.

The original protocol said serum IgE levels were to be measured at the beginning
and end of the trial. It was not reported in the final paper and the lack of
IgE testing was not addressed.

Drum Roll, Please

The results?

Acupuncture had greater improvement in the various scores than sham or wait list
but the effect was not clinically important.

And

All the adverse events were in the acupuncture group. 15 patients had 21 adverse
reactions. 13.6%, although mild and transient.

And.

While not significant, more guessed they were in the sham acupuncture group.

So a negative study. No surprise here.

What little difference between acupuncture and sham acupuncture could be
accounted for by blinding failure and the study being done in a society that
usually has positive effects for acupuncture. In fact, I was surprised at the
lack of effect in a study whose effects are based on the subjective reports of
the studied.

And if you are a Baysean kind of person, given the prior probability that
acupuncture would do anything is zero, you would rightly conclude that any
positive effect is a false positive, especially given the flaws in the study.

If this were a pharmaceutical, say an antibiotic, that had no clinically
relevant effects, had more adverse reactions, and was very time and money
intensive (10 sessions in the first two weeks, 6 in the second can’t be cheap), 
you would declare the pharmaceutical a bust and move on. But if you are the
Annals? How about an editorial by an acupuncturist promoting acupuncture? Time
to

Make Acupuncture Great Again

Yep. They released the Kraken.

The editorial briefly documents the authors use of acupuncture, never clarifying
which type or which points are used and conflating electo and standard
acupuncture. A lack of precision and clarity that is always the hallmark of
acupuncture discussions. He also does not mention Tong Ren, which, as I have
mentioned, is the only legitimate form of acupuncture. If anything will make
acupuncture great again, it would be Tong Ren.

The author of the editorial appears to think that the effects of acupuncture are
due to altering inflammation.

   I had come to terms with the fact that some of the more surprising claims
   from traditional Chinese medicine might have a basis in science. (nerp) A
   good example is the influence of acupuncture on the immune system. The vagal 
   anti-inflammatory reflex suggested a mechanism by which neural activity could
   modulate systemic inflammation

When you read paragraphs like this, you realize how little alt med providers
really know about illness and inflammation. And it was ELECTROacupuncture that
had the effect. I suppose those who die in the electric chair, the contacts at
acupoints on the head and feet, were impressively anti-inflamed.

Oddly, the greater the inflammation, the greater the effects of the at best
trivial interaction that is acupuncture. The effects of acupuncture in sepsis
being greater as there is so much more inflammation in sepsis. I have discussed 
sepsis and acupuncture. I was not impressed.

   When I saw the results of Zheng and colleagues’ article on acupuncture for
   chronic spontaneous urticaria (CSU) (7), I was not surprised to see a
   demonstration of efficacy over sham and waitlist control. But the results do 
   not seem to be as dramatic as we have seen in sepsis, which may reflect the
   fact that the degree of inflammation is much more modest.

A homeopathic-like mindset, I guess. The greater the inflammation, the more
acupuncture effect. So the greater the disease burden, the more effective the
therapy. By that rationale, 500 mg of cephalexin would be more effective for
prosthetic valve endocarditis than for a boil. The Annals thought this was a
reasonable assertion?

The author credits acupuncture for risk reduction for coronary artery disease in
patients with rheumatoid arthritis. That is an interesting article. The
acupuncture analyzed was based on procedure codes for acupuncture and
electoacupuncture.

   We analyzed the acupuncture type that patients received by the treatment
   codes, which included manual acupuncture of TCM type (B41, B42, B45, B46,
   B80-B84, B90-B94, P27041, P31103, P32103, and P33031) and electroacupuncture 
   (B43, B44, B86–89, and P33032)

I cannot for the life of me find the details of what these codes represent. So
just having acupuncture, irrespective of type or acupoints used, will decrease
CAD in RA patients. Amazingly powerful intervention. I think I may be a bit
skeptical here. But the article does have the most amusing artwork (see figure
two) to demonstrate the two types of acupuncture. Of course, no gloves used with
acupuncture.

The author concludes, in the attempt to make acupuncture great again, evaluates 
a loss and calls it a win:

   this is the first description of the efficacy of acupuncture in yet another
   nonpain condition, albeit lacking in clinical importance in terms of the
   magnitude of the mean difference from baseline. We should stay open to the
   potential for adjunctive use of acupuncture to influence outcomes, even in
   serious medical conditions, and remember that it is easily overlooked because
   it lacks the commercial backing of many of our modern interventions.

Nope. It was a negative study. Acupuncture is a theatrical placebo with no real 
physiologic effects outside of local trauma.

But consistent with those who want to make acupuncture great again, hint at
malign conspiracies as to why your intervention is a failure.

It must be awful to be a SCAM provider. Time, money, and ego invested into a
farce. The sunk cost must be in the Mariana Trench. It must be depressing to be 
a SCAM provider and live with the knowledge, however slight, that what you are
doing is nonsense but you are stuck.

I can’t find data on how many acupuncturists lose faith. But it is common enough
in pastors, so I would suspect there are more than a few SCAM providers who do 
not buy into their particular delusion but cannot change. A sad way to spend the
one life you have.

So another failure from the make acupuncture great again crew.Hmmm.Maybe the
Annals has one too many n’s after all.

Acupuncture Odds and Ends

Mark Crislip on December 26, 2014

Link



The aptly-named “Not Appearing In This Post” turtle of South America.

I’m cheating. No, I’m recycling. ‘Tis the season to have to no time to get
anything done. Since I know none of you pay attention to the blog of at the
Society for Science-Based Medicine and I have no time with work and the holidays
to come up with new material, I am going to collect and expand on the entries
on acupuncture I wrote from SfSBM. Anything I write really is worth reading
twice. I really need to make my multiple personality disorder work for me, but
the Goth cowgirl persona is a luddite at best, so 

Acupuncture: beer goggles or expensive wine?

Painting with a broad brush, I would say that acupuncture doesn’t work. By
‘work’ I would say that it has no effect that would change the underlying
physiology or anatomy of the person receiving the acupuncture.

‘Works” is different from having an effect, even a beneficial effect. Positive
interactions between a patient and a health care provider, even when offering a 
pseudo-medicine, will make some patients feel better about their disease. I
compare these pseudo-medicines, like acupuncture, to beer goggles. They change
perception but not reality.

While changing the perception of disease for the better is of benefit, it is
just not ethical to base treatment on the lie that acupuncture ‘works’.

What happens with a process like acupuncture to alter patients’ perception? It
doesn’t matter where the needles are placed or even if needles are used; twirled
toothpicks are just as effective as ‘real’ acupuncture, what ever that may be. 
What matters most for efficacy is if the patient thinks they are getting
acupuncture and if they believe acupuncture is effective. Then acupuncture will 
have a salubrious effect on subjective endpoints. That’s it. So what is going
on?

Another hint as to the mechanism of acupuncture is found in “When pain is not
only pain: Inserting needles into the body evokes distinct reward-related brain 
responses in the context of a treatment.”

In this study, 24 people received three identical stimuli: tactile, acupuncture,
or pain stimuli. There were two groups to receive the three stimuli, an
acupuncture treatment (AT) group and an acupuncture stimulation (AS) group. What
differed is what they were told before the stimuli:

   …participants in the AS group were primed to consider the acupuncture as a
   painful stimulus, whereas the participants in the AT group were told that the
   acupuncture was part of therapeutic treatment.

They had an fMRI (who doesn’t) and a questionnaire about their subjective
experience:

   Behavioral results generally revealed no differences between the AT and AS
   groups. The questionnaire results confirmed that there were no significant
   differences in expectancies, fear, or anticipation and subjective pain
   ratings related to needles being inserted into the body between patients in
   the AT and AS groups.

They found no analgesic effect in the acupuncture group. But there was a
difference in the fMRI (for what that is worth):

   We found that reward-related regions (specifically, the ventral striatum) of 
   the brain were activated by acupuncture stimulation and that in response to
   painful simulation, activity in pain-processing regions(the SII and DLPFC)
   was decreased only when participants were told that acupuncture needles were 
   a therapeutic tool.

And:

   As greater activation of the ventral striatum is generally correlated with
   more expectations of pleasure and rewards, our results could be interpreted
   to suggest that acupuncture stimulation was associated with the expectation
   of a reward – possibly an analgesic effect – for patients experiencing
   acupuncture in the context of a treatment (AT group).

So depending on the context, people process the same stimulus differently. A
needle that is thought to be for therapeutic acupuncture is different than the
exact same needle thought to be used for painful stimulation.

Maybe. It is a small study and fMRI’s have issues as we know from dead salmon.
But taken in the context of the literature pointing to the predominantly
positive subjective effects of pseudo-medicines it is curious finding. Maybe not
beer goggles; probably more like making wine taste better by giving it a higher
price.

Acupuncture needs belief to work

Well not really acupuncture, at least not as the ancient Chinese did it. I do
not think they had electricity to apply to the needles. But this was an
interesting study, “Expectancy in Real and Sham Electroacupuncture: Does
Believing Make It So?”

They took patients with joint pain due to aromatase inhibitors being used to
treat breast cancer. The patients had either sham electroacupuncture (no current
applied), electroacupuncture, or a wait-list control group, only about 20 in
each group.

No surprise, those who had an intervention, be it sham or electoacupncture, had 
more pain relief than the wait-list control. An intervention, even if worthless,
usually changes the subjective complaint for the better.

But here is where it gets interesting. They used the Acupuncture Expectancy
Score (AES), a measure of how much the patient thought acupuncture would help
their problem.

Over all, the higher the AES score, the better the pain response:

   Each point increase in Baseline expectancy in the SA group is significantly
   associated with a greater percent pain reduction at Week 8 (regression
   coefficient = 7.9, SE= 2.8, P = .007).

In the sham group those with a high AES also had a better pain response. What is
also interesting is that in the sham group there was no increase in the AES
score over time and the decrease in the pain was constant.

Some in the electroacupuncture group increased their AES score with time and
with a concomitant decrease in pain. Those who maintained a low AES scores had a
pain response that was unchanged over time.

What they do not mention, which is a flaw, is whether blinding was effective. A 
little current across an acupuncture needle could easily be noticed by some of
the patients and might have affected their perception of the intervention.

They say in the discussion:

   Expecting a positive outcome (expectancy) at the beginning of the trial was
   associated with the response to SA. In contrast, patients who responded to EA
   had increased expectancy over the course of their acupuncture treatment as
   compared with nonresponders, suggesting that positive responses during the
   process of EA increased the expectations of positive outcomes. Our findings
   imply that distinct mechanisms underlie the apparently similar clinical
   effect of EA and SA. These findings have important implications for
   acupuncture and pain research as well as for clinical practice.

It may be the responders to electroacupuncture were the ones who noticed a
tingling from the current and responded accordingly. Electroacupuncture is just 
a TENS unit tarted up with Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine and this study
has no implications for acupuncture except to reinforce its mechanism as an
elaborate placebo.

I will mention here that I had always been taught that TENS was a legitimate
form of pain relief. A quick review suggests TENS may be nothing but a placebo
as well. Since more elaborate placebos yield better responses, it may be that
those with the increased AES score were also those who knew they were getting
TENS, a more elaborate placebo.

I wish they had tested for effectiveness of blinding, it would have been a nice 
addition to understanding what happened in evaluating two different placebos.

The authors say in the introduction that:

   Although the response to SA has led skeptics to consider the acupuncture
   effect no more than placebo

And conclude with:

   Our findings suggest that distinct mechanisms exist between SA and EA and
   challenge the notion that acupuncture is “all placebo.”

Methinks you doth protest too much. I see the study has variations of placebo
effect, all placebo and nothing but placebo.

There were four kinds of beer goggles evaluated in this study; sham acupuncture 
with low or high AES and electroacupuncture with low or high AES with the added 
potential confounder that some in the high AES group may have known what they
were getting TENS. The increasing AES and subsequent improved pain response may 
be no more than the effects of a more elaborate placebo with a positive feedback
loop.

To my mind this is more data to support the notion that the effects of
acupuncture, like the effects of all of CAM, is simply the patient deciding they
are getting better, the pseudo-medical equivalent of kissing a boo boo to make 
it feel all better.

Animal torture

Psychology was, I admit, not my strong suit back in my pre-med days, the one
class that ruined an otherwise-exemplary report card.

The only thing I took away from my psychology class was the concept of learned
helplessness, perhaps because that describes a lot of medical education. To
quote the ever-helpful Wikipedia:

   Learned helplessness is a behaviour in which an organism forced to endure
   aversive, painful or otherwise unpleasant stimuli, becomes unable or
   unwilling to avoid subsequent encounters with those stimuli, even if they are
   escapable. Presumably, the organism has learned that it cannot control the
   situation and therefore does not take action to avoid the negative stimulus.

Put a dog in a box, shock it, and it gets depressed and stops looking for an
escape. I think of learned helplessness when I see someone abusing an animal by 
jabbing it with useless needles (aka acupuncture). I know it is projection, but 
every time I see pictures of animals getting acupuncture, I see a depressed
animal with learned helplessness.

Do any of these poor animals look happy with their acupuncture? Not to my eye.

The most recent animal to undergo well intentioned, and we know what the road to
hell is paved with, torture, are Spanish owls.

1,200 injured owls are brought every year to a hospital in Spain where, for the 
last 6 years, then have been tortured with needles once a week for 10 weeks.
Although they brag that 70% survive, I wonder if the added stress helped to kill
the remaining 30%. Ten weeks of weekly torture cannot be good for wild owls.
More likely they are improving in spite of the acupuncture rather than because
of the acupuncture and given the lack of gloves with the punctures, I wonder how
many died of inadvertent infections.

They give the usual nonsensical reason for using acupuncture and the usual
denial of harm:

   It stimulates self-curing mechanisms in the organism. It does not cause
   side-effects…

Don’t you think before you inflict pseudo-medicine on animals you would want to 
do a study not only to show efficacy, but to prove that you are not killing the 
animals with the added stress? I would. That is the nice things about animals:
they are unable to complain about the numerous complications of acupuncture and 
so the practitioner can delude themselves as to the safety of their torture.

Poor owls. I am not a PETA kind of guy, but I am sympathetic to all the animals 
needlessly abused with completely worthless ‘therapeutic’ and experimental
acupuncture.

After the fact rebuttal

I spent 5 days wandering the NE: Boston, Newport, Plymouth, back to Boston,
Salem and then home. I was invited to give a talk on influenza and participate
in a panel discussion about low back pain. The panel consisted predominantly of 
those who take care of backs for a living and I felt a bit like an Alzheimer’s
patient who wandered into the room by mistake.The panel was asked about using
pseudo-medicines and as one of the militant members of the science-based
medicine community, I gave my best three-minute summary on which SCAMs are
useless. Then one of the members of the audience made a comment that, due to
time constraints, I was unable to respond to.

So here is a paraphrase of the comment, and my response.

He started by saying he was a big believer in science-based medicine but…

But. Beware the but. That often means the speaker is about to endorse some bit
of pseudo-medicine that he thinks deserves our consideration because, hey, I use
it and it works for me. I was not disappointed.

He continued, mentioning that he has treated plantar fasciitis for years,
usually with a single needle, often with only one or two treatments and it works
more often than not.

This is, I suspect, the greatest reason that pseudo-medicines continue to
thrive.

First is relying on experience as a valid criterion for deciding on a
therapeutic intervention. Experience makes us better health care workers in so
many mays it is virtually impossible for HCWs to recognize that the three most
dangerous words in medicine are not “I lack insurance” but “In my experience.”
They are a powerful meme for the speaker and totally useless to the listener.

Variations of the concept are found in the ideas that:

   the plural of anecdote is anecdotes, not data

And the Richard Feynman quote:

   The first principle is that you must not fool yourself–and you are the
   easiest person to fool. So you have to be very careful about that. After
   you’ve not fooled yourself, it’s easy not to fool other scientists. You just 
   have to be honest in a conventional way after that.

The problem is that Dunning-Kruger appears to be the default mode for most
health care workers, the

   cognitive bias in which unskilled people make poor decisions and reach
   erroneous conclusions, but their incompetence denies them the metacognitive
   ability to recognize their mistakes.

So to my mind the speaker personified what may be the primary issue with
pseudo-medicines in health care: the reliance on experience and the inability to
recognize that it is useless.

He concluded with the usual chestnut about not throwing out the baby with the
bath water. I hate that cliché.

Me? When it comes to pseudo-medicine I would throw out the baby, the bath water,
the tub, the soap, the shampoo, the washcloth and the towel.

Lipstick on a pig?

I was wandering the Oxford English Dictionary and found a new definition for
worthless: “Noun. A clinical efficacy trial with no blinding, no placebo, and
only subjective endpoints derived from patient self-reporting.”

The OED is a stickler for examples of usage, so they pointed to “Effect of
Perineal Self-Acupressure on Constipation: A Randomized Controlled Trial” in the
Journal of General Internal Medicine. The study is out of UCLA, Yale and the
Southwestern Law School !?!

They compared usual care or perineal acupressure for constipation. Perineal
acupressure. Where did perineal acupuncture come from? I don’t know. The
introduction has a discussion on the potential benefits of perineal massage and 
pressure, which can alter perineal muscles, increase rectal tone (wouldn’t that 
increase constipation?) and perhaps aid in defecation.

Then they jump to testing:

   perineal self-acupressure, which consists of a patient repeatedly applying
   external pressure to the perineum.

Why acupressure? Why the acu? They make no mention of meridians or chi, which
suits me fine.

There is an acupoint in the perineum in Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine and 
it is not used for constipation, but rather it regulates yin:

  1. For yin deficient headaches

  2. Cold penis: a condition usually but not always associated with a lack of
    sexual desire

  3. Amenorrhoea and irregular menses

  4. Heat in the chest

  5. Pain in skin of the body, especially of abdomen and perineum

  6. Impotence, infertility and sterility, possibly frigidity

  7. Calms the mind: used for mania but can be used in less extreme conditions

The perineal points have nothing to do with constipation. So why the acu?
Because tarting up a lousy study with pseudo-medicine gives the results more
cachet and press than it deserves? That is my theory.

This is not an isolated example. A study adds ‘acu’ and now it gets far more
attention than one that doesn’t. We saw this with “Dopamine mediates vagal
modulation of the immune system by electroacupuncture.”

Virtually anything can get the acu designation if desired, and then more
attention. I give antibiotics through acupuncture IV’s. Much cooler than regular
IV’s. I can publish a study on my outcomes for cellulitis using acupuncture
IV’s. I’ll tell half the patients they are getting acupuncture IV’s and half
will get standard IV’s. I predict better satisfaction in the acupuncture IV
cohort.

Maybe we jump on the bandwagon as well to get more press: Acu-Science-Acu-Based 
Acu-Medicine?

Bad studies lead to wasting money

It is amazing how quickly a single study can lead to an analysis as to whether
an intervention should be used because it is cost effective.

There is no reason that acupuncture, a complicated magical ritual, should have
any specific effect on any pathologic process. However, when I watch videos of
acupuncture the process looks quite nice, except, of course, for the whole
needles being stuck in the skin with zero attention to infection control.
Relaxing in a caring and supportive environment cannot help but make people feel
better, as long as they do not get hepatitis B or MRSA.

Like all interventions that do nothing, acupuncture is indicated for virtually
everything (except as a form of contraception), at least by their proponents.
Depression is on the list of processes that are not effectively treated by
acupuncture.

After reviewing thirty, count ’em thirty, studies, with 2,812 patients, the last
Cochrane Review:

   found insufficient evidence to recommend the use of acupuncture for people
   with depression.

One would think that when 30 studies demonstrate an intervention with no basis
in reality is useless, no self-respecting IRB could ethically approve the 31st
study. Nope. In 2013 there was yet another study, “Acupuncture and Counselling
for Depression in Primary Care: A Randomised Controlled Trial“, that
demonstrated that counseling and acupuncture were associated with the same
degree of reduction in depression at three months.

With no wait list and no sham acupuncture control there can be zero conclusions 
made about whether or not acupuncture per se (as opposed to the magical ritual) 
was of benefit or whether it was the natural history of the depression in that
population.

The authors call it:

   A pragmatic trial asks whether the intervention works under real-life
   conditions.

While I would call the trial a waste of time and money, whose methodological
flaws ensure it proves nothing. Again, isn’t part of the ethical and practical
considerations of IRB’s to avoid studies that are methodologically garbage?
Guess not.

The article states no conflicts of interest, which I am sure is true technically
i.e. financially, but when the lead author of a study suggesting magic helps
depression is

   previously trained as a practitioner of acupuncture and Chinese herbal
   medicine and subsequently founded the Northern College of Acupuncture

I remember the ever-so-wise words:

   Conflicts of interest are very common in biomedical research, and typically
   they are inadequately and sparsely reported. Prejudice may not necessarily
   have financial roots. Scientists in a given field may be prejudiced purely
   because of their belief in a scientific theory or commitment to their own
   findings.

I will mention as an aside that PLOS does not publish author titles (Lac, ND,
MD) in their papers. If a pseudo-medicine is being evaluated it would be nice to
know which kind of pseudo-medical provider is doing the evaluation. As the old 
saying goes, “Go to Midas, get a muffler.”

So we have a preponderance of literature that demonstrates acupuncture is
useless for depression and a fatally-flawed study that proposes an efficacy that
doesn’t exist. What to do next? Not go to Disneyland.

You are a proponent of acupuncture. You have just finished a
methodologically-horrible study that you can spin into demonstrating acupuncture
is helpful for depression despite a vast contradictory literature. You note
that:

   Acupuncture is rarely provided within the UK’s mental health service or
   primary care, but private provision of acupuncture for depression is not
   uncommon.

Although what constitutes “not uncommon” from the reference is vague. In a
table, 7% of providers use acupuncture for “psychological” disorders and the
only mention of depression in the text is:

   Anxiety, stress and depression were the three most prevalent psychological
   complaints and more commonly treated by independent acupuncturists.

In what looks like a manipulation of PLOS as part of a marketing program to
increase the use of acupuncture in England, most of the same authors of the
original paper hired an economist who found that, hey, acupuncture is cost
effective.

If I had a conspiratorial bent, I would point to this as proof that the medical 
literature is being manipulated to further the financial gain of Big
Pseudo-Medicine.

But it is not.

Just another sad example of the failure of peer review when applied to
pseudo-medicine.

Bad infection control

In a prior entry I have mentioned my visual Googlewhack: I could find only one
picture of gloves being used during acupuncture, and it was not being performed 
by an acupuncturist but a physical therapist doing dry needling.

I have also discussed the recalcitrance to basic infection control that informs 
the practice of acupuncture. It gives me the willies to watch acupuncture
videos. It often looks as if they are trying to spread contagion with their
technique.

Up north in British Columbia an acupuncture clinic was closed because of poor

   infection prevention and control standards (that) poses a health hazard to
   clients.

That defines all the acupuncture I have witnessed.

   Based on the investigation of the centre, we are alerting clients of Ms. Hu
   that they may be at increased risk of exposure to blood-borne infections that
   can be transmitted by improper and unsanitary acupuncture techniques.

The article alludes to acupuncture as the source of infections as well as:

   other treatments involving blood or bodily fluids.

What was going on in the clinic?

How many people were exposed is not certain as:

   Murti said Hu did not keep proper records, and it’s difficult to know how
   many people might have been affected.

But it is more than 1,000 people. Take that, Typhoid Mary. The health department
is recommending testing by clients for blood-borne pathogens. Normally I would 
worry about HIV and Hepatitis B and C, but evidently Hu had even worse technique
than I would have thought possible.

On her door is a list of diseases for which she wants her clients to contact her
if they have been exposed to or currently have so she can make a special
appointment.

The diseases include smallpox. Smallpox.

Yes, if you have or have been exposed to smallpox, most certainly see Hu for
acupuncture, or perhaps other treatments involving blood or bodily fluids.

This list is a further suggestion that infection control is not well understood 
in the acupuncture world.

Cupping

We only have one big time professional sports team in Portland, the
Trailblazers. No football or baseball. We do have professional soccer, but that 
doesn’t really count. In Portland the Blazers rule.

I had long thought cupping in athletics was a protective device to prevent groin
injuries, although it is evidently voluntary in the NBA, as some have learned
to their discomfort.

I think protective cupping would be a good idea. Therapeutic? Not so much.
Evidently promoted by their Director of Player Health and Performance, cupping
is a form of pseudo-scientific nonsense that is being used by the Blazers. I
have discussed one form, moxibustion, before. Like most pseudo-medicine, it is
an elaborate placebo with no real effects on real disease.

Its alleged mechanism of action is:

   the idea is the suction draws fluid out of the area, Kaman explained,
   allowing tissues to heal more quickly.

And is not based on known processes. It is more akin to the wet sock treatment
for stuffy nose, divorced from anatomy and physiology.

I am not surprised the Blazers are using it, since athletes often use
pseudo-science. I suspect golfers lead the list. I still had to laugh at one
quote:

   “It’s scientific stuff,” Kaman said. “I could sit here and talk to you about 
   it, but you wouldn’t know what I was talking about. I’m not calling you dumb 
   it’s just a mixture of Western and Eastern medicines and some people think it
   works, some people don’t.

It is not scientific stuff, it is pseudo-scientific stuff. That is why no one
understands what you are talking about. The theory and practice behind cupping
is gibberish. Those who think cupping does not work are probably those who
understand reality. As one meta-analysis said:

   Although RCTs provide a higher quality of evidence, we included non-RCTs in
   this study because the limited number of RCTs did not provide convincing
   evidence.

Demonstrating the usual results of alternative medical studies: it only has
effects when the studies are poorly done. The most unreliable form of evidence
is the anecdote:

   “I find it works pretty good,” Kaman said and “It works,” Batum said.

Well, it doesn’t in any well done study. Any positive results are due to placebo
effects, the medical beer goggles.

I wonder if the Blazers will suggest giant magnets (3:52 mark) next for player
injuries?

Rationalizing the Ridiculous: Acupuncture

Mark Crislip on September 19, 2014

Link



I remain flummoxed. How do physicians and health care systems, trained in all
the sciences that lie at the heart of medicine, justify the use of
pseudo-medical interventions with no basis in reality? Rationalization. Making
excuses:

   a defense mechanism in which controversial behaviors or feelings are
   justified and explained in a seemingly rational or logical manner to avoid
   the true explanation, and are made consciously tolerable – or even admirable 
   and superior – by plausible means.

Rationalization of the ridiculous comes in many forms. It has been said that it 
is a mark of a first rate intelligence to able to hold two contradictory ideas
in the mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function. Clever as
it is, I suspect the opposite is true.

Acupuncture: Ignoring your own analysis

So often rationalization is as simple as denying your own data where the content
of a pseudo-medicine paper is at odds with its conclusions. The most egregious 
example is the Cassidy study on stroke and chiropractic. But other examples are 
easy to find. Take “Acupuncture and related techniques in ambulatory
anesthesia“, a review of the use of acupunctures (regular, electric and
acupressure) for postoperative pain and nausea.

They start off with an abstract that says:

   Research suggests that acustimulation may alleviate postoperative
   morbidities, although the body of evidence of the effect is equivocal.

‘Suggests’, ‘may’, ‘equivocal’. Hardly a ringing endorsement. The introduction
is equally lukewarm:

   trials of hands-on-therapies face inherent difficulties in the design of
   placebo controls, and the body of evidence is equivocal. The use of sham
   acustimulation as a placebo control is inclined to have high placebo effects

They compared a hodgepodge of acupunctures, with variable outcomes, some
positive and some negative. There were very few double blind studies and most
with a positive effect for a subjective endpoint (pain or nausea) often had no
change in objective endpoints (use of pain or nausea medications).

If this were a real intervention based on real physiology, I would conclude the 
intervention did nothing. As an intervention with no prior plausibility, the
results are even less impressive.

In this case? Well, they say:

   With reservations, as some of the trials reviewed are small and must be
   perceived with caution, the results suggest that acustimulation may be
   beneficial in alleviating postanesthetic morbidities. The techniques are easy
   to perform, and adverse events and costs are minimal. In particular,
   acupressure is noninvasive, well tolerated, and may have a good patient
   acceptability. Acupressure can be applied by medical staff, patients or
   parents and maintained after discharge. A feasibility study shows neither
   delay in the surgical procedure, nor additional anesthesia time attributed to
   the introduction of acupuncture and acupressure. It may be profitable to
   consider implementing acustimulation to ambulatory patients.

I presume they mean profitable in the sense of beneficial or useful.

It is really remarkable how a therapy that in this analysis is questionable at
best (and in other analyses worthless) is still suggested because it is cheap
and easy to apply, not because it is effective and based on sound medical
evidence. It is difficult to imagine such a low standard for approval of an
antibiotic. But with antibiotics you would expect a real effect against a real
infection.

Acupuncture clinics

The National Research Center in Complementary and Alternative Medicine,
Institute of Community Medicine in Norway, might suggest using acupuncture for
postoperative pain and nausea. In the US major medical institutions do not
suggest, they act. For example:

Loyola announces opening of new acupuncture clinic for patients with pelvic
health disorders.

The usual nonsense is put forth to justify charging patients for fantasy-based
therapies:

   These conditions place a significant burden on our health-care system and the
   economy due to the prevalence and the fact that many patients don’t respond 
   to traditional treatments, said Larissa Bresler, MD, a medical acupuncture
   doctor, Loyola University Health System, and an assistant professor of
   Urology, Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine. The goal of
   the clinic will be to offer patients another tool to help alleviate their
   symptoms without the side effects of medication.

That is the ‘since air travel and airplanes have problems we should rely on
flying carpets’ argument.

   Acupuncture has been used as a healing tool for more than 2,000 years.

The ever-popular appeal to antiquity logical fallacy, and not even a true appeal
since the use of needles is a recent development and as practiced at the turn
of the century TCM was gruesome:

   Chinese doctors own that they know nothing at all of surgery. They cannot tie
   an artery, amputate a finger or perform the simplest operation. The only
   mode of treatment in vogue which might be called surgical is acupuncture,
   practised for all kinds of ailments. The needles are of nine forms, and are
   frequently used red-hot, and occasionally left in the body for days. Having
   no practical knowledge of anatomy, the practitioners often pass needles into 
   large blood vessels and important organs, and immediate death has sometimes
   resulted. A little child was carried to the dispensary presenting a pitiable 
   spectacle. The doctor had told the parents that there was an excess of fire
   in its body, to let out which he must use cold needles, so he had pierced the
   abdomen deeply in several places. The poor little sufferer died shortly
   afterwards. For cholera the needling is in the arms. For some children’s
   diseases, especially convulsions, the needles are inserted under the nails.
   For eye diseases they are often driven into the back between the shoulders to
   a depth of several inches. Patients have come to us with large surfaces on
   their backs sloughing by reason of excessive treatment of this kind with
   instruments none too clean.

The Loyola press release mentions the mechanism by which acupuncture is alleged 
to work:

   Acupuncture is based on the traditional Chinese teaching that energy flows
   through the body along channels called meridians. Illness occurs when energy 
   is blocked or disrupted. The insertion of needles into designated points
   improves the flow of energy and releases feel-good hormones, beneficial
   chemicals and immune system cells to reduce inflammation, aid healing and
   promote pain relief.

Without mentioning that meridians and the energy it contains are nonsense,
divorced from physiology and anatomy and has never been demonstrated to exist.

They will use acupuncture for

   …pelvic pain, nausea from pelvic surgery, interstitial cystitis, painful
   bladder syndrome, postoperative pain, prostatitis and overactive bladder.

The reviews for use of acupuncture for the above conditions are typical – maybe 
it works but the studies are poorly done:

   Evidence for the efficacy of needle acupuncture for treating the disorders
   evaluated remains inconclusive. The intervention showed promising results for
   reducing pelvic and back pain during pregnancy and climacteric vasomotor
   symptoms, although well-designed studies are needed to make the results more 
   precise and reliable.

And:

   The evidence that acupuncture is effective for chronic prostatitis/chronic
   pelvic pain syndrome is encouraging but, because of several caveats, not
   conclusive. Therefore, more rigorous studies seem warranted.

Which is the same as it ever was. Acupuncture only has effects in studies with
poor methodology. The better the study, the worse the effect until well-designed
studies that remove all potential biases fail to show acupuncture has any
effect.

Which, given the prior plausibly that acupuncture would be effective for
anything is zero, is what would be expected. But always more studies need to be 
done.

It hardly seems a solid foundation for a clinic for treating and charging the
ill. I always wonder why the Board of Trustees of these institutions allows the 
use of magic in their hospitals.

But I hope that, since the acupuncturist involved is also a urologist, there
will finally be an answer to the question that has puzzled me for years: why
they are no meridians and acupoints in the male genitals? Why no life energy
flowing in the life-generating organs? You can probably guess my answer.

Integrating naturopathy

Forget acupuncture, what about using naturopaths? “Integrating naturopathy: can 
we move forward?” The short answer is no. I have discussed both naturopathic
education and ND fitness as primary care providers in the past.

The gist of the article is the author wants to dump all his difficult-to-treat
patients on naturopaths:

   With so many of our patients presenting with chronic pain, functional
   disorders, and other difficult-to-manage chronic conditions, allopathic
   primary care physicians clearly need more compelling options for managing
   chronic disease…Naturopaths would seem ideally positioned to fill this
   partnership role.

Clever in a Machiavellian kind of way. Play up the holistic BS and send them off
to the mostly harmless, although mostly fantasy-based, therapies that make up
naturopathic practice. If you have a troublesome patient what could be better
than to identify another practitioner who can take care of them better than you?
As a resident, transferring a patient to another service (from medicine to
surgery was most common) was not only for the patient’s benefit, you had a
transient dip in the work load and no longer had a patient whose issues (bad
gallbladder) you were not comfortable managing.

The only problem is that referring to naturopathy as a credible source for
medical diagnosis and treatment doesn’t make it so. To say:

   Naturopathic medicine is a distinct method of primary health care—an art,
   science, philosophy and practice of diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of
   illness. In stark contrast to a narrowly interpreted biomedical model, where 
   pharmaceuticals are administered to battle disease, Naturopathic physicians
   seek to restore and maintain optimum health in their patients by emphasizing 
   nature’s inherent self-healing process …. This is accomplished through
   education and the rational use of natural therapeutics. The naturopathic
   physician thus uses holistic approaches to enhance and restore the body’s own
   innate healing systems. Naturopaths undergo a 4-year graduate-level course
   of study but are generally not residency trained.

Ignores the fact that they are trained in unproven, often irrational, fantasy:
nutritional supplements, homeopathy, acupuncture, hydrotherapy and electrical
stimulation. There is no nonsensical therapy that is not in the naturopathic
armamentarium. That is part of the problem with naturopathy: any and all medical
magic is in their purview. And they are usually anti-vaccine.

The author recognizes there are conflicting paradigms between doctors and ND’s. 
You think? He gives several examples of the different approaches between MD and 
ND for some common diseases, but suggests that somehow these differences can be 
overcome. It would is like recommending raising an alligator as a household pet.
In the end, it will end badly. Say, honey, have you seen the dog and the baby?

Despite his suggestions that education and medical standards could somehow
integrate ND’s into a reality-based practice of medicine, to do so would require
the ND to abandon the fantasies in which they have invested time and money. I
doubt that will happen.

   Establishing and improving lines of open, respectful, constructive
   communication will be a first step toward developing the type of
   collaboration between allopathic and naturopathic physicians that our
   patients deserve.

Our patients do not deserve naturopathic practice, although the lateral pass of 
the difficult patient might make clinic easier. To quote me, if you mix cow pie 
with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple
pie worse. Our patients need a better apple pie, not cow pie.

Aroma Acupoint Therapy

“Aroma acupoint therapy” demonstrates how the combination of several nonsensical
ideas involving essential oils and acupuncture produces, unsurprisingly, yet
another nonsensical CAM treatment.

Jann Bellamy on November 5, 2020

Link



A perhaps under-appreciated accelerant of so-called “complementary and
alternative” medicine’s metastasis throughout our culture is CAM’s inherent
elasticity. While what is now known as conventional medicine must stick to the
science, a fantasy-based CAM can morph into any number of variants, limited only
by the imagination of its practitioners. Acupuncture is a perfect example. The 
concept of a nebulous energy flowing through our bodies via “meridians” unknown 
to anatomy, and the putative ability to manipulate this energy via needles stuck
into “acupoints”, has birthed battlefield acupuncture, acudetox, acupressure,
and electroacupuncture, all creatures of the modern era (not to mention the
dozens of pre-modern varieties that also exist).

Another progeny of this fecund acupuncture racket was brought to my attention
recently by a new article in Medical Acupuncture (the gift that keeps on giving)
titled “Aroma Acupoint Therapy for Symptom Management Patients: Early
Experiences from School-Based Health Centers”.

You know you’re in for a heaping helping of integrative ideology when the very
first sentence is:

   Complementary and integrative approaches to medicine are essential for
   holistic and patient-centered care.

Which is complete hooey.

The article describes “aroma acupoint therapy”, or “AAT” (the specifics of which
we’ll get to in a moment), for symptom management in a variety of ailments
suffered by adolescent patients presenting at school-based health centers in New
York City. Evidently, the institution of AAT is the brainchild of Melanie A.
Gold, DO, DMQ, who is board certified in “medical acupuncture” and is medical
director of seven of these health centers. (“DMQ”, which I’m guessing stands for
“Doctor of Medical Qigong”, refers to a particular type of certification in
qigong, a form of Chinese “energy medicine”. There is no national certification 
standard in qigong practice.) Gold was herself trained in AAT by its creator,
Peter Holmes, and, in turn, trained the school health center medical staff.

With the approval of the institutional review board of Columbia University
Irving Medical Center, a retrospective review was conducted of electronic
medical records of adolescent patients treated with AAT. We’ll get to the
findings of this review shortly, but first, let’s take a look at acupoints and
aromatherapy and how they were combined to create aroma acupoint therapy.

Briefly, as mentioned above, acupuncture points, or “acupoints”, are points on
the body, mostly located on meridians, through which “qi”, or energy, flows.
According to acupuncturists, insertion of a needle at these points influences
the flow of energy, which somehow treats disease and improves health. Acupoints,
qi, and meridians are fictional and research reveals that acupuncturists cannot
reliably find acupoints on the body. As we’ve pointed out many times here on
SBM, acupuncture is a theatrical placebo.

I assume that the “aroma” in the term “aroma acupoint therapy” refers to
aromatherapy because AAT employs essential oils and aromatherapy is the use of
inhaled essential oils (volatile compounds that contain the “essence” of the
plant from which they are extracted) with a therapeutic intent. Essential oils
are also applied topically for the same purpose. While the use of essential oils
is a billion dollar a year business in the U.S. (expected to exceed $11 billion
by 2022) and they are touted for many purposes, there is currently no reliable 
evidence that either inhalation or topical application is effective for any
condition and it is, in fact, illegal for an essential oil to claim it can
mitigate, treat or cure any disease.

I say “assume” here because the therapeutic intent of using essential oils in
AAT is (supposedly) achieved via application to the skin, not inhalation. Of
course, that is the beauty of CAM – nothing has to make sense, even the
terminology used.

Which brings us, finally, to an “explanation” of AAT. Here I quote extensively
from the article because I find it difficult to summarize gobbledygook.

   AAT is a safe and gentle treatment that involves placing specific essential
   oils on specific Chinese acupoints to trigger energetic changes in patients’ 
   bodies. The acupoints are the same as those used in acupuncture, with
   essential oils replacing needles as the stimuli . . .

   The origins of AAT go back to the early 1990s, when Mr. [Peter] Holmes [an
   acupuncturist and herbalist and the inventor of AAT] began experimenting with
   using essential oils on acupoints in his acupuncture practice. Finding them 
   very compatible with acupuncture, he gradually developed techniques of using 
   them alone on acupoints, not just in preparation for needling. Over the
   years, Mr. Holmes also developed the functional diagnostic system of the Six 
   Conditions that became the theoretical backbone of AAT, as well as the model 
   of Fragrance Energetics for tracking the effects of essential oils on
   individuals . . .

   The theoretical concept proposed by Mr. Holmes is that the natural
   bioenergetic frequency of an essential oil provides information to an
   acupoint. In the principle of resonance, the synergy between a certain oil
   and a particular point can trigger a specific type of therapeutic action in a
   patient. The key to successful treatment is creating the right synergy
   between certain oils and certain points. The treatment protocols of AAT
   reflect decades of Mr. Holmes’ experience with synergistic oil–point
   combinations when performed in a specific sequence.

[Footnote omitted.]

More specifically:

   Tense and Tense Alternating with Weak are 2 conditions or syndromes defined
   by Mr. Holmes that include physical as well as psychoemotional attributes. In
   general, Tense conditions (also called Wired) have the quality of
   contraction, spasm, increased sensation or pain, irritability, anxiety,
   nervousness, or restlessness. Tense Alternating with Weak conditions (also
   called Wired and Tired) are similar to Tense conditions but with elements of 
   fatigue, exhaustion, and/or mood dysregulation. Mr. Holmes developed 2
   protocols, 1 each to treat Tense and Tense Alternating with Weak conditions
   utilizing AAT, which he has found to be clinically safe, often effective
   after 1 treatment, and easy to teach health care providers and patients. . . 
   .

   The Tense protocol . . ., also called Calming Therapy, involves placing 1-2
   drops of 4 different essential oils on 5 acupoints bilaterally for 90 seconds
   on each acupoint in [a particular sequence].

Thus, for example, lavender drops are placed on the “Pericardium meridian 6 or
PC 6 (Neiguan) on the inner wrist 3 fingers’ breadth from the wrist crease
between the tendons of the palmaris longus and flexor carpi radialis”. The
accuracy of this, one assumes, is based on the well-established anatomical
principle that everyone’s fingers are of exactly the same width.

In other words, other than the acupoints (which, remember, no one can reliably
find), Holmes made the whole thing up.

Yet, despite the fact that Holmes’s assertions of safety and effectiveness
remain wholly unsupported by evidence and that his proposed mechanism of action 
is fantasy-based, Gold and her staff proceeded to treat adolescent patients at
the school clinics with AAT. Whether informed consent was obtained is not
disclosed.

Based on the “Tense” and “Tense Alternating with Weak” “protocols”, 15 students 
presenting with symptoms of headaches, menstrual cramps, nausea, shortness of
breath, pain, and dizziness (7 of these were assessed by the health care
provider as attributable to anxiety) were treated with AAT in addition to
standard medical therapy, such as ibuprofen. There was an average decrease in
pain score of 4 on a 10-point scale.

To the authors, this case series demonstrated that AAT is safe and noninvasive, 
easily taught, and well-received by providers and patients and, as well, the
“potential” for adopting AAT as an “effective treatment modality for symptom
management in adolescent patients”. It “opens the door for robust studies of the
clinical efficacy of AAT”.

In fact, there is no record of the patients’ receptivity to AAT reported in the 
article and no mention of monitoring for side effects. Irritation and allergic
reactions to topically-applied essential oils have been reported and some may
act as endocrine disruptors. The National Institute of Environmental Health
Sciences reports a possible link between the topical use of essential oils and
the onset of male gynecomastia (development of breast tissue).

Moreover, nothing in their research comes even close to suggesting that AAT is
effective, or warranting further trials. In what might be called quintuple Tooth
Fairy Science, the authors credulously assume the existence of (1) acupoints,
(2) a “bioenergetic frequency” of essential oils, (3) the ability of this
“bioenergetic frequency” to transfer information to an acupoint, (4) the ability
of the acupoint to accept this information, and (5) a “synergy” between the oil
and the acupoint that triggers a “therapeutic action”. No one has bothered to
establish that any of these phenomena actually exist. Of course, the presumed
effectiveness of AAT can more plausibly be attributed to the usual medical care 
patients received and other factors, such as the fluctuating nature of pain and 
the placebo effect of a novel treatment requiring additional time out of class
and administered by enthusiastic providers, who reported AAT as “enjoyable” and 
“efficient”.

Given the utter implausibility of AAT, my view is that clinical trials would be 
unethical and informed consent to treatment impossible because of the
misrepresentations involved. But since lack of evidence of safety and
effectiveness was no barrier to AAT’s use on adolescent patients at school
clinics and, indeed, negative trials have not ever stopped the use of any CAM
treatment that I am aware of, clinical trials would be superfluous anyway.

Acupuncture and cupping for adult idiopathic scoliosis at the VA

A veteran’s adult idiopathic scoliosis was treated at a VA health clinic with
acupuncture and cupping in an attempt to correct his spinal curvature, an
impossibility without surgery. The ideology of so-called integrative medicine is
firmly entrenched at the VA, to the detriment of veterans and taxpayers.

Jann Bellamy on October 8, 2020

Link



A recent article in the “medical journal” Medical Acupuncture describes the
“treatment” of adult idiopathic scoliosis with acupuncture and cupping at a
Veterans Administration (VA) “Department of Whole Health” in Fargo, North
Dakota. [Access requires a subscription.] This “research” was “supported with
the resources and the use of facilities” at the Fargo VA. To the authors of the 
article, the results indicate that “more research is needed on the efficacy of
TCM [Traditional Chinese Medicine] for treating adult idiopathic scoliosis.”

My takeaway is different. To me, the article confirms that the ideology of
so-called integrative medicine is firmly imbedded in the VA and that veterans
are being subjected to unethical, time-consuming, and worthless treatments that 
pose risks without the possibility of benefit. These treatments are being
foisted upon veterans by “health care providers” who do not have sufficient
knowledge of even the most basic medical facts behind their patients’ presenting
condition. All of this, by the way, is being done on the taxpayers’ dime.

We’ll begin with a brief description of the patient, his presenting condition,
and the medical science on scoliosis, the latter to help us understand just how 
far afield this patient’s treatment drifted.

According to the article, our veteran is 34 years old and presented to a
chiropractor (and one of the article’s authors) at the Fargo Veterans Health
Care System “Department of Whole Health” with back pain of some 7 months’
duration. (This chiropractor is also on the faculty of the chiropractic school
at Northwestern Health Sciences University in Minnesota, the relevance of which 
will be revealed shortly.) The patient complained of pain in the thoracic spine 
that interfered with bending and sitting. He denied any trauma but the article
notes that he wore heavy body armor during his service.

Based upon an undisclosed rationale, the chiropractor decided to take an x-ray
prior to initiating treatment and discovered “an idiopathic right-convex
scoliosis” of around 21 degrees, of which the patient was previously unaware.

Now, to the science. According to an orthopedic surgeon I consulted, there would
be no medical rationale for reducing the curve in an adult patient with this
degree of scoliosis and, in any event, the only effective way to do so is
surgery. So, had this veteran been under the care of a physician, the scoliosis 
itself would not have been treated and he could have been offered evidence-based
therapies for his back pain.

But that’s not what happened.

Our chiropractor, “during the second and third chiropractic visits”, “adjusted” 
the patient for a “spinal subluxation“. To those unfamiliar with chiropractic
jargon, let me translate. To a medical doctor, a “subluxation” is the partial
dislocation of a joint, like a dislocated shoulder. But to a chiropractor, a
subluxation is a putative spinal lesion that interferes with “nerve flow”
between the brain and the body’s organs, thereby causing ill health. There are
numerous other, equally implausible, definitions of the chiropractic subluxation
because, for over 100 years, chiropractors have been trying to retcon a
reasonable-sounding explanation of the subluxation into their founding myth
that, in 1895, a “magnetic healer” initially discovered the subluxation when he 
cured a deaf man by hitting him on the back. (No, really, I promise.) This is
the same fantastical belief system that gets chiropractors into trouble for
falsely claiming they can “boost” the immune system by detecting and correcting 
these subluxations, thereby helping one avoid COVID-19.

As to the “adjustment“, spinal manipulation, a manual therapy performed by
chiropractors, physical therapists, and some physicians, is a treatment of
questionable benefit for back pain. An “adjustment” is a special form of spinal 
manipulation, the purpose of which is to address the chiropractic subluxation.
Of course, this is impossible because chiropractic subluxations do not exist.
So, while physical therapists and physicians may use spinal manipulation for
back pain, only chiropractors “adjust” the spine for these mythical
subluxations.

Which brings us back to our chiropractor-author. The supposedly more
science-based chiropractors spend a lot of time and effort trying to convince us
that the subluxation is not the basis of modern chiropractic practice and that 
it is not taught in chiropractic schools any longer. But, here we have a
chiropractor on the faculty of an accredited chiropractic school adjusting
subluxations at a VA medical facility. Draw your own conclusions.

The chiropractor referred our veteran to an acupuncturist, the lead author of
the article and also on the staff of the Fargo VA, “with the hope of relieving
this patient’s pain that was related to a muscle spasm in his thoracic spine due
to the scoliosis”. According to my orthopedic consultant, the pain may not have
been due to a muscle spasm, the chiropractor perhaps misdiagnosing taut
paraspinal muscles that appear in nearly all scoliosis cases as a spasm. In
fact, we don’t know from this article whether the pain was caused by the
patient’s scoliosis at all.

Acupuncture is, as we do know, a theatrical placebo so there was no reason to
believe that acupuncture would relieve the pain, whether due to a spasm or not. 
End of story.

Nevertheless, the acupuncturist, who also attributed the patient’s “tight,
protruding, tender muscles” to a spasm, took things even further. Not only was
she going to treat this supposed spasm with acupuncture, she decided to get rid 
the spinal curvature itself!

   After a clinical review, the acupuncturist hypothesized that a combination of
   acupuncture and cupping techniques would help relax this patient’s muscles
   along his thoracic spine, thereby allowing the correction of his scoliotic
   curvature. [Emphasis added.]

The acupuncturist was proceeding on the notion that

   certain acupuncture-needle stimulation techniques can either tonify or sedate
   energy in meridians . . . [which] can have a relaxing and balancing effect. 
   . . [C]upping, a therapy that often uses fire [!] inside of a glass cup to
   create a vacuum effect . . . creates a negative pressure on the areas of the 
   body that it is applied to [and is] believed to increase the blood and energy
   flow to the area cupped . . .

In other words, the acupuncturist was attempting to affect the flow of a
mythical energy supposedly traveling through equally mythical meridians in the
body in order to straighten a curvature of the spine.

This is not, of course, anywhere in the vicinity of a hypothesis. As well, it is
worth noting that this acupuncturist is so poorly educated and trained she does
not know that her patient’s spinal curvature (1) doesn’t required treatment
and, moreover, (2) this “correction” is impossible. Why she thought relaxing the
muscles would straighten the spine is not revealed (not that this is possible, 
mind you) since “idiopathic scoliosis” means, by definition, that the cause is
unknown.

She proceeded to get informed consent “to establish a case study”. In this, the 
acupuncturist perhaps confused “case study“, which this is not, with “case
report“, which this also is not. This is an n=1 experiment on a human subject
and, as such, it is unethical because, as former SBM blogger Dr. Mark Crislip
pointed out in a post on CAM research, it is a waste of resources, it exposes a 
person to risk for no purpose, and it will not result in useful knowledge.

Acupuncture was performed on our veteran approximately two times a week for a
total of 15 treatments. I’ll spare you the details of which acupuncture points
were punctured and for what reason. Cupping was applied after needle removal and
repeated at subsequent visits based, in part, “on the appearance of previous
cupping marks”, meaning the bruises caused by cupping were still there several
days later. This was followed by t’ui na, “a method of TCM massage and bodywork”
and the application of an “herbal analgesic oil”.

After treatment by the acupuncturist, more x-rays were taken by the same VA
chiropractor, who found “a potential reduction” of 3 degrees in the scoliotic
curve to 18 degrees, although the authors admit this finding

   could have been due to radiograph variation [for some unexplained reason, the
   chiropractor used different x-ray views] and observer calculation
   variability, as previous studies have found variations with single-observer
   measurements of up to 3.2 °.

The patient’s self-reported pain since he initiated the approximately 7 ½ weeks 
of acupuncture was “85% alleviated” and “everything is feeling a bit looser”.

The authors conclude that their “study”

   demonstrated the effects of combination acupuncture and cupping therapy for a
   34-year-old veteran . . . with adult idiopathic scoliosis.

And:

   Although this case study did not find conclusive evidence on the ability of
   combination TCM to treat adult idiopathic scoliosis, the potential decrease
   in this patient’s . . . curvature warrants a larger randomized controlled
   trial to understand that effectiveness of combination TCM therapies to treat 
   adult idiopathic scoliosis.

I disagree. I conclude:

  1. Treatment of the patient’s back pain was fantasy-based, not evidence-based.

  2. The patient’s decrease in pain cannot be attributed to any treatment he
    received.

  3. The patient did not need any treatment for his scoliosis.

  4. The treatment he did get amounted to unethical experimentation on a human
    subject lacking in any scientific rationale whatsoever.

  5. The chiropractor and acupuncturist, in thinking there was any possibility that
    acupuncture and cupping could affect the spinal curvature, were shockingly 
    ignorant of the basics of scoliosis.

  6. There is no possible rationale for further study of acupuncture and cupping
    for scoliosis (or anything else, for that matter).

  7. The VA is allowing chiropractors and acupuncturists free rein to impose their 
    pseudoscience on veterans, apparently with no supervision by medical staff.

This whole affair is a shameful waste of taxpayers’ money and is likely
siphoning off funds from science-based healthcare at the VA.

Study of “Acupressure” for Constipation

Harriet Hall on December 16, 2014

Link



A recent study in the Journal of General Internal Medicine evaluated a treatment
for constipation. It tested whether training patients to massage the perineum
(the area between the vagina or scrotum and the anus) would improve their
reported bowel function and quality of life at 4 weeks after training. They
found that it did. It’s a simple, innocuous treatment that may be worth trying, 
but why, oh why, did they have to call it “acupressure”? That irritated me.
Should it have? Why should it matter? Isn’t a rose by any other name still a
rose? Is this a meaningless semantic quibble and hypersensitivity on my part, or
am I right to see it as yet another example of quackademia’s attempts to
infiltrate science-based medicine? I’ll explain my thinking and let you decide
for yourself.

Why perineal pressure?

Constipation is a common complaint that is usually treated with increased
dietary fiber and fluids, exercise, stool softeners, and laxatives. There were
no previous studies of perineal massage for constipation. Where did the idea of 
treating constipation with perineal pressure come from? The authors explain that
perineal massage is recommended in pregnancy to prevent lacerations and
decrease the need for episiotomy. True, but irrelevant. They explain that
patients with rectocele or descending perineum syndrome have used perineal or
transvaginal pressure to support the weakened rectal wall and aid in defecation.
Also true, but irrelevant for most patients with constipation. They cited a
study showing that perineal pressure increases rectal muscle tone by 52%, but
the clinical relevance of that finding is not clear. They cited other research
suggesting that perineal pressure might break up hard stools, relax the anal
sphincter, stimulate sacral nerves, and treat hemorrhoids. But none of the
studies they cited called it “acupressure.”

How the study was done

The study was randomized with a treatment group and a control group but no
blinding. The 100 participants met the Rome III criteria for functional
constipation. Both groups received educational materials about constipation and 
conventional treatment options. The self-acupressure group also received 3-5
minutes of oral instruction with the aid of a plastic anatomical model and were 
given handouts with written sex-specific instructions. The handout for women
explains:

   With two extended fingers (middle and index), you should press on your
   perineum, pushing toward the back of your body on the skin roughly half way
   between your vagina and anus. When you sense that you are just about to
   defecate, your fingers should be able to feel underneath your perineum the
   stool inside you pushing against your sphincter…you should push on your
   perineum in repeated pulses. Imagine that you are using your fingers to break
   up and guide the stool downward inside you. By pushing several times on the 
   skin, you can manually break up the stool before it passes through the
   sphincter. You should relax your sphincter only when the stool above it is
   sufficiently soft to pass through.

Subjects filled out questionnaires at the beginning of the study and again after
one month. The questionnaires asked about various subjective factors such as
ease of defecation, feeling of incomplete bowel evacuation, hemorrhoid symptoms,
physical and psychosocial discomfort, worries, satisfaction, quality of life,
etc. Eight patients were lost to follow-up and one decided not to practice
self-acupressure after instruction, so 91 subjects completed the study.

Study results

It worked! Outcomes for the treatment group were better than for the control
group. There were statistically significant differences in 13 out of the 18
primary and secondary outcomes. Patients in the treatment group reported using
the technique 3.6 times a week, and 82% said they intended to continue using it.

Limitations of the study

The authors themselves point out several limitations of the study. The sample
size was modest, the randomization left the two groups poorly balanced with
regard to gender and baseline scores, and the study was not blinded. Outcomes
were not measured objectively but only by subjective patient self-report. A
placebo effect and a Hawthorne observer effect may well have influenced results.

There was no comparison with other manual techniques. I wondered if it might be 
more effective for women to insert a finger in the vagina. Or for either sex to 
use a lubricated glove or finger cot and insert a finger in the rectum to
disimpact the stool directly and stimulate defecation. For that matter, if
they’re going to call it acupressure, why didn’t they compare it to stimulation 
of other acupoints elsewhere on the body that have traditionally been used to
treat constipation? (I suspect they knew that would be fruitless.)

Recommendation

In their conclusion, the authors say, “Clinicians should consider incorporating 
education in perineal self-acupressure as a treatment for constipation, along
with conventional interventions such as increased exercise and dietary fiber
intake.” The advice to consider trying perineal massage is reasonable, and I
have no quarrel with that. My only objection is to calling it acupressure.

What is acupressure?

Acupressure is a variant of acupuncture. Like acupuncture, it is based on the
concept that life energy (qi) flows through meridians and obstructions to the
flow can be treated by stimulating acupoints. There is no credible evidence that
qi, obstructions, meridians, or acupoints even exist. One self-styled world
expert on acupressure therapy recommends that constipation be treated, not by
pressure on the perineum, but by pressure at acupressure point CV6 on the
abdomen just below the belly button. Other online acupressure advice generally
involves points on the hand, with either steady pressure or light repetitive
tapping. One acupuncture website lists a whole slew of acupuncture points for
constipation, the particular combination varying according to whether the
patient has hot constipation, cold constipation, qi constipation, qi deficient
constipation, wind constipation, food constipation, blood deficient
constipation, or yin deficient constipation.

There is indeed an acupoint on the perineum, the Ren 1 point. It is said to
nourish Kidney Yin and resolve Damp-Heat, and is used for constipation, dysuria,
incontinence of feces and urine, hemorrhoids, rectal prolapse, spermatorrhea,
impotence, pruritus vulva, loss of consciousness, asphyxiation from drowning,
and manic psychosis. When I read that, my imagination ran wild. I couldn’t help 
envisioning an acupuncturist responding to a drowning emergency by pulling off
the victim’s swim trunks and sticking needles in his bottom. Or trying to do
that to a psychotic patient in the throes of a manic episode. Could be
interesting…

Why did the study call it “acupressure” rather than massage?

I was curious enough to write the lead author and ask him. He replied that they 
could just as well have called it massage. (So why didn’t they?) He said
acupressure was part of the Rome criteria for diagnosis of constipation, but the
Rome criteria don’t mention acu- anything. They only include “Manual maneuvers 
to facilitate at least 25% of defecations (e.g., digital evacuation, support of 
the pelvic floor)”.

I exchanged several e-mails with the author in an attempt to understand his
reasoning. He directed me to the website for the Center for East West Medicine. 
When I searched that site for constipation, I found only a reference to the
Large Intestine 6 (He Gu) point on the hand. That point is recommended for
headaches and jaw pain in addition to constipation, general pain, and delayed
labor. They say it must never be used during pregnancy because it may induce
labor; I wouldn’t worry about that.

The author is an MD, JD, and MTOM (Master of Traditional Oriental Medicine) who 
uses what he calls a “holistic paradigm” to make traditional Chinese medicine
diagnoses and treat patients on that basis. He said the study provided a
technique that would integrate well with conventional medicine. I think that
provides a crucial clue to understanding what is going on here.

Conclusion

The study suggests that perineal pressure or massage might be a useful addition 
to conventional treatment of constipation. We don’t usually go by the results of
a single study that has not been replicated, but in this case the treatment is 
harmless and not unreasonable to try. I only wish they had called it “perineal
pressure” instead of “acupressure.” I think the use of the word “acupressure”
constitutes a deliberate attempt to promote belief in fanciful alternative
medicine concepts and to infiltrate them into mainstream medicine. In my opinion
it is a prime example of the so-called “integrative” approach to medicine that 
science-based medicine so rightfully deplores and that Mark Crislip has compared
to mixing cow pies with apple pies.

Put it Over There with the Others: More “Promising Preliminary” Evidence for
Acupressure

Another day, another legitimate journal publishing a preliminary study
practically designed to spit out a positive result. Also, acupuncture robots?

Clay Jones on August 9, 2019

Link



As I am currently practicing my French in Quebec City, just a short post this
time around. Think of it as a minor coda to Steve’s post from last week on a
poorly designed and reported acupuncture study published in a respectable
journal. Instead of the Journal of the American Medical Association, however,
this ridiculous paper on self-administered acupressure for chronic low back pain
was published in Pain Medicine, which represents the American Academy of Pain
Medicine.

But before I get into the study, such as it is, I want to do some
humblebragging. Just a bit though. It’s a minor achievement to be sure, but it’s
one that that I am particularly proud of. I was featured in an editorial in the
June 2019 Medical Acupuncture, which is edited by friend of the blog and
battlefield acupuncture promoter Richard Niemtzow.

In the editorial, author Gerhard Litscher liberally quotes my 2016 satirical
post on “robotically-assisted acupuncture“, although he fails to mention my
reference to space herpes from the 1984 comedy classic The Ice Pirates. Don’t
believe Rotten Tomatoes, people. 91% of critics are apparently dead inside.

When I stumbled upon the editorial, I really was hoping that he had fallen into 
my trap and mistakenly confused my post with a serious discussion. But alas, he 
knew it was fake news and merely used my clever concept in juxtaposition with
advances in the actual development of robotic acupuncture. Here is a video
demonstration (“What is matter with you?”).

The developer claims to have been inspired by Baymax from Disney’s Big Hero 6,
but I’m not so sure that’s true. He states the following benefit from robot
acupuncture:

   Robots can free practitioners from exhaustive, repetitive labor so they can
   focus on designing better treatment plans.

From my satire post:

   As science progresses, and we continue to scale down robot technology and
   improve treatment algorithms, the physical act of acupuncture will be taken
   completely out of the hands of the practitioner. The human mind will be set
   free, allowing full mental focus on diagnosis.

In regards to the safety of the proposed robot acupuncture, there are some
limitations:

   Xu conceded that robots cannot be trusted with crucial parts of the body,
   such as the head, neck and waist.

But in the fictional world created within my mind palace, anything goes:

   The da Vinci Surgical System, a state of the art robotic technology, features
   a 3D high-definition magnification system and instruments able to maneuver
   with far greater precision than the human wrist and fingers. This is allowing
   specially trained acupuncturists to both locate and successfully target hard
   to reach acupuncture points, such as those on the eye, scrotum, and anal
   verge.

Now back to that acupressure “study“. 67 subjects with chronic low back pain
were recruited in Southeastern Michigan using flyers and newspaper ads, so
already this is a self-selected group that may consist of believers in
acupressure or one of its many close relatives. They were randomly split into
three groups, which included “relaxing acupressure”, “stimulating acupressure”, 
and usual care. There was no blinding.

After 6 weeks, the subjects were assessed for reductions from baseline in pain, 
fatigue, poor sleep, and overall disability. Pain scores were improved in both
acupressure groups compared to usual care, and fatigue was improved in only the 
stimulating acupressure group. There were no differences in sleep quality or
disability.

The results were, as expected, consistent with either the introduction of a
novel therapy, and perhaps the expectation of benefit in primed subjects,
without proper blinding. The acupressure was found to be safe, so at least there
is that. It’s unfortunate that a legitimate journal published this study. After
all, there are already thousands of preliminary studies out there showing weak 
results like this, even involving self-administered acupressure for chronic low 
back pain. If I didn’t know any better, I’d worry that the whole point is just
to mass produce positive results.

C’est tout pour le moment. Je serai de retour dans deux semaines.

Miscellany of Medical Malarkey Part 6

The Ohio measles outbreak is (hopefully) winding down. Vaccine rates among
American Kindergartners are dropping. A new cure for sickle cell disease might
not reach everyone who needs it. All that, and acupuncture for deadly
infections? It appears that the miscellany of medical malarkey has returned
again once more!

Clay Jones on January 20, 2023

Link



The last one came out years ago and he moved on, you think to yourself as a
chill runs down your spine. You know there is no way he would dust that old
concept off after all this time. Then why the sudden and overwhelming sense of
dread? Why the cold sweat?

Trust your instincts.

Through a combination of dark magic and poor time management skills, it has been
resurrected. In fact, it’s shambling towards you at this very moment. It’s
right around the corner, just out of frame. Can you hear it now? Can you smell
the rot?

Screaming won’t help. There is no escape. Just accept your fate and keep
reading.

That’s right. Here we are today with another collection of odds and ends from
both within and beyond the world of science-based medicine, where despite our
best efforts there exist alternative realities in the darkness of shadows yet to
be illuminated by science and reason. Behold…a miscellany of medical malarkey
is upon you!

The Ohio Measles Outbreaks 

Last month, I discussed a measles outbreak in central Ohio:

   Since late October, more than 70 children have been diagnosed with measles
   and 26 of them have been sick enough to require hospitalizations. Remember,
   despite it’s often bland portrayal in sitcoms and cartoons of the past,
   something that has been wielded as an anti-vaccine talking point, measles is 
   a terrible illness that historically put 25% of infected kids in the hospital
   and killed 1-2 per 1000.

   37% of the infected children in the current Ohio outbreak have been
   hospitalized so far, which underscores the fact that we don’t have effective 
   treatments. There is no modern medical anti-viral triumph that cures this
   disease. There is supportive care and correcting vitamin A deficiency, which 
   has been linked to increased risk of death. The modern medical triumph was
   the vaccine.

As of a week ago, this total has risen to 85 children with 8 additional
hospitalizations. 40% of the involved children were sick enough to be put in the
hospital, which continues to outpace historical percentages. There hasn’t been 
a death associated with this outbreak, but as I’ve discussed in the past that
doesn’t mean that these kids aren’t at risk of serious or even deadly
complications in the future.

While this outbreak has largely involved the unvaccinated, 24 of the cases were 
in children who were too young to have gotten their first dose. This is
important to point out because one (of many) garbage talking point spouted by
those proselytizing anti-vaccine beliefs is that the vaccinated shouldn’t care
about people who refuse immunizations if they believe they work. This is
obviously wrong because it ignores the need for herd immunity to protect those
who cannot receive immunizations or who remain unprotected despite their
immunizations, since no vaccine is 100% effective.

The last case of measles diagnosed in Ohio was on December 24th, which is
promising. If they remain measles free through the first week of February, the
outbreak will be officially over per CDC guidelines. Hopefully there will be a
silver lining of increased vaccine rates among the hesitant in response. Of
course, I would rather people respond to education and guidance from trusted
medical professionals in the future rather than the acute fear of an impending
infection.

Vaccine Rates Continue to Drop in U.S. Kindergartners

As reported last week, the official vaccine uptake numbers from 2021-2022 are in
and the decrease seen in 2020-2021 continued:

   Overall, those receiving state-required vaccinations declined to about 93%
   last year, down from 94% in the previous school year and 95% in the 2019-2020
   school year, according to the CDC report.

The specific vaccines included in the CDC data were the MMR vaccine (93.5%),
DTaP (diptheria, tetanus, pertussis, 93.1%), polio vaccine (93.5%), and
varicella (chickenpox) vaccine (92.8%). I imagine for many folks 93% seems like 
a pretty good number, and it would be for Mrs. Peebles’ Biology II class.
Unfortunately, for highly infectious diseases like measles we really need to be 
a bit closer to 100% in order to maintain herd immunity and protect vulnerable
people, particularly those who are at high risk of severe disease.

When it comes to vaccine rates, there is significant variation between and
within states, largely because of because of the three Ps of healthcare
disparity: politics, poverty, and prejudice. Sticking with measles, for example,
New York was a clear winner with an MMR vaccination rate of 98%. Great job, you
coastal liberal elites. Rhode Island came in second with just over 97%. Let’s
all raise a coffee milk toast to all those anti-virus Ocean Staters.

On the other end of the data are states like Alaska (78%), Wisconsin (82.6%),
and Georgia (83%). Overall, only 13 of the 49 (what’s your deal, Montana?)
states included in the data met the CDC goal of 95% of eligible kindergartners
having received both doses of the MMR vaccine. So is most states, and almost
certainly even in parts of the others, there are communities that are fully
primed for a major outbreak of this horrible disease.

Because of limitations in how this data was collected, the numbers could be even
worse in reality. For example, it didn’t catch home schooled kids. This data
doesn’t tell us why the numbers have continued to slip, but I doubt anyone would
deny the complex and multifactorial nature of the problem. When it comes to
reversing the trend, the CDC recommends rigorous enforcement of school vaccine
requirements, school-based vaccine clinics, school nurse follow-up with
undervaccinated students, and reminder/recall systems.

A Costly New Sickle Cell Cure

It’s hard to imagine a more heart wrenching malady than sickle cell disease, a
group of inherited genetic disorders that alter the shape of red blood cells and
can cause a wide variety of health problems. This can include anemia, because
the abnormal red blood cells have shorter life spans, but more infamously can
result in severe pain throughout the body, strokes, an increased risk of severe 
bacterial infections, and a lifespan often shortened by decades. In addition to 
the physical manifestations, there are also significant psychological and social
difficulties faced by patients with these conditions.

Because it mostly affects black people in the United States, there is a history 
of extreme disparity in the recognition, research, and response to sickle cell
disease. I wrote and then erased several attempts to encapsulate this issue, but
they all felt inadequate. I know the problems. I’ve seen the repercussions time
and time again. Hell, as a white man who grew up in the South, and then
practiced medicine down there for the first decade of my career, I know that
there were times when I contributed to it.

I’ve learned so much in recent years by truly listening to people’s lived
experiences, accepting that implicit bias saturates medicine, and, most
importantly, recognizing my part in it. Patients with sickle cell disease have
dealt with the worst of this bias in medicine. This NEJM “Perspective” from
2020, written by actual experts in the care of these patients, does a much
better job of explaining it than I ever could:

   Medicine is a mirror for the racial injustice in our society; it is a field
   riddled with racial disparities in everything from research funding to
   patient care to life expectancy.1-3 There may be no population of patients
   whose health care and outcomes are more affected by racism than those with
   sickle cell disease (SCD). Patients with SCD are too often marginalized and
   dismissed while seeking medical care when their bodies hurt and they cannot
   breathe. As medical leaders around the United States issue statements
   denouncing racial injustice and calling for us to “dismantle racism at every 
   level,”4 we must ensure that these pledges translate into durable
   improvements for patients with SCD.

Today, I can happily report that there are some significant improvements for
patients with sickle cell disease right around the corner:

   This year, Jackson and other people with sickle cell may have the option of
   finally living without the damage it causes. Two drug companies are seeking
   approval from the Food and Drug Administration for gene therapies that may
   provide what amounts to a cure. But the decision to take the medication —
   should it become available — is not so simple, it turns out.

This potential but very promising cure has, in clinical trials, halted the
process that leads to the many varied complications of sickle cell disease. The 
red blood cells produced in the bone marrow do not become misshapen. In addition
to prevention of the severe pain caused by the condition, these treatments
could save billions of dollars in medical costs if all patients who might
benefit gain access to them. Sadly, but not unexpectedly, many of them won’t.

First off, the expense will be a huge problem as the modified virus used to
deliver the gene therapy will run upwards of a million dollars per treatment.
Insurance might cover that, because the average lifetime cost of treating sickle
cell disease is almost twice that. But there are other factors that would add
to the cost in dollars or even lives:

   Treatment starts with intense chemotherapy in a hospital to wipe the bone
   marrow clean, leaving space for genetically modified red blood cells that
   result from the treatment. Patients then spend about a month in the hospital 
   waiting for the modified cells to grow. After they are discharged, the
   patients are immunocompromised for about six months while their immune
   systems recover.

   Insurers are likely to pay for the part of the treatment that involves using 
   a disabled virus to deliver the therapy. But whether they will pay for most
   of the chemotherapy, hospitalization and other costs is uncertain. Patients
   worry about bills from hospitals and doctors. Even if it is mostly covered,
   co-payments can be an issue.

In addition to the overall cost of these new therapies potentially preventing
patients from accessing them, many won’t be able to for medical reasons. Bone
marrow transplant is already an existing and potentially curative intervention
for sickle cell disease, but it has been limited because few patients have a
matched donor available. It is also only indicated for patients with severe
disease, in particular recurrent strokes, meaning that many don’t qualify
despite having significant and frequent disruptions in their quality of life,
multiple hospitalizations, severe pain, and shorter lives. And when they do
qualify, bone marrow transplant has significant potential risk and about 5% die 
because of complications.

The process that allows these new gene therapies to work, the ablation of a
patient’s bone marrow in order to start with a clean slate, is the same as with 
bone marrow transplant. Similarly they will be at risk of life threatening
infections for months. Though the issue of finding a matched donor would no
longer be a concern, I imagine that the criteria for deciding who qualifies for 
gene therapy would be the same. Finally, many older patients will be too
medically fragile to even consider taking the risk of ablative chemotherapy.

Oh, and this:

   And, independent of the cost, how easy will it be for patients and family
   members who assist them to take off a month or more for the treatment, often 
   traveling to distant cities with medical centers that can administer the
   treatment?

And finally…I can’t even with this crap

Acupuncture for sepsis. Maybe so, according to a systematic review and
meta-analysis that was published last May in Acupuncture in Medicine:

   The available evidence showed that combination of acupuncture and routine
   therapy may have benefit for sepsis compared with use of routine therapy
   only. Due to the low degree of certainty regarding its effects, further
   research is required.

I suspect that the routine therapy was doing most of the heavy lifting in those 
cases, but perhaps I’m just biased. I should keep an open mind. Although, there 
has been a long and sordid history of people thinking things work for sepsis,
sometimes for years, that end up being useless or even harmful. Xigris, I’m
looking in your direction. And you aren’t off the hook either, vitamin C. But
maybe the little needles are the ticket. Maybe they just need to be electrified.

See you next time!

Washington Post Falls For Acupuncture Pseudoscience

An opinion piece falls for all the usual acupuncture misdirection.

Steven Novella on July 26, 2023

Link

It has been fascinating (and frustrating) watching the cultural shift in
attitudes toward acupuncture over the last two decades. It is a study case in
how to promote pseudoscience, how to exploit the vulnerabilities in
evidence-based medicine, and how effective propaganda can be, even against
professionals who should know better. It also demonstrates the dire need for the
inclusion of science-based medicine principles when evaluating medical
interventions.

A recent Washington Post article by Trisha Pasricha, MD, MPH illustrates nicely 
the misinformation, and also selective use of information, that leads even some 
professionals to the wrong conclusion. She comes to a few dubious conclusions,
starting with this:

   A 2018 meta-analysis of over 20,000 patients in 39 high-quality randomized
   controlled trials found that acupuncture was superior to both sham and no
   acupuncture for back or neck pain, osteoarthritis, headaches and shoulder
   pain. These outcomes mostly persisted over time — even after 12 months of
   receiving treatment.

She is referring to the latest Vickers et al systematic review of acupuncture
for chronic pain. David Gorski has done a good job of deconstructing these
reviews, and I will again point out the limitations. But first I will point out 
how this is a good example of the selective use of information by Pasricha,
because she did not refer to a later 2020 systematic review (which included a
review of Vickers 2018 review) which concluded:

   Evidence from SRs suggests that there are insufficient high-quality RCTs to
   judge the efficacy of acupuncture for chronic pain associated with various
   medical conditions.

In other words, the evidence is too low quality to conclude that acupuncture
works, as desperate as proponents are to say we can reach that conclusion. This 
is also how different experts can look at the same data and come to different
conclusions – it depends on how much you weight different factors, what you
consider an “acceptable” study, and how you control for bias. There is also a
lot of spin. Even in the very favorable Vickers review, the authors acknowledge 
at the end:

   Variations in the effect size of acupuncture in different trials are driven
   predominately by differences in treatments received by the control group
   rather than by differences in the characteristics of acupuncture treatment.

This understated admission is doing a lot of heavy lifting, but can easily be
missed by the unwary. What this means is that differing “characteristics of
acupuncture” (more on this below) do not affect treatment outcome. What
determines the effect size (difference between sham and verum acupuncture) is
how good the sham acupuncture is at simulating verum acupuncture. This is a
pattern in the acupuncture literature we have long pointed out. The better the
study, the larger the study, and the better the blinding, the smaller the effect
size, with the best studies being negative. As you improve the control and
rigor of the study, the effect of acupuncture diminishes to zero. That is a
pattern in the research we see across all pseudosciences. It is a giant flashing
light indicating that acupuncture is nothing but placebo.

But – if you just do a meta-analysis across the spectrum of study quality up to 
some arbitrary cutoff, you can see statistical significance. You just have to
ignore all the troubling patterns within the data. This is the difference
between the 2018 review and the 2020 review above.

Acupuncture has some special problems all its own as well, which I have
summarized many times. Acupuncture is hard to blind, and only the best studies
do it adequately. Both the subject and the acupuncturist have to be blinded, or 
else the interaction with the unblinded acupuncturist will have an effect. China
famously has 100% positive clinical trials of acupuncture, a statistical
impossibility, and these studies contaminate systematic reviews. Studies using
electroacupuncture also contaminate reviews, introducing another variable
(electrical stimulation) that cannot be separated from whatever the needles
might be doing.

But also, devastating all by itself, is the heterogeneity of study design and
outcome. This stems from the big glaring problem with acupuncture – what, if
anything, are acupoints? Pasricha writes:

   The World Health Organization consensus recognizes 361 standardized acupoints
   on the human body. Acupoints appear to respond to varied stimulation, such
   as from pressure, heat and electricity.

   There’s still a lot we don’t know about how acupoints work. Some studies have
   shown that traditional acupoints may have a high density of nerve endings
   and mast cells. Stimulating these areas may lead to the release of chemicals 
   in the body (such as hormones) and ultimately impact the brain.

This is a horrible summary of the science of acupoints. For example, she
mentions that the WHO recognizes 361 acupoints, but does not point out that this
number, traditionally 365 points, is based on the number of days in the year,
because acupoints are a form of astrology in which astrological patterns are
projected onto the body.

She could have also pointed out that systematic reviews, even by acupuncturists,
fail to demonstrate where the acupoints actually are. They cannot be localized 
and there is no agreement on where they are or what they allegedly do. In short,
acupuncture points don’t exist. They are a figment of a prescientific
superstition. After, what, 60 or so years of research, there is still no
convincing evidence of any anatomical, biochemical, or physiological basis for
acupoints. Only tantalizing studies that show maybe some whisper of signal in a 
lot of noise, that cannot be reproduced or confirmed. Acupoints are the medical 
equivalent of blobsquatch.

This gets to the heterogeneity problem (one fatal aspect of it). When you
combine different acupuncture studies for a systematic review or meta analysis, 
invariably you are combining studies that used different acupuncture points for 
the same problem. How is that considered verum acupuncture? Does that mean that 
all of the points used in various combinations are correct (even within the
giant error bars of where the points are)? Meanwhile, elsewhere on the body is
incorrect? Is there even an elsewhere? With hundreds of giant overlapping
alleged acupoints, nowhere on the body is not an acupoint. And since there is
absolutely no standardization in terms of which acupoints to use, any pattern is
apparently acceptable.

The absence of standardization is another glaring feature of pseudoscience. Each
acupuncturist can determine for themselves which acupoints to use for a
particular problem, and where, exactly, those points are. For clinical trials,
typically the acupuncturists involved in the study just decide by consensus
which points to use, which is why different studies use different points.

The problem with a lack of mechanism for acupuncture has motivated proponents to
look at increasingly noisy and unreliable methods for trying to find “stuff
that happens” when you stick someone with needles. Pasricha refers to one study 
in carpal tunnel syndrome.

   So scientists looked at the subjects’ brains using functional MRI imaging.
   They found that needling at the wrist and ankle both resulted in significant 
   changes to how stimulation to the fingers was mapped onto the cerebral
   cortex.

That’s not really what they found. What they found, in my opinion, was random
and not predicted changes that were all over the place. This is the typical
noise we see in fMRI studies. They mean nothing without consistent replication, 
which we don’t have. Sometimes the changes were in the affected hand, sometimes 
they were not, and it did not depend on where the acupuncture was done.

But there is also separate reason to suspect some bias and p-hacking in the
data. The study also found that sticking acupuncture in the opposite ankle
increase nerve conduction times in the affected wrist. This is not something
that can be mediated through some remote and hypothetical brain effect. They
need to explain how sticking a needle in the left ankle will cause the right
median nerve at the wrist to have better myelination. No fMRI study of the brain
is going to explain this. Something that unlikely is evidence of bias or poor
research methods until proven otherwise.

Following the acupuncture story closely for 30 years also gives one a good
perspective – because there seems to be an never-ending revolving door of these 
preliminary studies, and proponents breathlessly reassuring that we are finally 
about to explain how acupuncture works. But we never seem to get closer.
Acupuncture research has been chasing its tail for decades, because acupuncture 
is a fiction. There are no acupoints, and the effects of acupuncture are nothing
but placebo. A fair and science-based reading of the literature clearly shows
this. But proponents have been experts and creating this false narrative, and
the Washington Post just fell for it.

Chaperones Needed. On acupuncture.

Mark Crislip on October 3, 2014

Link



Dr. Oz, one half of the You Doctors. And a professor. A professor.

I receive a monthly newsletter from my medical board. Among other issues
discussed are the results of disciplinary actions for physicians. Occasionally a
physician who has boundary issues is required to have a chaperone present when 
doing exams.

I was thinking that the concept of a chaperone could be more widely applicable. 
Consider “You Docs: Amazing acupuncture,” the latest from Drs Oz and Roizen.
Both are professors at their respective institutions. Professors. To judge from 
the ability to read and interpret the medical literature, both should not be
allowed near a journal without a chaperone to remind them about cognitive
biases, logical fallacies and what constitutes a good clinical study. Looking at
their recent review of acupuncture suggests they lack an understanding of all
three.

They start with the argument from antiquity, which is not only wrong as a
logical fallacy, it is wrong historically when they say:

   acupuncture has been a go-to therapy for 5,000 years.

Off by a factor of about 500. They are unaware that acupuncture as currently
practiced is relatively new, having been a form of bloodletting until recently
when the modern version with steel needlesbecame popular under Mao.

   However, in the early 1930s a Chinese pediatrician by the name of Cheng
   Dan’an (承淡安, 1899-1957) proposed that needling therapy should be resurrected 
   because its actions could potentially be explained by neurology. He therefore
   repositioned the points towards nerve pathways and away from blood
   vessels-where they were previously used for bloodletting.

They explain the mechanism of action as stimulating

   points in the body that affect chi or qi, the life energy.

without noting that chi or qi is a fantasy. No life energy has ever been
measured and virtually every point on the body is an acupoint in one of the
multiplicity of styles that are acupunctures. Except, as mentioned in the past, 
the genitals.

And they are unaware of the fact that the concept of qi and meridians has more
to do with the inventions of Soulié de Morant, a Frenchman of the 1930s, who
popularized acupuncture in Europe and that de Morant’s

   claims about acupuncture, and the lore of energy meridians and qi, are
   founded on sloppy translations, misconceptions, or even pure forgery.

They proceed to the appeal to popularity noting that singer Alicia Keys and bike
racer Vincenzo Nibali use acupuncture and

   North Americans being needled jumped from 2 million in 2002 to more than 14
   million in 2007.

I have found that entertainers are not a good source of information for my
health care. Rob Schneider and Jenny McCarthy have not been optimal for vaccine 
advice or TV physicians for dietary supplement advice. The popularity of vaccine
refusal has only been good for the spread of whooping cough, measles and mumps.
So perhaps the wisdom of the celebrities and the crowd may not be the most
reliable source for other health information.

But, they note, the WHO recommends acupuncture for a wide variety of illnesses:

   The World Health Organization says acupuncture may help ease digestive
   problems like constipation and diarrhea; chronic sinus and lung infections;
   all sorts of pain, from headaches and migraines to neck pain, back pain and
   osteoarthritis; infertility; and even urinary and menstrual problems.

That weasel word: may. Come to me with pneumococcal pneumonia and there’s no
‘may’ about it. I’ll cure you. Perhaps using acupuncture for lung infections
explains why it is the third and fourth most common cause of death in the world.

Here is a problem with newspaper articles: no references. So I have to guess
what references the You Docs are using. I suspect they are referring to the 1996
WHO report, described as a

   highly flawed pro-acupuncture piece of propaganda, not a scientific review of
   evidence. It was worthless in 1996, and now it has the added burden of being
   outdated.

It is a truly appalling work, ignoring prior plausibility, minimizing risks, and
also suggesting acupuncture for convulsions in infants, colour blindness (?!?),
closed head injury, and progressive bulbar and pseudobulbar paralysis among
other diseases. I am sure Dr. Oz will have the courage of his convictions and
use acupuncture in lieu of bypass surgery, should he ever need it. The WHO
recommends it after all.

They mention that Dr. Mike, the Chief Wellness Officer at the Cleveland Clinic
(with concerning difficulties counting as “there are more than 10 certified
acupuncture practitioners in the Wellness Institute’s Center for Integrative
Medicine”. That would be a number greater than 11 and less than infinity and
that represents a lot of acupuncture being done at the Cleveland Clinic) has
found

   good evidence that it works to ease gastroesophageal reflux, nerve pain and
   post-surgery pain.

Now if good evidence is small, unblinded, non-placebo controlled trials, then
yeah, there is good evidence for gastroesophageal reflux, and nerve pain:

   Despite the number of trials of manual acupuncture for DPN and their
   uniformly positive results, no clinically relevant conclusions can be drawn
   from this review due to the trials’ high risks of bias and the possibility of
   publication bias.

or

   8 relevant papers were identified. One was an experimental study which showed
   that electroacupuncture suppressed CIPN pain in rats. In addition, there
   were 7 very heterogeneous clinical studies, 1 controlled randomised study
   using auricular acupuncture, 2 randomized controlled studies using somatic
   acupuncture, and 3 case series/case reports which suggested a positive effect
   of acupuncture in CIPN. Conclusions. Only one controlled randomised study
   demonstrated that acupuncture may be beneficial for CIPN. All the clinical
   studies reviewed had important methodological limitations.

and post-surgery pain

   The meta-analysis showed positive results for acupuncture treatment of pain
   after surgery in terms of the visual analogue scale (VAS) for pain intensity 
   24 hours after surgery, when compared to sham acupuncture (standard mean
   difference -0.67 (-1.04 to -0.31), P = 0.0003), whereas the other
   meta-analysis did not show a positive effect of acupuncture on 24-hour opiate
   demands when compared to sham acupuncture (standard mean difference -0.23
   (-0.58 to 0.13), P = 0.21).

Although there are many postoperative acupuncture pain studies with variable
results, the preponderance of literature and high quality studies suggests no
efficacy. But the Cleveland Clinic is not a bastion of Science-Based Medicine.

If I am trying to decide on a restaurant or a new pair of shoes I pick ones I
tried and enjoyed in the past or have good reviews. When it comes to health care
I am a bit more selective in my criteria. I want what is effective in the best 
clinical trials. For the You Doctors the criteria is

   if you’re one of the folks who like the idea (of acupuncture), and the
   treatments work for you

try it and offer the following as support.

   It’s a pain soother: In a new University of California San Diego study, after
   31 kids (ages 2 to 17) had tonsillectomies, acupuncture muted their throat
   aches within minutes.

Retrospective, not blinded, no sham acupuncture, conducted by a clinician who is
a believer.

   The reported benefits of L14 stimulation is reinforced by the author’s own
   personal clinical acupuncture experience.

No opportunity for researcher bias here, is there?

   A hot-flash cooler: A new review of 12 studies involving 869 menopausal women
   concludes that acupuncture reduces the number and intensity of this annoying
   menopause symptom.

Take “Effects of acupuncture on menopause-related symptoms and quality of life
in women on natural menopause: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.”
There is no reason what-so-ever to suspect that acupuncture would do anything
for hot flashes, certainly not by classical Chinese Medicine theory of
nonexistent chi and meridians. An article suggests

   …that acupuncture caused a reduction in the concentration of β-endorphin in
   the hypothalamus, resulting from low concentrations of estrogen. These lower 
   levels could trigger the release of CGRP, which affects thermoregulation.

Acupuncture aficionados love to point to endorphin release secondary to sticking
someone with a sharp piece of metal for many of the alleged effects of
acupuncture. It is much to do about nothing, and would not explain how the ever 
so laughable laser acupuncture and acupressure would have the same effects. They
included many types of acupuncture, some mutually exclusive, in the study:

   traditional Chinese medicine acupuncture (TCMA), acupressure,
   electroacupuncture, laser acupuncture and ear acupuncture.

The mappings in the ear for ear acupuncture are not the same as traditional
Chinese acupuncture. But there is no acupuncture, but rather acupunctures
plural, as many as there are practitioners, since there is zero standardization 
of diagnosis and practice of the many forms of this pseudo-medicine.

If you are a Bayesian kind of gal, you would understand that if an intervention 
has no prior plausibility, then any likely positive results are likely false
positives and due to bias.

And the study suggests that any and all positive effects are due to poor
methodology and bias. As a rule, effects of pseudo-medical interventions such as
acupuncture only have effects for subjective, not objective, endpoints, and the
number and intensity of hot flashes is a subjective endpoint.

Key to any clinical trial: if an intervention is no different from placebo, IT
DOESN’T WORK. Sorry I shouted. The effect on hot flash frequency or severity
appeared to be linked to the number of treatment doses, number of sessions or
duration of treatment.

However, they also demonstrated that sham acupuncture could induce a treatment
effect comparable with that of true acupuncture for the reduction of hot flash
frequency.

The dose and the frequency of the drug made no difference in the outcome and it 
was no better than placebo. Therefore it works. And so we get misleading
headlines suggesting efficacy of acupunctures.

   A pound melter: When 91 overweight people followed the same healthy diet and 
   got real or sham ear acupuncture, those who got the real thing lost weight.

  1. Small sample size? Check.

  2. High dropout rate? Check.

  3. Bad statistics? Check.

  4. Inadequate blinding? Check.

  5. Small effect size? Check.

  6. Underlying prejudice/bias in favor of an intervention? Check.

  7. Totally improbable intervention? Check.

Ioannidis identified many features that render a clinical trial suspect. It
sometime appears that pseudo-medicine researchers try to hit as many of them as 
possible. Certainly this is the case where ear acupuncture was used as an
adjunct to weight loss and found to be effective. Almost every error that could 
be applied to a study, was. Patients received 5 point ear acupuncture, 1 point
ear acupuncture or sham acupuncture for 8 weeks:

   Those who received five-point acupuncture had needles placed 2 millimeters
   deep in one outer ear taped in place and kept there for a week. Then the same
   treatment was applied to the other ear… Other patients received similar
   treatment with one needle or with sham acupuncture where the needles were
   removed immediately after insertion.

I suspect that there was such a high drop out in the sham treatment as because
they knew they were not getting acupuncture. A lousy placebo renders an already 
silly and poorly done trial completely meaningless, like most of the acupuncture
trials.

But the real reason this trial is not valid is that Korean ear acupuncture is
not real acupuncture. Real acupuncture is traditional Chinese. Or Japanese. Not 
wait, hand acupuncture. Or foot acupuncture. No, wait, tongue acupuncture.
That’s the ticket. Or perhaps it’s the Micro Acupuncture Point System.

   An energizer for cancer patients: In two recent University of Pennsylvania
   studies, women receiving chemotherapy for early-stage breast cancer reported 
   reductions in tiredness, anxiety, depression and joint pain after receiving
   acupuncture.

Which was discussed by Dr. Novella:

   They were treated for 8 weeks with either RA (real) or SA (sum). Outcomes
   included several scales that essentially involve reporting subjective
   symptoms. The study found that both groups reported improvement in symptoms
   with treatment, but there was no statistically significant difference between
   the two. In the real world we refer to this as a negative study.

So acupuncture includes Chinese, Korean ear and electroacupuncture. Any and all 
acupunctures are equally useless. Except when the You Doctors read the
literature.

The You Docs finish by admitting it is all placebo anyway:

   We know that in some studies, sham acupuncture produces results almost as
   good (or as good) as the real thing. Perhaps the sham technique (pricking
   acupuncture points) works as well as inserting needles … or, in some cases,
   acupuncture works because people want it to. Future research will help sort
   that out.

It has already been sorted out by past research. Acupuncture only has subjective
effects when the patient believes it is effective. The You Docs need to read
the past literature.

They also suggest making sure that

   your practitioner is certified and state-licensed.

As if that makes a difference in quality. There is a letter to Acupuncture in
Medicine entitled “Pneumothorax complication of deep dry needling
demonstration“. Pneumothorax is a rare but well described complication of
acupuncture. I almost feel sorry for the practitioner as in the accompanying
video he keeps emphasizing the care that must be done in order to avoid just
that complication. Then you see the needle abruptly goes really deep. Pop.

Procedures, even useless procedures, have complications. It happens. But watch
the video for the most god-awful adherence to infection control you could ever
want to see.

  1. No gloves.

  2. No cleaning of the site where the needle is going to go (at least on film).

  3. His ungloved hands wander all over the patients back.

  4. He uses the tube in which the sterile needle sits as a pointer, touching his
    finger with it

  5. As he manipulates the needle up and down in the skin it bows, evidently
    bouncing against his other hand.

  6. And the coup de grace: after taking out the needle he covers bloody spot with 
    his bare finger.

Aarrrrrggggghhhhhhhhhhhhh.

And this from a practitioner of 45 years of experience teaching others how to do
dry needling. I cannot tell from the video if hands were washed before the
procedure; supposedly they were. It sure gives me the Infection Control willies.
It is difficult to infect people, even if you are trying. But not impossible,
given the 506 hits searching PubMed for “acupuncture and infection.” The British
acupuncturists are not enthusiastic for either gloves or cleaning the skin.
Perhaps that number of hits would have been a little smaller if they were more
fastidious about infection control.

But I have long noted an unwillingness of pseudo-medical providers to improve
practice for the patients’ benefit.

The You Doctors: they do not understand how to read the literature, recognize
acupuncture is a placebo, yet go ahead and suggest ways to

   get the most out of this healing therapy.

Come to think of it, I do not think a chaperone when reading the medical
literature will work.

Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine Hodgepodge

Mark Crislip on February 20, 2015

Link



Qing Dynasty (1662-1722) painting, traditional Chinese medical view of the human
viscera from the back. Image L0039962 from the Wellcome Trust image library,
via the Wikimedia Commons.

As I have noted before, more is published on acupuncture and traditional Chinese
pseudo-medicine than the other SCAM. Here are some of the articles that drew my
attention.

Captain Hook and acupuncture

Here is one of the more curious articles on acupuncture I have yet to find,
“Psychophysical and neurophysiological responses to acupuncture stimulation to
incorporated rubber hand.”

I did not know this, but you can fool a person into thinking that a rubber hand 
is their own.

   The synchronous tactile stimulation of the real hand of an individual and
   rubber hand leads to the feeling that the rubber hand is incorporated with
   the body of that individual. This is referred to as the rubber hand illusion 
   (RHI), and it occurs because the brain is attempting to interpret the
   interaction of the visual, tactile, and proprioceptive systems of the body,
   which in turn, leads to a re-calibration of the touch and the felt position
   of the hand. The multimodal visuotactile stimulation inherent in the RHI
   induces the brain to temporarily incorporate external objects into its body
   image. In addition, when the experimenter threatens the rubber hand with a
   needle during this illusion, it generally elicits an enhanced sympathetic
   response and a measurable cortical anxiety response, which indicates that the
   bodily ownership of the rubber hand causes changes in the interoceptive
   system of the brain.

Cool. Check out this video to see how it is done. So what happens when you do
acupuncture on a rubber hand that the brain thinks is its own?

   The findings of the present study clearly demonstrate that acupuncture
   stimulation to a rubber hand resulted in the experience of the DeQi sensation
   when the rubber hand was fully incorporated into the body.

As judged by fMRI findings (always taken with a grain of salt substitute) and
patient reports. DeQi is what dey feel when de needle is twirled in de skin.

So acupuncture of a rubber hand causes the same response as acupuncture in a
real hand. What does that say about acupuncture? That meridians and qi are
spontaneously generated in the rubber hand? Or that the response to acupuncture 
is all psychological with no effect on an underlying physiology, real or
imagined?

And now that there are socks with built in acupuncture I wonder if the socks
would have the same effect on an artificial leg.

Acupuncture: Beer goggles or over-priced wine?

Painting with a broad brush, I would say that acupuncture doesn’t work. By
‘work’ I would say that it causes no change in the underlying physiology or
anatomy of the person receiving the acupuncture.

‘Works’ is different from having an effect, even a beneficial effect. Positive
interactions between a patient and a health care provider, even when offering a 
pseudo-medicine, will make some patients feel better about their disease. I
compare these pseudo-medicines, like acupuncture, to beer goggles. They change
perception but not reality.

While changing the perception of disease for the better is of benefit, it is
just not ethical to base treatment on a lie.

What happens with a process like acupuncture to alter patient perceptions? It
doesn’t matter where the needles are placed or even if needles are used; twirled
tooth picks are just as effective as acupuncture needles. What matters most for
efficacy is if the patient thinks they are getting acupuncture and if they
believe acupuncture is effective. Then acupuncture will have an effect. That’s
it. So what is going on?

Another hint on the mechanism of acupuncture is in “When pain is not only pain: 
Inserting needles into the body evokes distinct reward-related brain responses
in the context of a treatment.”

In this study 24 people received three identical stimuli: tactile, acupuncture, 
and pain stimuli. There were two groups to receive the three stimuli, an
acupuncture treatment (AT) group and an acupuncture stimulation (AS) group. What
differed is what they were told before the stimuli

   participants in the AS group were primed to consider the acupuncture as a
   painful stimulus, whereas the participants in the AT group were told that the
   acupuncture was part of therapeutic treatment.

They had an fMRI (who doesn’t) and a questionnaire about their subjective
experience.

   Behavioral results generally revealed no differences between the AT and AS
   groups. The questionnaire results confirmed that there were no significant
   differences in expectancies, fear, or anticipation and subjective pain
   ratings related to needles being inserted into the body between patients in
   the AT and AS groups.

They found no analgesic effect in the acupuncture group. But there was a
difference in the fMRI (for what that is worth):

   We found that reward-related regions (specifically, the ventral striatum) of 
   the brain were activated by acupuncture stimulation and that in response to
   painful simulation, activity in pain-processing regions(the SII and DLPFC)
   was decreased only when participants were told that acupuncture needles were 
   a therapeutic tool.

And

   As greater activation of the ventral striatum is generally correlated with
   more expectations of pleasure and rewards, our results could be interpreted
   to suggest that acupuncture stimulation was associated with the expectation
   of a reward – possibly an analgesic effect – for patients experiencing
   acupuncture in the context of a treatment (AT group).

So depending on the context, people process the same stimulus differently. A
needle for therapeutic acupuncture is different than the exact same needle used 
for stimulation.

Maybe. It is a small study and fMRI’s have issues as we know from dead salmon.
But taken in the context of the literature pointing to the
predominantly-positive subjective effects of pseudo-medicines it is curious
finding. Maybe not beer goggles; probably more like making wine taste better by 
giving it a higher price.

Acupuncture works. If you believe it will.

I like antibiotics. They kill of the bacteria infecting my patients. It doesn’t 
matter what the patient thinks about the effectiveness of the antibiotics. They 
just work. Having a practice based almost entirely in acute care medicine, most 
of the interventions have effect (or not) independent of patient belief
concerning the interventions.

Not so with acupunctures. As I have said many times, acupuncture doesn’t work
i.e. alter any underlying physiologic process. But that doesn’t mean that the
innumerable forms of acupuncture don’t have an effect. They do.

I have mentioned in other entries the importance of expectation in acupunctures 
effect. Believing does make it so is an example. The more patients thought
acupunctures would have an effect, the greater the response. If the patients
were unenthusiastic about acupunctures efficacy, nothing happened.

There is a paper in the Clinical Journal of Pain, “Psychological Covariates of
Longitudinal Changes in Back-related Disability in Patients Undergoing
Acupuncture“, that carries on that theme.

They note:

   Indeed, acupuncture can be conceptualized as a complex intervention in which 
   changes in patients’ health are produced not only by needling but also by
   more psychosocial factors such as empathic therapeutic relationships and
   holistic consultations in which discussions of lifestyle and self-care can
   trigger changes in how patients think and feel about their symptoms and their
   ability to manage them.

But they also ask what are the psycho-social factors that lead to success or
failure of acupuncture for low back pain?

They had 485 patients from 83 acupuncturists before starting acupuncture for
back pain who took several questionnaires over the 6 months of their
acupuncture.

Interstingly, among other findings,

   People who started out with very low expectations of acupuncture – who
   thought it probably would not help them – were more likely to report less
   benefit as treatment went on.

As is often the case with the response to pseudo-medicines, rather than
concluding that since the effects of acupuncture are an elaborate ritual with no
intrinsic value beyond placebo, and perhaps it should be abandoned as useless
at best and unethical at worst, they suggest teaching acupuncturists to be
better at their elaborate ritual. You know, be a better liar and manipulator:

   Dr Bishop added that to improve the effectiveness of treatment,
   acupuncturists should consider helping patients to think more positively
   about their back pain as part of their consultations…his understanding could 
   lead in the future to better targeting of acupuncture and related therapies
   in order to maximise patient benefit.

Why not keep the power of positive thinking but attach it to reality-based
interventions instead of selling patients the TCM equivalent of supplements?

But researchers in pseudo-medicines are never looking to apply negative results 
to patient care.

Massive head scourge and acupuncture

I am old school. A germ theory kind of guy. Mumps, as an example, is due to the 
mumps virus, a Paramyxovirus that likes to infect the parotid glands and
occasionally other organs. There is no treatment but tincture of time.

There are other, more curious, supposed etiologies for mumps:

   Mumps is caused by invasion of the body by exopathogenic wind-heat toxin from
   the mouth and nose. This pathogen mixing with phlegm turns into fire to
   obstruct the Shaoyang and Yangming Channels, leading to lump due to
   accumulation of heat in the parotid region. Therefore, the principle of
   treatment should be to eliminate stagnated heat from the Shaoyang and
   Yangming Channels.

And how would one eliminate stagnated heat from the Shaoyang and Yangming
Channels? According to Dr. Long Wenjun, needles in the ear points of Antitragic 
Apex and Pancreas-Gallbladder are the first choice in treatment.

Although Song treated 1,000 cases with a single needle at the Pingjian point
(MA-T2). As with all self-limited diseases, the effect is satisfactory. And
don’t forget:

   The needle should be sterilized carefully to prevent infection.

If the Pingjian point is the same as either the Antitragic Apex or
Pancreas-Gallbladder, I can’t say for sure. The interwebs are not clear.

Both are incorrect, as the Fire-needle with sulfur is obviously better, although
I can’t discover exactly what it is. It does sound better. Fire-needle. With
sulfur. Kids will love that.

That is what I could find on Pubmed concerning mumps and acupuncture. Others on 
the web suggest different places on the skin to needle and perhaps a different
etiology. I do like the terms ‘massive head scourge’ and ‘frog scourge’ for
mumps and that website offers yet another acupuncture intervention point.

Give the known viral pathophysiology of mumps, there is zero reason to suspect
that the fanciful and inconsistent interventions mentioned above would have any 
effect on the mumps. It doesn’t stop the Cochrane reviews from looking for
something to meta-analyze. Like the prior review from 2012, they:

   aimed to determine the effectiveness and safety of using acupuncture to treat
   mumps in children.

But:

   identified no trials for inclusion in this updated review.

Oddly, the background does not mention that mumps is a virus but rather:

   …caused by ‘wind warmth evil’ (epidemic heat) and ‘pyretic toxicity’
   accumulated in the Shaoyang and Yangming meridians, thus the flow of Qi,
   sputum and ‘heat evil’ stagnate in and around the ears and the cheeks.
   Acupuncture can help expel ‘wind warmth evil’, clear pathogenic heat, remove 
   toxic substances, act as an anti-inflammatory, alleviate pain and
   re-establish the normal flow of Qi, thus restoring internal balance.

That is a reasonable background? Makes their motto (“Trusted evidence. Informed 
decisions. Better health.”) suspect. Then they suggested that:

   More high-quality research is needed.

More suggests there has been some quality research. There hasn’t. And is any
research needed? I think not. I would hope that IRB’s would recognize useless
pseudo-medicine when they see it and protect children from needless needles.
Yeah. Right. Like that will happen.

Otzi the Iceman and Acupuncture, redux.

I try to be circumspect. I really do. Respectful of the person, if not the idea.
Hate the sin, not the sinner. But some things are Just. So. Stupid.

Last year the stupidest comment by a reputable source I found was in the
Cochrane review of vitamin C for the cold:

   it may be worthwhile for common cold patients to test on an individual basis 
   whether therapeutic vitamin C is beneficial for them.

Seriously. As I said at the time:

   The uselessness of personal experience in determining efficacy of medical
   interventions is why we do clinical trials. For crying out loud, I though it 
   the raison d’être of the whole Cochrane Collaborative: relying on evidence
   instead of anecdotes. Wrong.

Here it is, less than two months into the new year and I doubt you will find a
more stupid interpretation of information for the rest of 2015 than “New tattoos
found on Otzi the Iceman support prehistoric acupuncture theory.”

Ötzi, the 5,300-year-old corpse found in the Italian Alps, has 61 tattoos in 19 
groups across his body. More were recently found using special photographic
techniques:

   Lars Krutak, an anthropologist who has published a book about the medicinal
   applications of tattoos, has said they may be on or near other acupuncture
   points.

   Commenting on the findings, Krutak said: “I was intrigued by the possibility 
   that the new set of tattoos were located on or near classical acupuncture
   points or meridians. If they were, perhaps these could be traced to Otzi’s
   known pathological conditions, such as gallbladder stones, whipworms in his
   colon and atherosclerosis.”

   He consulted Gillian Powers, an acupuncturist, who said the location of the
   new tattoos corresponds with treatments associated with whipworms and
   gallstones.

I wonder if archeologists are ingesting some of the hallucinogenic indigenous
plants to come up with ideas like that.

It seems that every time someone comes across a tattoo on a mummy, goodness
gracious, it is near an acupuncture point. Find tats on the neck of a Peruvian
mummy?

   A possible therapeutic origin may lie in the fact that the circles on the
   neck lie close to acupuncture points, having a relaxing and pain-relieving
   effect in the neck and head region.

There are perhaps 350 common acupoints, with some estimates putting the number
at over 2,000. The average male is about 2900 square inches, so there is an
acupuncture point every .68 square inches. Except, curiously, and
understandably, the eyes, under the nails, and the genitals.

With that many points, it is not hard to find associations because every point
on the skin is on or near an acupuncture point. He doesn’t seem to consider the 
notion that acupoints and meridians are nonsense that have no therapeutic effect
on any process. One gets the feeling this is the worst example (or best
example?) of confirmation bias ever.

   It cannot be ruled out that the Iceman’s tattoos were indeed applied as a
   therapeutic treatment. In future studies, the location of the new tattoos and
   its relation to acupuncture points and/or meridians should be further
   explored and discussed.

I think the tats were put there to ward off Big Foot and Nessie. Cannot rule
that out either and it should be further explored and discussed.

Body art is currently popular. 5,000 years from now they will pull the body of
an Oregonian out of an ice crevice on Mt. Hood or from a bog along the coast.
Looking at the barbed wire on the arm, the Chinese character on the calf or the 
abstract tramp stamp in the small of the back, they will find the tats near
acupoints and conclude they were medical tats.

So stupid. But the year is young. I still am betting the Cochrane Collaboration 
will surpass this bit of idiocy. They have yet to fail me.

It’s a bad flu season. Use acupuncture!?!

It was a bad flu season. We have had one death in my hospital system from
influenza this year. So what is to be done for the prevention and treatment of
influenza? University Hospitals in Cleveland suggests a worthless
pseudo-medicine: “Acupuncture for Cold and Flu Season.”

As an infectious disease doctor when I think of treating or preventing a
potentially fatal illnesses, somehow magic doesn’t jump to the top of the list.

They suggest that acupuncture:

   could also help you avoid colds and flu this winter – or at least send them
   packing sooner.

Weasel word, “could”. A search of PubMed for ‘influenza’ and ‘acupuncture’
yields nothing of note; even less after searching for ‘cold’ and ‘acupuncture.’ 
As far as the Pubmeds goes, there are no clinical trials to suggest that
acupuncture helps influenza or cold prevention or treatment.

Well not clinical trials but philosophy is the basis of treatment. Yes.
Philosophy.

   Eastern medical philosophy, acupuncture works by balancing and harmonizing qi
   (pronounced “chee”), or vital, life-force energy.

At one time Western philosophy thought illness was due to an imbalance of
humors. That was superseded by treating illness not based on philosophy but
rather on the reality of the sciences. Eastern medical philosophy evidently
prefers the philosophical fantasy of unblocking and revitalizing a mythical qi. 
Why a University is treating diseases based on philosophy instead of reality
eludes me. I mean, besides the whole “getting money for nothing” thing.

   Western medicine views acupuncture as a form of therapy that releases
   hormones into the bloodstream, sending signals to the nervous system.

No. Western medicine (and I hate the terms Western and Eastern, that seem
slightly racist and suggests there are two versions of reality when there is
one) sees acupuncture as an elaborate placebo that has never been shown to have 
efficacy in well-controlled clinical trials for any objective endpoint. They
continue:

   Q: How can acupuncture help during the cold and flu system?

   A: Studies have shown that patients receiving acupuncture have elevated
   immune-enhancing hormones and blood counts for up to three days after
   treatment. If you begin to feel the symptoms of the cold or flu coming on, it
   is important to visit your acupuncturist right away to get the most benefit 
   from your treatment. Acupuncture can:

  1. Prevent colds and flu by boosting the immune system

  2. Help you get over the cold or flu faster if you already have it

  3. Reduce chills, fever and body aches

  4. Relieve sore throat and congestion

Absolute nonsense unsupported by known biology or clinical trials. As I have
said before, you cannot boost the immune system, much less with fantastical
acupuncture, against influenza. Having your immune system boosted may be part of
the reason for worse outcomes in the obese and pregnant.

Still, this advice is offered by a University Integrative Medicine program that 
offers multiple therapies divorced from known reality: Acupuncture, Ayurveda,
reflexology and reiki. It would probably be unreasonable to expect them to offer
actual useful therapies.

That a university hospital’s website suggests nonsense for a serious illness
confirms the choice of Sisyphus for the logo of the Society for Science-Based
Medicine.

Seriously. It’s a bruise.

Sometimes I see an article and I have to double check that it is not from The
Onion. The Falun Gong-sponsored Epoch Times is not a satire publication
(although their ad for seeing how acidic your body is gives me pause) but they
did publish “Ancient Technique Scrapes Away Pain.”

The article concerns Gua sha, yet another ancient Chinese healing
pseudo-medicine where the skin is scrapped with a tool such as:

   something with a rounded edge that can be comfortably stroked across the
   body. Tools range from stones and bones shaped specifically for the job to
   large coins.

Gua sha is used to release congestion and stagnation of some sort or other to
help the body heal itself from the usual hodgepodge of illnesses. There are few 
studies on the Pubmed on the technique and none of any quality.

Look at the pictures with article, or look at the picture of this fellow’s back 
after Gua sha:



Apparently his Chi wasn’t up to par. From Bradwesley69 on the Wikimedia Commons.

It is a bruise from trauma.

Read the caption:

   Gua sha raises dark marks that can be mistaken for tissue damage.

What? Are you nuts? It’s a BRUISE. It IS tissue damage. Are you blind?

The Gua sha instructor says

   It looks like we are creating a bruise, or like we are breaking capillaries
   and causing some damage. What we’re actually doing is extravasating blood
   from the capillary bed,

“extravasating blood from the capillary bed?!?!” That’s what a BRUISE is.

Look at the results of an internet search for Gua sha. It’s bruising from
trauma.

At least the medical literature recognizes a “contusion injury to underlying
soft tissue” and an “intentionally create(d) therapeutic petechiae and
ecchymosis representing extravasation of blood in the subcutis.”

Or:

   Gua Sha is a traditional Chinese folk therapy that employs skin scraping to
   cause subcutaneous microvascular blood extravasation and bruises

It’s a bruise.

The most impressive denial of reality I have ever seen in years.

And finally

I received a tweet that said if acupuncture needs belief to work, why does it
work on animals? Well, it doesn’t. The SkepVet is a nice source for more erudite
discussions of the topic. With veterinary pseudo-medicine you are relying on
the reports of the owner, or perhaps the zookeeper.

“Acupuncture provides relief for Palm Beach Zoo Komodo dragon’s pain” is a
perfect example of reporting bias and silly reporting. Bob and Ray would be
proud.

Hannah, a Komodo dragon, has neck pain. So they corner the poor beast, hold her 
against her will and stick the poor animal with needles using horrible infection
control technique. I see septicemia in her future. When she finally escapes,
jacked up on fear and adrenaline, she goes to a place of prior safety and
comfort to escape what to her must be a close call with death. However, the zoo 
says:

   After receiving the acupuncture treatment, Hannah seemed to experience almost
   immediate relief, zoo officials said.

   She seemed to get very active and very interested in heading back to her
   sunny spot after the acupuncture

Of course she did. Stress and fear can make even severe injuries temporarily
seem insignificant as many a war story will confirm, a serious wound ignored
until the firefight is over. An injured animal will get more animated when
stressed to avoid being, I don’t know, killed and eaten? Lizards try and get
warm when stressed by infection. It is part of their survival technique since
they cannot mount a fever on their own.

That is animal acupuncture: a terrified animal trying to escape its tormenters, 
transiently appearing better after an intervention stops.

Sad.

Acupuncture Whac-a-Mole ™

Mark Crislip on January 10, 2014

Link

   Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.– George
   Santayana

   Most people don’t have that willingness to break bad habits. They have a lot 
   of excuses and they continue to produce bad clinical studies.– Carlos Santana
   (Well, not the last 4 words.)

One is a guitar player, one is a philosopher. I get them confused.

I think George was in charge of SCAM research at the NIH. It was Dr. Gorski who 
first used the term Whac-a-Mole to describe what we do. The same badly-done
studies are done over and over and misrepresented over and over, with only very 
minor variations on a theme. This is especially true of acupuncture, the most
extensively studied pseudo-medicine in search of something, anything, for which 
it might be effective. They are still searching.

I loved going mano-a-mano with my kids when they were younger on the Whac-a-Mole
machine in the Seaside arcade followed by root beer and elephant ears. It was
the last time I beat either of them at any athletic endeavor. So I enjoy
Whac-a-Mole, with mechanical rodents or bad research.

It sometime appears that pseudo-medicine researchers try and apply as many of
the criteria to their research as possible that Ioannidis identified as
rendering a clinical trial suspect.

  1. Small sample size? Check.

  2. High dropout rate? Check.

  3. Bad statistics? Check.

  4. Inadequate blinding? Check.

  5. Small effect size? Check.

  6. Underlying prejudice/bias in favor of an intervention? Check.

  7. Totally improbable intervention? Check.

Take the BMJ article, “Randomised clinical trial of five ear acupuncture points 
for the treatment of overweight people”. Please. It applies to this study where 
ear acupuncture was used as an adjunct to weight loss and found to be effective,
only if you lend credence to terribly done clinical trials. Almost every error 
that could occur in a study, did occur.

Ear acupuncture has an origin story on par with chiropractic or iridology:

   Auricular acupuncture therapy is based on the understanding [I do not think
   it means what you think it means – Ed.] that the external ear represents all 
   parts of the human body, including the internal organs, and provides
   acupuncture points corresponding to these parts. Auricular acupuncture
   therapy was discovered by Dr Paul Nogier based on observations that backaches
   were cured after the patient received a burn on their ear. Dr Nogier
   pictured an auricle as a fetus that was curled up and upside down; he used
   his anatomical knowledge to treat diseases by applying pressure to the
   reaction points that represent the internal organs.

The mind boggles over the inanities that are pseudo-medicine origins. At least
they could try and blame cosmic rays. or a radioactive spider (I am DC at heart,
Marvel origins are lame. I suppose that will get more discussion than the
entry).

Being completely disconnected with reality never stops a pseudo-medical study.
Patients received five-point ear acupuncture, one-point ear acupuncture or sham 
acupuncture for eight weeks:

   Treatment I subjects received unilateral acupuncture with indwelling needles 
   at five ear acupuncture points (Shen-men, Stomach, Spleen, Hunger,
   Endocrine), which are generally used in Korean clinical treatments (see
   online supplementary figure S1).19 20 Treatment II subjects received an
   indwelling needle unilaterally at the Hunger acupuncture point only, whose
   specificity has been reported.19 Treatment groups received acupuncture in one
   ear on the first visit. One week later, the applied needles were removed and
   the same treatment was performed on their other ear. The needles used for
   the treatment groups were tack-like, 0.2×2 (head diameter×point length)
   mm-sized Dong Bang acupuncture needles. The heads of tack-like needles are
   fixed on surgical tape so that when the steel points are inserted, the
   needles remain attached to the skin (Suwon, Korea). The depth of insertion
   was 2 mm.The control group received sham acupuncture at the five ear
   acupuncture points used in treatment I group at their first visit. The
   needles used for the control group were fixed on surgical tape, but were
   removed immediately after insertion (2 mm), while the surgical tape remained 
   on the acupuncture points

I suspect that there was such a high drop out in the sham treatment as because
they knew they were not getting acupuncture. As the study notes:

   we did not test the blinding of the control group; participants in this group
   might have examined the adhesive dressings in their ears and found no
   needles.

A lousy placebo renders an already silly and poorly done trial completely
meaningless, like most of the acupuncture trials.

Given that “A single doctor of traditional Korean medicine performed all
treatments”, it is highly likely that the Clever Hans effect was taking place:
subtle clues that suggested who was getting placebo.

Another flaw was while “Compliance with diet and exercise regimen was recorded
by the patients and checked weekly at the clinic”, the results were not reported
in the study and the main reason people dropped out was issues with following
the dietary restrictions.

So while those in the treatment groups lost more weight than the sham group,
there are so many flaws in the study that it would be impossible draw valid
conclusions. Like almost all acupuncture studies.

My favorite part of the study was the fifth inclusion criteria: “Hygienic
individuals”. At least they were clean, which is a good thing. I have seen one
patient lose an ear from a piercing and infections are reported with ear
acupuncture. Watching the sterile technique demonstration helps me understand
why Dr. Oz had a volunteer rather than trying it himself.

But the real reason this trial is not valid is that Korean ear acupuncture is
not real acupuncture. Real acupuncture is traditional Chinese. Or Japanese. No
wait, hand acupuncture. Or foot acupuncture. No, it’s tongue acupuncture that is
the real deal. That’s the ticket. Or perhaps it’s the Micro Acupuncture Point
System. So many acupunctures, so little reality.

Compare this to a study with better methodologies: “Patient-Reported Outcomes in
Women With Breast Cancer Enrolled in a Dual-Center, Double-Blind, Randomized
Controlled Trial Assessing the Effect of Acupuncture in Reducing Aromatase
Inhibitor-Induced Musculoskeletal Symptoms.”

This study worked hard to blind patients as to treatment arm:

   Although the acupuncturists were not blinded to the assignment, in an effort 
   to minimize the introduction of bias, the acupuncturists followed a prepared 
   script when engaging in conversation with the participants. All other
   individuals involved in the care of participants were blinded, including the 
   treating oncologist(s), nurses, and study team members. The participants also
   were blinded to their treatment assignment….Patients in the SA group
   received nonpenetrating, retractable needles placed in 14 sham acupoints
   located at the midpoint of the line connecting 2 real acupoints.

The endpoints are patient-reported symptoms, so one could predict the outcome
before it happens. Any SCAM compared to a good placebo (i.e. the patient cannot 
tell it is placebo) will always be equivalent for any outcome that is subjective
and better than no treatment. That result was best typified in the NEJM article
comparing various fake treatments for asthma. No effect will be seen if the
endpoint is objective. All pseudo-medical interventions are like kissing a
skinned knee in a child – comforting but with no important physical effects.

Same as it ever was, fake and real acupuncture were equivalent in relieving
symptoms. So abandon acupuncture, right? Especially since it is clear that
acupuncture has as much basis in reality as the four humor theory of disease.
Except for acupuncture based on auricular thermal injury.

I am a classicist. I have what would be the standard, perhaps Copenhagen,
interpretation of clinical trials. If a therapy is compared to placebo and they 
are found to be equivalent, then the therapy does not work and should be
abandoned.

There was a recent article in the NEJM where they evaluated patients with “knee 
symptoms consistent with a degenerative medial meniscus tear and no knee
osteoarthritis” and treated them with either arthroscopic partial meniscectomy
or sham surgery. There was no difference in outcomes and they concluded:

   …the results of this randomized, sham-controlled trial show that arthroscopic
   partial medial meniscectomy provides no significant benefit over sham
   surgery in patients with a degenerative meniscal tear and no knee
   osteoarthritis. These results argue against the current practice of
   performing arthroscopic partial meniscectomy in patients with a degenerative 
   meniscal tear.

Nowhere could I find a review of the article that suggested that arthroscopic
surgery worked if only you believe. It is an annoying interpretation of SCAM
interventions, that since the outcomes are equivalent to placebo, you are
getting an effect from the power of placebo. An example is from the Science 2.0 
website:

   Sometimes you just have to believe.

   Acupuncture has proven to be effective, though it isn’t actually being done. 
   When it comes to hot flashes due to breast cancer treatment, even skin pricks
   used to simulate acupuncture needle sticks might be enough to generate
   natural chemicals that improve symptoms, which would explain the results.

I’m sure that pharmaceutical companies would love that standard: if a drug is
equal to placebo then use it: then you just have to believe. I remember the
immortal words of B. Bunny: “What a Maroon.” I know, innuendo. Somehow rational 
thought flies out the door when pseudo-medicines comes innuendo.

Regular readers of my entries know my take on the preponderance of the
literature as to the nature of the placebo effect: it is mostly a myth. Placebo 
is medical beer goggles, making diseases appear better when they are not. As I
have mentioned in the past, SCAM = Placebo. Placebo = Nothing. Therefore SCAM = 
Nothing. Simple logic, n’est pas?

Acupuncture is like all pseudo-medicines: it only appears effective in flawed
studies. As the methodologies improve, the efficacy fades until well done
studies show no effect greater than placebo, aka no effect.

Acupuncture/TCPM Crapfest

Mark Crislip on November 13, 2015

Link



Look Ma! No gloves!

As I get older I get more grumpy. Issues that at one time I was rather sanguine 
about, now irritate the hell out of me. It is not like it was when I started
practice. Information was hard to come by. Going through the Index Medicus, with
the world’s tiniest font, wandering the stacks looking for papers, sending off 
for reprints, getting a precious Xerox (or even a mimeograph) of a classic paper
from an attending.

You understood the value of eminence-based medicine, as it took a career to
acquire and master the literature. You relied on the wisdom of old geezers like 
me who had decades of experience and reading.

That was then. Now? The world’s information is available almost instantaneously.
You may not be able to master a new topic spending a day on Google and Pubmed, 
but you can acquire a reasonable understanding, especially of you have some
background.

Because of Google and Pubmed, the only reasons for ignorance of your area of
expertise in medicine are time, laziness, or stupidity. As a specialist, only
time is an excuse. It is my job to keep up with infectious diseases, although
with over 10,000 articles a year in ID, it is impossible to read everything. But
if I have a question concerning patient care, I need to look it up. I have
another blog whose raison d’être is looking up answers to the daily questions
that arise in practice.

On the characteristics of a useful clinical trial

So the characteristics of a useful clinical trial are not hard to determine:
Randomized, double blind, placebo controlled, adequately powered. Because you
want to avoid spending time and money on a study only to end up with no useful
conclusions. This is especially important with acupuncture where it not does
matter what kind of acupuncture is used, if needles are used, where the needles 
are placed or even if you mime acupuncture or perform acupuncture on a rubber
hand. The key features for success in acupuncture are belief that the patient is
receiving acupuncture and that the patient believes the acupuncture will be
effective. And the stronger the belief, the better the subjective response.

Those characteristics of acupuncture and clinical trials are not hard to
discover. It you want a rigorous study of acupuncture, it has to be placebo
controlled, double blind and you need to assess both the belief in acupuncture
and the adequacy of blinding.

They never do that. Probably because deep in their heart of hearts they know
that quality studies will not support their particular SCAM. The current
buzzword is pragmatic, which the OED defines as ‘not wishing to do a quality
study that will not support my pseudo-scientific belief.’

There have been a gaggle of bad acupuncture studies the last few months, well,
few years, well few decades. It is apparent that those who do acupuncture
research have zero interest in doing a quality study. Let’s look at a few.
Prepare for an acupuncture crapfest.

Acupuncture is theatrical placebo. Specifically Peter Pan.

Acupuncture, as has mentioned so many times, is a theatrical placebo. But what
theatrical performance? I tend towards tragedy, mostly Macbeth:

   It is a taleTold by an acupuncturist, full of sound and fury,Signifying
   nothing.

But perhaps I should consider Peter Pan as a more apt metaphor.

Remember when Tinker Bell had chronic wing pain and was getting acupuncture and 
it didn’t appear to be effective? And Peter turns to the audience:

   “Do you believe in acupuncture? … If you believe,” Peter shouted, “clap your 
   hands; don’t let Tink hurt.”

And Tink’s pain went away for a while? You don’t? I do.

There is a Tinker Bell effect, where:

   things that are thought to exist only because people believe in them.

That describes the effect of acupuncture perfectly. There are multiple studies
that have demonstrated that patients who believe in the efficacy of acupuncture 
are those most likely to have an effect and the stronger the belief, the
stronger the effect. And that the placebo effect is significant:

   When compared to waitlist, standard care, or no treatment, the effect size of
   acupuncture is moderate, around 0.50, meaning that a large part of the
   acupuncture effect is due to placebo elements.

There is now another study to show the theater that is acupuncture is Peter Pan:
“Response to placebo acupuncture in insomnia: a secondary analysis of three
randomized controlled trials.”

The study:

   conducted a post-hoc analysis of three randomized, double- blind,
   placebo-controlled trials of acupuncture for primary insomnia and residual
   insomnia in depressed patients. The aim of the exploratory analysis is to
   determine patient characteristics that are predictive of a response to
   noninvasive placebo acupuncture for insomnia.

And it was the belief in acupuncture that was important in responding to placebo
acupuncture:

   higher expectation toward acupuncture were associated with greater placebo
   response.

Belief is why it doesn’t matter where the needles are placed, if the needles are
placebo, if toothpicks are used, if acupuncture is mimed, or if acupuncture is 
done on a rubber hand. The effects are the same as long as you believe you are
getting acupuncture and you believe it will work.

It is also why any acupuncture study is a waste of time if it does not include a
sham/placebo intervention, reporting if blinding was successful, and reporting 
of the beliefs of the patients in the intervention.

Otherwise you will not know why Tink got better.

The ongoing decline of quality in the Annals of Internal Medicine

Not like the Annals is paying any attention. As an example there is “Alexander
Technique Lessons or Acupuncture Sessions for Persons With Chronic Neck Pain: A 
Randomized Trial.”

Patients with chronic neck pain were randomized to:

   12 acupuncture sessions or 20 one-to-one Alexander lessons (both 600 minutes 
   total) plus usual care versus usual care alone.

Sham comparison for acupuncture? Nope. Belief in the interventions determined?
Nope. So you would expect patients to get better with the intervention when
compared to usual care. That is what ALWAYS occurs. Spend extra time (in this
case an extra 10 hours) and energy with a patient with a subjective problem and 
you would expect them to report improvement, compared to usual care.

And given that the authors are members of the British Acupuncture Society, the
results are obviously part of the Big Acupuncture conspiracy. Or potentially
subject to significant bias. Go to Midas, get a muffler.

And so much for holistic care. Neck pain is a symptom of some underling process;
we have no idea what these patients had. It was like a study that evaluated
antibiotic for fever.

And what kind of acupuncture? The methods state:

   Acupuncture practice was based on traditional Chinese medical theory,
   encompassing acupuncture-specific diagnostic explanations and related
   lifestyle advice.

That is quite a nonspecific intervention. You need to look in the table in the
appendix, the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with
a sign on the door saying beware of the leopard of medical papers, where you
find they used between 5 and 35 needles per session (average of 14) with 259
acupuncture points used that were left in between 1 and 60 minutes (average of
20).

AND

They could use moxibustion, electroacupuncture, ear seeds, cupping, acupressure,
and heat lamps.

AND

Give advice relating to exercise, relation, diet and rest.

And you say it was acupuncture that led to improvement? Really? Color me
skeptical. This is what passes for peer review these days at the Annals. Peer
review with peer as in ‘to look at’. I imagine an old person, peering over the
top of their glasses, saying “that ‘peers to be an acupuncture paper. Let’s
publish it.” Or, in this case, publishit ( ™,©,®), my new neologism for the
production of SCAM papers. Email me for volume discounts.

So the results of the study are what we would expect and consistent with every
acupuncture study that does not control for bias. It is, like all such studies, 
a waste of time and resources.

The summary for patients says:

   Both acupuncture and Alexander Technique lessons may provide long-term relief
   from chronic neck pain and associated disability.

I have come to the conclusion that when it comes to SCAM papers, those who
review them never really read them with anything that approaches a critical eye.

Dr. Edzard Ernst said in response to this article:

   I am truly surprised that a top journal like the Annals of Internal Medicine 
   decided to publish it.

Sorry, I must disagree. As a practicing Internist I have to say that the Annals 
has been slipping for years, with a long history of publishing gullible studies 
on pseudo-medicine. So much so they have lost at least one ‘n’ in my mind.

Non-falsifiable

It has often been noted that pseudo-medicines are immune to data. Practices are 
never abandoned or changed because of information that suggests a lack of safety
or efficacy.

Pseudo-medicines, as a recent US News article suggests, do not really require
data to support them, which is good for its proponents, since such data does not
exist. They can be satisfied with anecdote, knowing that it works.

However, when a study is done that fails to show efficacy of a pseudo-medicine
such as acupuncture, it is always interesting to watch the authors squirm and
try and rationalize their negative results.

No one has ever said after a negative study ‘looks like acupuncture is useless
for this condition. Stop using it’. That would require a bit of honesty about
what is probably a wasted career in acupuncture.

As two recent examples, there is “Short-Term Effect of Laser Acupuncture on
Lower Back Pain: A Randomized, Placebo-Controlled, Double-Blind Trial“.

In reality-based medicine, there is no reason to think laser acupuncture would
do anything. And it doesn’t. When compared to sham laser acupuncture,

   …there was no significant difference in outcomes between the two groups…

When an intervention is equal to placebo, in reality-based medicine we conclude 
that it has no efficacy. It is why, as an example, we abandoned internal mammary
ligation for angina.

But in the non-falsifiable world of pseudo-medicine?

   …the results suggest that laser acupuncture can provide effective pain
   alleviation and can be considered an option for relief from lower back pain…

Or take No Effect of Acupuncture in the Relief of Delayed-Onset Muscle Soreness:
Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial. People received needle, laser, sham
needle, sham laser acupuncture, and no intervention after exercise to see if
there was efficacy in treating muscle soreness.

Nope. Didn’t work. And why would it? The authors suggest:

   From a mechanistic point of view, these results have implications for further
   studies…the traditional acupuncture regimen, targeting muscle pain, might
   have been inappropriate as the DOMS mechanisms seem limited to the muscular
   unit and its innervation.

Or maybe acupuncture does nothing and is inappropriate for any intervention.

And as always, negative studies mean bigger, better studies need to be done:

   Further studies using long-term intervention, a larger sample size, and
   rigorous methodology are required to clarify the effect of laser acupuncture 
   on lower back pain.

Almost 50 years of clinical trials and still more studies need to be done. Only 
in the world of pseudo-medicine are the results of yet another negative study
used as indication for further studies.

No acupuncture on infants and children for China

If you have been a parent you probably remember just how vulnerable newborns and
young children are. I remain amazed we survived as a species before the advent 
of civilization; crying babies at night must have been the signal for
all-you-can-eat for predators on the veldt.

Acupuncture has long been popular in China but there are differences between its
practice in the West and East, as “‘Big needles, small bodies’—the absence of
acupuncture treatment for infants in contemporary Shanghai: a qualitative” study
makes clear.

At the Longhau Hospital acupuncture clinic it was noted that no infants and very
few children were seen in the acupuncture clinic. They wondered why,
conducting:

   Formal interviews and informal conversations with acupuncturists and other
   TCM professionals [which] revealed that acupuncture was neither routinely
   practiced nor recommended for infants and small children.

There were a variety of reasons for the lack of acupuncture in kids:

  1. ‘Nobody does paediatric acupuncture’. Lack of experience.

  2. ‘Not convenient’. Lack of recommendations.

  3. ‘No classic, no modern’. Lack of textbooks and training.

  4. ‘For now, zero’. The lack of a strong research base.

  5. ‘Of course it is painful’. The possibility of pain.

  6. ‘Eighty percent of acupuncture on children is CP or other neurology’.
    Indications for acupuncture. “Acupuncturists and other TCM clinicians
    expressed the clear opinion that needle acupuncture was indicated for very
    few paediatric conditions in general.”

  7. ‘TCM paediatrics is herbs’. The availability of TCM alternatives: Herbal
    medicine and Tui na.

  8. ‘The whole TCM world is shrinking in China, or at least in Shanghai’. The
    money and the system.

  9. It is a vicious cycle’. The slipping confidence.

And most interesting:

  1. ‘Now parents take children to the Western Children Hospitals’. Trust in
    Western paediatrics. “The vast majority of paediatric cases in Shanghai,
    particularly infants and toddlers, are treated at these hospitals. These
    hospitals provide treatment for a range of illnesses, from minor ailments to
    chronic or life-threatening conditions. Western medical hospitals are
    widely regarded as the first choice by Shanghainese parents seeking
    assessment, consultation and treatment for their children.”

When it comes to their children, parents in Shanghai appear know that
science-based, or Western as they call it, medicine, delivers. This,
unfortunately, is not always recognized by parents in the US.

And, as they note, not only is acupuncture not used in children, its use in the 
West is not based on either data or tradition in China:

   This study adds to the ongoing discussion on the evidence, utility and
   limitations of acupuncture in children, as well as in medicine in general.
   Contrary to our observations in Shanghai, acupuncturists in the Western world
   encourage acupuncture for children, including infants. One rationale
   underpinning this trend is that acupuncture is widely considered in the West 
   to be an integral part of TCM tradition, for patients of all ages. According 
   to our study, Western beliefs that acupuncture is routinely indicated and
   recommended for infants and small children within TCM are unfounded. Such
   beliefs may appear to be a Western interpretation, and are not based on
   actual Chinese modern-day practices or therapeutic recommendations. Recent
   controlled trials investigating the efficacy of acupuncture treatment in the 
   infant population yield conflicting results, and little clear empirical
   evidence is available to support the use of acupuncture. As such, it appears 
   that the rise of infant acupuncture in the West could be partly attributable 
   to Western acupuncturists’ own clinical observations and theoretical beliefs.
   In line with the principles of biomedical ethics, however, this study
   underscores that this rationale is insufficient to recommend a potentially
   painful treatment for infants and small children who lack the competence to
   provide informed consent.

No data for efficacy, no rationale within the context of TCM, potentially
harmful, and unethical. That sums up acupuncture in children for China. Now if
only doctors in the US would pay attention. For example…

When IRBs fail, babies suffer

I have been practicing medicine for 30 years. I spent most of my time in acute
care hospitals, so I am well acquainted with the many ways people can suffer.
Being 58, I have also had my share of medical problems that have caused a
reasonable amount of pain and suffering.

As a result I have a list of processes that I do not want to experience. At the 
top of the list are kidney stones, followed by a disk infection. Another disease
on the list is opiate withdrawal. I always have a heroin addict or two under my
care with one infection or another from injection drug use and going cold
turkey looks really miserable. The worst I am likely to experience is caffeine
withdrawal.

There are children who are born to addicted mothers and after birth will go
through withdrawal unless treated. Poor little things, their first experiences
in life the misery of withdrawal and they are unable to really ask for help.

There is a horrible, unconvincing literature on using ear acupuncture for
withdrawal in adults; the literature for children is even worse:

   This study, a painfully unnecessary attempt to determine the feasibility and 
   efficacy of acupuncture in neonatal and pediatric intensive care unit
   patients at risk of withdrawal, was a complete waste of time. You cannot
   determine efficacy at all based on it and the question of feasibility was
   answered a long time ago. This study added nothing to our understanding of
   withdrawal or even of acupuncture.

   Considering the reams of research showing that there are no benefits
   associated with the insertion of needles into, or pressing on, particular
   points on the body beyond placebo, it never should have happened.

The preponderance of the literature suggests that acupuncture is a theatrical
placebo and that it is belief in acupuncture that is the main predictor of a
response. Newborns, of course, can’t have a belief in the efficacy of
acupuncture nor can they complain if they are suffering. So why would you try
acupuncture on babies with withdrawal? Or laser acupuncture? Every time I see
the phrase laser acupuncture, I think really? You think that laser acupuncture
will do something? It just so flabbers my gaster than anyone with even a modicum
of understanding thinks laser acupuncture would be effective.

It didn’t stop “Laser Acupuncture for Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome: A Randomized
Controlled Trial.”

So here is the reasoning: ear acupuncture may help withdrawal in adults so we
will use laser acupuncture on 5 ear and 4 body acupuncture points, bilaterally
on babies. All men die. Socrates was a man. All dead men are Socrates.

Why, oh why, would anyone would who lives in reality would think that shining a 
red light on the skin would do anything for drug withdrawal? I wouldn’t. And the
reason the authors think it would help?

There isn’t any. None. They best they can offer is that it would be safe. That
is the level of reasoning behind the study. And the editors of Pediatrics
accepted it as reasonable. More ‘peer’ review.

But there is zero plausible reason offered by the authors that laser
acupuncture, an intervention even more worthless and implausible than needle
acupuncture, would help babies with addiction symptoms.

It did not stop the Ethics Committee of the Medical University of Graz from
approving it.

So children in withdrawal were assigned to laser acupuncture or control.

There was no blinding or sham procedure, except that the whole study was a sham 
in the more conventional use of the word.

The kids who received laser acupuncture had fewer drug treatment days although
they had the same Finnegan score, an objective and subjective measurement of
withdrawal symptoms in children.

So I read the study as newborns with equal amounts of withdrawal symptoms and
suffering had less medication for their withdrawal as the staff thought they
were being treated with the laser acupuncture. The laser-treated kids were
simply detoxed faster than their nonlaser controls. And probably suffered more. 
My wife, who worked for years in addictions, thinks it is a reasonable
explanation that the laser-treated were detoxed more rapidly.

Every time I read a pediatric acupuncture study I realize just how broken the
IRB system is when it comes to protecting vulnerable populations from being
abused by pseudo-medical providers.

Children and mice do not have a chance

There are 385 hits searching the PubMed for ‘acupuncture mice’. Assume 40 mice
per study. I would wager that is a marked underestimate that does not include
all the mice used in establishing models and failed studies.

I am not a PETA person but that is 15,400 mice essentially being abused trying
to prove TCPM (Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine) is effective.

Guidelines for ethical animal research state:

   …there should be a reasonable expectation that the research will:

   …Provide results that benefit the health or welfare of humans or other
   animals.

   …The scientific purpose of the research should be of sufficient potential
   significance to justify the use of nonhuman animals.

Given that in humans acupuncture is a theatrical placebo based on concepts
divorced from reality, I would say that any acupuncture research in animals is
unethical.

The animal welfare committees do not seem to be doing their job at numerous
facilities.

But then, why would you expect ethical treatment of animals when we can’t even
protect our own newborns from jaw-droppingly stupid studies?

Take “Laser acupuncture before heel lancing for pain management in healthy term 
newborns: a randomised controlled trial.”

Neonatologists.

From the Baskent University in Turkey.

Academic physicians actually thinking that:

   Acupuncture is a new non-pharmacological method for preventing pain in
   newborns

But not just acupuncture, laser acupuncture.

A laser:

   was applied to the Yintang point using a Laser PREMIO–30 unit for 30 s

The Yintang point is:

   Midway between the medial ends of the eyebrows

Yes.

They actually thought that shooting a child between the eyes with a low level
laser (at least the laser does have wobulation) would help decrease the pain
from a needle stick.

Surprise. Low level lasers and acupuncture, two interventions totally divorced
from reality was judged:

   less effective than oral sucrose for reducing the discomfort of this
   procedure.

Who would have thought? I mean besides anyone with even the barest understanding
of medicine, physiology, and physics? Certainly not those whose responsibility 
it was to review the research.

This nonsense was approved by an Institutional Review Board whose ostensible
task is to look out for the wellbeing of research subjects. I suppose IRB should
now stand for Ineffective Review Board? Incompetent Review Board? Inadequate
Review Board?

Mice and children. They don’t have a chance of being protected from the
investigation of magical pseudo-medicine.

BS (blood stasis) syndrome

I receive a lot of push notifications from Google and Pubmed covering a variety 
of pseudo-medical topics.

There is a phenomenal amount of research coming out of China that I would
perhaps classify as basic pseudo-science, not unlike the basic science of
reality-based medicine.

What they do is apply modern techniques and measurements to Traditional Chinese 
Pseudo-Medicine, TCPM, trying to validate their ancient pseudo-science. I am
sure the recent Nobel Prize will only lead to further encouragement of this
process. Like blood stagnation.

Today I saw in one of my patient’s chart the diagnosis qi deficiency and blood
stagnation as a reason for acupuncture. Don’t get me started. It was so very
dispiriting to see ancient nonsense in an EMR as if it were actually meaningful.
I knew that it was really a problem with too much phlegm and the patient needed
to be bled with leeches, but would they listen to me? No.

At least qi and blood stagnation don’t have ICD codes, even if acupuncture does.

The theory of TCPM, including qi and meridians, with diagnosis based on tongue
and pulse evaluation, was developed without the benefit of understanding
anatomy, physiology, microbiology etc, the basic sciences that are the
foundations of medicine. Because of that TCPM is not grounded in reality and
this results in a most peculiar literature such as “Practical Diagnostic
Criterion of Blood Stasis Syndrome: Introduction, Reliability, and Validity.”

What, you may ask, is BS? I mean blood stagnation? The other question is way too
open ended when directed at TCPM.

My first hit on Google says:

   Simply put, it means the flow of Blood is slowed down and brought to a static
   state.

We call that a clot in medicine.

   Normally, Blood is stored in the Liver

What?

   and propelled by the Heart Qi to flow through the body.

And here I thought it was the ventricular contractions of the heart.

   If Blood circulation is Stagnant or slowed down by certain factors, it will
   lead to retention of Blood in any part of the body or overflow of blood out
   of the vessels, resulting in Blood Stasis.

Huh? There are nouns and verbs and all the other parts of grammar but there no
content that maps to reality. As another author writes:

   Note for students: “The Liver stores Blood … when a person moves, Blood goes 
   to the channels, when at rest it goes to the Liver.” (Maciocia, Foundations, 
   p. 78) When you’re asleep or resting, the Blood collects and is stored in the
   Liver. When you’re active, the Blood is sent out to nourish and moisten the 
   muscles.

Students of what I do not know (gibberish?), but I would hope they are not
involved with patient care. I don’t think they are speaking metaphorically,
which is really sad and nicely demonstrates how removed from reality the BS in
TCPM is.

In TCPM, BS is bad:

   If blood stasis occurs within the body, known as “blood stasis syndrome
   (BSS),” characteristic symptoms such as pain in a fixed position, nyctalgia, 
   dark-purple coloring of the tongue or face, infraorbital darkness, sublingual
   varicosis, blood spots under the skin or tongue, or an astringent pulse can 
   manifest. In clinical practice, many diseases include these signs and
   symptoms, such as ischemic heart disease, cerebral vascular accident,
   diabetes mellitus, chronic gastritis, chronic renal failure, chronic
   hepatitis, trauma, and dysmenorrhea

Almost total nonsense. The manifestation of blood stasis are numerous. BS can
involve any organ. Just check out this diagram.

BS is disease as metaphor, although practitioners of BS do not think so although
even its practitioners evidently do not know what BS is:

   Of the 678 respondents, more than half (53%) had difficulties with the
   diagnosis of BSS because objective measurement methods were not readily
   available. Most respondents (88%) thought that the development of an
   objective diagnostic method for BSS was necessary.

Many researchers are trying to shoehorn BS into vascular diseases such as angina
and lipid disorders.

It is too bad that I only have access to the abstracts as the original are in
Chinese, because I really want to know more about phlegm-stasis cementation
syndrome in mini-swine. Who knew that:

   The interaction of phlegm, blood stasis and toxin syndromes helps promote the
   progress and development of AS plaques, which is the key pathogenesis of
   phlegm-stasis cementation syndrome in coronary heart disease.

Like so much of the TCPM research, time and money is being devoted to validate
with modernity BS concepts that are fundamentally grounded in fantasy.

Tongue acupuncture reigns supreme

There are innumerable forms of acupuncture, perhaps as many as there are
practitioners. Which acupuncture is best? Now there is a hint in the treatment
of post-stroke dysphagia.

   The patients were assigned into 2 groups: 90 in the Tongue acupuncture group 
   received tongue acupuncture on the basis of conventional medication, 90 in
   the conventional acupuncture group received acupuncture on the neck and
   wrist.

And tongue is better!

   On the basis of the conventional medication, tongue acupuncture would
   effectively improve the swallow functions, decrease the neurological deficit 
   and reduce the incidence of pneumonia in patients with post-stroke dysphagia.

Which one would expect as:

   Traditional Chinese medicine holds: post-stroke dysphagia is pathogenesis of 
   blocking meridians by the wind, fire, phlegm, blood stasis. Diseases in brain
   are related to the spleen, kidney and the heart. Tongue is closely related
   to zang-fu organs through the channels and collaterals directly or
   indirectly… By needling tongue, the heart, spleen, kidney meridian awake
   brain, dredge the bullishness and finally improve the swallowing functions.

Dredge the bullishess. They are dredging up something with acupuncture studies. 
It isn’t bullishess. Close though. I think that was a slight misspelling during 
translation.

Acupuncture Vignettes

Mark Crislip on March 7, 2014

Link


I seem to be writing a lot about acupuncture of late. As perhaps the most
popular pseudo-medicine, there seems to be more published on the topic. I have a
lot of internet searches set up to automatically feed me new information on
various SCAMs. Interestingly, all the chiropractic updates seem to be published 
on chiropractic economics sites, not from scientific sources. Go figure.

Here is a hodgepodge of articles, mostly from the scientific literature, I have 
read concerning acupuncture and TCM.

Tooth Fairy science and the constitution

Harriet Hall coined the term “Tooth Fairy science” which is:

   to doing research on a phenomenon before establishing that the phenomenon
   exists…You could measure how much money the Tooth Fairy leaves under the
   pillow, whether she leaves more cash for the first or last tooth, whether the
   payoff is greater if you leave the tooth in a plastic baggie versus wrapped 
   in Kleenex. You can get all kinds of good data that is reproducible and
   statistically significant. Yes, you have learned something. But you haven’t
   learned what you think you’ve learned, because you haven’t bothered to
   establish whether the Tooth Fairy really exists.

The concept encompasses most of pseudo-medicine. Much of traditional Chinese
medicine is based on concepts divorced from anatomy and physiology and are
perfect for Tooth Fairy science.

An example comes from the introduction of “The Association between
Yang-Deficient Constitution and Clinical Outcome of Highly Active Antiretroviral
Therapy on People Living with HIV.”

Before you read further, spit take warning. If you are drinking, swallow, so
liquid does not squirt out your nose and onto the computer.

   …more evidence is emerging that much of the wisdom of traditional medicine
   can in fact be explained at genomics level (Joshi et al. and the references
   therein). Recently, HLA class II polymorphisms were found associated with the
   physiologic characteristics defined by Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM).
   In TCM, constitution is believed to be a distinct characteristic of an
   individual. Constitution has been used to guide disease prevention, health
   care, and medical practice. Yang-Deficient Constitution is one of the major
   constitutions, which is characterized by chills, cold limbs, and also
   spontaneous sweating; loose tools [sic] and/or profuse clear urine; and
   lassitude.

So they decided to:

   …systematically investigate whether there is any association between
   Yang-Deficient Constitution and complications incurred from HIV infection and
   design evidence-based treatment, we conducted a prospective observational
   study for evaluating the association between Yang-Deficient Constitution and 
   clinical outcomes.

On a scale of 1 to 5 they asked HIV patients the following questions to see if
they were Yang-Deficient:

  1. Do you feel cold at your limbs?

  2. Are you sensitive to cold at stomach, back, waist, or laps? Are you usually
    sensitive to cold weather and dress more than others?

  3. Are you more sensitive to cold air (such as outside of winter,
    air-conditioning, or electric fan)?

  4. Do you have flu- or cold-like symptoms more frequently or easily than others?

  5. Do you feel uncomfortable or worried for cold water or foods?

  6. Do you have pulpy bowel after having cold water or foods?

I have taken care of AIDS patients since the beginning of the epidemic and I
cannot imagine how those questions could be relevant in any way to HIV, its
treatment and complications.

They then collected a tonne (English measurement, it is that large) of data and 
ran it through the old p-value machine and found some barely significant
results. They concluded:

   Yang-Deficient Constitution score has a potential to be developed as a
   predictor for early HIV-related mortality and side effects. The interrelation
   and underlying mechanisms should be further investigated for evidence-based 
   design of a more appropriate treatment strategy.

They go so far as to suggest it is the mitochondria. Medication toxicity in HIV 
is often due to mitochondrial toxicity. Mitochondria are important for energy.
Yang deficiency syndrome patients have weak or imbalanced energy. Therefore:

   Yang-Deficient Constitution is susceptible to mitochondrial toxicity is worth
   further investigation.

At least quantum effects are not blamed.

I keep going back to Ioannidis and there are at least three reasons, besides
thinking the idea that Yang-Deficient Constitution is valid, that the
conclusions of the study are false:

  1. Corollary 3: The greater the number and the lesser the selection of tested
    relationships in a scientific field, the less likely the research findings
    are to be true.

  2. Corollary 4: The greater the flexibility in designs, definitions, outcomes,
    and analytical models in a scientific field, the less likely the research
    findings are to be true.

  3. Corollary 5: The greater the financial and other interests and prejudices in a
    scientific field, the less likely the research findings are to be true.

I guess they did not read the paper. Few in the pseudo-medical world seem to.
Data mining garbage does not lead to diamonds. Tooth Fairy science at its more
pure. Supported by the Chinese Government and Stanley Ho Centre for Emerging
Infectious Diseases. Good money thrown away.

“Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair!”Nothing beside remains. Round the
decayOf that colossal wreck, boundless and bareThe lone and level sands stretch 
far away.

Acupuncture beer goggles

I most studies, sham acupuncture is no better than real acupuncture for the
relief of pain. The usual interpretation is that if an intervention is no
different than a placebo, the intervention does not work. But there is always
the issue that sham and real are better at relieving pain than doing nothing.
So, goes the thinking, the efficacy of acupuncture comes from the power of
placebo.

I have always referred to pseudo-medical therapies as beer goggles: they do not 
change reality, just the perception of reality. Changing perception of disease
is an important result of an interaction with the patient. I attempt it all the 
time, although unlike pseudo-medical practitioners, I try do it truthfully.

Little did I realize there is a medical term for beer goggles: tactile
discrimination training. It is when:

   …stimulation of some form is applied to the painful area and the patient is
   asked to decide on the locality or type of stimulation, an approach that has 
   been shown to be effective in the management of certain chronic pain
   problems.

In this study they decided to compare acupuncture to acupuncture used as tactile
discrimination training in chronic low back pain. The protocol was:

   After locating the points, the 14 needles were inserted. We used 15 mm
   needles fully inserted to ensure that the depth of needling was the same
   across conditions. In the experimental condition, participants participated
   in a sensory discrimination training task similar to that described by
   Moseley et al.19 A picture of a back with the position of each needle
   numbered (see figure 1) was positioned so that it could be comfortably viewed
   by the participant. The clinician then rotated a single needle in accordance
   with a random number sequence and the participant was required to nominate
   which needle was being stimulated, if the participant committed an error,
   they were told which point had in fact been stimulated. Each needle was
   stimulated for 3 s with a 10-s interval between each stimulus. This task was 
   performed with visualization of the back via a mirror in the first 10 min and
   progressed to no visualisation in the last 10 min. In the control condition,
   participants were asked to lay comfortably and relaxed and to not attend to 
   the needles. During the 20 min control condition the therapist manipulated
   needles at the same rate and using the same random sequence as they did in
   the experimental condition.

Of note, both were done by the same person, an acupuncturist. The only
difference between the acupuncture and the tactile discrimination was:

   participants responded to each needle manipulation by trying to localize the 
   position of the needle that was being manipulated.

And the tactile discrimination acupuncture outperformed acupuncture for pain
reduction.

This helps explain why sham and real acupuncture have the same effect, why
acupuncture does not depend in where the needles are placed or even if needles
are used. It is a form of tactile discrimination training, aka beer goggles.
Perception is altered, not underlying pathology.

Blind men and the elephant in the room

There was a recent PLOS article, “Decreased Risk of Stroke in Patients with
Traumatic Brain Injury Receiving Acupuncture Treatment: A Population-Based
Retrospective Cohort Study.”

It was a:

   a retrospective cohort study of 7409 TBI patients receiving acupuncture
   treatment and 29,636 propensity-score-matched TBI patients without
   acupuncture treatment in 2000–2008 as controls.

And it found that:

   TBI patients with acupuncture treatment (4.9 per 1000 person-years) had a
   lower incidence of stroke compared with those without acupuncture treatment
   (7.5 per 1000 person-years), with a HR of 0.59 (95% CI = 0.50–0.69) after
   adjustment for sociodemographics, coexisting medical conditions and
   medications.

Interesting result. Why did they do the study? Well, in Taiwan acupuncture is a 
common treatment and no one had ever looked to see if it could prevent a stroke.
It is a tough job, but someone had to do it.

Retrospective studies are always interesting, but not definitive, since there
may be differences between the treatment and controls that would be potentially 
avoided in a prospective randomized trial. So were there differences in the two 
groups? Yep.

The acupuncture group was more likely to be on anti-coagulants, (p= 0.0003),
antiplatelet drugs (p To properly evaluate whether acupuncture treatment is
associated with reduced stroke risk in TBI patients, we used propensity score to
match the difference of age, sex, low income, and density of TCM physicians,
mental disorders, hypertension, diabetes, ischemia heart disease,
hyperlipidemia, migraine and epilepsy between TBI patients with and without
acupuncture treatment. To accurately estimate risk of stroke after TBI for
patients with and without acupuncture treatment, residual confounding effects
were adjusted in the multivariable Cox proportional hazard models.Seems so.

They had 2 possible explanations for the effects of acupuncture. The first was
that acupuncture had biologic effects. I would bet against it. There is no
plausible reason acupuncture could prevent stoke. The other was that patients in
the acupuncture group had better care.

   …patients with TBI who choose acupuncture treatment may have better
   knowledge, attitudes and practices regarding physical rehabilitation and
   disease prevention, which we believe could also contribute to reduce
   new-onset stroke event after TBI.

Given that the acupuncture patients were more likely to be on a medical therapy 
that prevents strokes, that is a more likely answer.

It wasn’t the acupuncture, it was the medications.

When I first read this article and looked at the table that demonstrated the
marked difference in medications in the two groups, I could not believe it. I
read it over and over, thinking “no, that couldn’t be.” I could not understand
how anyone could be blind to what would appear to be a simple explanation of the
difference between the two groups. The most impressive example of confirmation 
bias I have ever seen.

Electroacupuncture is not acupuncture

“When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, ’it means
just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.”“The question is,” said
Alice, “whether you can make words mean so many different things.”“The question 
is,” said Humpty Dumpty, “which is to be master— that’s all.”

In my feeds I kept seeing variations of the theme: acupuncture treats sepsis. As
an infectious disease doc it tweaked my interest since sepsis (a particularly
severe manifestation of infection) is a disease that I routinely treat and
routinely kills.

So what was this amazing study? “Dopamine mediates vagal modulation of the
immune system by electroacupuncture.”

First, it was in mice.

Second, the reasoning was as follows. Many of the symptoms of sepsis are due to 
inflammation medicated by cytokines. Stimulating the vagus nerve decreases the
inflammatory response in a variety of other diseases. It is hard to stimulate
the vagus nerve directly since it is deep in the neck and check. So

   We hypothesized that electroacupuncture can be an alternative strategy for
   vagal stimulation.

The key word is electroacupuncture.

Recently they excavated a 2000 year old tomb in China, and what they found was, 
in a word, incredible. First was a set of acupuncture needles. But more amazing 
was a set of dead AA batteries in a mechanical dragon that evidently rolled
across the floor while playing cymbals. It strongly suggests that the ancient
Chinese used electroacupuncture.

So they stuck a needle in the ST36 Zusanli point of mice. Which is in the leg,
below the knee. Who knew that mice and humans had the same meridians and
acupoints? Then they cranked in some voltage and measured various cytokines and 
other inflammatory mediators under various conditions to see what happens. The
results were interesting. The electroacupuncture-treated mice had decreased
mortality by an:

   …anti-inflammatory mechanism mediated by the sciatic and vagus nerves that
   modulates the production of catecholamines in the adrenal glands.

But here are some key discoveries from the paper:

   The anti-inflammatory effects of electroacupuncture are voltage dependent.

And:

   Direct electrical stimulation of the vagus nerve mimicked the production of
   dopamine and norepinephrine induced by electroacupuncture.

And:

   …direct electrical stimulation of the sciatic nerve mimicked the
   anti-inflammatory effects of electroacupuncture (Fig. 1f) in a
   voltage-dependent manner.

They did not use a random peripheral site to apply the voltage or another
acupuncture point as a control. As best I can tell, the study actually had
nothing to do with acupuncture. What they demonstrated was electrical
stimulation of peripheral nerves or the vagus nerve had anti-inflammatory
effects. The use of the specific acupuncture point was, well, pointless.

This is the kind of study that drives me nuts. You could remove all the
references to acupuncture and the results would be just as applicable. I suppose
it would then lack the sexiness that acupuncture adds. Without acupuncture as a
hook, I wonder if it would have been published in Nature Medicine or get the
notice it did.

And, while interesting, given all the monitors on a patient in the ICU with
sepsis, I can’t see any clinical utility until some clever researcher figures
out a way to give the electricity without messing up the EKG etc.

Acupuncture and erectile dysfunction

Harvard Medical School has Harvard Health Publications. Their Editor-in-Chief,
Dr. Anthony Koraroff has a column called Ask Doctor. K. In the recent issues
they ask him, “Is acupuncture an effective treatment for erectile dysfunction?” 
Dr. K’s response suggests that being from Harvard is not a preventative for
getting almost everything about acupuncture wrong.

   One non-drug treatment used for ED is acupuncture, the ancient Chinese
   practice in which a practitioner inserts hair-thin needles into specific
   sites along the body’s “meridians.” According to traditional beliefs, the
   body’s Qi (pronounced “chee”), or vital force, flows along these meridians.
   By stimulating specific acupoints, the practitioner aims to restore the
   proper flow of energy in the body.

He fails to mention that this is a pre-scientific concept with zero basis in
reality. There are no meridians or acupoints or any sort of life energy. It is
nonsense. And which acupuncture does he advise as the ‘real acupuncture’:
Chinese, Japanese, Hand, Foot, Tongue, Ear or the German MAPS?

   In treating ED, the acupuncture needles are placed in the wall of the
   abdomen.

Of course they are. I would be more curious why no acupuncture map ever shows
meridians and acupoints in the genitals. You would think the life force would be
in the life-generating organs. I know why. If you are a male making stuff up,
the last thing you would do is stick needles in the genitals. Makes one think it
would be useless for erectile dysfunction.

   Western scientists have a different explanation.

I have always found the phase “western scientist” at best patronizing and at
worst racist, but that is me. There is one science, used by humans all over the 
world, and to judge from output the last decade those “eastern scientists” are
kicking our research butts.

   They speculate that the needles stimulate the release of endorphins, the
   body’s natural painkillers. Other theories claim the needles release
   neurotransmitters, chemicals that carry messages between nerve endings.

Let’s see. You stick needles in someone and twist them and you get a pain
response? And in response to a noxious stimulus neurotransmitters are made?
Who’da thunk it? And water is wet. And how would that have any effect on the
panoply of diseases that acupuncture is supposed to help, from ED to fertility
to herniated discs? Hint. It doesn’t.

   Unfortunately, there just hasn’t been enough good research to determine if
   acupuncture is useful for ED.

Why unfortunately? Given prior plausibility, why waste time and money on a
useless therapy. But he is right. From a recent meta-analysis of acupuncture and
ED:

   Most investigations had methodological flaws, e.g. inadequate study design,
   poor reporting of results, small sample size, and publication without
   appropriate peer review process.

He continues:

   There are more studies of acupuncture as a treatment for chronic pain. Some
   scientists point to studies that compare acupuncture to “sham acupuncture,”
   in which the needles are deliberately not placed properly. Such studies
   sometimes find that both real and sham acupuncture relieve pain. This
   suggests to them that acupuncture may work by causing a placebo effect.

No, this suggests that acupuncture does nothing. If real acupuncture has the
same effects as twirling toothpicks, safe to say it is ineffective. Or would he 
use the same justification for using internal mammary artery ligation for
angina? And if he is suggesting placebo medicine, well, that is usually
considered unethical.

   Whether this is true or not, what matters to patients is that their condition
   has been improved. Some of my patients have had good relief of their pain.

It doesn’t matter that the costly treatment you are suggesting is not based in
reality and has no efficacy? A classic example of why I say the three most
dangerous words in medicine are “in my experience.”

   As for acupuncture to treat erectile dysfunction, if you’d like to give it a 
   try, go ahead. Be sure to seek out an experienced acupuncturist. And remember
   that it can be time-consuming and expensive. But in experienced hands, it is
   safe.

No reason whatsoever in the discussion to suggest it would have any efficacy at 
all, but use it any way despite the cost. And those experienced hands? Yet
another photo without gloves; bare fingers poking around the needle site.
Acupuncture is not safe in any hands experienced or otherwise:

   468 patient safety incidents were identified; 325 met our inclusion criteria 
   for analysis. Adverse events reported include retained needles (31%),
   dizziness (30%), loss of consciousness/unresponsive (19%), falls (4%),
   Bruising or soreness at needle site (2%), Pneumothorax (1%) and other adverse
   reactions (12%). The majority (95%) of the incidents were categorized as low
   or no harm.

And this did not include the numerous reports of infection from the sloppy
infection-prevention technique that defines acupuncture.

Let’s see. No reason it should be effective for ED, no clinical trials to
suggest efficacy, has complications and cost, and in my experience it
occasionally works for pain so try it for ED. I am not impressed with the
advice. Ask Dr. K? Maybe not so much if it concerns acupuncture.

Combinations

Pseudo-medicines combine and recombine in a continual fantastical dance. Pick
any two alternative medicines and someone, somewhere, has combined them into a
unique treatment modality. My favorite is Tong Ren, a voodoo form of
acupuncture.

I had thought, perhaps incorrectly, that no one could come up with a more
ludicrous combination. Perhaps it would be dark energy homeopathy or dark matter
acupuncture. I suppose it is just a matter of time before someone combines some
pseudo-medical modality with the time cube and their nonsense will reign
supreme.

Until then it is more mundane combinations.

There is the idea that as long as you are sticking needles in people you might
as well add other substances to the needle and drag them into the dermis. It is 
called mesotherapy. Like much of pseudo-medicine, the concept doesn’t entail the
concept of germ theory, which is just a theory after all.

There have been 35 reports of odd infections associated with mesotherapy, often 
atypical mycobacteria.

Evidently there is also bee venom acupuncture:

   Bee venom acupuncture is growing in popularity, especially in Korea, and is
   used primarily for pain relief in many kinds of diseases as an alternative
   medical treatment.

And, in a new report, bee venom acupuncture is also associated with odd
infections:

   We report 3 cases of Mycobacterium chelonae infections after bee venom
   acupuncture. All were treated with antibiotics and surgery.

A common organism in the environment and water, Mycobacterium chelonae is not an
uncommon cause of soft tissue infections where simple infection control
interventions are ignored.

The authors finish with inadvertent whimsy:

   Considering the increasing use of bee venom therapy and considerable
   morbidity of NTM infection, prevention efforts of infections are needed
   through strict adherence to infection control principles, including
   sterilization of venom extraction, purification process, injection equipment,
   and environment.

Strict adherence? LOL. I would be happy with gloves.

Acupuncture as gamma-hydroxybutyrate

Interesting headline: 80-Year-Old Man Paralyzes Women with Acupuncture, Molests 
Them.

   Seo is also accused of taking off A’s panties and molesting her after
   paralyzing her with acupuncture needles in the foot, he got access to A after
   promising to treat her uterus. Another victim, a 22-year-old employee, was
   also molested after receiving paralyzing acupuncture from Seo.

As one commentator said:

   I thought paralysis acupuncture was only possible in movies.

You are correct, Sir. There is no way acupuncture could cause paralysis. It
cannot and does not do anything. But what might have happened? I lack
information in this particular case, but I have seen two patients with
hysterical paralysis and hysterical blindness (aka conversion disorder). Neither
had a physiologic cause of their problem but neither could walk or see. I have 
seen patient with melanomas the size of a large button mushroom and another with
an erosive tumor on his abdomen the size of a dinner plate. Both completely
denied anything wrong. It was hard to believe the patients were unaware of the
problem. I have been amazed over the years of what people can do given the right
situations.

  2. I wonder what kind of social expectations allowed the acupuncturists to
    convince his victims that they were paralyzed. Some odd combination of male 
    dominance, conversion disorder and Stockholm syndrome? I don’t know. If
    indeed the event occurred as written. Given the inability of most news
    outlets to be even remotely accurate about pseudo-medicines, I am a touch
    skeptical that the events occurred as reported. It is more interesting, if
    true, about a milieu that allows a predator to use a worthless
    pseudo-medicine as a weapon for abuse.

PNAS Publishes Rank Pseudoscience

The Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences recently published an
article on acupuncture. It’s a highly credulous take that tries to convince the 
reader that acupuncture is more than just a highly theatrical placebo.
Quackademic medicine continues apace.

Steven Novella on April 29, 2026

Link


At SBM we have two basic missions, which are really just different ends of the
same spectrum. We are trying to raise the ceiling of rigorous science in the
practice of medicine. This is a complex topic involving factors such as
statistical methods, preregistering trials, p-hacking, and various forms of
publication bias. At the same time we are trying to raise the floor by
addressing the worse pseudoscience that is trying (successfully, unfortunately) 
to infiltrate medicine. On the former task it feels like we are rowing alongside
others in our field – journal editors, university departments, and
statisticians. But in the latter, tackling pseudoscience, it often feels that
either we are working alone, or many experts who should know better are actively
working against us, and actually supporting pseudoscience in medicine. This is 
due in part to a frustrating double standard in which regular medicine is held
to a high standard, while “alternative” medicine has a standard all its own
(functionally no standard).

The latest example of this disastrous double standard is a PNAS article on
acupuncture. The article is completely gullible, written as if it were a
promotional piece entirely by advocates, without a hint of critical thinking or 
skepticism. It is also internally inconsistent, even incoherent, but does
usefully give the game away for those paying attention, especially with a
background in SBM. The author is Lynne Peeples, a journalist, not a scientist.
This makes sense in that the piece reads like a feature, with a typical
narrative structure, not like an academic review or even opinion.

The piece, after profiling a TCM practitioner, opens with a biased review of the
literature on acupuncture. Peeples makes it seem as if there is a growing
evidence-based that acupuncture actually works, relying heavily on reviews like 
one by Vickers. We have already deconstructed the Vickers review here, showing
why it is biased and does not show acupuncture works. We have also written often
about how negative acupuncture studies are interpreted to make it seem they are
positive. She also ignored other better reviews, such as this 2020 systematic
review of systematic reviews of acupuncture which found: “Evidence from SRs
suggests that there are insufficient high-quality RCTs to judge the efficacy of 
acupuncture for chronic pain associated with various medical conditions.”

David Gorski correctly reinterpreted this from an SBM perspective –
“Inconclusive literature plus no plausible physiologic mechanism for acupuncture
to work equal an ineffective treatment whose effects are nonspecific placebo
effects.” As I have said many times, the null hypothesis of acupuncture is that 
it is nothing but theatrical placebo, and there is insufficient evidence to
reject the null.

Peeples later hits upon a key reason why the evidence for acupuncture is
lacking, but gullibly buys that standard spin of acupuncturists:

“Because sham acupuncture can also trigger genuine analgesic and other
biological pathways, however, it is not a true placebo. Both factors may help
explain some earlier confusing results, according to Nielsen. She authored
another paper in September that argued a failure to account for the very real
effects of sham controls led to widespread underestimation of acupuncture’s
efficacy, noting that funders now prefer comparisons to standard care.”

Here is what is really happening. Those “confusing results” were actually
negative results, verum or true acupuncture works no better than placebo or sham
acupuncture. The more rigorous the study design, the better the blinding, the
smaller any apparent effect, and the best studies are negative. This is a clear 
signal of a null effect, and supports the conclusion that acupuncture is a
theatrical placebo. Sham acupuncture has “genuine” effects, but they are all
placebo effects. That makes it a great placebo, because it controls for all
factors other than the acupuncture itself.

The conclusion is the killer, though – “funders now prefer comparisons to
standard care”. Of course they do – because those studies are usually positive. 
If you are doing an unblinded pain study, it will be positive, because pain is
highly subjective and amenable to placebo effects and non-specific effects.
Unblinded pain studies are basically worthless for determining efficacy. The
fact that acupuncture researchers have moved beyond designing more rigorous
studies (because they are frustratingly negative) to doing unblinded studies is 
extremely telling.

Much of the article is also about possible mechanisms. It is folly, however, to 
speculate about how a treatment works before determining if a treatment works,
but here we are. She recounts the usual nonsense – sticking a needle in the skin
can release endorphins, affect immune function, and even alter brain function. 
I file all this under: “stuff happens”. Of course stuff happens, because you are
actually sticking needles into the skin. There may even be some immediate
counter-irritation type effect. But none of this explains any significant
long-term effect. This is where her article gets incoherent, in the way that
many pseudosciences are. They make individual arguments that do not all hold
together, because they are not describing and actual underlying reality, just a 
made-up narrative.

She describes the clinical evidence but then cites putative mechanisms that do
not explain the alleged clinical effects. She then hand waves about non-pain
applications of acupuncture (asthma, fertility, addiction) and says we will have
to find mechanisms for them. She buys into the false claim that sham
acupuncture is not a good control but misses the implication – what the absence 
of superiority over sham acupuncture shows is that it does not matter where you 
stick the needles, or even if you stick the needles through the skin. This
means, even if you think there is a worthwhile nonspecific effect here (I
don’t), acupuncture points are meaningless. So then why tie a putative mechanism
to specific acupuncture points? Either they matter or they don’t.

She misses the fact that these same reviews she is citing often use different
points in different studies, and that acupuncturists cannot even agree on where 
points are or what they do. It is all tradition and personal choice – exactly as
if acupuncture were a cultural belief rather than an actual reality.

She spends a lot of time touting the facia and interstitium as potential
networks in the body, explaining alleged distant effects of acupuncture. But
there is no evidence to support this, or that they correspond to meridians or
acupuncture points. Again, she unwittingly give away the game – ” “How on earth 
did they understand that a point lateral in the fifth digit of the foot
connected to the eye system?” asks Jeremy Pulsifer, an acupuncturist in New York
City. “Modern science is finally saying, ‘We don’t know how they knew, but
somehow there was an awareness that is far more sophisticated than we’ve ever
given them credit for.’”

The simple answer is – they didn’t. What is more likely, that these ancient
people had incredible anatomically precise (and functionally impossible)
knowledge they could not possibly have had, or that this is all cultural belief?
Since acupuncture points scientifically do not exist, the latter answer is
preferred. She also simultaneously touts auricular acupuncture, a completely
different system based entirely on ear acupoints. How could conflicting systems 
of acupuncture points simultaneously exist and be valid?

She fails to point out that originally acupuncture had 365 acupoints – one for
each day of the year, because acupuncture was essentially astrology. It was
astrology based on superstition, not some mystical hidden incredible anatomical 
knowledge. She also buys into the trope that acupuncture reflects ancient
knowledge, when it is only a century old. The version of acupuncture that we
know was retconned in the early 20th century to become part of a new Traditional
Chinese Medicine, woven together from older traditions that were mutually
hostile. Prior to that acupuncture used large lances and was more like
bloodletting than anything else.

PNAS should be ashamed, and rightly criticized, for publishing such a blatantly 
biased piece promoting pseudoscience.

More credulous nonsense about acupuncture, this time from National Geographic

PNAS recently published credulous nonsense about acupuncture so bad that I
thought it couldn’t be topped. “Hold my beer!” cried National Geographic, as it 
proceeded to top PNAS.

David Gorski on May 11, 2026

Link


A mere couple of weeks ago, our fearless leader and founder, Dr. Steve Novella, 
found an example of a credulous take on acupuncture of the sort that I couldn’t 
recall having seen in years and years, deconstructing it as deftly as usual.
This promotion of acupuncture took the form of an article in the Proceedings of 
the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), and Dr. Novella quite rightly called it
an example of the “disastrous double standard” in which “regular medicine is
held to a high standard, while ‘alternative’ medicine has a standard all its
own,” accurately describing the article as “completely gullible, written as if
it were a promotional piece entirely by advocates, without a hint of critical
thinking or skepticism.” What was particularly disturbing about this article
was, of course, that it was published in the official journal of the National
Academy of Sciences. As a bit of history, I will mention that PNAS was long
problematic, basically the journal into which Academy members tended to dump
work that they had trouble getting published elsewhere, largely because Academy 
members could in the past basically publish almost anything in PNAS, either
themselves or as the Academy member submitting favored work by someone else.
(It’s how two-time Nobel Prize winner Linus Pauling first got his horrible
studies on using vitamin C to treat cancer and the common cold published in the 
1970s.) However, in recent years, PNAS has tightened its editorial standards so 
that members can’t just publish, in essence, anything they want. It appears,
however, that the editors have a ways to go when it comes to not publishing
ridiculously credulous propaganda about “integrative medicine” and traditional
Chinese medicine.

The current example comes not from an academic journal, but from National
Geographic. Written by Daniel Siefert, the article is entitled Scientists are
finally decoding how acupuncture eases pain. (Spoiler alert: No, they aren’t.
Seriously, they aren’t. Certainly no good evidence is cited in this article to
support such a conclusion, other than a clinical trial that, above all, once
again supports the conclusion that acupuncture is a theatrical placebo.) Before 
I proceed, in the name of total transparency, I will point out that from
2006-2017 I regularly blogged for a collective known as ScienceBlogs. (May it
rest in peace.) This is relevant because National Geographic purchased
ScienceBlogs and owned it until its demise in 2017, which meant that I blogged
for NatGeo for six years and collected maybe a few thousand dollars in blogging 
income during the course of that time period. (Honestly, I don’t remember and
don’t feel like looking it up. It was several hundred dollars a year.) There you
have it, my conflict of interest. Make of it what you will. Also, I am aware
that NatGeo has been problematic for several years, since it was acquired by
21st Century Fox in 2015, which was then acquired by The Mouse (Disney) in 2017.
(Yes, NatGeo is owned by Disney, like, seemingly, most media these days.) Also,
in 2023 NatGeo laid off all its staff writers and switched to a freelance-only 
model, ultimately ceasing publishing newsstand editions in 2024. So it’s less of
a surprise that NatGeo would go all-in on promoting acupuncture, but
nonetheless disappointing to those of us “olds” with fond memories of reading
our parents’ issues decades ago.

Now, let’s get to the credulous take on acupuncture.

Acupuncture is science, ma-an!

One of the key (and ubiquitous) claims made in pretty much every piece of
acupuncture propaganda tarted up as a news feature (as in PNAS) or a serious
article for a lay audience (as in NatGeo) is that “Western science” is finally
starting to understand the biochemical and physiological mechanisms that
“explain” how the “ancient wisdom” of acupuncture does the miraculous things
claimed for it. It’s a gambit that I like to describe as saying, “Acupuncture is
science, ma-an!” or “‘Western science’ is finally validating Eastern
mysticism!” And, make no mistake, as I’ve described many times, acupuncture is
based on a prescientific understanding of how the human body works and what
causes disease and other physical symptoms. There is no such thing as “qi,” the 
mystical magical “life force” energy that supposedly magically wends its way
down acupuncture meridians and whose flow is “unblocked” by placing needles
somewhere along said meridians. (How? Who knows? Don’t ask, unbeliever!)

Unsurprisingly, NatGeo follows this script quite slavishly:

A needle prick doesn’t seem like it should quiet severe pain. But in some cases,
it does—easing migraines, dulling pain, even helping patients endure
childbirth. In one randomized trial in emergency settings, acupuncture relieved 
acute pain more quickly and effectively than intravenous morphine, with fewer
side effects.

Acupuncture, a practice rooted in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), has long
occupied a gray zone between medicine and mystery: widely used to treat pain,
yet often dismissed as a placebo.

But advances in imaging and clinical research are shifting that view. Scientists
are uncovering how a needle can trigger a chain reaction inside the body,
activating immune cells, releasing pain-modulating chemicals, and altering brain
activity. What’s emerging is a clearer picture of a measurable, body-wide
response—one that is helping position acupuncture as a low-cost, non-addictive
option in pain management worldwide.

At the risk of being too repetitive of Steve’s points a couple of weeks ago, I
nonetheless find it useful to compare the above passage from NatGeo to a (very) 
similar passage in the PNAS article. It’s almost as though these articles follow
a script:

Although the picture remains incomplete, several lines of research are
elucidating the biological underpinnings of acupuncture. They include the
involvement of endogenous opioids and the role of loose connective
tissue—including fascia, a body-wide network of collagen fibers embedded in an
extracellular matrix rich in hyaluronic acid and other proteins. This tissue
could be the medium that transmits the effects of local needling to distant
systems, echoing the TCM concept of meridians.

By giving ancient ideas a modern scientific footing, recent discoveries are
bolstering Western acceptance and strengthening the case that acupuncture’s
benefits are not just a placebo effect. “Clinical evidence is important,” says
Peter Wayne, director of research for the Osher Center for Integrative Health at
Harvard Medical School and Brigham and Women’s Hospital, in Boston. “But
without plausible mechanisms, community uptake is much slower.”

Western science and technology are also creating opportunities to enhance
acupuncture practice with knowledge from the burgeoning field of bioelectronic
medicine (1). Still, many researchers and practitioners marvel at the
sophistication of the original practice. “How on earth did they understand that 
a point lateral in the fifth digit of the foot connected to the eye system?”
asks Jeremy Pulsifer, an acupuncturist in New York City. “Modern science is
finally saying, ‘We don’t know how they knew, but somehow there was an awareness
that is far more sophisticated than we’ve ever given them credit for.’”

See what I mean about the ubiquitous propaganda narratives that “Acupuncture is 
science, ma-an!” and “‘Western science’ is finally validating Eastern
mysticism!” The PNAS article even marvels at how “sophisticated” the ancient
Chinese were. You’ll note additional narratives, the most prominent of which is 
what I like to call “Meridians are anatomy, ma-an, not bullshit.” (Hint: They’re
bullshit.)

As I read the NatGeo article, one thing that irritated the crap out of me were
all the claims made without any links to the actual studies or articles in which
the study results being cited were reported—with only a handful of exceptions. 
Seriously, when I read the part about how acupuncture in the emergency room
supposedly worked better than morphine for pain, I cringed, because no link was 
provided. I did, however, immediately recognize that Seifert was likely
referring to a 2016 clinical study examining the use of acupuncture in the
emergency room, published in 2016 in The American Journal of Emergency Medicine,
entitled Acupuncture versus intravenous morphine in the management of acute
pain in the emergency department. Having a long history with this subject is
definitely useful, because I also remembered that I had deconstructed that
article in depth soon after it was published, which is why I will not go into
detail here other than to point out that there were a lot of problems with the
study that led me to conclude that it did not even come close to showing what
its conclusions claimed that the data showed. (It’s also possible that Seifert
was referring to a different “emergency acupuncture” study that I deconstructed 
in 2017, but I doubt it, not that it isn’t worth clicking on the link to my old 
post and enjoying my amusing riffing on one of my favorite 1970s TV shows that I
loved when I was a teenager, Emergency! In any case, the claim that acupuncture
is better than morphine for pain relief is just another way in which purveyors 
of unscientific “integrative” medicine see the opioid crisis as an opportunity
to peddle their pseudoscience.

As for migraines, Dr Novella, neurologist that he is, has written a number of
times about how acupuncture doesn’t work for migraines, dating back at least to 
2012. As for easing “chronic pain,” apparently the best reference Seifert could 
come up with was a KFF article on Ukrainian volunteer acupuncturists working to 
help rehabilitate veterans of that country’s war with Russia (there’s no good
evidence that acupuncture relieves chronic pain), while the evidence that
acupuncture can ease the pain from childbirth is a press release from the
University of California-Irvine, which, as you might recall, is deep into
“integrative medicine” nonsense, thanks to $200 million in funding from the
wealthy homeopathy-loving couple, Susan and Henry Samueli, turning UCI into a
wretched hive of scum and quackademic medicine.

Next up, following the script, are the supposed “findings” that “prove” that
there’s something to acupuncture and that it’s science ma-an, starting with the 
“ancient wisdom meets cutting edge science and technology” narrative in which
those nasty “Western” scientific and medial “skeptics” are slowly being
convinced by the overwhelming weight of fantastic evidence being produced by
modern science, thus narrowing the chasm between TCM and science:

For centuries, the language of Traditional Chinese Medicine—concepts like
meridians and qi, or vital energy—left many Western researchers unconvinced.

That disconnect is now narrowing. As clinical research has progressed,
scientists are gaining a clearer picture of what happens when a needle meets
tissue, says Mingxiao Yang, an assistant professor at Nanyang Technological
University in Singapore, whose integrative health lab explores TCM through
cutting-edge technology.

The response begins locally. The slight mechanical tug of a needle, known as
mechanotransduction, sets off a cascade of biochemical signals in the
surrounding connective tissue. This activity causes skin mast cells (think of
them as your body’s first line of defense) to release compounds such as
histamine, serotonin, and adenosine into nearby tissue. Those signals then
stimulate nerve endings, sending messages to brain regions involved in
processing and modulating pain.

Acupuncture may also engage broader pain-regulation pathways, including a “pain 
inhibits pain,” sensation, in which one stimulus can dampen the perception of
another, Yang explains.

The above narrative is nothing more than a combination of very old claims by
acupuncturists that acupuncture “works” by releasing endorphins, adenosine, and 
other substances locally, supposedly magically transporting those
pain-suppressing signals to the brain. Mark Crislip long ago reviewed the
evidence for the “endorphin hypothesis” and found it wanting, while I’ve written
multiple times since 2010 about how unconvincing the evidence for locally
released adenosine as the mediator of the claimed analgesic effect of
acupuncture has been. All of the above is handwaving nonsense, as are the
references to X-ray studies showing “immune cells drifting toward acupuncture
needles, where they release pain mediators,” ultrasound showing “the ripple
effect of a needle’s tug in real time and how those effects may vary depending
on where a needle is placed,” and this lovely passage that basically says that
acupuncture is placebo:

Psychologically, the mere anticipation of potential healing plays its own role
too, Yang adds. “Treatment expectancy and belief, mediated partly through the
brain’s reward circuitry, may also contribute to acupuncture-induced pain
relief.”

It’s amazing how acupuncture believers admit explicitly that acupuncture is a
placebo without saying explicitly that acupuncture is a placebo, isn’t it?

Then there’s this doozy:

Researchers have reported an 80 percent overlap between classical meridian
pathways and connective tissue networks, regions that appear to contain higher
densities of nerve fibers than surrounding areas. One analysis found that these 
dense points may contain 1.4 times as many nerve fibers as non-acupoints.

“The traditional map of the meridians should be reinterpreted as a profound,
ancient blueprint of the body’s neural and fascial networks,” says Judith
Schlaeger, a professor at the College of Nursing at the University of Illinois
in Chicago. “The most effective points are often those that act as high-access
ports to the nervous system.”

Wow! 1.4 times as many nerve fibers? Seriously, that’s not very impressive, even
if I actually accepted the evidence as spun in the review article cited, which 
is published in a credulous traditional Chinese medicine journal, as reliable
and science-based. As for the 80% overlap claimed, guess whose lab produced the 
paper cited? Yes, it’s the Helene Langevin, a somewhat regular topic of this
blog because she is the Director of the National Center for Complementary and
Integrative Health (NCCIH), and, more importantly for purposes of this post,
someone who has long been known for desperately trying to use ultrasound studies
on cadavers and living humans to claim to find anatomic correlates with
acupuncture meridians. Let’s just put it this way. Acupuncture meridians are
lines imagined on the extremities and the torso that head towards the spine and 
brain. Of course some of them track somewhat closely with the paths of major
nerves and blood vessels, because that’s how the human body is put together!
This coincidence doesn’t imply that meridians and acupoints have consistent
anatomical correlates, the efforts of acupuncturists and believers to argue that
they do, to the point of mapping these correlates to animals such as dogs and
even elephants, notwithstanding.

Before I move on to the study that gets the most attention from Seifert, I think
it’s worth pointing out the revisionist history of traditional Chinese medicine
championed by Chairman Mao and, since Mao’s death in the 1970s, successive
Chinese governments. People seem to think that what is now considered
“acupuncture” has always been the same dating back thousands of years, with thin
needles precisely inserted into acupoints along meridians, when this form of
acupuncture has only predominated for around a century. Dr. Harriet Hall once
discussed the memoir of a Scottish surgeon named Dugald Christie who had served 
in China as a missionary for three decades spanning the late 19th and early 20th
centuries, quoting his account of what passed for acupuncture during that time:

Chinese doctors own that they know nothing at all of surgery. They cannot tie an
artery, amputate a finger or perform the simplest operation. The only mode of
treatment in vogue which might be called surgical is acupuncture, practised for 
all kinds of ailments. The needles are of nine forms, and are frequently used
red-hot, and occasionally left in the body for days. Having no practical
knowledge of anatomy, the practitioners often pass needles into large blood
vessels and important organs, and immediate death has sometimes resulted. A
little child was carried to the dispensary presenting a pitiable spectacle. The 
doctor had told the parents that there was an excess of fire in its body, to let
out which he must use cold needles, so he had pierced the abdomen deeply in
several places. The poor little sufferer died shortly afterwards. For cholera
the needling is in the arms. For some children’s diseases, especially
convulsions, the needles are inserted under the nails. For eye diseases they are
often driven into the back between the shoulders to a depth of several inches. 
Patients have come to us with large surfaces on their backs sloughing by reason 
of excessive treatment of this kind with instruments none too clean.

Speaking of the “excess of fire” in the child’s body, I like to point out that
TCM has a lot in common with “Western” humoral theory. For example, humoral
theory has the four humors, blood, yellow bile, black bile, and phlegm,
imbalances of which were thought to cause disease and whose “balance” physicians
tried to restore, dating back to the time of Hippocrates and continuing until
nearly the time of Dugald. TCM, on the other hand, has the Five Elements (wood, 
fire, earth, water, and metal), and diseases are thought to be due to imbalances
of the characteristics of these elements, such as heat/fire and
dampness/dryness, whose “imbalances” are corrected by TCM. Interestingly, there 
is evidence that much of the “theory” behind acupuncture was heavily influenced 
by astrology and that there are sufficient similarities between needling in
China and bloodletting in Europe to warrant strong suspicion that both practices
grew from the same conceptual framework.

Another aspect of the revisionist history of acupuncture embodied in the PNAS
and NatGeo articles comes from the little-known history of the needles
themselves. It turns out that the thin filiform needles now associated with
acupuncture didn’t exist until less than 100 years ago. Before that, needles
were large and coarse, as described by Dugald. Indeed, in the first two decades 
of the 20th century, acupuncture was falling out of favor, and it wasn’t until
the 1930s that a Chinese pediatrician named Cheng Dan’an proposed that needling 
therapy be resurrected because (he thought then) its actions could be explained 
through neurology. He also replaced the previously used coarse needles with the 
fine filiform needles in use today. No wonder there are so many “styles” of
acupuncture. Then, in the 1940s and 1950s, Chairman Mao, facing a shortage of
science-based physicians, started promoting TCM and acupuncture not just to his 
own people but to the “West” as evidence of the superiority of eastern medical
systems, complete with reports of “acupuncture anesthesia,” which Dr. Kimball
Atwood discussed early on in the history of SBM in epic fashion in a series
entitled “Acupuncture Anesthesia”: A Proclamation from Chairman Mao (Part I,
Part II, Part III, Part IV, and Part V). It is a tradition that even the
rapaciously state-managed capitalism of today’s China can’t resist continuing to
promote.

Acupuncture is real, not a placebo, ma-an!

The article’s last half is mostly about a study that is represented as slam-dunk
evidence to silence the doubters who argue that acupuncture is an elaborate
placebo (which it is). I’ll cite Seifert before turning my attention to the
actual study:

For decades, one question has lingered: Does acupuncture work beyond the placebo
effect? Answering that has proved difficult.

“The ‘true face’ of acupuncture remained elusive,” says Schlaeger.
“Investigators lacked the ability to use the definitive clinical methodology—the
double-blind randomized controlled trial—to separate acupuncture’s genuine
physiological effects from the placebo effect.”

That barrier may finally be shifting. Her team has just completed what they
describe as the world’s first double-blind acupuncture trial (where neither the 
participants, 89 women suffering from chronic vulva pain, nor the researchers
themselves knew if real or sham needles were administered).

“The trial was made possible by a specially designed placebo needle, developed
by Nobuari Takakura of Tokyo Ariake University of Medical and Health Sciences,
which conceals the depth of needle penetration. He explains that “without a
double-blind study environment, the decoding of the mechanisms of acupuncture
would be impossible, because investigators wouldn’t be able to distinguish its
true physiological effect from the power of expectation.”

Wait, what? The world’s first double-blind acupuncture trial, you say?
Seriously? We at SBM have been deconstructing double-blind acupuncture trials
for a long time, and Dr. Novella even noted in 2008 that techniques to study
acupuncture using double-blind trial designs had been developed. That same year,
I snarkily pointed out the dangers of using valid placebo controls in clinical 
trials of acupuncture, namely that double-blind studies show no difference
between placebo/sham acupuncture and “real” acupuncture. No, believers have been
doing double-blind trials of acupuncture for close to two decades. They just
don’t like them because the answer is almost always that sham/placebo
acupuncture performs no better than “true”/”real” acupuncture in double-blinded 
trial designs. Indeed, if there’s one thing that’s pretty consistent about
randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trials of acupuncture, it’s that sham
acupuncture used as placebo is generally indistinguishable from “real”
acupuncture. In brief, it doesn’t matter where you stick the needles. The result
is the same and easily attributable to placebo effects. Nor are whatever
needles used in this study the first needles that conceal the depth of
penetration of the needle. We at SBM have been writing about studies using
various designs of such needles for at least 15 years.

But, hey, who knows? Maybe this study is the one! You never know.

The study, Long-lasting effect of penetrating acupuncture among responders:
Double-blind RCT of acupuncture for vulvodynia, was published in January in The 
Journal of Pain. Unsurprisingly, I saw an old not-a-friend-of-the-blog, Ted
Kaptchuk, listed as one of the authors. Kaptchuk, you might recall, is a
tireless promoter of acupuncture and, in other contexts, is known for promoting 
the idea that it is possible to harness the placebo effect without deceiving the
patient. We, of course, have pointed out that his studies show nothing of the
sort.

First off, what is vulvodynia? The authors start right out describing this
horrible, debilitating condition before pivoting to why they think acupuncture
can help:

Vulvodynia is vulvar pain of unknown etiology that lasts at least 3-months, may 
have other potentially associated factors, and affects 7% of American women.1–3 
The pain of vulvodynia renders sexual intercourse virtually impossible and
devastates intimate relationships.4–6 Seventy percent of women with vulvodynia
report severe pain (greater than 6/10).7 To reduce their pain 60% use alcohol
and 43% use alcohol with analgesics (including opioids).8 The severe chronic
pain of vulvodynia may lead to physical disability9 and even suicidal
ideation.10 The two most common subtypes of vulvodynia are provoked
vestibulodynia (PVD), pain limited to the vulvar vestibule and vaginal introitus
that is provoked by touch,11 and generalized vulvodynia, spontaneous diffuse
vulvar pain that can spread to the perineum and inner thighs.7 Although many
have been tried, few therapies have been proven efficacious.12

Acupuncture has been shown to be effective in a meta-analysis of 39 high-quality
randomized trials of acupuncture in 20,827 patients for the treatment of four
chronic pain conditions: nonspecific musculoskeletal pain, osteoarthritis,
chronic headache, and shoulder pain (all p <.001).13 In contrast to these four
chronic pain conditions,13 there have been only six acupuncture studies14–19 of 
which two had acupuncture sham-control focused on feasibility17,18 and
four14–16,19 provided some evidence of the effect of acupuncture on vulvodynia. 
In all of them, women who received acupuncture had less pain, better quality of 
life, improved sexual health, and improved mental health. However, three were
single-group uncontrolled acupuncture studies and none were blinded,14–16 which 
limits conclusions about the efficacy of acupuncture for vulvodynia.

As you can see, vulvodynia is one of those conditions for which, unfortunately, 
science-based medicine doesn’t have a good pathophysiological explanation or
good treatments that reliably bring relief. Unsurprisingly, the authors are
citing one of the meta-analyses by Andrew Vickers that claim to show that
acupuncture works but, when examined more closely, do not. Both Dr. Novella and 
I have both explained why the original Vickers meta-analysis doesn’t demonstrate
that acupuncture works. The rest of the studies cited are the usual hodgepodge 
of dubious studies.

Let’s see how Seifert spins the results of the study, and then I’ll look at the 
study itself:

The team’s findings, recently published in the Journal of Pain, show that both
real and sham acupuncture work can provide relief, just not equally. True
acupuncture offers much longer-lasting relief of up to 12 weeks in some cases,
while relief from the placebo diminished after four weeks. Since true
acupuncture creates a micro-injury that releases a burst of chemical substances,
“the central nervous system is excited,” Schlaeger explains, “triggering the
body’s natural long-term repair mechanisms”

Takakaura adds, this shows that while the placebo-powered relief of ‘the ritual 
of care’ exists, “relief fades quickly because there is no lasting stimulus.
This is the clear boundary between the fleeting nature of placebo versus the
sustained effect of a true intervention.

Even so, questions remain. Larger studies and replication will be needed to
confirm these findings and determine how broadly they apply.

Spoiler alert: More studies won’t quite confirm these findings, other than that 
they will likely confirm that there is no difference in pain relief between sham
and true acupuncture; that is, unless they are not truly double-blind:

Eligibility criteria included:

  1. vulvar pain for at least 3-months duration
  2. a vulvodynia diagnosis as determined by gynecologic exam
  3. at least 18 years old
  4. spoke and read English at the initial screening
  5. a Tampon Test self-reported vulvar pain intensity score of 4 or greater on the
    Pain Intensity Number Scale (PINS 0–10) after inserting and removing a
    tampon because in women with vulvodynia, the pain of inserting and removing 
    a tampon is significantly correlated with daily vulvar pain and dyspareunia 
    (pain with sexual intercourse)
  6. be acupuncture naïve to enable participants to be blind to group allocation.
Exclusion criteria included conditions that can cause vulvar and vaginal pain
but are not vulvodynia:

  1. pain secondary to atrophic vaginitis
  2. current vaginitis (candida, bacterial vaginosis, trichomonas vaginalis)
  3. inflammatory conditions
  4. neoplastic disorders of the genitals, including cancer or pre-cancer of the
    vulva, or Paget’s disease
  5. neurologic disorders affecting the genitals including pudendal nerve
    entrapment
  6. spinal cord nerve compression
  7. genital trauma
  8. history of surgery radiation, or chemotherapy to the genitals
  9. hormonal deficiencies.
  10. pregnancy because, amazingly, “some of the acupoints in the protocol are
    forbidden in pregnancy,” and I have no idea why.
Here’s the flowchart of study procedures:

Study flowchart
And here is the needle design:

Design of retractable needles used.
And here are the acupoints that were used:

Acupuncture points used.
These points do not have any anatomic relationship to the vulva or vagina other 
than maybe the ones over the groin, but only because they are the closest to the
anatomic areas targeted.

The results were pretty unremarkable. Among the 89 women who participated in the
study, there was not even a whiff of a hint of a statistically significant
difference between the sham and true acupuncture groups for the primary outcome 
of vulvar pain, in any of the secondary outcomes, such as dyspareunia and the
tampon test. Moreover, the percentage of responders was similar in both groups: 
acupuncture 58%, placebo 57%. I also note that on the ten-point pain scale, the 
improvements noted in both groups were quite modest, with effects so small that 
I really do have to wonder if they were at all clinically relevant, a problem
many of these acupuncture studies that I discussed in detail when I
deconstructed the 2012 Vickers meta-analysis. None of this stopped the authors
from analyzing the “responder-participants” using a Kaplan-Meier curve that
purports to show that the rate at which the participants’ symptoms returned to
baseline was slower for the “true” acupuncture group, with the responders
showing, according to the authors, a “consistently higher rate of return to
baseline pain during the 12-week post-treatment follow-up in the placebo group
compared to the acupuncture group (hazard ratio: 2.72, 95% CI: 1.13–6.54).”

Does this mean anything? Who knows? One big flaw that I saw in the study right
away was that the blinding was uneven, with more participants in the “true”
acupuncture group guessing correctly which group they were in at baseline and
ten weeks compared to the sham acupuncture group. The authors also noted:

However, most of the acupuncturists did not maintain the blind in this
double-blind, multi-needle, multi-session study. Therefore, provider
expectations, conveyed nonverbally and not measured, may have influenced
participant outcomes.63 The finding that the skin-touch placebo achieved
blinding for the participants, thus reducing the risk of bias, is further
evidence it serves as an acupuncture placebo.64

So, basically, this was an attempt at a double-blind study, but as carried out
it wasn’t really completely double-blind. Then comes the hand-waving:

This trial revealed the true efficacy of penetrating acupuncture under a
rigorous experimental protocol; however, the control of the treatment
environment may not adequately represent the actual clinical benefits for
patients receiving acupuncture treatments as part of their care. There may be
synergy between the acupuncture effect, the therapeutic effect of the
relationship between the acupuncturist and participant, and the calming effect
of common rituals, such as playing music,62 to enhance the efficacy of
acupuncture. Therefore, more clinical benefit than that indicated by the results
of this study can be expected. Future studies are needed to clarify the
potential of such synergies when using penetrating or placebo needles.

In the duration-of-effect phase of this study, the longer lasting effect of
acupuncture is to be expected because it is known that placebo effects do not
last as long as treatment effects.60,71 A single systematic review72identified
the placebo effect over time for acupuncture treatment periods ranging from 3 to
12 weeks. In the review, the placebo effect increased from baseline up to 12
weeks and then began to decrease. In contrast, findings from the responders
after the RCT’s 10 sessions over 5 weeks suggest that the placebo effect
diminished after 4 weeks, but the acupuncture effect persisted for 12 weeks for 
more responders. The prolonged duration of the effect of penetrating acupuncture
is an important signpost of acupuncture’s salutogenic properties, meaning the
ability to endogenously restore health in chronic pain patients.73,74 The
findings that acupuncture not only reduced provoked vulvar pain and that it
lasted longer in responders than for those receiving placebo is important. These
RCT findings offer a viable treatment option for patients with vulvodynia.

No, they do not. The trial showed that acupuncture doesn’t work for vulvodynia. 
The authors point out that this study also didn’t have a no-acupuncture “usual
care” group, which, I admit, would have been interesting, but all such a group
would have provided was an estimate for the placebo effects evoked by the sham
and “true” acupuncture needling.

Remember my usual saying when it comes to trials of acupuncture: “Inconclusive
literature plus no plausible physiologic mechanism for acupuncture to work equal
an ineffective treatment whose effects are nonspecific placebo effects.” The
same is true at the individual study level, like this study. This study is, by
the authors’ own admission, inconclusive, although, notably, this doesn’t stop
the authors from calling for studies investigating the “effects among
acupuncture responders and non-responders,” as well as for “larger, pragmatic
trials.” Same as it ever was. Again, this study was negative. Yet Seifert
swallows the narrative that this study was some sort of bombshell evidence that 
acupuncture really does work after all. (Take that, you nasty skeptics!) It most
definitely isn’t. It’s yet another study that shows that acupuncture doesn’t
work, but that also contains enough of a germ of a difference between the study 
and placebo groups to allow acupuncture advocates to spin it as supporting the
use of acupuncture.

Closing the loop on the acupuncture narrative

Unsurprisingly, Seifert’s NatGeo article concludes that all this evidence,
especially the new vulvodynia study, tells us that the ancient Chinese really
must have been onto something. Never mind that how the Chinese did acupuncture
thousands of years ago—or even 100 years ago—hardly resembles what passes for
acupuncture now. None of that stops Seifert from credulously quoting acupuncture
enthusiasts trotting out the same narratives as in the PNAS paper, such as
touting how adopting acupuncture “could reshape how pain is treated
globally—offering a low-cost, non-addictive option even as health systems search
for alternatives to pharmaceuticals” and:

The results could be transformative. In the United States, where the opioid
crisis has claimed more than a million lives since 2000, non-pharmacological
approaches to pain management are gaining renewed attention. Some studies
suggest acupuncture may reduce both postoperative pain and the need for opioid
medications, though results vary.

I couldn’t resist laughing when I read “though results vary.” That phrase is
doing a lot of heavy lifting. In any case, as I keep saying, it’s a script, and 
Seifert regurgitates a variant of that script quite unimaginatively. I also keep
saying that, to believers in acupuncture and other alternative medicine, the
opioid crisis represents an opportunity, and that’s why a reference to the
opioid addiction crisis is always front and center in credulous propaganda about
acupuncture. It’s all about more than that, though, as the script tells us:

As the evidence base grows, acupuncture may also serve as a gateway for broader 
acceptance of other traditional therapies, from herbal medicine to
meditation—many of which are now studied with increasing clinical rigor.

Again, same as it ever was. Acupuncture is indeed a “gateway drug,” if you will,
to the whole panoply of quackery that “integrative medicine” attempts to
“integrate” into science-based medicine. Worse, as Seifert relates, the World
Health Organization (WHO) is actively promoting TCM and other prescientific
forms of medicine. Sadly, with our own Department of Health and Human Services, 
thanks to its takeover by antivax activist Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and his “make
America healthy again” (MAHA) movement, look for variants of this script to be
increasingly applied to spread from acupuncture to all manner of quackery
promoted by MAHA.

NYT Epic Fail on Acupuncture

Steven Novella on May 13, 2026

Link


This makes the third time in just two weeks that a major mainstream or
scientific outlet published credible nonsense about acupuncture, but I had to
cover it after dozens of people e-mailed me about this recent article in the New
York Times Magazine. It is ostensibly about the interstitium, but pivots to
using this recent discovery to retcon an alleged explanation for how acupuncture
“works”.  The discussion of the interstitium itself is fine, but then the
author veered off into gratuitous pseudoscience.

The interstitium was proposed in 2018 based on a study showing that the
interstitial connective tissue spaces around organs and other tissues in the
body are not separate spaces, but all appear to be connected. Essentially, the
authors propose that this is a body-wide fluid-filled space through which fluids
flow and communicate. This adds to the other fluid systems in the body, such as
the lymphatic system (which drains excess fluid from tissues), the circulatory 
system (which distributes oxygen and nutrients and carries away waste), and the 
spinal fluid system (which is inside and surrounds the central nervous
system). Later studies have supported the evidence for one continuous
interstitial space.

Of course, the more we know about how the body works, the better we will be able
to understand disease processes and design treatments. Cancer cells, for
example, might spread through the interstitium, resulting in distant metastasis.

The NYT, however, decided to tack onto this interesting update in our biological
knowledge a bit of rank pseudoscience. The author starts with the statement
that Thiese, one of the original researchers, was approached at a talk in China 
by a practitioner of Traditional Chinese Medicine who said, “We’ve been talking 
about it (the interstitium) for 4,000 years.” He accepted this third-hand
information uncritically. Um…no, they haven’t. No ancient culture had any
significant knowledge of human anatomy. They didn’t know basic things about how 
the body works, such as how blood circulates. They didn’t know what all the
organs did. They didn’t even know that tissues are made of cells until the
1800s. All this person was doing was taking a basic concept, like the body is
connected, and applying it to this new anatomical knowledge. It’s meaningless.

Further, what we currently know as acupuncture is actually only about a hundred 
years old. It was created by fiat to unite the various Chinese medical
traditions, which were mutually exclusive, into one system.  They were not using
filiform needles 4,000 years ago; they didn’t even have steel. We don’t really 
know what they were doing. The first text that describes something like
acupuncture is from 100 BC. But there was no unified theory or practice at this 
time. Needles were more like lances and likely were used for multiple purposes. 
Acupuncture sometimes involved blood letting or lancing, and other times
involved “chi”. However, there was also the belief that blood is what spread chi
throughout the body, so they were not entirely distinct. Again, these various
traditions were not brought together until the early 20th century.

In fact, descriptions of acupuncture from the 19th century bear little
resemblance to the modern version. These did not always involve points or
meridians and used large needles deeply inserted into tissues, usually at the
point of pain or injury.

The notion of chi, or an energy vital force, which spreads through meridians,
seems to go back about 2,000 years in some traditions. But this had nothing to
do with any knowledge of anatomy or physiology. In fact, for about 2,000 years, 
until 1923, dissection of dead bodies was banned in China, so they had very
little knowledge of anatomy. The meridians were therefore not based on anatomy, 
but on their cosmology – it was essentially astrology. It is therefore
completely pseudoscientific and ahistorical to argue that Chinese acupuncturists
had detailed knowledge of the interstitium 4,000 years ago – this is nonsense
from beginning to end.

This “ancient wisdom” trope makes especially little sense with a complex system 
like acupuncture. It’s one thing to claim that a pre-scientific culture noticed 
that taking some herb had an obvious physiological response. It is quite another
to claim that they somehow figured out hundreds of specific points on the body 
that correlated to non-obvious and even distant physiological and
disease-modifying effects. No ancient culture had the methods necessary to work 
out something so elaborate and complex. To claim they did is historical
pseudoscience.

The NYT author then provides some reference to studies apparently showing an
alignment between the interstitium and acupuncture meridians (channels through
which chi flows). These studies all come from China, which has a documented
history of poor science relating to acupuncture. But even taken at face value,
the evidence appears worthless. Essentially, dye spread up the arm when pressed,
and there is a meridian that goes up the arm. Wow. They don’t even closely
align. It would be amazing if dye did not spread in a way that could be so
loosely correlated with some meridian.

There is no credible evidence that meridians exist – and they were never meant
to represent anything anatomical. There is no evidence that acupuncture points
exist, and acupuncturists cannot even agree on where they are or what they do.
Different traditions of acupuncture use entirely different systems of points.
There is no evidence that “chi” or any life energy or vital force exists. This
is all culture, with no underpinning reality.

So no – the interstitium does not provide an explanation for how acupuncture
works. That is all blatant retconning. Further, there is no credible evidence
that acupuncture even works. After thousands of studies, researchers have failed
to definitively reject the null hypothesis. The best clinical studies show no
difference between true acupuncture and sham acupuncture – it is all placebo.
The media, however, has mostly bought into the propaganda and continues to
gullibly spread this pseudoscience.


A blast from the past: The “interstitium,” the inspiration for that recent awful
NYT acupuncture article

I’m on vacation this week and decided to repost a 2018 article that I had
written for my other blog (but never published on SBM) that’s oddly relevant to 
the SBM post last week about that awful NYT acupuncture article. Meet the
introduction of the “interstitium” in acupuncture, complete with a major Deepak 
Chopra connection!

David Gorski on May 18, 2026

Link


Editors note: I’m on vacation this week, or, more appropriately, staycation.
Believe it or not, I decided not to write anything new this week. (I know, I
know, but I’m learning to step away every now and then, if only to keep my
sanity given the relentless flow of horrors against science coming from the
federal government right now.) On the other hand, after finishing my post last
week about that ridiculously credulous National Geographic article on
acupuncture, I immediately regretted that I had completed that post before I saw
an even more ridiculously credulous article on acupuncture published in the New
York Times the very Sunday that I was writing my post about the NatGeo article.
Fortunately, our fearless founder Dr. Novella responded to what our readers
wanted with a deconstruction of his own. Now here’s the thing. That NYT article,
however, brought back memories of something that I had written about in 2018.
That was the year that a research article claiming to have found a new “organ”
that the authors dubbed the “interstitium,” was published. I was unimpressed but
not entirely dismissive. Soon after, this “discovery” had the press,
acupuncture advocates glommed onto it, as did Deepak Chopra. (I did mention
briefly that Bill Maher was very much impressed by the discovery. Make of that
what you will.) In any event, in my absence, I thought that our readers might
enjoy taking a trip back to April 4, 2018 and reading how the whole
“interstitium”-acupuncture narrative got started, which (I hope) will provide
context to Steve’s post. I’ve added a little bit in the way of updates and
corrected some typos.

I’ll (probably) be back next week, even though it’s a holiday here in the US.
Here we go!

Yesterday, I wrote about some rather interesting science that’s been rather
overhyped in the press, to the point of having already been invoked as a
potential mechanism by which acupuncture can work. I’m referring to the
“interstitium,” which was the subject of a number of stories last week about how
this finding represented the discovery of a hitherto unknown new organ.
Unsurprisingly, I was less than impressed by the hype.

If you want the details of just what the interstitium is and how it was
discovered, check out yesterday’s post. The CliffsNotes version is that the
interstitium is a network of fluid-filled spaces in various organs that appear
to communicate with the lymphatic system and could serve as the conduit for
immune proteins and cells, a repository for “third space” fluid, a potential
“shock absorber” for cells, and even a route for cancer cells to metastasize.
However interesting this discovery is, it is a stretch to call the interstitium 
a new organ, however. At the time, I thought that the person responsible for the
“interstitium as a previously undiscovered new organ” narrative had to have
been some PR flack at NYU who promoted that narrative in a press release, even
though no mention of a new organ is found in the actual paper reporting the
discovery of the interstitium. Maybe, I speculated, Neil Theise, the pathologist
whose observations sparked the study, had been played and just decided to go
along with the study. Partially arguing against that was his invocation of his
discovery as a potential mechanism by which acupuncture might work, but I gave
Theise the benefit of the doubt.

That was a mistake, as I discovered when a friend pointed me in the direction of
some more information and after Kavin Senapathy published an article in Slate
yesterday showing that Theise is very much into New Age nonsense, to the point
of apparently being tight with, of all people, Deepak Chopra. But, first, his
Twitter feed (note: this Tweet doesn’t seem to exist any longer, and so I cut
and pasted from my original post):

We discovered a new human organ! Maybe the biggest by volume! Introducing: the
interstitium! 20% of the body (~10 liters) of an average young adult.
https://t.co/SHv3nzqnPm… @DeepakChopraMD @DeepakChopra
@carolynfrangel@NondualScience

— neil theise (@neiltheise) March 27, 2018

That’s right. There’s Dr. Theise on the very same day his study was published
online by Scientific Reports, touting the claim that he and his team had
discovered a new organ. Not only that, but he tagged Deepak Chopra and Menas C. 
Kafatos, who co-authored You Are The Universe: Discovering Your Cosmic Self and 
Why It Matters, as well as Carolyn Rangel, President of Deepak Chopra LLC, and
Rudy Tanzi, who’s co-authored multiple books with Chopra, including Super Genes:
Unlock the Astonishing Power of Your DNA for Optimum Health and Well-Being. He 
also tagged the Twitter feed for Science & Nonduality, whose website
demonstrates some serious woo. I also note that Dr. Theise tags these people a
lot. A lot.

Then there was this link that Theise retweeted:

This is how I’ve been hiding from scientists for so long. #interstitium
pic.twitter.com/x8dEuE1WNo

— Interstitium (@Interstitium1) March 28, 2018

Interestingly, this Twitter feed for someone going by the handle of Interstitium
was created in March 2018 and, as of the time I wrote this last night, only 18 
Tweets. All of them are about the “interstitium” as described in Theise’s paper.
This Twitter feed almost certainly must belong to Theise as well. In a way,
I’ll give the guy credit. I have to admit that some of the Tweets are actually
rather funny:

What’s your body’s biggest organ? Get your mind out of the gutter! It’s me, the 
#Interstitium.

— Interstitium (@Interstitium1) March 30, 2018

Can’t wait until I’m a #Jeopardy clue! #Interstitium

— Interstitium (@Interstitium1) March 30, 2018

20% of your body’s weight is #Interstitium fluid. So be nice to me and I’ll help
you fit in your skinny jeans.

— Interstitium (@Interstitium1) April 3, 2018

I must be honest: the #mesentery and I have broken up. We had a good
relationship sparked by being “discovered” so closely together. But they never
let me forget that Da Vinci described them first and they’re in Gray’s Anatomy.
#interstitium will find love some day.

— Interstitium (@Interstitium1) April 5, 2018

Scientists: this is how cancer really travels through the #Interstitium
pic.twitter.com/l91FXu4f5j

— Interstitium (@Interstitium1) April 5, 2018

Theise is also touting his paper on his own Twitter feed:

What do you think, John Oliver? #LastWeekTonight#nametheneworgan

— neil theise (@neiltheise) March 29, 2018

He also describes himself as a “consciousness theorist,” which to me is a red
flag regarding how science-based he is:

#LGBTscience! MD, Liver pathologist, anatomist (new anatomy of “the
interstitium” of every human organ SOON), stem cell biologist, philosopher of
science (Godel anyone?), consciousness theorist. Breaking social/science
boundaries x30! Queer science is thinking outside the box!

— neil theise (@neiltheise) February 11, 2018

Indeed, in May Dr. Theise is scheduled to speak at the Sivanada Ashram Yoga
Retreat in the Bahamas, where he, along with Chopra’s co-conspirator Menas
Kafatos, along with Debashish Banerjee and Swami Brahmananda will “further
explore the intersection of consciousness, or Brahman, and human perception,” as
well as:

  1. How universal awareness gives rise to the universe through the experiencing
    process
  2. How different states of consciousness create different realities
  3. How consciousness will inform the future of medicine, technology, and social
    well-being
  4. Qualia-based medicine such as Ayurveda, Chinese Medicine, qigong, and energy
    healing
  5. The relationship of qualia to subtle energy fields, the chakras,  the Buddhist
    wheel of awareness, and sacred geometry
  6. Shared resonance of qualia through community.
That’s some serious woo there. I also discovered a whole lot of other woo.
Indeed, seeing Theise’s Twitter feed and doing some searches on his name
revealed a whole lot. I also learned in this report:

What’s next for Theise, Carr-Locke, and Benias? They’re bracing for feedback,
but looking forward to the as-yet-unexplored, boundary-pushing potential of the 
interstitium. Theise said their team had submitted their paper to eight
different journals (one sending the feedback that a new organ was “not of
interest to a general audience”) before finally being accepted by Scientific
Reports.

I wondered in my last post why, if this finding were so groundbreaking, it had
been published in Scientific Reports, an open access journal published by Nature
Publishing Group that has been known for a propensity to publish dubious
studies promoting New Age nonsense and even antivaccine pseudoscience. Now, I
will admit to some articles that I have submitted to more than one journal
before they were finally accepted. However, eight is a whole lot. My personal
record for the number of journals I’ve submitted the same manuscript to before
it was accepted is only four, and after that I swore I would never bother to
submit to that many journals again, given how much of a pain that it was. I can 
only wonder which journals they submitted to and how far down the scale they had
to go to get into Scientific Reports. On the other hand, in terms of impact
factor, Scientific Reports is not too shabby at 4.259. Be that as it may, much
is explained by this observation, namely that a lot of journals either weren’t
interested or found serious deficiencies in Theise’s manuscript.

I also learned from Senapathy that it wasn’t just Science Friday or The Cut that
included Theise’s musings on how the “interstitium” could explain acupuncture
and other alternative medicine modalities. It was CNN and Business Insider too. 
She also confirmed what I started figuring out by looking at Theise’s Twitter
feed:

Theise is a liver pathologist and stem cell researcher. He has long been
interested in legitimizing alternative medicine practices. He’s collaborated
with alternative medicine and New Age movement mogul Deepak Chopra on articles, 
podcasts, and YouTube videos, even speaking at a Chopra Center seminar. In 2003,
he wrote in Tricycle, a western Buddhist perspective magazine, on how his
meditations helped him discover “the synergy between dharma practice and
scientific inquiry.”

I started perusing some of the links I found about Theise, and this is an
understatement. For instance, Theise has a website. (Note added in 2026: Had a
website. I’ve updated links to his website as Archive.org links.) His biography 
asserts:

Subsequently, while continuing laboratory and clinical research, he has extended
his work to areas of theoretical biology and complexity theory, defining a
“post-modern biology.” These ideas suggest that alternate models of the body,
other than Cell Doctrine, may be necessary to understand non-Western approaches 
to the body and health.

Oh, dear. He believes that there has to be some sort of special pleading in the 
description of human biology, an alternate model of the body, to understand
“non-Western” approaches to health. A perusal of his CV shows that he’s long
been giving talks on various similar topics. He’s been a Zen Buddhist for a
number of years, and it’s become apparent that his religious beliefs are very
much intruding into his science. He’s featured on the Chopra Center website, and
that’s never a good sign as far as a person’s attitude towards woo goes.

However, I was curious just what Theise meant by his assertion that alternate
models of the body might be necessary to understand “non-Western” approaches to 
the body and health. It didn’t take me long to find his 2009 article, Beyond
Cell Doctrine: Complexity Theory Informs Alternate Models of the Body for
Cross‐Cultural Dialogue. The first part of the article starts out with a bit of 
an exaggeration, representing “cell theory” as the be-all and end-all of
“Western” medicine and biology, citing multiple papers in which he argues that
stem cells and our newer understanding of cellular plasticity somehow means that
cell theory is “incomplete.” Cell theory, of course, is the theory that all
organisms are made up of cells, that they are the basic structural and
organizational unit of all organisms, and that all cells come from preexisting
cells. The modern version of cell theory takes into account newer discoveries in
science since the time cells were first identified and cell theory solidified a
couple hundred years ago, such as the ideas that energy flow occurs within
cells, heredity information flows between cells, and that cells have the basic
chemical composition.

Theise’s basic idea seems to be that stem cell plasticity, the trafficking of
cells between organs, recent insights regarding stem cells, repression and
de-repression of gene expression, and the application of Complexity Theory to
cell and molecular biology all call for the reevaluation of cell theory. In his 
paper on cross-cultural dialogue and how alternative models of the body could
allow us to “understand non-Western medicine” he starts out making some
provocative, but not too out there, observations. For instance:

What if the technology had been different? What if the first structures visible 
with the new technology had been the nuclei, not cell walls or membranes? Then, 
a very different answer to the ancient debate would have been conceived. The
body would indeed look like an endlessly divisible fluid, only with small little
globes suspended in it. Twenty years later, with the advent of histochemical
staining to demonstrate cell membranes, the fluid theory of the body would not
have been jettisoned; rather, the new structures perhaps would have been
described as semi permeable partitioning of the fluid continuum.

This is an interesting speculation, but it doesn’t really tell us how this
alternate model of the body would have changed medicine. Yes, it’s true that
what the body looks like will change depending upon the scale we choose, as
Theise argues:

Changing scale will also yield other possible models. A nanoscopic view of the
body is quite different than a microscopic view. Cells cease to exist at that
finer scale level; indeed the body itself ceases to be apparent. The body’s
functions become dominated by quantum effects very different from effects seen
at higher scale, some of which even clearly manifest at higher levels. Examples 
of biologically relevant quantum effects include the importance of quantum
tunneling for the energy requirements of some enzymatic action23, 24 and the
above described role of Brownian motion in providing energy of movement for
interacting single molecules as described above.

Quantum. Yes he went there. No wonder he likes Deepak Chopra so much. He also
takes the simple observation that the structure of the body looks like at
different levels of scale, and how cell theory is not a useful model molecular
scale, and tries to apply it to “Eastern” medicine by portraying such
“non-Western” medicine as looking at the body from a different scale, like
looking at it as a fluid interrupted by membranes or at a subcellular level. it 
does not go well. First, after stating that prejudice against acupuncture isn’t 
the only thing that makes it difficult to study in the West, but a very simple
other observation. Basically, he admits that there is no anatomic correlate for 
acupuncture points or meridians. Because of that:

To explain it in Western terms, we must identify what is going on structurally
at the acupuncture points. Yet if one dissects these areas, one does not find an
underlying anatomic structure that is readily described by our standard
categories: there are no nerves, lymphovascular structures, tendons, fascial
planes, or muscle fibers at these points or along the meridians. If they cannot 
be described in terms of our standard gross anatomy, they cannot be described by
cells, the building blocks of that anatomy. Thus, it appears that the model of 
cell doctrine is, at least to date, inherently incapable of explaining
acupuncture. While it is a consistent model and thus successfully produces
hypotheses concerning many observable bodily phenomena, which can be tested and 
refined, it is also an incomplete model.

That’s right. Because “Western” medical models like cell theory can’t explain
acupuncture, to Theise these models must be incomplete. In other words, if there
are no structures in whatever model in “Western medicine” you like to choose
that can explain acupuncture, he’ll just accept the non-evidence-based models
postulated by quacks:

Tibetan medicine speaks of different “bodies” which co‐exist within our single
body: a coarse body, a subtle body, and an energy body. Previously, these
phrases always conjured in my imagination overlapping, superimposed “bodies”
that were independent of each other and probably only metaphorical (my typically
Western bias).

However, when discussing how the body might function or appear at different
levels of scale in small groups of American and Tibetan doctors and scientists, 
the possibility that there was more substance to these terms became apparent. Is
it possible that “other bodies” of the Tibetan and other systems actually
correspond to our bodies at different levels of scale? If so, can we appreciate 
medical philosophy and science of other cultural systems, such as the Tibetan
system, not as naïve metaphor, but as poetically expressed, yet still precise
approaches to considering how the body is put together and might be repaired if 
injured?

Leading Theise to conclude:

Various changes in perspective and scale of observation lead to alternate
possible models–also incomplete but possibly also of great use–that may reveal
the accuracy of some Asian models, despite the seemingly metaphorical
terminology employed in those systems (from a Euro‐American perspective).
Limiting ourselves to cell doctrine means that some bodily phenomena may remain 
resistant to cell‐based hypothesis formation and testing.

In other words, it science doesn’t support acupuncture, change the models
science uses until it does. Notice the assumption here, which is that
acupuncture works and that if acupuncture works there must be some mechanism
that explains it. If “Western” medical models, like cell theory, do not provide 
an explanation for acupuncture, then they must be incomplete. That is the crux
of Theise’s argument. Again, Theise is wrong in his very premise. Acupuncture
doesn’t work. As I like to say, it doesn’t matter where the needles are placed. 
It doesn’t even matter if the needles are placed. Indeed, twirling toothpicks
against the skin produces the same effect. Basically, acupuncture is nothing
more than a theatrical placebo. It does not work any more than placebo. He even 
tries to invoke a bastardized version of Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle,
which he calls “cellular uncertainty”:

When we first proposed this principle, the reference to Heisenberg (“cellular
uncertainty”) was intended to be more metaphorical than real. However, we now
see that, as with elementary particles, “cellular uncertainty” is not an
artifact, a limitation of our incomplete technological abilities to study the
cell. Rather, a cell’s existence is contingent on the level of scale at which
the body is observed. Without inherent, scale‐independent existence the cell is 
by definition “uncertain” precisely in the meaning of Heisenberg: by examining
the cell we change the cell.

I can sense the physicists in my readership grinding their collective teeth.
Basically, Theise seems to be making the common mistake of confusing the
uncertainty principle, which states that there is a limit to the precision with 
which certain pairs of physical properties of a particle, known as complementary
variables, such as position x and momentum p, can be known, and the observer
effect, which notes that measurements can’t be made of certain systems without
changing something in the system. Here’s the thing. The observer effect can be
quantified. By itself, that the observer effect exists for a system doesn’t mean
the model that system represents is incomplete. I do so love bad analogies to
physics, and I suspect my physicist readers will have more to say, maybe even to
tell me I got it all wrong. Hey, I’m just a simple surgeon, but I suspect I
understand these things better than Theise does. Let’s just put it this way.
Theise seems to be going even beyond confusing the uncertainty principle with
observer effects. The changes in the cells and other biological structures that 
occur from our observing them are really artifacts of the technology we use to
measure them, such as the need to fix cells for histology or isolate DNA to
sequence it. I’ll point out that he has published the same sort of argument on
the Chopra Center website and here.

Deepak Chopra in 2018.
If you don’t believe how far down the rabbit hole Dr. Theise has gone, take a
look at some video interviews he did with Deepak Chopra. First, here he is in a 
preview of a longer interview (which requires a subscription to Curiosity
Stream), going deep into Choprawoo about evolution and the “sentient universe”
in which the two ask if consciousness is the driver of evolution:

“There is sentience at all levels, from ultramicroscopic to galactic”? Ugh.
What’s being peddled in the video is basically just warmed-over intelligent
design creationism, substituting the “sentience of the universe” as the guiding 
force for evolution instead of God. It’s the sort of drivel that Chopra is known
for, given that Chopra detests the idea that evolution could be a random
process (he also hates the idea that behavior can be deterministic), and
has spewed many times over the years. No wonder Theise and Chopra are buds.

Here he is in 2016 being interviewed by Chopra for Sages and Scientists:

In this, we learn that Theise is heavily into “nonduality” and consciousness.
For some reason, most of the video is blackscreen after the first four minutes
or so. If you want the full effect of Theise’s views, though, check out this
appearance at Chopra’s Sages & Scientists in 2013:

And here he is at Chopra’s conference in 2014, in which he talks about liver
transplant recipients who have memories from the donor, as though the donor’s
liver somehow transfers memories from its previous owner to the recipient:

Michael Shermer (who in 2026 has since fallen a long way from skepticism,
assuming that he hadn’t already fallen then) tries to add some skepticism to
this whole discussion, but he’s mostly outnumbered, the token skeptic. That
year, Chopra also apparently wanted evolutionary biologist Jerry Coyne (who in
2026 has also fallen a long way that is similar to Shermer), but Coyne rebuffed 
him. Be that as it may, clearly Neil Theise is tight with Deepak Chopra. He
seems to show up at Chopra’s conferences almost every year.

After learning all that I have about Neil Theise, I’ve been thinking about his
“discovery” of the “interstitium.” Knowing what I know now about how he views
“cell theory” to be incomplete because it doesn’t provide a means of explaining 
acupuncture, I can’t help but view the “interstitium” as he describes it in a
different way. Specifically, I’m a hell of a lot more skeptical that this is a
real finding that will stand up to scrutiny by other scientists. After all, a
close relationship with Deepak Chopra does not exactly imbue me with confidence 
that Neil Theise is dedicated to rigorous science. In fact, I now strongly
suspect that Theise “discovered” the interstitium because it is the sort of
discovery that confirms his preexisting beliefs and provides him a means of
“explaining” how acupuncture and other alternative medicine can supposedly
produce systemic effects from local manipulation, because, above all, he
believes that acupuncture works even though it is only a theatrical placebo.
Indeed, until I see other scientists not associated with Deepak Chopra reproduce
some of Theise’s key findings, I’m just going to file this “discovery” of the
“interstitium” in the “unproven and probably false” category.

And, to bring everything full circle back to 2026, I’m going to conclude that
the NYT has been a useful idiot for laundering Deepak Chopra’s New Age nonsense 
to give the impression that it’s actual science.

Lipstick on Fengxi

Another attempt to demonstrate that the fiction of acupuncture is based in
reality. This time it is the interstitium. Nope.

Mark Crislip on May 19, 2026

Link


There are two areas that I think I have a degree of expertise and knowledge. One
is infectious diseases (fading rapidly in retirement). The other is SCAMs
(Supplements, Complementary and Alternative Medicine). In both areas, I have
long noted that those without the same understanding and experience that I have 
often do a less than stellar job in understanding the literature.

Practitioners of SCAMs are continually striving to map their fictitious
interventions onto reality in order to justify and explain why and how their
particular form on nonsense works. Difficult to do when the effects do not
extend beyond a placebo effect.

You know the placebo effect: the beer goggles of medicine.

But that does not stop their trying. There are no end to papers in the Pubmeds
attributing any number of radiologic, anatomic or metabolic changes to account
for SCAM effects. And now we have a new explanation for acupuncture.

What is the mindset one needs to have to demonstrate the purported reality-based
mechanism by which a SCAM such as acupuncture has effects? Well, you have to
have just fallen off the turnip truck, leaving critical thinking behind. It
helps to be vague, misrepresent studies, to repeat long discredited myths, use
overwrought adjectives, and maximize your inner Humpty Dumpty:

“When I quote an alternative medicine study,’ Humpty Dumpty said in rather a
scornful tone, ‘it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.’

And to that end, the most recent attempt to put lipstick on Fengxi we have the
breathless

The Astounding Discovery That Could Link Eastern and Western Medicine

The detection of another circulatory system in the human body could have
enormous scientific implications.

What is this astounding structure? A third space for fluid transport, after the 
vascular and lymphatic systems, we have the interstitium.


What is this interstitium of which you speak? All the connective tissue in us is
made of collagen and hyaluronic acid and it contains sacs of water/fluid and
are connected. This was missed for years, as the structure is lost in most
prepared specimens. The fact that these are all connected in a newish finding
(emphasis added):

Freezing biopsy tissue before fixation preserved the anatomy of this structure, 
demonstrating that it is part of the submucosa and a previously unappreciated
fluid-filled interstitial space, draining to lymph nodes and supported by a
complex network of thick collagen bundles. These bundles are intermittently
lined on one side by fibroblast-like cells that stain with endothelial markers
and vimentin, although there is a highly unusual and extensive unlined interface
between the matrix proteins of the bundles and the surrounding fluid. We
observed similar structures in numerous tissues that are subject to intermittent
or rhythmic compression, including the submucosae of the entire
gastrointestinal tract and urinary bladder, the dermis, the peri-bronchial and
peri-arterial soft tissues, and fascia. These anatomic structures may be
important in cancer metastasis, edema, fibrosis, and mechanical functioning of
many or all tissues and organs. In sum, we describe the anatomy and histology of
a previously unrecognized, though widespread, macroscopic, fluid-filled space
within and between tissues, a novel expansion and specification of the concept
of the human interstitium.

Kind of cool. My first response was interesting, but not earth-shattering. We
are filled with an interconnected microscopic water-filled bubble wrap. Not a
real surprise and researchers continue to find new anatomical structures.
Whether this warrants the designation of an organ, I will leave to anatomists.
Seems more of a Pluto than a planet X. Or even a planet Claire. But hardly
astounding.

I had fretted about the local interstitium for most of my career. Where did the 
fluid go in third-spacing? Where is the infection? In the cell? The
interstitium? Another space? And did the antibiotics reach that space? As an
inside baseball example, you should not treat pneumonia with daptomycin, as it
has negligible levels in the alveoli, but for septic pulmonary emboli, an
infection that is in the interstitium of the lung can respond. Sometimes. But
don’t try that at home.

After describing the interstitium, the train takes the express route from
Realityville to Fantasyland.

Theise, Wells and colleagues were praised by their scientific peers for their
findings. “This work was really comprehensive,” says David Merrick, an assistant
professor of medicine at the University of Pennsylvania. But the idea of there 
being a circulatory system involving the body’s connective tissues was not
unfamiliar to some medical systems.

“This knowledge is actually quite ancient,” says Leah Welsh, an osteopathic
physician and an assistant professor of family and community medicine at Ohio
State. “It’s something that other systems of medicine have been offering for a
long time, but they didn’t have microscopes.”

What? If no microscopes, what exactly were these other systems offering? How did
they know about the interstitium if they had no ability to see it? A little
specificity or a reference would sure be nice with such a claim. I went looking 
and could find nothing outside of Traditional Chinese Pseudo Medicine (TCPM).
Usual vague assertions. But an assistant processor said it, so it must be so.
Meh.

As Theise told an interviewer from “Radiolab” in 2023, an expert in traditional 
Chinese medicine approached him at a conference in China where he was speaking
on the interstitium and said, “We’ve been talking about it for 4,000 years.”

Have they now. Talking about collagen bundles and hyaluronic acid and sacs of
fluid? Of course not.

Once again, it looks like conventional medicine is finally catching up with
Traditional Chinese Medicine. Just this past week, scientists reported that they
have discovered a “new organ”, which they have named the interstitium. The
Chinese have known about this organ for centuries, but they named it the san
jiao.

The san jiao is responsible for the movement and transformation of various
solids and fluids throughout the body, as well as for the production and
circulation of nourishing energy and protective energy. It is not a single
self-contained organ, but rather a functional energy system involved in
regulating the activities of other organs. It is composed of three parts, known 
as ‘burners’, each associated with one of the body’s three main cavities:
thorax, abdomen and pelvis. An ancient Chinese medical text states: ‘The Upper
Burner controls intake, the Middle Burner controls transformation, the Lower
Burner controls elimination.’

In Traditional Chinese Medicine, the san jiao channel is used to move energy and
lift depression. The san jiao channel begins at the tip of the fourth (ring)
finger and runs up along the dorsum of the hand and lower arm, to the back side 
of the upper arm, over the shoulder, up the neck, wraps around the ear and ends 
at the outer corner of the eyebrow. The san jiao channel is found bilaterally,
but only one side has to be used for treatments to be effective.

What fictional TCPM and the reality-based description of the interstitium have
in common is exactly zero.

And that is one explanation. Since there are as many forms of acupuncture as
there are practitioners, it is no surprise that there is another link of TCPM
and the interstitium that I will not quote, as it is gibberish. Read it here.
But SCAM proponents so love to apply the lipstick of science to their particular
pig.

One of the most intriguing areas of current research is whether there is a
connection between the interstitium and the ancient Chinese practice of
acupuncture.

Intriguing? Naw. Only if you believe that TCPM is not a fiction. It’s like
looking to anatomy and physiology to explain the mechanism of newly discovered
forms of kryptonite.

the Man of Steel discovers some never-before-seen variants of Kryptonite:
purple, cobalt, speckled and rainbow. He’s determined to figure out how these
new variants affect Kryptonians by experimenting on himself with the help of a
very reluctant Batman.

Although I suspect kryptonite has its effects mediated by meridians and chi.
Seems just as reasonable as most TCPM explanations. Just another example of
trying to map BS onto reality. Never gonna happen.

Acupuncture is used to treat conditions as varied as chronic pain, migraines,
seasonal allergies and nausea caused by chemotherapy, but some of its actions
have never been completely explained. The discovery of the interstitium may help
us understand in modern biomedical terms how acupuncture works.

Acupuncture is used to treat these ailments, but with no efficacy beyond
placebo.

Chronic pain? Here is one meta-analysis

Acupuncture as an adjunct therapy may provide post-treatment pain relief lasting
at least 3 months for patients with chronic neck pain, although it is not
superior to sham acupuncture.

Not superior to sham, aka the placebo effect.

Migraines? In a metaanalysis of 21 studies, the best they can come up with is
‘may:-

Conclusion: The body of evidence suggests that acupuncture may be more effective
than sham acupuncture in the treatment of migraine.

and you only get the may as

the certainty evidence across outcomes was low to very low

Allergies?

The performance bias and attrition bias are serious in most studies that were
included. Selection bias may also have affected the quality of the evidence.

Conclusion: Acupuncture may have an advantage over no intervention and sham
acupuncture in improving nasal symptoms and quality of life for adults with AR

Nausea?

Conclusion: Acupuncture in addition to usual care may increase the complete
control of chemotherapy-induced acute vomiting and delayed vomiting but the
certainty of evidence was very low.

Anyone see a pattern? Poorly done biased studies MAY show effects. As a rule
with SCAMs, the better the study, the less the efficacy.

And, unfortunately, studies out of China are suspect as

Although many SRs of acupuncture interventions have been published in Chinese
journals, the reporting quality is troubling

and there are no negative acupuncture studies out of China

No trial published in China or Russia/USSR found a test treatment to be
ineffective.

and

80% of China’s clinical trial data are fraudulent, investigation finds

with retractions for fraud being common.

Safe to say acupuncture is a suspect literature that needs to be read with care 
and critical thinking, sorely lacking in this article. The NYT, not mine.

Acupuncture doesn’t work for any objective process in well-done
placebo-controlled trials and only has minimal subjective effects. Ya know,
placebo. But in all these kinds of papers, efficacy is presumed where none
exists, and the studies are cherry-picked and are often misrepresented to
provide evidence.

The principles of the practice invoke two circulating elements: chi and blood.

Traditional Chinese medicine describes chi as flowing along one of 12 main
tracks, called meridians.

Chi and meridians do not exist. Sorry. They do not. And blood? My blood and TCPM
Blood are not the same.

In TCM, Blood remains a red liquid full of nutrients that flows through blood
vessels; however, it possesses much wider functions not recognized in Western
medicine, such as having the roles of “harboring the Mind” and “moistening the
body.”

In TCM, Blood is inseparable from Qi. In fact Blood is a very dense material
form of Qi. Qi gives Blood energy and life force, hence activating Blood.

Formation of blood

Blood is generated by the interaction of Grain Qi from food and drinks that
enter the Stomach and Spleen and Essence from the Kidneys.

Therefore the two main important organs for the formation of Blood are Spleen
and Kidneys according to TCM.

This is very much different from Western Medicine which states that formation of
Blood is solely from bone marrow and hematopoietic stem cells and mention
nothing about Spleen, Stomach and Kidneys.

Total nonsense. TCPM uses reverse-Jabberwocky. In the poem, Lewis Carroll uses
nonsense words in place of nouns and adjectives, but we understand what vorpal
or beamish likely mean in context. In TCPM, standard words like blood are used, 
but the definitions are nonsense. It is so mimsy.

Acupuncturists insert small needles into specific points on the body to enhance 
the flow of chi.

Specific? Har de har har. Different practitioners will use different points for 
the same disease. There were originally 365 acupoints. Hm. 365. That number
seems familiar. But now there are over 2000. And there are the points for
Japanese and Korean and ear and foot and hand and head acupuncture. There are
many words to be used to describe acupuncture. Specific isn’t one of them.
Virtually any place on the skin can be an acupoint. And, oddly, none in the
eyes, under the nails, or in the genitalia. I wonder why that may be.

And just how does one know that the flow is enhanced when chi never measured,
never seen, does not exist? Ah, the mysteries of TCPM.

In a 2002 study, Helene Langevin and Jason Yandow mapped the locations of
acupuncture points in the arms to the fascia between and around muscles.

Oh please. Read the paper for gods sakes.

We hypothesize that the network of acupuncture points and meridians can be
viewed as a representation of the network formed by interstitial connective
tissue. This hypointermuscular or intramuscular connective tissue planes
intermuscular or intramuscular connective tissue planes thesis is supported by
ultrasound images showing connective tissue cleavage planes at acupuncture
points in normal human subjects. To test this hypothesis, we mapped acupuncture 
points in serial gross anatomical sections through the human arm. We found an
80% correspondence between the sites of acupuncture points and the location of
intermuscular or intramuscular connective tissue planes in postmortem tissue
sections.

They found what they were looking for and could find it only 80% of the time.
There may be occasional correspondence, but no anatomical structures that are
acupoints or meridians. The lack of control is astounding and renders this
mapping meaningless.

acupuncture points have since been found to lie within the same areas of
connective tissue where fluid flows through the interstitium.

A 2019 paper by researchers in China, led by Dr. Hongyi Li, explains how they
injected chemical tracers into acupuncture points in the hands and feet of
cadavers and used chest compressions to push fluid through the bodies.

Fluorescent photography enabled them to see the tracers traveling toward the
heart within interstitial spaces of the arms and legs. Li and colleagues clearly
recognized, just as Wells and Theise did, that they had glimpsed evidence of an
interstitial circulation system.

That is one weird ass study. As noted, they injected tracers in fresh cadaver
feet and hands at acupoints and then did 2.5 hours of chest compression on the
corpses to see where the tracer went. Not certain what the chest compressions
did, as the blood clots quickly after death. I have done chest compression and
know all too well the crunching of bones that can happen. What do 2.5 hours of
chest compressions do to a corpse? I just imagine the body flopping like a fish 
with each compression. Kind of a mediastinal meat tenderizer. Like I said, weird
ass. The authors wondered if the result had anything to do with acupuncture, as

However, the transport courses of the fibrous extravascular pathways from the
thumb were significantly individual in all subjects and different from the
diagrammatic drawing of Lung Meridians in Meridian Atlas. The visualized fibrous
pathways were not the proof for the Meridians & Collaterals network but could
be an anatomic structure for interstitial fluid transport, mediated by which
acupuncture signals from an acupuncture point can be transmitted into an
associated visceral structure hypothetically.

If acupuncture points seem to reside within the interstitium, could the
meridians run through the interstitium as well?

If? Seem? Seems a stretch. And meridians? Naw. And what is it about these
collagen bundles and sacs of fluid that result in specific structures like
acupoints? What is different about the interstitum here but not there that makes
it an acupoint or a meridian? Don’t think they have thought this through.

In 2021, a group of researchers conducted a similar experiment in China on
living subjects, injecting dye into acupuncture points in the forearms of 15
volunteers.

In almost all of them, the dye slowly migrated upward along a route
corresponding to the pericardium meridian, which passes through the wrist and
along the inner arm. (Pericardium is the same meridian stimulated by anti-nausea
wrist acupressure devices popular on cruise ships.)

Is it pressure? Or needles? If pressure works for nausea, then why use needles? 
Except acupressure is also ineffective:

Neither band nor placebo prevented the development of motion sickness,
regardless of whether the bands were used correctly or incorrectly.

Remember how they said specific points are used in acupuncture. In this study
they used

Pericardium (PC) meridian and the acupoints were identified on the forearm from 
the wrist to the elbow by two TCM physicians (Drs. Zhao and Hu) according to
“Nomenclature and location of acupuncture points” (GB/T 12346-2006) issued by
the Standardization Administration of China. Acupuncture point locations were
reached by consensus and further refined or confirmed with the use of a
low-electrical impedance locator device.

Yeah, they really know precisely where acupoints are. The injections were
intradermal, but I thought the points were mapped to intermuscular or
intramuscular connective tissue planes. So much inconsistency in the TCPM world,
but that is how it should be as practitioners make it up as they go along.

“This pathway doesn’t go in the veins, it doesn’t go superficially,” says Andrew
Ahn, the study’s senior author and an assistant professor at Harvard Medical
School. It goes instead, he told me, into the interstitium between the muscles: 
“When I saw that, I said: ‘We’re onto something. This truly has to do with
acupuncture.’”

Nope. It just has to do with the flow of material along the interstitium.

“I actually do think that the interstitium could be the link between Eastern and
Western medicine,” Wells told me. “But you have to show scientifically that
that’s the case.”

Never gonna happen, since one cannot scientifically show that a fiction is real.

It is a tale/Told by an acupuncturist, full of sound and fury,/Signifying
nothing.

After this detour into nonsense, the trip down the interstitial highway veers
back to reality, so I will not quote further except to note that there may be
some interesting results from these findings that have nothing to do with TCPM. 
One of the potential applications is the spread of cancer or infections. As an
aside, intra-abdominal abscesses tend to form in the right upper quadrant
between the liver and diaphragm and very rarely in the left upper quadrant
between the spleen and diaphragm. I was always taught it was because the RUQ has
the lowest pressure, but that seemed inadequate to me. Using the interstitium
flow as their highway may be a more valid explanation if that is where the flow 
goes. Better than saying the RUQ sucks.

Unexplained is how the semi-random placement of needles into collagen and water 
will treat virtually any disease, from pain to allergies to migraines, all with 
different anatomy and physiology. And how does the interstitium explain the near
infinite varieties of acupuncture: Japanese, Korean, foot, hand, ear, head and 
the stupidest of the stupid, Tong Ren. Cause it can’t. Cause acupuncture is
fictional.

I have to admit it flabbers my gaster that this article was written by a
pulmonary and critical care physician and an associate professor of medicine. At
my hospitals the critical care docs were among the most hard-ass evidence
driven in the system. I cannot see where the author has ever written, studied or
practiced acupuncture. He does not appear to be a true believer. I suspect this
is the typical hubris of physicians who think their expertise in one area of
medicine translates into another, in this case acupuncture. The author likely
came across something like Is the Newly Described Interstitial Network the
Anatomical Basis of Acupuncture Meridians? A Commentary and credulously ran with
it. The result is the usual Dunning-Kruger superficial and gullible
understanding of acupuncture that the NYT essay manifests. Safe to say he is not
a regular reader of this blog.

The interstitium is the latest of many bandwagons to try and explain the
unexplainable. Always remember that the diagnosis (based on examination of the
tongue and pulse) and treatment of disease in TCPM is divorced from reality and,
as such, will continue to try, and fail, to justify its existence with
incomparable reality.

And why does this crap get into the NYT? The editor of the NYT newsletter, the
Morning, said in reference to the above

Acupuncture works, of course. The studies are clear. People seek it out for
treatment of all sorts of ills, from chronic pain and migraines to anxiety and
insomnia.

Is it some variation of “quack magnetism” – the tendency of people and
institutions who buy into one conspiracy or pseudoscience to promote many, or
even all, of them? Or a new version of homeopathy: like deludes like? Birds of a
feather and all that. Or maybe they used the Halupedia for research, although
humans have never needed AI to hallucinate nonsense.

Whatever the reason, the result is embarrassing for the writer and the
publisher.


A very special issue of Medical Acupuncture

David Gorski on April 22, 2013

Link


Every so often, our “friends” on the other side of the science aisle (i.e., the 
supporters of “complementary and alternative medicine”—otherwise known as CAM or
“integrative medicine”) give me a present when I’m looking for a topic for my
weekly bit of brain droppings about medicine, science, and/or why CAM is
neither. It’s also been a while since I’ve written about this particular
subject; so it’s a win-win for all sides! I get a topic. A certain CAM journal
gets extra traffic. And you get the benefit of my usually brilliant
deconstruction of dubious science. What could go wrong? I mean, I might not be
Mark Crislip, but I do enjoy a good dive into a pile of pseudoscience every now 
and then. It’s just a weird trait of mine.

In any case, there is a journal called Medical Acupuncture. Sadly, it’s
published by a real scientific publisher, Mary Ann Liebert, Inc., a publisher
that has a stable of decent, if not top tier, journals. Unfortunately, it also
has a stable of CAM journals, including, of course, the aforementioned journal
Medical Acupuncture. Because I happen to be on the mailing list for Mary Ann
Liebert, Inc., I recently got an e-mail with an announcement:

How Does Acupuncture Work? The Science behind the Therapy Is Explored in a
Special Issue of Medical Acupuncture

   New Rochelle, NY, April 16, 2013—Even as medical acupuncture is increasingly 
   being validated as an effective treatment for a broad range of medical
   conditions, what has been missing is an understanding of the basic science
   and mechanisms of action of this age-old method of healing. A special issue
   of Medical Acupuncture, a peer-reviewed journal published by Mary Ann
   Liebert, Inc., publishers presents a series of articles by authors from
   around the world who provide diverse and insightful perspectives on the
   science and physiologic responses underlying medical acupuncture. The issue
   is available free on the Medical Acupuncture website.

   “Understanding acupuncture in the same manner that we understand the
   mechanism of action and pharmacokinetics of a particular drug will,
   similarly, enable us to match treatments better with conditions,” states
   Guest Editor Richard F. Hobbs, III, MD. “The net effect will be improved
   outcomes,” he writes in his editorial “Basic Science Matters.”

The beauty of this gift to me is that not only can I write about the contents of
this issue, but the articles are available for free; so you can read them too. 
No paywalls! One wonders what possessed the editors of this particular journal
to provide such an awesome gift to both me and you, our readers.

In any case, I would certainly agree that basic science matters. After all,
that’s the whole point of science-based medicine (SBM), isn’t it? That
evidence-based medicine (EBM) in its current incarnation relegates basic science
considerations to the lowest rung of evidence on its hierarchy of clinical
evidence. Indeed, I spent quite some time talking about just that in my talk to 
the National Capital Area Skeptics a month and a half ago. Basically, EBM
suffers from what I like to refer to as “methodolatry,” which an epidemiologist 
fellow blogger defined as the “profane worship of the randomized clinical trial 
as the only valid method of investigation. Indeed, the gods of EBM, namely the
reviewers for the Cochrane Collaborative, are particularly prone to
methodolatry. Indeed, one of the key points we at SBM try to make is that this
sort of methodolatry provides and opening for pseudoscientific treatment
modalities like acupuncture to gain the appearance of efficacy in some parts of 
the medical literature. Basic science considerations are, in essence, ignored in
determining whether there is sufficient prior scientific plausibility of
acupuncture to treat, for instance, infertility or depression, and equivocal,
bias-prone clinical trials are ranked much higher than the basic science
considerations that make the hypothesis that acupuncture can do anything for
infertility so implausible as to border on impossible, barring new evidence
speaking to its plausibility.

Of course, in a way acupuncture is a special case. I’ve said it before, and I’ll
say it again (at the risk of boring my readers): I actually used to think that 
maybe there was something to acupuncture, for the simple reason that it involves
an actual physical act on the human body, namely sticking needles into it. On a
strictly conceptual level, one can speculate that maybe sticking needles into
the skin does something. However, the more I read about acupuncture, the more I 
delved into the actual scientific literature purporting to support acupuncture, 
the more I realized that there’s no “there” there, even from studies done by
advocates, in which negative or equivocal results are almost uniformly spun to
be supportive of acupuncture, and mechanisms that probably have little to do
with any purported effects of acupuncture. The “adenosine” mechanism I wrote
about three years ago comes to mind. The bottom line when it comes to
acupuncture is that it’s almost certainly all placebo. It doesn’t matter where
you stick the needles. In other words, acupuncture “meridians” are nonsense,
which is not surprising, given that attempts to associate any real anatomical
structures to meridians have uniformly failed. It doesn’t even matter if the
needles are stuck in; twirling toothpicks against the skin does just as well,
dubious systematic reviews of acupuncture not withstanding.

So let’s see what Dr. Hobbes, who is based at Plum Blossom Acupuncture and
Integrative Medicine, a clinic that offers woo ranging from acupuncture to
cupping to moxibustion, has to say about how “basic science matters“:

   Medical acupuncture is a part of medicine and is being validated,
   increasingly, as an effective treatment for a wide range of conditions.1
   However, for the most part, we are missing the foundation, the basic science 
   piece. This is a deficiency which, in my view, we must correct. Understanding
   acupuncture in the same manner that we understand the mechanism of action
   and pharmacokinetics of a particular drug will, similarly, enable us to match
   treatments better with conditions. The net effect will be improved outcomes.

   How does one define “basic science” in the field of acupuncture? There are
   traditional paradigms that many of us use every day in treating patients, and
   then there are views that are informed by those subjects we studied in
   medical school. So far, efforts to “connect the dots” have not been
   completely successful. However, progress is being made, and once that goal is
   achieved, the sharp lines of demarcation between Western and Oriental
   medicine will disappear.

   For this special issue, we encouraged the submission of exemplary studies or 
   comprehensive review articles dealing with research methodologies, physical
   properties of points and channels, signaling mechanisms, and mechanisms of
   acupuncture effects.

Apparently, Dr. Hobbes has a different definition of what constitutes “exemplary
studies” or “comprehensive review articles” than I do. For instance, the
article he cites to support his claim that acupuncture is being increasingly
“validated as an effective treatment” for a wide range of (I note, unrelated)
conditions is Vickers et al, a systematic review that has been a chew toy of
various SBM bloggers, including Steve Novella, Mark Crislip, and myself.
Basically, Vickers et al was an article that found a “statistically significant”
but clearly clinically insignificant difference between pain scores in sham
control versus acupuncture-treated patients with chronic pain syndromes, as I
discussed in inordinate detail. If this is “clinical validation,” then we should
cease all acupuncture studies right now as a pointless waste of money that
unethically subject patients to risk with no likelihood of benefit! Amusingly,
just a month and a half ago Andrew J. Vickers, the first author of the review,
published a followup rebuttal in (of course!) a CAM journal in which he whined
about how those nasty, nasty “skeptics” (he even used the term “sceptics
movement” in full U.K. spelling) were so unfair in their criticisms, singling
out Steve Novella, a blogger who also wrote about the study under the ‘nym
askeptic, and my alter-ego for particular opprobrium.

But let’s look at the rest of what Dr. Hobbes wrote. Truly, it could very well
have qualified for Kimball Atwood’s much missed feature, the Weekly Waluation of
the Weasel Words of Woo. I particularly like the part where he contrasts the
“traditional paradigms that many of us use every day in treating patients”
versus the “views that are informed by those subjects we studied in medical
school.” Notice how he refers to his beliefs about “acupuncture” as “paradigms” 
and what he was taught in medical school about the science that says that
acupuncture is pseudoscience as “views.” It’s a simultaneously subtle (if you’re
not familiar with CAM weasel words) and not-so-subtle (if you are) denigration 
of scientific medicine. I also like how he uses what I consider to be the racist
distinction between “Western” medicine (i.e., evidence- and science-based
medicine) and “Oriental” medicine (i.e., traditional Chinese medicine).
Seriously, does he even realize the implication he’s making, namely that
“Western” medicine is scientific and “Oriental medicine” is touchy-feeling and
“holistic”? Doesn’t he realize that there are some damned good “Oriental”
scientists, every bit on par with “Western” scientists, and that they have come 
to the same conclusion, namely that acupuncture is placebo?

So let’s take a look at some of these studies and review articles. The first one
that caught my eye was one by John Longhurst, MD, PhD of the Samueli Center for
Integrative Medicine at the University of California, Irvine, entitled
Acupuncture’s Cardiovascular Actions: A Mechanistic Perspective. Dr. Longhurst
begins:

   The practice of acupuncture began 2000–3000 years ago. Until the last 50
   years, acupuncture developed empirically and its art was passed on from
   teacher to student through practical application. More recently,
   practitioners began to find that acupuncture had a rightful place in
   mainstream medicine and could be used to treat a number of conditions and
   symptoms. The public outside the Orient has accepted acupuncture because of a
   perception that it reduces pain effectively and successfully reverses a
   number of other medical problems. Western medical and scientific communities 
   have been more reluctant to accept this practice because of the absence of
   controlled clinical trials and scant scientific evidence for its mechanisms
   of action. However, there may be reason for this skepticism to change. The
   number of articles published on acupuncture research (451 articles worldwide 
   in 2009) has been increasing almost exponentially over the last several
   decades, with the United States and China both taking lead roles in advancing
   understanding of this ancient therapy.1

Don’t you just love the argumentum ad populum (appeal to popularity)? The point 
is that, because there are now lots of articles on acupuncture and the number
has been increasing, it must mean there is something to acupuncture. Never mind 
that the vast majority of articles are of low quality and that the higher the
quality of the research the more likely the findings are to be negative, just
like homeopathy. Then there’s also the “appeal to antiquity,” which argues or
implies that, just because people have been doing something for a long time,
there must be something to it. I like to point out that bloodletting was viewed 
as an excellent treatment for almost any ailment for hundreds, if not thousands 
of years, before the late 19th century, when the rise of scientific medicine
showed that it was not.

One thing I noticed about this review article right away is that nearly all the 
studies it discussed were about electroacupuncture (EA). This is, in my mind, a 
classic “bait and switch,” in which therapy is described as acupuncture but is
in reality nothing more than electrical nerve stimulation clumsily grafted onto 
acupuncture. One might reasonably expect that electrical stimulation of certain 
nerves might have physiological effects. For instance, anyone who’s ever
undergone a nerve conduction study, as I have, know this. (It’s a study that
could easily be used as torture, let me tell you.) The very basis of nerve
conduction is electrochemical, and it can be influenced by electrical currents. 
That doesn’t make it acupuncture. Worse, the insistence of using acupuncture
points, instead of nerves that might actually have physiological relevance, only
muddies the waters, making it less likely that an actual, useful therapy might 
be derived from the mix of electricity and the vitalism of traditional Chinese
medicine that is “electroacupuncture.” Basically, it’s nothing more than a
“rebranding” of acupuncture, which doesn’t work, by disguising something that
might work (electrical nerve stimulation) as somehow being acupuncture. After
all, the Chinese of hundreds (or thousands) of years ago who supposedly invented
acupuncture did not have knowledge of electricity, nor did they have the
technology to construct batteries or generators. Personally, I think that it’s
telling that in many places I saw references to “acupuncture,” but when I
clicked on the citations to support the claim I found papers on EA. Indeed, the 
authors even point out that they focus on EA because “this form of acupuncture
is easy to standardize.” No kidding. And they should stop calling EA
“acupuncture,” because it’s not.

Next up is an amusing little study from the New England School of Acupuncture,
led by a naturopath named Keith Spaulding, entitled Acupuncture Needle
Stimulation Induces Changes in Bioelectric Potential. It’s a study of 14 healthy
volunteers from ages 24 to 52 in which the investigators tried to tell if there
were differences in electrical potential attributable to acupuncture based on
needle positioning on “real” acupuncture sites and “sham” acupuncture sites:

   Randomized clinical trials (RCTs) of acupuncture often include stimulating
   verum acupoints and nearby so-called “sham” acupoints. Clinical effectiveness
   has been reported with both verum and sham stimulation. The verum
   acupuncture is often only marginally better than the sham acupuncture.6–8
   This leads researchers to question if sham acupuncture is indeed a
   physiologically inactive control placebo.9 An electrophysiological correlate 
   of these clinical findings would be eliciting from the sham acupuncture at a 
   nonacupoint a bioelectrical response that is nearly as strong as the
   bioelectrical response from stimulating a verum acupoint.

   The aim of this study was to document changes in the bioelectric potential
   that occur in response to needling Pericardium 4 (PC 4) and PC 4cont
   (control) at four sites on the forearm PC 4, a nearby nonacupuncture point
   (PC4cont) and two distal points (PC 6 and a nearby nonacupoint (PC 6cont) It 
   was hypothesized that a greater bioelectric potential amplitude was induced
   distal to the point of stimulation only when the needling site was on the
   acupuncture point and the distal measured site was on the meridian.

One notes that this was not a blinded study, which pretty much sinks it right
there. The acupuncturists knew who was getting what, and they decided the depth 
of insertion of the needles. They could easily have unconsciously inserted
needles into the “true” sites in a systematically different way than they did
for the “control” sites. Moreover, the placement of the reference electrode in
the umbilicus, by the authors’ own admission, produced a “noise floor” acting as
an artifact. Even with the lack of blinding, the results of this study are
completely underwhelming. Basically, the investigators found that when the PC4
site was stimulated there was a greater response compared to when a control site
(a non-accupoint) was stimulated, leading the authors to observe, “A
translation phenomenon (an induced polarization) was seen at the distal site
when the proximal site was stimulated. At PC 6 with PC 4 stimulated there was a 
larger amplitude (p<0.05), compared to the control response.” One notes that out
of three sets of comparisons, only one was statistically significantly
different, and then only with p=0.02. Also, since multiple comparisons were
being made (in reality, six sets, rather than three sets of two) one could argue
that an adjustment for multiple comparisons should have been made, which might 
have made the single result obtained no longer statistically significant. Be
that as it may, this is hardly a “highly rigorous” study and basically
demonstrates nothing.

The remaining studies were even less “interesting.” For instance, there was a
study of “laser acupuncture” in depression. (Whenever I hear the term “laser”
attached to acupuncture, I can’t help but think of Dr. Evil demanding to have
“sharks with frickin’ laser beams attached to their heads,” but that’s just me.)
This study looked at functional MRI imaging of patients with and without
depression subjected to laser acupuncture on four putative antidepressant
acupoints, and concluded:

   Laser acupuncture on LR 8, LR 14, and CV 14 stimulated both the anterior and 
   posterior DMN in both the nondepressed and depressed participants. However,
   in the nondepressed participants, there was consistently outstanding
   modulation of the anterior DMN at the medial frontal gyrus across all three
   acupoints. In the depressed participants, there was wider posterior DMN
   modulation at the parieto–temporal–limbic cortices. This is part of the
   antidepressant effect of laser acupuncture.

There’s one problem. (Well, there are a lot of problems, but this is the most
glaring.) Nowhere could I find out whether the analysis of the fMRI images was
blinded; i.e., nowhere does it say whether the radiologists analyzing the images
knew which patients were depressed or not or which image series represented
patients receiving “real” acupuncture versus sham. Given how finicky
interpreting fMRI studies can be and how easily they can show something where
there is nothing, blinding of the radiologists analyzing an fMRI study is
essential. That’s at a minimum, not even including whether the patients or the
practitioners were blinded or not. One would think that if the fMRIs were
analyzed in a blinded fashion that the investigators would have mentioned it; so
I have to assume that they were not.

Perhaps the most hilariously pointless study in the group was done by a group in
Germany and entitled Transcontinental High-Tech Teleacupuncture Studies and
Integrative Laser Medicine. Wow. That sure sounds science-y, doesn’t it. Very
impressive. But what the heck does it mean? Basically, the investigators studied
subjects in China undergoing laser acupuncture therapy and “integrative laser
therapy” (whatever that means), as well as EA and regular acupuncture, and had
the subjects’ electrocardiogram readings transmitted to their facility in
Germany at the Medical University of Graz, where they were analyzed. Quite
honestly, this is about as pointless a use of telemedicine as I can imagine, and
it’s not even that sophisticated. I mean, really. We’re doing telesurgery over 
thousands of miles now, and all these investigators could do is to transmit ECG 
data from China to Germany?

I’m not impressed.

There are other articles, of course, all of about the same level of scientific
rigor or less. None of them validate acupuncture in any way or provide any
compelling evidence for a physiologically plausible mechanism, all of which
makes the introduction by Richard C. Niemtzow, MD, PhD, MPH (yes, that Richard
C. Niemtzow, the one who has promoted “battlefield acupuncture” for our troops
in combat), entitled Basic Science: Mysteries and Mechanisms of Acupuncture, all
the more cringe-inducing. First of all, it’s quite telling that Niemtzow begins
with a quote from Hamlet (Act 1, Scene V), “There are more things in heaven and
earth, Horatio,than are dreamt of in your philosophy.” It’s a Shakespeare quote
that quacks love as a means of claiming that science can’t study their
quackery. Ironically enough, Niemtzow uses it to introduce a short article in
which he tries to paint himself as a hopeless dinosaur dedicated to science:

   Every day, acupuncturists insert tiny metal needles into acupuncture points
   located on meridians, hoping to combat a myriad of clinical pathologies. For 
   the most part, we practitioners are witness to a clinical benefit. Otherwise,
   physicians would have stopped performing this technique several thousand
   years ago, and we would not be using it today. However, while we witness
   healing, none of us has ever seen an acupuncture point let alone a meridian. 
   Modern investigational technology, at its best, fails to provide evidence of 
   these two very basic structures.

One notes that the obvious conclusion from this summary of the existing evidence
regarding acupuncture meridians and points is that they do not exist. Somehow, 
Niemtzow fails to take the logical next step to that conclusion. Instead, he
writes:

   With this in mind, I know that many of us have asked: “How does acupuncture
   work?” Perhaps we depended, somewhat, on mythical explanations influenced by 
   the classic readings. When I hypothesized Western mechanisms that might offer
   an explanation, I was told, by one of my esteemed colleagues, that
   acupuncture does not follow Newtonian physics. I thought, perhaps, that was
   an excuse to avoid “drilling” deeper to uncover the same mechanisms that
   enriched our understanding of allopathic medicine. My wife, who was trained
   in acupuncture in China, told me that exploring acupuncture on a molecular
   level to seek an explanation as to “how it works” is, somewhat, a fallacy.
   She posited that, to understand acupuncture, one most [sic] explore its
   relationships to the environment, animal and plant life, weather, seasons,
   and the universe. However, I have to admit that I am an “old die hard”; for
   me, natural events do have scientific explanations and placing a needle in an
   acupuncture point on a meridian and producing a physiological effect could
   be understood by using the scientific technology used to understand
   allopathic medicine.

Good for you, Dr. Niemtzow! Maybe there’s hope for you yet! Or maybe not. In a
way, Dr. Niemtzow reminds me of one of the past presidents of the American
Association of Naturopathic Physicians, Carl Hangee-Bauer, ND, LAc (note that
he’s an acupuncturist as well), taking umbrage at criticisms of naturopathy as
unscientific and then declaring his allegiance to rigorous science, even though 
his practice is rife with what I consider to be pseudoscience, such as
traditional Chinese medicine, “biotherapeutic drainage,” detoxification, and
others, as well as unproven modalities such as breast thermography. “Science,”
Dr. Niemtzow. You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think
it means. (Hint: It does not mean acupuncture.)

Amusingly, in that same editorial, Dr. Niemtzow admits that “a collection of
high-quality basic science articles is very difficult to obtain, given the fact 
that, over the years, we have received and only published a few articles on this
topic.” One wonders why not. Could it be because we’re dealing with
acupuncture? Sure it could. In any case, it’s hard not to feel a little bit
sorry for Dr. Niemtzow. He thinks he’s scientific, while his wife in reality
provides a closer approximation of what real acupuncturists think. He also
thinks he’s scientifically studying acupuncture, when in fact what he is doing
is curating articles designed to validate the treatment rather than to see if
there really is anything to it from a scientific standpoint. That fundamental
tension makes me wonder when he’ll just give up and let his true proclivities
rule.

                               Animal acupuncture

                                  David Ramey

                                      Link

Periodically, one sees newspaper articles extolling the virtues of acupuncture
for animals. To those familiar with the practice of acupuncture, the tag lines
are nauseatingly familiar, e.g., acupuncture has been around for thousands of
years, it works to stimulate the animal’s natural energies, etc., etc. Ditto the
testimonials; Fluffy wasn’t helped by anything else; now, after a few months of
treatment (and plenty of time), Fluffy is running around happily. Some may even
take such testimony further, asserting, for example, with some rather tortured 
logic, that since acupuncture “works” in animals, and animals aren’t thought to 
be susceptible to placebo effects, then acupuncture must therefore work in
people.

In fact, other than testimonials, there’s really no good evidence that
acupuncture does work in animals. In fact, acupuncture isn’t much practiced in
veterinary medicine – a distinct (but very vocal) minority of veterinarians may 
practice it. In fact, the most recent review on the management of canine
arthritis concluded, “There was weak or no evidence in support of the use of”
various modalities, including electrostimulated acupuncture and gold wire
acupuncture,”1 and a recent study of electroacupuncture for postoperative pain
after back surgery in dogs concluded that there was “equivocal evidence” for an 
effect, even though there was no difference in analgesics used between treatment
and control groups.2

So, what’s with the newspaper articles? Most scientifically minded people are
familiar with the problems that beset testimonial evidence, so there’s little
reason to repeat them here. But I don’t think that most people – and especially 
newspaper reporters – have any idea of the distortions, half-truths, and flat
out lies that have been advanced in support of animal acupuncture.

First off, acupuncture has not been used in animals for thousands of years; at
least if one defines acupuncture as involving the use of fine needles at
specific points, and surely if one is interested in written evidence (Chinese
writing is about 2500 years old). That’s not to say that the Chinese didn’t do
things at points on the animal’s body; they certainly did, just like most every 
other ancient culture from which there are records. But such interventions were 
bleeding and cautery, and if one includes lancets to cause bleeding as
acupuncture, then while acupunture is an ancient practice, it didn’t start in
China, and it didn’t involve “qi” and all of the other metaphysical trappings of
the practice. In fact, there’s absolutely no history at all of anyone –
including the Chinese – using fine needles to treat animals until well into the 
20th century.

Acupuncture points also haven’t been shown to exist in animals (or people, for
that matter). In fact, the acupuncture charts devised for animals are inventions
of the 20th century, made by “transposing” one of the myriad human charts
directly onto animals. That’s one reason why horses have a “gall bladder”
meridian (putative channels which connect acupuncture points, which also haven’t
been shown to exist), even though they don’t have a gall bladder. But, when it 
comes to animal acupuncture, there’s apparently no absurdity sufficiently large 
to cause practitioners any embarrassment.

Although not nearly as extensively as in human medicine, acupuncture has been
studied in animals. Looking over the results, one can occasionally find positive
studies, especially if the studies have been poorly designed. There have been
two reviews on veterinary acupuncture. One, looking at the evidence across all
animal species, concluded that there wasn’t enough compelling evidence to either
support or refute the practice3; the other, in horses, concluded that there
wasn’t good evidence to support the practice, and that the best studies were
uniformly negative.4

In spite of the fact that no good evidence to support the practice of animal
acupuncture has emerged in the several decades in which it has been proposed
(roughly coinciding with the emergence of interest in human medicine in the
early 1970s), there are for profit ventures that will “certify” veterinarians to
practice acupuncture, such as the “Chi Institute” in Florida, or the
International Veterinary Acupuncture Society. None of the certifications offered
by these organizations is recognized by the Board of Specialities of the
American Veterinary Medical Association, presumably because such recognition
depends on the ability to demonstrate a body of scientific support.

Veterinary acupuncture is a triumph of style over substance. Fortunately, most
veterinarians haven’t succumbed to offering needless needles to animals, in
spite of the fact that there are apparently some people eager for such
“options.” But when you read the next article extolling the virtues of the
practice, keep in mind that you’re reading a level of journalism commensurate
with what’s seen on the entertainment pages, information that has essentially
nothing to do with good science.

REFERENCES:

1. Sanderson RO, Beata C, Flipo RM, Genevois JP, Macias C, Tacke S, Vezzoni A,
Innes JF. Systematic Review of the Management of Canine Arthritis. Vet Rec. 2009
Apr 4;164(14):418-24.

2. Laim A, Jaggy A, Forterre F, et al. Effects of adjunct electroacupuncture on 
severity of postoperative pain in dogs undergoing hemilaminectomy because of
acute thoracolumbar intervertebral disk disease. J Am Vet Med Assoc, 2009;
234(9): 1141-6.

3. Habacher, G, Pittler, MH, Ernst, E. Effectiveness of acupuncture in
veterinary medicine: systematic review. J Vet Intern Med 2006; 20(3):480-8.

4. Ramey, DW, Lee, M and Messer, NT. “A Review of the Western Veterinary
Literature on Equine Acupuncture.” J Eq Vet Sci, 2001; 21(2): 56 – 60.

New Developments in Acupuncture: Turtles and Motion-Style Treatments

Harriet Hall on June 4, 2013

Link


Note: Lest you think that SBM is becoming “turtles all the way down,”   let me
apologize for the duplication and explain that I had already written this right 
before I read Mark Crislip’s Turtle Agony article on Friday.   My focus is
different, and turtles were only a small part of my article, so I decided to
leave the turtles in. If you prefer to avoid a turtle overdose, you can just
skip the Turtlepuncture section and go on to the Motion Style Acupuncture
section. They are clearly labeled for your convenience.

The “science” of acupuncture trudges ever onward without really getting
anywhere. New developments include a report of turtlepuncture  and a study about
treating low back pain with a new kind of “motion style” acupuncture using
passive or active movement while the needles are in place. I found the first
amusing and the second unconvincing.

Turtlepuncture 

A group of Ridley sea turtles were rescued after being stranded during a cold
spell that left them hypothermic and unable to function. In addition to the
usual rescue and rehabilitation efforts, two of the turtles, Dexter and Fletcher
Moon, were treated with acupuncture. It was intended to  “decrease inflammation
and swelling on their front flippers, restore a full range of motion on those
limbs and help the animals regain their appetites.” It allegedly worked: their
appetite and the use of their limbs improved. But without any controlled
observations, this is only an anecdotal report and means very little. They might
have recovered just as well without the treatment, for all we know.

I searched for studies on turtle acupuncture. I found studies on the miraculous 
turtle eight meridians method, the eight methods of intelligent turtle, turtle
probing needling, green turtle searching and boring acupuncture, the
extraordinary turtle flying method, and turtle probing the cave needle
manipulation, and one case report of treating an American red-footed tortoise.
Nothing on treating turtles.

How did they know where to put the needles? They worked with a veterinarian to
find analogies between the anatomy of turtles and other animals. And acupuncture
points in animals are based on analogies with humans, sometimes with amusing
results: diagrams for horse acupuncture show a gall bladder meridian but horses 
don’t have gall bladders!

I’m glad the turtles got better, but I don’t give acupuncture the credit.

Motion Style Acupuncture

A Korean study was published in the journal Pain.  It was a multicenter,
randomized, controlled, comparative effectiveness trial with a total of 58
patients with acute low back pain. It compared one session of motion style
acupuncture to one injection of diclofenac. Patients in the acupuncture group
improved more than those in the diclofenac group.

What Is It? The authors tell us that motion style acupuncture treatment (MSAT)
is a relatively novel method that has been recently used increasingly often in
South Korea, but the only reference they offer refers to two case reports. In
their MSAT protocol, two assistants stood on both sides of the patient with
their arms around his waist. Acupuncture needles were inserted at points
selected according to Traditional Chinese Medicine and previous clinical
experience. The deqi sensation was not sought, but practitioners “occasionally” 
manually stimulated the needle at the GV16 point. With the needles in place, the
patients were asked to walk with assistance. As walking improved, less support 
was provided. When the patient was walking without support, the needles were
removed and he was asked to continue walking for 1-2 minutes. The patients were 
given verbal encouragement.

Why Diclofenac? The comparison treatment was a 75 mg intramuscular injection of 
diclofenac sodium,  a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug or NSAID. The
rationale for choosing it as a comparison was unclear. NSAIDs have been proven
effective for acute low back pain, but they are usually given orally. A recent
view of acute low back pain treatment does not mention the IM option.  Neither
does the Mayo Clinic website.   I couldn’t find any sources that recommended IM 
administration over the oral route. I’m guessing they chose it for this study
because it was a convenient way to give one strong, rapidly acting dose for
comparison with one acupuncture treatment.

Results. Pain was assessed on a scale according to subjective patient
self-reports, and disability was assessed by a questionnaire at 30 min, 2 weeks,
4 weeks and 24 weeks after treatment. The outcomes were significantly better
for MSAT for the earlier times but not at 24 weeks.

Does This Really Support Acupuncture?  They called this a comparative
effectiveness trial. Comparative effectiveness trials are typically used to
compare established interventions to see which of two effective treatments is
more effective. They are not intended to explore a new, untested treatment like 
MSAT. There are problems with this study. The subjects were Koreans who may have
been culturally predisposed to expect results from acupuncture. Endpoints were 
subjective. Blinding was not possible. Instead of a single treatment and an
atypical control, it would have been better to compare typical MSAT treatment to
standard conventional treatment of low back pain.

What bothers me the most is that the MSAT group essentially got two treatments: 
acupuncture and assisted mobilization. I’d like to know what would happen if
they got the second without the first. Maybe the needles were superfluous.

Patients with acute back pain avoid walking because it hurts. If they avoid
using the muscles due to fear of pain, they can become conditioned to expect
pain. Often they have severe pain when they first start walking, but if they can
keep walking the pain tends to diminish. Patients who remain active recover
faster; that’s why bed rest is no longer recommended. And a recent study showed 
statistically and clinically significant benefit from cognitive functional
therapy. This involves re-framing and confidence-building as described here.

So what if all back pain patients were encouraged to walk and were assisted with
the support and cheerleading? This acupuncture study would have been a far
better study if it had included a motion-style treatment control group without
the acupuncture component: MST instead of MSAT.

Conclusion

Color me skeptical. I question the use of acupuncture on turtles and on
non-chelonian patients with acute back pain. The evidence doesn’t support it.
I’m optimistic that assisted walking with physical support and encouragement
might prove to be an effective treatment for patients with acute low back pain. 
I hope further studies will investigate that.

People Encouraging Turtle Agony*: Animal Acupuncture

Mark Crislip on May 31, 2013

Link

Lest anyone think I am a heartless bastard, I would like it to be known that I
do not like to see any creature suffer or die. I am the kind of person who, when
finding a spider in the house, is likely to catch it and toss it outside. I
always think, “I can’t squish the end result of 6 billion years of evolution”.
Except mosquitoes. Those I squish with glee. Infection vectors can die die die
die.

I like animals and hate to see them suffer unnecessarily. Like sticking them
with needles. Frontal lobes are nice to have. They can let you know that pain is
coming and provide preparation and compensation. Once I had a steel bar smack
me on the head, opening up a six-inch cut to the bone. No, my brain was not
affected, thank you very much. Everything predates the head trauma. When the ER 
doc numbed the scalp for sutures, he missed the last half-inch and I felt the
needle. Knowing what was going on I steeled myself and let him do the last two
sutures with no lidocaine, since the needle hurt only a little worse than the
lidocaine injection. I have had many other unpleasant medical procedures in my
56 years but knowing what was coming and understanding why makes it easier to
tolerate a needle popping into the knee joint or an abdominal drain being
pulled.

Animals, and young humans, lack the ability to comprehend the what and why of
pain inflicted as part of medicine. Adults can make a conscious decision to be
endure pain and fool themselves into thinking it is of benefit. No pain, no
gain. Animals can make no such choice.

For example consider sea turtles, who, apparently, are subjected to all sorts of
nonsense at the New England Aquarium including acupuncture and laser therapy.
As is obvious, I am no veterinarian, the only animal of which I have any
understanding of anatomy and physiology is a human, but even with that
background it is remarkable what is reported from New England. I used to say the
‘B’ students went into journalism; given the credulous reporting perhaps the
standards have been lowered. They certainly have for marine biologists and
veterinarians, who are evidently shortchanged in their education.

Several hundred sea turtles were washed ashore in New England after a severe
storm. Hypothermic, injured, infected and malnourished, they were transferred to
the New England Aquarium for care. It sounds like the animals were quite ill.

Some animals were not getting better rapidly enough with conventional medicine. 
Conventional medicine: based on known reality. The application of physiology,
biochemistry, anatomy, epidemiology, etc to disease that has led to astounding
increases in life expectancy and relief from innumerable diseases that plagued
humankind.

So they decided to inflict a pair of fantasy based, I mean alternative,
therapies on some of the turtles. Alternative: not based on physiology,
biochemistry, anatomy, epidemiology, and has never had an impact on any
important disease, ever.

At first I read the headline (with the obligatory pun) “Slow pokes: Acupuncture 
helps hypothermic turtles” as the acupuncture was being used to help
hypothermia, which made me laugh. Turtle thermoregulation is complex but just
moving them from the cold sea to a warm lab should raise their temperature. But 
then I realized I misinterpreted the headline. Acupuncture was being used as
ineffective therapy for conditions other than hypothermia.

To summarize acupuncture, a topic discussed at length in this blog, its basic
principles, those of meridians and chi, are fictional. I tried to find a
meridian map of turtles and failed. I found a pig, a cat, a dog, a cow and a
horse diagram, but no turtle. Not that it matters, since the meridians are
fantasy. The horse, which has no gallbladder, does have a gallbladder meridian, 
although it conveniently has nothing to do with the gallbladder:

   Although the horse does not have a gall bladder organ as such, the meridian
   is the same as in the human, and it has a lot to do with the integrity of
   ligaments especially in the hips and pelvis.

Like I said. Fantasy anatomy and physiology.

I note again that on every human and animal acupuncture map there are no
meridians or puncture points in the genitalia. Ironically no important life
energy runs through the reproductive organs, perhaps explaining why there is no 
acupuncture-based (or alternative therapy of any kind for that matter) birth
control, although a few needles in the genitalia could certainly have a negative
effect on reproduction.

Acupuncture does not have any effect on physiological processes outside of those
that determine perception. It doesn’t matter where you put the needles, or even
if you use needles. Twirled toothpicks have the same effect. Acupuncture only
has effects on subjective outcomes and only then if the receiver is a believer
and thinks they are receiving acupuncture. I am always amused by those who note 
sticking a needle into flesh yields a pain response:

   The mechanisms underlying pain relief from insertion of needles are unknown, 
   but it has been suggested that it may involve recruitment of the body’s own
   pain reduction system, possibly attended by an increased release of
   endorphins, serotonin, norepinephrine, or gamma-aminobutyric acid.

Gee, acupuncture does cause the physiologic effects one would expect from the
noxious stimuli of being poked with a needle. Or hitting one’s toe with a
hammer.

Acupuncture does not, as the report says,

   …reduce stress, increase blood flow and boost the immune system.

Can an animal have a response to a therapy whose entire result is dependent on
higher-level cognitive functions that convince the receiver they are improved?
The same effect as your mother kissing your injury to make it better? I am,
well, skeptical.

In the photographs the turtle looks nonplussed, although they appear to be
holding the poor animal so it cannot escape. But then, every turtle in every
picture looks nonplussed. Expressive faces are not in the reptilian repertoire. 
Usually. Not like some dogs who, to my anthropomorphizing eye, do not look happy
being stuck with needles.

I am a very ill turtle. Infected, injured, starving. I have been hauled out of
my usual environment, taken out of the water, held down on a table by enormous
creatures who are sticking me with needles. I would think that the turtle would,
in its tiny ‘I don’t want to get eaten’ brain’, be having the turtle equivalent
of NONONONONONONONONO I DON’T WANT TO DIE.

But that’s probably just me who thinks perhaps the whole process of worthless
needling would only be stressful for the turtle.

The turtle gets combined reality and fantasy based therapies and gets better,
the fantasy based therapy gets some of the credit:

   Dexter and Fletcher Moon have already had three acupuncture sessions,
   scheduled once a week, said Merigo, who broke into a broad smile as she
   described their improvements over the past three weeks.

   “These two turtles really had very limited limb use and they weren’t eating. 
   We are seeing improved limb use and improved appetite,” Merigo said. “They
   are eating on their own, which is fantastic.”

   McManus, the acupuncturist, was restrained when describing her reaction to
   the results.

   “It makes me feel very happy,” McManus said. “Acupuncture is not alternative 
   to conventional medicine – they are also receiving Western treatments as
   well, but the fact that it can work in conjunction with the other treatments 
   they are getting makes me very happy.”

Although the stress of being punctured may have slowed their recovery, it is the
usual mistake of crediting effects where there is none.

It was nice that, unlike most acupuncturists, animal and human, the practitioner
is using gloves, although everyone appears to wear gloves when handling the
turtles.

I am extrapolating from humans and am probably in error when applying what I
know to turtles. When humans have severe pneumonia or other severe infectious
diseases or trauma, like these turtles, the inflammatory response may be
followed by an anti-inflammatory response. A week or two into their
hospitalization, a patient may have an increased risk of infection, not only
from all the interventions but also because they are at an immune nadir. The
greater the initial insult, the greater the subsequent immune dysfunction and
risk of infection. Stress is bad.

Take the stress of the initial insult, the infections and malnutrition, being
held down and poked with needles and then, with new holes in your hide, being
tossed in bacteria-laden salt water. Can’t be good.

Years ago I was sitting in the wards of a hospital in LA when a patient started 
yelling in pain. The surgeon had ordered sugar for an open wound and the
cafeteria had sent up salt by mistake, making the aphorism all too real. I doubt
the needles were causing enough damage to the hide to sting when placed back in
the salt water, nor to allow the bacteria in the water a chance to find a toe
hold (pili hold?) but who can say? Yertle ain’t talking and, like all turtles
all the time, looks unfazed.

The preponderance of data suggests that acupuncture effects are almost entirely 
in the mind of the beholder. The well-designed studies demonstrate that the
effects are due almost entirely to bias and are clinically trivial. A placebo
effect, the archetype of which was in Penn and Teller’s episode on magnetism. A 
gutter downspout was bent into the shape of a giant magnet and guess what? The
patient had an effect from the fake therapy. That is the basic mechanism of all 
alternative medicine, including acupuncture.

I went searching the Pubmeds for animal clinical trials of acupuncture and found
little, although human trials are animal trials.

Acupuncture being the needling equivalent of faux magnets makes experiments and 
therapies on animals a little discomforting. There are many animal models for
acupuncture and I would wonder if they cross the ethical Rubicon. Is it OK to do
studies on animals when the prior plausibility of efficacy is as close to zero 
as one could want and well-done clinical trials show effects are limited to
higher cognitive abilities the animals lack? Is it OK to poke a turtle to induce
a marginal placebo effect when it lacks the higher functions to generate such
an effect? At some level are not all animal acupuncture studies animal abuse? I 
wonder.

Animal acupuncture raises other questions: are the rat, dog or turtle meridians 
the same as humans? If so, why? Genetics? Is the chi same? If so, why? Does a
species as evolutionarily removed from humans as a sea turtle have the same
response to acupuncture? Does the shell not have any acupuncture sites? If not, 
why not? It appears from the pictures on the web they only target the soft
structures. If human meridians map onto reptiles, are they not missing important
sites hidden under the shell, leading to misaligning the energy flow, like only
balancing two tires on a car? Of course, asking reality-based questions about
acupuncture is like asking about the genetic differences between Orcs, Elves,
and Hobbits. It is all fiction.

At some level I can understand trying acupuncture as it has a certain cachet in 
popular culture, albeit an undeserved one. Most people are not going to wander
to the pages of SBM looking for a critical appraisal of acupuncture. But lasers?
Really? Laser therapy is nuts, unless you like to get your therapeutic
interventions from advertising copy:

   When all the results were in it turned out this turtle has a systemic
   infection. We started treating for the infection but the swelling did not
   seem to diminish. As we continued the antibiotics we also started using a
   laser for the edema (swelling) of the joint area.

How does the laser therapy work?I found this at the Companion Therapy Laser
website:

   The Companion therapy laser system sends photons, or packets of light energy,
   deep into tissue without damaging it. These photons are absorbed within the 
   mitochondria of the cells and induce a chemical change called
   “photo-bio-modulation”. This light energy then inspires production of ATP in 
   the cell. ATP is the fuel, or energy, cells need for repair and rejuvenation.
   Impaired or injured cells do not make this fuel at an optimal rate.
   Increased ATP production leads to healthier cells, healthier tissue, and
   healthier animals.

Show of hands. Does this modified photosynthesis make sense to anyone? I guess
the biochemistry of turtles resembles plants more than I suspected. And why did 
it make sense to the veterinarians at the New England Aquarium?

The closest explanation I could find of this bizarro statement was:

   ATP production, according to Kremer’s research, is not based on chemical
   energy release, as taught in universities today, but rests on the absorption 
   of photons of light from the zero-point quantum medium.

Or for those who prefer their gibberish more science-y:

   Biochemistry and medical science have failed to this day to explain the
   function of the adenine groups of ATP as no biochemical reaction with this
   adenine ring molecule is shown. However, an understanding can be gained,
   within the framework of the cell symbiosis concept, from the biophysical
   attributes of light absorption of the adenine group. All essential components
   of mitochondrial cell respiration are light absorbing molecules with
   characteristic “frequency windows” of absorption maxima from nearly UV
   spectrum to the longer wave yellow/orange spectral range of visible light up 
   to ca. 600nm. Yet the source of the electromagnetic energy is not sunlight.
   In fact a low frequency pulsating electromagnetic field is induced by the
   constant flow of uncoupled, paramagnetic aligned electrons in the respiratory
   organelles. The electromotive power generated by this process is
   catalytically enormously strengthened by the enzyme complexes of the
   respiratory chain (acceleration factor1017). This effects an interaction
   between the electrons and the protons likewise aligned parallel to the
   induced magnetic field dependent on the strength of the magnetic field
   between the antiparallel aligned electrons and protons. This process produces
   a quantum dynamic transfer of information via photon exchange energy. The
   source of photons is ultimately fluctuations of resonance frequencies of the 
   physical vacuum (zero-point energy field). The transferred information is
   stored in the spin of the protons that proceed to the ATP synthesis complex
   via proton gradients. There the resonance information is transferred by a
   unique rotation system to the adenine group of ATP whose electrons can move
   freely in the alternating double bonds of the ring molecules. The ATP serves 
   as an “antennae molecule” for the reception and relaying of resonance
   information from the “morphogenetic background field.” Human symbiosis is
   consequently not a heat power machine but a light frequency modulated
   information transforming medium. All the time this cell symbiosis is
   resonance coupled with the lowest not yet materialized energy status
   (physical vacuum as inexhaustible “global information pool”).

I suspect the laser they used is not producing a zero-point quantum medium. As
to why they further stressed the turtle with useless laser therapy, I cannot
say. The internet said it would help, I suppose. In the photos the turtle has
the same stoic expression that marks the species, but I can’t imagine that from 
the turtle perspective the process is any less terrifying than a shark coming at
them. Three large animals holding it down, preventing flight or fight and
flashing them with a worthless laser.

I just hope the laser unit was donated, as they cost $18,900 to $27,900
depending on the model. My fish would be fried if I was a member of the aquarium
and saw that they wasted money on a laser therapy.

I am grateful they saved the turtles but I hope I do not come back as a turtle
in the next life. Cold, starving, injured and infected, thrown from the sea,
held down to prevent escape then poked with needles and flashed with lasers.
Beats dying on the beach, but I hope my caregivers have a little more sense and 
education.

*I know, a stretch, but I so wanted the acronym PETA.

Veterinary quackery at the San Diego Zoo

As I was spending a quiet Saturday night watching Animal Planet, I was disturbed
to see out and out quackery on The Zoo:San Diego, as an elephant named Tembo,
who was suffering from arthritis of the hip and one of her legs, was being
subjected to thermography and acupuncture. Yes, as with human medicine,
acupuncture quackery has infiltrated even the highest levels of veterinary
medicine.

David Gorski on September 2, 2019

Link



In the US, it’s a holiday weekend, and as a result I had considered taking today
off. Then I saw something on TV that made me think that at least a brief post
(well, for me, anyway) would be in order. To understand what changed my mind,
I’ll give a little background first. Being the boring old farts that we are, my 
wife and I typically spend our Saturday nights watching TV, usually Animal
Planet. In particular, we like Dr. Jeff, and we like The Zoo, which is focused
on the San Diego Zoo this season. While flipping channels, though, I came across
this:

I don't think that subjecting elephants to acupuncture quackery, as a commercial
for tonight's episode of #TheZooSD shows, is showing love for elephants. I'll
be watching to set how bad it is.🤦🏻‍♂️ https://t.co/FlEo0Buibg

— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) August 31, 2019

Et tu, San Diego Zoo?

So I decided to watch, you know, to see how bad the episode was. Sadly (and I do
mean sadly), another major segment in the show featured the zookeepers and
staff preparing to send a panda who had been at the San Diego Zoo for 23 years
back to China. That storyline was genuinely moving, as ono zookeeper who had
cared for the panda for over 20 years had to deal with sending her charge away. 
I’m just glad that my wife and I got to see the pandas last year, before they
were shipped back to China.

Then, sadly, but for a much different reason, there was the other storyline. It 
featured Tembo, the “retired Hollywood elephant.” She’s 48 years old and
apparently has arthritis in her rear hip and one of her legs. The segment
started out benignly enough, with a zookeeper approaching the elephant exhibit
with food and to observe how she moves to assess the stiffness in her right
front leg. It looks like a fairly standard training/assessment session. A
veterinarian accompanied the zookeeper and noted that she thought that Tembo was
favoring a leg.

Then I saw it, the zookeeper saying:

   To address the pain that Tembo’s been experiencing, it’s important for us to 
   always think out of the box. So Dr. Beth will be coming in the next few weeks
   to provide her with some acupuncture. Dr. Beth has provided acupuncture
   treatment to a variety of animals at the zoo with great success. Tembo’s the 
   first elephant we’ll be attempting that with, and we’re really hopeful to see
   some positive effects with it.

My reaction? I bet you can guess:



When Godzilla gives you the facepalm, you know the failure is epic.

Sadly, apparently to the staff at the San Diego Zoo, “outside the box” means
“embrace quackery”. My first reaction (after the facepalm, that is) was: How do 
the zookeepers know that the acupuncture on the other animals has had “great
success”? We’ve discussed animal acupuncture here on multiple occasions before. 
As veterinarian David Ramey has described, there’s no good evidence that
acupuncture works in animals, to which I would add that there’s also no good
evidence that acupuncture works in humans. He also notes, as we have bene saying
all along, that there’s no good evidence that acupuncture points exist in
people, much less animals; indeed, as Harriet Hall and Steve Novella described
just this week, even acupuncturists can’t define where acupuncture points are in
humans, nor can they agree where they are.

As I’ve said before many times, it doesn’t matter where you stick the needles in
(“acupuncture points” or not) and it doesn’t even matter if you stick the
needles in (toothpicks work as well), the effect is the same, nonspecific and
placebo. As we say, acupuncture is a theatrical placebo. In its present form, it
isn’t even ancient, particularly for animals. Indeed, the filiform needles
currently used by acupuncturists were only introduced in the 1930s.

But, wait, you say! Can there be placebo effects in animals? Of course there can
be, but it’s not the same as placebos in humans. Rather it’s something that’s
sometimes called transferred or caregiver placebo effects. After all, animals
can’t tell us how they are doing or if they’re in pain. The way we assess how
animals feel is by what we observe, and it’s known that humans who think their
dog has been treated is more likely to say that the dog’s health has improved.
Basically, acupuncture is even more clearly quackery in animals than it is in
humans, and that’s saying a lot. It’s a fraud. So it’s incorrect that animals
aren’t subject to placebo effects; it’s just that those effects are mediated
through the caregiver.

So about halfway through the episode, we’re treated to Dr. Beth Bicknese and
Lead Mammal Keeper Robbie Clark bringing Tembo into a building and subjecting
her to needles stuck into her skin. Before this, Dr. Beth describes how she was 
certified in animal acupuncture and has been using acupuncture on animals around
the zoo for a while now. She opines about how chronic pain, such as what Tembo 
has been experiencing from her arthritis is just the sort of condition that
responds well to acupuncture. She describes how regular acupuncture needles are 
too thin and weak to get through the thick skin of an elephant. Her solution to 
this problem? She uses larger syringe needles, with the acupuncture needles
going through it. (Who knew that the Seldinger technique works for acupuncture?)
While she’s getting ready to stick needles into Tembo, Dr. Beth continues to
describe what she’s doing, in particular how her goal is not to hit the “pain
fibers,” but to hit the “non-pain” fibers, or the pressure and heat fibers, so
that we can “try to remind the nervous system that there are other impulses
other than pain.” My reaction, besides WTF?

This:

Dr. Beth further described how she used horse acupuncture points because
elephants most resemble horses. Of course, there is no evidence that acupuncture
does anything whatsoever other than puncturing the skin; so what Dr. Beth is
shown doing in this segment is still utter quackery. She even pulls the “bait
and switch” of using electroacupuncture (which is not acupuncture).

The quackery gets even worse, though. Remember thermography? Remember how it’s
utter quackery, the sort of thing naturopaths use to “diagnose” everything from 
breast cancer to “inflammation“? Yes, Dr. Beth brought in Dr. Barbara Durrant,
Director of Reproductive Physiology, to do thermography on Tembo. (They called
it “thermal imaging,” but it was really thermography.) Here’s the thing, though.
Even when appropriately used, thermography is very dependent upon a lot of
conditions, including the temperature of the room in which it is used, how long 
the subject of the thermography has been in the room to acclimate and have skin 
temperature. In any event, Dr. Durrant describes how the red areas (higher
temperature/heat) are where Tembo is feeling pain due to inflammation. On what
evidence is this based? None. Thermography isn’t even validated for humans, much
less for elephants, the thermography camera being used doesn’t even look all
that sophisticated, and all we’re treated to is a subjective reading of the
“heat signatures.” They didn’t even appear to do any computer image analysis. Or
maybe they did and just didn’t show it on the episode, but even in that case it
would still have been quackery. The episode ends showing Tembo playing in the
mud, her pain supposedly relieved by the acupuncture, with Robbie Clark
intoning:

   Playing in the mud is actually good personal skin care. It can act as
   sunscreen and insect repellent for her. It’s great to hear that the heat in
   Tembo’s right hip has decreased, which lets us know that the acupuncture is
   working. Diagnosing and treating elephants is tough. We’ve put a lot of time 
   and attention into Tembo’s medical care, and we’ve seen a lot of progress,
   and that’s something that we’re really excited about. We really look forward 
   to seeing Tembo continue to thrive with us here at the zoo.

Obviously, I don’t expect much better from Animal Planet. It’s a TV network. Its
interest is in showing what its audience wants to watch, almost regardless of
whether it’s scientifically accurate or supportable or not, and showing an
elephant getting acupuncture is, without a doubt interesting. To me it’s
interesting for all the wrong reasons, but for an audience that doesn’t realize 
that acupuncture is quackery, it’s still interesting. The San Diego Zoo, on the 
other hand, is one of the premier zoos in the country, if not the world. One
would expect that it would provide only the best science-based veterinary care
for its animal charges. I expect quackery like elephant acupuncture perhaps in
Asia, where belief in traditional Chinese medicine is more embedded in the
culture than it is here. Indeed, there are stories of elephants that have been
“cured” of various ailments in Singapore. In the US, however, one would normally
expect evidence- and science-based animal care, not quackery.

Clearly, that is not the case, at least not in San Diego. An episode of The
Zoo:San Diego just showed one of the zoo’s vets subjecting an elephant to rank
quackery and describing how she’s used the same quackery on many other animals
at the zoo. Of course, one can look at this another way. Presumably, to be a
veterinarian at one of the most prestigious zoos in the country, you have to be 
the cream of the crop. If what is presumably one of the very best vets in the
country has embraced quackery like acupuncture and thermography, what hope does 
the profession have for being evidence- and science-based?

Pet Acupuncture and Life

Traditional intuit whale acupuncture.

Mark Crislip on January 20, 2026

Link


One of the many characteristics that point to the fact that I am elderly is that
I like to read the daily paper. Or, in the case of the Oregonian, the 5 times
weekly paper. I have been reading the paper since I could read. As a nod to
modernity, I read it on line. Perhaps a nod to aging, I do so because I can
increase the font size. Seriously. All time best inventions: clean water,
vaccines, and the ability to increase font size.

The paper’s format has not changed in years. News section. Opinion section.
Sports. And the Life section, where there is advice, horrorscopes, reviews and
the occasionally problematic column.

As an example of problematic, I came across Treating animals with acupuncture
has gone mainstream. That wily, old acupuncture. Going mainstream since 1972.

Before we delve into the article, I wondered about the history of animal
acupuncture. Turns out acupuncture has been used on animals as long as humans.
They just took human charts of meridians and acupoints and laid them over
animals. Which is why horses have a gall bladder meridian despite lacking a gall
bladder.

Chi, the nonexistent life force, is found in all living creatures. Even
bacteria:

Chi sites serve as stimulators of DNA double-strand break repair in bacteria,
which can arise from radiation or chemical treatments, or result from
replication fork breakage during DNA replication.

Oops. Wrong chi. If qi, then I can’t find where micro-organisms are credited
with the ‘energy’. And who knows with prions and viri. But our pets have qi and 
so are amenable to acupuncture.


As an unrelated rat hole I went down whether plants have their own types of qi. 
Yep. It helps determine what plants are used in feng shui.

There are a few trials of acupuncture in plants that allegedly increase yield,
although I can find no articles on treating plant diseases. Plants have a
meridian system that is not in the nervous, lymphatic or blood systems, since
plants lack the structures. So they have been looking for meridians in all the
wrong places. Instead,

Some argue that it belongs to nervous system, some believe it is part of
lymphatic or blood vessel system. There is no conclusion so far. If plants also 
have energy channel system, can we start our research on energy channels at the 
common structures shared by human bodies and plants?

Common structures? Such as? Unless we are studying Swamp Thing.

I did find one news report on acupuncture on fish. It supports my contention
that acupuncturissts just make it up as they go along:

In human beings, the treatment to stimulate the body’s immune system involves
three points, said Wu, who has been practicing acupuncture for more than 12
years. The first, on the shin, about three inches below the kneecap, is called
zu san li, or three measures of the leg.

The problem, of course, is that fish have no shins. So, Wu picked a spot near
the fish’s tail and hoped for the best.

Anyway, back to the Oregonian. As discussed in TNTC articles on this blog, there
is no reason to suspect acupuncture is effective for any pathologic process,
since it is based on fiction. Same is true in animals:

On the basis of the findings of this systematic review, there is no compelling
evidence to recommend or reject acupuncture for any condition in domestic
animals.

So just how as acupuncture gone mainstream in animals? Let’s see what they have 
to say.

There are two schools of thought about veterinary acupuncture. The original form
of acupuncture, which has been practiced for thousands of years, follows
principles of traditional Chinese medicine. It views the patient through a lens 
of five elements: wood, fire, earth, metal and water.

AKA a school detached from reality.

Each element is associated with a different type of energy. Practitioners work
to maintain balance between those energies, which they believe is essential for 
a healthy body to function.

Well, that tells me nothing. How that lens is applied to animals? Can’t say. And
no mention of qi or meridians, so fundamental fictional underpinnings of TCPM
are not mentioned. So, really, two paragraphs that have no explanatory content.

In traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine, the fake diagnosis is made by examining 
the tongue and the pulse. Is that done with animals? You betcha:

The pulse is assessed in various locations, depending on species. Cats, dogs,
goats, and sheep have their femoral pulses checked. Equine pulses are palpated
using the common carotid at the base of the neck or external maxillary artery,
while the ventral tail (median caudal artery) is assessed in the bovine.

The tongue diagnosis would be easy with our old English bull dog.

Another approach focuses on anatomical effects on the body. Practitioners place 
needles to achieve specific effects by stimulating muscles or nerves.

OK. That sounds semi-reasonable, although

Both versions of acupuncture can help veterinary patients.

How? Don’t know. But let’s read on.

They mention there is also electroacupuncture and that it is more effective. I
remain of the opinion that once you apply electricity, it is no longer
acupuncture. It is just modified TENS and the effects are due to the electricity
and have nothing to do with the needles or any aspect of acupuncture.

Then there is the only article quoted in support of acupuncture. So effective,
it is quoted twice.

Herniated disks can be very painful for animals. A 2023 study found that when
dogs with this condition were treated with acupuncture, nearly 80% recovered,
compared with 60% of animals whose cases were managed conservatively without
acupuncture.

Well. It was a retrospective study of 94 dogs over 6 years. The 60%? Historical 
controls. They do not define recovery but note for historical controls

Considering the differences in defining recovery among different studies, it was
expected that the recovery rate in this study would be slightly lower than
those in the previous reports. For example, some studies considered successful
treatment as an occasional ability to stand or walk independently.

And how were the acupuncture points chosen?

According to TCM pathogenesis, the main cause of TL-IVDH is the obstruction of
pelvic Tai-yang Bladder and the Du Channel due to the deficiency of Kidney Qi
and the invasion of external pathogens. Therefore, acupuncture treatment aims to
increase blood circulation, remove blood stasis and tonify Liver and Kidney.

Gibberish.

Crap study and I think misrepresented by the author, who to my reading implies
this as a comparative treatment trial. Twice.

Acupuncture and electroacupuncture both increase the body’s levels of compounds 
called endogenous opioids. These are pain-relieving substances that the body
produces naturally. They work similarly to pharmaceutical opioids, such as
fentanyl and morphine.

So acupuncture inflicts pain and increases endogenous opioids. A destroy the
village to save it situation.

Acupuncture increases these compounds so dramatically that the effect can be
reversed with opioid antidotes, such as Narcan.

I could not find the article to support that statement. Instead I found mostly
the opposite:

This does not support the hypothesis that acupuncture therapy is mediated by
endorphin.

and

In an attempt to replicate a study by D. J. Mayer et al. (see record
1977-23009-001), 14 university students and staff who demonstrated acupunctural 
analgesia during electrical stimulation of the LI-4 point on the hands received 
either 1.2 mg naloxone or saline under double-blind conditions. Pain thresholds 
elevated by acupuncture failed to reverse when naloxone was given. Review of
experimental design issues, other related human Ss research, and animal studies 
on acupunctural analgesia provided little convincing evidence that endorphins
play a significant role in acupunctural analgesia

At this point in the article, I am not convinced the author is reliable when
reporting the literature if it contradicts his belief in the efficacy of
acupuncture and misrepresents the articles that do. References sure would be
nice to know for sure. Lack of references is the most problematic aspect of
articles in the Life section of the paper

Studies in small animal medicine show that using acupuncture can speed up
healing from nerve injuries, such as spinal cord damage from herniated disks.

One very small study in rats to support the effect median nerve damage , but,
like for herniated discs, it was ELECTROacupuncture, and so the effects were
likely from the electricity not the acupuncture. I still think passing off
electroacupuncture as acupuncture is at best disingenuous.

They continue

Acupuncture can also make other techniques, such as epidural nerve blocks, more 
effective when both methods are used together.

I can’t find the reference to support this assertion. This maybe? Or this?
Neither, really. The statement is too ill-defined to know. But neither study
used fake acupuncture as a control and both came from China, where all the women
are strong, all the men are good-looking, and all the acupuncture studies are
above average, aka positive. So color me unimpressed.

Many vets are using acupuncture creatively for other purposes, such as
increasing sick animals’ appetites, improving their digestion and accelerating
healing from injuries.

For appetite, perhaps but multiple forms of acupuncture were used as well as
different acupoints, suggesting that any effect would be nonspecific. Also

Although the majority of reviewed studies reported positive effects, several
methodological limitations must be acknowledged. Sample sizes were often small, 
blinding was inconsistently applied, and few studies included long-term
follow-up data. Moreover, heterogeneity in acupuncture techniques(manual) vs.
electroacupuncture), acupoint combinations, and treatment duration complicates
direct comparisons (Li et al., 2022). Standardization of acupuncture protocols
is thus essential to improve reproducibility and facilitate clinical
translation. Additionally, while hormonal assays were commonly used, behavioral 
assessments of appetite—such as feed approach latency or chewing time—were less 
frequently reported, limiting holistic interpretation of outcomes.

I did not have access to many of the articles in the review. For example,
Appetite response to auricular acupuncture in broilers from Poultry Integrative 
Medicine, 3(1), 22–28. Chickens have ears? Yep. Small ones. But I would love to 
know how this was done and, given the relative size of human fingers and chicken
ears, how they managed to not activate every acupoint at once. I guess they
just squeezed the head. Much to my surprise, there are no videos on the
interwebs showing chicken auricular acupuncture. I knew I should not have let my
subscription to Poultry Integrative Medicine lapse.

Improving digestion? Not certain what that means, but using it as a search term 
yields nothing of note.

Healing from injuries? What does that refer to? Wound? Fracture? Bruise? Sore
muscle? Too vague for a search. Given that the better the study, the less
acupuncture effect in humans, I would suppose the same would be true in animals.
As has been noted over and over here at SBM, acupuncture does nothing,

They proceed to say how they use acupuncture, and sometime electoecupuncture, at
the University of Tennessee:

Our practice at the University of Tennessee has used acupuncture most
extensively to help rehabilitate animals recovering from conditions like radial 
nerve paralysis and femoral nerve injury. We can use acupuncture to stimulate
muscles or to provide pain relief, either by itself or combined with other
therapies.

Also used to prevent muscle atrophy, treat spinal inflammation in goats (Jordan 
or James?), and osteoarthritis in llamas and alpacas.

We use acupuncture and electroacupuncture to stimulate the goats’ large and
accessory spinal nerves and the muscles in the animals’ legs and backs. This
gives the goats more muscle function when the inflammation clears, and we
believe it helps reduce their pain.

Poor goats. In pain and caregivers believe they are not hurting. Who knows?

If there is a nerve or muscle involved, there is probably a veterinary treatment
option using acupuncture or electroacupuncture. New studies regularly add to
our understanding of the neurology and biochemistry that underlie these
therapies.

New studies tend to be crap and add little to nothing. 50 years and still no one
can show acupuncture’s efficacy in quality studies, as repeatedly documented in
this blog.

If your vet recommends acupuncture for a dog or cat — especially for chronic
pain — you can be confident that it’s not a fringe treatment. As long as the
person treating your pet is a licensed veterinarian, and is certified by a
professional organization like Curacore, Chi University or the American Academy 
of Veterinary Acupuncture, acupuncture should make your pet more comfortable and
improve its quality of life.

Nope. Not fringe. Unfortunately. Just a useless waste of time and money and your
dog will get the added suffering of being needled. Probably my bias, but photos
of dogs with acupuncture needles look like they are unhappy.

It is why I am skeptical of the information in the Life section. No rigor and
none of the fact checking of the News section. Except Dear Abby, of course. She 
is always spot on.


How To Listen to Chi

Harriet Hall on July 14, 2015

Link



My Chi says my puppy is bad for me and I should get rid of it. I’m keeping the
puppy, and getting rid of my Chi instead.

   You will need flat shoes and a bottle of vitamins, herbal formula, or
   prescription medicine.

   Step 1: Hold the bottle with both hands, touching your chest

   Step 2: Stand up straight and get your balance

   Step 3: Close your eyes and feel what is happening to your body.

   Results:

   If your body moves forward or stays neutral – going side to side – then
   whatever you are holding near your chest is okay for you. Your Chi matches.

   If your body moves backwards – whatever you are holding is not good for you. 
   Your body is repelling it. Chi is saying it doesn’t want that.

   You can do this test on just about anything – a bottle of wine, foods,
   clothing. It’s easy to test and see if these things bring positive or
   negative energy to your body.

Oh dear, my Chi says it doesn’t match my new shoes. Guess I’ll have to take them
back to the store. My body moved forwards when I held a bottle of rat poison;
does that mean my Chi wants me to die?! My body swayed backwards when I held my 
new puppy against my chest; I guess my Chi wants me to take it back to the
pound. I won’t do it! Fuck you, Chi! Pardon my language, but I love my puppy and
that really made me angry.

No, seriously, how can anyone fall for such nonsense? Even if you thought it
might be true, anyone who’s ever watched Mythbusters ought to know enough to set
up a simple blinded test and bust that ridiculous myth all to smithereens.

Why does Restful Sleep™ hate puppies?

But apparently people are falling for it. The company that sells Restful Sleep™ 
is making enough money to pay for a half-page ad in USA Today, which is where I 
read those instructions. That can’t be cheap. No, it’s not cheap; I looked it up
and a half-page black-and-white ad goes for $73,200. Apparently plenty of
gullible consumers are spending their hard-earned money on a 2,000-year-old
sleep remedy that Dr. Yan Ping Xu says produces healthy sleep by balancing the
spleen Chi, which is the central train station for your entire body. Every organ
is affected by spleen Chi. When it is not functioning properly, you may
experience fatigue, anxiety, worry, restlessness, and poor concentration.

Testimonials. Exclusive low introductory price. Free shipping. 30-day,
satisfaction-guaranteed, risk-free trial period. Not sold in stores! Déjà vu,
anyone?

What are the ingredients?

Restful Sleep™ contains:

King herbs to nourish the Chi:

  1. Asian ginseng

  2. Atractylodes (which of the eight species?)

  3. Astragalus (which of the 3,000 species?)

Queen herbs to support the King herbs and nourish the blood:

  1. Longan

  2. Dong quai

  3. Jujube seed

  4. Poria (a fungal genus that is no longer used)

  5. Jujube fruit

Assistant herbs to calm the spirit:

  1. Costus (which of the more than 100 species?)

  2. Polygala (which of the many hundreds of species?)

Harmonizer herbs to bring balance to the formula and help moderate any harsh
effects associated with other herbs:

  1. Licorice

  2. Ginger

Modern minerals (the Western approach [sic]):

  1. Calcium

  2. Magnesium

  3. Potassium

And we can be sure this will help you sleep because…

It has the same exact ingredients in Yi-Fang that have been used for over 2,000 
years! A Chinese healer says it supports the spleen! Customers say it works!
There is even a “Science” tab (albeit with nothing even remotely resembling
science). Doesn’t that inspire confidence that the claims are true?

Conclusion: Get a puppy instead

I won’t waste any more time on this. I just thought SBM readers would enjoy a
laugh. I printed out what I had written, put it in a bottle, held it to my chest
and closed my eyes. My body stayed neutral. So I know my Chi wants me to share 
it with you. You, too, can listen to your Chi. Have fun!

Science-Based Satire: Improperly Performed Acupuncture Linked to Spontaneous
Human Combustion

Clay Jones on August 16, 2013

Link


Experts in traditional Chinese medicine are warning patients to avoid unlicensed
acupuncture practitioners after an apparent case of spontaneous human
combustion.

Baton Rouge, LA-When investigators climbed from out of the smoldering debris
that was the home of Hank Thomas, the looks on their faces told the gathering
crowd what these hardened veterans of the Baton Rouge Fire Department couldn’t
put into words. Thomas, a yoga instructor and avid fisherman who had lived in
Baton Rouge his entire life, had exploded. And as the grisly details slowly
emerge, people are asking questions about what might be to blame and how they
can prevent being the next Baton Rougian to erupt into a massive fireball of
body parts and Tony Chachere’s Creole Seasoning.

Some local medical professionals have proposed a controversial theory. Based on 
reports that Thomas has undergone acupuncture treatments for sciatica several
times in the weeks preceding his untimely fulmination, a group of local experts 
are speaking out. They are warning the community to beware of discount
acupuncture clinics.

“We aren’t saying that every incidence of spontaneous human combustion is linked
to the incorrect placement of acupuncture needles,” Kuang Zhu LAC, Chief of
Pragmatic Acupuncture in the Health and Wellness division of Vic’s Day Spa and
Pet Grooming Center, explained during a recent press conference. “But in some
cases, there is a relationship that is hard to explain otherwise.”

Zhu, a legally licensed acupuncturist in Baton Rouge, Louisiana for over thirty 
years and founder of the “Know Your Needler!” campaign, is reaching out to the
Baton Rouge community because of concerns that there are patients seeking care
from unlicensed and poorly trained practitioners that don’t charge as much per
session. “These rogue needle-wielding impersonators don’t fully grasp the power 
of acupuncture, acupressure, sonopuncture, electroacupuncture, cold laser
therapy, or any of the other ancient techniques of stimulating specific
acupoints. With great ability to heal, comes an equal ability to harm.”

Acupuncture, a component of Traditional Chinese Medicine developed sometime in
the past 5,000 years, involves the insertion of small needles into specific
points on the body in order to improve the flow of life energy or Qi. These
points are found along meridians, major pathways in the body through which our
life energy courses that are different from blood vessels, nerves and lymphatics
in that Western science has been unable to locate them during anatomical
investigation or with modern imaging techniques. When Qi is obstructed, it
becomes stagnant and illness develops. Properly placed needles relieve this
obstruction and improve our health in a number of ways. Needles placed
haphazardly can, according to Zhu, lead to further obstruction, a worsening of
one’s health, and perhaps even a fiery death.

Zhu states that the phenomenon of injury by inappropriate acupuncture is not
new. He has seen countless milder cases over his three decades of practice in
the United States. But the worst occurred during his childhood in China.
“Neighborhood gangs and even local police forces would use purposefully
incorrect acupuncture as punishment or as an interrogation enhancer,” Zhu
revealed. “Once I saw a body with the hao zhen needles still inserted in
acupoints I did not even know existed. Oh, the disharmony! My childhood ended
that day. I’ve heard that the American military is even using acupuncture on the
battlefield now.”

But not every local acupuncturist supports Zhu’s theory that excessive and
erroneous needle placement is to blame for unexplained explosions of American
citizens. Frank Grimes, a Baton Rouge chiropractor who incorporates acupuncture 
into his armamentarium of healing modalities, reminds us that correlation
doesn’t always equal causation. “Yes, some of the remaining body parts have been
found with needles still in them,” He admits. “But my concern is that linking
acupuncture to spontaneous human combustion is akin to the claim that
chiropractic manipulation of the neck causes strokes. Perhaps people who are
already about to explode seek out acupuncture for symptomatic relief.”

At the heart of this issue for Zhu and his colleagues is the health of their
community. He admits that acupuncture-induced detonation is likely rare despite 
the recent occurrence, and that most people who receive acupuncture from
improperly trained practitioners will at most only experience mild stagnation of
Qi. “Thankfully most of these victims of acupuncture fraud do not suffer from
serious conditions and will improve with the passage of time. My main concern is
that the people who do have dangerous imbalances in their yin or yang might
delay seeking out proper care just to save a few bucks.”

Zhu also expressed concern for subjects of clinical trials testing the
effectiveness of acupuncture. “I worry that study participants exposed to phony 
acupuncture may be at risk for continued imbalances or worse.” In addition to
raising awareness of the dangers of improperly performed acupuncture, the Know
Your Needler! campaign is also calling for the immediate end of all
placebo-controlled trials that incorporate sham acupuncture.

Okay, I made this up. It’s clearly satire, but if you were fooled please follow 
this link and start reading. It may be a joke but this phony news piece does
have a point, and it wasn’t just to poke some fun at acupuncture adherents and
their claims, or science reporting these days. I did enjoy doing that
tremendously, however.

To my knowledge, there has yet to be discovered a medical treatment that works
by altering the structure or physiology of the body that is completely risk
free. Whether pharmaceutical or “natural”, Eastern or Western, homeopathic or
allopathic, if there is both a specific and measurable therapeutic benefit there
is always the potential for negative side effects. Sure, the range of side
effects vary from the extremely mild and annoying to deadly, but they are always
there.

Some legitimate therapies are extremely safe when used or dosed appropriately
but as the old saying goes, the poison is often in the dose. Even dihydrogen
oxide is dangerous when a large enough amount is ingested, leading to water
intoxication, hyponatremia, seizures and eventually death. But most
interventions will carry varying degrees of risk at recommended doses as well as
when overdone. Even minor surgical procedures, such as the simple incision and 
drainage of a small abscess that can be performed in most physicians’ offices,
can lead to unanticipated complications. Again the risk can be quite small, or
even negligible, and the benefits almost always outweigh these risks, but there 
is no such thing as a free lunch in the world of medicine.

Many of the proposed health benefits of alternative medical therapies, an
arbitrary and often nonsensical collection of treatments and approaches to
health care, are decidedly non-specific. They rely on subjective placebo effects
elicited by bias and altered perception without measurable objective
improvement. Claims of benefits related to their use tend to involve such
nebulous entities as boosting of the immune system (but never which component), 
reducing stress, improving mood, vague references to organ health (splenic
fatigue?) and the enhancement of male.

Claims of this type, of which there are a seemingly endless supply, are very
effective at what they were designed to do. Thanks in large part to comical
governmental regulation, the also seemingly endless supply of people willing to 
be separated from their money are enticed by statements which are never
subjected to the nuisance of providing supporting evidence outside of the
occasional testimonial. Acupuncture in particular thrives on placebo effects and
vague claims, and does not deserve its place at the top of the heap in regards 
to public and physician perception of legitimacy.

Unfortunately it doesn’t stop there. When proponents of irregular medicine make 
specific claims, such as ginkgo biloba preventing the onset of dementia in the
elderly, or chiropractic adjustments being effective in treating asthma, the
results of the few properly designed studies range from equivocal to negative.
Despite the reality that thus far no alternative therapy has been shown to be
effective for any specific condition, practitioners of even the most ludicrous
of modalities forge ahead unfazed.

So if acupuncture has a specific effect on the physiology of the body, by
altering the release of neurotransmitters or increasing the secretion of
endogenous hormones, or whatever proposed biological mechanism you prefer, and
it is capable of impacting specific diseases, then there must be the potential
for unwanted side effects. And I don’t mean just the obvious infectious issues
associated with the use of unclean needles/hands or the potential for traumatic 
injury when needles are shoved through the linings of the heart or lungs. And,
of course, I also don’t truly believe that there must be catastrophic side
effects equivalent to spontaneously bursting into flames.

If acupuncture works for the host of conditions its proponents claim it to,
conditions as disparate as Parkinson’s disease and polycystic ovarian disease,
then there has to be a downside. Whatever alterations in the physiology of the
body to improve fertility, relieve migraines and lower cholesterol, they can’t
be risk free. I take the extreme difficulty in finding discussion of any such
acupuncture side effects by proponents as evidence for the lack of any effect at
all. To me, the absurdity of such an extreme side effect as exploding due to
pent up Qi is equally matched by the ridiculous claim that shoving tiny needles 
into a patient’s skin results in an effect beyond that of placebo.

Science-Based Satire: Robotically-Assisted Acupuncture Brings Ancient Healing
Technique Into the 21st Century

Clay Jones on July 15, 2016

Link



An acupuncturist and acupuncture anesthetist perform robotically-assisted
acupuncture on a patient who has been feeling kind of tired lately

Developed over many thousands of years (or maybe a little less), what has come
to be known as traditional Chinese acupuncture has proven capable of curing or
at least ameliorating the symptoms of a variety of medical conditions. But one
of its greatest strengths, the intimate connection between the practitioner and 
the acupuncture needle, is also one of its most significant weaknesses. Taking
advantage of the robotic technology being used by surgeons to perform an
increasing number of minimally-invasive procedures, cutting edge acupuncture
providers are now able to provide relief for patients that were once felt to be 
either poor candidates or had failed to improve despite treatments with
traditional acupuncture by hand.

The healing art of acupuncture may have deep roots in an ancient Eastern
culture, but the modern technology now being used to augment it is pure Western 
medicine. The da Vinci Surgical System, a state of the art robotic technology,
features a 3D high-definition magnification system and instruments able to
maneuver with far greater precision than the human wrist and fingers. This is
allowing specially trained acupuncturists to both locate and successfully target
hard to reach acupuncture points, such as those on the eye, scrotum, and anal
verge. This expands the number of conditions amenable to acupuncture to
everything except space herpes.

“It’s obvious to me that this is an improvement, a paradigm shift if you will.
It’s a leap forward in our ability to take care of our patients,” da Vinci
certified acupuncturist Mort Fishman explained. “It really comes down to the
bottom line. If someone in my family needed acupuncture, would I want that
provider to be trained in robotics? Yes, I would.”

The improved vision and manual dexterity enjoyed by providers using the da Vinci
system has allowed acupuncture to catch up to other alternative medical fields,
some of which have been incorporating modern technology into their protocols
for years. Chiropractors, practitioners who treat a variety of musculoskeletal
conditions and also asthma for some reason, have historically been quick to
adopt the latest high tech electronic devices, primarily in order to facilitate 
the location of abnormalities in the spine called subluxations. Once found,
these silent killers can be removed using traditional hands-on techniques or
with advanced space age technology. Some experts have even mastered the
combination of manual and technology-based treatments.

Fishman, who is a pioneer in robotically-assisted minimally-invasive acupuncture
fertility treatments, is already looking to the future. He envisions a day when
even this groundbreaking technology is considered to old-fashioned. “As science
progresses, and we continue to scale down robot technology and improve
treatment algorithms, the physical act of acupuncture will be taken completely
out of the hands of the practitioner. The human mind will be set free, allowing 
full mental focus on diagnosis.”

Science-Based Satire: TCM Experts Baffled by Man Born Without Meridians

Has the first case of complete congenital Qi deficiency been diagnosed in
Massachusetts? Is it possible to run a successful landscaping business without
any meridians? Where can you get acupuncture and your car detailed at the same
time? All these questions and more will be answered in today’s post, which I
completely made up.

Clay Jones on September 1, 2023

Link



Natick, MA – Traditional Chinese medical experts are baffled by the recent
discovery of a Massachusetts man seemingly born without acupuncture meridians,
but a leading theory has emerged.


Rab Garrett, owner of Garrett Landscaping and Lawn Maintenance in Natick, is the
first human to be diagnosed with complete congenital Qi deficiency

“This truly is unexplored territory and we don’t exactly know what to make of
the finding,” Dr. Chulong Xue, head of Qi dynamics for the National Center for
Complementary and Integrative Health’s Task Force on Traditional Chinese
Medicine, explained. “We don’t know how the subject is even alive, let alone how
he has maintained a successful landscaping business for the past 18 years, but 
you can be certain that I’m going to get to the bottom of this even if it
depletes all of my fire element.”

Meridians are vital conduits that serve as a distribution network for the
dispersal of energy throughout the human body. According to Dr. Mort Fishman,
the director of Mysteries of the East Lansing Med Spa and Acupuncture Warehouse,
home of the 5-Minute Miracle intravenous hangover cure, this energy, known as
Qi, binds and sustains all life in the universe. “It’s quite simple really, but 
also highly complex, and the whole system contains a number of core concepts
that reveal themselves in subtle yet obvious ways, and we’ve known this for
thousands of years.”

Though many humans have been found to have deficiencies in Qi, this has largely 
been linked to lifestyle choices and outside stressors. Fishman often coaches
clients on ways to improve both the quantity and quality of their life force.
“It’s important to avoid overexertion, emotional imbalances, and irregular
eating. I’ve lost count of how many patients have come to see me because they
ate something too cold or were a little too anxious about something.” This is
the first known case of complete congenital absence of meridians and Qi,
however.

Xue and his team of researchers, consisting of some of the brightest minds in
meridian research, have spent the past several days working on an intriguing
hypothesis that could explain how a human could live and thrive without any
measurable Qi. After spending several hours examining the subject’s tongue and
pulses for clues, and running him through a functional MRI machine down in the
basement a few times, Xue concluded that the subject is likely a Chinese hopping
vampire, known as a Jiangshi. “The ability to maintain form and function
despite a complete absence of a meridian system can’t be explained any other
way, at least not scientifically.”

Rab Garrett isn’t sold on this theory. He claims to have simply been curious
about acupuncture after reading an article on the Cleveland Clinic website
discussing the top 5 natural remedies for grimp and grimp-like illness. “I had a
groupon for an integrative medicine clinic where you can also get your car
washed, and the next thing I know I’m being whisked off to Bethesda for tests. I
don’t know about this energy vampire thing, but the car looks great and I would
absolutely go back there.”

Nonsense, wherever the meridian leads

Acupuncture and meridians and Qi! Oh…meh. This, my friends, is a well worn path 
in the annals of SBM and I have little if anything to add to what minds greater 
than mine have had to say in the not too distant past.

According to Mark Crislip, acupuncture is silly and built on a foundation of
baloney:

   Meridians, chi, tongue and pulse diagnosis, the entire foundation of
   traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine, is built on smoke and mirrors.
   Acupuncture is all sound and fury, signifying nothing.

When I sit down to mock something like acupuncture, and especially with
chiropractic, I often take the approach of considering the possibility that
everything the believers are saying is 100% true. I allow the notion to settle
deep into my subconscious mind and then, once fully enmeshed in this fantastical
new reality, I try to logically imagine all the potential outcomes and then
take it one step further*.

That extra step serves, I hope, two purposes. I want it to be clear that what
I’m writing is make believe, something I don’t always succeed at, but not too
clear. I wan’t to “toe the Poe” and fall just short of violating that
well-established law. I also want the reader who is perhaps unaware that the
topic I’m focusing on is nonsense to recognize that my fictional reality is
ridiculous and to be gently invited to consider that their understanding of that
topic might be as well. Does that ever happen? Have I ever changed someone’s
mind through satire or absurdist humor? Anecdotally, yes…but more studies are
needed.

*Okay, sometimes I take it several steps further. Don’t judge me.

Science-Based Satire: NCCIH Announces Development of Revolutionary “Needleless” 
Acupuncture System

The NCCIH has announced the development of a revolutionary form of “needleless” 
acupuncture that may soon replace the use of surgical-grade, .25 millimeter
thick stainless steel needles that have been in use for millennia.

Clay Jones on May 19, 2017

Link



Bethesda, MD – Researchers at the National Center for Complementary and
Integrative Health (NCCIH) have announced the discovery of a revolutionary form 
of “needleless” acupuncture that may soon replace the use of surgical-grade, .25
millimeter thick stainless steel needles that have been in use for millennia.



10,000-year-old cave drawing of prehistoric veterinary acupuncture providers

Acupuncture, a component of Traditional Chinese Medicine developed sometime in
the past 5 to 10,000 years, traditionally has involved the use of tiny needles, 
and also sometimes lasers, to treat specific points on the body in order to
improve the flow of life energy, which is known as Qi. Developed intuitively
through painstaking trial and error over many thousands of years, traditional
Chinese acupuncture has proven time and time again its ability to ameliorate and
even cure a variety of medical conditions. But despite its amazing historical
track record, some proponents have worried about the future of acupuncture.

“This is a revolutionary leap forward in our ability to convince even the most
acupuncture-hesitant people to open their minds to the benefits of acupuncture, 
” Kuang Zhu LAC, Head of Pragmatic Acupuncture Research at NCCIH, explained.
“The key was developing an acupuncture needle that is invisible to the untrained
naked eye and seemingly lacking in material existence. I can see it though.”

Despite thousands of years of successful use, and reams of peer-reviewed
positive studies in the medical literature, acupuncture practitioners have faced
many barriers to widespread acceptance by both the general public and
conventional medical providers. Zhu lists needle phobia and worry over possible 
pain, injury, and infection as potential roadblocks. He also worries that
skeptical propaganda may play a role:

   The internet can be a tremendous tool for gathering information, but anyone
   with a computer can write a blog post claiming that positive outcomes from
   acupuncture are subjective responses to placebo, or that it doesn’t matter
   where or even if the needles are inserted into the skin. Honestly I don’t
   know where they come up with this stuff.

The revolutionary new acupuncture delivery system first came to the attention of
the NCCIH, and Director Josephine Briggs, M.D., when two men showed up one day 
claiming to be metallurgists capable of producing acupuncture needles of an
almost unimaginably fine gauge. According to the men, their needles would be
imperceptible to all but the most brilliant of researchers. And, most
importantly, they would be completely pain and risk free without compromising
effectiveness.

Zhu and the NCCIH have so far denied requests to witness the manufacturing
process and have refused access to the new needles for inspection, citing the
potential for ultra-weak spontaneous photon emission from the human eye to
disrupt their cohesive non-existence. “Also the untrained hand will be unable to
perceive the needles when held. And the untrained mind will fail to grasp their
existence cognitively.”

Rather than waste time funding expensive randomized controlled trials comparing 
the new needles to sham acupuncture, the Pragmatic Acupuncture Research
department has decided to rely on real world evidence. Individual acupuncture
providers will have access to the new needles in just a few weeks, and the first
published studies should be accepted by the end of the year. The NCCIH is
confident that intelligent patients will be very happy with their results.

Science-Based Satire: Acupuncture Researchers Find Powerful Proof of Ancient
Mechanism of Action

Have researchers proven the existence of acupoints by shoving needles into
subjects brains? Will you soon be able to buy an OTC acupuncture kit at CVS? No!
This is satire.

Clay Jones on August 16, 2024

Link

Bethesda, MD – Scientists at the National Center for Complementary and
Integrative Health (NCCIH) in Bethesda have announced the results of
groundbreaking research that they believe confirms an ancient theory behind the 
effectiveness of acupuncture.

Acupuncture researcher Steve Smith, shown here confirming that Subject #72 is
properly blinded to whether or not he has a needle inserted into his brain
before asking if his lower back pain feels any better

“Skeptics love to point out the fact that there is no proven mechanism of action
when it comes to acupuncture,” NCCIH Director Helene Langevin explained.
“Despite several millennia of proof that it works for a wide variety of medical 
conditions, like pain and infertility, they want to focus on a tiny issue like
scientific implausibility instead of on the millions of satisfied patients. Well
those skeptics won’t be able to poke any holes in this study! Do you see what I
just did? Because it’s acupuncture.”

Ever since acupuncture was first discovered thousands of years ago when a
Chinese peasant accidentally fell on a porcupine and noticed that his chi was
30% less stagnant*, medical professionals have assumed that it must work for
some reason. According to Langevin, the study, which will be published next
month in Online Publishing Module 453 – Medical Needle Shoving, finally solves
one of acupuncture’s greatest mysteries. “Does it really matter where or even if
the needles are inserted? Essentially, do specific and reproducible acupoints
exist? Now we know. The chi, the meridians. All of it. It’s all true.”

In the NCCIH study, researchers inserted needles directly into the brains of
volunteers in order to log any specific reactions unique to each location. A
weak electrical current was also applied to each needle in order to add several 
paragraphs to the study’s conclusion section. Langevin is calling the results
historic.

Not only does this research prove the existence of acupoints, but many of the
subjects reported feeling relief after the procedure was completed and their
skulls were stapled back in place. This supports the use of acupuncture for
anxiety.

Although acupuncture is popular, and widely accepted as an evidence-based
medical intervention by many physicians, some patients are not yet benefiting
from this cutting edge application of ancient folk wisdom. With numerous health 
crises plaguing the country, one company is already working on submitting an
application to the Food and Drug Administration for over-the-counter approval of
an acupuncture kit developed for home use. While not meant to replace expert
analysis for determination of which specific acupoints need unclogging, this
could improve access to for millions of Americans.

Joanne Fabrics, shown here discussing the proper use of a home acupuncture kit
prescribed by her acupuncturist, sadly died three days later from fulminant
splenic ennui 

The company is Battlefield Acupuncture Inc., a manufacturer of needles, seeds,
and pressure application devices traditionally used by trained professionals.
But what is home acupuncture? Is it safe in the hands of amateurs? Could the
wrong person figure out a way to reverse the healing powers of acupuncture and
use it for evil instead, perhaps causing chi to back up until a person literally
explodes?

Acupuncture is an ancient form of modern healthcare that was discovered
thousands of years ago when its secrets were transmitted into the mind of a
Chinese peasant by a large black bird. It involves the insertion of thin
stainless steel needles into highly specific points on the body that were
initially mapped out by shoving needles into random spots and asking subjects’
if their livers felt stronger. These “acupoints”, now proven to exist beyond any
doubt, are areas where chi, a mystical science energy that regulates human
health, has become stagnant. Needle insertion into acupoints allows chi to flow 
freely, and is primarily used in cases of any medical problem in humans.

Some critics, like Kuang Zhu LAC, Chief of Pragmatic Acupuncture in the Health
and Wellness division of Vic’s Day Spa and Pet Grooming Center in Baton Rouge,
Louisiana, are worried that improperly performed acupuncture could result in
serious adverse outcomes:

“We aren’t saying that every incidence of spontaneous human combustion is linked
to the incorrect placement of acupuncture needles. But in some cases, there is 
a temporal relationship that is hard to explain otherwise.”

Battlefield Acupuncture, Inc. in early December announced that its acupuncture
kits were granted expedited special review from the FDA to become an
“over-the-counter (OTC) emergency treatment for known or suspected chi
stagnation”. This would make them the first such devices to receive the
fast-track review. Expedited special review means that the FDA plans to evaluate
the submission within just a few months, and is reserved for when a treatment
“is really popular with white people and Cleveland Clinic tweets about it.”

*There is an alternative hypothesis regarding the discovery of acupuncture which
has gained in popularity over the past few decades. Proponents claim that a
Chinese farmer found it just lying there in a crashed alien spaceship thousands 
of years ago.

Unpoking the Nonsense

Not a lot to add to this one. Acupuncture is silly and I like mocking it. I
mean, it has everything: an implausible and ritualistic belief system, its own
ridiculous pseudo-history, wildly inappropriate claims of health benefits, and
widespread acceptance by everyone from the guy who cuts my hair to leading
experts in a science and medicine despite being something some guy essentially
just made up in the 1950s.

See Steve’s post from a couple weeks ago for a nice discussion of the problems
with assumptions made regarding acupuncture’s history and the many limitations
in the research so often held up as proof of its benefit. The bottom line is
that acupuncture stands as likely the best example of a core weakness in the
conceptualization and execution of evidence-based medicine, and in just how
challenging it is for even intelligent and well-meaning people to maintain
skepticism in the face of a decades-long systemic public relations campaign
behind what is, in reality, a bunch of nonsense.

               Acupuncture: Media, Regulation, Law and Education

Scientific Fraud in China

There is a systemic problem with fraud in Chinese medical science. The problem
goes all the way to the top.

Steven Novella on November 27, 2019

Link



Editor’s note: Dr. Novella is away, so we are reposting this article from his
personal blog, NeuroLogica.

There is plenty of fraud and corruption in the world, even in the halls of
science. No one has a monopoly. But there are some hot spots that deserve
specific attention. Recently significant concerns have been raised about the
published research of Xuetao Cao, a Chinese immunologist. This story is
newsworthy because Cao is not just any immunologist – he is also the President
of Nankai University, in Tianjin, China. But more to the point – he is the
Chairman of research integrity for all Chinese research. When your head of
research integrity is exposed for massive scientific fraud, you have a problem.

Here is a thorough treatment of the evidence for fraud, which covers over 50
published papers. The fabrication of data was noticed because much of it has to 
do with pictures, of western blots, gels, flow cytometry images, and microscopy 
images. There appears to be two general types of fabrication going on. One type 
results from sending the same sample multiple times through analysis, but
treating the data as if it came from different samples. In this case the
resulting imaging will be strikingly similar in pattern, but not identical. The 
second type of fabrication is to simply Photoshop copy and paste images.

Either way, the resulting data fabrication is undeniable once it is noticed. The
images are simply too similar (and again, sometimes identical) to be genuine
data. Once researchers started pouring through Cao’s other papers, the extensive
fraud became obvious. When confronted with this revelation online, Cao
responded by first standing behind his work, then stating:

   Nevertheless, there is no excuse for any lapse in supervision or laboratory
   leadership and the concerns you raised serve as a fresh reminder to me just
   how important my role and responsibility are as mentor, supervisor, and lab
   leader; and how I might have fallen short.

Wow – you see what he just did there? He simultaneously apologized and took
responsibility, but only for failure of supervision. So essentially he is
throwing all of the people who work for him under the bus. Either way, however, 
this is really bad for Cao. Even in the best-case scenario, all the fraud was
perpetrated by others under his watch. Keep in mind, he is in charge of research
integrity for all of China, but apparently can’t keep an eye on his own lab.
There are certainly famous cases where research assistants were the ones
perpetrating the fraud. Another immunologist, Jacques Benveniste, claimed to
have evidence of immunological activity from high “homeopathic” dilutions. An
investigation found his results to be highly unreliable at least, and likely
straight-up fraudulent (although may have been due to really sloppy techniques
and bias). But it also appears that the positive results all seemed to come from
one lab assistant, Elizabeth Davenas – certainly a disturbing pattern.

Perhaps a similar pattern will emerge from Cao’s lab, but it seems unlikely that
an overzealous assistant can be responsible for data fabrication in 50
published studies. This is clearly a systemic problem.

But there have always been reasons to suspect that Cao’s research, and the
rocketing trajectory of his resultant career, were dubious. In 1988 Cao
published a paper in which he claimed that the energy produced by Qi was able to
prevent melanoma metastasis in mice. Whenever research claims that magic works,
you have to be suspicious. But if the magic is politically favored by the
powers that be, that can do wonders for your career.

The debate now focuses on how to interpret this incident, specifically what does
this say about Chinese scientific research in general? There are those who
point out that scientific fraud exists everywhere, so we shouldn’t over
interpret the implications of this case. But I don’t buy that. While every
country has its scientific fraud, there seem to be clusters that require special
attention – and China is a cluster. We can only speculate, however, about the
causes. The simplest explanation (so simple that it doesn’t really add much
insight) is that it comes down to culture. Well, sure. Integrity is mostly about
culture, the culture that exists in a profession, in a society, and in
institutions. Science only works when most people follow the rules, when there
are guardrails in place to maximize quality control, and when there is
zero-tolerance for breaking the rules. When the single person in charge of
enforcing those rules in China is exposed as a massive violator, there is a
systemic problem.

There is also strong cultural pressure in China to prove that the core beliefs
of their culture (traditional Chinese medicine and Qi) are real and powerful.
This is ideological science. As powerful evidence for this effect is acupuncture
research. Two reviews, in 1998 and again in 2014, found that 100% of
acupuncture studies coming out of China were positive. This is statistically
impossible, even if acupuncture worked (and it almost certainly doesn’t). This
is also a bit much even for just publication bias. It could all be incredible
researcher bias, but bias blurs imperceptibly into fraud. When you are fudging
your research methods, and you know this isn’t pristine, how much of that is
bias and how much fraud? In the end, it doesn’t really matter.

There is also legitimate concern that totalitarian governments do not create an 
environment in which science can flourish. Science requires transparency, it
requires valuing method over results, and it should be ideologically neutral.
These are not concepts that flourish under a totalitarian regime. Also, the
scientists who get promoted to positions of respect and power are likely to be
those who please the regime, by proving, for example, that their cultural
propaganda is real. So the selective pressures for advancement do not prioritize
research integrity.

Cao, I think, embodies all of this. This should not be viewed as an isolated
incident, or even researcher. The very fact that Cao has risen to the highest
heights of setting the standards for science in China means that we have to look
at the systemic implications of this case.

There are a couple of other lessons we should note as well. First, and
unfortunately, we need to look at all research coming out of China with an
especially careful eye. The system is broken, and cannot be given the benefit of
the doubt.

But even more broadly, scientific journals need to evaluate their methods for
rooting out fraud before it is published. The existing filter is not adequate.
It is unfortunate that journals need to expend resources just looking at
submitted papers to detect sloppy techniques, bias, and conscious fraud, but
nothing less is now acceptable. Trust in published peer-reviewed science is
critical to the system, and after a blow like this (and the many others) steps
need to be taken to restore trust by raising the bar of quality control.

                          How popular is acupuncture?

                                Brennen McKenzie

                                      Link

Everybody’s Doing It

One argument that often comes up when skeptics and proponents of so-called
complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) debate is the question of the
popularity of various CAM practices. Advocates of CAM often claim these
practices are widely used and growing rapidly in popularity. Obviously, CAM
proponents have an interest in characterizing their practices as widely accepted
and utilized. Even though the popularity of an idea is not a reliable
indication of whether or not it is true, most people are inclined to accept that
if a lot of people believe in something there must be at least some truth to
it. The evidence against this idea is overwhelming, but it is a deeply
intuitive, intransigent notion that can only rarely be dislodged.

It might therefore be useful to get some idea of whether or not the claims of
great popularity for CAM treatments are true. If they are not, fruitless debates
about the probative value of such popularity could potentially be avoided, and 
it might be possible to diminish the allure associated with the belief that
“everybody’s doing it.” 

Surveys of CAM Use

It is difficult to find good quality objective data on the popularity of
particular CAM interventions, and many of the surveys that have been done are
potentially misleading. For example,. the 2007 CDC National Health Interview
Survey (NHIS) is widely cited as showing that about 30% of Americans use CAM
therapies. A careful look at the details of this survey, however, shows that
many of the supposed CAM therapies are really relaxation or exercise practices, 
such as massage and yoga, not medical therapies. Chiropractic is the only
medical therapy generally classified as alternative that was used by more than
10% of people in the survey. And that was primarily for idiopathic lower back
pain, an indication for which it is generally accepted, even by skeptics such as
myself, as having some demonstrated benefit, about equal to standard medical
interventions. These usage numbers haven’t changed in decades, which belies the 
notion that CAM is growing in popularity.

Similarly, much was made by the media of a recent CDC survey that supposedly
showed widespread use of CAM therapies in hospice care facilities. A close
analysis of this survey, also shows that most of the therapies listed are not
truly alternative medical interventions and that fewer than half the facilities 
surveyed offered true CAM therapies, and fewer than 10% of patients in those
facilities actually employed the CAM practices offered.

Studies of Acupuncture Use

I thought it might be useful to look at some of the data concerning the
popularity acupuncture, since it is probably the most widely used and accepted
CAM therapy after chiropractic, and there have been a few interesting studies in
this area. There are certainly no comprehensive, high-quality data concerning
how many people use acupuncture, for what indications, and with what sort of
beliefs in its underlying theory or effectiveness. My purpose is not to make a
definitive statement about how popular acupuncture is but simply to take a small
step beyond vague impressions and unsupported claims about the popularity of
this intervention and look at what research there is and what insight, if any,
these numbers might give us. 

The 2007 NHIS data indicated 6.5% of Americans had reported ever using
acupuncture. Of these, 22% had seen an acupuncturist in the last 12 months. 25% 
of those who had tried acupuncture had done so once, and 70% had seen an
acupuncturist fewer than 5 times. The vast majority of those who had seen an
acupuncturist had done so for some kind of pain, primarily arthritis and other
orthopedic pain, headaches, or fibromyalgia. About 40% of the people who
reported using acupuncture for a specific condition specifically reported not
using conventional therapies for that condition, while 20-40% reported using
some kind of conventional medical therapy for the same condition. 

It is often argued that lack of interest in the utilizing acupuncture is driven 
more by cultural prejudice or belief systems than by concerns about the evidence
for its efficacy. There is likely some truth to the fact that people from
different cultures prefer familiar styles of medical treatment, though of course
this says nothing about what is actually safe or effective. And part of the
appeal of acupuncture in the West is likely its exotic, “foreign” associations.

Some surveys of acupuncture use have looked at whether different ethnic groups
in the West have differences in their utilization of acupuncture. Interestingly,
one study from Canada found that while White and Chinese Canadians differed in 
their use of some CAM modalities, their overall use of CAM was the same, and
their use of acupuncture specifically was about the same: roughly 8%. (Therapies
included in definition of CAM in Quan et al 2008: Herbal remedies, massage
therapy, chiropractic, acupuncture, amino acids, naturopathy, homeopathy, reiki,
ayurvedic medicine, biofeedback, hypnosis.)

In contrast, a survey of Chinese Americans in a mental health services program
found about 25% used acupuncture, and that this use was more prevalent among
“less acculturated” individuals. This, of course, is a group not at all
representative of the general population, so the relevance of this to overall
acupuncture use among Chinese Americans and Americans of other ethnicities is
not clear. Other studies have shown significant but complex relationships
between ethnicity, education, and other variables and the likelihood of
acupuncture use.

It seems reasonable that cultural traditions play some role in the acceptance or
rejection of acupuncture as a medical therapy, but the current data do not
support that cultural affiliation alone is the most important variable, and the 
reasons people use acupuncture seem quite consistent regardless of ethnicity or 
nationality. In any case, studies of populations in North America do not show
anything approaching a majority of the population regularly using acupuncture as
a medical therapy. Numbers vary from less than 10% to as high as 50% in some
populations, but most tend to be in the lower end of that range.

Since acupuncture as it is currently understood and practiced in Europe and
North America originated in China and has been employed there and in other Asian
countries for a lot longer than it has been used in the West (though not nearly
as long as is usually claimed), it makes sense that it would be far more widely
used in that part of the world if it is truly as popular a therapy as its
proponents claim.

One 2007 study in Taiwan found about 11% of beneficiaries of national health
insurance had used acupuncture in a given year. Interestingly, while the survey 
found that overall use of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) therapies was much 
higher than this (primarily due to use of herbal remedies), the use of TCM was
still far behind the use of so-called “Western” medicine. TCM clinic visits
accounted for only 9% of outpatient visits reimbursed under the national health 
insurance. This is similar to another study which found Chinese medicine (of all
covered types) accounted for only 5% of the reimbursed care under the national 
health insurance system. The same study indicated that “Western” medicine was
utilized more than Chinese medicine, especially among children, the elderly, and
those with severe disease (consistent with the pattern of CAM use in the U.S., 
which is generally for self-limiting or chronic disease).

Yet another study in Taiwan specifically investigated acupuncture use and found 
about 6.2% of people covered by national health insurance utilized acupuncture
in a given year, and over the seven years surveyed about 25% of covered
individuals had received acupuncture treatment. As in the U.S., the vast
majority of the acupuncture treatment sought was for musculoskeletal conditions 
or injuries (88%).

And a recently published series of surveys conducted in Japan found that about
5-7% of respondents used acupuncture in a given year, and that over a lifetime
between 20-27% of respondents had at some time tried acupuncture. More than 80% 
of the use of acupuncture was for musculoskeletal complaints. About half of
those who had used acupuncture indicated they would use it again, and about 37% 
indicated they would not.

The Bottom Line

So what does all of this mean? Well, probably not very much. Of course,
differences in healthcare systems, insurance systems, study methods, and many
other factors that are difficult to identify and asses, make direct comparisons 
between the use of specific CAM interventions in different countries very
unreliable. I don’t believe the quality of the data generally allow very
confident statements about the popularity of acupuncture or other specific CAM
methods. However, proponents of acupuncture, and CAM generally often make such
statements, trying to convey the impression that their approaches are growing
rapidly in popularity and only perverse, closed-minded curmudgeons still resist 
them. The little evidence we have certainly does not support such claims. 

In the case of acupuncture, for example, the data show relatively low levels of 
utilization even in those countries generally regarded as having long historical
traditions of using acupuncture. Informal investigations (e.g. 1, 2) have
suggested that acupuncture and other CAM practices associated with China may not
be as popular even in their native land as proponents in North America claim,
and the formal studies I have discussed here seem to support that impression.

A large majority of people who seek acupuncture therapy, regardless of ethnicity
or nationality, do so for treatment of musculoskeletal conditions and pain.
There is good evidence that the therapeutic ritual of acupuncture has some
symptomatic benefit for such indications. This is almost certainly a
non-specific treatment effect (aka “placebo”). It does not seem to matter where 
needles are inserted or if they are inserted at all, and acupuncture therapy
does not appear to measurably affect the course of any actual disease. (The
Skeptic’s Dictionary has a clear and concise review).

The research data on acupuncture utilization suggests that from about 5-25% of
people, regardless of nationality or ethnicity, will at some time try
acupuncture for, mostly for some kind of musculoskeletal pain. Conventional
therapies are often used along with acupuncture, and they are far more popular
overall, especially for serious or acute conditions. So the little research
there is suggests that acupuncture occupies a niche common to many CAM
therapies. It is used at a low level by a small to moderate proportion of the
population for conditions that are either mild, self-limiting, or without a
definitive conventional treatment, and it is rarely used in lieu of conventional
medical care. This is hardly a mounting wave of enthusiasm for acupuncture
itself, much less the mystical theories and postmodern cognitive relativism
often associated with it. 

So when proponents of acupuncture say it must work because it has been widely
used for thousands of years in Asia and is growing rapidly in popularity in the 
West, rebutting the argumentum ad populum and argumentum ad antiquitatem
fallacies may not be the skeptic’s only option. It may be worthwhile, and
simpler, just to point out that acupuncture is neither as old nor as popular as 
is commonly supposed.

References

Chang LC. Huang N. Chou YJ. Lee CH. Kao FY. Huang YT. Utilization patterns of
Chinese medicine and Western medicine under the National Health Insurance
Program in Taiwan, a population-based study from 1997 to 2003. BMC Health Serv
Res. 2008 Aug 9;8:170.

Chen FP. Chen TJ. Kung YY. Chen YC. Chou LF. Chen FJ. Hwang SJ. Use frequency of
traditional Chinese medicine in Taiwan. BMC Health Serv Res. 2007 Feb 23;7:26.

Chen FP, Kung YY, Chen TJ, Hwang SJ. Demographics and patterns of acupuncture
use in the Chinese population: the Taiwan experience. J Altern Complement Med.
2006 May;12(4):379-87.

Eisenberg DM. Kessler RC. Foster C. Norlock FE. Calkins DR. Delbanco TL.
Unconventional medicine in the United States. Prevalence, costs, and patterns of
use. N Engl J Med. 1993 Jan 28;328(4):246-52.

Ishizaki N. Yano T. Kawakita K. Public status and prevalence of acupuncture in
Japan. eCAM 2010;7(4):493-500.

Quan H. Lai D. Johnson D. Verhoef M. Musto R. Complementary and alternative
medicine use among Chinese and White Canadians. Can Fam Physician. 2008
Nov;54(11):1563-9.

Upchurch DM. Burke A. Dye C. Chyu L. Kusunoki Y. Greendale GA.A Sociobehavioral 
Model of Acupuncture Use, Patterns, and Satisfaction Among Women in the US,
2002Womens Health Issues. 2008; 18(1): 62–71. 

ICD-11: A triumph of the “integration” of quackery with real medicine

ICD-10 is an a standardized system of alphanumeric codes for diagnoses
maintained by the World Health Organization used throughout the world for
billing, epidemiology, research, and cataloging causes of death. Its successor, 
ICD-11, is nearing completion, and unfortunately appears to be taking the
“integration” of traditional medicine to a whole new level by integrating quack 
diagnoses with real diagnoses.

David Gorski on March 19, 2018

Link



Like most doctors, I detest ICD codes, and in particular I detest ICD-10. Of
course, I realize that most non-physicians reading this are asking, “What the
heck is an ICD code, and what is ICD-10”? Basically, ICD stands for
International Classification of Diseases, and ICD codes are alphanumeric codes
used to classify diagnoses. They system’s history dates back to 1893, and the
World Health Organization has been responsible for its maintenance and updating 
since its founding in 1948, at which time ICD-6 was the most current version.
Indeed, The WHO Nomenclature Regulations, adopted in 1967, stipulated that
Member States use the most current ICD revision for mortality and morbidity
statistics. The ICD has been revised and published in a series of editions to
reflect advances in health and medical science over time. The most current
version is ICD-10, which was endorsed in May 1990 by the Forty-third World
Health Assembly and formally adopted by the WHO in 1994.

ICD codes started out as being a standardized list of diseases and conditions to
be used on death certificates as causes of death. These days, ICD codes are
used for a number of purposes, although most doctors encounter these codes when 
they use them for billing insurance companies, Medicare, or Medicaid for their
services. However, ICD codes are also used for epidemiology, health management, 
clinical diagnoses, and death certificates. According to the WHO:

   ICD is the foundation for the identification of health trends and statistics 
   globally, and the international standard for reporting diseases and health
   conditions. It is the diagnostic classification standard for all clinical and
   research purposes. ICD defines the universe of diseases, disorders, injuries
   and other related health conditions, listed in a comprehensive, hierarchical
   fashion that allows for:

  1. easy storage, retrieval and analysis of health information for evidenced-based
    decision-making;

  2. sharing and comparing health information between hospitals, regions, settings 
    and countries; and

  3. data comparisons in the same location across different time periods.

   Uses include monitoring of the incidence and prevalence of diseases,
   observing reimbursements and resource allocation trends, and keeping track of
   safety and quality guidelines. They also include the counting of deaths as
   well as diseases, injuries, symptoms, reasons for encounter, factors that
   influence health status, and external causes of disease.

Normally, ICD codes were updated roughly every ten years, but ICD-10 is now
nearly a quarter of a century old. As you might imagine, it’s getting a bit long
in the tooth, no matter how long the US delayed in requiring its use. (The US, 
being ever so slow, didn’t switch from ICD-9 to ICD-10 until 2015, after most of
the rest of the world had been using ICD-10 for decades. I could go on about
how much fun it was to make that switch at the hospital and clinic level, given 
that I was in charge of creating new billing forms for our breast center in
preparation for the adoption of ICD-10, but I doubt that it would interest most 
of you.) So ICD-11 is in active development, having undergone field testing in
2017, with a current goal of a version to be approved in 2018, as this report
indicates. There’s also this:



ICD-11 Project Plan

Do you see what I see all the way to the right of the timeline, near the end?
Yes, it’s traditional medicine, and, yes, it is exactly what you think.
Traditional Chinese medicine diagnoses are being incorporated into the ICD-11.
Truly, the “integration” or “unification” of traditional Chinese medicine with
science-based medicine is nearly complete. Let’s take a look. Soon (or maybe not
so soon if the US takes as long to implement ICD-11 as it did to implement
ICD-11), I will be able to code for liver yin deficiency pattern (ICD-11 code
SF50) or liver qi stagnation pattern (ICD-11 code SF57). This is not the first
time we have discussed the issue on SBM. Would that it were the last.

Quackery codes to be introduced in the ICD-11?

I decided to write about how quackery is insinuating itself into the ICD-11
because a reader sent me this link, which is a browser for the latest beta draft
of ICD-11. You can scroll down to 26, which is Traditional Medicine conditions 
– Module 1, where the WHO describes this section thusly:

   This chapter refers to disorders and patterns which originated in ancient
   Chinese Medicine and are commonly used in China, Japan, Korea, and elsewhere 
   around the world. This list represents a union set of harmonized traditional 
   medicine conditions of the Chinese, Japanese, and Korean classifications. For
   an extended list of traditional medicine conditions, please refer to the
   International Classification of Traditional Medicine (ICTM).

Oh, yes. There is an International Classification of Traditional Medicine
(ICTM). I’ll get to that momentarily. First, let’s look at what the WHO has come
up with for “integrating” traditional medicine into real medicine. In fairness,
I will note that the introduction specifies this:

   The use of the ICD-11 TM Chapter is optional for those who would like to
   record epidemiological data about traditional medicine practice. This chapter
   should not be used for mortality reporting.

Well that’s a relief! Of course, you and I know that, once ICD-11 is adopted,
practitioners of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), such as naturopaths,
acupuncturists, and the like, will be lobbying hard to make sure that this
chapter is used. But let’s look at what the WHO says about TCM:

   A disorder in traditional medicine, disorder (TM)*, refers to a set of
   dysfunctions in any of the body systems which presents with associated
   manifestations, i.e. a single or a group of specified signs, symptoms, or
   findings. Each disorder (TM) may be defined by its symptomology, etiology,
   course and outcome, or treatment response. 1 Symptomology: signs, symptoms or
   unique findings by traditional medicine diagnostic methods, including
   inspection such as tongue examination, history taking (inquiry), listening
   and smelling examination, palpation such as pulse taking, abdominal
   examination, and other methods. 2 TM Etiology: the underlying traditional
   medicine explanatory style, such as environmental factors (historically known
   in TM translations as the external contractions), emotional factors
   (historically known in TM translations as the seven emotions), or other
   pathological factors, processes, and products. 3 Course and outcome: a unique
   path of development of the disorder (TM) over time. 4 Treatment response:
   known response to traditional medicine interventions. In defining a disorder 
   (TM), symptomology and etiology are required. Course and outcome, and
   treatment response are optional.

   A pattern in traditional medicine, pattern (TM), refers to the complete
   clinical presentation of the patient at a given moment in time including all 
   findings. Findings may include symptomology or patient constitution, among
   other things. 1 Symptomology (as above). 2 Constitution: the characteristics 
   of an individual, including structural and functional characteristics,
   temperament, ability to adapt to environmental changes, or susceptibility to 
   various health conditions. This is relatively stable, being in part
   genetically determined while partially acquired.

Let’s take a look at some of the more…interesting…TCM diagnoses that ICD-11 will
allow practitioners to code for:

   SG26 Bladder meridian pattern (TM)A pattern characterized by clashing
   headache and sensation that the eyes are being torn out. The nape of the neck
   is tight, there is pain in the spine, the waist arches backwards, the thigh 
   cannot flex, the back of the knee has lumps and there is a sensation that the
   calf is being split apart. Symptoms and signs also include excess
   lacrimation, nasal congestion, pain in the head, neck, back, waist, sacrum,
   back of the knee, calf and foot, and impaired use of the little toe. It may
   be explained by Bladder meridian dysfunction.

I do like the addition of “impaired use of the little toe.” It’s such a nice
little detailed touch to the otherwise nonspecific. That’s the symptom that
cinches the diagnosis, I bet. Of course, if you have a headache so severe that
it feels as though your eyes are being torn out, along with pain in the spine
and all these other symptoms, I’d be worried about either a brain tumor or
meningitis, among other potentially life-threatening conditions. Of course,
adding all these other symptoms just makes the whole thing a mess. But you’ll
soon be able to code for it!

I like this next one just for the name:

   SG29 Triple energizer meridian pattern (TM)A pattern characterized by
   deafness and tinnitus, swelling and obstruction of the throat. Symptoms and
   signs also include sweating, pain at the lateral corners of the eye and
   cheeks, pain behind the ear and along the shoulders, upper arms, elbows and
   outer border of the forearms and impaired use of the fourth finger. It may be
   explained by Triple Energizer meridian dysfunction.

I suppose this must be worse than the double or single energizer meridian
pattern. Actually, there doesn’t appear to be such a diagnosis. Why always
triple? Who knows. I do note, though, that there are various subdiagnoses,
including upper energizer stage patterns (SG70), middle energizer stage patterns
(SG71), and lower energizer stage patterns (SG72). Of course, you know this is 
an ICD classification, because even diagnoses based on prescientific mystical
beliefs include something like triple energizer stage patterns (TM), unspecified
(SG7Z). Doctors, nurses, medical coders, and others who use ICD-10 codes on a
regular basis will get that joke.

Before I move on, I can’t resist listing a couple more. I mentioned that I’ll
soon be able to code for liver qi stagnation, but what does that mean? It means 
exactly what it sounds like:

   SF57 Liver qi stagnation pattern (TM)A pattern characterized by distending
   and burning pain of the hypochondrium, along with restlessness, irritability,
   bitter taste, dry mouth, red tongue with yellow coating or a wiry rapid
   pulse. It may be explained by long-term stagnation of liver system qi induced
   internal fire factor that affects tissues and functions associated with the 
   liver system.

Because I sure don’t want my qi stagnated by internal fire factor or qi
stagnation producing internal fire factor. (I can’t tell which they mean from
the rather garbled phrasing of that definition.) In any case, these Traditional 
Medicine codes are all based on several patterns. Here are several:

  1. Principle-based patterns: “Based on the analysis of symptomatology and
    constitution of a patient, patterns are categorized into eight principles
    which consist of four groups of opposing characteristics i.e. Yin & Yang,
    Heat & Cold, Deficiency & Excess and Interior & Exterior (and with the
    addition of three intermediate patterns). These principles constitute the
    most basic patterns which may be combined for pattern differentiation in
    more refined detail.”

  2. Environmental factor patterns: “This section comprises patterns with a shared 
    explanation related to environmental factors (i.e. wind, cold, dampness,
    dryness, fire, summer-heat) and the presence of the pathogens, parasites or 
    toxins.”

  3. Body constituents patterns: “This section comprises a range of dysfunctions of
    four body constituents, which is qi, blood, fluid and essence. These
    patterns are grouped together on the basis of their common etiology such as 
    an abnormal flow of qi, blood, or essence or dysfunctional distribution of
    fluid.” (I note that this section has diagnoses like qi deficiency pattern, 
    qi stagnation pattern, qi uprising pattern, qi collapse pattern, qi sinking 
    pattern, and, of course, qi patterns, unspecified.)

  4. Organ system patterns: “This section comprises a range of Qi disturbance
    patterns grouped together on the basis of their having in common a
    demonstrable etiology in Qi, which means invisible action, function, or
    working that circulates throughout the body. Qi Patterns (TM) may be
    explained by a disorder of physical energy supply, mental disorder, or a
    [sic] autonomic nerve system disorder.”

  5. Meridian and collateral patterns: “This section contains a group of TM
    patterns caused by functional disorder of meridians consisting of twelve
    main meridians and eight extra meridians.”

  6. Six stage patterns: “This section contains patterns in accordance with the
    six-stage theory. A common characteristic of the Six-stage patterns included
    in this section is their relationship with the acute febrile conditions.”

  7. Triple energizer stage patterns: “This section comprises dysfunctional
    systemic patterns of coordination, assimilation, elimination and integration
    attributed to invasion and transformation of the dampness-heat factor on
    the three portions of the body cavity (upper energizer, middle energizer and
    lower energizer), through which the visceral qi is transformed.” And you
    wouldn’t want your visceral qi transformed, now would you?

  8. Four constitution medicine patterns: “Four Constitution Medicine Patterns are 
    classified by each type of constitution: Large Yang Type (Large Lung Small
    Liver), Small Yang Type (Large Spleen Small Kidney), Large Yin Type (Large
    Liver Small Lung), and Small Yin Type (Large Kidney Small Spleen). Metabolic
    processes in Four Constitution Medicine can be divided into 2 categories:
    Qi-Humor metabolism and Water-Food metabolism. Large Yang Type patterns and 
    Large Yin Type patterns are caused by disorder of the Qi-Humor metabolism
    while Small Yang Type patterns and Small Yin Type patterns are caused by
    disorder of the Water-Food metabolism. Patterns occurring for each type of
    constitution can be subdivided into three types: external TM disorder,
    internal TM disorder and external-internal combined TM disorder. External TM
    disorder is caused by imbalance of Seong (Innate Nature) and internal TM
    disorder is caused by the imbalance of Jeong (Emotional Disposition).”

I could go on, as I didn’t list all of them, but you get the idea. These
diagnoses are not based in science or modern medicine, but rather in
prescientific beliefs about the body and vitalistic mystical and religious
beliefs dating back millennia. Such diagnoses have no place being included in a 
classification system that is supposed to reflect the latest in medical science.
If you don’t believe me, I encourage you to go to the ICD-11 Beta Draft and
peruse Traditional Medicine Conditions.

Why is the WHO “integrating” quackery with real medicine in ICD-11?

As I perused the ridiculous pseudoscientific “diagnoses” in the Traditional
Medicine section of the ICD-11 Beta Draft, one question kept going through my
mind: Why? Why is the WHO “integrating” quackery with real medicine in the
official disease classification system used by basically the whole world? Why is
it betraying the trust it was granted when the maintenance and updating of the 
International Classification of Diseases were first entrusted to it in 1948? It 
began with something I mentioned above, the International Classification of
Traditional Medicine (ICTM), a project designed to classify the use of
traditional medicine. The WHO justified starting the ICTM project by pointing to
a survey of its member nations that showed that in some Asian countries, over
80% of the population depends on some form of traditional medicine. Of course,
my response to that factoid would be that greater efforts must be made to get
science-based medicine to these people, not that we should infect the ICD system
with quack diagnoses, but that’s just me.

In any event, this is the WHO’s justification for developing the ICTM:

   “We recognize that the use of traditional medicine is widespread. For many
   people – especially in the Western Pacific, South-East Asia, Africa and Latin
   America – traditional medicine is the primary source of health care,” said
   Dr Marie-Paule Kieny, Assistant Director-General of Innovation, Information, 
   Evidence and Research at WHO. “Throughout the rest of the world, particularly
   Europe and North America, use of herbal medicines, acupuncture, and other
   traditional medicine practices is increasing. Global classification and
   terminology tools, for traditional medicine, however, have been lacking.”

And:

   “Several countries have created national standards for the classification of 
   traditional medicine but there is no international platform that allows the
   harmonization of data for clinical, epidemiological and statistical use.
   There is a need for this information to allow clinicians, researchers and
   policy-makers to comprehensively monitor safety, efficacy, use, spending and 
   trends in health care,” said Kieny.

   The classification will initially focus on traditional medicine practices
   from China, Japan and the Republic of Korea that have evolved and spread
   worldwide.

Believe it or not, I could support an international classification system for
traditional medicine if its sole purpose were as a research tool and it were
kept separate from science-based classifications. For instance, such a
classification could be used to study herb-drug interactions, an area where
there is a great deal that is still unknown. Also, if we knew who uses TCM, for 
what conditions, and why, we might be able to develop more effective strategies 
to encourage the use of effective science-based medicine in such populations. I 
am even sympathetic to one argument, which is that many indigenous peoples are
essentially “invisible” to health statistics because they use only traditional
medicine.

To address these problems does not require integrating such a classification
system with ICD-11, and, such uses were never the intent for the ICTM, which was
always intended to be integrated into ICD-11 from its very inception. Indeed,
the WHO has been promoting traditional medicine use for a long time. I first
became aware of it a few years ago, when the WHO participated in writing
supplements for Science promoting the “integration” of TCM with science-based
medicine. One of the supplements discussed the WHO’s Traditional Medicine
Strategy (2014– 2023), highlighting the global scientific challenges and showing
how a systems biology approach can be applied to traditional medicine like
acupuncture.

Before that, though, in 2008, the WHO held a Congress on Traditional Medicine in
Beijing and adopted the Beijing Declaration, which was basically a declaration 
to support the use of traditional medicine. You can read the whole declaration
for yourself here, but here are some key statements:

   I. The knowledge of traditional medicine, treatments and practices should be 
   respected, preserved, promoted and communicated widely and appropriately
   based on the circumstances in each country.

Yes, you read that right. It gets worse, though. Here are three more parts of
the Declaration:

   III. Recognizing the progress of many governments to date in integrating
   traditional medicine into their national health systems, we call on those who
   have not yet done so to take action.

And:

   V. Governments should establish systems for the qualification, accreditation 
   or licensing of traditional medicine practitioners. Traditional medicine
   practitioners should upgrade their knowledge and skills based on national
   requirements.

   VI. The communication between conventional and traditional medicine providers
   should be strengthened and appropriate training programmes be established
   for health professionals, medical students and relevant researchers.

This is nothing less than a call for the full “integration” of TCM quackery with
science-based medicine. I can’t help but point out that the WHO’s own press
release on ICTM in 2010 stated that its purpose was to “assist in creating an
evidence base for traditional medicine,” as though the assumption was that
traditional medicine works. As Ryan Abbott, director of research and project
management for Nova Worldwide Consulting and a former member of WHO’s
traditional medicine team, put it, “Inclusion in the WHO Family of International
Classifications, a very conventional tool of mainstream medical care, would be 
a powerful endorsement of traditional medicine.” Abbott also noted that an
additional impact might include greater insurance reimbursement for traditional 
providers and services.

Because of course it will. That’s a huge part of the purpose. Insurance
companies, governments, and third party payers use ICD-10 codes and CPT
procedure codes to determine reimbursement. Inclusion of traditional medicine
diagnoses in ICD-11 would provide a powerful tool for quacks to use to lobby for
reimbursement for their services.

Proponents also know what the purpose of ICTM and its integration into ICD-11
really is:

   The ICTM can be used as an independent, stand-alone classification and could 
   also be included as an additional chapter within the ICD, in part or as a
   whole. This will enable unification of the conventional and traditional
   medicine classifications for diagnosis and interventions. The project will
   establish links with the WHO Family of International Classifications (WHOFIC)
   network to enable the membership of ICTM as a derived classification of the 
   WHO family.

That’s the real purpose of ICTM and the inclusion of a subset of it in ICD-11:
The “integration” of quackery as an equal with science-based medicine. Yes, the 
WHO says that the traditional medicine module of ICD-11 is optional. For now. I 
predict that it won’t be long after ICD-11 is adopted and various nations begin 
to implement it that it will cease to be optional.

Somewhere Chairman Mao Zedong is smiling

I’ve written before, as have other SBM bloggers, about how the construct that we
know today as “traditional Chinese medicine” was actually created by Communist 
dictator Chairman Mao Zedong in the 1940s and 1950s. Basically, Mao, seeing that
he did not have the resources to provide real medicine to all his people,
decided to tap into the various schools of traditional medicine. In doing so, he
and his physicians and scientists essentially retconned the history of TCM to
turn it into seemingly an intellectually consistent whole system, when in
reality there were many forms of traditional Chinese medicine flowing out of
many folk traditions. Meanwhile, Mao himself eschewed TCM, not believing in it:

   …In The Private Life of Chairman Mao, Li Zhisui, one of Mao’s personal
   physicians, recounts a conversation they had on the subject. Trained as an
   M.D. in Western medicine, Li admitted to being baffled by ancient Chinese
   medical books, especially their theories relating to the five elements. It
   turns out his employer also found them implausible.

   “Even though I believe we should promote Chinese medicine,” Mao told him, “I 
   personally do not believe in it. I don’t take Chinese medicine.”

Yet in a 1950 speech, Mao proclaimed:

   Our nation’s health work teams are large. They have to concern themselves
   with over 500 million people [including the] young, old, and ill. … At
   present, doctors of Western medicine are few, and thus the broad masses of
   the people, and in particular the peasants, rely on Chinese medicine to treat
   illness. Therefore, we must strive for the complete unification of Chinese
   medicine. (Translations from Kim Taylor’s Chinese Medicine in Early Communist
   China, 1945-1963: A Medicine of Revolution.)

Indeed, much of the reason why TCM spread beyond China to much of the developed 
world, to the point that major academic medical centers such as the Cleveland
Clinic offer it, is because Mao aggressively promoted it. Indeed, if you want to
know just how aggressively over how long a period of time Mao promoted the
export of TCM, it’s worth it to read Kimball Atwood’s epic “Acupuncture
Anesthesia”: A Proclamation from Chairman Mao, particularly part III, in which
Mao’s efforts to unify TCM with “Western” medicine into a new “whole” are
detailed. Indeed, it’s worth repeating Communist Party slogans about medicine
from Mao’s era:

   1945-50 ‘The Co-operation of Chinese and Western Medicines’

   1950-8 ‘The Unification of Chinese and Western Medicines’

   1950-53 ‘Chinese Medicine studies Western Medicine’

   1954-8 ‘Western Medicine studies Chinese Medicine’

   1958- ‘The Integration of Chinese and Western Medicines’

Lest you think that the above slogans are merely artifacts of history from 60+
years ago, think again. A little over a year ago, China passed a law requiring
the “integration” of TCM with “Western” medicine, explicitly elevating its
status with respect to the state to be on “equal footing.” It also goes a long
way towards protecting the business interests of TCM industries, such as those
that manufacture herbal remedies. So China is still in the business of promoting
the export of TCM, even more than 40 years after Mao’s death.

I doubt that even Mao could have imagined such a triumph of completely
integrating TCM into the very codebook for modern medical diagnoses, the ICD-11,
but that triumph will soon be upon us. My only hope in the US is that we will
be as slow to adopt ICD-11 as we were to adopt ICD-10.

California Acupuncture Board: a Mockery of Consumer Protection

Ben Kavoussi on June 22, 2012

Link


   Many of the specific issues that the Governor and the Legislature asked the
   Commission to review have festered because the [California] Acupuncture Board
   has often acted as a venue for promoting the profession rather than
   regulating the profession.

   — Little Hoover Commission, Regulation of Acupuncture: A Complementary
   Therapy Framework: September 2004, page 63.

On March 12, 2012, during a brief Sunset Review hearing, the California Senate
Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development asked the California
Acupuncture Board (the Board) to respond to a set of harsh criticisms.

It is not the first time that the dysfunctional Board — which falls under the
Department of Consumer Affairs — is being scrutinized by the legislator. The
Board has a long history of operating in an inefficient manner, misreading its
governing statutes, and potentially endangering the public by refusing to
promulgate regulations concerning the sterilization of acupuncture needles or
the wear of medical gloves by practitioners.

In the past, members and affiliates have even been investigated for taking
bribes and selling licensing exam answers. The Board was replaced several times 
in order to clean up the quasi-anarchic and corrupt practice of acupuncture and 
Oriental medicine in California.

This time, the Senate Committee listed 10 major issues in a Background Paper,
which is a worthwhile read for those interested in the regulation of
acupuncture. The Senate expressed serious concerns about many administrative,
educational, licensing, enforcement, consumer protection and budgetary matters. 
In response, the Board Chair and Executive Director offered little explanation. 
The Board now must respond to the Background Paper in specifics.

Trouble at the state acupuncture regulating authority goes back to 1982. The
longtime chairman of the former acupuncture regulating agency (the Acupuncture
Committee), Chae Woo Lew, was selling the answers to the California Acupuncture 
Licensing Examination for $10,000 to $20,000. He made $500,000 to $800,000 from 
an estimated 80 test takers. He was caught in 1988, but only a few dozen
individuals who bought answers from him were ever caught. Lew was sentenced in
1990 to five years in prison.

In 1999 Acupuncture Committee became the Acupuncture Board. The Board was
sunrisen until June of 2002.

During the 2002 sunset review of the Board, an independent state oversight
agency called the Little Hoover Commission (LHC) was charged to assess
longstanding and contentious issues regarding the State’s regulation of
acupuncture — including a review of the scope of practice and educational
requirements for acupuncturists, the process for accrediting acupuncture schools
and for examining licensees.

LHC provided its assessment to the Legislature in September 2004 in a report
called Regulation of Acupuncture: A Complementary Therapy Framework, (Report
#175). LHC blamed the Board for many of the problems the profession faced. The
report stated that the Board had “too frequently acted as a venue for promoting 
rather than regulating the profession.” It added that as a result, the Board had
“missed opportunities to protect the public by providing accurate and complete 
information about the therapies that licensees can provide.” The report also
stated that the Board had not “adequately incorporated emerging scientific
evidence into board policies, regulations and public communications.”

The following Board review in 2005 found little improvements. Among the main
concerns was the fact that the Board had misread its governing statutes
concerning the scope of practice of acupuncturists. It also pointed out that the
Board had potentially endangered the public by refusing to promulgate
regulations concerning the sterilization of needles or even to discuss this
issue as an agenda item in any public meeting.

During the most recent Board review, the Senate committee pointed out that most 
of the current issues are the same as those the former sunset review committees 
had struggled with. The persistence of these issues appears to indicate a
general lack of accountability and follow-through on the part of the Board,
making one wonder if there is a real willingness to take direction from the
Legislature and to implement its recommendations.

The March 12, 2012, hearing ended with the Senate Committese letting the Board’s
Chair and Executive Director know that it was very concerned about how the
Board operates.

One of the persisting issue is the Board’s insufficient oversight of continuing 
education units (CEUs) . The Board has consistently approved material that is
“grossly out of compliance” with it own regulations. The Senate Committee gave
examples of courses in numerology, vitalism, astrology, “the Capacity and
Function of Love,” cosmology, magic, sound healing with tuning forks; Reiki and 
“Four Energy Healing Theories,” whatever that means.

A 2003 CEU certificate in “Alchemical Acupuncture” taught by Jeffrey C. Yuen. A 
     workshop in such outrageous nonsense is sufficient to renew an active
                       acupuncture license in California.

The Board has indeed a long history of approving CEUs in hocus pocus. Examples
are courses in mysticism, Taoism, alchemy, astrology, iridology, magic, geomancy
(I-Ching), numerology, etc. The latest list is available here. What is most
disturbing is the Board’s continuing denial that there is something wrong with
approving a course in subjects such as astrology…

This flyer states in a different section that “This workshop is approved for 21 
               CEUs in Category 1 by the California State Board.”

  After a complaint letter to the Board, its Executive Officer, Janelle Wedge,
writes to me that: “Based on the comments received, there is no reason to alter 
  the approval of the course.” Wedge resigned right after the Senate hearing.

Another Senate criticism was the disciplinary case management time-frame. The
Board, which is responsible for regulating the practice of approximately 10,000 
acupuncturists, takes at least 2½ years to investigate and take action. Since
2008, there has been an average of 223 enforcement cases per year; the majority 
involve unprofessional conduct, ethical issues, practice management issues and
sexual misconduct. A list of disciplinary actions is available at the Board
Actions webpage. The Board has received an average of 145 direct complaints
complaints per year since 2008. It has also received 78 arrest/conviction
reports from law enforcement since 2008.

And arrest and conviction there is — even for major crimes, such as trafficking 
in persons and sexual slavery. The media reports that since 2006, 17 people from
10 massage and acupuncture parlors in Redondo Beach, CA, have been arrested for
alleged acts of prostitution (The Daily Breeze, Dec 8, 2010). In June 2009, 22 
women – most of them Chinese nationals – were arrested in Vista, CA, in
connection with 9 day spas and acupuncture clinics (FOX 5 San Diego, June 4,
2009). Prior to that, in March 2007, in one of the largest prostitution
investigations ever in Orange County, CA, five individuals were arrested in
business that advertised acupuncture and massage but sex was the only service
provided.

  According to District Attorney Tony Rackauckas, plastic food wraps were used
instead of condoms in an acupuncture brothel in Orange County, CA. Photo source:
                            Orange County Register.

Crime at acupuncture and massage parlors is such a concern that some local
governments in Southern California have taken their own preventative measures by
withholding business licensing. For example, the neighboring cities of Redondo 
Beach and Torrance have recently passed Urgency Ordinances that impose a
moratorium on the issuance of any new permit, license, approval or entitlement
pertaining to new massage/bodywork and acupuncture businesses, services and
practitioners.

The picture that emerges here based on the Senate review and reports in the
media, is that acupuncture in California is a poorly-regulated and corrupt
profession with an ill-defined scope of practice. Many practitioners are deluded
purveyors of New Age mumbo-jumbo, and a few are criminals involved in human
trafficking and prostitution. The dysfunctional Acupuncture Board not only does 
not protect the public from quacks and criminals, but quite to the contrary, has
a long legacy of acting in their favor. None of this serves the best interest
of the public.

By looking at this picture, the world “Kafkaesque” comes to my mind. It is the
only term that can accurately describe the senseless, disorienting and often
menacing complexity of acupuncture regulation in California. The Board’s failure
to follow a clear course of action, its unwillingness to implement its mission,
the incomprehensible delays in disciplinary actions, and the bizarre and
illogical rationale for some of its decisions, all point to the cynical
dereliction of public safety by a group of defiant insiders.

California Acupuncturists Don’t Need to Know English!

Ben Kavoussi on September 1, 2013

Link


   English proficiency is not a necessary precursor to becoming a contributing
   citizen in California’s economy and should not be used by the Board to
   discriminate against talented and skilled individuals who seek to provide
   high-quality acupuncture services in California.

   — State Senators Curren D. Price Jr. and Darrell Steinberg, letter to the
   California Acupuncture Board, March 22, 2013.

To appreciate the recklessness of this statement, and to illustrate the
Senators’ disconnect with the reality of Oriental medicine, let’s take a look at
a consummate example of services provided by acupuncturists. The following
video features the “Master” Kim Nam-soo demonstrating his moxibustion technique.
He conducted a similar workshop for future acupuncturists in 2010 at Emperor’s 
College of Traditional Oriental Medicine in Santa Monica, CA. Make sure you do
not miss the part where the Master is skillfully adding his own spit to the
treatment!

Kim Nam-Soo (also known as “Gudang”) is a 97-year-old acupuncturist from South
Korea. In this video, he is teaching a form of moxibustion (burning of a mugwort
cone on or near the skin). He is first preparing a wad of mugwort (Artemisia
vulgaris), he is then placing it on an acupuncture point and burning it with an 
incense stick. Note that he is using his own saliva to make the mugwort more
malleable before sticking it to the patient’s skin!

Besides acupuncture and moxibustion, the other services these “talented and
skilled” individuals provide consist of massage, cupping, breathing techniques, 
and the use of herbal, animal and mineral products. In most states, bloodletting
is not part of their scope of practice — except for Arkansas.

Forty years after the legalization of the profession in California, one can
complete a 4-year vocational degree in acupuncture and Oriental medicine here in
the Golden State — all in Chinese or Korean — and then pass a state licensing
exam in the same language. The license allows the graduates to lawfully act as a
“primary care provider” without having a working knowledge of English! As a
result of this aberration in our healthcare laws, hundreds of unscrupulous
fortune-seekers come to California each year to learn and practice unscientific 
mumbo-jumbo without ever learning English. Most of them could not study
acupuncture in their native country because healthcare providers are upheld at a
much higher standard than here, and acupuncturists are required to know modern 
biomedical sciences along with traditional modalities.

The Acupuncture Board of the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) was recently
working to address this issue by limiting the California Acupuncture Licensure
Examination (CALE) to English-only. On March 20, 2013, the CA Acupuncture Board 
organized a town hall meeting in San Francisco to present the reasons behind the
necessity of an English-only licensing exam and then ask for public comments
(click on the following image to read the report obtained under the California
Public Records Act).

Yet, the initiative came to an abrupt end by a cease-and-desist letter from
State Senators Curren D. Price Jr., Chair of the Senate Business, Professions
and Economic Development Committee, and Senate President pro Tem Darrell
Steinberg. The Senators have asked the Acupuncture Board to immediately abandon 
its attempts to institute an English-only exam. They are claiming that asking
for language proficiency from a healthcare provider is “discrimination!”

Ironically, the cease-and-desist letter came from the same Senate committee that
harshly criticized the Board in March 2012 for promoting the profession instead
of protecting the public. Exactly a year later, it is the Senators themselves
that have come to promote the profession, and to act in overt disregard for the 
California Business and Professions Code 4928.1:

   Protection of the public shall be the highest priority for the Acupuncture
   Board in exercising its licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions.
   Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests
   sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount.

Also, this letter is rather curious in that it does not seem to be stating an
official position of the Senate or the Business, Professions and Economic
Development Committee. The letter starts “We write . . .” but it does not say
that either the Senate or the Committee took a vote on the issue, nor do the
Senators claim to be writing on behalf of either body. It rather seems that the 
letter reflects the Senators’ personal opinion, even if this request is on the
official Senate stationary and the authors use their official title.

What is also strange here, is the fact that the licensing of healthcare
providers without English fluency is not a real concern for the Senators. A
staff member who wished to remain anonymous even confirmed that the Senators
wrote this letter without consulting any conventional healthcare providers,
public health officials, or anyone else with knowledge of infectious diseases,
pharmacology, or drug-herb interactions.

Senators Price and Steinberg (and their advisers in this matter, LeOndra Clark, 
and Bill Gage) seem to have allowed the popularity of Oriental medicine in the
Golden State to cloud their common sense, leading them to ignore the crucial
fact that acupuncture is not without adverse effects because it is an invasive
procedure. They are ignoring that many complications can arise from acupuncture 
and threaten the patient after needling or after the use of supplements. An
acupuncturist who does not have enough English proficiency to conduct a thorough
patient interview may not be able to ensure that the modalities within his or
her scope of practice are not contraindicated or otherwise subject to caution.

It is therefore important to remind the Senators and their advisers, LeOndra
Clark and Bill Gage, that although acupuncture does not seem very harmful, a
2012 study by Wheway et al. indicated that the total figure of needling adverse 
incidents is likely under-reported and underestimated. Some of these incidents
are medical emergencies involving organ injury. When needles are pushed in too
deeply, they can indeed injure nerves or puncture internal organs – particularly
the lungs, which causes pneumothorax.

Additional dangers include bleeding or bruising due to needling, especially in
cases where the patient has a bleeding disorder or takes anticoagulants.
Electro-acupuncture, which involves applying mild electrical pulses to the
needles — something akin to Percutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation (PENS) —
can interfere with a pacemaker. Acupuncture can also lead to pregnancy
complications. This is why an acupuncturist has to be able to effectively
communicate with patients and to also make sure that emergency services are
available.1

The use of herbal products also requires effective patient-provider
communication. Besides the inherent toxicity of some of them, the potential for 
herb-drug interactions also exists and should always be a real concern. Several 
of herbal products have been demonstrated to compete with drugs for cellular
receptors, and therefore, a mostly unknown and unreported form of “polypharmacy”
exists in patients that also take conventional drugs.2

A good example is the commonly used medicinal herb dang gui (Angelica sinensis).
Also known as dong quai, tangkuei, or “female ginseng,” Chinese medicine uses
dang gui for premenstrual, menopausal, and other gynecological symptoms, as well
as for fatigue, anemia, and high blood pressure. Pharmacological properties of 
this herb have been attributed to constituent coumarins, polysaccharides,
fenulate and/or falvonoids.3,4 In a clinical setting, the concurrent use of dang
gui and warfarin reportedly potentiates the anticoagulant effects of the
latter, and increases the international normalized ratio (INR) – a measure to
monitor the impact of anticoagulants. This can cause widespread bruising.5,6
Considering these factors, the use of dang gui with anticoagulants, platelet
inhibitors and thrombolytic agents is contraindicated.7,8

Licorice root, known as gan cao in Chinese, is another commonly used example
that can cause drug-herb interactions. Licorice which contains compounds that
mimic aldosterone can interfere with the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone axis and 
lead to hypokalaemia.9 Licorice has been demonstrated to decrease the clearance 
of prednisolone and to increase prednisolone bioavailability. Licorice has also 
been reported to potentiate the cutaneous vasoconstrictor response of
hydrocortisone. In total, more than 100 drugs are known to interact with
licorice, including corticosteroids, antihypertensives, diuretics, laxatives,
and other potassium-depleting drugs.10

The California Acupuncture Board, whose mandate is to protect the public, has
attempted several times to address the lack of proper patient-provider or
provider-provider communication. But every time, groups of practitioners,
students, school representatives, and trade insiders vehemently object to any
change by claiming discrimination, by calling themselves “contributing
citizens,” and by receiving support from politicians who know even less about
acupuncture and Oriental medicine than they do about healthcare or patient
safety. On March 20, 2013, they came in large numbers for a showdown at a town
hall meeting in San Francisco, where the Board was presenting the reasons behind
the proposal to limit the licensing exam to English only.

Immediately after, State Senators Price Jr. and Steinberg ran to their rescue
with a cease-and-desist letter stating that the US is not necessarily an
“English-speaking country,” and that “English proficiency is not a necessary
precursor to becoming a contributing citizen in California’s economy.” The
Senators also add:

   We respectfully request the Board to immediately cease and desist in its
   efforts to adopt an English-based examination and urge the Board’s
   consideration of other robust examination options that require a high level
   of competency for licensure and also preserve the ability for applicants to
   take the examination in languages other than English.

The Board cancelled other town hall meetings it had scheduled and laid the issue
to rest.

In many ways this setback speaks to California’s poor healthcare policies, its
politicians, and the place of science in its public health arena. Making
healthcare policies based on racial and ethnic politics indicates a profound
lack of concern for science and evidence in medicine. Also, claiming that
effective patient-provider communication and language proficiency are not
necessary to provide an invasive procedure such as acupuncture irresponsibly
endangers the public by reducing medicine to the rank of politics.

For those of us who put our faith in science and evidence, these non-English
speaking “contributing,” “talented and skilled” citizens, are in reality
ignorant voodoo-doctors who have become “primary” healthcare providers because
of an enormous absurdity in California law. Since the legalization of
acupuncture in the Golden State, these individuals have continuously endangered 
the public, and each time anyone tries to do anything about patient safety, they
run to the first medically-illiterate politician they can find, and cry
harassment and discrimination.

Unfortunately, now that California lists acupuncture as a benefit that insurers 
must include in new plans under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care, New 
Age hocus-pocus has taken a false sense of legitimacy and efficacy simply
because it is listed as a mandatory benefit under the new healthcare law.
Acupuncture joins tobacco cessation, vision screening and other benefits that
insurers must cover for patients under new plans, beginning in 2014.
Appallingly, this turns deluded ignorants into much needed providers; and if
they do not speak any English, as long as they are contributing to California’s 
economy, oh well!

As for the crackpot who came to California in 2010 to teach future
acupuncturists how to put spit and filth on patients, according to The Korea
Times he was suspended in his native country the year before for practicing his 
craft without a license.11

With many thanks to Harriet Hall, Ui-Won Hwang, Paul Ingram and JooNyun Kim for 
their valuable assistance or comments. The opinions expressed here are those of 
the author.

REFERENCES

  1. Wheway J, Agbabiaka TB, Ernst E. Patient safety incidents from acupuncture
    treatments: a review of reports to the National Patient Safety Agency. Int J
    Risk Saf Med 2012;24:163-9.  Return to text

  2. Chan E, Tan M, Xin J, Sudarsanam S, Johnson DE. Interactions between
    traditional Chinese medicines and Western therapeutics. Curr Opin Drug
    Discov Devel. 2010 Jan;13(1):50-65. Review. PubMed PMID: 20047146.  Return
    to text

  3. Zhao KJ, Dong TT, Tu PF, Song ZH, Lo CK, Tsim KW: Molecular genetic and
    chemical assessment of Radix Angelica (Danggui) in China. J Agric Food Chem 
    (2003) (9):2576-2583.  Return to text

  4. Page RL 2nd, Lawrence JD. Potentiation of warfarin by dong quai.
    Pharmacotherapy. 1999;19:870-876.  Return to text

  5. Fugh-Berman A: Herb-drug interactions. Lancet (2000) 355 (9198):134-138. 
    Return to text

  6. Drug interactions between Abbokinase and dong quai: Drugs. com, Drugsite
    Trust, North Shore, Auckland, New Zealand (2009).
    www.drugs.com/drug-interactions/abbokinase-with-dong-quai-2280-3882-2366-0.h
    tml [Accessed 11 May 2013].  Return to text

  7. Dong quai (Angelica sinensis): US National Library of Medicine, Bethesda, MD, 
    USA (2009). www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/druginfo/natural/936.html [Accessed 
    11 May 2013].  Return to text

  8. Circosta C, Pasquale RD, Palumbo DR, Samperi S, Occhiuto F. Estrogenic
    activity of standardized extract of Angelica sinensis. Phytother Res.
    2006;20(8):665-9.  Return to text

  9. Epstein MT, Espiner EA, Donald RA, Hughes H. Effect of eating liquorice on the
    renin-angiotensin aldosterone axis in normal subjects. Br Med J. 1977 Feb
    19;1(6059):488-90.  Return to text

  10. Licorice drug interactions: Drugs.com, Drugsite Trust, North Shore, Auckland, 
    New Zealand (2009). www.drugs.com/drug-interactions/ licorice-index.html
    [Accessed 11 May 2013].  Return to text

  11. Han J. Acupuncturist Causes Controversy. The Korea Times (2009-01-27).
    www.koreatimes.co.kr/www/news/biz/2009/07/123_38492.html [Accessed 28 May
    2013].  Return to text

California Acupuncture Licensing: Sinking Lower in the Slime!

Ben Kavoussi on February 1, 2013

Link


   The sun shone down upon that putrescence,As if to roast it to a turn,And to
   give back a hundredfold to great NatureThe elements she had combined…—
   Charles Baudelaire, The Carcase1

Trouble for the struggling California Acupuncture Board (Board) is far from
being over.

After being taken to task by the California Senate less than a year ago for
acting “as a venue for promoting the profession” rather than regulating it, now 
the Board is being petitioned for reform by license applicants after a major
compromise in the California Acupuncture Licensing Examination (CALI). This is
the exam that allows the graduates of state-approved training programs to
practice acupuncture, herbalism and Asian massage in California. Physicians who 
use these modalities are regulated by the Medical Board.

Bear in mind that California is the only state in the nation that has its own
acupuncture licensing examination. In other states where the profession is
regulated, candidates have to take a battery of computer-based tests developed
by the National Certification Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine
(NCCAOM). The California test is designed by the Department of Consumer Affairs,
and could be taken in English, Chinese or Korean. This means that an individual
can get licensed and practice healthcare in California, without understanding a
word of English!

The recent test compromise is so significant that the Office of Professional
Examination Services (OPES)—an entity within the Department of Consumer Affairs 
which develops licensing examinations—was called to testify during the November 
2012 Board meeting.

Bob Holmgren of OPES told the Board that following a tip, investigators
discovered that test preparation seminars in the Los Angeles area were selling
study guides that contained actual questions from former exams. How did this
happen? Holmgren believes that a number of test takers have been memorizing
questions, so that seminar organizers can reconstruct the whole
examination—something that is in clear violation of Section 123 of Business and 
Professions Code. Holmgren called the level of accuracy of these study guides
“shocking,” and added that the questions went back for years.

  Bob Holmgren of OPES testified in Sacramento during the November 2012 Board
  meeting. The room was filled with students, school representatives and trade
                                representatives.

Based on this finding, OPES disregarded the answers to the compromised questions
in the August 2012 examination. As a result, there was a 30% drop in the
passing rate of an exam that already had a low passing rate. A total of 439
candidates took the exam: 270 (61.5%) failed; 169 (38.49%) passed. A pass/ fail 
history of the exam shows these percentages to be at a record low.

It is not the first time that the State is dealing with cheating and corruption 
in its acupuncture licensing system. Back in 1980s, the chairman of the former
acupuncture regulating agency (the Acupuncture Committee), Chae Woo Lew, was
caught selling test questions for $10,000 to $20,000. Lew was sentenced to five 
years in prison. According to the Los Angeles County district attorney’s office,
there may be over 100 acupuncturists involved in the licensing payoff scheme.
Only a fraction of all the unqualified practitioners who may have become
licensed with Lew’s alleged assistance were caught and prosecuted (Los Angeles
Times, March 04, 1989).

Cheating and criminal behavior was a particular area of concern for the “Little 
Hoover Commission” (an independent oversight agency that investigates State
government operations to improve efficiency, economy and service) in 2004. The
Commission recommended that to prevent fraud, the responsibility of creating and
administrating the licensing exam should be placed in the hands of an outside
agency, preferably a national organization, such as NCCAOM.

The Hoover Commission’s policy recommendations and legislative proposals about
acupuncture met stiff political opposition from the Board and professional
organizations, and were never implemented.

However, on March 12, 2012, during the Sunset Review hearing, the California
Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development brought up
the Little Hoover Commission’s findings and expressed serious concerns about the
ongoing administrative, educational, licensing and consumer protection issues
that the Board has not been able to resolve for over a decade.

Added to this discontent and disconnect, is the political (and possibly legal)
action by aggrieved license applicants who failed the last exam because of the
removal of the comprised questions. A group of them operating under the name of 
CALE United Test Front (CTUF) has called upon the Board and the Dept. of
Consumer Affairs to justify its recent 30% drop in the passing rate. They have
also requested the institution of an exam that is “created, and administered
utilizing professional methods, standards and industry input specifically from
educators and acupuncturists to avoid less disconnect from exam content and what
is being actually taught in the schools.”

Another group of applicants has hired an attorney who recently sent a letter to 
the Board, detailing the group’s concerns, in addition to charges of negligence 
if the Board does not respond to the test takers’ demands for the re-scoring of 
the August 2012 exam to a “customary 70% cut score.” He is also asking for
greater transparency with respect to all processes associated with the creation,
administration, and assessment of the exam.

Their attorney, Robert Sulnick, argues that the Board has a “fiduciary duty to
ensure fair examinations,” and added that throughout its history, “independent
oversight committees have identified breaches of fiduciary duty, identifying
difficulties with the acupuncture examination (i.e. fraud and criminal
charges).”

Notice that the referenced breaches of fiduciary duty that were discussed by
several oversight committees were towards the people of California. Nowhere this
failure to adequately protect the public is more evident than in the content of
the licensing exam.

Indeed, since the Business and Professions Code Section 4926 defines the
practice of acupuncture as being “subject to regulation and control as a primary
health care profession,” the Board is therefore licensing traditional and folk 
healers so they can work as first-contact health care providers! And the
licensing examination is a reflection of this regulatory lunacy.

In its current form, the exam does not assess the level of medical knowledge
that provides the future practitioner with the knowledge, skills and abilities
necessary to perform “primary health care.” To the contrary, the exam’s primary 
focus, and what is being taught in schools, is the practice of acupuncture and
Asian Medicine, not “primary care,” as it is defined by the Institute of
Medicine in Primary Care: America’s Health in a New Era (1996).

This immediately begs the following questions: how can individuals who do not
have adequate competencies in the scientific basis of disease and evidence-based
medicine, act as primary care providers? Don’t we have here an obvious
disconnect between the regulation of acupuncture, and the reality of its
teaching, licensing and practice? Isn’t this a legislative blunder that can
negatively impact the public’s health and safety?

These are issues that the State oversight entities have actually brought to the 
Board’s attention in 2001, but have never been addressed–mostly due to political
pressure by acupuncture organizations and training programs.

These influential training programs are by and large post-secondary vocational
institutions existing as standalone schools. Some of them were actually founded 
as religious institutions, which exempted them from the usual post-secondary
regulations. With student loan money pouring in, little oversight from the
State, lax accreditation standards, and an easy pathway for international
student visas, an acupuncture school is an easy start-up with big profit
potentials. The key has been the sympathetic Board. Any regular attendee will
tell you that at most Board meetings, the majority of attendees are school
representatives or lobbyists looking after their interests by encouraging the
status quo in the content of the exam and the regulation of acupuncture.

Regardless; the next exam is scheduled for February 14, 2013. According to the
Board’s attorney, Spencer L. Walker, only after the completion of the cheating
investigation and a review and evaluation by an independent expert, the Board
will schedule this matter for discussion at a future Board meeting. A timeline
for the investigation and discussion has not been set.

Meanwhile, countless Californians will continue to seek “primary care” from
providers who do not have adequate training in scientific and evidence-based
medicine. A few of these providers might even have obtained their license
fraudulently. As for the wronged test-takers, their concerns seem unlikely to be
addressed before the February 2013 exam. And it is almost a certainty that none
of this convoluted mess will be cleaned up anytime soon, given that the Board
has a long history of—as Robert Sulnick puts it–“kicking the can down the road.”

The opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not reflect the
positions of the above mentioned individuals, agencies or organizations.

References:

1. Richard Herne Shepherd, Translations from Charles Baudelaire with a few
original poems. (London: John Camden Hotten, 1869)

                      Legislative Alchemy III: Acupuncture

                                 Jann Bellamy 

                                      Link

Acupuncture is typically depicted as sticking needles at various points on the
body prescribed (inconsistently, it turns out) by charts indicating purported
“meridians” through which “qi” flows in the human, or animal , body. However,
from one of the many SBM posts on acupuncture , this one by Dr. Novella , we in 
fact know that:

   the consensus of the best clinical studies on acupuncture show that there is 
   no specific effect of sticking needles into acupuncture points. Choosing
   random points works just as well, as does poking the skin with toothpicks
   rather than penetrating the skin with a needle to elicit the alleged “de qi”.
   The most parsimonious interpretation of the evidence is that the needles
   (i.e. acupuncture itself) are superfluous — any perceived benefit comes from 
   the therapeutic interaction. This has been directly studied, and the evidence
   suggests that the way to maximize the subjective effects from the ritual of 
   acupuncture is to enhance the interaction with the practitioner, and has
   nothing to do with the acupuncture itself. Acupuncture is a clear example of 
   selling a specific procedure based entirely on non-specific effects from the 
   therapeutic interaction — a good bedside manner and some hopeful
   encouragement.”

Unfortunately, those who draft state legislation do not read SBM. They should.
If they did, they wouldn’t be enacting acupuncture practice acts. But they do.

Through the magic of legislative alchemy, acupuncture or, in some cases,
“oriental medicine,” is a licensed health care profession in 43 states. Like
naturopaths, acupuncturists attempted to expand their geographic range in 2011
and, like chiropractors as well, tried to broaden their scope of practice to
include methods and treatments far from their original tradition, wherever that 
may lie.

Kansas does not become the 44th state

Kansas does not license acupuncturists as a separate “healing art,”although, by 
statute, both naturopaths and veterinarians can employ acupuncture in their
practices. In 2011, the “acupuncture and oriental medicine practice act” was
introduced in the state Senate but never made it out of the Public Health and
Welfare Committee.

Although it failed, it is worth reviewing for those unfamiliar with acupuncture 
practice acts as it demonstrates the startlingly broad scope of practice
typically granted acupuncturists and “oriental medicine” practitioners by state 
law. It is as well a perfect example of legislative alchemy in its incorporation
of sheer nonsense.

As with recent attempts by chiropractors to sound less chiropractic ,
acupuncturists are apparently trying to camouflage the more psuedoscientific-
sounding concepts by re-casting them in what we might call faux biomedical
language. Thus, nowhere in the Kansas legislation will you find any reference to
“qi” or “meridians.” No, here acupuncture is

   a form of health care that is based on a theory of energetic physiology that 
   describes and explains the interrelationship of bodily organs or functions
   with an associated acupuncture point or combination of points that are
   stimulated in order to restore the normal function of the bodily organ or
   function.”

Thus, the “practice of acupuncture” is

   the use of needles or of oriental medicine therapies for the purpose of
   normalizing energetic physiological functions including pain control and for 
   the promotion, maintenance and restoration of health.”

“Qi” and “meridian” are out. “Energetic physiological functions” are in. And
needles are not the only way to “normalize” these “energetic physiological
functions.” Not by a long shot.

Acupuncturists would also have at their disposal “oriental medicine therapies.” 
And what exactly is “oriental medicine?” According to this proposed legislation,
“oriental medicine”

   means the distinct system of health care that uses health techniques of
   oriental medicine, both traditional and modern, to diagnose, evaluate,
   examine, manage and treat for the prevention, cure or correction of disease, 
   illness, injury, pain or other physical or mental condition by controlling
   and regulating the flow and balance of energy, form and function to restore, 
   promote and maintain health.”

So, “oriental medicine” is health care that uses “oriental medicine.” Got it? I 
suppose the fact that it must achieve its purpose by “controlling and regulating
the flow and balance of energy, form and function” is somewhat of an
explanation. I do not know, for there is no clue in the proposed statutory
language, whether said “regulating the flow and balance of energy” etc. is the
same thing as “normalizing energetic physiological functions.” Whatever that
means.

In this vein of “daffy definitions,” we also learn that:

  1. “biofeedback device” is “an instrument that is used to detect and amplify
    internal physiological processes and mental functioning.”

  2. “herbal and animal-based substances” includes substances of “animal, vegetable
    or mineral origin.”(emphasis added) (I suppose the draftsman of this
    legislation missed that day in biology, or missed biology altogether.)

  3. “Nutritional supplement means a nutritional substance, including a concentrate
    or extract of such a substance.” (That’s it — the entire definition.)

Under the proposed statute, the “practice of acupuncture includes, but is not
limited to:”

dietary and nutritional counseling “based on traditional [but not "modern",
apparently] Chinese medical principles”

recommendation, administration or dispensing of food, vitamins, minerals,
enzymes, homeopathic preparations, amino acids or nutritional supplements (see
above for definition).

So, homeopathy, supplements, diet, amino acids, vitamins, minerals, enzymes and 
biofeedback devices were all to become part of acupuncture practice under the
new law. Apparently what acupuncturists, like chiropractors, really want to be
is naturopaths.

Expanding scope of practice

Acupuncturists in Connecticut, where they are already licensed, were successful 
in expanding their practice by convincing the legislature to abandon any control
over what they do as long as their practices are “consistent with accepted
standards within the acupuncture and Oriental medicine profession.”

This was accomplished in a single section of a 98-section public health bill
governing such diverse topics as regulation of day care, treatment of STDs,
recording of vital statistics, and needle exchange programs. The term “sneaking 
it in” comes to mind.

Connecticut had already modernized, if you will, acupuncture by eschewing the
old-fashioned terms “qi” and “meridians” for “the theory of physiological
interrelationship of body organs with an associated point or combination of
points for diseases, disorders and dysfunctions of the body.” The new practice
act, however, abandons that definition for “modulation and restoration of normal
function in and between the body’s energetic and organ systems and
biomechanical, metabolic and circulation functions using stimulation of selected
points.” Whether this is a new “theory” or simply a restatement of the old
“theory” is not disclosed.

In any event, Connecticut acupuncturists are no longer limited to “needles,
heat, pressure or electrical stimulation” of said points. Now any “method” is ok
as long as it complies with the aforementioned “standards” of the “acupuncture 
and Oriental medicine profession.”

Also added as means for achieving “promotion and maintenance [as opposed to
“modulation and restoration”] of normal function in the body’s energetic and
organ system and biochemical, metabolic and circulation functions” are “Oriental
dietary principles,” including (of course!) “supplements” and “other practices 
. . . consistent with the recognized standards of the . . . profession and
accepted by the National Certification Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental
Medicine.”

Acupuncturists can now also perform “assessment of body function, development of
a comprehensive treatment plan and evaluation of treatment outcomes according
to acupuncture and Oriental medicine theory.”

Putting it all together, the Connecticut acupuncturist will now be able to
assess the body’s energetic system, treat the energetic system with any method
consistent with professional standards, and know when the energetic system is
modulated/restored/promoted/maintained through assessment of treatment outcomes.
An amazing achievement considering that no research has ever demonstrated that 
this “energetic system” exists or what its properties might be.

The acupuncturist as naturopath

In addition to their try for licensing in Kansas, and success at expanding their
scope of practice in Connecticut, acupuncturists attempted to become
naturopaths in other states where they are already licensed. To date, success
has eluded them.

In Ohio, a bill would have added a new type of practice — “Oriental Medicine” — 
separate from acupuncture, while at the same time increasing the scope of
practice for acupuncturists. Acupuncturists would be allowed to use
“supplemental techniques” including “the use of traditional and modern oriental 
therapeutics [the scope of which are not defined], counseling [including] the
provision of information regarding lifestyle modifications and the therapeutic
use of foods and supplements including homeopathics, gladulars, vitamins, and
minerals.”

“Oriental medicine” practice, on the other hand, is defined as “a form of health
care in which acupuncture is performed with or without the use of herbal
therapy” which is not the same as “supplemental techniques” (see above). Once
again demonstrating that one does not need to have taken biology to draft
licensed health care provider legislation, “herbal therapy” is defined as “the
use of herbs, vitamins, minerals, organ extracts, homeopathics or physiological 
materials for energetic or physiologic therapy.”

New York Senate and Assembly bills would expand “the profession of acupuncture” 
to allow “recommendation of traditional remedies and supplements including, but 
not limited to, the recommendation of diet, herbs and natural products, and
their preparation in accordance with traditional and modern practices of modern 
East Asian or Oriental (Chinese, Korean or Japanese) medical theory.” What! No
homeopathy?

Acupuncture for drug addiction

In Massachusetts, a bill would expand the scope of acupuncture practice to treat
drug addiction via “Acupuncture Injection Therapy” defined as “the injection of
herbs, homeopathic, and other nutritional supplements in the form of sterile
substances into acupuncture points by means of hypodermic needles but not
intravenous therapy.” The purpose of this is to “help prevent addiction to
prescription drugs and prevent and reduce drug abuse; to promote, maintain, and 
restore health; for pain management and palliative care; and for acupuncture
anesthesia.” This is so obviously dangerous that snark escapes me. The bill has 
not passed, although the Massachusetts legislature has not adjourned for the
year.

“Acupuncture Injection Therapy” is not the only way acupuncture is used to treat
substance abuse. In Colorado, licensed acupuncturists already use “five point
NADA auricular acupuncture” which, as a bill summary explains, “is acupuncture
done on the ear that is often used to treat substance abuse, mental health and
behavioral health disorders.” “NADA” is the “National Acupuncture Detoxification
Association.”

Apparently, other health care providers want to get in on the act, so proposed
legislation would allow chiropractors, physicians, physician assistants, nurses,
mental health professionals, and psychiatric technicians to perform this “five 
point NADA auricular acupuncture” but only if, as further explained in the
summary, “they have successfully completed the proper training.” This bill
actually made it to the Colorado House floor, where it failed to pass.

New Mexico

Faithful SBM readers will be wondering by now, “what about New Mexico, the state
where anyone can practice medicine?” And they won’t be disappointed. There was,
of course, a bill introduced in New Mexico to expand the acupuncturists’ scope 
of practice.

In New Mexico, as you might guess, acupuncturists already have limited
prescriptive authority. Too limited, in their opinion.

First, they attempted to eliminate the requirement that prescription of
“devices” be limited to those “necessary in the practice of oriental medicine.” 
As for drugs and their mode of administration, acupuncturists already had a
formulary in the current practice act, but apparently didn’t like it. So, as did
the New Mexico chiropractors, they tried to change it. It would have
specifically included the following, although whether the acupuncturists could
already prescribe and administer some of these under the current statute is
unclear: subcutaneous and intramuscular epinephrine, injectable vitamin B-12,
intradermal and subcutaneous injection of homeopathics, dextrose, minerals,
sarapin and vitamins, and IV administration of water-soluble vitamins and
minerals.

While, under the current statute, acupuncturists can prescribe “bioidentical
hormones” they would be able to prescribe under the proposed expansion “topical 
estradiol, estriol, progesterone, testosterone and desiccated thyroid,” but only
if the acupuncturist had “a signed collaborative practice agreement” with an
M.D. or D.O. Thus, as with chiropractors and naturopaths who want to prescribe
real drugs, adult supervision would be required. The bill died in committee. 
Even New Mexico has its standards.

Sticking needles in healthy people

As noted in the Introduction, research discloses that it doesn’t matter where
you stick the needle in acupuncture. A bill introduced in the Oregon legislature
was refreshingly honest about that fact. The bill, which died in committee,
would have changed the statutory definition of acupuncture, currently “an
Oriental health care practice used to promote health and to treat neurological, 
organic or functional disorders by the stimulation of specific points on the
surface of the body by the insertion of needles.” “Oriental” would have been
removed, as would have “specific points,” which simply became “points in and on 
the body.” In other words: stick it anywhere, it’s all the same.

As also noted, acupuncture doesn’t work. This makes it perfect for treating
someone who isn’t sick, as a Pennsylvania bill — most certainly unintentionally 
— acknowledged. Under Pennsylvania law, acupuncturists can treat “a person’s
condition” without the condition being diagnosed by a physician, dentist or
podiatrist for 60 days. After that time, the treatment may continue only if the 
person “obtained a diagnosis of the treated condition” by a physician, dentist
or podiatrist. A proposed amendment to this law would make these limitations
inapplicable “if a person does not present any symptoms of a condition.”

It’s really the ideal “CAM” legislation — ineffective treatments for people who 
are not ill — and it may become state law. Both the House and Senate versions of
this bill have made it to the floor of the Pennsylvania legislature, which
meets year-round.

Conclusion

As I’ve said before, no person should be subjected to scientifically implausible
diagnostic methods and treatments. States should be working to eliminate such
practices, not giving out licenses to perpetuate them.

Which brings me to “The Cure,” anti-sCAM legislation I’ll be proposing in a
future post. Stay tuned.

Legislative Alchemy 2017: Acupuncture

Acupuncture is nothing more than a theatrical placebo. Yet acupuncturists,
defined as primary care practitioners in some states, are succeeding in
licensing and practice expansion efforts in state legislatures.

Jann Bellamy on January 19, 2018

Link



Legislative Alchemy

Acupuncture is a theatrical placebo. Its proposed mechanism of action is highly 
implausible and:

   after decades of research and more than 3000 trials, acupuncture researchers 
   have failed to reject the null hypothesis, and any remaining possible
   specific effect from acupuncture is so tiny as to be clinically
   insignificant.

   In layman’s terms, acupuncture does not work – for anything.

Even the very CAM-friendly National Center for Complementary and Integrative
Health (NCCIH), in its own weasel-worded way, comes close to conceding the
point:

   Research suggests that acupuncture can help manage certain pain conditions,
   but evidence about its value for other health conditions is uncertain.
   [Emphasis added.]

Somebody tell the state legislatures. Via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, 47
states have legalized the practice of acupuncture along with, in some cases,
Traditional Chinese, Oriental or East Asian medicine. In several states,
acupuncture practice acts describe acupuncturists as primary care practitioners 
and/or give them the authority diagnose and treat any condition or disease. For 
example, in my state, Florida, the practice act says that acupuncture:

   means a form of primary health care, based on traditional Chinese medical
   concepts and modern oriental medical techniques, that employs acupuncture
   diagnosis and treatment, as well as adjunctive therapies and diagnostic
   techniques, for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health and the
   prevention of disease. [Emphasis added.]

In Nevada,

   “Acupuncture” means the insertion of needles into the human body by piercing 
   the skin of the body to control and regulate the flow and balance of energy
   in the body and to cure, relieve or palliate:

   (a) Any ailment or disease of the mind or body; or

   (b) Any wound, bodily injury or deformity. [Emphasis added.]

And in New Mexico:

   “doctor of oriental medicine” means a person licensed as a physician to
   practice acupuncture and oriental medicine with the ability to practice
   independently, serve as a primary care provider and as necessary collaborate 
   with other health care providers . . .

   “oriental medicine” means the distinct system of primary health care that
   uses all allied techniques of oriental medicine, both traditional and modern,
   to diagnose, treat and prescribe for the prevention, cure or correction of
   disease, illness, injury, pain or other physical or mental condition by
   controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy, form and function 
   to restore and maintain health. [Emphasis added.]

As with state chiropractic and naturopathic licensing, most states rely on a
closed-loop system of education and examinations that is completely controlled
by acupuncturists in determining who is qualified to become licensed. The
National Certification Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (NCCAOM)
administers the certification exams recognized by the states. Applicants for
certification must have either graduated from schools accredited by the
Accreditation Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (ACAOM) or
foreign schools meeting criteria set by the NCCAOM.

While the ACAOM is approved as an accrediting agency by the U.S. Department of
Education, the Department does not review the scientific validity of what is
taught or perform any independent analysis of the graduates’ ability to
competently and safely practice. Its focus is on administrative matters and the 
financial stability of the schools. The ACAOM standards do not require a college
degree for admission to an accredited acupuncture/Oriental Medicine school and 
only 500 hours of supervised patient care are required in accredited programs to
graduate with a Master’s in acupuncture (700 hours for a Master’s in Oriental
Medicine). A Master’s allows one to sit for the NCCAOM exam. In sum, someone
with no college degree and 500 hours of clinical training can become a “primary 
care provider” in some states.

2017 bills

Today we look at bills filed in eleven states to license, or expand the practice
of, acupuncturists during the 2017 state legislative sessions. Six were
successful. Two bills were defeated; three remain pending.

Prior to last year, acupuncturists did not have a practice act in Wyoming. This 
year they succeeded in gaining one, although the Wyoming legislature stopped
short of giving them the right to practice Oriental Medicine, which was
eliminated in the final bill. Acupuncture is somewhat narrowly defined as
inserting needles, with or without electric current or heat, into the body for:

   therapeutic purpose of promoting, maintaining and restoring health, including
   [but, we note, not limited to] the treatment of dysfunctions of the body
   involving pain.

Wyoming also joins several states who’ve been bamboozled into thinking sticking 
needles into peoples’ ears, otherwise known as “auricular acupuncture,” is
effective for substance abuse and mental health issues. Promoted based on an
unpublished and cherry-picked review of the evidence by an organization called
the National Acupuncture Detoxification Association (NADA), it is a perennial
favorite with state legislatures looking to address mental health issues and
drug abuse on the cheap.

New Hampshire enacted legislation creating something called a “Certified
Acupuncture Detoxification Specialist,” who must be trained in the NADA protocol
and supervised by an acupuncturist, although the “Specialist” needn’t be an
acupuncturist himself. They can use “acu-detox” for:

   behavioral health applications, including addictions, mental health, and
   disaster and emotional trauma.

One version of the bill specified that “acu-detox” could be used only in
conjunction with other therapies but that bit of consumer protection against the
ineffectiveness of pseudoscience in treating serious conditions was rejected.

Likewise, in Maine, a new law requires the state Department of Health and Human 
Services to develop a pilot project that will treat alcohol and substance abuse 
using the unproven NADA protocol. Fortunately, more sober minds prevailed in
West Virginia, where a bill allowing the practice of NADA auricular acupuncture 
for chemical dependency failed.

Like their fellow CAM practitioners, naturopaths and chiropractors, once
licensed, acupuncturists will return again and again to the state legislatures
for practice expansion. In 2017, they succeeded in a big way in Illinois. There 
the legislature added the practice of “East Asian” medicine to the
acupuncturists’ scope of practice, defined to include needle acupuncture,
moxibustion, herbal medicine, and dietary supplements, among others, to:

   normalize physiological functions, or for the treatment of diseases or
   dysfunctions of the body.

Acupuncture itself is broadly defined to include not only traditional needle
acupuncture, but also far-infrared, electro- and magnetic stimulation, cold
laser, cupping, dry needling (discussed below), and the bruising massage
practice known as gua sha:



Apparently his Chi wasn’t up to par. From Bradwesley69 on the Wikimedia Commons.

In a move reminiscent of the chiropractic lobby’s efforts to make chiropractic
schools the arbiter of what chiropractors can and cannot do, Illinois
practitioners of acupuncture and East Asian medicine are permitted to perform a 
differential diagnosis via principles and techniques taught in acupuncture
schools, like the fanciful tongue and pulse diagnosis.

Acupuncture: ineffective but treats everything

Illinois practitioners must refer patients to a physician or dentist if the
patient’s condition is beyond their scope of practice, which raises and
interesting question: Just what is beyond the East Asian medicine/acupuncture
practitioner’s scope of practice when he is permitted to perform a differential 
diagnosis (albeit based on total pseudoscience) and treat, without limitation,
“diseases or dysfunctions of the body”?

If you consult the Acufinder acupuncture referral website, you’ll find
acupuncture’s usefulness in treating disease is virtually unlimited:

   Acupuncture and Chinese medicine are extremely successful in the treatment of
   a multitude of conditions. Many people try Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine
   as a “last resort” to serious and complex medical problems and find that it 
   can help them when other treatments could not.

   Acupuncture is also often used as a preventative medicine. Many people see
   their acupuncturist only 2-4 times a year for a “tune up” or “balancing”
   treatment. This can prevent disease and promote health, energy and vitality.

“While no means a complete list of what Acupuncture and Traditional Chinese
Medicine can treat,” Acufinder lists, among many others, allergies, anemia,
depression, high blood pressure, heart disease, bronchitis, impotence,
infertility, fibrosis, candida, Epstein Barr virus, lupus, hepatitis, stroke,
polio, emphysema and diabetes. No evidence is cited for any of these claims.

Acufinder is, by the way, on Heatlhline’s list of “Best Blogs: Alternative
Medicine 2017.” Healthline, which is Hon@Code certified, apparently has a high
tolerance for quackery. Sayer Ji’s GreenMedinfo blog, which our good friend Orac
has anointed one of the “quackiest, crankiest sites on the Internet” (sample
post: “The Homeopathic Answer to Mumps”) also made the list.

If we can’t trust Acufinder, how about a more responsible source for determining
what acupuncture can successfully treat? How about the University of Miami’s
Miller School of Medicine? Unfortunately, in a perfect example of “infiltrative 
pseudoscience,” the University agrees with Acufinder on a number of diseases and
conditions “for which acupuncture is effective” or for which, more vaguely,
“people commonly find acupuncture treatment to be effective,” including
allergies, asthma, depression, high blood pressure, impotence, Bell’s palsy,
infertility, heart disease, bronchitis, and stroke. In addition to “people,” the
University lists the NIH (without any specific citations) and the discredited
WHO report on acupuncture as its sources of evidence. Oddly, if the NIH really
supports these claims, no one told the NIH’s own National Center for
Complementary and Integrative Health.

In fact, unsupported claims like those found on both Acufinder’s and the
University of Miami’s websites appear to be more the norm than the exception.
And herein lies the danger of Legislative Alchemy: States like Illinois give
fantasy-based practitioners a broad scope of practice, allowing them to diagnose
and treat both fake and very real diseases. Even presumably reliable sources,
like medical schools, promote unproven (or disproven) uses, leaving the public
with the false impression that acupuncture is effective for any number of
conditions. (You can find another example here, from the University of
California at San Francisco.)

A similar fate may await the citizens of Michigan, where a substantial practice 
expansion bill introduced in 2017 remains pending. Acupuncturists there are
currently limited to needle acupuncture. In addition to giving acupuncturists
licensed health care professional status, the bill would, like Illinois, give
them the authority to diagnose and treat any disease or condition in patients of
any age using “traditional and contemporary East Asian medical theory.” They
would be able to use “electroacupuncture” (i.e., TENS rebranded as acupuncture),
“dermal friction” (gua sha), cupping, herbal remedies, and homeopathy (which is
German in origin, not East Asian). Acupuncturists could also supervise
NADA-trained practitioners treating substance abuse.New Mexico, as noted,
already defines acupuncturists as “primary care” practitioners and permits them 
to perform and order diagnostic testing, as well as practice bleeding. The state
Board of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine can issue certificates expanding
their practice to include the authority to compound drugs on their formulary,
such as bioidentical hormones, and deliver these products by IV, as well as
prescribing and administering live cell products, among others.

Fortunately, the New Mexico legislature refused to go further last year and
allow the Board to issue certificates to practice “holistic integrative
medicine” and add to the acupuncturists’ formulary “substances used for
detoxification and chelation.” A bill permitting all that and more failed.

Mississippi and Nebraska used to require a physician referral for acupuncture
treatment. Acupuncturists tried to dilute these patient protections in both
states and succeeded, although Mississippi turned around and added even more
limitations on their practice in the final bill. While the Mississippi
legislature repealed the referral requirement, patients must, with very limited 
exceptions, have a physician evaluation within the last six months for the
condition the acupuncturist will treat, and the acupuncturist must inform
patients that acupuncture is not a substitute for medical care. Referral to a
physician is required if the patient’s condition doesn’t improve and
acupuncturists are prohibited from diagnosing.

Nebraska removed the referral requirement as well, but added that the
acupuncturist must refer the patient to an “appropriate practitioner” if the
condition is beyond his training, competence or experience. These limitations,
as noted above, may not exist in the mind of the typical acupuncturist.

As if state budgets weren’t strained enough, pending companion House and Senate 
bills in Minnesota appropriate $375,000 of the public’s money to do what is
essentially worthless “study” amounting to no more than a collection of
anecdotes which will supposedly determine the effectiveness of acupuncture for
pain and its potential to reduce opioid abuse. Why a much cheaper literature
search on PubMed could not meet this goal is not explained, although the bills
are perhaps a testament to the scientific illiteracy of the legislators who
support it.

Finally, the turf wars: Physical therapists (PTs) and acupuncturists are
fighting over a practice called “dry needling.” According to physical
therapists, dry needling:

   uses a thin filiform needle to penetrate the skin and stimulate underlying
   myofascial trigger points, muscular, and connective tissues for the
   management of neuromusculoskeletal pain and movement impairments.

It is based on, according to PTs, “western neuroanatomy and modern scientific
study of the musculoskeletal and nervous system” and not on the mumbo jumbo of
blocked “qi” and “meridians.” Just because the technique is similar to needle
acupuncture, the American Physical Therapy Association points out, does not mean
it constitutes the practice of acupuncture. Acupuncturists say it is just that 
and are trying to lock PTs out of using dry needling.

In addition to their huge practice expansion in Illinois, acupuncturists there
convinced the legislature to define dry needling as “acupuncture,” thereby
preventing PTs from performing it (unless they go to the trouble of getting a
license to practice acupuncture). A similar bill defining dry needling as the
practice of acupuncture remains pending in Massachusetts.

You can follow pending acupuncture/Oriental medicine/East Asian
medicine/Traditional Chinese medicine (as well as chiropractic and naturopathic)
bills on the Society for Science-Based Medicine website and find out how to
contact your state legislators about them. Bills introduced in 2018 will be
added to the SfSBM website soon.

Legislative Alchemy 2018: Acupuncturists seek practice expansion and competition
elimination 

Acupuncturists want to expand their scope of practice far beyond sticking
needles in people. Too many states are allowing them to treat pretty much
anything with unproven and potentially dangerous remedies.

Jann Bellamy on January 3, 2019

Link



In the third and final installment in our annual review of Legislative Alchemy –
the deliberate incorporation of pseudoscience into health care via legislation 
– we take a look at 2017-2018 bills aiming to license and expand the scope of
practice of acupuncturists and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) practitioners,
as well as eliminate their competition. (We previously covered chiropractic and
naturopathic Legislative Alchemy.)

Acupuncture occupies an exalted place in the pantheon of CAM practices. Though
it is no more scientifically plausible or evidence-based than a number of other 
CAM modalities generally rejected by “conventional” medicine (e.g.,
chiropractic, naturopathy, homeopathy), acupuncture has been embraced by the
medical community.

The University of California San Diego School of Medicine’s Center for
Integrative Medicine, for example, promotes acupuncture for a long list of
diseases and conditions. The Center claims that “case-controlled clinical
studies have shown that acupuncture has been an effective treatment” for, among 
others, leukopenia (low white blood cell count), turning a breech fetus,
hypertension, and allergic rhinitis.

In the first place, case-control studies cannot determine the efficacy of a
treatment. And, in fact, there is no reliable evidence (also here) that
acupuncture is effective for any of these. The list specifically ignores a
Cochrane Review conclusion that there is “no evidence that acupuncture is useful
in the management of long-lasting hypertension.”

Disturbingly, the Center goes on to list several dozen more diseases and
conditions for which it claims acupuncture has “limited but probable evidence”
(that is, even less evidence) to support its therapeutic use, including
bronchial asthma, cholecystitis (gallbladder inflammation), diabetes,
hyperlipaemia, and schizophrenia.

The whole webpage is, in my view, irresponsible and potentially dangerous, yet
is a useful demonstration of the credulous acceptance of acupuncture by the
medical community.

Even putting aside the absurdity of promoting acupuncture to patients for all
manner of ills, what most medical doctors likely don’t realize is that many
acupuncturists have an extremely broad scope of practice, or would like to, if
the push for initial licensing or practice expansion to include diagnosis and
treatment far beyond sticking needles in “acupuncture points” is any indication.
Thus, thanks to state legislators, a physician referring a patient to an
acupuncturist will, perhaps unknowingly, expose the patient to the entire
panoply of pseudoscience encompassed by a particular state’s acupuncture
practice act.

Acupuncture “primary care”

Acupuncturists are licensed or otherwise regulated health care professionals in 
47 states. A few states, like Michigan, limit the practice to needle
acupuncture, although Michigan does not limit the diseases or conditions
acupuncturists can treat. Other states give acupuncturists the authority to
practice Traditional Chinese Medicine, with its plethora of pseudoscientific
diagnoses and treatments (not to mention its threat to endangered species) or
otherwise grant broad scopes of practice, including, in some cases, describing
acupuncture as “primary care.” A few examples [boldface added in quotes]:

Nevada’s practice act defines “Oriental medicine” as

   that system of the healing art which places the chief emphasis on the flow
   and balance of energy in the body mechanism as being the most important
   single factor in maintaining the well-being of the organism in health and
   disease.

“Acupuncture” is defined as

   the insertion of needles into the human body by piercing the skin of the body
   to control and regulate the flow and balance of energy to cure, relieve, or 
   palliate: (a) Any ailment or disease of the mind or body; or (b) Any wound,
   bodily injury or deformity.

Even though most herbal remedies are unproven and too many contain contaminants 
and substitutions, “herbal medicine” is defined as:

   Suggesting, recommending, prescribing or directing the use of herbs for the
   cure, relief or palliation of any ailment or disease of the mind or body, or 
   for the cure or relief of any wound, bodily injury or deformity.

My state, Florida, defines “acupuncture” as

   a form of primary health care, based on traditional Chinese medical concepts 
   and modern oriental medical techniques, that employs acupuncture diagnosis
   and treatment, as well as adjunctive therapies and diagnostic techniques, for
   the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health and the prevention of 
   disease.

The Florida Board of Acupuncture has expansively interpreted “adjunctive
therapies and diagnostic techniques” to include reflexology, laser
biostimulation, Kirlian photography, thermography, nutritional counseling, and
recommendation of homeopathic remedies.

And in Arkansas,

   Acupuncture’ means the insertion, manipulation, and removal of needles from
   the body and the use of other modalities and procedures at specific locations
   on the body for the prevention, cure, or correction of a malady, illness,
   injury, pain, or other condition or disorder by controlling and regulating
   the flow and balance of energy and function of the patient to restore and
   maintain health.

In Arkansas’s practice act “related techniques” include magnets, cold laser, and
something called “ion pumping cord.” The Arkansas State Board of Acupuncture
has enacted rules which take the scope of acupuncture practice even further to
include ordering radiological, laboratory, or other diagnostic tests, Oriental
medicine injection therapy, biofeedback, and prescription or administration of
homeopathic medicine, enzymes, and glandulars. The rules also permit:

   The stimulation of points or areas of the body using needles, heat, cold,
   light, lasers, sound, vibration, magnetism, electricity, bleeding, suction,
   pressure, Gua Sha, or other devices or means.

Yes, you read that right: Bleeding patients is perfectly legal in Arkansas.

2017-2018 Bills: licensing, practice expansion, turf wars

Despite their stunning successes in incorporating nonsense into law in most
states, it looks like acupuncturists will suffer the same fate as naturopaths
this year, with a complete shutout. And, as was the case with its naturopathic
licensing bill, Michigan turned out to be a real nail biter.

Michigan, as mentioned, currently allows acupuncturists to register with the
state and limits their practice to needle acupuncture. Senate Bill 683 would
have allowed acupuncturists to become licensed and vastly expand their scope of 
practice to include laser acupuncture, electroacupuncture and dry needling as
well as “dermal friction” (gua sha), cupping, prescribing herbal remedies, and
homeopathy (which has nothing to do with TCM). Acupuncturists would be able to
diagnose and treat any disease or condition in patients of any age using
“traditional and contemporary East Asian medical theory,” which is undefined.

The bill would also allow the practice of auricular acupuncture for substance
abuse treatment, under the supervision of an acupuncturist or physician, by
anyone with a certification from the National Acupuncture Detoxification
Association (NADA). NADA auricular acupuncture is based on a highly implausible 
mechanism of action and  has never been proven effective for substance abuse.
NADA’s promotion of auricular acupuncture is based on an unpublished and
cherry-picked review of the evidence.

SB 683 passed in the Senate, successfully navigated the House committee system, 
then made it to a second reading before the full House. Thankfully, the clock
ran out before the bill came up for a final vote.

Oklahoma is one of the three states that does not license or otherwise
officially regulate acupuncturists. Three different licensing bills were
introduced in the state Senate. Two bills (Senate Bills 1119 and 1501) contained
similar provisions, permitting needle acupuncture for “promoting, maintaining
and restoring health” even though acupuncture has not been proven to do any of
these things, including alleviation of pain. They also permitted the practice of
NADA auricular acupuncture for treating mental and emotional health, post and
acute trauma, substance abuse, and chemical dependency. An acupuncture board
would regulate acupuncturists, giving the fox the keys to the henhouse.

Senate Bill 1523 went even further, describing acupuncture as “primary health
care” and allowing acupuncturists to diagnose, using fanciful methods like
tongue and pulse diagnosis. Acupuncturists could, in addition to needle
acupuncture, employ moxibustion, herbal therapies, and “other adjunctive
properties”, and practice Oriental medicine. Under SB 1523, regulation would be 
under the state osteopathic board in consultation with an acupuncture committee.

Despite the full-court press of having three licensing bills introduced in one
session, all failed.

In West Virginia, House Bill 4465 created NADA-trained “auricular acupuncture
detoxification specialists” and would have allowed these “specialists” to
perform “auricular acudetox” for the treatment of substance abuse, alcoholism,
chemical dependency, detoxification, behavioral therapy, and trauma recovery.
The bill actually passed in the House and Senate. The session ended before House
could concur in a Senate amendment, dooming the bill.

In Minnesota, proposed legislation (Senate Bill 1958; House Bill 2389) would
have the state spend $375,000 of taxpayer funds to study acupuncture for pain
relief and the potential of acupuncture treatments to reduce opioid
prescriptions. Here’s how the “study” would be conducted:

   The study shall include collection of data from at least 200 cases where an
   individual receiving acupuncture treatment for pain relief had more than six 
   but not more than 30 acupuncture treatments within a six-month period. Data
   shall be collected from at least ten treatment sites and ten referral sites, 
   including both rural and urban sites. . . . The report shall analyze the
   collected data . . . from the referral practitioner, the treatment
   practitioner, and the individual participant.

In other words, a $375,000 unrandomized, uncontrolled, and unblinded collection 
of anecdotes, which would prove nothing. Fortunately, the state treasury won’t
have to shell out the money because the bills failed.

There is a turf war going on between acupuncturists and physical therapists over
the practice of “dry needling.”  Acupuncturists claim that dry needling is the 
practice of acupuncture and sought to enshrine their view in Massachusetts law
(House Bill 3247; Senate Bill 1182) by defining the insertion of filiform
needles as acupuncture, thereby granting themselves a monopoly on the practice. 
Physical therapists disagree, pointing out that

   The objectives and philosophy behind the use of dry needling by physical
   therapists is not based on ancient theories or tenets of traditional Chinese 
   medicine. The performance of modern dry needling by physical therapists is
   based on western neuroanatomy and modern scientific study of the
   musculoskeletal and nervous systems.

The PTs won this particular battle; both bills died in committee.

The only legislative victories for acupuncturists were minor and did not involve
initial licensing or practice expansion. Louisiana eliminated a requirement
that acupuncturists have a relationship with a physician to provide for
referrals and follow-up care. California extended the Acupuncture Board and its 
authority to regulate acupuncturists to 2023.

Public health, safety and welfare? Where?

The majority of state legislatures convene this month for a new session and the 
rest will soon follow. Acupuncturists, chiropractors, and naturopaths will be
waiting at the statehouse doors with freshly-drafted bills granting them
licensure and practice expansion. To my knowledge, other than delicensing
naturopaths in a handful of states or making the practice illegal, no
legislation has ever been introduced protecting the public from the useless and 
sometimes dangerous diagnoses and treatments CAM practitioners foist on
patients. This is despite the fact that the states’ authority to regulate health
care practitioners is constitutionally grounded in the police power, that is,
the authority to protect the public’s health, welfare and safety. They are doing
just the opposite. As Steve Novella pointed out just yesterday, it is high time
politicians put patients ahead of these profiteers of pseudoscience.

Legislative Alchemy 2019: Acupuncturists score Medicare coverage and scope of
practice expansion 

Through the magic of legislative alchemy, acupuncture has already scored some
big wins in 2020, including Medicare coverage.

Jann Bellamy on February 13, 2020

Link



Today we take a look at how the magic of Legislative Alchemy managed to
incorporate even more pseudoscience into the American health care system in 2019
via licensing and scope of practice expansion, as well as taxpayer-funded
insurance coverage, for acupuncturists. Based on a mythical, pre-scientific
system of invisible meridians guiding an ethereal “energy” through the body,
acupuncture has successfully invaded the most prominent medical institutions
because, well, “integrative” medicine. Attempts to put lipstick on a pig by
proposing a physiological basis for acupuncture’s methods and effects (such as
they are) remain unconvincing and acupuncture is, in fact, a theatrical placebo.

Unfortunately, none of that matters to policy makers who succumb to the siren
song of “popularity” or are just too scientifically illiterate to know better,
or both. Riding acupuncture’s coattails into the realm of government-approved
fantasy medicine, Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), also known as East Asian
Medicine, also known as Eastern Medicine, also known as Oriental Medicine, has
become a licensed health care profession as well. Unbound by the strictures of
science and the scientific method, practitioners claim success in treating
cancer, asthma, allergies, infertility, neurological disorders, and
cardiovascular disease, among other conditions. In fact, according to them, they
can treat pretty much anything.

As with climate change denial and anti-vaccination propaganda, the rejection of 
evidence in favor of ideology and a good, old-fashioned profit motive can beat
back science again and again. Now, on to the specifics.

Medicare coverage

Last July, I wrote a post titled “Medicare proposal covers acupuncture for back 
pain study participants: A prelude to full coverage?” And the answer is – yes,
just without a the study. At the time, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid
Services (which makes Medicare coverage decisions) said:

   While we believe the evidence is promising, we do not believe the evidence is
   sufficient at this time for representative older patients with chronic
   nonspecific low back pain. We believe additional research would be needed in 
   order to make a favorable coverage determination . . .

Yet, without a jot of additional evidence, in January, 2020, the Trump
administration announced it was skipping the proposed study and going straight
to a decision allowing Medicare coverage of acupuncture for chronic low back
pain for up to 12 visits in 90 days, with an additional 8 sessions for patients 
demonstrating an improvement. “Chronic low back pain” is defined as lasting 12
weeks or longer, nonspecific (i.e., not related to an identifiable cause, like
infectious disease), and not associated with surgery or pregnancy. (Why
pregnancy? Because Medicare beneficiaries can be under age 65 in certain
circumstances.) If the patient is not improving, treatment must be discontinued.

But what kind of acupuncture? After all, SBM contributor emeritus Dr. Mark
Crislip found

   over 30 different types of acupuncture with many different modes of operation
   and fantasy explanations for their claimed effectiveness.

CMS doesn’t say. Given the seemingly boundless inventiveness of practitioners in
fabricating new forms of “acupuncture”, expect this new revenue source to get
their creative juices flowing. (CMS does say it considers “dry needling” to be
“a type of acupuncture”.)

Even while covering acupuncture, without admitting it out loud, there seems to
be a recognition that it is not a good idea to let acupuncturists, or
chiropractors, loose with a big wad of taxpayer money. Physicians providing
acupuncture “in accordance with applicable state requirements” are covered.
Physician assistants and nurse practitioners/clinical nurse specialists are
covered if they also have a degree in acupuncture or Oriental Medicine and a
state license to practice acupuncture. Acupuncturists having a degree and a
state license, but without other professional credentials, referred to in the
decision as “auxiliary personnel”, are covered only if supervised by a
physician, P.A. or nurse practitioner/clinical nurse specialist. Acupuncture
provided by chiropractors, even if allowed by their state license, is not
covered.

Licensing

Oklahoma is one of the few states that does not license acupuncturists.
Introduced in 2019, pending Senate Bill 734 would change that by licensing
acupuncturists to insert “acupuncture needles into the body”, with or without
using an electric current or heat,

   for the therapeutic purpose of promoting, maintain and restoring health,
   including the treatment of dysfunctions of the body involving pain . . .

Interestingly, the bill, unlike other licensing acts, does not acknowledge the
existence any mystical meridians, their imagined blockage, or their putative
unblocking via insertion of needles at specific points. That is not to say this 
omission is an improvement: It is hard to imagine what disease or condition
wouldn’t fall under this fuzzy definition, including cancer.

“Auricular acupuncture” is separately licensed and approved for “treating mental
and emotional health, post and acute trauma, substance abuse and chemical
dependency” even though there is no reliable evidence that this highly
implausible method (basically, sticking needles in the outer ear) is effective
for anything.

Acupuncturists would be regulated by a Board of Acupuncture consisting of three 
acupuncturists, one public member, and one licensed health care professional who
is not an acupuncturist. Given the expansive array of conditions both
acupuncturists and auricular acupuncturists are authorized to treat, and the
history of acupuncture boards fluffing the regulations with all manner of
accessory pseudoscience, one can expect an equally expansive approach to the
Board’s “promulgat[ing] rules and regulations as necessary to carry out this
act”.

On the bright side, SB 734 was introduced over a year ago and has yet to have a 
committee hearing scheduled. This may prevent its meeting a March legislative
deadline for further consideration.

More auricular acupuncture

Auricular acupuncture was also on the 2019 legislative agendas of West Virginia,
Maine and Massachusetts. Like all auricular acupuncture legislation, the
National Acupuncture Detoxification Association (NADA), which heavily promotes
the practice, is written into the regulatory requirements for attaining a
certificate or license, typically by adopting the NADA protocol for auricular
acupuncture as the statutory definition of the practice or requiring NADA
training.

In West Virginia, House Bill 2324 was signed into law, allowing certain licensed
health care professionals (e.g., nurses, psychologists, and chiropractors) and 
others (e.g., social workers, emergency medical service providers) to practice
“auricular acudetox” therapy “for the treatment of substance abuse, alcoholism, 
chemical dependency, detoxification, behavioral therapy, or trauma recovery.”

The Maine Legislature passed legislation (House Bill 809) creating a separate
license for the NADA-trained “auricular acupuncture detoxification specialist”, 
who is allowed to treat “substance use and co-occurring disorders” as part of an
established treatment program. Only alcohol and drug counselors, physicians,
physicians assistants, nurses, nurse practitioners, psychologists and other
professional counselors are eligible for licensing but they (physicians, PAs,
and nurses included) can practice only under the supervision of a licensed
acupuncturist. (An acupuncturist’s scope of practice would already include
auricular acupuncture.)

Similar to Maine, bills were introduced in 2019 in Massachusetts (House Bill
1880, Senate Bill 1336) allowing physicians, nurses, psychologists, and other
types of mental health practitioners trained by NADA to register as “acupuncture
detoxification specialists” for “the treatment of addictions, mental and
behavioral health, disaster relief, and emotional trauma”, but only under the
supervision of a licensed acupuncturist. Those bills remain pending in 2020.

Practice expansion

With licensing come the perennial pleas for practice expansion. A popular ask is
getting the legislature to take the mere sticking-needles-in-people variety of 
acupuncture and infuse it with the virtually unlimited quackery that
Oriental/Traditional Chinese/East Asian/Eastern Medicine offers the
practitioner. Maybe, instead of the abbreviation “TCM”, we should use “OTCEAEM” 
to cover all the bases, since they appear to differ in name only. For example,
Maryland House Bill 404, signed by the Governor into law, changes “oriental” to 
“East Asian” medicine in the acupuncture practice act. “Normalizing energetic
physiological functions” is the purpose of both, according to Maryland law.

This new law incorporates some stealth practice expansion as well. Like the
proposed Oklahoma practice act, the legislature seems to be dumping the idea
that acupuncture is limited to specified “points” on the body. (Maybe because no
one can find them?) Thus, while the old acupuncture was based on “a theory of
energetic physiology that describes the interrelationship of the body organs or 
functions with an associated point or combination of points”, the new
acupuncture is “based on East Asian medical theories” that describe this same
interrelationship, but all references to “points” are stricken from the law. The
old definition of acupuncture included “stimulation of points of the body by
the insertion of acupuncture needles.” The new definition eliminates “points of”
and “acupuncture”.

In a similar practice-expanding vein, references to specific treatments included
in the scope of practice (e.g., herbal and nutritional therapies) have been
largely eliminated in favor of the far more elastic “East Asian medical
therapies . . . performed in according with the principles of East Asian medical
theories and practices”. All of this will leave the State Acupuncture Board
(five acupuncturists, two public members) with plenty of room to fill in the
regulatory blanks. Interestingly, it was on the Board’s recommendation that the 
legislature “updated” the definition of acupuncture “to more accurately reflect 
the therapies that are currently practiced by the acupuncture profession.”

Michigan is a textbook example of using a lower tier of acupuncture regulation
as a springboard to becoming a licensed healthcare profession, with the state
imprimatur of legitimacy that designation (falsely) bestows. Prior to a new law 
enacted last year, acupuncturists simply registered with the state. Now, thanks 
to the magic of Legislative Alchemy, acupuncturists are a licensed profession
with a broad scope of practice that goes far beyond traditional needle
acupuncture.

As Dr. David Gorski, SBM’s managing editor and a Michigan resident, described in
his post on what was then a bill pending before the legislature, acupuncturists
are, under the new law, allowed to use all sorts of acupuncture techniques:
laser, electroacupuncture, dry needling and “intramuscular stimulation”. In
addition to treatments one normally associates with traditional acupuncture
practice, like moxibustion, cupping, and dermal friction, the new law includes
the practice of “East Asian medicine”, which is not defined – a list “includes” 
certain practices, like herbal medicines, but “is not limited to” those
practices – leaving an big, amorphous canvas upon which to paint a definition of
one’s choosing. Case in point: Per the new law, East Asian medicine includes
manual therapy, dietary counseling, therapeutic exercise, lifestyle coaching and
homeopathy. Yes, homeopathy, German in origin, is now a part of East Asian
medicine because the Michigan legislature said so. And, in an example of how
slapping the term “East Asian medicine” on just about any method magically
transplants it into the East Asian canon, “lifestyle coaching” is defined as
“the process of advising a patient about healthy lifestyle choices and habits in
accordance with East Asian medical theory”.

And who better to help fill in that canvas than the Michigan Board of
Acupuncture, consisting of seven acupuncturists, three physicians, and three
public members (you do the math), which is granted the authority to write the
rules governing acupuncture and “East Asian” practice. As Dr. Gorski pointed
out:

   That’s the problem with the state regulating quackery. It isn’t science-based
   practitioners defining the standard of care and educational requirements for
   “professions” like acupuncture. It’s the quacks themselves.

In an example of poaching legitimate medical techniques to further quackery,
Utah granted acupuncturists limited prescription privileges in 2019 by giving
them the authority to employ “injection therapy”. This is defined as using a
hypodermic needle to inject, either subcutaneously or intramuscularly, any of
the following substances, in liquid form, into acupuncture points:

  1. A nutritional substance (a term that is undefined, but presumably includes, at
    the least, substances that are classified as dietary supplements if taken
    by mouth, such as vitamins, minerals, and herbs)

  2. A local anesthetic

  3. Autologous blood (for what purpose, I have no idea)

  4. Sterile water

  5. Dextrose

  6. Sodium bicarbonate

  7. Sterile saline

“Injection therapy” cannot be performed on pregnant women or children under
eight. But taking your nine-year-old to an acupuncturist for an injection of his
own blood is perfectly acceptable to the Utah legislature.

Bills before the Rhode Island Senate and House attempted to change “Oriental
medicine” to “Chinese medicine”, expand the scope of practice, and add
NADA-trained auricular acupuncture practitioners to the practice act.
Fortunately, they failed.

Like other bills creating variously-named auricular acupuncture practitioners,
this one limited the practice to physicians, PAs, nurses and nurse
practitioners, and mental health professionals, who would be called “auricular
acupuncture technicians”, an appellation that doesn’t seem particularly
appealing to health care professionals. Acupuncture and Chinese Medicine would
include both traditional “pulse, tongue, palpation and observational diagnosis” 
as well as “diagnostic techniques based on newer scientific models”, another
squishy term left to the imagination of practitioners. Acupuncture, “adjunct
therapies”, and “Chinese herbal medicine” could be used “for the treatment of
any ailment”. Herbal medicine included both preparation of formulas from Chinese
herbal literature, modifications of those formulas, and “writing of new
formulas”. In other words, in addition to mixing up herbal remedies other people
made up, you could make up your own!

In Washington, a bill passed changing “East Asian medicine” to “acupuncture and 
Eastern medicine” in state law, as well as changing “East Asian medicine
practitioner” to “Acupuncturist” or “Acupuncturist and Eastern medicine
practitioner”. And, straight from a report of the House Committee on Health Care
& Wellness:

   A person licensed as an Acupuncturist may use the title Acupuncturist,
   Acupuncturist and Eastern medicine practitioner, or East Asian medicine
   practitioner and use the letters L. Ac., EAMP, or AEMP.

Well, that should clear things up!

Another Washington bill expands the scope of practice for acupuncturists (and
whatever other names they go by) by defining their practice as “a holistic
system of medicine” which includes “using needles therapeutically”, and

   diagnosing and treating conditions according to medical traditions from
   China, Japan, Korea, and other East Asian countries, and application of
   modern evidence-based research to maintain and promote wellness, prevent,
   manage, and reduce pain, manage substance abuse disorder [including NADA
   auricular acupuncture], and prevent, diagnose, and treat conditions and
   diseases.

Query what wouldn’t be covered by this broad definition.

Washington acupuncturists (etc.) already have the authority to use injection
therapy, which includes, in liquid form, herbs, minerals, vitamins, and
homeopathic and “nutritional” substances. The bill would add the right to use
oxygen, epinephrine and medical ozone “for potential emergency purposes” even
though the FDA issued a rule in 2016 stating that “ozone is a toxic gas with no 
known useful medical application in specific, adjunctive, or preventive
therapy”, effectively banning its use by banning the manufacture and sale of
devices that produce it, although quacks still manage to get their hands on
these machines.

Apparently, this last bill remains pending, held over from the 2019. If not, no 
worries. A 2020 bill has been introduced amending the acupuncture practice act
with essentially the same provisions, minus (thankfully) the ozone. It never
ends. Stay tuned.

Acupuncture practice acts: legalized quackery

Jann Bellamy on August 23, 2012

Link


As Ben Kavoussi observed recently,

   [o]nce considered archaic and obsolete, Oriental Medicine has greatly
   benefited from the postmodern attitudes towards science and knowledge. This
   is because postmodernists consider the ‘truth’ as being relative to one’s
   viewpoint or stance. They do not see science as a superior process of
   acquiring knowledge, but as a ‘belief system,’ a ‘language game,’ which does 
   not give more access to truth than other conceptual constructs.

This “postmodern fallacy,” he continued,

   has allowed the return of mass professional delusions under the label of
   Chinese, Oriental or Asian Medicine. As an unfortunate byproduct, dangerous
   and outdated therapies have been legitimized, and quacks and charlatans can
   overtly defraud those who cannot distinguish scientific medicine from lore
   and fantasy.

There is probably no better example of this “unfortunate byproduct” than the
state acupuncture and oriental medicine practice acts. These laws have indeed
legitimized dangerous and outdated therapies, allowing quacks and charlatans to 
defraud the public.

State practice acts

Via the magic of legislative alchemy, acupuncture, or sometimes, more broadly,
Oriental or Traditional Chinese  medicine, is a licensed health care practice in
44 states in the U.S. and the District of Columbia. As with all licensed health
care practices, each state defines the acupuncturists’ scope of practice via
legislation commonly referred to as a practice act.

Some states, perhaps unwilling to let the genie fully escape the bottle, allow
acupuncture only by prescription or under the supervision of a physician.
Others, like New Jersey and New York, at least require that an acupuncturist
advise patients about the importance of consulting with a licensed physician
regarding the patient’s condition. In Louisiana, only physicians can become
acupuncturists.

Yet in many states acupuncturists enjoy a broad and unsupervised scope of
practice. Here’s a sample of practice acts typical in their definition of
acupuncture and oriental medicine.

New Mexico:

   ‘acupuncture’ means the surgical use of needles inserted into and removed
   from the body and the use of other devices, modalities and procedures at
   specific locations on the body for the prevention, cure or correction of any 
   disease, illness, injury, pain or other condition by controlling and
   regulating the flow and balance of energy and function to restore and
   maintain health.

   ‘oriental medicine’ means the distinct system of primary health care that
   uses all allied techniques of oriental medicine, both traditional and modern,
   to diagnose, treat and prescribe for the prevention, cure or correction of
   disease, illness, injury, pain or other physical or mental condition by
   controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy, form and function 
   to restore and maintain health.

Florida:

   ‘Acupuncture’ means a form of primary health care, based on traditional
   Chinese medical concepts and modern oriental medical techniques, that employs
   acupuncture diagnosis and treatment, as well as adjunctive therapies and
   diagnostic techniques, for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of
   health and the prevention of disease.

Maryland:

   ‘Practice acupuncture’ means the use of oriental medical therapies for the
   purpose of normalizing energetic physiological functions including pain
   control, and for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health.

Colorado:

   ‘Acupuncture’ means a system of health care based upon traditional oriental
   medical concepts that employs oriental methods of diagnosis, treatment, and
   adjunctive therapies for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of
   health and the prevention of disease.

Arkansas:

   ‘Acupuncture’ means the insertion, manipulation, and removal of needles from 
   the body and the use of other modalities and procedures at specific locations
   on the body for the prevention, cure, or correction of a malady, illness,
   injury, pain, or other condition or disorder by controlling and regulating
   the flow and balance of energy and function of the patient to restore and
   maintain health.

New Hampshire:

   ‘Oriental medicine means the distinct system of health care that diagnoses
   and treats illness, injury, pain, or other conditions by controlling and
   regulating the flow and balance of energy to restore and maintain health.

Nevada:

Nevada is even more expansive in its definition of Oriental medicine, which
includes both the practice of acupuncture and herbal medicine. “Oriental
medicine” is

   that system of the healing art which places the chief emphasis on the flow
   and balance of energy in the body mechanism as being the most important
   single factor in maintaining the well-being of the organism in health and
   disease.

“Acupuncture” is defined as

   the insertion of needles into the human body by piercing the skin of the body
   to control and regulate the flow and balance of energy to cure, relieve, or 
   palliate:

   (a) Any ailment or disease of the mind or body; or

   (b) Any wound, bodily injury or deformity.

“Herbal medicine” is

   Suggesting, recommending, prescribing or directing the use of herbs for the
   cure, relief or palliation of any ailment or disease of the mind or body, or 
   for the cure or relief of any wound, bodily injury or deformity.

Public health and safety?

A state’s constitutional authority to regulate health care practices is based on
the state’s power to protect the public health, welfare and safety. Indeed,
some of the practice acts begin with a statement about how the state needs to
regulate acupuncture and oriental medicine in the interest of the public’s
health and safety. Of course, as Dr. Edzard Ernst pointed out, “the most
meticulous regulation of nonsense must still result in nonsense.” With
acupuncture and oriental medicine, the nonsense is pernicious.

A cure for disease?

Note how each practice act assumes acupuncturists and oriental medicine
practitioners can diagnose and effectively prevent or cure actual disease, among
other supposed benefits. One can accept this as true only by believing in the
entire traditional oriental medicine myth, aptly defined almost 80 years ago by 
a Chinese medical school dean as a “weird medley of philosophy, religion,
superstition, magic, alchemy, astrology, feng shui, divination, sorcery,
demonology and quackery.” I can only assume the good Southern Baptist lawmakers 
who populate the legislatures here in the deep South, where I live, had no clue 
about oriental medicine’s true nature when they voted for these practice acts.
In fact, I’ll bet the vast majority of state legislators who made acupuncture
and oriental medicine a licensed health care practice had no idea that they were
legalizing superstition, magic, astrology, sorcery and demonology. They really 
should pay more attention to what they are voting on.

Legitimizing this “weird medley” has real consequences for the public.
Acupuncturists claim they can treat a wide range of diseases and conditions. A
small sample includes malaria, anorexia, fever, parasitic diseases, asthma,
dementia, depression, epilepsy, paralysis, uterine bleeding, convulsions, heart 
palpitations, diabetes and jaundice. And it is perfectly legal for them to do so
under many of the state practice acts.

Acupuncturists as primary care providers?

In enacting these practice acts, the states give acupuncture and oriental
medicine an undeserved imprimatur of legitimacy by making it a form of “health
care.” In Florida and New Mexico, it is specifically described as “primary
health care.” After declaring oriental medicine is “a system of primary health
care,” here’s how New Mexico defines “primary care provider,” and therefore
defines an oriental medicine practitioner, in the practice act:

   a health care practitioner acting within the scope of the health care
   practitioner’s license who provides the first level of basic or general
   health care for a person’s health needs, including diagnostic and treatment
   services, initiates referrals to other health care practitioners and
   maintains the continuity of care when appropriate.

Even without such explicit language, by allowing oriental diagnostic methods and
treatment “for the promotion, maintenance, and restoration of health and the
prevention of disease” the scope of acupuncture practice in some states
approaches that of an M.D. or D.O. Compare this to the standard definition of
the practice of medicine, this from Florida:

   the diagnosis, treatment, operation, or prescription for any human disease,
   pain, injury, deformity, or other physical or mental condition.

It would appear the only real difference is in the methods of diagnosis and
treatment employed. For example, by law an M.D. can treat with surgery and
prescription drugs, whereas an acupuncturist cannot. Yet, according to the
language of their respective practice acts, both can diagnose and treat any
disease.

Adjunctive quackery

As well, these practice acts, and the regulations enacted pursuant to them, give
acupuncturists the right to use a smorgasbord of implausible and unproven
diagnostic methods and treatments that go far beyond simply using needles to
manipulate “qi.”

For example, by incorporating “modern oriental medicine concepts,” the door is
left open to add to the existing implausible and unproven “oriental diagnosis
and treatment” methods currently being passed off as “ancient.” Simply by
labeling a “concept” as “modern,” new “concepts,” no matter how ill conceived,
can legitimately fall within the permissible scope of practice.

In addition to “oriental medical diagnosis and treatment,” “adjunctive” or
“related” treatments are legally permissible. Because that term is left
undefined, again the door is left open to add whatever acupuncturists deem
“adjunctive,” whether it be additional forms of quackery or legitimate means
that acupuncturists would seem ill-suited to employ. For example, in Florida,
the Board of Acupuncture has decided the following are “adjunctive:”
reflexology,  laser biostimulation, Kirlian photography, thermograpy,
nutritional counseling, lifestyle and stress counseling, and recommendation of
homeopathic remedies.

In Arkansas’s practice act, “related techniques” include magnets, cold laser,
ion pumping cord, lifestyle counseling, eating guidelines, massage incidental to
acupuncture, and exercise techniques. The Arkansas State Board of Acupuncture
and Related Techniques has enacted regulations which take the scope of
acupuncture practice even further to include ordering radiological, laboratory
or other diagnostic tests, Oriental medicine injection therapy, physical
medicine modalities and techniques, biofeedback, and prescription or
administration of homeopathic medicine, enzymes, and glandulars. The regulations
also permit:

   The stimulation of points or areas of the body using needles, heat, cold,
   light, lasers, sound , vibration, magnetism, electricity, bleeding, suction, 
   pressure, Gua Sha, or other devices or means.

That’s right. The barbaric practice of bleeding is legal in Arkansas.

Bleeding is also legal in New Hampshire, thanks to regulations adopted by the
New Hampshire Board of Acupuncture Licensing. The Board’s regulations also
permit “insertion and retention, for days or weeks, of intradermal needles or
press tacks in acupuncture points.” And the Board allows acupuncturists to use
(as defined in the regulations):

craniosacral therapy – “a treatment approach using gentle massage pressure to
rebalance the craniosacral system”

polarity therapy – “a holistic therapy that combines bodywork, dietary
adjustments, and exercises to restore the balance of the body’s vital energy
through correction of the electromagnetic field of the body”

reiki – “a Japanese energy therapy that uses energy transmission to balance the 
biofield that surrounds the human body”

therapeutic touch –“ an energetic therapy . . . that employs a
laying-on-of-hands technique based on oriental theories of energy flow”

zero balancing — “a touch technique for aligning the body’s energy and
musculoskeletal system”

Which raises a few questions in my mind, if you’ll permit me a bit of
digression. If you are sick, how does the New Hampshire acupuncturist know which
system is out of whack? Or does being sick automatically mean that all of your 
systems – craniosacral, electromagnetic, energy flow, biofield and the alignment
of your energy and musculoskeletal system – are malfunctioning? If so, it’s
going to get awfully expensive to treat your illness. Time consuming too, what
with having to spend all that time in treatment. And how does the acupuncturist 
know when your systems are properly aligned or balanced or flowing or whatever
it is they are supposed to be doing?

Conclusion

Just yesterday, Steve Novella observed how the pseudoscience of homeopathy is a 
fraud being perpetrated on the public and how governments and regulatory
agencies which are supposed to protect the public from medical fraud have failed
to do so. Here we have yet another example of a pseudoscientific “CAM” practice
foisted off on the public as legitimate medicine with the blessing of the
government.

Acupuncture and oriental medicine belong in the Middle Ages, not in modern
health care. We know acupuncture doesn’t work. And while some of the herbs used 
in oriental medicine may work, we can’t know that until they go through properly
conducted drug trials. Licensing acupuncturists and oriental medicine
practitioners and giving them the right to “diagnose,” “prevent” and “cure”
disease and to employ other nonsensical “CAM” practices and products is most
certainly not in the best interest of the public’s health, safety and welfare.
Unfortunately, the problem is only getting worse as acupuncture schools crank
out more graduates who then get their state licenses and go into practice.

Acupuncture: NCCAM Calls California’s Bluff

Ben Kavoussi on September 14, 2012

Link


   The [California Department of Consumer Affairs’] use of the term
   “endorsement” is inaccurate, may confuse the public, and may lead the public 
   to falsely conclude that NIH has made certain efficacy and/or safety
   conclusions regarding acupuncture. Further, consensus conference reports are 
   not a policy statement of NIH or the Federal Government… NIH asks that you
   correct these two points of information in your booklet and on your website.

   — Jack Killen, MD, Deputy Director, NCCAM, NIH

I have to praise the Deputy Director of the National Center for Complementary
and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), Jack Killen, for asking the State of
California to remove a couple of false claims in a “Consumer’s Guide” on
acupuncture.

Indeed, on June 12, 2012, Dr. Killen wrote a letter to the California Department
of Consumer Affairs (DCA) expressing concerns about an informational booklet
which makes the unfounded claim that the NIH “formally” endorses acupuncture.
The booklet also incorrectly states that NIH has “found clear evidence that
needle acupuncture is effective” for a list of conditions. Here’s a snapshot of 
this publication:

Albeit the long letter, the message is clear and simple: “As a U.S. Federal
research agency, NIH does not endorse any product, service, or treatment.”

Soon after receiving the letter, the DCA removed the booklet from circulation,
deleted the online version from its website, and stopped sending out copies to
new licensees.

This official booklet has been published for over a decade. There have been 3
editions since 2002, and all claim that NIH “formally” supports acupuncture and 
that there is “clear evidence” of its efficacy.

As a result, thousands of unsuspecting patients have since 2002 chosen
acupuncture as a treatment.

I first came across the booklet in 2009. Shocked by its preposterous claims, I
wrote a letter to NCCAM the same year and asked for clarifications. Their
response contained the same essential message found in Killen’s recent letter:

   The booklet misstates the purpose of the 1997 consensus panel on acupuncture.
   As a Federal research agency, the NIH does not endorse any product, service 
   or treatment, nor are NIH consensus documents statements of policy.

   — Terry Evans, NCCAM, March 3, 2009

Since 2008, I have sent Terry Evans’ letter to the California DCA and its
Acupuncture Board on several occasions. In response, I was told each time that
although the NIH does not explicitly state that they “formally endorse”
acupuncture, “supporting statements in the 1997 report could be interpreted as
an endorsement”!

In other words, according to State of California, the NIH formally endorses
acupuncture, even if it the NCCAM – one of the institutes and centers that make 
up the NIH – explicitly says that it does not!

The latest version of this asinine statement was sent to me in May 2012 by
Reichel Everhart, the DCA Deputy Director for Board and Bureau Relations:

Just 3 months prior to Everhart’s letter, DCA’s Acupuncture Board was put in the
hot-seat by the State Senate, mainly for failing to protect the public. The
Senate explicitly told the Board that its mission was to regulate the
profession, not to promote or to protect it. But so far, the Senate criticism
have fallen on deaf ears: a senior member and former Chair of the California
Acupuncture Board made this baffling statement in a public meeting just around
the same time Everhart wrote to me:

   I think given what is in front of this Board, and the work that we are
   continuing to do to try to create legitimacy around the entire subject and to
   maintain legitimacy and to promote the profession, we should oppose anything
   that is so nebulous that should possibly detract from the standardized work 
   that is being done nationally…

   — Robert Brewer, former Chair and current member of the California
   Acupuncture Board, May 17, 2012

Brewer’s statement provides an insight on why it has taken so long to remove the
booklet in California: there is an obvious resistance to any evidence that is
not in favor of acupuncture or disputes its very purpose. California is not the 
only state with a protectionist acupuncture board: many regulatory agencies
across the US have long operated as lobbies, with the sole intent of
legitimizing and promoting the profession. As co-blogger Jann Bellamy recently
wrote in a an article about acupuncture practice acts in the US, some even allow
the practitioners to act as primary healthcare providers:

   Licensing acupuncturists and oriental medicine practitioners and giving them 
   the right to “diagnose,” “prevent” and “cure” disease and to employ other
   nonsensical “CAM” practices and products is most certainly not in the best
   interest of the public’s health, safety and welfare.

Fortunately, the Californian Senate seems to be fully aware of the absurdity of 
regulating acupuncturists as primary care providers. They also know that the
Board has a long history of acting as a shield for acupuncture training programs
and professional organizations. In March 2012, the Senate Business, Professions
and Economic Development Committee made the following comment that supports my 
argument:

   Both the [Little Hoover Commission] and Legislative Counsel did not believe
   that the law creating the Acupuncture Act intended for an acupuncturist to be
   the primary care professional responsible for coordinating (or being the
   “gatekeeper”) for the ultimate care of a patient.

The Senate Committee was referring to the 2004 findings of the Little Hoover
Commission, an independent state oversight agency that investigates the
government and makes recommendations to promote efficiency and to improve
service. The commission’s report (Report #175, September 2004) to the Governor
and the Legislature had observed:

   The policy choice to give patients direct access to acupuncturists was clear,
   but the statutory intent to regulate acupuncturists as a “primary care
   health care profession” is not. The term has many potential meanings. While
   some people may turn to acupuncturists first for everything that ails them
   (one potential meaning), it is difficult to see how practitioners of an
   alternative healing paradigm can be responsible for coordinating care with
   biomedical specialists (another potential meaning).”

   — (Regulation of Acupuncture: A Complementary Therapy Framework, page 25.)

After the 2012 sunset review, the Senate gave the Acupuncture Board two years to
address a long list of problems and concerns. My hopes are that at the end of
this deadline (or even before) the Senate realizes the futility of having a
separate board for acupuncture.

Meanwhile, what should be done with the 10,000 or more active licensees in
California? Even if they use “a smorgasbord of implausible and unproven
diagnostic methods and treatments” — as Jann Bellamy puts it — I do not foresee 
an immediate end to their licensing, especially during an economic downturn.
However, the state also has the obligation to place the protection the public at
the highest priority.

In my opinion, the best way out of this quagmire is to disallow acupuncturists
to work as primary care providers, and to require prior consulting and screening
by a physician, a nurse practitioner or a physician assistant. This is in the
best interest of the public, for it leaves the responsibility of coordinating
the ultimate care of a patient in the hands of a competent primary care
provider.

But at least for now, witchdoctors in California can no longer bluff out that
the NIH formally endorses their craft, and that there is clear evidence that it 
is works for anything!

With many thanks to Daniel Bederian-Gardner, Jann Bellamy and Paul Ingraham for 
their valuable comments. The opinions expressed here are the author’s.

“Integrative medicine” advocates: Co-opting the opioid crisis to promote funding
for acupuncture by Medicaid

The opioid epidemic is a serious public health crisis in the U.S., and new tools
and treatments to deal with chronic pain are urgently needed. Unfortunately,
where public health officials see a crisis, advocates of “integrating” quackery 
with science-based medicine see an opportunity. In this case, promoters of
pseudomedicine are taking advantage of the opioid crisis to persuade state
Medicaid systems to pay for quackery like acupuncture.

David Gorski on January 22, 2018

Link



SBM regular Jann Bellamy frequently writes about what she refers to as
“legislative alchemy“; that is, attempts by advocates of unscientific,
pseudoscientific systems of medicine like traditional Chinese medicine or
naturopathy to slap a patina of legitimacy on their quackery through state
licensure of practitioners. There is another form of legislative alchemy,
however, that doesn’t involve licensing quacks. There are two keys to the
perception of legitimacy of a medical specialty among the public, and certainly 
one is licensure by the state. However, a second key is reimbursement for
services by third party payers, particularly government payers like Medicaid and
Medicare. Although I had been vaguely aware of such efforts before, to my
knowledge they have been scattered and in general relatively unsuccessful, in
contrast to efforts to .

I learned recently that Medicaid is the most recent target, with acupuncture the
desired treatment, as an article in STAT News reported:

   The quickest way to erase pain is to give patients an opioid. But a rise in
   prescriptions has fueled a national epidemic of fatal overdoses, with a large
   share of the deaths occurring in low-income communities.

   Under intense pressure to combat the problem, states across the country are
   expanding their Medicaid programs to cover alternative treatments such as
   acupuncture, massage, and yoga. The effort could increase non-opioid options 
   for low-income patients suffering from pain. But it also opens states to
   criticism from skeptics who say taxpayers are being forced to fund unproven
   treatments based on political expediency instead of sound science.

   Ohio’s Medicaid department took the most dramatic step this month by
   extending coverage of acupuncture treatments delivered by non-medical
   providers for patients with low-back pain and migraines, a step likely to
   allow much greater access and attract new practitioners to the field.

Because I trained in Cleveland and still have connections there, I had taken
note of the Cleveland.com article referenced in the STAT story, which provides
more detail:

   Starting January 1, more than 108,000 Ohioans on Medicaid who have diagnosed 
   low back pain or migraines will be able to see an acupuncturist for pain
   management. The change in policy is part of an effort to reduce the number of
   unnecessary opioid prescriptions and overdose deaths in the state that arise
   from treating chronic pain with addictive drugs.

   For the past year, Ohio has been one of six states in the country to cover
   acupuncture treatments for Medicaid patients, but only when offered by a
   doctor. Starting tomorrow, Medicaid reimbursement will be open to licensed
   non-physician acupuncturists who register as Medicaid providers.

   The agency hopes that expanding access to the treatment, a centuries-old
   pain-relief technique that involves inserting hair-thin needles into the skin
   at specific points, will save money over time on addiction treatment and
   other costs related to opioid use.

   Practitioners and their patients say it’s about time more people had access
   to the proven and safe, but expensive, non-drug therapy, and that more
   insurers should follow suit.

These sorts of decisions are the culmination of a strategy that is as old as
alarm in public health circles about the rise of opioid addiction and the wave
of overdose deaths sweeping the nation.

Co-opting the opioid crisis: A calculated strategy to sell quackery

It’s become increasingly clear to me that the opioid crisis has been adopted by 
advocates of “integrating” quackery into medicine as the most important new
“foot in the door” or “wedge” to open the way to the legitimization and funding 
of pseudoscientific treatments like acupuncture. Basically, advocates of
“integrative medicine” are taking advantage of the urgency of the current search
for non-opioid and non-pharmacologic treatments for chronic pain to promote
their placebo-based pseudoscience as the solution to the crisis. It’s become one
of the main talking points used by advocates to open the door for the
“integration” of mystical, prescientific, and pseudoscientific treatments like
acupuncture into medicine. Indeed, whenever you hear the terms “non-drug
therapy” or “nonpharmacologic management of pain” used by advocates with respect
to the opioid crisis and chronic pain management, it’s code for placebo-based
quackery. The quacks are not even subtle about it.

It’s a rationale that comes right from the top, from the most prominent
proponents of “integrative medicine.” For instance, the National Center for
Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) featured the opioid crisis as a
compelling reason for its existence in its latest five year strategic plan,
which made the “nonpharmacologic management of pain” one of its top research
priorities. Since then, NCCIH has been promoting such approaches, science-based 
or quackery like acupuncture, as its own, the better to seamlessly integrate
pseudoscience with science. Elsewhere, the same sort of rationale is used to
justify the introduction of quackery into the VA medical system. Even the FDA is
considering encouraging knowledge about chiropractic and acupuncture as
approaches for chronic pain.

It’s not just the NCCIH, the VA, and the FDA either. Journals, even prestigious 
medical journals, The BMJ and JAMA increasingly buy into the message that
“nonpharmacologic treatment for chronic pain = ‘integrative medicine.'” Medical 
professional societies are jumping on the bandwagon as well. For instance, the
American College of Physicians included acupuncture on its list of recommended
strategies for low back pain. An entire professional organization, the Society
for Integrative Oncology, is devoted to diluting the science of oncology with a 
mixture of lifestyle interventions that are in no way “alternative” or
“integrative” plus pseudoscientific nonsense. Even NCI-designated comprehensive 
cancer centers like Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center are increasingly
“integrating” quackery with oncology. And don’t even get me started on
“naturopathic oncology,” which is becoming increasingly accepted and
metastasizing outside of academia.

The strategy is starting to work, as STAT reports:

   But Ohio is not alone. Eleven other states have implemented policies to
   encourage beneficiaries to use alternative therapies to help manage their
   pain and limit reliance on opioids, according to a 2016 survey by the
   National Academy for State Health Policy. In addition to acupuncture, covered
   services include massage, yoga, chiropractic manipulation, and various forms
   of physical and behavioral therapy, among others.

   Two states, Maine and Vermont, are currently considering whether to expand
   coverage of acupuncture to treat pain after conducting studies to test its
   effectiveness for beneficiaries.

More on Maine and Vermont later. First, back to Ohio.

Meanwhile, back in Ohio…

So let’s take a closer look at what’s going on in Ohio by going back to the
Cleveland.com article:

   Dr. Maya Myslenski, a pediatrician who practices in the emergency department 
   at MetroHealth Medical Center, has been offering acupuncture to her patients 
   for a variety of ailments for more than two years. It helps patients with
   both acute and chronic pain, anxiety, and some stomach ailments, she said.

   “A lot of our [Medicaid] patients can’t afford to go to private offices for
   treatments,” Myslenski said. “I’m beyond thrilled about treatments being
   covered for them.”

Noooo! During my residency at University Hospitals of Cleveland, I did part of
my training at MetroHealth Medical Center, particularly for trauma. I
moonlighted as a helicopter flight physician for Metro LifeFlight, which is
based at MetroHealth Medical Center.

Unfortunately, this article is quite credulous about acupuncture, repeating the 
usual tropes used to justify it:

   In Ohio, the move to cover acupuncture for chronic pain conditions began in
   earnest in January of 2016, when Gov. John Kasich’s Cabinet Opiate Action
   Team (GCOAT) released a guideline for the management of acute pain outside of
   emergency departments. The guideline said that non-drug therapies such as
   acupuncture (as well as physical and massage therapies, biofeedback and
   hypnotherapy) should be considered as first-line treatments for acute pain.
   The Governor’s team also encouraged Medicaid to further research and review
   acupuncture.

   Then in January of 2017, the Joint Commission, the not-for-profit
   organization that certifies hospitals have met certain safety standards,
   changed its pain management standards to require that accredited hospitals
   provide nonpharmacological pain treatments.

   Around the same time, the American College of Physicians issued new
   guidelines for the treatment of low back pain, which recommended that doctors
   treat patients with non-drug therapies first, including acupuncture.

One more time: The ACP guidelines were poorly conceived and based on weak
science. I’ve also mentioned the Joint Commission’s recommendations before.
While it’s not unreasonable to promote the use of nonpharmacological approaches 
to pain, those approaches must be science- and evidence-based. So far, advocates
of unscientific approaches like acupuncture have been getting away with using
the opioid crisis as a cover to advance their quackery and even get the
government and insurance companies to pay for it. They’re not even subtle about 
it:

   “It may take another year or so, but I do think it’s going to lead to a
   change in policy,” he said. “The opioid crisis has helped the establishment
   catch up a little to research on acupuncture. There’s been a big change in
   attitude in terms of openness to this sort of thing.”

The person making the above statement is Robert Davis, a Vermont acupuncturist
who led the state’s pilot testing acupuncture for back pain. Yeah, that gives me
a lot of confidence in the scientific validity of the pilot studies being done 
in various states. I note that his website basically relies on testimonials to
claim that acupuncture “works”; well, that and “ample clinical experience,
supported by some research data.”

I also can’t help but note that even the author of this story lazily cites a
“meta-analysis” from the Australian Acupuncture and Chinese Medicine Association
that was not published in any peer-reviewed journal as “evidence” for the
efficacy of acupuncture, as he lays down quotes like:

   West said the research on acupuncture has become much clearer in recent
   years, both on how well it works and how it can save money.

   “There are some really big, recent studies that clearly show that acupuncture
   is not only comparable to Western medicine in how effective it is, but it’s 
   safer and it’s cost-effective,” West said. “In chronic low back pain, you can
   save money over the long-term, give people just as good care and they’re not
   getting addicted to pain medication.”

   It costs the insurer between 70 cents and $1 per month, per policy, to add
   acupuncture coverage, West said. “It just doesn’t make sense not to when
   we’re spending $1 billion a year in Ohio on addiction treatment.”

No, when you’re spending $1 billion a year on addiction treatment for Ohio
residents, it doesn’t make sense to waste money on ineffective and
pseudoscientific treatments. What’s next? Narconon? Also, no, there are not
“really big, recent studies that clearly show that acupuncture is comparable to 
“Western” medicine, much less cost effective. In general, most studies of
acupuncture tend to be relatively small, poorly controlled, and equivocal in
results, while meta-analyses of acupuncture studies are generally the epitome of
“garbage in, garbage out.” In general, the larger and better designed the
acupuncture study, the smaller the effect, with the effect size being in essence
zero in the very best studies. Moreover, it doesn’t matter where you place the 
needles or even if you place the needles in; the effect is the same,
nonspecific. Acupuncture doesn’t work. It is theatrical placebo.

As for Jared West, who was quoted above, he’s an acupuncturist, of course. Not
surprisingly, he offers acupuncture, moxibustion, and cupping quackery. He’s
also president of the Ohio Association of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine and 
is helping providers navigate the Medicaid registration process and has advised 
the state on reimbursement and other issues.

Beyond Ohio

The STAT article notes several other states considering letting Medicaid
recipients choose acupuncture and other alternative treatments, which brings us 
back to Vermont:

   “Acupuncture is not going to solve the opioid crisis,” said Robert Davis, an 
   acupuncturist who led Vermont’s Medicaid study. “But acupuncture is one tool 
   that helps patients. It helps them get their feet back under them.” Vermont’s
   study found that, among about 150 pain patients, acupuncture improved
   patients’ rating of pain, fatigue, depression, and other measures — though
   the study didn’t include a control group, and so may have reflected a placebo
   effect.

I encourage you to read the study. It was not published in any peer-reviewed
medical journal, just on the Vermont Legislature website. It is an utterly
worthless study, a total waste of Vermont taxpayer money. Indeed, you can tell
this study is utterly useless from its design as described in the abstract:

   A pilot-level prospective pragmatic intervention trial design was chosen as
   the most appropriate approach for this project after a thorough analysis of
   the legislative goals, resources, and timeline provided by Act 173, along
   with a review of the existing scientific literature. Several acupuncture
   trialists considered to be subject-matter experts by their peers were
   consulted in order to confirm the soundness of this approach. Qualitative
   interviews were also utilized to understand the experience from the patients’
   perspective. Pragmatic trials are designed to answer questions useful to
   clinicians and policy makers because they aim to maximize external validity
   and generalizability to a real-world setting. This pilot included a
   heterogeneous group of chronic pain patients that were treated by
   Vermont-licensed acupuncturists who provided treatment in their private
   clinics in line with their standard practice. This design was intended to
   reflect what would happen if acupuncture reimbursement were offered for local
   chronic pain patients by the local population of acupuncturists. As a Phase 
   1 uncontrolled pilot, this study was designed to provide qualitative and
   implementation data that may help policy-makers. The Department of Vermont
   Health Access (DVHA) decided this was the best research design available in
   the short timeframe. A thorough description of the rationale for this
   approach is described in the Progress Report to the Legislature and a journal
   article published on this topic.

Whenever you hear the words “pilot” and “pragmatic” in a description of a study 
design for an intervention designed to treat a subjective complaint like pain,
you know it’s guaranteed to show a positive result, thanks to placebo effects.
Acupuncturists love pragmatic studies for this very reason. It is true that
pragmatic studies are designed to test interventions as used in the “real
world,” but there is an assumption behind them, namely that the treatment being 
tested has already been shown to be efficacious in well-designed randomized
controlled clinical trials. Indeed, for real interventions, frequently what is
found in pragmatic trials is that the treatment doesn’t work as well in the
“real world” as it did in clinical trials, usually because of the variability
and lack of consistency that inevitably arise when treatments are released “into
the wild.” In the case of treatments that don’t work better than placebo but do
induce placebo effects, pragmatic trials almost always show more efficacy than 
well-designed randomized trials. Again, that’s the point. This trial is so
useless that it’s hardly worth even citing its results. If you want an idea of
how biased this study is, just look at some of the comments from patients
included in Appendix A:

  1. “My acupuncture was life changing… I saw and felt and continue to feel a
    marked difference in my pain and mental clarity. I believe it saved my
    life.”

  2. “Acupuncture helped me to get my life back.”

  3. “I was very skeptical about this treatment being effective. As the weeks went 
    by, I noticed different changes taking place in my body: my digestive system
    functioned much better, so my diet improved; I required less sleeping
    medication because my sleep was better; my pain level was much decreased; I 
    had more genuine energy; and most especially, I had better mobility. The
    mobility change enabled me to walk more in fresh air and increased my good
    energy level. A circle of reinforcements that has made my life much better, 
    more productive and happier. It has cut down my need for other medical
    interventions like physical therapy and medications for various ailments.
    People have noticed the outward improvement.”

  4. “I went to a regular doctor for over six years and my pain only became more
    intense and more frequent. This is the longest I’ve gone without pain or
    medication in well over a year.”

  5. “this is a very necessary way to treat pain. I am very allergic to many
    medications and during the study I was able to walk and do more without an
    allergic reaction.”

You get the idea.

STAT does note that the evidence base for acupuncture is pretty thin, citing
Cochrane reviews on acupuncture as a treatment for various conditions. Cochrane,
for instance, points out that the there is a short term small benefit for
patients with chronic low back pain but “notes that most studies are of low
quality”; that acupuncture can help arthritis patients, but that the benefits
are “too small, and too susceptible to placebo, to be considered clinically
relevant”; and that acupuncture can offer a small benefit for migraines. (Note: 
Acupuncture doesn’t work for migraine, as Steve Novella has explained.)

Despite how poor its own study is, Vermont is using it to guide policy:

   As states weigh the evidence and opposing arguments, many are moving
   cautiously. In Vermont, the Medicaid department is still considering how to
   translate the findings of its study into recommendations to state lawmakers, 
   who will ultimately decide whether to expand coverage.

Elsewhere:

   Oregon has created a similar approach, according to the survey by the
   National Academy for State Health Policy. The state covers several treatment 
   options for patients with low-back pain, including acupuncture, chiropractic 
   care, physical and occupational therapy, and behavioral therapy. The state
   also recommends treatment plans that include yoga, massage, and exercise
   therapy, although applicability of those services is determined by
   organizations that coordinate care for Oregon’s Medicaid beneficiaries.

Mark Crislip has previously noted how woo-friendly Oregon is.

The future of Medicaid?

Given the seriousness of the opioid epidemic and the public health imperative to
institute policies to bring it under control, it is not surprising that
integrative medicine advocates saw an opening. I don’t believe that they are
being cynical or disingenuous (at least not the vast majority of them). Rather, 
they really believe that their quackery really can function as nonpharmacologic 
treatments for chronic pain. In other words, the vast majority of them are true 
believers, not scammers. The problem is that they are incorrect.

Alternative medicine, in particular acupuncture, is not the answer—or even one
among many answers—to the opioid crisis. Worse, government funding tends to be a
zero sum game, particularly now, which means that any funds diverted to pay for
acupuncture and other alternative medicine, be it to provide services to those 
with chronic pain or to do research on non-opioid and non-pharmacologic
treatments for pain, are funds not available to pay for science-based treatment.
Unfortunately, I predict that acupuncture advocates and advocates of other
unscientific treatments will likely be as persistent as naturopaths in pursuing 
their state-by-state legislative goals. As much as I’m half tempted to welcome
them to the bureaucratic pain that is accepting Medicaid reimbursement and the
very low reimbursement rates with a hearty, “Be careful what you wish for, you
just might get it,” we proponents of science-based medicine need to resist these
incursions in each state where we become aware of them.

Medicare proposal covers acupuncture for back pain study participants: A prelude
to full coverage?

Medicare coverage of acupuncture is under consideration. A new proposal would
provide coverage to Medicare patients participating in studies of acupuncture
for back pain. This research would be used in making a final decision.

Jann Bellamy on July 18, 2019

Link



Medicare will cover acupuncture treatments under a proposal announced by the
Trump administration on July 15, but only for Medicare beneficiaries with
chronic low back pain enrolled in research to determine whether the treatment
decreases their pain, improves function, or decreases the use of other medical
treatments, such as opioids. According to Health and Human Services Secretary
Alex Azar, the proposal is part of an effort to address the opioid addiction
epidemic by providing patients with “new options while expanding our scientific 
understanding of alternative approaches to pain”.

This decision is part of a larger effort to decide whether acupuncture should be
covered for all seniors insured by Medicare:

   CMS [Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services] is opening this national
   coverage analysis (NCA) to complete a thorough review of the evidence to
   determine if acupuncture for CLBP is reasonable and necessary under the
   Medicare program.

CMS says it reviewed the literature on the effectiveness of acupuncture for
chronic low back pain, as well as guidelines and professional society
recommendations. Unfortunately, these included some unreliable sources on
acupuncture, such as the Veterans Administration and the American College of
Physicians guidelines. CMS decided that

   While we believe the evidence is promising, we do not believe the evidence is
   sufficient at this time for representative older patients with chronic
   nonspecific low back pain. We believe additional research would be needed in 
   order to make a favorable coverage determination . . .

Hence, the decision to help fund that research.

Any fair review of the evidence for acupuncture answers the question the
government is about to spend taxpayer money asking all over again: We already
know that acupuncture is nothing more than an elaborate placebo and that it does
not work, for anything. Thus, this effort is not justifiable based on any real 
need to do more research. Here’s what SBM’s Steve Novella, MD, had to say in a
Washington Post story on the subject:

   “The whole thing is a big scam,” said Steven Novella, an assistant professor 
   of neurology at the Yale School of Medicine and editor of the “Science-Based 
   Medicine” website. “The only honest interpretation of the data is that
   acupuncture is a theatrical placebo.” . . .

   Novella said that the efficacy attributed to acupuncture in the 2018 review
   [referred to in the story] could easily be explained by various research
   biases and that no drug would be allowed on the market based on that level of
   proof.“We never get that threshold of evidence that you need in medicine,
   where you get that persistent effect, and it’s replicable” across numerous
   studies, he said.

Exactly. The only explanation in my mind, then, is political: It is another
success in the relentless campaign by CAM proponents to promote pseudoscience as
the best thing since sliced bread for pain relief and therefore the cure for
America’s opioid crisis. And, given the state of the evidence that prompted
CMS’s proposal, I fear that similarly weak evidence produced by this research
could prompt national coverage.

There are reasons other than wasting taxpayer money to oppose this proposal. CMS
should not be considering Medicare coverage of acupuncture at all because of
what I’ve referred to as integrative medicine’s “collateral damage”. If CMS were
to decide to cover acupuncture outside of research, that necessarily means
patients would be seeing licensed acupuncturists in private office settings,
giving acupuncturists the opportunity to sell patients on the vast array of
pseudoscience covered by the acupuncturist’s scope of practice. (In fact, as we 
shall see, given the nature of the clinical trials under consideration, this
could well occur within the context of research covered by CMS’s current
proposal.)

For example, depending on their scope of practice, licensed acupuncturists have 
broad authority to diagnose and treat any disease or condition with, not just
acupuncture, but also bleeding, reflexology, Kirlian photography, thermograpy,
homeopathy, gua sha, Chinese herbs (basically, unrefined and unproven drugs),
magnets, reiki, therapeutic touch, cranial sacral therapy, Oriental medicine
injection therapy (including caffeine and other substances), polarity therapy,
dietary supplements, cupping, and, in New Hampshire, “insertion and retention,
for days or weeks, of intradermal needles or press tacks in acupuncture points”.
One study that reviewed acupuncturists’ websites showed that a majority
advertised treatments for allergies and asthma that were unsupported by
evidence. About 92 percent of seniors have at least one chronic disease and 77
percent have at least two, making them prime targets for cross-selling.
Conditions like dementia, cognitive decline, and other mental health issues make
older adults even more vulnerable.

CMS may also want to consider Florida’s experience in covering acupuncture for
motor vehicle accident injuries. (Although, interestingly, cost-effectiveness
analysis is apparently not a part of determining Medicare coverage.) A 2010
study by the Department of Insurance found that acupuncture was the second most 
expensive average provider charge per claim, clocking in at $3,674, more per
claim than ER doctors, general practitioners, and orthopedic surgeons. The
legislature responded by eliminating acupuncture coverage from no-fault auto
insurance.

Medicare-supported studies

The 47-page “Proposed Decision Memo for Acupuncture for Chronic Low Back Pain”
describes the requirements for the acupuncture research, which must be performed
in clinical trials supported by the NIH or “CMS approved studies meeting AHRQ
[Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality] criteria.” Of note, the NIH has
already announced a “large-scale pragmatic trial to evaluate the impact of, and 
strategies to best implement, acupuncture treatment of older adults (65 years
and older) with chronic low back pain.” Interesting language there: Why a
“pragmatic trial” of a treatment with, at best, highly dubious evidence of
effectiveness? Why “impact of” – what does that even mean in a research context?
And why announce you are going to study “strategies to best implement
acupuncture treatment” before you know the results of the “impact” studies, such
as they are? Also of note: the NIH will not fund studies that propose a sham
control. Why?

Here’s why, as explained by SBM’s own David Gorski, MD, PhD, himself an
NIH-funded researcher:

   Whenever you hear the words “pilot” and “pragmatic” in a description of a
   study design for an intervention designed to treat a subjective complaint
   like pain, you know it’s guaranteed to show a positive result, thanks to
   placebo effects. Acupuncturists love pragmatic studies for this very reason. 
   It is true that pragmatic studies are designed to test interventions as used 
   in the “real world,” but there is an assumption behind them, namely that the 
   treatment being tested has already been shown to be efficacious in
   well-designed randomized controlled clinical trials. Indeed, for real
   interventions, frequently what is found in pragmatic trials is that the
   treatment doesn’t work as well in the “real world” as it did in clinical
   trials, usually because of the variability and lack of consistency that
   inevitably arise when treatments are released “into the wild.” In the case of
   treatments that don’t work better than placebo but do induce placebo
   effects, pragmatic trials almost always show more efficacy than well-designed
   randomized trials. Again, that’s the point.

CMS’s proposed Medicare coverage for research studies requires:

   A minimum 12-week acupuncture intervention versus usual care or other
   intervention for chronic low back pain. Endpoints must be measured at 12
   weeks, 6 months, and 12 months . . . with comparison to usual care, or other 
   planned comparator arm.

In other words, CMS’s research will suffer from the same deficiencies as the
NIH’s pragmatic trial.

In keeping with Medicare coverage requirements under the Social Security Act,
acupuncture can be furnished in these studies only by physicians, or by
physician assistants, nurse practitioners, and “auxiliary personnel,” all of
whom (save physicians) must be licensed acupuncturists, have a graduate degree
in acupuncture or Oriental Medicine from a school accredited by the
Accreditation Commission on Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine, and certified by 
the National Certification Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine,
both fox-guarding-the-henhouse organizations that, respectively, accredit
acupuncture schools and test their graduates. “Auxiliary personnel” (presumably,
acupuncturists who are not PAs or nurses) must be under the direct supervision 
of a physician, PA, NP, or clinical nurse specialist.

Thus, while physicians, depending on state licensing requirements, may have
taken a “medical acupuncture” course to learn acupuncture, all others will be
fully steeped in the mysticism and pseudoscience that comes with an acupuncture 
degree.

In its discussion of acupuncture, CMS does not acknowledge the recent political 
origins of TCM and contemporary forms of acupuncture, although it does (sort of)
admit that it’s not really “thousands of years” old. While stating that it
found insufficient evidence for covering acupuncture, CMS then turns around and 
declares that “Western medical acupuncture” employs the “principles of evidence 
based medicine”. It also dutifully marches through surrogate outcomes that are
widely claimed as explaining acupuncture’s mechanism of action; e.g., endogenous
opioids and release of adenosine. And, perhaps without realizing that it is
doing so, CMS admits that “acupuncture” can mean whatever the practitioner wants
it to mean.

   [T]here is a diversity of theoretical models and techniques that are all
   described as acupuncture . . . [including] needling at specifically chosen
   points . . . [and] “non-needling” techniques focused on these points. Modern 
   medical acupuncturists choose anatomically and physiologically important
   treatment points which many include both traditional acupuncture points and
   other non-traditional fixed points. . . . [T]here are several variations to
   traditional acupuncture including shallow needling, intradermal needling or
   intramuscular needling . . . twirling, plucking or thrusting [the]
   acupuncture needles. There are numerous variations of manually or
   electrically stimulated “needling” techniques, as well as multiple
   “non-needling” acupuncture techniques.

All of which raises the question: if a study uses one method of selecting
acupuncture points and one method of needling (or non-needling), how
generalizable are its results to other methods? And, if Medicare is to cover
acupuncture nationally, how could it ever describe just which “acupuncture” it
covers? Or, will it cover all acupuncture, despite the negative studies of
particular methods? How would that be justifiable as “reasonable and necessary
to the diagnosis and treatment of illness or injury,” the legal standard for
Medicare coverage?

Finally, CMS’s criteria for studies include:

  1. “The rationale for the study is well supported by available scientific and
    medical evidence.”

  2. “The research study is in compliance with all applicable Federal regulations
    concerning the protection of human subjects. . .” [which requires studies to
    be based on sound science].

  3. “All aspects of the study are conducted according to appropriate standards of 
    scientific integrity.”

The implausibility of acupuncture (hand-waving about surrogate measures aside)
should (but won’t) disqualify any study of acupuncture if these criteria are
enforced.

CMS will accept comments on the proposal until August 14, 2019, and is
“particularly interested in comments that address current studies of acupuncture
(randomized controlled trials, observational trials, and registries) in the
Medicare population.” (Thus, it would be especially helpful if those with a
background in medicine or research would comment.) Many SBM readers complain
about the infiltration of CAM; here’s the chance to do something about it. When 
CMS previously floated the idea of Medicare coverage for acupuncture, proponents
came out in droves. Only “a few commenters did not support CMS coverage.” Let’s
do better this time.

HB 4710: Licensing and expanding the scope of practice of acupuncturists in
Michigan

Last week, HB 4710, a bill to license acupuncturists, was considered by the
Michigan House of Representatives Health Policy Committee. If passed into law,
HB 4710 would do far more than license the quackery that is acupuncture. It
would also expand the scope of practice of acupuncturists to include homeopathy,
“health coaching”, and dietary advice, and is yet another example of what
practitioners of pseudoscientific medicine crave: The imprimatur of state
approval for their “profession.”

David Gorski on June 24, 2019

Link



If there’s one thing that practitioners of pseudoscientific medicine and
quackery crave, it’s respectability. They want to be taken seriously by patients
and physicians, because with respectability means no longer being viewed as
quacks or even fringe and acceptance as legitimate health care providers. This
is a fight that they’ve been waging at least 50 or 60 years. The success that
they’ve had can be seen in the evolution of how a lot of quackery is described. 
As I discussed several years ago, way back in the mists of time, say, 50 years
ago, “quackery” was the preferred term used to refer to ineffective and
potentially harmful medical practices not supported by evidence. Not
surprisingly, quacks and charlatans did not like this.

Beginning in the 1960s and 1970s, supporters of quackery decided that they would
never get anywhere selling their products, except to a small minority of
people, if they continued to allow physicians to define their favorite quackery 
as being…well, quackery. Thus was born the term “alternative medicine”. Although
practitioners of alternative medicine liked this term better than the terms
“quackery” and “quacks”, they were, not surprisingly, still not satisfied. Thus 
was born in the 1990s the term “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM).
Because CAM therapies are used in addition to real medicine, over a relatively
brief period of time the name change had its intended effect. No longer did many
physicians automatically view modalities that were once considered quackery,
later considered “alternative”, and now considered “CAM” as quackery, and those 
that still did were dismissed as close-minded, stubborn, and dogmatic, relics
who were trying to swim against the coming tide of wonderful CAM magic that
would transform medicine in the future.

Of course, the latest evolution of this term is “integrative medicine”. It came 
about beginning around 20 years ago because “complementary” in CAM implied that 
the nostrums that fell under the rubric of CAM were somehow less than real
medicine (which, of course, they are—much less—but that’s not what their
advocates belief). They were, after all, “complementary” or “alternative”.
Medicine was the cake, and their wares were just the icing. That wasn’t good
enough. They craved respect. They wanted to be co-equals with physicians and
science- and evidence-based medicine. The term “integrative medicine” (IM)
served their purpose perfectly. No longer were their treatments merely
“complementary” to real medicine. Oh, no. Now they were “integrating” their
treatments with those of science- and evidence-based medicine! The implication, 
the very, very, very intentional implication, was that alternative medicine was 
co-equal to science- and evidence-based medicine, an equal partner in the
“integrating”. Further permutations are evolving as well, the most common of
which is “integrative health”, in order to imply that “integrative medicine” is 
about more than just medicine, but rather overall health. Unfortunately, this
moniker for integrating quackery into medicine (or health) is catching on.

That, of course, was still not enough. What’s the ultimate demonstration that a 
medical practice is accepted by society? Obviously, it’s licensure by the state.
Practitioners of unscientific modalities, such as chiropractors,
acupuncturists, naturopaths, and others crave licensure by the state.
Chiropractors have been the most successful, having achieved licensure in all 50
states, and we’ve frequently written about attempts by naturopaths to claim
licensure and be accepted as equivalent to primary care physicians, but
acupuncturists have not been idle. They’ve been trying to be licensed in my
state, and last week I did my part to oppose the licensure of acupuncturists.
I’ll discuss the current state of the legislation and then provide an example of
what can happen in a state that actually does license acupuncturists to show
the consequences of licensing a pseudoscientific mystical modality that’s far
more based on a prescientific superstitious understanding of how the body works 
than it is of anything resembling a modern scientific understanding of human
physiology, genetics, and biochemistry.

HB 4710: Michigan acupuncturists try to claim licensure and expanded scope of
practice

Last week, Jann Bellamy and I got an email from CFI-Michigan asking for
assistance opposing HB 4710, a bill that was going to come before the Health
Policy Committee last Thursday. Unfortunately, Thursday is my main clinic day,
and I only had two days’ notice. I couldn’t very well cancel clinic on such
short notice, particularly given that I’m going to miss a clinic on July 4
because it’s a holiday. That didn’t mean I wasn’t willing to help. Of course,
these sorts of legislative hearings are often announced on short notice, which
means in many cases that only those without jobs or the most passionately
engaged can manage to drop everything they’re doing and journey to Lansing to
attend these meetings. I had experienced the same thing a few years ago when
misbegotten right-to-try legislation was pushed through the Michigan
legislature.

First, however, let’s take a look at HB 4710 itself. Before I discuss the
content of HB 4710 itself, I should point out that in the State of Michigan,
acupuncturist is a title that is a registered profession. Basically, right now
all that acupuncturists have to do is to register with the state, submit a
background check, and pay a $275.75 fee.

So what would HB 4710 do? It would change the profession of acupuncturist in
Michigan from a registered profession to a licensed profession. It would also
turn “acupuncturist” into a protected term that can only be used by licensees
and seems to establish a presumption in favor of being awarded a license as long
as an individual has education or training “appropriate to the practice of
acupuncture”. There would also be a continuing education requirement for
acupuncturists seeking license renewal.

If that were all that HB 4710 would do if passed into law, that would be bad
enough, but licensing acupuncturists is not all that it would do. Come, my
friends, let’s read a bit of the text. Basically, the bill expands the scope of 
practice of acupuncturists to include:

   (A) “ACUPRESSURE” MEANS A FORM OF MANUAL THERAPY IN WHICH PHYSICAL PRESSURE
   IS APPLIED TO VARIOUS POINTS ON THE BODY.

   (B) (a) “Acupuncture” means the insertion and manipulation of needles through
   the surface of the human body. at specific locations on the human body for
   the prevention or correction of disease, injury, pain, or other condition.
   ACUPUNCTURE INCLUDES, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO, LASER ACUPUNCTURE,
   ELECTROACUPUNCTURE, PRICKING THERAPY, DRY NEEDLING, AND INTRAMUSCULAR
   STIMULATION.

   (C) (b) “Acupuncturist” means an individual who practices acupuncture and is 
   registered, or otherwise authorized, LICENSED under this part TO ENGAGE IN
   THE PRACTICE OF ACUPUNCTURE.

   (D) “CUPPING” MEANS THE PLACEMENT OF A SPECIALLY DESIGNED CUP ON THE BODY TO 
   CREATE SUCTION.

   (E) “DERMAL FRICTION” MEANS THE USE OF REPEATED, CLOSELY TIMED,
   UNIDIRECTIONAL PRESS-STROKING WITH A SMOOTH-EDGED INSTRUMENT OVER A
   LUBRICATED AREA OF THE BODY.

   (F) “DIETARY COUNSELING” MEANS THE PROCESS OF ADVISING A PATIENT ABOUT
   HEALTHY FOOD CHOICES AND HEALTHY EATING HABITS IN ACCORDANCE WITH EAST ASIAN 
   MEDICAL THEORY.

   (G) “DRY NEEDLING” MEANS A REHABILITATIVE PROCEDURE USING FILIFORM NEEDLES TO
   PENETRATE THE SKIN OR UNDERLYING TISSUES BY TARGETING ONLY MYOFASCIAL
   TRIGGER POINTS AND MUSCULAR AND CONNECTIVE TISSUES TO AFFECT CHANGE IN BODY
   STRUCTURES AND FUNCTIONS FOR THE EVALUATION AND MANAGEMENT OF
   NEUROMUSCULOSKELETAL PAIN AND MOVEMENT IMPAIRMENT. DRY NEEDLING DOES NOT
   INCLUDE THE STIMULATION OF AURICULAR POINTS OR OTHER ACUPUNCTURE POINTS.

   (H) “EAST ASIAN MEDICINE TECHNIQUES” INCLUDES, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO,
   ACUPUNCTURE, MANUAL THERAPY, MOXIBUSTION, HEAT THERAPY, DIETARY COUNSELING,
   THERAPEUTIC EXERCISE, ACUPRESSURE, CUPPING, DERMAL FRICTION, HOMEOPATHY,
   LIFESTYLE COACHING, AND TREATMENT WITH HERBAL MEDICINES.

   (I) “HEAT THERAPY” MEANS THE USE OF HEAT IN THERAPY, SUCH AS FOR PAIN RELIEF 
   AND HEALTH.

   (J) “HERBAL MEDICINE” MEANS THE INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL USE OF A PLANT OR A
   PLANT EXTRACT, A MINERAL, OR AN ANIMAL PRODUCT, THAT IS NOT A PRESCRIPTION
   DRUG AS THAT TERM IS DEFINED IN SECTION 17708.

   (K) “HOMEOPATHY” MEANS THE USE OF A HIGHLY DILUTED NATURAL REMEDY FROM THE
   PLANT, MINERAL, AND ANIMAL DOMAIN.

   (L) “LIFESTYLE COACHING” MEANS THE PROCESS OF ADVISING A PATIENT ABOUT
   HEALTHY LIFESTYLE CHOICES AND HABITS IN ACCORDANCE WITH EAST ASIAN MEDICAL
   THEORY.

   (M) “MANUAL THERAPY” MEANS THE APPLICATION OF AN ACCURATELY DETERMINED AND
   SPECIFICALLY DIRECTED MANUAL FORCE TO THE BODY, EXCLUDING A HIGH-VELOCITY,
   LOW-AMPLITUDE THRUST TO THE SPINE.

   (N) “MOXIBUSTION” MEANS BURNING THE DRIED PLANT Artemisia vulgaris ON OR VERY
   NEAR THE SURFACE OF THE SKIN AS A FORM OF THERAPY.

   (O) “PRACTICE OF ACUPUNCTURE”, SUBJECT TO SUBSECTION (2), MEANS THE USE OF
   TRADITIONAL AND CONTEMPORARY EAST ASIAN MEDICAL THEORY TO ASSESS AND DIAGNOSE
   A PATIENT, TO DEVELOP A PLAN TO TREAT THE PATIENT, AND TO TREAT THE PATIENT 
   THROUGH EAST ASIAN MEDICINE TECHNIQUES.

Of all of these, H is the key. Basically, if passed into law, this provision
would grant acupuncturists the scope of practice to do anything that is
associated with “East Asian Medicine”, including acupuncture, manual therapy,
moxibustion, heat therapy, dietary counseling, therapeutic exercise,
acupressure, cupping, dermal friction, homeopathy, lifestyle coaching, and
herbal medicine. Two of these stand out. For instance, since when has homeopathy
ever been a part of “East Asian medicine”? When has homeopathy had anything
whatsoever to do with traditional Chinese medicine or acupuncture? It’s its own 
quackery, “Western” or European quackery! Homeopathy was invented by Samuel
Hahnemann in the late 1700s…in Germany! Yet, for some reason, acupuncturists in 
Michigan want to embrace it. It’s almost as though the acupuncturists promoting 
HB 4710 want to grab as much quackery as they can get away with and codify it
into law allowing them to do almost anything, as long as it isn’t chiropractic
(which this bill would prohibit them from doing, although it would let them do
“manual therapy”) and they can claim it as part of “Eastern Asian medicine.”

Note also how this bill would let acupuncturists embrace “lifestyle coaching”
and dietary advice as well. Apparently acupuncturists don’t think that
acupuncture is woo enough for them and want to expand their scope of practice as
much as possible, in much the same way naturopaths try to expand their scope of
practice to be able to prescribe actual pharmaceutical drugs and represent
themselves as primary care providers. (Never mind all that vitalistic nonsense
and how strongly antivaccine most naturopaths are.)

Of course, there would be a board to regulate acupuncturists:

   Sec. 16525. (1) The WITHIN 12 MONTHS AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE
   AMENDATORY ACT THAT AMENDED THIS SECTION, THE department, in consultation
   with the board, shall promulgate rules setting forth the minimum standards
   for registration as an acupuncturist. The department, in consultation with
   the board, may adopt by reference the professional standards issued by a
   certified program that is recognized by the national commission for
   certifying agencies or by a nationally recognized trade association.THAT
   ESTABLISH THE MINIMUM STANDARDS FOR LICENSURE AS AN ACUPUNCTURIST AND
   IMPLEMENT THE LICENSURE PROGRAM FOR THE PRACTICE OF ACUPUNCTURE. IN
   PROMULGATING RULES FOR PURPOSES OF SECTION 16515(1), THE DEPARTMENT, IN
   CONSULTATION WITH THE BOARD, MAY ADOPT BY REFERENCE THE PROFESSIONAL
   STANDARDS ISSUED BY A CERTIFIED PROGRAM THAT IS RECOGNIZED BY THE NATIONAL
   COMMISSION FOR CERTIFYING AGENCIES. IN PROMULGATING RULES FOR PURPOSES OF
   SECTION 16515(2), THE DEPARTMENT, IN CONSULTATION WITH THE BOARD, SHALL
   CONSIDER WHETHER AN APPLICANT HAS COMPLETED SYSTEMATIC ACUPUNCTURE EDUCATION 
   THAT INCLUDES LIVE LECTURES, DEMONSTRATIONS, AND SUPERVISED CLINICAL TRAINING
   SPECIFIC TO ACUPUNCTURE.

That’s the problem with the state regulating quackery. It isn’t science-based
practitioners defining the standard of care and educational requirements for
“professions” like acupuncture. It’s the quacks themselves. We’ve seen this
issue with naturopaths, whose board in California, for instance, sought to sweep
the particularly egregious death of a patient due to quackery under the rug.
It’s why I argue that licensed quack “professionals” (like naturopaths) are no
safer or less quacky than unlicensed ones.

Let’s look at an example in acupuncture.

Arizona acupuncture board “takes on the opioid crisis”

Acupuncture is a licensed profession in Arizona, complete with an Acupuncture
Board of Examiners, as are so many other forms of quackery, such as homeopathic 
physicians, naturopaths, and more. On Friday, I came across an article on
Cronkite News by Tim Ryan entitled “Arizona acupuncture board takes on the
opioid crisis“:

   The State of Arizona Acupuncture Board of Examiners has entered the fight
   against opioid abuse, approving chemical dependency programs for a form of
   acupuncture that involves the outer ear. Supporters say auricular acupuncture
   helps people break free of addiction, but a skeptic says there’s zero
   evidence acupuncture relieves any condition.

   “I don’t think (auricular acupuncture is) the complete answer, but I think it
   can really help change the tide,” said Dr. Mario Fontes, clinic director of 
   Natural Medicine & Detox in central Phoenix, which offers a board-approved
   chemical dependency program.

That skeptic, as you’ll see, is our very own Steve Novella. Unfortunately, this 
article plays out as a typical annoying article about quackery in mainstream
press, full of false balance. Basically, it’s a “he said/he said” article,
pitting Novella against a member of the State of Arizona Acupuncture Board of
Examiners, Mario Fontes. You can tell where the reporter’s sympathies lie in the
way that he gives Fontes the last word. After listing Novella’s reasonable
criticisms of acupuncture that any regular reader of this blog or Neurologica
Blog would be familiar with (acupuncture is a theatrical placebo; acupuncturists
cherry pick studies; acupuncture is not benign; licensing acupuncture grants
legitimacy to pseudoscience), Ryan allows Fontes to dismiss it all thusly:

   Fontes said he has faced critics like Novella his entire career, but he
   remains undeterred.

   “Anytime there’s something that’s not mainstream, eventually, it becomes
   integrated, and there’s always going to be the people opposed to that,” he
   said. “The people who want our help, we’re here for. The people who don’t,
   that’s OK.”

   Noting that acupuncture has been practiced for millennia, Fontes contends
   that something more than a placebo effect is occurring, while medicines we’ve
   had for only a century, such as antibiotics, already are failing.

   “It’s the predominant belief that the true path to health is drugs, radiation
   and surgery,” Fontes said. “I just don’t believe that.”

Of course, acupuncture, at least as we know it, has not been “practiced for
millennia.” Acupuncture evolved from the Eastern version of a very well known
European form of ancient medical practice, namely bloodletting. As Steve Novella
noted, needles were originally lancets and acupuncture points were located over
veins to be opened. Qi, or the Chinese concept of the life force, was believed 
to be at least in part in the blood, and bloodletting was thus thought to free
the flow of qi. Unsurprisingly once you know this, this concept was closely
related to the Galenic concept of using bloodletting to free the flow of static 
blood in the tissue. It’s also been argued that some acupuncture points are
based on astrology. Indeed, reading descriptions from as recently as 106 years
ago of the use of acupuncture in China by a Scottish surgeon named Dugald
Christie produces horrifying examples of how acupuncture was practiced in the
far more recent past than advocates would have you believe:

   Chinese doctors own that they know nothing at all of surgery. They cannot tie
   an artery, amputate a finger or perform the simplest operation. The only
   mode of treatment in vogue which might be called surgical is acupuncture,
   practised for all kinds of ailments. The needles are of nine forms, and are
   frequently used red-hot, and occasionally left in the body for days. Having
   no practical knowledge of anatomy, the practitioners often pass needles into 
   large blood vessels and important organs, and immediate death has sometimes
   resulted. A little child was carried to the dispensary presenting a pitiable 
   spectacle. The doctor had told the parents that there was an excess of fire
   in its body, to let out which he must use cold needles, so he had pierced the
   abdomen deeply in several places. The poor little sufferer died shortly
   afterwards. For cholera the needling is in the arms. For some children’s
   diseases, especially convulsions, the needles are inserted under the nails.
   For eye diseases they are often driven into the back between the shoulders to
   a depth of several inches. Patients have come to us with large surfaces on
   their backs sloughing by reason of excessive treatment of this kind with
   instruments none too clean.

That bit about “excess of fire in the body” reminds me of something, namely how 
the traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) concepts underlying acupuncture involve
“imbalances” in the “Five Elements”. In that, TCM is very similar to “ancient
Western concepts”, namely humoral theory, which posited that disease is due to
an “imbalance” in the four humors. As I like to say (sarcastically, of course), 
TCM is so very trendy, but where’s the love for traditional Western medicine?
Indeed, TCM isn’t even very ancient. What we know today as TCM was a result of
Chairman Mao, who was facing a dire shortage of real physicians, instructing his
medical authorities to harmonize the many forms of Chinese folk medicine into a
seemingly consistent whole and promote its “integration” with “Western
medicine”. Basically, the history of TCM as promoted by its advocates has been
retconned to leave that aspect out. Indeed, acupuncture itself, at least as
practiced now, is not ancient. In the 1930s a Chinese pediatrician named Cheng
Dan’an proposed that needling therapy be resurrected because (he thought then)
its actions could be explained through neurology. He also replaced the
previously used coarse needles with the fine filiform needles in use today. No
wonder there are so many “styles” of acupuncture.

Of course, I’ve written many times about how acupuncturists and other advocates 
of integrative medicine have been co-opting the opioid addiction crisis to
promote whatever pseudoscientific medicine they believe in. Basically, the claim
is that acupuncture, naturopathy, or whatever pseudoscience the advocates
believe in can alleviate the opioid crisis by providing “nonpharmacological
treatments” to relieve chronic pain. This has led to acupuncture advocates, for 
instance, to lobby various states to have Medicaid programs cover acupuncture.
Some of the ways this misuse of the opioid crisis have been quite horrible, such
as the proposal in Oregon to require that Medicaid patients be involuntarily
weaned from opioids in favor of these “integrative” nonpharmacological
approaches to pain, damn the evidence. Not surprisingly, three acupuncturists
and a chiropractor sit on the committee that made this proposal.

Of course, one aspect of this article is that, whether intentionally or not, it 
reveals just how much other quackery is associated with acupuncture. This occurs
through the focus on Mario Fontes, whose interest in alternative medicine
“began with homeopathy, and later he expanded into acupuncture.” Yes, that’s
homeopathy, or, as I like to call it, The One Quackery To Rule Them All. He’s
also the one pushing auricular acupuncture as a treatment for opioid addiction:

   First developed by French physician Paul Nogier in the 1950s, auricular
   acupuncture, also known as acu-detox, uses needles placed in one to five
   acupuncture points in the outer ear. Proponents say the practice offers a
   non-pharmacological approach to managing a range of issues, from pain to
   stress to post traumatic stress disorder to opiate withdrawals.

   The acupuncture board has made efforts to make it easier for auricular
   acupuncturists to gain certification for the past few years to help address
   the opioid crisis, said the board’s executive director, David Geriminski.

Unfortunately, auricular acupuncture has become popular in the military in the
form of “battlefield acupuncture” (no, I’m not kidding) and in the Veterans
Health Administration. It is, unsurprisingly, even more quacky than regular
acupuncture.

That’s not all, though. Mario Fontes offers quite the cornucopia of what I and
skeptics consider quackery himself, as the perusal of his website, Natural
Medicine & Detox, quickly reveals. For instance, here he is in his role as a
clinical instructor at the American Medical College of Homeopathy and the
Phoenix Institute of Herbal Medicine and Acupuncture, waxing poetic about
combining The One Quackery To Rule Them All (homeopathy) with acupuncture:

Hilariously, Fontes goes on about how the “energetics” of acupuncture can be
applied to the “energetics” of homeopathy and how homeopathy is safer than
herbal medicine, which is probably true (because most homeopathic remedies are
diluted to the point of being just water) but irrelevant. He also offers colon
hydrotherapy; homeopathy (of course!); detox foot baths (the quackiest of
quacky); “nutritional IVs” (also very quacky); chelation therapy (dangerous
quackery); and much, much more.

Basically, acupuncturists often offer far more quackery than just acupuncture,
and HB 4710 would license them in Michigan to do just that.

Acupuncture in Michigan

Checking out the website of a member of the State of Arizona Board of
Acupuncture Examiners and observing all the quackery this board member offers
led me to wonder whether the same would be true in Michigan. Some Googling
rapidly led me to a listing of acupuncturists in Michigan. One practice that’s
seemed to have well-optimized its SEO such that it shows up high on Google
searches for acupuncture in Michigan is, appropriately enough, Michigan
Associates of Acupuncture and Integrative Medicine. It offers the usual unproven
acupuncture treatments along with TCM, craniosacral therapy, herbal medicine,
and “nutrition”. Another large acupuncture practice, Acupuncture of West
Michigan, offers acupuncture and herbal medicine, claiming that acupuncture and 
TCM can treat cardiac conditions (angina pectoris, atherosclerosis, anemia,
hypertension, palpitations, coronary heart disease); neurological disorders
(Bell’s palsy, dizziness, headaches, migraines, neuralgia, stroke, paralysis,
tics, tremors); addictions (smoking, drugs, alcohol); GI conditions (low
appetite, food sensitivities, peptic ulcer, constipation, colitis, Crohn’s
disease, diarrhea, indigestion, irritable bowel syndrome, nausea, vomiting,
gastritis); and, well, basically almost everything except, fortunately, cancer, 
noting:

   With our modern diet and lifestyle, Acupuncture and Herbs are usually needed 
   to effect a cure. But, making these changes will almost always get people
   better faster and help them stay healthy. Acupuncture is for treatment.
   Lifestyle is for prevention.

Other prominent acupuncture clinics include the Family Wellness Center, which in
addition to acupuncture offers BioSET (R) Allergy Treatment and herbal therapy;
Grand Wellness, which also offers reiki, distance healing, and crystal therapy;
and Michigan Laser and Acupuncture Center, which offers something called
Meridian Regulatory Acupuncture (MRA), which “introduces electrons where they
are needled in the body to activate its defense, compensatory and regulating
mechanisms in the control of pain and of disorder. MRA is a standardized
acupuncture application, and controls the delivery of pure flow of electrical
energy into the precise points making the treatment more efficient and
effective”.

Yes, I think that, should acupuncturists in Michigan become licensed, they will 
expand their offerings of quackery to match those of acupuncturists in Arizona.

Oppose HB 4710 and bills licensing acupuncture, wherever they are introduced

Fortunately, my state representative (Matt Koleszar) is on the Michigan House
Health Policy Committee. Unfortunately, one of the sponsors of HB 4710 (Hank
Vaupel) is the chair of the Health Policy Committee. Still, I wrote to both Rep.
Kolezar and cc’ed the secretary responsible for organizing testimony and
statements before the committee:

   Dear Rep. Koleszar:

   As a constituent in your district, I am writing to express the strongest
   opposition that I can to HB 4710, the bill currently before the House Health 
   Policy Committee to change the profession of acupuncturist from a registered 
   profession to a licensed profession. My presumption is that you—along with
   everyone on the Health Policy Committee—will agree that medicine should be
   based on solid science showing that the interventions used are effective and 
   safe. Thus, state licensure should only be granted to medical professions
   whose practices are supported by science and evidence. The reasons are
   two-fold: First, to protect the public from dubious and potentially dangerous
   practitioners and, second, because state licensure confers the imprimatur of
   the state, with all the respectability that provides, on the profession.
   Contrary to what its practitioners and supporters claim, acupuncture is
   supported by neither science nor evidence.

   Although I do not presume to speak for anyone other than myself on this
   topic, to make you aware of my qualifications, I will state that I currently 
   hold the title of Professor of Surgery at Wayne State University. I am also a
   surgical oncologist and breast cancer researcher at the Barbara Ann Karmanos
   Cancer Institute and have been a medical blogger for nearly 15 years. In
   that latter role, I write my personal blog (respectfulinsolence.com) and
   serve as managing editor of Science-Based Medicine
   (sciencebasedmedicine.org), a group blog dedicated to discussing the
   interface of science, pseudoscience, and medicine, and there is copious
   material published on both blogs to support my arguments here.

   Acupuncture has no basis in human physiology or science. “Meridians” used by 
   acupuncturists to guide the insertion of their needles have no basis in
   anatomy, and “qi,” the “life energy” whose flow, acupuncturists claim, is
   unblocked or redirected, has no basis in physics or chemistry and has never
   been detected or characterized. It is claimed that acupuncture is effective
   for a wide variety of conditions with little or no relationship in
   pathophysiology (cause), which, in my experience, is a huge red flag that it 
   doesn’t work for anything, other than through nonspecific effects. Indeed,
   there is a reason why acupuncture has been referred to as a “theatrical
   placebo,” because that’s what it is. (Please see attached PDF for an
   excellent discussion of this.) I would remind you and the committee that the 
   usual standard that the FDA uses for approving a new treatment is that it be 
   more effective than placebo. Although there are individual studies that
   report acupuncture to be better than placebo for some ailments, when you
   critically examine the totality of the evidence, the effects of acupuncture
   are indistinguishable from sham acupuncture. Basically, it doesn’t matter
   where you stick the needles, and it doesn’t even matter if you stick the
   needles in. Consistent with the lack of specificity of acupuncture effects,
   there is a 2009 German study [Arch Intern Med.2009;169(9):858-866] that shows
   that twirling toothpicks against the skin is just as effective as “true”
   acupuncture.

   If all this bill did were to license acupuncturists, that would be bad
   enough, but it goes beyond that. If passed, it would expand the scope of
   practice to include moxibustion, homeopathy (which has nothing to do with
   acupuncture or Traditional Chinese Medicine), acupressure, cupping, and
   dermal friction (otherwise known as gua sha) among other “treatments.”
   Homeopathy, in particular, is pure quackery based on pseudoscience and
   mystical thinking that has nothing to do with acupuncture. Acupuncture
   originated in Asia, although it is unclear how long ago; homeopathy
   originated independently in Germany in the late 1700s and has never been part
   of traditional Chinese medicine. From a historical and factual point of
   view, to claim, as this bill does, that homeopathy is part of “East Asian
   medicine” is so inaccurate as to be risible.

   As for why I call homeopathy “pure quackery, I will explain. Homeopathy is
   based on two “Laws”: (1) the Law of Similars, which states that, to relieve a
   symptom you need to use something that causes that symptom; and (2) the Law 
   of Infinitesimals, which states that a remedy becomes stronger the more it is
   diluted. The Law of Similars has no basis in science, physiology, or
   biology; it is, in essence sympathetic magic turned into medicine by Samuel
   Hahnemann, the creator of homeopathy. The Law of Infinitesimals is even more 
   ridiculous. Chemists know that any dilution more than around 12C (twelve
   100-fold dilutions) is unlikely to have any starting substance left. This is 
   because a mole of a substance only has around 6 x 10^23 molecules, and a 12C 
   solution is a 1 x 10^24 dilution. I would point out to the committee that
   many homeopathic remedies are diluted to 30C (a 10^60-fold dilution) or even 
   100C—or even higher. I would also point out that the number of atoms in the
   known universe is only estimated to be around 10^78 to 10^82. The math and
   chemistry of homeopathy are ridiculous. Not surprisingly, homeopathy is no
   better than placebo, because it is, in essence, water. The other treatments
   encompassed by the scope of practice expansion granted acupuncturists by this
   bill are scarcely any better in terms of their evidence base. Traditional
   Chinese medicine, for instance, is based on prescientific beliefs about how
   the body works not validated by science and includes such diagnostic
   modalities as “tongue diagnosis” and “pulse diagnosis,” neither of which is
   validated by science.

   In addition to the issue of state licensure conferring respectability to
   pseudoscience, a major problem with licensing a specialty that is not based
   in science is that it will be members of that specialty who form a board to
   oversee the practitioners of that specialty, which means that there will be
   no scientific standards regulating that specialty. In other words,
   acupuncture will be what acupuncturists claim that it is, and the standard of
   care will be what acupuncturists dictate it to be. Neither will be based in 
   science, and, contrary to the intent of the bill, the public will not be
   protected from bad actors any more than they are by the present system. In
   addition, the reason practitioners of unconventional specialties like
   acupuncture so crave state licensure is that it is the first step to
   requiring insurers to pay for their services. This, if it comes to pass (as
   it likely will if acupuncture is licensed), will result in a diversion and
   waste of precious health care resources to pay for ineffective therapies.

   In conclusion, acupuncture does not meet the minimal requirements for a
   medical specialty to be licensed by the state. It is not based in science,
   but rather in prescientific mysticism; there is no clear standard of care to 
   guide regulation; there is no clear standard of education for practitioners; 
   and available scientific evidence is most consistent with its effects being
   all nonspecific or placebo effects, an expected finding given the scientific 
   implausibility of the practice. Worse, HB 4710 would broaden the scope of
   acupuncturists to include the use of modalities that, like homeopathy, can
   only be described as pure quackery. I urge you and the committee to reject
   this bill and not send it to the full House for consideration and request
   that my email and the accompanying article be included in the evidence
   presented during the June 20 committee meeting.

   Sincerely,

   David H. Gorski, MD, PhD

For good measure, I included Steve Novella and David Colqhoun’s famous article, 
“Acupuncture is a theatrical placebo: the end of a myth“. If anyone else wants
to comment on the licensure of acupuncture in Michigan, feel free to use my
letter as a template. In addition, Jennifer Beahan, executive director of
CFI-Michigan, testified in person, providing more points to make:

And CFI-Michigan issued a call to action, Stop The Grab Bag Of Quackery In
Michigan!, which provides a nice summary of arguments against licensing
acupuncturists.

If you live in Michigan, now is the time to contact your state representative to
express opposition to HB 4710, particularly if your representative sits on the 
Michigan House Health Policy Committee, as my representative does. This isn’t
the first attempt by acupuncturists to attain licensure, and it surely won’t be 
the last; that is, assuming they are unsuccessful, an outcome that I will do my 
best to help to bring about. Unfortunately, the transcript of the testimony is
not (yet) online, but I very well might discuss on my not-so-super-secret other 
blog when the transcript is published.

If you don’t live in Michigan, keep an eye out for these sorts of bills in your 
state. Often they are introduced on the down-low, and that results in only
advocates writing to legislators and showing up to testify at meetings of the
relevant committees. It truly is, as Jann Bellamy describes it, legislative
alchemy.

           NEJM and Acupuncture: Even the best can publish nonsense.

                                  Mark Crislip

                                      Link

I realize that the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) review of acupuncture 
has already been covered by Drs. Gorski and Novella. But my ego knows no bounds;
so I thought I would add my two cents, especially since this review, more than 
any paper I have read, generates a deep sense on betrayal.

There was a time when I believed my betters. Then the Annals of Internal
Medicine had their absolutely ghastly series on SCAMS, the publication of which 
was partly responsible for interest in the topic. Since that series of articles,
I have doubt whenever I read an Annals article. When a previously respected
journal panders completely to woo, they lose all respectability. Sure, the
editors that were responsible for that travesty are long gone, but the taint
remains. I tell my kids that once a trust has been violated, it is difficult to 
get it back. The Annals has permanently lost my trust, I am afraid.

But we will always have Paris. I mean the NEJM. The NEJM is the premier medical 
journal. Just because an article is published in the NEJM doesn’t mean it’s
right; the results of clinical trials are always being superseded by new
information. But the article has supposedly been rigorously peer reviewed. Its
like Harvard and… Oops, Bad example. Harvard, as we have seen, has feet of clay,
and so, evidently, does the The New England Journal of Medicine.

Goodness, gracious, great balls of fire, the editors of the NEJM have fallen
into the depths of nonsense with this one.

Let’s go through it, shall we.

First up, the authors:

   Brian M. Berman, M.D., Helene H. Langevin, M.D., Claudia M. Witt, M.D.,
   M.B.A., and Ronald Dubner, D.D.S., Ph.D.

   From the Center for Integrative Medicine, University of Maryland School
   of Medicine (B.M.B.), and the University of Maryland Dental School (R.D.) —
   both in Baltimore; the Department of Neurology and the Program in Integrative
   Health, University of Vermont College of Medicine, Burlington (H.H.L.); and 
   the Institute for Social Medicine, Epidemiology, and Health Economics,
   Charité University Medical Center, Berlin (C.M.W.).

You always want acknowledged experts in a field to write your review. If you
want a review of Lyme disease, you ask a Lyme expert (The Connecticut Attorney
General not withstanding), and if you want a review of heart attacks, you ask a 
cardiologist.

So in that spirit, if you want a review of prescientific magic, you want someone
well-versed in the practice of prescientific magic. Fortunately, these authors 
seem well qualified. Dr. Berman founded the Center for Integrative Medicine at
University of Maryland and has a long history of research into acupuncture. The 
center has on its staff a reflexologist/reiki master. Really. And the center
offers:

   Physician Consultations, Acupuncture, Nutrition, Massage, Homeopathy,
   Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction, Shiatsu, Reflexology, Yoga, Qi Gong, Tai 
   Chi, Osteopathic Manipulation.

The University of Maryland proudly offer both acupuncture and reiki to their
trauma patients.

   Reiki is a Japanese technique of relaxation that works similarly to
   acupuncture, in that you are releasing and moving energy,” explains Donna
   Audia, R.N., a nurse on Shock Trauma’s pain management team and a certified
   Reiki master. “By using Reiki with trauma patients, we are not only helping
   them to relax, we’re also making them active participants in their own
   healing, and that can be very empowering.

   Reaction from trauma patients has been positive, with most requesting
   follow-up treatments. In fact, many family members ask to be a part of the
   Reiki session. A group of volunteers trained in Reiki now visits Shock Trauma
   regularly. The University of Maryland Medical Center is the only facility in
   the country offering Reiki to trauma patients, although it has also been
   used to treat people with cancer and other illnesses.

Seriously. Your body has been shattered in a car accident and your health care
providers think they can improve your condition by moving and releasing your
energy by waving their hands over you.

If, god forbid, you have trauma in Maryland, get transferred. Fast.

Dr. Berman has published extensively on acupuncture and Dr. Witt has published
multiple articles on homeopathy, including one using homeopathy for low back
pain.

So two of the authors are well grounded in magical thinking: who better to write
a NEJM review on acupuncture? They found a Dumbledore, a Gandalf, to write the 
article, which explains the content as the editors of the NEJM were evidently
hit with the confundus charm. As I think about it, that is not the best
metaphor, since in the fantasy world, magic is real, but in the real world,
magic is fantasy, as well as a review article in the NEJM.

The authors start with a case of chronic low back pain with mild degenerative
disease but no anatomical or physiologic reason for the pain. The vignette ends 
with:

   The patient wonders whether acupuncture would be beneficial and asks for 
   a referral to a licensed acupuncturist.

Nope. Simple enough. Acupuncture is nonsense. Oh wait. There’s more.

They review the epidemiology, physiology and anatomy of chronic low back pain
and note that the understanding of the disease is a long way from satisfactory
and conclude with:

   In addition, psychological and behavioral factors, including fear of
   movement, appear to play an important role in patients with chronic low back 
   pain. Such patients have been shown to have altered brain-activation patterns
   at subcortical and cortical sites associated with emotion and postural
   control. Studies comparing psychosocial variables with anatomical findings
   have shown the former to have greater predictive value than the latter.

In other words, with low back pain there is a big psychological overlay. It is
the psychological overlay of pain that makes it difficult to determine the
effectiveness of a therapy meant to decrease the pain. When treating a condition
in medicine, most interventions attempt to alter the underlying
pathophysiology: block a receptor with a drug, alter anatomy with a procedure as
examples. If the intervention has no effect on the underlying pathophysiology, 
then there is little reason to expect benefit beyond a placebo effect, which is 
almost no effect.

Then they jump into acupuncture.

   Acupuncture is a therapeutic intervention…

It is an intervention, yes, but therapeutic? Therapeutic means relating to
healing of disease. So they are front loading the language, saying at the
beginning that acupuncture is effective rather than proving the case. I would
have used ‘useless magical’ instead of ‘therapeutic,’ but that’s me.

   Although a number of different techniques or schools of acupuncture
   practice have arisen, the approach used in traditional Chinese medicine
   appears to be the most widely practiced in the United States.

Why? Is Chinese acupuncture better? Or is popularity the criteria we use for
determining appropriate medical care? There is Chinese and Japanese and tongue
and foot and ear and the German head acupuncture. Is there any justification
offered for using one over the other? Which is the correct style? As I have said
before, it is a trick question, like asking which is the real astrology:
European, Indian or Mayan. It makes no difference.

Then they delve into real nonsense.

   Traditional Chinese medicine espouses an ancient physiological system
   (not based on Western scientific empiricism) in which health is seen as the
   result of harmony among bodily functions and between body and nature.
   Internal disharmony is believed to cause blockage of the body’s vital energy,
   known as qi, which flows along 12 primary and 8 secondary meridians.
   Blockage of qi is thought to be manifested as tenderness on palpation. The
   insertion of acupuncture needles at specific points along the meridians is
   supposed to restore the proper flow of qi.

I hate to point out that the physiologic system I use, based on so-called
“Western scientific empiricism,” is also based on anatomy, chemistry,
biochemistry, histology etc. All based on physical structures that can be
isolated and examined.

Meridians and qi blockage is based on what? Nothing. Meridians and qi do not
exist. Here is the NEJM offering up, complete with a picture, the idea of
meridians and qi as if they are a meaningful construct. Next up in the NEJM will
be:

   Traditional European medicine espouses an ancient physiological system
   (not based on Western scientific empiricism) in which health is seen as the
   result of harmony among bodily functions and between body and nature.
   Internal disharmony is believed to cause blockage of the body’s vital energy,
   known as humors: black bile, yellow bile, phlegm, and blood which flows in
   the body. Blockage of humors is thought to be manifested as illness. Bleeding
   and purging is supposed to restore the proper flow of balance of humors.

If anyone sees a conceptual difference between the two paragraphs, let the
editors of the NEJM know after they accept my review on therapeutic bleeding.
Being published in the NEJM is the medical equivalent of being on the cover of
the Rolling Stone, and I think I have my opportunity.

   Efforts have been made to characterize the effects of acupuncture in
   terms of the established principles of medical physiology on which Western
   medicine is based.

Why? Isn’t an ancient physiological system enough upon which to base a
therapeutic intervention?

   These efforts remain inconclusive, for several reasons. First, the
   majority of studies have been conducted in animals, and it is difficult to
   relate findings from such studies to effects in humans. Second, acupuncture
   has been shown to activate peripheral-nerve fibers of all sizes, rendering a 
   systematic study of responses complex. Third, the acupuncture experience is
   dominated by a strong psychosocial context, including expectations, beliefs, 
   and the therapeutic milieu.

And fourth, having no basis in reality, acupuncture can’t work any more than
homeopathy or reiki. It is tooth fairy science, published in the NEJM.

Then they delve into the physiology of acupuncture and the basic science
studies. Fine. You stick people with needles, you will get a variety of
physiologic responses, both locally and in the brain. The question is whether
these effects are specific to acupuncture or nonspecific results of poking
people with a sharp object. Like all acupuncture apologists, they lack a certain
precision in what they consider acupuncture, and offer electroacupuncture as
evidence.

   In the rat, electroacupuncture has been shown to induce pituitary
   secretion of adrenocorticotropic hormone and cortisol, leading to systemic
   antiinflammatory effects.

Ah yes, electroacupuncture. I remember when they discovered those ancient
Chinese Duracell’s and alligator clips that allowed the Chinese to shock their
patients.

I quote from the electroacupuncture article, referenced above:

   While the EA frequency was held constant, intensity was adjusted slowly
   over the period of approximately 2 min to the designated level of 3 mA, which
   is the maximum EA current intensity that a conscious animal can tolerate.
   Mild muscle twitching was observed… For sham treatment control, acupuncture
   needles were inserted bilaterally into GB30 without electrical stimulation or
   manual needle manipulation.

And when shocked, the rabbits released ACTH and cortisol, as any animal would if
electrocuted. Release of ACTH and cortisol is part of the response to stress. I
can just see the poor rat, “placed under an inverted clear plastic chamber” for
observation saying,” don’t tase me bro, don’t tase me bro.” Wait. It’s not a
taser. It’s a projectile electroacupuncture remote deliver system, and if I use 
it on you, you are going to release some cortisol and ACTH as well, bro.

Did the NEJM editors look at the references? They seriously need some new
reviewers.

But I will grant them that sticking needles in people has physiologic effects
and shocking a rat makes it squirt cortisol.

However, acupuncture is about putting needles in specific sites. In the animal
models and human studies they attempt to needle specific sites that correlate
with treating a disease. Most acupuncture studies use the traditional sites
associated with whatever illness they are not really treating; acupuncture is
about putting the needle just so.

The basic science concerns, as I read it, the effects of needling people. If you
are going to recommend acupuncture, and they will, then you need to justify the
use of needles in specific sites by people trained in acupuncture, and the
literature doesn’t support that. It doesn’t matter where you put the needles, or
even if you use needles at all, as we have mentioned, since twirling a
toothpick has better effects on knee pain than needling. And I will ask again:
whose style of acupuncture are you going to use? Ear, tongue, foot, Japanese or 
German or Chinese?

Then they move on to the clinical trials and my gaster is flabbered.

   … real acupuncture treatments were no more effective than sham
   acupuncture treatments. There was nevertheless evidence that both real
   acupuncture and sham acupuncture were more effective than no treatment and
   that acupuncture can be a useful supplement to other forms of conventional
   therapy for low back pain.

Lets take a trip back in time.

There was procedure for the treatment of angina where they ligated the internal 
mammary artery. The theory was that by tying off the artery the back-pressure
forced blood down the coronary arteries and relieved cardiac pain.

Angina improved and there are about 40 plus papers in the 50s and 60s on the
benefit of the procedure as well as the underlying physiology of the procedure. 
Mammary artery ligation ‘worked’ and was popular in the early 60s. Until the
procedure was compared to a sham operation. That’s right. They opened people up 
and did nothing.

The result?

   The combined results of two RCTs comparing an earlier surgical procedure 
   for angina — bilateral internal mammary artery ligation (BIMAL) — to a sham
   surgery clearly show that patients “experienced significant subjective
   improvement,” with both BIMAL (67% substantial improvement) and the sham
   procedure (82% substantial improvement). [see Moerman, Meaning, Medicine and 
   the “Placebo Effect”, 2002]

So how would you interpret the study? If a procedure is equal sham, then I would
say the procedure does not work. In the case of sham surgery, no underlying
change occurred in the blood supply to the ischemic heart. This study is perhaps
the classic clinical trial that demonstrates the difficulty in assessing the
results of an intervention for pain. Patients had significant improvement in
their angina. Much better than doing nothing (although these studies did not
have a ‘usual care’ wing), 2/3 of angina patients do not get significant
improvement on their own.

And guess what? Open heart surgery “has been shown to induce pituitary secretion
of adrenocorticotropic hormone and cortisol, leading to systemic
antiinflammatory effects.” Surgery releases endogenous opioids and I bet it
actives both peripheral and central pain fibers.

Hmmmm. Looks like we have a justification for going back to treating angina with
internal mammary artery ligation.

The authors of the review justify the recommendation on the two studies that
demonstrate the equivalence of sham acupuncture and real acupuncture in treating
low back pain, the same number of studies for mammary artery ligation.

Now being an article on back pain, they did not include the article that showed 
knee pain treated with sham acupuncture (in this case twirling tooth picks on
the skin) is superior to real acupuncture. It matters not where the needles are 
placed or even if needles are used.

So far the authors provide no historical scientific plausibility, non-specific
modern pathophysiology, a bit of gratuitous rabbit torture, and two clinical
trials that demonstrate no efficacy of acupuncture over placebo. Their level of 
justification reaches that of mammary artery ligation. I start to wonder if the 
NEJM editors actually read the review before publishing it. The authors then
move on to clinical use.

   (Acupuncture) not been established to be superior to sham acupuncture for
   the relief of symptoms of low back pain [translation: it doesn’t work]. As a
   result, it is not often regarded as the first choice of therapy
   [translation: clinicians do not like to use ineffective therapy].

   However, since extensive clinical trials [er, since when did two become
   extensive? Are the authors even reading the manuscript?] have suggested that 
   acupuncture may be more effective than usual care, it is not unreasonable to 
   consider acupuncture before [you mean as first line therapy? when it doesn’t 
   work?] or together with conventional treatments, such as physical therapy,
   pain medication, and exercise [adding nothing to something does not increase 
   the net effect].

That is some interesting sentence structure, worthy of Animal Farm: even though 
acupuncture doesn’t work, and isn’t first line therapy for pain, it should be
used for first line therapy. Although the qualifiers ‘not been established,’
‘suggested’, ‘may be,’ and ‘not unreasonable’ muddy the water with their
density.

   Acupuncture is a regulated discipline, and patients should be referred
   only to practitioners who are licensed by the state in which they practice.

Why? It’s like Duck’s Breath Mystery Theatre’s Dr. Science. A license to
practice ineffective nonsense still results in ineffective nonsense.

   In the traditional practice of acupuncture, needle insertion itself may
   be accompanied by a variety of ancillary procedures, including palpation of
   the radial artery and other areas of the body, examination of the tongue, and
   recommendation of herbal medications. All of these steps are based on the
   application of principles of traditional Chinese medicine, as opposed to
   Western physiological and medical concepts. To what extent such procedures
   may contribute to the psychological milieu of acupuncture is unknown, and
   only a few studies have examined the context in which acupuncture treatment
   is delivered.

Note, it is not that radial artery palpation and tongue examination increase the
diagnostic accuracy, it is to contribute to the psychological milieu. Like a
psychic talking to your dead parent, it is important to make the environment
conducive to fooling the patient into believing that an actual effect is
occurring.

Take the pulse. In TCM they are not looking for tachycardia, but imaginary
diseases based on imaginary diagnosis. An example:

   Each pulse position can reflect different phenomena in different
   situations. For example, in a state of health, the left middle pulse (Liver) 
   will be relatively soft and smooth, neither superficial nor deep. Therefore, 
   we can say the liver and gall bladder energies are balanced or that the Yin
   and Yang within the Liver/Gall Bladder sphere are balanced. If a patient is
   experiencing migraine headaches and her pulse feels wiry (harder or tighter
   than normal) and more superficial and pounding, then we may diagnose this as 
   Excessive Liver Fire (Yang) Rising (up the Gall Bladder channel to the head).
   The pulse reflects the rising energy.”

Or tongue examination, which is another example of prescientific nonsense where 
the body is represented on the tongue.

The editors of the NEJM seem to think this is reasonable, worthy of unqualified 
discussion. Of course, there is no reference to demonstrate that these additions
increase diagnostic or therapeutic accuracy.

   The practitioner may further stimulate the needle with electrical current
   (electroacupuncture), moxibustion (burning the herb artemisia vulgaris at
   the end of the acupuncture needle), or heat.

Why? No data given that this nonsense increases efficacy. I keep telling myself 
this is the NEJM, adding their imprimatur to the respectability of burning a
plant on top a needle stuck in the skin to ease chronic pain. Then they note
that patients need multiple treatments, a minimum of 12, with boosters, and they
need to come in to prophylactically keep their spine aligned — no wait, the
last is what chiropractors do. It seems, at 65 to 125 dollars a pop, that
acupuncturists have recognized the financial wisdom of D.D. Palmer’s
descendants. The NEJM is suggesting that people pay around 1200 bucks for what
is, at best, a placebo.

The authors go on to the adverse effects. “8.6% reported at least one adverse
event, and 2.2% reported one that required treatment.” Pretty impressive
complication rate for an expensive, ineffective therapy! They do not mention
that in the acupuncture/toothpick for knee pain study, toothpicks had the same
effect as acupuncture and zero side effects, nor do they mention the
well-reported cases of infection from sloppy aseptic technique.

I will ask you. If you have two procedures of equal efficacy and one has zero
side effects, are you not ethically bound to suggest the procedure with no
complications? If you are going to suggest acupuncture, ethically you have to
offer sham acupuncture with twirled toothpicks, especially when what you offer
is no better than a placebo effect.

Then, in the areas of uncertainty section of the review, they note that the
effects of acupuncture are mostly explained by elaborate placebo effects.
Benefit from acupuncture is

   mostly attributable to contextual and psychosocial factors, such as
   patients’ beliefs and expectations, attention from the acupuncturist, and
   highly focused, spatially directed attention on the part of the patient.
   These studies also seem to indicate that needles do not need to stimulate the
   traditionally identified acupuncture points or actually penetrate the skin
   to produce the anticipated effect.

It does nothing, and you do not need to do acupuncture to get the effect.
Acupuncture has complications and ethically can one recommend and charge for an 
elaborate placebo? I do not think so. Not the authors.

   The patient in the vignette has chronic back pain that has not responded 
   to a number of medical treatments.

So instead, we will go with the unethical, expensive, useless placebo.

   He has specifically requested a referral for acupuncture, and we would
   suggest a course of 10 to 12 treatments over a period of 8 weeks from a
   licensed acupuncturist or a physician trained in medical acupuncture.

Can you believe this? From the NEJM! Such total tripe. I rely on the NEJM to
provide reviews of relevant medical topics as, outside of ID and quackery, I do 
not have the time to read the primary literature. If this is the best NEJM can
do on a topic upon which I have some background, then I suppose I cannot trust
them in the future. As I tell my kids, you can judge a person by the company
they keep.

The NEJM has lost some of its credibility. I doubt they will ever get it back.

  Credulity about acupuncture infiltrates the New England Journal of Medicine

                                  David Gorski

                                      Link

One of the things that disturbs me the most about where medicine is going is the
infiltration of quackery into academic medicine. So prevalent is this
unfortunate phenomenon that Doctor RW even coined a truly apt term for it:
Quackademic medicine. In essence, pseudoscientific and even prescientific ideas 
are rapidly being “integrated” with science-based medicine, or, as I tend to
view it, quackery is being “integrated” with scientific medicine, to the gradual
erosion of scientific standards in medicine. No quackery is too quacky, it
seems. Even homeopathy and naturopathy can seemingly find their way into
academic medical centers.

Probably the most common form of pseudoscience to wend its way into what should 
be bastions of scientific medicine is acupuncture. Harvard, Stanford, Yale, M.
D. Anderson, and many others, they’ve all fallen under the sway of the idea that
somehow sticking thin little needles into points that bear no relationship to
any known anatomic structure and that supposedly “unblock” the flow of some sort
of “life energy” that can’t be detected by any means that science has. Most
recently, as I described, studies that seek to “prove that acupuncture works”
have found their way into high quality, high impact journals whose editors
should know better but apparently can’t recognize that the evidence in the study
doesn’t actually show what the authors claim it shows. Even so, there are some 
journals that I didn’t expect to see this sort of infiltration of quackademic
medicine. Granted, I never expected it to show itself in one of the Nature
journals, as it did in the study I just mentioned. I also never expected it to
show up in that flagship of clinical journals, a journal that is one of the
highest impact and most read medical journals that exists. I’m talking the New
England Journal of Medicine, and, unfortunately, I’m also talking an
unfortunately credulous article from Dr. Brian M. Berman, who is the founder of 
the Center for Integrative Medicine, University of Maryland School of Medicine
and the holder of multiple NCCAM center grants, and other institutions, entitled
Acupuncture for Chronic Low Back Pain.

The article appeared under the section of the NEJM known as Clinical
Therapeutics. Articles published in this section begin:

   …with a case vignette that includes a therapeutic recommendation. A
   discussion of the clinical problem and the mechanism of benefit of this form 
   of therapy follows. Major clinical studies, the clinical use of this therapy,
   and potential adverse effects are reviewed. Relevant formal guidelines, if
   they exist, are presented. The article ends with the authors’ clinical
   recommendations.

And this is the clinical vignette:

   A 45-year-old construction worker with a 7-year history of intermittent
   low back pain is seen by his family physician. The pain has gradually
   increased over the past 4 months, despite pain medications, physical therapy,
   and two epidural corticosteroid injections. The pain is described as a dull 
   ache in the lumbosacral area with episodic aching in the posterior aspect of 
   both thighs; it worsens with prolonged standing and sitting. He is concerned 
   about losing his job, while at the same time worried that continuing to work 
   could cause further pain. The results of a neurologic examination and a
   straight-leg–raising test are normal. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) shows 
   evidence of moderate degenerative disk disease at the L4–L5 and L5–S1 levels 
   and a small midline disk herniation at L5–S1 without frank nerve impingement.
   The patient wonders whether acupuncture would be beneficial and asks for a
   referral to a licensed acupuncturist.

Berman et al begins with a simple discussion of low back pain, which, as he
correctly notes, is an incredibly common clinical problem. He also points out
that most of the really bad causes of low back pain (tumors, infection, or
inflammatory disorders) are seen relatively infrequently in common practice. The
most common cause of low back pain is the dreaded “I” or “N” word: idiopathic
or nonspecific, both of which basically mean that we don’t know what causes it. 
So far, fair enough. Berman et al even produce a fairly good discussion of the
pathophysiology of low back pain, including the role of the central nervous
system, behavioral elements, and musculoskeletal contributions, among others.
Then, unfortunately, the authors go off the deep end:

   Traditional Chinese medicine espouses an ancient physiological system
   (not based on Western scientific empiricism) in which health is seen as the
   result of harmony among bodily functions and between body and nature.
   Internal disharmony is believed to cause blockage of the body’s vital energy,
   known as qi, which flows along 12 primary and 8 secondary meridians (Figure 
   1). Blockage of qi is thought to be manifested as tenderness on palpation.
   The insertion of acupuncture needles at specific points along the meridians
   is supposed to restore the proper flow of qi.

They even include a figure of acupuncture points

It was at this point that I wondered whether I was reading the NEJM or a
quackademic medical journal such as the Journal of Alternative and Complementary
Medicine. Here was an actual discussion of qi as though it might actually exist
and as though meridians and qi were anything other than the result of
prescientific concepts about how the body works and disease develops. One
wonders if, for its next trick, the NEJM will publish Clinical Therapeutics
articles touting the wonders of the humoral theory of disease and how the four
humors must be balanced. Or maybe the miasma theory. That was a good one, and
quite in accord with the modern day obsession with contamination and
“detoxification.”

My expectation to see greater woo appearing in the NEJM notwithstanding, as most
CAM advocates do, Berman et al next try to justify acupuncture, starting with
the belief that it works and then working backwards to cherry pick studies that 
they believe to support the hypothesis that acupuncture works for low back pain 
as anything other than a placebo effect. They begin with several inconclusive
and conflicting animal studies, concluding by mentioning the study that I
blogged so extensively about two months ago without noting that it didn’t show
what the authors thought it showed, nor did it demonstrate that adenosine
mediates the effects of acupuncture. As I pointed out, what really irritated me 
about the adenosine study was that it was relatively interesting science but it 
was yoked into the service of trying to justify acupuncture with an animal model
that had very little to do with acupuncture.

Next, Berman et al decide to delve into the clinical evidence for acupuncture:

   A number of clinical trials have evaluated the efficacy of acupuncture
   for chronic low back pain. A meta-analysis in 2008, which involved a total of
   6359 patients,44 showed that real acupuncture treatments were no more
   effective than sham acupuncture treatments. There was nevertheless evidence
   that both real acupuncture and sham acupuncture were more effective than no
   treatment and that acupuncture can be a useful supplement to other forms of
   conventional therapy for low back pain.

At least Berman’s honest about this one in admitting that the meta-analysis
showed that real acupuncture is no more effective than sham acupuncture,
something that regular readers of this blog know. Then Berman tries to do what
acupuncture apologists do every time they encounter studies that show that
“true” acupuncture performs no better than the acupuncture control. Rather than 
simply admitting that acupuncture doesn’t work and that acupuncture effects are 
placebo effects, they try to spin the results by pointing out that both sham and
“real” acupuncture “work” and therefore are useful! In other words, they argue 
for placebo medicine without calling it placebo medicine. They then do it again 
for a German trial. Unfortunately for them, it’s a study in which, as is the
case with many acupuncture studies, the results didn’t mean what the authors
claimed they mean. Once again, Berman tries to represent the finding that sham
acupuncture was just as effective as “real” acupuncture. In any randomized
clinical trial of a conventional therapy, such a result would lead to the
conclusion that the therapy doesn’t work, but not in acupuncture. If both the
placebo control and the treatment are indistinguishable from each other, then
that means acupuncture must work.

The third study that Berman chooses is a so-called “pragmatic” trial. Basically,
it’s a mixed randomized trial with a non-randomized cohort. Let me quote one
small passage from the trial that demonstrates why it is an utterly useless
study:

   In this study, neither providers nor patients were blinded to treatment. 
   Therefore, a bias due to unblinding cannot be ruled out.

That’s putting it mildly. Basically, the study is utterly worthless because it
can’t account for the rather large placebo effect that is common in intervention
studies for back pain. In fact, it’s fairly amazing that the peer reviewers at 
the NEJM let that pass. Be that as it may, Berman et al next write an amazing
series of statements, beginning with:

   Acupuncture is considered to be a form of alternative or complementary
   medicine, and as noted above, it has not been established to be superior to
   sham acupuncture for the relief of symptoms of low back pain.

In other words, acupuncture does not work. Even so:

   However, since extensive clinical trials have suggested that acupuncture 
   may be more effective than usual care, it is not unreasonable to consider
   acupuncture before or together with conventional treatments, such as physical
   therapy, pain medication, and exercise. Many pain specialists incorporate
   acupuncture into a multidisciplinary approach to the management of chronic
   low back pain.

In other words, even though acupuncture does not work, we should use it anyway
because there are enough practitioners who believe it works and use it even
though extensive clinical trials have shown that acupuncture is no better than
sham acupuncture, and neither are better than placebo effects.

Even though:

   As noted above, the most recent well-powered clinical trials of
   acupuncture for chronic low back pain showed that sham acupuncture was as
   effective as real acupuncture. The simplest explanation of such findings is
   that the specific therapeutic effects of acupuncture, if present, are small, 
   whereas its clinically relevant benefits are mostly attributable to
   contextual and psychosocial factors, such as patients’ beliefs and
   expectations, attention from the acupuncturist, and highly focused, spatially
   directed attention on the part of the patient.34,65 These studies also seem 
   to indicate that needles do not need to stimulate the traditionally
   identified acupuncture points or actually penetrate the skin to produce the
   anticipated effect.

In other words, acupuncture does not work.

Let’s put it this way. Berman concedes that “true acupuncture” doesn’t work any 
better than sham acupuncture for low back pain. He concedes that it doesn’t
matter where you stick the needles. It makes no difference; the effect is the
same. He concedes that any perceived benefit from acupuncture in low back pain
is due to nonspecific factors, in particular psychosocial factors, patient’s
expectations, and the attention paid to the patient by the acupuncturist. What, 
I ask, do we call such a treatment, a treatment that is no better than placebo
control and whose efficacy depends on beliefs and expectations, attention from
the provider, and contextual factors.

We call it a placebo. A placebo.

That’s just what Berman is recommending to this patient in the clinical vignette
that started out this post, a placebo intervention. We can argue about whether 
it’s ever ethical to use a placebo intervention, particularly for conditions
that don’t respond well to conventional therapy and for which eschewing
conventional therapy probably won’t cause harm, but we should be honest about
the nature of the intervention. That’s the problem with CAM interventions like
acupuncture. Its practitioners and advocates don’t acknowledge that they are
placebos, and, whether they realize it or not, by failing to do so they are
deceiving patients. In fact, Berman’s recommendation that the patient go to a
licensed acupuncturist with “adequate training” doesn’t even jibe with his
findings in his review article. After all, if it doesn’t mater where you place
the needles, then it doesn’t matter if the acupuncturist is trained.

As Steve Novella points out, what Berman is doing in this article in the NEJM is
the same thing that CAM advocates in general and acupuncture apologists in
particular have a maddening tendency to do. They either cherry pick studies that
appear to indicate that their favored woo works. When, as Berman et al were,
they are forced to admit that well-designed studies with lots of patients show
that their woo is no better than a valid placebo control, they then shift to
embracing the placebo, to owning it, so to speak, all without actually calling
it placebo.

What I find so disturbing about this NEJM article is not so much that Berman et 
al pulled these usual CAM tricks. I expect that. I see it all the time in CAM
journals and sometimes in unsuspecting legitimate medical or scientific
journals. What I find so disturbing about this NEJM article is that the peer
reviewers did not spot the obvious CAM abuses of language designed to obscure
the fact that acupuncture is no better than placebo. The editors of the NEJM
should be ashamed of themselves. The peer reviewers who reviewed this article
should be ashamed of themselves. Those of us who rely on the NEJM for
evidence-based findings and assessments of various treatments should be afraid.

After all, if quackademic medicine can infiltrate the NEJM, there’s nowhere it
can’t go.

        Acupuncture Pseudoscience in the New England Journal of Medicine

                                 Steven Novella

                                      Link

Here is the conclusion quoted from a recent New England Journal of Medicine
(NEJM) review article on acupuncture for back pain:

   As noted above, the most recent wellpowered clinical trials of
   acupuncture for chronic low back pain showed that sham acupuncture was as
   effective as real acupuncture. The simplest explanation of such findings is
   that the specific therapeutic effects of acupuncture, if present, are small, 
   whereas its clinically relevant benefits are mostly attributable to
   contextual and psychosocial factors, such as patients’ beliefs and
   expectations, attention from the acupuncturist, and highly focused, spatially
   directed attention on the part of the patient.

Translation – acupuncture does not work. Why, then, are the same authors in the 
same paper recommending that acupuncture be used for chronic low back pain? This
is the insanity of the bizarro world of CAM (complementary and alternative
medicine). Yesterday David covered the same article, which I had also covered on
NeuroLogica, but we both thought this issue important enough to document our
thoughts and objections on SBM.

Let’s break down their conclusions a bit. They have reviewed the clinical
evidence, as I and others have done before, and found that when real acupuncture
is compared to various forms of sham acupuncture (the acupuncture version of a 
placebo) there is no difference. As I have written many times before – it
doesn’t matter where you stick the needles, or even if you stick the needles.
Reviews have also concluded that there is no evidence for the mere existence of 
acupuncture points. Since acupuncture consists of sticking needles in
acupuncture points, the only reasonable conclusion from this evidence is that
there is no specific effect from acupuncture – acupuncture does not work.

The phrase, “contextual and psychosocial factors, such as patients’ beliefs and 
expectations, attention from the acupuncturist, and highly focused, spatially
directed attention on the part of the patient.” is a fancy way of saying
“placebo effects.” In other words, there are some non-specific subjective
benefits to getting attention from a practitioner. There is this assumption,
however, that these benefits are real and worthwhile. However, they are likely
to be illusory – an artifact of observation and reporting, not a real
improvement in the patient’s condition. In real science-based medicine, that is 
the underlying assumption – placebo effects are largely illusory – a variable to
be controlled for.

But there has been recent controversy over the role of the placebo effect in
ethical and evidence-based practice. This is, in my opinion, largely a back door
attempt to justify CAM treatments that do not work. The claim is that placebo
effects are real and useful. But a systematic review of the placebo effect in
clinical trials concluded:

   We did not find that placebo interventions have important clinical
   effects in general. However, in certain settings placebo interventions can
   influence patient-reported outcomes, especially pain and nausea, though it is
   difficult to distinguish patient-reported effects of placebo from biased
   reporting. The effect on pain varied, even among trials with low risk of
   bias, from negligible to clinically important. Variations in the effect of
   placebo were partly explained by variations in how trials were conducted and 
   how patients were informed.

In other words – for any objective outcome, there is no important placebo
effect. For outcomes that are subjectively reported by patients, there is a
highly variable placebo effect. It is plausible that the expectation of benefit 
could result in the release of dopamine and endorphins and produce a
physiological decrease in pain, for example, in a subset of people, and there is
some evidence for this. But this is, at best, a transient symptomatic effect – 
not therapeutic.

Such effects are also non-specific – meaning they do not derive from the
intervention itself, but from the therapeutic ritual surrounding the
intervention. Even treatments that do not work may therefore provide these
non-specific benefits. My opinion is that the non-specific benefits of the
ritual of treatment should be combined with an actually effective treatment, not
magic pretending to be medicine. There are many reasons for this. One is the
ethics of patient autonomy and informed consent – giving a fake treatment to a
patient violates the patient’s rights, in my opinion.

Further, there is potential downstream harm from convincing patients that fake
magical treatments are effective, because of placebo effects. Then using obscure
language to hide the fact that the treatment actually does not work. This
distorts the public’s view of medicine, and of what works, and sets them up to
be victims of fake treatments when their ailment is not subjective or
self-limiting. In other words – refer them to an acupuncturists when they have
back pain and they may rely upon acupuncture, or some other non-scientific
intervention, when they have a more serious illness.

There is further harm caused by diverting research time, money, and other
resources from more fruitful lines of investigation in order to pursue a theory 
that has no basis in biology. There are thousands of published studies on
acupuncture – given the negative results of this research most of this has been 
a waste of time and resources.

The authors of this article recommend:

   He has specifically requested a referral for acupuncture, and we would
   suggest a course of 10 to 12 treatments over a period of 8 weeks from a
   licensed acupuncturist or a physician trained in medical acupuncture.

This contradicts their own conclusions. Why is training in acupuncture
necessary? That training largely consists of identifying acupuncture points,
knowing which points to use on an individual patient, and knowing the technique 
of needle insertion – but none of these things matter. The sham ritual is all
that matters – you can literally fake it and get the same response. I bet a 10
minute video is all that is necessary. In fact I bet even that is not necessary 
– you could probably fake it well enough to get a maximum placebo effect without
any prior demonstration.

What the authors of this article have done is something that is increasingly
common in CAM (when it is trying to infiltrate academia and peer-reviewed
journals like the NEJM) – reviewing the evidence, admitting that the CAM
treatment does not work, then making an elaborate and misleading appeal to
placebo effects, and ending with a recommendation to use the treatment that does
not work. Specifically, they not only recommend using the treatment, but in its
fullest magical form, complete with all the disproven claims (that is what
“medical acupuncture” is). It’s a bait and switch con game, nothing more. Come
for the placebo effect, then be treated with magical nonsense.

American Family Physician Endorses Acupuncture

A CME article in American Family Physician misrepresents the evidence, claiming 
acupuncture has been proven safe and effective. An accompanying editorial gives 
despicable advice on how to manipulate patients to accept this theatrical
placebo.

Harriet Hall on July 30, 2019

Link



The flagship journal of my specialty of family medicine is the American Family
Physician. Each issue contains a quiz that qualifies for continuing medical
education credit (CME). I have long relied on it to keep me up to date, and its 
information is generally trustworthy. So far it has not promoted alternative
medicine, but there have been occasional lapses. I have written several letters 
to the editor, two of which were published and are listed in PubMed, on the GAIT
trial of glucosamine and chondroitin and on the poor evidence for green tea. In
both cases, the authors replied, made excuses, and failed to adequately address
the points I raised; so I wonder if my letters did more harm than good.

My heart sank when I saw that the current issue (July 15, 2019) featured an
article on Acupuncture for Pain. It annoyed me enough that I felt compelled to
try again. I wrote a letter to the editor, but I will not be surprised if they
decide not to publish it. Standing up for rigorous science and reason is not
popular, and many MDs lack an understanding of the many ways studies can produce
false results. They may think any positive study is good “evidence”. I think
that’s what happened here. The authors found plenty of evidence to confirm their
belief that acupuncture is effective for pain. They failed to appreciate that
much of that positive evidence was flawed. They didn’t seek out negative
evidence that contradicted their beliefs. They said acupuncture was safe and
effective. And AFP compounded the error with an editorial in the same issue on
Integrating Medical Acupuncture into Family Medicine Practice that discusses
strategies for convincing doctors and patients that acupuncture is effective and
recommends family physicians be trained in it.

The evidence described in the article

They describe measurable effects on the nervous system like functional magnetic 
resonance imaging and the release of endogenous opioids. They do not mention
that similar findings are seen with placebo responses. They say the mechanism of
action is “likely not completely known”. In my opinion, it is known: it’s
called the placebo response.

They explain that acupuncture research is problematic due to the difficulty of
credible blinding and the heterogeneity of acupuncture practices. They admit
“most of the evidence is low or moderate quality”. But they go on to cite low
quality evidence for low back pain, knee osteoarthritis, headaches, neck pain,
fibromyalgia, and post-operative pain (although they do mention that most of
those studies are small and at risk of bias).

They cite studies showing that acupuncture is safe. They say no serious events
such as hospital admission, permanent disability, or death have occurred. That’s
demonstrably false. Several deaths have been reported in the literature, as
have hospitalizations to treat pneumothorax and to surgically remove acupuncture
needles that have migrated and caused complications like cardiac tamponade.
They cite systematic reviews that support their thesis but fail to cite Edzard
Ernst’s systematic review of systematic reviews that found a mix of negative,
positive, and inconclusive results and found only one case where more than one
systematic review reached a positive conclusion. For neck pain. Is there any
other pain treatment that works for pain in the neck but not in any other part
of the body?

They conclude that acupuncture may “work” only because of “patient expectations,
the treatment ritual, the therapeutic interaction with the acupuncturist, and
other aspects of the placebo response”. They essentially agree with Colquhoun
and Novella that acupuncture is a theatrical placebo. And they cite the asthma
study where patients had subjective but not objective improvements. Despite all 
this, they recommend acupuncture. Medical ethicists reject the use of placebos
in clinical practice as unethical.

In my opinion, the article is biased, incomplete, gives false information, and
is unethical. You can read the whole article online and form your own opinion.

The accompanying editorial recommends quack-speak

In my opinion, the editorial is despicable. It gives these examples of suggested
language designed to persuade patients:

  1. “I think acupuncture may help you. I’ve noticed in my own patients that it
    seems pretty beneficial. Eighty percent of my patients get better with
    acupuncture or have a positive response.”

  2. “There are more options available, but I recommend acupuncture. I use it on
    myself and my family to try to help with pain and discomfort.”

  3. “Acupuncture is ideal for avoiding adverse effects of medications and
    returning people to work without impairment.”

  4. “This is a treatment where we just try to center your thoughts around
    calmness.”

  5. “These are strong [acu-]points. These are more powerful points.”

  6. “The acupuncture treatment is going to help settle your body and your mind.”

  7. “If you get any response, that’s good. Eventually, I want to get you spaced
    out to three to four months, so you’re coming in for a maintenance
    treatment.”

  8. “Acupuncture is like unlocking a door. To unlock a locked door, first you have
    to pick up the key. That’s your first appointment. Then you have to
    actually move toward the door, and that’s your second treatment. You have to
    put the key in the door. That’s your third treatment. Turn it, fourth; turn
    the handle, fifth; open the door, sixth; walk through, seventh. That’s how 
    acupuncture works—you’re not going to see one treatment be a miracle. It’s a
    stepwise process.”

  9. “You’ve been out of balance for awhile, and it feels uncomfortable to try and 
    push you back into that equilibrium. That’s okay if you feel bad for the
    first couple of days. It will get better. Any kind of a change is a good
    sign, because it means that we did something to activate that and to improve
    that.”

Does all that sound familiar? It should. It is not the language of science. It
could have been taken directly from the playbooks of many a quack and charlatan.

Conclusion: AFP erred

The AFP is wrong. Acupuncture is a theatrical placebo. It is not supported by
good evidence. Any apparent improvements are subjective rather than objective;
they are small in magnitude and not clinically significant. Acupuncture is not
entirely safe; it can cause serious complications and even deaths. Placebos, by 
definition, may “please” the patient, but it is unethical to prescribe them. And
a placebo treatment that has no objective benefits and risks killing patients
or putting them in the hospital has a particularly unacceptable risk/benefit
ratio. There is no scientific justification for using acupuncture in clinical
practice.

AAFP Promotes Acupuncture

The AAFP is not following its own standards for CME. Its monograph on
Musculoskeletal Therapies devotes 1/4 of its content to acupuncture, dry
needling, and cupping; and one of its four “key practice recommendations” is to 
consider electroacupuncture for fibromyalgia.

Harriet Hall on October 9, 2018

Link



Jann Bellamy recently wrote about the American Academy of Family Physicians
(AAFP) and their policy on approved content for continuing medical education
(CME) activities. The AAFP said, “given the current lack of evidence, the COCPD 
does not deem it appropriate to learn how to practice functional medicine or
implement related techniques within an AAFP-certified CME activity.”

Moreover, they said:

   The AAFP Credit System strives to certify CME that is evidence-based,
   objective and balanced, which means benefits have been proven and all
   possible risks, side effects and negative outcomes should be acknowledged.
   Ideally, CME includes fair, balanced consideration of all usual and customary
   approaches and not only the approach preferred by the CME provider.

Not practicing what it preaches

The AAFP speaks with forked tongue. Their own CME program is far from fair and
balanced. It promotes acupuncture, dry needling, cupping, and referral to
alternative practitioners.

For many years, the AAFP has offered a CME program called FP Essentials, for
which they award 60 CME credits a year. Every month, they publish a monograph on
a topic important to family physicians. I have subscribed for as long as I can 
remember, and I thought I could rely on it to keep me up-to-date with
evidence-based information. I can no longer trust it. In their recent monograph 
on Musculoskeletal Therapies, there is a whole section (constituting a whopping 
1/4 of the material presented) devoted to acupuncture, dry needling, and
cupping! One-fourth of what they think family physicians should know about
treating musculoskeletal conditions is non-evidence-based alternative medicine. 
This is not acceptable.

Their concept of evidence-based medicine is exactly the kind of thing that led
us to establish the Science-Based Medicine blog. They are willing to accept any 
published studies at face value without considering prior plausibility and
without recognizing the factors that so often lead to false conclusions in
alternative medicine research.

Acupuncture

They recommend acupuncture as first-line therapy for chronic back pain. They say
there is evidence that it may benefit neck pain, lateral elbow pain, peripheral
joint osteoarthritis, shoulder pain, and fibromyalgia. They say, “acupuncture
consistently has been shown to be more effective than no treatment.” They seem
not to understand that doing anything will appear more effective than no
treatment, and that studies comparing acupuncture to no treatment are useless.

A truly fair, balanced consideration of all the evidence on acupuncture led
David Colquhoun and Steven Novella to conclude that acupuncture is a theatrical 
placebo. What’s more, its effect on pain is questionable. Edzard Ernst et al.
did a systematic review of systematic reviews of acupuncture for pain. They
found 57 systematic reviews; the results were a mix of negative, positive, and
inconclusive results. There were only four conditions for which more than one
systematic review reached the same conclusions, and in only one of the four did 
they agree on a positive conclusion (neck pain). (Think about this: If
acupuncture worked well for pain, wouldn’t the results be more consistent, and
wouldn’t it work for pain in all parts of the body rather than just in the
neck?) They explained how inconsistencies, biases, conflicting conclusions, and 
recent high quality studies throw doubt on even the most positive reviews.

They also demolished the “acupuncture is harmless” myth by reporting 95
published cases of serious adverse effects including infection, pneumothorax,
and five deaths. Admittedly some but not all of these might have been avoided by
better training in anatomy and infection control.

The AAFP monograph provides many references to acupuncture studies, but it is
apparent that they are cherry-picking. Colquhoun and Novella’s articles and
Edzard Ernst’s review of reviews are conspicuously absent.

Assuming acupuncture works and trying to explain how it works

The AAFP monograph describes several hypothetical mechanisms of action. It says 
it was originally believed to work by manipulating the life force “qi” at
acupuncture points along meridians. It doesn’t question that explanation. It
doesn’t point out that qi, acupoints and meridians are mythical concepts from a 
prescientific era. It says there is some evidence that acupoints have a discrete
histologic architecture with a corresponding high electrical conductivity
capacity. It also mentions the gate theory of pain, endogenous endorphin release
(Note: this also occurs with placebos, and they acknowledge that it is an
unsatisfactory explanation because the pain relief lasts longer than the
endorphin half-life), and the connective tissue theory. It says, “The connective
tissue theory uses the ancient concept of meridians” – with no comment about
the validity of that concept. It claims that the neurotransmitter theory may
explain the effects of acupuncture on conditions such as depression, anxiety,
and substance abuse. (What effects? Systematic reviews are negative.) It
mentions that “placebo effects also may be involved”, but It doesn’t acknowledge
that placebo could be the sole mechanism and that all the published evidence is
compatible with the hypothesis that acupuncture is a theatrical placebo.

Describing the published evidence

It describes the published evidence for acupuncture for low back pain, neck
pain, lateral elbow pain, peripheral joint osteoarthritis, shoulder pain, and
fibromyalgia. It admits that most of the trials it cites are low quality,
insufficient evidence, inconclusive, sometimes negative, or not clinically
significant. One wonders why it bothered to cite them.

It doesn’t differentiate between studies of traditional acupuncture and variants
like electroacupuncture and ear acupuncture. It does mention that the
fibromyalgia study was for electroacupuncture, and it concluded, “Thus,
electroacupuncture should be considered for patients with fibromyalgia.” In
fact, that recommendation is one of the four Key Practice Recommendations listed
at the beginning of the monograph.

Dry needling

After covering acupuncture, the monograph goes on to discuss dry needling. Mark 
Crislip reviewed dry needling for us a couple of years ago. He stressed that it 
had nothing to do with acupuncture. He was not impressed by the published
evidence; in fact, one of the systematic reviews he found showed that the
placebo was more effective than the dry needling! The monograph chose to cite
another, more positive review showing that dry needling was more effective than 
no treatment but not more effective than traditional management, with risk of
bias and little evidence of long-term benefit. They call this “low- to
moderate-quality evidence”. Whaaat?

Cupping

The monograph says cupping produces hematomas (in other words, it deliberately
injures the skin) and carries a risk of infection. Cupping is theorized to
“increase circulation to resolve stagnant blood and lymph, which is thought to
be a source of pathology”. (A source my pathology course in medical school
failed to mention.) It describes the literature as “conflicting in terms of
evidence of efficacy”. It acknowledges that good research is difficult due to
the variety of practices and the impossibility of blinding. Since there is a
lack of good evidence, why does it devote six paragraphs to cupping in a
monograph about all musculoskeletal therapies? It could have just explained what
cupping is and said there is no good evidence; two sentences would have been
sufficient.

Issues to consider

Under this heading, it comments that patients who expect these “integrative”
practices to work will report benefit even with sham procedures. It wonders
whether skeptics will respond. It compares rates of acceptance by various groups
(women, people of Asian descent, etc.) and reports the reasons patients give
for choosing acupuncture: “The holistic and collaborative nature of treatment”. 
It mentions that acupuncture sessions can cost up to $200 and that insurance may
not pay.

Referral guidelines

It provides guidelines for referring patients for integrative and alternative
medicine therapies. It starts by saying there doesn’t appear to be increased
liability for doctors to refer patients for these services. Think about that.
Can you imagine commenting on liability in a discussion about referral to an
orthopedic surgeon or other reputable practitioner? It says the referring doctor
should ensure that the integrative practitioner is trained, licensed, and has
malpractice insurance (!). Referral documents should include diagnosis, previous
and ongoing treatments, and goals of therapy. The alternative treatment should 
have a favorable risk to benefit ratio compared to other treatments for the same
conditions. It should be based on a reasonable expectation of favorable outcome
and be based on the expectation that it will offer greater benefits than no
treatment (but as I pointed out, any treatment will offer greater placebo
benefits than no treatment). The thought process leading to the referral should 
be documented in the medical record, and the referring physician is required to 
monitor the results of treatment.

It describes how the physician can get training in these modalities. “Using the 
learned skill set will depend on the clinician’s practice environment.”

Conclusion: A betrayal

In response to Jann Bellamy’s article, one of our commenters said, “There are
plenty of CAM methods that are safe, while also having enough supporters to have
tentative credibility with the public. The public mostly doesn’t care too much 
about the science.” I’m sure this is true, but the AAFP should care about the
science. And the AAFP’s members should care whether the AAFP maintains its
reputation as a reliable source of the best science-based medical information.

Another commenter said, “Sugar pills and saline injections have also been
consistently shown to be more effective than no treatment. Should we bring those
back too?”

There is an obvious disconnect between what the AAFP says are its standards for 
CME and the CME it actually offers. I feel angry and betrayed by my own
professional organization, an organization that I was once proud to belong to.

                            AFP Promotes Acupuncture

                                 Harriet Hall 

                                      Link

I subscribe to American Family Physician, the peer-reviewed journal of the
American Academy of Family Physicians. It emphasizes evidence-based medicine and
most articles include a table showing strength of evidence ratings for key
recommendations for practice. Lately, its scientific rigor has been slipping. I 
have complained to the editor about several articles whose recommendations were 
not based on the best science, and I have been consistently ignored. 

Acupuncture for Chronic Low Back Pain 

A recent article on chronic low back pain recommended acupuncture and gave it an
“A” rating corresponding to “consistent, good-quality patient-oriented
evidence.” I wrote the following letter to the editor and to the author of the
article: 

   In the recent article on chronic low back pain
   http://www.aafp.org/afp/20090615/1067.html I was very disturbed to see
   acupuncture listed as beneficial with an evidence rating of “A.” That rating 
   was supported by 4 references:

   Reference 2 (Chou et al.), consisted of practice guidelines recommendations
   that lumped acupuncture with other nonpharmacologic interventions (intensive 
   interdisciplinary rehabilitation, exercise therapy, acupuncture, massage
   therapy, spinal manipulation, yoga, cognitive-behavioral therapy, or
   progressive relaxation).” And labeled all of these as a “weak recommendation,
   moderate-quality evidence.”

   Reference 22 (Sherman et al.) addressed current practices but did not comment
   on the efficacy of acupuncture.

   Reference 23 (Furlan et al.) was a Cochrane review showing no evidence that
   acupuncture is effective for acute low back pain and commenting that the
   studies indicating its effectiveness in chronic low back pain were of “lower 
   methodologic quality.”

   Reference 24 (Witt et al.) only showed that adding acupuncture to routine
   care improved outcome and was cost-effective: it did not assess the
   effectiveness of acupuncture as a stand-alone treatment.

   In contrast, this recent systematic analysis
   http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19250001?ordinalpos=7&itool=EntrezSystem2.
   PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DefaultReportPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum 
   showed that true acupuncture is no more effective than sham acupuncture.
   Numerous studies with a retractable sham acupuncture needle (like a stage
   dagger) have shown that the sham procedure is equally effective (and at least
   in one study the sham procedure was more effective). Even toothpicks seem to
   work! http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,1897636,00.html

   This study
   http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19433697?ordinalpos=3&itool=EntrezSystem2.
   PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DefaultReportPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum 
   showed that it doesn’t matter where you put the needle or whether you
   penetrate the skin and commented “These findings raise questions about
   acupuncture’s purported mechanisms of action. It remains unclear whether
   acupuncture or our simulated method of acupuncture provide physiologically
   important stimulation or represent placebo or nonspecific effects.”

   Acupuncture studies are all less than ideal in that double-blinding is
   impossible: the acupuncturist always knows whether he is administering a sham
   treatment.

   Some studies have suggested that acupuncture releases endorphins in the
   brain, but studies also show that placebos elicit endorphin release.

   All this evidence is compatible with the hypothesis that acupuncture is
   nothing more than an elaborate placebo.

   If we had similar evidence that an analgesic drug was no better than a sham
   drug (a sugar pill), you would not be recommending it. How can you justify
   recommending acupuncture? How can you justify an “A” evidence rating?

I received no response from either the editor or the author. 

Acupuncture for Pain 

The current issue features an article “Acupuncture for Pain”  by Robert B.
Kelly, a family physician who is associate director of a family medicine
residency program and associate professor at Case Western Reserve University
School of Medicine. He is also a member of the American Academy of Medical
Acupuncture and a diplomate of the American Board of Medical Acupuncture. In the
“author disclosures” this was not listed as a conflict of interest, but it
should have been. 

The article claims

   Based on published evidence, acupuncture is most likely to benefit patients
   with low back pain, neck pain, chronic idiopathic or tension headache,
   migraine, and knee osteoarthritis. Promising but less definitive data exist
   for shoulder pain, fibromyalgia, temporomandibular joint pain and
   postoperative pain.

It assigns “A” strength of evidence ratings (consistent good-quality
patient-oriented evidence) to acupuncture for low back pain, neck pain, headache
(chronic idiopathic), and headache (migraine). It assigns “B” ratings
(inconsistent or limited quality patient-oriented evidence) to acupuncture for
shoulder pain, knee osteoarthritis, fibromyalgia, temporomandibular joint pain, 
and postoperative pain. Note the inconsistency: knee osteoarthritis is listed
among the conditions “most likely to benefit” but then is given only a “B”
rating. 

It presents a biased picture of the published research.  For chronic low back
pain, it cites these studies: 

  1. A systematic review of RCTs that found “There is moderate evidence that
    acupuncture is more effective than no treatment, and strong evidence of no
    significant difference between acupuncture and sham acupuncture, for
    short-term pain relief.” In other words, acupuncture is no better than
    placebo, and using a placebo is better than doing nothing.

  2. A randomized controlled trial showing that acupuncture was better than no
    treatment, but that the control (superficial needling at non-acupuncture
    points) was equally effective. In other words, acupuncture was no better
    than their placebo control.

  3. A randomized controlled trial that concluded “Effectiveness of acupuncture,
    either verum or sham, was almost twice that of conventional therapy.” There 
    was no significant difference between “verum” acupuncture and the sham
    (placebo).

  4. A pragmatic randomized trial that compared usual care to acupuncture. There
    was no attempt to control for possible placebo effects with a sham
    acupuncture control.

  5. A pragmatic randomized trial that compared routine care with or without
    acupuncture. There was no attempt to control for possible placebo effects.

  6. A Cochrane review that concluded  “The data do not allow firm conclusions
    about the effectiveness of acupuncture for acute low-back pain. For chronic 
    low-back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and functional 
    improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after treatment 
    and in the short-term only. Acupuncture is not more effective than other
    conventional and “alternative” treatments. The data suggest that acupuncture
    and dry-needling may be useful adjuncts to other therapies for chronic
    low-back pain. Because most of the studies were of lower methodological
    quality, there certainly is a further need for higher quality trials in this
    area.”

  7. A meta-analysis that concluded “Acupuncture effectively relieves chronic low
    back pain. No evidence suggests that acupuncture is more effective than
    other active therapies.” 

It does not cite these studies: 

  1. A systematic review of RCTs that concluded “There is moderate evidence that
    acupuncture is more effective than no treatment, and strong evidence of no
    significant difference between acupuncture and sham acupuncture, for
    short-term pain relief.” No significant difference between acupuncture and
    sham acupuncture means acupuncture is not better than placebo.

  2. A Cochrane review that concluded  “The evidence summarised in this systematic 
    review does not indicate that acupuncture is effective for the treatment of 
    back pain.”

  3. A systematic review of RCTs that concluded:   “Because this systematic review 
    did not clearly indicate that acupuncture is effective in the management of 
    back pain, the authors would not recommend acupuncture as a regular
    treatment for patients with low back pain.”  

It does not cite the other studies I cited in my letter showing that acupuncture
is no better than placebo and that it makes no difference where you put the
needle or even whether you use a needle (toothpicks and retractable needles are 
equally effective).  

Other Kinds of Pain 

Kelly says “A systematic review on temporomandibular joint (TMJ) pain concluded 
that acupuncture significantly improved symptoms.” 

That’s not exactly what the review said. Its conclusion was: 

   Overall, their results suggest that acupuncture might be an effective therapy
   for temporomandibular joint dysfunction. However, none of the studies was
   designed to control for a placebo effect. CONCLUSION: Even though all studies
   are in accordance with the notion that acupuncture is effective for
   temporomandibular joint dysfunction, this hypothesis requires confirmation
   through more rigorous investigations. [emphasis added] 

He also discusses the use of acupuncture for other painful conditions including 
neck and shoulder pain, headache, and arthritis. The evidence he cites is
similarly unconvincing for those conditions. 

Excuses 

Kelly offers excuses and special pleading in an attempt to validate his
recommendations. He suggests that “Western scientific methods” like RCTs do not 
lend themselves to the study of individualized treatment based on such things as
pulse diagnosis, tongue diagnosis, herbal therapies, dietary modifications,
ear, hand, or scalp acupuncture in addition to or instead of body acupuncture.
He admits that there is no statistical difference between sham and actual
acupuncture, but he doesn’t acknowledge the implications of that fact. 

Acupuncturists believe in what they are doing. Personal experience, patient
gratitude, the natural course of illness, the placebo response and other factors
conspire to impair judgment. This makes it difficult for them to be as
objective as an outside observer.

This is a clear case of denial. To see why, substitute “drug” for acupuncture
and “sugar pill” for sham acupuncture. When a controlled study shows that your
treatment works no better than your placebo control, the only logical conclusion
is that the treatment is no better than placebo. Imagine a drug company saying 
“Our drug works and the placebo works too.” Neither the drug nor the placebo
would get past the FDA. 

There is only one science. The same standards apply to acupuncture as to drug
therapies. A placebo by any other name is still a placebo.   

It is sad to see a journal I respected depart from rigorous science-based
medicine and succumb to the CAM temptation, especially when it tries to justify 
its defection by misrepresenting the state of the evidence. It has been said
that there is no such thing as alternative medicine: there is only medicine that
works and medicine that doesn’t. When a treatment is shown to work, it is
adopted by mainstream medicine and is no longer “alternative.” Acupuncture
remains “alternative,” and even AFP recognizes that fact by listing this article
as one in a series on “Alternative and Complementary Medicine.”

Therapy or Injury? Your Tax Dollars at Work.

Harriet Hall on July 31, 2012

Link


The U.S. Army Medical Command recently announced a job opening  in the
Interdisciplinary Pain Management Center at the San Antonio Military Medical
Center at Fort Sam Houston, Texas. Two GS-12 positions were advertised for
acupuncturists at a salary of $68,809 to $89,450. As a licensed acupuncturist, a
candidate would be expected to

   offer a full array of the most current and emerging evidenced based
   approaches in integrative medicine for patients with acute and chronic pain
   who have not responded well to conventional treatment modalities.

This is wrong on more levels than one. After giving lip service to the
politically correct term “evidence based” they proceed to include clearly
non-evidence-based modalities in the job description. Rigorous scientists do not
classify acupuncture itself as evidence-based, since the evidence is compatible
with the hypothesis that it is no more than an elaborate system to provide
placebo and other nonspecific effects. And the described duties of the position 
make it even worse. 

Duties:

  1. Diagnose and manage pain disorders and their related neurological and
    musculoskeletal systems

  2. Prevent or modify the perception of pain using acupuncture and Chinese
    medicine modalities

  3. Apply acupuncture techniques to restore and normalize physiological functions

  4. Counsel patients on nutrition, exercise, sleep habits, and stress management

  5. Treat various illnesses/diseases using Chinese medicine modalities such as
    cupping, moxibustion, and visualization techniques

  6. Develop treatment goals in conjunction with fully credentialed providers

  7. Evaluate patient progress and response to treatment regimen

  8. Prescribe orthotic devices, materials, and appliances

  9. Apply supports such as straps, tapes, bandages, and braces as necessary

  10. Instruct patients, family, and/or healthcare providers in holistic treatment
    plans/procedures.

  11. Consult with and refer patients to appropriate specialty care providers

  12. Promote quality and cost-effective outcomes across the continuum

This raises questions in my mind, and I hope in yours too:

  1. When they diagnose pain disorders are they making valid scientific diagnoses, 
    or diagnoses within the mythical TCM system of qi, yin, yang, and the 5
    elements (fire, wood, water, metal, earth)?

  2. Do acupuncturists even claim to be qualified to prescribe orthotic devices and
    braces?

  3. Are they trained to counsel patients on nutrition, exercise, sleep habits and 
    stress management?

  4. There is some evidence that acupuncture works for pain and nausea: some people
    are willing to accept that evidence while others reject it as compatible
    with non-specific treatment effects. But there is no credible evidence to
    support the use of acupuncture in any other condition. How, then, can
    acupuncturists be expected to “restore and normalize physiological
    functions”?

  5. Are acupuncturists adequately trained to know when to refer patients to
    appropriate specialty care providers?

  6. Even if one accepts the equivocal evidence for acupuncture relieving pain,
    where is there any credible evidence for cupping and moxibustion?

  7. Cupping leaves visible bruises on the skin (see picture) and moxibustion can
    leave burns; how can these injuries to patients be justified?

  8. Visualization techniques have been discredited. Marcia Angell has called them 
    part of a new mind-body “religion” that encourages false hope.

In an era where we are being asked to study comparative effectiveness and to
reduce costs, how can the Army justify hiring acupuncturists to provide unproven
services that are based only on prescientific thinking and testimonial
“evidence”?Moxibustion has not been shown to be effective for any condition and 
it can burn and sometimes permanently scar the skin. I’m not a lawyer, but it
sounds to me like this might meet the legal definition of battery. I find it
difficult to imagine that patients are made aware of all the pros and cons and
are giving true informed consent to these procedures.

We have discussed military acupuncture before. The Air Force is teaching its
doctors to do ear acupuncture, a system that was invented in 1957 by a single
individual based on his idiosyncratic perception that the shape of the ear
looked something like a fetus curled up in the uterus. They call it “battlefield
acupuncture.”  And a Navy program is snowing doctors with false and incomplete 
information and persuading them to adopt acupuncture into their practices.

Shame on the DOD! I hope a lot of people write their congressmen to protest this
misuse of tax dollars.

Do You Believe in Magic? Oregon Does. Chiropractic and Acupuncture for Pain.

Mark Crislip on August 7, 2015

Link



Pictured: OHP and HERB picking “evidence-based treatment options”

Do You Believe in Magic?

   Do you believe in magic for a back pains fix

   How the needles can free her, where ever it pricks

   And it’s magic, if the chi is groovy

   It makes you feel happy like an old-time movie

   I’ll tell you about the magic, and it’ll free your soul

   But it’s like trying to tell a CAM ’bout randomized control

   If you believe in magic don’t bother to choose

   Although subluxation is simply a ruse

   Just go and get adjusted on the table

   It won’t wipe off the pain no matter how hard you try

   Your wallet is empty and you can’t seem to find

   How you got there, so just blow your mind

   If you believe in magic, come along with me

   We’ll CAM until morning paid for by the OHP

   And maybe, if the CAM is right

   I’ll meet you tomorrow, sort of late at night

   And we’ll go dancing, baby, then you’ll see

   How the magic’s in the CAM and the CAM’s in me

   Yeah, do you believe in magic

   Yeah, believe in the magic of a back pains fix

   Believe in the magic of CAM

   Believe in the magic that can set you free

   Oh, talking ’bout magic

   Do you believe like I believe… Do you believe in magic

   Do you believe like I believe… Do you believe, believer

   Do you believe like I believe… Do you believe in magic

   The Lovin’ Spoonful. Sort-of.

Maybe not my best lyrics.

More Oregon magic

It continues.

Oregon has a problem with prescription pain pills. Oregon leads the nation in
the abuse of such drugs, federal statistics show, with Oregon’s rate of
prescription drug abuse 39 percent higher than the national average. Go us.

Why that is, I do not know. As an Infectious Disease doctor I prescribe a
narcotic about once a year. There are real problems with the treatment of
chronic pain and while I am aware of the issues and the changes over the last 25
years, it does not impact my practice, so my knowledge of the issues is basic.

I am also well aware of the Oregon Health Plan (OHP). The OHP was intended to
make health care more available to the working poor, while rationing benefits.
They were fairly transparent that resources were fixed and not everything would 
be covered.

Given limited resources, part of the plan has always included a prioritization
of treatments and diagnostics, paying for care that give the most bang for the
buck. Not a perfect way to ration care and as is always the case, no good deed
goes unpunished.

Another effect of limiting care, according to the Bend Bulletin, may be that:

   OHP members who suffer back pain have been left with no choice but to take
   drugs, and the policy could be contributing to Oregon’s high rate of narcotic
   abuse

since other interventions to treat back pain are not paid for. Interventions
like acupuncture and chiropractic.

New guidelines were recently updated by the Health Evidence Review Board (HERB) 
and as a result:

   The new guidelines open the door to acupuncture, chiropractic, cognitive
   behavioral therapy, osteopathic manipulation and physical and occupational
   therapy.

To be picky, the guidelines do not say chiropractic, but “spinal manipulation,” 
although the codes to be used are those for chiropractic manipulation. And as is
so often the case, the title of an organization often does not describe what
they actually do. As in the ‘Health Evidence Review’ part. As the local ID
expert in my hospital, or for this blog, when I review the evidence, I try to
read as much as is possible, not only relying on reviews, but as much of the
primary literature as I can. I found that the primary literature is
misrepresented by not only reviews, but the authors of the primary literature.
This is perhaps particularly true in the SCAM world, as the careful evaluation
of a paper will determine.

HERB reviews reviews

As best I can tell, the HERB relied on two reviews, “Diagnosis and Treatment of 
Low Back Pain: A Joint Clinical Practice Guideline” from the American College of
Physicians and the American Pain Society from 2007 and “Nonpharmacologic
Therapies for Acute and Chronic Low Back Pain: A Review of the Evidence for an
American Pain Society/American College of Physicians Clinical Practice
Guideline” from 2007.

That is it. Two reviews, from 2007, from the same journal (from the same
issue!). That hardly seems a sufficient basis upon which to make decisions.

The first review notes:

   For chronic low back pain, moderately effective nonpharmacologic therapies
   include acupuncture (114–115)…spinal manipulation (108)

Reference 114 concludes:

   For chronic low back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and 
   functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after 
   treatment and in the short-term only. Acupuncture is not more effective than 
   other conventional and “alternative” treatments. The data suggest that
   acupuncture and dry-needling may be useful adjuncts to other therapies for
   chronic low back pain. Because most of the studies were of lower methodologic
   quality, there is a clear need for higher quality trials in this area.

And 115:

   The quantity and quality of the included trials varied.

   CONCLUSIONS: Acupuncture effectively relieves chronic low back pain. No
   evidence suggests that acupuncture is more effective than other active
   therapies.

To add to the mix, the Cochrane review notes:

   For chronic low-back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and 
   functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after 
   treatment and in the short-term only. Acupuncture is not more effective than 
   other conventional and “alternative” treatments. The data suggest that
   acupuncture and dry-needling may be useful adjuncts to other therapies for
   chronic low-back pain. Because most of the studies were of lower
   methodological quality, there certainly is a further need for higher quality 
   trials in this area.

Virtually every acupuncture meta-analysis, from the first one in 1980, has some 
variation of

   Various potential sources of bias, including problems with blindness,
   precluded a conclusive finding although most results apparently favoured
   acupuncture.

The second reference used by HERB? For acupuncture they state:

   For chronic low back pain, both systematic reviews found acupuncture
   moderately more effective than no treatment or sham treatments for short-term
   (<6 weeks’ [16] or <3 months’ [17–18] duration) pain relief. Acupuncture was
   also associated with moderate short-term improvements in functional status
   compared with no treatment (standardized mean differences, 0.62 [CI, 0.30 to 
   0.95][16], and 0.63 [CI, 0.19 to 1.08][17–18]), but not compared with sham
   therapies

As we have noted, if a therapy is no better than sham/placebo

IT DOES NOT WORK.

Sorry.

I yelled.

But sometimes I just get too aggravated by the double standards of SCAM
evidence. To continue:

   A recent, higher-quality trial not included in the systematic reviews found
   no differences between acupuncture and sham acupuncture for pain or function 
   (Appendix Table 8) (130).

   Evidence of longer-term benefits from acupuncture is mixed. Acupuncture was
   moderately superior for long-term (>6 weeks’ duration) pain relief compared
   with sham TENS in 2 trials and compared with no additional treatment in 5
   trials, although there were no significant differences compared with sham
   acupuncture. One higher-quality trial found no differences in pain 1 year
   after acupuncture therapy compared with provision of a self-care education
   book (161). A higher-quality trial not included in the systematic reviews
   found clinically insignificant differences (<5 points on 100-point scales)
   between acupuncture and no acupuncture for pain and function after 6 months .
   Another recent, higher-quality trial found acupuncture slightly superior to 
   usual care on Short Form–36 pain scores after 24 months (weighted mean
   difference, 8 points [CI, 0.7 to 15.3 points]) and for recent use of
   medications for low back pain (60% vs. 41%), although ODI scores and other
   outcomes did not differ.

So for acupuncture approval, OHP relied on reviews of meta-analysis, and the
primary sources suggest the therapies result in at best short term efficacy, the
positive effects likely due to poor methodologies and long term effects that
were ‘slightly superior’ or ‘clinically insignificant’.

They evidently did not review the literature to show that acupuncture is a
theatrical placebo, has no basis in reality-based medicine and that most
positive effects are due to bias in poorly done studies.

   …results should be interpreted in the context of the limitations identified, 
   particularly in relation to the heterogeneity in the study characteristics
   and the low methodological quality in many of the included studies.

Thin gruel indeed to justify the State paying for acupuncture. My tax dollars in
action. Or my tax dollars inaction, since they did not do what I would consider
due diligence in reviewing the literature.

Same as it ever was.

Chiropractic steps up to the wand

The analysis of chiropractic is equally unimpressive.

Reference 108, a meta-analysis, states:

   Spinal manipulative therapy had no statistically or clinically significant
   advantage over general practitioner care, analgesics, physical therapy,
   exercises, or back school. Results for patients with chronic low back pain
   were similar. Radiation of pain, study quality, profession of manipulator,
   and use of manipulation alone or in combination with other therapies did not 
   affect these results.

   CONCLUSIONS:

   There is no evidence that spinal manipulative therapy is superior to other
   standard treatments for patients with acute or chronic low back pain.

And that chiropractic is no better other therapies:

   High quality evidence suggests that there is no clinically relevant
   difference between SMT and other interventions for reducing pain and
   improving function in patients with chronic low-back pain.

The conclusions of the second reference used by HERB are equally tepid about the
benefits of chiropractic.

   For low back pain of unspecified duration, 1 higher-quality trial (681
   patients) found no differences in pain, functional status, or other outcomes 
   between patients randomly assigned to chiropractic versus medical management.
   The other trial (1334 patients) found spinal manipulation to be slightly
   superior to usual care for pain and disability (about 5 points on 100-point
   scales) after 3 months in patients with subacute or chronic low back pain,
   although effects were not as pronounced after 12 months, and differences on
   the RDQ did not reach clinical significance (about 1 point). Manipulation and
   exercise did not significantly differ, and the addition of manipulation to
   exercise therapy was no better than exercise alone.

Not, as was mentioned in the newspaper, that:

   Large, randomized trials have shown that for chronic back pain, acupuncture
   and chiropractic therapy are equally helpful, said Dr. Richard Deyo,
   professor of evidence-based medicine at Oregon Health & Science University.
   He served on a task force that advised the Health Evidence Review Commission.
   “Different people respond to different things,” he said. “The outcomes tend 
   to be very similar, in the short term at least.”

It is more accurate to say they are equal placebos, doing nothing, since short
term improvement is just what one would expect from a placebo that does nothing 
to the underlying process. I do not think I read the same papers as Dr. Deyo.
And if you tend towards the Bayesian approach, it your intervention has no prior
plausibility, like acupuncture or chiropractic, then any positive result is
likely a false positive.

And should I mention that the deliberate use of placebos are unethical? Naw.

Scraped knees and entomophagy

I will mention in passing that I have long been of the opinion that most SCAMs
are the equivalent of kissing a child’s boo-boo or apes grooming each other.
Chiropractic and acupuncture are touch-based elaborate treatment rituals and
much of their perceived beneficial effects could be from:

   mounting evidence that more elaborate treatment rituals trigger larger
   nonspecific effects. The reasons for this remain unclear. In a pilot field
   study, we investigated the role of psychophysiological changes during a
   touch-based healing ritual for improvements in subjective
   well-being….Subjective well-being increased significantly from before to
   after the ritual. The analysis of psychophysiological changes revealed a
   significant increase in respiratory rate from baseline to ritual, while skin 
   conductance, heart rate, and heart rate variability did not change. Increases
   in [skin conductance levels] as well as decreases in respiratory rate from
   baseline to ritual were significantly associated with improvements in
   subjective well-being…. Conclusion. Higher sympathetic arousal during a
   touch-based healing ritual predicted improvements in subjective well-being.

So the state is going to pay for the metaphorical picking and eating of lice.

And this also ignores the question of the state paying for practitioners of
magical pseudo-medicines and all the associated useless interventions and
beliefs espoused by chiropractors, naturopaths and traditional Chinese medicine 
practitioners noted at length on this blog.

It hardly seems like a good use of Oregon’s resources, nor a good approach to
chronic back pain. It seems that Ben Goldacre’s aphorism is being ignored: Just 
because there are flaws in aircraft design that doesn’t mean flying carpets
exist.

Oregon chooses flying carpets.

They do suggest a possible benefit:

   The expense of a broader range of treatments could be offset by a decline in 
   narcotics use

And I hope they do some epidemiologic studies to show benefit of adding
pseudo-medicines to OHP, although I am not so sure the cost is worth the lack of
benefit.

Credentialing magic

Being credentialed is a necessary pain. I have to document for my hospitals and 
some insurance companies that I am trained in my specialty and should be
competent to practice medicine. It is a lot of paperwork and it has to be kept
up to date. I am, however, credentialed in reality-based medicine.

How do you credential someone in a field that is based in pseudo-medicine,
divorced from reality, with a panoply of imaginary diseases treated with equally
imaginary therapies? Like naturopathy?

As noted by one author who desperately wants to give his difficult patients to
naturopaths:

   Unfortunately, a number of serious difficulties can be encountered by
   internal medicine, family medicine, and pediatric physicians who refer
   patients to, or attempt to comanage patients with, naturopathic physicians.

And:

   Yet because of differentials in paradigm and/or clinical experience,
   naturopaths commonly order laboratory tests that are either unrecognizable or
   seem inappropriate to internists.

They don’t seem inappropriate, they are inappropriate, but to be expected from
an education and training dominated by nonsense. I have discussed at length why 
naturopathic training is useless for diagnosis and treatment. It is an old joke,
but ND really does mean Not a Doctor.

It does not worry my alma mater, Oregon Health Sciences University, who ignores 
the whole science part of their title so they can credential naturopaths. How
they do it is detailed in “A Framework for Credentialing Naturopathic Physicians
in Academic Health Centers: Oregon Health and Science University.”

They state:

   To maintain consistency with the rigorous standards applied to all
   credentialed healthcare professionals at the institution, the requirements
   include postdoctoral training (clinical or research) in an AHC to establish
   cultural competence and the completion of one year in a residency approved by
   the Council on Naturopathic Medical Education or two years of direct
   clinical practice in a hospital accredited by the Joint Commission or the
   Centers for Medicare and MedicaidServices to establish clinical competence.

But pay no attention to the content of the education. Being extensively trained 
in pseudo-medicine does not mean the practitioner should be allowed to take care
of patients, especially at a University.

So what good is:

  1. Successful graduation from a 4-year accredited, post-baccalaureate, training
    program with designation as a Doctor of Naturopathic Medicine

  2. Successful completion of one year CNME (Council on Naturopathic Medicine
    Education) accredited residency or evidence of 2 years direct clinical
    practice in a Joint Commission or CMS accredited hospital or academic
    medical center

  3. Post-Doctoral Training for at least 2 years in an Academic Medical Center

  4. Successful completion of NPLEX (Naturopathic Physicians Licensing
    Examinations) with a current license as an Oregon Licensed Naturopathic
    Physician

  5. Additional Active Clinical Practice for at least 2 years, immediately
    preceding the request for clinical privileges at OHSU, documentable via
    reports of specific activities from the locations of practice

When it is all based in nonsense? Playing doctor does not make you a doctor.

OHSU does have far more requirements than most practicing naturopaths have who
pretend they can function as primary care physicians.

Pseudo-medicine. Paid for by the state, approved by the University.

And lest you be smug, I bet the same things are happening in your state.

                                Acupuncture CME

                                   Mark Crislip

                                      Link

Some Universities have more cachet than others. On the West coast it is Stanford
that has the reputation as the best. There is Oxford, Yale, MIT, and maybe
Whatsamatta U. I would wager that in most people’s mind the crème de la crème is
Harvard. Harvard is where you find the best of the best. If Harvard is
involved, a project gains an extra gobbet of credibility. Brigham and Women’s
Hospital also has a similar reputation in the US as one of the hospitals
associated with only Harvard and the New England Journal of Medicine. Premier
university, premier hospital, premier journal.

So if Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Harvard Medical School are offering
continuing medical information (CME) for acupuncture, there must be something to
it, right? A course called “Structural Acupuncture for Physicians” must have
some validity.

Brigham and Women’s Hospital, which is a teaching affiliate of Harvard Medical
School, includes the Oscher Clinical Center for Complementary and Integrative
Medical Therapies. The Oscher center offers acupuncture, yoga, chiropractic and 
a variety of other modalities including craniosacral therapy.

There are few things, in a world of alternative nonsense, as nonsensical as
craniosacral therapy .

   A craniosacral therapy session involves the therapist placing their hands
   on the patient, which they say allows them to tune into what they call the
   craniosacral system. The practitioner gently works with the spine and the
   skull and its cranial sutures, diaphragms, and fascia. In this way, the
   restrictions of nerve passages are said to be eased, the movement of
   cerebrospinal fluid through the spinal cord is said to be optimized, and
   misaligned bones are said to be restored to their proper position.

Cranial Sacral therapists think they can improve the flow of spinal fluid flow
by gently massaging the skull. Really. I can’t make this stuff up. I operate
under the assumption that you can judge a person by the company they keep,
although guilt by association is problematic in medical institutions. Programs
are often started in hospitals for financial reasons without the benefit of
scientific or medical input. It is one of the many prices we pay in the US for a
for-profit medical system. But if there is a institution whose scientific
standards are such that they allow craniosacral therapy, well, they lose a major
chunk of credibility. As the saying goes, you lie down with pigs, you come up
smellin’ like garbage.

On the other hand, it would be much easier to participate on committee work. The
Pharmacy and Therapeutics committees in which I participate spends significant 
time evaluating the literature to decide how best to utilize new drugs and
therapies. If only we offered craniosacral therapy: I would never have to
justify a treatment based on science and reality again. So now I realize, sadly,
that Brigham and Women’s and, by extension Harvard, has questionable scientific
standards, or, if they have standards, they apply them selectively.

The brochure states

   This unique course provides practical, hands-on training in acupuncture. 
   The training program is designed to bring together Eastern and Western views 
   of health and disease into a result-oriented acupuncture style. You will
   learn to evaluate and treat patients using modern Japanese acupuncture
   techniques that link classical Chinese theory to concrete, understandable
   clinical diagnostic and treatment techniques.

Whenever I hear about the Eastern views of health and disease I always think of 
General Westmoreland in the movie “Hearts and Minds.” I know, cheap shot. But an
Eastern heart attack is different from a Western heart attack how?

What, I wonder, is a “result-oriented acupuncture style.” Since acupuncture has 
little, if any, efficacy, it cannot have therapeutic results. Maybe the key word
is style. There is style and there is substance. I suppose they could be
suggesting that the acupuncture they are teaching will only look like it is
working?

Style probably refers to the type of acupuncture, as in Kiiko Style acupuncture.
Like the kung fu movies I watched as a teen, there are various acupuncture
styles that need to compete in a winner take alltournament, to determine once
and for all whose acupuncture is strongest.

Modern Japanese acupuncture differs from Chinese acupuncture in that they use
finer needles that are not placed as deeply. Japanese acupuncture does seem to
share one feature with Chinese acupuncture, at least to judge from the videos of
the procedure I can find searching YouTube: a complete lack of understanding of
sterile technique. I you want to get the willies watch a video on acupuncture, 
Japanese or otherwise. Barehanded, no hand washing, the practitioner touches the
area to be pierced, no alcohol wipe is used, and the junction of needle/skin is
manipulated. The Kiiko style, to judge from the photographs on the website,
does not include gloves. These videos should be entitled “How to transmit
infectious diseases.”

I assume they will use sterile technique at the course, since “emphasis is given
to “hands-on” point location and needling techniques based upon palpatory
feedback” although one cannot be sanguine in regards to a hospital system that
uses craniosacral therapy. Germ theory is, after all, just a theory.

   The didactic portion of the course will focus on bridging the gap between
   acupuncture practice and science. The scientific basis of acupuncture and
   the methodological problems with acupuncture research is presented as part of
   the discussion of specific clinical conditions throughout the course.

That will be an interesting discussion. Since the acupuncture literature, as
discussed at length on this blog, is such that the best studies show no effect
and the science is only barely applicable to acupuncture and pain treatment, it 
would be fun to be a fly on the wall and see how they ‘bridge the gap” for the
justification of the covered uses: Pain Control, Hormonal Imbalances, OB/GYN
Problems, GI Disorders, Scar Treatments, Structural and Orthopedic Problems,
Cardiac and Vascular Disorders, Autoimmune and Autonomic Disorders, Mood
Disorders, Myofascial and Neuroanatomic Treatment.

Not only will they be teaching Japanese acupuncture and classic Chinese
acupuncture, but also auricular acupuncture and the German Microsystem approach 
(MAPS: Mikro-Aku-Punkt-Systeme). That last one

   … is based on the Somatotopic fields comprising of specific points of
   correspondence in the Auricle (Ear), Scalp, Oral Cavity etc. A micro system
   is like a Map of the body — somatotope or a cartography of the whole organism
   similar to the homunculus discovered in the sensory motor cortex of the
   brain. Each of the Micro system points have a clearly defined correlation to 
   and interrelation with a particular organ or function…For Example EAR
   Acupuncture is one such Micro-system. It was discovered by the french doctor 
   Nogier who decoded the functional correspondences of the respective ear
   points. The punctual cartography of the Ear resembles an upside down embryo.

MAPS is apparently the result of the unholy mating of acupuncture and
phrenology.

I am surprised they did not include Korean Hand Acupuncture, foot acupuncture
and tongue acupuncture. They are leaving out three key styles of acupuncture.
One wonders how six styles of acupuncture can all be valid, share similar
physiology, and be supported by the same science, given their differences. I
suppose it is like asking which is the valid style of astrology: Indian,
Western, or Mayan. It is a trick question. They are all nonsense.

The best constructed study to date on acupuncture demonstrated that sham
acupuncture by twirling toothpicks on the skin is arguably more effective and
definitely has fewer side effects when compared to ‘real’ acupuncture. I can use
quotes with the best of them. I wonder it they will pass out a box of
toothpicks. Since twirling toothpicksgives similar results with fewer
complications, one wonders how they justify teaching acupuncture styles that are
less efficacious and more dangerous than toothpicks. Can you ethically offer an
equivalent therapy with more side effects than a known competitor?

Let’s see, cost of the class: $6650. For that kind of cash, who needs ethics?
That’s right, if you are a Harvard-affiliated hospital you can charge the cost
of two loaded, top-of-the-line MacBook Pros to teach magic. I bet they get it.
“Harvard-trained acupuncturist” would look great on a business card and provide 
instant credibility. A quick google finds practitioners whose websites mention
the Harvard course for their training. Premium price for premium nonsense.

I am only disappointed they did not charge ten dollars more. $6660. Now there’s 
a number.

As the web page for the Oscler center says

   The market for complementary and integrative medicine is vast and shows
   no sign of diminishing. This trend must be guided by scientific inquiry,
   clinical judgment, regulatory authority, and shared decision-making. – Dr.
   David Eisenberg.

The market. Not the need. The market. It is depressing when good institutions
promote worthless nonsense.

Next time I read the NEJM and see an article from Harvard or Brigham and
Women’s, I will not be as accepting of the result as I was in the past. They
have lost some of their credibility with me. It is sad. Great institutions can
have feet of clay. At least there are still institutions you can believe in.
Mom. Apple Pie. Baseball. Go Barry Bonds.

               No Education? No Training? No License? No Problem!

                                 Jann Bellamy 

                                      Link

When Daniel David Palmer, the inventor of chiropractic, and his acolytes first
took up the practice of chiropractic, around the turn of the last century, they 
were jailed for the unlicensed practice of medicine. If history had left them
there, we might not be fighting a continuing battle with the pseudoscience that 
is “alternative” medicine today.

Unfortunately, the Kansas legislature intervened on the chiropractors’ behalf
and passed the first chiropractic practice act in 1913. Over the years, state by
state, the notions that subluxations interfere with nerve flow, causing ill
health, and that only chiropractors could “correct” these subluxations, thereby 
restoring health, were incorporated into state law. As well, chiropractors were 
given a broad scope of practice and allowed to call themselves “doctor.” In
1974, Louisiana’s passage of a chiropractic practice act made chiropractic legal
in all 50 states.

Acupuncturists and naturopaths copied this successful formula by convincing
state legislatures to incorporate their pseudoscientific ideas directly into
practice acts, thereby managing to become licensed health care providers.
Legislative fiat triumphed over scientific facts time after time.

Laws allowing the practice of “alternative” medicine did not totally eliminate
resistance to pseudoscientific practices from some quarters. Insurance
companies, for example, refused to pay for treatments they considered
experimental. Medicare did not cover chiropractic. Labs and x-ray facilities
wouldn’t allow use of their services. But for each roadblock science tried to
put in the way, state and federal legislators were there to remove it, paving
the way toward “acceptance.”

Finally, even medical doctors were unable to resist the enticing smell of money 
wafting over from “alternative” clinics. Again legislators smoothed the
transition from medicine to “alternative” medicine by effectively doing away
with a science-based standard of care.

Still, this was not enough in the eyes of some. It deprived those seeking
“health freedom” the “right” to choose whatever health care they wanted from
whatever practitioner they wanted. So the legislatures of three states —
Minnesota (2000),Rhode Island (2002) and New Mexico (2009 ) — came up with an
equitable solution by essentially setting up a separate health care profession: 
the unlicensed practice of health care. In fact, the laws of both Rhode Island
and New Mexico are titled the “Unlicensed Health Care Practice Act.” At least
they’re up front about it.

(Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana and Oklahoma also provide some legal
cover for unlicensed practitioners, mainly by protecting them from prosecution
for the practice of medicine.)

Ironically, these laws are promoted as public safety measures, so that the state
can exercise some control over health care practices not officially licensed.
Perhaps some legislators really believe this is effective — as opposed to, say, 
requiring that all practices have a plausible basis in science and maybe even
some evidence of effectiveness.

The acts passed by Rhode Island and Minnesota are almost identical. New Mexico’s
is more liberal, but contains many of the same provisions. This suggests these 
laws are based on templates fed to drafters by promoters of “health freedom” and
are passed with few changes.

The statutes contain various provisions common to licensed health care practice 
acts: a supervisory authority, a bill of rights for the consumer, reporting
requirements, confidentiality requirements, prohibitions on sex with patients
(who are called “clients” in Minnesota and Rhode Island), and penalties for
violations.

On the other hand, no malpractice insurance is required nor is there a specific 
provision for informed consent of the patient/client. As is common with other
licensed “alternative” practitioners, unlicensed practitioners can’t perform
surgery, prescribe drugs, invade the human body, use medical devices, or
practice dentistry. They also cannot manipulate or adjust the articulations of
joints or the spine, obviously in deference to the chiropractic lobby.

Then things get really weird.

First, other than as stated above, there is virtually no limitation on what
these unlicensed practitioners can do, as long as it falls into “the broad
domain of complementary and alternative healing methods and treatments.” Given
the facts that (1) these “healing methods” are made up, and (2) some are of
fairly recent origin (e.g., cranial sacral therapy), it appears reasonable to
conclude that one can simply create a “healing method,” call it “alternative,”
and set up shop. The unemployed should take note.

Specifically mentioned in the statutes as permissible treatments are
acupressure, Alexander technique, aroma therapy, ayurveda, craniosacral therapy,
crystal therapy, detoxification practices and therapies, energetic healing (as 
opposed to the lethargic kind, I guess), Rolfing, Gerson therapy, colostrum
therapy, therapeutic touch, herbology, herbalism, polarity therapy, homeopathy, 
nondiagnostic iridology, Qi Gong, culturally traditional healing practices,
anthroposophy, folk practices, healing practices utilizing food, dietary
supplements, nutrients, and the physical forces of heat, cold, water, touch, and
light, healing touch, homeopathy, body work, massage, meditation, mind-body
healing practices, naturopathy, noninvasive instrumentalities, holistic
kinesiology and other muscle testing techniques. However, it’s made clear in the
statutes that this list is not meant as a limitation on the therapies which can
be legally offered to the public.

Minnesota and Rhode Island add an extra layer of practitioner protection: having
already ok’d unlicensed alternative medicine “healing methods,” these states
assure practitioners on the cutting edge of pseudo-medicine that use of a “less 
customary approach” will not per se subject them to discipline. So now we have
conventional alternative medicine and alternative alternative medicine? If the
“less customary approach” is used with conventional alternative medicine, should
we call it complementary alternative alternative medicine? So much to figure
out!

Unlicensed practitioners cannot provide a “medical diagnosis,” or, as New Mexico
puts it, the practitioner cannot “make a specific conventional medical
diagnosis,” which is “a medical term that is commonly used and understood in
conventional western medicine.” In another dig at “conventional western
medicine,” plain old prescription drugs become “dangerous drugs” under New
Mexico law. A “dangerous drug” is defined as “a drug that is required by
applicable federal or state law or rule to be dispensed pursuant to a
prescription.” Thus unlicensed practitioners are prohibited from prescribing or 
dispensing “dangerous drugs.”

To make sure unlicensed practitioners don’t pull one over on the public,
Minnesota and Rhode Island (but not New Mexico) list as “prohibited conduct:”

   “Advertising that is false, fraudulent, deceptive or misleading;” and

   “Conduct likely to deceive, defraud, or harm the public.”

Good luck with that!

As further public protection, these states require their own version of a
written quack Miranda warning. For example:

   THE STATE OF MINNESOTA HAS NOT ADOPTED ANY EDUCATIONAL AND TRAINING
   STANDARDS FOR UNLICENSED COMPLEMENTARY AND ALTERNATIVE HEALTH CARE
   PRACTITIONERS BUT WE ARE GOING TO LET THEM PRACTICE MEDICINE ANYWAY.

Actually, I made up that last part, after “PRACTITIONERS.” The rest is right out
of the statutes.

As part of disclosure requirements, this must be followed by,

   THIS STATEMENT OF CREDENTIALS IS FOR INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY.

These “credentials” are “the degrees, training, experience, or other
qualifications of the practitioner regarding the complementary and alternative
health care being provided.” Considering this, the reader might look into
investing in the diploma mill industry.

And note that credentials aren’t required — it’s just that if you have some you 
must let the client know what they are.

Perhaps to prevent their states from becoming havens for parents who want
unrestricted access to “alternative” practices for their children, both
Minnesota and Rhode Island (but, again, not New Mexico) make clear that “a
parent who obtains complementary and alternative health care for the parent’s
minor child is not relieved the duty to seek necessary medical care [for the
child].” In fact, unlicensed practitioners are required to report to the
authorities that a child is not receiving necessary medical care, although if
the practitioner’s world view dictates that medical care is unnecessary, what
happens then?

Minnesota prevents the unlicensed practitioner from using the title “doctor,”
“Dr.” or “physician.” Rhode Island prevents “false or misleading” use of these
terms. New Mexico simply prevents the practitioner from describing himself as a 
“licensed doctor or physician.”

That New Mexico! Here’s what else they do there. The other two states, as might 
be expected, prevent a person from providing unlicensed services if he has been 
convicted of a felony. Not New Mexico! The convicted felon is prevented from
practicing only until he satisfies the terms of his sentence. After that, it’s
back to aromatherapy, iridology, polarity therapy, or whatever else he was up to
before his unfortunate encounter with the criminal justice system.

I must ask: Is it really good public policy to allow a convicted thief such easy
access to a person’s wallet?

And here’s the best part, saved for last: Minnesota and Rhode Island require the
practitioner to provide, in writing, “a brief summary, in plain language, of
the theoretical approach used by the practitioner in providing services to
clients.” What we wouldn’t give to see that! In fact, if you are ever in either 
of these states, be sure to have a complementary or alternative health care
treatment from an unlicensed practitioner, and be sure to get your written,
plain language summary of her “theoretical approach.” Send it to me here.
[After, of course, signing a complete release absolving me of all liability for 
anything bad that happens to you at the hands of the unlicensed practitioner.]
If my SBM editors agree to it, I’ll write a post about them. And bonus points
for any summary containing the phrase “on a quantum level.”

Jann J. Bellamy is a Florida attorney.  She left the active practice of law in
2006 to form a non-profit, the Campaign for Science-Based Healthcare, which
educates the public about “alternative” healthcare claims and advocates for a
state law requiring that all healthcare offered in Florida meet a basic
scientific standard.  She is also a columnist for Health News Florida.

                    Cavalcade of Quackery: A Pantomine Horse

                                Wallace Sampson

                                      Link

Last week I received the news release below that Steve Zeitzew, an orthopedic
surgeon at VA Hospital Los Angeles and UCLA, sent to the Healthfraud list. It
was sent to me by our colleague Liz Woeckner, President of the nonprofit
research protection advocacy organization Citizens for Responsible Care in
Research (CIRCARE) http://www.circare.org/

Ms. Woeckner sent it on with a cryptic comment, wondering if this action was a
quid pro quo for the Chinese granting less than a dozen FDA “inspection
stations” in Chinese cities. The latter is supposed to be an attempt to control 
the impurities and adulterants of Chinese herbal products.

But before proceeding, read for yourselves:

Monday, June 16, 2008 Contact: HHS Press Office

   HHS Secretary and Chinese Minister of Health Sign Memorandum of Understanding
   on Traditional Chinese Medicine Research .

   HHS Secretary Mike Leavitt today signed a memorandum of understanding with
   Chinese Vice Minister of Health Wang Guoqiang to foster collaboration between
   scientists in both countries in research on integrative and traditional
   Chinese medicine. The signing marks the opening of a two-day traditional
   Chinese medicine Research Roundtable at the National Institutes of Health
   (NIH). The roundtable features scientific presentations by researchers from
   China and the United States. Topics include the synthesis of Western medicine
   and traditional Chinese medicine, criteria for evaluating traditional
   Chinese medicine practices, and the application of modern scientific tools
   such as proteomics (the study of proteins) to the study of traditional
   Chinese medicine. “Many Americans incorporate alternative medical practices
   into their personal health care and are interested in the potential of a
   variety of traditional Chinese medicine approaches,” Secretary Leavitt said. 
   “This project will advance our understanding of when and how to appropriately
   integrate traditional Chinese medicine with Western medical approaches to
   improve the health of the American and Chinese people.” The memorandum of
   understanding and the establishment of the international collaboration will
   aid in furthering scientific research on traditional Chinese medicine.
   Participants in the roundtable include a delegation from the Chinese State
   Administration on Traditional Chinese Medicine, academics from U.S.
   universities, and scientists and researchers from NIH, Indian Health Service 
   and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Thirty-six percent of Americans
   use some form of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM), according to
   the 2002 National Health Interview Survey. In the United States, traditional 
   Chinese medicine is an alternative medical system that is considered a part
   of complementary and alternative medicine. Integrative medicine combines
   mainstream medical practices with alternative medical practices. Traditional 
   Chinese medicine involves numerous practices including acupuncture, tai chi, 
   and herbal therapies. In 2007, NIH’s National Center for Complementary and
   Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) supported nearly $20 million in research on
   traditional Chinese medicine practices. Secretary Leavitt was joined at the
   signing by FDA Commissioner Andrew von Eschenbach, M.D., and NCCAM Director
   Josephine P. Briggs, M.D. The roundtable, which was coordinated by NCCAM,
   National Cancer Institute’s Office of Cancer Complementary and Alternative
   Medicine and the Fogarty International Center, is being held in advance of
   the Fourth Session of the United States-China Strategic Economic Dialogue,
   which began today in Annapolis, Md.

Each sentence reveals one or more covert messages, errors, and contrary
principles which science and medicine would ignore at risk of its demise. Sound 
over the top? Not really; alarming at least, if government functionaries
continue to set health policies indirectly by sponsoring implausible research. .

First, they perpetuate the false dichotomy of “Western” and “TC” medicines. TCM 
can be compared to scientific medicine or to traditional (19th century and
before) Euro-American folk and empirical medicine. They obviously have not been 
reading us. Do the organizers know what “synthesis of Western medicine and
[…TCM] means? Do they mean integrating? What?I know of know no self-identified
analyst or student of TCM who can make a rational scientific presentation of
TCM. One of TCM’s prominent proponents considers scientific controls to be forms
of biases. [Kaptchuck T, Effect of interpretive bias on research evidence. BMJ.
2003 Jun 28;326(7404):1453-5;] A concept similar to “roadblocks” to the
acceptance of “CAM” in the White House Commission charges. These conceptual
deviations are post-modern language distortions, propaganda tools of the
“CAM/IM“ movement.

I have pointed out that scientific characteristics were never a part of TCM. It 
lacked objective observation, consistency of observation, classification of
observed phenomena, information storage, rationality and logic, consistent
written transmission, objectively descriptive language, and a method for
analysis or for interpretation. The system of elements , q’i, and yin/yang did
not include a method for developing theories or independent natural conepts. TCM
depended on empiricism, unreliable observation, was plagued by post hoc
reasoning and causality error. It lacked a concept of error and a system for
self-analysis to correct error. In fact, the culture discouraged analysis and
criticism, considered to be bad form and disrespectful. TCM depended on
individuals who rarely communicated in a formal, direct, manner. Add to that a
system that accepted manipulation to suit the mood and concept of the observer
or authority. I conclude that there is nothing in TCM to study scientifically.
So now they want to develop scientific criteria to apply to their observations? 
Proteomics? On what? Actions of herbs? Words again fail me at the glaring
presumptuousness and ignorance required to conceive such a project. (the
“audacity of hope?”  .

“Many Americans incorporate alternative medical practices into their personal
health care and are interested in the potential of a variety of traditional
Chinese medicine approaches,” Secretary Leavitt said. “This project will advance
our understanding of when and how to appropriately integrate traditional
Chinese medicine with Western medical approaches to improve the health of the
American and Chinese people.”

Here again, the assumptions have no basis. One assumption is that a significant 
number of Americans use [TCM.] Most surveys of use, even those biased favoring
“CAM” show no single method reaching above 2 percent or so except for
chiropractic and dietary supplements. Most methods lounge at the 1-3 percent
level. These levels have plateaued over 2-3 decades even in the face of
advertising and positive propaganda. Yet, I suppose that one percent of 300M
being 3M, some sort of case could be made. But nothing but a jangling confusion 
of borderline and conflicting findings will result from further study. Unless
they appoint people with critical analysis experience, a wide reading knowledge 
of the history and use of TCM, and a scientific view, their research conclusions
will be indeterminate over the next 10 years or more. They will continue to
rely on ideologues, advocates, self-deluded practitioners, and politically
correct academics for advice and pronouncements.

They will probably exclude scientific or skeptical analysts, so there is no way 
they will develop a credible commentary on how best to integrate TCM and improve
the health of the American and Chinese people. Well, they got it backwards
again. It’s China that has to integrate scientific medicine over there. Their
scientists and physicians clamor for it. The Chinese can begin with public
health principles like inhibiting spitting in the streets, cleaning up their air
(finally but it took the Olympics) personal hygiene, cleaning their toilets,
improving their food handling methods, and other systematic changes. They might 
even follow their own modern physicians’ wishes, abandon their herbal industry
and revive their prior inhibition of acupuncture/moxibustion methods instead of 
promoting the integration of TCM into our medical system.

The memorandum of understanding and the establishment of the international
collaboration will aid in furthering scientific research on traditional Chinese 
medicine. Participants in the roundtable include a delegation from the Chinese
State Administration on Traditional Chinese Medicine, academics from U.S.
universities, and scientists and researchers from NIH, Indian Health Service and
the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Thirty-six percent of Americans use
some form of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM), according to the 2002
National Health Interview Survey.

So there will be an international collaboration to “aid in furthering scientific
research…” And they list the kinds of attendees at their 2-day conference.
First, who is not there? Representation from the largest group of China’s
medical community, its scientific physicians. Up to 6 years ago they outnumbered
“TCM” physicians atleast 5:1, and I heard some say 10:1. The two communities of
physicians practice by separate rules and traditions, the scientific ones
practicing as do others throughout the world. Most of those do not even know
much about TCM, and they rarely exchange professionally with the TCMers. They
will not be there, of course. Who are the American “academics?” I’ll bet most
will be people with NCCAM grants for TCM, some with published papers on
acupuncture and TCM, but I doubt more than a token of unconflicted objective
scientists, if any at all. Researchers from NIH? Bets from here they are
advocates or NIH sponsored TCM researchers. Here we see the same internalized
network of special interests at work again, naming one another to consulting
positions. Indian health Service? Indian health Service?

They repeat the meaningless “thirty-six percent” figure, which has nothing to do
with the number or percent who use TCM (<10 percent.) The true figures are
published and they don’t quote them. Perfect for a presidential election year,
right?

   In the United States, traditional Chinese medicine is an alternative medical 
   system that is considered a part of complementary and alternative medicine.
   Integrative medicine combines mainstream medical practices with alternative
   medical practices. Traditional Chinese medicine involves numerous practices
   including acupuncture, tai chi, and herbal therapies. In 2007, NIH’s National
   Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) supported nearly
   $20 million in research on traditional Chinese medicine practices.

Well, let’s let the reader incorporate this part…doesn’t add much to me except
for the $20M.

OK, at this point you may have thought back up there someplace, how about the
big picture? What the… is the federal government through HHS doing in this,
mixing international politics with the independent and quasi-free medical
scientific enterprise that is operating quite well, thank you? Changes in a
scientific system come through a natural evolution based on the accumulation of 
bits of knowledge, with research proceeding on the basis of the preceding
knowledge base. If one wants to study cultural folkway medicines and methods,
research would have to be highly selective. One simply cannot study a system as 
a whole scientifically. That is one of “Holistic Medicine“ and “CAM‘s“ early
complaints about “the Medical System,” that they claimed was structured so as to
prejudice knowledge coming from traditional systems. Some even believed a
conspiracy, constructed to exclude them. Neither can one study each method and
material of the thousands in each tradition that is presented or discovered. The
selection for research has to be based on the validity of reported observations
of those methods most consilient with the scientific knowledge base. One might 
excuse some private business or foundation seeking some outlet for research
funds and that has a personal or organizational (for profit) motive for doing
some badly founded research. At least the funding source and even a profit
motive would be open and apparent – as we say, transparent – even if we consider
their projects highly implausible. But this attempt is a disguise – a pantomime
horse hiding its real propulsion mechanism under a distracting cover.

What is HHS doing, using a cover of medical science and for what? The government
doesn’t do such things without pressure from some group or perceived
self-interest in negotiation. In this case, what are the respective interests?
There could be several.

For China, the most apparent is awakening the American population to the hidden 
miracles of TCM – and the marketing of supplements. Ka Kit Hui, a practitioner
in Santa Monica, Calif., been promoting TCM herbs for several decades. I debated
him on the subject at Stanford in 1995 or so at which time he extolled the
undiscovered miracles in TC herbal medicine. Again in a letter to the editor to 
JAMA in 1997 he predicted that TCM herbals would be the prime economic product
of the 21st century. I dismissed the statement in a response, but here we are,
nearly 1/10th the way through the century, and here is TCM herbalism making
inroads. China must see a large market, a population at least a third of
their’s, and in view of the differences in income, living standard, and
disposable income, a market that is at least as large in dollars/yuens as China 
has at home – probably greater.

What motivates the US? For one, TCMers may be behind the effort. They are on a
path toward legitimizing the OMD degree and licensing of TCM practice. They
already have acupuncture licensure in a plurality of states. They have a dozen
or more schools of TCM. The California state legislature several years ago
dropped an attempt to standardize teaching in the California schools – a first
step to a standard exam and thus an academic standard for licensure. But they
will be back. It took naturopaths over 15 years to get their licensure and
degree recognition – another history familiar to Kim Atwood and others. The rest
of the ulicensed hordes are following through an accompanying though crippled
series of Access to Medical Treatment Acts. They persist – getting bits here and
there and then, in an alignment of the planets minute, achieving passage of
licensure legislation that imprints their initials in gold.

The formation of the NCCAM was a major step for TCMers. Now an HHS officially-
sanctioned 2 day conference opens the plausibility of studying more TCM just as 
acupuncture systematic reviews are showing indeterminacy to ineffectiveness,
herbs are being found more dangerous than helpful, and products from the PRC
being found adulterated with metals and with standard pharmaceuticals. A fly on 
the wall of certain congressmen and senators and of HHS director Leavitt could
tell us a lot. (Here we go again with a FOI request.)

As for government sourced motives, as Ms. Woeckner suggested, we probably had to
pay a price for the stationing of FDA offices in Chinese cities. I still fail
to see what they can do about adulteration of products, much of which could be
shifted to way stations in Taiwan or in the US.

Unless someone on the inside squeals or finds that whistle to blow, seems to me 
we are getting taken to the cleaners again. At least this time it isn’t nuclear 
secrets given away by a Secretary of Commerce (Hazel O’Leary 10-12 years ago) or
nuclear and missile technology sales OK’d by a greedy industry CEO and an
unnamed agency as Chinese influence money came through in the 1996 election.

Oh, I think I’m getting it. We graciously level the military playing field in
the interest of world peace by sharing nuclear and missile technology with China
in return for political contributions. We get stripes and chevrons from the
public and press. Then we help level the health playing field, increasing
China’s level by sharing scientific advances with Chinese medical authorities
and then finance the research. We accept a lowering of American health and
medical standards by adopting some of China’s methods. Ya gotta balance those
equations.

And finally,

   The roundtable, which was coordinated by NCCAM, National Cancer Institute’s
   Office of Cancer Complementary and Alternative Medicine and the Fogarty
   International Center, is being held in advance of the Fourth Session of the
   United States-China Strategic Economic Dialogue, which began today in
   Annapolis, Md.

Oh.

                      An ICD Code for the Running Piglets!

                                 Ben Kavoussi 

                                      Link

   … animals are divided into (a) those that belong to the emperor; (b)
   embalmed ones; (c) those that are trained; (d) suckling pigs; (e) mermaids;
   (f) fabulous ones; (g) stray dogs; (h) those that are included in this
   classification; (i) those that tremble as if they were mad; (j) innumerable
   ones; (k) those drawn with a very fine camel’s-hair brush; (l) etcetera; (m) 
   those that have just broken the flower vase; (n) those that at a distance
   resemble flies.

   – Jorge Luis Borges (1899–1986)1

Not too long ago, I came across a disease taxonomy proposed by a certain
East-West Medical Research Institute (EWMRI), that includes the kind of
fantastic afflictions — such as “running piglet” disorder — fit for the best
Borgesian list.

This obscure institute, located at Kyung Hee University in Seoul, Korea, is one 
of the 800 WHO Collaborating Centres designated to carry out various activities 
in support of the Organization’s programs. With the collaboration of China,
Japan, Vietnam, Australia, and the US, this center is working to incorporate
medieval Asian disease nomenclature to the 11th version of the International
Classification of Disease (ICD-11).

The proposed taxonomy that has resulted from the collaboration is called the
International Classification of Traditional Medicine (ICTM). It resembles a
shopping list made by randomly mixing a medical dictionary with Harry Potter,
and reads like a Surrealist poem penned in a marathon Automatic Writing session.
Right after influenza, dysentery, and cholera, one can find miasmatic malaria
(瘴瘧)… pestilence (瘟疫)… plum-pit qi (梅核氣)… running piglet (奔豚)… wasting-thirst
(消渴)… T-shaped malnutrition (丁奚疳)… umbilical wind (臍風)… syndrome of liver fire
blazing the ear (肝火燔耳證) (ouch!)… and many other astonishing entries, which I
invite you to browse for your own amusement — or dismay.

The 2007 version of the WHO International Standard Terminologies on Traditional 
Medicine in the Western Pacific Region lists the proposed disease categories on 
pages 162 to 203.

The proposal suggests that “a future ICTM could comprise not only East Asian
Traditional Medicine but traditional medicine practices from other WHO regions… 
such as India, Sri Lanka and Africa.” This leaves us to wonder whether “pacing
zombie swagger” may figure as a possible entry if the ICTM decides to include
the Caribbean one day?!

I recognize that the Korean research institute, the Kyung Hee University, and
the health care community in Asian countries are free to believe in the
existence of pestilence or miasmatic malaria, and can treat their populations
with incantations, amulets, talismans, lancing, or even bloodletting, if they so
choose. But what really concerns me is the possibility that these medieval
views on disease might someday become legitimized in the US, not only because
they fit New Age ideas and ideals, but also because they bear WHO’s seal of
approval.

Traditional acupuncturists in many US states already practice medicine based on 
medieval views similar to those expressed by Avicenna (c. 980–1037) in the 1025 
Canon of Medicine, which — although ingenious for its time — was already
obsolete in the 17th century. This “medical primitivism” (the rejection of
science-based and industrialized medicine) is the result of the counterculture
of the 1960s, postmodern ideology, and the New Age movement. Trough political
pressure, primitivism has increasingly become an acceptable form of healthcare
in the US under the guise of “alternative” or “Oriental” medicine. An ICD that
includes the “running piglet” might reinforce this political momentum, and might
further the resurrection and re-legitimation of notions that are closer to
fantasy than reality.

Indeed, as Jeannie Kang, an acupuncturist in Los Angeles, CA, and the head of
the American Association of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (AAAOM) Korean
Advisory Council, writes in Qi-Unity Report:

   Incorporating traditional medicine into the ICD coding system for medical
   records and billing is an essential prerequisite for advancement of
   traditional medicine into the mainstream medical system. The WHO has agreed
   to work with a standardized terminology on the basic terms it has identified.

The last WHO meeting to discuss the ICTM was held in the Philippines, February
7–11, 2011.

I find that this “standardized terminology” bears a significant — and
instructive — resemblance to the outlandish bestiary that Borges recounts in The
Analytical Language of John Wilkins. Borges, whose Magical Realism blends facts
and fiction liberally, attributes the passage he cites to an elusive Chinese
encyclopedia called The Celestial Emporium of Benevolent Knowledge.

The naive oddity of the underlying logic of association that yields the
Celestial Emporium‘s taxonomy has inspired considerable commentary, notably by
the philosopher Michel Foucault, who writes in The Order of Things that it
shatters “all the familiar landmarks of thought — our thought, the thought that 
bears the stamp of our age and our geography.”2 But more pertinently, the
clinical psychologist, Louis A Sass, writes in Madness and Modernism that such
oddity of thinking shows the signs of a typical schizophrenic thought pattern.3

Different cultures at different stages of their development have used different 
logics of association to categorize illnesses. Prior the advent of modern
science, disease taxonomies (nosologies) were predominantly based on symptoms,
and identified by means of vernacular naming systems. “Running piglet” is, for
instance, a Chinese agrarian metaphor that indicates a panic attack. However,
scientific nosology is predominantly based on etiology (causative agent) or
pathogenesis (causative mechanism), except for idiopathic conditions. As a
result, most ancient categories have disappeared: they are obsolete.
“Melancholia” (meaning “excess of black bile”) is an example. Other categories
are archaic: that is, when the name is used in modern nosology, it refers to a
significantly different category. Malaria (originally meaning “bad air”) is a
good example. The proposed addition to the ICD11 ignores this important paradigm
shift.

Therefore, tossing modern and obsolete categories together into a single system 
of categorization, like the proposed ICTM, departs from common-sense, loses
coherence, fragments into contradictory points of view, and ultimately turns
into a “word salad”: a mixture of words and expressions that, while seemingly
meaningful, actually carries no significance.

Lastly, I think the illogical nosology for which the AAAOM is “very excited” is 
the product of a style of thought that is, at best, idiosyncratic and odd. At
worst, it is the hallmark of the cognitive slippage and technophobic delusions
that characterize the modern apologists of unscientific medicine(s). In all, it 
is a significant leap away from reason, in the direction of the Dark Ages.

With special thanks to Kristin Koster, PhD, for her valuable contribution.

REFERENCES

Borges, Jorge Luis (Author), Weinberger, Eliot (Editor). ‘The Analytical
Language of John Wilkins’ in Selected Nonfictions. Penguin Books. 1999. Return
to text

Foucault, Michel. The Order of Things: An Archaeology of Human Sciences.
Tavistock. 1985. Return to text

Sass, Louis A. Madness and Modernism: Insanity in the Light of Modern Art,
Literature and Thought. Harvard University Press. 1998. Return to text

                        The Good Rewards of Bad Science

                                  Ben Kavoussi

                                      Link

   All the world sees us

   In grand style wherever we are;

   The big and the small

   Are infatuated with us:

   They run to our remedies

   And regard us as gods

   And to our prescriptions

   Principles and regimens, they submit themselves.

   Molière, The Imaginary Invalid (1673)1

The passage above is part of a burlesque doctoral conferment ceremony, where the
French playwright Molière (1622-1673) mocks the unscrupulous physicians of his 
time. “All the excellency of their art consists in pompous gibberish, in a
specious babbling, which gives you words instead of reasons, and promises
instead of results,” he writes. In Moliere’s plays doctors never cure anyone;
they are put on stage just to display their own vanity and ignorance.2 The
Spanish painter Francisco de Goya (1746-1828) also took on the same issue by
painting in 1799 a well attired jackass taking the pulse of a dying man, in a
pose that accentuates the large gem on his hoof.

But if the asinine doctors of Molière and de Goya’s time never cured anyone, it 
is because they held prescientific views, and believed that disease was caused
by imbalances in “humors,” and by malefic influences of the Heavens. Even the
most educated among them treated illnesses in good faith by purging,
bloodletting and enema at astrologically auspicious times. In contrast, current 
physicians who for the sake of funding embrace and endorse unscientific views
and practices under the guise of CAM or integrative medicine, do so knowing that
they often contradict the established principles of physics, chemistry, and
biology. Therefore, in addition to promoting “snake oil science”3 (as R. Barker 
Bausell calls it), these physicians are also guilty of bad faith. Most of this
takes place at large academic centers, where funding seems to outweigh the
concern for science. As Val Jones, MD, writes in 2009′s Top 5 Threats To Science
In Medicine:

   Often referred to by David Gorski as “Quackademic” Medical Centers – there is
   a growing trend among these centers to accept endowments for “integrative”
   approaches to medical care. Because of the economic realities of decreasing
   healthcare reimbursements – these once proud defenders of science are now
   accepting money to “study” implausible and often disproven medical treatments
   because they’re trendy. Scientists at these centers are forced to look the
   other way while patients (who trust the center’s reputation that took tens of
   decades to build) are exposed to placebo medicine under the guise of
   “holistic” healthcare.

A list of these centers, available at the Academic Woo Aggregator website,
reveals the prestigious University of California (UC) as the most represented,
with 3 centers: the UCSF Osher Center for Integrative Medicine; the Susan
Samueli Center for Integrative Medicine at UC Irvine; and the Collaborative
Centers for Integrative Medicine at UCLA, which includes the Center for
East-West Medicine. The William R. Pritchard Veterinary Medical Teaching
Hospital at UC Davis, with its Acupuncture and Traditional Chinese Veterinary
Medicine (TCVM) clinic, should perhaps be added to the list.

Among them, UCSF’s Osher Center for Integrative Medicine has the largest
funding, with a cumulative sum of over $28 million. Established in 1997 by the
Dean Emeritus of the School of Medicine, Haile T. Debas, MD, and the very
generous support of the Bernard Osher Foundation, the UCSF Center collaborates
with Harvard University, and the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm.

Some of the “integrative” medicine research involves acupuncture, even if it
might end up being a source of scientific embarrassment. Consider, for instance,
the dubious research during the 1990s at UC Irvine by the physicist Zang-Hee
Cho, who claimed to have in vivo evidence by fMRI for acupuncture’s putative
effects. Cho and his colleagues published a series of papers, notably one in the
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), where they claimed to
have observed a correlation between the visual cortex and an acupuncture point
on the toe. Based on this unconfirmed observation, they became persuaded that
acupuncture involves the activation of the cortical region associated with the
targeted organ.4 Cho went as far as claiming that the cortical activation
depends on the subject’s personality type, which could be yin or yang!
Fortunately, the PNAS article, which is often referenced by acupuncture
apologists, was retracted in June 2006 by Cho himself and a number of its
coauthors:

   Accumulating evidence suggests that the central nervous system is essential
   for processing these effects, via its modulation of the autonomic nervous
   system, neuro-immune system, and hormonal regulation. We, therefore, carried 
   out a series of studies questioning whether there really is point specificity
   in acupuncture, especially vis-à-vis pain and acupuncture analgesic effects 
   as we originally reported in our PNAS article, that had not yet been
   confirmed by other studies… Having concluded that there is no point
   specificity, at least for pain and analgesic effects, and that we no longer
   agree with the results in our PNAS article, the undersigned authors are
   retracting the article.

   Z. H. Cho

   S. C. Chung

   H. J. Lee

   E. K. Wong

   B. I. Min5

Cho has since left the University of California, and is now the Director of the 
Neuroscience Research Institute at Gachon University of Medicine and Science in 
Korea. However, his research lead to a $5.7 million gift to UC Irvine in 2000 by
Henry and Susan Samueli to research acupuncture, herbal therapy, and the
“Indian science of life,” Ayurveda. This funding was used to create the Susan
Samueli Center for Integrative Medicine.

UCLA’s “integrative” medicine also involves acupuncture. Although several
separate groups and individuals provide acupuncture at UCLA, most of it is now
centralized at the Center for East-West Medicine, which was founded in 1993 by
its current Director, Ka-Kit Hui, MD. The Center’s website states that in March 
2005, the Annenberg Foundation awarded $2 million to UCLA to establish the
Wallis Annenberg Endowed Chair in Integrative East-West Medicine. An additional 
$115,790 grant allowed for the creation of a “healing environment.” Meanwhile,
the Center is using UCLA’s international fame to lend legitimacy to Chinese folk
medicine. Take a peek at UCLA Today of Jun 17, 2010:

   Representing a 5,000-year history of traditional Chinese medicine, Chinese
   Vice Minister of Health Dr. Wang Guoqiang and a six-person delegation came to
   campus June 11 to see what they could learn from UCLA, which has long been
   at the forefront of research in integrative medicine and education in the
   western world… The Chinese delegation, which had a four-day stay in the U.S.,
   chose UCLA as the only academic medical center to visit to learn how
   traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) and integrative medicine are practiced as 
   a new health care model… Wang is the highest-ranking official in China
   overseeing the development of Chinese medicine and integrated medicine.

Now read the following grim news about UCLA’s budget, announced just three
months before, which might put the arrival of the Chinese delegation in a whole 
new perspective. UCLA Today wrote on Feb 18, 2010 that:

In planning for next year’s budget, campus leaders believe that UCLA will face a
permanent loss of $117 million in state funding for 2010-11, the same as in
2009-10, but with one difference. The $55 million cut that was made on a
one-time basis in 2009-10 will become permanent… And although Gov. Arnold
Schwarzenegger seeks to restore the one-time $305 million reduction made to UC’s
budget this fiscal year — $55 million of which was cut from UCLA’s budget —
campus leaders said they are assuming that the State Legislature is going to
reject his proposal.

With UCLA experiencing an unprecedented drop in state support, even snake oil
science is welcomed, as long as it leads to further funding prospects. After
all, as the Roman Emperor Vespasian once said: Pecunia non olet (money does not 
smell).

   In my 2009 post Astrology with Needles, I presented images from European
   manuals of bloodletting, which clearly indicate that the acclaimed 5,000-year
   history of traditional Chinese medicine does not include acupuncture as we
   know it today. What the Chinese practiced is lancing and bloodletting with
   bodkins and lancets, which significantly resembled what Europeans and Muslims
   also practiced. This is why the venipuncture points portrayed in European
   medieval manuscripts significantly overlap with key points described in the
   Chinese classics. In addition, the evidence presented in my recent post, The 
   Acupuncture and Fasciae Fallacy, shows that the tools described in the
   Chinese classics resemble fleams and other venipuncture instruments of
   medieval Europe, and have little resemblance to what is currently considered 
   an acupuncture needle. This is because acupuncture with fine needles is a
   modern invention; one that was transformed from a side-lined practice of the 
   early 20th-century to an essential and high-profile part of the national
   health-care system under the Chinese Communist Party.6

Finally, the visit of the Chinese delegation to UCLA reminds me of a 1998 French
film called The Dinner Game (Le dîner de cons). In it, Pierre and his Parisian 
friends organize a dinner party each week, where everyone invites the most
ridiculous character he can find, so they can all have a good time mocking him. 
But when Pierre invites François, who he thinks will steal the show, his
clueless guest inadvertently exposes hidden and embarrassing aspects of Pierre’s
life. The visitors that have come to UCLA to represent 5,000 years of
hocus-pocus, and are eager to learn about an integrative medicine that is mainly
a showcase to obtain funding, might have–like François–unknowingly exposed a
mockery, and with it, a great charade.

REFERENCES:

1. Poqulin JB (Author), Frame DM (Translator, Introduction). The Misanthrope and
Other Plays. Signet Classics. 1968. The quoted section was translated by
Barbara J. Becker, PhD.

2. Livingston PN. Comic Treatment: Molière and the Farce of Medicine. Vol. 94,
No. 4, French Issue: Perspectives in Mimesis (May, 1979), pp. 676-687.

3. Barker Bausell R. Snake Oil Science: The Truth about Complementary and
Alternative Medicine. Oxford University Press. 1st edition. 2007.

4. Cho ZH, Chung SC, Jones JP, Park JB, Park HJ, Lee HJ, Wong EK, Min BI. New
findings of the correlation between acupoints and corresponding brain cortices
using functional MRI. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1998 Mar 3;95(5):2670-3.

5. Retraction in Cho ZH, Chung SC, Lee HJ, Wong EK, Min BI. Proc Natl Acad Sci U
S A. 2006 Jul 5;103(27):1052.

6. Taylor K. Chinese Medicine in Early Communist China, 1945-1963: A Medicine of
Revolution. Routledge. 2005.

                                Without Borders

                                  Mark Crislip

                                      Link


   Take up the White Man’s burden–

   The savage wars of peace–

   Fill full the mouth of Famine

   And bid the sickness cease;

   And when your goal is nearest

   The end for others sought,

   Watch CAM and woo Folly

   Bring all your hopes to nought.

   Rudyard Kipling. Sort of.

The White Man’s burden, a bit of racism from the 19th century:

   The term “the white man’s burden” has been interpreted as racist, or
   taken as a metaphor for a condescending view of non-Western national culture 
   and economic traditions, identified as a sense of European ascendancy which
   has been called “cultural imperialism.” An alternative interpretation is the 
   philanthropic view, common in Kipling’s formative years, that the rich have a
   moral duty and obligation to help “the poor” “better” themselves whether the
   poor want the help or not. The term “the white man’s burden” has been
   interpreted as racist, or taken as a metaphor for a condescending view of
   non-Western national culture and economic traditions, identified as a sense
   of European ascendancy which has been called “cultural imperialism.” An
   alternative interpretation is the philanthropic view, common in Kipling’s
   formative years, that the rich have a moral duty and obligation to help “the 
   poor” “better” themselves whether the poor want the help or not.

I will let the commentators debate the meaning of the poem. There are places in 
the world so devastated by poverty, disease and political corruption that it may
be beyond the capacity of the local populations to overcome. They need outside 
help. Certainly, the impulse to help those less fortunate than yourselves is a
noble tradition. Haiti, Central America and Uganda are parts of the world that
need assistance in overcoming an incredible number of problems to reach even a
basic level of material support for its population.

What better way to help people in dire need of the basic requirements for health
and material well being than to provide them with Western SCAMs?  At least in
the industrialized West, we have options. If acupuncture or homeopathy or reiki 
does not take care of our problem or our diseases worsen, we are a quick trip
away from the ER.  We may not be able to afford the care, health care being the 
number one cause of bankruptcy in the US, but at least effective health care is 
available. Other societies do not have that option. Often their one point of
contact with health care  providers and/or shamans is their only contact and
there is no infrastructure to take care of the ill.  Uganda spends $135 per
capita on health care,  and has 0.047  physicians per 1,000 people. 1,500
doctors for a population of 35 million. Haiti spends  $82 per capita. I spend
more each year on my daily peanut butter and jelly sandwich for lunch ($1.10) 
By comparison, the US spends $6,000 a year per capita on health care.

These are societies where small amounts of money spent carefully can have
enormous impact. Relatively small amounts of money can do enormous good in
impoverished parts of the world. Ten dollars can buy a mosquito net and prevent 
malaria.  The measles vaccine costs less than a dollar a dose and can prevent
devastating outbreaks of disease.  One hundred dollars  can provide the hungry
with 2 chickens and a goat. So why spend the money on nonsense?  I know it is a 
false choice.  Just because money is being spent on something useless like
homeopathy or acupuncture does not mean that the same money would go to a more
rational choice if it were otherwise available.

In medicine we are aware of the ethical issues in treating vulnerable
populations.  The poor and uneducated do not have the resources to separate fact
from fiction and may lack the background to make truly informed decisions.

Yet none of this stops the sCAM believers from exporting their nonsense to the
poor, the hungry, the under educated and the desperate.

Research

The only thing necessary for the triumph of disease is for good men to do
homeopathy.

  EDMUND BURKE.  Sort of.

Diarrhea is a major source of morbidity and mortality in large parts of the
world, the second (I originally wrote number 2)  cause of infant death in the
world.  Treatment and prevention of diarrheal illness is key to decreasing
infant mortality world wide.  How might I make a major impact?  Provide clean
water?  Rotavirus vaccination? Wait, I have it! Let’s give random homeopathic
medications to the children in the slums of Nicaragua and compare it to placebo 
and see if it helps their diarrhea.  Treatment of acute childhood diarrhea with 
homeopathic medicine: a randomized clinical trial in Nicaragua did just that.

So what did they use for treatments of diarrhea and why (besides normal
hydration)?

Who had oversight on this study? From the paper:

   Informed consent was obtained from the parent or guardian using a
   disclosure statement that had been approved by the human subjects review
   committee of the University of Washington.”

One third of Nicaraguans are illiterate and only half get a fifth grade
education. I would think, obviously erroneously, University of Washington would 
recognize that the parents of children in Nicaraguan slums may not have the
background to understand informed consent or the essential irrationality, er,
science,  of homeopathic nostrums, and one would hope that the University  of
Washington would be interested in protecting those who cannot protect
themselves.   Evidently not, since their faculty continues to export magic to
vulnerable  children and adults in third world countries. Not yet ethically
Tuskegee level research, but they are working on it.

I understand that one persons lapse in medical and scientific understanding is
another’s opportunity for a nationally syndicated television show, but they
might have well piled the money spent on the study and burned it for all the
good it did the subjects and the medical literature.  At least they could have
used the heat to pasteurize some milk.

Homeopaths Without Borders. Or sense.

   Men never do bad medicine so completely and cheerfully as when they do it
   from a homeopathic conviction.

   BLAISE PASCAL. Kind of.

Doctors Without Borders,  also known as Médecins Sans Frontières, is an
organization that sends physicians to some of the most needy parts of the world.
Using the style, but not the substance of Doctors without Borders, is
Homeopaths without Borders, or, as the RationalWiki called it, Médecins Sans
Médicaments.  Their goal is to send homeopathic care to those in need.  Based in
Florida, it appears to be the work of one homeopath and almost all its work is 
in Haiti.

   “the poor health of the people here is striking. So many girls and women 
   have vaginal infections. So many children have infected cuts. So many men
   have reddened eyes, rotten teeth, and injuries that are healing badly. The
   nurses and docs here are as dedicated as anywhere else, but they lack
   supplies, and they don’t have medicines.”

They need help.  Shall we provide money for antibiotics? Dental Care? Good
nutrition?  Clean water?

So lets supply them with water, and not even enough to wash those infected cuts.
I have to admit this brings conflicting emotions.  I have to admire anyone who
will take the time to go to a disaster like Haiti and work to help those in
need.  On the other hand, they offer nothing but false hope and magic, so cannot
make the lives of Haitians any better. Time, money and resources, which could
be used so much more productively, wasted.  I see many patients who have pissed 
away their lives and opportunity with heroin or alcohol or other bad choices.

   “Look, if you had one shot, or one opportunity

   To seize everything you ever wanted-One moment

   Would you capture it or just let it slip?

   Give effective therapy or a homeopathy? “

   M. Mather. Sort of.

Wasted opportunities always inspires angst. So does Médecins Sans Médicaments.

It does show how powerful delusional states can be for believers of nonsense,
since as RationalWiki states “Essentially, they go to nations with sub-standard 
healthcare, and dilute it even more to make it 10-430 times as good as the
healthcare in wealthier nations.”

PanAfrican Acupuncture Project

   The evil that is in the world almost always comes of ignorance, and good 
   intentions may do as much harm as malevolence if they lack understanding.

   ALBERT CAMUS, The Plague

How best to spend very limited resources and maximize the health in Uganda,
where AIDS, malaria, and Tb are endemic and have devastated the country? 
Mosquito nets and condoms would be a good start to prevent these blood and
mosquito borne illnesses.  Naw.  That might actually improve peoples lives.  Or 
we could use acupuncture instead:

   “The PanAfrican Acupuncture Project trains healthcare workers in Africa
   to use simple and effective acupuncture techniques that enable them to treat 
   the devastating and debilitating symptoms associated with HIV/AIDS, malaria, 
   and TB.”

Again, I do admire the urge to go to Africa and help others.  They ask for
donations and trainers on the website, expecting the trainers to provide their
own airfare and $3,000 (aka 300 mosquito nets) to cover their own costs.  No
small commitment. Of course, they provide a vulnerable population worthless
magic, and I can only imagine what four grand could provide for clean water or
malaria nets, interventions  that would actually benefit the Ugandans.

But what is scary is the web page.  Uganda is rife with HIV, which is spread,
by, hmmmm, lets see, sex, blood and needles. Unsterilized needles.  In Africa,
reuse of needles has been common, often due to lack of resources for
sterilization, and has helped to spread HIV and perhaps other infectious
diseases. So they have photos of people sticking needles into patients who could
and do have HIV. Not a glove to be seen. Remember that blood borne illnesses
are spread with acupuncture needles: Hepatitis B, hepatitis C and, rarely in the
West, HIV.  It is rare to spread these diseases where good technique is
followed scrupulously.  Poor societies are not known for the resources that
allow them to fastidiously take care of proper cleaning.  Would anyone besides
me worry that some acupuncture needles have a chance of being reused after
poking an HIV positive patient?

As best as I can tell from the website, they are training people to potentially 
spread HIV between patients when and if sterilization breaks down and placing
the acupuncturist at small, but real, risk should a needle stick injury occur.  
The have trained over 100 local acupuncturists and hope to spread acupuncture,
and the occasional blood borne viral illness, beyond Uganda to other African
countries.  No benefit and all risk. The PanAfrican Acupuncture Project may have
a commitment to philanthropy, but I am not convinced they have a commitment to 
preventing disease transmission.

   “Give me your tired, your poor,

   Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,

   The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.

   Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,

   I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”

   And waste their resources and health with CAM.

   Emma Lazarus, 1883

There are Chiropractors Without Borders and Naturopaths Without Borders who have
three principles:

  1. Health care is a human right for all, not a privilege for the few.

  2. Everyone deserves the best healthcare, regardless of finances.

  3. Naturopathic Medicine is well suited for resource-poor settings.

Unfortunately, the third has no relationship to the first two.

There is Reiki Without Borders and Herbalists without Borders fortunately for
the third world,  all seem to be the work of a few individuals, although Haiti
appears to be the common destination.  Poor Haitians. They really need a border.

The West has a long and sordid history of exporting disaster to the third world.
It is nice to know that sCAMsters,  even if only a very small subset, are
continuing the time honored tradition of maltreatment of indigenous peoples in
the name of helping them.

Fortunately there are doctors, nurses, engineers, teachers, chemists and
scientists without borders, who can offer substantive help.  Even Clowns without
Borders would have something to offer, although not for everyone.

   People aren’t either wicked or noble. They’re like chef’s salads, with
   good things and bad things chopped and mixed together in a vinaigrette of
   confusion and conflict and alternative medicine.

   DANIEL HANDLER (as Lemony Snicket). Sort of.

                   You. You. Who are you calling a You You? 

                                  Mark Crislip

                                      Link

The YOU Docs, for those of you (YOU?) who are unaware, are Doctors Mehmet Oz and
Mike Roizen, authors of books about YOU and a weekly newspaper column called
The YOU Docs. It’s all about YOU.

There are two areas of the knowledge where I have more than passing
understanding: infectious diseases and sCAMs. It always concerns me when I read 
nonsense in the few areas where I have some expertise. I have to wonder about
the validity of other information in the paper like war and the economy. You
know, important stuff. It could probably be argued that since the YOU Docs are
in the “How We Live” section, the same section that carries horoscopes, the
movie and TV reviews, the weather report — the fiction section — it should not
taken seriously. After all, it is usually adjacent to the People’s Pharmacist,
and my father always told me that you can judge a person by the company they
keep.

The YOU Docs had a column with the headline: “Research backs acupuncture for a
range of ills“. More fiction? Research backs acupuncture? News to me, but they
are, after all, YOU Docs, and therefore may have information not accessible to
mere docs with a small ‘d’. I grant up front to the authors that it is hard to
be rigorous, or even coherent, in a 452 word essay. I am over 3,200 words for
this entry. There are also no references, so I have to assume I found the
correct research mentioned by the hints in the text.

They start with the usual appeal to antiquity:

   Acupuncture has been around a long, long time: Archeologists have
   unearthed 5,000-year-old stone needles in Inner Mongolia.

If it is old, it must be efficacious. People would not use ineffective
treatments for centuries, would they? This, of course, assumes that the Chinese,
and other ancient healing modalities, had at their disposal an organized,
consistent way to keep track of data to judge the efficacy of a therapy. While
the use of acupuncture may stretch into antiquity, clinical and epidemiologic
studies from ancient times are non-existent. The ancients only had anecdotes to 
guide them, and if there is no other lesson to be learned from SBM, the three
most dangerous words in medicine remain “in my experience.”

One indirect way to evaluate the benefits of acupuncture and Chinese medicine in
general is life expectancy. In 1900 it was 30 years. Good job traditional
Chinese medicine. Now life expectancy is 71. Why?

“This can be attributed to the advancement of science and technology, especially
in medical science,” said Zhao Baohua, vice-director of China Association for
Aged People.

Goodness gracious. Reductionist Western Medicine more than doubling life
expectancy. If only they had relied on acupuncture, perhaps population control
would not have become such an important issue in the Peoples Republic.

As an aside, I cannot find anything but secondary references about the
5,000-year-old stone needles used for acupuncture. How it is ascertained that
these needles were not used for sewing and were in fact used for acupuncture I
cannot discover. A 5000-year-old package insert? I find one argument that these 
5,000-year-old needles were used as scalpels and not for acupuncture.

The YOU Docs proceed to

But we like this popular form of energy medicine because it’s backed by an
impressive body of 21st-century research. Energy medicine? Yes, it seems to
change the electric currents or nerve impulses in your body.

That is what is nice about alternative medicine, a lack of consistency in
terminology. Usually the term ‘Energy Therapy’ refers to energies that no one
has ever measured, not altering nerve conduction. The NCCAM definitions are as
good as any:

   Energy Medicine

   Energy therapies involve the use of energy fields. They are of two types:

   Biofield therapies are intended to affect energy fields that purportedly 
   surround and penetrate the human body. The existence of such fields has not
   yet been scientifically proven. Some forms of energy therapy manipulate
   biofields by applying pressure and/or manipulating the body by placing the
   hands in, or through, these fields. Examples include qi gong, Reiki, and
   Therapeutic Touch.

   Bioelectromagnetic-based therapies involve the unconventional use of
   electromagnetic fields, such as pulsed fields, magnetic fields, or
   alternating-current or direct-current fields.

Usually I do not think of nerve impulses as being part of energy therapy, but
that just may be me.

So as I am given to understand the YOU Docs, the mechanism of action of
acupuncture is to alter nerve impulses. It would also suggest, then, that the
cause of the diseases treated by acupuncture is due to altered nerve impulses,
or perhaps the acupuncturist is only treating symptoms and not the underlying
disease. All those diseases treated by one intervention that alters nerve
conduction. And I thought aspirin was the wonder drug that works wonders. The
YOU Docs have a different understanding of physiology than I learned at school.

What is the data to support the effect of acupuncture on diseases and symptoms
by altering nerve conduction? It would be simple enough. Pick a disease or
symptom. Nerve impulse measured before treatment. Acupuncture. Resolution of
disease or symptom. Nerve impulse altered.

There is one study, small (which I could not get before the post went up), that 
demonstrates this effect in diabetic neuropathy. There are studies that show
alterations in nerve function in rats and MRI studies that show CNS changes with
acupuncture. But the simple temporal relationship that would suggest a cause
and effect does not exist for any other process treated by acupuncture.

BTW: electroacupuncture doesn’t count as acupuncture for the purpose of this
discussion. That is not acupuncture as defined in the article. To the best of my
understanding the ancient Chinese lacked electricity.

   This therapy involves inserting hair-thin needles into specific points on
   the body to treat countless problems, ranging from easing chronic pain and
   insomnia to reducing the side effects of cancer treatments and helping
   smokers quit.

Note “specific points.” A consistent result of recent acupuncture studies is
that the effects of acupuncture do not depend on where the needles are placed or
even if the needles break the skin. I realize that it is a short article, but
we are only a few paragraphs in and it appears the YOU Docs lack a good command 
of the literature concerning acupuncture. I may be picky, but precision of
understanding is important in medicine. You wouldn’t want your, oh, I don’t
know, heart surgeon to say, “We are going to bypass one of your arteries,
somewhere there in your chest.”

As to smoking cessation? Not so much.

   The significant short-term effect was lost with the random-effects model 
   for pooling, or by removing the outlying study that led to heterogeneity. The
   long-term result shows no effect of acupuncture compared with sham
   acupuncture. There was no consistent evidence that acupuncture is superior to
   no treatment, and no evidence that the effect of acupuncture was different
   from that of other anti-smoking interventions, or that any particular
   acupuncture technique is superior to other techniques.

The YOU Docs go on to give specific examples of acupuncture efficacy, managing, 
with awesome consistency, to get it wrong every time. I come to this with a
slightly unforgiving attitude. I am a specialist. What defines a specialist is, 
in part, is mastery, or an attempt at mastery, of the relevant medical
literature. I also work in a teaching hospital. I expect my residents and
medical students, when reading a paper, to get the basic concepts of the paper
correct and understand some the nuance of the papers they read. It is expected
that the teaching attendings, when quoting the literature, will get it right,
understand the nuance of the medical literature, and not cherry pick.

   Just months ago, a Hong Kong University study of 60 insomniacs found
   those who got acupuncture fell asleep faster and were more likely to stay
   that way than those who got a fake version of the treatment.

I guess they are referring to “Electroacupuncture for primary insomnia: a
randomized controlled trial” which, while not being acupuncture, does meet the
criteria as mentioned for being the correct reference.

The authors conclusion of the study?

   MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS: Self-reported questionnaires, 1-week sleep
   diaries, and 3-day actigraphy were collected at baseline and 1 week after
   treatment. The Insomnia Severity Index was used as the primary outcome
   measure. Both groups showed significant improvement compared with the
   pretreatment baseline. One-way analysis of covariance adjusted for baseline
   scores showed that there were significantly greater improvements in sleep
   efficiency by sleep diary and actigraphy in the electroacupuncture group.
   However, no significant between-group differences were observed in the
   Insomnia Severity Index and other outcome measures. The proportions of
   subjects having less than 30 minutes of wake after sleep onset and a sleep
   efficiency of at least 85% at the posttreatment visit were significantly
   higher in the electroacupuncture group. All adverse events were mild in
   severity.

   CONCLUSION: We found a slight advantage of electroacupuncture over
   placebo acupuncture in the short-term treatment of primary insomnia. Because 
   of some limitations of the current study, further studies are necessary to
   verify the effectiveness of acupuncture for insomnia.

Not exactly a ringing endorsement of acupuncture for insomnia.

Of interest there is another acupuncture study for insomnia that used sham
acupuncture and it was equally unimpressive.

   RESULTS: No statistically significant differences were observed between
   the groups relating to parameters associated with the definition of insomnia.
   The treatment group experienced that it was easier to wake up in the morning
   compared with the control group (repeated-measures analysis of variance, p =
   0.04). Both groups showed a statistically significant recovery in subjective
   sleep parameters during the study period (weeks 1-6) compared with baseline 
   values (week 0).

   CONCLUSIONS: Only modest evidence was found supporting the hypothesis
   that AAT may have an effect on insomnia. Least improvements were found in
   total sleep time and number of awakenings, 2 parameters directly associated
   with the definition of insomnia. AAT may have a role in the treatment of
   insomnia, especially in combination with other treatments such as cognitive
   behavioral therapy. This study provides an example of how to perform studies 
   using alternative therapies for sleep disorders.

Funny. The treatment group woke up easier and that was a benefit for those
suffering from insomnia how?

One difference between the two insomnia studies was that the second study used
auricular acupuncture. They stuck the needles in the ear. So what nerve or
nerves associated with sleep would warrant sticking needles in the ear in one
study and sticking them in another site in a different study. According to the
YOU Docs the needles were supposed to be placed in ‘specific sites’. What
anatomy and physiology could the two studies have in common? Maybe in this
context specific refers to anywhere on the patient. Or I am I trying to find a
logical consistency with tooth fairy science?

And, as a final note, a Cochrane review of acupuncture and insomnia says

   The small number of randomized controlled trials, together with the poor 
   methodological quality and significant clinical heterogeneity, means that the
   current evidence is not sufficiently extensive or rigorous to support the
   use of any form of acupuncture for the treatment of insomnia.

The YOU Docs say “We like this popular form of energy medicine because it’s
backed by an impressive body of 21st-century research.”

I guess it doesn’t take much to impress the YOU Docs. Actually, the totality of 
acupuncture studies are impressive in the same way a large pig farm can be
impressive.

The YOU Docs continue.

   Arthritis relief: British researchers who analyzed five well-designed
   studies of 1,334 people with bum knees have confirmed that acupuncture
   relieves debilitating joint pain related to arthritis.

What made these studies ‘well designed’? If the authors considered the
acupuncture to be adequate it was well designed:

   we defined acupuncture as ‘adequate’ if it consisted of at least six
   treatments, at least one per week, with at least four points needled for each
   painful knee for at least 20 min, and either needle sensation (de qi)
   achieved in manual acupuncture, or electrical stimulation of sufficient
   intensity to produce more than minimal sensation.

The definition was, it seems, mostly based on the authors’ opinion. The
references do not suggest the definition is derived from rigorous testing. There
is, by the way, no interest in whether the same specific points are used, just 
that a sufficiency of needles were used. There is more to a well-defined study
than the authors opinion as to what constitutes adequacy of a clinical trial.
How about sample size, blinding, etc.? Multiple needles would lead to one
adequate outcome.

How good was the pain control? As the authors state in the discussion,

   The size of the effect on pain was not dramatic: recalculating the data
   as standardized mean difference, the effect size compared to sham acupuncture
   is 0.4 which is considered ‘moderate’

Another ringing endorsement for the efficacy of acupuncture.

The Annals of Internal Medicine meta-analysis of acupuncture for knee pain comes
to an alternative conclusion.

   Sham-controlled trials show clinically irrelevant short-term benefits of 
   acupuncture for treating knee osteoarthritis. Waiting list-controlled trials 
   suggest clinically relevant benefits, some of which may be due to placebo or 
   expectation.

Given the great heterogeneity in the studies of acupuncture and arthritis one
can probably come to any conclusion you desire if you pick the right subsets of 
studies. Another group of British scientists (they call themselves Oxford
Scientists) did a systematic review of systematic reviews of acupuncture and
concluded:

   Qualified support for acupuncture was originally reported in 12 out of 35
   systematic reviews, and strong support was found in another six. Applying
   stricter inclusion criteria, however, showed that none of the 35 reviews
   supported acupuncture, predominantly because there were too few patients in
   the randomized, double blind studies. Six reviews with more than 200 patients
   in randomized, double blind studies had good evidence of no benefit.
   Systematic reviews of acupuncture have overstated effectiveness by including 
   studies likely to be biased. They provide no robust evidence that acupuncture
   works for any indication.

I guess the Oxford Scientists don’t know an adequate trial when they see one.

The YOU Docs continue:

   Squelching pain: In a landmark German study of 1,162 back-pain sufferers,
   twice as many got relief from acupuncture as from conventional fixes such as
   drugs or physical therapy. Acupuncture also has been proved at least as
   effective as pain drugs not only for treating migraines, but for preventing
   them, too.

This refers to the Archives of Internal Medicine where back pain patients had
‘real’ acupuncture, fake acupuncture or standard care. The sham acupuncture was 
twirling a toothpick on the skin. Really.

The ‘real’ acupuncture (both individualized and standardized placement of
needles, that pesky need for ‘specific’ acupuncture points keeps disappearing)
and the toothpick had the same improvement in pain.

Would you conclude that this is a landmark study showing the efficacy of
acupuncture or conclude that whatever led to the pain improvement, it was not
specific to acupuncture? Or do twirled toothpicks alter nerve conduction? If
treatment and placebo have the same effect, one usually concludes that the
treatment doth not work. Unless you never bothered to read past the press
release.

Also, in the ‘landmark’ study

   Rates of adverse experiences differed by treatment group: 6 of 157
   participants for individualized acupuncture, 6 of 158 for standardized
   acupuncture, and 0 of 162 for simulated acupuncture.

So if you were an ethical doctor who reads the literature carefully, if offered 
two treatments of equal efficacy but one treatment had no side effects, would
you not choose the treatment with the least side effects? If you are going to
offer advice based on a landmark study, and want to maximize efficacy and
minimize side effects, how could you not recommend twirled toothpicks as the
acupuncture modality of choice?

Migraines? The Cochrane review, if you want to believe them, demonstrated

   Fourteen trials compared a ‘true’ acupuncture intervention with a variety
   of sham interventions. Pooled analyses did not show a statistically
   significant superiority for true acupuncture for any outcome in any of the
   time windows, but the results of single trials varied considerably. Four
   trials compared acupuncture to proven prophylactic drug treatment. Overall in
   these trials acupuncture was associated with slightly better outcomes and
   fewer adverse effects than prophylactic drug treatment.

When compared to sham acupuncture, ‘real’ acupuncture is no better for
migraines. Do you get the impression that acupuncture is no more than an
elaborate, nonspecific placebo effect and only has results with subjective
endpoints and only clinically irrelevant short-term benefits?

The YOU Docs go on (with an increasing lack of confidence in the authors. If I
can find so much in error in a few short paragraphs, why bother to read on? I do
it for you. But not YOU. My caps lock is not stuck).

   Reducing treatment side effects: Dozens of studies show acupuncture helps
   quell pain, nausea, fatigue, hot flashes and dry mouth in cancer patients
   undergoing chemotherapy, radiation or both.

And dozens do not.

   Three RCTs compared the effects of manual acupuncture with sham
   acupuncture. One RCT showed favorable effects of acupuncture in reducing hot 
   flash frequency, while other two RCTs failed to do so.

or

   There was no difference between combined acupuncture and acupressure
   treatment at P6 and at the sham point for the nausea score.

Just where is this “impressive body of 21st-century research” supporting
acupuncture? Acupuncture research is mostly a collection of poorly done studies 
that demonstrate marginal effect and a few definitive studies that show no
efficacy. The body of 21st century research does not support acupuncture, at
least if you bother to acquaint yourself with the details of the studies. As a
rule of thumb, when there are multiple studies hovering around efficacious, some
showing benefit and others not, it is unlikely that any clinically relevant
effect is occurring.

   “How can one therapy do so much?”

Well, because it doesn’t.

   Eastern and Western medical philosophies merge when a licensed
   acupuncturist inserts those sterile, disposable needles into your skin.

The needles may be sterile, but the photographs all too often show the bare
fingers right at the insertion site. Search Google images of acupuncture. If you
like sterile technique, the photos will give you the heebe jebees. Looking at
Google images it is not surprising that there was at least one reported outbreak
of MRSA due to poor technique. Acupuncture technique evidently doesn’t bother
itself with the impressive body of 21st-century research on germ theory and
infection control.

The YOU Docs conclude

   You don’t have to believe in it for acupuncture to work. Case in point:
   Veterinarians know that acupuncture often helps ailing horses, goats, cats
   and dogs (including Titan, the world’s biggest Great Dane) in measurable
   ways, such as being able to walk and run again. With animals, there’s no
   placebo effect. It either works or it doesn’t. Same for people. Many
   skeptical people who’ve tried acupuncture as a last resort become believers
   when they see results.

I am not as well versed in veterinary literature, although I cannot imagine that
acupuncture should be any less effective in animals than it is in humans. As
one review suggests “on the basis of the findings of this systematic review,
there is no compelling evidence to recommend or reject acupuncture for any
condition in domestic animals.” Why the lack of a firm conclusion? “The
methodologic quality of these trials was variable but, on average, was low.”

I guess only the YOU Docs find the veterinary research part of an “impressive
body of 21st-century research.” The authors of the review did not. I will refer 
you Dr. Ramey for reviews on animal acupuncture and animal placebo for a more
expert evaluation.

“It either works or it doesn’t. Same for people.” For acupuncture, it’s the
latter. That statement, from the YOU Docs, is as simple a dismissal of evidence 
and scientific based medicine I have ever read. Anecdote rules!

In the end I am left wondering.

Did the YOU Docs read the references and not understand them?

Did the YOU Docs read the references and choose to interpret them in an original
way to ensure that the conclusion ‘acupuncture works’?

   “You keep using that phrase. I do not think it means what you think it
   means.” – Inigo Montoya.

Did the YOU Docs not read the references and relied on second hand reports?

It is a good thing the YOU Docs are not rotating on my service this month. Such 
scholarship would be difficult to award a passing grade, even for a 452 word
essay, since it was wrong about almost every specific. However, I am one of the 
grumpy, old school docs who expect MDs to get it right, even if limited to 452
words.

Addendum

I am ever so proud that I made no L. Frank Baum references for this entry. But
allow me to recommend Wicked, the Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the
West. I read it right after I having read the Wizard of Oz to my eldest. The
sequels are awful and the musical is worse, but Wicked is a wonderful book.

                                    Sky Maul

                                  Mark Crislip

                                      Link

The worst part of flying is the take off and landing. Not that I am nervous
about those parts of the trip, it is that I am all electronic. Once I have to
turn off my electronic devices, all I am left with is my own thoughts or what is
in the seat pocket in front of me. Since there is nothing to be gained from
quiet introspection, I am stuck with either the in-flight magazine or SkyMall. I
usually choose the latter. SkyMall, for those of you who do not fly, is a
collection of catalogs bound in one volume. I have occasionally purchased
products found in SkyMall and thumb through it with mild interest.

This time one product caught my eye, the Aculife home acupuncture/acupressure
device. I had never noticed the ‘health’-related products in SkyMall before,
usually looking for electronic gadgets that I really do not need. I was curious.
How many other products besides Aculife are in the catalogue? According to the 
interwebs, about 100,000,000 Americans fly every year and well over half a
billion people world wide. A lot of people can potentially look at SkyMall,
including the occasional skeptic.

I have written about the many styles of acupuncture in the past: hand and foot
and tongue and ear and head and Chinese and Japanese. So many meridians and
acupuncture points, how does the body find room for it all? Aculife makes it all
simple. It’s all gauche, er, I mean in the left hand.

According to makers of Aculife, you can now “help strengthen your health with
the latest ancient technology.” Of course I can, and for $199.95 I had better be
able to.

It is an interesting diagram they produce showing where the acupuncture/Aculife 
acupoints are. Touch one with the probe and if abnormal, flip a switch and give 
a little electric current to re-balance the qi. The points recommended with
Aculife do not, as best I can tell, correspond very well with the diagrams on
the interwebs for ‘classic’ forms of hand acupuncture, so we have yet another
collection of acupoints and another style of acupuncture.

Some points are both odd and worrisome: there is a point for breast tumor, one
for high blood pressure, one for chest pain and one for coffee ground emesis.
Coffee ground emesis is what we in the medicine business refer to when bleeding 
in the stomach that has time to coagulate before vomiting. Acid plus blood
equals a gamish that looks like coffee grounds (except for the time as an intern
I was called to the psych unit to evaluate coffee ground emesis that I
eventually determined was due to the fact the patient was eating coffee grounds 
out of the garbage). These are all serious medical symptoms or problems that
could easily lead to mortality and significant morbidity if someone were to use 
Aculife to treat their angina or stomach bleeding or, curiously, enteric fever. 
There is a point for Salmonella typhi, also known as enteric fever or typhoid
fever. Why this infection gets its own acupuncture point, since it is rare in
the US, and a more common infection like MRSA does not, I cannot elucidate.

There are two hearts (for Klingons?), one cardiac area, and an area for left and
right ventricle and atrium, all of which are separate from chest pain and rapid
heart beat. Gallbladder, gallstone and inflamed gall bladder are in different
places. The blood sugar and diabetes points are on different part of the hand,
unless it is diabetes insipidus they are pointing to. It is so confusing.

One of the many reasons I am not a surgeon, besides having zero hand-eye
coordination, is that I found gross anatomy difficult. Cadaver innards are
nothing compared to the anatomy that sits on the left hand of Aculife. What, I
wonder, sits on the right hand?

Fortunately, despite having points for tumors, rapid heart beat and bleeding,
the device comes with the following:

   WARNING: Do not use if pregnant, have a pacemaker or suffer from
   malignant tumors, excessive bleeding or tuberculosis. Not to be used by
   children under the age of 3.

An odd collection of contraindications. Tuberculosis? OK for the use S. typhi
but not TB? I wonder why. I can understand a contraindication for pacemakers
since the device applies current, but Tb? It seems so random. I am obviously
missing the deeper understanding of disease provided by Aculife.

The advertisement also says “FDA approved.” Searching the FDA site it appears
the Aculife has a 510 (k). A 510 (k) evidently means the FDA has cleared a
product for sale, but makes no claim as to efficacy and as I understand the
Byzantine language at the FDA, the 510 (k) is used to classify a device’s
potential safety, but not how safe it actually is. The Aculife is a class 2
device, “These devices pose a moderate level of risk to the user.” According to 
devicewatch.org, it is evidently not legal to advertise a 510(k) cleared device 
as “FDA-approved.” If there is more to the Aculife FDA approval, I cannot find
it at the FDA.

The FDA submission available at FDA.gov says that Aculife is intended for “use
in the practice of acupuncture by qualified practitioners of acupuncture as
determined by states.” So I should not purchase Aculife since I am not a
qualified practitioner?

There is a listing of state acupuncture licensure requirements and most States
appear to require a NCCAOM examination in acupuncture as a minimum
qualification. I wonder if the FDA submissions cover the widespread marketing to
anyone who flies in an airplane? The ad says “Be your own acupuncturist.
Diagnose and heal yourself and your family.” Not the requirements for being
qualified acupuncturist in Oregon, but the qualification granted by purchasing
an Aculife is probably no worse than the results of “real” acupuncture training 
and taking the exam, and certainly less expensive. I would be willing to grant
anyone who uses an Aculife the title Qualified Acupuncture Practitioner,
regardless of State regulations. I am also King of the Moon, and anyone who uses
therapeutic moon rays is, as a result, a qualified homeopathic practitioner.
Who can gainsay my authority and claim?

The SkyMall site also gives the best reason yet for using acupuncture:

   Ötzi, a 5,000 year old mummy found in the Alps during 1991, has spurred a
   whole new vigor into modern research of the Ancient Chinese medical practice
   of acupuncture. Recent examinations of the mummy found that Otzi has a
   number of tattoos that coincide with acupuncture points that would be used to
   treat various ailments from which he was suffering.

Ötzi’s tattoos, by the way, were not on the hands so how they relate to the
Aculife is uncertain.

   Ötzi had several carbon tattoos including groups of short, parallel,
   vertical lines to both sides of the lumbar spine, a cruciform mark behind the
   right knee, and various marks around both ankles.

Puh-lease. Compare the tattoos on the iceman to any acupuncture map, and it
would not be hard to find a correspondence between any random tattoo and an
acupuncture point.

I noted in the shower this morning that some of the freckles on my left arm are 
close to acupuncture points and when connected with a Sharpie, closely follow a 
meridian. Lest you think that these are random melanin spots and melanin can’t
‘know’ where acupuncture sites are, melanin may be able to sense the power
flowing in these meridians, like lay lines in the earth, and coalesce to guide
future medical interventions. I once had a patient with an Omaya reservoir
placed in the scalp so he could have amphotericin B injected directly into his
spinal fluid to treat a fungal meningitis. The spot where we had to access the
reservoir was right at a freckle on his scalp. Coincidence? I think not.

The tattoos on the mummy were not even points, but lines. As the Ötzi site says

   The Iceman’s body is covered with over 50 tattoos in the form of groups
   of lines and crosses. Unlike modern tattooing methods, the tattoos were not
   produced with needles but by means of fine incisions into which charcoal was 
   rubbed. Interestingly, Ötzi’s tattoos are located at points where his body
   was subjected to considerable strain during his lifetime and very probably
   caused him a lot of pain due to wear. The tattoos were therefore probably
   intended as therapeutic measures rather than as symbols.

What part of a Neolithic man was not “subjected to considerable strain during
his lifetime”? Or mine, I am not Neolithic and at 53 I feel more like the Tin
Man everyday.

   One or several groups of vertical lines are located to the left and right
   of the spinal column, on the left calf, on the left instep and one the inner
   and outer ankle joint, two lines cross the left wrist, a cross-shaped mark
   appears on the back of the right knee and besides the left Achilles tendon.
   The Iceman had therefore undergone pain-relieving treatment on multiple
   occasions. Astonishingly, the tattooed areas correspond to skin acupuncture
   lines Before Ötzi it was thought that this treatment had only originated two 
   thousand years later in Asia.

What is astonishing is that this nonsense comes from the Museum responsible for 
the evaluation of Ötzi, the Ötzi Museum.

Why would they report such speculation as fact? Probably in part thanks to the
Lancet, which published what had to be the goofiest article ever in a major
medical journal. As always, when I make a claim someone in the comments will
suggest an example of something worse. I wait with breathless anticipation.

The Lancet has always had a reputation of a good journal that was always willing
to publish results that may be a bit outside the box. Sometimes that is good
and spurs further investigations. But given the ubiquity of acupuncture sites,
anything placed on the skin could be near a acupuncture point. I have on my
right palm, about a centimeter down from the webbing between the first and
second finger an inadvertent tattoo. In second grade I had a piece of pencil
lead accidentally jammed into my hand and the point was left behind. It is right
at the cough and bronchitis point for Chinese acupuncture, the liver point of
Korean acupuncture and near one of the many cardiac points of the Aculife. It is
the eye point for colorpuncture and the chest/lung/upper back or thymus point, 
depending on which reflexologist you believe. That is one busy piece of carbon, 
deposited at such an energetically active intersection. I wonder what effects it
has on my health.

What did they do in the Lancet ‘report’?

Because some of the tattoos on Ötzi are simple linear geometric shapes and
located on less visible parts of the body they must not be decorative but of
medical significance. Really. They know the mind of a 5500 year corpse. Why are 
they not religious symbols with no medical significance. Or maybe he was a
neolithic punk.

I suppose if he had an ornate tramp stamp it would be recognized as medical as
well, since no one routinely sees the small of the back and it could not
possibly be ornamental. I see a fair number of homemade tat’s in the sociopathic
populations of the US and I would not consider these to be decorative either.
They must be medical. But from this unwarranted supposition, fertilizer is made.

The Ötzi museum says there are over 50 tat’s on the iceman. They thought 15 were
near acupuncture sites. I wonder it you randomly threw 50 darts at a full sized
outline of a human, how many would land near an acupuncture point? I bet more
than 15.

After noting that the tat’s on the iceman could very well have moved in the last
several thousand years from desiccation and skin movement (they presume they
moved farther rather than closer to acupuncture sites), they measure the
distance from the tat’s to the classic points. The distance ranged from 0 to 7
mm with an average of 2 mm. That seems like a random distribution to me. And
these are line tat’s, so there is a lot of leeway in deciding how far from an
acupuncture point they are. The Lancet paper does not mention if the distance
measured is to the start, end, or middle of the line.

Like seeing bunnies in clouds, they see a pattern:

   The tattoos…possibly as a guide to self-treatment marking where to
   puncture when pain occur. The fact that not randomly selected points were
   marked by tattoos, seems especially intriguing. From an acupuncturists
   viewpoint, the combination of points represents a meaningful therapeutic
   regimen.

Of course, acupuncturists believe in acupuncture, so they may be a wee bit
biased. They conclude with a statement that would be right at home in Medical
Hypothesis,

   The above findings provide strong evidence that a form of medical
   therapeutics, very similar to what we know as Chinese acupuncture, was
   already in practice 5200 years ago in Central Europe.

This is not molehills into mountains but a grain of sand into a tectonic range. 
Now I am inclined to cut the authors some slack, since the paper was published
in 1999. The last decade of acupuncture clinical trials have demonstrated that
acupuncture points do not matter (they are pointless). It matters not where you 
place the needles or even if you use needles; toothpick twirling is just as
good. All that matters is the patient believe they are having acupuncture
performed to get, at best, a clinically negligible analgesic response to
acupuncture.

I would have expected that current research into tat’s and mummies would take
into account the state of the art of medical research. Not so, for it appears
that tattoos as acupuncture points may be a meme for the gullible
anthropologist, or at least one who doesn’t bother to read the literature before
coming to a conclusion.

   The 1000-year-old female mummy was found unwrapped in the sand of the
   desert at Chiribaya Alta in southern Peru in the early 1990s. She bears two
   distinct types of tattoos: emblems representing birds, apes, reptiles and
   other symbols cover her hands, arm and lower left leg, while an asymmetric
   pattern of overlapping circles is present on her neck.

What might those tat’s on the neck represent? Body art? Religious symbols? An
emblem to ward off vampires? A landing zone for hickeys? Are they evidence of
Ancient Astronauts like the Nazca lines? More reasonable solutions that the one 
proffered by the author:

   Pabst points out that the circles are close to Chinese acupuncture
   points. She says that tattooing a person at these points could have worked in
   a similar way to how acupuncture is thought to work.

Since acupuncture doesn’t work there is no need to postulate that the tat is
there for the same reason.

I think they all have it wrong. Look carefully at the location of the tattoo
points. There mark the intersections of the webbing on Spiderman’s costume.
These are not acupuncture points, but rather reflect the ability of both Ötzi
and the Peruvian mummy to see into the future imaginings of Stan Lee. I think it
makes as much sense based on the data.

It turns out that ignoring science and the scientific method may be the wave of 
the future in anthropology.

   A new long-range plan for the American Anthropological Association that
   omits the word “science” from the organization’s vision for its future has
   exposed fissures in the discipline.

That explains it. Wild extrapolations based on minimal information is so much
easier than carefully constructed conclusions based on data.

I was originally going to discuss the Head Spa Massager, the X5 HairLaser and
others, but the Aculife took me down many unexpected pathways and I am the
slowest writer at SBM. They did have numerous cool gadgets and products on
SkyMall. Me? I really want Voldemort’s wand and the One ring. Both work using
the same mechanism as acupuncture and mummy medical tattoo’s. I have ordered
them and soon I will be invincible.

Acupuncturist Complains About Wikipedia

An acupuncturist complains about Wikipedia, saying it is under the control of
self-styled skeptics who bias the content and bully anyone who disagrees. She
only demonstrates her own bias; Wikipedia had good reason to ban her from
editing.

Harriet Hall on May 16, 2017

Link


Acupuncturist Mel Hopper Koppelman published an article titled “WikiTweaks: The 
Encyclopedia that Anyone (Who is a Skeptic) Can Edit,” in The Journal of Chinese
Medicine No. 113, p 35-7, February 2017. The article is behind a paywall but
the abstract says:

   This article documents recent attempts to update the Acupuncture page on
   Wikipedia with current scientific knowledge, and describes how such pages are
   presently controlled by self-styled skeptics, who prevent anyone else from
   editing them, thus ensuring the information conforms to their own biased and 
   skeptical beliefs. The author provides key research papers and mainstream
   medical guidelines from around the world in order to provide acupuncture
   practitioners with robust evidence that can be used to counter biased and
   unfounded claims about acupuncture.

This abstract is misleading. She never actually tried to update the Acupuncture 
page. She presents no evidence that the editors she interacted with are
“self-styled skeptics.” Her belief that anyone or any group can “control”
Wikipedia pages is a delusion and a conspiracy theory. And what she provides is 
not “robust evidence” but cherry-picked studies and faulty reasoning. She is the
one who is biased.

What does the article really say?

I have read the full article, and I’ll try to summarize Koppelman’s arguments.

The introductory paragraph reveals her bias: “The growing realisation by the
public that the reliance on pharmaceuticals and invasive interventions for
complex chronic health conditions is often ineffective and carries significant
risk. (Null et al., 2005) means that patients are researching alternative
solutions for their health problems rather than passively relying on the expert 
opinion of conventional health care providers.”

Medical information on the internet. In this section, she points out that
Wikipedia is a trusted source that plays a big role in educating the public. She
complains that it calls acupuncture a pseudoscience and is biased: “Any of the 
positive research and recommendations that have been allowed to remain appears
to have been done so grudgingly, with a negative spin taken at every possible
turn.”

Bullying and banning. Here she describes her editing experience.

   Last month I joined Wikipedia as an editor to find out just how easy it is to
   bring the acupuncture in line with the published evidence. Shortly after
   joining in with the discussion and presenting respectful and referenced
   arguments as to why acupuncture should not be classed as pseudoscience, I was
   indefinitely banned from editing Wikipedia. I would later find out that I
   was the most recent in a (very) long line of editors who were bullied and
   then banned for disagreeing with the established Wiki-‘consensus’ that
   acupuncture is ‘pre-scientific gobbledygook.’

To support this belief of bullying, she cites a notorious troll who was
repeatedly banned for good reasons.

Acupuncture? Fringe? Here she claims that highly respected sources accept
acupuncture, so it can’t be considered fringe. She feels these sources were
disregarded by skeptical editors in favor of two sources that describe
acupuncture as pseudoscientific.

Key evidence for your arsenal. Here she claims that “skeptics do not update
their beliefs based on new evidence.” She provides a list of 3 systematic
reviews that support acupuncture, and 9 published treatment guidelines that
include acupuncture. This amounts to a nice exercise in cherry-picking. She
tells us the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) recommends
acupuncture for the prevention of migraines and tension headaches. She doesn’t 
tell us that it doesn’t recommend acupuncture for the treatment of headaches.
And that it doesn’t recommend it for any other types of headache. She doesn’t
tell us that NICE no longer recommends acupuncture for low back pain. She
doesn’t tell us that Edzard Ernst and his colleagues did a systematic review of 
systematic reviews of acupuncture for pain and found that “Unanimously positive 
conclusions from more than one high-quality systematic review existed only for
neck pain.” She doesn’t mention David Colquhoun and Steven Novella’s review of
the published evidence pro and con and their analysis of the methodological
pitfalls in acupuncture research. They found that the most parsimonious
explanation for the positive acupuncture studies is that they are false
positives. They concluded that acupuncture is a theatrical placebo.

Koppelman’s article is a version of a blog post where she claims:

   The page, controlled by a group of staunch anti-acupuncture ‘pseudoskeptics’ 
   – insists that the mainstream support for acupuncture from the medical and
   scientific community doesn’t exist, even when it is presented to them, and
   presents their subjective minority opinion as the dominant one. They mainly
   do this by a) ignoring high-quality sources that contradict their perspective
   and b) systematically intimidating, bullying and banning anyone who dares to
   say otherwise. This state of affairs is problematic on many levels, not
   least of which because it directly impedes access to informed health care
   choice.

Orac has written about another acupuncturist, Mike Cummings, who made similar
accusations. He claimed “[the acupuncture page on Wikipedia] appears to be
controlled by semi professional anti-CAM pseudosceptics”

What really happened on Wikipedia?

Editors can preserve their anonymity, but in the blog post that the article was 
drawn from Koppelman reveals her Wikipedia talk page identity as “Ellaqmentry.” 
She quotes Arthur Rubin:

   @Ellaqmentry: You have done absolutely nothing right. A cursory inspection of
   the talk page archives should have shown you that your arguments have been
   made and rejected for years. . . if you persist in making those comments, you
   are likely to become another (editor banned from Acupuncture).

She says she asked Arthur to please not bully her but he proceeded to vandalize 
her user page by removing the “new user” tag. Arthur’s revision is documented
here.

Ellaqmentry posted repeatedly on the talk page between 13 and 16 December She
tried to persuade her interlocutors that the Acupuncture article should not say 
acupuncture is a pseudoscience. She did not succeed. As one of the editors
commented, ‘The reaction of the community was: “oh no, not this shit again”.’
The matter had been thrashed out at length in earlier discussions.

   Already discussed at length. Reliable sources describe acupuncture as
   pseudoscience. Trypanophiles have two options: either they can produce good
   science, or they can attack Wikipedia for reflecting the reliable sources.
   The latter is easier. Especially since they have consistently shown they
   cannot do the former at all. Guy (Help!) 23:07, 7 February 2017 (UTC)

The statistics for Ellaqmentry’s contributions are available here. All she did
was interact on the acupuncture discussion page and edit her own account. She
never actually attempted to edit the Wikipedia Acupuncture page.

She was blocked from editing because “it appears you are not here to build an
encyclopedia.” She submitted an unblock request that was denied because:

   (1) Your editing has been highly disruptive. (2) You do not acknowledge the
   problems with your editing, and on the contrary you make it clear that you
   intend to continue in the same way. (3) I have extensively studied the
   relevant editing histories, and it is clear way beyond reasonable doubt that 
   you are LesVegas evading your block on that account.

In the subsequent discussion, it was clarified that even without the suspicion
of sockpuppetry, a ban was justified by what Wikipedia calls NOTHERE. It refers 
to editors who are “not here” to build an encyclopedia but to further a personal
agenda. Koppelman joined Wikipedia with a single purpose: to challenge the
wording of a single article. She waltzed into a discussion on a talk page that
had a long history of trolling and point-of-view-pushing. The other editors
didn’t “bully” her, but they quickly lost patience. They reacted with
understandable frustration because “Here we go again!” They were terse and
factual rather than supportive and instructive.

Susan Gerbic wrote an article for Skeptical Inquirer: “Is Wikipedia a
Conspiracy? Common Myths Explained.” She explains how Wikipedia works. She
advises new editors to “First learn to edit and start on non-confrontational
pages. Improve pages by fixing grammar and spelling. Work on many topics, which 
shows the editing community that you are there to help.”

Who is Koppelman? We have met her before. Mark Crislip tried to answer her
“questions for Science-Based Medicine” and was not impressed. An acupuncturist
and functional medicine practitioner based in Leicester, UK, Koppelman is the
Executive Vice President of the Acupuncture Now Foundation. The Foundation
webpage describes her as “passionate about raising the profile of acupuncture.” 
She is that. Unfortunately, passion doesn’t equate to truth.

Conclusion: Koppelman is biased; Wikipedia is not

According to the abstract, she attempted “to update the Acupuncture page on
Wikipedia with current scientific knowledge, and describes how such pages are
presently controlled by self-styled skeptics, who prevent anyone else from
editing them, thus ensuring the information conforms to their own biased and
skeptical beliefs.”

The Wikipedia editing process is transparent and self-correcting; and if it is
biased, it is biased only in favor of evidence and reason. Koppelman’s misguided
attempt to influence Wikipedia was a good demonstration that the editing
process works well to prevent people like her from injecting bias into the
articles.

In his response to a petition about censorship, bullying, and banning of
dissenting editors Jimmy Wales, co-founder of Wikipedia said:

   Every single person who signed this petition needs to go back to check their 
   premises and think harder about what it means to be honest, factual,
   truthful. Wikipedia’s policies around this kind of thing are spot-on and
   correct. If you can get your work published in respectable scientific
   journals – that is to say, if you can produce evidence through replicable
   scientific experiments, then Wikipedia will cover it appropriately.

More Americans turning to complementary approaches to pain control

The use of of complementary health approaches overall, and for pain management, 
is growing among US adults.

Scott Gavura on February 1, 2024

Link



Like many people I’ve suffered from occasional back pain, on and off, for years.
And when I’ve had acute pain, I’ve taken non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs 
(NSAIDs) like ibuprofen (Advil). Working 12-hour shifts, always on my feet, led 
me to some debilitating back pain. And while I’ve never found NSAIDs to be
miracle drugs, I did find they were providing some pain relief. After taking
them for a multi-week spell when I was really uncomfortable, I found myself
diagnosed with a stomach ulcer. Once I healed, I’ve found regular exercise
(particularly strength training) seems to keep the back pain at bay. I haven’t
had a bad bout for years.

We may think nothing of popping a few Advil now and then, but NSAIDs have been
linked to about 30% of drug-related hospital admissions, and it’s estimated that
12,000-16,000 Americans die annually as a result of gastrointestinal bleeding
caused by NSAIDs.

As a pharmacist I’ve also seen first hand the devastating impact that narcotics 
can have on people as well. The awareness of the potential harms of opioids is
much more prevalent, among health professionals and consumers, than it was 10-20
years ago.

While there have been good developments in non-narcotic treatments for
conditions like migraine, there is still a lot of pain that’s treated with
“conventional” drug therapy – analgesics, anti-inflammatories, and narcotics.
Given none of these products actually fix the underlying cause of the pain and
given their toxicity, it’s understandable there’s interest and enthusiasm for
non-drug approaches to pain control. A new paper confirms that growing interest 
over a 20 year period.

A new paper from Richard L Nahin and colleagues at the NIH (National Center for 
Complementary and Integrative Health) examines responses from the 2002, 2012,
and 2022 National Health Interview Survey (NHIS), which is a household interview
survey done annually and nationally. The survey had the same questions about
acupuncture, guided imagery and/or progressive muscle relaxation, massage,
naturopathy, and yoga in the three periods. Questions on chiropractic care and
meditation were worded very differently differently in 2012, limiting
comparison. Typical questions looked like:

  1. During the past 12 months, did you see a practitioner for acupuncture?

    1. For what health problems or conditions did you use acupuncture?

  2. During the past 12 months, did you see a practitioner for naturopathy?

    1. For what health problems or conditions did you use naturopathy?

Utilization of Complementary Approaches Overall

Outcomes were the changes over time in use of any of the seven complementary
health approaches, and each complementary approach for any reason, and for pain 
management. Here are the results:

Between 2002 and 2022, there was a significant increase in the utilization of
all approaches. All individual modalities experienced significant upward trends.
The overall prevalence of using any of the seven approaches rose from 19.2% to 
36.7%. Yoga exhibited the largest increase, growing from 5.0% in 2002 to 15.8%
in 2022. Meditation had the highest prevalence in 2022, with 17.3% of
individuals reporting its use. Acupuncture rose from 1.0% in 2002 to 2.2% in
2022. There was little utilization of naturopathy, but it did grow as well.

Utilization of Complementary Approaches for Pain Control

Among those using any of the seven complementary approaches, reports of use for 
pain management increased significantly from 42.3% in 2002 to 49.2% in 2022. All
individual approaches showed statistically significant increases in use for for
pain management. Yoga was associated with the largest increase, rising from
11.4% in 2002 to 28.8% in 2022. Chiropractic care had the highest overall usage 
for pain management, with 85.7% of individuals reporting its use in 2022.

Conclusion

The overall effectiveness of these different types of treatments have been
covered in multiple posts in the past, so I won’t rehash the evidence here,
other than to say that the evidence supporting them is weak. Nevertheless, over 
20 years, there has been an increasing use of all of them, often for pain
management. This aligns with a national increase in pain prevalence reported –
which is arguably a subject for another post. This survey doesn’t outline why
these approaches are gaining in popularity, but the belief that these approaches
are effective, and sometimes endorsed in pain management guidelines, may be a
factor. Growing insurance coverage (even for arguably ineffective interventions,
like acupuncture) may also be contributing to more utilization. I suspect that 
there is also a growing desire to reduce the use of drug therapy, which in many 
circumstances is completely appropriate. With a growing prevalence of Americans 
suffering from pain, we should expect interest to continue to grow in different 
treatment options.

Chinese BioMedical Research: Sturgeon’s Law In Action

A Chinese government investigation has found that 80%, yes eighty percent, of
Chinese biomedical research is fabricated. I bet that is an underestimate for
Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine.

Mark Crislip on January 20, 2017

Link



   A liar will not be believed, even when he speaks the truth.– Aesop



Not even the Bocca della Verità can tell if a Chinese medical study is
fabricated.

I do not have much to write about this week. Nothing came across my feeds that
inspired me to prolonged pontification and much of my time this week has been
spent at the local outdoor store trying to purchase weapons for my children.
Both of them are in school, one on L.A. and the other in Boston, and I have been
made aware of the real and serious dangers posed by grizzly bears for unarmed
students. A magnum should slow down any bear that is not smarter than average.

So I offer this short entry on an issue that arose this week.

It has long been noted that there is a discrepancy in outcomes in clinical
trials of Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine (TCMP) between those studies that 
have been done in China and those done in the US and Europe.

99% of acupunctures studies in China for acupuncture are positive and:

   No trial published in China or Russia/USSR found a test treatment to be
   ineffective.

This odd result has always been ascribed to a combination of culture bias and,
perhaps, poor methodologies.

   The method of randomisation was often inappropriately described. Blinding was
   used in only 15% of trials. Only a few studies had sample sizes of 300
   subjects or more. Many trials used as a control another Chinese medicine
   treatment whose effectiveness had often not been evaluated by randomised
   controlled trials. Most trials focused on short term or intermediate rather
   than long term outcomes. Most trials did not report data on compliance and
   completeness of follow up. Effectiveness was rarely quantitatively expressed 
   and reported Intention to treat analysis was never mentioned. Over half did
   not report data on baseline characteristics or on side effects. Many trials
   were published as short reports. Most trials claimed that the tested
   treatments were effective, indicating that publication bias may be common; a 
   funnel plot of the 49 trials of acupuncture in the treatment of stroke
   confirmed selective publication of positive trials in the area, suggesting
   that acupuncture may not be more effective than the control treatments

As we have discussed at length in this blog, the poorer the methodology, the
more likely a pseudo-medical study will have a positive result.

But the issue is not cultural bias or badly done studies. Nope.

Chinese researchers just make shit up.

An evaluation by the Chinese government found that:

   more than 80 percent of clinical data is “fabricated,”

It seems that making up data is de rigueur in China:

   “Clinical data fabrication was an open secret even before the inspection,”
   the paper quoted an unnamed hospital chief as saying.

Academic ethics is also an underdeveloped field in China, leading to an academic
culture that is accepting of manipulation of data.I don’t think that the 80
percent figure is overstated. I grew up a science fiction fan and a follower of 
Sturgeon’s law: “ninety percent of everything is crap.” It looks like Chinese
medical researchers use it as a commandment rather than a warning.

The review does not specifically mention if TCPM studies were included and my
reading suggests that the investigation applies to standard biomedical research.
But given the fantastical nature of TCPM and the vanishingly small (on order of
gravitation wave detection, one-ten-thousandth the diameter of a proton (10-19 
meter)) prior plausibility of TCPM and likelihood that most of TCPM is Oakland, 
I would wonder if 80% is a gross underestimate.

Which presents an interesting and difficult problem. At what point can you no
longer trust the veracity of the literature? 1.97% of researchers admit to
making up data and more have other nefarious practices. Worrisome but not as
difficult as a culture of fabrication. A single researcher will do less damage
than a whole society. A single fake paper is likely to be swamped by the
preponderance of the literature. But what if the entire literature is built on
lies? Then what?

Evaluating the medical literature as a practicing physician, I would assume that
if a researcher made up his data for one study, then all his data and
subsequent bloviating would be suspect. Like Wakefield. I would assume anything 
Wakefield says would be a lie until I could prove otherwise. And that goes
against my default position to assume that people are usually not deliberately
lying to me. I was raised to think a person is only as good as their word. Of
course outside of the medical literature lying is not always considered a
detriment. For the electoral college 80% is evidently just fine.

If patients put their health, wealth, and life in my hands, I have to know that 
the clinical trials I am basing my decisions on are as close to true as
possible. Truthiness is not good enough.

Can we automatically assume that all the biomedical research coming out of China
is fabricated? How can we tell? We can’t. And I would be especially skeptical
of clinical trials of TCPM. It would also be interesting to see the results of
the almost too numerous to count acupuncture meta-analyses if they were
re-analyzed after removing all the Chinese studies.

Unfortunately when it comes to the medical literature from China, since the
information can’t be verified you have to assume it cannot be trusted and so no 
longer counts. It has to be considered persona non grata unless it can
demonstrate otherwise.

I assume true believers in TCPM will ignore the findings and point to the malign
influence of big pharma on medical research, as if that makes the lies out of
China just peachy.

Dr. Cummings over at the BMJ Blogs was recently upset that acupuncture is
considered by Wikipedia to be a pseudo-science. Acupuncture/TCPM literature is
likely far worse, the lying lies of liars.

                            Other “Eastern” Remedies

What Is Traditional Chinese Medicine?

Traditional Chinese Medicine is not actual medicine, and should not be treated
as such. It has more in common with Galen’s theory of the four humors than
anything a doctor would recognize today.

Steven Novella on January 25, 2012

Link


One of the themes of science-based medicine is to be suspicious of any form of
medicine that is not science-based. In other words, beware of dodgy qualifiers
placed before “medicine,” such as: “alternative”, “integrative”, or
“complementary” – those that imply that something other than science or evidence
is being used to determine which treatments are safe and effective. I would
also include “traditional Chinese” medicine in the dodgy category. A recent
article defending Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) provides, ironically, an
excellent argument for the rejection of TCM as a valid form of medicine. The
authors, Jingqing Hua and Baoyan Liub, engage in a number of logical fallacies
that are worth exploring.

Their introduction sets the tone:

   Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) has a history of thousands of years. It is
   formed by summarizing the precious experience of understanding life,
   maintaining health, and fighting diseases accumulated in daily life,
   production and medical practice. It not only has systematic theories, but
   also has abundant preventative and therapeutic methods for disease.

It may be trivially true that TCM has a long history, but it is hard to ignore
that the placement of this statement at the beginning of a scientific article
implies an argument from antiquity – that TCM should be taken seriously because 
of this long history. I would argue that this is actually a reason to be
suspicious of TCM, for it derives from a pre-scientific largely
superstition-based culture, similar in this way to the pre-scientific Western
culture that produced the humoral (Galenic) theory of biology.

The next line is an admission that TCM is largely based on anecdotal
information, described as the “precious experience” of life. This is a point
that is often overlooked or not understood by proponents but central to the
scientific/skeptical position – what is the value and predictive power of
“precious experience” in developing a system of medicine?

I maintain that there are many good reasons to conclude that any system which
derives from everyday experience is likely to be seriously flawed and almost
entirely cut off from reality. Obvious short term effects, the lowest hanging
fruit of observation, are likely to be reliable. Uncontrolled observation is a
reasonable way to discover which plants, for example, are deadly poisons. This
is likely to produce some false positives but few false negatives, which is fine
for survival.

Other obvious effects, like nausea, diarrhea, and psychedelic effects are also
easy to discover. Similarly it was probably obvious that people need to eat,
breathe, and drink in order to stay healthy and alive. But records of
pre-scientific thinking about health and disease shows that little else was.

Pre-scientific doctors thought, for example, that pus was a good thing, a sign
that a wound was healing. They also did not realize that removing blood from the
body was harmful, because they did not understand the vital physiological
effects of blood and had fanciful superstitious notions about its role in the
body.

So there are severe practical limits to what uncontrolled life experiences could
figure out about health and disease. Every culture figured out some basic
things, like local plants that had some uses, how to treat some forms of trauma,
and to midwife childbirth, but could not figure out the complexities of
biology, physiology, anatomy, biochemistry, genetics, infection and disease
pathophysiology and epidemiology.

Understanding health and disease took a more sophisticated method of observing
nature – science.

How, then, could a pre-scientific culture without any knowledge of modern
biology and without the methods of science develop a valid and effective system 
of medicine? The answer is – they couldn’t. In addition, there is now a large
body of psychological research showing the many ways in which people
systematically deceive themselves when it comes to finding correlations and
making assumptions about cause and effect.

There is nothing about the Chinese culture or the Chinese people that should
make them exempt from these documented psychological effects, or that would make
their culture unique among the world’s cultures in stumbling upon notions about
health and illness that were actually correct. It is extreme cultural hubris to
think otherwise. When the institution of medicine in the West incorporated
scientific methods as the standard of determining which treatments were safe and
effective, and in understanding disease, over time almost everything that
constituted “traditional Western medicine” was overturned. The “precious
experience” of centuries of Western medicine resulted in largely worthless or
harmful treatments, from blood-letting to toxic mineral-based treatments.

The same is true for every other culture, including Asian culture. As evidence
for this, in my opinion, is the very description of TCM given by the authors.
They give a description of TCM philosophy, breaking it down into three
components. The first is yin-yang:

   According to the theory of yin–yang, all opposite matters in the universe,
   which are interrelated with each other or two opposite aspects within one
   matter, can be defined as yin or yang.

This is a “push-pull” philosophy of health – but it is just that, a philosophy. 
Nothing has been discovered in physiology that correlates with yin-yang, that
would lead to the prediction that a yin-yang systems exists, or supports the
existence or effects of yin-yang. It is just a made-up notion without any basis 
in physical reality – just like the balancing of the four humors of Galenic
medicine.

Defenders of yin-yang, however, will often make superficial comparisons to any
system in the body (and other areas of science) that has a basic duality or
dichotomy. They then argue that this is “yin-yang”. However, such an
interpretation renders yin-yang vague and non-specific enough to be worthless.
As with the predictions of Nostradamus, humans are good at retrofitting –
finding apparent correlations. Many systems in the body exist in a certain
balance, and many systems are interrelated. Some of these systems may have two
dominant components (sympathetic vs parasympathetic), but others have three or
more (such as the complex interplay among the various neurotransmitters in the
brain).

Any variable (blood pressure, heart rate, GI motility, temperature, etc,) can be
either increased or decreased – an inherently dichotomous situation. So it is
trivial to call any such variable evidence of “yin-yang”. But yin-yang does not 
have any specific existence, nor does it provide any specific insight into
physiology. In has no more of a relationship to actual biology than Galenic
medicine, which can be said to have contained the insight that the body contains
a balance of various fluids. This is also true, but trivially and
non-specifically so.

Next is the five phases:

   The five phases theory defines the nature of matters based on the related
   characteristics of wood, fire, earth, metal, and water. The five phases
   maintain the generation and restriction relationship among them. TCM uses
   five phase theory to describe the relationship between five zang and their
   physiological function, five zang and structure and function of various parts
   of the human body, and also the correlation between each part of human body 
   and nature and society.

Your liver, apparently, has the aspect of wood. This is an elaborate belief
system, just like astrology, and has as much validity. It is rather poetic, also
like astrology, and one can understand how a pre-scientific society would
develop such ideas in order to attempt to understand something as complex and
mysterious as the human body and illness.

There is no reason to presume, however, that such a description offers any
insight into how the body functions or how to approach or treat any particular
ailment. The authors give an example:

   In the treatment of the syndrome of disharmony between the heart and kidney
   caused by deficiency of kidney-yin and hyperactivity of heart-fire, according
   to the law of ‘water restrains fire’, we can use the therapy of reducing
   fire and reinforcing water.

I would rather treat a problem with heart or kidney function based upon a good
‘ol reductionist view of heart and renal function, understanding the role of
blood pressure, body fluids, kidney function and regulation, electrolytes, etc. 
The notion (“law”?) that water restrains fire does not seem to offer any insight
into how to treat a pre-renal syndrome.

Finally there is the visceral and meridian theories, which constitute an
alternate (meaning incorrect) way of understanding the organs of the body:

   Also, combining visceral manifestation theory with yin–yang and five phase
   theory, TCM has formed its own understanding towards the law of physiological
   and pathological changes of the human body. For instance, the liver matches 
   wood, and the spleen belongs to earth. The over-acting of wood will lead to
   over-restraining on earth. Thus, we can see patients with transverse invasion
   of the stagnated liver-qi attacking the spleen.

How exactly does stagnated liver-qi attck the spleen? How would this be
diagnosed? What I am saying is – what is the reductionist understanding of these
concepts? It is common for proponents of such alternate ways of knowing to
denigrate reductionist science, but if a way of “understanding” how something
works reflects reality, then it should make sense and hold up to the evidence
all the way down.

“Reductionist” really just means deeper levels of understanding how the world
works. It should not be confused with “hyperreductionism” which means ignoring
or minimizing higher order levels of organization and function. You cannot, for 
example, understand how the body works just from biochemisty, or even from
studying single cells. You have to understand how tissues, organs, and the whole
body works together.

Science, actually, takes the most holistic view of health and disease, for it
attempts to understand how the body works at every level of organization, and
recognizes the folly of ignoring any level. You cannot ignore how the system
works together, nor can you ignore how the individual parts work all the way
down to their most basic components.

Ancient philosophies of medicine, however, either ignore the deeper levels of
function, or make up fanciful underlying concepts, like wood and earth, that
have nothing to do with reality.

Finally they describe the meridians:

   The meridians transport qi and blood all over the body, link up the upper and
   the lower, the inside and the surface of the human body, response and
   conduct the information.

Except, there is no evidence that the meridians actually exist. At the risk of
sounding redundant, they are as made up and fictional as the ether, flogistum,
Bigfoot, and unicorns. The linking of qi and blood is reflective of the fact
that the notion of qi is historically tied to blood, and techniques such as
acupuncture and cupping were also closely related to bleeding techniques that we
are more familiar with from Galenic medicine.

This leads to the next section on therapeutics in TCM. Of course they discuss
acupuncture and also moxibustion and massage, but give very quick descriptions. 
They state multiple times that these techniques “treat disease” – which is an
odd and extraordinary claim for several reasons. There is, of course, no
evidence that acupuncture or moxibustion alters the course of any disease. You
have to believe in the notions of qi etc. described above to believe that there 
is any plausibility to the use of acupuncture for disease. Even for symptomatic 
treatment (the bulk of scientific acupuncture studies) the evidence is weak to
negative.

The authors also describe TCM herbalism, stating:

   Currently, there are over 12,800 types of Chinese medicinals known by people,
   including over 11,000 medicinal plants, over 1500 medicinal animals, and
   over 80 medicinal minerals. Also, there are approximately 1 million TCM
   prescriptions found.

This relates to my main point above – how could practitioners have sorted out
the risks, benefit, side effects, interactions, indications, pharmacodynamics,
and pharmacokinetics of one million preparations without using any systematic
scientific methods? This would be a challenge for a modern scientific
institution, and would have been impossible for any pre-scientific society. One 
has to either ignore this issue, or assume preternatural abilities on the part
of TCM practitioners, at the very least making them immune to all the mechanisms
of deception and bias that seem to plague modern ordinary humans.

All of this background is just a long windup to what appears to be the main
point of this article – the challenge of studying these therapies and ideas with
modern scientific methods. Those of us familiar with this line of reasoning can
see the massive special pleading coming a mile away.

They outline four challenges to scientifically studying TCM – that TCM considers
overall health (I guess rather than just one condition at a time), therapies
require ongoing assessment and adjustment, multiple therapies are given
simultaneously to work together, and there are multiple targets of therapy.

Let me turn this around a bit – assuming the premises of this reasoning are true
(that TCM must include these higher levels of complexity) then it is true that 
TCM treatments would be difficult to study systematically. At the same time,
however, they would make it very difficult (likely impossible) to derive any
reliable conclusions about therapy from “precious experience”. I would argue
that the same features that make TCM difficult to study in a controlled setting 
make it impossible to assess in an uncontrolled setting.

So how, then, can TCM practitioners have any practical knowledge about what
therapies work and are appropriate in specific situations? Something akin to
“magical intuition” is the only answer.

That point aside – it is difficult, but not impossible, to study such
treatments. First, I disagree with the premise and believe it is just special
pleading, an excuse for the lack of scientific evidence for TCM. In modern
medicine we often use multiple treatments working together to address a complex 
syndrome. Each individual component, however, should contribute to the overall
benefit, and should be able to demonstrate its contribution in controlled
studies.

Any contribution too small to detect in clinical trials is probably too small to
be of clinical significance. Also, even if we accept the premise that multiple 
treatments only work when given together, you can still study this in a
controlled setting – by individualizing a holistic treatment plan and then
giving it or a placebo substitute in a blinded fashion.

You may have noticed that I left off the fifth “challenge” to studying TCM
(which is often used as an excuse for a lack of evidence). The authors write:

   Finally, the cultural characteristic embodied in traditional Chinese medicine
   requires more consideration on ecological features of data in TCM when
   conducting statistical analysis.

I’m not sure what to make of that statement, and the authors give no further
explanation. I would just point out that science – and reality – has no cultural
characteristic. If something is true about the world, it is true no matter what
culture you come from. The point of science is to be transparent and universal,
so that anyone doing the same experiment, no matter what culture they come
from, should have the same result.

Conclusion: TCM is not medicine

TCM is a pre-scientific superstitious view of biology and illness, similar to
the humoral theory of Galen, or the notions of any pre-scientific culture. It is
strange and unscientific to treat TCM as anything else. Any individual
diagnostic or treatment method within TCM should be evaluated according to
standard principles of science and science-based medicine, and not given special
treatment.

Shilling for traditional Chinese medicine: Nature leaves its readers a lump of
coal before Christmas

David Gorski on December 26, 2011

Link


I’ve subscribed to Nature for many years now, even though I don’t always read
it. Nature is one of the oldest and most respected scientific journals around.
It’s been around since 1869 and is said to be the world’s most cited journal.
What makes Nature unusual these days is that it’s one of the last of the
remaining general science journals and one of the two that still publish
original peer-reviewed research in a wide variety of scientific fields.
Astronomy, physics, chemistry, medicine, biology, Nature publishes it all. The
only other journal of its type that I can think of is Science, which also has a 
similar high impact factor. In any case, getting published in Nature is a big
deal, one that can make a career. Believe it or not, I actually have a Nature
publication. True, it’s from the 1990s, and, true, I’m only the fourth author,
but it is a Nature publication. Ever since then, I keep telling myself that, one
of these days, I’ll manage to find a way to be published again in Nature,
although I realize that it’s looking increasingly unlikely that that will
happen. Such is the power and cachet of Nature. It’s a name that has provided
prestige to some of its spinoff journals, such as Nature Medicine, although of
late Nature appears to have diluted the brand name beyond belief.

Nature sells out

All of the above is why I’m very, very disappointed in Nature for having dropped
a huge lump of coal into the stockings of supporters of science-based medicine 
a mere three days before Christmas. Maybe its editors thought that it wouldn’t
be noticed right before the holiday season. I don’t know. I do know that I
noticed. Basically, Nature sold out to a Japanese pharmaceutical company, which,
along with a research institute, bought a supplement in Nature that is in
essence an advertorial for its point of view. Don’t believe me? Check out this
acknowledgment of the sponsors published in the advertorial:

   We are grateful for the support of our sponsors, Saishunkan Pharmaceutical
   Co., ltd. and the Kitasato University Oriental Medicine Research Center. As
   always, Nature carries sole responsibility for all editorial content.

Yes, you read it right. Nature sold out to a Japanese supplement manufacturer
and a quackademic medical center. But what did Saishunkan Pharmaceutical Company
and the Kitasato University Oriental Medicine Research Center get in return for
their money? Believe it or not, they got a whole supplement entitled
Traditional Asian Medicine. This supplement is basically, with a minimal degree 
of skepticism, an attempt to convince Nature‘s readers that traditional Chinese 
medicine (TCM) is science-based and, even more than that, represents the cutting
edge of medical science based on systems biology. Basically, it’s a mixture of 
The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly, with the vast majority falling credulously into
the latter two categories by a wide margin.

Let’s start by taking a look at the main sponsor of the supplement, Saishunkan
Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., which is described thusly:

   Saishunkan is a herbal medicine manufacturer which aims to help people make
   the most of their natural powers of healing and self-recovery. Based on the
   idea from herbal medicine that humans are part of the nature, our dream and
   joy is to ease the worries and concerns of aging, which comes to everyone. We
   maximize our capabilities to support lively and happy aging by using the
   power of nature to enhance human revitalization.

   Our business started with a herbal formula “Tsusanto” for easing pains of
   neuralgia and rheumatism. In 1974, “Domohorn Wrinkle”, a family of basic
   skincare products intended for mature skin came to being from the same
   principles of herbal medicine.

Interestingly, Tsusanto is mentioned in a report on Pharmaceuticals and Medical 
Devices Safety Information and described as “ Ephedra Herb/Glycyrrhiza/Apricot
Kernel/Stephania Tetrandra/Coix Seed Ephedra Herb/Apricot Kernel/Coix
Seed/Glycyrrhiza/Sinomenium Stem/ Animal Bile. Meanwhile, Domohorn Wrinkle is
described as containing a selection of about 150 “natural” ingredients. The
company itself wants to argue that this is scientific, and, as evidence to
support its products, it includes a message published in the supplement. The
two-page message is basically a lot of self-serving company propaganda with a
couple of Western blots and graphs, the better to make it more science-y.
Apparently one of its concoctions increases levels of certain heat shock
proteins, and this is trumpeted as evidence that they work. I’m not impressed.

Meanwhile the Kitasato University Oriental Medicine Research Center is described
thusly:

   The Oriental Medicine Research Center provides two types of clinical
   activities: medical treatment based on Kampo medicine theory, primarily using
   decoctions, and acupuncture that follows our country’s traditional
   techniques. To prepare Kampo medicines, we have set up an exclusive pharmacy 
   that is in charge of dispensing and formulating these medications, focusing
   on crude drugs. Patients come from all over the country in search of
   treatments based on Oriental medicine, both Kampo medicine and acupuncture/
   moxibustion.

Kampo medicine, for those of you not familiar with it, is simply the Japanese
study and adaptation of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). As practiced today, 
it does seem somewhat different in that the Japanese government regulates Kampo 
medications as pharmaceutical products, rather than supplements. It is, however,
the same TCM woo, just transplanted to Japan.

The selling of TCM as being “personalized” medicine

The overall approach of the articles in this supplement appear to follow roughly
the form and arguments of the very first article by Michelle Grayson,
Traditional Asian Medicine. So let’s start there. It’s all on display there,
claims that TCM is being “integrated” into “Western” medicine, and, most
annoying of all to me, the claim that TCM is so “personalized” that randomized
clinical trials are very difficult, if not impossible, to do:

   Yet a bit of probing revealed what a complex story this is. Not only are big 
   efforts underway to modernize traditional medicine in China and Japan, but
   Western medicine is adopting some aspects of the Eastern point of view too.
   In particular, modern medical practitioners are coming around to the idea
   that certain illnesses cannot be reduced to one isolatable, treatable cause. 
   Rather, a fall from good health often involves many small, subtle effects
   that create a system-wide imbalance.

   But do traditional medicines actually work? Their personalized nature makes
   randomized controlled trials — the gold standard for testing drugs —
   extremely difficult. Rarely are two formulations identical. However, as
   modern medicine becomes more personalized, using biological and genetic
   markers, it is inadvertently developing the tools to better test traditional 
   medicines.

The other theme that runs through these articles, besides the implication that
TCM is just too personalized to be studied easily using randomized clinical
trials is the very conscious effort to link this “personalization” with the new 
era of genomic medicine, whose fruits (if we ever realize them) will one day be 
considered truly personalized medicine based on a patient’s genomic profile.
Honestly, it should be profoundly embarrassing to Nature that one of its own
actually wrote this twaddle. Actually, Nature should be profoundly embarrassed
at publishing so much twaddle in this supplement. I could, if I so desired,
spend several days, one post per day, deconstructing these articles. I’m not
sure if I’m really up for the task right now, given the proximity of the
holidays, although I might very well change my mind. I’m also likely to have
more to say about this supplement issue on my other blog next week.

In the meantime, the next installment in the series is Convergence: Where West
meets East starts with a passage that any supporter of SBM will find incredibly 
irritating. See how many fallacies you can count in just this short snippet of
text:

   For around 200 years, two very different systems of medicine have been used
   in Asia to cure diseases and keep people healthy. The local Asian one is
   based on traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) — herbal mixtures developed
   though observation and experience accumulated over thousands of years, but
   with unknown mechanisms of action. On the other hand, modern medicine,
   imported from the West, consists of chemically purified compounds that have
   been discovered through scientific investigation and tested in controlled
   clinical trials.

Yes, there it is, the the false dichotomy of “East” versus “West,” which
portrays the “East” as being more spiritual and the “West” as being unfeeling,
scientific, and out of touch with nature. Notice the reference to “chemically
purified compounds” compared to the “natural” compounds of TCM. Notice the
argument from antiquity, which implies that because TCM is ancient (“Observation
and experience accumulated over thousands of years”) contrasted with science.
Just this brief paragraph is a veritable plethora of woo-speak! It doesn’t get
any better from there.

There’s a long section on TCM diagnosis, which in reality is based on a
prescientific understanding of disease and how the human body functions. In
essence, they boil down to imbalances in the five “elements,” which are
basically the Chinese version of the four humors plus one. Remember that a major
component of TCM diagnosis is something called “tongue diagnosis,” which the
article even dutifully reproduces, complete with woo diagnoses like Yin
Deficiency and Yang Deficiency, not to mention Qi Stagnation. This system is
described, in all seriousness by the author, as producing diagnoses that are a
“finer level of classification than disease groupings in modern medicine.” I kid
you not. In support of this, a study published in the American Journal of
Chinese Medicine is cited in which the authors used TCM diagnoses to classify
rheumatoid arthritis patients. The study concluded that patients with
cold-pattern symptoms (diagnosed by TCM, of course) responded better to real
medicine, while patients with qi deficiency responded better to TCM. In any
case, this entire article is very much woo-omics, like the Ayurogenomics that I 
discussed a while back; i.e, a total abuse of genomics and systems biology. They
even use and abuse poor Leroy Hood, one of the originators of systems biology. 
Unfortunately, this abuse appears to be not without basis, as Hood has been
known to drop some rather silly statements about how “traditional medicine” is a
lot like “multitargeted” therapy, something I hadn’t known until after I did a 
bit of Googling after having read this supplement.

The rest of the supplement is chock full of similar atrocities against
skepticism and science. For example, there’s an article by Felix Chueng entitled
TCM: Made in China, which is basically one long appeal to popularity, listing
how many people use TCM, how many companies manufacture it, and how this number 
is growing, as though this were evidence that TCM must be scientifically valid. 
Chueng even appeals to the one example of how a blind squirrel can find an acorn
every so often, namely the example of the antimalaria drug artemisinin, which
was isolated from an herb described in TCM. Another article by Chueng extolls
the glories of how TCM is practiced in the clinic. It’s nothing more than one
long anecdote, in which the author, suffering from a “persistent back problem”
that also causes leg pain (which sounds a lot like sciatica) goes to a TCM
clinic. There, he’s diagnosed with xinhuo (“heart fire) and then treated with
acupuncture, moxibustion, and cupping. He was even treated with–believe it or
not–bloodletting to clear the “heart fire.” He concludes:

   I walked happily away with my leg feeling much better. As I left the
   hospital, I saw the women still doing their baduanjin. I began to wonder if
   maybe I should start practicing baduanjin too.

Baduanjin is a form of Tai Chi.

As I read this account, I wondered: This guy is editor of Nature China in Hong
Kong. I couldn’t help but also wonder if Chueng had ever heard of placebo
effects, because he was describing a lovely example of them in his anecdote.

A blind squirrel finds an acorn occasionally, or: The use and abuse of systems
biology

Much of this supplement has to do with a tactic that I’m seeing more and more
from promoters of TCM, Ayurveda, and the like, namely that the principles of TCM
are a lot like the new, more “holistic” principles of systems biology and that 
TCM herbal preparations are really rationally designed mixtures of active
compounds designed to “hit multiple biological targets,” an example of which can
be found in this bit of pure propaganda for TCM found in an article by Zhiguo
Xu entitled Modernization: One step at a time. Once again, the example of
artemisinin is trotted out as an example to imply that all TCM must have
something to it. Of course, what’s interesting is that the description of
artemisinin provided in this article is nothing more than good, old-fashioned
pharmacognosy; i.e., natural products pharmacology. In fact, that, and the other
example culled from TCM, arsenic trioxide, are used to imply that the view of
TCM that purified compounds aren’t the best way to treat disease, that there is 
synergy between different compounds in herbs:

   For decades, European and US regulatory agencies held the view that a drug
   must be either a highly purified or synthetic agent. Traditional medicines
   could not qualify under this definition because a TCM preparation is a
   concoction rather than a single compound, and the chemical structures of the 
   active ingredients are undefined. Consequently, when it came to assessing a
   traditional medicine for efficacy, most effort went into identifying the
   principal agent within a herb or mixture of herbs and purifying it as a
   single chemical compound. However, “academic scientists and the
   pharmaceutical industry have not been very successful at isolating the active
   substances in TCM preparations”, says Bai Lu.

   Others share Lu’s dour outlook. “Few active ingredients are extracted from
   TCM herbs by modern scientific approaches,” says Yi Rao, dean of life
   sciences at Peking University in Beijing. “Those extracted effectively have
   not been demonstrated to be clinically successful.” Indeed, he says,
   “artemisinin and arsenic trioxide are perhaps the only two examples”.

The author seems not to realize that these two examples of medications isolated 
from TCM treatments, far from indicating the importance of having multiple
ingredients, actually demonstrate the importance of isolating the active
compound and purifying it. Yet the entire focus of this particular article is to
claim that there is “synergy” between ingredients of herbs and how to capture
it. The problem is, there usually isn’t. Herbs can be drugs, but they are impure
drugs. Perhaps the reason that so few active substances have been isolated from
TCM herbs is because there just aren’t that many.

Even more amusingly, another example is described, something called the
Herbalome project. This is nothing more than high throughput screening of herbs 
from TCM for active ingredients using liquid chromatography and other methods of
separation. Analyzing 500 samples a day, the project has thus far identified
the active ingredient from only one herb. Inadvertently, the Herbalome project
appears to be demonstrating that there probably isn’t much that’s useful in the 
herbal medicine of TCM that hasn’t already been identified. Of course, that
leads to this excuse:

   For example, Liang acknowledges that one of the major tools used by his team 
   as part of the Herbalome — high-throughput screening — is not ideally suited 
   to the task. That’s because TCM concoctions are mixtures of multiple active
   compounds, and a typical Chinese medicine is intended to hit multiple
   biological targets.

Notice the rebranding. The originators of TCM had no idea what a “biological
target” was. They were trying to “rebalance the elements” or “correct the flow
of qi.” They weren’t trying to “hit multiple biological targets,” and they used 
herbs because that was all they had. Substances found in TCM that actually had
some activity against real diseases (substances such as artemisinin and arsenic 
trioxide) were discovered by accident, not because the principles of TCM
facilitated their identification. In any case, what the Herbalome project is
doing is nothing different than high throughput screening of natural products
that just happened to be used in TCM.

The previous article, at least, had a germ of truth to it in that there might
occasionally be active compounds in various TCM medications. However, the next
article takes this to the “next level” of woo by claiming that TCM is finally
being appreciated because it’s being vindicated by new findings in systems
biology and genomic medicine. It’s a horrible, horrible article by Jan van der
Greef, principal scientist at the Netherlands Organization for Applied
Scientific Research (TNO), professor of Analytical Biosciences at Leiden
University and chairman of the Sino-Dutch Centre for Preventive and Personalized
Medicine, entitled All Systems Go. Practically every paragraph had seriously
cringe-worthy sentences in it (to supporters of SBM like me, anyway), passages
like this:

   The concepts and practices of systems biology align very closely with those
   of traditional Asian medicine. Consider the very idea of ‘health’. The
   current World Health Organization definition of the term is based on a 1948
   consensus: “A state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and
   not merely the absence of disease or infirmity.” However, an emerging concept
   of health in the scientific literature describes an ability to adapt and
   self-manage in the face of social, physical and emotional challenges1. This
   perspective has, of course, long been central to the concept of health in
   traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), which further includes spiritual
   fulfilment and a sense of individual well-being.

And:

   But there is a growing realization in the West that single biomarkers are not
   enough. A better approach is to look at patterns of biomarker responses to a
   challenge. These data will provide insight into the resilience of allostatic
   mechanisms, and hence into a person’s health, an approach not unlike the
   tenets of TCM.

Get it? Understand? According to van der Greef, TCM was ahead of its time, and
“Western” science is only now catching up! This assertion is, of course, a pair 
of fetid dingo’s kidneys. What’s really going on is that woo-friendly “Western” 
scientists like van der Greef are retrofitting new scientific findings into the 
framework of TCM and declaring that they fit. In reality, what quackademics are 
doing is taking parts of TCM that sound vaguely as though they fit in with the
latest scientific findings in systems biology and grafting them on to create a
Frankenstein monster made up of parts of systems biology with a parts from TCM
stitched together. Add to that the typical alt-med excuse that “your science
can’t study my woo” because it’s “personalized” and randomized clinical trials
can’t handle that, and you have the recipe for the infiltration of quackademic
medicine into academia.

In all fairness, I will concede that the Nature supplement isn’t entirely bad.
For instance, there is a reasonably good article on biodiversity and how TCM
threatens it by using body parts of animals belonging to endangered species, a
practice that generates a lucrative trade in endangered species. Unfortunately, 
the article fails to describe just how cruel some of the techniques used to
obtain these body parts and fluids can be and just how much they endanger
species like tigers. There is, however, a nice debunking of the idea that rhino 
horn has been used for thousands of years to treat cancer. (It turns out that it
was made up less than 100 years ago.) There’s also an article on the dangers of
herbal medicine, which can cause side effects, sometimes severe. However,
overall the articles in this supplement leave this reader with the inescapable
impression of boosterism. This is, of course, not surprising, given that this
supplement should be viewed, more than anything else, as an advertising
supplement, bought and paid for by its sponsors.

A thought comparison

As I read this supplement, I couldn’t help but think of what the reaction would 
be from CAM practitioners to a supplement bought and paid for by a
pharmaceutical company. (Actually, this supplement was bought and paid for by a 
pharmaceutical company; it’s just that it was bout and paid for by a
pharmaceutical company that makes TCM remedies.) The reaction would be
unrelentingly hostile, and rightly so. In fact, I highly doubt that Nature would
agree to publish a supplement funded by, for example, Merck, Pfizer, or
Sanofi-Aventis extolling the virtues of their products. I doubt even more highly
that it would hire out its own editors to write articles for such a supplement.
Yet that’s exactly what Nature has done in this case for TCM.

I’m left with the conclusion that, to their eternal shame, by publishing this
issue, the editors of Nature have become willing shills for the TCM industry.
Nature has sold out, and its editors and publisher should be called out for it.

                                     Reiki

                                 Steven Novella

                                      Link

Reiki (pronounced raykey) is a form of “energy healing,” essentially the Asian
version of faith healing or laying on of hands. Practitioners believe they are
transferring life energy to the patient, increasing their well-being. The
practice is popular among nurses, and in fact is practiced by nurses at my own
institution (Yale).

From reiki.org, we get this description:

   Reiki is a Japanese technique for stress reduction and relaxation that also
   promotes healing. It is administered by “laying on hands” and is based on the
   idea that an unseen “life force energy” flows through us and is what causes 
   us to be alive. If one’s “life force energy” is low, then we are more likely 
   to get sick or feel stress, and if it is high, we are more capable of being
   happy and healthy.

Reiki is therefore a form of vitalism – the pre-scientific belief that some
spiritual energy animates the living, and is what separates living things from
non-living things. The notion of vitalism was always an intellectual
place-holder, responsible for whatever aspects of biology were not currently
understood. But as science progressed, eventually we figured out all of the
basic functions of life and there was simply nothing left for the vital force to
do. It therefore faded from scientific thinking. We can add to that the fact
that no one has been able to provide positive evidence for the existence of a
vital force – it remains entirely unknown to science.

But the discarded science and superstition of the past is the “alternative
medicine” of today. There are many so-called “CAM” modalities that are based on 
vitalism, including Reiki. Reiki, in fact, is very similar to therapeutic touch,
another energy healing modality that was popular among nurses, and although it 
continues to be used it is much less popular after 9 year old girl (Emily Rosa) 
performed an elegant experiment to show that it was nothing but self-deception. 
Reiki nicely moved in to fill the void.

The research on Reiki, and energy healing in general, is similar to that of many
similar modalities – those with very low scientific plausibility that are not
taken very seriously by medical scientists. The research is of generally low
quality, poorly controlled small studies that seem designed to justify Reiki
rather than see if it actually works. The most recently published study, for
example, looks at anxiety levels and self-reported well being in cancer patient 
and finds, unsurprisingly, that patients feel better when they receive the kind 
attention of a nurse. The study is completely uncontrolled, and therefore of
dubious value. One might consider such a study a complete waste of time and
effort, as the results were never in doubt.

A 2011 review of reiki studies concluded:

   The existing research does not allow conclusions regarding the efficacy or
   effectiveness of energy healing. Future studies should adhere to existing
   standards of research on the efficacy and effectiveness of a treatment, and
   given the complex character of potential outcomes, cross-disciplinary
   methodologies may be relevant. To extend the scope of clinical trials,
   psychosocial processes should be taken into account and explored, rather than
   dismissed as placebo.

In other words – existing research is a such poor quality we cannot draw any
useful conclusion from it. I disagree, however, that this necessarily means that
more research is needed. The low plausibility of using magical energy that has 
never been demonstrated to exist by medical science argues otherwise. Further,
the last sentence is odd – it suggests the authors are trying to spin placebo
effects into real effects. This is increasingly the strategy of alternative
medicine advocates as it becomes clear that most of the modalities they favor do
not work any better than placebo (which means they don’t work).

Reiki is now squarely in that camp. Published at about the same time as the
review (and therefore not included in the review) is a well-designed study of
Reiki where Reiki was compared to placebo Reiki (someone not trained in Reiki
simply goes through the motions) vs usual care (no intervention). Not
surprisingly, both the real Reiki and the sham Reiki groups did better on
self-reported well-being than the no intervention group, but they were
indistinguishable from each other. Therefore Reiki did not better than placebo. 
That means Reiki doesn’t work (at least in the regular world of science-based
medicine).

The authors conclude:

   The findings indicate that the presence of an RN providing one-on-one support
   during chemotherapy was influential in raising comfort and well-being
   levels, with or without an attempted healing energy field.

I notice the authors did not conclude “Reiki doesn’t work.” This is odd, given
that both the treatment and placebo groups had the same effect on subjective
outcomes. With regular medical interventions we conclude from this outcome that 
the treatment does not work. Imagine a pharmaceutical company concluding:

   The findings indicate that taking a pill during chemotherapy was influential 
   in raising comfort and well-being levels, with or without an active
   ingredient.

Therefore – taking pills is helpful. Let’s not fret about whether the active
ingredient has any specific physiological effects. Reiki supporters appear to
have taken a page out of the acupuncture handbook. If real and sham acupuncture 
are both better than no intervention (they argue), than acupuncture works,
whether real or placebo.

This article by Edzard Ernst recently published in the Guardian also discusses
this Reiki study. Ernst points out that, not only is it scientifically dubious
to conclude from such studies anything other than the treatment does not work,
it is ethically questionable to give such treatments as a placebo intervention. 
He writes

   By insisting that patients must not be treated with placebos like reiki,
   scientists also advocate that they receive treatments that demonstrably work 
   better that placebo. For instance, massage has been shown to improve the
   wellbeing of cancer patients beyond a placebo effect. If a patient receives a
   massage with empathy, sympathy, time, understanding and dedication, she
   would benefit from the placebo effect – just like the reiki patient – but, in
   addition, she would also benefit from the specific effect of the treatment
   that massage does and Reiki does not offer.

This is a critical point that I have been making also. Essentially, you cannot
justify ineffective treatments simply because they provide a placebo effect.
That is because effective treatments also provide the same placebo effect, but
also provide specific benefits because they actually work.

I would argue that there are also many potential harms from convincing patients 
that unscientific treatments are effective because of their non-specific placebo
effects. This is a deception, violates patient autonomy and informed consent,
and sets them up to perhaps rely on ineffective “magical” treatments for
non-self-limiting illnesses.

Let’s get back to the authors conclusions from the Reiki study – they argue that
this study shows that the:

   “presence of an RN providing one-on-one support during chemotherapy was
   influential in raising comfort and well-being levels…”

The part about “with or without an attempted healing energy field” is entirely
irrelevant, and you could just as well substitute any ineffective or magical
treatment for “healing energy” is that statement. But the first part of the
conclusion is also dubious, in that we did not need this study to come to this
conclusion.

It has already been well-established, to the point that it is appropriately
taken as a given, that people feel better when they get the kind attention of
someone else, especially if they are sick and that person is a health care
professional with training and experience in comforting sick patients. We don’t 
need to keep studying this over and over again.

Kind attention plus X makes people feel better, just as well as kind attention
alone. Great. We do not need to study this with every possible form of
unscientific intervention filling in for X. And it is deceptive and unscientific
to suggest that whatever fills in for X has some value because of this
equation.

This is what I call the “part of this complete breakfast” fallacy. Even as a
child I recognized that when a commercial advertised their pastries as being
part of the complete nutrition offered by an otherwise nutritious breakfast, the
pastries were nutritionally irrelevant. They added nothing, and the commercial 
was being deceptive in trying to make me think that they were nutritious simply 
by their proximity to a nutritious breakfast.

Reiki, acupuncture, homeopathy, and similar methods may be “part of this
feel-good intervention,” but they are an irrelevant and superfluous part. It is 
the kind attention of the practitioner that matters – and only that attention.
So such attention might as well be part of legitimate science-based
interventions that also have a specific physiological benefit.

This suggests that the real purpose of the ritual of reiki, or other superfluous
placebo ritual, is not to achieve a positive end for the patient but to give
the practitioner a marketable “skill” (even though the evidence shows that
someone without any such skill or training can get the same results). In a
recent article about reiki making its way into hospitals, Kryak and Vitale
write:

   There is a growing interest among health care providers, especially
   professional nurses to promote caring-healing approaches in patient care and 
   self-care. Health care environments are places of human caring and holistic
   nurses are helping to lead the way that contemporary health care institutions
   must become holistic places of healing. The practice of Reiki as well as
   other practices can assist in the creation of this transformative process.

I submit that if the goal is to make hospitals and other health care
environments more nurturing, promoting reiki and similar modalities is that
exactly wrong way to do it. They are tying a worthwhile goal to blatant
pseudoscience, and therefore legitimate resistance to the pseudoscience will
also cause resistance to the nurturing.

If we accept that health care environments can be improved by more time and
resources being applied to patient comfort, reduced anxiety, and enhanced self
sense of well-being – then let’s use what works, the time and attention of a
caring provider. The placebo ritual that is reiki (or acupuncture, or whatever) 
is wasteful, distracting, and arguably unethical. It unnecessarily complicates
efforts to improve patient caring by promoting demonstrable pseudoscience.

No, editors of The Atlantic, reiki does not work

Over the weekend, The Atlantic published an article by Jordan Kisner touting the
benefits of reiki and arguing that you shouldn’t listen to all those nasty
skeptics calling it woo-woo. Unsurprisingly, the article is a credulous mess
citing only token skepticism and relying on weak evidence. The Atlantic‘s
embrace of quackery continues.

David Gorski on March 9, 2020

Link



I subscribed to The Atlantic for many years, having been introduced to through
my mother’s subscription while I was in high school and college and then
subscribing to it myself after I had moved away from southeast Michigan. That
all stopped in 2009 when I noticed that the magazine had taken a distinctive
turn away from medical evidence in the form of articles spreading misinformation
about the H1N1 pandemic, promoting the “integration” of quackery, mysticism,
and pseudoscience into medicine, revisionist history of the “evolution” of
“integrative medicine,” and even apologetics for chelation therapy. I guess
that’s not enough pseudoscience for The Atlantic, though, because over the
weekend I became aware that apparently the editors of the magazine are all in
for reiki, as demonstrated by a recently published article by Jordan Kisner:

Great. @TheAtlantic goes all-in for a medical scam. @gorskon @CaulfieldTim
@stevennovella https://t.co/0hnSb6yMNk

— Steven Salzberg (@StevenSalzberg1) March 7, 2020

What a title!

I hadn’t heard of Jordan Kisner before; so I did a bit of Googling. She’s a
writer who’s published in several major magazines. She’s written a book called
Thin Places: Essays from In Between, titled after an essay she had written about
an experimental neurosurgery developed to treat severe obsessive-compulsive
disorder. Her article has been noticed, and she’s aware of the pushback:

Good morning! I wrote for @TheAtlantic about reiki & the swirl of conflicting
opinions it produces, even among ppl who practice it. As expected, my mentions
are a MESS. Hope you enjoy 😉 https://t.co/TMySjJGhzP

— Jordan Kisner (@jordan_kisner) March 7, 2020

To be honest, I really didn’t think that The Atlantic could go much lower in
terms of promoting quackery, but, damn, did they prove me wrong! Reiki?
Seriously? If there are two quackeries battling it out for the title of The One 
Quackery To Rule Them All, based on their sheer ridiculousness and disconnect
from reality, homeopathy is obviously a contender, but so is reiki. Reiki is
based on the belief that a reiki master is able to channel “healing energy” from
something called the “universal source” into another person, with therapeutic
effect. Of course, as we’ve discussed more times than I can possibly remember
over the years, no one has ever detected or demonstrated the existence of this
“life force” or energy (or a “universal source,” for that matter), much less
anyone’s ability to control or channel it. Basically, reiki is faith healing
that substitutes a different mystical belief system for Christianity. Replace
the word “God” or “Jesus” with “universal source”, and there really is no
conceptual difference in what is happening. It’s the laying on of hands, pure
and simple.

Ms. Kisner starts with the rightful skepticism that many express regarding
reiki:

   “When I started it, they all just called it that crap. Like, ‘Oh, they’re
   over there doing that crap.’ ” This nurse, whom I’ll call Jamie, was on the
   line from a Veterans Affairs medical center in the Northeast. She’d been
   struggling for a few minutes between the impulse to tout the program she’d
   piloted, which offers Reiki to vets as part of their medical care, and the
   impulse to “tread lightly,” because some of the doctors, nurses, and
   administrators she works with still think that Reiki is quackery or—you know.

   Reiki, a healing practice codified in the early 20th century in Japan, was
   until recently an unexpected offering for a VA medical center. In Japanese,
   rei roughly translates to “spiritual”; ki is commonly translated as “vital
   energy.” A session often looks more like mysticism than medicine: Healers
   silently place their hands on or over a person’s body to evoke a “universal
   life force.” A Reiki treatment can even, practitioners believe, be conducted 
   from miles away.

Yes, reiki masters do claim to be able to heal over distances, in which case
reiki resembles intercessory prayer more than anything else. Of course, there’s 
no evidence that they can, in fact, do anything of the sort.

I nearly coughed up the coffee I was drinking as I wrote this when I read the
next paragraph:

   Reiki’s growing popularity in the U.S.—and its acceptance at some of the most
   respected American hospitals—has placed it at the nexus of large, uneasy
   shifts in American attitudes toward our own health care. Various non-Western 
   practices have become popular complements to conventional medicine in the
   past few decades, chief among them yoga, meditation, and acupuncture, all of 
   which have been the subject of rigorous scientific studies that have
   established and explained their effectiveness. Reiki is the latest entrant
   into the suite of common additional treatments. Its presence is particularly 
   vexing to naysayers because Reiki delivers demonstrable salutary effects
   without a proven cause.

Take that, skeptics! How does your science explain that? Well, let’s see what
I’m supposed to be explaining:

   Over the past two decades, a number of studies have shown that Reiki
   treatments help diminish the negative side effects of chemotherapy, improve
   surgical outcomes, regulate the autonomic nervous system, and dramatically
   alter people’s experience of physical and emotional pain associated with
   illness. But no conclusive, peer-reviewed study has explained its mechanisms,
   much less confirmed the existence of a healing energy that passes between
   bodies on command. Nevertheless, Reiki treatment, training, and education are
   now available at many esteemed hospitals in the United States, including
   Memorial Sloan Kettering, Cleveland Clinic, New York Presbyterian, the Yale
   Cancer Center, the Mayo Clinic, and Brigham and Women’s Hospital.

Yes, it is true that, unfortunately, reiki has infiltrated quite a few
respectable hospitals. Heck, I’ve been bemoaning this development a long time,
ever since I first discovered the ridiculous reiki pamphlet published by the
Cleveland Clinic that touts reiki as “hands-on natural healing using the
universal life force energy…which means vital life force energy that flows
through all living things. Reiki, an abundant, gentle spiritual energy is not
tied to any specific religion or nationality.”

What about the studies that Ms. Kisner linked to? The first one is utterly
worthless. It’s not randomized. There’s no control group. It’s not blinded. It’s
just a single arm study in which subjects underwent reiki sessions and filled
out an online questionnaire immediately before and after. There is nothing in
the positive results reported in this study that couldn’t be easily explained by
a combination of placebo effects and relaxation from lying on a table for an
hour while someone pays attention to you.

The second study is only slightly better. It’s basically a randomized trial of
reiki versus classical music versus nothing in patients recovering from acute
coronary syndrome (heart attack). It’s unblinded as well, and there’s no result 
reported there that couldn’t be explained by a combination of human contact,
placebo effects, and relaxation. It’s also a ten-year-old study, and a pilot
study at that. I was unable to find a follow-up. This is really, really thin
gruel to be basing such expansive claims for the effectiveness of reiki on.

So what else does Ms. Kisner have? Anecdotes, of course:

   When Jamie introduced Reiki at the VA center 10 years ago, she overrode the
   objections of some colleagues who thought it was pseudoscience and out of
   step with the general culture of the VA, where people are inclined to be
   suspicious of anything that might be described as “woo woo.” But she insisted
   that the VA—which also offers yoga, acupuncture, massage, clinical hypnosis,
   and tai chi—should explore any supplementary treatment for chronic pain and 
   PTSD that doesn’t involve pharmaceuticals, especially narcotics. The veterans
   started coming, slowly, and the ones who came started coming back. Jamie
   didn’t promise anything other than that it might help them feel calm or help 
   them with pain. The Reiki practitioner she hired was a local woman, somewhat 
   hard-nosed, not inclined to offer anyone crystals. Soon after the program
   began, Jamie was getting calls from doctors and nurses: “Hey, is the lady
   here? Someone wants that crap.”

   The effects were startling, Jamie told me. Veterans who complained that their
   body had “forgotten how to sleep” came in for Reiki and were asleep on the
   table within minutes. Others reported that their pain declined from a 4 to a 
   2, or that they felt more peaceful. One patient, a man with a personality
   disorder who suffers from cancer and severe pain, tended to stop his normal
   routine of screaming and yelling at the staff when he came in for his Reiki
   sessions.

Has she ever done any sort of rigorous studies to try to determine if reiki, in 
fact, does what she claims it does? Reiki research is, of course, plagued with
the same sorts of methodological flaws that so much research into “alternative” 
medicine is plagued with. It’s uncommon to find a serious attempt at blinding,
for instance, even single blinding the patients, and most studies have sample
sizes that are way too small to make much in the way of conclusions. Then there 
is the issue of prior plausibility. Again, there is no evidence that there is
any mystical magical energy field that another human being can impact by
channeling mystical magical energy from a mystical magical universal source. If 
you’re going to convince me that reiki is worth investigating, there has to be
concrete evidence that its effects go beyond that of just placebo, regression to
the mean, and confirmation bias.

Later in the article, Ms. Kisner describes her experiences after she decided to 
train to be able perform reiki. She signed up to be able to learn to do hands-on
practice and distance healing. (Master training is the next level up, where one
can teach others reiki.) There were actually some unintentionally hilarious
bits in this section of the article, in which Ms. Kisner described some of what 
she was taught, and this question and answer session with the reiki masters
teaching the course:

   You can do Reiki on animals, they told us. “Cats are extra attuned to
   Reiki—cats almost do Reiki on their own. They can heal you.” No one
   questioned this. The same goes for plants, the masters suggested. Get two
   roses and give Reiki to one; that rose will live longer. A student raised her
   hand. “But you told us never to give Reiki without consent. How can you get 
   consent from a flower or a tree?”

   “You can talk to a tree!” one of the masters said. “You should always ask the
   tree’s permission. Maybe it will tell you to Reiki the next tree.” I glanced
   around the room for raised eyebrows, but there were only more eager
   questions: Can you Reiki someone who has transitioned to the afterlife? Yes. 
   Can you Reiki your food to make it healing? Yes, and you should.

   We were told that once the masters attuned us, our bodies and spirits would
   vibrate at a higher frequency than before, and we would stay on that higher
   frequency for the rest of our life. This would constitute a permanent
   transition in our physical and spiritual states. I was silently indignant: I 
   do not believe in permanently alterable personal vibrations, whatever that
   means, and anyway I wanted mine left alone.

And yet she went through with the class anyway.

Still, based on this sort of question and answer session, it’s hard to conclude 
that reiki is anything but magic. You can aim it at anything you want and
magically make it better, more “healthy”. Cats, being creatures long associated 
with witchcraft, are naturally more receptive to reiki and even able to do it.
One wonders, though. If reiki is magic, can it be used for evil? Just as there
is black magic, is there black reiki? Inquiring minds want to know!

As for the “attunement” that the masters did at the end of the course to grant
their trainees the “power” to do reiki, it sure sounds a lot like a religious
initiation ceremony than anything else:

   And then, the moment for attunement having arrived, we were led in small
   groups to a narrow, darkened room. Before we passed through the doorway, one 
   of the masters traced Reiki symbols in the air over each of us. “You guys,”
   said the other, making what I hoped was a joke, “we’re going to visit some
   other planets.” I can’t describe what happened next, because our eyes were
   closed while the masters performed silent rituals that aren’t explained to
   nonmasters.

I will give Ms. Kisner credit for one thing. In her paragraph of token
skepticism, she quotes Steve Novella and me:

   Many physicians and scientists still believe that allowing Reiki to share
   space with medicine is at best silly and at worst dangerous. In 2014, David
   Gorski, a surgical oncologist, and Steven Novella, a neurologist, co-wrote an
   article calling for an end to clinical trials of Reiki and other forms of
   energy medicine. To assess approaches rooted in “prescientific thinking” with
   tools designed to evaluate “well-supported science- and evidence-based”
   treatments, they argued, degrades “the scientific basis of medicine.” It saps
   resources from research into valid therapies, and misleads patients.

Well, yes. Nothing’s happened in the nearly six years since we published that
article to make me change my mind. Ms. Kisner’s response:

   Other doctors and researchers have accepted the line of argument that Miles
   and many other Reiki advocates have put forward: The practice has no known
   negative side effects, and has been shown by various studies that pass
   evidentiary muster to help patients in a variety of ways when used as a
   complementary practice. Unlike the many FDA-approved medications that barely 
   beat a placebo in studies and carry negative side effects, Reiki is cheap and
   safe to implement. Does its exact mechanism need to be understood for it to 
   be accepted as a useful therapeutic option? For decades, experts weren’t
   precisely sure how acetaminophen (Tylenol) eases pain, but Americans still
   took billions of doses every year. Many medical treatments are adopted for
   their efficacy long before their mechanisms are known or understood. Why
   should this be different?

This is a common trope invoked by supporters of quackery; so I’ll tell her why
it’s different. We might not have known the biochemical and physiological
mechanism of aspirin and acetaminophen, but, unlike the case for reiki, we had
strong evidence that they actually did relieve pain and, in the case of aspirin,
inflammation. Furthermore, we knew that, however they worked, the mechanism did
not involve invoking mystical magical energy fields and a physical mechanism
that violates the laws of physics and chemistry.

In fact, some reiki advocates, like Pamela Miles, seem to understand this very
objection:

   Miles falls on the conservative end of Reiki evangelists in that she’s
   careful not to make claims about its mechanisms or efficacy that can’t be
   supported in a scientific context. She does not, for example, subscribe to
   the belief that Reiki energy is a substance that can be given, received, or
   measured. No evidence of this has been confirmed, she pointed out. “Reiki is 
   a spiritual practice,” she said. “That’s what it was to the founder, Mikao
   Usui. And all spiritual practices have healing by-products because spiritual 
   practice restores balance, bringing us back to our center, and enhancing our 
   awareness of our core selves.” When I asked her to explain what that meant
   practically, she chose her words carefully. “Through an unknown mechanism,
   when a Reiki practitioner places their hands—mindfully and with detachment—it
   evokes the healing response from deep within the system,” she said. “We
   really don’t know why this happens.”

Of course, this is still faith healing, laying on hands. The difference is that 
it invokes mystery: We don’t know. Also, there’s no evidence that reiki “evokes 
a healing response from deep within the system.” There’s no convincing evidence 
of any specific effect from reiki that can’t be explained by a combination of
placebo effects, regression to the mean, confirmation bias, and perhaps
relaxation.

Still, this brings me to how I would handle reiki. Personally, I view reiki as
more of a religious practice. It is not medicine; so it should not be treated as
medicine. Don’t “integrate” reiki into medicine, because, again, it is not
medicine. Don’t make any health claims for reiki Instead, treat reiki masters
like chaplains and their visits to patients the same way health care facilities 
treat visits by priests, ministers, rabbis, and imams.

As for The Atlantic, stop publishing utterly credulous paeans to quackery like
this article.

Reiki: Fraudulent Misrepresentation

Jann Bellamy on June 12, 2014

Link



The Center for Integrative Medicine at the Cleveland Clinic sells reiki
treatments (also here) to patients with cancer, fertility issues, Parkinson’s
Disease and digestive problems, as well as other diseases and conditions. The
Center’s website ad describes reiki as

   a form of hands-on, natural healing that uses universal life force energy . .
   . [a] vital life force energy that flows through all living things. This
   gentle energy is limitless in abundance and is believed to be a spiritual
   form of energy. The Reiki practitioner is the conduit between you and the
   source of the universal life force energy. . . You may experience the energy 
   as sensations such as heat, tingling, or pulsing where the practitioner
   places her hands on your body, or you may feel these sensations move through 
   your body to other locations. This is the energy flowing into you.

This “universal life force energy” is described as having certain positive
effects on one’s own energy, such as “energetically balancing” one physically,
replenishing one’s supply of energy, improving distribution of that energy in
the body, and dissolving “energy blockages.” It also increases one’s
“vibrational frequencies,” although how these frequencies relate to one’s
energy, or to anything else for that matter, is not made clear.

The Center claims that reiki has specific medical benefits. These include:

  1. Lessening symptoms and side effects of traditional treatments

  2. Success in all types of physical healing

  3. Detoxifying the body

  4. Pain relief

  5. Stimulating bone and tissue healing after injury or surgery

  6. Stimulating the body’s immune system

If you are in good health, the Center recommends monthly reiki treatments to
“enhance your ability to respond to unhealthy elements in your environment and
help you to handle stress.”

For those of you not familiar with the Cleveland Clinic, it is a top ranked (and
here) U.S. hospital, although it has experienced some difficulties of late.
According to its website:

   All health information posted on the site is based on the latest research and
   national treatment standards, and have been written or reviewed and approved
   by Cleveland Clinic physicians or health professionals unless otherwise
   specified.

The website is HonCode certified.

The Cleveland Clinic is not the only hospital selling reiki to patients.
According to a recent article in the Washington Post:

   More than 60 U.S. hospitals have adopted Reiki as part of patient services,
   according to a UCLA study, and Reiki education is offered at 800 hospitals.

The Cleveland Clinic touts this popularity as a selling point for reiki:

   Its popularity has spread all over the world, and is now used in many medical
   facilities, such as hospitals and hospices.

Which brings up an interesting question: Could a medical facility’s selling
reiki to the public give rise to an individual or class action lawsuit for
fraud? If so, then hospitals and other health care facilities are needlessly
subjecting themselves to liability, something they generally go to great strides
to avoid.

Homeopathy could serve as a cautionary tale for the hospital industry. Numerous 
class actions based on fraud, as well as consumer protection laws, have been
filed against homeopathic remedy manufacturers in the last several years. (Class
actions can aggregate many small claims of financial loss for plaintiffs
unlikely to bring individual suits.) To my knowledge, all of these have settled,
costing the companies millions of dollars. One manufacturer has decided to opt 
out of the American and Canadian markets because of liability concerns.
Homeopathic products are still very much on the shelves but, then again,
homeopathic remedy companies seem fairly shameless. I would think that medical
facilities, which trade on their reputations for excellence in patient care,
have a lot more to fear from a suit for fraudulent misrepresentation.

I wrote about CAM and fraud a couple of years ago, but it is a subject worth
revisiting. As we’ve seen, the mere lack of scientific plausibility, evidence of
effectiveness or collateral damage doesn’t appear to penetrate the mindset of
those who engage in CAM promotion. Perhaps the unseemly optics of being a
defendant in an action for fraud, plus the possible financial impact, could
chill the passion for integrating pseudoscience into otherwise respectable
medical organizations.

The law of fraudulent misrepresentation

What is fraud? It can take a number of forms: tort, contract, criminal. The
concept has been incorporated into several specialized state and federal laws,
such as deceptive trade practices, consumer protection and securities laws.
Here, we are discussing what is known as the tort of fraudulent
misrepresentation, also called deceit. Fraud is a very old concept adopted in
America from the English legal system when it became an independent country with
its own system of laws. While the law of fraudulent misrepresentation varies in
some respects from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, here we’ll use a general
statement of its elements from the Restatement 2d of Torts. (The Restatement is 
sort of “best practices” guide to certain areas of the law composed by experts
in the field.)

If you want to successfully sue someone for fraudulent misrepresentation, you
have to prove certain defined elements of that tort. Let’s imagine a
hypothetical case in which the plaintiff is a cancer patient who receives
ongoing treatment at a certain hospital. In our discussion, we’ll assume that
the patient has seen the hospital’s website advertisement for reiki and that it 
contains the same information as the Cleveland Clinic’s ad. The patient has
decided to purchase a session with one of the hospital’s integrative medicine
center’s practitioners. We’ll also assume that the information given to our
cancer patient in person is the same as, or at least not inconsistent with, the 
information in the ad.

Here’s what the patient will have to prove to win his case against the hospital:

  1. The hospital fraudulently made a misrepresentation of fact or opinion.

  2. The hospital intended to induce the patient to purchase a reiki session.

  3. The patient acted in justifiable reliance on the misrepresentation.

  4. Pecuniary damage to the patient resulting from his reliance.

Let’s get a few of these out of the way right off the bat. The hospital
obviously intends that the patient rely on its advertisement for reiki in
purchasing its services, that is, it “intends to induce plaintiff to act.” And, 
to the extent the patient paid for those services, the patient has suffered
damages, even though the amount may be small. The hospital would also be liable 
for any physical harm caused by reiki. As reiki has no known ill effects, a fact
that undercuts its very credibility as a treatment, we can safely assume
physical harm won’t be an issue.

(Although it would certainly make for an amusing case if the patient claimed
that reiki actually messed up his “energy distribution,” thereby making him even
more ill. How would the hospital defend against that? Would it put on evidence 
that this energy doesn’t exist and can’t cause any harm, thus proving the
patient’s case for misrepresentation?)

Misrepresentation of facts

To recap, here’s what the patient is told: During reiki, a practitioner receives
energy from a source, then proceeds to replenish the patient’s own energy
and/or manipulate the patient’s energy by causing it to move through the body.
The practitioner can also unblock energy to facilitate its proper flow.
Objective evidence that energy is flowing may be felt by the patient in the form
of heat, tingling or pulsing. Treatment effects are both a positive effect on
the body’s energy itself and specific improvements in the patient’s medical
condition, such as stimulation of bone and tissue healing after injury or
surgery, an unspecified “success” in physical healing and “detoxifying” the
body.

Here is what we actually know about reiki:

  1. There is no evidence that this “energy” exists or that it’s putative deficit
    or suboptimal movement is detrimental to health.

  2. Physical effects such as tingling must be attributed to some other phenomena.

  3. Reiki is ineffective, although it may evoke some sort of placebo response.

  4. “Detoxification” and “boosting the immune system,” are bogus.

So, yes, there are misrepresentations in the ad.

Even if the hospital were to argue that the statements are in fact true and that
there was some evidence (no matter how poor) in support of the ad’s claims, we 
can still characterize the ad as misleading.

   A statement containing a half-truth may be as misleading as a statement
   wholly false. Thus, a statement that contains only favorable matters and
   omits all reference to unfavorable matters is as much a false represention as
   if all the facts stated were untrue.

Restatement 2d of Torts, Sec. 529, comment a.

To avoid characterization as misleading, the ad should, at the very least,
inform the patient of reiki’s lack of plausibility and the extremely poor
quality of the evidence supporting its use. Even at that, it might not pass
muster.

Are these misrepresentations fraudulent?

Whether a misrepresentation is fraudulent refers solely to the hospitals
knowledge of the untrue character of it representations. I know hospitals are
business entities, such as corporations, and they can’t “know” anything except
through their employees and other agents who act for them. But to keep it
simple, we’ll just refer to the hospital itself instead of having to say “the
hospital’s employee” or “the hospital’s agent.” And we won’t worry about whether
the reiki practitioner was totally clueless and really believed what the ad
said. Hopefully she doesn’t hold such a position of authority that there is no
medical doctor somewhere up the supervisory line who holds the responsibility of
knowing what she is up to. Why? Because no medical doctor could credibly
testify he did not know, or did not strongly suspect, that the ad wasn’t telling
the full story. Or, at the least, he knew there must be some disconfirming
evidence to contradict the ad’s claims. His knowledge is the hospital’s
knowledge from a legal standpoint.

The law of fraudulent misrepresentation does not get into issues of whether the 
hospital’s intent was pure or whether it was “trying to help.” “Intent” refers
to the intent to withhold information, or to give false information, not intent 
in some evil sense. What the law requires, if you are selling a product or
service to a consumer, is that you tell the consumer what you know about the
product or service and you don’t leave out information that a person purchasing 
your product would want to know. (I think we can safely assume that a patient
would want to know that a treatment is worthless.)

If you don’t have the complete story, but you operate with a reckless
indifference to what the complete story is, you can also be held liable. Or if
you represent something as fact when you actually know you don’t have all the
facts, or don’t think you do, you can be held liable as well. In short, you
can’t represent something as a fact unless you indeed know it is a fact, or at
least honestly think you know it as a fact, without doubts or a disregard for
the facts. A hospital that presents itself as offering the best care, yet fails 
to determine the full extent of the evidence for (or against) that care, or
knows there is other evidence out there that may contradict what it is telling
patients, is potentially liable for fraudulent misrepresentation whether the
treatment is chemotherapy or reiki. It makes no difference as far as liability
is concerned.

Was our patient’s reliance on the hospital’s claims justifiable?

So far, we’ve looked at the hospital’s conduct and found that, based on the
facts we’ve used in our hypothetical, the hospital has both misrepresented the
facts and has done so intentionally. Let’s turn to our cancer patient, because
to successfully make out a case for fraudulent misrepresentation, we have to
show that the patient (a) relied on the misrepresentation in deciding to
purchase a reiki treatment and that (b) the reliance was justified.

We’ve already determined that the patient relied on the hospital’s information –
otherwise, why would he buy the treatment? But was his reliable justifiable?

If the patient were you or I (if you are a faithful SBM reader), we would know
that the hospital’s claims are false, and we wouldn’t win. Actual knowledge of
falsity bars recovery. But what about other patients, who don’t know anything
about reiki? Are they required to do their own research? No, not in an action
for fraudulent misrepresentation, even where the falsity of the information
about reiki could have been ascertained without much trouble or expense. (Say,
by reading Science-Based Medicine, or Wikipedia, or Respectful Insolence.) If a 
patient is highly suspicious, there might be a question of whether he relied on 
the misrepresentations or whether his reliance was justifiable, and some
jurisdictions do impose a duty to investigate where there is reason to suspect a
statement is false.

But the standard is not whether a reasonable person would investigate these
claims. That is the standard for contributory negligence – what a reasonable
person would do – and contributory negligence is not applicable in fraudulent
misrepresentation lawsuits, because it is an intentional tort. The only question
would be is whether the patient himself was suspicious of falsity. (And that
would be a dicey question for the defendant’s attorney to ask the plaintiff:
“Didn’t you even suspect my client’s statements were false?”) He is not required
to investigate. This is especially true where, as here, the plaintiff may
particularly vulnerable due to his illness and the defendant knows of that
vulnerability. (Of course, the hospital could not be heard to argue that it
didn’t know its cancer patients are vulnerable due to their illness.) It is also
especially true where there is a relationship of trust and confidence between
the plaintiff and defendant, a situation that most certainly describes that
between a patient and hospital, especially where the hospital advertises itself 
as providing top notch care.

Closing argument

To sum up the case for our cancer patient: The hospital advertised a treatment, 
reiki, claiming it provides specific health benefits by adding to, moving and/or
unblocking the patient’s “energy.” The hospital knew these claims are false (or
it disregarded the facts), yet intended that our patient rely on these false
claims in order to induce him to purchase one or more reiki sessions. The
plaintiff did, in fact, rely on the hospital’s statements of health benefits and
was justified in believing reiki could actually produce these benefits, a
reliance grounded, in part, because he believed that his hospital would provide 
accurate health information. Our patient has proved all the elements of
fraudulent misrepresentation and should win his case.

Reiki: Fraudulent Misrepresentation – Revisited

Factual misrepresentations about manipulating “energy” in a patient’s body and
its positive effects on health are integral to reiki. They can also be the basis
of an action for fraudulent misrepresentation.

Jann Bellamy on September 28, 2017

Link



I’m on vacation, so I’ve updated a post from several years ago.

Six years ago, I confessed in one of my early SBM posts that, during my
continuing education about so-called “complementary and alternative” medicine
[I’d add “integrative medicine” now], one question presented itself in my mind
over and over: Isn’t that fraud? In that post I concluded:

   As criticism of CAM for scientific implausibility grows and study after study
   fails to support claims of effectiveness, we may reach a point where it
   becomes impossible for the CAM practitioner to avoid knowing that CAM is
   based on misrepresentations, making it much harder to defeat claims of
   fraudulent misrepresentation.

Wrong! At least in part. There’s no doubt the putative evidence base for CAM
products and practices has shriveled in the past six years as we’ve chronicled
in many SBM posts on subjects like acupuncture, homeopathy, chiropractic, and
supplements. But those who promote CAM, now rebranded as “integrative medicine,”
appear to be totally unfazed by the prospect that they are fudging on the facts
and possibly subjecting themselves to liability.

A few years later, I pointed out how claims made by the venerable Cleveland
Clinic for reiki might well constitute the tort of fraudulent misrepresentation.
Unfortunately, no one seems to have listened. While some of the Cleveland
Clinic’s material on reiki appears to have been rewritten since that post,
demonstrable misrepresentations remain. They’ve even added a new form of “energy
medicine” (the category of woo under which reiki is catalogued) called “Eden
Energy Medicine.” (If you’d like to read a big load of woo-speak “explaining”
Eden Energy Medicine, you can do so here, complete with a discussion of “energy 
points” and, as you’d expect , “quantum compatibility.”)

In fact, the Cleveland Clinic publicly reaffirmed its commitment to quackademic 
medicine just this year. After public outcry over an anti-vaccination screed
written by the director of the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute forced the
Clinic’s CEO to issue a strongly-worded statement supporting vaccination
science, some wondered if this might signal a repudiation of pseudoscience.

Sadly, no. A full-throated defense of selling services with no plausibility
and/or insufficient evidence of effectiveness followed quickly on the heels of
the Cleveland Clinic’s mea culpa. The Cleveland Clinic’s Wellness Institute
still offers acupuncture, acupressure, laser acupuncture, craniosacral therapy, 
therapeutic touch, functional medicine, chiropractic, and herbs (also here) as
well as “energy medicine,” in addition to the aforementioned reiki and Eden
Energy Medicine. It proffers wholly credulous descriptions of “integrative”
treatments on its website.

The Wellness Institute describes reiki as:

   hands-on, natural healing that uses the universal life force energy . . . [a]
   vital life force energy that flows through all living things . . . The Reiki
   practitioner is the conduit between the patient and the source of the
   universal life force energy; the energy flows through the practitioner’s
   energy field and through her hands to the patient. . . . [She] places her
   hands in specific energy locations . . . [t]he length of time determined by
   the flow of energy through her hands. . . . The patient experiences the
   energy as sensations such as heat, tingling, or pulsing where the
   practitioner has placed her hands. Sometimes, the sensations are felt moving 
   through the body.

This “universal life force energy” has, according to the Institute, certain
positive effects, such as dissolving “energy blockages” and “supply[ing]
universal life force energy to the body.” It also increases one’s “vibrational
frequency on physical, mental emotional and spiritual levels,” although how
these frequencies relate to one’s energy, or to anything else for that matter,
is not made clear.

In its explanation of energy medicine, under the heading “What We Treat” (note
the use of the word “treat”), the Institute claims that various “energy
techniques,” such as the practitioner moving her hands over the body, creates
“new energy patterns” which “improve health.” The Institute asserts that energy 
medicine in general, including reiki, benefits certain medical conditions,
including:

  1. Depression

  2. Digestive issues

  3. Autoimmune conditions

  4. Cancer treatment recovery

  5. Hormone imbalance

As for reiki in particular, the Institute says it will “improve overall health” 
and “may do the following:”

  1. Detoxifying the body

  2. Help to relieve pain

  3. Stimulate bone and tissue healing after injury or surgery

  4. Stimulate the body’s immune system

If you are in good health, the Institute recommends monthly reiki treatments to:

   enhance your ability to respond to unhealthy elements in your environment and
   help you to handle stress. By promoting the harmonious distribution of
   energy, Reiki is an excellent form of preventive medicine.

According to its website:

   All health information posted on the site is based on the latest research and
   national treatment standards, and have been written or reviewed and approved
   by Cleveland Clinic physicians or health professionals unless otherwise
   specified.

Of course, the Cleveland Clinic is not the only hospital selling reiki to
patients. According to an article in the Washington Post:

   More than 60 U.S. hospitals have adopted Reiki as part of patient services,
   according to a UCLA study, and Reiki education is offered at 800 hospitals.

Which brings up an interesting question: Could a medical facility’s selling
reiki to the public give rise to an individual or class action lawsuit for
fraud? If so, then hospitals and other health care facilities are needlessly
subjecting themselves to liability, something they generally go to great strides
to avoid.

The law of fraudulent misrepresentation

What is fraud? It can take a number of forms: tort, contract, criminal. The
concept has been incorporated into several specialized state and federal laws,
such as deceptive trade practices, consumer protection and securities laws.
Here, we are discussing what is known as the tort of fraudulent
misrepresentation, also called deceit. Fraud is a very old concept adopted in
America from the English legal system when it became an independent country with
its own system of laws. While the law of fraudulent misrepresentation varies in
some respects from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, here we’ll use a general
statement of its elements from the Restatement 2d of Torts. (The Restatement is 
sort of “best practices” guide to certain areas of the law composed by experts
in the field.)

If you want to successfully sue someone for fraudulent misrepresentation, you
have to prove certain defined elements of that tort. Let’s imagine a
hypothetical case in which the plaintiff is a cancer patient who has had surgery
to resect a tumor and receives ongoing treatment at a hospital. In our
discussion, we’ll assume that the patient has seen his hospital’s website
advertisement for energy medicine, specifically reiki, and that it contains the 
same information as the Cleveland Clinic’s. The patient has decided to purchase 
several sessions with one of the hospital’s integrative medicine center’s
practitioners. We’ll also assume that the information given to our cancer
patient in person is the same as, or at least not inconsistent with, the
information on the Cleveland Clinic’s website.

Here’s what the patient will have to prove to win his case against the hospital:

  1. The hospital fraudulently made a misrepresentation of fact or opinion.

  2. The hospital intended to induce the patient to purchase a reiki session.

  3. The patient acted in justifiable reliance on the misrepresentation.

  4. Pecuniary damage to the patient resulting from his reliance.

Let’s get a couple of these out of the way right off the bat. The hospital
obviously intends that the patient rely on its advertisement for reiki in
purchasing its services, that is, it “intends to induce plaintiff to act.” And, 
to the extent the patient paid for those services, the patient has suffered
damages, even though the amount may be small. The hospital would also be liable 
for any physical harm caused by reiki. As reiki has no known ill effects, a fact
that undercuts its very credibility as a treatment, we can safely assume
physical harm won’t be an issue.

(Although it would certainly make for an amusing case if the patient claimed
that reiki actually messed up his “energy distribution,” thereby making him even
more ill. How would the hospital defend against that? Would it put on evidence 
that this energy doesn’t exist and can’t cause any harm, thus proving the
patient’s case for misrepresentation?)

Misrepresentation of facts

To recap, here’s what the patient is told: During reiki, a practitioner receives
energy from a source, then proceeds to manipulate the patient’s energy by
causing it to move through the body. The practitioner can also unblock energy to
facilitate its proper flow. Objective evidence that energy is flowing may be
felt by the patient in the form of heat, tingling or pulsing. Treatment effects 
are both a positive effect on the body’s energy itself and specific improvements
in the patient’s medical condition, such as stimulation of bone and tissue
healing after surgery, pain relief, stimulation of the immune system, and
“detoxifying” the body.

Here is what we actually know about reiki:

  1. There is no evidence that this “energy” exists or that it’s putative deficit
    or suboptimal movement is detrimental to health.

  2. Physical effects such as tingling must be attributed to some other phenomena.

  3. There is no credible evidence that reiki is effective for any medical
    condition, although it may evoke some sort of placebo response.

  4. “Detoxification” and “boosting the immune system,” are bogus.

So, yes, there are misrepresentations in the ad.

Even if the hospital were to argue that the statements are in fact true and that
there was some evidence (no matter how poor) in support of the ad’s claims, we 
can still characterize the ad as misleading.

   A statement containing a half-truth may be as misleading as a statement
   wholly false. Thus, a statement that contains only favorable matters and
   omits all reference to unfavorable matters is as much a false represention as
   if all the facts stated were untrue.

Restatement 2d of Torts, Sec. 529, comment a.

To avoid characterization as misleading, the ad should, at the very least,
inform the patient of reiki’s lack of plausibility and the extremely poor
quality of the evidence supporting its use. Even at that, it might not pass
muster.

Are these misrepresentations fraudulent?

Whether a misrepresentation is fraudulent refers solely to the hospital’s
knowledge of the untrue character of it representations. Of course, hospitals
are business entities, such as corporations, and they can’t “know” anything
except through their employees and other agents who act for them. But to keep it
simple, we’ll just refer to the hospital itself instead of having to say “the
hospital’s employee” or “the hospital’s agent.” And we won’t worry about whether
the reiki practitioner was totally clueless and really believed what the ad
said. Hopefully, she doesn’t hold such a position of authority that there is no 
medical doctor somewhere up the supervisory line who has the responsibility of
knowing what she is up to. Why? Because no medical doctor could credibly testify
he did not know, or did not strongly suspect, that the ad wasn’t telling the
full story. Or, at the least, he knew there must be some disconfirming evidence 
to contradict the ad’s claims. His knowledge is the hospital’s knowledge from a 
legal standpoint.

The law of fraudulent misrepresentation does not get into issues of whether the 
hospital’s intent was pure or whether it was “trying to help.” “Intent” refers
to the intent to withhold information, or to give false information, not intent 
in some evil sense. What the law requires, if you are selling a product or
service to a consumer, is that you tell the consumer what you know about the
product or service and you don’t leave out information that a person purchasing 
your product would want to know. (I think we can safely assume that a patient
would want to know that a treatment is worthless.)

If you don’t have the complete story, but you operate with a reckless
indifference to what the complete story is, you can also be held liable. Or if
you represent something as fact when you actually know you don’t have all the
facts, or think you might not have all the facts, you can be held liable as
well. In short, you can’t represent something as a fact unless you indeed know
it is a fact, or at least honestly think you know it as a fact, without doubts
or a disregard for the facts. A hospital that presents itself as offering the
best care, yet fails to determine the full extent of the evidence for (or
against) that care, or knows there is other evidence out there that may
contradict what it is telling patients, is potentially liable for fraudulent
misrepresentation whether the treatment is chemotherapy or reiki. It makes no
difference as far as liability is concerned.

Was our patient’s reliance on the hospital’s claims justifiable?

So far, we’ve looked at the hospital’s conduct and found that, based on the
facts we’ve used in our hypothetical, the hospital has both misrepresented the
facts and has done so intentionally. Let’s turn to our cancer patient, because
to successfully make out a case for fraudulent misrepresentation, we have to
show that the patient (a) relied on the misrepresentation in deciding to
purchase a reiki treatment and that (b) the reliance was justified.

We’ve already determined that the patient relied on the hospital’s information –
otherwise, why would he buy the treatment? But was his reliable justifiable?

If the patient were you (if you are a faithful SBM reader) or I, we would know
that the hospital’s claims are false, and we wouldn’t win. Actual knowledge of
falsity bars recovery. But what about other patients, who don’t know anything
about reiki? Are they required to do their own research? No, not in an action
for fraudulent misrepresentation, even where the falsity of the information
about reiki could have been ascertained without much trouble or expense. (Say,
by reading Science-Based Medicine, or Wikipedia, or Respectful Insolence.) If a 
patient is highly suspicious, there might be a question of whether he relied on 
the misrepresentations or whether his reliance was justifiable, and some
jurisdictions do impose a duty to investigate where there is reason to suspect a
statement is false.

But the standard is not whether a reasonable person would investigate these
claims. That is the standard for contributory negligence – what a reasonable
person would do – and contributory negligence is not applicable in fraudulent
misrepresentation lawsuits, because it is an intentional tort. The only question
would be is whether the patient himself was suspicious of falsity. (And that
would be a dicey question for the defendant’s attorney to ask the plaintiff:
“Didn’t you even suspect my client’s statements were false?”) He is not required
to investigate. This is especially true where, as here, the plaintiff may
particularly vulnerable due to his illness and the defendant knows of that
vulnerability. (Of course, the hospital could not be heard to argue that it
didn’t know its cancer patients are vulnerable due to their illness.) It is also
especially true where there is a relationship of trust and confidence between
the plaintiff and defendant, a situation that most certainly describes that
between a patient and hospital, especially where the hospital advertises itself 
as providing top notch care.

Closing argument

To sum up the case for our cancer patient: The hospital advertised a treatment, 
reiki, claiming it provides specific health benefits by adding to, moving and/or
unblocking the patient’s “energy.” The hospital knew these claims are false, or
it disregarded the facts, yet intended that our patient rely on these false
claims in order to induce him to purchase one or more reiki sessions. The
plaintiff did, in fact, rely on the hospital’s statements of health benefits and
was justified in believing reiki could actually produce these benefits, a
reliance grounded, in part, because he believed that his hospital would provide 
accurate health information. Our patient has proved all the elements of
fraudulent misrepresentation and should win his case.

Reiki and Therapeutic Touch. Compare and Contrast.

What? I’m not on vacation? I have to write a post? Crap. Remember those college 
essays? Compare and Contrast two topics and fill a Blue Book with your wisdom.
Well, let’s compare and contrast reiki and therapeutic touch, henceforth known
as RATT.

Mark Crislip on December 9, 2016

Link



What? I’m not on vacation? I have to write a post? Crap.

Remember those college essays? Compare and Contrast two topics and fill a Blue
Book with your wisdom. Do they even use Blue Books anymore? I always hated the
fact they were wide, rather than college, ruled. Now it is all about using Word 
and Microsoft doesn’t have a Blue Book mode.

See? There can be human progress. In Blue Books if not in medical education. I
was annoyed to learn that reiki was being offered for continuing medical
education at one of my institutions. We have so little pseudo-medicine where I
practice that duty rarely calls.

I could not let such an abomination pass without comment. So I fired up the
interwebs to find my SBM post on the topic…only to find such a post does not
exist. I did a podcast on the topic back in the early days before my SBM life.
Who wants to listen to a podcast from 2008? I am not even going to listen to it 
in preparation for this blog post.

I needed to write a review on the topic, not only to send to those who are
offering reiki for CME, but also for the wider world. Reiki, and to a lesser
extent its identical twin Therapeutic Touch, are remarkably popular in
integrative medicine clinics. And, of course, because the world needs more Mark 
Crislip™ even if I was recently described on iTunes as an:

   arrogant, intolerant, obscene verbal bully.

It is nice to know people are paying attention. Maybe that should be my motto.

RATTing out the science

To make my life easier, when applicable I will lump the two pseudo-medicines
together as RATT, Reiki And Therapeutic Touch.

RATT is a form of ‘energy’ therapy and, when it comes to ‘energy’, RATT
practitioners are evidently great fans of the Princess Bride, but then, who
isn’t?

Energy is, as us physics pedants like to point out, the ability to do work, and 
comes in many forms, from chemical to thermal.

The ‘energy’ of RATT (and all of CAM) is none of these energies known by
science. It isn’t even dark energy. It is ‘energy’, man, and what Thomas
Jefferson had in mind when he famously said

   Ridicule is the only weapon which can be used against unintelligible
   propositions. Ideas must be distinct before reason can act upon them; and no 
   man ever had a distinct idea of the CAM ‘energy’. It is the mere Abracadabra 
   of the mountebanks calling themselves practitioners of reiki.

Jefferson would probably have been called an arrogant, intolerant, obscene
verbal bully for a comment like that. ‘Energy’ deserves the scare quotes, much
the in same way you know that ‘fresh’ fish isn’t really fresh. There is no
‘energy’ and if the scare quotes had a brain they would recognize the fact.

Yes. I had to do that. Must…Write…Awful…Puns.

This ‘energy’, be it in RATT or Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine or
Chiropractic, is undetected and undetectable by reality-based measurements. We
can detect gravity waves but not the human energy field. My theory is that the
‘energy’ is propagated by vibrating (yes, there are vibrations) N rays. There
must be a carrier by which these ‘energies’ are transmitted. RATT and N rays do 
have the same key characteristic: they are detectable by their proponents until 
the ability of the observer to fool themselves is removed.

There is always the chance, however remote, that there is a new form of hitherto
unsuspected ‘energy’ that humans produce and can be detected only by humans,
although by what anatomical structure is uncertain. It took a PhD physicist to
demonstrate that N-rays were a figment of an overactive imagination. For
therapeutic touch it required a 6th grader.

Most readers of SBM are aware of Emily Rosa who, in 6th grade, tested the
ability of TT practitioners to detect a human ‘energy’ field with a simple and
elegant protocol. They couldn’t detect the ‘energy’ and Emily got a publication 
in JAMA.

Not that such a study dissuaded TT practitioners. Like a dowser who can’t find
water under controlled circumstances, the experience was not disconfirming of
the intervention. Arguments were raised to the JAMA results but as best I can
tell, TT proponents have never bothered to prove the basis of their practice.

So we have established that there is no human ‘energy’ as is understood by
reality-based science and, even if there was a new ‘energy’, its proponents
cannot prove it exists outside of their reiki box and the power of imagination.

So why does RATT even exist?

TT was, invented? discovered? pulled out of thin air? Just what to you call the 
process of producing works of fiction? Oh yeah. Created.

TT was created in the 70s by a Professor/RN and a “gifted energy healer”.
Gifted? Says who? How does someone get the designation of “gifted energy
healer”? I cannot imagine the steps required reach that lofty goal. Just imagine
the recertification test. And a google search reveals a step above, the truly
gifted energy healer. Somehow much better than a false, terrible energy healer.

I suspect that the popularity of TT derives from the urge in nursing to find a
unique way to interact with patients that allows independence from physicians.
And unlike much of quackademia, TT started at the quackademic hill top and then 
rolled down like, well you know the metaphor.

Reiki (bad spell checker. Not reeky. Yes more GOT, perhaps, but stop it) started
at the bottom, in fact rock bottom.

Usui Mikao created reiki. After being unable to hold down a steady job he became
a Buddhist priest and, after 21 days of fasting and prayer, hallucinating from 
hypoglycemia and sleep deprivation, it is said he came up with reeky. That’s
about right. Most medical acupuncture courses for example, are about three weeks
long. It doesn’t really take that much to learn most pseudo-medicines, much
less invent a whole new system. DD Palmer seems to have put together
chiropractic in a couple of days.

With a spiritual patina and Scientology-like levels, reiki does have the appeal,
I suppose, of the mysterious and ineffable.

Homeopathic touching

To me the most amazing characteristic of RATT is, for the most part, the patient
is not touched. Hands are just waved over the patient. Watch as a professor of 
nursing brushes flies off the, er, I mean balances the vibrational energy or
some such of her client. Client. Doesn’t she mean mark? Just don’t watch while
drinking milk.

And reiki? They seem to have the same creepy propensity of chiropractors for
demonstrating on pretty, scantily clad, females. And what is it up with THAT? TT
as Therapeutic Trump? Trump Touch?

But RATT is often the homeopathy of touch. Nothing there at all. No energy, no
touch. Do not even have to worry about good hand hygiene.

Having a RATT session does look beneficial. Who wouldn’t want to lie down and
relax during a busy day? An excuse for a nap is always welcome as long as the
whole” inappropriate groping disguised as energy balancing” thing didn’t occur.

RATTy research

But the fact that RATT is a fiction wrapped inside a charade inside a fraud
doesn’t mean there isn’t research. It just means the research stinks on ice.
Meta-analyses suggest a lack of methodological rigor. As one reiki meta-analysis
noted:

   The serious methodological and reporting limitations of limited existing
   Reiki studies preclude a definitive conclusion on its effectiveness.

Although I would disagree about the need for high quality studies for reiki.

Another review, including therapeutic touch, suggested:

   The methodologic limitations of several studies make it difficult to draw
   definitive conclusions about the efficacy of distant healing.

With a follow-up several years later suggesting:

   Since the publication of our previous systematic review in 2000, several
   rigorous new studies have emerged. Collectively they shift the weight of the 
   evidence against the notion that distant healing is more than a placebo.

I keep re-reading the last sentence to parse the meaning. If Hemingway had
written the conclusion he might have said the evidence indicates that the
effects of distant healing are due to placebo. And noted the dried and frozen
carcass of a leopard.

With RATT trials, and in fact all pseudo-medical studies with no basis in
reality, you want a good placebo control, you want to know if blinding was
successful in the patient and, above all, you do not want a study that compares 
RATT to usual care.

As has been noted by Dr. Edzard Ernst, a study design that compares a treatment 
to standard care will ALWAYS yield a positive result, also stating:

   They do not represent an honest test of anything, simply because we know
   their result even before the trial has started. They are not science but
   thinly disguised promotion. They are not just a waste of money, they are
   dangerous – because they produce misleading results – and they are thus also 
   unethical.

And there is that whole prior plausibility problem. Sitting right at zero, it is
as certain as the sun rising in the east that any positive study of RATT is
going to be a false positive.

So I will mostly limit myself to studies that have a placebo control. Which
oddly brings up this article, I suppose because it contains “No touch” in the
abstract. Sometimes you have to wonder about PubMed.

And now the completely expected results

Reading these studies is partly for amusement, but I find as I age they also
generate a bit of angst. About 75% of my life is over and it is a time to look
back on what I have accomplished. The thought of having spent the prime years of
one’s life immersed in a worthless pseudo-science is so sad.

RATT has been tried for a variety of processes for no rational reason, the old
‘when you have a hammer everything is a nail’ problem. RATT has been used for
everything from agitation to carpal tunnel to, I hear, raising the dead, and the
results tend to be all over the map, some positive but mostly negative. As is
often the case with pseudo-medicine, the better the methodology, the less the
effect.

A curious study with placebo is “Therapeutic touch for nausea in breast cancer
patients receiving chemotherapy: Composing a treatment.”

Their placebo was:

   the practitioner’s hands-to-patient’s body distance was different (more than 
   20 cm) and in fact there was no energy transfer.

No energy transfer! And they know that how? It was followed by the classic post 
hoc torturing the data until it confessed. Three different statistical analyses 
were used to generate significance, one for each table, for reasons never
explained. Oddly placebo was better at decreasing the frequency of nausea but
not noted as such. It is a study with opaque reporting at best.

In “Investigating the effect of therapeutic touch on the intensity of acute
chemotherapy-induced vomiting in breast cancer women under chemotherapy,” TT was
compared to placebo and standard care. Connoisseurs of SBM will not be
surprised by the results.

   …there was a statistically significant difference between the control group
   and the intervention group and between the control group and the placebo
   group (P < 0.0001). However, there was no significant difference between the 
   placebo and intervention groups (P = 0.07).

TT had no effect on carpal tunnel compared to sham TT; but why would it?

The other hint as to the mechanism of Reiki is found in “Reiki’s effect on
patients with total knee arthroplasty: A pilot study” where reiki was
effectively compared to usual therapy except in the post-anesthesia recovery,
were patients have little awareness as they wake up. Just what is expected in a 
placebo therapy.

I think one trial sums up the effects of ‘energy’ therapy best:

   The findings indicate that the presence of an RN providing one-on-one support
   during chemotherapy was influential in raising comfort and well-being
   levels, with or without an attempted healing energy field.

A caring provider is what is needed to help patients cope; not a pseudo-medicine
based on pseudo-science that only offers fraudulent placebo effects.

An Unimpressive Reiki Study

Steven Novella on March 11, 2026

Link


I often get e-mail suggesting topics to cover on SBM or elsewhere in my social
media content. I like getting these e-mails when they are organic, coming from
readers here with genuine questions about some questionable claim or practice.
But often they are press contacts, by a professional promoter pushing a new
study or shopping around an author or someone they represent. These are rarely
useful, but often ironically humorous, trying to promote some type of
pseudoscience.

Recently I was sent a promotion for a study of Reiki, stating, “A new U.S.
clinical study conducted by researchers from the University of Utah, Harvard and
Florida State University has found that Reiki, a non-pharmacological,
non-invasive therapy, significantly reduced symptoms of chronic knee
osteoarthritis (KOA), supporting the feasibility of complementary therapies as
drug-free pain management interventions.”

I have to say, I knew right away what the flaws in this study were likely to be,
and I doubted the claim that the study properly shows that Reiki “significantly
reduced symptoms”. Of course, “significant” can mean clinically significant or 
statistically significant, and for a clinical study to be meaningful you really 
need both simultaneously.

I doubted the claim being made for two reasons. The first is that there is zero 
plausibility for Reiki having any treatment-specific effects (other than
nonspecific placebo-type effects). According to Reiki.org, Reiki “involves a
practitioner, trained by a Master, placing their hands lightly on or just above 
a fully clothed recipient to guide “life force energy” (ki), aiming to clear
energy blockages and support the body’s natural healing abilities.” Life force
energy does not exist (as much as it is possible to say scientifically that
anything does not exist), and therefore any claim to manipulate this
non-existence force has no plausibility. Practitioners believe it is their
intention to heal their client which is what unblock their life force energy, a 
phenomenon (affecting reality through pure intention) which also almost
certainly does not exist. So using a non-existent method to affect a
non-existent energy is, to say the least, an extraordinary claim.

Further, whenever I receive a claim that a study shows that some impossible
thing is true, there is always a major flaw in the study. Always. By this I mean
that the study does not justify rejecting the null hypothesis. They don’t even 
meet the threshold for doing so with a reasonably plausible hypothesis, let
alone an extremely implausible one. So let’s dive into this study to show you
what I mean.

The study is Complementary therapies for chronic knee pain: A placebo-controlled
RCT of Reiki and mindfulness. There were four arms to this study – Reiki,
placebo reiki which they call feiki (that name is the best thing about the
study), mindfulness, and waitlist control. Right there I would have bet real
money what the outcome of the study was – Reiki was significantly better than
waitlist control, but not than feiki. And sure enough, that was the outcome.
This is a negative study, being deceptively presented as a positive study. But
let’s go into more detail.

The study is of symptoms from chronic knee pain and the main outcome measure is 
a self-report of symptoms at baseline, one month, and two months. We have a
study with a subjective outcome (nothing objective is being measured), which
means that the control and blinding has to be exquisite or the results are not
meaningful. The authors claims the study had “successful blinding.” However,
this claim is based entirely on their attempts to blind the study, and not any
measure of how successful the blinding was (such as asking participants if they 
thought they were in the treatment or placebo arm).

There is also the potential for asymmetrical study adherence. Even before
allocation, however, of the 606 eligible subject, 335 refused to participate.
This suggests the possibility that subjects who agree to the study were
predisposed to believe in Reiki or mindfulness. After allocation – “Of the 132
participants that began treatment, 127 (96 %) were treatment completers. All but
three participants completed Feiki, all but one completed Reiki, and all
participants completed mindfulness training. Of the participants that began
treatment, 89 % completed their post-assessment and 92 % completed the 2-month
follow-up assessment.” So while there was a small drop out (still, higher in the
feiki group), about 10% failed to complete their assessments.

Worse, despite claiming that the blinding was successful, there is good reason
to believe that it was not. The big problem is that the people giving Reiki and 
feiki were not blinded. They were instructed to follow a script to minimize
differences in interaction, but this was likely not enough. This is critical,
given that the alternative hypothesis to a specific effect from Reiki, and the
one that I think is supported by the evidence, is that the subjective effects
are entirely due to the therapeutic interaction with the practitioner. It’s hard
to imaging that these interactions were similar given that, “Feiki providers
were trained to occupy their mind by counting backwards from 1000 by 7 s in
their head while administering treatment.” This was to make sure they did not
accidentally give “real” Reiki by intending to heal their subject.

So we have a subjective outcome with unblinded providers and some asymmetry in
completion and a significant dropout of post-treatment evaluations, in a study
with a modest size. This is hardly a compelling study. But arguably – none of
this really matters, because the study was negative anyway. Here are the
results:

“At the 2-month follow-up, participants in both the Reiki (x̄=32.64, 95 %
CI=26.85–38.43, t = 2.29, p = .023, Cohen’s d=0.52) and Mindfulness
(x̄=27.62, 95 % CI=21.94–33.29, t = 3.54, p < .001, d=.80) conditions reported
significantly lower osteoarthritis symptom severity compared to those in the WLC
condition (x̄=42.07, 95 % CI=36.40–47.75). Additionally, Mindfulness
participants reported significantly less symptom severity than those in the
Feiki condition (x̄=39.45, 95 % CI=33.76–45.14, t = 2.90, p = .004, d=.65. The
difference between the Reiki and Feiki conditions approached statistical
significance (t = 1.65, p = .10, d=.37), while symptom severity did not differ
significantly between the Reiki and Mindfulness conditions
(t = 1.22, p = .22, d=.28).”

“Approached statistical significance” is a euphemism for “not statistically
significant”, i.e. negative. But the researchers try to rescue their results by 
doing an unusual analysis. They examined the “trajectories of change” and found 
that between the 1 month treatment and the 2 month treatment the mindfulness and
Reiki groups were doing better and the feiki group was doing worse, and the
slopes of these changes were significant. Did they really plan on making this
very unusual analysis prior to the study? Did they do any other atypical
analyses? Did they statistically adjust for making multiple comparisons? This
reeks of p-hacking, and in any case does not change the fact that the primary
comparison, and the only one that really matters in this study – a direct
comparison of Reiki to feiki, was negative.

The study authors do their best to spin these negative results to make them seem
encouraging. They do call their results “preliminary”, which is accurate, and
then state, “While additional research is needed to confirm efficacy and
elucidate underlying mechanisms, study findings contribute to the growing
literature on Reiki and other Biofield Therapies as possible means of chronic
pain management.”

Ah, the “additional research is needed” gambit. Sure, this is a legitimate way
to characterize preliminary evidence. It is also a telltale sign of the limits
and flaws in the evidence-based medicine (EBM) model, which fails to consider
prior plausibility. I really don’t think additional research is needed. This was
a negative study of a highly implausible (nigh impossible) hypothesis. Even
with some wiggle room provided by questionable blinding (unblinded treatment
providers with a highly subjective outcome) they couldn’t achieve statistical
significance.

What happens with treatments like Reiki and similar low probability treatments
like acupuncture, which are essentially theatrical placebos, is that we are
stuck in an endless cycle of preliminary evidence with significant flaws, and
with the most rigorous comparisons being largely negative. Meanwhile proponents 
tout these ultimately negative and/or highly unconvincing results as showing
these are viable alternatives to real medicine.

But we never ever get to a reasonable threshold for rejecting the null
hypothesis. We never convincingly demonstrate that these treatments work or that
any of the underlying principles are valid. Life force energy still dot not
exist, and you cannot heal patients with your intention.

                      Rhinos and tigers and bears. Oh my.

                                  Mark Crislip

                                      Link

   More than any other time in history, mankind faces a crossroads. One path
   leads to despair and utter hopelessness. The other, to total extinction. Let 
   us pray we have the wisdom to choose correctly.

   ~ Woody Allen

No good deed goes unpunished.

The website whatstheharm.net is a depressing recitation of the harm that humans 
do to themselves and others from participating in various forms of nonsense in
the attempt to do good. It my backfire, and instead pain and death result.

I would bet that most practitioners of medical woo are true believers. They do
not intend to harm people, and believe they are doing good for their patients.
Certainly the consumers of alternative therapies intend to have good benefits
from their use of sCAM modalities. Most want to get better, and do not intend to
hurt themselves or others.

Unfortunately, actions always have unintended consequences. Sometimes the harm
is directly to the patient. Sometimes the harm in indirect, with collateral
damage to people or the environment. My hospital system has an extensive
recycling program to handle the huge amounts of waste generated by the need to
insure that all manner of materials are sterile. Patients in isolation consume
large amounts of paper and plastic to keep infection confined. My hospitals
actively look for ways to decrease their environmental impact and carbon
footprint and still deliver high quality medical care. Legacy Health System,
where I work, is an award winning leader recycling medical waste, which is a lot
more difficult to dispose of than the pop cans and paper bags in your house.
Hopefully the trash in your house is not covered with pus, blood and other
potentially hazardous medical waste. We try to be good global citizens.

I wonder if some branches of the alternative medical industrial complex are so
environmentally conscious.

Natural products are at the greatest risk for being adversely affected by a
demand for their use. If millions of people want a natural product that has
limited supply, soon that product will be exhausted and the product extinct.
Adverse effects from alternative therapies can come in many forms, and the
alternative practice with the greatest adverse impact on the environment is
probably traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). A billion or more people wanting a 
traditional herbal or animal product is going to have a detrimental effect on
the herb or animal being consumed. There are numerous examples of the adverse
effects on the environment from traditional Chinese medicine.

For years the Rhinoceros was hunted not for food or sport, but for the horn.
There is a form of magical thinking that derives function from the structure of 
a natural product like a rhino horn. It looks like a penis. I guess. I must not 
have been paying close attention during in my urology rotation. Because it looks
like a penis, it must have efficacy on impotence. So the rhino horn was ground 
up to treat impotence. For centuries it was the Enzyte of the world. But Rhino
horn is more than an aphrodisiac. Although the rhino horn is no more than a
fingernail with extra calcium and phosphorus, the horn has been used in Chinese 
medicine to treat damn near anything.

I will note here that trying to determine what a given Chinese preparation is
‘really’ used for is an exercise in frustration and, as best as I can determine,
there as many uses for each TCM preparation as there are acupuncture points: an
infinite number only limited by the imagination of the practitioner.

   “It (rhino horn) should not be taken by pregnant women; it will kill the
   fetus. As an antidote to poisons (in Europe it was said to fall to pieces if 
   poison were poured into it). To cure devil possession and keep away all evil 
   spirits and miasmas. For gelsemium [jasmine] and snake poisoning. To remove
   hallucinations and bewitching nightmares. Continuous administration lightens 
   the body and makes one very robust. For typhoid, headache, and feverish
   colds. For carbuncles and boils full of pus. For intermittent fevers with
   delirium. To expel fear and anxiety, to calm the liver and clear the vision. 
   It is a sedative to the viscera, a tonic, antipyretic. It dissolves phlegm.
   It is an antidote to the evil miasma of hill streams. For infantile
   convulsions and dysentery. Ashed and taken with water to treat violent
   vomiting, food poisoning, and overdosage of poisonous drugs. For arthritis,
   melancholia, loss of the voice. Ground up into a paste with water it is given
   for hematemesis [throat hemorrhage], epistaxis [nosebleeds], rectal
   bleeding, heavy smallpox, etc. (1)”

I like that ‘etc.’ at the end. I thought Bayer aspirin was the wonder drug that 
works wonders, but aspirin will not calm the evil miasma of hill streams, mores 
the pity. With all the alleged benefits of consuming rhino horn, all with no
biologic plausibility whosoever, it is no wonder that despite the advent of
Viagra and its cousins, the rhino is still being hunted for its horn. A century 
ago, there were one million black rhinos in Africa; now there are 2,500 and the 
population is falling (2). A horn fetches $500 in a country where the average
farmers makes $1.50 a day (2a). On the international market a horns gets more
than $10,000 for a kilogram. No wonder the Rhino is hunted to near extinction.
The fact that they have no medicinal benefit does not prevent the harvesting of 
the rhino. All species eventually become extinct, but to become extinct because 
of medical woo is particularly depressing.

Rhinos are not the the only animal disappearing due to relentless harvesting of 
animal parts for worthless therapies.

Tigers

In 1900 there were 100,000 tigers in India, now there are less than 5,000. China
now has under 100 tigers, as they are killed and chopped up into their
constituent parts for many worthless medical therapies, including, but not
limited to

   ” a tiger’s penis soaked in alcohol is said to increase virility; its nose
   suspended over the marriage bed is believed to increase the chance of having 
   a boy and its whiskers are said to cure toothache (4).”

TCM loves the tiger bones, something that the tiger cannot live without, as a
treatment for arthritis, often as a tiger bone wine. 14% of the US has some form
of arthritis, and if the numbers are true for China, there are 172 million
potential customers for tiger bones. There are also many people outside of China
who use the therapy as well. That’s a lot of tiger bones, and given declining
tiger populations, it is no wonder tiger bones go for 400 dollars a kilogram,
each tiger having 4.5 kilograms of bone.

   “The usual dosage for Tiger bone taken orally to treat rheumatic pain is
   three to six grams daily. At this rate, a daily user of Tiger bone would
   consume one to two kilos of bone per year. Extrapolated further, the world’s 
   remaining Tigers would provide, at most, a year’s supply of medicine to 125
   800 daily users – the equivalent of far less than even 1% of China’s human
   population (13).”

That would be about 1/3 a tiger per year per person.

It is not a minor problem: “More than 150,000 over-the-counter traditional
Chinese medicines containing – or purporting to contain – tiger bone and parts
from other critically endangered species are sold in the United States (4).”
Support TCM, you are indirectly supporting the extinction of rhinos and tiger
and more.

As Tigers are harvested to extinction, traditional Chinese medicine has
substituted other big cats like leopards, whose days are now probably numbered.

Bears

“In traditional clinical practice, bear bile was used in fever fighting,
detoxification, inflammation, swelling and pain reduction. It was also used in
the cure of carbuncle of heat type, pyocutaneous diseases, hemorrhoid,
overabundance of liver-fire, convulsion caused by the overabundance of heat,
epilepsy, tic, and redness of eyes due to liver heat etc (15).”

Again that pesky etc. Pick a disease, real or imagined, and bear bile may be a
therapy. The one problem not treated with bear bile that I could find is
impotence, the only TCM animal product not used for some sort of sexual
dysfunction. The producers and consumers of TCM products seem to have a lot of
sexual dysfunction. Cause or effect?

Rather than hunt bears, farmers keep bears in cages with a catheter in their
gall bladder where they can drain the bile like sap from a maple tree. It is not
a good life for the bear and often fatal. The Chinese have hundreds of farms
with thousands of bears, as do other SE Asian countries.

There is an active ingredient in bear bile, ursodeoxycholic acid, that dissolves
gall stones. It can be, and is, synthesized for human use. Oddly enough, the
natural product is considered superior to synthesized molecule, and so the bile 
drainage continues and the bear population in China continues to dwindle to
supply bear for the farms.

I never thought I would be agree with PETA on anything, but torturing bears for 
bile that does nothing or has a synthetic equivalent hardly seems like an
ethical treatment of an animal. The Humane Society description of bear bile
harvesting does not appear particularly pleasant for the bear, which has its
bile ‘milked’ without the benefit of anesthesia (14).

   ” An un-sterile latex or stainless steel catheter was inserted through the
   external fistula directly into the gall bladders of each bear to drain the
   fluid daily either by gravity into a tray or by suction with an un-sterile
   syringe. This extraction method was called the “Free-dripping Fistula
   Technique”. The fluid was then dried and manufactured as “Bear Bile Powder”
   (Bear bile extraction) . The bears were suffering extreme pain due to daily
   bile extractions. Many of them often die from illnesses (such as
   cholecystitis, cholelithiasis, polyp formation, obstruction of the cystic
   duct, strictures and partial herniation of the gall bladder wall, liver
   cancer) and chronic infections caused by the presence of foreign bodies and
   their open wounds (15).”

Besides bear farms, bears are illegally hunted for their gallbladders all over
the world.

   The usual dose of bear bile is 0.25–2.5 g is taken as a pill or powder (15), 
   and given that the average bear in a farm makes 20 to 40 ml a day of milked
   bile, it takes a lot of bears to provide the required bile. Prices vary, but 
   bear bile can go for $1000 dollars for 250 cc. In beer talk, that would be
   about half a pint.

“In 1970 one kilo of bear gall bladder cost around US $200, but by 1990 the
price had risen to between US $3,000 and US $5,000 per kilo. Recent market price
with legal certification has risen to between US $30,000 and US $50,000 per
kilo (our experience in legal market of Hong Kong) (15).”

There is considerable financial incentive to hunt bears to extinction to provide
worthless medications.

Sharks

The Chinese are not the only culture who uses nonsense to help drive animals
into extinction. 100 million sharks are killed every year. Some are killed as a 
by product of fishing, some for food, some for sharks fin soup, and some for
medication. Somewhere along the line it was mistakenly thought that sharks do
not get cancer. They do get cancer, and they get cancer of cartilage, albeit not
very frequently. William Lane, PhD has been the primary marketing force behind 
the idea that shark cartilage can prevent and treat cancer, publishing books on 
the topic and selling shark products. Again, there was no good reason to suggest
that shark cartilage had anti-tumor effects, although some data in the lab
suggests that it inhibits the formation of new blood vessels, needed to support 
tumor growth. The clinical trials for any efficacy of shark cartilage in the
treatment of cancer have been negative, but the end result was has been to help 
push 126 shark species towards extinction.

A Google search reveals many organic/natural/ online pharmacies sell shark
cartilage. I suppose extinction is natural and organic, and supporting and
profiting from the extinction of animal species is also natural and organic. Who
cares is Jaws is going extinct? Not the purveyors of shark cartilage.

Saiga antelope

These animals have been hunted for their horns, which are used to treat stroke, 
colds and high blood pressure, and, since rhino horn is both expensive and rare,
a cheaper alternative to rhino horn. Because of the protection of the rhino
combined with their tiny numbers, the practitioners of traditional Chinese
medicine have had to find another species to decimate for useless medical
therapy. As a result their numbers of Saiga have gone from 1 million to under
30,000 and falling.

Turtles and Tortoises (7)

Half of the 90 turtle species in Southeast Asia are endangered, due to demand in
China for turtle meat and traditional medicines. “The World Conservation Fund
has documented the rapid decline in just the last few years of the Chinese
three-striped box turtle, whose fat, used in soup and jelly, is believed to cure
cancer; only a few colonies of the once-abundant turtle now survive in the wild
(9).”

Sea horses (8)

There approximately 90 health and medicine products containing sea horse are
sold in China and elsewhere. As is often the case, the sea-horses are being used
for, among other things, an aphrodisiac. . To meet this demand some 20,000,000 
sea horses are harvested each year. All die for no valid reason, and seahorse
stocks are plummeting.

Other animals consumed by traditional Chinese medicine include the slow loris,
whose fur is believed to accelerate healing of wounds. Extracts from the
eyeballs of the loris are turned into a love potion. The civet cat is used for
its anal scent gland to induce abortions well as to treat arthritis, stimulating
blood flow, and increasing libido. Again with the impotence.

As mentioned above, it is not just the Chinese that use animal parts for
medicinal purposes, but the effects are the best documented due to the large
population and the economic clout that allows the trade in medical animal parts 
to flourish. India, Brazil, and Sudan are a few of the countries with documented
use of local plants and animals for medicinal purposes (16), however they have 
not (yet) had a documented adverse effect on the local ecosystems.

Data suggests in Brazil:

   “Of the total of species recorded, 24 (71%) are not under extinction risk. On
   the other hand, Myrmecophaga tridactyla (Linnaeus 1758), Coendou cf.
   prehensilis (Linnaeus 1758), Dusicyon sp., Mazama cf. Americana (Erxleben
   1777), Rhea americana (Linnaeus 1758), and Crypturellus noctivagus zabele
   (Spix) 1825, which are officially considered as threatened species by the
   Brazilian Institute of Environment and Renewable Natural Resources (1989),
   were found among the set of faunistic resources prescribed as medicines at
   the time of this research.”

There is good money in the trade of animals, even to the point where the
director of the Berlin zoo was selling ‘extra’ tigers to the Chinese for medical
use (10).

Plants have it worse than animals, feeding the voracious appetite for
traditional Chinese medicine. Over 400 plants are at risk for extinction from
medical use as 5 billion people use plants as the basis for their medical care, 
although not all of them from traditional Chinese medicine. Examples include,
but are not limited to

Magnolia

Half of the world’s species of magnolias are under threat of extinction, which
is used in traditional Chinese medicine to treat cancers and slow down the onset
of heart disease (12). There are two diseases with similar pathophysiology:
cancer and heart disease. I can see why they have the same treatment.

Manchurian Ginseng (13)

A popular treatment for memory function as well as cancer, COPD, diabetes,
fatigue, increasing libido (where it that etc. when I need it?), Ginseng has all
but been eradicated in China and Korea. As a result it is harvested in the US
and sent to China. Wild ginseng is though to have better medicinal properties
than farm raised, so the harvest of wild ginseng continues in the US,
threatening that species with extinction in the US as well.

Dendrobium candidum

An orchid that is believed to cure hoarseness, is so rare that it now costs
12,000 times more than wheat.

Licorice

Licorice root is an Asian plant species commonly used for pain relief and to
treat coughs, skin infections, food and drug poisoning. Licorice is almost wiped
out in China – “largely at the hands of Chinese soldiers making some pocket
money by digging up the plant while on duty in the country’s northern border
region, which is called by some the “licorice zone”(6). Due to excessive
harvesting and habitat destruction, licorice root is now grown in less than half
its previous area; reduced from 50,000 square miles to about 19,000 square
miles.”

These are just the tip of the iceberg as “of the 1,581 species of animals used
as a medical resource, 1,306 are terrestrial animals and 275 are marine animals…
11,146 are of plant origin (5).

One of the complaints about natural herbal medications is that there is
uncertainty as to what the concentration of active products, if any, are. It is 
argued that a superior way to treat disease is to isolate the active ingredient 
and then synthesize it. Herbalist of all stripe reply that one needs the complex
formulation of the natural product for efficacy. No natural/herbal product I am
aware of is superior to the synthesized pure product and none of the
synthesized products lead to animal or plant extinction.

We are, perhaps, at the beginning of a mass extinction of animal and plant
species for a variety of reasons. That we are wiping out ginseng and tigers and 
bears for the myth that they can cure or treat disease, that these plants and
animals are dying out because of belief in magic, is evil.

Some Chinese practitioners object to interference and criticism of their
practice, feeling it is racist for the West to put limits on Eastern practices
that we do not understand.

   “In addition, we would like to point out that recent campaigns against the
   use of some of our medical resources, for example tiger bones, bear bile and 
   rhino horns, have led to a negative stereotyping of our practice…As part of a
   scheme in recent history to cast the then Chinese herbalists as ‘the other’,
   their use of animal material medica has been exploited in the past to
   devalue the yao they use, and in the process, devalue and delegitimize their 
   medical practice (5).”

It is racist to be against unproven, implausible magic that is leading to the
extinction of hundreds of animal and plant species. Special pleading to allow
the pointless extinction and torture of animals for worthless medical therapies.

There is also a movement to make traditional Chinese medicine sustainable, by
using alternative worthless products instead of endangered medically worthless
products. There are arguments that the bear bile farms are helping prevent the
bears from being hunted to extinction, a sort sort of greening TCM induced
extinction. Traditional Chinese Medicines is the Hummer of the altmed world,
trying to sustain the a destructive practice despite its causing more harm than 
good to the world. It could be an unexpected byproduct of the adoption of
science based medicine that rhinos and tigers and bears would be saved from TCM 
induced extinction. Perhaps the rational use of science derived evidence will
make the TCM therapies will go the way of acupuncture….. bad example. One would 
hope that if science would demonstrate that the therapies are worthless or that 
there are synthetic alternatives, that the march of the tiger and rhino towards 
oblivion would be halted.

Homeopathy

Water is an increasingly precious resource in the world, and will become even
more so as the glacier melt that provides water to large numbers of people
disappear with the glaciers. I have read that future wars in the mideast may be 
over water not oil.

It takes a lot of water to make a homeopathic concoction.

I love this quote, from the Australian Councils Against Health Care Fraud

   “Homeopathic vaccines – (A) little bottle of water contains what the label
   describes as a homeopathic vaccine against meningococcal disease. As if that 
   lie is not enough, the label also contains a claim which puts the product in 
   breach of consumer protection and fair trading laws. It says that this
   preparation is “200C”, but if that is the case then the manufacture of this
   single bottle would have involved 800 manufacturing steps (excluding
   packaging) and would have produced 495 litres of waste water. (To produce a
   single year’s worth of “vaccine” doses would require 73% of the water needed 
   to produce all of the Coca Cola consumed in Australia in a year.)”

Evidently they drink a lot of Coke down under. To make one 200C vial of
meningococcal vaccine would take as much water as a 50 minute shower with a low 
flow shower head. That is a lot of wasted water (17). Multiply that by the
hundreds of different homeopathic concoctions and you have an enormous amount of
water being wasted for no purpose.

It is a moral-ethical question as to where your responsibility ends. We recycle 
in part because there is a sense that we are responsible for our garbage even
after we have thrown it away. A similar sense of responsibility is lacking for
our carbon footprint, but growing. I am old enough to remember more politically 
active times, when one did not eat California grapes or Nestles chocolate
because to do so was to support a companies that were ‘evil’. In part I have
accepted nothing, not even a piece of pizza, from a drug company in over 25
years because half of drug costs go to support advertising. My patients
subsidize the cost of my ‘free’ pizza and I think it is not ethical for my
patients to pay more for medications so I can get a free pen or other trash to
add to the landfill. Everyone will draw the line as to where their
responsibility ends at a different place.

The bumper sticker reads “Think globally, act locally”. Want to help rhinos and 
tigers and bears? Don’t support the practices that are driving them to
extinction. Support your local traditional Chinese practitioner and you may be
inadvertently supporting the extinction of numerous animal and plant species as 
well as doing nothing to promote your own health.

The harm of medical woo can extend beyond the damage we do to ourselves and
others. It can lead to extinction. As Clint said, “Its a hell of thing to kill a
species.”

Just don’t bring up the plane flight to the SBM conference.

References

Thanks to my colleagues, esp Dr. Atwood,  who covered spot my two weeks ago when
I was ill.

(1)http://209.85.173.132/search?q=cache:U648KL9qCKcJ:www.biaza.org.uk/public/ima
ges/campaigns/rhinoDocs/chinese.pdf+rhino+horn+aphrodisiac&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=12&g
l=us

(2)
http://entertainment.timesonline.co.uk/tol/arts_and_entertainment/article378490.
ece

2a) http://www.american.edu/TED/rhinoblk.htm

(3) <sarcasm></sarcasm >

(4) http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/special_report/1998/chinese_new_year/50218.stm

(5)
http://www.environment.gov.au/biodiversity/trade-use/publications/symposium/tige
r.html#materia

(6) http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/the-bear-bile-cure-539187.html

(7) http://www.itmonline.org/arts/turtles.htm

(8) http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/feat/archives/2003/06/24/2003056592

(9) http://advocacy.britannica.com/blog/advocacy/2008/11/708/

(10)
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/earthnews/3336945/Berlin-Zoo-director-accused-o
f-selling-animals-for-Chinese-medicine.html

(11)
http://bigcatrescue.blogspot.com/2007/02/clouded-leopard-parts-used-in-chinese.h
tml

(12)
http://chinesemedicinenews.com/2008/01/19/medical-plants-face-extinction-magnoli
a-included

(13) www.traffic.org/species-reports/traffic_species_mammals14.pdf

(14)
http://www.hsus.org/wildlife/issues_facing_wildlife/wildlife_trade/the_unbearabl
e_trade_in_bear_parts_and_bile/

(15) http://www.ethnobiomed.com/content/5/1/2

(16)
http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0001-37652005000100004&l
ng=en&nrm=iso&tlng=en

(17) It has been suggested by others that, given the vast quantities of water
needed to make homeopathic concoctions, perhaps they are not really making the
preparations with the dilutions like they say they are. In Portland water bills 
are public knowledge and every year the local paper publishes the top 10 water
users. We do not have a homeopathic factory in the city, but might I suggest
that if you have one in your city, get the water bill and see how much water
they use and compare it to the homeopathic concoction production.

Traditional Medicine Based Extinction. An Update.

What we do best.

Mark Crislip on August 19, 2025


Link

It always amazes me what can be accomplished by consistently working at task
every day. Every time I go over one of the many bridges that span the
Willamette, I marvel at what humans can do. Hundreds of people working every day
for months and viola, the Fremont Bridge. I remember watching the news as they 
raised the central span into place all those years ago. The local newsman asked 
what they would do if it was too small. I still marvel every time I cross the
bridge.

Millions or billions of people consistently performing the same task every day
does not always result in an Empire State building, an Eiffel Tower or a Great
Pyramid. 1.5 billion cars driving every day? 4.6 metric tonnes CO2 added to the 
atmosphere per car per year. People tossing plastics? 400 million tonnes a year 
in the environment.

1.3 billion people use Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine (TCPM) and other
traditional pseudo-medicines (TPM). Many of the nostrums proffered by these
traditions are plants and animal parts, a limited resource.

Over 11 000 herb plants have been recorded in various TCM-related pharmacopeia, 
and the commonly used ones are ∼700 species.

and

98 of 616 ingredients listed in the latest Pharmacopoeia are animal‐based , and 
823 animal species are documented in the Medical Fauna of China as having been
used or still in use with most being insects or other invertebrates.

Over a billion people using TPM are going to have an adverse impact of the
plants and animals misused as medicine, all to no purpose. There are many
traditional pseudo-medicines that misuse animals and plants in a fruitless
attempt to treat illnesses.

I reviewed this aspect of TCPM all the way back in 2009. 2009? Gives one pause, 
where does the time go? But the release of a poor bear who spent 21 years in a
bile farm cage suggested it might be time to produce an update the pointless
cruelty and death at the heart of TCPM. To be honest, it is not all TCPM. The
useless use of animals and plants is not limited to the Chinese and is a feature
of many traditional medicines. Those in the west are also responsible for
needless death and suffering, as some TCPM and adjacent pseudomedicines are
popular.

And TPM is big money:

nearly two-fifths of the seizures of illegally trafficked wildlife products made
in the EU were of a medicinal nature

Rhinoceros

Let us start with the poster boy. Poster-animal.

Yeah. Rhinos. Horn used as an aphrodisiac. Like eating fingernails is going to
help your impotence. It is a bit of sympathetic magic that says something about 
those who partake. But I will not go there. Or there. As much as I want to.

Rhino horn is used for more than sexual dysfunction. I find nosebleeds, hangover
cure, fevers and stroke prevention on the list of its alleged TCPM benefits.
But not that I can find baldness, which is odd that the horn is mostly tightly
packed keratin aka hair. In Vietnam rhino horn is touted as a cancer cure (NOT
part of TCPM, where rhino horn is not used for cancer treatment). Since 2009
cancer treatment has only made it worse for rhinos. As of 2013

The country’s appetite for rhino horn is so great that it now fetches up to
$100,000/kg, making it worth more than its weight in gold. (Horns average around
1-3 kg each, depending on the species.)

Rhino horn may be worth even more today.

A recent report puts the price of rhino horn in Asia at $60,000 per pound.

Although prices vary depending on the report and the year.

And who knows what tariffs will add to the cost of rhino horn imported into the 
US for the purpose of MAHA. Hahahahahahaha. At that price, it is not surprising 
that rhino poaching (illegal hunting, not cooking in boiling water) has
increased since 2009, peaking in 2015 at about 1300 rhinos a year, now around
600 a year. Rhinos have enough problems surviving with habitat loss, poaching
for a worthless cancer cure only makes a bad problem worse.

There have been suggestions that there needs to be a rhino horn substitute.
Like, what? Besides, reality -based treatments? You might eat saccharin instead 
of sugar. Both are sweet, after all. But given that the benefits of rhino horns 
are imaginary, what could be offered as a substitute? Floor clippings from
Supercuts? Why not? Technically the same product.

They are trying both dehorning and injecting horns with radioactive compounds to
combat poaching, but given the demand and the money involved, I would not be
optimistic for the future of the Rataxes’ family.

Tigers

Demand, and price, for tiger parts, especially bone, eyes, and penis, have
increased.

In Taiwan, a bowl of tiger penis soup (to boost virility) goes for $320, and a
pair of eyes (to fight epilepsy and malaria) for $170. Powdered tiger humerus
bone (for treating ulcers rheumatism and typhoid) brings up to $1,450 lb. in
Seoul.

And we complain about the price gouging of Big Pharma, At least most Pharma
products are based on reality and are mostly effective. And don’t usually
exterminate animals.

Since China has almost eradicated its own tiger population, it is now looking
for a new supply of tigers from Bangladesh and Nepal. The World Wildlife Fund
estimates that one-third of the breeding-age female tigers were lost between
1989 and 1991 in this area.

Computer models suggest even small amounts of tiger poaching have huge effects
on limited populations:

The model predicts, If poachers killed 10 of the animals in a tiger group every 
year for three years, the group would have less than a 20 percent chance of
extinction in the 75 years after poaching stopped. Destroying 15 tigers a year
for 3 years, however, bumps the probability of extinction up to 50 percent. If
poachers kill 15 tigers in a group each year for six years, or 10 animals for
nine years, this will destroy the group.

At least conservation efforts have made some increase in tiger populations.

In 2010, the estimated number of wild tigers was approximately 3,200, a low
point after a long period of decline. By 2022, the population had grown to an
estimated 4,500 tigers, and by 2024, the latest estimate from the Global Tiger
Forum placed the number at 5,574 wild tigers.

Which is nothing to the 8000 tigers estimated to be in tiger farmss, where they 
are being raised to be turned into worthless nostrums, like tiger bone wine at
$257 per 500 ml (about 17 ounces). Sad end to a big cat.

Seahorses

Seahorses have been used by TCPM for 600 years and thought to be a natural
Viagra. Huh? Why? If it is sympathetic magic like a rhino horn, the users have
issues greater than impotence and premature ejaculation. I can’t find a good
explanation for seahorses as ED medication besides seahorses as an energy
enhancer. As an aside, it seems most products are used for ED of some sort,
which doesn’t jibe with China’s population.

With

“37 million seahorses are caught in the wild every year.”

it is no wonder,

“populations of at least 11 species of seahorse have dropped by between 30 –
50%”

One would think that Viagra would help the seahorses. Save them for harvest I
mean. Not aware that seahorses have ED. Nope.

Rather than diminish its appeal, however, Viagra appears to have spurred a huge 
increase in demand for impotence remedies using seahorses as a cheaper
alternative to the western wonder drug.

Even when there is a drug that actually works, people prefer to wipe out animals
instead.

Donkey

Donkey-hide gelatin, ejiao in Chinese, is made by boiling donkey skins, poaching
in both meanings. I presume once the donkey has been removed.

It has been used in traditional Chinese medicine for thousands of years. Why
donkey? Don’t know, although one review suggests it was because they ran out of 
cows and had a lot of extra donkey around. Tell that to Shrek. But

Since the Song Dynasty, most medical experts have agreed that donkey should be
the raw material for ejiao

Which begs the question just who these medical experts are. Probably recently
hired at the CDC and NIH, as I think about it.

Many of the articles suggest the product is beneficial in hematopoesis. I could 
not find much and it was almost all in rodents. How applicable 5-FU and γ-ray
radiation induced anemic mice models are to human diseases is questionable. And 
virtually all studies started with the statement that ejiao is beneficial for
anemia, and sought to find the reason. Yep, no bias there. Oh no.

The one human study in blood-deficient patients, a TCPM diagnosis that has
NOTHING to do with anemia, found.

the hematocrit and red blood cell numbers decreased in the placebo control
group, but decreased significantly less in the Ejiao treatment group.

So make of that as you will.

As with all TCPM, it is recommended for a hodgepodge of medical conditions, but 
not impotence. Or not.

“When a man takes ejiao, he will be strong and virile and have a long life. When
a woman takes ejiao, she will keep her youth and become as beautiful as a
princess.

Must be sold in a Disney movie where the princesses are always beautiful.

As China has run out of donkeys, they have shifted to African donkey sand the
animal has not benefited from the attention.

China needs about 5 million donkeys a year to produce and meet the demand for
ejiao, and about 2 million of these come from China’s own population of the
animals. Of the remaining 3 million or more sourced abroad,

With some local populations dropping by 70%. It is an 8 billion dollar a year
industry and hides go for around $800 a kilogram. Many donkeys are stolen from
their owners who need the animals to help in farming. Can you say a donkey is a 
work-horse? Sounds wrong.

To make matters worse, in 10211 there was a popular Chinese TV drama, Empresses 
in the Palace, that

was all set in the (Chinese) imperial court and at a certain time of the day the
ladies of the court would all say, ‘Let’s have some ejiao,’” said Pope. Ejiao, 
also called donkey glue, is used as medicine or as a tonic for health and beauty
in China.

“As a result of this program the demand for ejiao just literally went through
the roof.”

God forbid an internet influencer decides ejiao is a thing. It could the be the 
straw that broke the donkeys back.

So donkeys are being slaughtered at amazing rates to provide a worthless TCPM
and it is only getting worse.

Pangolin

Pangolins are scaled anteaters, a mammal that has been used in TCPM for
thousands of years. Especially the scales.

Fresh scales are never used, but dried scales are roasted, ashed, cooked in oil,
butter, vinegar, boy’s urine, or roasted with earth or oyster-shells, to cure a
variety of ills. Amongst these are excessive nervousness and hysterical crying 
in children, women possessed by devils and ogres, malarial fever and deafness.

Cooked in boy’s urine? Women possessed by devils and ogres? The things you find 
when going down the rat holes of TCPM. But that was in 1938; there is less
promotion of the product for demon possession today. And it is well known that
ogre are resistant to pangolin exorcism. Now the scales allegedly help blood
flow and dissolve clot. Besides China, the scales are also used in other parts
of Asia and in Africa, with the uses are variable depending on the part of the
world. In Ghana

Pangolin scales and bones were the most prevalent prescribed body parts and
indicated the highest cultural significance among traditional healing practices 
primarily for the treatment of spiritual protection, rheumatism, financial
rituals and convulsions.

Probably used on Wall Street as well. It would explain a lot. Used for impotence
as well. Of course.

And, as always, the various diseases treated have zero common pathophysiology.

Not unsurprisingly, for reality-based treatments,  pangolin scales do nothing:

In conclusion, there is no reliable evidence for the clinical value of Squama
Manitis.

Pangolin scales remain in high demand, it being the most highly trafficked
mammal on the planet. I can’t tell if humans are on the list, but at a million
poached over the last decade, it is tough being a pangolin:

All eight species of pangolin are assessed as threatened by the IUCN, while
three are classified as critically endangered.

And all for nothing.

Saiga Antelope

In 2009 I wrote

These animals have been hunted for their horns, which are used to treat stroke, 
colds and high blood pressure, and, since rhino horn is both expensive and rare,
a cheaper alternative to rhino horn. Because of the protection of the rhino
combined with their tiny numbers, the practitioners of traditional Chinese
medicine have had to find another species to decimate for useless medical
therapy. As a result their numbers of Saiga have gone from 1 million to under
30,000 and falling.

The animal appeared to be following in the footsteps of his console cousins.

But no.

Saiga, once close to extinction with a population of only 48,000 in 2005, has
experienced an extraordinary rebound in Kazakhstan.

Current estimates now surpass 1.9 million, showcasing a triumph attributable to 
nearly two decades of dedicated conservation work by governments,
non-governmental organizations, research organizations, and the Service

So it is not all gloom and doom. Well, it is. Kazakhstan is experiencing severe 
impacts from global warming, with temperatures rising at a rate twice the global
average and the country now ranked among the top ten most affected by climate
change. Rather than being killed for their horns, they may get to succumb to
consequences of climate change. Out of the frying pan, into the fire.

Humans

Yep. Humans. Extinction of humans is not an issue. Yet. But for albinos?

In the last decade, close to 200 killings and more than 500 attacks on people
with albinism have been reported in 27 sub-Saharan African countries.

Tanzania has the highest number of recorded attacks globally at more than 170.
There have also been reports of attacks in the Democratic Republic of Congo,
Malawi, Mozambique and Burundi.

Most of these attacks are fueled by rising demand for the body parts of people
with albinism used in rituals by traditional healers, known as muti killing or
black magic, juju.

The hair and bones, genitals and thumbs of people with albinism are said to
possess distinct powers. Alleged to bring wealth or success, they are often
dried and ground, put into a package to be carried, to be secreted in boats,
businesses, homes or clothing, or scattered in the sea.

What can one really say about something so awful and so wrong?

The above is but a sample of the impact traditional medicines have on wildlife, 
either by ‘harvesting’ wild animals or raising them in cages for useless
consumption.

70 different wild animals used in traditional Chinese medicine listed in
Pharmacopoeia. However, scientists have evidence of over 2,200 species being
used.

and this doesn’t include the rest of the world. As to plants

723 species used as treatments are threatened with extinction.

It is mostly getting worse and all for naught.

I suppose the list will grow ever longer.

On the bright side…Can’t think of one.


          Asian Bear Bile Remedies: Traditional Medicine or Barbarism?

                                 Ben Kavoussi 

                                      Link

   Imagine living 20 years spending 24 hours a day in a cage that tightly
   fits your body, not giving you room to stand up, stretch out, turn around, or
   move at all.

   Imagine that twice a day during these years you would have a metal
   catheter inserted into a hole which has been cut into your abdomen, allowing 
   the catheter to easily puncture your gall bladder, or maybe a long syringe
   inserted into your gall bladder, piercing through your skin again and again, 
   by people who are not doctors.

   Imagine becoming infected and cancerous because of this twice-daily
   physical invasion, and becoming neurotic due to your claustrophobic
   imprisonment.

   Imagine having one or both of your hands cut off so someone can sell them
   for a lot of money.

   Imagine you begin to chew at your hands, if you are lucky enough to have 
   one or both left, due to your developing neuroticism, and to distract
   yourself from the pain you experience twice a day, every day, for your entire
   life.

   This is reality for an estimated minimum of 12,000 bears across Asia.

   – Sara Pegarella, JD

Currently, animal activists across China are up in arms because Gui Zhen Tang
Pharmaceutical Corporation, a Fujian-based company that sells bear bile for use 
in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), has tried to increase production through 
an initial public offering (IPO). The company is being accused of cruelty
towards animals in the process of extracting their bile at an industrial scale. 
Bear bile, or Xiong Dan (熊胆), is an important ingredient in TCM.

The issue is not new: since the early 2000s, animal activists have circulated
hundreds of shocking articles, images, and videos that recount unimaginable
cruelty towards caged bears in Asia. The practice has even outraged celebrities,
such as Jackie Chan, who have pleaded with consumers to stop buying products
made from bears and other endangered species. But now it’s all over the news.
Gui Zhen Tang’s IPO has met with fierce public opposition, and has once again
led environmentalists to appeal against the cruelty of live bear bile
extraction.

As this documentary shows, bear bile is sold throughout Asia for a variety of
conditions. The Chinese Herbal Medicine: Materia Medica (1986) by Dan Bensky,
Andrew Gamble, and Ted Kaptchuk lists bear bile as a remedy for trauma, sprains,
fractures, hemorrhoids, conjunctivitis, severe hepatitis, high fever,
convulsions, and delirium. The Materia Medica also states that “because of the
high price of bear bile (Xiong Dan), often cow bile, Fei Bovus (Niu Dan), is
substituted at a higher dose.”1 There is no mention, however, of the horrific
means by which the animal bile is obtained. The guide also lists other animal
products (rhinoceros horn, tiger bones, deer musk, and bat and squirrel feces
[sic]) used as medicine.

Image 1. The bear bile entry in the 1986 version of Materia Medica by Bensky et 
al. The entry in the latest edition (3rd ed. 2004) has been moved to “Obsolete
Substances.” Image used with the explicit permission of Eastland Press.

The globalization of TCM has lead to a dramatic increase in the demand for bear 
bile along with other traditional remedies. Bear bile is sold in Asian
apothecaries throughout the world in the form of powder, solution or pills. It
is likewise the key ingredient in many Asian “patent medicines” used for
tapeworm, childhood nutritional impairment, hangovers, colds, and even cancer.
Bear bile is even found in Chinese throat lozenges, shampoo, wine, and tea.

Image 2. Raw bear bile in both liquid and powder forms. Photo: Kathleen E.
McLaughlin, the Chronicle Foreign Service correspondent in Beijing

Overall, the worldwide trade in bear parts, including bile, is estimated to be a
$2 billion industry. Research in August 2007 by the animal rights group Animals
Asia shows its staggering profitability: while the wholesale price of bile
powder is around US$410 per kg in China, the retail price increases
exponentially to 25 to 50 fold in South Korea, and to 80 fold in Japan
(US$33,000 per kg)!

While the trade in bear products is prohibited under the Convention on
International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES), and the importation and trade
of bear bile products to North America is illegal under both US and Canadian
law, many products are still openly offered for sale in Chinese stores. Back in 
2001, when the World Society for the Protection of Animals conducted a probe of 
Asian shops in Canada and four US cities — Chicago, New York, Washington, and
San Francisco — it found that 91% of the shops surveyed sold some form of bear
part, including farmed bile powder, bile medicines, and whole gallbladders,
which the merchants claimed originated from wild bears in China. When WildAid,
an animal rights group based in San Francisco, sent an undercover investigator
into Chinatown in 2004, two shopkeepers readily produced vials in velvet-lined
boxes with pictures of a bears on the lid.

Bear bile is obtained through surgically implanting a tube in the animal, in a
process called “milking,” that produces an average 15 ml (.5 oz) of bile each
time. The Humane Society of the United States reports that the process of
milking is so painful for the bears that they moan and often chew their paws
during the procedure. In order to make access to the animals easier, the farmers
often break the bears’ teeth and pull out their claws, sometimes brutally
removing whole digits. If the bears stop producing bile, they are left to die,
or are killed for their gallbladder and paws (considered a delicacy in China).

According to Jeanette McDermott, the founder of Ursa Freedom Project, bear
farming in Asia increased during the 1980s in response to the dwindling supply
of bear parts obtained from bears hunted in the wild. Tragically, the situation 
grew out of control, and by the early 1990s, there were over 400 bear farms in
operation, containing more that 10,000 bears. Plans were in place to increase
the number of bears in farms to 40,000 by the year 2000.

Today, China produces 7,000 kilos of bear bile annually, much of which is
illegally exported to Japan, Korea, Australia, Canada, and the US. Whole bear
gallbladders are also exported: the Humane Society of the United States says
smugglers have been caught with gallbladders packed in coffee to conceal their
smell, or dipped in chocolate to disguise them as chocolate-covered figs.

Most of the bears used in bile farming are Himalayan black bears (Ursus
thibetanus), also known as “Asiatic black bears” or “Moon bears,” due to the
cream-colored crescent moon shape on their chests. As their population has
decreased by almost 40 percent over the past few decades, they have been listed 
(since 2000) as among the most critically endangered species on the
International Union on Conservation of Nature’s Red List of Threatened Species.

A number of the bears in bile farms are captured illegally in the wild as cubs. 
Poachers either wait to capture new-born cubs until the mother leaves the den in
search of food , or sometimes they simply kill her to get to the babies. Some
of the cubs are born in captivity — but in either case, bear cubs rarely survive
to adulthood — and those who do often grow into the bars of their cages as
their bodies mature.

Image 3. Is this traditional medicine or savagery and barbarism? Photo:
Cornelius Maarselar/Animals Asia

Animal activists posing as potential clients report that the caged bears moan,
writhe in pain, and clutch their stomachs as the bile drains from their bodies. 
Sometimes the bears try to pull out the catheters. Those that succeed are
immobilized in an iron corset. Under-nourished and highly stressed from horrific
pain and unnatural confinement, the bears lie in agony, in their own filth.

According to Jeanette McDermott, bile is not the farmers’ only source of profit 
from the bears. Some farmers amputate one or two paws from live bears to sell to
restaurants. When bears are no longer able to secrete bile, they are left to
die from sickness or starvation. Bears might endure this torture for up to 25
years, making their lifetime a reality of suffering and pain in the name of
“natural” and “traditional” medicine.

Image 4. This metal clamp is placed around bears who might struggle or move
around excessively in order to ensure they remain still through the painful bile
extraction. Photo: Animals Asia

There are a number of extremely painful techniques used for milking bear bile.
Image 4, above, illustrates the common extraction technique that relies on
plastic or metal catheters, and often necessitates a metal jacket in order to
restrain the bears (the chilling details can be found at the Animals Asia
website). Some farms rely on an ultrasound machine to guide a catheter connected
to a medicinal pump. In this method, the bears are sedated — usually with
ketamine — restrained with ropes, and have their abdomens jabbed repeatedly with
four-inch needles until the gallbladder is located. Animals Asia suspects that 
this process leads to dangerous leakages of bile into the body, and to a slow
and agonizing death from peritonitis.

In recent years, China has introduced a new, “humane,” free-dripping extraction 
method, which does away with the need for catheters. Free-dripping involves
carving a permanent hole, or fistula, into the bear’s abdomen and gall bladder, 
from which bile drips out freely. The damage caused by the bile’s leaking back
into the abdomen, together with infection from the permanently open puncture, is
even worse than the catheters method, and results in a high mortality rate.
Often, the bears’ livers and gallbladders become severely diseased through this 
process, and the collected bile is contaminated with pus, blood, urine and
feces.

Image 5. Sometimes a hollow steel stick is pushed through the bear’s abdomen,
and the bile runs into a basin under the cage. In this case, about half of the
bears die from infections or other complications. Photo: Animals Asia

Image 6. Ultrasound bile extraction from a bear in Vietnam. Photo: Asia Wild
Life

A healthy bear’s bile is as fluid as water, and ranges in color from bright
yellow-orange to green. However, Animals Asia’s vets have described bile leaking
from the gallbladders of farmed bears as “black sludge.” Eminent Chinese and
Vietnamese pathologists have warned the public not to use bile taken from sick
bears.

The active substance in bile (of bear and all other mammals) is ursodeoxycholic 
acid (UDCA), also known as Ursodiol, which is easily synthesized, and has been
available for several decades. It is estimated that 100,000 kilos of synthetic
UDCA are already being used each year in China, Japan, and South Korea, and that
the total world consumption may double this figure.

Despite the availability and affordability of synthetic UDCA and suitable herbal
alternatives, some practitioners obstinately continue to prescribe bear bile,
which in turn drives up the market demand, and pressures the Chinese government 
to continue to allow the practice of bear farming.

The world’s appetite for bear bile and other parts has also led to the hunting
and killing of wild bears in the North America. The media reports that the
poaching of bear gallbladder for its use in TCM is on the rise in the US. The
Los Angles Times, of August 22, 2008, writes that Fish and Game Wardens in
California (CA) often report finding dead black bear carcasses that have been
skinned and dismembered. The gallbladder is by far the most often stolen part
(see the Los Angeles Times of November 29, 2010). The CA animal safety group,
BEAR League, reports that since the beginning of 2007, as many as 87 dead bears 
have been found near state roadsides. On occasion, they report the bears’ heads 
or paws are cut off, but they also report finding bear carcasses with the
gallbladder missing.

Image 7. This California black bear was struck and killed on State Highway 89
near Lake Tahoe in August 2008. State wildlife officials say the gallbladder was
removed. Photo: BEAR League

The appalling impact of TCM on endangered species goes well beyond bears though.
It affects the world’s most precious and protected animals, such as Bengal
tigers, American bears and African rhinos. A worldwide interest in alternative
medicine and the ease of international commerce now put dozens of species
worldwide at risk. And while most of traditional Chinese medicines rely on
herbs, the demand for products made at the expense of threatened animals
continues to grow. In reality, many of the current claims associated with the
medicinal value of animal products are spurious; but reality hasn’t stopped the 
rising demand for these illegal substances, and the profits to be made by
poachers and smugglers rise.2

While the use of some animal products was perhaps justifiable in the past  —
when there were no alternatives available, the extent of demand was limited, and
the particular species were plentiful in their natural habitat — it is no
longer sustainable, or justifiable, given our modern, globalized, and
technically-advanced world. Today, with other approved therapeutic alternatives 
available, there is little justification for the use of endangered species such 
as the black bear.3

The belief advanced by the Counterculture of the 1960s and the New Age movement 
— that “natural” curatives are better than their synthetic equivalents —
contributes enormously to TCM’s popularity in North America today. These groups 
originally objected to the growing over-consumption and over-reliance on
synthetically-produced medicines, over natural alternatives. And while these
concerns should be considered serious, the apologists of TCM and other types of 
traditional medicines fail to recognize that at present, their massive demand
for “natural” products has made crime against animals commonplace. TCM has
behind it a powerful, moneyed group of consumers whose “needs” now drive a whole
black market economy — one that supports poachers, bear bile farmers, and all
types of heinous torture.

As I wrote his article, I was overwhelmed with rage, and repulsed not only by
the horrific images of the animal holocaust in Asia, but also by the enormous
hypocrisy of the proponents of TCM, who effectively claim that pus-infested bear
bile, and the by-products of animals tortured, disfigured, and dismembered in
the name of the“natural” are better, safer, and “gentler” than synthetic
pharmaceuticals.

With many thanks to Sara Pegarella, JD, and Kristin Koster, PhD, for their
valuable comments.

The above mentioned animal rights advocacy groups (Animals Asia, Asia Wild Life,
etc.) were not interviewed for this piece and any information attributable to
them was taken from their websites. I encourage you to visit these sites to
become more informed and involved.

REFERENCES

  1. Bensky D, Gamble A, Kaptchuck T. Chinese Herbal Medicine: Materia Medica. 
    Revised Edition. Eastland Press. 1986. Return to text

  2. Ellis R. Tiger Bone & Rhino Horn: The Destruction of Wildlife for
    Traditional Chinese Medicine. Island Press; 1 edition. 2005. Return to text

  3. Still J. Use of animal products in traditional Chinese medicine:
    environmental impact and health hazards. Complement Ther Med. 2003
    Jun;11(2):118-22. Return to text

Chinese government recommends bear bile for COVID-19

The Chinese Government is relentlessly promoting TCM for COVID-19, including a
remedy containing bear bile, which is cruelly extracted from the gall bladders
of living wild or “farmed” bears.

Jann Bellamy on May 7, 2020

Link



The National Health Commission of the People’s Republic of China recommends
injections containing bear bile in official guidelines for the treatment of
COVID-19 with Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). The Environmental
Investigation Agency (EIA), a global environmental non-profit, discovered Tan Re
Qing, a Chinese patent medicine, among the government’s COVID-19 treatment
recommendations. (You can find it on the official list here.) One of the
ingredients in Tan Re Qing is bear bile, which is harvested from the
gallbladders of bears, either in the wild or from bears held in captivity and
“milked” for their bile. (In response to a claim that this was “fake news”, EIA 
posted a rebuttal, with further evidence.)

EIA noted the irony in China’s promoting bear bile as a COVID-19 remedy “despite
a scientific consensus pointing to China’s wildlife trade as the most likely
cause of the coronavirus pandemic”. The organization, which monitors illegal
trafficking in wild animals, says traffickers were touting their illegal
products based on the Chinese government’s recommendations. Bear bile farming is
legal in China, but harvesting from wild bears is not. Bear bile is also
imported into China from Laos, Vietnam, and North Korea, even though Asiatic
black bears, a species commonly farmed for their bile, are protected from
international commercial trade in animals and animal products under the
Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora.

Bear bile extraction is nauseatingly cruel. As a recent National Geographic
article explains:

   At bear bile farms in China and across Southeast Asia, the animals may be
   kept for decades in small cages. Bile is routinely extracted by inserting a
   catheter, syringe, or pipe into the gallbladder. All methods for extracting
   bile are invasive and “cause severe suffering, pain, and infection,”
   according to Animals Asia, a nonprofit dedicated to ending bear bile farming.
   Neglect and disease are common on these farms, and consumers risk ingesting 
   bile from sick bears, which may be contaminated with blood, feces, pus,
   urine, and bacteria, according to Animals Asia.

From a 2011 SBM post on TCM:

   The Humane Society of the United States reports that the process of milking
   is so painful for the bears that they moan and often chew their paws during
   the procedure. In order to make access to the animals easier, the farmers
   often break the bears’ teeth and pull out their claws, sometimes brutally
   removing whole digits. If the bears stop producing bile, they are left to
   die, or are killed for their gallbladder and paws (considered a delicacy in
   China).

National Geographic also reports a concern about another TCM product recommended
by the Chinese government for COVID-19: Angong Niuhuang Wan, a pill
traditionally containing rhino horn. Although rhino horn is banned from global
trade and, under Chinese law, the pill must instead contain buffalo horn, some
traffickers continue to market pills containing rhino horn.

Indian officials were so alarmed that the recommended remedies might encourage
poaching they sent out an alert to wildlife officers. One senior forest official
told an Indian newspaper:

   They (poachers) do poaching whenever there is an opportunity. Poaching is
   basically demand-driven. If the demand is high then people will take the
   risks.

Promotion of TCM for COVID-19

The Chinese government is busy promoting TCM for COVID-19, including exporting
TCM products and practitioners to “help” other countries. At a press conference,
a Chinese official claimed, without evidence (because there is none), that TCM 
has “alleviated symptoms, reduced the severity of the virus, improved recovery
rates and reduced mortality rates”.

One China expert sees this boosterism as a means of deflecting criticism of
China’s response to the pandemic by “causing distraction from questions that
could be embarrassing for the Chinese government”. It also jibes with the
government’s use of TCM as a tool of nationalism and a lucrative export product.

As David Gorski explained in a prescient 2016 SBM post, Chinese authorities are 
aggressively promoting TCM by putting TCM and “Western” medicine on “equal
footing”, with specific policies “giving equal attention to TCM and Western
medicine”. All of this is, as he pointed out, in accord with Mao’s original
fabrication of so-called “traditional Chinese medicine” as a means of unifying
China and, to boot, a cost-saving measure replacing effective medicine with
cheap pseudoscience. This plan includes:

1. Enacting the “Law on Traditional Chinese Medicine”, effective in 2017, requiring
local governments to set up TCM institutions in publicly-funded health care
facilities, envisioning TCM as “key to reform of medical and health sectors and 
the drive toward a Healthy China”.

2. State support of TCM research, and development and protection of TCM
intellectual property and TCM formulae as state secrets.

3. Of special relevance to COVID-19, expansion of TCM in dealing with disease
prevention and control and “dealing with public health incidents”.

4. “Protecting and breeding” rare or endangered wildlife, implying that “the
government will promote the preservation and utilization of these animals for
their various body parts that are, barbarically, used in TCM concoctions”.

Hence, bear bile as a COVID-19 remedy.

As one Chinese official commented at the time,

   The new law on traditional Chinese medicine will improve global TCM
   influence, and give a boost to China’s soft power.

Here in the U.S., acupuncturists and TCM practitioners are happy to help spread 
the government’s propaganda and concomitant “boost to China’s soft power” by
credulously regurgitating questionable Chinese research, aided by state
legislators who have given these practitioners broad scopes of practice and
incorporated their pseudoscience into state law. So, ironically, while the Trump
administration rails against the Chinese government for (among other things)
its role in fomenting a global pandemic, state-licensed health care
practitioners are actively promoting what is, in part, a bid for global
influence by that same Chinese government.

Thus, the Council of Colleges of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (CCAOM),
doing its own part to give “equal attention to TCM and Western medicine”, links 
several documents on treating COVID-19 with TCM among its “Member Resources“.
The CCAOM was created “to advance the standing of acupuncture and Oriental
medicine (AOM) in the U.S.”, accomplished in part by its establishment of the
Accreditation Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine, the U.S
Department of Education-approved accrediting agency for acupuncture and TCM
schools. Accreditation makes acupuncture/TCM students eligible for federal
student loans. (I wonder what Betsy DeVos would think if she knew the agency she
heads plays an important part in advancing China’s interests in the U.S.)

One resource, the “Hubei Province Integrated Chinese/Western Medicine Hospital
Critical Viral Respiratory Disease Formulas“, helpfully explains that “the new
coronavirus pneumonia roughly approximates Chinese medicine’s ‘warm disease’ or 
‘epidemic disease’ category'”, with presenting symptoms including “feeling
heaviness in the body” and “greasy tongue coating”.

   The fundamental pathogenic factors are dampness and heat. Clinically we need 
   to consider the upper and middle burner for our primary treatment strategy,
   paying attention to latent heat, and damage to qi and yen.

Some 10 pages of TCM remedies are provided, ending with the recommendation that 
health care providers “secure and guard your upright, healthy qi”.

Another recommended resource, “How COVID-19 (2019-nCoV) is Currently Treated in 
China with TCM“, translates Chinese treatment protocols into English, advising
that “Chinese medicine should take a primary role in effective treatment and
must not be absent in action” and asking readers to “please share this article
and the herbal prescriptions with everyone”.

Here, we learn authorities in Wuhan issued an edict that “all medical
institutions in Wuhan will ensure that all infected patients take Chinese
medicine before midnight on February 3, 2020.” (So much for informed consent!)
Treatments include herbal formulas “administered to patients according to the
individual’s TCM pattern diagnosis” (a nonsensical, pre-scientific system),
including tongue and pulse diagnosis. Patients also received acupuncture at
specified points “to strengthen the immune system”, “alleviate early symptoms,
and to shorten the duration of the virus”, as well as moxibustion.

Specific treatment protocols are set out, based on TCM diagnoses such as
“wind-cold invading the exterior”, for which the “treatment strategy” is “expel 
wind, release the exterior, clear heat, detoxify”. Another diagnosis: “damp heat
afflicting the lung”, with the advised “treatment strategy” of “transform
dampness, detoxify, disperse the lungs and expel pathogens”. And so on.

Based solely on the uncontrolled, unrandomized, unblinded observation of
patients, results attributed to these TCM treatments are described as reduction 
of fever, increase in energy, and “obvious improvement in symptoms and an
overall improved mental state”. The document claims that the Hubei Provincial
Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine

   diligently used TCM . . . revealing that Chinese herbs played a definitive
   role in positive treatment outcomes. Chinese herbal formulas harbor the
   unique potential to reduce fever and cough symptoms, limit disease
   progression, and improve overall immunity, and thus a person’s ability to
   mount an essential response to the virus.

Yet another CCAOM resource is from the Healthcare Medicine Institute, a provider
of state-approved acupuncture/TCM continuing education courses in the U.S.,
titled “Acupuncture and Herbs COVID-19 (Coronavirus) Findings“. The entire
document credulously repeats literally unbelievable results claimed by Chinese
health authorities for a remedy called Qing Fei Pai Du Tang, a concoction of
some 20 different herbs:

1. For patients with pneumonia, symptoms “markedly improved” for 60%, and 30%
“stabilized”, for a 90% positive response rate.

2. Of 701 COVID-19 patients treated, “130 patients were cured, symptoms including
fever and coughing completely resolved in an additional 51 patients, symptom
improvements occurred in an additional 268 patients, and stabilization occurred 
in 212 patients.”

3. 112 patients had a body temperature in excess of 37.3 degrees C. “After taking
Qing Fei Pai Du Tang for one day, 51.8% of patients’ body temperatures returned 
to normal. After 6 days, 94.6% returned to normal temperature.”

4. Of 351 patients, 214 had coughs. “After one day of drinking Qing Fei Pai Du
Tang, 46.7% of patients’ coughs completely resolved. After 6 days, 80.6% had
significant reductions in coughing.”

The “Findings” also recommend acupuncture points for COVID-19 treatment,
including several “to eliminate pathogens from the body”.

Given the Chinese government’s relentless promotion, one can fairly view TCM as 
an ambassador for China’s international influence. After all, no one can
legitimately make the case that it offers safe and effective treatment of
disease. Yet, TCM (often in the form of acupuncture, a theatrical placebo) has
infiltrated every facet of the U.S. healthcare system: prestigious medical
centers, government institutions, public and private insurance, and healthcare
provider licensing. All of this was done with the full support of the U.S. and
state governments, albeit unwittingly, in the form of licensing laws, research
funds, mandated insurance coverage, and legitimization of TCM education
(including student loans). Without much effort on its part, the Chinese
government has, in the guise of a healthcare practice, been wildly successful in
spreading its ideology throughout America, an ideology grounded in a rejection 
of science, indifference to human suffering, and cruelty to animals.

Exploitation of Mammals for Traditional Remedies

A recent review hints at the extent to which endangered mammals are exploited
for fake medicines.

Steven Novella on December 9, 2020

Link



One of the often overlooked harms of unscientific medical practices is the
exploitation of animals, including threatened and endangered species, for
traditional remedies. With over 7 billion people on the planet and growing,
almost anything a large segment of that population does is likely to have an
impact on the environment, including driving species to extinction.

The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that over 80% of the world’s
population relies upon animal-derived treatments. They report:

   Wild and domestic animals and their by-products (e.g., hooves, skins, bones, 
   feathers, tusks) form important ingredients in the preparation of curative,
   protective and preventive medicine. For example, in Traditional Chinese
   Medicine (TCM), more than 1500 animal species have been recorded to be of
   some medicinal use. In India nearly 15–20 percent of the Ayurvedic medicine
   is based on animal-derived substances. In Bahia State, in the northeast of
   Brazil, over 180 medicinal animals have been recorded.

A recently published global review focusing on mammals specifically has found
similarly alarming numbers. They found:

   Our results show that 521 mammalian species are used to source products to
   treat 371 ailments. In our database, 155 mammalian species are considered
   threatened (Vulnerable, Endangered, or Critically Endangered), and a further 
   46 are Near Threatened…

That’s 201 mammalian species that are somewhere between near threatened and
critically endangered. A few of the more charismatic species get most of the
attention. For example – the pangolin is poached for its scales, which are
ground into a powder and used to treat a variety of ailments. National
Geographic reports that more than a million of these animals have been poached
between 2000 and 2013. While also used for their meat, the primary driver of the
illegal pangolin trade is the use of their scales in Traditional Chinese
Medicine (TCM). This makes the pangolin (including all eight known species) the 
most illegally trafficked animal in the world. They have been all-but wiped out 
in Asia, and recently the trafficking has shifted to African species.

China, for their part, has promised to crack down on this trade and has removed 
them from the official list of TCM products. But their efforts are seen as
insufficient and perhaps insincere. The Guardian reports:

   But the EIA report reveals huge gaps in Chinese enforcement. The government
   continues to allow pharmaceutical companies to use pangolin scales from the
   national stockpile, which is “shrouded in secrecy and never seems to run
   out”. A related report earlier this year found China’s medical insurance
   system was still reimbursing users for traditional remedies containing
   pangolin, which undermined the broader goal of reducing the illegal trade.

This is also not only a recent problem. Nature Magazine covered the exact same
problem – in 1938.

   The animal itself is eaten, but a greater danger arises from the belief that 
   the scales have medicinal value. Fresh scales are never used, but dried
   scales are roasted, ashed, cooked in oil, butter, vinegar, boy’s urine, or
   roasted with earth or oyster-shells, to cure a variety of ills. Amongst these
   are excessive nervousness and hysterical crying in children, women possessed
   by devils and ogres, malarial fever and deafness.

They talk about the thousands of animals trafficked each year and even
regulations to stem the trade, so all that has really changed is the magnitude
of the problem. More than 80 years later the animal is in even greater illegal
use and we are still getting false promises of cracking down on the trade.

Further, this is not a matter of having to sacrifice a legitimate use that is
just unsustainable. Products made from pangolin scales for alleged medicinal use
are complete pseudoscience. Pangolin scales are made from keratin. They are
essentially fingernails. Belief that they have any healing properties is pure
magic. Therefore the people who buy such products in the belief that they will
help their ailment are also being exploited. Purging medicine of pseudoscience
will take care of the problem of endangering species for fake medicine as a
bonus.

Pangolins, of course, are only one example. Tigers, rhinos, sun bears, and
Asiatic bears are also exploited for body parts based upon purely
pseudoscientific claims (for tiger bones, rhino horns, and bear bile) – along
with over 500 other mammalian species.

If there is one thing we have learned in trying to regulate harmful trades,
whether in fake medicine or recreational drugs, for example, is that – if the
demand is there, someone will figure out a way to make money by fulfilling that 
demand. As the 1938 Nature article illustrated, we will not solve the problem by
“cracking down”, although making trade in endangered species illegal is a good 
start. It is also important for the government not to officially sanction fake
medical products. But these measures are only nibbling around the edges, if
there is still massive demand.

Curbing demand requires a cultural change, which is not easy. It starts with an 
understanding of the relationship between science and legitimate medicine, which
is further based on basic scientific literacy and critical thinking skills.
This is another lesson recently learned (and perhaps relearned by every
generation) – as the proverb goes, for the forest to be green each tree must be 
green (attributed to George Harrison who in turn was quoting the Maharishi). In 
order for us to have a rational society, a critical portion of individual people
must be rational. Certainly we want rational regulations from the top – but
that alone will not accomplish much if the masses want pseudoscience.

In the tradition of Chairman Mao, traditional Chinese medicine gets a new boost 
by the Chinese government

Despite a lack of evidence for its efficacy and safety, traditional Chinese
medicine (TCM) has made major inroads into US medical centers, both academic and
community. I’ve told the story of how Chairman Mao Zedong created the myth of
TCM and promoted it to credulous Westerners to facilitate the “integration” of
TCM and “Western medicine.” Over the holiday break, I learned that this process 
continues apace, even in today’s China.

David Gorski on January 2, 2017

Link


Of all the forms of unproven and disproven alternative medicine being
enthusiastically “integrated” into science-based medicine by proponents of
“integrative medicine” (formerly—and sometimes still—known as “complementary and
alternative medicine,” or CAM), so-called “traditional Chinese medicine” (TCM) 
is clearly among the most popular and seemingly the most accepted. After all,
acupuncture, the most famous modality in the TCM armamentarium, is offered in
dozens of academic medical centers and hundreds of medical centers in the US,
but it goes beyond that. It doesn’t matter that the totality of science and
evidence, when critically examined, strongly supports the conclusion that
acupuncture is nothing more than, as Steve Novella and David Colquhoun put it, a
“theatrical placebo,” with no detectable difference in effect compared to sham 
or “placebo” acupuncture. As I like to point out periodically, just twirling
toothpicks on the skin produces equivalent perceived relief of back pain to
acupuncture, overhyped and dubious systematic reviews frequently cited by
acupuncturists notwithstanding.

It’s worse than that, however. It’s not just acupuncture, but it’s the whole
ancient, prescientific system of medicine. It’s also more than athletes very
publicly discussing the use of “cupping” quackery to enhance their performance, 
thereby glamorizing it. Oh, sure, occasionally a drug derived from an herb used 
in TCM will be found to be useful for something, leading to TCM proponents to
argue that this finding vindicates TCM, when in fact it’s far more a triumph of 
pharmacognosy (natural products pharmacology) than a vindication of TCM. None of
this stops academic medical centers from embracing TCM, as, for example, the
Cleveland Clinic did when it set up a TCM clinic and hired an herbalist, which
appears to have served as a prelude to its hiring Dr. Mark Hyman and embracing
functional medicine. Thanks to the specialty dubbed “integrative medicine” by
its proponents (and more appropriately called “integrating quackery with
medicine” by skeptics), you can find articles in the scientific literature
discussing qi (life energy) and its flow through acupuncture meridians or
diseases as deficiencies or imbalances in hot/cold or dry/wet as though there
were actual scientific validity to them.

What many people don’t realize, even skeptics, is that the “integration” of TCM 
into scientific medicine is not new. It was the realization of Chairman Mao
Zedong’s dream. Apparently it still is. I was reminded of this by an article in 
Bloomberg entitled “Traditional Medicine Won’t Cure China’s Ills.” It’s based on
a story published by Chinese media, “China adopts law on traditional medicine.”
Basically, China adopted a law to provide TCM a larger role in the Chinese
health care system, in essence legislating the “integration” of TCM with
science-based medicine.

A brief history of the “integration” of traditional Chinese medicine into
“Western” medicine

I’ve written in detail before about how Chairman Mao and his medical authorities
in Communist China more or less invented what we know today as TCM and how this
history has in essence been retconned into the narrative we hear today about
how TCM represents “ancient knowledge” and how acupuncture is thousands of years
old. (Never mind that the technology to make such thin needles didn’t exist two
thousand years ago, and that, as recently as a century ago, acupuncture was a
brutal and primitive, using nothing like the thin, shiny needles acupuncturists 
use today.) If you want the detailed account, check this post out. For purposes 
of this post I’ll provide the CliffsNotes version, beginning with this quote by 
Chairman Mao:

   Our nation’s health work teams are large. They have to concern themselves
   with over 500 million people [including the] young, old, and ill. … At
   present, doctors of Western medicine are few, and thus the broad masses of
   the people, and in particular the peasants, rely on Chinese medicine to treat
   illness. Therefore, we must strive for the complete unification of Chinese
   medicine. (Translations from Kim Taylor’s Chinese Medicine in Early Communist
   China, 1945-1963: A Medicine of Revolution.)

And, more pertinently:

   Mao was under no illusion that Chinese medicine—a key component of
   naturopathic education—actually worked. In The Private Life of Chairman Mao, 
   Li Zhisui, one of Mao’s personal physicians, recounts a conversation they had
   on the subject. Trained as an M.D. in Western medicine, Li admitted to being
   baffled by ancient Chinese medical books, especially their theories relating
   to the five elements. It turns out his employer also found them implausible.

   “Even though I believe we should promote Chinese medicine,” Mao told him, “I 
   personally do not believe in it. I don’t take Chinese medicine.”

Yes, the exportation of TCM to the world was quite deliberate, as part of a
strategy to popularize it among the Chinese. There was a problem, however. There
was no such thing as “traditional Chinese medicine” per se. Rather, there were 
traditional Chinese medicines. For many centuries, healing practices in China
had been highly variable. Attempts at institutionalizing medical education were 
mostly unsuccessful and “most practitioners drew at will on a mixture of
demonology, astrology, yin-yang five phases theory, classic texts, folk wisdom, 
and personal experience.” Mao realized that TCM would be unappealing to
foreigners, as even many Chinese, particularly those with an education,
understood that TCM was mostly quackery. For instance, in 1923, Lu Xun realized 
that “Chinese doctors are no more than a type of swindler, either intentional or
unintentional, and I sympathize with deceived sick people and their families.” 
Such sentiments were common among the upper classes and the educated. Indeed, as
we have seen, Mao himself didn’t use TCM practitioners. He wanted scientific
“Western” medicine. The same was true of educated Chinese. It still is. TCM is
far less popular among educated middle class and affluent Chinese than
conventional medicine.

Mao’s strategy to deal with the criticisms of TCM of being prescientific and
chock full of vitalistic and superstitious nonsense was quite clever. It
consisted of two strategies, both designed to mythologize TCM as being a
scientifically sound and harmonious “whole medical system” and to provide
“evidence” that it worked. In other words, his health officials did their best
to “scientize” it. Textbooks were written that portrayed TCM not as a wide
variety of disparate folk medicine traditions, but rather as a harmonious
theoretical and practical whole, with the contradictions and self-contradictions
in the “classic” texts papered over and pounded into a self-consistent system. 
Terms such as “holism” (zhengtiguan) and “preventative care” (yufangxing) were
used to provide the new system with appealing foundational principles,
principles that are now standard fare in arguments about the benefits of
alternative medicine. This version of TCM was taught in newly founded academies 
and exported to the West.

The second part of the strategy was to provide spectacular anecdotes that
appeared to demonstrate that TCM worked. The most famous of these was the case
of James Reston, a New York Times editor who underwent an emergency appendectomy
while visiting China in 1971. This story, it turned out, was very much
overblown. In fact, the surgeons there used a fairly standard anesthesia
technique, described by our SBM colleague Kimball Atwood as sounding like a
“standard regional technique, most likely an epidural,” and acupuncture was used
to treat cramping on second evening after the surgery, which, not surprisingly,
resolved, as most postoperative ileus does. Over time, more reports of
“acupuncture anesthesia” trickled out of China to a credulous, enthusiastic
Western press. Let’s just say that, examined critically, these stories are not
convincing, and some examples have been cataloged by our very own Kimball Atwood
in his “Acupuncture Anesthesia”: A Proclamation from Chairman Mao series (see
Part I, Part II, Part III, Part IV, and Part V for the details).

Mao’s vision was nothing less than the “integration” of TCM into “Western
medicine,” as discussed by Atwood through the listing of five party slogans
about TCM:

  1. 1945-50 ‘The Co-operation of Chinese and Western Medicines’

  2. 1950-8 ‘The Unification of Chinese and Western Medicines’

  3. 1950-53 ‘Chinese Medicine studies Western Medicine’

  4. 1954-8 ‘Western Medicine studies Chinese Medicine’

  5. 1958- ‘The Integration of Chinese and Western Medicines’

Mao’s idea was nothing less than the complete unification of TCM and “Western”
medicine, as quoted by Kimball Atwood further from The Private Life of Chairman 
Mao:

   Mao laughed. ‘The theory of yin and yang and the five elements really is very
   difficult,’ he said. ‘The theory is used by doctors of Chinese medicine to
   explain the physiological and pathological conditions of the human body. What
   I believe is that Chinese and Western medicine should be integrated.
   Well-trained doctors of Western medicine should learn Chinese medicine;
   senior doctors of Chinese medicine should learn anatomy, physiology,
   bacteriology, pathology, and so on. They should learn how to use modern
   science to explain the principles of Chinese medicine. They should translate 
   some classical Chinese medicine books into modern language, with proper
   annotations and explanations. Then a new medical science, based on the
   integration of Chinese and Western medicine, can emerge. That would be a
   great contribution to the world.’

Clearly, we at SBM disagree.

2016: China mandates the integration of Chinese and “Western medicine”

Fast forward to the end of 2016:

   China’s top legislature on Sunday adopted a law on traditional Chinese
   medicine (TCM) to give TCM a bigger role in the medical system.

   The Law on Traditional Chinese Medicine was approved at the end of a
   seven-day session of the National People’s Congress (NPC) Standing Committee 
   which concluded on Sunday afternoon.

   Huang Wei, deputy director of the NPC Standing Committee commission for
   legislative affairs, said the law, which will go into effect on July 1, 2017,
   is a significant step in the development of TCM. It is key to reform of
   medical and health sectors and the drive toward a “Healthy China.”

   According to the new law, county-level governments and above must set up TCM 
   institutions in public-funded general hospitals and mother and child care
   centers. Private investment will be encouraged in these institutions.

   All TCM practitioners must pass tests. Apprentices and previously unlicensed 
   specialists with considerable medical experience may only begin practice when
   they have recommendations from at least two qualified practitioners and pass
   relevant tests.

   With a history of more than 2,000 years, TCM is seen by many as a national
   treasure in China for its unique theories and practices, such as herbal
   medicine, acupuncture, massage and dietetics.

   This is especially the case since Tu Youyou won the 2015 Nobel Prize for her 
   work using artemisinin to treat malaria.

Argh! See what I mean? This is exactly what I was talking about when I pointed
out how TCM apologists always point to various medicines that were derived from 
herbs used in TCM as validation of TCM even when they aren’t. They also tend to 
forget all the hundreds of other TCM herbs that have never been shown to have
medicinal properties. I’d also argue that TCM is no more a “national treasure”
of China than humoral theory is to any nation in Europe. The two do, after all, 
share many characteristics, not the least of which is the belief that disease is
due to an “imbalance” of various things. In humoral theory, it’s imbalances in 
the four humors. In TCM, it’s imbalances in the five elements. In both systems
of medicine, vitalism is largely the basis of the concepts that undergird them.

In any case, what the Chinese authorities have done is the equivalent of, say,
German authorities mandating homeopathy clinics because homeopathy was invented 
by a German and is therefore a “national treasure” for its “unique theories and 
practices” or if, say, Greece mandated the opening of clinics utilizing the four
humors theory to treat disease because Hippocrates taught humoral theory,
making it a “national treasure” for its “unique theories and practices.” Of
course, humoral theory is not so unique; it resembles TCM quite a bit in the
basic concepts underlying it.

It turns out that TCM has continued to benefit from the policies that Mao
instituted to favor it. As Adam Minter observes, TCM is a favored state
industry, and the traditional medicines pharmaceutical industry raked in $114
billion in 2015 and represents nearly 29% of China’s pharmaceutical industry. In
China, TCM is big business. The TCM herbs and concoctions thus sold were
dispensed by 452,000 practitioners working out of tens of thousands of
clinics—many no more than single-room storefronts.

The law, while mandating the “integration” of TCM into conventional medicine in 
China (or at least its government support), does increase the regulation of
those who practice TCM, but it does so in a way that elevates the status of TCM:

   To this end, the new law said China puts TCM and Western medicine on equal
   footing in China, with better training for TCM professionals, with TCM and
   Western medicine learn from each other and complementing each other.

   The state will support TCM research and development and protect TCM
   intellectual property.

   Special protection will be given to TCM formulas that are considered state
   secrets, it said.

   Use of technology and expansion of TCM in dealing with emergency public
   health incidents and diseases prevention and control should increase.

   The state will protect medical resources including protection and breeding of
   rare or endangered wildlife, the law said.

   The law went on to pledge enhanced supervision of raw TCM materials, banning 
   the use of toxic pesticides.

Putting TCM (and all of CAM) on “equal footing” to science-based medicine is
what CAM proponents have been striving for all along. It’s a large part of the
reason why “alternative medicine” was renamed “CAM” and then, more recently,
renamed “integrative medicine.” As I’ve described before, “alternative” implied 
that it isn’t real medicine (which the vast majority of alternative medicine is 
not), and “complementary” implied that standard science-based medicine was the
main medicine, and the “complementary” medicine (like TCM and other “alternative
medicines”) were merely the “icing on the cake,” not as important as
conventional medicine and, worst of all, not strictly necessary. Renaming the
specialty “integrative medicine” and implying that this new specialty
“integrates the best of both worlds” were intended to counter that perception
and put the woo on equal footing with scientific medicine, just as Mao tried to 
do nearly 70 years ago and the current Chinese government is trying to do now.

One also can’t help but notice that a lot of this new law goes towards
protecting the business interests of the TCM industry in a manner that, if it
were done for the pharmaceutical company, would provoke howls of outrage from
CAM proponents—and rightly so. Worse, the part about “protecting and breeding”
of rare or endangered wildlife implies to me that the government will promote
the preservation and utilization of these animals for their various body parts
that are, barbarically, used in TCM concoctions. For example, we’ve discussed
before how cruelly bears are confined and operated on in order to harvest bear
bile for various TCM treatments. We’ve also discussed how the market for animal 
parts for TCM remedies is endangering animals and could lead to extinctions as
the TCM industry seeks tiger penis and rhinoceros horns to mix into their
nostrums. It might well be a good thing if the Chinese government steps in to
protect tigers and rhinos, but nothing in this law seems to say anything about
ceasing the use of such animal components.

The one good thing about China’s new law

The only potentially good thing about the law is the regulation of toxic
ingredients. As Minter notes:

   This lack of oversight extends to the thriving industry of traditional
   pharmaceuticals. Last year, a team of scientists found that nearly 90 percent
   of TCM remedies marketed in Australia contained undeclared ingredients,
   including antibiotics and decongestants, heavy metals such as lead and
   arsenic, and a range of plant and animal matter — not least, the DNA of
   endangered snow leopards. The situation is almost certainly worse in China,
   which lacks Australia’s (clearly inadequate) screening procedures. A 2013
   Greenpeace study found pesticides in 51 of 65 popular herbal remedies
   marketed in TCM shops in China and Hong Kong. In one case, contamination
   levels were 500 times the European Union’s accepted safety limit.

   It’s impossible to calculate the human toll of shady TCM practices, but there
   are hints. Several recent studies have found that herbal remedies are the
   leading cause of drug-induced liver failure in China, accounting for as much 
   as 43 percent of all cases. The problem is equally severe in other countries 
   where TCM is rapidly expanding: Herbal remedies may account for up to 40
   percent of drug-induced liver injuries in South Korea and 55 percent in
   Singapore.

We’ve discussed this problem before multiple times on SBM (e.g., this discussion
of contamination of TCM medicines with heavy metals). If China is going to
permit and even encourage the TCM industry, at the very least it has a duty to
make sure that the products its companies are selling are not dangerous. This is
a duty that Chinese government has thus far failed miserably to live up to, a
failure that has been documented on more occasions than I can recount. It is
long past time that the Chinese government remedied that failure. I am not,
however, optimistic that it will actually do so.

The real cost of traditional Chinese medicine in China and beyond

The law passed by the Chinese government last week is nothing new. China has
been trying to “integrate” its prescientific system of national medicine that
was cobbled together from various conflicting and internally inconsistent folk
medicine traditions ever since Chairman Mao first hatched the idea after the end
of World War II. Indeed, as a white paper published by the Chinese government a
month ago (no doubt as a justification for the recently passed law), the
promotion of TCM by the Chinese government did not end with the death of
Chairman Mao in 1976. For example, here’s what’s been happening lately:

   Since the CPC’s 18th National Congress in 2012, the Party and the government 
   have granted greater importance to the development of TCM, and made a series 
   of major policy decisions and adopted a number of plans in this regard. At
   the National Conference on Hygiene and Health held in August 2016, President 
   Xi Jinping emphasized the importance of revitalizing and developing
   traditional Chinese medicine. The CPC’s 18th National Congress and the Fifth 
   Plenary Session of the 18th CPC Central Committee both reiterated the
   necessity to pay equal attention to the development of traditional Chinese
   medicine and Western medicine and lend support to the development of TCM and 
   ethnic minority medicine. In 2015, the executive meeting of the State Council
   approved the Law on Traditional Chinese Medicine (draft) and submitted it to
   the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress for deliberation
   and approval, intending to provide a sounder policy environment and legal
   basis for TCM development. In 2016 the CPC Central Committee and the State
   Council issued the Outline of the Healthy China 2030 Plan, a guide to
   improving the health of the Chinese people in the coming 15 years. It sets
   out a series of tasks and measures to implement the program and develop TCM. 
   The State Council issued the Outline of the Strategic Plan on the Development
   of Traditional Chinese Medicine (2016-2030), which made TCM development a
   national strategy, with systemic plans for TCM development in the new era.
   These decisions and plans have mapped out a grand blueprint that focuses on
   the full revitalization of TCM, accelerated reform of the medical and
   healthcare system, the building of a medical and healthcare system with
   Chinese characteristics, and the advancement of the healthy China plan, thus 
   ushering in a new era of development for TCM.

Two of the goals are:

   Equal attention to TCM and Western medicine. Equal status shall be accorded
   to TCM and Western medicine in terms of ideological understanding, legal
   status, academic development, and practical application. Efforts shall be
   made to improve system of administration related to TCM, increase financial
   input, formulate policies, laws and regulations suited to the unique features
   of TCM, promote coordinated development of TCM and Western medicine, and
   make sure that they both serve the maintenance and improvement of the
   people’s health.

   Making TCM and Western medicine complementary to each other, and letting each
   play to its strengths. The state encourages exchanges between TCM and
   Western medicine, and creates opportunities for Western medical practitioners
   to learn from their TCM counterparts. Modern medicine courses are offered at
   TCM colleges and universities to strengthen the cultivation of doctors who
   have a good knowledge of both TCM and Western medicine. In addition to the
   general departments, TCM hospitals have been encouraged to open specialized
   departments for specific diseases. General hospitals and community-level
   medical care organizations have been encouraged to set up TCM departments,
   and TCM has been made available to patients in the basic medical care system 
   and efforts have been made to make it play a more important role in basic
   medical care. A mechanism has been established for TCM to participate in
   medical relief of public emergencies and the prevention and control of
   serious infectious diseases.

Now there’s a waste of money and effort, using TCM to participate in medical
emergencies and the prevention and control of serious diseases. It sounds as
though, like homeopaths without borders, there will soon be TCM practitioners
without borders. Battlefield acupuncture, anyone? Oh, wait. That’s not China.
That’s the US. One wonders if China is getting ideas from the countries to which
it exported TCM to consider using acupuncture and TCM in the emergency
department.

Aside from the destruction of endangered species, the poisoning of the unwary by
adulterated and contaminated TCM herbs, and the degradation of the science of
medicine where TCM is “integrated,” there is the opportunity cost of investing
in TCM. As Minter notes, TCM sucks up billions of dollars that could be better
spent on China’s regular health care system, which, he also notes, is “badly
lagging.” Chinese hospitals are overburdened and underfunded, and there is a
shortage of pediatricians that even the government-run press is calling
“urgent.” Ironically, the reason for this shortage is very similar to the reason
why primary care specialties are unattractive in the US. Chinese medical
students don’t want to become pediatricians because of long hours and low pay;
more lucrative specialties such as ophthalmology or cardiology, are much more
attractive. One student even says, “In China, we say ‘Ophthalmology is gold, the
surgical department is silver, and pediatrics is rubbish’. Some of my
classmates have pointed out that pediatricians only earn half the average salary
of other specialist doctors.” Instead of investing hundreds of millions of
dollars in TCM, China would do better to bolster its science-based medical
system.

On the other hand, remember why Mao promoted TCM: To save money. He didn’t have 
the resources to provide real medicine to all of his people. China in 2017 has
the resources, but chooses not to invest them that way. Instead, as its white
paper says, China’s goal is this:

   China will learn from the achievements of modern civilization, uphold the
   principle of making the ancient serve the contemporary, and strive to promote
   the modernization of TCM by making every effort to carry on the good
   traditions and practices of Chinese medicine, and promote the innovative
   development of TCM for health preservation, so that TCM will be incorporated 
   into the modern outlook on health to serve the people. By 2020, every Chinese
   citizen will have access to basic TCM services, and by 2030 TCM services
   will cover all areas of medical care. Meanwhile, China will also actively
   introduce TCM to the rest of the world, and promote the integration of TCM
   and other traditional medicine with modern technology, so as to explore a new
   model of healthcare to improve the well-being of all people of the world,
   and make a full contribution to global progress and a brighter future for
   mankind.

This policy is virtually indistinguishable from the one Chairman Mao instituted 
in the 1950s. The main difference is that this time, it goes much further, in
particular to protect the profits of the Chinese traditional pharmaceutical
industry, which was not nearly as large or international in Mao’s time.

Don’t believe me? Listen to Huang Wei, deputy director of the NPC Standing
Committee commission for legislative affairs, who puts it this way:

   “The new law on traditional Chinese medicine will improve global TCM
   influence, and give a boost to China’s soft power,” Huang said.

Yes, the Chinese government is working to complete Chairman Mao’s vision by the 
year 2030, in part to project China’s “soft power.” If supporters of SBM think
it was tough to combat the propaganda promoting TCM before, now we have one of
the most powerful nations in the world, one with the second largest economy in
the world, stating that its goal is the integration of its favored national
quackery with science-based medicine. Our task is about to get a whole lot more 
difficult.

If there is an afterlife, somewhere, Chairman Mao is smiling.

What’s in your Traditional Chinese Medicine?

What’s in your Traditional Chinese Medicine? An Australian analysis of 26
products found 92% were contaminated with heavy metals, undeclared plants,
pharmaceuticals, or even animals like the endangered snow leopard, cat, dog, rat
and pit viper.

Scott Gavura on December 17, 2015

Link



An analysis of 26 Traditional Chinese Medicine products found 92% were
contaminated with pharmaceuticals, heavy metals, or the DNA of animals,
including traces of cat, dog, rat, or pit viper.

Two weeks ago I detailed the pervasive problem of poor quality supplements. The 
main reason for this seems to be weak regulatory standards that prioritize the
rights of manufacturers to sell supplements over the rights of consumers to buy 
safe, high quality, properly-labelled products. Call it “health freedom“, where 
the freedom belongs to producers, who in many countries are largely freed from
most of the quality and safety regulations that are in place for licensed
prescription and non-prescription pharmaceuticals. The result of weak regulation
is that few supplements sold on the market today have been properly tested for 
safety or effectiveness, and there are few quality standards for the production 
of these products.

Not surprisingly, there are persistent signs that consumers may face real risks 
to their health from using these products. Now a new study from Australia
confirms what past studies have already shown: adulterated and contaminated
herbal remedies are the rule, rather than the exception. They often contain
undeclared ingredients ranging from potential allergens to heavy metals to
endangered species.

At a minimum, we should expect supplements to be labelled properly. Consumers
should know what they are paying for, and get what they pay for — anything else 
is fraudulent and potentially very dangerous.

So how does a consumer know that the label on a bottle of supplements is
accurate? It’s almost impossible. With drug products, drug regulators inspect
manufacturing facilities, verify production standards, and enforce the quality
and consistency of the final product. When it comes to supplements such as
herbal remedies, none of this may occur. Not only must the source material be
verified, but a lack of contaminants must be verified. Herbals and botanicals
are plant-based products that are natural concoctions of chemicals which are
rarely purified or standardized to contain a predictable amount of any single
active ingredient. Unless the manufacturer tests rigorously for specific
additives, chemical adulterants, or toxic substances (like heavy metals), there 
is no way to know for certain that a herbal remedy is pure and uncontaminated.
There is no routinely-conducted quality testing, so consumers are completely at 
the mercy of the manufacturer’s own quality assurance process that must confirm 
the presence of the desired substance and also the absence of contaminating
substances. And there is no evidence that this is taking place.

Endangered species, pharmaceuticals, and heavy metals in your herbal remedies

A group of Australian researchers recently published a study of legally
purchased Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). They used a series of molecular
tests to see if what was on the label was actually in the bottle, and then
further tested the products for pharmaceuticals, heavy metals, and other
contaminants. What they found was a startling lack of product quality, and in
some cases, what appears to be the deliberate adulteration of TCM with
prescription and non-prescription drugs.

The researchers purchased 26 TCM products from retail stores in Australia, and
directly from Australian TCM practitioners. Samples included tablets/capsules,
teas, and one liquid sample. They first attempted to do a DNA analysis, and
found sufficient DNA in 22 of the samples. There was so much plant contamination
that the authors noted the number of ingredients were often “too numerous to
list” and so they highlighted the most concerning ingredients. For instance, one
product contained Asarum (TCM1) which contains aristolochic acid, a strongly
carcinogenic (and natural) substance which has been banned worldwide.

Half of the products they purchased were not even legally approved by the
Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA), yet even that approval was no mark of
quality: contamination was found in products whether they were approved or not. 
Plants and animals not listed on the label were found in most products,
including:

  1. the snow leopard (an endangered species)

  2. cat

  3. dog

  4. rat

  5. shrub frog

  6. pit viper

  7. a variety of bovids (such as goats)

The contamination doesn’t end there. A wide array of pharmaceutical contaminants
was also found in the samples including:

  1. analgesics like acetaminophen

  2. antihistamines

  3. steroids

  4. anti-inflammatories like ibuprofen

  5. erectile dysfunction drugs like sildenafil (Viagra)

  6. antibiotics

  7. stimulants

  8. The anticoagulant (“blood thinner”) warfarin, used in rat poison

  9. Most spectacularly, clinically significant amounts of two neurotoxins, brucine
    and strychnine

Twenty-five samples were screened for the heavy metals arsenic, cadmium, and
lead. Twenty contained at least one heavy metal. Eleven contained all three
metals. In many cases the amount consumed per day, if the product dose
instructions were followed, would result in heavy metal consumption that
exceeded safe levels.

The bottom line? Only two of 26 products tested were not found to contain any
undeclared substances:

Manufacturing mistakes? Unlikely!

Is sloppy manufacturing and cross-contamination between different products to
blame? Unlikely, given the pattern of contamination observed.

  1. One sample (TCM18) was sold as weight-gain promoting product. It was
    adulterated with both cyproheptadine and the steroid dexamethasone, both of 
    which are drugs that can increase appetite.

  2. Another (TCM2) sold as product for “reducing hay fever” and “nasal secretions”
    contain a stimulant/decongestant, ephedrine, an analgesic, salicylic acid, 
    an antibiotic, amoxicillin, and a blood thinner, warfarin. It is frightening
    that none of these ingredients were actually disclosed, creating a real
    risk of harm.

  3. Finally, TCM8, marketed for “arthritis” and “pain” contained traces of the
    endangered snow panther, as well as tiger. Tigers have a long history of use
    in TCM, a prescientific belief that is driving the poaching of these
    animals, risking their extinction.

Who is happy with the status quo? Manufacturers.

Loose regulatory structures in Australia (and worldwide) have resulted in TCM
remedies that largely fail to meet even basic quality standards for medicines.
There is no acceptable reason for contamination (and adulteration) of TCM, yet
this appears to be commonplace based on the sample studied. Perhaps not
surprisingly, the Chinese Medicine Society in Australia feels the status quo is 
acceptable, and warns against anything that might result in products that meet
basic health and quality standards:

   The Federation of Chinese Medicine Society of Australia said the study
   provides no cause for concern, saying contamination would not be widespread
   in Australia. The society’s president, Professor Lin Tzi Chiang, acknowledged
   that some manufacturers might not be complying with standards set by the
   TGA, but said by and large most manufacturers would be doing the right thing.

   “Unfortunately for sure, there might be one or two products that it might
   happen like that, but it cannot be blamed on the whole profession,” he told
   SBS World News.

   He warned against over-regulation of traditional Chinese medicines, saying it
   would place an unfair burden on the industry and profession.

The evidence demonstrates otherwise. 92% of products tested failed to meet
quality standards. A single adulterated or contaminated pharmaceutical product
in a country like Australia would trigger a national recall and quite likely
legal repercussions for the manufacturer. Yet contamination and adulteration
appear to be business as usual in the TCM industry, where advocates are
oblivious to the possibility of harm, and don’t even mention the right of
consumers to purchase products that don’t contain unlabelled Viagra, dog,
endangered species, or neurotoxins.

Still no evidence of effectiveness

All of the problems with TCM products found in this study need to be considered 
in the context of what we know about their efficacy, because ultimately a
decision to take any product to improve our health needs to balance expected
benefits against known risks. With TCM, any benefits we can expect are unclear. 
While the specific products studied in this analysis are not named, I’m not
aware of any TCM product that is backed by good evidence of efficacy or safety. 
Even if it was effective, how could we be confident that it wasn’t due to the
inclusion of prescription drugs?

Given the lack of any established benefits, and the almost certain likelihood
that any given TCM product (in Australia, at least) is probably contaminated or 
adulterated, consumers are in the worst possible situation. I can’t think of any
circumstances where the benefits might be clear enough to outweigh the risks.

Regulation of the supplement industry has been approached with a light touch,
and now the consequences are being documented. The idea that herbal remedies
including TCM are safe and effective is a marketing strategy based on a fallacy.
Consumers may risk their own health when they buy products that are quite
likely to be adulterated and contaminated. The industry’s unwillingness to
recognize the problem and to clean up its own act is telling — these companies
prioritize profits over consumer safety. And as long as consumers keep buying
their products, and regulators do nothing, there’s little reason for the
situation to change. At Science-Based Medicine we continue to advocate for more 
rigorous standards for supplements, herbal products and TCM — standards that are
equivalent to drug products, where products are tested for quality and where
claims of effectiveness must be backed by evidence. Until standards improve, or 
unless you don’t mind some endangered species or heavy metals in your remedy,
you’re better off steering clear of TCM.

Hickey: On Cupping.

Mark Crislip on April 4, 2014

Link




A customer-slash-victim undergoing dry cupping. I know, super gross, right?

Always start with an excuse. I have been ill for the last 10 days. I suspect I
picked up an infection from the woman I slept with in Vegas.* I normally go
through the day at warp 5 (I do not want to destroy space-time), but this
illness has reduced my mental functioning in the evening to one-half impulse at 
best, with thoughts moving at the speed of a cold Oregon slug. So bear with me.

There can be an odd popularity to medicine. I see this in antibiotics usage.
When a patient is admitted to the ICU with sepsis, while awaiting cultures you
try and kill all the likely bacteria that may be trying to kill the patient. At 
any given time most doctors can only remember two antibiotics and the current
popular duo is vancomycin and pipericillin/tazobactam. It is a reasonable
choice, one of many combinations that would treat most patients with sepsis. I
am not certain how this combination became so popular, although I have been told
that the pipericillin/tazobactam reps have been very active at the Universities
with medical students and residents. As the adage goes, “Give me a student
until he is seven and I will give you the doctor.”

There are also popular trends in alternative medicine as well. Every now and
then there is a flurry of mentions on the interwebs suggesting that a
pseudo-medicine has become all the rage. Or maybe it is just the echo chamber
that is the interwebs.

This week it is “Oil Pulling Might Be The Next Big Thing — Or Not” and “What is 
cupping? Lena Dunham the latest celeb to try the ancient Chinese remedy for pain
relief.”

If oil pulling appears on the Huffington Post it must popular, although Dr.
Novella is skeptical as to its efficacy. And just thinking of swishing oil in my
mouth for 20 minutes or so gives me that gaggy feeling.

Cupping is not the protection I used for karate as a kid. Cupping is a technique
where a vacuum is made in container and applied to the skin, and the vacuum
sucks on the skin creating a welt. Basically cupping gives the patient a hickey 
without, usually, the mess and aggravation of making out.

Medicine has, for the most part, toughened me. I have learned not to scream or
vomit when faced with the occasional surprise such as an unexpected squirt of
pus up a tie or a jar filled to the brim with dried boogers. But the photos of
cupping on the interwebs give me the wiggins. It doesn’t make me gaggy like oil 
pulling, but ick.

Cupping is one of the ancient therapies, used in Egypt, China, and Greece.
Antiquity is always a reliable guide for health and life-style choices. I live
in a pyramid with my terracotta army, tended by my slaves and planning the
conquest of a city-state based on the entrails of a sacrificed goat. What was
good enough for the ancients is good enough for me. Except for that whole “short
life expectancy from infections” thing. It is an oddity of the appeal to
antiquity in that it is mostly used to justify pseudo-medicines, but little else
in life if you are not Amish. I can’t see anything in my personal or
professional life that uses the methods of the ancients. I am certainly glad it 
is not used in the brewing of beer.

Cupping is like acupuncture in that at different times and places variations on 
the technique have evolved. There are a many forms of forms of cupping: dry,
fire, retained, moving, flash, needles, medicinal and wet among others. In wet
cupping they make a small incision in the area of suction to make sure that
blood is drawn out to:

   remove harmful substances and toxins from the body to promote healing.

That is like cleaning a swimming pool by taking out a cup of water.

Like acupuncture, there is no process for which it cannot be used. Except birth 
control. As best as can be determined, prevention of conception is not the
strong suit of TCM. But it has been suggested that there are 1,001 diseases for 
which cupping can be of benefit (although they mention only 120).

   Our results suggest that CT is currently prescribed for up to 120 diseases
   and disorders that are difficult to treat, including cutaneous (21.7%),
   musculoskeletal (15%), and central nervous system (13.3%) disorders.

There is no reason cupping should have any effect on any disease beyond the
usual placebo effect and it would be difficult to do placebo controlled trials
given the large hickeys induced by the procedure, although someone has devised a
form of sham cupping. Given the dramatic changes to the skin from cupping, I
would expect the technique to be a particularly powerful set of beer goggles.
The more impressive the placebo, the more it will alter perception. And, like a 
good set of beer goggles:

   majority of studies show potential benefit on pain conditions…that there is
   insufficient high-quality evidence to support the use of cupping therapy on
   relevant diseases….Existing trials are of small size and low methodological
   quality. Further high quality studies of larger sample size are needed to
   assess the effectiveness of cupping therapy.

More studies needed. They always say that, no matter how ridiculous the
intervention. I would beg to differ. There is no reason to waste time and money 
on interventions with no reason to work. I would also expect, since cupping has 
no reality-based reason for efficacy, that it would have no significant effect
on a process with a hard endpoint like hypertension. And it doesn’t.

Like most pseudo-medicine, cupping only shows efficacy in poorly-controlled
trials and usually only for subjective endpoints.

   Despite the large number of studies on cupping therapy, including the 62 new 
   ones, there remains a lack of well-designed investigations [Shocking – Ed.]. 
   Of the 135 RCTs included in this review, 84.44% were high risk of bias [What 
   ! Ed.] . One issue is adherence to the Consolidated Standards of Reporting
   Trials (CONSORT) in which randomization methods should be clearly described
   and fully reported. Another issue is blinding, which continues to be a
   challenge for studies involving manual healing therapies, such as
   acupuncture, massage, and cupping therapy.

Reality also remains a challenge, but that is almost never considered in the
discussion:

   our study is based on a process that has no basis in anatomy and physiology
   and as such any likely efficacy can be accounted for by bias and poor study
   design. More research needs to be done.

I love the purported mechanism:

   The mechanism of cupping therapy is not clear, but some researchers suggest
   that placement of cups on selected acupoints on the skin produces hyperemia
   or hemostasis, which results in a therapeutic effect.

Exactly how skin hypermia or hemostasis would have any effect beyond the local
hickey is never explained, except in the context of mystical fiction:

   Like acupuncture, cupping follows the lines of the meridians. There are five 
   meridian lines on the back, and these are where the cups are usually placed. 
   Using these points, cupping can help to align and relax qi, as well as target
   more specific maladies. By targeting the meridian channels, cupping strives 
   to ‘open’ these channels – the paths through which life energy flows freely
   throughout the body, through all tissues and organs, thus providing a
   smoother and more free-flowing qi (life force).

When you look at the ginormous welts (not for the squeamish) on cupping patients
you have to wonder just how select these points are. They must activate half a 
dozen acupoints with each cupping. Shouldn’t it set off a qi storm with so many 
acupoints being activated at once? Oh, wait, I’m sorry. For a moment I was
considering the process as if it actually corresponded with reality.

I can see how cupping would be popular since it leaves a tell-tale mark that
lets those around you know that you are one of the cognoscenti without the
permanence of a tattoo. No one knows if you are getting acupuncture or reiki,
but the hickey on the back is an instant attention-getter, the perfect
pseudo-medical ‘look at me’ sign that advertises your subtle understanding of
ancient Chinese wisdom. Seems perfect for Hollywood.

Or it might suggest you would be interested in helping move some money from
Nigeria to the US to help out a poor widow whose husband left her a fortune.

And if you have been cupped perhaps there is a way to remove the embarrassing
bruise.

Two notes.

April 12/13 I will be in Manchester at QED  ostensibly to give a talk and
participate in panel discussion. I am really there to see if there are any
English beers better than those here in Beervana. I doubt it.

I have had issues with the Quackcast and iTunes RSS feeds. I think it is fixed. 
If you have been a listener but wonder where the podcast has gone, delete the
feed and resubscribe.


*My wife was ill first and I suspect I got it from her. Get your mind out of the
gutter.

Cupping – Olympic Pseudoscience

Steven Novella on August 10, 2016

Four years ago, while watching the 2012 Olympic Games, I noticed a lot of
athletes wearing colored strips in various patterns on their body. I discovered 
that these strips were called kinesiotape, and they were used to enhance
performance, reduce injury, and help muscles recover more quickly. I also
discovered that these claims for kinesiotape were complete nonsense.

This year at the 2016 Rio Olympics, I (and many other people, judging by my
e-mails) noticed that many athletes, especially the swimmers, had what appeared 
to be circular bruises on their backs, shoulders, and sometimes elsewhere on
their body. I immediately recognized the telltale signs of cupping, a
pseudoscientific treatment that is part of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM).

Pseudoscience in sports

What both kinesiotape and cupping have in common, other than a lack of evidence 
that they work, is that they are immediately visible to the casual observer
(another example would be the hologram bracelets that were once common). This
led me to suspect that they represent only the tip of the nonsense iceberg at
the Olympics. What other worthless treatments are athletes using that don’t
leave visible marks on their skin?

Competitive sports are a fertile playground for pseudoscience. Athletes look for
anything that will give them the tiniest edge. Even the false belief that one
has an edge may lead to a slight benefit from placebo effects. Coaches likely
don’t care if a benefit is entirely psychological, all they care about is
performance and victory.

This same psychology has also led to superstitions being rampant in sports. I
don’t think anyone would propose a serious mechanism by which licking a bat
leads to more home runs, but that is not much different from proposing
mechanisms for how blatant medical pseudoscience might work.

The vulnerability of athletes to superstitions and placebo effects has resulted 
in an industry of sports snake oil. The industry targets professional or elite
athletes, and then uses them as an endorsement for their products so that the
average weekend athlete will buy their product.

This is what is most troubling about Michael Phelps walking around the Olympic
pool with circular bruises all over his back. He is a walking advertisement for 
pseudoscience.

Cupping

Like many “ancient” alternative treatments, cupping began its life as a
completely superstition-based therapy, part of a pre-scientific culture without 
the slightest clue about the physiological mechanisms of health and disease.

Cupping is a form of bloodletting. Today this is called “wet cupping” to
distinguish it from “dry cupping” which does not cause bleeding. The treatment
involves placing a glass cup against the skin and then creating a partial vacuum
in the cup in order to suck blood to the skin. Traditionally this was achieved 
by burning incense on top of the cup to heat the air inside.

In wet cupping the practitioner would then lance the skin and let the blood
flow. The purpose of this was to remove “stagnant blood, expel heat, treat high 
fever, loss of consciousness, convulsion, and pain.” Well, that is what some TCM
practitioners say today. Back in the day the purpose was to purge “chi”, a word
that means blood, or the energy within blood. Cupping was nothing but Chinese
bloodletting.

Cupping as a form of bloodletting is still performed today, as wet cupping. In
Arabic it is called hijama.

As with many forms of ancient treatments, modern practitioners use the same or
similar techniques but simply alter the claims they make for it to sound more
acceptable to modern ears.

One manifestation of this is the specific claims for what the treatment treats. 
The target ailments tend to gravitate toward common subjective symptoms. Low
back pain, muscle pain, joint pain, fatigue, and headaches are all common
targets. This is a clear sign that the claims made for these treatments are
being driven by market forces, not plausibility, evidence, research, or science.

Another manifestation is the alleged mechanisms cited to justify the treatment. 
These tend to follow the popular narratives of the day, and again are driven by 
market forces, not science. Centuries ago cupping would release chi. Today it is
used to expel unnamed toxins, increase blood flow, or activate the immune
system.

There is no compelling reason to believe that cupping does any of these things. 
These are just the available hand-waving justifications.

Cupping research

We currently live in a world where no medical claim is so absurd that someone
will not think it deserves serious research. So yes, there is actual medical
research into cupping. I always have mixed feelings about this. Such research is
clearly a waste of resources, and is also probably unethical. It also does not 
affect the practice of proponents. It is nice to have actual research to analyze
and point to, but overall it is probably not worth it.

The published studies on cupping are exactly what you would expect them to be
(at least if you are a regular reader of SBM or have any familiarity with
medical pseudoscience).

Let me start with what I believe to be the definitive review: a review of
systematic reviews by Edzard Ernst, which concludes:

   In conclusion, this overview of SRs suggests that cupping may be effective
   for reducing pain. The evidence is insufficient for other indications. All
   SRs are based on primary studies with a high risk of bias. Therefore,
   considerable uncertainty remains about the therapeutic value of cupping.

His review, and my reading of the published research, are very consistent with
the typical pattern of biased research into a treatment that does not work. We
see lots of small and poor quality studies, the kinds that are almost guaranteed
to generate false positive results.

The higher quality studies tend to be negative. There may be a residue of
positive studies dealing with subjective symptoms, because those are the hardest
to control for rigorously. We never see an objective positive outcome.

Further, positive results tend to cluster within highly biased research groups. 
Ernst points out that most of the positive studies and reviews on cupping come
from China. There is good reason to suspect overwhelming bias in such studies,
and previous reviews have shown, for example, that 100% of acupuncture studies
published in China were positive. Such uniformly positive results are
statistically impossible without systematic bias.

Other systematic reviews, including those by favorable researchers published in 
pro-CAM journals, are similarly unconvincing. For example, a 2013 review of
cupping for low back pain included only one randomized controlled trial, which
showed:

   In the RCT, the effective rate of the wet-cupping group was similar to that
   of the waiting-list group (p>0.05).

So they included non RCTs, case reports, and editorials, because:

   Although RCTs provide a higher quality of evidence, we included non-RCTs in
   this study because the limited number of RCTs did not provide convincing
   evidence.

The bottom line of all of this is that research into cupping is mostly negative 
or of poor quality and with high bias. There is no good compelling evidence for 
any real physiological effect from cupping.

Apologists might argue that at least the therapy is benign, but not so fast.
There is a tendency to assume that a treatment is benign just because no one has
bothered to document potential risks.

For example, there is a case report of cupping clearly causing the spread of
psoriasis in one patient – the psoriatic lesions occurred in a strange circular 
pattern, getting the attention of the dermatologists treating the patient.

More common side effects include bruising, burns, and skin infection. Aggressive
wet cupping can also lead to anemia.

Granted, side effects are likely to be minor, but without any proven or
plausible benefit any side effects are not worth it, including the discomfort,
expense, and negative cosmetic effects.

Conclusion: Cupping is pseudoscience

Cupping is no different than acupuncture, bloodletting, phrenology, or any other
medical pseudoscience. The treatment is based in pre-scientific superstitions, 
and has simply been rebranded to more effectively market the treatment to modern
customers.

It is now just another alternative treatment, lacking plausibility, lacking any 
compelling evidence for efficacy, and promoted for the usual array of subjective
symptoms with the usual array of handwaving justifications.

It is unfortunate that elite athletics, including the Olympics, is such a hot
bed for pseudoscience. The Olympic Games are supposed to celebrate excellence,
hard work, dedication, and friendly competition. Now it also represents
gullibility and superstition, and spreads that gullibility to the viewing world.


Note: Orac has covered cupping at the Olympics as well (twice)

Facial Cupping: A Kinder, Gentler, Sillier Kind of Cupping

A new cupping fad using silicone devices is gentler than traditional cupping,
but even sillier. There is no evidence of health benefits.

Harriet Hall on October 31, 2017

Link


I keep thinking, “Now I’ve seen everything,” and I am constantly being proven
wrong. I recently came across the new fad of facial cupping. After I stopped
laughing, I went on to an amazed appreciation of the extent of human creativity 
and entrepreneurship.

Cupping is a traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) treatment often applied over
acupuncture points. Traditionally, the air in a glass bulb is heated, and when
it is applied to the skin and the air cools, it creates a vacuum, sucking up a
blob of skin. It leaves unsightly bruises (remember the pictures of Michael
Phelps at the Olympics and of actress Gwyneth Paltrow?) Sometimes the skin is
incised, and blood is drawn up into the bulb. The new fad of facial cupping is
kinder and gentler. Less suction is involved, and no visible marks are left on
the skin.

You can see facial cupping in action on videos like this one. The cups are made 
of silicone and are of various sizes; the smallest ones are used around the
eyes. You squeeze gently before you apply it to the skin, and when you release
the squeeze, it creates a vacuum that sucks a bit of skin up into the device.
You can treat a single spot or sweep the device across an area without breaking 
the suction. It doesn’t leave scars, but it can produce a transient redness. In 
the video, the patient is being treated at a spa, but cupping kits are being
marketed for people to use on themselves at home.

One product description says:

   What is Cupping? Cupping therapy is a form of alternative medicine in which
   cups are placed on the skin to create suction in order to increase blood
   flow, reduce inflammation and activate lymphatic drainage. Cupping therapy
   dates back to ancient Egypt, Asia and Middle East. Cupping brings fresh blood
   to the area, improves circulation and is widely used to treat pain,
   digestive problems, release toxins, improve appearance of cellulite and much 
   more! When can I expect to see results? Impress me! In many cases, results
   are visible after only a few cupping treatments, though you will start
   feeling and looking better instantly! With regular use, you will experience
   muscle tension relaxation, rejuvenation, increased energy, firmness and a
   more toned, healthier physique. Reduced stress, improved circulation and pain
   relief are just some of the many benefits you can see and feel. Remember,
   results are cumulative. To be effective, use regularly until optimal results 
   are reached, follow a healthy diet, exercise and drink plenty of water!

Even if all that were true (which it probably isn’t), it might only apply to the
original kind of cupping, the kind with strong enough suction to leave large
welts on the skin

For advocates of “natural” treatments, I don’t see anything “natural” about
cupping. But there is a “natural” alternative: hickeys or love bites. Is anyone 
advocating those?

So, some genius had the brainstorm that if you reduced the suction to where no
visible lesions were produced, cupping would be more acceptable and you could
make a lot of money selling weak suction devices. I wonder if this should be
called “pseudo-cupping”? It’s homeopathic thinking, analogous to what Hahnemann 
did. He came to believe that all effective drugs produce symptoms in healthy
individuals similar to those of the diseases that they treat, then he kept
diluting his remedies until they no longer produced those symptoms (nor did they
do anything else!).

Another website sells both the old and new types of cup. It claims therapeutic
benefits of gentle facial cupping for patients with sinus infections, headaches,
facial paralysis, earaches, and temporomandibular joint pain (TMJ). It claims
to help patients suffering from these conditions “without the need for more
extensive treatments.” It is illegal for them to make such disease-specific
claims, and could be dangerous if patients are discouraged from effective
treatments for these conditions.

On another page, they list the top 7 benefits of cupping:

  1. Relief from pain

  2. Promote relaxation

  3. Promote healing from injuries

  4. Clear, flawless skin

  5. Better digestion

  6. Relief from respiratory issues

  7. Detoxification

And a sidebar claims benefits for tonsillitis, angina pectoris, osteoarthritis, 
gout, endometriosis, infertility, urinary incontinence, high blood pressure,
heartburn, neuralgia, and diabetes!

But wait! There’s more! Anemia, hemophilia, wrinkles, mental problems, varicose 
veins, weight loss, diarrhea, conjunctivitis, frozen shoulder, fever, herpes,
cervical spondylosis, and “scaring” (a typo, but cupping does scare me.) And
“anti-aging” claims are common.

Amazon sells them. One customer reports using them to pop pimples. One said she 
is hoping to reduce cellulite. One reports a large decrease in dimpling in her
legs. One said “Painful, but seems to be helping [helping for what?]” One said, 
“Hard to use.” One said, “Not sure if it works but it doesn’t provide good
suction and feels like a deep massage.” One said, “Didn’t work.”

I got a kick out of two 2-star customer reviews. The first said she used the
cups about six times and they no longer suction. The second asked, “What to do
when an item sucks because it doesn’t suck?”

Evidence?

Is there evidence for any kind of cupping? According to the American Cancer
Society, “There is no scientific evidence that cupping leads to any health
benefits….No research or clinical studies have been done on cupping. Any reports
of successful treatment with cupping are anecdotal. There is no scientific
evidence that cupping can cure cancer or any other disease.”

Edzard Ernst employed cupping himself 40 years ago before he started looking for
scientific evidence. He says cupping has a significant placebo effect, and the 
most plausible mode of action is counter-irritation (analogous to hitting your
thumb with a hammer to distract you from the pain of a headache). He mentions
recent research but characterizes it as “flimsy” at best. It is impossible to do
blinded studies, and most of the positive studies are out of China, where
negative studies are never published.

The bottom line: there is no credible evidence for the original form of cupping,
and there is even less evidence for the newer, kinder, gentler version.

Suggestion?

An article in Vogue, “Cupping Works Even Better on Your Face,” inadvertently
provides insight into the psychological mechanisms behind customer satisfaction 
and glowing testimonials:

   My skin was tighter, pinker, plumper; my jawline lifted. The irksome fine
   lines on my forehead had taken leave, and my eyebrows even appeared slightly 
   higher. I’d been skeptical, but it was as if I’d just awakened from a
   five-year nap [I can’t help wondering how she knows this. How many five-year 
   naps has she had?] “Look at those cheekbones,” Goldstein said admiringly.

   Having barely sacrificed any extra time (her sessions, with their added
   skin-treatment component, run 30 minutes), I returned triumphantly to the
   office, where a colleague complimented me on my unusually rested appearance. 
   Later that night, I told my boyfriend what had happened. He narrowed his
   eyes. “You know, maybe your face does look a bit thinner and more angular,”
   he surmised. Two days later, apropos of nothing, he revised his opinion. “I
   don’t know why,” he said, “but you look more beautiful this week than you
   ever have.

Suggestion is very powerful. Especially without controlled observations.

Conclusion: It sucks

Facial cupping sucks. In more than one sense.

As I see it, it offers two benefits: a mostly harmless sort of masturbatory
pastime for self-absorbed and self-indulgent users, and a source of amusement
for skeptics.

Moxibustion

Moxibustion is the burning of mugwort close to, or sometimes into, the skin.
Does it work? No. Why do people use it? Because it’s old.

Mark Crislip on April 18, 2014

Link



There are many forms of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), and many have the
same underlying theory: they stimulate non-existent acupuncture points to alter 
the flow of non-existent qi. For each form of TCM there are many variations on a
theme. There are, for example, a half-dozen styles of acupuncture and multiple 
forms of cupping all trying to move the qi. That qi is an untameable beast, hard
to corral into a proper gate even by the best acupoint wrangler.

There is, fortunately, yet another way, moxibustion, to alter that most
intractable mysterious life energy.

Moxibustion is the burning of mugwort over acupoints.

What is mugwort? I resist the urge to make a Harry Potter pun about where
Muggles go to school. No wait, I just did. Sorry. You know the old saying: yield
to temptation, it may not pass you way again. Mugwort is a member of the daisy 
family, related to ragweed and, like ragweed, a common cause of hay fever. It is
also used in food and was used in beer before hops was discovered.

Why mugwort for moxibustion? I can’t find a good reason beyond the argument from
antiquity. That is what they have done for thousands of years, so it must be
good.

How is moxibustion done? There are multiple styles. There is both direct and
indirect moxibustion.

In direct moxibustion, a small, cone-shaped amount of mugwort is put on an
acupuncture point and burned.

This direct moxibustion is further divided into scarring and non-scarring. With 
scarring moxibustion, the moxa is placed on an acupuncture point and burns until
it causes blisters and scarring, what we in medicine would call a
deep-partial-thickness second degree burn.

With non-scarring moxibustion, the burning moxa is removed before it burns the
skin. How nice.

Indirect moxibustion is a more popular form of since there is a lower risk of
pain or burning. There’s a surprise. People want to avoid second degree burns.
With indirect moxibustion, a moxa cigar is held over the skin until the area
turns red.

Yet another form of indirect moxibustion uses both acupuncture needles and moxa.
A needle is inserted into an acupoint then the needle is wrapped in moxa and
lit. The needle heats up and so does the skin.

So many ways to try and alter qi. How a second degree burn could be helpful for 
any process, much less mythical qi, mystifies me.

What is moxibustion used for? Anything and everything. Except, I suppose, as a
burn therapy. That would be throwing gas on the fire as it were. Moxibustion is 
often used in conjunction with other qi-wrangling interventions such as cupping 
and acupuncture.

It has been used without success for hypertension, pain, tennis elbow, and
irritable bowel syndrome, all diseases with a similar underlying cause. I
suppose when all you have is a mugwort, everything is a moxibustion. No surprise
the studies with positive results are poorly done, are prone to bias, and are
often from Asia where no TCM study is ever negative. As one systematic review of
moxibustion systematic reviews noted:

   In conclusion, this overview of SRs suggests that moxibustion is effective
   for correcting breech presentation, whereas for other conditions, the
   evidence does not reach a firm conclusion because of several limitations. All
   SRs are, however, based on studies with a high risk of bias. Therefore,
   considerable uncertainty remains about the therapeutic value of moxibustion.

They all suggest that higher quality studies need to be done to determine if
moxibustion is actually effective. I would tend to think not. Negative studies
never, ever, dissuade proponents. Given the prior plausibility that burning
mugwort on or near the skin would have any effect on any disease is somewhere on
the order of naught, I would not waste the money. But that is a defining
characteristic of SCAM, its proponents develop resistance to disconfirming facts
faster than gonorrhea to antibiotics.

The big claim to fame of moxibustion is reversal of breech positioning in the
JAMA article “Moxibustion for Correction of Breech Presentation”.

   Since ancient times, traditional Chinese medicine has proposed moxibustion of
   acupoint BL 67 (Zhiyin) to promote version of fetuses in breech
   presentation. Moxibustion is a traditional Chinese method that uses the heat 
   generated by burning herbal preparations containing Artemisia vulgaris
   (mugwort) (the Japanese name is moxa) to stimulate acupuncture points.
   Acupoint BL 67 is beside the outer corner of the fifth toenail.

They did a non-blinded, small, non-placebo trial in China and it appeared to be 
effective.

To me it would be nuts to think burning mugwort at the 5th toenail would do
anything to cause a baby to shift position in the uterus and I would be inclined
to think positive results would be likely to noise and not be reproducible. It 
wasn’t.

They repeated the study in Italy and, what a surprise, moxibustion did nothing
to breech positioning.

A Cochrane Review concluded:

   Moxibustion was not found to reduce the number of non-cephalic presentations 
   at birth compared with no treatment (P = 0.45)

Does moxibustion have complications? Yes. Burns are the most frequently-reported
complication. Given that some forms of the technique try to cause second-degree
burns, I suppose that burns are not technically a bug but a feature. But there 
has been a review of the issue and they found:

   The most common effects identified in this review were allergic reactions,
   burns, and infections such as cellulitis and hepatitis C. Allergic reactions 
   were reported in six case reports (four case reports related to infections
   and two related to burns). The other articles were case reports of
   xerophthalmia, xeroderma, hyperpigmented macules, ptosis and eversion of the 
   eyelids. In clinical trials, various adverse events such as rubefaction,
   blistering, itching sensations, discomfort due to smoke, general fatigue,
   stomach upsets, flare-ups, headaches, and burns were reported. Tenderness and
   pressure in the epigastric region or in one of the hypochondriac regions,
   unpleasant odor with or without nausea and throat problems, abdominal pain,
   premature birth, premature rupture of the membrane and bleeding due to excess
   pressure on the anterior placenta were reported in pregnant women.

Summary: Moxibustion is yet another TCM modality with no utility for the
treatment of any illness and has known complications from its use. Given the
ludicrousness of its underlying mechanism I can see no reason to waste money on 
further clinical trials.

Follow-up:

1) The results are in. I prefer the beer in Portland to the beer in the UK for a
variety of reasons, but UK beers are a bit flat and creamy compared to Pacific 
NW beer. And they do not know their hops. I was warned that a beer was hoppy.
After a sip I wanted to do my best Crocodile Dundee imitation. ‘That’s not a
hoppy beer.’ Pull out an Arrogant Bastard. ‘That’s a hoppy beer.’

2) QED was a fantastic conference. Great people, great lectures, great location.

The Red Marks of Pseudo-Medicine: Gua Sha

Claiming that an inflammatory response to injury is inherently therapeutic is a 
massive leap of faith.

William Mitchell on February 16, 2026

Link


[Note: After the death in the family last weekend, Dr. Gorski has decided to
take one more week off from posting at SBM. He now plans to return to regular
posting next week.]

In my clinical life as a pediatric hematologist specializing in bleeding and
clotting disorders, I am essentially a “Bruise Detective.” My clinic is a
constant parade of children with unexplained purple spots, mysterious bruises,
and nosebleeds that won’t quit. My job is to determine if a child’s bruising is 
a benign badge of playground courage or the first sign of a serious bleeding
disorder. I spend my days obsessing over the structural integrity of capillaries
and the delicate balance of clotting factors.

Source: Wikipedia

So, you can imagine my reaction to images like the one above. The skin is
covered in confluent bruising (where individual bruises merge into one solid
purple mass) and linear petechiae (tiny, pinhead-sized red dots appearing in
long, angry streaks as if the patient had been attacked by a very small, very
rhythmic tiger).

To the untrained eye, it looks like a high-velocity friction burn (or even
strangulation when it occurs on the neck). The culprit, however, isn’t a
traumatic accident; it is a “wellness” treatment gaining popularity at your
local med spa. Gua Sha.

To a hematologist, seeing a patient pay a premium to have their capillaries
intentionally shattered under the guise of “healing” is a bit like a firefighter
watching someone pay an “arson consultant” to “detoxify” their living room with
a blowtorch.

What is Gua Sha?

Gua (scraping) Sha (sand/redness) is a Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM)
practice that involves using a smooth-edged tool—traditionally jade, bone, or
even a ceramic soup spoon—to apply pressurized strokes to lubricated skin. The
goal is to produce sha: the bright red or purple spots that the medical
community recognizes as localized trauma, but which TCM calls the release of
“blood stasis” and “toxins.”

Gua Sha Scraping Tool

The tools have become more Instagram-friendly lately—often pink quartz carved
into hearts—but the underlying premise remains rooted in pre-scientific
vitalism. This relies heavily on the Argument from Antiquity—the logical fallacy
that because a practice is old, it must be effective.

Examining the “Evidence”: The Fascia and Microcirculation

Proponents of Gua Sha often point to physiological “markers” to justify the
practice. However, when viewed through the lens of SBM, these markers are more
illustrative of “theatrical” physiology than clinical efficacy.

One popular theory is the “Squeeze Film” Lubrication Model proposed by Stecco et
al. (2013), which suggests that mechanical pressure increases the flow of
hyaluronic acid between fascial layers. Hyaluronic acid acts as a lubricant for 
these tissues. They make no mention, however, that aggressive scraping is
superior to simple massage. More recently, a study by Wang et al. (2025) claimed
that just 15 minutes of Gua Sha could “thin” the thoracolumbar fascia and
thereby “reduce stiffness, improve mobility, and alleviate low back pain by
releasing adhesions and restoring tissue glide”.

However, these studies supporting Gua Sha suffer from several critical flaws:

  1. The Anisotropy Artifact: Fascia is highly organized and collagen-rich. Its
    appearance on ultrasound changes drastically based on the angle of the
    probe. Research in PLOS One shows that a tilt of just 5 degrees can
    significantly alter thickness measurements. A “thinning” of 0.06 mm is well 
    within the margin of error for probe angulation—it is more likely a
    measurement error than a biological breakthrough.

  2. The Microcirculation Gap: A frequently cited study in the Journal of Internal 
    Medicine showed a fourfold increase in microcirculation at the treated site.
    But any localized trauma triggers vasodilation. The crucial questions
    remain: Microcirculation of what specific substances? In what
    concentrations? To what end? Claiming that an inflammatory response to
    injury is inherently therapeutic is a massive leap of faith.

A Watchman or a Driver of Illness?

In recent literature, such as Slater et al. (2024), researchers have proposed
that the fascial system may act as a “watchman”—a highly innervated sensory
organ that receives and processes information on whole-body health and
inflammation.

This is an intriguing biological hypothesis, but it is being over-interpreted by
practitioners and proponents of Gua Sha. Even if we concede that fascia acts as
a “watchman” or a marker of systemic dysregulation, it does not necessarily
follow that intervening on the fascia will modify the underlying disease in any 
meaningful way.

In medical science, a marker is not always a lever. If the “watchman” is
screaming because there is a systemic inflammatory fire, “scraping” the watchman
until he bruises does nothing to put out the fire. It is a confusion of cause
and effect. We currently lack high-quality, blinded interventional studies
proving that “fascial health” is a modifiable variable that improves objective
disease outcomes. Without that evidence, recommending or performing Gua Sha
based on fascial theory is like painting over a “Check Engine” light: the
dashboard looks different, but the engine is still knocking.

When “Sha” Is Dangerous

While the “wellness” industry often assumes its customers are the “worried
well,” my clinic is proof that unrecognized bleeding disorders are hiding in
plain sight.

Von Willebrand Disease (VWD), an inheritable bleeding disorder, affects up to 1%
of the population. Many people reach adulthood without a diagnosis, only
realizing they have a problem after a surgical procedure (or, perhaps a
particularly aggressive spa day).

Then there is Hereditary Hemorrhagic Telangiectasia (HHT). HHT is a genetic
disorder where the normal “buffer” of capillaries between arteries and veins is 
missing, leading to fragile, direct connections (arteriovenous malformations)
that are prone to rupture. It is estimated to affect 1 in 5,000 people, yet
roughly 80% of those with HHT remain undiagnosed. These patients are essentially
walking around with “vascular short-circuits” that are extremely vulnerable to 
mechanical trauma.

For these patients, the “vigorous scraping” of Gua Sha isn’t just a quirky
wellness trend; it’s a recipe for massive hematomas or even skin necrosis. There
is profound irony in a patient with a bleeding disorder seeking a “detoxifying”
treatment that intentionally induces the very vascular trauma their body is
genetically ill-equipped to handle.

Comparison to Cupping

Gua Sha is the “friction” cousin to cupping’s “suction”. Both share the same
central fallacy: that inducing localized ecchymosis (bruising) is therapeutic.
Both rely on the visual “theatrics” of the bruise to convince the patient that
something “potent” has happened. In both cases, the “toxins” supposedly being
released remain unidentified by any biochemical analysis. They are metaphorical 
toxins—a linguistic sleight of hand used to sell a physical injury.

Conclusion

As skeptics, we must challenge the idea that “ancient” equates to “effective.”
Gua Sha celebrates tissue trauma as a sign of healing. While the nature of touch
and the placebo effect may provide temporary symptomatic relief, we must be
clear about the physiology: we are looking at ruptured capillaries and localized
inflammation.

Before a patient visits a med spa for a “scraping” session, they should ask
themselves why they are paying to undergo a treatment that, in any other
context, would be classified as physical assault. As for me, I think I’ll keep
my jade for jewelry and encourage my patients to keep their capillaries intact.

WHO Promotes Unscientific TCM

The World Health Organization endorses quackery in the form of TCM.

Steven Novella on June 5, 2019

Link



The World Health Organization (WHO) was founded in 1948 as part of the UN. Among
its principles set forth in its constitution is: “The enjoyment of the highest 
attainable standard of health is one of the fundamental rights of every human
being without distinction of race, religion, political belief, economic or
social condition.” The WHO also recognizes that, “Evidence-based medicine vital 
for health and medical progress”.

So it is extremely disappointing that the WHO, in its latest International
Classification of Diseases (ICD-11), has chosen to include a chapter on
Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) diagnoses. David Gorski wrote about this
several months ago, and since then there has been increased backlash against the
WHO. Of note, there is an editorial in Nature critical of the decision. While
the editorial is good, it does not go far enough, in my opinion.

The ICD codes are, as the name implies, an international standard for medical
diagnoses. They are used in the US for billing and epidemiological records; all 
doctors are familiar with them and many, like David, are not fans. The codes are
obsessively at the “splitter” end of the spectrum, and can make an otherwise
simple task rather challenging and frustrating. But at least they are based in
reality.

With the coming ICD-11, and the chapter on TCM, this is no longer strictly true.
There is no way to honestly view the TCM chapter as anything other than a
full-throated endorsement of pseudoscience in medicine. It describes the TCM
entries as including:

   Symptomatology: signs, symptoms or unique findings by traditional medicine
   diagnostic methods, including inspection such as tongue examination, history 
   taking (inquiry), listening and smelling examination, palpation such as pulse
   taking, abdominal examination, and other methods.

The specific TCM methods are nothing but superstitious quackery. Tongue
examination, smelling, and pulse diagnosis are not valid methods of medical
examination, and do not relate to any actual disease or illness. They are the
equivalent of the medieval European practice of carefully examining the color of
urine in order to make diagnoses. They are as scientific as iridology or
phrenology.

The WHO defends itself by saying that these codes are optional, and that they
don’t specifically endorse any individual TCM treatment. But I think that they
implicitly do, if not explicitly. In fact, listing response to treatment as part
of the TCM diagnostic code is optional, but may be included. If you endorse a
fake diagnosis that only has fake treatments, then you are endorsing the fake
treatments by extension. There are no evidence-based treatments for the
imaginary TCM diagnostic codes – so what do they think is the result of
legitimizing the diagnoses?

To give an example of how this will be used, Acupuncture Today gave the
following case:

   TCM pulse: string-like.*

   TCM tongue: dusky, thin white coat.*

   If my patient is seeking an acupuncture treatment, in my notes I will write
   down a TCM diagnosis that I may select based on Channel Pattern
   Identification/Syndrome Differentiation. Migraine due to obstruction of
   lesser yang meridian.* If my patient is seeking an herbal treatment, in my
   notes I will write down a TCM diagnosis that I may select based on Visceral
   Pattern Identification/Syndrome Differentiation. Migraine due to ascendant
   hyperactivity of liver yang.*

There is simply no way to codify the “ascendant hyperactivity of liver yang”
without endorsing the underlying pseudoscience. This patient has typical
migraine – trying to understand it as a disorder of the yang meridian by
examining the tongue is not science-based, and is completely disconnected from
reality. But most importantly, the point of all this is to determine which
unscientific treatment to give, such as which pattern of acupuncture to inflict 
on the patient. It is directly tied to treatment, and the WHO cannot pretend
otherwise.

The same acupuncture article gives as a further justification for the ICD-11 (a 
common talking point for defenders) that it is necessary to capture morbidity
and mortality data in countries that use TCM. However, these codes are optional,
and the WHO specifically states cannot be used to capture such data. They must 
be coded in addition to a standard medical diagnosis. So this justification is
nonsense – unless, of course, there are plans in ICD-12 to make the TCM
diagnoses not optional.

The WHO’s downplaying of the implications of their coding system is also
contradicted by the very people who are happy about it’s inclusion. As the
Nature editors state:

   TCM practitioners around the world have celebrated its incorporation into the
   document as crucial for the international spread of the system. So has
   China. On 26 May, a government newspaper called it a “major step for TCM’s
   internationalization” and a tremendous help in establishing TCM centres
   around the world.

Of course they are celebrating. I can also tell you, as someone on the front
lines of trying to promote science-based medicine and oppose the infiltration of
quackery into medicine, the fact that the WHO legitimizes TCM in this way is
often used as a debating point to defend pseudoscience. It is also a frequent
point of confusion for those who are just trying to understand what is going on.
If TCM is not based on science, why does the WHO endorse it? There must be
something to it, they reason.

Here is where I quibble with the Nature editorial:

   Traditional medicine should certainly not be dismissed: sometimes it is all
   that’s available in many parts of the world. Some life-saving therapies have 
   come from natural products, and there are doubtless more to be found.
   Famously, the gold-standard malaria drug, artemisinin, was discovered in
   China — isolated from sweet wormwood (Artemisia annua), a herb used in TCM.
   It is also important to distinguish practices that do harm from those that
   might not work but are relatively benign, and those that might work but have 
   not been tested rigorously.

This is an example of buying into the framing or propaganda of pseudoscience.
The fact that effective drugs have been developed from plant-based or other
natural sources is not contested – but it also is not in any way an endorsement 
of alternative medicine. It does not mean that any TCM diagnosis or treatment is
legitimate. The fact that we purified opiates from poppy, or digitalis from
foxglove, does not mean that the unscientific use of unpurified herbs to treat
imaginary illnesses is in any way valid – let alone all the other treatment that
don’t even use herbal drugs, but use magical treatments like yang meridians.

I also object to characterizing any pseudoscientific treatment as “benign”.
Sure, treatments that cause direct harm are worse than those that do nothing,
like homeopathy, for example. But an unscientific treatment that does not cause 
direct harm is not benign. There are many ways to cause harm other than direct
physical harm, including distracting from and delaying effective treatments,
fostering distrust in scientific and medical institutions, wasting resources,
instilling false hope, and promoting pseudoscientific belief systems. None of
these things should ever be confused with being “benign”.

You also have to be careful when referring to treatments that “might work but
have not been tested rigorously”. These treatments may also not work, and may
cause harm. If they haven’t been tested rigorously, we don’t know. But also, we 
can make predictions based on prior probability. I have not rigorously tested
the practice of eating spiders in order to treat migraine headaches, and the
practice may not cause direct harm, but that does not mean we just don’t know if
it works and therefore it’s OK to promote the practice.

To its credit, the editorial also points out that TCM, in addition to promoting 
unscientific practices, is also a threat to many endangered species whose body
parts are values as TCM treatments. So the WHO is now complicit in the
threatening of species like the rhino and pangolin, whose parts comprise a
multi-billion dollar TCM industry that has exhausted supplies in Asia and is now
threatening species in Africa.

The WHO decision to include TCM in their ICD-11 codes is wrong, and should be
vigorously criticized and opposed. This is now an important battle line in the
struggle between science-based medicine and the promotion of rank quackery
presenting itself as just “traditional” and desperate for legitimacy.

“Eliminating cancer” with Traditional Chinese Medicine and other
state-sanctioned quackery

State-approved continuing education courses pump a steady stream of fresh
pseudoscience into acupuncture and Traditional Chinese Medicine practice.
Courses include claims of “eliminating cancer” and “reversing pediatric asthma” 
as well as anti-vaccination tropes.

Jann Bellamy on October 24, 2019

Link



Via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, state legislatures incorporate
pseudoscience into health care practitioner licensing laws, giving
chiropractors, naturopathic “doctors”, and acupuncturists free rein to impose
their particular paradigms of nonsense on patients. For acupuncturists, that
paradigm is control of the body’s putative “energy” (or, “qi”), which allegedly 
flows via “meridians”, to treat disease by sticking patients with needles at
specified (but elusive) “acupuncture points”. Having legalized this magical
system of human functioning, the legislatures include a cornucopia of quackery
in the practitioner’s toolkit via the authority, for example, to prescribe
dietary supplements, Chinese herbs, and homeopathic remedies and to perform gua 
sha, moxibustion, and cupping.

Acupuncturists are licensed or registered in 47 states and D.C. In some
jurisdictions they can also practice what is variously called Traditional
Chinese Medicine (TCM), Oriental Medicine, and East Asian Medicine. Their scope 
of practice can approach that of a medical doctor. While the methods allowed are
different (e.g., surgery vs. cupping), the scope – treating any patient of any 
age with any disease or condition – is similar.

New Mexico, for example, defines acupuncture as

   the surgical use of needles inserted into and removed from the body and the
   use of other devices, modalities and procedures at specific locations on the 
   body for the prevention, cure or correction of any disease, illness, injury, 
   pain or other condition by controlling and regulating the flow and balance of
   energy and function to restore and maintain health.

[Emphasis added.]

“Oriental medicine” is the use of

   all allied techniques of oriental medicine, both traditional and modern, to
   diagnose, treat and prescribe for the prevention, cure or correction of
   disease, illness, injury, pain or other physical or mental condition by
   controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy, form and function 
   to restore and maintain health.

[Emphasis added.]

“Doctors of Oriental Medicine” in New Mexico are allowed to call themselves
physicians and practice primary care.

Acupuncture regulatory boards add even more pseudoscience (and additional income
streams) to the mix via their rules and regulations. The Florida Board of
Acupuncture allows acupuncturists to use Kirlian photography as a diagnostic
method. The Arkansas Board of Acupuncture permits the use of bleeding.

But wait, there’s more! Perhaps underappreciated in its perniciousness, these
regulatory boards (operating under the fiction that they are protecting the
public’s health by requiring practitioners to remain up-to-date in their field) 
approve continuing education courses that pump a steady stream of fresh
pseudoscience into the system. Freed from the strictures of actual science,
courses can offer their own permutations of pseudoscience for practitioners to
foist on their patients. (Unfortunately, “integrative medicine” practitioners do
the same thing.) Today, we’ll take a look at some of these courses and see how,
once again, the states are serving as handmaidens to the quackery industry.

The National Certification Commission on Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine
(NCCAOM), a private agency organized and run by acupuncturists and TCM
practitioners, creates and administers exams required in 46 jurisdictions to
become licensed. It also approves courses accepted for continuing education
credit by many states. Some merely fleece the gullible; others are downright
dangerous. (Actual course names [with link] are followed by a brief description 
of the course.)

Stroke, cancer, and other serious conditions

10,000 needles: The Future of Stroke Rehab Using Nanopuncture: Teaches
post-stroke rehab for paralysis, a “highly effective system” that can “produce
drastic improvements” in post-stroke patients. Claims acupuncture is “highly
effective” for treating post-stroke sequelae.

The TCM Treatment of Post Stroke, Apoplexia & Paraplegia: “Covers the
classifications, diagnosis, and treatment plans via TCM; with the most commonly 
used acupuncture points and herbal formulas.”

Advanced Chinese Medical Oncology: Treating cancer patients with Traditional
Chinese Medicine, including learning to make early diagnosis and using “Shen
Xiang Wen Tong Therapy to recall the lost immunity and restore the homeostasis, 
eventually eliminating cancer.”

A Case Study Analysis: Lung Cancer Symptoms to Brain Tumor: A “renowned pulse
diagnostician . . . shares how to treat symptoms of lung cancer and a brain
tumor . . . what the pulse can reveal and what are the most appropriate herbal
formulas to treat the symptoms.” [Link added.]

Acupuncture Technique for Cancer Care: Teaches how to treat nose and throat
cancer with acupuncture point prescriptions for each of three types of
diagnosis: “A. Heat pathogen invades Lung, B. Liver depression with phlegm
congestion, and C. Blood stagnation interrupts the channels.”

Acupuncture for Parkinson’s Disease and Dementia: “Skillful acupuncture
approaches to the treatment of Alzheimer’s Disease and Parkinson’s Disease.”

Clinical Orthopedic Strategies: Arthritis and Bi Syndrome: “Designed to give the
practicing acupuncturist a working knowledge of various forms of arthritis,
including how to make a differential diagnosis using physical exam, laboratory
and x-ray.” [For an “explanation” of Bi Syndrome see here.]

A Complete Course of Treating Diabetes Mellitus by Acupuncturists – Part I: “An 
effective TCM way to treat diabetes mellitus – the ear magnet therapy is
introduced. . . Related health conditions such as ear magnet treat food craving,
weight lose [sic], insomnia, nausea, etc. are presented.”

Heart Disease Prevention and Treatment: Using Traditional Chinese medicine to
recognize, diagnose, and treat the conditions of chest pain, arrhythmias,
hyperlipidemia, hypertension, coronary artery disease, and heart failure.

Treating lupus and infections using Tung points and nutrition: Acupuncture point
prescriptions and TCM herbal remedies for treating lupus.

Dr. Tan’s Balance Method for Traumas and Sports Injuries: Learn “the five
systems of the Balance Method to uncover the magic healing power of acupuncture 
for all types of traumas and sports injuries.”

Modern and Classical Chinese Medicine Approach to Multiple Sclerosis: “Important
treatment protocols effective for MS using some body and scalp acupuncture,
moxibustion and herbal medicine.”

Cholesterol, Asthma, Depression, and More! Drugs and Their Herbal Alternatives: 
Discussed “Western medications for cholesterol, asthma, and depression, their
actions, side effects and herbal alternatives.”

Allergies, IBS, and Chronic Infection: Acupuncture, Hara, and Herbs – Part I:
Based on “extensive clinical research and time-tested protocols” learn “to
easily find effective distal points for internal conditions relating to the Lung
and Heart such as the common cold, allergies, nasal issues, palpitations,
anxiety, and insomnia.”

Treating HIV and AIDS with Western and Oriental Medicine: Learn to “identify the
western and TCM diagnosis for HIV and AIDS and its chief clinical
manifestations. Both western and TCM treatments for HIV and AIDS, common
side-effects associated with prescription drug treatments, and an herbal
alternative treatment.”

Cardiovascular & Respiratory Disorders: Pulse Dx & Herbal Tx: “Using Master
Chang’s unique system of pulse diagnosis techniques, derived from years of
clinical experience, you can learn to correctly identify and effectively apply
his strategic herbal treatments towards the treatment of cardiovascular and
respiratory disorders.”

Pregnancy, women’s health, and pediatrics

Complex diseases of pregnancy: Covers “difficult to treat conditions that many
experienced practitioners seem to treat effortlessly” including TCM diagnosis
and treatment of “abdominal pain, hypermobility, acute and chronic digestive and
urinary complaints, and conditions such as pre-eclampsia.”

Pregnancy Complications: Differential Pulse Diagnosis & Herbal Treatment: Using 
“unique diagnostic methods” of pulse diagnosis, skin temperature, vital signs
and the ears in treatment of pregnancy complications, including “appropriate
herbal formulas.”

Pregnancy: Maternity Acupuncture Care: Problem Solving Through Clinical
Scenarios: Acupuncture treatment for birth preparation, medical induction,
miscarriage, stillbirth, and breech presentation.

Why Treat Children: “Major childhood ailments such as asthma. [sic] allergies
and chronic infections can be easily and effectively treated with acupuncture,
herbal medicine and diet therapy.”

Effective Immune Support from Pediatrics to Geriatrics and Understanding the
Vaccine Myths: “Immunizations are widely touted by conventional medicine and
mainstream media as being responsible for eradicating and preventing many
infectious diseases. This course will cover the following: Discussions and
research reviewing the history and current risks and use of vaccinations;
debating mass vaccination and the history of vaccine implementation; vaccine
adverse reactions and mortality. The seminar presents objective data on the
history, questionable efficacy and inconsistent safety of vaccine programs. It
goes on to train clinicians in using safe, effective and practical tools for
improving the immune health of their patients.” The course was given by Standard
Process of North Carolina, a dietary supplement company that sells through
licensed healthcare professionals in N.C. This is not the only course teaching
anti-vaccination tropes sponsored by a company affiliated with Standard Process.

The Treatment Of Children Using Classic Formulas: Teaches how to integrate “the 
type of child with the type of illness.” For example, “which type of child with 
allergic purpura will respond well to Xiao Chai Hu Tang, Ban Xiao Hou Po Tang,
Ma Xing Shi Gan Tang or Xiao Jian Zhong Tang”, all of which can be used to treat
this illness based on “differentiating the type of child.”

Acupuncture Manipulation and Scalp Needling for Pediatric Autism: “The most
important and most difficult technique in all manipulations is Heat-producing
Needling and Coldness due to Heaven-penetrating. . . . This unique acupuncture
method is widely used in medicinal diseases. Although the operation is
difficult, as long as you master the key points and practice more, you can still
master it.”

Advanced Pediatrics: Childhood Eczema & Dermatology: Teaches the etiology and
pathogenesis of eczema from the Oriental perspective and the “importance of the 
Spleen, Lungs and Kidney in the progression of eczema.” Looks at “the
conventional methods of treatment and the harm they do in the long term”. Covers
TCM patterns of differentiation, acupuncture point prescriptions, sho-ni-shin
protocol and herbal formulas with modifications for acute and chronic eczema.”
[Sho-ni-shin is apparently a panacea for pediatric illnesses.]

Advanced Pediatric & Sho-ni-shin: Behavioral Disorders: Covers “a wide range of 
children’s behavioral disorders, from hyperactivity, Attention Deficit Disorder 
and autism as well as anxiety, insomnia and night terrors.” In-depth treatment
protocols with acupuncture, Sho-ni-shin techniques and herbal medicine. “On
Sunday afternoon I will demonstrate on live children.”

Chinese Medicine Pediatrics and Ear Infections: Covers diagnostics, treatment
principles, acupuncture point prescriptions, herbal formulas, moxa techniques,
shoni-shin techniques and dietetics recommendations for pediatric ear
infections-otitis media. “Learn how to diagnose and treat pediatric ear
infections by downloading the course material, taking an online quiz and
receiving a certificate of completion.”

Reversing Pediatric Asthma with Chinese Medicine: “Helps practitioners who
aren’t sure how to treat pediatric asthma, learn the step-by-step process for
using Chinese medicine to address acute asthma symptoms for immediate relief”
and “to create and implement long term treatment plans to reverse asthma
symptoms altogether.”

Chinese Medicine Pediatrics and Gynecology: “Chinese Medicine pediatric and
gynecologic case histories. Learn treatments for life-threatening illnesses to
newborn babies, complications after labor and delivery, irregular menstruation, 
infectious diseases and chronic gynecological and pediatric conditions.”

Advanced Gynecology: Treatment of many common gynecological conditions “as per
the Chengdu University of TCM and the extensive clinical experiences of” the
instructor. Includes “irregular cycles, dysmenorrhea, amenorrhea, menorrhagia,
metrorrhagia, PCOS (polycystic ovaries and syndrome), Leiomyomas (fibroids),
Bartholins cysts, dermoid cysts / teratoma’s, endometriosis and adenomyosis,
P.I.D. (Pelvic Inflammatory Disease), vulvovaginitis, HPV and granuloma, HSV
(genital Herpes), vaginismus, vaginal dryness, vaginal discharges and infections
(parasitic, bacterial, viral and fungal), and UTI’s.”

Integrative quackery

(Like integrative medicine, but without the real medicine part.)

First Aid Homeopathy: ‘First Aid Homeopathic Remedies for acute and or emergency
situations. . . Includes a chart with easy to understand diagram and useful
remedies.”

Introduction to Drainage Homeopathy: “Both Chinese Medicine and Homeopathy rely 
on the bodies [sic] natural healing ability. . . .The Unda drops are unique
homeopathic formulations which are based on strongly stimulating the bodies
[sic] ability to free itself from the heaviness of both mental and physical
toxins allowing the body to follow the natural course of healing itself.”

Acu-point Injection Part IV: Herbs & Homeopathy: For certification in “acu-point
injection”. Class covers “herbal injectable preparations” for “specific
maladies” and homeopathy. Includes “hands on practice.”

CranioSacral Therapy for Pediatrics: “How to work with the special issues that
surround the application of CranioSacral Therapy and SomatoEmotional Release as 
they relate to infants and children.” [Link added.]

Mending the Mind: Using Nutrition, Herbs and Lifestyle to Reawaken the Brain
from Dementia: “Learn how to recognize and address the root causes of dementia
from a nutritional, herbal and functional medicine approach.” [Link added.]

Functional Medicine: GI, Thyroid & Adrenal Assessment: “Utilizing Functional
Medicine to optimize health using patient symptoms as a guide to the underlying 
cause of specific conditions. Healthcare professionals will learn more about
autoimmunity, leaky gut and how to address symptoms and conditions with diet and
nutrients, as well as specific testing that should be done.” Course was
presented by a dietary supplement company.

Essential Oils for Colds, Flu, Viral & Bacterial Infection: “Discover how
essential oils have been used safely and with proven efficacy for herpes virus, 
shingles, MRSA and other viral and bacterial infections. The antimicrobial
action (antibacterial, antifungal, and antiviral) of essential oils is one of
their most effective properties.” Course given by Bastyr University.

Adrenal Fatigue: “In terms of TCM, exhaustion of mingmen fire will affect
production and distribution of qi and blood, and negatively impact stomach fire 
and heart yang.” Diagnosis with lab saliva testing, various Oriental medicine
approaches to diagnosis and differentiation, therapeutic use of Chinese herbal
products and formulas, and Chinese and Japanese acupuncture approaches.
[“Adrenal fatigue” is explained here.]

Endocrine Mastery: Optimizing Thyroid, Adrenal and Blood Sugar: “The combined,
cumulative and negative effects of chemical toxicity, over medication, radiation
exposure, vaccinations, and genetically-modified foods are devastating.
Endocrine-related conditions are spreading at an alarming rate, and include
diabetes and pre-diabetes (#1), hypothyroid (#2), adrenal fatigue, obesity,
cardiovascular disease, infertility, insulin resistance and metabolic syndrome.”

Reversing Thyroid Conditions and Brain Inflammation with Acupuncture and Stem
Cells: “Confidently assess clinical and sub- clinical inflammation in patients
who present with thyroid and brain conditions [and] . . . learn treatment
protocols to address the cause of the inflammation using acupuncture techniques 
and stem cells.”

Aesthetics and more nonsense

4 Hour Advanced Cosmetic Acupuncture Video: Learn to “treat and significantly
improve aging facial conditions” (e.g., wrinkles, skin sagging), general health,
and overall well-being using cosmetic acupuncture.

Celestial AcuLift – Cosmetic Acupuncture: For a “deeper insight into how and why
cosmetic Acupuncture works.” The “first time old and new, traditional Chinese
medicine and 5 element are combined in such a way.”

Bodyintuitive: “The language and philosophical understandings of Chinese
medicine are woven together with a Western medical view of the mind and body . .
. You’ll become fluent in both languages, moving back and forth between what
are known as the rarified energies of the body – Qi, Blood, Yin, Yang and
Essence – and the latest 21st century scientific understanding of hormonal,
structural and biochemical imbalances . . .”

Acupuncture is a theatrical placebo, effective for nothing. Yet acupuncturists
and TCM practitioners, with the states’ blessing, are claiming they can treat
serious illnesses. Many of their continuing education courses seem to be little 
more than marketing opportunities for the dietary supplement companies who
sponsor them. As well, practitioners are fabricating even more fantasy
therapies, slapping the term “acupuncture” or “TCM” on them, and selling them to
the public, again with the states’ blessing. They appear to have little sense
of professional responsibility or ethics. Without intervention from the state
legislatures, this situation will only worsen.

And the states’ response? Expanding their scope of practice.

TCM for COVID-19

Despite the many claims, there is no real evidence that traditional Chinese
medicine (TCM) is effective for prevention or treatment of COVID-19

Harriet Hall on April 7, 2020

Link



There have been many claims for the efficacy (and even the superiority) of
traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) compared to so-called “Western” medicine. The
COVID-19 outbreak that started in Wuhan, China, could have been a unique
opportunity for them to demonstrate to the world just how effective TCM could
be. They might have cured COVID-19 with TCM, and they might have done controlled
studies to show that herbal remedies were better than pharmaceutical remedies. 
But they didn’t. Here’s what happened instead.

They used “Western” pharmaceuticals

Based on evidence from a seriously flawed study, Chinese health organizations
have officially recommended that COVID-19 patients take chloroquine. Chloroquine
phosphate tablets (500 mg, 2 times per day) for a total of 10 days is the
official recommendation of the Department of Science and Technology of Guangdong
Province and Health Commission of Guangdong Province.

But a small controlled study subsequently showed no benefit.

Favipiravir (Avigan), a drug developed to treat new strains of influenza, was
given to 340 COVID-19 patients in Wuhan, China. Chinese authorities reported
that it was safe and “clearly effective.” Patients who got the drug tested
negative for the virus in four days, compared to 11 days for patients who did
not get the drug. X-rays showed improvements in 91% of those who got the drug,
compared to 62% of those who didn’t. The article describing that study appears
to have been withdrawn.

They added TCM to other treatments

In one published study, four pneumonia patients were treated with both Western
pharmaceutical and Chinese herbal antivirals (lopinavir/ritonavir (Kaletra®),
arbidol, and Shufeng Jiedu Capsule). Three patients improved symptomatically and
two were discharged with negative tests. But one of those had tested negative
before treatment, so presumably the diagnosis of COVID-19 was wrong. There was
no control group, so no way to know whether their clinical course might have
been the same with pharmaceuticals alone – or with no treatment at all.

A Chinese healthcare institute claims that acupuncturists trained in herbal
medicine have treated COVID-19 patients with “important results”. They reported 
a 90% success rate with Qing Fei Pai Du Tang, a remedy dating back to the Han
dynasty. Qing Fei Pai Du Tang is a mixture of 21 herbs, two of which (Ma Huang
and Xi Xin) have been banned or restricted in other countries due to toxic
effects.

They did poorly designed studies and reported anecdotal data

An integrative medicine website lists published research papers related to the
treatment of COVID-19 using traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). It claims that:

   the core pathogenesis of COVID-19 is a dampness pestilence caused by external
   cold-dampness distressing lung and spleen, transforming to heat due to
   dysfunctional qi activity and endogenous stagnated heat.

That is not the language of science.

They recommend various herbal regimens for different stages of the disease. They
report that the use of herbal medicine to treat COVID-19 was widespread in
China, that 85% of confirmed COVID-19 cases were treated with herbal remedies.
They provide a long list of recommended herbal decoctions, powders, pills,
granules, capsules, and injections. They report several allegedly successful
studies – retrospective cohorts, case series, and case studies – using different
herbal formulations, sometimes “semi-individualized,” and different endpoints. 
Nothing resembling a well-designed clinical trial with an appropriate control
group. They describe ongoing research on various proposed treatments including
chloroquine, convalescent plasma, favipiravir, and stem cell therapy. None of
these are TCM, but they recommend TCM. They recommend using TCM as an adjunctive
therapeutic option but admit that “The clinical evidence of CM [Chinese
medicine] on COVID-19 is far from conclusive.”

An article on MedicineNet reported that supplements suggested by the Chinese
Journal of Integrative Medicine to treat or prevent coronavirus include:

  1. Radix astragali (Huangqi),

  2. Radix glycyrrhizae (Gancao),

  3. Radix saposhnikoviae (Fangfeng),

  4. Rhizoma Atractylodis Macrocephalae (Baizhu),

  5. Lonicerae Japonicae Flos (Jinyinhua), and

  6. Fructus forsythia (Lianqiao)

They also reported claims that Qingfei Paidu soup, made with ephedra and
licorice root, had been effective in treating the symptoms of hundreds of
COVID-19 patients; but they pointed out that those claims had not been verified 
by researchers or news reporters outside of China.

They repeat the NIH warning that not only are the claims inconclusive, but “some
TCM herbal and supplement products may be adulterated with pesticides,
industrial chemicals, prescription pharmaceuticals, or mislabeled herbs and
other substances”. The NIH points out that even when studies show improvements, 
they are only of marginal benefit. The NIH has concluded that:

   no evidence exists that any combination of herbs will cure COVID-19, or even 
   lessen symptoms.

TCM hype and hope outweigh scientific evidence

TCM is gaining popularity in Africa because “TCM has so far played a substantial
role in China’s fight against the novel coronavirus”.

YouTube videos claim that TCM has been proven effective, and Chinese doctors
offer to share their expertise with overseas counterparts.

I don’t know what all these sources mean by “proven effective”, but the evidence
is far below the standard that I would accept as “proof”.

Chinese government sources and news sources that follow the
government-controlled narrative must be considered unreliable. TCM is important 
to the Chinese national agenda, and a propaganda campaign has “pumped up
pseudoscience”.

Other bogus claims for COVID-19 treatments abound

I wrote an article for the Skeptical Inquirer website about how COVID-19 has
provided a field day for scams and misinformation. Every kind of alternative
medicine has jumped on the coronavirus bandwagon. Here are a few examples:

  1. A doctor in India has been claiming Prince Charles is his patient and was
    cured through homeopathy and Ayurveda. A task force plans to study the
    treatment that was used. A spokesperson for Prince Charles said, “This
    information is incorrect. The Prince of Wales followed the medical advice of
    the National Health Service (NHS) in the UK and nothing more”.

  2. Acupuncturists have claimed that COVID-19 can be treated by stimulating an
    acupressure point for the lungs to help strengthen Qi and blood flow.

  3. Jann Bellamy has written about chiropractors claiming to protect patients from
    coronavirus with spinal adjustments.

  4. Indian authorities are irresponsibly pushing homeopathic remedies like
    Arsenicum album 30C and two drops of sesame oil in each nostril each morning
    for prevention.

  5. Naturopaths are pushing intravenous vitamin C.

  6. Functional medicine practitioners are promoting detox, supplements,
    eliminating sugar, and “boosting the immune system” with diet.

The bogus claims make the Internet sound like a duck farm at feeding time. The
Center for Inquiry has developed a new resource to inoculate against coronavirus
misinformation.

The bottom line: TCM is probably not effective for prevention or cure of
COVID-19

The NIH commented on alternative treatments including herbal therapies and teas.
They said “There is no scientific evidence that any of these alternative
remedies can prevent or cure the illness caused by COVID-19″. Instead of
believing TCM claims, we should listen to the scientific experts and wait for
real evidence.

TCM (Traditional Chinese Medicine): New Developments

Evidence for the efficacy of Traditional Chinese Medicine is scanty,
unconvincing, and often fraudulent. China is seeing a resurgence of TCM, even
teaching it to children. But in Australia, restrictions are being placed on
misleading advertising.

Harriet Hall on September 26, 2017

Link



What is traditional Chinese medicine (TCM)? And if it works, why aren’t we all
using it? Here’s one explanation:

   With rich experience accumulating for thousands of years, Chinese medicine
   (CM) is a treasure for human healthcare. It is a patient-oriented medical
   system which takes a holistic approach in treating the subjects instead of
   the diseases. CM possesses a broad spectrum of treatment modalities,
   including herbal, proprietary CM, acupuncture, moxibustion, and qigong.
   Selection of therapy is tailor-made on which pattern of disharmony can be
   identified.

   However, the scientific validity of CM due to the lack of scientific evidence
   is being challenged. Thus, there is a great demand in the knowledge gap to
   explore the scientific and evidence-based knowledge of CM…we need to provide 
   more efficacies and safety evidence to demonstrate its effectiveness in the
   modern era.

That statement is wrong-headed in so many ways:

  1. Experience, even “rich experience,” can be misleading; it is no substitute for
    controlled scientific studies.

  2. Age is not a reliable guide to truth. Astrology is ancient, but it is ancient 
    nonsense, not ancient wisdom.

  3. Misleading alternative medicine buzzwords: patient-oriented, holistic,
    treating people instead of diseases. Ideas that alternative medicine has
    co-opted from the goals of the best mainstream clinical practice.

  4. Acupuncture is theatrical placebo.

  5. Proprietary? Doesn’t that mean they’re not revealing what’s in it?

  6. Moxibustion?!

  7. Tailor-made on patterns of disharmony? What does that even mean?

  8. “Scientific validity is being challenged because of lack of scientific
    evidence.” Of course it is, because we can’t know if a treatment works if
    there is no scientific evidence.

  9. “We need to… demonstrate its effectiveness.” Scientists don’t set out to
    “demonstrate” effectiveness. They try to find out “if” something is
    effective.

The basis of TCM

The concepts underlying TCM are fanciful ideas that originated in a
pre-scientific era; they have no basis in reality. They posit a vitalistic
energy (qi) that circulates through meridians that connect to body organs. They 
think in terms of yin/yang and the five elements (wood, fire, earth, metal, and 
water). Therapy is based on patterns of disharmony, and different practitioners 
identify different patterns and prescribe different remedies. They examine
things like the color and shape of the tongue, the smell of the breath, the
sound of the voice. They claim to be able to palpate 12 different pulses and
find qualities like “floating, slippery, bolstering-like, thread and quick.” The
remedies they prescribe include animal parts (sometimes from endangered
species), plant extracts, and mineral products.

Problems with research

At best, the evidence for the effectiveness of TCM is scanty:

   America’s National Institutes of Health looked at 70 systematic reviews of
   TCM treatments. In 41 of them, the trials were too small or badly designed to
   be of use. In 29, the studies showed possible benefits but problems with
   sample sizes and other flaws meant the results were inconclusive. Shu-chuen
   Li of Newcastle University in Australia found that only a quarter of the
   studies he looked at showed some benefits, but most of these were marginal.

Nearly 100% of TCM studies from China report that TCM is effective. If studies
get negative results, they aren’t published. This is not just publication bias. 
A survey of Chinese clinical trials revealed fraudulent practice on a massive
scale; it found that 80% of the data was fabricated. Guangdong-based rights
activist Mai Ke said there is an all-pervasive culture of fakery across all
products made in the country.

A study from the Centre for Evidence-Based Chinese Medicine at Beijing
University of Chinese Medicine found strong evidence of publication bias,
manipulation, positive conclusions based on data that showed no significant
difference, and other problems.

Proponents of TCM like to claim that its research was good enough to be awarded 
a Nobel Prize. Tu Youyou won a Nobel Prize for the discovery of artemisinin, a
malaria drug derived from a plant that had been used for other purposes in TCM. 
But this was in no way a victory for TCM or herbalism. It was a victory for
pure, standard, “Western” scientific pharmacognosy.

Chinese Medical Board of Australia urges caution in advertising claims

Our colleagues in Australia are making some progress in combatting
misinformation about TCM. The Friends of Science in Medicine (FSM) submitted
over 1,000 images from TCM/acupuncture websites to AHPRA, the Australian Health 
Practitioner Regulation Agency. And as a result, the Chinese Medicine Board of
Australia issued this statement in their Newsletter:

   Because of the higher standard of evidence required for public advertising,
   acceptable evidence to support advertising claims needs to be based on
   findings obtained from quantitative methodology such as systematic reviews of
   randomised, and high quality controlled trials…All advertisers must ensure
   that any statements and claims made about Chinese medicine practice are not
   false, misleading or deceptive or create an unreasonable expectation of
   benefits from such services.

   If your advertising includes therapeutic claims about the treatment of heath 
   conditions, you must be able to substantiate each claim with acceptable
   evidence to support such claims. The Board is particularly concerned about
   claims that acupuncture is a safe and effective treatment for turning breech 
   babies.

They go on to say that practitioners should not cite the WHO document about
conditions acupuncture can effectively treat, because it has not been updated
for five years and it does not meet the requirements to be acceptable evidence. 
They still think “traditional use evidence” is sufficient for treating patients,
but it should not be used in advertising.

FSM’s Loretta Marron has said that in her opinion, this “means that practitioner
websites can’t make ANY claims because there is no ‘robust’ evidence for any
TCM intervention!”

Indoctrinating the young

In a disturbing development that has sparked controversy in China, children as
young as 12 are being taught how to administer acupuncture. TCM has been added
to the curriculum in Zhejiang province, 100,000 textbooks have been distributed,
more are on the way, and there are plans to extend the program throughout the
country. It is seen as “a way to get Chinese medicine’s scientific [sic] values 
and spirit into every household. Instilling a love of our country’s traditional 
culture in primary and secondary school students will be good for the health of 
the whole society.” Not everyone approves; comments have included “Poisoning yet
another generation,” and “Let’s also start courses in fortune telling and palm 
reading.”

In February 2016, the State Council released a “Strategic Development Plan for
Chinese Medicine (2016-2030)” that seeks to spread knowledge of TCM into
campuses and homes and also promote TCM abroad.

TCM is big business

An article in The Economist describes a TCM boom in China. It features Fang
Yuan, who sells antlers (to treat breast disease!) in the world’s largest market
for TCM with 10,000 traders in the town of Bozhou in China. Tibetan caterpillar
fungus, the “Viagra of the Himalayas” sells for more than the same weight of
gold. The number of hospitals offering TCM grew from 2,500 in 2003 to 4,000 at
the end of 2015. Since 2011 the number of licensed practitioners increased 50%. 
60,000 TCM medicines have been approved by the government, accounting for almost
a third of the pharmaceutical market. TCM now accounts for 16% of total medical
care, up from 14% in 2011.

The president of China has said that TCM is in its golden age; the Communist
Party insists that it be made equal in status to “Western” medicine. Safety laws
have been passed to regulate the production of TCM medicines, but professional 
requirements have been relaxed for TCM practitioners. Costs for TCM are
estimated to be 24% lower than for conventional medicine. But that is likely to 
be false economy, since the Economist article points out that the evidence that 
TCM works is scanty.

Loretta Marron wrote in an e-mail that:

   China is protecting its $40Bn Chinese medicine export and sales industry and 
   attempting to grow it and is influencing our country [Australia, but probably
   many other countries too] through the back door, by giving millions of
   dollars to our Universities for so called ‘collaborative’ research which may 
   translate into building TCM ‘research’ hospitals – here and abroad.

   (Yiling Pharmaceutical, a company that makes herbal remedies based on
   traditional recipes has a market capitalisation of ($3bn)! )

Quality control issues

A large percentage of TCM remedies are contaminated or adulterated with
pharmaceuticals. One survey found some form of undeclared substance in 9 out of 
10 medicines tested. They found plant or animal DNA from species not listed on
the label. Significant levels of toxic heavy metals were found in over half of
the medicines.

According to Edzard Ernst, Chinese officials have tried to ignore or suppress
the information about contaminants, fearing that “their profits might be
endangered by being open about the dubious quality of their TCM-exports.”

Conclusion: Buyer beware

There is little evidence that TCM remedies are safe and effective. Acupuncture
has been exhaustively studied and found to be theatrical placebo. Some remedies 
have never been properly studied, and many of the studies that have been done
are poor quality and may even be fraudulent. And you can’t be sure what you’re
getting: many of the products are mislabeled, contaminated, or adulterated.
Using TCM is a gamble. Mainstream science-based medicine isn’t perfect, but it’s
a much better bet.

TCM Hodgepodge

Mark Crislip on June 27, 2014

Link


I suspect there is more published about traditional Chinese medicine than any
other SCAM. Here are some of the recent curiosities of TCM.

Burning genitals

   The little girls laughed about the germs, because they didn’t believe in
   them; but they believed about the disease, because they’d seen that happen.
   Spirits caused it, everyone knew that. Spirits and bad luck. Jack had not
   said the right prayers.– Oryx and Crake

I long ago gave up on the idea that there are a finite number of pseudo-medical 
treatments. Anything a human can imagine will probably be used as a SCAM
intervention. I remain amazed at the permutations that occur in the
pseudo-medical world, not unlike the mix and match bioforms in Oryx and Crake.

Not everyone knows basic anatomy and physiology that allows for understanding of
disease. Instead, people often rely on metaphor and magic for their
understanding, especially in the world of pseudo-medicine. Sympathetic magic
lies at the heart of many SCAMs.

The classic example is rhino horns for impotence. But there are other examples. 
What makes blood flow to a body part? Heat. What is hot? Fire. Why are you
impotent? Lack of blood flow. Put it all together and it spells fire: Set your
crotch alight to cure impotence. Really.

   It is all about keeping blood flow moving rapidly. The warmth from the
   burning towels speeds the blood through the body and it makes me perform 50% 
   better in bed.

The accompanying photo of a flaming groin is a prelude to a What’s the harm?
entry or a most unpleasant admission to the burn center if it goes horribly
wrong.

There is nothing on the PubMeds concerning fire therapy and little on the
internet. There are several versions fire therapy. It

   is much more advanced and powerful than Moxibustion.

Given the total uselessness of moxibustion, I suspect the being several times
more powerful than nothing is still nothing.

While the current photographs are from China, it allegedly originated in Tibet
where:

   The thermotherapeutic procedure consists in the application of a herbal
   product with a specific formula for each disease under treatment on the area 
   of the affected organ. The area is covered with a towel soaked in alcohol and
   it is then lighted [sic]. The heat produced by the burning of the alcohol is
   easily born by the patient. The procedure is stopped when the patient
   announces a disconfort [sic]. The vasodilator effect produced by the fire
   heat accelerates the local blood circulation and the local metabolism. Thus, 
   the curing substances of the herbs will be carried directly to the sick organ
   and they will act immediately at local level.

I would not rely on any therapy that bases its endpoint upon the use a safeword.
It is not a therapy for Dave Grohl, although Jerry Lee Lewis might approve.

Its alleged mechanism of action is because

   All health problems relate microcirculation deficiency. At capillary level,
   the blood become stagnate [sic], then toxin will be cumulate [sic], using
   Fire Dragon Therapy can improve the microcirculation and to remove stagnate
   [sic] toxins.

Yep. Toxins. And:

   The vasodilator effect produced by the fire heat accelerates the local blood 
   circulation and the local metabolism. Thus, the curing substances of the
   herbs will be carried directly to the sick organ and they will act
   immediately at local level.

Like most pseudo-medicines, there is no process for which fire therapy cannot be
used, including as a beauty aid.

   General fire dragon therapy can help cure the following disorders:
   Indigestion, low metabolism, low temperature, melancholy, pain caused by
   stress and tension, insomnia, anxiety, fear, panic attacks, stomach
   distension, vertigo, hiatus hernia, benign tumors, cold bile disease, joint
   pains, arthritis, bone deformation, joint inflammation, superficial fever
   (empty fever), post-menopause syndrome and nerve inflammation (sciatic nerve,
   neurological disorders, etc.). In short, fire dragon therapy is good for
   diseases which manifest from phlegm and wind humoral disorders.

Phlegm and wind. Good for teenage boys? And are the effects? Of course

   Huo Long therapy produces many side effects, but all of them are positive.

Whew.

The procedure as described is relatively safe: the towels are wet and it is the 
alcohol vapor above the towel, not the liquid alcohol on the towel, that is
burning. As long as it doesn’t ignite the clothes or the environment, it poses
little risk.

But it sure looks stupid to me.

Pop Pop

There is often the suggestion that you should consult a licensed and certified
acupuncturist, not just any old needle wrangler down the street, to practice
their magic on you.

I don’t know. I would think that licensed and certified magic is no more
effective than unlicensed and uncertified magic.

Maybe they might know a bit more if certified, but the pass rates for
acupuncture boards are not impressive, at least in California.

In February 2014, only 62% of first-time test takers in California passed and
overall 49% passed. Gives one pause.

There are several sites on the internet with Acupuncture Board questions and
flash cards. I took the tests and missed all the questions. The questions often 
seemed goofy to me, but then I find all of the theory and practice of
acupuncture goofy.

Knowing the crossing point of the spleen meridian and the throughfare vessel or 
that cupping removes putrefaction and promotes granulation somehow has no
relevance to what I would consider biomedical reality.

I wonder, as an aside, what the result of board certification will be on the
practice of acupuncture. There are a huge variety of styles (by country and by
practitioner), acupoints, variations (bee venom or cat gut added) and
techniques. There are more acupuncutures than acupuncture, perhaps as many forms
as there are practitioners. I also note that some schools have high pass rates 
and others do not. I predict with board certification the variability of
acupuncture will decline as, at least in the US, they teach to the test.

The biomedical sample questions were often simplistic and, if indicative of the 
knowledge base of practitioners who want to be primary care providers, scary. I 
was reassured to find questions concerning proper hand hygiene and sterilization
of needles, although I am skeptical about their application.

What I did not find (and that doesn’t mean they were not there; it was not an
exhaustive search) were questions testing whether acupuncturists had an
understanding of the importance of the anatomy under their acupoints. Evidently 
not, for if you search acupuncture and complications on the PubMeds you will
find seven pages of articles, some of which have titles that suggest needle
points are going where they should not:

  1. “A needle penetrating the stomach cavity after acupuncture.”

  2. “Life-threatening cardiac tamponade: a rare complication of acupuncture.”

  3. “Is pneumothorax after acupuncture so uncommon?”

  4. “Staphylococcus aureus pericardial abscess presenting as severe sepsis and
    septic shock after acupuncture therapy.”

  5. “Cervical epidural abscess after cupping and acupuncture.”

  6. “An acute cervical epidural hematoma as a complication of dry needling.”

  7. “Hemopericardium following acupuncture.”

  8. “Cardiac tamponade caused by acupuncture: a review of the literature.”

Some of those are impressive. It takes real effort to get deep enough to pop a
stomach or heart. I would hard-pressed to accomplish such a result deliberately.

Those are the results of the first two pages of search results and does not
include my all-time favorite:

“Acupuncture needle found in ex-South Korea president’s lung”

   “I can’t figure out how the needle got into there,” Dr Sung Myung-whun was
   quoted as telling reporters at the hospital after the operation. “It is a
   mystery for me, too.”

Um, maybe because acupuncturists don’t really know what they are doing when they
stick needles in people? They do not really know how deep they can safely push 
a needle since they have no understanding of anatomy?

There is a push to include acupuncturists as primary care physicians. Given the 
nature of their training and what it includes to pass their Boards (mostly
magic) and excludes (reality and anatomy), I would not be skeptical of their
abilities.

CIGO: Cochrane In, Garbage Out.

The Cochrane reviews. They give me pause. I understand the need and utility of
systematic reviews and meta-analysis. They can give a nice overview of a topic
and suggest the utility or lack thereof of a given therapy. But they are not
definitive and suffer from the problem of GIGO: garbage in garbage out.

GIGO is especially pertinent when the methodologies of systematic reviews are
applied to pseudo-medical interventions that are divorced from reality.

My colleagues and I have written extensively about acupuncture (we have
collected many of the essays in book form available at Amzazon. Hint. Hint.).

The summary of acupuncture: it is not based in reality (there are no meridians
or acupoints) and well-designed clinical trials suggest the acupuncture only
works for subjective endpoints if the patient thinks they are getting
acupuncture and believe it to be effective. It does not matter where needles are
placed or even if needles are used at all. From a prior plausibility
perspective, any positive effect from acupuncture is likely due to a combination
of bias and poor study design.

But that never stops the Cochrane collaboration, who will run anything and
everything through their grinder to produce a meta-analysis sausage.
Unfortunately, unlike sausage, I often know what goes into the meta-analysis.

Acupuncture is the rodent hair and insect parts in the bratwurst that is
“Acupuncture for treating acute ankle sprains in adults.” Can I beat a metaphor 
to death or what? Anything and everything that calls itself acupuncture is
included; no form was ignored:

   We included all types of acupuncture practices, such as needle acupuncture,
   electroacupuncture, laser acupuncture, pharmacoacupuncture, non-penetrating
   acupuncture point stimulation (e.g. acupressure and magnets) and moxibustion.
   Acupuncture could be compared with control (no treatment or placebo) or
   another standard non-surgical intervention.

Acupuncture, as is of then the case, is anything they want it to be. Insert
Humpty quote here. Talk about your “heterogeneous group of acupuncture and
quasi-acupuncture.” And, what surprise, they did not find any evidence that
acupuncture, however defined, was effective for acute ankle sprain:

   The currently available evidence from a very heterogeneous group of
   randomized and quasi-randomised controlled trials evaluating the effects of
   acupuncture for the treatment of acute ankle sprains does not provide
   reliable support for either the effectiveness or safety of acupuncture
   treatments, alone or in combination with other non-surgical interventions; or
   in comparison with other non-surgical interventions.

Of course, reality will never provide reliable support for either the
effectiveness or safety of acupuncture treatments, because acupuncture is based 
on fantasy and its practitioners don’t really know what they are doing. When
seen through the lens of the information provided by prior high-quality studies 
of acupuncture, it would suggest the following conclusion promotes a waste of
time and money:

   Future rigorous randomised clinical trials with larger sample sizes will be
   necessary to establish robust clinical evidence concerning the effectiveness 
   and safety of acupuncture treatment for acute ankle sprains.

But for some reason the Cochrane group always suggests more studies. At least
they did not suggest that it may be worthwhile for ankle sprain patients to test
on an individual basis whether therapeutic acupuncture is beneficial for them.

They can only be that lunkheaded once. I hope.

TB or Not TB

As regular readers are aware, I am an Infectious Disease doctor and have been
Medical Director of the infection control program my hospital system for 24
years.

It is impressive how Murphy rules in infection control. If something can cause
an infection, it will cause an infection given the right circumstances.

Needles sticking the skin can drag in bacteria from the skin of the patient,
from the hand of the practitioner or even from the slight aerosolization of spit
from the practitioner, dragging oral bacteria into spinal fluid. It is why we
wear a mask and gloves for many injections.

I have mentioned my Googlewack before. As best I can tell there is exactly one
picture of an acupuncturist using gloves (actually, a physical therapist doing
dry needling) on a Google image search.

Careful infection control technique is not high on the to-do list of acupuncture
practitioners and a search of PubMed will result in a long list of
mostly-preventable infections. As I think about it, since there is no real
indication for acupuncture, they are completely preventable infections.

And now there is a report of cutaneous TB: “Analysis of 30 Patients with
Acupuncture-Induced Primary Inoculation Tuberculosis”

   The use of Chinese acupuncture needles which are able to deeply penetrate
   into the tissues surrounding tendons and nerves provide an ideal route for
   the inoculation of tuberculosis. The patients in our outbreak underwent
   acupuncture twice daily for two weeks. This high degree of potential exposure
   may explain why there were no cases of spontaneous healing.

From an infection control perspective, it was interesting that

   Despite the unsuccessful identification of the source of contamination, it is
   apparent that these infections were linked to acupuncture and moxibustion,
   because the 30 patients had the same epidemiological characteristics.

   Most of the 30 patients had multiple skin infections, but the lesions were
   located to the sites of acupuncture and electrotherapy. Lesion severity and
   drug reactions in individual patient were similar, but we did not know
   whether these multiple lesions were independent or the result of the
   inoculation infections in the wounds via hemo-disseminated Mycobacterium
   tuberculosis.

And some patients had metastatic infections:

   Although, occurrence of the three patients with meningeal and pulmonary
   tuberculosis and two patients with knee tuberculosis had confirmed the
   hemo-disseminated ability of this primary inoculation Mycobacterium
   tuberculosis to other tissues and the compartments.

And they finish with a little ironic humor:

   Mycobacterium can easily spread without proper microbiological control of
   these procedures. To this end, it was recently suggested that herbal medicine
   and acupuncture professions should also develop a system of statutory
   regulation which should help prevent these issues.

Those whose world view holds that disease is due to the fanciful constructs of
meridians and chi are unlikely to pay close attention to germs and their
potential spread. In medicine we are fortunate that it is usually hard to infect
other humans, especially if you are punctilious about applying the concepts of 
infection control. Too bad infection prevention is not part of their
understanding.

Traditional Chinese herbalism at the Cleveland Clinic? What happened to
science-based medicine?

Quackademic medicine has taken a bold step forward at The Cleveland Clinic,
which has opened a traditional Chinese medicine herbal practice.

David Gorski on April 26, 2014

Link


I don’t recall if I’ve ever mentioned my connection with the Cleveland Clinic
Foundation (CCF). I probably have, but just don’t remember it. Long-time readers
might recall that I did my general surgery training at Case Western Reserve
University at University Hospitals of Cleveland. Indeed, I did my PhD there as
well in the Department of Physiology and Biophysics. Up the road less than a
mile from UH is the Cleveland Clinic. As it turns out, during my stint in
Physiology and Biophysics at CWRU, I happened to do a research rotation in a lab
at the CCF, which lasted a few months. OK, so it’s not much of a connection. It
was over 20 years ago and only lasted a few months, but it’s something that
gives me an obvious and blatant hook to start out this post, particularly given 
the number of cardiac patients I delivered to the CCF back in the early 1990s
when I moonlighted as a flight physician for Metro LifeFlight.

Obvious and clunky introduction aside (hey, they can’t all be brilliant; so I’ll
settle for nauseatingly self-deprecating), several of my readers have been
sending me a link to a story that appeared in the Wall Street Journal the other 
day: A Top Hospital Opens Up to Chinese Herbs as Medicines: Evidence is lacking 
that herbs are effective. I also noticed that our fearless leader Steve Novella 
blogged about it and was tempted to let it pass, given that I had seemingly lost
my window, but then I realized that there’s always something I can add to a
post, even after the topic’s been blogged by Steve Novella. Whether that
something is of value or not, I leave to the reader. So here we go. Besides, if 
this article truly indicates a new trend in academic medical centers, it’s—if
you’ll excuse the term—quantum leap in the infiltration of quackademic medicine 
into formerly reputable medical centers. It’s a depressing thing, and it needs
to be publicized.

Of course, the Cleveland Clinic has long been a poster child for the evils of
quackademic medicine. Indeed, take a look at its Center for Integrative
Medicine. Offerings there include acupuncture, chiropractic, something called
“holistic psychotherapy,” reiki (of course!), and Chinese herbal therapy. I
frequently use the CCF’s woo-ful description of reiki using the “universal life 
source energy” to heal patients as an example of the utter mystical-religious
nonsense that has infiltrated once-proud medical institutions, along with other 
prime examples carefully curated from selections from other quackademic academic
medical centers. So, naturally, it’s not surprising that the CCF would be a
“pioneer” (if you can call it that) in bringing traditional Chinese herbal
medicine right into the heart of an academic medical center.

The WSJ article isn’t too bad in that it’s not overly credulous and, as the
title even proclaims, notes that there isn’t much evidence to support the use of
herbal medicine. Of course, herbal medicine is among the most plausible of
“complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” for the
simple reason that, for an herb to have a medical effect, there must be a
chemical (or chemicals) in it that have pharmacological activity. In other
words, there have to be drugs in them thar plants! That’s why pharmaceutical
companies and the NIH are so interested in screening natural compounds for
chemical properties and pharmaceutical activities that might indicate that they 
could function as useful drugs. True, much of the low-hanging fruit in terms of 
naturally occurring chemicals that can make useful drugs has been found and
turned into drugs, but there are likely to be lots more where that came from. It
just won’t be as easy to identify and characterize them as it was in the past.

As I’ve also described many times and Steve Novella mentioned in his post, the
problem with herbal medicines is that they are adulterated drugs (or, as Steve
put it, “dirty” drugs). They are not pure. It’s almost impossible to control
lot-to-lot consistency with respect to content of active ingredients, given how 
location, weather, soil conditions, rainfall, and many other factors can affect 
how the plants from which the medicines are extracted grow and therefore their
chemical composition. Let’s just put it this way. It’s much safer and more
predictable to administer digoxin to a patient who needs its activity on the
heart than it would be for the patient to chew on some foxglove leaves. Given
digoxin’s relatively narrow therapeutic window (the difference between the doses
needed to produce therapeutic effects and the lowest dose that will cause
significant toxicity), that’s critical. There are lots of herbs that can cause
significant toxicity, such as Aristolochia, which can cause kidney damage; kava,
which can cause liver toxicity; and many others.

The reason physicians moved away from herbal medicine to pharmaceutical drugs is
for predictability. Purified active components have a more predictable action
because the amount of drug is tightly controlled and known to a very precise
degree, while impurities are kept to a minimum. Moreover, these drugs can be
combined with various inactive agents to control how fast they are absorbed into
the bloodstream, thus providing another level of control. All of these
characteristics make the drugs much more predictable than any drugs still
contained in dead plant matter. None of this even takes into account the
widespread problem with contamination of herbal remedies with heavy metals, such
as lead or even arsenic. It’s such a problem that a particularly obnoxious
supporter of quackery has started trying to “distinguish” himself and his
supplements from the competition by setting up a lab, measuring heavy metals in 
his competitors’ products, and then periodically publishing scare stories about 
“contamination” of various supplements and herbal products. (Yes, I’m referring 
to Mike Adams.)

So what, exactly, is the CCF doing? Let’s take a look at the patient vignette
that begins the WSJ article:

   Christina Lunka appeared nervous and excited as she sat in the Chinese herbal
   therapy center recently opened by the Cleveland Clinic.

   The 49-year-old had been to many doctors seeking help for ongoing issues that
   included joint pain and digestive problems. Now the Kirtland, Ohio, resident
   was hoping to find relief through herbal remedies.

   “Do you have something for inflammation?” Ms. Lunka asked herbalist Galina
   Roofener during a one-hour consultation.

   “Absolutely,” responded Ms. Roofener. “This is for pain, for digestion, for
   inflammation, all of the above,” she said, handing Ms. Lunka a bottle with
   capsules of an herbal combination called Xiao Yao San, which translates as
   free and easy wanderer. The capsules include about eight different herbs,
   including licorice, mint leaf and white peony root.

This is nonsense. I’d bet a dollar (to steal a cliche) that Roofener has no
solid evidence to support any of these claims. It’d be among the safest of bets,
particularly given that this isn’t even a single herb she’s talking about. It’s
a bunch of herbs all ground together. Even Dr. Josephine Briggs, the director
of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), whom 
we’ve discussed many times before, is quoted in this article characterizing the 
“evidence base for these approaches using modern rigorous methods of randomized 
trials” as “quite thin,” which is an understatement. Surprisingly (to me at
least) she also apparently admitted that, although NCCAM is looking at the basic
science of some herbal products, it is currently not funding any efficacy
studies involving humans (i.e., randomized clinical trials) of herbal remedies
right now. If NCCAM isn’t even funding clinical trials of herbal medicines, they
really must not be showing any promise lately. Actually, they aren’t, and
haven’t been for quite some time. There are a number of trials now showing that 
various herbal remedies thought to be very promising don’t actually work, such
as ginkgo biloba for memory, saw palmetto for benign prostatic hypertrophy, or
black cohosh for menopausal symptoms.

It’s also some good money. Consultations are $100, and follow-up visits are $60.
True, many visits to real doctors cost more, but in most cases insurance covers
them, minus acopay, with all the paperwork that’s required. This sounds as
though it’s pure cash on the barrelhead. Add to that the cost of a month’s
supply of herbal remedies ($100), and it sounds as though the CCF could easily
turn this clinic into a pretty nice profit center, after a slow start. The
practitioner, Galina Roofener, is a graduate of the East West College of Natural
Medicine in Sarasota, which is largely a school of acupuncture and traditional 
Chinese medicine (TCM). It seems a bit confused about what TCM is, though. Under
a section of its website entitled What is traditional Chinese medicine? it
lists electroacupuncture (who knew they had sources of usable electricity in
ancient China?), biopuncture (yes, biopuncture), and homeopathy. Who knew? Maybe
Samuel Hahnemann was Chinese.

In any case, Roofener worked at clinic called Asian Therapies Acupuncture Clinic
before taking a job at CCF. All that’s there now is a message describing how
she sold her practice and moved to Cleveland to work for the CCF. However, the
Wayback Machine of Archive.org reveals what the website looked like in 2011.
There, I found a number of interesting things. Unfortunately, even many of the
Archive.org pages are gone, but the titles live on, titles touting the quackery 
that is thermography for breast cancer, acupuncture for the flu, and lots of
evidence that Roofener used homeopathy, which is not surprising given that she’s
a naturopath as well, apparently. (Her LinkedIn page also confirms her use of
homeopathy.)

Deceptively, Roofener is required by law to invoke the quack Miranda warning
as…well, I’ll let the WSJ article explain it to you:

   Ms. Roofener’s license doesn’t allow her to claim she treats diseases, a
   Cleveland Clinic spokeswoman says. She can’t say that Chinese herbs will
   treat colitis, for instance, but she can say that she can stop diarrhea and
   pain. She cannot treat arthritis but can alleviate joint pain, the
   spokeswoman says.

And:

   At the Cleveland Clinic’s herbal center, new patients are given a one-hour
   consultation that may include a battery of questions (How’s your sleep? Body 
   temperature? Ringing in your ears? Headaches?), a physical examination of the
   tongue, and the traditional Chinese method for pulse-taking (three fingers
   on each wrist to check different pulses corresponding to various organ
   systems). They are asked to sign a waiver acknowledging that “herbal
   supplements are not a substitute for a medical diagnosis.”

Clearly.

Still, in another recent story about Galina Roofener and the herbal clinic at
the CCF, Roofener is quotes thusly:

   The center doesn’t take walk-ins and primarily sees patients with conditions 
   that Western medicine has, for whatever reason, failed to remedy. “For
   something like acute pneumonia, Western antibiotics may be faster and more
   cost-effective,” says Roofener. “But if someone has antibiotic resistance, we
   can strengthen their immune system.”

Egad! “Strengthen the immune system”? Seriously? That’s one of the top quack
claims, regardless of what the quackery is!

Yes, as Steve Novella noted, the CCF is out-and-out admitting in the quack
Miranda warning on its consent form for its herbal medicine clinic that the TCM 
diagnoses Roofener is making and the herbal remedies she is prescribing to treat
them are not real medical diagnoses and not real medicine. That’s a staggering 
admission for an academic medical center to make, that it is offering to its
patients medicine that is not real medicine, a system of diagnosis that is not a
science-based system of diagnosis. Worse, its physicians are actually referring
patients to this clinic, even though they know that there’s no real evidence
that it works. For example:

   Maged Rizk, a gastroenterologist at Cleveland Clinic who referred Mr.
   McGeehan, says Chinese herbal medicine is still being critically evaluated.
   “In the past it wasn’t even considered seriously,” Dr. Rizk says. “At this
   point there is a thinking, ‘Some of the things we’re doing now aren’t very
   effective. Should we really be looking at alternatives a little more
   seriously?’ I think the verdict is still out,” he says.

So, basically, Dr. Rizk seems to be arguing that because current science- and
evidence-based treatments for some conditions don’t work as well as we would
like we should try treatments with no evidence to support them.

I think I know what’s going on here. I could be wrong, but it sure smells like
it. Basically, what we are talking about here are patients with chronic
conditions, particularly conditions causing chronic symptoms (there is, for
instance, a patient in the story who suffers from chronic nausea), that are not 
well controlled or well treated with current science- and evidence-based
medicine. Understandably, doctors become almost as frustrated as patients when
they can’t alleviate their patients’ symptoms. They feel powerless. It’s not
surprising that there is a strong temptation to fob the patient off on someone
else. It’s also very easy—seductively so—to rationalize a referral to someone
like Roofener based on the rationale that maybe she can do something. And if she
can’t at least the patient will be someone else’s problem for a while. I know, 
I know. That’s harsh, but it’s a bit more complicated than that. Few doctors
actually want to give up. It’s just that, given an “out” like Roofener’s clinic,
it’s not surprising that even good doctors (you have to be good to be on the
staff of the CCF) might be tempted to take that out.

Still, we rely on institutions like the CCF to be at the cutting edge of
science. We expect that the treatments they offer will be based on the best
available science. We do not expect that institutions like the CCF will embrace 
a prescientific system of medicine that is rooted in what is, in essence, the
Asian variant of the humoral theory of medicine in which disease is attributed
to imbalances in the five elements rather than the four humors, whose treatments
are based on a rationale of somehow channeling or redirecting the flow of a
nonexistent “life energy” that has yet to be detected by science and whose
medicines are impure mixtures of natural products with nothing resembling what
we could consider rigorous evidence of efficacy and safety.

The infiltration of quackademic medicine into medical academia continues apace, 
to our shame as a profession.

Herbal Center at Cleveland Clinic

Steven Novella on April 23, 2014

Link



The infiltration of pseudoscience and simply bad medicine into mainstream
medicine continues. Hospitals are an easy breech point because they are run by
administrators who may have more talent and interest in marketing than in
science. Many hospitals in my area, for example, proudly display their
“integrative” centers, offering nutrition advice and massage alongside more
dubious offerings, such as reflexology and reiki.

So-called “alternative” treatments are tempting because they are often not
covered by insurance, and so patients will have to pay cash for them, and they
are often inexpensive to run – so they are a nice cash cow for hospitals.

The Wall Street Journal reports another, more serious, chapter in this
infiltration – the opening of Chinese herbal clinics, specifically in the
Cleveland Clinic. The article itself is reasonably balanced, and lacks the
gushing anecdotes that most such pieces have, but could certainly have been more
hard-hitting in terms of the serious problems with herbal medicine.

Herbal treatments are interesting from a scientific point of view because they
are perhaps at the most plausible end of the CAM spectrum. The WSJ article would
have benefited from stating explicitly that herbs are drugs. Their actions in
the body are entirely pharmacological. This fact is often missed by proponents
and in discussions of herbal remedies. They are drugs.

Herbs, however, are drugs that have not been adequately studied, whose active
ingredients may not be known, that contain many chemicals, with unknown
pharmacokinetics, dynamics, and drug-drug interactions. Dosing is nearly
impossible to standardize. Bioavailability is anyone’s guess. And quality
control is highly dubious. Other than that, they’re great.

I’m not sure why anyone would choose to take a poorly studied, dirty, variable, 
and poorly regulated combination of drugs with unknown efficacy. The answer, of 
course, must be marketing. People think herbs are “natural,” an irrelevant
feature that does nothing to mitigate the many downsides of these dirty drugs.
They are also reassured by the fact that they are part of an ancient and exotic 
medical system, the argument from antiquity. Of course, bloodletting also
survived for thousands of years.

Plants are a perfectly reasonable source of potential pharmacological compounds.
Much of the low-hanging fruit, of course, has already been picked. There is
also huge incentive on the part of pharmaceutical companies to find other useful
compounds in plants, and herbal remedies might provide a clue to potential
targets. What’s left over are the dregs, what is now marketed as “herbal
medicine.”

Many of the most popular herbal products, those that have been studies in
rigorous clinical trials, have been found not to work. Gingko biloba does not
work for memory or dementia. Echinacea does not work for the cold or flu. Black 
cohosh does not work for menopausal symptoms. Saw palmetto does not work for
benign prostatic hypertrophy.

Perhaps the best candidate for an effective herbal remedy is St. John’s wort for
depression. Apparently there is some anti-depressant effect from this herb, but
only if you speak German (German studies are much more favorable than studies
from other countries). Otherwise the benefits are mild and inconsistent. This is
not surprising because St. John’s wort contains MAO inhibitors, which have a
known antidepressant effect. They also have serious drug-drug interactions.

There are other herbs with promising preliminary results – but as readers of SBM
know well, preliminary results are very unreliable and not predictive of the
outcome of large rigorous trials.

The notion that herbs are somehow magically safe is very insidious. They are
drugs with all the potential toxicity and drug-drug interactions of drugs.
Perhaps they have the virtue, because their active ingredients are not purified,
of generally having low doses of the chemicals they contain, but that cuts both
ways, reducing useful effects and side effects alike.

Assuming lack of toxicity is largely based on the relative paucity of studies
looking for toxicity. Toxicity from herbs, however, is not uncommon. Nephropathy
(kidney damage) from Aristolochia, liver damage from kava-containing products, 
and black cohosh has also been linked to liver damage (here is a more extensive 
list of popular herbal products with known toxicities).

Toxicity can occur even when an herbal product is unadulterated and taken as
intended. However, perhaps the biggest problem with the herbal industry is its
poor regulation. There are problems with fungal contamination, mislabeling or
mistranslating of herbs, and heavy metal contamination.

When buying herbal remedies off the shelf they are likely not even to contain
what the label indicates. A recent study found that:

   Most (59%) of the products tested contained DNA barcodes from plant species
   not listed on the labels. Although we were able to authenticate almost half
   (48%) of the products, one-third of these also contained contaminants and or 
   fillers not listed on the label. Product substitution occurred in 30/44 of
   the products tested and only 2/12 companies had products without any
   substitution, contamination or fillers. Some of the contaminants we found
   pose serious health risks to consumers.

Therefore, even when a clinical trial, using carefully prepared and verified
herbal preparations, finds some potential benefit, you cannot assume that a
commercial product based on that herb will have the same effect. You may not
even be getting the herb you think you are getting.

In his latest book, Paul Offit tells the story of attempting to regulate herbal 
product use in his hospital. Eventually he settled for one criterion, that the
manufacturers provide documentation of what is actually in the products. They
refused to do this. One has to wonder why.

How does an herbal clinic work in practice? The WSJ reports about the Cleveland 
Clinic, when asked for something for inflammation:

   “Absolutely,” responded Ms. Roofener. “This is for pain, for digestion, for
   inflammation, all of the above,” she said, handing Ms. Lunka a bottle with
   capsules of an herbal combination called Xiao Yao San, which translates as
   free and easy wanderer. The capsules include about eight different herbs,
   including licorice, mint leaf and white peony root.

Not only does the preparation contain all the unrefined chemicals of a single
herb, but a combination of many herbs. They also report:

   At the Cleveland Clinic’s herbal center, new patients are given a one-hour
   consultation that may include a battery of questions (How’s your sleep? Body 
   temperature? Ringing in your ears? Headaches?), a physical examination of the
   tongue, and the traditional Chinese method for pulse-taking (three fingers
   on each wrist to check different pulses corresponding to various organ
   systems). They are asked to sign a waiver acknowledging that “herbal
   supplements are not a substitute for a medical diagnosis.”

So – herbal remedies are not real medicines that treat actual diseases. They are
just claimed to alleviate symptoms – without, of course, any evidence of
efficacy except for the anecdotal experience of the practitioner. Pulse
analysis, by the way, is nothing but a medical cold reading, not unlike
iridology or any other bogus diagnostic method.

Conclusion

We advocate for high standards of science within medicine because that is the
only way to offer patients the best chance of safe and effective treatments. It 
is also the only way to give proper informed consent, which requires
transparency and reliable information.

It is a scandal that a hospital would offer a medical service to their patients 
that is not based on the best science has to offer, is based on numerous
deceptions and misrepresentations, logical fallacies, and poor methods. In fact,
they make patients sign wavers that essentially say that what they are
providing is not real medicine.

Only the insanity of brilliant marketing can pull off such a deception.

            The Annals of Internal Medicine Qualifies for Fail Blog.

                                  Mark Crislip

                                      Link

As most readers of the blog know, I am mostly an Infectious Disease doc. I spend
my day diagnosing and treating infections and infectious complications. It is, 
as I have said before, a simple job. Me find bug, me kill bug, me go home. Kill 
bug. It is the key part of what I do everyday, and if there is karmic payback
for the billions of microbial lives I have erased from the earth these past 25
years, my next life is not going to be so pleasant. I will probably come back as
a rabbit in a syphilis lab.

It is always fun when my hobby, writing for SBM, crosses paths with my job. This
month the Annals of Internal Medicine published “Oseltamivir Compared With the 
Chinese Traditional Therapy Maxingshigan–Yinqiaosan in the Treatment of H1N1
Influenza. A Randomized Trial.”

I though big pharma was good at coming up with names I do not know how to
pronounce. If someone could provide a pronunciation guide in the comments, it
would be ever so helpful, so I will not have to embarrass myself when this entry
becomes a Quackcast. Dr. Hall wrote about this article on Tuesday, and I have
avoided reading her post until this one is up, so there may be overlap in what
is discussed.

What is Maxingshigan–Yinqiaosan (MY)? Twelve herbs, one better than the Colonel 
(and speaking of pronunciation, why is it pronounced “kernel”?) but lacking the 
spices. It contains

   zhimahuang (honey-fried Herba Ephedrae), 6 g; zhimu (Rhizoma Anemarrhenae),
   10 g; qinghao (Herba Artemisiae Annuae), 15 g; shigao (Gypsum Fibrosum), 30
   g; yin- hua (Flos Lonicerae Japonicae), 15 g; huangqin (Radix Scutellariae), 
   15 g; chaoxingren (stir-baked Semen Armeniacae Amarum), 15 g; lianqiao
   (Fructus Forsythiae), 15 g; bohe (Fructus Forsythiae), 6 g; zhebeimu (Bulbus 
   Fritillariae Thunbergii), 10 g; niubangzi (Fructus Arctii Tosum), 15 g; and
   gancao (Radix Et Rhizoma Glycyrrhizae), 10 g.

Quite the melange of products. Could there be antiviral or immunomodulating
molecules in such a hodgepodge? Certainly. There is no a priori reason that
Maxingshigan–Yinqiaosan would, or would not, have efficacy against influenza or 
its complications.

The reasons to test MY are partly appeals to antiquity, “Traditional Chinese
medicine has been used to treat seasonal influenza for thousands of years,” plus
a reference that, upon searching, does not contain the word influenza. Or
pneumonia. Or respiratory tract infection.

You have to wonder, when you are in the second paragraph of the introduction and
looking up the primary sources and they do not match the text, just how careful
the researchers and the editors of the journal are. It’s the Annals. Not very. 
Which is why my subscription lapsed. And, to demonstrate just how infantile I
can truly be, when I discuss the journal with residents, I pronounce it as if it
had one ‘n’. But do not accidentally type in the url at work with Annals
spelled with one ‘n’; I discovered our firewall filter has an Anals.org
weakness.

In Europe, pandemic influenza has been recognized for perhaps 500 years: “Then
suddenly, in July and August 1510, a ‘gasping oppression’ with cough, fever, and
a sensation of constriction of the heart and lungs began to rage, seemingly
everywhere at once.” And local flu has been known for maybe 650 years. Given
those numbers, “thousands of years” seems a wee bit of hyperbole, especially
when the reference doesn’t support the assertion. And as best I can tell from
the Googles, no influenza was reported in China until the 1800s, and given
traditional diagnostic testing modalities, I doubt they were looking at patterns
of disease that would be identified today as influenza.

Then they say

   In a recent meta-analysis of 31 randomized clinical trials including 5514
   cases of influenza, the authors concluded that TCM had significantly
   increased clinical efficacy compared with placebo or no intervention.

And that analysis was? A systematic review of chuanhuning for acute respiratory 
tract infections. Chinese Archives of Traditional Chinese Medicine.
2007;25:2200-3.

The abstract said “There were 31 RCTs with 5514 cases were involved.” 5514 cases
of acute respiratory tract infections, not 5514 cases of influenza.  Although I
may be slapped down for this, as the original is in Chinese and there is
nothing on the Pubmeds relating to chuanhuning.

Looking for the primary references of the systematic review as best as I could
given the language issues, the Googles find “etiological diagnosis by clinical
experiments and tissue civilization experiments show namely the product of
inactivated influenza virus A type Ⅰ, Ⅲ type A, pneumonia, adenovirus (Adv) Ⅲ
type, Ⅳ type, intestinal syncytial virus and respiratory syncytial virus (Rsv)
have inactivation” and the few trials I could locate were for a hodgepodge of
viral and other upper and lower respiratory infections.

Chuanhuning is not in the current regimen to be tested, and the authors of the
systemic review mention “the evidence is not strong due to the general poor
methodological quality.”

The argument, not supported by the references, for testing MY is: product A may 
work for influenza, so let’s try an entirely different product for influenza.
Could the editors of the Annals be doing a worse job at reading the papers in
their journals?

They then mention “Modern pharmacologic studies demonstrated that some TCM
formulas had antiviral and immunomodulating effects (13, 14).” Reference 13 is
Chen N, Ren L. [Modern pharmacology research and clinical use of max-
ingshigan]. Academic Journal of Guang Dong College of Pharmacy. 2004;545-6. and 
reference 14 is Huang JM, Chen DP, Yang LP. [The immunomodulating effects of
maxingshigan on asthma mice models]. Journal of Fujian Traditional Chinese Med- 
icine. 2003;34:38-9. At least both references have maxingshigan in the title,
but whether the content matches the assertions, well, let’s say their
credibility has not been demonstrated.

Of course, no study of “Eastern” medicine would be complete without the appeal
to popularity:

   During the early days of the 2009 H1N1 influenza A pandemic, the popular
   herbal formula maxingshigan–yinqiaosan was used widely by TCM practitioners
   to reduce symptoms.

Years ago, at conference, one of my attendings was being detailed about a new
antibiotic, and the rep finished up with “and it is popular in Europe.” To which
my attending replied “So was Hitler for a while.” A pre-Interweb version of
Godwin’s Law.

Searching for Maxingshigan–Yinqiaosan in the Pubmeds yields little but the
intriguing, yet unavailable, Two hundred and thirty-five cases of high fever
caused by exopathogen treated with yinqiao maxing shigan tang.

I went through the tedium of searching each component of MY in the Pubmeds and
its relationship to influenza and found nothing of note.

So the reason for the study, really, is that people were using it. Let’s see if 
it really works.

They randomized people with mild PCR proven influenza to

   Oseltamivir, 75 mg twice daily; maxingshigan– yinqiaosan decoction (composed 
   of 12 Chinese herbal medicines, including honey-fried Herba Ephedrae), 200 mL
   4 times daily; oseltamivir plus maxingshigan–yinqiaosan; or no intervention 
   (control). Interventions and control were given for 5 days.

   Primary outcome was time to fever resolution. Secondary outcomes included
   symptom scores and viral shedding determined by using real-time reverse
   transcriptase polymerase chain reaction.

It was not blinded, only a small flaw given the endpoint, and most patients did 
not receive an intervention until relatively late in the disease, when the
impact would be lessened

   In our study, the median time from onset of illness to randomization was 34.5
   hours; 23.2% of patients presented 48 to 72 hours after the onset of
   symptoms.

Sooner is better with the treatment of all acute infections, and given the delay
in therapy, they are approaching a natural history of disease study more than a
therapeutic intervention study.

They found

   Significant reductions in the estimated median time to fever resolution
   compared with the control group (26.0 hours [95% CI, 24.0 to 33.0 hours])
   were seen with oseltamivir (34% [95% CI, 20% to 46%]; P < 0.001),
   maxingshigan–yinqiaosan (37% [CI, 23% to 49%]; P < 0.001), and oseltamivir
   plus maxingshigan– yinqiaosan (47% [CI, 35% to 56%]; P < 0.001). Time to
   fever resolution was reduced by 19% (CI, 0.3% to 34%; P < 0.05) with
   oseltamivir plus maxingshigan–yinqiaosan compared with oseltamivir. The
   interventions and control did not differ in terms of decrease in symptom
   scores (P < 0.38).

The actual numbers: control had fever for 26 hours, oseltamivir for 20, the MY
16 and the oseltamivir plus MY was 15, in real numbers the results are almost
clinically irrelevant. And the treatment groups were randomized later than the
no treatment group, and temperatures measurement started at randomization. So if
the treatment groups have a head start in temperature measurement, that wipes
out at mostly of the therapeutic advantage doesn’t it? Most of the difference
due to when they started counting.

If you measure from symptom onset to resolution of fevers, you get

Control: 56 hours

MY: 51 hours

Oseltamivir: 55 hours

MY plus oseltamivir: 47 hours

It is the duration of illness that is clinically the important feature, so even 
if the effects are statistically significant, the difference is not clinically
significant.  And besides fever, there was no improvement in other symptoms: “No
difference in any individual symptom, including cough, sore throat, headache,
or fatigue, was observed after treatment.” Fever often remits before other
symptoms of influenza, and given the duration of illness, from a clinical
perspective, none of the interventions did much of anything.

As to viral shedding

   the median viral titer in throat swabs at enrollment was similar, and a rapid
   decrease in virus shedding was observed in all 4 groups (P < 0.001) Changes 
   in virus shedding from baseline to day 5 did not differ by treatment group (P
   < 0.69 for time-by-treatment interaction).

Both baseline swab specimens and specimens collected on days 1 to 5 for
evaluation of virus shedding were available for 148 participants. Compared with 
the 262 patients without viral shedding measurements, these 148 patients had
lower symptom scores; a lower proportion of cough, headache, and fatigue; lower 
leukocyte counts; and longer time from onset of illness to randomization.
Therefore, the virus shedding results from these 148 patients were not
representative of the entire study population

But when you look at the actual curves,

Link

there is separation between the oseltamivir containing regimens and those
without, with the MY closer to the control. It suggests that the effect of MY is
anti pyretic/immunomodulatory rather than antiviral. And given that the control
group started the PCR measurements earlier as well, yo would expect slighly
higher viral levels. If there is an effect from MY, it is a small one, and it
appears to be less antiviral and more antipyretic, although the authors state

The study could not determine whether the observed effects of
maxingshigan–yinqiaosan were due to anti- pyretic or antiviral effects.

I bet the former.

Given that the patients were all healthy, had mild illness and were treated
relatively late in the disease, I would expect to any intervention to have a
modest effect, and theirs was modest indeed.

Non sequitur central continues in the discussion where they discuss potential
mechanisms of action and note

   During the outbreak of the severe acute respiratory syndrome in Hong Kong,
   Poon and associates (24) showed that 2 herbal formulas had immunomodulating
   effects. In their study of healthy volunteers, they found that the CD4 –CD8
   ratio of T lymphocytes was significantly increased after participants
   received Chinese herbal medicine for 14 days (24).

The reference, Immunomodulatory Effects of a Traditional Chinese Medicine with
Potential Antiviral Activity: A Self-Control Study, states

   We investigated the immunomodulating effects of an innovative TCM regimen
   derived from two herbal formulas (Sang Ju Yin and Yu Ping Feng San) for
   treating febrile diseases.

I am limited by language, variability in TCM medications and lousy editors at
the Annals, but apparently Sang Ju Yin is Mulberry & Chrysanthemum Pills and Yu 
Ping Feng San, or Jade Screen Teapills, and neither have any ingredients in
common with MY.

Sang Ju Yin and Yu Ping Feng San has to do with the mechanism of MY how? That is
the kind of discussion the Annals has for its readers: randomness. Linear,
logical thought appears passé these days. The authors seem to think all TCM are 
the same, and there is no reason to differentiate one TCM over another for
mechanism of action: “More studies are needed to clarify the mechanisms of TCM.”

Me and my reductionist Western approach, thinking that different products, with 
different constituents, are actually different, with perhaps different,
unrelated mechanisms of action, if they have a mechanism of action at all.

There were articles, again not available in English, that demonstrate in vitro
effects of shigan on influenza A. That the references indeed demonstrate what
the authors purport, well, I will have to trust the researchers and the editors 
of the Annals. They have done a fine job to date.

It would appear from one abstract, that 31.25 mg/ml of maxing shigan had
multiple effects on viral replication in the test tube and that 31.25 mg/ml was 
the optimal concentration of the product.

In the study patients received 200 mL of MY orally 4 times daily. So for fun,
assume 100% bioavailabilty. Lets assume 31.25 mg/ml in the preparation the
patients received. Who knows. 200 x 31.25 is 6250 mg. A human volume is about
70,000 mls.  Assuming a uniform volume of distribution, that gives the
concentration of MY at 0.089 mg/ml. Seems a wee bit below the needed MIC. Of
course, a lot of assumptions in the calculation, mostly around the concentration
of the medication, its absorption and the volume of distribution. The first and
third were guesses, the second was probably a large overestimation (medications
are rarely 100% absorbed). The real concentrations of MY are probably much less
that 0.089 mg /ml.

50% alcohol will also inactivate influenza in vitro. Outside of a frat party,
those levels are not achievable in vivo. Always the issue of going from in vitro
to in vivo studies

The authors finish up with

   In conclusion, in previously healthy young adults and adolescents who
   presented with uncomplicated 2009 H1N1 influenza A virus infection, therapy
   with oseltamivir and maxingshigan–yinqiaosan (alone and in combination) was
   associated with faster resolution of fever. Maxingshigan– yinqiaosan can be
   used as an alternative treatment of H1N1 influenza A virus infection when
   oseltamivir is not available.

and the abstract, which is all most people will read, ends with

   These data suggest that maxingshigan– yinqiaosan may be used as an
   alternative treatment of H1N1 influenza virus infection

So here is where I am going to get picky.

My take, looking at the PCR data, is that MY does not treat influenza. There is 
no real change in the PCR viral concentrations. When you treat an infection, you
kill it, or at least prevent it from reproducing. They did not treat influenza,
they treated an epiphenomena of influenza, the fever. Treating fever is not the
same as treating infection. And of course, it looks like the effect is an
artifact of when they started counting, and given the lack of response of other 
symptoms, this is a mostly a natural history of influenza study.

And should you treat fever? Well, no. There is an interesting literature, with
many a methodological issue, that suggests treating a fever is not a good idea.

In animal models and human studies, treating a fever is associated with
prolonged illness and, depending on the study, increased mortality. There is no 
definitive study, but an hour of perusing the literature will show an
interesting pattern. Fevers are usually good. Treating fevers is usually bad.

Fevers are an important and ancient response to infection. Most parts of the
immune system function better at higher temperatures. Sometimes the patient
lacks the physiologic reserve to cope with the metabolic demands of fever (poor 
cardiac or lung function) and strokes and heart attacks may be larger if the
patient has a fever. So sometimes you need to treat fevers. But for most acute
infectious diseases that have been evaluated, patients  and animals that have
their fever suppressed are have a more prolonged illness, more complications, or
increased mortality.

I never treat my kids fevers. They make less noise when they are 102 and will
probably resolve their infection faster if I let the fever go, and that will get
them to school and me to work that much sooner. Of course, when my wife takes
over, she gives them Tylenol. No man is a hero to his valet. Not that my wife is
my valet. It is a saying.

I could find no specific data regarding outcomes in treating influenza
associated fevers, but I expect like most other infections, it would be a bad
idea. And there is always that point in the inflammatory response where the
beneficial effects are overwhelmed by the adverse effects of too brisk a
response: SIRS, sepsis, TSS and the ever popular cytokine storm, although the
fever per se is not issue in those processes.

What annoys, and concerns me at the end, is the confusion between treating
influenza and treating the symptoms of influenza. The first was not
demonstrated, the second perhaps was and is usually a bad idea.

Conclusion

The effects of MY on fever are probably not real, and if real are mostly
clinically irrelevant and probably counterproductive for the treatment of
influenza.

As to the mechanics of the paper (proper use of references, critical thinking), 
if it were from a college student, I would give it a ‘C’.  If it were from a
resident on service? Flunk.

And the Annals? In my professional lifetime they have gone from a first tier
journal to second tier to now? Now, I shed a tear. Almost as funny as Fail Blog.

                      Testing a Chinese Herbal Flu Remedy

                                 Harriet Hall 

                                      Link

During the early days of the 2009 H1N1 influenza A pandemic, the popular herbal 
formula maxingshigan–yinqiaosan was used widely by TCM practitioners to reduce
symptoms. (It’s hard to pronounce and spell, so I’ll refer to it as M-Y.) A new 
study was done to test whether M-Y worked and to compare it to the prescription 
drug oseltamivir. It showed that M-Y did not work for the purpose it was being
used for: it did not reduce symptoms, although it did reduce the duration of one
sign, fever, allowing researchers to claim they had proved that it works as
well as oseltamivir.

“Oseltamivir Compared With the Chinese Traditional Therapy:
Maxingshigan–Yinqiaosan in the Treatment of H1N1 Influenza” by Wang et al. was
published in the Annals of Internal Medicine earlier this month. The study was
done in China, which is notorious for only publishing positive studies. Even if 
it were an impeccable study, we would have to wonder if other studies with
unfavorable results had been “file-drawered.” It’s not impeccable; it’s
seriously peccable.

It was randomized, prospective, and controlled; but not placebo controlled,
because they couldn’t figure out how to prepare an adequate placebo control.
They considered that including a no treatment group compensated for not using a 
placebo control, and that objective temperature measurement could be expected to
get around any bias. It might not: the nurses who took the temperatures were
blinded to the study, but the patients were not. It’s possible that those who
knew they were getting M-Y might have believed in it and their bias might have
somehow subtly influenced data gathering so that M-Y appeared more equivalent to
oseltamivir than it actually was.

There are other problems besides the lack of blinding.

Background

It’s always fun to read the introduction section of a CAM paper. It gives
insight into the researchers’ beliefs and frequently includes footnote
references to studies that don’t say what they seem to think they say. In their 
introduction, Wang et al. say

   Traditional Chinese medicine has been used to treat seasonal influenza for
   thousands of years.

The article they reference to support that claim doesn’t support it. It is an
opinion piece about “Chinese medicinal materials and their interface with
Western medical concepts.” It’s not a historical study, and it doesn’t directly 
address influenza . Anyway, thousands of years ago TCM did not recognize
influenza as a unique disease entity or have any way of diagnosing it
accurately.  And TCM does not equate to M-Y.

Next they cite a meta-analysis that they say showed the effectiveness and safety
of TCM, but it was not about flu or about M-Y. It was about studies of common
cold patients with wind-cold syndrome. It concluded

   TCM new drugs developed in recent years for preventing and treating common
   cold have better therapeutic effects than the old ones. They can accelerate
   the onset time of lowering body temperature and improve the symptoms of
   common cold without any significant adverse reactions. Because of lacking of 
   placebo-controlled and blank-controlled studies, further high-quality trials 
   are still needed.

The abstract is too garbled to understand, but it indicates that if there was
any significant effect of “TCM” it was very small in magnitude. Saying that a
study of TCM for colds shows that M-Y works for influenza is like saying that a 
study of Western medicine for pneumonia proves that penicillin works for
bronchitis.

Design

   the decision about whether to initiate antiviral therapy is individualized on
   the basis of the clinician’s judgment and on what is known about the
   benefits of therapy. Therefore, it was ethically possible for us to include a
   control group that received no intervention.

If individual decisions are ethically acceptable, how can it be ethical to
decide that a whole random group of patients will be consigned to treatment or
no-treatment groups?

The new study had over 400 subjects and few dropouts. Patients were admitted to 
the hospital and followed closely. Viral studies confirmed H1N1 influenza. There
were 4 arms: M-Y, oseltamivir, M-Y plus oseltamivir, and a no treatment group. 
Endpoints were both objective (temperature and viral shedding) and subjective
(reported symptoms).

Results

Time to resolution of fever was significantly shorter in all treatment groups
than in no-treatment control group, and was comparable in the different
treatment groups. There were no differences between groups on symptoms or viral 
shedding.  There was no difference in acetaminophen use between groups. Patients
in the control group were more likely to be prescribed antibiotics, even though
they acknowledge that physicians often respond inappropriately to persistent
temperature elevations by administering antibiotics that are not called for in
that situation.  If they knew that, why did they allow it to happen?

Complications like pneumonia were rare and not significantly different between
groups.

Side effects were incomprehensibly rare: Two patients reported nausea and
vomiting while taking M-Y and there were no side effects in the other groups.
This is puzzling, since studies of oseltamivir have shown a 9-10% incidence of
nausea and vomiting with the drug and 3-6% with placebo.

They interpreted their findings as showing that maxingshigan–yinqiaosan does not
act as an antiviral, whereas the benefit of oseltamivir derives entirely from
its antiviral activity. Their data do not justify that interpretation.

The Mixture

When herbs are mixed, I always wonder how they decided which ones to use. In
this case, maxingshigan studies have shown immunomodulatory effects, but what
about the other 11 ingredients?

M-Y is a mixture of 12 herbs. In this study the herbs were tested to rule out
contamination with heavy metals, insecticides, and microbes. The need for such
testing brings up a concern: when patients buy M-Y on the market, what are they 
getting?

The 12 ingredients, as far as I could determine from the information in the
paper, correspond to ephedra, anemarrhena rhizome, artemisia (wormwood), gypsum,
honeysuckle, skullcap, bitter apricot kernel, forsythia fruit, peppermint,
fritillaria bulb, burdock, and licorice. Only about half of these are listed in 
the Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database. For most of these, flu is not
listed as an indication (although allergies and respiratory infections are
sometimes mentioned), and most say there is insufficient evidence to rate safety
or to rate effectiveness for any indication. Some include warnings: ephedra is 
unsafe and is illegal in the US; apricot kernels are a source of cyanide. It is 
hard to imagine a rationale for combining these particular 12 ingredients for
any purpose, much less for flu. Maybe I lack imagination.

An appendix that lists Chinese and English names for the ingredients includes
this helpful explanation:

   Chinese herbs are usually prescribed in formulas that contain “king”
   medicines, which provide the strongest therapeutic action; “minister”
   medicines, which assist the “king” medicine in its therapeutic actions;
   “assistant” medicines, which aid the “minister” medicine in treating a lesser
   aspect of the disease; and “ambassador” medicines that are intended to
   reduce the toxicity of the other medicines in the formula or guide the
   formula to the targeted organ or region of the body.

They offer no justification for which ingredient has which of these purposes or 
how they knew whether they actually work for those purposes. These terms are not
scientifically meaningful and are unexpected in a journal like the Annals of
Internal Medicine.

Conclusion

Most patients with influenza recover with no specific treatment; but oseltamivir
is often used with the goals of faster recovery, reduced symptoms and fewer
complications. It is also used to prevent influenza. But it is far from perfect.
Studies have shown that it reduced the risk of pneumonia and of pneumonia,
fever, and viral shedding. Its symptom-reducing effects are not very robust, and
it can have some side effects. It would be nice if we had a safer, more
effective remedy.

They concluded:

   Maxingshigan–yinqiaosan can be used as an alternative treatment of H1N1
   influenza A virus infection when oseltamivir is not available.

I can’t really argue with that, but why not try to make oseltamivir available?
Why not try to insure the purity and safety of available preparations of M-Y?
More importantly, why not try to figure out what each of those 12 herbs does,
whether all 12 are essential for its effectiveness, and whether worrisome
ingredients like ephedra and cyanide could be eliminated?

It is admirable that TCM practitioners are trying to study their remedies
scientifically; but this study doesn’t convince me that M-Y offers any advantage
over oseltamivir, or even that it is a reasonable substitute.

The Questionable Ethics of Medical Grade Nonsense: Chinese Herbal Medicine and
Kawasaki Disease

A toddler in China with Kawasaki disease was treated with herbs and potions
rather than science, and is extremely lucky to have survived without serious
complications.

Clay Jones on July 10, 2020

Link



Two months ago I wrote a post on Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in Children
(MIS-C), a rare condition associated with SARS-CoV-2 that causes severe
inflammation throughout the body three to four weeks after an often-unrecognized
infection. This week I diagnosed my first case of MIS-C, and when thinking
through a differential for a patient presenting with persistent high fever,
diffuse rash, and conjunctivitis was reminded of a case report I had come across
a while ago and had tucked away for a possible future discussion. It’s bad.
Real bad. I’m talking screaming at the computer monitor and then having to
explain to my kids that everything is okay, Daddy is just upset at some doctors 
in China, kind of bad.

Published in the European Journal of Integrative Medicine last year, the report 
describes the treatment of a 17-month-old child suffering from Kawasaki disease 
(KD) with Chinese Herbal Medicine. Herbal therapy in this case was used instead 
of a science-based drug therapy proven to be safe and effective in preventing a 
deadly potential complication. The treatment strategy employed and ultimately
recommended by the authors of the paper amounts to an abomination of disregard
for the child’s well-being and is an egregious violation of ethical principles
fundamental to the practice of medicine.

My patient with probable MIS-C reminded me of this case report on treating
Kawasaki disease with quackery because KD and MIS-C share many features. In
fact, KD is one of the most important conditions we consider when evaluating
pediatric patients with prolonged fever and systemic inflammation because a
delay in appropriate treatment can be catastrophic.

Allow me to explain in a bit more detail.

What is Kawasaki disease?

The most common cause of acquired heart disease in developed countries, KD is a 
febrile illness in children that is associated with inflammation of medium-sized
arteries (vasculitis) throughout the body. Of particular concern is the
possible involvement of the coronary arteries that deliver oxygenated blood to
cardiac muscle. The underlying cause of KD is a mystery, and despite decades of 
study and refinement of our understanding of the clinical course, there is no
established diagnostic test.

The diagnosis of KD is based on a set of criteria that any pediatrician or
family doctor should know by heart. In addition to these historical and exam
findings there are also a host of laboratory and imaging studies that can
support a clinical suspicion. And while the diagnosis of so-called “classic” KD 
can be fairly straightforward, many cases are “incomplete” and clinical judgment
must be relied upon. So, sadly, despite the fact that our diagnostic criteria
are very purposefully designed to be a bit oversensitive in order to avoid the
potential tragedy of delayed diagnosis, there are still children who suffer what
are largely preventable sequelae.

KD is a self-limited condition that typically affects children less than 5 years
of age, although it can rarely be seen in older children. This means that the
unremitting fever, painful cracked lips and tongue, widespread rash, swollen and
tender extremities, enlarged neck glands, and red eyes that make up the classic
diagnostic clinical criteria will resolve without intervention, usually within 
10 days of the first fever. Even the infamous extreme irritability seen in these
patients, who are most often less than 3 years of age when hospitalized, will
almost always just go away on its own. The potential problem, and it’s a big
potential problem for these patients, is that even with appropriate treatment 3%
to 5% of children with KD will have involvement of the coronary arteries.
Without treatment, this occurs in a full quarter of patients.

Inflammation of the heart and coronary arteries can weaken the walls of these
vital blood vessels. This weakening will result in mild dilation in most cases, 
but can also lead to giant aneurysms that put a child at particular risk for a
host of acute and chronic cardiac problems. Death can occur months to years
later when the coronary arteries become stiffened, thus decreasing blood flow to
the cardiac muscle and resulting in myocardial infarction (“heart attack”), or 
during the acute phase of the illness when the function of the heart is impaired
or there is an abnormal electrical rhythm.

The first description of KD came in 1967 from Japanese pediatrician Tomisaku
Kawasaki, but it took several years before the link was made between the
diagnosis and coronary artery involvement. It has since been seen in all
geographic regions, however Japanese children are significantly more likely to
be diagnosed than any other group. In the United States, around 1 in 5,000
children under the age of 5 years are hospitalized because of KD every year, but
in Japan that rate is about thirteen times higher.

There is a clear genetic predisposition to developing KD, but there have also
been seasonal peaks as well as increased incidence in localized areas, which
points towards a possible viral etiology. There have also been various bacterial
toxins proposed as candidate triggers. There may in fact be several agents that
trigger a common final pathway in genetically-susceptible children. To date,
however, there is no proven cause.

The standard treatment for KD is intravenous immune globulin, or IVIG, ideally
given within 10 days of the onset of fever. It’s safety and efficacy is well
established even if the exact mechanism of action in treating KD isn’t clear. It
appears to have a general anti-inflammatory effect but it may also bind toxins 
or modulate the adaptive and innate immune response in a variety of ways.
Regardless, it almost always stops the fever and other signs of inflammation
within 24 hours of dosing, and it significantly reduces the risk of coronary
artery complications. It’s an expensive drug, but it is very cost effective
considering the savings of preventing things like heart transplants in toddlers.

One more interesting tidbit on Kawasaki disease. It is one of the very few
conditions for which we actually recommend aspirin in young children, primarily 
for its anti-thrombotic (clot prevention) properties. There isn’t any evidence
that it prevents coronary artery lesions or hastens recovery, however. It is
just a thing that we do because it’s a thing that we have always done.

If a child doesn’t have evidence of coronary artery involvement at the 6-week
check after treatment, aspirin is typically discontinued. Aspirin use has been
linked to a rapidly progressive encephalopathy associated with liver dysfunction
(Reye syndrome) in pre-pubertal children. Although the occurrence of Reye
syndrome in the setting of treating KD with aspirin is incredibly rare, I can’t 
help but be a bit apprehensive every time I prescribe it.

Chinese herbal medicine for Kawasaki disease?

In the case report, an irritable and febrile 17-month-old child was
appropriately diagnosed with KD by a “Western medical physician” based on
clinical diagnostic criteria. This isn’t one of those cases where maybe it was
actually something else. He had 5 days of fever, red eyes without discharge,
swollen hands and feet, inflamed lips and tongue, a diffuse rash, and swollen
neck glands. This diagnosis was also supported by elevated inflammatory markers 
in his blood. Hospitalization was recommended but the family refused and opted
for outpatient herbal treatment by an affiliated traditional Chinese medicine
clinic.

He was prescribed a number of herbal remedies and followed closely by the
clinic. The signs and symptoms of his KD improved over the following several
days, resolving completely by the eleventh day of illness. Two days later the
skin around his fingernails and toenails began to peel, a finding that is alone 
almost diagnostic of KD when it occurs 2-3 weeks after a febrile illness. He had
two ultrasounds of the heart several weeks after his diagnosis that did not
find any involvement of the coronary arteries. 12 months after his diagnosis he 
was healthy and thriving, likely unaware of just how lucky he was.

The authors of the paper, some of which having had the medical training to know 
better, explain Kawasaki disease in the language of TCM. There is a lot of
nonsense about pathogenic heat and toxin battling positive Qi, coagulated
meridians, and something called a phlegm nucleus. When attempting to reconcile
the particular herbal remedies they chose with a more scientific understanding
of the condition, they don’t have much to go on. It’s essentially just rat
models and other preclinical research. Certainly there isn’t anything that would
remotely justify taking the risk that they did, and there is no mention of
providing proper informed consent to the child’s parents. They conclude the
paper by declaring that their approach is safe and effective as an alternative
to IVIG.

Conclusion: Stick to science-based treatment of Kawasaki disease

The child at the center of this case report was extremely lucky. While the odds 
were in his favor because of its self-limited nature, he still faced a 25%
chance of injury to his coronary arteries and all the potential subsequent
adverse outcomes of untreated Kawasaki disease. There is simply no evidence to
support the use of any herbal remedy as a treatment for such a serious
condition.

    2. Standard of care management of KD that is safe and effective was available
      to this child, it just wasn’t given. Also, it wasn’t clear that the
      family, who was essentially thrown under the bus in this report, was even 
      made aware of the risk of not treating their child with IVIG, thus
      violating fundamental ethical principles in the practice of medicine. This
      simply should not have been allowed to happen and the European Journal of
      Integrative Medicine had no business publishing this report.

Liver cancer, naturally

Aristolochic acid, a highly toxic substance naturally found in some traditional 
herbal medicines, may be a significant cause of liver cancer.

Scott Gavura on November 2, 2017

Link


Not all cancers affect all populations equally. Liver cancer is the fifth-most
common cancer worldwide, but the prevalence varies widely. Liver cancer cases
skew heavily to less developed regions of the world, where 83% of cases are
found – it’s over six times more common there than in Northern Europe, for
example. In Asia, the high rates of liver cancer have been linked to hepatitis B
and C, which is widespread, and a proven cause of cancer. And liver cancer
continues to strike Asian American and Pacific Islanders more than any other
American ethnic group as well, where hepatitis continues to circulate in the
population. Now there’s new evidence to suggest that a substance found in some
traditional Chinese medicines may also be causing liver cancer. They’re called
aristolochic acids, and they illustrate, with a substantial body count, that
what’s natural isn’t necessarily healthy or good.

What are Aristolochic acids?

In the early 1990’s a strange cluster of acute, end-stage renal disease appeared
in women in Belgium. It was determined that all had been exposed to the
chemical aristolochic acid (AA) at a weight loss clinic, due to the consumption 
of Chinese herbs which contained natural AA. Approximately one third of the more
than 300 cases have subsequently required a kidney transplant, and cancers of
the urothelial tract in this group have also been widespread. In the Balkans,
low level exposure to AA via flour consumption that contains seeds from
Aristolochia clematitis is believed to be responsible for what is now called
Balkan-endemic nephropathy. Subsequent study that was initiated after the
Belgian case identified that that AA is responsible for tumour development and
for activating destructive fibrotic changes in the kidney. For over a decade now
it has been well established that AA is a nephrotoxin and a powerful carcinogen
with a short “latency period”, in that it causes permanently damage, quickly.
What’s remarkable is that none of this was known until the 1990s despite
“thousands of years” of use as a traditional medicine. As Steven Novella noted
in a past post on aristolochic acid and urinary tract cancer:

   This example just highlights the fact that widespread use of an herbal
   product, or any treatment, is not sufficient to ensure that it is safe, or
   even that it is effective. Common use may be enough to detect immediate or
   obvious effects, but not increased risk of developing disease over time. That
   requires careful epidemiology or specific clinical studies. We know about
   the risks of prescription drugs only because they are studied, and then
   tracked once they are on the market. Without similar study and tracking there
   is simply no way to know about the risks of herbal products. Relying upon
   “generally recognized as safe” is folly.

While herbal remedies that contain AA are now banned in many countries,
AA-induced kidney damage and related cancers continues to appear worldwide. As
AA’s cancer-causing effects have now been widely studied, the distinct way that 
they damage cells has been described as a sort of “signature” that is easily
identifiable in tumour samples. This brings us to this new study of liver
cancers attributed to AA, which have been less closely associated with AA. This 
study used that unique “signature” to look for AA exposure.

Aristolochic acids and liver cancers

There is good evidence to show that the consumption of AA-containing products in
Taiwan has been widespread through the use of prescribed herbal medicines. The 
paper is entitled “Aristolochic acids and their derivatives are widely
implicated in liver cancers in Taiwan and throughout Asia” and it’s from Alvin
Ng and associates, published in Science Translational Medicine in October, 2017.
This was a retrospective analysis of hepatocellular carcinomas (HCC, liver
cancer in lay terms) and patients were included if they (1) had true HCC (2)
there was sufficient DNA available from a sample of the tumour. 98 HCCs from
Taiwan hospitals were studied based on whole-exome sequencing and mutation
identification. They looked for the distinctive way in which AA causes
mutations. The researchers subsequently examined 1,400 HCCs from other regions
in the world. The final analysis was as follows:

1. Taiwan: 78% of tumours had evidence of AA exposure

2. China: 47% of tumours had evidence of AA exposure

3. Southeast Asia: 29% of tumours had evidence of AA exposure

4. Korea: 13% of tumours had evidence of AA exposure

5. Japan: 2.7% of tumours had evidence of AA exposure

6. North America: 4.8% of tumours (in one hospital, 22% of 87 patients, all of
Asian ancestry, had evidence of AA exposure)

7. Europe: 1.7% of tumours had evidence of AA exposure

Here is the global breakdown, with the red portion illustrating the proportion
of tumours that were linked to AA exposure:



Global distribution of mutagenesis associated with aristolochic acid and
derivatives in liver cancer.

Reducing your risk of kidney and liver cancer

Herbal remedies are popular worldwide. In China and other countries in Asia,
there is strong support for, and belief in “traditional” Chinese medicine
despite the fact that it is neither truly traditional (as it is now promoted),
nor particularly effective. This new analysis shows that the use of (or exposure
to) AA is widespread in some parts of the world, and appears to be be a cause
in a  substantial numbers of liver cancers. The authors noted that the presence 
of AA-associated cancer does not appear to be declining in Taiwan, despite the
banning of some AA-containing herbs in 2003. This may be due to a lag effect
(like cancer and smoking) but may also be due to continued exposure to, or
consumption of, AA-containing products.

If you’re a user of traditional Chinese medicine, avoiding AA is easier said
than done, unless you have impeccable knowledge of herbs, their origins, and the
supply chains you’re getting your products from. I’ve blogged before about TCM,
noting that contamination is common. Mislabelling of products also appears to
be widespread, suggesting that rigorous and credible testing of final products
may be the only way consumers can be assured they’re avoiding AA in the products
they buy. The linkage of AA to kidney damage, and the evolving story of its
cancer-causing potential illustrates that even widespread use of a product for
hundreds (or thousands) of years give no automatic assurance of safety. If it
were not for the Belgian weight loss clinic kidney failure cluster, the
widespread toxicity of AA may not even be known today.

                       An Herbal Cure for Peanut Allergy?

                                 Harriet Hall 

                                      Link

Peanut allergy is uncommon but devastating. Even a tiny trace of peanut can
cause an anaphylactic reaction and death. That’s why labels specify “produced on
shared equipment with nuts or peanuts” or “produced in a facility that also
processes nuts.” There is no effective treatment: patients have to rely on
avoiding peanuts and carrying emergency epinephrine injectors. Parents of
peanut-allergic children live in fear that their child will be inadvertently
exposed at school or at a friend’s house. Wouldn’t it be great if we could fix
it so they could eat peanuts with impunity?

There is a ray of hope. Studies are underway on a Chinese herbal medicine
(FAHF-2) that shows promise. I generally shy away from Chinese herbal remedies, 
because they are marketed without adequate testing and the products are not
quality controlled. The typical course of events is (1) a preliminary study or a
history of use in China, (2) marketing in the U.S. with overblown claims.

This is different.

FAHF-2 has been tested in a mouse model in well-designed studies at reputable
U.S. institutions (Mount Sinai and Johns Hopkins). Research was funded by
private foundations and government grants (not by manufacturers or business
interests) and published in a reputable peer-reviewed journal, The Journal of
Allergy and Clinical Immunology. As far as I can find, it’s not being marketed
in the U.S. No claims are being made for it. It hasn’t been tested in humans.
The NCCAM has funded the first clinical trial with an estimated completion date 
of December 2009.

The researchers had been studying a mouse model of allergic asthma and had had
some success with another herbal formula. This prompted them to look into peanut
allergy. Food allergy is not described in the traditional Chinese medicine
(TCM) literature, but there was an herbal formula called Food Allergy Herbal
Formula -1 (FAHF-1) that had been used in Asia for prevention of allergies and
asthma. It contained ling zhi, an herb that had anti-inflammatory and
anti-allergy properties, and wu mei wan, which had been used to treat
gastrointestinal symptoms. It also contained 9 other herbs.

They tested FAHF-1 on a mouse model of peanut allergy. They found that it
completely blocked the anaphylactic reaction when the allergic mice were
challenged with peanuts. It not only blocked clinical symptoms, but it reduced
mast cell degranulation, histamine release, peanut-specific serum IgE levels,
and Th2 cytokine secretion. They checked the mice for possible toxic effects on 
liver and kidney and for possible immune suppression, and found no
abnormalities.

Two of the ingredients were worrisome. Xi xin is wild ginger, which can contain 
aristolochic acid. Fu zi contains aconite. Both are toxic to humans.
Aristolochic acid was implicated in an epidemic of kidney damage in Belgium from
a contaminated herbal weight loss product. They simplified the mixture by
removing these two ingredients, and called the new formula FAHF-2. They tested
this new formula and found it worked just as well. The effects persisted for
several weeks after treatment was discontinued.

They wondered if using just wu mei or ling zhi alone would work. In preliminary 
studies it appeared that neither was as effective as the whole formula. They
postulated that some kind of synergism was at work. I wondered why they didn’t
try eliminating herbs one by one, starting with the ones they thought were least
likely to contribute. I find it difficult to imagine that all 9 herbs are
necessary for the synergism, especially since they already removed 2 herbs
without making any difference. It’s always possible that one herb might be
acting antagonistically and that removing it might improve the effect.

Lo and behold, in 2008 they did almost what I thought they should. They tested
individual components and found only partial activity in them. They concluded
that the whole shebang was the best thing to use in continued testing.

The formula they are now working with contains:

• ling zhi (ganoderma lucidum), 28.17%

• wu mei (fructus pruni mume), 28.17%

• huang lian (rhizoma coptidis), 8.46%

• ren shen (radix ginseng), 8.45%

• huang bai (cortex phellodendri), 5.63%

• gan jiang (rhizoma zingiberis officinalis), 8.45%

• dang gui (radix angelicae sinensis), 8.45%

• gui zhi (ramulus cinnamomi cassiae), 2.81%

• chuan jiao (pericarpium zanthoxyli bungeanum), 1.41%

They have experimented with different extraction methods and have tried to
minimize the bitter taste.

A clinical trial was approved by the NCCAM and is in progress. It is only a
small preliminary study with 18 subjects. If this trial is successful, they will
go on to larger trials.

Most drugs that enter initial clinical testing never make it to market. I don’t 
have high hopes for this one. It may not have the same effect in humans. It may 
turn out to have harmful side effects. The mouse model may be flawed. One or
more ingredients may be superfluous.

There doesn’t seem to be any rhyme or reason to the particular combination of
nine ingredients. That doesn’t mean it can’t work, but it makes me wonder. How
many evidence-based remedies can you think of that contain multiple herbal
ingredients? I can’t think of any offhand. They thought for a while that PC-SPES
was one. It was a mixture of 8 herbs that appeared to slow the progression of
prostate cancer, but it turned out to be a real fiasco. Double-blind testing
showed it was significantly better than placebo – but only because the
manufacturer had been spiking the mixture with 3 pharmaceutical drugs!
Independent lab analysis of early batches showed significant amounts of
diethylstilbestrol (DES), which is a synthetic estrogen, and indomethacin, a
potent anti-inflammatory drug. Later batches showed that warfarin, a powerful
anticoagulant (blood thinner), had been added to counteract the tendency of DES 
to cause blood clots. The researchers were sincere, but their suppliers were
engaged in deliberate and dangerous hanky-panky.

Whether FAHF-2 pans out or not, I have to applaud the researchers. They didn’t
patent it as a diet supplement and try to sell it to the public. They are doing 
good science. This is the way all herbal medicine claims should be handled, with
stepwise investigation including attempts to isolate effective components.

If it does turn out to work, they’ll have to come up with a snappier name.

Tai Chi versus physical therapy for osteoarthritis of the knee: How CAM
“rebranding” works

David Gorski on May 23, 2016

Link



“Complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), now more frequently referred to 
as “integrative medicine” by its proponents, consists of a hodge-podge of
largely unrelated treatments that range from seemingly reasonable (e.g., diet
and exercise) to pure quackery (e.g., acupuncture, reiki and other “energy
medicine”) that CAM proponents are trying furiously to “integrate” as coequals
into science-based medicine. They do this because they have fallen under the
sway of an ideology that posits a false dichotomy: To practice true “holistic”
and “preventative” medicine, physicians and other health care professionals must
embrace the pre-scientific, pseudoscientific, or anti-scientific ideas about
medicine that underlie much of the “alternative medicine” being “integrated.”

Unfortunately, they’ve been largely successful over the last 25 years or so.
From my perspective, the strategy that has been the most effective in
mainstreaming quack practices as part of “integrative medicine” has been what I 
like to call the “rebranding” of practices that could and should be part of
standard, science-based medicine. I’m referring, of course, to nutrition and
dietary interventions, as well as lifestyle interventions, specifically
exercise. To the extent that standard medicine might have undervalued such
interventions over the past few decades, we practitioners of science-based
medicine might be said, to some extent at least, to have brought this on
ourselves. On the other hand, it is not as though doctors haven’t been advising 
our patients to quit smoking and moderate their drinking and to lose weight
through altering their diet and exercising more for many decades. We do this
because we know it works. For instance, when some naturopathic quack touts
“curing” type II diabetes with a vegan diet plus exercise, we know that can work
because we know that losing weight can normalize blood sugar values in many
cases of type II diabetes. Heck, the Endocrine Society itself even says so,
declaring “lifestyle optimization” as “essential for all patients with diabetes”
and recommending that all patients with type II diabetes “strive to attain and 
maintain an optimal weight through a primarily plant-based diet high in
polyunsaturated and monounsaturated fatty acids, with limited intake of
saturated fatty acids and avoidance of trans fats,” that they lose weight
through physical activity, and get enough rest. A vegan diet just takes that
dietary advice to an unnecessary extreme, and any supplements recommended are
almost always unnecessary.

Yet, through the wonders of “integrative medicine,” these sorts of diet and
lifestyle interventions are “rebranded” as somehow “alternative” or
“integrative” and then wedded to all sorts of quackery, like acupuncture, reiki,
and dubious supplements. This “rebranding” unfortunately allows the
respectability of effective interventions to be commingled with treatments based
on prescientific vitalism or pseudoscience, like acupuncture. Worse, these
science-based interventions end up being blended with the same sort of nonsense.
For instance, I’ve often said that yoga is simply a system of exercise if you
strip it of its mystical ideas of kundalini, which are based in vitalism. Ditto 
Tai Chi. I’ve often noted that exercise, at least gentle exercise, is good for
almost everything, most importantly, general health, and speculated that yoga or
Tai Chi is unlikely to be any better than other forms of exercise that
encourage and develop similar levels of cardiovascular fitness and
musculoskeletal flexibility. But yoga and Tai Chi are “cool,” “hip,” and
“alternative.” So they’re sexier, but probably no more effective than other
similar interventions, as a paper in published in the Annals of Internal
Medicine showed.

Tai chi versus osteoarthritis

Tai Chi, for those of you unfamiliar with it, is a martial art that combines
slow, deliberate, graceful stretching with breathing exercises, relaxation, and 
visualization. I’ve also discussed a seemingly positive study published in the
New England Journal of Medicine looking at Tai Chi as an intervention in
fibromyalgia patients. At the time, I pointed out that fibromyalgia symptoms
could potentially be helped by exercise, and that Tai Chi, therefore, would
appear to be at least as good a candidate exercise regimen as any because of its
gentleness, requirement for control, and relaxation. It is not at all
unreasonable to hypothesize that Tai Chi might benefit patients with
fibromyalgia, as it does appear to benefit some patients with other conditions, 
although not for any reasons of “energy flows” or alterations of the flow of qi.
I was actually underwhelmed, asking “What is ‘alternative’ or ‘complementary’
about any of these findings?”

Similarly, it’s not unreasonable to hypothesize that gentle isometric exercise
might benefit patients with osteoarthritis of the knee, and physical therapy is 
already known to be an effective intervention. That’s why I was interested to
note on the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH)
blog a reference to a study that was described thusly: “Study Shows Tai Chi and 
Physical Therapy Were Equally Helpful for Knee Osteoarthritis.” Of course, NCCIH
sells this study as Tai Chi being “as helpful as physical therapy in reducing
pain and improving physical functioning.” After what I’ve heard from a lot of
integrative medicine advocates touting Tai Chi for all manner of ills, I can’t
help but refer to the study as having found that Tai Chi is no better than
physical therapy. The actual study was published in the Annals of Internal
Medicine by a research group mainly based at Tufts University, along with
recommendations for patients, both as Online First prepublications.

One thing I can’t help but point out here is that one of the key prerequisites
for doing a comparative effectiveness study for two interventions is that both
interventions need to have been validated in randomized clinical trials as being
safe and effective. So it’s only natural to ask whether Tai Chi reaches that
bar. The authors state in their introduction:

   Tai Chi is a multicomponent traditional Chinese mind–body practice that
   combines meditation with slow, gentle, graceful movements; deep diaphragmatic
   breathing; and relaxation (6). Previous studies have indicated that Tai Chi 
   can reduce pain and improve physical and psychological health among patients 
   with chronic rheumatic disorders, such as rheumatoid arthritis and
   fibromyalgia (7–13). In our previous randomized trial, participants with knee
   osteoarthritis who completed 12 weeks of Tai Chi showed greater improvements
   in pain, physical function, depression, and health status compared with an
   attention control group (12). A 2013 updated meta-analysis of 7 studies that 
   included 348 participants with osteoarthritis showed significant reductions
   in pain and improvements in physical function after 8 to 24 weeks of Tai Chi 
   training compared with a waiting list, attention control, or usual physical
   activity (14).

   Those prior trials suggested that Tai Chi could provide a practical exercise 
   regimen with an integrative mind–body approach to manage knee osteoarthritis.
   The physical component provides exercise benefits that are consistent with
   recommendations for knee osteoarthritis (physical function, balance, and
   muscle strength) (15), and the mind component promotes psychological
   well-being, life satisfaction, and improved perceptions of health (9, 16). To
   date, however, no randomized trials have directly compared Tai Chi and
   standard care treatments. The primary goal of this study was to compare the
   effectiveness of Tai Chi versus a physical therapy regimen among a large
   sample of patients with symptomatic and radiographic knee osteoarthritis who 
   were seen in the clinical setting and followed for 12 months.

The one thing that stands out here is that none of the Tai Chi studies listed
had anything resembling a proper control group. They all compared Tai Chi with
wait list, usual activity, or attention groups, which means, in essence, that
Tai Chi was compared to no specific treatments with physical activity above and 
beyond what patients normally did. The NCCIH itself is less sanguine about the
benefits of Tai Chi for osteoarthritis, summarizing the science, citing a single
small 2009 randomized study funded by the NCCIH that found that Tai Chi was
associated with “improvement in pain and physical function as well as in
depression and health-related quality of life when compared to participants
enrolled in an education and stretching program.”

Personally, although I’m not entirely convinced that Tai Chi is all it’s cracked
up to be for osteoarthritis, it does appear to be a modality worth testing in
comparative effectiveness research.

Tai chi versus physical therapy for knee osteoarthritis: The cage match

So let’s look at the study itself. Its design is pretty straightforward as these
things go: A randomized, single-blind comparative effectiveness trial comparing
standard physical therapy with Tai Chi for 52 weeks. Patients were randomly
assigned to either Tai Chi (2 times per week for 12 weeks) or physical therapy
in a clinical setting (2 times per week for 6 weeks, followed by 6 weeks of
rigorously monitored home exercise). If you want the gory details of the design 
of the clinical trial, they were published in 2014 at BMC Complementary and
Alternative Medicine. The primary outcome measured is pain as estimated by the
Western Ontario and McMaster University (WOMAC) Index pain subscale. Secondary
outcomes measured include WOMAC stiffness and function domain scores, lower
extremity strength and power, physical performance tests, psychosocial
functioning (mental health, self-efficacy, stress, depression, mindfulness, and 
social support), durability of effect after treatment ends, healthcare
utilization, outcome expectation, adherence, and occurrence of adverse events.

The study population consists of 204 people ≥ age 40 who meet the American
College of Rheumatology criteria for symptomatic knee osteoarthritis confirmed
by the study rheumatologist and who have radiographic evidence of knee
osteoarthritis confirmed by a radiologist. Exclusion criteria include prior
experience with Tai Chi or other similar types of complementary and alternative 
medicine such as Qi Gong or yoga, or prior experience with physical therapy
programs for knee OA in the past year; serious medical conditions that limit
their ability to safely participate in either the Tai Chi or physical therapy
programs; any intra-articular steroid injections or reconstructive surgery in
the three months prior to baseline screening on the most severely affected knee 
(study knee); any intra-articular hyaluronic acid injections in the six months
prior to baseline screening; inability to pass the Mini-Mental Status
examination; or inability to walk without a cane or other assistive device for
the entire duration of the baseline assessments. Pregnancy and inability to
speak English were also exclusion criteria.

The interventions to which subjects were randomized included either Tai Chi or
physical therapy. The Tai Chi instructors taught Yang-style Tai Chi, which is
apparently the most popular of the five main styles of Tai Chi and looks like
this:

The Tai Chi taught to the subjects was standardized, and the investigators
condensed the 108 postures of classical Yang style Tai Chi to 10 forms that
could be learned by older subjects with knee osteoarthritis within 12 weeks,
selecting these forms because they are easily learned, represent progressive
degrees of stress to postural stability, and are likely to improve physical
function without unduly stressing the knee joints. In contrast, the physical
therapy sessions consisted of a personalized program developed by one of the
physical therapists after assessment of the diagnostic and physical findings to 
address specific treatment goals developed collaboratively and consistent with
current evidence-based recommendations. After six weeks, the participants
transitioned to an at home exercise program. For both groups, along with primary
and secondary outcomes, changes in medication use were tracked.

Overall, 1,195 patients were prescreened for participation, leading to 282 being
assessed, of which 204 met the eligibility criteria and were randomized. The
mean age was 60 years. Of these, 70% were women, and the racial/ethnic
composition was diverse (53% white). Participants were pretty well-balanced.

Overall, the results are summarized in the graphs below (click to embiggen):

As you can see, most of the differences between Tai Chi and physical therapy are
not statistically significant, and those that are turn out to be small in
magnitude, as you can see. Given that, it’s important to keep in mind that this 
study is only single-blinded. Only the research study nurses, physical function 
assessors, and sponsor personnel were blinded to the treatment assignments,
while the participants, obviously, knew what group they were in, as did the Tai 
Chi instructors and the physical therapists. This led the investigators to
concede:

   Limitations of this research include patients’ awareness of their treatment
   group assignment and preconceived notions of treatment benefit potentially
   influencing their health and functional outcomes. For a study involving
   complex, multicomponent mind–body therapy, searching for and finding a
   feasible, useful, and valid sham comparison group remains challenging, with
   no well-accepted solution (40). Our study was necessarily single-blinded, a
   design with well-known limitations. To try to mitigate the influence of
   preexisting beliefs and expectations about the relative benefits of the
   interventions, we explicitly informed potential participants that the study
   was designed to test the effects of 2 different types of exercise programs.
   By emphasizing equipoise, we hoped to decrease expectations and minimize bias
   by not mentioning Tai Chi specifically. Using the Outcome Expectations for
   Exercise Scale to assess the possibility of bias, we found that participants’
   expectations of benefit from their randomly assigned treatment regimen were 
   similar (Tai Chi, 3.9 [SD, 0.5]; physical therapy, 3.9 [SD, 0.6]).
   Furthermore, total session attendance rates were similar between groups (74% 
   for Tai Chi and 81% for physical therapy).

Of course, the participants knew what they were getting after they were
randomized and could easily have evolved as they continued in their assigned
program over the course of 52 weeks. Personally, I consider the single-blind
nature of the study to be likely enough to explain the two seemingly positive
results found, which were basically the ones most susceptible to placebo
effects. In addition, one glaring weakness in the study that I can’t help but
note is that the subjects using Tai Chi were instructed twice a week for 12
weeks before being on their own, while the physical therapy group only had
therapy with a physical therapist for six weeks before being set loose on a
“monitored” exercise program, whatever that meant. It almost seems as though
clinical trial was set up in a way designed to minimize the effect of physical
therapy relative to Tai Chi. I rather suspect that insurance considerations
might have played a role, as insurance tends to be reluctant to pay for more
than 4-6 weeks of physical therapy for anything, and insisting on more would
have necessitated a funding source to pay for the additional sessions.

Tai chi versus physical therapy: A draw but a victory of rebranding

This study’s results simply reinforce what I’ve been saying all along. For the
most part, gentle exercise and joint mobilization are gentle exercise and joint 
mobilization and the specific form they take doesn’t much matter, as long as
care is taken to make sure they are not potentially injurious. It surprises me
not at all that this study found a course of Tai Chi and physical therapy to be 
basically the same in effectiveness at relieving pain and stiffness due to
osteoarthritis of the knee. Had I known about this trial when it was first
announced, that’s the result I would have predicted.

So what’s the problem?

Here’s the problem. The vitalistic component of Tai Chi is being touted as the
reason why it’s seemingly more effective at alleviating depression. For
instance, see this quote by an “integrative physiotherapist” named Patricia
Ladis in an article about the study:

   “Top factors that determine physical therapy success have been getting 7-9
   hours of sleep while in treatment, and connecting with their physical
   therapist. This is in contrast to “Tai Chi, where you are in an introspective
   space,” she emphasized. “You can be quiet in your mind as you explore and
   focus on the movements of your body.”

   Ladies offered “that is a hugely beneficial thing for healing from pain. A
   quiet mind leads to a quiet body. Similar to the beneficial effects of
   meditation, someone in a daily introspective practice like Tai Chi or Yoga
   can have great health benefits.”

And:

   “Sometimes people can not even endure Tai Chi because any global movement
   hurts, and in those cases physical therapy is crucial,” said Ladis. “Tai Chi 
   is a great movement practice and has been very efficient at restoring
   proprioception and balance that physical therapy aims to accomplish. But it
   is also balancing to the mind and mobilizes the chi (energy) of the body
   which is crucial when we have degenerative changes and as we age. This is why
   this ancient practice is adopted by many and has helped so many. I believe
   for prevention or post physical therapy, Tai Chi can be very beneficial,” she
   added.

No, no, no. If Tai Chi is as effective as physical therapy in relieving pain and
stiffness due to osteoarthritis, it’s because of the exercise, because it
mobilizes the affected joints in a gentle manner. Chi has nothing to do with it,
but, thanks to the rebranding of exercise as somehow “integrative” or
“alternative” through Tai Chi, Qi Gong, or yoga, woo is legitimized, and you get
even orthopedic surgeons characterizing Tai Chi as “more holistic than
traditional physical therapy offered in North America” and going on to say:

   Romeo further explained that “Tai Chi as taught by Tai Chi masters includes a
   very holistic approach to the person, including not only the physical
   requirements, but also the balance in mental health, whole body stability,
   meditation, breathing, and mind-body focus or connection. This helps people
   develop more positive mental attitudes and well-being, which is likely to
   also play a role in overall recovery from the stress musculoskeletal
   impairment.”

No, exercise works, whether it’s Tai Chi, yoga, Qi Gong, or the regimen
developed by a physical therapist. No woo is needed, but that’s not how studies 
like this are reported by CAM advocates.

Unfortunately, “rebranding” works.

      Tai chi and fibromyalgia in the New England Journal of Medicine: An
                          “alternative” frame succeeds

                                  David Gorski

                                      Link

It never seems to fail. I go away for a few days, in this case to combine fun
with pleasure and pleasure with fun by giving a talk to the Chicago Skeptics and
at the same time meeting my brand new (well, by this time three weeks old)
nephew for the first time, and something always happens. Before I get to what
happened, I just want to point out that the talk actually went pretty darned
well. I was utterly shocked that it was pretty much standing room only, with
perhaps 50 people there to hear me. Honestly, don’t you people have anything
better to do on a beautiful Saturday afternoon in August? But, seriously, the
whole thing was a blast, and the assembled skeptics there didn’t even let me off
the hook, as at least a couple of them asked some fairly challenging questions,
one of which, I must admit, I wasn’t prepared for. In any case, my thanks go
out to Dr. Jennifer Newport, skeptical Chicago pediatrician extraordinaire and
organizer of my talk and the party at her apartment afterward. Between the two
events she raised hundreds of dollars for the vaccination drive going on at
DragonCon this weekend, Chicago Skeptics, the Women Thinking Free Foundation,
and CFI-Chicago for inviting me and being such fantastic hosts.

Back to business. Science-based medicine (SBM) business, that is.

What happened while I was away could almost be characterized by the New England 
Journal of Medicine (NEJM) singing “Oops, I did it again.” Three weeks ago, the 
hallowed pages of the NEJM hosted a truly execrably credulous review article
about acupuncture. So bad was the article that it “merited” the incredibly rare 
triple beat-down from this very blog, with posts by Steve Novella, the
ever-irascible Mark Crislip, and myself in rapid succession applying the
clue-by-four. As I was preparing to leave for Chicago on Thursday, I happened to
look at the very latest issue of the NEJM hot off the presses, and what to my
wondering (and watering–it is ragweed season) eyes should appear but an article 
reporting a study on the use of tai chi in treating fibromyalgia. Entitled A
Randomized Trial of Tai Chi for Fibromyalgia, the study comes out of the Tufts
University School of Medicine and the Newton-Wellesley Hospital in Boston and
was carried out by a team led by Chenchen Wang, MD, MPH. Not surprisingly, the
study has gotten a lot of play in the media, for example, in this story in the
L.A. Times, which is at least reasonably restrained, probably because it an AP
wire story by Marilynn Marchione, who has written some excellent articles about 
“alternative” medicine before. Even the usually reliable GoozNews seems smitten 
with this study beyond what it rates, characterizing it as “rare victory for the
National Institute of Health’s National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine and Sen. Tom Harkin (D-IA), who routinely comes under fire 
for pushing funding for these types of studies.”

I’m less impressed. You’ll see what I mean in a few minutes, I hope. First,
however, let’s look at the study itself.

Fibromyalgia, like many chronic conditions, truly sucks. If there’s one
condition or disease (or whatever you want to call it) that is poorly understood
by medical science thus far, it’s fibromyalgia. Indeed, like some diseases that
are also not well understood, there has even been some debate whether or not
fibromyalgia exists as a distinct disease. Although that debate appears to have 
been largely settled in favor of fibromyalgia as a clinical entity,
unfortunately, the pathogenesis and pathobiology of fibromyalgia remain
“incompletely” understood (meaning not well understood at all), and there is
considerable controversy over the precise diagnostic criteria to use to define
the syndrome. The authors of this study describe fibromyalgia thusly:

   Fibromyalgia is a common and complex clinical syndrome characterized by
   chronic and widespread musculoskeletal pain, fatigue, sleep disturbance, and 
   physical and psychological impairment.

“Common and complex” usually means that a lot of people have it; we don’t
understand it; and we don’t have any good treatments for it. An accompanying
editorial by Gloria Y. Yeh, M.D., M.P.H., Ted J. Kaptchuk, and Robert H.
Shmerling, M.D. entitled Prescribing tai chi for fibromyalgia: Are we there yet?
describes fibromyalgia thusly:

   Fibromyalgia is a common and poorly understood pain disorder that
   afflicts an estimated 200 million or more people worldwide.1 The lack of
   objective abnormalities detected on physical examination and standard blood
   and imaging tests has led many physicians to question the existence of this
   disorder.2 However, for those experiencing the pain and other associated
   symptoms (including fatigue, stiffness, and nonrestorative sleep), there is
   little doubt that the condition is real — and so is the need for relief.
   Studies over the past decade suggest that fibromyalgia may be due, at least
   in part, to an alteration in pain sensitivity in the central nervous system.3
   Other potential mechanistic contributors include a genetic predisposition,
   emotional or physical stress, disordered sleep, and neurohormonal
   dysfunction.

These sorts of conditions are the most frustrating of conditions to deal with,
particularly for patients but also for doctors. After all, no one goes into
medicine to tell patients that there’s not much he can do for them; yet that’s
what doctors all too often end up having no choice but to tell fibromyalgia
patients. Not surprisingly, patients are neither happy nor satisfied with this, 
nor should they be. They’re suffering, and they want relief. Also not
surprisingly they’re willing to try almost anything, including the rankest forms
of quackery peddled by unscrupulous quacks.

Let me hasten to add right here that I am most definitely not saying that tai
chi is a rank form of quackery pedaled by unscrupulous quacks. It’s a martial
art that combines slow, deliberate, graceful stretching and isometric exercises 
with breathing exercises, relaxation, and visualization. I was merely using the 
reference to quacks to explain why it’s not surprising that physicians might
consider tai chi as an intervention in patients with fibromyalgia, given that
currently the standard interventions recommended consist of exercise, sleep
hygiene, and medications. Unfortunately, all of these interventions have
problems, particularly the pharmacological interventions, which in general
aren’t all that effective. One might even say that demonstrating their efficacy 
to be greater than that of placebo interventions has been difficult. Although
exercise is helpful in fibromyalgia, it is not known what kind, intensity, or
combination of exercise modalities works, and, of the ones that may work, which 
one works the best. Tai chi, therefore, would appear to be at least as good a
candidate exercise regimen as any because of its gentleness, requirement for
control, and relaxation. It is not at all unreasonable to hypothesize that tai
chi might benefit patients with fibromyalgia, although not for any reasons of
“energy flows” or alterations of the flow of qi.

In this particular study, the design was fairly straightforward and is
summarized below (click for a larger image):

Randomization

Basically, the study examined 66 patients diagnosed with fibromyalgia by the
time randomization was complete, of which 33 were assigned to the tai chi group 
and 33 to a sham group that underwent stretching exercises. The specific tai chi
intervention used for this clinical trial was described thusly:

   The tai chi intervention took place twice a week for 12 weeks, and each
   session lasted for 60 minutes. Classes were taught by a tai chi master with
   more than 20 years of teaching experience. In the first session, he explained
   the theory behind tai chi and its procedures and provided participants with 
   printed materials on its principles and techniques. In subsequent sessions,
   participants practiced 10 forms from the classic Yang style of tai chi18
   under his instruction. Each session included a warm-up and self-massage,
   followed by a review of principles, movements, breathing techniques, and
   relaxation in tai chi. Throughout the intervention period, participants were 
   instructed to practice tai chi at home for at least 20 minutes each day. At
   the end of the 12-week intervention, participants were encouraged to maintain
   their tai chi practice, using an instructional DVD, up until the follow-up
   visit at 24 weeks.

The control intervention consisted of this:

   Our wellness education and stretching program similarly included
   60-minute sessions held twice a week for 12 weeks.19 At each session, a
   variety of health professionals provided a 40-minute didactic lesson on a
   topic relating to fibromyalgia, including the diagnostic criteria; coping
   strategies and problem-solving techniques; diet and nutrition; sleep
   disorders and fibromyalgia; pain management, therapies, and medications;
   physical and mental health; exercise; and wellness and lifestyle
   management.20 For the final 20 minutes of each class, participants practiced 
   stretching exercises supervised by the research staff. Stretches involved the
   upper body, trunk, and lower body and were held for 15 to 20 seconds.
   Participants were instructed to practice stretching at home for 20 minutes a 
   day.

One can certainly argue whether the sham control intervention was an appropriate
sham control or not. It would depend to some extent what sort of stretching
exercises were included, as well as other factors, such as the quality of the
instructional material and the attention paid to the patients by the wellness
education instructor. Also, one might imagine that the self-massage part of the 
tai chi intervention might have some benefit. It’s hard to say.

What one can say about this is that there does appear to be a suspicious
difference between the two groups. Note that the protocol specifies that one tai
chi master with over 20 years of teaching experience instructed the tai chi
group, while multiple members of the research staff did the control instruction.
More worrisome, note that the control group only underwent 20 minutes of
exercise during its 60 minute sessions. It’s not specified how long the tai chi 
group exercised during its 60 minute sessions, but it would not be unreasonable 
to speculate that most of the 60 minute session was spent doing tai chi. Be that
as it may, there was no blinding at all, and it’s a pretty fair bet that the
subjects in the tai chi group knew that they were receiving tai chi.

That problem aside, subjects were evaluated before starting the trial and then
periodically for the severity of their fibromyalgia symptoms. The primary
outcome measure was the change in the score on the Fibromyalgia Impact
Questionnaire, a 100-point scale that estimates intensity of pain, physical
functioning, fatigue, morning tiredness, stiffness, depression, anxiety, job
difficulty, and overall well-being at 12 weeks. Secondary outcomes included the 
FIQ score at each week, as well as a number of other measures of fibromyalgia
severity, chronic pain, and quality of life. Participants continued their
regular medications and treatments, making note of any changes that occurred
during the study period.

The results demonstrated improvement in FIQ scores in the tai chi group from
62.9±15.5 to 35.1±18.8, with an improvement in the control group from 68.0±11 to
58.6±17.6, with a highly statistically significant p-value. Investigators also 
noted improvements in other measures of pain and quality of life, all in favor
of the tai chi group. More patients in the tai chi group had discontinued their 
medications to treat fibromyalgia by the end of the study period, but the
difference was not statistically significant.

As you might expect, this study had a number of limitations. First, it isn’t
very large. Another problem is that it looked at fairly short term outcomes.
Fibromyalgia is a chronic condition for which 12 to 24 weeks do not represent a 
sufficiently long period of time to judge whether any potential responses will
be durable. Previous studies have found that exercise can help fibromyalgia but 
that the effects are not always durable. This is particularly true given that
fibromyalgia, like many chronic pain syndromes, is prone to placebo effects due 
to interventions, regardless of whether they’re effective or not. That’s one
aspect of the condition that makes fibromyalgia so difficult to study.

More importantly, I must reiterate that this study was not double-blind. The
authors justify this lack of blinding by arguing that there is no accepted and
validated sham tai chi intervention. Fair enough. It took many years before
scientists studying acupuncture managed to develop and validate various forms of
sham needles that successfully blinded both patient and practitioner as to
whether they were undergoing “true” or sham acupuncture. The authors also point 
out that investigators told study subjects that tai chi was being tested.
Rather, they told subjects that they were testing the effects of two different
exercise training programs, one of which was combined with education. Fair
enough as well, but whether this “deemphasis” of tai chi worked or not to
minimize expectations and placebo effects is highly arguable. Do the
investigators really think that most of the tai chi group didn’t realize they
were doing some form of “Eastern” martial art? Yeh et al sum up the difficulty
in coming up with an adequate sham intervention for tai chi very well:

   The authors state that they tried to minimize any a priori differences
   between expectations for tai chi and the control intervention, which
   consisted of stretching and health education, and they report that
   expectations in the two groups were similar at baseline. However, it seems
   likely that when a persuasive and enthusiastic teacher of tai chi first
   explained its potential benefits to the class, expectations in this group
   were heightened. The authors dutifully suggest that a sham tai chi
   intervention would have been desirable as a control. Ideally, a placebo
   control matches all aspects of the therapeutic intervention except for the
   “active” element of that intervention. But what is the active element of a
   complex, multicomponent therapy such as tai chi?11 Is it rhythmic exercise,
   deliberate and deep breathing, contemplative concentration, group support,
   relaxing imagery, a charismatic teacher, or some synergistic combination of
   these elements? If so, would the matched control include awkward movements,
   halted breathing, participant isolation, unpleasant imagery, or a tepid
   teacher? Would the resulting sham intervention be credible, valid, or even
   genuinely inactive?

These are all excellent questions. Unfortunately, Yeh et al then strongly imply 
that a “quixotic” search for the “ideal sham” would be a waste of time, which is
rather annoying because such a search doesn’t have to be quixotic, nor would it
be a waste of time. All you have to do is to break down tai chi into its key
elements: the slow, graceful stretching and isometric exercises, the breathing
exercises, the relaxation exercises. If it’s possible to break down tai chi into
its important elements, then it would be possible to determine which aspects of
tai chi are providing the benefit and which are not.

On the other hand, maybe Yeh et al have a point–except that they didn’t go far
enough. I’ll show you what I mean.

Let’s for the moment and for the sake of argument accept the findings of Wang et
al. Let’s say that tai chi is the greatest thing since sliced bread and that it
alleviates fibromyalgia pain and stiffness better than anything we’ve yet come 
up with. Let’s assume all of those things are true, just for the moment and then
think about it. What thought comes to mind to you? I know what thought comes to
mind to me. In fact, I put this thought on a slide that I used when I spoke to 
the assembled throngs of Chicago Skeptics:

Alternative

That’s right. Why on earth is this result “provocative” (as Yeh et al describe
it) or even the least bit surprising? Why on earth is it in the least bit
“alternative” or “complementary”? Stripped to its essence and particularly
stripped of its woo elements about qi, all tai chi is is exercise and
relaxation, and we already know that exercise can be useful for fibromyalgia!
The only question is what type, intensity, and regimen does the most good, and
this study answers that question to the extent that it tells us that an exercise
regimen resembling tai chi seems to work pretty well. Excellent! Science-based 
medicine can build on that! But why is this finding “alternative”? It shouldn’t 
be. Why was this study funded by the National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) and why is it being touted by NCCAM (and GoozNews) 
as a “success”? It’s a study that had no reason to be done at NCCAM. It could
have and should have been funded by the appropriate Institute in the NIH.

As I’ve written time and time again, exercise and relaxation interventions have 
been completely co-opted by the CAM movement as “alternative” when there is no a
priori reason that they should be considered anything other than science-based 
interventions. Just because they are difficult to study doesn’t make them any
less science-based. It just means they are difficult to study and that science
has to work harder to validate them. However, CAM supporters know that co-opting
less controversial modalities with some degree of prior plausibility that have 
no real reason not to fall under the mantle of science-based medicine allows
them to slip the woo in alongside it. The Trojan horse is diet, exercise, and
natural products derived from plants (i.e., herbal medicine). The Greeks jumping
out of the belly of the horse are the woo, including acupuncture, “energy
medicine” (including the “qi” aspect of tai chi), and even homeopathy. It also
helps if the Trojan horse is something “Eastern,” because that’s so much cooler 
than ancient Western medicine, such as leeches and trying to balance the four
humors, although apparently homeopathy, as German and therefore “Western” as it 
is, is still “cool enough.”

When it comes to the infiltration of quackademic medicine into medical academia,
language and how various “alternative” or “complementary” treatment modalities 
are framed are everything. That’s how CAM can co-opt nutrition as somehow being 
“alternative.” It’s how CAM can claim exercise as being “alternative.” It’s how 
CAM can take the long-respected field of pharmacognosy, infuse it with the woo
that is herbalism, and suddenly make the whole field suspect. None of these
modalities should not be considered “science-based,” but CAM has claimed them as
its own and used them as the Trojan horse to enter stealthily the bastions of
medical academia. Once there, the horse disgorges the real woo, like
acupuncture, reiki, and homeopathy, “integrating” quackery with science-based
medicine until it’s hard to tell the difference between the two.

Indian Doctors Fight Against Quackery

To address a doctor shortage, Indian health minister JP Nadda is proposing
licensing practitioners of ayurveda and homeopathy. This would be a terrible
mistake.

Steven Novella on January 3, 2018

Link



There has been an ongoing internal debate among those of use promoting science
in medicine – how fragile vs robust is the dedication to science in the medical 
profession? In other words, how much of an existential threat do movements such 
as “alternative medicine” really present to the culture of science that
dominates medical practice?

There are those who think that science has a critical advantage, it actually
works, and in the long run it will win out. In the extreme one might think that 
all we have to do is keep our heads down, do the science, and let pseudoscience 
whither naturally over time. At the other end of the spectrum is the belief
that, if we let it, pseudoscience in all its various forms can completely erode 
out the center of the medical profession, turning health care providers into
virtual witch doctors.

I am somewhere in the middle as both sides have a point, but I think we need to 
assume that the reality is toward the existential threat end of the spectrum.
The other perspective breeds complacency. I also think that if you look around
the world you gain a broader perspective, and it becomes clear that dedication
to science within the medical profession or anywhere is a fragile cultural
construct.

Recent cultural trends in the West also reinforce the “fragile” perspective.
Deference to expertise and respect for objective information appear to be on the
wane. The democratization of information means that everyone can be their own
expert, do their own “research”, and decide reality for themselves, even
concerning highly technical areas. At the same time, scientists, scholars, and
professionals are insufficiently engaged with the culture and politics to
effectively counter these trends. The world is changing around them, and at
times I have to wonder if they are even noticing.

The even deeper threat is that as new doctors and scientists replace the old,
they will be steeped in the new culture. In a generation no one will be left to 
question the complete infiltration of quackery into the medical profession. This
is what happened in China, with the infiltration of Traditional Chinese
Medicine (TCM) by proclamation of Chairman Mao.

Quackery in India

Politicians in India are now attempting to replicate Mao’s transformation of
medicine in China, and for the same reason. India has a doctor shortage, lacking
about half the health care professionals needed to meet the minimum World
Health Organization benchmark. To address this shortage some politicians are
proposing a bill to license practitioners of Siddha, Ayurvedic, and homeopathic 
medicine as health care providers in India. The bill is being proposed by health
minister JP Nadda.

The bill would allow such practitioners to prescribe medicine and function as
primary care doctors after a brief “bridge” course – basically a crash course in
medicine (the exact length of the course has not been determined, but Indian
states that have similar laws already license practitioners after a three-month 
course).

Further:

   Clause 49 of the Bill calls for a joint sitting of the National Medical
   Commission, the Central Council of Homoeopathy and the Central Council of
   Indian Medicine at least once a year ‘to enhance the interface between
   homoeopathy, Indian Systems of Medicine and modern systems of medicine’.

The joint sitting will also have input into the development of “educational
modules or programmes” across all areas of medical education.

Fortunately the Indian Medical Association (IMA) is opposing the bill vigorously
(as they should). The association’s president, KK Aggarwal, stated:

   The government is giving sanction to quackery. If those doctors make mistakes
   and people pay with their lives, who is going to be held accountable?

The threat goes beyond individual practitioners making specific mistakes. This
gets back to the “robust vs fragile” argument. If this bill is passed it will
demonstrate how fragile the dedication to science in medicine can be. Science
itself is dependent upon support from society, including specifically from
institutions, such as government. Without that support, scientists can believe
whatever they want but it won’t matter.

We have seen the same types of things happen in the US, with the licensing of
entire professions such as chiropractic and naturopathy that are not dedicated
to a scientific basis for health care. Those professions then lobby for greater 
and greater scope of practice, and push the entire practice of medicine in the
direction of pseudoscience. Medical school education is now infiltrated with
quackery – producing doctors who will be the next generation of experts to make 
decisions about further infiltration of quackery.

There is also great harm in the government “giving sanction” to quackery,
because it is then interpreted as a mark of legitimacy. Regardless of the
initial reasons given for regulations allowing the practice of pseudoscience in 
medicine, once the regulations exist they will be presented and interpreted
generally as an indication that the pseudoscience is legitimate.

Indian regulators may think they are proposing a short term solution to their
doctor shortage, one that can be reversed in the future, but they would be
wrong. History has shown that once pseudoscience takes hold culturally and
institutionally it is very difficult to get rid of. Again, TCM in China is an
excellent example. The superstitious notions of chi are so deeply embedded in
the culture that it is not going anywhere for the foreseeable future.

China has even exported some of its TCM pseudoscience to the West, specifically 
acupuncture. Acupuncture (the sticking of needles into imaginary points on the
body to influence the life force, chi) is pure pseudoscience. It has no
plausible mechanism, and despite thousands of studies has not been shown
convincingly to work for anything. And yet it has thoroughly infiltrated
medicine in the US, and people generally believe it is legitimate.

Proponents have managed to use poorly designed or executed studies, or
misinterpreted negative studies, to push acupuncture into the mainstream. This
is the very essence of pseudoscience – using the appearance of science to arrive
at a predetermined conclusion. Acupuncture now exists in its own bubble of
pseudoscience, apparently immune to any objective and critical assessment. All
it took was a less than robust dedication to rigorous standards of science in
medicine.

That is what the Indian bill threatens to do. There is already a massive problem
of medical pseudoscience in India. This bill would legitimize all of it, give
it regulatory and educational power, and set back the cause of science-based
medicine in India indefinitely.

This struggle is happening throughout the world. In the last half century the
pendulum has unfortunately swung massively in the direction of pseudoscience.
There is still a core strength to science that does have a long term advantage, 
but even if you take the maximally optimistic view, there is still a tremendous 
amount of harm that pseudoscience will do in the meantime. Anything less than
this optimistic view results in the indefinite incorporation of rank
pseudoscience into the institutions of medicine.

    Neti pots – Ancient Ayurvedic Treatment Validated by Scientific Evidence

                                 Harriet Hall 

                                      Link

Nasal irrigation with salt water is recommended by 87% of family doctors as an
adjunctive treatment to relieve the symptoms of nasal congestion and sinusitis. 
The simplest method is to hold salt water in your cupped hand, block one nostril
while you inhale the water into the other nostril, then blow your nose. The
high-tech version is to use a Neti pot, a little jug with a spout. You pour the 
salt solution from the Neti pot into one nostril and it drains out the other
nostril. The technique is described here.  

The Neti pot originated in India in Ayurvedic medicine. Neti is Sanskrit for
“nasal cleansing.” Other related ancient techniques that have not been adopted
by scientific medicine include using a string instead of water and a yoga
technique where you close one nostril, pour the solution into the other nostril 
and allow it to run out of the mouth. 

Nasal irrigation provides short-term symptomatic relief and may improve nasal
mucociliary clearance. It removes mucus not only from the nose but also from the
maxillary and ethmoid sinuses.  

A randomized controlled trial in 2002 found that daily hypertonic saline nasal
irrigation improves sinus-related quality of life, decreases symptoms, and
decreases medication use in patients with frequent sinusitis.  Its effectiveness
is supported by a Cochrane review.  

A recent review article in American Family Physician  gave nasal irrigation an
“A” strength of evidence rating as an effective adjunctive therapy for symptoms 
of chronic rhinosinusitis, and  a “B” rating for irritant and allergic rhinitis 
and viral upper respiratory infections. 

Just don’t overdo it. A new study presented at the annual meeting of the
American College of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology in November 2009 found that
while short-term nasal irrigation is therapeutic, long-term use of nasal
irrigation is harmful. Regular users of irrigation who continued using it had an
average of 8 episodes of recurrent rhinosinusitis per year, while those who
discontinued it only averaged 3 episodes per year.  The investigators
hypothesized that the nasal mucosa serves as the first line of defense, and
irrigation depletes the nose of its immune blanket of mucus, thereby increasing 
the risk of recurrent infection.

Oil Pulling Your Leg

Steven Novella on March 12, 2014

Link


Oil pulling is a traditional Ayurveda method of oral care. It involves swishing 
sesame oil or a similar oil, perhaps mixed with other substances, in the mouth
for 10-20 minutes as a means of preventing caries (cavities), reducing bacteria,
and promoting healthy gums. In our internet-fueled age of misinformation, oil
pulling has seen a surge in popularity as it makes the rounds on Facebook and
other popular social media sites.

The proliferation of unscientific medical advice also essentially assured that
oil pulling would be updated to incorporate the latest marketing memes in the
alternative marketplace. It is therefore not surprising that this technique is
being presented as a cure-all, treating all sorts of systemic diseases by
allegedly pulling toxins from the mouth. The Wellness Mama (the first hit on
Google) proclaims:

   Oil pulling is an age-old remedy that uses natural substances to clean and
   detoxify teeth and gums. It has the added effect of whitening teeth naturally
   and evidence even shows that it is beneficial in improving gums and removing
   harmful bacteria!

Food Matters also gushes:

   It is believed that these oils help the lymphatic system of the body as
   harmful bacteria are removed and beneficial microflora are given with [sic] a
   healthy environment to flourish. Because of this holistic perspective, oil
   pulling has been used as a preventative health measure for many other
   conditions.

This is followed by a long list of conditions from migraines to bronchitis. 

Oil pulling for dental care

Using oil as a rinse for oral care in the time before modern medicine was
perhaps not a bad idea, and does have a modicum of plausibility. Just the
mechanical act of swishing any fluid around the mouth is likely to dislodge bits
of food and clean the teeth. I wouldn’t recommend it over brushing your teeth, 
but it is probably better than nothing.

Recently several researchers have done small pilot studies looking at the
effects of oil pulling. Some are overtly trying to support traditional Indian
treatments, but at least they are clear about their biases. In any case, these
small studies show that swishing oil in the mouth daily does have an effect,
unsurprisingly, on oral bacteria.

A 2008 study by Asokan et al. found that a standard mouthwash containing
chlorhexidine reduced Streptococcus mutans (a significant contributor to tooth
decay) in plaque at all four time points measured (24 hours, 48 hours, 1 week
and 2 weeks) and in the saliva in the latter three time points. The oil pulling 
group had reduced S. mutans only in plaque at one and two weeks. So the standard
therapy, chlorhexidine, was superior to oil pulling in reducing S. mutans.

A 2011 study also by Asokan published in an Indian journal found that oil
pulling was equally effective to chlorhexidine in reducing halitosis and
bacteria associated with halitosis.

Asokan also investigated a possible mechanisms of action of oil pulling. He
found:

   Sesamin and sesamolin isolated from sesame oil did not have any antibacterial
   effect against oral microorganisms like Streptococcus mutans, Streptococcus 
   mitis and Streptococcus viridans. Emulsification of sesame oil occurs during 
   oil-pulling therapy. Increased consumption of NaOH in titration is a definite
   indication of a possible saponification process.

And concluded:

   The myth that the effect of oil-pulling therapy on oral health was just a
   placebo effect has been broken and there are clear indications of possible
   saponification and emulsification process, which enhances its mechanical
   cleaning action.

It seems that rinsing with oil leaves oil in the oral cavity, and that swishing 
with oil can have a mechanical cleaning action.

That also seems to be the extent of the peer-reviewed scientific literature on
oiling pulling – a few preliminary studies by a single researcher with an
apparent cultural bias. Even if researcher bias is put aside, the evidence is
hardly overwhelming. If taken at face value it indicates that swishing with oil 
is helpful to oral health, probably just because of the mechanical cleaning
(perhaps enhanced by oil emulsification), but is not as effective as standard
modern therapy with mouth wash.

Proponents of oil pulling do provide a few more references in obscure journals, 
but they do not show up on Pubmed even when searching by exact title and author 
names (which suggests the journals are not officially recognized as
peer-reviewed). The studies show similar results – preliminary evidence that
swishing with various oils reduces some bacteria, but not better than
chlorhexidine.

I did come across one other published paper on oil pulling – a report of
recurrent lipoid pneumonia from oil pulling. Lipoid pneumonia is a chemical lung
disease caused by aspirating (breathing in) small amounts of oil. The long
duration of mouth swishing with oil recommended by oil pulling advocates may
increase the risk of lipoid pneumonia as a complication. This is a good reminder
that no matter how “natural” and “ancient” a treatment is, we should not assume
it is entirely without risk.

Oil pulling for general health

While oil pulling may be a better-than-nothing alternative if you are stuck
without modern dental care, there is no scientific basis in either plausibility 
or empirical evidence for any claims of benefits to general health. Of course,
lack of plausibility and evidence is not a barrier to promotion by the
alternative gurus.

The claim here is that oil pulling removes “toxins” and harmful bacteria from
the body through the oral cavity. Like all alleged detox treatments, specific
toxins are never named or measured, nor is any specific causal link made to the 
specific diseases that are claimed to be treated.

Proponents often refer to the preliminary studies above showing some effect for 
oral health, again probably just from the mechanical swishing, and then use that
to claim that “oil pulling works,” followed by claims that it treats specific
diseases and conditions for which there is no evidence. Dr. Bruce Fife, who
wrote about recommending oil pulling, claims you should try it:

   If you suffer from asthma, diabetes, arthritis, migraine headaches, or any
   chronic illness,

and

   All disease starts in the mouth!

In the extreme oil pulling has become just another “one cure to cure them all”
alternative pseudoscience.

Conclusion

Oil pulling is a suggestive misnomer, implying that something bad is being
pulled from the mouth (toxins and bacteria). What little scientific evidence
exists shows that it is probably not as effective as standard mouth wash, and
what benefit it has is likely entirely due to the mechanical act of swishing to 
remove particles and bacteria from teeth and gums.

There is no reason either theoretically or based upon any evidence to recommend 
oil pulling (which should be renamed “oil-swishing”) instead of standard modern 
health care with flossing, tooth-brushing, and mouth rinse. However, it does
appear to be better than nothing, and might have a role in developing countries 
without access to modern oral care. The one caveat is that extended periods of
swishing that are commonly recommended (10-20 minutes) are likely not necessary 
and further present a risk of lipoid pneumonia from accidentally breathing in
small amounts of oil.

Oil pulling for general health or any other indication is pure pseudoscience.
Detox claims are based on nothing, as are all detox claims. There is no evidence
or plausible rationale to recommend oil pulling for any indication other than
as a poor substitute for oral care.

A Poorly Conceived Study Fails to Prove Ayurveda Works

Quackery is alive, well, and government-supported in India, as demonstrated by a
terrible study of Ayurveda.

Apoorva Chandra on July 17, 2020

Link



[Editor’s note: Here is a guest post from Dr. Apoorva Chandra, an emergency
medicine physician from India, currently working and training in the UK.
Welcome!]

As COVID-19 spread across the world, another significant problem came to light: 
the spread of pseudoscience and misinformation.

Although this isn’t a new problem, the pandemic-struck world has become a
fertile ground for the proponents of pseudoscience to spread pseudoscience and
misinformation in the name of so-called “alternative” medicines and magic cures.

What’s more worrying is that science literacy is so uncommon that even some
scientists and doctors are promoting absolutely baseless claims and alternative 
therapies in the name of science! The failure of professionals to understand
science and scientific methodology facilitates the spread of pseudoscientific
information because their voices are considered by the masses to be scientific
and authoritative.

Pseudoscience in India

Pseudoscience is extremely common in India and we even have a government
Ministry of AYUSH (Ayurveda, Unani, Siddha and Homeopathy…Yes! HOMEOPATHY)
dedicated to peddling pseudoscience. There are even government-run homeopathic
medical colleges churning out “doctors”. Imagine someone being trained as a
“doctor” in an imaginary “science”! In short, pseudoscience is legitimized by
the government itself in India. I don’t mean to personally attack the “doctors” 
trained by these colleges and universities. They are merely victims of a system 
which does not understand science. If only they could realize this and make the 
leap to real science!

Apart from this, pseudoscience is visible everywhere – newspapers, TVs, banners,
and at small talks. There’s more pseudoscience in the public sphere in India
than there is real science.

Since the COVID-19 pandemic began, there have been dozens of claims of cures and
effective treatments – most of them complete nonsense. One recent entry is Baba
Ramdev’s “Coronil”, an “Ayurvedic medicine” proclaimed to have a 100% success
rate. It is the epitome of pseudoscience, false claims, and misinformation. This
has even turned political. Many doctors are supporting this in the name of
“open mindedness“, clearly demonstrating that they don’t understand what science
is.

What triggered my concern was an argument/debate with a doctor who was
justifying alternative medicines and was also making multiple vague claims about
how “Ayurveda” works and is genuine (without providing any evidence), which
resulted in a series of tweets. He claimed that Ayurveda was scientific, but he 
demanded differential treatment for Ayurveda and less scientific scrutiny for
Ayurvedic medicines. When I questioned this, his answers were once again vague, 
claiming it is a “different system of medicine”. He did not give any rational
answer when asked “What exactly does that mean in a scientific sense?” (Is he
claiming that there’s an alternative physics, chemistry, biology/physiology? He 
doesn’t say.) My interlocutor claimed that evidence of the efficacy of Ayurveda 
for stroke has been published; he provided a link to that “evidence”. I read the
study, which in itself raises some serious questions about the state of science
in India.

The study

The study in question is “Modulation of Cardiac Autonomic Dysfunction in
Ischemic Stroke following Ayurveda (Indian System of Medicine) Treatment” in
Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine.

After reading it, I hardly know where to begin; but I’ll try to list some of my 
concerns.

  1. First, let me clarify that this is not a post against Ayurveda. Ayurveda
    potentially may have a few medicines that may work, because it uses
    substances (herbs) that may contain active components. Human beings have
    evolved to be good at pattern recognition, but they also recognize false
    patterns. The only way to know if something works is to follow a strict and 
    disciplined scientific process with specific definitions of what we study.
    Saying something works just because it’s Ayurveda, ancient, or based on
    anecdotes is not evidence, and there can’t be a different yardstick for the 
    assessment of efficacy, safety, or toxicity of Ayurvedic drugs.

  2. The study is classified under “Evidence based complementary and alternative
    medicine.” But there is nothing called “alternative medicine” or
    “complementary medicine” in science. As Tim Minchin famously said, if there 
    was scientific evidence proving that an alternative medicine worked, it
    would no longer be called alternative but would just be called “medicine”.
    When people claim something is alternative medicine, they are usually
    looking for a way to bypass scientific methodology and claim fake scientific
    legitimacy.

  3. The title mentions Ayurveda as if it were a single medicine or an
    intervention, but the study uses a mishmash of multiple interventions and
    treatments whose efficacy and safety have not been established. Further,
    there is no rationale for that particular combination of interventions.

  4. It was a small, single center study with a sample size of 50. Multiple
    dropouts and technical difficulties resulted in analysis of only 24
    patients. Heart rate variability, one of the main treatment measures, could 
    not be analyzed in 12 patients due to the presence of artifacts in the ECG. 
    The study has not been replicated or corroborated elsewhere. The patients
    were admitted to the Advanced Ayurvedic Research Institute for Mental Health
    and Neurosciences, creating a conflict of interest as researchers were
    obviously biased in favor of Ayurveda.

  5. Although patients were said to be randomized, there was no blinding, which
    makes the entire study meaningless because there are so many confounding
    factors and biases in play. This is a typical A vs A+B design where new
    interventions are added to conventional treatment and the combination is
    compared to conventional treatment alone. As pointed out by Edzard Ernst,
    this is a recipe for guaranteeing positive results that are almost certainly
    spurious. Subjects know they are getting special, extra treatments, so
    placebo responses and other psychological factors come into play.

  6. The introduction says “From an Ayurveda perspective, stroke is recognized as
    pakshaghata (hemiplegia), a disease attributed to an aberration of vatadosha
    (a physiologic entity)”. What physiologic entity is that? The reference
    cited is Charaka Samhita“. It is bizarre to make a claim based only on a
    book written centuries ago and call that evidence!

  7. “The diverse treatments advocated in Ayurveda for this disease primarily
    harmonize the aberrant physiology”. Wait! Wait! What is the “aberrant
    physiology”? And what might “harmonizing” it mean? Science demands precise
    terminology.

  8. Patients with stroke were assessed by a neurologist and by an Ayurvedic
    physician who made a diagnosis of pakshaghata (hemiplegia). How did they
    manage to agree? Were there any cases where their diagnoses differed? We
    aren’t told.

  9. What Group 2 got in the name of ‘Ayurveda’ is beyond belief. There are so many
    medications mentioned and so many interventions done, how on the earth
    would you know which one worked and which did not (if something even worked 
    in the first place)? What is the justification or evidence for using all
    these interventions in those patients? This is problematic on so many
    different levels!

  10. The three main outcome measures, heart rate variability, blood pressure
    variability, and baroreflex sensitivity, are not routinely measured in
    stroke patients. Their clinical significance remains questionable.

  11. I’m not a statistician, but isn’t it useless to apply statistical measures to 
    data from an ill-conceived study that couldn’t possibly produce meaningful
    results?

  12. A requisite quantity of Niramisha Mahamasha taila (medicated oil) was warmed
    on a water bath and applied on the patient’s body. Fun fact: The ingredients
    of this oil include more than 30 herbs. How did they know which herbs to
    mix?

  13. Perspiration was induced by putting patients in wooden boxes for 10–15 minutes
    depending on the patients’ “tolerance level”. What determined their
    tolerance? What is the effect of perspiration on physiology?

  14. Enemas were administered with a mixture of 19 herbs. Why enemas? Why that
    mixture of herbs? Enemas are known to potentially cause harm; is this even
    ethical?

  15. Patients were also given some medicines orally. Nobody knows what they are or 
    how they work but they are called Ashtavarga Kashaya and Ksheerabala, made
    up of 8 and 3 herbs respectively! Evidence for their use? Justification?

  16. They used combinations of almost 60 different herbs given rectally, orally,
    and by massage, and they performed 3 interventions: massage, sitting in a
    box to induce perspiration, and enemas! They give no justification other
    than “It’s Ayurveda.”

  17. The discussion section is problematic. “The science of Ayurveda has evolved by
    in-depth observation and experience of scholars. However, the potential
    benefits of this science need to be evaluated with objectivity.” Isn’t that 
    an admission that Ayurveda is not a science?

  18. “The current study demonstrated that cardiac autonomic functions can be used
    as a marker to detect one facet of aberrant physiology in pakshaghata
    (hemiplegia) and that a whole system Ayurveda treatment protocol as used
    here was able to modulate the same.” But they did not test whether that
    “modulation” produced any clinical benefits.

  19. “The study has used a whole system treatment protocol, adapted from Ayurveda
    classics keeping in mind convenience for clinical application.” This is pure
    meaningless jargon.

  20. They vaguely talk about antioxidant and neuroprotective actions of these
    herbs. “Antioxidant” is a word used so often in pseudoscience and so
    carelessly thrown around I get suspicious when someone uses it!

  21. They conclude that Ayurveda could be useful in stroke as an “adjuvant”
    therapy! This is speculation, not a conclusion supported by the data.

I’m tired and speechless! They say when assessing or appraising a study we
should comment about its good points. The only positive thing I can think of is 
that somebody thought of doing a study and all the patients got standard
therapy. Unfortunately, the second group were bombarded with a lot of different 
things that didn’t make sense and were probably unethical.

My larger concerns

This study was poorly designed and should never have been done. It is filled
with logical fallacies, baseless assumptions, and treatments that are not
supported by scientific evidence. It is full of red flags. How it got approval
from the ethics committee is beyond me.

It assumes the value of Ayurveda and calls it a science, which it clearly is
not.

It was done in NIMHANS (National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences), 
a premier institute of national importance, and funded by the Department of
AYUSH (Ayurveda, Unani, Siddha and Homeopathy) Ministry of Health & Family
Welfare. These government ministries legitimize quackery in India by legally
promoting homeopathy and other alternative medicines.

Pseudoscience has already gained access to reputed academic institutions and we 
are on a slippery slope! It’s time we take note of this and stand up for
science!

Yoga Woo

Steven Novella on July 31, 2013

Link


Yoga is an increasingly popular form of exercise in the US. According to Yoga
Journal more than 20 million Americans use yoga as their form of exercise. As a 
form of exercise yoga is fairly straightforward, involving stretching and
holding poses that strengthen muscles. It also carries the generic benefits of
any exercise in terms of calorie-burning and cardiovascular health.

Yoga, however, is more than exercise – it also comes with a “spiritual” angle.
The term itself refers to a number of practices originating in ancient India
meant to strength mind, body, and spirit. For this reason it has become a
popular target for marketing the latest health pseudoscience. You will be hard
pressed, in fact, to find a yoga class that does not incorporate some degree of 
outright woo, the only question really is not if, but how much. This is
unfortunate because yoga may be an effective alternative for low-impact
exercise.

There is some evidence that yoga, for example, is effective in relieving low
back pain, although it may not be more effective than usual care. There is a
lack of quality studies comparing yoga to other forms of exercise, and so we may
just be seeing the generic benefits of exercise. Still, if the classes are fun 
and they keep people motivated to continue their exercise regimen, that is
useful.

Yoga, therefore, fits into a more general phenomenon of marketing a specific
intervention as if it has specific benefits, when in fact it only has generic
benefits. For example, there are many studies showing that transcendental
meditation is effective for lowering blood pressure. However, studies generally 
compare TM to no intervention, not to other forms of relaxation. The
parsimonious interpretation is that TM confers the generic benefits of
relaxation, but there is no evidence to suggest it confers any specific
benefits.

Therefore, before we conclude that any relaxation has specific benefits we need 
to demonstrate that it has benefits above and beyond those for the relaxation
itself. The same is true of any form of exercise, any form of mental activity
for cognition, and any form of massage for muscle relaxation. It is therefore
misleading to say that “Yoga works for X, or has these benefits” when the
evidence only shows that exercise has those benefit, and there is nothing
special about yoga as a form of exercise.

In addition to marketing generic benefits as if they were specific to yoga,
proponents often mix in a liberal dose of pure pseudoscience and mysticism. Most
yoga practitioners I know expect at least a casual mention of “energy” or some 
similar reference from their yoga instructors and are content to just ignore it.
Some instructors, however, go way beyond a little mystical window dressing. The
following e-mail I received from one skeptical yoga practitioner is typical:

   I have recently been trying to lose weight, in addition to dietary changes, I
   have been exercising more, along with a normal gym routine I have decided to
   try yoga. I did quick a PubMed search and there did seem to be some evidence
   that yoga is effective for losing weight. During the classes the teacher
   stands at the front and gives a bit of dialogue to accompany the instructions
   on how to do the poses. Some of the things they say in these dialogues
   picked my skeptical ears and are the reason for this email. Along with the
   obligatory ”shared energy” and ”shared spirit” type of comments, which I
   fully expected, they made some other claims which have a pseudo sciencey
   twinge and I was hoping you guys could clear them up for me. Here are some of
   the more memorable ones in no particular order; during one bent over pose
   they say you are squeezing the pancreas/liver this apparently pushes toxin
   out and they also say you can taste the toxins coming out in your mouth
   (taste described as chloriney), during reverse back bending pose they say if 
   you look back as far as you can you can stretch your optic nerve, in one pose
   where you bend your arms awkwardly they say that you build up blood pressure
   and when this pressure is released the blood will move so intensely through 
   you arteries it will blast away plaque build up, near the end they have a
   breathing exercise which they claim is pushing out all the toxins the
   stretching has apparently pushed into your lungs, throughout they talk about 
   the increasing of bone density and of joint strength, finally that stretching
   your lower back calms you because personal stress building up in your lower 
   back muscles/tissues. Are any of these thing possible or is it all pure
   pseudo science?

None of those specific claims is based in reality. I certainly hope that yoga
practitioners are not squeezing their liver or pancreas, or that they are
stretching their optic nerve. Nerves don’t like to be stretched – that causes
damage. It also would not be safe to perform a maneuver that backs up your blood
flow and then releases it in a powerful blast. This has a much greater chance
of causing a brain hemorrhage than scouring plaque off your arteries. In other
words, the yoga instructor better hope that everything they are claiming is a
lie, or else they are likely to find themselves liable for very real medical
harm.

This brings up a very important question about yoga – how safe is it? All
interventions should be considered on a risk vs benefit basis. While it seems
that yoga carries with it the generic benefits of exercise, how does it rate in 
terms of risk? Not very well, it turns out – but of course, it depends on
exactly how it is practiced. There is risk of injury from yoga, as there is with
any sport or significant exercise. But yoga often involves poses that push the 
practitioner to extremes. There are reports, for example, of vertebral artery
dissection and subsequent stroke from excessive neck extension or rotation.

In a telling New York Times article, yoga teacher Glenn Black warns that yoga is
not for most people, but rather should be reserved for people who are already
in good physical condition. For the general public the risk of injury is high,
and they should be given either very basic routines, or targeted exercises for
their specific issues. This would be more in line with what a physical therapist
would do for a client – assess their needs and vulnerabilities, then target
exercises that will be safe and effective for them. Other risks include
overstretching ligaments, herniated discs, and neck or back strain.

Yoga is also susceptible to evidence-free marketing fads. I recently learned
about so-called “hot yoga,” which is essentially yoga in a hot and humid
environment. Such an environment might be conducive to dehydration and becoming 
overheated, but there is no evidence that it enhances the exercise or has any
health benefits.

Conclusion

Yoga, if practiced responsibly, seems to be a reasonably effective form of
stretching and exercise. There is insufficient evidence, however, to conclude
that it is any superior to any other form of exercise of the same duration and
intensity. There are concerns about the safety of yoga, as it often involves
extreme stretching or poses that the average person might find not only
difficult but physically harmful. I would therefore recommend caution before
starting a yoga routine. If you have any physical limitations or medical
conditions, consult your physician and consider a physical therapy assessment
first. Find an instructor who seems reasonable and evidence-based. And do not
feel pressured to try poses that are painful or seem to push you beyond
reasonable physical limits.

Further – all of the mystical and pseudoscientific woo that often accompanies
yoga is counterproductive. It may be useful for marketing to the gullible, but
it taints the entire practice with pseudoscience. I would also find it difficult
to trust in the competence of an instructor who thinks a yoga pose will squeeze
toxins out of my liver.

It would be nice, but perhaps too much to hope for, to have a science-based yoga
movement – yoga-based exercises minus the woo, and evidence-based to maximize
safety and effectiveness.

The Yoga RCT

Back in December, 2020, Chief Scientist for the WHO Dr. Soumya Swaminathan
tweeted about a study that suggested yoga helped improve various blood markers
in people with diabetes. However, a major flaw prevents the study from being
rigorous enough to believe its conclusions.

Apoorva Chandra on June 20, 2021

Link



[Editor’s note: With this post we welcome back Dr. Apoorva Chandra, who
previously wrote about Ayurveda. He returns with a post about a questionable
clinical trial of yoga. Welcome back!]

This isn’t even a significant study that needed any attention in the first place
to be honest. But, one fine evening, the chief scientist of WHO decided to
tweet about this study.

Yoga improves all parameters in type 2 diabetes. Such evidence from randomized
clinical trials is critical for traditional medicine scale up @moayush
@vaidyakotecha @ncdalliance @MikkelsenBente_ @WHO https://t.co/Ye9s8zFHEB

— Soumya Swaminathan (@doctorsoumya) December 26, 2020

The Ministry of AYUSH, which legitimises pseudoscience and gives pseudoscience
(including homeopathy) a legal platform in India, was also tagged in the tweet. 
To give the benefit of doubt and because of her excellent track record, I would 
like to believe that this tweet was an error or was done in haste and not
intentional. However, Dr. Swaminathan seemed to defend the tweet/study in follow
up tweets despite the flaws in the study that were rightly pointed out by many.
“We should see the full paper and then draw conclusions. I agree that
methodology is important and all RCTs are not of a similar standard. We should
focus on robust evidence generation to back claims of efficacy of any product”
said the chief scientist of WHO responding to one of the very valid criticisms
of the study on Twitter. That sounded like a reasonable suggestion although I
wish Dr. Swaminathan had seen the full paper and realised how badly designed it 
was before tweeting about it to reach conclusions that are not supported by the 
study’s claims. Anyway, let me take this suggestion forward and look into the
full study and see if there’s anything on it that is new, ground-breaking, or
noteworthy.

To begin with, let me clarify, I’m not against yoga. Yoga (sans all the woo,
hype, mysticism, supernatural claims, and the accompanying pseudoscience) would 
probably be beneficial as a part of a healthy lifestyle as a form of exercise
when done within reasonable limits. It is the ‘cure for all’ claims that I’m
against. Regular physical exercise has shown to be beneficial for multiple
conditions and for general health as a whole in multiple validated studies and
there’s no doubt about it. Yoga isn’t anything special or an exception to that. 
If the claim is that a specific type of yoga is beneficial to a specific
condition or disease process then the study has to be very specific and
explicitly include these specifics – something that I have not seen so far.
Vagueness seems to be the bread and butter of alternative medicine studies.

I am against misrepresentations like those found in this study, claiming yoga to
be different from and superior to exercise just because you call it ‘yoga’.

I am also against being vague about the definition of yoga and trying to market 
it as some kind of magic cure for everything or a secret science now being
revealed.

Let us have a closer look at the study in question.

Methodology

The study seems to measure following markers to claim ‘yoga’ is superior to
exercise:

  1. BMI

  2. blood glucose levels

  3. HbA1c

  4. lipid levels

  5. IL6

  6. TNFα

  7. TBARS

  8. Adiponectin

  9. PTGIS

  10. sleep quality

As a clinician, measuring BMI, blood glucose levels, HbA1c, and lipid levels is 
understandable but the clinical relevance of the rest of the so-called
inflammatory markers in diabetes is still not fully understood and not something
routinely measured in clinical practice. Using their values as surrogate
markers is therefore largely unhelpful. I will talk about ‘sleep quality’ later 
because this RCT is going to get more interesting soon.

This was a randomised control study involving 2 groups. Of course, due to the
nature of the study, blinding of participants was not an option.

But look at the 2 groups. They only defy logic at every step from here on.

Group 1/No yoga “was advised to do simple physical exercises for 50 minutes for 
5 days in a week”. There is no explanation what these ‘simple physical
exercises’ were or how they were ‘advised’. However, the interventions with
Group 2 are very interesting.

Group 2/Yoga group: “was advised yoga intervention and were instructed to
practice it for a period of 50 minutes for 5 days in a week”. All the subjects
in group 2 were trained by a yoga teacher. During their first session, each
participant was educated on diabetes, risk factors, its complications, and the
importance of yoga in maintaining glycaemic control and preventing the
complications due to diabetes. In addition, they were given training on
yogasanas using a separate yoga module for 30 minutes and static loosening
exercise for 20 minutes. This training was given to the subjects individually
and they practiced it in the supervision of the yoga teacher till they could do 
the module on their own. Later they were advised to practice the same activity
for 5 days per week at home.

The yoga module (given as supplement 2) included quick relaxation techniques
beginning with loosening exercises for the legs, spine, neck and shoulders and
then asanas such as Thadasana, Trikonasana, Vajrasana, Konasana,
Patchimothasana, Uttanapadasana, Sarvangasana, Matchyasana, Salabasana, and
Pranayama including abdomen breathing, Nadisudhi, Kabalbhati, Sitali, and
Brahmari relaxation technique. A copy of the module was given to them with clear
instructions.

They were also instructed to contact the yoga teacher through telephone for any 
clarifications related to the asanas as they practiced at home. Telephone calls 
were also made by the researcher once in a fortnight to motivate the subjects
for continuing yoga practice/exercise and also to increase compliance with the
yoga practice and exercises among the study subjects. Very few required more
than one session for learning the asanas and most were able perform them
completely on their own. After the first session, few subjects had confirmed the
correct procedure of the asanas with the yoga teacher by making video calls
while they were practicing. The events such as hypoglycemia during the study
period was also recorded.

A pause for thought

Let’s do a thought experiment: Bring in two teams, calling it an RCT between
Cricket and Cricket Pro. Cricket team is advised to go and practice for 5 days a
week for the next 3 months before the match. However, nobody cares once they
are ‘advised’ and they are left on their own or nobody knows how they are doing 
for 3 months.

Cricket Pro team gets a coach, each member gets a personal trainer, are
encouraged to carry on with different techniques, have regular compliance
checks, etc. Conduct a match at the end of three months and declare Cricket Pro 
is better than Team Cricket as they won. Isn’t this more than obvious to
everyone? What exactly are they trying to ‘prove’?

I am really not sure how they can be serious and call this a reasonable
methodology for an RCT. I fail to understand why and how this methodology, with 
obvious differences between the two groups, was designed for an RCT with any
goal other than to misrepresent something. Or is this the general lack of
understanding of how RCTs are done? In both cases I’m worried.

And what about the sleep quality?

A quick word about ‘sleep quality’ in the yoga group. Sleep quality was measured
via survey using a qualitative scale. There are various biases and confounders 
in play in this methodology and this is an extremely subjective and unreliable
way of measuring something like sleep quality especially in a study like this.

So what can we conclude?

So, does this study prove what it claims to be proving? Absolutely NOT. This is 
a study with glaringly-obvious flawed methodology designed to present yoga as
superior to exercise with inadequate data on the non-yoga group.

The study goes into details of the statistics of these different markers and
contains different tables and graphs, but I’m stopping here because it is
pointless to apply statistics and graphs when the methodology is almost
hilariously bad.

Other points to consider:

  1. The study was funded by the Department of Science and Technology, Government
    of India, Science and Technology in Yoga and Meditation (SATYAM) project

  2. A WHO Collaborating Centre for Research Education and Training in Diabetes was
    also a part of the study

  3. This is in agreement with many other studies which show the benefits of
    regular exercise.

Is it a completely useless study? What else could it suggest? Possibly not.
Although it is flawed, it seems to be suggesting regular exercise and stretching
could be beneficial in a variety of health conditions, including diabetes,
without demonstrating yoga brings anything extra to the table. Unfortunately the
biggest concern is the WHO chief scientist, who holds a position of authority, 
tweeting about this study – which has in turn has been shared multiple times,
especially by people who have keen interest in promoting pseudoscience on social
media, as a ‘proof’ or ‘evidence’ for their other baseless claims because it
has been shared by none other than the chief scientist of WHO.

It is really unfortunate that flawed studies like these are used to market
‘yoga’. It is important to appreciate yoga for what it is and call out
misinformation and misleading claims in the name of yoga. While yoga may have
real health benefits, the associated pseudoscience and ‘cure for all’ claims are
actually detrimental to health. The real benefits of exercise or ‘yoga’ has
been hijacked by numerous gurus and mystics promoting pseudoscientific and
supernatural claims and unfortunately yoga has become a buzzword to mislead
people into accepting claims that are not backed by science. ‘Yoga’ also has a
brand value which drives many financial interests in disregard for the actual
science. The present Indian government is enthusiastic about promoting yoga on
an international level, which may not be completely harmful in itself but the
government clearly lacks insight into the pseudoscience it intentionally and
unintentionally promotes with this.

Lastly, we hope doctors, scientists and people who hold responsible positions
review what they share on social media and not add more fuel to the already
problematic pseudoscience industry.

Ayurvedic practitioners push for licensing in Colorado

Ayurvedic practitioners’ attempt to become licensed health care professionals in
Colorado failed an initial review but that is unlikely to stop them from
pursuing their goal. Ayurveda is pseudoscience and its practices can be
dangerous. Unfortunately, that is no barrier to state licensing.

Jann Bellamy on November 21, 2019

Link



A year ago, a Sunrise Review Application (Application) was submitted to the
Colorado Department of Regulatory Affairs (DORA), proposing the licensing of
Ayurvedic “doctors” and other Ayurvedic practitioners in that state. Per
Colorado law, DORA reviewed the Application and, last month, issued its Sunrise 
Review recommending that the state not regulate Ayurvedic “professionals”, but
this does not prevent a licensing bill from being introduced, or from passing,
in the Colorado legislature. (The deadline for bill introduction is in January, 
2020.) Based on information submitted in the Application, it appears that this
effort may be the beginning of a national campaign to legitimize Ayurvedic
practice via licensing. With this, we start a new chapter in the rich history of
Legislative Alchemy, that is, the deliberate incorporation of pseudoscience
into the American healthcare system via legislation in lieu of evidence.

We’ll return to this effort in a moment, but first, let’s take a brief look at
Ayurveda, a prescientific belief system that originated, and is still practiced 
extensively, in India. Ayurvedic practitioners believe that all people are made 
up of five basic elements (space, air, fire, water, and earth) that combine into
three “life forces” or “energies”, called “doshas”. These doshas (vata, pitta, 
and kapha), control different bodily functions. Each person is, according to
this belief system, a unique mixture of these doshas, although one usually
dominates. Whether you get sick, and the illnesses you develop, depend on the
balance of your doshas.

The vata dosha is thought to be the most powerful, controlling basic bodily
functions, such as cell division, as well as one’s mind, breathing, blood flow, 
heart function, and elimination. Things like “eating again too soon after a
meal, fear, grief, and staying up too late” can disrupt one’s vata dosha. If
vata dosha is your main dosha, Ayurvedic practice predicts you are more
susceptible to developing conditions like “anxiety, asthma, heart disease, skin 
problems, and rheumatoid arthritis”.

According to Wikipedia,

   Ayurveda has eight ways to diagnose illness, called Nadi (pulse), Mootra
   (urine), Mala (stool), Jihva (tongue), Shabda (speech), Sparsha (touch), Druk
   (vision), and Aakruti (appearance).

Treatments include herbal remedies, oils, enemas, bloodletting, diets,
meditation, yoga, and, of course, “detoxification”, called “Panchakarma”, the
“benefits” of which were described in a previous SBM post:

   Panchakarma will remove the excess doshas and correct imbalances in them as
   well as eliminate the harmful ama out of your system through the body’s own
   organs and channels of elimination (colon, sweat glands, lungs, bladder,
   urinary tract, stomach, intestines, etc). Panchakarma purifies the tissues at
   a very deep level. It involves daily massages and oil baths, herbal enemas, 
   nasal administrations. It is a very pleasurable experience. Ayurveda
   recommends Panchakarma as a seasonal treatment for maintaining mental and
   physical hygiene and balance.

Personally, I had not thought herbal enemas would be “very pleasurable” but,
then again, I’ve not tried one.

There is, of course, no evidence that these doshas exist, and the dangers of
basing diagnosis and treatment on a fantasy-based system of human functioning
should be obvious. For example, the “Ayurvedic Practitioner Certification Exam
Detailed Reference Guide” (2019 Ed.) lists as possible causes of psychosis
demons, the influence of snakes, spirits, divine intervention, celestial
musicians, and possession.

Even according to the CAM-friendly National Center for Complementary and
Integrative Medicine, regrettably ignoring the fact that the whole system is
based on magical thinking, says that while there is very limited evidence that
some Ayurvedic herbal remedies might possibly be effective for a few conditions,
“there is little scientific evidence” of its value for other health issues.

There are, however, a number of well-recognized dangers of Ayurveda, one of the 
most worrying of which is the use of metals like gold, mercury, copper, and
silver in its remedies, a subject we’ve addressed here on SBM and noted by the
NCCIH:

   A 2015 published survey of people who use Ayurvedic preparations showed that 
   40 percent had elevated blood levels of lead and some had elevated blood
   levels of mercury. About one in four of the supplements tested had high
   levels of lead and almost half of them had high levels of mercury.

There is also a danger of arsenic poisoning. This is in addition to the usual
risk of taking any herbal remedy, which, due to lack of effective regulation,
may be contaminated or suffer from other quality issues.

Sunrise Review Application

With that background, let’s turn to the Sunrise Review Application and DORA’s
recommendation against licensing Ayurvedic practitioners.

First, we learn from the Application that Ayurvedic practitioners have taken a
page from the chiropractic, naturopathic, and Traditional Chinese
Medicine/acupuncture (TCM) playbook and set up a system of organizations that,
on their face, mimic those of the medical profession, but are actually designed 
to incorporate and perpetuate their pseudoscientific belief systems and, via
self-regulation, shield them from outside scrutiny. These are the

  1. National Ayurvedic Medical Association, an private association of Ayurvedic
    “doctors” and other Ayurvedic practitioners with “more than 800 Ayurvedic
    professional members in the United States.”

  2. National Ayurvedic Medical Association Certification Board, a private
    association which establishes the number of hours of instruction needed to
    complete training for the three levels of practice for which they seek
    licensure in Colorado: Ayurvedic Doctor, Ayurvedic Practitioner and
    Ayurvedic Health Counselor, and administers the “rigorous” exams required
    for certification. (You can find the study guide for the “rigorous”
    Practitioner certification exam here. For clarity, I will use “Practitioner”
    when referring to that specific level of practice and “practitioner” or
    “provider” to refer to those who practice Ayurveda in general, whatever
    their level.)

  3. National Ayurvedic Medical Association Accreditation Council, a private
    organization, which is gearing up to apply for recognition from the U.S.
    Department of Education as the accrediting agency for Ayurvedic schools in
    the U.S. If successful, their students will be eligible for taxpayer-funded 
    student loans and their educational institutions eligible for federal
    research money.

Although no specific licensing bill is proposed, it is apparent that the
Application contemplates that the state, as in the case of chiropractic,
naturopathic and TCM licensing, would default to these private organizations,
created and run by Ayurvedic practitioners, to control the education, training, 
examination, and continuing education requirements for Ayurvedic practitioners, 
thereby ensuring that science and protection of the public’s health will not
intrude.

Second, the Application makes no apologies for the fantastical practices of
Ayurveda (which it sets out in some detail) nor does it pretend that there is
any evidence to support their effectiveness or safety. (In fact, the Application
admits to some of their dangers, a point we’ll return to shortly.) Rather, the 
case for licensing is based on familiar logical fallacies we frequently see
trotted out in the promotion of pseudoscientific practitioners. One, CAM is
“popular”, based on the logical fallacy which

   tells us that if something is popular, it must be good/true/valid, but this
   is not so, especially in a society where clever marketing, social and
   political weight, and money can buy popularity.

Two, an appeal to authority, in this case invoking the World Health Organization
which “recognizes Ayurveda as a form of traditional and complementary medicine”
in its “Traditional Medicine Strategy” and “encourages Member States to
consider [Traditional and Complementary Medicine] as an important part of the
health system,” a move that has been widely criticized as “antithetical to the
[WHO’s] commitment to evidence-based medicine, a desertion of duty to uphold the
highest scientific standards”, and which the WHO itself says is not an
endorsement of T&CM.

Third, in spite of its basis in pseudoscience and the lack of evidence of safety
and effectiveness, the Application seeks an extremely broad scope of practice. 
Ayurvedic “doctors” and Ayurvedic Practitioners need have only 6 college credits
in anatomy and physiology plus, respectively, 3,000-4,500 hours of education
and training in Ayurveda and 300 patient encounters, or 1,500-2,500 hours and
150 patients encounters, to be eligible for “certification”. How these hours are
calculated is not explained. Of course, much of this time is spent learning
nonsensical concepts such as:

   Changes in vikṛti due to changes in agni, guṇas resulting in digestive
   disorders, appetite and elimination changes

   Attributes (guṇas) that cause the doṣas to accumulate and become aggravated

   Diet (āhāra) and lifestyle (vihāra); how diet, climate, season and age impact
   the prakṛti and subsequently contribute to doṣa vikṛti and cause of disease

   What constitutes excess, deficient and the imbalance of doṣas within their
   own site

   Theory of similar and dissimilar and balancing the doṣa vikṛti through a
   proper daily routine, seasonal routine and basic six tastes (rasa) for a
   person of each constitutional type

And so on.

Yet, for both “doctors” and Practitioners, the Application does not propose any 
limitation on the scope of practice. It includes diagnosis, treatment, and
management “from the Ayurvedic perspective” of any disease or condition in any
patient of any age, unsupervised by any other health care professional. The
Ayurvedic Health Counselor, with 600-1,000 hours of education and 50 patient
encounters, offers “health promotion and disease prevention” using “principles
of Ayurvedic medicine”, including assessment of the patient’s Ayurvedic
constitution and the imbalance and state of his or her doshas. They refer
patients to Ayurvedic “doctors” or Practitioners when the patient’s “disease
state” requires diagnosis and treatment, but also practice unsupervised.

Fourth, the Application claims that licensure would “ensure that Ayurveda
recommendations be given in coordination and cooperation with the
client/patient’s licensed healthcare team” although no actual requirement for
“coordination and coordination” is proposed. Presumably to shore up this notion,
and perhaps to allay any fears that Ayurvedic providers might harm patients
because they don’t know what they’re doing, the Application makes some
extraordinary claims for Ayurvedic providers’ proficiency in “Western” medicine.
According to the Application, Ayurvedic “doctors”

   have a working knowledge of Western medical pathology, pharmacology,
   diagnostic reports, and treatments, in order to interface with the Western
   medical community and modify the Ayurvedic management of cases accordingly,
   as needed.

They also

   have a working knowledge of Western medical diagnostic and treatment
   terminology and practices, sufficient to enable them to correlate those terms
   and diagnosis into Ayurvedic understanding and practice.

As well, they have

   an informed awareness of public health and epidemiology . . . from the
   Western and Ayurvedic perspectives.

Ayurvedic Practitioners “must be able to refer a patient for assessment and
possible treatment by a medical practitioner” and “have knowledge of red flag
symptoms that require immediate referral” and (in a statement of breathtaking
hubris) “must understand how other health care professionals can complement the 
care being provided by the Ayurvedic Practitioner”.

Even Ayurvedic Health Counselors “have the knowledge of symptoms that require
referral to a licensed medical professional”.

In my opinion, these claims are both disingenuous and dangerous. Ayurvedic
providers are educated and trained (such as it is) wholly outside the mainstream
American medical educational and training system and fully accept prescientific
beliefs as a substitute for “Western” science-based medicine. Yet, they are
somehow able to both put aside their fantastical notions about predetermined
disease susceptibilities based on inborn doshas and their imbalances and
magically transform themselves into competent “Western” medical diagnosticians. 
Not only that, they can take these two irreconcilable systems and combine them
in their management of patients, much like NASA and astrologists work together
to combine “Western” astronomy, physics, and chemistry with the predetermined
fates ascribed to one’s “sign” into one successful space program. (Actually,
they don’t.)

Judge for yourself just how credible this claim could be by examining the
curricula of the school ranked number one by universities.com for “Best Colleges
with Ayurvedic Medicine/Ayurvedic Degrees in the United States”, Southern
California University of Health Sciences, a school that also offers
chiropractic, acupuncture, and oriental medicine degrees.

Upon completing the one-year program conferring the Ayurvedic Wellness Educator 
Certificate, consisting of online and weekend courses, recorded lectures, and
working in the school clinic, a student can enroll in the Ayurvedic Practitioner
Certificate program. This program lasts one year as well, and also consists of 
online and weekend courses and recorded lectures. The “Clinical Internship” is
four weeks long, for 15 hours per week, or a total of 60 hours. The description 
says nothing about learning or employing “Western” medicine.

Fifth, the Application admits that Ayurvedic remedies include dangerous metals, 
such as lead, and dangerous herbs, such as Ashwagandha, which can affect adrenal
hormones, citing medical literature exposing these risks. It promises that
licensing will solve these issues with vague assurances of compulsory adherence 
to best practices and practitioner competency and training. At best, this might 
work to exclude therapies once the harm is discovered, but it does nothing to
address the problem of using unproven therapies whose harms are not yet known
because testing for safety is considered unnecessary. (The Colorado Citizens for
Science in Medicine filed Comments with DORA opposing licensing and listed even
more dangers for DORA’s consideration.)

In fact, the one remedial step Ayurvedic organizations have taken does not
appear to be working. According to the Application, in 2008, several
organizations agreed practitioners should stop using any product to which lead, 
mercury, or arsenic (but not copper, silver, gold or herbs) have been
intentionally added “until modern Western science have proven the safety of such
products” underscoring that Ayurvedic practitioners do not consider it their
job to evaluate the safety of their therapies. (Leave that task to “modern
Western science”.) Yet, several of the harms reported in the medical literature 
occurred after that date.

Sixth, and finally, the Application fully admits that one goal of licensing is
increased prestige:

   Regulation gives a measure of authenticity, professionalism, credentialing,
   integrating and complimenting other healthcare modalities. . . Regulation
   also achieves an enhanced status in the eyes of the public, which equates
   Ayurvedic professionals with professionals licensed in other fields.

In other words, the public will be completely fooled.

They may also seek coverage under health insurance plans. Indeed, at least
theoretically, insurers would be required to cover their services under Section 
2706 of the Affordable Care Act. (Although that has not been the financial boon 
anticipated by CAM providers.)

DORA recommends a “no”

Fortunately, as noted, DORA recommended against regulation, via licensing, of
Ayurvedic “professionals”, although, as also noted, this does not prevent the
legislature from passing a bill doing just that. Now, a normal person might
think: “Of course they didn’t recommend licensing! Ayurveda is total nonsense!” 
Unfortunately, being nonsense-based does not legally preclude licensing or
registration (another form of regulation, with its attendant imprimatur of
legitimacy) in Colorado, which also regulates chiropractors and naturopathic
“doctors” or, more accurately, allows them to self-regulate.

Instead, DORA considered the criteria mandated by law, the first of which asks
whether the practice of Ayurveda “clearly harms or endangers the health, safety,
or welfare of the public”. In other words, the more dangerous you are, the more
likely you are to be awarded the honor of being licensed and, as the Ayurvedic 
providers put it, achieving an “enhanced status in the eyes of the public”.
Based on the information it had, DORA concluded that “Ayurvedic professionals
are not causing widespread harm to consumers who utilize their services” and
that most examples of consumer harm were “product-related, not practice-related”
ignoring the fact that many of these products were supplied by Ayurvedic
practitioners (although some were in India).

The second criterion is whether the public needs and can benefit from initial
and continuing professional competence through, for example, educational and
examination requirements. DORA decided it wasn’t necessary to address this one, 
as there was insufficient evidence to conclude the unregulated practice of
Ayurveda harms the public. (Again, apparently, the fact that this education and 
examination would be fantasy-based is not a consideration in the eyes of the
law, had DORA chosen to address this criteria.)

In fact, its decision on the first criterion pretty much allowed DORA to skip
consideration of all the remaining criteria. The agency did note that Colorado’s
Natural Health Consumer Protection Act or, as I prefer to call it, the Quack
Full Employment Act, permits the practice of Ayurveda, which, in DORA’s view,
provides some pubic protection. Indeed, lack of licensing doesn’t seem to be
stopping anyone: There are about 70 Ayurvedic practitioners currently plying
their trade in the state.

While this is the first attempt in recent years at licensing Ayurvedic
practitioners, a bill was filed in New Hampshire back in 1999 to license
Ayurvedic “physicians”, who would be allowed to diagnose and treat any patient, 
regardless of age, disease, or condition. They could employ physical and
orificial examinations, pulse analysis, X-rays, electrocardiograms, ultrasound, 
phlebotomy, clinical laboratory tests and examinations, and physiological
function tests, do minor office surgery, prescribe according to a formulary,
prescribe barrier contraceptives, and practice “natural” childbirth. They would 
have been self-regulated by their own Ayurvedic Board of Examiners. Fortunately,
the bill was defeated.

The Indian Medical Association, whose members see first-hand what the widespread
practice of Ayurveda looks like, were faced with the prospect of licensing
Ayurvedic practitioners in their country. They opposed licensing, saying:

   The government is giving sanction to quackery. If those doctors make mistakes
   and people pay with their lives, who is going to be held accountable?

Exactly. State legislatures in the U.S. should heed their warning.

Islamic Medicine and the Biopolitics of Antiscience in Iran

When Islamic Medicine Kills the Ayatollah!

Kiarash Aramesh on March 13, 2025

Link


Ayatollah Sayyid Mahmoud Hashemi Shahroudi, the powerful Chief Justice of the
Islamic Republic of Iran from 1999 to 2009 and one of the potential successors
of the Supreme Leader, died of cancer in December 2018. After his death, his son
revealed that the ayatollah had delayed the cancer treatments recommended by
his doctors because he had trusted “Islamic medicine” to cure his disease. As a 
result, when he finally decided to use “western” medicine, it was too late, and 
the cancer had already metastasized extensively.

Ayatollah Shahroudi was not alone in his faith in Islamic medicine. Many other
high-ranked Shi’a scholars avidly support it to be a part of the biopolitical
agenda of the Islamic government. In contrast, others argue that medicine is an 
independent discipline and cannot be derived from religious scripture.

Religious Biopolitics and Islamic Medicine in Iran

In February 2019, a video went viral on Iranian social media featuring a
prominent Shi’a cleric burning a copy of Harrison’s Principles of Internal
Medicine. That cleric was Ayatollah Abbas Tabrizian, known to his followers as
“the father of Islamic medicine.” By burning that medical textbook, he intended 
to symbolically declare war against what he refers to as “colonialist, western, 
and chemical medicine.” Instead, he promotes what he calls Islamic medicine.

Born in 1962 in Najaf, Iraq, Tabrizian is a high-ranked Shi’a cleric (an
ayatollah) and a graduate of major Shi’a seminaries. Although he is currently
the most prominent figure in Islamic medicine in Iran, he is not alone in
supporting Islamic medicine; other prominent ayatollahs have asserted their
different degrees of support for it.

Islamic Science

The founder of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Ayatollah Khomeini, once stated
that “Fiqh (or Shari’a) is a comprehensive plan for human life from the cradle
to the grave!” The Islamic Republic, over the past 45 years, has attempted to
base its politics, economics, and social policies on the Shi’a version of
Islamic Shari’a. Many Shi’a scholars wonder why not medicine.

Developing “Islamic” science, including Islamic medicine, has been a big part of
the Islamization agenda for a powerful group of Shi’a scholars since the
establishment of the Islamic Republic in Iran. For example, Ayatollah Sayyid
Mohammad Mendi Mir Bagheri, the head of the “Islamic Sciences Academy of Qom,”
and an influential figure and a potential (but not likely) future successor of
the supreme leader, is an advocate of creating Islamic science, even Islamic
physics, chemistry, and of course, medicine. Powerful figures like him are the
faces of a branch of Islamic biopolitics in Iran that promotes the development
of Islamic medicine.

Islamic Medicine as a Branch of Antiscience

Pseudoscience attempts to masquerade as legitimate science, yet it falls short
of meeting scientific standards. In contrast, antiscience positions itself as
superior to and more authoritative than science. Despite their differences, the 
boundary between pseudoscience and antiscience often blurs, making it
challenging to distinguish between the two. However, in the case of Islamic
medicine, this distinction is clear: It represents antiscience outright.

Islamic medicine asserts that understanding human health and illness, along with
preventive and therapeutic measures and treatments, must be derived from the
religious scriptures. The religious scripture in Shi’a Islam encompasses the
Quran and Sunna. Sunna is what the prophet and twelve innocent Imams, his
rightful successors, have said (hadith), did, or agreed upon. Through a process 
called Ijtihad, Shi’a scholars derive decrees from those sources.

Being well-trained in Ijtihad, Ayatollah Tabrizian, and his followers pursue an 
endeavor that has long intrigued clerics: deriving medical practices from the
Islamic scripture to establish an Islamic medicine.

The Boundaries of Shari’a: Islamic Government and Islamic Medicine

It is important to clarify a few points:

First, this paper focuses on Iran’s experience, where approximately ninety
percent of Iranians are officially classified as Shi’a. This designation is
recorded on their birth certificates and cannot be changed later in life. While 
current Iranian law permits gender changes in rare cases, changing one’s
religion is strictly forbidden and punishable by death. As a result, the true
percentage of Iranians who genuinely adhere to Shi’a Islam is unknown. Recent
polls and estimates indicate a growing trend, particularly among younger
generations, towards identifying as non-religious or as followers of other
religions such as Christianity and Zoroastrianism.

Second, Iran is governed as an Islamic Republic, meaning that, according to its 
constitution, all laws, rules, and regulations must be based on Islam or at
least not contradict it. In this context, “Islam” specifically refers to Shi’a
Islam. The officially recognized version of Shi’a Islam is the one that is
taught in formal religious seminaries. A key concept in Iran’s Islamic Republic,
known as “velayat-e faqih”, is the rule of the Supreme Leader, a senior figure 
(ayatollah) educated in these seminaries. Therefore, unless stated otherwise,
this paper uses the term “Islam” to refer to the formal version of Shi’a Islam
as practiced and interpreted in Iran.

Third, within Shi’a scholarship (comprising fuqaha or ayatollahs), there have
long been debates about whether scripture or reason should be the primary source
of law and ethics. “Scripture” refers to the Qur’an, considered the highest
source of jurisprudence, and the Sunnah. As mentioned above, in Shi’a Islam, the
Sunnah includes the sayings, actions, and approvals of the Prophet and his
successors, the twelve Imams, which are recorded in various “hadith” books.
Despite these debates, most Shi’a scholars aligned with the formal and ruling
version of Islam in Iran maintain that when scripture provides a clear assertion
or guidance, it takes precedence over reason.

Fourth, Shi’a scholars have long debated what aspects of life are covered by
shari’a (fiqh or the jurisprudence and ethics derived from the Scripture) and
what are not. This question has produced different answers over time. In the
formal version of Islam that includes the theory of “velayat-e faqih,” it is
accepted that there are such things as Islamic politics and Islamic
economy—areas guided by the scripture and led by ayatollahs. However, there has 
been no consensus on whether there is such a thing as “Islamic medicine.”

The Role of Islamic Medicine

The current leader and the top brass of the Islamic Republic do not rely on
Islamic medicine for their own healthcare. Instead, they access high-quality
scientific medical treatments that are unaffordable to most Iranians. Instances 
like the one mentioned at the beginning of this paper are rare. While the
Iranian Ministry of Health and Medical Education does support Traditional
Iranian Medicine, it disapproves of Islamic medicine and frequently clashes with
its practitioners. Furthermore, many high-ranking Shi’a scholars, including
some who support the Islamic government, argue that Islamic medicine does not
exist. They claim that the medical-related hadiths are either too few in number 
or insufficiently authenticated as being attributed to the Prophet or Imams to
establish a distinct branch of medicine.

However, many influential Shi’a scholars, including ayatollahs, are avid
supporters and providers of Islamic medicine. They contend that if politics,
economics, and ethics must be derived from the Scripture, then medicine should
be as well. Despite debates over the authenticity of some health-related
instructions attributed to the Prophet or Imams, the sheer volume of these
instructions makes it challenging for many Shi’a scholars to dismiss the
existence of Islamic medicine entirely.

Practitioners of Islamic medicine, often educated in Shi’a seminaries, have
strong connections in influential circles, making it challenging for the
Ministry of Health to oppose them effectively. As a result, despite official
disapproval, these practitioners maintain a presence in the media, including on 
government-controlled national TV. They continue to thrive in a profitable
market by appealing to people whose religious beliefs lead them to become
customers of Islamic medicine.

The COVID-19 Pandemic and The Purveyors of Islamic Medicine

The COVID-19 pandemic quickly became a fertile ground for spreading
health-related disinformation as it gained global attention in early 2020. With 
a recovery rate of approximately 98%, proponents of unverified treatments often 
attributed natural recoveries to their own so-called success stories.
Additionally, widespread public fear drove many anxious individuals toward
self-assured promoters of “miracle cures.” Islamic medicine was quick to seek a 
portion of this lucrative market.

Ayatollah Tabrizian emerged as a notable purveyor of such miracle cures for
COVID-19. A vocal anti-vaccine advocate, he frequently disseminated conspiracy
theories through his lectures, which were shared on his popular online and
social media accounts. He recommended applying violet oil to the anus as both a 
preventive and therapeutic measure against COVID-19, a suggestion that became a 
joke among Iranians. Additionally, he promoted a remedy attributed to Imam Kazim
(765 – 799 CE), one of the 12 innocent Imams referred to above in Shi’a Islam, 
claiming it could cure all respiratory diseases, including COVID-19.

In March 2020, a video went viral showing one of Tabrizian’s students, Morteza
Kohansal, inside a COVID-19 hospital ward. Without wearing a mask, Kohansal
applied “Prophet’s perfume” to the noses of hospitalized patients. This
dangerous behavior was extensively condemned by healthcare professionals at the 
time.

The Practice of Islamic Medicine

Islamic medicine is now practiced in numerous unlicensed clinics, and its
products are being sold extensively by the representatives of Ayatollah
Tabrizian and other purveyors all over Iran and even in other countries with
Shi’a populations, such as Iraq. They are popular in social media; for example, 
the current number of followers of Ayatollah Tbrizian’s Telegram channel is
almost 140 thousand, and it exceeded 200 thousand in the past; even though
Telegram is banned in Iran and people need to use internet censorship
circumvention (ICC) tools to access it. Here is a glimpse of some of the
content, in addition to the treatments for COVID-19 mentioned above:

1. Their social media and other online pages are full of anti-science and
anti-Western claims, such as conspiracy theories about the plans of the infidels
and the imperialists to harm Muslims by depriving them of their natural
remedies and religious lifestyle and, instead, selling them the products of
pharmaceutical companies and genetically modified food.

2. Their understanding of human anatomy, physiology, and pathophysiology, and their
terminology in these fields, are similar to that of Traditional Iranian
Medicine, which is based on the theory of humors and temperaments.  The reason
is apparent. The scripture they rely on was developed at a time (7th to 11th
centuries BC) when those theories were dominant in the Middle East. However,
they distance themselves from the philosophical bases of those theories and
attribute all the processes and changes in the human body to the will and
command of God.

3. For example, on the official website of Ayatollah Tabrizian, there’s a section
that includes his lectures on “Islamic anatomy”. Those lectures are a funny
mixture of modern, humoral, and scripture-based anatomy stitched together with
magical thinking. According to them, for instance, semen is derived from vessels
and hair; if during conception, the parents are under stress, their future
child will resemble their (the child’s) uncles; also, the future children
inherit their blood from the mother and their bones from the father (Lecture
30); the chest is made of phlegm; also phlegm comes from other organs, such as
the brain, to the chest, that is why there is an overflow of sputum in the chest
that makes its way to the outside of the body with coughing. The chest has a
cold temperament and cools the heart to prevent it from becoming too hot and
damage the body (Lecture18);  the basic material of hair and nails is
“diseases,” and growing hair and nails is the body’s way to excrete diseases
(Lecture #1); the reason behind some embryonic anomalies is their refusal to
accept God’s creed at the time of conception; and Satan has the ability to flow 
within human vessels like blood and cause diseases (Lecture # 27).

4. Their preventive and therapeutic instructions and remedies are also derived from
the scripture. For example, on their website, they sell potions and amulets to 
treat epilepsy (which they claim is caused by jinn), blood cancer, thalassemia, 
hemophilia, diabetes, and innumerable other conditions. These purported
medications are made from a combination of various herbs. The only evidence
supporting their safety and effectiveness comes from their descriptions in
religious scripture and the interpretations of experts in Islamic jurisprudence 
and medicine. In addition, interventions such as wet cupping and bloodletting
are performed according to the instructions found in the scripture.

5. In addition to the seminary-educated purveyors, many other practitioners of
Islamic medicine, including many charlatans, try to gain a share of this
lucrative market. Their practices include many bizarre claims, such as
prescribing camel’s brain for treating platelet deficiency and camel urine for
treating respiratory diseases. However, because they lack the knowledge and
training to derive instructions from the scripture, it is hard to include them
in the circle of valid practitioners of Islamic medicine.

An Aggressive but Declining Form of Religiosity

In his book Religion’s Sudden Decline, Ronald Inglehart describes how between
2008 and 2020, most developed countries have become less religious. In other
words, organized religions have lost their popularity, and fewer percentages of 
people still consider themselves religious in that sense. This book also
explains how, by becoming less popular, some religions become more aggressive
and extremist in their social—including biopolitical—viewpoints and approaches.

Although no formal statistics exist, it is a consensual observation that in the 
past decades, the traditional version of Shi’a Islam has lost its popularity in 
Iran. The percentage of people who still follow the instructions of ayatollahs
has shrunk significantly. At the same time, extremist ideas and aggressive
approaches have become more prevalent among the powerful fraction of Shi’a
scholars and believers who are facing social shrinkage and loss of popularity.
For example, by having control of the parliament, they have passed extremist
laws on family planning, abortion, and, most recently, women’s obligatory hijab,
hoping to force people, especially women, to follow their medieval ideas. The
recent outburst of Islamic medicine can be seen as a part of such a phenomenon.

Conclusions

Islamic medicine, as is currently promoted and practiced by some Shi’a scholars 
in Iran, is a branch of medical antiscience. The proponents of Islamic medicine 
in Iran try to integrate it into the political agenda of the Islamic government,
so it becomes a part of the regime’s biopolitical agenda, along with its
reproductive and forced veiling (hijab) policies. Most Shi’a scholars, either
inside or outside of the government, oppose the notion of deriving an
independent school of medicine from the scripture (although they agree with
following the health-related instructions of the scripture in various degrees). 
Even most of the leading figures of the Islamic Republic don’t trust the
purveyors of Islamic medicine with their health. However, the purveyors of
Islamic medicine and their supporters are still powerful enough to safeguard a
vast and lucrative market for practicing their medicine and marketing their
products.

There are no formal statistics on the damage incurred by such practices.
However, many cases, including the ones that occurred during the COVID-19
pandemic, have made their way into the media and show just the tip of the
iceberg of the damage created by the purveyors of Islamic medicine in Iran.
Informing people about the risks of such practices will always be part of the
agenda of the proponents of science-based medicine in Iran. The same problem,
with variations in their features, should be addressed in other Muslim-majority 
countries and Muslim communities all over the world.



